The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.
FEDERAL RESERVE BANK OF ATLANTA VOLUME .... 17 , NUMBER 2 , 2007 C a., E Cl. 0 a., > a., "C u E 0 C 0 Transitioning Youth from Foster u a., "C C C1l .... >-. Care to Successful Adulthood / C ::, E E 0 u C LouisianaSpeaks https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Don't Bet the House Is Bankruptcy Reform Legislation Working? Predatory Lending and the Military part ners in commun i t y a nd e conom ic d e velo p m e nt PAGE 1 2 Don't Bet the House I lonw mortgag<' f"orC'closures art> at n•cord lt•n• ls across tht' c-ountr.v because' of rising intNest rat C's and dPc l ining honw \·alues. Emory law prof"C'ssor Frank A IC'xancln gi\·es ac!Yi ce to homPo\\·nNs on how to stan' off finandal pitfalls. PAGE 1 4 Is Bankruptcy Reform Legislation Working? ChangPs to tlw t ·.s. Bankruptcy ("()(IC' in :WO;i yit• lcl mixPcl rC'sul ts in i>oth the numbC'r of consumt'r filin gs by stall' ancl tlw PffC'cliwness of its c-rt•dit c-ounscling rC'quirl'mC'nt S. PAGE PA G E 2 Transitioning Youth from Foster Care to Successful Adulthood 1 6 Predatory Lending and the Military Effl'c-th·C' (ktolwr 1, a new la\\·, thl' \\'anwr Ac-t , will protpc-t sl'1YicPmen and \\·onH'll ancl thl'ir famili<'s from pr('(latory lending prac-ticPs. Foster youth aging out of the syste m face many barriers that limit th eir oppo rtuniti es for econ omic success. Th e Jim Casey Youth Opportuni ty Initiative illustrates a comprehensive strategy to engage communit y and PAGE 1 8 Free Tax Sites Generate Refunds for Nashville Families T lw I as ll\' il ll' \\'pa lt h Bui l d i ng AllianC'C' is ai> IP to help t ho usands o f fam ilies c lai m thl' ir f"Pclna l t ax business leaders in addressing this issue. FEATURES PA G E 7 LouisianaSpeaks In the \rnke of hu rricanes Katrina and Hila, thousands of Louisiana cit izens take part in a un iqu<' n•gional planning process that is \\·orking to t'nsurP tlwi r \·oiees are' heard in the rebuilding C'ffo11s. https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis rC'f"un cl s in 200(i. PAGE 2 0 Spotlight on the District Alabama and Georgia Complexities of Community Development Finance In theory, lhe concept "community clevelopmenl finance" coverage and max imu m suggests a broad sel of acthities lhal usually i ncludes loan-I o-rn lue guide l ines, innornti\·e, flexib le financial products designed to chan - lencic'rs must also address nel inn'stments into clisadvantagecl commwlities where no nt raditio nal fac to rs to m,ffkels don't func l ion well on their own. miti ga l <' l he level o f ri sk of each brownfield proj C'ct. !l ow the concep t p lays out in pract ice \·ariC's wide ly clepencling on lhe needs of the community ancl lhe When using different layers resources availab le. Some practitioners view comm u- of fin ancing, it is import ant ni ty ckvelopnwnt fin ance th rough a lens of affordable to understcrnd the guidelines of each product including housing, w hile others tllink more in I erm s of small busi- terms, conditi ons and lim itations of gu,.mrnl<:>e. It is also nC'ss ent<:>q)rise de\·<:> lopment. But r<'ganUess of tlw per- Clil ical to determine 1he level and class of contamina.nls spC'ct i\·e, clevelopnwnt ancl financC' organizations musl fo un cl in a specific sitP through sitP ancVor soil sampl<' join forces to address risks an d challenges. assessmen ts p1ior lo consummati.t1g a deal. F\utherm orP, lenclers shoul d mitigate their liabil ity by complyi.t1g with One of the most important tilings I've lea.med in my yea.rs specific criteria that protect them from l he C'ompreh<:>n- of community development e>,,1)<:>ri<:>nce is that the 1isks sive Environmental RPsponse, Compensation, and Lia- ancl chal lmges diff<:>r- someti mes grca.tly---even among bil ity Acl (C ERCLA). si milar deals. It is t herefore extremely important to und<:>rsta.nd the potential problems ancl benefits of a The EPA has taken a proacl i\·e ro le to inform lenders of pa1iicula.r project when approaching fin ance. A comb i- U1e sl PPS requi.t·ed to establish exemp t ion from CERCLA nati on of nn ancing products that complement each other liabil ily. The Federal Rese1ve Bank o f Atl anta recently helps to mitigate the IC'\'el of risk crnd improve the long held a foru m with the EPA and industry professionals in lerm \iability of each project. ou r New Orleans Branch to help educalP lhe local banking comm unity. Ol lw r forums of this IYJ)P are p larnwd RPnewing brownfiPld sill's seems to be one of tlw mosl throughout th e country. challPnging community developnwnt acthities. According lo the Emironmenta.1 Protection Agency (EPA ), a The A tl anta Fed enco urages fin ancial institutions to brownfiP ld is " rpa J property, the expansion, reclPvclop- parti cipate in such trai ning programs l o gain a deeper menl, or rPUSP of w hich may be complicated by llw prP- und prstanding of bol h l lw oppor tun it iPs and the com - sencP or potential presence of a hazard ous substance, plcx ili es associated w ith unique com mu nity cle\'e lop- poll utant , or contam inant. '' The t ·.s. has approx imately me nl finance deals. Thi s tY])e of trai ni ng wi ll enablP 4:'i0,000 brownfi<:>lds, many of which arP located in or banks lo sel up strong program s that Pnsure proper cluC' ,war industri al parks. clili gm cP in assessing ancl miligaling IPnci<'r risk. Tlw large number o f sites and the potPnlial fo r redP\'elopnwnl present fma.ncial institutions wi th great opportunil ies. But banks musl be acutely aware of the illll11C'ciial e and inherent risks associated with these types of deal s. In aclclition to app ly ing stanclarcl ban k underwriting Juan C. Sanchez principles such as analysis of cash fl ow, debt service Comm uni ty Affa.i.t's Officer FEDERAL RESERVE https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis BANK OF ATLANTA one - TraDsitioning Youth from Foster · · Care to Successful Adulthood 1 : -: • t W0 https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis OLUME 17, NUMBER 2 FOSTER YOUTH AGING OUT OF THE SYSTEM HAVE BECOME ONE OF THE COUNTRY'S MOST VULNERABLE POPULATIONS. Tlwrc ar e curTC' nt ly about :5 00,000 children in fos ter cl o not haH' a clri\·er's license. \\·hich again limits th eir cart' across t hC' co unt ry. Eac h y(' ar, ap p ro x illl at C' ly j ob oppo11unities. Third , mmi y youth do not ha\"C' acccss 20,000 youth, dC'C' mcd IC'gal adult s at age 18, "agc out " to basic lw alt h care. o f th e roster c-m·e systC'm. Whil e thc number of children Fou rth , th ey do not h,n-e the finan cial rcsom ces needcd in th e foster ecu-C' systelll has been ckclinin g, the nulllber to sC'cun' housing. Thes(' ymmg pC'ople do not hm·e sup- o f youth aging out o f th e system cont inues to i ncn',L'>C'. port iH' adu lts wh o can co-sign on an ap,u-tment le,L'>P or Mos t young pC'opl C' at age 18 sti ll rc,Jy on fa mi ly and help th cm w ith rent deposits, so housi ng is always a sig- colllmunit y suppor t to help them tran siti on in to adu lt- nificant c·oncc'm. Finally, tlwse youth hm·c, no financi al hoo d. Fos t er yo u! h, ho w eve r. han' no pe rm anent safrty rw t, ,md many lac k ba5ic lifr ,md fin ancial rmmagc'- fami ly o r suppo rt nC' t \1·ork t o ass ist t hC'm as tlwy agC' ment skills. Owrcoming these bm-riers and helping th cs0 out o f thC' systC'm, and only limit C' d assistance' is ,n-ail- young p0op le achieH' eco nomic succ <'SS is critical for abl 0 fro lll th C' st at0s t o suppo rt th C' ir transi ti on t o stabi l izing this ve ry n tl nerabl e population . ind cp(' tHl ence. i\l any of th ese yo un g peo p le han' lilllit 0d c' ducati on, fpw basic skill s and no ro le' moclels Resources for youth aging out of foster care Govt>ni nw nt o ffi cials, foundati ons and n 's<>rn·c-hers ,m' or adult nlC'ntors. increasingly recognizing th e challenges th at youth aging The issue out of foster car e face mid the need for gr0atc>r resources Young people !0m·ing foster can' fac0 rrnmy lllore chal- to prc'JKm' them for th e adult w orld. Tlw largPsl fec!Prally lC'ng('S tha11 their pc'C'rs who come from support i\'C' frnni- fu nded prog r<ml to assist these young pc'opll' is the .John l i0s. ResParc-h indi ca tes th at four yPars aft n !Paving H. ChafC'P (Chafee) Fost Pr C,u·e Inclepcnci<'nc·<' Progr,u11. fostc'r cme, -Hi 1)('rcC'nl of these youth hm·e not linislw d Cn 'al <'cl in Hl99, thi s program prmicl <'S stat cs \1·ith fund- h igh school, 2:5 pc' n 'C'nt hm·e bC'C'll honlC'IC'ss, -t 2 percC'nl ing to cr0atc mid exp,md progrmn s to assist youth tnm- hav<' become parpnt.s themselves and fpwer than 20 pe r- si t ioning ou t of fos t<' r ca re, up t o agP 2 1. State s are sel f-supporting 1• rcqui rc•d to pro\·id