Full text of Occupational Hazards to Young Workers
The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.
UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF LABOR F rances Perkins, Secretary V" C H ILD R EN ’S BUREAU . . Katharine F. Lenroot, Chief Occupational Hazards to Young Workers R eport N o. 1 THE EXPLOSIVES-MANUFACTURING INDUSTRIES M Bu reau P u b l ic a t io n N o. 273 UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT PRINTIN G OFFICE WASHINGTON : 1942 "V For sale by the Superintendent of Documents, Washington, D. C. - - - - - - - - - - Priee 10 cents -34Ä.7 https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis *173 ^iticoltural 4~MedianiMl College College Siati OCCUPATIONAL H AZARDS TO YOUNG W ORKERS Report No. 1.—The Explosives-Manufacturing Industries, Publica tion No. 273. Report No. 2.—Motor-Vehicle Drivers and Helpers, Publication No. 274. Report No. 3.—The Coal-Mining Industry, Publication No. 275. Report No. 4.—The Logging and Sawmilling Industries, Publica tion No. 276. Report No. 5.—Woodworking Machines, Publication No. 277. n y V.' U, 1 https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis CONTENTS ■4 Page K y Letter of transmittal______________________________________________________________ Introduction____________________________________________________________________ Method and scope of study___________________________________________________ Definition of explosives________________________________________________________ Nature of the explosives industries and their hazards_______________________ Size and location of plan ts. ____ ;_„________________________________ Processes and hazards.___________________________________________________ Special hazards to minors________________________________________________ Statistical measures of hazard_________________________________________________ Industrial-injury rates____________________________________________________ Experience under workmen’s compensation_____________________________ Employment of minors in the explosives industries_________________________ State standards______________________________________ Report of Advisory Committee on Employment of Minors in Hazard ous Occupations, 1932__________________________________________________ N . R . A. codes_______________________________ Industry policies_________________________________________ 1930 census data______________________________ ____________________ ;_______ Attitudes toward an 18-year minimum-age standard__________________________ Conclusions______ _ _.------------------------ ----------------------------------------------------------------Appendix A— Legal basis for the investigation_________________________________ Appendix B— Principal articles classified as explosives by the Interstate Commerce Commission_____________ Appendix C— Number of explosives-manufacturing plants in specified States and their chief product____________________________ — ___________ _ Appendix D — State minimum-age standards for explosives manufacturing and for general manufacturing________________________________________________ Appendix E-—Provisions in State laws establishing minimum-age standards for work in connection with explosives, January 1, 1939_________________ Appendix F— Hazardous-Occupations OrderN o. 1______________________________ in https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis iv 1 1 2 2 2 3 6 6 6 7 8 8 9 9 10 10 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 LETTER OF TRANSMITTAL U nited S tates D epartment op L abor, C hildren’ s B ureau , Washington, June 17, 194-1There is transmitted herewith a report on the occupa tional hazards to young workers o f employment in the explosivesmanufacturing industry. This study is the first o f a series made by the Children’s Bureau to guide the Chief of the Bureau in deter mining occupations that are particularly hazardous for young work ers and therefore subject to an 18-year minimum age under the child-labor provisions o f the Fair Labor Standards Act o f 1938. The data in this report formed the factual basis for HazardousOccupation Order No. 1, effective July 1, 1939, which declared all occupations in or about plants manufacturing explosives or articles containing explosive components to be particularly hazardous for minors 16 and 17 years o f age. A copy of this order appears in the appendix. The report was originally published in mimeographed form on March 15, 1939, when the proposed order was issued. In this printed bulletin the information presented is that which appeared in the original mimeographed report, without the addition o f figures that have since become available. The study was planned and carried on under the general direc tion of Beatrice McConnell, Director of the Industrial Division o f the Children’s Bureau. The research was conducted and the report written by Elizabeth S. Johnson, then specialist in hazardousoccupations research. Respectfully submitted. K atharine F. L enroot, Chief. M adam : H on . F rances P erkins , Secretary of Labor. https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Occupational Hazards to Young Workers The Explosives-Manufacturing Industries The Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 recognizes the need to protect young workers 16 and 17 years o f age against unsafe and unhealthful working conditions. Under the child-labor provisions o f this act, the basic minimum age for general employment is 16 years, but there is an 18-year minimum age for occupations declared by the Chief of the Children’s Bureau to be particularly hazardous for young workers. The present investigation of the hazards o f employment in the explosives-manufacturing industries was undertaken to guide the Chief o f the Bureau in determining whether or not occupations in these industries should be declared particularly hazardous for minors 16 and 17 years of age under the Fair Labor Standards Act. The need to investigate the hazards to young persons of work in explo sives factories was indicated by the danger from explosions which exists in such plants despite all safety precautions. Although acci dents of this type may happen infrequently, they are likely to assume the proportions of a major disaster when they do occur, killing or severely injuring a number of workers at one time. METHOD AND SCOPE OF STUDY 1 V In this investigation published and unpublished material has been used, including reports of the United States Bureau o f Labor Sta tistics on industrial accidents and on employment in the explosivesmanufacturing industries and statistics on workmen’s-compensation costs compiled by agencies which set insurance rates for workmen’s compensation. The experience o f persons directly connected with the industries manufacturing explosives, including articles containing explosive components, has been extensively drawn upon. The persons con sulted included trade-association officials, employers, representatives o f organized-labor groups, and safety experts with specialized knowl edge o f the manufacture and handling o f explosives. These persons provided valuable