View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

FINAL AGENDA

Committee on Financial Analysis
Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia
April 20 and 21, 1966

Wednesday, April 20 :
Morning (9:00 A.M.)
I.

The Concept of Liquidity
A.

Role in Economic Analysis —
Reserve Bank of St. Louis
Comment:

B.

Leonall Anderson, Federal

Richard Davis, Federal Reserve Bank
of New York
Arthur Broida, Board of Governors

Bank Liquidity — Martin Blyn, Federal Reserve Bank
of Cleveland
James Pierce, Board of Governors
Comment:

John Zoellner, Federal. Reserve Bank
of Kansas City

mcheon (12:30 P.M. to 1:30 P.M.)
-rp>mfl-rV^ ~bv Mr. Karl R . Bopp, P r e s i d e n t . Federal
Reserve Bank of Philadelphia

T n fn rm n 1

Afternoon (2:00 P.M. to 5:00 P.M.)
C.




Corporate Liquidity — Hugh Chaimoff, Federal Reserve
Bank of Philadelphia
Comment:

George Cloos, Federal Reserve Bank
of Chicago

-2-

Thursday, April 21:
Morning (9:00 A.M. to 1:00 P.M.)
II.

The Significance of Total Credit
A.

Bank Credit and Total. Credit —
Reserve Bank of New York
Comment:

B.

Marshall Puckett, Federal

Lyle Gramley, Board of Governors
James Duprey, Federal Reserve Bank
of Minneapolis

Total Credit Flows — Concept, Measurement, and Estimation
Stephen Taylor, Board of Governors
Comment:

Ronald Cooper, Federal Reserve Bank
of San Francisco

Luncheon (l:30 P.M. to 2:30 P.M.)
—

Informal remarks by academic guests

Afternoon (2:00 P.M. to 4:00 P.M.)
—

Recapitulation and planning for future meetings




Maurice Mann, Chairman
Committee on Financial Analysis

Kci

apr 28

April 25, 1966.

System Committee on Financial Analysis
Summary Minutes of Meeting Held in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
April 19-21, 1966

Present for all or part of the meeting:
Boston
New York
Philadelphia

Cleveland
Richmond
Atlanta
Chicago
St. Louis
Minneapolis
Kansas City
Dallas
San Francisco
Board
Guests

Messrs. Anderson and Murphy
Messrs. Davis and Puckett
Messrs. Bopp, Rothwell, Aff, Alderfer,
Chairnoff, Eastburn, O'Leary, Staats,
and Miss Deutermann
Messrs. Mann (Chairman) and Blyn
Mr. Haymes
Messrs. Wyand, Crowe, and Brandt
Messrs. Stiles and Cloos
Messrs. Bowsher and Anderson
Mr. Duprey
Messrs. Zoellner and Struble
Mr. Saylor
Mr. Cooper
Messrs. Partee, Gramley, Broida, Pierce,
and Taylor
Professors A. G. Hart, Columbia University,
Albert Ando, University of Pennsylvania
and Lawrence R. Klein, University of
Pennsylvania.

The Spring meeting of the Committee on Financial Analysis was
convened at 9:00 a.m., April 20, 1966, at the Federal Reserve Bank of
Philadelphia. Mr. Mann presided.
The first day of the session was concerned with the concept
of liquidity and its relevance for ecnonomic activity and central
banking. Leonall Anderson (Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis) opened
this part of the program with a paper on the concept of liquidity and
its role in economic analysis, focusing particularly on the consumer
sector. Richard Davis (Federal Reserve Bank of New York) and Arthur
Broida (Board of Governors) provided formal comments. Following this
were two papers on bank liquidity given by ftartin Blyn (Federal Reserve
Bank of Cleveland) and James Pierce (Board of Governors). The
discussant for these two papers was John Zoellner (Federal Reserve Bank
of Kansas City). The question of corporate liquidity was treated
in a paper by Hugh Chairnoff (Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia),
with formal discussion by George Cloos (Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago)