C' a 20 pncent local matc h for tlw cent ,u·c, complC'lc' iy Cc'nsus data show that only :3 pC'rc·c,nt of young people \1·ho agC' out o f thC' fostC'r care systcm are li kely to finish fe deral fund s. Chafr'e funds m·e fkxible, and states u m tailor progr,UlL'> collC'gc•, compm·ed with 28 percent o ft he l '.S. population. to me<'t t lw specific needs of their foster youth populati on. Young pC'oplC' IC'aving fostC'r cm·e disproportionately suf- Sta t C's ha ve cl e\·e loppd a range o f S(' JYicps inc-l uclin g fer fro m mental ,me! other heal th problellls mid ar e more' educal ional programs, training, employm t>nt assist,m c·c' lik 0ly to be irl\"o h·C' d w ith crimina l ac ti\·iti es. Th 0se an cl fi nancial support to help those leming fost er care youth ar0 oft en VC't y isolated mi d face a future of li1ing to beco rnC' healthy, se l f-sufficient adu lts. Whi le t hcsP in poverty. funcls hav<' helped state's acl clress some or th e neecl s or youth aging out o f thC' foster cm·e system, tlw fund ing is Barriers to economic success not sufTi c-iC'nl to pro\·iclC' lhC' comp relwnsin' assistance' You ng people corning out of thP fos tPr care sys t0m face' a nu mber o r barri ers that lim it th eir opportunit ies neeclC'd by th ese yo uth . Th P .Jim Casey Yo ut h Opportuniti C's Initi ati ve ( tlw for ('conomic success. First, they o ft en hm·e low educa- "Initiath·C'") is mi oth er significant resource to assist youth ti onal at tainnw nt and no w ork experi ence, so th eir j ob lea\·i ng th C' foster ca re' sys tem. T his nati ona l program opportun ities arP li mited. Second , many o f till'SC' youth brings togC' th c r pcop le ancl r eso urces to help yo uth FEDERAL RESERVE https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis BANK OF ATLANTA I hr e e make the connections they need to assist with education, employment, health care, housing and suppori i ve relation- Ymmg people between the ages of 14 and 23 are eligible to participate in the Oppmtunity Passport program if ships. Th e Initiati ve is currently w orking in 10 commu- th ey ar·e in th e child wclfar·e system on th eir 14th birth- niti cs across t he coun t ry i nc luding A tl anta, Nash vill e cl ay ar1cl have successfully completed the required iinan- ancl Tampa (a co-investment si Le w ith I hr Ecke rd Farnily cial literacy traini ng. About 2,000 youth arc enrolled in I he Foundati on). In all conummilies, the Initiative encomages Oppmtlmity Passport prograr11 nationwiclr , and LogN her, youth r ngagement, and local coorclinal ors Lo work in U1eir they have sawcl almost $1.5 million through IOAs. communiti es to deYelop partnerships and resources Th e slruct urc o f th e m at ched savin gs acco unts is to provid e a safel y net for those transiti oning out of different in each conmrnnity in ter ms o flhe ar11ounl the foster car·e. youth car1 sm·e, the ar11ow1t of th e local match ar1cl th e Th e center piccr of the I nit iati ve is the> Opportunity assets th at can be purchased. Ilowcve>r, th e most com- Passport '", wh ich is designed t o creatr new oppor tu- mon asset goa l for the youth is a car, fo llowed by rent niti es and fin ancial reso urces for yo uth Iraving foster deposits, educati onal expenses ar1cl health car·e expenses. care. T hr goal o f the program is Lo hel p young people Th e num ber o f youth reaching Lhrir savi ngs goal nati on- leaving fost er car e: w ide is continuing to increase. • to become linancial ly literate, • to gain experi ence using the ma.inst ream banking system , • l o bu ild assets for education, housing or other e;,.,_rpcnses, at1cl • Lo receive streamlined educati onal and vocati onal assistance. Fostering Success provides services to Nashville youth Each year, th e> Tennessee Department o f Chilclrr n 's Sen ices estim at es t hat 200 youth age out o f th e fost er car·e system in Davidson Cmmly , ar1d many encl up incarcerated o r homelrss. Th e Fosterin g Success program launched in Nashv i ll e, Tenn., al Va nde r bil t University in 2002 providrs fo rm er foster care youth access Lo education, emp loyment, transpo rtati on, housing and olhr r "DOOR OPENERS" CONNECT YOUTH oppo rt un iti rs th ey need to beco me success ful adu lts . Jim Casey You th Opport uniti es Initiat i\·e pr O\ided th e f AGING OUT OF FOSTER CARE TO i nitial fund i ng fo r th e program . Foster ing Success is a col laborati\·c effort o f many HOUSING, JOBS, MENTORS AND pariners including Vand erbilt Cniversily, th e Tennessee OTHER OPPORTUNITIES THAT Mr trop o lit an Nas l1\·i ll e and se veral o ther n onpro fi t Departm r n t o f Chil dren's SerYi crs, L: nit ed Way o f agenc ies in WILL HELP THEM GAIN FINANCIAL ashvill c. T he collaboralivr also recrives signilicanl suppo1t fro m community ar1d business lcadr rs across the city who offer assistance and resources Lo INDEPENDENCE. support youth aging out of th e foster care sys tem. Thi s i\ l idd lr Tennessee program srJYes youth facin g barri ers to economi c success common am ong yo uth The prograr11 includes Uu·ee components: (1) personal aging out of th e fost er car e syst em nat ionwid e. I ni ti al debit accounts for shmi-Lerm expenses, (2) matched surveys of form er foster youth enro ll ed in Fost er ing savings accounts or Individ ual Development Account Success indi cated that l in 3 youth did not have a GED (IDA) and (3) "doo r opene rs" or servi ces th at conn ect and th e maj or it y did not have access to transportati on , y outh aging out of fost er car e to ho usin g, jobs, m en- whi ch is crit ical fo r fi nding a j ob. tors and other oppor tunities th at w ill help th em gain finan cial i ndepe nd ence. fou r https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Th e Opportunity Passp ort, a central initi ative of Fostering Success, is admi nister ed by Monroe Hard ing, a VOLUME 17 , NUMBER 2 nonprofit agency in ashville that has developed a one- The Jim Casey Youth Opportunity Initiative illu trates s top shop for youth transitioning out of foste r care. the type of comprehensive strategy that is needed to Curre ntly more than 225 youth ar e e nrolled in the engage community and business leaders in helping the e Opportunity Passport, and 160 yo uth have met the ir yo uth transition out of foster care to become healthy, savings goals a nd purchased asse ts worth $165, 000. produc tive and financially self-sufficient adults. ♦ Opportunity Passport offers a 100 pe rcent ma tc h for savings up to $1,000 each year fo r 3 years. The ave rage This article was written by Jessica Le Veen Faff, regional community development manager in the Atlanta Fed's Nashville Branch. match is $525. Most youth save for cars, housing, educatio n a nd insura nce. U.S. Bank has been a key s uppo rter of this initiati ve in Nashvi ll e, hosting the IDA acco unts for foste r yo uth and providing those enroll ed in the program with a personal bank account for their s hort term expenses. The impact of Fostering Success has been s ignifi cant for forn1 e r foster care youth in Nashvill e. Through th e Opportunity Passport, ma ny have gained so me fin a ncial stability. Follo w-up s urveys of partic ipa nts in the program indi cate that 53 percent of program parti cipants are no w li ving ind epe nd entl y; 25 pe rcent Endnotes 1 Based on data from the U.S. Department or llealth and lluman Services and the Jim Casey Youth Opportunit y ini tiative. 2 Thi s data are all based on t hose w ho r esponded negative ly to th ese ques ti ons initially; it is not based on ever yo ne w ho is enroll ed in th e Opportunity Passport prog r am. Thus, o f those wh o wer e not liv ing independently, 53 percent ar c now li ving independently an d o f those w ho had not finished high school/GE D, 25 percent have now comp leted high schoo l or earned their GED. ha ve finish ed hi gh school or earn ed their GED ; a ncl 23 pe rcent have completed some training or education afte r high school." Clearly, the prospects for youth who pa rti cipate in this initia tive are improving. Th e s uccess of this initiati ve has turned it from a pi lot proj ect into a s us taina bl e co mmunity colla bo rali \'e. Currently, Fostering Success partners are exp lo ring op ti ons to expa nd the initia l i\'e ac ross th e s ta te within the next three years. Conclusion Young people aging o ut of the foster care system face many of the sam e ba rriers as other youth canting from im poverished fami lies, but they lack th e traditi o na l fa mi ly and community s uppo rt to help them trans it ion into adulthood. As a result, fo rm e r foster care yo uth oft C'n face a ve ry blC'ak futme of unemployment , poverty ;;rncl homeless ness. Funding to assist these youth i limited, but there is grovving recognition that he lping the m as th ey leaYe the fos te r care system will reduce the futme cost to society. https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis I Affordable Housing for Former Foster Youth Finding affo rdable rental housing is a significant This is ashville's first step toward providing safe, challenge for youth aging out of the foster care system. affordable housing for 18- to 23-year-olds emerging from They face barriers such as the Jack of savings for a foster care, many of whom have been a part of state cus- security deposit, a poor or nonexistent credit history tody for their entire lives. Young people who rent the and the lack of a parent or guardian to co-sign a lease units must meet certain criteria: they must have been in on an apartment. state custody previously and be at least 18 years old; their In addition, many of these youth do not have steady employment so they can not afford to pay rent. Thus the chance of former foster youth ending up homeless for caseworkers must verify that they have basic skills to live on their own; and they must be in school or working. The rent will vary based on the individual's income, some pe1iod of time is high, and the need for permanent, but on average, monthly rent for each unit will range affordable housing is critical to help these youth transi- from $230 to $270, well below the market rent for a tion into adulthood. one-bedroom apartment in Nashville. As the youth increase their income, their rent will also increase. Tennessee nonprofits address housing needs Two nonprofits in ashville partnered almost five years ago to develop a model to address the housing needs of Supportive services to ensure project's success Monroe Harding will provide a staff member who over- foster youth aging out of the system. Woodbine Commu- sees the homes, checks in with the youth at least once nity Organization, a nonprofit housing developer, part- per day, verifies their employment and educational nered with Monroe Harding, a nonprofit agency that status on a regular basis and assists them with their works with foster youth in independent living needs. ashvil1e, to develop three homes with a total of 14 units of affordable rental hous- "The housing project opens doors for youth who have ing specifically for this population. Each person will have been in foster care and allows the teens to gain the tools a private bedroom and bathroom, and share common and skills they need to succeed in life," says Patty Harman, living space in the home. The first units became avail- President and CEO of Monroe Harding, Inc. able in spring 2007. Woodbine Comrnwlity Organization is the developer and owner of the house, and Monroe Harding is managing and leasing the units. This venture is an example of the type of public/private partnership needed to develop quality housing that is also affordable for former foster youths with very limited income. Woodbine Community Organization, one of the largest nonprofit multi-family housing developers in Nashville, provided the development expertise and overall project management. The project received fimding from the Federal Horne Loan Bank of Cincinnati through PrimeTrust Bank, a community bank based in Bellevue, Tenn. Woodbine received the three lots used for development along with a HOME grant from the Metropolitan Development Housing Agency (MDHA). ♦ This article was written by Jessica LeVeen Farr, regional conununity development manager in the Atlanta Fed's ashville Branch. Tennessee nonprofits have worked for five years to meet housing needs for youth leaving foster care. six https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis VOLUME 17, NUMBER 2 Louisiana Speaks IN SPITE OF THE CHAOS AND TRAGEDY PRODUCED BY HURRICANES KATRINA AND RITA IN THE SUMMER OF 2005 , A FEW BRAVE VISIONARIES HAVE DARED TO LOOK BEYOND THE DESTRUCTION AND GRASP THE OPPORTUNITY TO BUILD A NEW AND IMPROVED LOUISIANA. Bolsterl'd by world-class plannprs Calt horpl' & Associ- Tlw Regional Plan ww; onicially adopted in 1ay 2007, ates. 11101irnted by the chiw of local part1wrs like Eliza- and already the initiatiw has persuadl'd tlw Louisiana beth "Boo" Thomas, executh·p dirC'ctor of thl' CC'nter for Ll'gislature to act upon se\·eral ke:v recommendations Planning ExcC'llence, blessed with the assistancC' of from the plan. the Louisiana Recon'ry Aulhority, infusC'd with the inn'stml'nt of funding and human capital from several national and loca l foundations and think -ta nks, this Tlw Regional Plan grew out of the struggll's of many group C'mbarkecl on a rl'gional planning process that who, like mysl'lf, had to put gri C'f bC'hind tlwm to pm- C'ncompassC's southern Louisiana from Lake' Charil's to sue the promise' of the future. WhC'n the le\·ees broke, I St. Bernard parish. watched from my stairs ,LS the water rose in my honw One oft lw hallmarks of the initialin' has be<'n its soaking hardwood floors. rugs, furniture , my C'IC'ctrieal um\·,n-eii ng and uncompromising commitnwn t to secure system and equipment. The "C ity that Care Forgot" lay and res1wct the opinions of its most important stake- undc'r water and burdened \1·ith troubles. That morn- holclers- the residents of southern Louisim1a. Owr tlw ing I lay in 90-degree heat in my upstairs bedroom and last 18 months more th,m 27,000 citizens in :32 different thought abo ut the city's future- my future. states p,u1icipatecl in South Louisim1a's Regional \'ision In spite of tlw initia l shock, it dawned 011 me that poll. This represents the largPst and most inc lusi\'l' th is disaster might haV(' c-rPated tlw bold oppor1unit y regional planning outrPach cmnpaign e\·er concluctPd in we' nePded. As a community cle\'Plopment professiona l the l -nited States. I could see the potential for reim·enting a healthier, safc'r FEDERAL RESERVE https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis BANK OF ATLANTA seven city while preserving and promoting our unique culture \'ation of Louisiai1a's cultures; and the need for greater and considerable assets. Apparently I wasn't the only public parti cipation in the planni ng processes." one who was dreaming big. Others were thinking broadly abo ut what it would take to create and encourage healthy conm1Lmities: smart Anyone working in the public ai·ena knows U1at getting gravvth; enviro1rn1ental protection; effi cient, high-speed people from di\'e rse backgro unds and perspectives to transportation systems; robust economic development work towai·cls a conrn1on vision can be dau nting a t best. that capitalizes on "cluster industries"; inelusive zoning But the LouisianaSpeaks team saw this as a unique and tha t enco urages safe, affo rdabl e workforce housing; cri tical opportunity to craft a plan that would serw the public spaces that promote healt hy living and human region for the next 50 years. Almost a thousand people int eraction ; cradle-to-grave educational systems that fro m all sectors of th e region came toget her at loca- encourage lifelong learning and meet the demands of a tions in fiv e major cities to share their creative solu- variety of employm ent sectors. tions to th e region 's proble ms and, in man y cases, put aside the ir personal biases for the bene fit of the plan. T priori y or in lu ·ve Ianni~ During the full-clay workshops, citizens crafted a "cohe- To accomplish their goal o r creating an agenda that reflected the priorities of Southern Louisiana residents, regional planners turned to experts s uch as the New s ive set of s trategies for creating a safe r, smarter, more prosperous Louisiana. " For a res ident of New Orleans who is also a commu- York-based nonprofit AmericaSpeaks. This organization nity development practitioner, the process, progression had e>..1)erience in reaching out to fai tlu ng mem bers of and results of Lou isianaSpeaks were fasc inating both disaster-affected communiti es: in the wake of 9/11 , it to observe and paiticipate in. For me this movement was respons ible for gu iding the com·e rsatio n for the represented one of the most optimistic and meaningful recove1y in New York. Am e ricaSpeaks went to extra- symbols of the recove1y. 0 ordinaiy lengths to get paiticipation from all segments Could it be that om residents really want high-speed, of the community, from the high-powered Wall Street low-em issions public transit that connects Baton Rouge banker to the hom eless man tempora ril y relocated to and New Orleans? Would they really be willing to gi\'e New Jersey. up their two-acre backyards in favo r of more high- This nonprofit applied its experti se in outreach to density, interactive development? Are we really eager speai·head a similai· effort in Louisiana. The Louisiana- to walk to