information on hazards and employment practices in these industries and gave their opinions regarding the need o f for bidding employment of minors under 18 years of age in plants manu facturing explosives. Extensive investigation of conditions now existing in individual plants was not deemed necessary in view of information and advice received from employers and workers in the industries and from the safety and explosives experts consulted. However, a few plants, including one fireworks factory and one ammunition plant, were visited, and the occupations and plant lay-out were observed. l https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis 2 OCCUPATIONAL HAZARDS TO YOUNG WORKERS DEFINITION OF EXPLOSIVES In general, the term “ explosives” means any chemical compound or mechanical mixture which, upon the application o f fire, friction, shock, or detonation, will generate gases capable o f causing destruc tive pressure upon surrounding objects. The term “ explosives” is customarily used to refer to compounds or mixtures that are explosive, such as dynamite, black powder, smokeless powder, and fulminate of mercury. Manufactured articles containing explosive components are not commonly spoken of as explosives, even though they are technically so classified. However, in the Transportation o f Explosives Act1 and regulations o f the Interstate Commerce Commission issued thereunder, ammunition, blasting caps, fireworks, primers, detonating and time fuses, and many similar articles as well as the basic explosive compounds and mixtures are classified as explosives for the purpose of regulating their transportation in interstate and foreign commerce.2 A list of the principal articles in this classification is shown in appendix B, page 14. The term “ explosives” as used in this report—for example, in the references to explosives industries, explosives manufacture, or ex plosives plants—means any goods classified as explosives in the regulations o f the Interstate Commerce Commission. NATURE OF THE EXPLOSIVES INDUSTRIES AND THEIR HAZARDS Size and location of plants. Explosives manufacture embraces several distinct industries with different types of products. These products are divided by the Census o f Manufactures into three groups: (1) ammunition and related products, (2) explosives, and (3) fireworks and allied prod ucts. The 1935 Census of Manufactures reported a total of 11,757 wage earners and 139 establishments in these groups, as follows : Number of establishments Ammunition and related products (including blasting caps)---------------13 Explosives1------------------------------------------74 Fireworks and allied products---------52 Total _______________________________ Number of wage earners ( average for year) 139 5,590 4, 570 1,588 11,757 1 “ E x p lo siv e s ” is u sed b y th e C ensus o f M a n u fa ctu res to m ean b a s ic e xp lo s iv e com p ou n d s a n d m ix tu res on ly . S o u r c e : B ien n ia l C ensus o f M a n u fa ctu res, 1935, pp. 607, 658, 671. th e Census, W a sh in g ton , 1938. U. S. B u rea u o f These figures are probably understatements both of the number of establishments and of the number of wage earners, since the Census of Manufactures reports only establishments with products valued at $5,000 or more during the given year. A larger number of 1 A c t o f M a rch 4, 1921 (4 1 S ta t. 1 4 4 4 ). 2 R e g u la tio n s f o r T ra n s p o rta tio n b y R a il o f E x p losiv es and O th er D a n g e ro u s A rtic le s in F re ig h t, E xp ress, a n d B a g ga ge S ervices, D ock et 3666, as a m en ded. In te rs ta te C om m erce C om m ission , W a sh in g ton . https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis EXPLOSIVES-MANUFACTURING INDUSTRIES 3 plants (151) was reported in February 1938 by the Bureau of Ex plosives of the American Association of Railroads, an agency inspect ing for compliance with the Interstate Commerce Commission regula tions for the transportation o f explosives. This number presumably includes all plants shipping in interstate commerce by rail, regard less o f value of product.1 These plants were distributed by type of product as follows: Number of plants Amm unition__________________________________________ .____________ 11 Blasting caps_______________________________________________________ 3 Basic explosivecompoundsand mixtures_________________________ 61 Fireworks________________ __________________________________________ 73 Other and type notspecified_____________________________________ 3 Total------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------151 This source gives no information on the number o f employees. Neither these figures nor any others on number, size, and location of explosives plants given in this report include arsenals or other establishments operated by the United States Government. Explosives plants are scattered over the United States. Despite their comparatively small number, they are found in 29 States.* The largest number is m Pennsylvania, the most important mining State in the United States, where 27 plants were reported by the Bureau o f Explosives. The other States which lead in number of plants are Ohio (18), New Jersey (16), Illinois (15), and California (10). The distribution of plants throughout the country is shown in appendix C,page 15. The plants tend to be small except in the ammunition industry. According to the Census of Manufactures, plants manufacturing basic explosive compounds and mixtures employed on an average 60 wage earners each during 1935. Those manufacturing fireworks and allied products employed even fewer, averaging 30 wage earners each. Establishments manufacturing ammunition and related products, on the other hand, employed an average of 431 wage earners during the same year. Processes and hazards. Basic explosive compounds and m ixtures.—The two chief types of basic explosive compounds and mixtures are high explosives and black powder. High explosives, such as dynamite and picric acid, are manufactured by chemical processes. In the case o f dynamite, this involves first the making of nitric and sulphuric acid and then the nitration process, in which glycerin is combined with nitric and sulphuric acid to produce nitroglycerin, the explosive base o f dynamite. Other supplementary processes include the preparation o f a dope (that is, an absorbent carrier for the nitroglycerin), the making of paper shells, and the packing of appropriate quantities of dynamite into the shells. The manufacture of black powder, on the other hand, involves chiefly a pulverizing and mixing process. The essential 1 L is t o f M a n u fa ctu re rs o f E x p losiv es, com p ile d b y th e C h ie f In s p e cto r, B u rea u o f E x p lo sives, A ss o cia tio n o f A m erica n R a ilro a d s, N ew Y ork . F eb ru a ry , 1938. 