View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

Profitwise
News and Views
Published by the Consumer and Community Affairs Division

Special Edition
May 2004

Neighborhood Housing
Services of Chicago
Home Ownership
Preservation Initiative
This edition of Profitwise News & Views comprises a
summary of presentations made on Wednesday,
September 3, 2003 at the Federal Reserve Bank of
Chicago by Neighborhood Housing Services of Chicago,
the City of Chicago, and key financial institutions in
Chicago on the progress of HOPI —The Home
Ownership Preservation Initiative, a foreclosure prevention
and foreclosed property reclamation initiative.

Neighborhood Housing Services of Chicago
Home Ownership Preservation Initiative
Profitwise News and Views welcomes story ideas,
suggestions, and letters from bankers, community
organizations and other subscribers. It is mailed (either
electronically or via U.S. mail) at no charge to state
member banks, financial holding companies, bank holding companies, government agencies, nonprofit organizations, academics, and community economic development professionals. You may subscribe by writing to:
Profitwise News and Views
Consumer and Community Affairs Division
Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago
230 S. LaSalle Street
Chicago, IL 60604-1413
or
CCA-PUBS@chi.frb.org

n Wednesday, September 3, 2003, the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago
hosted a breakfast meeting at which Neighborhood Housing Services (NHS)
of Chicago made a presentation on the progress of HOPI, the Home Ownership
Preservation Initiative. HOPI, officially launched in April of 2003, is a partnership
between the City of Chicago, NHS and key financial institutions who conduct business
in Chicago, including General Motors Acceptance Corporation–Residential Funding
Corporation (GMAC-RFC), Chase Manhattan Mortgage Corp., Bank One Corp.,
LaSalle Bank, Harris Trust and Savings Bank, Bank of America Corp., and
Washington Mutual, Inc.

O

The partnership established two goals at inception:
■ Prevent foreclosures in targeted neighborhoods through various means
■ Reclaim foreclosed properties and return them to vital use as

neighborhood assets.
The material in Profitwise News and Views is not
necessarily endorsed by, and does not necessarily
represent views of the Board of Governors of the
Federal Reserve System or the Federal Reserve
Bank of Chicago.
Advisor
Alicia Williams
Managing Editor
Michael V. Berry
Assistant Editor
Kathleen Toledano
Compliance Editor
Steven W. Kuehl
Economic Development Editor
Harry Pestine
Economic Research Editor
Robin Newberger
Contributing Editor
Jeremiah Boyle
Production Associates
Mary Jo Cannistra
Jennifer Cornman

For the first goal, the numeric target is to prevent 500 foreclosures per year through
loss mitigation, including loan workouts, refinancing and small loans to help homeowners
remain current on mortgage payments. For the second, in collaboration with (primary
and secondary market) mortgage finance partners, NHS plans on acquiring 100 foreclosed single-family homes per year over three years in targeted neighborhoods.
NHS will rehab these homes, making them safe and habitable, to prepare them for sale
to income qualified families. The overriding goal is to prevent neighborhoods from losing market value as a result of the inevitable conditions that arise from excessive
vacancies, and create more stable neighborhoods in the city’s lower- and moderateincome communities.
Alicia Williams, vice president of Consumer and Community Affairs for the Federal
Reserve Bank of Chicago, opened the meeting. Michael H. Moskow, president and
CEO of the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago, provided the Chicago Fed’s perspective
on the problem and touched on NHS’s tireless and creative efforts to address it.
Mayor Richard M. Daley discussed the city’s leadership in addressing foreclosures
and offered support and encouragement for the initiative. The full texts of the
remarks follow in this issue.
John G. Markowski, commissioner, City of Chicago, Department of Housing (DOH),
Bruce A. Gottschall, executive director, NHS of Chicago, Bruce Paradis, president and
CEO, GMAC-RFC, and Steve Paton, vice president, Chase Manhattan Mortgage
Corporation, provided progress on the initiative from their respective viewpoints.
Summing up the meeting and the next steps for HOPI was Richard Monocchio,
first deputy commissioner at DOH.
Visit the website of the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago at:

Home Ownership
Preservation Initiative
Chicago, Illinois
September 3, 2003

REMARKS BY:

overriding goal of NHS is to foster a level of stability in

MICHAEL H. MOSKOW
President and CEO, Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago

neighborhoods so that their services are no longer needed.
True to this ideal, NHS has closed seven neighborhood
offices over the years after successful efforts to stabilize
local housing markets.

