View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

Y
EDUCATION AND DEMOCRACY

/
(An address by Chester C. Davis, Member, Board of."Governors, >
Poderal Reserve System, at the dedication of Long Agri—
""
cultural Hall, May .12, 1937, at CIemson Agricultural
College, Clcmson, South Carolina)
We are gathered to dedicate a new agricultural "building to tho
^vice of South Carolina, and to tho memory of the worth and works of
^ttanknown "by most of us and loved by all who knew him. Dr, Long's
j^vice hero as Director of Extension spanned half the life of Clomson
°Hege - twenty-two crowded years which carried tho light from tho
g^PUs of this great institution to every hillside and valley of the
c
"And now ho rests; his greatness and his sweetness
No more shall seem at strife;
And death has moulded into calm completeness
Tho statue of his life."
SG

Dr. Long was an outstanding figure among those who on this
made a vital', breathing force of tho vision of another great man,
light of whoso life is all around us here. The impact of the
jinking of Thomas C-. Clcmson has been felt all over the land, not only
n
the State for whose people ho established this institution
1

The event which gave to tho world tho nucleus of Clcmson Colrobbod it of tho man who could have influenced and enjoyed its
J^^tivo years most. Tho linos might truly have been written of him
said"'Twas his to lend a life; 'twas man's to borrow;
'Twas his to make, but not to share, the morrow."
f°So

tv •
Horo, then, were two men who marked their times„ Tho seed of
l?031-^
usefulness
lay not in tho times, but in them. Certainly not the
o.J 3 half of tho century, nor the first third of the prcsont one, throw
to men as stirring and as demanding as that which the
^ challenge
chal
s3
°nt
°nt and future hold out to the youth of today
^ U S f

„

„

^

,

O

-

J

_ -O

i-T.

.

+- VN-vj

Diogenes or.ee remarked that the foundation of every state i
°ducation°of its youth. That was over twenty-two hundred years ago,
oj^ it seems understatement when wo apply it to tho complex problems
Modern democracy. Enlightened public opinion resting on full iniJ^tion stands as the only hope for tho continued successful functional of democratic government *
We are in a swiftly-changing day. The progress of tho future,
,v'ell as tho accomplishments of the pas t, rest on the shoulders of men
tJJ.Women who uso the powers bostowod on thorn to create better instiions to moot new conditions®
tV/
' tuS
Al

Forgetting all else that distinguished them, wo think of the
educators whoso names arc perpetuated here in Long AgriculHall of Clcmson College. But tho field of education is so

I ^21
XERO
COPY

^y

broad that I should like to mark out for a moment's consideration that
n
°w subdivision to which Dr. Long gave the last quarter century of his
*lch life o
I mean no unfavorable comparisons to bo drawn from the fact
j^t I speak of agricultural extension today, rather than research
through experiment stations, or resident instruction such as has dcjolopcd in this groat institution and the half-a-hundred kindred schools
•J-1} the length and breadth of the land. But truly hero is a development
v
ithout parallel in the recent history of educations
This far-flung organization, scarcoly come of ago, radiates
^om the agricultural colleges into direct or indirect touch with the
million farm homes of America. It brings to them the discoveries
* the experiment stations and the physical and economic information
Which better and sounder agriculture is being developed,, You will
search this century in vain without finding another contribution to
QUcation as important in its present and future significance as this
ystora of practical teaching brought intimately into the daily lives
1
farm families«
3
Perhaps you think I speak too feelingly of the work of the
v
°
°ted
men
and women wo know as the Extension Service, There is a
v
03?
y good reason, if I do.
Five years ago the farming sections of the United States colla£scd in a condition of disorganization, of physical and financial
<U
t ^solution, not equaled at any time since commercial farming was cs~
•polished in this country. You men and women of South Carolina who
ivoa in tho heart of the Cotton South through those dark days need no
of mine to recall them to you,
Four years ago today tho Agricultural Adjustment Act became
* It provided tho means by which tho cotton grower, the tobacco
the producers of whoat and corn and hogs and all tho crops
jw^kis diversified country could organize to balance their supply with
voting markets; and build back their income and purchasing powor so
CC1
1 to tho welfare of the nation^