2 T h e B ien n ia l C ensus o f M a n u fa ctu res, 1935, an d th e B ureau o f E x p lo siv e s b o th g iv e th is to ta l num ber o f S tates, a lth ou gh th ere w as a s lig h t v a ria tio n in th e States and in the d istrib u tio n o f p lan ts. https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis 4 OCCUPATIONAL HAZARDS TO YOUNG WORKERS ingredients o f the powder are saltpeter, charcoal, and sulphur, which the manufacturer procures as raw materials. Plants manufacturing basic explosive compounds and mixtures are usually small, so that losses in case o f explosion may be minimized, and they are usually located near the place where the product is used. However, the demands for technical skill in manufacture and for capital investment are considerable. These requirements have con tributed to the integration o f ownership and management that char acterizes the industry. Three companies employ about three-fourths o f the wage earners in the manufacture of high explosives and about one-half of the wage earners in the black-powder branch of the industry.* The grave danger o f explosions has given rise to elaborate pre cautionary measures for promoting safety in manufacturing opera tions and in the handling o f materials. These include the use of small separate buildings for various operations, the control of some processes from a distance in order to remove the worker from the immediate scene of danger, avoidance of open fires and of mechanisms or tools capable o f generating sparks, and limitation o f quantities o f explosive materials kept in one place at any time. Storage o f explosives, whether at explosives-manufacturing plants or elsewhere, is also governed by carefully developed standards. Highly developed safety programs characterize the large com panies operating several plants. Furthermore, methods of safe practice and safe construction and operation of plants have been prescribed by State authority in important explosives-producing States through special codes or laws applying specifically to plants manufacturing or using explosives. Several important explosivesproducing States, including Massachusetts, New Jersey, Pennsyl vania, and Washington, have codes regulating the manufacture of explosives in addition to others regulating the storage and use of explosives in manufacturing plants and elsewhere. The manufacture of explosives is characterized not only by the danger o f explosion but also by danger of poisoning from the acids and other chemicals used in some processes, as in the manufacture of nitroglycerin, fulminate of mercury, and picric acid.4 Several States have special codes or laws providing for the protection o f workers from the injurious effects of nitro-amido compounds contained in many of the explosives. Fireworks <—The fireworks industry has three divisions, according to*product: The commercial division, producing fireworks for the open market; the display division, producing fireworks for special displays; and the fusee division, producing flares, fusees, and torpedoes for signals on railways and highways.5 Fireworks manufacture, particularly m the commercial and dis play divisions, requires relatively little capital, uses chiefly hand processes, and is highly seasonal. The peak season is just before * E a rn in g s a n d H ou rs In th e E x p lo siv e s In d u stry , O cto b e r 1937. M o n th ly L a b o r R eview V o l. 47, N o. 2 (A u gu st 1 9 3 8 ), pp. 378—392. B ureau o f L a b or S ta tistics, U. S. D epartm ent o f L a b or, W ash in g ton . 4 O ccu p a tio n H a za rd s a n d D ia g n o s tic S ign s, b y L o u is I. D u b lin a n d R o b e rt J. V an e. B u lle tin N o , 582, p. 7 , U. S. B u rea u o f L a b o r S ta tistics. * E a rn in g s a n d H ou rs in th e F ire w o r k s In d u s try , O ctob e r 1937. M o n th ly L a b o r R eview , V ol. 46, No. 4 (A p r il 1 9 3 8 ), pp. 9 4 2 -9 5 5 . https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis EXPLOSIVES-MANUFACTURING INDUSTRIES 5 the Fourth o f July, and lesser seasons precede special holidays or festivals celebrated by the use o f fireworks. The industry has many S1? aS °Perators a.nd is highly competitive. An important feature ^reworks industry, from the point of view o f employment o f young workers, is the presence in the commercial ana display divisions of very small enterprises carried on intermittently in the proprietor s dwelling, instead o f in a permanent place o f business. The small concerns which make up this unstable fringe of the indus try are commonly referred to as family enterprises, but it is probable that many o f them employ neighbors and relatives as well as members o f the proprietor’s immediate family, and that they come under the jurisdiction o f the Fair Labor Standards Act if they ship in interstate commerce. J * The seasonal nature o f the industry and the small size and insta bility of many concerns contribute to the hazard to the workers. Lack of technical knowledge on the part o f the proprietor, lack of proper equipment, and the periodic recruiting o f inexperienced workers unfamiliar with the precautions essential for safety in the industry increase the danger of explosion, even though the quantities o f explosive materials handled are not nearly so large as m plants manufacturing basic explosive compounds and mixtures. The haz ards o f fireworks manufacture are recognized by State safety codes, in addition to the State codes governing the manufacture, storage and use o f explosives in general, at least four States have special codes setting forth the requirements and precautions which must be ob served m fireworks factories (Massachusetts, New Jersey Ohio Pennsylvania). ’ ’ Fireworks manufacture comprises chiefly hand-work operations, ih e most hazardous occupations are the mixing o f the powders and other ingredients for explosive and color effects and the loading i mgre.dients into cardboard shells or other containers. Much o f the work is in the assembling and decorating o f parts after the loading, and it is at these light hand-work tasks that young persons are likely to be employed. Ammunition.-—The manufacture o f ammunition is quite different from the. manufacture of fireworks or o f the basic explosive compounds and mixtures. It is essentially a fabricating industry using highly mechanized processes and is conducted in a few large operating units. The processes are chiefly the forming and shaping of metal or metal-and-paper shells, o f primer parts, of bullets, and o f shot, and the loading and assembling of these parts. Many of the parts are metal and are fabricated by the use o f power presses, chiefly punch stamping, and drawing presses. Private concerns make mainly smallarms ammunition, although they may also manufacture some bombs tear-gas cartridges, and similar articles. The major types of occupations involved in the making of smallarms ammunition are: » Forming parts by machine before they are primed or loaded. (2) Manufacturing primers, which involves the handling o f ful minate o f mercury or other initiating or priming explosive. (3) Loading primed shells with powder much o f which is done bv machine. J 2 0 0 6 0 4 °— 42--------2 https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis 6 OCCUPATIONAL HAZARDS TO YOUNG WORKERS (4) Forming and assembling parts by machine after they are primed or loaded with explosive materials. (5) Inspecting