our workplaces, grocery stores, schools a nd Speaks initiative included tlu·ee stages of public paitici- greet each other on streets built for people instead of pation: surveys, stakehold e r wo rks hops a nd pub lic cars? Co uld we agree on or at least s upp ort the kinds opinion polling. Each of the outreach efforts made use of industries we want to provide our liveli hood over of all forms of media and technology t·o reach the public: th e next ten years? And even m ore daring: based on Interne t, printed media, e-mail blasts, radio, television public input, cou ld we actually hold o ur elected repre- and word-of-mouth were just a fe w of the methods senta tives accountable for putting o ur scai-ce resources used to publi cize th e project. where th ey make the most sense-fo r everyone·7 We The group's initial goal was to get a sound w1derstai1ding of the wants, concerns and awai·e ness of Louisiai1a's were ready for one of the most important tests of democracy, the voting poll. residents ai1d leaders. A rai1dom sai11ple telephone survey in Februaiy 2006 reached 2,500 residents, ai1cl 100 of those s mveyecl paiticipated in cletailecl interviews over The planning group managed to accomp li s h th e U1e next six months. SeYeral key themes emerged accord- almost-impossible goal of clistilling dow11 the hopes ai1cl ing to the repmt: "the impo1tai1ce of financial, storm ai1cl dreams of th ousands of citizens and leaders to fi ve personal safety; a desire for greater prosperity; preser- distinct a reas of strategic direction. The s urvey asked eight https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis VOLUME 17, NUMBER 2 respondents fi,·r ba5ic yet ciit icaJ questions (srr sicleb,u-). kids from sc hool and to shop. FPw of us arr aware Whik it might spem r,L'i.V on tlw sLU'facr to makP these that thi s t_vpp of clp,·plopmrnt is an increasingly c'xprn- choicPs as incli,·iduals. thesP clrcisions. likP human siw ,,·ay to gro\\'. Our quality of lifP. possibl~· Pwn the relati onships t hrmsrl\·rs, in nil\·e rr1wrcuss ions that lrngt h of our lifrspa n, is being comprom ist'd by sprncl- ext rnd IJC'yond the indi v idual. ing morr timr in tra ffi c, get tin g lrss exercise and lC'ss For examplt', traditionally tlw oil and gas sPclor has frrsh air. In addition wr facr in crC'asPd strPss brcause chin'n a largr prrcentagP of Louisiana's rc·onomy. But lrt's of highrr property taxPs and gasoline costs relatc'cl to say you support your fami ly by working offshore on an sp rawl. Thr best choi ce for mo,·ing forward mi ght oil rig, ,uicl yrt you enj oy the beauty and peacP of fishing SPC' m clPar, but mo,·in g forward might lw Pasirr said al da,,11 in Uw local marshes. Mrnw belit'VP that tlw oi l and than cl one. gas economy cont:Iibutrs to tJw shrinking of our " ·etlands. ls tlwrP a compromisP solution that can SC'tYP both your economic and personal interPsts·> Is it possiblr lo attract Onr oft hp most powerful stat isl ics on the Louisi- nrw compan irs whi lr simultrn1Pously growing small busi- anaSpraks ballot wprr srvp ral analyses oft he cost lo nesst' S locally·> Wouldn't this strategy strain rPsources If we continur to gro\\' as \\'e mr \\'e and business incentin•s'? Ho,,· \\'ould \\'P restructure our • To hm·r mw +1-3,000 nrw people' li,ing in a floodplain tax code to C'ncouragr small business dr,·elopnwnr> • To log ,ui ,1\'erage of cm miles of trm·eling per house- Although Nrw Orlrans alone hosts more th an five uni,·rrsit i es, wr con tinu e to suffer from "brain clrain" that draws our best and brightest to grrrner economic and professional opportunities. In the absence of local C,Ul PXpPcl: hold each clay • To pay m ·rr 60 prrcrnt morr in fue l costs than if we li\·ed in clensrr, c-losrr communit ies. And, as the graph belo\\' sho\\'S, \\'e can P:-.l)ect to job clewlopmrnt her<', would strengthrning our uniwr- pay o,·er $:2..\ million more in public funds o,·er t lw sities only lrad to ha,·ing OLff talPnt ancl Pnergy cheny- nrxt •15 years t o support infrastructure ancl roads. picked by out -o f~statr companirs·> Total Infrastructure Cost (2005-2050) Billions of 2007 Dollars What intriguPs me tlw most m·r the choices wr must makr about how wr want to grow and mm·r fo1ward $58.2B $60 ,L'i a rrgion. llistoli cally Louisi,uia citizms and clrc-tecl officials hm·r hrlcl onto n:•1y strong incli,iclual prope1iy rights. E,·en [)('fore thr storn1s NC'w Orlrm1s was losing S50 S40 $34B an m·rragP of four perc-rnt of its population e\Tty decade to Uw no1ih shorp of'Lakp Ponchmtrain ,mcl ernrrging brd- S30 room conui1unities in surrounding arras. Baton Rougearra rrsiclrnts were purchasing homrs in thr 1warby to,,·ns likP Gonzales ancl eYen sleepy l l ammoncl ,,·as S20 S10 rxprriPncing inc rrasrd growth. Evacurrs from llurri cane Katrina rxacerbatrd the problems associat ed with S· housing, lranspo1iation and educational infra.st ru ctmes. Option A Few high-clrnsity residential buildings exist in our Option B major cit irs. Condos and warrhouse/lo rt rrdevr lopmenls ■ Regional Transit were sren as appropriatr housing p1imarily for thr pio- ■ Infrastructure Option C Regional Highway (local roads, storm , water. electr1cal) neering young, urban professionals, artists or rrtirrrs. Cars arr requirrd to gPt to ,,·ork easi ly, lo pick up thr FEDERAL RESERVE BANK OF ATLANTA https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Source: Louisiana Recovery Authority nine But if we agree on the third option, "focusing develop- Mor{\ to com ment on existing cities and towns," our housing modes In the ne>--1, issue of Parinas I'll discuss the resulting wou ld s hift to more condominiums, apartments and regional plan and how it fits with other plans a nd the townhouses, and more public funds would go to build 17 Targe ted Neighborhood Zones adopted by the City of light rail systems rather than roads. New Orleans' Office of Recovery Management. I'll also Even though now only one out of every four famili es in American can afford to purchase their own home, provide updates on key legislation that can affect the implementation of the plan and relay how leaders and most of our potential first-time homebuyers pursue the citizens have reacted. And lastly, I'll share stories about dream of a single-family, detached home with a front how this has affected the work we do as conununity yard and porch of th eir own. I'm a professional who development professionals and rebuilcling residents. To preaches the message of homeownership as one of the be sure, I'm looking forward to being a part of the best asset-builcling strategies for low-wealth fan1 ilies. By regional vision that will be with me for the rest of my charn1eling their desire for homeownership into a more clays here in New Orleans. As a profess ional and afforda ble living situation s uch as a condo, wo uld I be resident it's a journey and a dventure that, eagerly and perpetuating the frustrations of renting? cautiously, I undertake. ♦ I pondered these issues as I cast my own ballot over the Inte rnet. In spite of my apprehensions about how This article was w1itten by Nancy Montoya, regional conrn1w1ity deve lopme nt manager in the Atlanta Fed's New Orleans Branch. this movement would trans late into my own work , I foun d myself infused with a sense of hope and optimism Photo on page 7 by Marvin Na uman courtesy of FEMA. for Louisiana's future. LouisianaSpeaks Poll Questions Below are the five questions posed to Louisiana residents in the LouisianaSpeaks Regional Vision poll: 1. What are your top priorities for economic development in Louisiana? (pick three) 3. How important do you think funding and implementation of the state's proposed plan is to the recovery? (pick one) • Pursuing new opportunities in traditional sectors · Very important • Fostering knowledge-based businesses • Somewhat important · Expanding trade and shipping · Somewhat unimportant • Attracting and retaining companies • Not at all important Nurturing entrepreneurs and small companies • Not sure/ No opinion · Expanding job-skills and vocational training • Strengthening colleges and universities 4. How should we grow? (pick one) · Keep building and developing as we are 2. Which values in the state's proposed plan are most important to you? (pick three) • Modify development patterns · Focus development on existing cities and towns · Community preservation · Commercial fishing 5. What is the right mix of property rights and · Navigation and ports community risk? (pick one) · Recreational hunting and fish ing · Emphasize property rights (i.e, no increased restrictions on · Oil and gas infrastructure • Wildlife habitat and flyWays tenFRASER Digitized for https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis how or where people build, shared risk increases) • Balance property rights and community risk · Emphasize reducing community risk (i.e., development prohibited in unprotected, flood-prone areas) VOLUME 17, NUMBER 2 HOW DOES YOUR PAYMENT WORK? https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Don't Bet the House IT WAS JUST A FEW YEARS AGO THAT WE WARNED FRIENDS AND FAMILIES MEMBERS: "DON'T BET THE HOUSE" AND "DON'T MORTGAGE YOUR FUTURE." homebuyers, for all mortgage brokprs and mortgage bcmkPrs, and especially for gowrnnwntaJ agencies and elect ed o ffi cials w ho have responsibility for hous in g America's fami lies. The .J(' I IS Report confirms that w(' have done thin gs in n'cent years to undercut the stability of the dream of safe ,md decent housing for all. The decade oft he DOs and the first hair o f this decade witnessed tremendous annual appreciation in home \·alues and simultaneous record high rates of homemrnership. The housing mrn·ket is now in a "correction'· phase which is painful to many. I Ialf of the met ropolitrn1 areas in the Cnited States had a real dollar decline in median home p1ices bet \\·een the fou11 h qurn1er of :200-5 and the fourth qurn1er of :2006. In recent years, howe\·er, t lwse risks have become badges of honor as we 'n, bet the house and mort- The national homeownership rate dedined in :2006, ,md mortgage delinquencies rn1d foreclosures rose shaqJly. gaged the future. And now \\"(' are beginning to see E\·en more troubling, hO\\·eyer, rn·e tlw shifts which ha\·e the consequences. oc-c-u1-recl in the fundamental concept ions of home- I lome mm1 gage foreclosures are at record levels, and ownership, putting at C'\'en great er risk the long-term we 're not yet sure th at we ca n see the bottom o r th e consequences to the Arne1icrn1 dream. We have unfortu- market downturn. llomeowners today ,u-e more vu lner- nately forgotten the ach·ice of om grandp,u-ents rn1d great able to losing their homes than at any point in the last grandp,u-ents in five ways. 80 years-when our grandparent s and great grcmdparents learned not to "bet th e ho use." As a soc iety we have failed to heed those words of ach·ice. Uninformed choices putting American dream at risk First, the terms of residential fimrnce are so complex and nufab le that homeO\\llers rarely know what they Housing market undergoing correction in home values are doing. Precious few really understm1d a graduated The Joint Center for Housing Stud ies (JCIIS) at 1-1,u·- paynwnt adjustab le rate mmigage with negative rn11orli - \'cU-d has recently released ils mrnual su1Yey of housing- zation. In 2006, almost 12 percent of all lorn1 01iginat ions 77w Sla/e qftlw Sa/ion's Ho11si11g .2007-and the data are i.J1\·oh·0d mmigages \\ith defened pa_v1n0nts of principal not encouraging. It paints a powerful pictLu-e not just of and interest, pushing mrny only for a brief time the the current excess im·entories of houses but of the rea- IJC'nding crisis. sons why homeownership is more precarious today Second, we\·e gone a\\·ay from th(' dassic fixed-rate than in decades. This brief :30-page report shou ld be mortgag0 which fo.:0s the arnmmt or the monthly pa~1nents required reading for all homeowners and prospecti\·e for the ent ire life of tlw lorn1, and in which 0ach paym0nt Digitized twelve for FRASER https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis VOLUME 17, NUMBER 2 im·oln's a small but d<:'linite builclup of equity, of smings. ancl by preempting state and local attempts to neate ln steacl, we rrjo ice in the l owrst possib le m onth ly substantive protectio ns. If all borrowers had achwic-ed paym('nls founcl in interest-only loans or teaser rates, degrees in rra l estat0 finance then disclosures might bli ndly ignoring tomorrow. Though AHi\1s ha\"C' been a wor k to sort en the problems. But that's not tlw \my it is. significant part oft he n'sident ial mortgage market for :2:) years, the rC'lia nce on traclitional AHi\ls has clec:li1wcl in tlw fac-0 of interest-only loans and paymen t option Low-income families less able to bear risk Some ca n af fo r cl t o t akr ri sks in ba lancing th eir loans, which counted for almost one-third of all loan incomes, tllC'ir e:s,_7)('nci itures and their mortgage debt. It is originations in :2006. thosr who h,we less who trncl to get hw-t more. The cost Third, we sr0k to borrow tlw largest possiblr amount of housing has continued to rise while incomes hm·e not, for tlw biggest possible housr, making the lowrst clmrn at IC'ast not for fami lies in the lo\,·er half of the clistribu- paynwnt possible. With little or no clown payment and lion of fami ly incom0 in tlw C.S. lla l f of all low-income little or no equity builclup. thr only "cushion·· that the fam i lies are spending more than .)0 pC'l"cc-nt of their homC'0\\11er has w hrn tough times come lies in the hopr inco me on housing- th e defin ition of sc-\·C'l"e!y cost- for constantly increasing home \·alu0s: but that is pre- burdenecl , and this is at a time when feclc-ral assistance cisely w hat stops happening in tough times. T he JCII S fo r affordab le- housi ng is not c-\·c-n keeping up with infla- Hc-po11 points out that r:3 percent of recent homebuycrs lion in real clollar terms. (in 200:3 and 200..t) already hm·c- "negative- equ it y" in thC'ir As a socie ty we all bear responsib il ity. The lending homes as the mo1igage debt exceedecl the Yalu(' of the industry nee-els to regain its sanity in loan underwriting home. \\'ith dee-lining home ntluc-s, higher interest rates crit0ria and in designing loan products. Our politic-al coming into effect and cleferred principal payments. tlw leaders need to rc-con•r thei r courage in setting lega l numbC'l"s canying 1wgati\·e equity \1ill likely incTeas0 in limits designed to protect a futw-e for us all. As bmTm1·ers the next :2,-! months. we need to reclaim the knowledge- ,md und0rstancl ing of Fm11ih , \1·e\·e taken the beauty and simpUcity of ATi\l the relationship b0l\1·c-en our incom0, tlw pa)1nents w e cash and applied i t to our homes. Between :2002 ancl might have to make and tlw reser\'C'S we have fo r th ose :2006, consunwr debt increase-cl by :21 percent , but O\·c-rall tough times. mortgage- debt increasC'cl by 6:2 percent. Whc-ne\'er we' Fo r curr0nt ancl future homeowners tlwr0 is st ill time desire or nee-cl cash we quickly and simply refinance (on to protect thc-rnsc-lws e\·C'n if the lending industry and terms \1·e don't understand), kming tlw cupbmu·cl b,u-c- politi cal l0aclers c-lose their eyes ancl point their fingers. f"or those tough ti m es. O\·er S,'i percent of all m o1igagc- Consumers can and must take ach'antage of intc-nsi\"C:' refimuicings in :2006 im·oh·ecl cashing out equity, and thC' financial literacy and home-buyer education programs. aggr0gate amou nt of home equity cashed out last year Ex isting ho m eow ner s now confront i ng imposs i ble was $:3-):2 billion-mor0 than 10 times the amount caslwd mo r tgage- obligations can and should sc-rk help imme- out just six years earli0r in :2000. \\1wn home p1ices stop diatrly. The recc'nt ly created consumer forec losure- rising this option quickly cUsappears. prc-\'ent ion program (l-888-995-1 !OPE) is a powerfu l Fifth and finally, ,1·0\·e let dmrn our legal and social first step, but it is only a first step. A second step is for guards against the cl<rngers of short- t0rm gains wh ich rvc- ryone to read and th en rea d again 711(' Stale ri( lilr lead to long-term losses. \\'e\·e completely abandoned .\"alion'.