•

As one who was honored by some responsibility in tho adminis°^ion
of
that law during the first thrco years of organization and
Ot)
•j^Fation, I know what tho Extension Service of tho agricultural colour?03 moant to tho farmers of tho land. If it had not boon for the
s
Ui3 tenco of that system, trained and trusted, ready to take up now and
j^^icd responsibilities, the work that was done under tho Agricultural
^stmont Act could not have been accomplished.
v^
These are times of swift movement and change. The farmers
£0 ^operated under tho A.A.A.,—and their number represented nearly
thc six and a
half million farm units in the country — those
0:i?s
^ho
and wo who wore temporarily your servants in administering
law believed, that the opportunity stretched ahead of us to achieve
? f°undation of our beginnings, through closc-knit cooperation,
U]?
ing equality for agriculture in tho economic life of the nation.

XERO i
copy :

. .
More than two and a half years aftor the Act went into offeet,
uring which it wa3 operating with the force of law, the high court of
land, in an astounding decision, struck the foundations from beneath
ao program, A majority of the court held that agricultural production
, 3 ^ local matter in which States, but not the Federal Government, might
0
concerned. There is no time to review that decision hero. Perhaps,
°wover, you will grant mo leave to digress for a little comment.
In my present work with tho Board of Governors of the Federal
System I have become acutely aware that, while ^Government spendin a depression to kocp the wheels of industry turning is a vital
a h °^ rrIod-orn government', it is equally important to be able to call
^ aalt and commence retiring the public debt when business has regained
3
own momentum. With that in mind, I should like to remind not this
i^Jonco alone, but tho great host of American business and financial
cilGorGd
th^ er>3
- most when the Supremo Court ruled against tho A.A.A.
farr 1
' program was one emergency enterprise designed to be self- to pay its way as it wont along, without drain on the
1
itod States Treasury.

Ro
.

I cannot review in this brief talk the recent history of
',tt-1°na'1" ^ a r m legislation. In any event, I should have hesitated to
it, because the distinguished Chairman of tho Senate Committee
"^iculture, your own Senator Ellison D. Smith of South Carolina,
^Pocted to bo hero today—the dean cf the Senators of tho majority
toi»
~ n Washington, whom you have honored with the longest continuous
,vh \Qvory accorded a Senator from your State. It was Senator Smith
0
brunt;
Son
°r
battle in guiding through tho Senate the
r^Q £ Conservation Act which was enacted within little more than a
noS
the Supremo Court ruling. Tho farmers of the country are
^ o p e r a t i n g under that law. Tho personal assistance and courtesy
agi>- Senator Smith has accorded me during tho years of our service to
^ ^culture add to my pleasure in speaking hero in his state today.
•3ott-i

Questions considered in the A.A.A. case have not boon
tJlG
majority opinion tho Court abandoned tho philosophy
Co®? which earlier problems had been met, and which had made of our
Y/q.sS ^tution a vital guide for a growing nation. The majority opinion
^o ?? °-nto-bollum opinion. Tho philosophy pervades it which moved
the t n t B u c h a n a n .' o n February 24, 1859, to voto th'o act establishing
v
ot nci"Grant agricultural colleges, because, as ho then wrote in his
in ? 1 m ° 3 s a SO: ''Congress docs not havo tho power to appropriate money
ivG
Treasury for tho purpose of educating tho people of tho rcspectW f t a t o s . Should Congress exercise such a power, this would bo to
Co^t" down the barriers which have been so carefully constructed in tho
°tltution to separate Federal from State authority."
In

8tn4.
Inevitably the contrast springs into my mind between that
^ ^ o a t , that philosophy, and an utterance on the same subject by tho
tho 1 ° S^ve his" name to this groat college - Thomas Clemson, not only
/Y 1oundor of this institution but one of tho fathers of tho present
Oqxi m o f agricultural and scientific education through Land Grant
C0n;;GSes. He worked for the passage of tho Land Grant College Act,
'
a movement to establish such a collcgc, he wrote:

J 2§?)