Good morning. I’m Michael Moskow,
president and CEO of the Federal
Reserve Bank of Chicago. We are
pleased to host this morning’s meeting
to discuss strategies to preserve homeownership in Chicago neighborhoods.
Let me begin by welcoming our honored guests: Mayor Richard Daley,
Chicago Department of Housing
commissioner Jack Markowski, first deputy commissioner
Richard Monocchio, Bruce Paradis, CEO of GMAC-RFC,
Steve Paton, vice president of Chase Mortgage, and Bruce
Gottschall, executive director of NHS. And I’d also like to
welcome all the members of the capital markets community
that have joined us today.
The Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago has worked closely
with Neighborhood Housing Services for many years. On a
personal note, I worked closely with the national leader of
NHS back in the early 1970s when I was in Washington, D.C.
and worked at HUD. For almost three decades, NHS has
served troubled Chicago neighborhoods with innovative and
effective programs. They always work with an eye to the
underlying causes of disinvestment and their resolution. Put
simply, they have never been afraid to think big. For many
years, NHS has been recognized as one of the most effective
nonprofit housing organizations in the nation. Several
attributes of the organization have been key to their success.
NHS is adept at enlisting support at the neighborhood
level, and also from corporate, financial and political leaders.
They understand all sides of the complex issues facing
communities. NHS creates coherent, goal-oriented programs
whose outcomes are readily measurable, and then leverages
public and private investment to undertake them. But the

Since a growing economy is central to the Federal Reserve’s
overall mission, the Chicago Fed is keenly interested in
promoting sound local economies within our District. Our
relationship with NHS in recent years stems from our
mutual involvement in the Mortgage Credit Access Partnership,
MCAP, which was initiated in 1996 by our Consumer and
Community Affairs division. Our role in MCAP was to bring
together about 100 organizations to address obstacles to
fair housing and fair access to mortgage credit. In the course
of MCAP, NHS created the Foreclosure Intervention Program,
and later the Neighborhood Oriented Recovery Mortgage
Assistance Loan, or NORMAL program, both of which were
introduced here at the Fed at meetings similar to today’s.
In October of 2000, NHS introduced the Home Ownership
Preservation Initiative–HOPI—again here at the Fed, and
returned to provide a detailed progress report on HOPI
earlier this year. Partnerships with lenders and loan servicers
that developed from these meetings have greatly increased
the effectiveness of
Chicago’s loss mitigation and lending
“Partnerships with lenders and
strategies. We at the
loan servicers that developed
Chicago Fed are
to have had
from these meetings have greatly pleased
some small part in
getting this series of
increased the effectiveness of
successful initiatives
Chicago’s loss mitigation and
off the ground.

lending strategies.”
Michael Moskow, President and CEO,
Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago

Profitwise News and Views Special Edition

However, despite
these considerable
efforts, foreclosures
in Chicago neighborhoods are occurring
May 2004