<i l/011si11_q 2007. all substan ti ve lega l constraints on residenti al mortgage- Don't bet th e house. Don't mm1gage your fut ure. ♦ bom)\\i.ng in the name of freedom and instant satisfaction, leaving the fo reelosecl-upon family wi th Uttle freedom and no satisfaction. For th e past :30 years pub l ic- policies hm·0 responded to market failures and market ab us0s in rrsiclential linai1c0 by incrrasing 1muiclatmy disclosures FEDERAL RESERVE BANK OF ATLANTA https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Thrsc \ icws are prC'sPntecl by Frank S. AlexallclPr. prof"(' ssor of law at E1110 1y Llniwrs ity School o f" Law, an Pxpcrt in ( ;porgia rC'al C'statp l,nancP and forcc-losurc law. Tlw Stol e r!f /li e' ,Vr,/ irJII \ l/011si11u ,.!007 is m·ailab lP o n line al ,1,n1·.jchs.l1,uYarcl.Pclu/ public-ations/niarkets/s<>n2007/ i11clPx .htm I hi r I e en Is Bankruptcy Reform Legislation Working? Bankruptcy Institut e (ABI), 500,000 consumers raced to fil e c laims the wee k before the bankruptcy law took Subtitle A-General Pro effect. ' This rush to fil e in 2005 n'ry likely cont1ibutccl to the subsequent steep drop in 2006 filings. The question remains whether the new legislation ,,ill (a) am keep bankruptcy filings low. Figur0s for 2007 alrcacly indicate a significant 1ise in filings. Growth in tlw numbers of bankrupt cy filings can be tracE'CI to an increase in mmigagc deli nquencies and foreclosu res nationw icl c. Some anal ys t s p redi ct that bankruptcy filin gs co ulcl r each pre-reform levels o f on e million by year-encl. r it c u s · b et!f s ·m o The effecti,·eness of credit coLmseling, a critical component o r the bankruptcy reform legislation, is unclcr scrutiny in response to opi ni ons staled in a recent Govern ment Acco unt abi lity Office (GAO) repo rt. It IN 2005 WHEN LEGISLATORS LAUNCHED BANKRUPTCY REFORM MEASURES , indicates that th e pre-filing credit coLmscling required by the law docs not seem to be workin g as int ended. ' Accord ing to the GAO, "Anecdotal e,idcnce suggests that by the time most cot1SLm1ers recei,·e cow1Seling, tlwir ANNUAL PERSONAL BANKRUPTCY financial situations arc dire, lem·ing them with no ,iable al ternatiYe to bankruptcy." The GAO recommenclecl FILINGS WERE AVERAGING WELL OVER that the Justice Department track and analyze the r esults of' nedil co un seling to gauge its i mpac t on 1 MILLION PER YEAR. bankrupt cy filings . Justice Dep,u-tmcnl tracking results show that at le,1St The nu mber doubled to just over 2 mill ion in 2005 due 10 p0rccnt or I he consLm1ers w ho compktcd counseling to the sLU'gc of filings in anticipation of' tlw October enact- decided not to fil0 bankruptcy. Ilowe,·cr, the data cl o not ment date. (See Pal'/1 w1·s Vol. 15, No. 2.) rule out th e possibi li ty that filings may ha\·c oeeurrecl at a No t surprisi ngly, the barrage of filin gs in 2005 was later date. The .Justi ce Department plans to impro\·e cur- followed by a dramatic decrease in 2006. Co nsum er rent tracking procedures with enhanced automation and bank rupt cies dropped by 71 perce nt , l o a tota l of tim e series data that will provide more reliab le infor- 598,000 filings for th e year. mation on th e ou tcome of cr edit counse ling. Docs thi s mean the legis lation has succ·ccdcd in putting a clamper on bankruptcy filings·? Not necessarily. l\1ost analysts be lie\'C tha t passage of' I he legislatio n Georgia lead nation's " ank u .y ca · a " Most states logged a signifi can t decrease in pe rsonal prompt eel many consumers who were working through bankruptcy fili ngs in 2006. Georgia saw a drop as well credit problems to opt instead for filing- before tougher but con tinuccl to lead the nation with the highest number measures were pu t in place. According to the Arne1ican of individual filings. On a per capita basis (basccl on fourteen https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis VOLUME 17, NUMBER 2 of dosl' lo a yp;u· in slal0s like Flo1ida ,md :\'e,, York whPrc' forec-losurC' happPns under judicial law. Hat 11C'r lhwi IOS(' lheir honlC'S, most c·onsumC'l'S opl lo [ilC' for STATE 2006 2005 79 ,273 (8)* Cha pt N L:3 p ro t PC' l ion l o slow clow n o r stop fo rP- GEORGIA 39 ,142 CALIFORNIA 37 ,107 162 ,532 (1) In addition , ChaptPr J:l rporganization bankrnptcy TEXAS 34 ,550 117 ,612 (3) rl'l ic l' fil ings arl' 111orp common in (;po rgia tha n Chap- OHIO 34,466 133 ,541 (2) trr 7 liquidation filings. BPcause f Pdl'l'al bankrnptcy 88 ,402 (7) fffonn tm·gptpd ChaptPr 7 filings, thl' IPgislation·s impact 65 ,360 ( 11) w,L'i closun' proc·Pc'dings. MICHIGAN 32 ,746 TENNESSEE 31 ,406 ILLINOIS 29 ,774 105,964 (6) Anotlwr c·ont1ibuling f~ll'tor ,,·as (;c'orgia·s high \'Olunw NEW YORK 29,059 107 ,489 (4) or nonl racl it ionaJ mid subprinw mo11gagc' loans in rc'CC'n t FLORIDA 24 ,709 106,250 (5) years. :\lost of lh<'Sl' lllo11gagrs wrn' PXlPnckd to first - PENNSYLVANIA 23 ,190 77 ,587 (10) not as pronounced in Gc'orgia. ti.Jll(' honH' buyc'1-s ,,·ho qualified basPd on lo,, int roduc-tory rail's sd H'dull'd l o rt'Sl't within <>Ill' to two years. 1\ow that ra t<' adjustnwnts h,ffe lwgun to occu r, lllany affc,c·tpd bo1To,1·c' 1'S han' not bren ablP to makp tlw highpr STATE FILINGS PER 1,000 HOUSEHOLDS 2006 2005 TENNESSEE 13.3 28.0 (3) * GEORGIA 11.4 23 .6 (11) ALABAMA 10.8 26 .7 (7 ) INDIANA 9.0 32.5 (1) MICHIGAN 8.5 23 .0 (13) ARKANSAS 8.5 27.8 (5) MISSISSIPPI 8.1 21 .9 (18 ) OHIO 7.7 29.7 (2) KENTUCKY 7.4 24.3 (9) LOUISIANA 6.8 21.6 (19) paymPnl. Ol'tPn tlwy arr not able lo rpfinancP IJpc·ausP of tlH' 1wgali\·r amo11ization typical!~ associatC'd \\'ith thC's<' p rod uc ts. Ma ny of thPse consu mPrs now fac·c' tlw p rosprc t or forC'c losur<' and poss ib ly ba n k ru p tcy. ,\ !so of note. tlw top Hl highest filing statC's on a 1wr capita basis includc'd fi\·r Sixth Distlic-t state's: Alabama, Georgia, Louisi,rna, :\l ississippi and Tc'nnPSSl'<'. Florida nrnkc'd :JS and :J.'j for :ZOO(i ,rnd 200-:i n'SP<'c·lin'ly (Table' 2). ,. DC'l>at<' continues aboul till' effPc-tin'nPss of tlw bankru p t C'Y rpfo rm IPgis lal ion. Some argul' that I IH' nrw rPq uirPme nl s and add itiona l costs o n ly impose mo1T s,,,ir,·,·: / '..'i. Uo11kr1111t,·_1I Court. l .S. r ·,,11s11s H11r<'<111 burdC'ns on consumC'1'S ,,·ho lrgitimatC'ly nec>d d!'l>I rrlipf'. Othc'r'S aSSC'ti that tllC' law is necessmy to c-tu'h ahusr mid filings pPr 1,000 l1<1usl'holcls) . lw,n'\'l'r. GC'orgia C'IHkd rnsurP that those c·onsumC'l'S ,,·ho c-,m afford to repay at thl' yPar Sl'(·ond IH'h incl TennC'SSC'('. k'ast a portion or tlw ir dPbts do so. ♦ Part or tlH' rpason for Georgia's dubious distinct ion 111ay lH' tlw statp's nl'ditor-fril'ndly la,,·s, \\'hich han' This ar1 idl' 11·as 1\l'illC'n h.' Lisa EasH' n1 ood. finan('ial analysl in tlH• Supc>1Yision and RC'gulaIion cli\ision at till' AIlanta Ft'<'- oftpn lef't borrowNs with k\\' options ot hN lhan bankruptcy to protect lhem in tlH' e\·ent of financial difficult il's, Psp0(·ia lly when a 111ortgagP is i1n-oln'cl. (il'orgia is a non-judicial state that permits IPnders to forc•close on a home \\'ilhoul going lo court. From initiating foreclosure' proceedings to selling a honH' on t hl' court house slc'ps, l 11C' procC'ss c·,rn be c·omplekd in as fp,,· as :l'i clays in (ieorgia, co111parC'CI with a l i1110lhune F E DERAL RES E R V E BAN K O F A TL ANTA https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Endnotes 1 Erika Lo,·pi.'·, "BankrupJc·y Filings Rist' l p1n1rd TrPnd is Expt' <'lt•cl to ConIinuP Through :200,." llri 11s/ ()11 ('/i m 11ic/1. Apri l !I, :200,. ~(;n•gory Stanford, ··Bankrupt cy: Repairs lo l."'111 \!'P<IPd ." Tit<' .\l i/11 ·<111k,·1• ./() 111'11<1/ Se11ti11Pi. ~la.' I , :!00,. fifteen Predatory Lending and the Military PREDATORY LENDING IS ALWAYS PROBLEMATIC, BUT IT'S A SPECIAL CONCERN WHEN MILITARY PERSONNEL ARE PREYED UPON DURING ACTIVE DUTY. A NEW LAW WILL HELP CURB ABUSES , AND THE FEDERAL RESERVE IS PLAYING A REGULATORY ROLE ALONGSIDE THE DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE {DOD}. Protective provisions within The Jo hn Warner National A 2005 s urvey of serviceme mbers rated pe rso na l Defense Autho rization Act for Fiscal Year 2007 (Warner finances lllo re stress ful than deploylllents , health con- Act) were s igned int o law in Octo be r 2006 and wi ll cerns, life e\·enls a nd personal relations hips. The most become effecti\·e October 1, 2007. Also known as the common traps ha\'e been payday loans, \'ehicle title loans, Talent Amendment, the new legislation vvill protect ser- nlilit3ly instal lment loans, tax ref1-md an ticipatio n loans \'ice men and wolllen and their fam ilies frolll some of the and rent-to-mvn purchases. worst practices of loan sharks. Early in 2005, legis lation was proposed to limit preda- Financial stress not only affects the well-being of individual se1v ice melllbers but also the operation of the arllled tory lending practices targeting mil it3ly personnel. The forces as a whole. Financial strain is so system ic Lhat Servicelllembers Anti-Predato1y Lending Protection Act many members have become unqualified for s l rategic sought to limit the an nual percen tage rate (APR) to secLUity clearances, thereby comp romising the ability of 36 percent, enhance disclosme of loan terms and rest1ict the amwd forces to conduct their missions. As a result of auto matic loan roll-overs. (See Par/11C'l's Vo l.1 5, No.2.) these concerns, the DOD developed a strategic plan to Although this bill didn't become law, it paved th e way reduce the stress related to financial prob lems, increase for the new legis la tion. the personal savi ngs of its members, decrease its mem- Effects of predatory lending prevalence or predatory lending practices. bers' dependence on unsecured debt, a nd decrease the Over the last several years, DOD has been increas- Even though the DOD has been paitnering with a nw11- ing finan cial education for membe rs of the lll il itary. ber of organizations li ke the FDIC to prmide financial O\'er 40 percent of military se1Y ice personnel a re education, these efforts have not been sufficient to stem under Ihe age of 25, and ma ny are no t experie nced the tide of predatory lending. DOD therefore pressed Con- in financial matters. Thus th ey are easy targets for gress to prO\ide greater legal protections from predatory predatory len ders. lending practices. sixtee n https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis VOLUME 17, NUMBER 2 New rules to curb abuses SC'ction 670 of the W,:m1er Act , ·'Limit ations on Terms of Consumer Credit Extended to Scnic·p :\!embers and :2. Any clisclosmes requircd by llw Truth in LC'ncling Act: ;J. A clear d0sc1ipt ion of tlw payrncnt obligation; a11d -l. A "co\·crcd borrower idt>ntification stat0ment." DC'prnd0 nt s," is designed to curtail abusive pract ices assoeiat cd with payday lending an d other prcclat ory l0nding praclic-cs largt>ted al military pt>rso nnl'l . Tlw law applies to both sr1...-ic-P members and their dcp enc!C' nt s. It st ipul at cs th at the APR of a c-overe cl Framing the regulations Thc new legislation assigns DOD lhC' responsibilit y of issuing regulations and in1pl0menting them. l low0H'r, it also stipulalcs that DOD must consu lt with t]l(' FcclPral extension of ncdit cannot excrcd :36 pere0 nt. and it R0s01Ye and other primary banking regulato1y agencies manclatcs disclosures and terms mirroring thc Truth in as wcll as th0 FTC <U1d NC'l .A. This l\-ill be tlw first time Lcnding Ac t. It also in (' luclcs a pro\·ision against any DOD has bPPn im·ol\·pcl in drafting r0gu lati ons thal will stal e or fC'Cleral preemption , unlcss th ose law s prmi clc affpc-t th e banking industry. Proposrd regulations \l'C're C'\·en grcater protections. published in the FeclC'ral R0gister on Ap1il 11 , :2007, ,me! Othcr pro\'isions inC'ludc thc follow ing proh ibitions: tlw c-onmH'nt period ended in Jww :2007. • Lcndc'rs may not roll o\·C'r. n' new. rrfinance or ( 'onmw nt s acknowlC'dge that signi fi cant protect ions consolidatP c-reclit unless th<' nC'w tnmsac-tion ar<' added into law by the stat ed pro\·isions, but I lwy rcsults in more fa\'Cnable tcrms to thC' borrowC'r. also cite c-ha.ll0ngcs, including crafting language' that does • Borrowers nmnot bc requircd or allowed to w ai\'C' thC' right to IC'gal r('COLU-SC'. • In t lw case o f di spute, lcndcrs cannot rc' quirr the not presrnt contradic-tions or cr0ate confusion with regard to Pxisting la\1·s and regulations. For example, som<' beliP\'<' that disc-losing ,rn APH and a i\lAPR might borrower to submit to arbitration or impose onerous bc confusing to consumers, or that t lw dcfinit ion of "c-on- lc>gal nolieP prmisions. sumPr crc>dit" might be too rnuTowly statrcl. The \\'arner Act prm·idcs speci fi c c!C'finilions of the Others ai·guc that installnient lmms should b0 inc-lucled. terms "interrst," "APR" and "c-onsunwr cr Pclit. " For St ill otlwrs note that open-Pnded neclit such as c-r0dit pxamplP. its dPf'inilion of APR incl udes all fpes and ca rd s, bank o\·ercl raft l oans and payday loans O\'C'r 91 cha.rgc>s eo1mccted to the loan, inc-luding singlc-prcmiwn clays 11·en' not addr cssecl. Furtlwrmorc, somc a.re' c-on- credit insuranc0 and other products sole! in connection ccrn0d that prcdatory lcnc!C'rs will r0struc-lun' loan terms 1\·ith the> transaction. Sonw of thes0 fprs and chargPs to g0t around the rc'g ulation ·s d0f'inilion of "consumer are c>xempt from standard APR calculat ions so thr Iww crt> dit " in o rd er to co ntinue their p rcdat ory pract ic0s. method of calcu lation is being called tlw "M ilitaiy AP ff' or ·':\lAPR." Prior to becoming ohligatccl through th0 transaction, An important debate Enhancing consumer protrctions for s0nicen1('111bers each app li cant must be provided w ith a clear and con- is c-lpar[y lwnclicia.l. But som0 have' argued th at in tt>rms spicuous "con' red borrowC'r identification statement" of p0rsonal finance our senicenl('mb01-s ,u·0 no different that must be signed by th0 borrower. than the rpst of us, ,u1d that consumers as a wholc cou ld It shou ld lw noted that the law docs not apply to resi- b01wlit from strong0 r prot 0c-t ion against prcdatmy prac- dential mortgag0 loans and loans to purchasP \ 'C'hic l0s. tice's. At llw sa.nw lime. r0gu latory bocli0s must walk a Residc>ntial mortgag0 loans ar0 defined not only as finc line to m·oicl undue rest ri ction against acc0ss lo purchasc monc'y but also relinancing, home cquity loans crcd it. Whilc thc debate continues, all parties agr0P upon and home equity lines of credit. the rnlue of hming fin ancial education in making \1·ise For cm·ercd loans, s0nicemembers should <'xpect to recci\·p th e following at the loan closing: I. A disclosurP cont aining the l\-lAPR and tlw total fina ncial choic0s. ♦ This ,utic l<' \\'as 11-ritlPn by ~li c-hael ~lilnPr, rPgional c-omn111nit y dp1·plopnwn1 director in thP A1lm1ta FPcl's Birmingham 13r,rnc-h. dollar amount of all charg0s; FEDERAL RESERVE BANK OF ATLANTA https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis seventeen Free Tax Sites Generate Refunds for Nashville Families THANKS TO FREE TAX PREPARATION AND THE EARNED INCOME TAX ~ 1040 CREDIT, MORE THAN 6,000 LOW- Label 's llrsl name and uutllll L ~ II a ,oint r9turn. sl)OUSO E L LwJt f\NT'l8 haVe HonMt~l~ a po b01t, see page \6. and sttael): rl yau - --;:;:- - ~ - - - . ; atorfl9" ~ AND MODERATE-INCOME FAMILIES "l t ~ THROUGHOUT NASHVILLE RECEIVED A TOTAL OF MORE THAN $9 MILLION IN FEDERAL TAX REFUNDS THIS PAST TAX SEASON. The Kasl1\ille \\'ealth Building Alliance (1 \VBA) spon- to call :2-1-1 to get a free, one-hour financial consulta- sored 13 tax preparation assistance sit es, plus a mobile ti on whic h in c ludes a custo mized budget and goa l w1it that traveled to se,·eral nonprofit organizations w1d assessment as we ll as information about resources local employers to provide help for households earning for further help . $-!0,000 or less. Thanks to th e work of the Volun tec•r 1.ncome Tax Assistance (\1TA) sites: • 6,2 13 returns were filed through al l VITA sit es, a 6 percent in crease o,·er 2006; • $8,946,529 in Federal refw1ds were due to VITA site clients, a 4 percent increase m ·er 2006; • $;3, 009,:283 in Earned I ncome Tax Cred it (E l TC) refW1ds \\·ere tallied, a 7 percent increase o,·er :2006. Eac h VITA client also received a fre e "Fi nancial Sta- NWBA extends its reach through new partners The Kash,ille Wealth Building Alliance \\·orks ,,·ith nu merous compan ies and organizations to broaden its outreach and educational efforts. This year, thei r coUaborations produced: • Four new \'!TA sites, including an employersponsored VITA site at Tyson Foods that offe red sel"\ices in 9 different languages. • A new partnership with Tennessee's Depai1rnent of bility Resource Guide," w hi c-h provides a cornpreh C'n- Human Se1Yices, which sponsored the NWBA's lai-- si, ·C' listing of the free or affordab le asset-b uilding gest VITA site and implemented EITC outreach to se1vices in NashYill e. \'ITA clients were encouraged Fami lies First and food stan1p clients. eighteen https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis VOLUME 17, NUMBER 2 • A ne\\' partnership \\'ilh a local compmw, Ble\il1s Inc. , to prmidC' a fn'C'-standing VlTA sitP in a lowincome' arC'a. fami ly claiming the crC'dit, but also a boost for thC' Nas ll\'ille eco nomy. "ThC' 'ripple' C'ffect' from EITC refunds spent in .\ash- • A new partnership with \ 'anderb ilt l ' ni\'C'rsit y to establish a \'lTA silC' m1el sill' coordinator to targC't \ 'm1dC'rbilt stuclC'nts and employees. dllC' producC's millions of dollars each yC'ar in pc·onomic stimu lus, crPat es hunclrC'cls ofjohs cluP to innPased demand for products and sPnices purchased \\ith EJT(' • A 76 pc•rcpnt incrpa-;0 in calls to UnitPcl Way's 2- 1-1 rC'funds, m1d r('clu c·C's pm·C'rty w ithin our local c·omrnu- call CC'nlC'r in i\'asl1\ille/Da\idson County about thC' nity." said Congressman Jim Cooper C'ith Dist1ict , Ten- hours and local ion of \'lTA sit C'S. nC'SSC'C' ). CongrC'ssmm1 CoopC'r is 01w o f th e found ing members of tlw '.'JWBA. Economic ripple extends to Nashville economy The EJT(' is m·guably the most C'ffccli\'C' m1ti-powrty N \\ 'BA is a broad-basPd coalition of go\·ernmPnt, nonpro fit s, churclws and businrssrs working togpt lwr to program in America and lifts more chilclrC'n out of help low- and modrratr-inconw incli\·iduals m1cl families po\·erty than any singlP fC'cleral program or combinat ion tlu·oughout Nash\·illc/Dmiclson Count y to build mid main- of fpderal progrm11s. It prmides one of tlw bC'st oppor- tain financial stability. Sponsors incluclr: BIC'\ins Inc.; tunitirs for working f'amiliC'S to put monC'y int o sa\ings, Ba nk of AmC'rica; Regions Bank; TC'nnC'SSC'P l)ppart - 1\·hich is mi irnpo1im1t step towards helping thC'm achiC'\'C' ment of lluman SenicC's (DIIS); Tyson Foods Inc. ; thC' grpater financial stability. Bank of An economic impact study sponsored by tlw :'\\\'BA found that EITC is not only a bC'nC'fit for tlw working 1aslwillC'; CS Commun it y CrC'clit t ·nion, and Da\i cl & Ad riC'nn C' Piston. l 'nited \\'ay of !