and packing, practically all of which is done after the parts or products are primed or loaded. Almost all the opportunities for employment in the industry in volve either work on machines (chiefly power presses) or work in handling explosives in large or small quantities. The hazard from explosion appears to be definitely less in many occupations in ammunition manufacture than in the manufacture of fireworks or of basic explosive compounds or mixtures. The most dangerous part o f the manufacture o f small-arms ammunition is the making o f primers. The fulminate used is an industrial poison, and it or other initiating or priming explosives used in the primer are set off chiefly by shock or impact. In many occupations the amount o f explosive in the parts being handled is relatively small, so that explosions in ammunition factories are less likely to spread than in other types of explosives plants. Furthermore, the powder used in ammunition is for the most part smokeless powder, which is less readily ignited than black powder. Most ammunition plants have well-developed safety programs. No special State codes have been issued for ammunition manufacture, but general codes on the storage and use o f explosives apply to plants manufacturing ammunition as well as to other plants. Blasting caps.—A blasting cap is a small device consisting of a metal container and a quantity o f an initiating or priming explosive, such as fulminate of mercury or lead azide. It is used in setting off a charge o f dynamite or other explosive in blasting. The processes o f manufacture are similar to those in the making o f ammunition, but on the whole they are more hazardous since pro portionately more explosive material is used and since the con struction o f the cap is such that it is more readily set off than ammu nition. The manufacture o f blasting caps and the manufacture of ammunition are carried on in separate plants and are considered to be separate industries. Special hazards to minors. Work in the manufacture o f explosives, including articles con taining explosive components, is hazardous, particularly for the young worker, who is characteristically curious and irresponsible. A young person cannot be expected to exercise at all times the good judgment and caution which are required in this work; nor can he be expected to recognize conditions that may call for special atten tion to prevent an explosion, even though he has been told o f the principles and rules tor safe practice. Also^ he is very likely to venture about the plant and handle objects in an unsafe manner, whether or not he nas been given proper instructions or has been forbidden to enter certain parts o f the plant. STATISTICAL MEASURES OF HAZARD Industrial-injury rates. Nation-wide figures on accident rates in explosives manufacture are available for 1936 for a sample group o f establishments reporting https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis EXPLOSIVES-MANUFACTURING INDUSTRIES 7 to the United States Bureau o f Labor Statistics.1 These show for 33 explosives-manufacturing establishments2 a high severity rate of disabling injuries, though a low frequency rate. The severity rate (that is, the number o f days lost per 1,000 employee-hours worked) was 4.34 for explosives industries, compared with 2.08 for all manufacturing industries combined.3 These figures indicate that explosives manufacture was twice as hazardous as all manufac turing industries combined, in terms of severity of injuries. Ex plosives ranked sixth in severitv among the 66 manufacturing industries for which the Bureau o f Labor Statistics published injury rates for 1936. On the other hand, the frequency rate (that is, the number of disabling injuries per 1,000,000 man-nours worked) was 6.61 for explosives manufacture, compared with 16.61 for all manufacturing industries combined. This low frequency rate doubtless reflects the safety consciousness o f the explosives industries and the general effectiveness o f their safety programs. The high severity rate, on the other hand, re flects the hazards inherent in these industries, which result in a high total injury cost despite all the precautions taken. No comparable figures are available for earlier years. For 1937, preliminary figures are available for explosives plants but not for all manufacturing industries combined. The frequency rate of dis abling injuries in explosives industries in 1937 (6.30) was about the same as in the preceding year (6.61). The severity rate (2.36) was lower than in 1936 but was nevertheless higher than the 1936 severity rate for all manufacturing industries (2.08).4 Unfortunately, no figures are available showing injuries to minors only. Experience under workmen’s compensation. Another statistical measure o f hazard is workmen’s-compensation costs in relation to pay rolls. In order that premium rates for work men’s-compensation insurance may bear a relation to the costs in curred in a particular industry, rate-making agencies tabulate insured pay-roll and compensation losses for specific industry and occupation classifications for use in arriving at the premium rates to be charged for workmen’s-compensation insurance in each classification. The pure premium (that is, the rate of compensation loss in relation to insured pay roll) for explosives classifications is available for 34 States and the District of Columbia combined from the National Council on Compensation Insurance, an organization serving insur ance companies by preparing workmen’s-compensation premium rates.® Similar figures are available for Pennsylvania from its sepa1 In d u s tria l I n ju rie s in th e U n ited S ta tes D u rin g 1936, M o n th ly L a b o r R e v ie w , V o l. 47, No. 1 (J u ly 1 9 3 8 ), pp. 1 8 -3 0 . 2 M o s t o f th ese e sta b lish m en ts m a n u fa ctu re b a s ic e x p lo s iv e co m p o u n d s a n d m ix tu res. 8 I n ca ses o f te m p o r a r y d isa b ility , th e tim e lo ss rep resen ts a ctu a l d a y s o f d isa b ility . I n cases o f fa ta l o r p erm a n en t in ju rie s , th e tim e loss is com p u te d a cco r d in g t o th e A m e rica n sta n d a rd s ca le o f tim e c h a r g e s ; d ea th a n d p erm a n en t t o ta l d isa b ility , f o r in sta n ce , a re ch a rg e d a s 6 .0 0 0 d ays. (A m e r ic a n S ta n d a rd M eth od o f C o m p ilin g In d u s tria l I n ju r y R ates, p. 6. A m e r ic a n S ta n d a rd s A s s o c ia tio n , N ew Y o r k C ity , 1 9 3 7 .) * P re lim in a ry figu res fr o m th e U. S. B u rea u o f L a b o r S ta tistics. * W ork m en ’ s C om p en sa tion E x p e rie n ce C om p iled in 1987. N a tio n a l C o u n cil o n C om p en sa tio n In su ra n ce, N ew Y ork . A ll S ta tes a re rep resen ted e x c e p t A rk a n sas. D ela w a re. F lo rid a , M ississip p i, N evada, N ew H a m p sh ire, N orth D a k ota , O h io, O regon , P e n n sy lv a n ia , S ou th C a ro lin a , W ash in g ton , W e st V ir g in ia , W y om in g . https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis 8 OCCUPATIONAL HAZARDS TO YOUNG WORKERS rate rate-making agency, the Pennsylvania