!co

- 4 -

"The only hope wo havo for tho advancomont of agriculture
is through the sciences and yet there is not one singlo
institution on this continent where a proper scientific
education can bo obtained. Those who wish to cultivate
science are compelled to resort to institutions maintained by the monarchied governments of Europe.• •
"If I were called upon to say how money would bo oxponded with the greatest possible security for usefulness,
I would point with confidence to such an institution as
the act proposes..t
"Such a project to moot tho wants of tho people and tho
ago will require large outlays, but once established
under a proper organization, it will be tho pride and
ornament of" tho State; it will turn out annually persons
well and oroporly educated and capable of superintending
and directing any art without possible chanco of failure,poor land will be- invigorated, the recuperative energies
of exhausted soils restored - and wealth and prosperity
will prevail where desolation, want and wretchedness now
obtain."
There you have the issue — there tho contrast. On one hand
man who wraps himself in draperies of tho dead and says, "You can't?
ether, the man who says, "We will" and leads tho way. On ono
the man who bcliovos anything is evil that threatens to disturb
G
On the other, the man who socs that tho adaptation of
0/J status quo.
institutions to moot changing pressures is tho only way to prevent
^Plosion.

0£

G

It is in the nature of man to consider the present order
and
fe
enduring. Even trained observers are disposed to see pcrEdward Gibbon was writing the third
v ^ion in things' as they are,
rpUtao of his "Rise and Fall of tho Roman Empire" in 1780, when tho
v/orc smouldering that within tho dccado flamed forth in tho
Gibbon know Franco as woll as any of his contcmporav?ttch Revolution*.
Vot
find him writing of Europe at that time as ono great
»Whose inhabitants have attained almost the same level of policeto"? ancl cultivation. Tho balance of power," ho wrote, "will continue
w ^uctuatc, and the prosperity of our own or tho neighboring kingdoms
alternately oxaltccl and depressed; but these partial events can°ssontially injure our general state of happiness, the system of
th
and laws, and manners which so advantageously distinguish, above
^ost of mankind, the Europeans and their Colonicscr
W,
Surely tho man is an optimist who believes our problems are
>wlo<l, or can bo settled without continued action by people through
government, perhaps along unprecedented lines,, Surely the man
thn t0t
lessons of history who boliovcs all will be woll if wo ox
lC3 United States can only turn the clock back to tho fovcrish late
^tios.
lQn

There are problems to solve, and they arc not easy. Without
tho field of agriculture, arc wo not concerned to see that
na
itions that brought on the collapse of 1932 are not repeated?
XERO
COPY i

~ 5

vo wo not ready to attack tho fundamental causes that havo brought on
dispossession of land by fornor owners, and a terrible waste of
"°il^resourccs thomselvos? A half century ago only one out of four
^orican farmors rented tho land he tilled. Today more than two out
° five aro tenants, and tho percentage is rising,
g
A year ago, in April, I was driving through Denmark with tho
R o t a r y of the Danish Council of Agriculture. Ho pointed to a group
cq gildings rising in a field to our loft, and said, ?!I invite you to
"back in 1938, to attend the exposition celebrating tho one hundred
fiftieth annivorsry of the abolition of tenancy in Denmark*"
This was and remains a remarkable and admirable accomplishment
bai
problem which tho Danes had to moot, with their homogeneous,
pav^1?00^ farm population, was far simpler than that of this country,
°icularly in the Southern, cotton-growing states *
In our country the firs*
first principle of sccuro land ownership
Ja ^°PGndablo and adequate incomo
To establish men as owners on the
ow
vni thoy nnow
farm as
as tenants
tenants will
will accomplish nothing of permanent
vafr.^y
farm
Ug
unless there is a profitable return upon the farming operation*
t^.. .
Tho problem of farm tenancy is a challenge to the constructive
in
of this generation,, Sixty-five percent of all farmers engaged
c
otf
of cotton farm land owned by somoono else. Yet tho
the
states; illustrate clearly the point I cm trying to make — that
n
adoquato returns for farming must be solved before
^sfactory solution to the tenancy question is found,
Eleven states produce practically all of our cotton. Those
states contain 45 »4 percent of all the farmers in tho United
Cs
* Yet those farmers, nearly half of all, received in 1935 only
cr>0?^cont, or little more than one-fourth, of tho gross income from
and livestock in this country.
fe^