1

today at very high rates, and vacant buildings threaten the
stability of neighborhoods and future reinvestment opportunities. We need to better understand the dynamics of
foreclosures, their origin and results, and to work together
to develop solutions to keep families in their homes. To
this end, Federal Reserve Board Governor Edward Gramlich
is supporting an effort to study how the securitization of
subprime loans impacts efforts to preserve homeownership. The goal is also to foster dialogue within the capital
markets about practices that impact loss rates, and their
impact on communities, and we hope to learn a great deal
from this effort.
Before I introduce Mayor Daley, let me leave you with a few
final thoughts. We have learned that difficult issues facing
the lending industry take creative thinking and cooperation
from all quarters. We are delighted that you are all here to
learn more about the important work of NHS to preserve
homeownership, and I hope that you consider carefully
becoming an active partner. We have worked with NHS
before to roll out innovative programs, and we have seen
great results. NHS is once again breaking new ground by
looking beyond the lenders to the sources of capital to
promote their important goals. And, there is an opportunity
to hold up the City of Chicago, NHS and its partners as
national leaders in identifying best practices and addressing
this critical challenge.
I am now honored to introduce Mayor Richard M. Daley.
Under his leadership, Chicago is at the forefront of understanding and addressing foreclosures. Mayor Daley recently
presented this issue to the U. S. Conference of Mayors
and through the Department of Housing, is committing
staff and resources to combat this vital neighborhood issue.

REMARKS BY:
RICHARD M. DALEY
Mayor, City of Chicago
Good Morning. I want to thank Michael
Moskow and the Federal Reserve
for hosting this meeting. We appreciate
their continuing support of our efforts
to combat foreclosures and preserve
affordable neighborhoods. I’d also
like to recognize the Department of
Housing, as well as Neighborhood
Housing Services, for spearheading
the Home Ownership Preservation Initiative.
This past January, I addressed the U.S. Conference of Mayors
about the damage that foreclosures are doing to our cities
today, in a time of high unemployment and economic
uncertainty. I urged mayors everywhere to work together
to focus national attention on this issue that affects us all.
2

Profitwise News and Views Special Edition

May 2004

These foreclosures have a devastating effect, not only on
the families involved, but also on the surrounding communities.
They threaten to erode some of the neighborhood
improvements and positive investments that we have all
worked so hard to achieve.
Here in Chicago, we have made a strong commitment to
assisting homeowners and working with lenders to turn
around foreclosed homes. We are here today to thank and
acknowledge each to the 20 financial institutions in this
room for joining our work in this initiative. We first met in
February here at the Federal Reserve to explore how partnerships could be formed. You will recall that our efforts
are centered on two areas.
Our first priority is to preserve homeownership whenever
possible, to keep families in their homes through counseling,
loss mitigation, and
loan workouts. And
when foreclosure is
“Here in Chicago we have made
unavoidable, we
a strong commitment to assisting want to make sure
the vacant properties
homeowners and working with
left behind are prelenders to turn around
served for affordable
homeownership.
foreclosed homes.”
That means getting
these buildings into
Richard M. Daley, Mayor, City of Chicago
the hands of responsible parties who
can rehabilitate them and sell them to owner occupants.
Working together, we have already made good progress.
Since April 1, 2003, we have helped nearly 150 homeowners
stay in their homes and we have reclaimed 30 foreclosed
properties so they can become assets to their communities.
More important, we have laid the foundation to work
together in addressing the foreclosure problem by sharing
information and strategies. We understand that we are all
in this together. Foreclosures weaken neighborhood markets
and affect all of our bottom lines. The idea behind the Home
Ownership Preservation Initiative is finding innovative solutions and then sharing them with other institutions.
For example, many of you have told us that if people sought
help earlier, we would have a much greater likelihood of
success. We believe people are often afraid to call their
lender when they are in trouble, but they might be willing
to call the city for help. So we hope, that by January 2004,
families facing foreclosure will be able to call the city’s
non-emergency number—311—for assistance.1 We would
refer them to counselors or to the appropriate lender to
work out a payment plan.
We all know that foreclosure is expensive to everyone. It’s
much cheaper in the long run to make a small financial
concession that allows a family to stay in its home. We
are also making progress on turning vacant properties into
homeownership opportunities, and I challenge each of you