At lunch on the first dav the group was greeted by Mr. Karl Bopp
(President. Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia) who spoke informally
on the role and prospects for research in the formulation and implementa­
tion of monetary policy.
On the second day the Committee's attention focused on the
significance of credit flows for evaluation of financial market develop­
ments. Marshall Puckett of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York
evaluated the significance of differing growth rates of bank credit as
a potential indicator of credit availability and as a proxy for total
credit flows. The formal discussants for his paper were James Duprey
(Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis) and Lyle Gramley (Board of Governors).
Stephen Taylor (Board of Governors) then discussed the concept, measure­
ment, and estimation of total credit flows in the context of the flowof-funds accounting system. Ronald Cooper (Federal Reserve Bank of
San Francisco) discussed a paper by himself and Robert J. Oster, in which
an attempt was made to utilize flow-of-funds data for sectoral analysis
of cyclical changes in flows of funds.
The first day's session on liquidity was attended by
Professor A. G. Hart of Columbia University and Professor Lawrence R.
Klein of the University of Pennsylvania. The second day's session
was attended by Professor Albert Ando of the University of Pennsylvania.
The latter part of the second day was devoted to Committee
business and planning for the fall meeting, tentatively scheduled to
be held at the Fedaral Reserve Bank of Minneapolis during the week of
October 17-21. The specific date will be announced later. The first
day of that session will deal with recent progress in the linkage
research area. Selected members of Mr. Mann's working group on
linkage research will provide papers. There will be three invited
papers on the second day, by Professor Albert Ando of the University of
Pennsylvania, Fred Struble of the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City,
and Thomas Thomson of the Board of Governors. Ando's paper will be on
a special purpose model for monetary policy. Struble will provide a
survey paper on the term structure of interest rates. Thomson will
give a paper on short-run reserve adjustments of commercial banks.
The Committee decided to continue the policy of soliciting short formal
commentaries on the principal papers. Specific discussants will be
announced later, along with the more detailed agenda for the fall
meeting. It is the sense of the Committee that all papers to be
presented at the fall meeting should be distributed to Committee members
as far in advance as possible.
The Committee accepted with regret the resignation of
J. Charles Partee as Secretary, offering its sincere thanks for a
task well done.
The meeting was adjourned at 2:45 p.m. on April 21.w




Lyle E. Gramley,
Secretary,
System Research
Committee on Financial Analysis.

Listing for Meeting of
Committee on Financial Analysis
Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia
April 20-21, 1966
MEMBERS- COMMITTEE ON FINANCIAL ANALYSIS
Maurice Mann, Chairman
Paul Anderson
Richard Davis
J. C. Rothwell
Harmon Haymes
Robert R. Wyand, II
Lynn A. Stiles
Norman N. Bowsher
James N. Duprey
John F. Zoellner
R. Gerald Saylor
Ronald Cooper
J. Charles Partee, Secretary

(Cleveland)
(Boston)
(New York)
(Philadelphia)
(Richmond)
(Atlanta)
(Chicago)
(St. Louis)
(Minneapolis)
(Kansas City)
(Dallas)
(San Francisco)
(Board)

OTHER PARTICIPANTS
Neil Murphy
Edward A. Aff
Clay J. Anderson
Evan B. Alderfer
Hugh Chairnoff
Elizabeth P. Deutermann
David P. Eastbum
David C. Melnicoff
Lawrence C. Murdoch
John F. O'Leary
Kenneth M. Snader
William F. Staats
Bertram W. Zumeta
Martin Blyn
Harry Brandt
Paul Crowe
George Cloos
Leonall. C. Anderson
Fred Struble
Arthur Broida
James Eckert
Lyle E. Gramley
James Pierce
Stephen Taylor




(Boston)
(Philadelphia)
(Philadelphia)
(Philadelphia)
(Philadelphia)
(Philadelphia)
(Philadelphia)
(Ph ilade lph ia)
(Philadelphia)
(Philadelphia)
(Philadelphia)
(Philadelphia)
(Philadelphia)
(Cleveland)
(Atlanta)
(Atlanta)
(Chicago)
(St. Louis)
(Kansas City)
(Board)
(Board)
(Board)
(Board)
(Board)

GUESTS

Prof. Albert Ando
Department of Economics
University of Pennsylvania
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

Prof. John G. Gurley
Department of Economics
Stanford University
Stanford, California

Prof. Irwin Friend
Department of Economics
University of Pennsylvania
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

Prof. A. G. Hart
Department of Economics
Columbia University
New York

Prof. Lawrence R. Klein
Department of Economics
University of Pennsylvania
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania