View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

Regional Growth: Full Steam Ahead
September 18, 2014
The regional economy is surging, with the Texas Business
Outlook Survey (TBOS) production and revenue indexes at
multiyear highs and annualized job growth of 3.6 percent
year to date. Second-quarter job growth was 4.6 percent
annualized, and July job growth was just as fast. Energy
production continues to increase, and the rig count has
risen since last August in spite of a decline in oil prices.
Texas exports rebounded in July.
Housing markets have cooled off just enough to slow the
frenetic pace of house price appreciation the past three
years; however, prices are still rising, construction is increasing and sales volume is rebounding.
Commercial real estate markets are also characterized by
rising rents, continued construction and low vacancy rates,
although there are early signs that activity may be slowing
from very high levels.

Chart 1
Texas Employment Growing at Blistering Pace
Percent*
6
4.5
4
Texas

2
0
-2

U.S.

-4
-6
-8

2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
*Seasonally adjusted, annualized rate.
NOTES: Growth is quarter/quarter; shading represents an incomplete third quarter for 2014, which is
July/June for Texas and August/June for U.S.
SOURCES: Bureau of Labor Statistics; Texas Workforce Commission; seasonal adjustments by the
Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas.

Chart 2
TBOS Production and Revenue Growth at Multiyear Highs

Texas Job Growth Spikes; Dallas Heating Up

Index*

Texas employment grew an annualized 4.5 percent in July,
about the same as the 4.6 percent growth realized in the
second quarter—the strongest quarterly growth since 1997
(Chart 1). Employment gains are broad based, with the
energy sector still adding jobs at a faster rate than all other sectors. The unemployment rate remained unchanged at
5.1 percent in July.
Among Texas metropolitan areas, Dallas has seen the fastest employment growth at 4.6 percent year to date, outpacing Austin and Houston. Employment has grown at a
slightly slower rate in major metros with a relatively large
federal government presence and/or manufacturing industry, namely San Antonio, Fort Worth and El Paso.
TBOS Indexes Indicate Continued Robust Growth
The three-month moving averages of the Texas Manufacturing Outlook Survey (TMOS) and Texas Service Sector
Outlook Survey (TSSOS) headline indexes suggest that
economic activity in the state continued to grow at a robust pace in the first half of the year and may have accelerated in the second quarter (Chart 2). Both indexes are
well above their average values for the postrecession period.

Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas

40
Aug.

30

19.8

20

13.8

10
0
-10

Revenue (TSSOS)

-20

Mean TSSOS since 2010 = 10

Production (TMOS)
Mean TMOS since 2010 = 6.8

-30
-40
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
*Three-month moving average; seasonally adjusted.
SOURCES: Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas Texas Business Outlook Surveys (TBOS): Texas
Manufacturing Outlook Survey (TMOS) and Texas Service Sector Outlook Survey (TSSOS).

2014

Contract Values Bolstered by New Petrochemical
Plant
Texas construction contract values reached a record in July
when plans for a new petrochemical plant in Freeport
caused a spike in the data. As a result, inflation-adjusted
construction contract values in the state surpassed their
prerecession peak by 2.2 percent.
Residential Permits Strong; Commercial Rents Climb
Multifamily building permits have surpassed prerecession
highs in Texas and the nation this year (Chart 3). Texas

Regional Economic Update

1

Chart 3
Permits Data Suggest Texas Multifamily Building
May Cool Off After a Remarkable Run
Index, January 2006 = 100*
200

Texas
multifamily

180
160

160.9

140
U.S.
multifamily

120
100

100.7

80

Texas single
family
56.4

60
40

36.2
U.S. single
family

20
0
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
*Five-month moving average; seasonally adjusted, annualized rates.
NOTE: Last data point is July.
SOURCE: U.S. Census Bureau.

2012

2013

2014

multifamily construction has been very strong, but a decline
in permits since the start of the year suggests apartment
construction may begin to slow. Despite the increased supply of apartments, rents continue to rise in all major Texas
metros due to continued solid demand.
In contrast to the roaring growth in multifamily, singlefamily home construction has increased gradually. This
slower growth is in part due to constraints on the supply
side, such as a shortage of developed lots, higher construction costs and widespread labor shortages. Texas home
price appreciation is slowing, increasing 0.2 percent in the
second quarter, according to the Federal Housing Finance
Agency purchase-only house price index. Year over year,
prices are up 6.5 percent.
Office markets are healthy, marked by rising rents in all
major metros. Lease rates in Houston are nearing those in
Austin—the city with the highest office rents in the state—
while rents are rising more slowly in Fort Worth and San
Antonio. Rising rents have spurred office construction
enough that some observers are concerned new supply will
depress rent growth, particularly in Houston.