to continue to find ways to work with Neighborhood
Housing Services on this important neighborhood revitalization strategy.
Let me give you one example of how this can work. Sandra
Traback has been principal of Chavez Elementary School
in the Bank of the Yards community since it opened in 1993.
Sandra believes that in order to have positive change in the
schools, you need positive change in the community. This
month, Sandra is buying a rehabbed home from Neighborhood
Housing Services on the 5000 block of South Marshfield,
three blocks from her school. NHS acquired this foreclosed
property from HUD, along with 30 other properties in Back
of the Yards that are being rehabbed and sold to homeowners.
I am honored that Sandy is with us today and commend her
for her dedication to the Back of the Yards.
But NHS can’t do it alone, and that is where the partnership
with financial institutions comes in. In May, NHS and the
Department of Housing took some people from Chase to
Back of the Yards and showed them the rehab underway
on Sandra Traback’s house. It turns out that Chase was
foreclosing on a vacant, fire-damaged house on the very
same block. Understanding the importance of that house
to the revitalization the block, Chase representatives
immediately agreed to donate the property to NHS. This is
an important story, because it shows the inter-connection
of all of our work. The impact extends far beyond the two
vacant houses that are being rehabbed. For the other homeowners on the block, it means they don’t have to worry
about the crime and illegal activity that vacant buildings
attract. For the lenders, it means that property values don’t
decline as a result of deteriorating conditions on the block.
Imagine if we could sell all of these foreclosed properties
to people like Sandra Traback.
Today I challenge you to think about creating healthy, vital
markets over the long term. For this to happen we need
the help of industry leaders like you, making a commitment
to explore partnerships with groups like NHS to rehabilitate
buildings to a high standard of quality and sell to owner
occupants. When neighbors see construction activity on
homes that have been vacant for months or even years,
they are more inclined to invest in the upkeep of their own
properties. This activity also helps preserve the values of
other homes in the
neighborhood. With
“I challenge each of you to continue every vacant building
rehabilitated, and
to find ways to work with
every new family that
Neighborhood Housing Services
buys one of these
buildings through a
on this important neighborhood
legitimate loan, we
revitalization strategy.”
are creating value
and confidence in
Richard M. Daley, Mayor, City of Chicago
the future of our
neighborhoods.

While we have made encouraging progress, there is much
to be done to spur more neighborhood investment. I challenge
each of you, as industry leaders, to continue the dialogue
we have begun over the past few months. I would like to
hear from you on a quarterly basis about our progress toward
our three-year goal of helping 1,500 families stay in their
homes and reclaiming 300 buildings. Many of you have
already devised new business approaches—challenging old
standard operating procedures and constraints. I am sure
I can count on you to continue this innovative thinking.
Thank you again for your commitment to our city and our
neighborhoods. Working together, we can make our communities even stronger and healthier than they are today.

ALICIA WILLIAMS
Vice President, Consumer and Community Affairs,
Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago
Ms. Williams began by highlighting the strong interest the
Fed has in community development and working on issues
that impact communities economically. Ms. Williams spoke
about the relationships the Fed cultivates to promote stable
and sustainable community development, as well as fair
access to credit and financial services. The Chicago Fed
and its Consumer and Community Affairs division have a
long-standing relationship with Neighborhood Housing
Services of Chicago because of the organization’s outstanding
efforts—and results—in positively impacting communities
facing disinvestment. “Through this partnership, we at the
Fed have seen firsthand the positive impact NHS has had
on Chicago’s neighborhoods. Much of NHS’s sustained
success can be attributed to Bruce Gottshall’s leadership
and the diligent work of his staff.”

JOHN G. MARKOWSKI
Commissioner, City of Chicago, Department of Housing
Mr. Markowski noted the city government’s awareness of
the impact of foreclosures and resulting neighborhood
decay, and that it is a national as well as a local issue.
The city’s Department of Housing tracks closely the related
trends regionally and nationally in an effort to gauge the
effectiveness of the new HOPI initiative. He provided
recent data that underscore the problem.
National data kept by the Mortgage Bankers Association
show that the rate of foreclosures nationwide hit a record
high of 1. 2 percent of all loans originated in the first quarter
of 2003, the highest level in at least 20 years. In Chicago,
foreclosures have more than doubled over the past six years,
and the estimated city rate of home foreclosures was 4.7
percent in 2001, three times the Illinois statewide rate.
Profitwise News and Views Special Edition