Compensation Rating and Inspection Bureau.6 Figures for 34 States and the District of Columbia, based on the 5 policy-years 1930-34, show a pure premium of 4.25 (that is, $4.25 per $100 o f pay roll) for explosives classifications, about three and one-half times the average for all manufacturing classifications (1.24).7 For Pennsylvania the pure premium for explosives manu facture, based on $1,750,000 o f pay roll during the 5 policy-years 1932-36, was 1.38, two and one-half times the average for all manu facturing classifications in the State (0.54).8 These figures on compensation costs show the explosives industries to be even more hazardous, relative to all manufacturing industries, than do accident statistics. This is probably due in part to the fact that the reports of rates prepared by the insurance rate-making agencies do not include the experience of firms that are self-insuring under State workmen’s-compensation laws. These firms are the ones most likely to have highly developed safety programs, and they are well represented in the accident figures o f the Bureau of Labor Statistics, which are based on a voluntary reporting system. As a measure o f hazard, compensation costs in relation to pay roll are themselves subject to distortion because factors other than extent o f disability enter into their determination. Differences in wage levels affect comparisons between industries and between States, and differences in benefit provisions of workmen’s-compensation laws, as well as differences in method and standards of administration, like wise affect comparisons between States or regions. However, in the case of the explosives industries, which are scattered geographically and which as a group have a wage level apparently not far from the average for all manufacturing, it is believed that the figures on compensation costs are significant as an indication of relative hazard. EMPLOYMENT OF MINORS IN THE EXPLOSIVES INDUSTRIES State standards. Work in connection with the manufacture of explosives is recog nized as hazardous for young workers under the laws o f 22 States. O f these States, 11 prohibit such employment for all minors under 18 years of age, 1 for minors under 17 years, and 10 for minors under 16 years. In 1938, 65 of the 151 plants reported to be engaged in the manufacture o f explosives were located in States with an 18-year minimum age for work with explosives (including Pennsylvania and Ohio). One plant was in a State with a 17-year minimum age for such employment. Twenty-three plants were located in States where a 16-year minimum age applied either by specific provision or by provision for general manufacturing. The remaining 62 plants were located in 13 States that permitted employment in explosives plants at 14 years of age. (Appendix D, p. 16.) • C la ssifica tion E x p erien ce P o lic y Y ea rs 1932 T h r o u g h 1930. P e n n sy lv a n ia S ch ed u le Z , vol. 1. P en n sy lv a n ia C om p en sa tion R a tin g an d I n s p e ctio n B u rea u , H a rrisb u rg. T W ork m en ’ s C om p en sa tion E x p erien ce C om p iled in 1937, pp. 185—188. N a tio n a l C ou n cil o n C om p en sa tion In su ra n ce, N ew Y ork . See a lso th e C o u n c il’s C ircu la r L etter^ N o v 10 1937 4 C la ssifica tion E x p erien ce P o lic y Y ea rs 1932 T h rou g h 1936, v o l. 1, pp. 99, 100T T h e a vera g e fo r a ll m a u fa c tu rin g cla ss ifica tion s w as com p u ted fro m s ta tis tic s co n ta in e d in th is rep ort. https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis EXPLOSIVES-MANUFACTURING INDUSTRIES 9 The State minimum-age provisions for work in the manufacture or handling of explosives vary in application with respect both to the occupations and to the types of explosives covered. (Appendix E, p. IT.) For the most part the proivsions are broad in coverage so far as occupations are concerned, applying in many States to any work “ in or about establishments where * * * explosives are manufactured, compounded, or stored.” The provisions ox some States are narrower, applying either to work “in the manufacture, pack ing, or storing” of explosives or to the handling or use o f explosives. The range o f products covered varies to some extent, and the lack of definition of such terms as “explosives” or as “ other dangerous ex plosives” means that the exact coverage is not always clear. How ever, when the provision relates to any work in or about plants where explosives are compounded or stored as well as manufactured, at least part o f the explosive materials handled in the plant would probably be within the coverage o f the provision, ana the entire manufacturing plant would therefore be affected by the minimum-age requirement. Report of Advisory Committee on Employment of Minors in Hazardous Occupations, 1932. This committee, appointed by the Chief o f the Children’s Bureau in 1932 on the recommendation of the White House Conference on Child Health and Protection, recommended a list of specific occupa tions that should be prohibited to minors under 18 years o f age. This list included among the occupations involving mechanical hazards any employment “ in the manufacture, transportation, or use of explosives, or explosive or highly inflammable substances.” 1 The recommenda tions o f this committee served as the basis for recommendations made by the Labor Advisory Board to N. R. A. code authorities regarding lists o f occupations hazardous to minors. The establishment o f such lists was provided for by many of the N. R. A. codes. N. R. A. codes. When the National Recovery Administration set up minimum-age standards in the industry codes, some recognition was accorded the hazardous nature o f work in explosives plants. A flat 18-year mini mum age was provided in the code for the pyrotechnic-manufacturing industry (fireworks) from the outset. However, work in explosives plants was not definitely recognized as requiring a higher standard than the basic 16-year minimum in the other two codes governing ex plosives industries—that is, the codes for the manufacture of small arms and ammunition and for chemical manufacturing. The latter code, however, contained a provision to the effect that any higher mini mum age set by State law should be observed. The former contained provision for an 18-year minimum age in hazardous occupations to be listed by the code authority, but no list of such occupations was set up.2 1 R e p o rt o f th e A d v is o r y C om m ittee on E m p loy m en t o f M in o rs in H a za rd o u s O ccu p a tion s. M o n th ly L a b or R eview , V ol. 35. No. 0 (D ecem ber 1 9 3 2 ), pp. 1 3 1 5 -1 3 2 2 . * H is to ry o f the C ode o f F a ir C om p etition fo r th e Sm all A rm s and A m m u n itio n M anu fa c t u r in g In d u s try , pp. 45, 4 8 -4 9 . D iv is io n o f R eview , N a tio n a l R e co v e r y A d m in is tr a tio n . (M a n u scr ip t on file w ith th e N . R . A . R e co rd s S ection , U . S. D e p a rtm e n t o f C om m erce, W a s h in g t o n .) https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis 10 OCCUPATIONAL HAZARDS TO YOUNG WORKERS Industry policies. A ll persons representing management, either as officials o f trade associations or as employers, who were consulted in the course o f this study stated that it was the policy o f the concern or concerns they represented to hire only persons 18 years o f age or over for work in or about explosives plants. Indeed, many said that no one under 21 or even under a higher age was permitted to work at the more hazardous occupations m the plants, such as mixing powder. Although observing an 18-year minimum age in general, one ammu nition plant reported that it made an exception m the case o f mail boys, using boys between 16 and 18 years to carry mail and messages through the plant (including some workrooms where the explosive materials were handled). Several persons representing the industries involved and others familiar with various branches of explosives manufacture reported that so far as they knew minors under 18 were employed in such manufacture only by small fireworks concerns not represented in the trade association o f the fireworks industry. 