Or put it another way. The average gross return for each
in the cotton states was less than half the average for the farm'
c
°rvh tilc o n ' t i r c country including southern farmers. Hero is a ccniltl?ation of population engaged in farming for a poor return, with
s w | ° or no opportunity for profitable occupation vet developed to
its income. So long as that condition prevails, living
ard
-s will bo unsatisfactory no matter how the terms of land tenuro
shuffiod.
opp

W.

The South is maing great strides in the development of now
tun
itios for employment from its rich potential resources. The
^ 8 of the Cotton Belt, along with farmers of the West and the
arc
organized, with tho help cf tho Federal Government, in a war
3t

practices that waste their soil. What is being accomplished
U i w ^ s , -s do all enduring endeavors of a democracy, upon intelligent
l a n d i n g among tho massos of tho pooplc. That understanding
upon information and education, brought to the pooplo in
* W t o use. In that work tho agricultural colleges, with their oxperistations and extension sorvicc, havo mado a notable, perhaps an
°-llelod contribution.

—-

XERO
i.'n C O P Y

f^

f—-*!

c^

-6-

Expcrionco of the last few years has shewn that this stimu^v?, o n
r.iass thinking makes great coordinated national effort possi—
D
i°* Recent observations havo hade no wish that some comparablo
Qd
.ucational force existed in the field of banking, rionoy and credit.
It is clear to mo that we arc in a period of far-reaching
^angc and evolution in our money and credit policies,and in the agon^J-os that aro concerned with them® What is done will affect vitally
nan, woman and child of the nation. The farmer down to the last
-^Gcroppcr fs. family has in part his future in the stake, Our ex^^ionccs of the early 'twenties, and again in the early 'thirties, arc
^ f r e s h in our minds. Yot it has seemed to me that in this field
is almost a total lack of the general information which is csscna
l to clear and unprejudiced thinking,,
Much of our thinking about money goes back to the day when
onc
£ ° r n o r another, usually with fixed value in gold or
9 consti
ou
'buted the medium of exchange. Today about 95 percent of
r
business is settled by bank chocks„ The banker who extends credit
nonoy by an entry on his books or on the books of another bank—
y
that
can build a house, pay for making a crop, or run a business
0r
fac-b
It pays the wagosof labor, or buys raw material for a

c

^

Similarly, when banks restrict credit or when banks fail, they
Co
as
contraction of our bank currency, of our money, just as truly
is !louSh the government collected bank notes and destroyed them. This
t L ^ y credit control must bo oxorcisod by a public body representing
^ intorosts of tho whole nation,
a v.

The power to create and destroy money is a gigantic power and
responsibility. N 0 thread of common policy runs through tho
no?
possess this power. Nearly two-thirds of them in number are
bombers
of the Federal Roscrvo System, although 86 percent of the
Vol
1.5 onG 0:r clocking accounts is carried by System banks.
The more than
j30' 0 0 banks aro chartered, supervised or examined by at least 51
^ato and distinct authorities«,
c^q.,.
30Vn

The laws and rules under which tho vital functions of money,
d banking are conducted arc written by tho Congress and the
legislatures. In the long run, Congresses arc responsive to
in
opinion. Yot how can public opinion exert constructive forcc
^ ^iolcl where there Is so little general information and thought?
an