May 2004

3

In the City of Chicago, 3,100 people lost their home to
foreclosure in 2001; between 1998 and 2001, 10,000
foreclosures were documented.
In 2001, 41 percent of foreclosure starts2 in the City of
Chicago occurred in NHS targeted communities, Auburn
Gresham/Englewood, Back of the Yards, Chicago Lawn/
Gage Park, Garfield Boulevard, North Lawndale, Roseland,
South Chicago, West Englewood, and West Humboldt.
These nine NHS communities have a highly disproportionate
share of the city’s foreclosures in that year. In the most
recent data for July 2003, there were 654 foreclosure
starts for the entire city. Thirty-four percent of these starts
were in the NHS target areas, a slight drop from 2001, but
far above the city-wide average. Foreclosure starts in the
nine NHS targeted areas reach completion faster and
more frequently than in other areas of the city. More than
half occurred within three years after origination, compared
with 12 percent in 1993.
“These statistics underline the importance of a targeted
approach, bringing together all the key actors in the lending
and investing community. Everybody here has already made
a commitment to help homeowners at risk of foreclosure
stay in their homes,” said Markowski.
The Department of Housing has established programs to
help families catch up on their mortgages and enable
neighborhood based
agencies to provide
foreclosure counsel“These statistics underline
ing. The Department
the importance of a targeted
of Housing is also
working directly with
approach, bringing together all
HUD and organizathe key actors in the lending
tions such as NHS
to take over foreand investing community.”
closed HUD-owned
properties (those
John G. Markowski, Commissioner,
that had FHACity of Chicago, Department of Housing
insured mortgages),
rehab them, and
return them to productive use. Even though these efforts
have had impact, they cannot address the full scope of the
problem in the hardest hit communities. Accordingly,
DOH is looking to all of the HOPI partners to ensure
responsible underwriting practices, and participate in active,
coordinated, and creative efforts to help families avoid
foreclosure.
“What is most encouraging is to see how many of you have
stepped up to the plate in coming up with new ideas and
initiatives for preventing foreclosures and handling REO3
properties.”

4

Profitwise News and Views Special Edition

May 2004

BRUCE GOTTSCHALL
Executive Director, Neighborhood Housing Services
of Chicago
Mr. Gottschall began
by thanking NHS’s
long term partners—
“Our charge and challenge is to
lenders, the city,
find ways to partner together to
insurers—who have
create improved methods of keeping contributed and
invested millions of
people in their homes and promoting dollars in NHS’s
efforts to revitalize
neighborhood revitalization.”
Chicago’s neighborBruce Gottschall, Executive Director,
hoods. He continued
Neighborhood Housing Services of Chicago
by thanking NHS’s
new partners for
their commitment,
interest and leadership in partnering to improve Chicago’s
neighborhoods, and in looking for innovative ways to jointly
address the issues of foreclosures and vacant properties.
Mr. Gottschall pointed out that those who have toured
NHS targeted neighborhoods have seen first-hand both the
strength and the vulnerability of the city’s neighborhoods and
markets. A vacant building or two on a block can undermine
years of home improvement, homeownership, and block
club work.
He went on to express that the success to date of the
initiative is due to the participants’ understanding of the
severe impact of the default and foreclosure problem in a
relatively small number of neighborhoods. The broad availability of mortgages coupled with the rapid growth in the
market or asset-backed securities has created unintended
negative consequences for families, neighborhoods and
some sectors of the financial industry.
Mr. Gottschall went on to note the range of actors and
interests in the securities market—securities issuers,
underwriters, investors, rating agencies—that are far
removed from neighborhood revitalization and development
concerns.4 This complex infrastructure underscores the
importance of research funded by Neighborhood Reinvestment
Corporation to measure the impact of the subprime mortgage finance market on neighborhoods.
Since the beginning of the HOPI initiative on April 1, 2003,
lenders and NHS have worked together to keep more than
150 financially distressed families in their homes. Lenders
and NHS are working on ways to link their respective
services and capacities to assist borrowers in need of help
in the most effective way. NHS’s refinance loans and deferred
payment loans have been resources to resolve default and
halt foreclosure.