1930 census data. Unfortunately, no current data are available regarding the number and ages o f children in the explosives industries. Figures from the 1930 Census o f Occupations probably represent a maximum estimate o f current employment. In 1930, 584 minors under 18 years o f age were reported as operatives or laborers in explosives, ammunition, and fireworks factories. These 584 comprised about 5 percent o f the 10,951 workers o f all ages (10 years and over) in these occupational groups. No break-down is given for the 3 types of explosives manufacture, but it is probable that the vast majority of the young workers included in the following figures were in the fireworks industry: 10 14 16 18 20 Age of worker Number Total _________________________________________ 10,951 Percent 100.0 4 26 554 956 9,411 Í1) .2 5.1 8.7 86.0 to 13 years_____________ and 15 years__________ and 17 years---------------and 19 years--------------years and over________ 1 L ess th a n o n e-ten th o f 1 p ercen t. S o u r c e : F ifte e n th C ensus o f th e U n ited S ta tes, 1930. P o p u la tio n , v o l. V , ta b le 6, pp. 1 2 2 -1 2 5 , a n d ta b le 10, pp. 8 5 3 -3 5 4 . U. S. B u rea u o f th e Census, W ash in g to n , 1983. ATTITUDES TOWARD AN 18-YEAR MINIMUMAGE STANDARD A ll persons consulted regarding an 18-year minimum age for work in or about explosives plants, including representatives of employers and of labor and safety experts, were of the opinion that a general 18-year standard is desirable for employment in explosives indus tries. From the point o f view o f employers, the most important reason for this opinion appeared to be the need of the industries https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis EXPLOSIVE S-MANUFACTURING INDUSTRIES 11 for steady, mature, and responsible employees in a working environ ment entailing many hazards and requiring strict observance of many rules of safe practice for the protection o f life and property. Some persons questioned the desirability of applying the order to office workers, including mail boys. However, others regarded office and errand work at explosives plants as occupations that should be declared hazardous for minors under 18. With this one exception, the persons consulted during the investigation were in agreement that a hazardous-occupations order relating to explosives manufacture should apply to any work in or about the plant. https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis CONCLUSIONS 1. Workers in plants manufacturing explosives, including articles containing explosive components, are especially' subject to accident hazards from explosion despite the progress made by manufacturers in developing safeguards. 2. The accident severity rate for explosives manufacture was about twice as great as the average for all manufacturing industries in 1936, on the basis o f available but incomplete figures. The accident frequency rate was not high, but injuries due to explosion are very likely to be serious or fatal. Workmen’s-compensation experience likewise shows a high injury cost for explosives manufacture. 3. Occupations in explosives-manufacturing plants are especially hazardous for young persons, who are characteristically curious and irresponsible, because they cannot be relied upon to exercise caution and good judgment in observing the many necessary safety pre cautions in conducting themselves about the plant and at their work. This obviously concerns not only the safety o f the minor but that o f his fellow worker as well. 4. The unsuitability for young persons o f work in establishments manufacturing or handling explosives has been recognized by 22 States in setting a higher minimum age for work in connection with the manufacture or use of explosives than for other employment. Eleven States at present prohibit the employment o f minors under 18 years o f age in connection with explosives manufacture, including Pennsylvania and Ohio, two o f the most important explosives-manu facturing States. 5. It is the policy o f leading manufacturers operating explosives plants to observe an 18-year minimum age regardless o f the State o f operation. A t the present time the only type o f work in ex plosives manufacture in which any substantial number o f minors under 18 years o f age appear to be engaged is in small fireworks factories not represented by the trade association o f the fireworks industry. 6. The term “ explosives” should be understood to include ammuni tion, black powder, blasting caps, fireworks, high explosives, primers, smokeless powder, and all goods classified and defined to be explosives by the Interstate Commerce Commission in Regulations for Trans portation by Rail o f Explosives and Other Dangerous Articles in Freight, Express, and Baggage Services, as amended, Docket 3666, issued pursuant to sec. 233 of the Act o f March 4, 1921 (ch. 172, 41 Stat. 1445, U. S. Code, ti. 18, sec. 383). https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Appendix A.—Legal Basis for the Investigation This investigation has been conducted by the Industrial Division o f the Children’s Bureau pursuant to the regulation entitled “ Proce dure Governing Determinations of Hazardous Occupations,” 1 issued by the Chief o f the Children’s Bureau on November 3, 1938, pursuant to the authority conferred by section 3 (1) of the Fair Labor Stand ards Act of 1938 (Act of June 25, 1938, ch. 676, 52 Stat. 1060, U. S. Code, Supp. IY , ti. 29, sec. 201), hereafter referred to as the Act. This subsection, which defines oppressive child labor as that term is used in the Act, provides in part as follow s: (1) “Oppressive child labor” means a condition of employment under which (1) any employee under the age of sixteen years is employed by an employer * * * in any occupation, or (2) any employee between the ages of sixteen and eighteen years is employed by an employer in any occupation which the Chief of the Children’s Bureau in the Department of Labor shall find and by order declare to be particularly hazardous for the employment of children between such ages or detrimental to their health or well-being; * * *. For the purpose of establishing an orderly procedure for deter mining and declaring occupations to be particularly hazardous for the employment of minors 16 and 17 years o f age or detrimental to their health or well-being, the Chief of the Children’s Bureau issued the regulation, Procedure Governing Determinations of Hazardous Occupations, the first section of which provided in part as follow s: Sec. 421.1. Investigation and conference.