Shun
What is tho function of gold in the future monetary system?
of i wo again pin our faith to gold or some other metal or combination
t h o ^ a l s as a sort of automatic regulator of our money system? Or is
mc^ Wo *la going to novo still farther in the direction of what is callcd
then 0(1 n °noy -- that is, managed by human agencies rather than by
3t 0 ^ ot ically automatic gold or some othor disembodied mechanism? What
^Wiivj

U U

l.li.U:i.U

t/iA/UJ.

u

a o

u v . u i x u u j . ^

w w

v^-iw

man, and on as reasonable terms, as to tho largo urban borrow; Have we taken adoquato stops to avoid future waves of bank fail3 a
nd financial liquidation? What is the inter-relationship of our
XERO i
COn V !

- 7 -

anc1- o t h o r

ah

investors with the public debt? Should the government
the almost universal practice of issuing interest-bearing bonds
bQ??.1^ borrows on credit, and turn to the issuance of non-interest
aring notes in their stead?
I could add to those questions indefinitely and so could any
0£
1 woulci n o t
if
attempt to answer them to your satisfaction oven
V/CI, n o
that°
to m J time and your patience. I assure you
1:110
aro
in h
questions
not unimportant or remote. Every one of them is
the foreground or background of public consideration today.
Sy

,

The main economic problem of our generation is to devise a
? wllGr °in the flow of money will be steady and uninterrupted, inonly in proportion to our ability to produce more goods0
of
Perhaps more than any other class, suffer from the alternation
? 0Cis anci cl-rouSilts in the money flow. They owe it to themselves,
* 08
to play an a-ctivo role in devising a system of levees and
•o ^ V o i r s in our financial mechanism, so that the flow of money will
FCa^0ciuo.tc, and no more than adequate, to match the flow of goods at a
t w ° n a b l y stable price level® I am hopeful that more and more atton-'
i Gp
be paid, to this range of problems in our agricultural colg^Q ?• It is not enough that wo should increase our efficiency in
do^^J^o and making things. There must also be a market and a steady
•ana for the things wo are capablo of producing*
c^o

t^.
There is need for someone to write a primer explaining these
rs
°Ug 2 * There is need for agencies to disseminate it. It is dangerou^J0. ov°nsimplify the factors of the problem, but at least they
b 0
to bo oxprossed so that wo can understand thorn.
V/

hat fi
* v/ i sh sonioono would do in the field of money and credit
a r
do 5
G icultural colleges and extension service arc beginning to
SW"?
domain of agricultural economics. But my thought today is
d l ^ ; to stato some of the questions, not to answer them. I have
a
'dy strayed too far from the occasion*

f^Q^ ,
^inc1

For no particular reason except that I have wandered away
essential topic, and now must return, there comos to my
inscription that stands over the gate of a very old English
"Give fools their gold, and knaves their power,
Let fortunes bubble rise and fall;
Who sows a fiold, or tonds a flower,
Or plants a tree, is more than all,"

And now in conclusion, to the youth assembled hero, to the
South Carolina, just one word of encouragement and chalv/
^Ut '
iH not go from this campus into a fixed and settled world,
a sw
i£tly~changing scene which needs your leadership and will
w 10
W ^ d g o
" ^now him, and you who did not, sense the
i°ft by the passing of that rich life which gave tho now agrih0
hall its name. Though ho worked hard and accomplished greatly,
^Oat
^ins""0 to toll you that the tasks loft unfinished are
Qx>
than those that were put behinde
171

°n

XERO
COPY i

- 8 -

^
In South Africa, at tho closo of his crowded life, Cecil
^odcs, the greatest Englishman of his generation, suixiod up in his
^ast words tho fooling of those who hand tho baton to thoso who nust
arry on. Turning his face away fron tho faithful friends who were
Oes
ido hin, ho said:
"So little dono - so r.iuch tc,do0:T
Thoso words throw down tho challenge to you who have the
•So and tho training to take it up*