In its target neighborhoods, NHS has been successful at
revitalizing vacant buildings and returning them to good
condition for new homeowners. Mr. Gottschall emphasized
that further loss mitigation methods need to be explored,
so that the negative impact of vacant properties can further
be diminished. Creating positive momentum through good
quality rehab and owner occupancy is an essential ingredient
for neighborhood and housing market stability.

BRUCE PARADIS
President and Chief Executive Officer, GMAC-RFC
As a subsidiary of GMAC, Mr. Paradis pointed out that RFC
plays a different role than typical lenders in the community.
It does not have storefronts, but buys loans from the people
who make loans. RFC purchases loans that are made by
mortgage bankers and mortgage brokers. They then fund
these loans with proceeds of securities sales. RFC is a
leading issuer of asset-backed securities. In 2003, RFC
funded approximately $50 billion in mortgages. Since RFC
started in the early 1980s, it has issued over $200 billion
worth of securities, mostly funding “nonconforming” mortgages, including loans to households with lower credit scores
that are often called subprime mortgages, and priced to
reflect the added risk associated with a blemished or
insufficiently long credit history.

Foreclosure Prevention
Mr. Paradis estimated that in 2003, RFC will lose $500
million due to foreclosures. In the past, the only option
offered to a customer facing foreclosure was to increase
the payment to offset past delinquency. Today, RFC aims
to partner in Chicago with groups who share a common
objective, to reduce losses attributable to foreclose. When
foreclosure is the only option, RFC will turn over properties
to NHS rapidly, and will use creative solutions to keep
families in their homes whenever possible. Partnering with
NHS, RFC plans to determine homeowners’ needs, and
craft further methods to keep families in their homes.

“I’d like to thank NHS and the City of Chicago for the
wonderful partnership experience. We will be back year
after year to talk about the goals we set and the progress
of the programs,” stated Mr. Paradis.

STEVE PATON
Vice President, Chase Manhattan Mortgage Corporation
Mr. Paton is the manager of REO and post-foreclosure
properties for Chase, a portfolio of about 3,500 properties.
Chase became a HOPI partner several months prior to the
meeting. Mr. Paton pointed out that there are no similar
programs in other parts of the country. He stated that the
city benefits from the relationship, since many vacant
properties ultimately end up demolished—sometimes at
city expense—resulting in loss of tax revenue and decay
of once vibrant communities.
For “high-risk” postforeclosure properties,
“As properties sit in foreclosure
Chase has created
field service officers.
they are costly to maintain. We
The field service
officers work closely
are glad to see someone rehab
with neighborhood
the properties to benefit the
organizations, such as
NHS and the city, to
community.”
preserve the value
Steve Paton, Vice President,
and integrity of housChase Manhattan Mortgage Corporation
ing assets within
communities. Chase
recently donated
their first foreclosed property to NHS. “As properties sit in
foreclosure they are costly to maintain, we are glad to see
someone rehab the properties to benefit the community,”
stated Mr. Paton, adding: “We look forward to the continued
partnership with NHS and the City of Chicago.”

Mr. Paradis pointed out that the HOPI pilot program is in
part a learning process. The long-term objective is to build
a scalable model that can be replicated by other lenders
while addressing the needs of lenders, businesses, and
financially distressed homeowners. Ultimately, the goal is
to extend the model to other cities facing high foreclosure
rates. An integral part of the RFC model is an alliance with
credit counseling agencies that began in 2001. When borrowers are delinquent over 60 days, they are referred to a
reputable credit counseling agency. RFC pays the credit
agency $100 per client.