— Preparatory to the making of a finding by the Chief of the Children’s Bureau that an occupation or a group of occupations is particularly hazardous for the employment of minors between 16 and 18 years of age or is detrimental to their health or well-being, a study shall be made of information obtained by the Bureau, or submitted to it with respect to the hazardous or detrimental nature of such occupation or occupations. Conferences may be held with representative employers and workers in the industry, experts in industrial health and safety, and others for the purpose of discussing the nature and characteristics of the occupation or occupations under consideration. A public hearing may be held upon reasonable public notice of the time and place thereof whenever such action is deemed by the Chief of the Bureau to be expedient for the purpose of obtaining such evidence with respect to the nature and characteristics of such occupation or group of occupations. A transcript of the proceedings of any such hearing shall be made and filed with the Bureau. A report of facts and conclusions with respect to the hazardous or detrimental nature of the occupation or occupations under consideration shall be prepared upon the basis of such information and evidence. In accordance with the provisions of the Act and the regulation referred to above, the Chief of the Children’s Bureau instructed the Industrial Division of the Bureau to conduct an investigation with respect to the hazardous or detrimental nature o f occupations in plants manufacturing explosives, including articles containing explosive components, with special reference to young workers, and to con sider the problems involved in drafting an order under section 3 (1) o f the Act. 1 P ro c e d u re G ov ern in g D eterm in a tion s o f H a za rd ou s O ccu p a tio n s, T it le 29— L a b o r, ch . I V — C h ild ren ’s B ureau— C hild L a b or— pt. 421. F ed era l R e giste r, v o l. 3, p. 264 0 D I, N ovem b er 5, 1938. 13 https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Appendix B.—Principal Articles Classified as Explosives by the Interstate Commerce Commission1 Ammunition for cannon with explo sive projectiles, including gas, smoke, and incendiary projectiles. Ammunition for cannon without ex plosive projectiles, or without pro jectiles. Ammunition for small arms with ex plosive bullets. Black powder. Blasting caps. Bombs, explosive. Boosters. Cartridge shells, primed, empty. Chemical ammunition containing ex plosive components. Combination fuzes. Combination primers. Cordeau détonant. Delay electric igniters. Detonating fuzes. Diazodinitrophenol. Electric squibs. Empty cartridge bags— black-powder igniters. Fireworks. Fulminates. Fuse igniters. Fuse lighters. Grenades, explosive, including hand and rifle grenades. Grenades, primed, empty. Guanyl nitrosamino guanylidene hy drazine. Guanyl nitrosamino guanyl tetrazene (tetrazene). High explosives. Instantaneous fuse. Lead azide. Lead styphnate. Low explosives. Mines, explosive. Nitro mannite. Nitrosoguanidine. Pentaerythrite tetranitrate. Percussion caps. Percussion fuzes. Primers. Projectiles, explosive. Safety squibs. Small-arms ammunition. Small-arms primers. Smokeless powder for cannon. Smokeless powder for small arms. Tetrazene. Time fuzes. Torpedoes, explosive. Tracer fuzes. 1 R eg u la tion s fo r T ra n s p o rta tio n b y R a il o f E x p lo siv e s a n d O th e r D a n g e ro u s A r tic le s in F re ig h t, E xp ress, a n d B a g g a g e S ervice. D o c k e t 3666, pt. I, p ars. 51, 52, pp. 25, 26, an d S up p lem ent N o. 1, p. 2. 14 https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Appendix C.—N u m b e r of Explosives-Manufacturing Plants in Specified States and Their Chief Product Plants operated b y private concerns Plants operaied b y U. S. Other Govern Am and type ment m uni Blast not tion ing caps specified Chief product State Total United States........................ Alabama________ Arizona.......................... Arkansas.............. ......... California______________ Colorado______________ Connecticut________ Delaware_______ District of Colum bia........ Illinois........................ Indiana______ ____ Kansas______________ K e n tu ck y ............... M aryland........................... Massachusetts..................... M ichigan_____________ M innesota____________ . M issouri________ __________ Nebraska___________ . N ew Jersey___________ N ew Y ork ____________ Ohio__________________ Pennsylvania........................... South Carolina...................... Tennessee............................... Texas................................... U tah......... ..................... V irginia.............................. Washington_____________ West Virginia________________ Wisconsin___________ Basic explosive compounds Fire works and mixtures 151 61 3 1 1 10 1 5 1 1 15 4 3 2 i 4 5 2 1 7 1 16 8 18 27 3 1 1 4 1 13 3 1 1 i 7 1 1 5 i i 6 2 1 2 1 1 2 3 4 i 2 73 11 3 16 5 1 2 i 1 5 2 2 1 1 1 4 4 4 1 10 0 10 12 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 spedfieddeS 2 PlaDtS manufacturing eordeau detonant and safety fuse and one plant with product not of manufacturers of explosives, compiled b y Bureau of Explosives, American Association r?vis,ed 1938»,New York. This list Includes all plants known to ship in interstate commerce products classified as explosives b y the regulations of the Interstate Commerce Commission. 15 https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis A p p e n d i x D.—State Minimum-Age Standards for Explosives M a n u f a c t u r i n g and for General Manufacturing States with minimum-age standards Minimum-age standards applicable to work in explosives manufacture Num ber M inim um age specified for work with explosives:* N o minimum age specified for work with explosives but minimum age set for general manufacturing: Number with ex plosives plants Number of plants 49 29 151 *11 »1 no 10 1 4 65 1 22 *3 624 1 *13 1 62 i Appendix E , gives the exact coverage of these provisions. __ ■ a Arizona, Delaware, Indiana, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, N ew M exico, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Virginia, Wisconsin. Explosives plants are located in all these States except N ew Mexico. « Connecticut, Iowa, Missouri, Nevada, N ew Y ork, North Carolina, Oklahoma, Rhode Island, Vermont, W yom ing. Explosives plants are located in Connecticut, Iowa, Missouri, and N ew York. * Montana, South Carolina, Utah. Only Utah has an explosives plant. . ,. . * In a few of the 24 States exemptions are found permitting employment of children under 14 years of age ^ ^ A tob a m a ^ A rk a n ^ lca h fO T ^ a fM ora d o, District of Columbia, Illinois, Kansas, Kentucky, Minnesota, Nebraska, N ew Jersey, Tennessee, Washington. 