\let ropolitm1 .\asl1\ille is a IC'acling part nC'r of tl1C' :-,;\\'BA. ♦ Th is article \\'as \\'ritten by Rachel FrPPZP. Nash,·illP \\'palth Bui ld ing Allianc·p managp;· at t ·ni tPd \\'a,v \'asl11ill<'. 2007 Season Results PERFORMANCE INDICATORS ALL CLIENTS 6,243 # filing returns Total federal refunds claimed $8,946,529 Total Earned Income Tax Credit $3,009,283 29.12 % 1,678 # claiming Earned Income Tax Credit $117 ,568 Total child & dependent care credit 257 # claiming child & dependent care credit 4.46% $1 ,925,230 Total child tax credit $1,483 # claiming child tax credit 25.74% $283,747 Total education credit 6.56% 378 # claiming education credit 270 4.69 % # with positive tax amounts 3,498 60.71 % # with positive federal refund amounts 5,133 89.08% # using direct deposit (federal tax) 3,075 59.91 % 5,154 89.45% # claiming unemp loyment compensation # federal returns filed (electronic) Median Adjusted Gross Income # with AGI > $37,263 S"111rr•: Nashl'i/1,• Wn1//h U11ildi11,11 Alli11111·,• - FEDERAL RESERVE BANK OF ATLANTA https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis $20,078 Ir 717 II I 12.44% nineteen ALABAMA HOUSING PLAN HOLDS PROMISE FOR FUTURE The l lillsDale communit_v of :\lobile. Ala .. has assw11rcl the motto "forging a futurr " to dPsc-ribe its neighborhood rr\·italizat ion efforts. Located curren tl y choose from se\·en different floor plans, but DASH " ·ill r\·entually make up to 1:2 plans arnilable. DASH hopes to attract familirs clisplaced by llurric-ane Katrina as 11·ell as any buyC'rs interrsted in a re\ita li zecl I lillsDalP. along one of the arC'a·s main transportation arteries and acljac-ent to Cn ivrrs it y of South A labama, this onc-e\ibrant nrighbor hood is embarking on a plan to rrc-laim its srnse of community and attrac-t 1w11· rPsiclents. Unique aspects of plan in aclcl ition to incorporating modul,u· housing, an othrr uniqur feature' of thr reYita li zation plan i s thr sca le and targeted nature oft he !'uncling pro\·idecl by local DASH partners in HillsDale revitalization Spearheaded by the residents ancl supported by DASII gO\·ernment. Rather than parce ling out smaller pots of money to (Jkpenclable. Affordable, Sustainable Housing) for the \·arious community cle\·elopment projects, the threr- Gulf Coast, a Ne ighbor\\lorks® affili ate\ thr re\·itali- member CDBG (Community De\·elopmrnt Block Grant ) zal ion plan wi ll build :2:20 new homes and renO\·ate Entitleme nt Com mitt ee maclr th e bol d decision to :2..J t'x isting homes in the 1wighborhoocl. Tlw total in\'est- dedicat e over $750,000 of tlw city's $:3 mill ion annual n1<'nt is Pslimated at almost $:27 mi lli on. C'DBG fun d to projects in thr I lillsDa le neighborh ood. Threr nrw modC'i homes were showcasPd recently lo The money will be usrcl to build sidrwal ks, impron' resick'nts, local banks ancl other stakeholcit'rs. They ,u-e drainage, refurbish a nearby park and help residents modu lar c-onstruct ion with upscale amenitic's such as with clown payment assistance. oak cabinrts and garclen tubs making tlwm appear far pricier than comparable site-built affordable homes. Tlw units range from a two-bedroom. nll:2-square-fool Construction of the ne\1· homes 11·ill begin in midNowmber, ancl DASII anticipatrs that they 11·ill br ready for occupancy by January :2008. Homebuyer training homr pricrcl at $DG ,OOO, to a l ,..JGO-sq uare-foot. four- classes wi ll begin in brclroo m , two-bath honlC' for $1..JD.000. Buyers c-an ownPrsh i p Crn I Pr. ove mlwr at lhr DASH llom e- For more in formati on about t hr clrvelopm ent or DASI I for the Gui£ Coast call (:251) ..J:38-7800 or \·isit thC' website at wvvw.dashgulfc-oast. org. ♦ This anic-le 1u1s \ITittc-n by :\" ancy :\lontoya, regional c·ommun it y dc-n'lopment managc' r in tlH' A tl anta Fed's '.\e\\" OrlPans Bran ch. twenty https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis VOLUME 17, NUMBER 2 GEORGIA FORECLOSURE SOLUTIONS: HELP FOR GEORGIA HOMEOWNERS T he rece nt rise in forec losure ac ti vi ty is a national cular emphasis on the trend affecting thousands of LS. households. According foreclosure process in to RealtyTrac® , more than 1.2 million foreelosu res were Georgia. lnte1Y iews wit h fi lccl nationwide in 200G. Th is issue is of pmticular con- nat iona l an d st ate leaders cern in the Southeast, where Georgia ranked sixLh in the prov id e info rlll ation al.J ouL rPsou1-c-es availab le t o nation in forec losures last yem·. no nprofit agencies that work w i th co nsumers to T he Fc-dc-ral Reserve Bank of At lanta's Co mm unity prc-ser\'c- the ir hollles. I n addi ti on, Emrny L1w School Affai rs o ffi ce recog ni zes that foreclosures can have- a pro rc-ssor Fra nk Akxan der explains the (')..l)C-dic-ncy of de\·astati ng ripple effect on consumers, finan cial insti- the foreelosure process in Georgia compared to ot her tutions m,cl the overall commu nity. Combining research, sta tc-s. communicati on m,d active- involvernc-nt, the Community Perh aps th e- most importm,t aspect of th e \icleo is a Affai rs sta ff has w ork ed w it h com muni ty part ners to seg ment tha t highli ght s sevC'ral consum ers w ho have pro,·icle i nformati on that w ill help those affected by face d forec los ure. T hey describe thei r p reclica nwnts forec-losures lllake more informed decisions. and offc-r acl\·ice fo r oth C'rs facing simi lar probl ems. Atlanta Fed partners in foreclosure prevention campaign Th C' Atlm,ta Resc-1Ye Bank is an ac-ti\·e partner i n the NeighborWorks Arnc-1i ca/National Ad Council Foreclosure So l uti ons Ca mpaign, w hi ch promotes th P Homeownership Preserrn tion Foun dation's (IIPF) nationa l HOPE hotl ine in Georgia. 1-888-005-1!OPE (.JG7:3). QppratPd by I-IPF' and sta!T(•cl in par t by CC'CS of Greater Atl anta co unselors, t hP hot lin P connpcts honwow,wrs facing \ fo reclosure \\'ith free counseli ng 2-t hou rs a day, 7 days a WC'l' k. The HOPE hotl ine was launched in G(•o rgia in ea rl y 2007. Bet ween Jan uary and Apri l 2007, over (i,:300 The At lanta Feel has responded w ith two i«'Y ini tiati,·es: (1) production of a \i cl eo that presents sollle of the iss ues Gc-orgians ar c- facing as a res ult or forC'c losures, homeowners called the hotline, m,d approximately 1,:500 caJ IPrs recein'ci cou nseling. Both of these initiatives m·e pmi of the- Atlanta Fed's m, d (2) part icipation in a national fo rC'closu re prevention ongoing effort to promote a bett er unclerstm,cli ng of' l'ore- cmnpa.ign in partnership w ith SC'\·eral national, state and closure issuPs in the r egion and to support programs local orgm, izat ions. tha t seek to help affect eel consumers. Video focuses on Georgia foreclosures Th is aitici(' " ·as \\TiltC'n by Sibyl Slade, rpgio nal co mmunit,\· dcvC' lop mc•nl 111a11agC' r at tilP Atlant a rC'cl. ♦ The Bank's fo rec losure- p r e\·en t ion \'icieo p ro\·i d cs a nationa l perspecti ,·e on forC'closm e issues w it h parti - FEDERAL RESERVE BANK OF https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis ATLANTA t wenty - one FE D E RA L RESE RV E BA NK O F ATL ANT A C OMMUN ITY AFFA I RS 10 00 DEP A RTME NT PE ACHTREE STREE T , N.E. ATL ANT A , GEO RG IA 303 0 9 - 4470 CH AN GE SE RV ICE RE QUE STE D STAFF VICE PRESIDENT Steve Foley COMMUNITY AFFAIRS OFFICER Juan C. Sanchez COMMUNITY AFFAIRS DIRECTOR Wayne Sm ith EDITOR Jennifer Grie r PRODUCTION MANAGER l la rri ette Grisso m STAFF WRITERS Jess ica Le Vee n Farr Mike Milner Nancy Montoya Sibyl Slade CONTRIBUTING WRITERS Frank S. Alexander Lisa Easterwood Rac hel Freeze DESIGNERS Peter Ha mil to n Odi e Swa negan Free subscription and add itional copies are a\'ailable upo n request by mail at the Community Affairs Department add ress aboYe, o r e-mail us at Pa rt11 c1·s@a ll..fib.org, or call 404/498-7287; FAX 404/498-7342 . The \'iews ciqJ ressecl arc not necessarily those of the Fede raJ Resen ·e Bank of Atlanta or the Fede ral Rese1ve Syste m. Material may be reprinted or a bs tracted provided tha t Paii ners is c redi ted and prO\i decl with a copy of the publication. www. frbatl anta.org https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis PR ESORTED STANDARD U.S. PO STAGE PA ID Atlan t a, GA Perm it No . 29 2