Profitwise News and Views Special Edition

May 2004

5

NEXT STEPS

Chicago Foreclosure Starts 1993 vs. 2001

RICHARD MONOCCHIO
First Deputy Commissioner, City of Chicago
Department of Housing

9000

Mr. Monocchio explained the challenge by Mayor Daley to
all city agencies to deal with vacant buildings. It is called
the Troubled Building Initiative. Members of every agency
in the city, from the Department of Sanitation to the police
and fire departments, will report any possible abandoned
building (and associated criminal activity) to the Department
of Housing, so immediate steps may be taken before the
property negatively impacts the community. There are currently 1, 200 units of housing, single and multi-family, in
some stage of rehabilitation with either the city or a nonprofit taking control to rehab the property, and ultimately
selling it to owner-occupants.

The 311 Campaign

8000

8,556

7000
6000
5000
4000

4,927

3000
2000
1000
0

Mentioned by Mayor Daley, the 311 Campaign, will connect
a caller facing foreclosure or unable to make mortgage payments with an experienced credit counselor to work on their
individual situation. The city has also enlisted schools, and
Peoples Energy to get the message out to families who
have been unwilling to contact their lenders, and to show
them that the city is committed to saving their home and
preventing foreclosure. The Department of Housing is
planning to issue quarterly reports on foreclosures and
vacant properties, and will reconvene the HOPI participants
every six months to assess the progress of the initiative.

1993

2001

Chicago Foreclosure Findings
■ Foreclosures are starting earlier in the life of mortgage

loans. In 2001, 54% of foreclosures were on loans two
years old or less, compared with only 16% in 1993.
■ Between 1993 and 2001, foreclosures started on

FHA/VA mortgages did not increase.
■ Subprime foreclosures grew to 3,878 in 2001, from

“Six months ago the partners were unsure of what effective
outcomes would be produced. Since then, the commitment
of the city as expressed by the mayor, NHS, and the private
banking sector, has gotten the initiative off to an
enthusiastic beginning.”
Richard Monocchio, First Deputy Commissioner, City of Chicago
Department of Housing

6

Profitwise News and Views Special Edition

May 2004

662 in 1993, nearly a 500% increase on loans with
interest rates that exceed 35 basis points above prime.
■ Over 3,000 Chicago families lost their homes in 2001.
■ Only 25 lenders/servicers held 75% of the foreclosures

started in Chicago in 2001.
■ Chicago’s asset control area program has reached 200

foreclosed FHA properties and put them back into productive use in the last 18 months.

Conclusion
Neighborhood Housing Services of Chicago is approaching
30 years of successful neighborhood redevelopment. The
HOPI initiative is the latest in a series of more recent,
successful NHS initiatives that have positively impacted
redeveloping or troubled Chicago neighborhoods and their
residents. Beginning with the Foreclosure Intervention
Program (FIP) introduced at the Fed in October 1997,
NHS launched an innovative and comprehensive initiative
to prevent foreclosures in targeted Chicago communities.
With the rise of predatory mortgage lending, NHS introduced
the Neighborhood Ownership Recovery Mortgage Assistance
Loan program, providing counseling, loan workouts and
legal assistance for victims of predatory lending. HOPI
adds a new dimension, engaging the investment community
in a broader effort to stem foreclosures, but also to bring
unavoidably foreclosed homes back to market as soon as
possible. The Fed’s Consumer and Community Affairs
Division has worked with NHS as a committed partner,
and will continue to document and support the efforts of
NHS in this critical work.
For more information on the HOPI initiative or other NHS
programs, call NHS at 773-329-4010, or visit their Web
site at http://www.nhschicago.org. For past NHS articles,
see http://www.chicagofed.org/publications/profitwise/
2003/pwwinter03.pdf

Notes
1 The 311 Center formally opened on March 11, 2004.
2 After 90 days of non-payment, a lender will typically begin
foreclosure proceedings. In some cases the homeowner does not
ultimately lose the home. By seeking assistance from NHS or other
organizations able to intercede on their behalf, they can obtain
counseling, financial aid and if necessary legal assistance. Foreclosure