Chart 4
Net Imports of Petroleum Products Go Negative as Exports Surge
Millions of barrels per day*
4

Rig Counts Rise, While Oil Prices Dip

3

Crude oil prices have trended downward since late July,
while natural gas prices have firmed slightly. Drilling activity has picked up slightly in the Eleventh Federal Reserve
District. Since August, the Texas rig count has been over
900—the highest in two years—and New Mexico is at 96
rigs—its highest level since 2006.

2
1
0
-1

Plentiful supplies of relatively inexpensive oil and natural
gas liquids in the Gulf Coast region have led to record exports of petroleum products. The U.S. has been a net exporter of petroleum products since July 2011 (Chart 4). A
recent U.S. ruling allowing some exports of condensate
could further boost this trend.

-2
-3
2002
2004
2006
2008
*Four-week moving average.
NOTE: Last data point is the week of Aug. 29.
SOURCE: Energy Information Administration.

2010

2012

2014

July Exports Surge
Chart 5
TBOS Wage Pressures at Postrecession Highs
Index*
30
25

Wages (TMOS)
Wages (TSSOS)
Mean TMOS since 2010 = 15.4

20

Mean TSSOS since 2010 = 13.4

22.1
20.2

15
10
5

Prices and Wage Pressures Growing

0
-5
-10
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
*Three-month moving average; seasonally adjusted.
SOURCES: Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas Texas Business Outlook Survey (TBOS): Texas
Manufacturing Outlook Survey (TMOS) and Texas Service Sector Outlook Survey (TSSOS).

Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas

Texas exports rose in July after six straight months of no
growth. The July total of $26.5 billion surpassed the prior
peak earlier this year (in January). Year to date, exports
are up 7.8 percent over the same period last year. Weak
global demand is contributing to slow export growth. Texas
exports are likely helped by the dominance of refined petroleum products and the extent of intra-industry trade,
which reflects domestic demand more than international
demand.

2014

Both the TMOS finished goods prices and the TSSOS selling
prices indexes have been rising at above-average rates this
year, with August readings well above their postrecession
averages.

Regional Economic Update

2

Chart 6
Current Company Outlook Stumbles; Future Outlook Remains Bright
Index*
40

30

Company outlook
6-month (TMOS)

20

10

0

Company outlook
current (TMOS)

-10

-20
2010
2011
2012
2013
*Seasonally adjusted.
SOURCE: Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas' Texas Manufacturing Outlook Survey (TMOS).

2014

The payroll survey data on average hourly earnings for all
private sector workers suggests wages are rising faster in
Texas than in the U.S. Texas hourly earnings rose 3.6 percent in the past year, compared with a U.S. increase of 1.7
percent over the same period. Wage pressures remain far
above their average levels, according to both TMOS and
TSSOS (Chart 5). At index values around 20, TSSOS wage
pressures remain near their series high reached earlier this
year (in April). The TMOS wage index hit 23.7 in August and
is at levels not seen since January 2008.
Outlook Positive, but Growth Pace Unsustainable
The Dallas Fed leading index grew in June for the fifth consecutive month, rising 0.4 percent. Combined with strong
July employment gains, the Dallas Fed forecast is for 3.6
percent job growth in 2014.
All told, the regional economy is growing at an unsustainable
pace. Texas employment has grown at more than twice its
long-run average rate over the past four months. Declines in
unemployment measures have slowed, suggesting Texas is
near full employment and slack is being depleted. The rapid
growth has led to labor shortages, which can cause bottlenecks in production and hurt productivity. Tight labor and
housing markets are leading to mounting wage pressures
and increasing prices.
A sign of possible slowing is the TMOS current company outlook index, which turned sharply downward in August, falling
9.8 points from July. Comparing that with the future (sixmonth-ahead) company outlook index that ticked up slightly
in August, the slowdown may be just temporary (Chart 6).
—Sarah Bindner and Pia Orrenius
………........................................................................
About the Authors
Bindner is a research assistant and Orrenius is vice president and senior economist in the Research Department at
the Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas.

Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas

Regional Economic Update

3