View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

Search



A

A

A

REAL ESTATE RESEARCH

ABOUT

July 10, 2013

REAL ESTATE RESEARCH
SEARCH

Real Estate Research provided
analysis of topical research and
current issues in the fields of housing
and real estate economics. Authors
for the blog included the Atlanta Fed's
Jessica Dill, Kristopher Gerardi, Carl
Hudson, and analysts, as well as the

Why Housing Rebound May Continue at a Slower Rate
Than Hoped For

Search
RECENT POSTS

Perhaps it's because I've worked with bank examiners for many years, but I often
question financial news that seems too optimistic. On July 1, 2013, the U.S.

Assessing the Size and Spread of
Vulnerable Renter Households in

Census Bureau reported that overall construction spending increased in May.
Private residential construction, which generally leads the economy, grew 24.4

the Southeast
What's Being Done to Help Renters

In December 2020, content from Real
Estate Research became part of

percent from May 2012 to May 2013. Beyond being cautious with one data point,
I think that there are several reasons why housing's rebound may be slower than

during the Pandemic?
An Update on Forbearance Trends

Policy Hub. Future articles will be
released in Policy Hub: Macroblog.

hoped.

Examining the Effects of COVID-19
on the Southeast Housing Market

To be clear, residential real estate conditions have been improving, albeit from
record low levels of activity. Sales of both new and existing houses have been

Southeast Housing Market and
COVID-19

trending up recently, but remain near historically low levels. Additionally, the
quantity of new and existing homes readily available for sale is low.

Update on Lot Availability and
Construction Lending

Homebuilders in the Sixth Federal Reserve District (which includes Alabama,
Florida, and Georgia and parts of Louisiana, Mississippi, and Tennessee)

Tax Reform's Effect on Low-Income
Housing

recently reported that new home sales and construction have been ahead of
year-earlier levels and that buyer traffic remains strong (see this SouthPoint

Housing Headwinds
Where Is the Housing Sector

post). Builders noted, however, that access to financing and a shortage of
developed lots continued to constrain construction activity. In conjunction with

Headed?
Did Harvey Influence the Housing

the recent construction spending data release, it is this last point that I aim to dig
into a bit deeper in this blog post.

Market?
CATEGORIES

Since the housing bust, construction and development (C&D) lending has been

Affordable housing goals

in sharp decline in terms of aggregate dollars and as a percent of total bank
assets. Using year-end data, we find that C&D loans peaked in 2007 at $629.4

Credit conditions
Expansion of mortgage credit

billion. As of 2012, they stood at $203.8 billion. As of March 2013, C&D loans
accounted for 1.4 percent of bank assets, unchanged from December 2012 and

Federal Housing Authority
Financial crisis

the lowest level since at least 1991. The decline in C&D lending is broad based
given that similar trends are seen for banks under and over $1 billion in total

Foreclosure contagion
Foreclosure laws

assets. With the recent reports of growing construction spending, will bank
lending practices dampen construction growth going forward?

Governmentsponsored enterprises
GSE

Banks represent a significant funding source for homebuilders, especially

Homebuyer tax credit
Homeownership

nonpublic homebuilders. Using data from 1991 to 2012, there appears to be a
strong, positive relationship between bank construction lending and private

House price indexes
Household formations

residential construction put in place—see the chart. Of course, it's impossible to
tell from this chart whether construction activity is responding to changes in

Housing boom
Housing crisis

credit supply or credit supply is responding to changes in construction demand.
However, banks have been extremely tight with credit in the aftermath of the

Housing demand
Housing prices

financial crisis, and there aren't many signs that banks plan to change course
any time soon. So it may be reasonable to assume that a continued reduction in

Income segregation
Individual Development Account

bank C&D lending is likely to limit future gains in construction activity.

Loan modifications
Monetary policy

Boston Fed's Christopher Foote and
Paul Willen.

Disclaimer
Email Me
Subscribe by E-mail
Subscribe by RSS
Other Fed Websites
Comment Standards:
Comments are moderated and will
not appear until the moderator has
approved them.
Please submit appropriate
comments. Inappropriate comments
include content that is abusive,
harassing, or threatening; obscene,
vulgar, or profane; an attack of a
personal nature; or overtly political.
In addition, no off-topic remarks or
spam is permitted.

Mortgage crisis
Mortgage default
Mortgage interest tax deduction
Mortgage supply
Multifamily housing
Negative equity
Positive demand shock
Positive externalities
Rental homes
Securitization
Subprime MBS
Subprime mortgages
Supply elasticity
Uncategorized
Upward mobility
Urban growth

A case for optimism
In conversations with banks of various sizes, two things are often repeated. First,
bankers indicate there is little appetite for growth in C&D lending and second,
banks of various sizes want to increase commercial and industrial lending (C&I).
For many banks, a move from C&D lending to C&I lending is easier said than
done—the skillsets needed for C&I lending differ from those associated with
C&D. Acquiring C&I expertise is a challenge particularly for smaller banks. So
what's a community bank going to do?
An old adage is to do what you know best. For many community banks that
would be C&D lending. Given the reports of lot shortages and house inventory
being low, it would seem that profitable opportunities for C&D lending exist.
There is nothing wrong with C&D loans appropriately underwritten and subject to
reasonable risk management. A key question is when banks start moving back to
C&D lending, will they be able to resist the shortcuts of the last cycle? Let's hope
that banks can successfully navigate a return to C&D lending so that the housing
market can continue to recover.

By Carl Hudson, Director, Center for Real Estate Analytics in the Atlanta Fed's
research department
July 10, 2013 in Credit conditions, House price indexes, Housing boom
| Permalink

Frequently Asked Questions
GDPNow

Careers
Contact Us

Inflation Project
Jobs Calculator
Market Probability Tracker

A to Z index
Follow the Fed
Publications

Speakers Bureau
Teacher Workshops

Disclaimer & Terms of Use
Online Privacy Policy

Wage Growth Tracker

Data Privacy Policy
Home

1000 Peachtree Street N.E.
Atlanta, Georgia 30309
404-498-8500

Careers