Resources
Neighborhood Housing Services
www.nhschicago.org
City of Chicago, Department of Housing
www.cityofchicago.org/housing
Gorey, Rochelle Nawrocki, and Mary Fran Riley.
Neighborhood Housing Services of Chicago:
Making a Difference In Chicago Neighborhoods,
Profitwise, Winter 2003,
Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago.
This publication may be accessed at
www.chicagofed.org/community_development/
profitwise_news_and_views.cfm
Harvard’s Joint Center for Housing Studies at
www.jchs.harvard.edu

Kathleen Toledano and Michael V. Berry summarized
the conference sessions.
Kathleen Toledano is a community development analyst
in the Consumer and Community Affairs division, Emerging
Consumer and Compliance Issues unit of the Federal
Reserve Bank of Chicago. She is also the assistant editor
of Profitwise News and Views. Ms. Toledano is on the board
of Amicus, the Fed’s employee volunteer association. She
has been a member of Amicus since joining the bank in
1997. Ms. Toledano studies community development issues
and speaks on emerging consumer issues for the Fed. Ms.
Toledano holds a B.A. in anthropology from the University
of Illinois Chicago, and attended postgraduate studies at
the University of Pittsburgh.

is a costly, inefficient process, and it is in the interest of both
borrower and lender to avoid it.
3 REO property is real estate that is currently owned by HUD
or financial institutions after foreclosure.
4 The growing secondary market for subprime mortgages has
created opportunities for borrowers with blemished credit to
access mortgage financing. To the extent that some mortgageoriginating intermediaries have been overly aggressive in marketing
to low- and moderate-income communities, and underwriting
borrowers with limited ability to repay, the foreclosure rate and

Michael V. Berry joined the Federal Reserve Bank of
Chicago’s Consumer and Community Affairs division in
December 1995 as a researcher and program manager.
He is currently the manager of the Emerging Consumer
and Compliance Issues Unit. Mr. Berry is also the managing
editor of (and a frequent contributor to) the Federal Reserve
Bank of Chicago’s Profitwise News and Views publication.
Mr. Berry is a director of the Regional Redevelopment
Corporation, a nonprofit housing development organization
formed in 1992. Mr. Berry holds a B.A. in Political Science
from Susquehanna University and an M.B.A. from
DePaul University.

negative impact in those communities has been significant.

Profitwise News and Views Special Edition

May 2004

7

Neighborhood Housing
Services Programs

Homeownership Education

Loan Counseling and Refinancing

NHS offers, free of charge, a comprehensive set of homeownership programs that include classroom sessions and
individual counseling. NHS issues pre-approval letters for
qualified home purchasers who complete the home
ownership orientation and classes. NHS also offers a
regular schedule of classes taught in Spanish, and housing
counselors are bilingual.

NHS offers affordable loans to help homeowners remain
in or improve their homes through refinance loans, refinance/rehab loans, and foreclosure intervention. NHS
loans are used often to refinance high-cost, improvident or
predatory loans. NHS provides foreclosure intervention
services and counseling for families who are experiencing
temporary financial difficulties and are at risk of losing
their home to foreclosure.

Mortgage Lending
NHS is a licensed mortgage lender and offers loans for
home purchase or purchase/rehab for buyers in Chicago
neighborhoods targeted by NHS. Products include mortgage
and purchase/rehab loans, “gap” loans to assist homebuyers
in purchasing a home, and first–time homebuyers loans.

Home Repair Programs
NHS offers home improvement loans for large or small
needs, ranging from general home improvements (e.g., new
kitchen, roof, siding, central air conditioning, etc.) to Chicago
Home Safety Partnership loans for improvements such as
correcting dangerous electrical problems or hazardous
heating systems. NHS also offers loans for substantial rehabilitation of one-to-four-unit buildings.

Construction Services
NHS helps finance repairs with a staff of trained construction
specialists. NHS staff helps homeowners ensure that work
is done correctly by writing construction specifications,
reviewing bids from contractors for the homeowner to
select from, and monitoring the construction for the lender
(NHS) to ensure that the repairs are done properly.

8

Profitwise News and Views Special Edition

May 2004