16 https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Appendix E.—Provisions in State Laws Establishing Minimum-Age Standards for Work in Connection With Explosives, Jan. 1, 1939 Provisions States M inim um age In or about establishments where nitroglycerin, dyna N evada.................... . . ....................... mite, gunpowder, or other high or dangerous explo Arizona, Delaware, Indiana, M ary sives are manufactured, compounded, or stored. (D e l land, Massachusetts, Michigan,1 aware and Massachusetts laws om it “ stored.” Some Ohio, Wisconsin. States list a few other explosives, such as dualin and guncotton.) In establishments where explosives are manufactured, Pennsylvania *. handled, or stored, as follows: Black powder (all va rieties), dry guncotton, nitroglycerin, dynamite, chlo rates, fulminates, picric acid, fireworks, and any other substances which are subject to expansion b y the aid of shock, friction, spark, or heat. (Smokeless powder, wet guncotton, and wet nitrostarch, while not properly classed with the above as explosives, are also included.) In the manufacture, packing, or storing of powder, dyna Connecticut, Missouri, N ew M ex mite, nitroglycerin compounds, fuses, or other explo ico, N ew Y ork, Oklahoma, sives. (N ew Y ork: “ manufacture, packing, or storing R hode Island. of explosives.” ) In connection with the manufacture, transportation, or North C a rolin a ..____ ___________ use of explosives or highly inflammable substances. In the handling of explosives___________________________ (Verm ont. (Virginia— A n y work in which the handling or use of gunpowder, Iow a____ dynamite, or other like explosive is required. A t or about any place where explosives are used. (Texas: (Texas______ “ In any place.” ) [New Mexico. In operating any place where gunpowder, dynamite, or W yom ing___ other dangerous explosive is manufactured, stored, or compounded or in handling in any manner any danger ous explosive. 16 18 18 16 16 16 18 16 17 18 16 1 Established b y regulation in accordance with authority granted b y the State child-labor law. 17 https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Appendix F.—Hazardous-Occupations Order No. 1 May 18, 1939. Occupations Particularly Hazardous for the Employment of Minors Between 16 and 18 Years of Age or Detrimental to Their Health or Well-Being Sec. 422.1. Occupations in or about plants manufacturing ex plosives or articles containing explosive components.— (a) Finding of fact.— By virtue of and pursuant to the authority conferred by section 3 (1) o f the Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 (52 Stat. 1060) and pursuant to the regulation prescribing the Procedure Governing Determinations of Hazardous Occupations; 1 an investigation having been conducted with respect to the hazards for minors between 16 and 18 years of age in occupations in or about plants manufacturing explosives or articles containing explosive components; a report of the investigation having been submitted to the Chief o f the Children’s Bureau showing that, despite progress in the promotion of safe work ing conditions, the manufacture of explosives and articles containing explosive components is hazardous in nature, that according to avail able figures the accident severity rate for such manufacture has been higher than the average for all manufacturing industries, that work men’s compensation experience likewise shows a high injury cost for such manufacture, that employment in plants manufacturing explo sives or articles containing explosive components is especially hazardous for young workers who are characteristically lacking in the exercise of caution, that in recognition of the particular hazards for young workers o f employment in connection with explosives, 22 States have set a specific minimum age for such employment, higher than for other employment, and that the policy of many manufac turers of explosives or articles containing explosive components is to employ no minors under 18 years o f age in their plants; a public hearing having been held with respect to a proposed finding and order based upon the said report and all parties appearing at the hearing having been given opportunity to be heard, to question wit nesses, and to file briefs and additional statements subsequent to the hearing; the record o f the hearing having been duly considered and certain changes having been made in the proposed finding and order in accordance with suggestions made at the hearing; oppor tunity having been given to all interested parties to file objections within 15 days following publication in the Federal Register2 of the proposed finding and order, as revised, and no objection disclosing just cause for further revision thereof having been received; and sufficient reason appearing therefor, Now, therefore, I, Katharine F. Lenroot, Chief o f the Children’s Bureau o f the United States Department o f Labor, hereby find that all occupations in or about plants manufacturing explosives or 1 Issu ed N ovem b er 3, 1938, p u rsu a n t t o th e a u th o rity c o n fe rre d b y se ctio n 3 ( 1 ) o f th e F a ir L a b or S tandards A ct o f 1938 (5 2 S tat. 1 0 6 0 ), published in th e F ed era l R egister, v o l. 3, p 264 0 D I. N ovem b er 5, 1938. a T h e F ed era l R eg ister, v o l. 4 , p. 175 8 D I , M a y 2, 1939. https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis 19 EXPLOSIVE S-MANUFACTURING INDUSTRIES articles containing explosive components are particularly hazardous for the employment o f minors between 16 and 18 years o f age. (b) Order. Accordingly, I hereby declare that all occupations in or about any plant manufacturing explosives or articles containing explosive components are particularly hazardous for the employment of minors between 16 and 18 years of age. Definitions. For the purpose o f this order— (1) The term plant manufacturing explosives or articles containing explosive components means the land with all buildings and other structures thereon used in connection with the manufacturing or processing of explosives or articles containing explosive components. (2) The terms explosives’ and “articles containing explosive components’’ mean and include ammunition, black powder, blasting caps, fireworks, high explosives, primers, smokeless powder, and all goods classified and defined as explosives by the Interstate Commerce Commission in Regulations for Trans portation by Rail of Explosives, et cetera, as amended, Docket 3666, issued nursuant to the Act of March 4, 1921 (ch. 172, 41 Stat. 1444, U. S. Code, ti 18. sec, 382). This order shall become effective on July 1, 1939, and shall be in force and effect until amended or repealed by order hereafter made and published by the Chief of the Children’s Bureau. K a t h a r in e F. L en root , Chief of the Children's Bureau. https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis