View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

• _




MARCH 30, 1869.

I s it the habit of men constituted like this assemblage and the
other House to bow in obedience to, and believe the suggestions
made by, wealthy capitalists? The same influence is operating
on every public officer in the land, and if he be not more than
human, as I have heretofore said, he will surrender to the temptations placed before him* Here, under my own observation,
was an offer to a $3000 clerk to report upon a certain matter
i n a certain way ; and $100,000 worth of temptation was placed
before him. Here, also, in my belief, was the cause of a provision agreed to by both Houses of Congress, being left off an appropriation bill involving a saving to this Government of
$2,000,000. These are two instances out of thousands.
The people are led to believe that the distillers of whisky
are the real offenders in corrupting public officers. This is not
so. The laws of Congress are of such a character that the distiller can barely survive after he has paid the levies put upon
him by Government officials, acting' as the tools of the power I
have indicated, which stands behind and shares in the theft and
Retortion. The forced levies of arbitrary power, in the most corrupt days of the Roman empire never much exceeded those I have
indicated. In their operations stand charged some names that
are high in the estimation of the people of the Republic. A s
this power is unseen and subtle, it is much more dangerous and
vicious. I t shields itself, if attacked, behind its victim or toolHence the capitalist will as readily abandon parties, politicians,
legislatures, banks, etc., as lie bus used them, whenever they
fall into disfavor with the people, whenever the people nrc
tempted to strike against this tool or victim to obtain redress—
and each time missing the real cause of their misery—the actual
culprits escape. You can never put your hands on them bodily,
for their number is added to or taken from as speculations or
operations succeed or fail. The people may strike down the
tool or victim, as they did in the case of Jeffreys, but they will
never reach the scat of thei^"13^TSTes~^
have driven the



king from the throne; in our case b y taking the control of the
money market, as indicated by the proposition to disburse the
Government funds and place on the market daily the balances
of Government receipts and individual deposits, and this through
men who have the public confidence, and whose operations will
surely command the situation, give stability to material interests,
to society, to religion, and politics, and liberate the people.
I have not raised my voice to destroy any public or private interests, but to preserve tbem all, and I come to show the clear way
to remedy the difficulty. Adopt it, and that speedily, or your
seats will be vacated and the people will do it for themselves ; and
as constitutions are of no possible account without it, they will
make it the first article that they next enact. This statement
is made for the consideration of the candid and thoughtful, and
I ask of those who can comprehend what I now say to show the
people the true cause of their difficulties.
I made a statement some days since as to the disparity of
production between this country and Great Britain. I have obtained some information on that point, which I send to the desk
to be read as part of my remarks.
[The Chief Clerk read as follows ;]
W A S H I N G T O N , March 12,

: I n response to y o u r r e q u e s t for a s t a t e m e n t s h o w i n g t h e
r a t e of increase in t h e product of w h e a t per acre in Great Britain, a n d giving some idea of t h e r a t e of decrease in production per acre in t h i s c o u n t r y ,
allow m e to s a y t h a t o u r t e m p o r a r y o c c u p a n c y of l a n d s in wheat, a n d the
extension of wheat-growing to n e w fields, w h i c h will in t u r n b e a b a n d o n e d
in a few y e a r s , p r e v e n t s a proper appreciation of t h e a l a r m i n g decrease in
t h e yield which is actually observed in localities in w h i c h wheat-growing
h a s been long practiced.
I t is a fact t h a t diminution of yield is t h e rule, to which t h e only exceptions are furnished b y a few scientific farmers in all States in w h i c h the
same l a n d s are cultivated in w h e a t for a series of y e a r s . F o r instance, in
Ohio, for a period of five y e a r s ending in 1854, t h e average yield w a s thirteen a n d t h r e e t e n t h s b u s h e l s ; for succeeding period of five y e a r s , eleven
a n d two t e n t h s b u s h e l s ; for eight y e a r s , e n d i n g in 1867, t e n a n d five
t e n t h s bushels- Comparing t h e period ending in 1S54 w i t h t h e last five
y e a r s , a still greater r e d u c t i o n is shown, n i n e a n d t h r e e t e n t h s b u s h e l s
being the average, or a reduction of four bushels, or t h i r t y p e r cent decrease
in fourteen y e a r s .
I n 1866, owing t o t h e severe winter-killing, t h e average w a s r u i n o u s l y
d e p r e s s e d in t h e Ohio Valley, being b u t four a n d five t e n t h s b u s h e l s in Ohio,
five a n d nine t e n t h s in Indiana, and six a n d i\vo t e n t h s in K e n t u c k y .
average for t h e U n i t e d States in t h a t y e a r did n o t exceed ten a n d five t e n t h s
* A r e m a r k a b l e decrease in production is r e p o r t e d i n . t h e Genesee Valley,
tlie b r e a d - y i e l d i n g section so famous a few y e a r s since* Tlie N e w - Y o r k
c e n s u s of 1865 gives b u t twelve bushels as the average for the crop of 1864
in t h a t State. O u r national average for a few y e a r s p a s t h a s n o t exceeded

t w e l v e b u s h e l s p e r a c r e , n o t w i t h s t a n d i n g t h e larger yields of California, and
o c c a s i o n a l l y s o m e of newly-settled western and n o r t h - w e s t e r n S t a t e s .
^ T u r n i n g to E n g l a n d , an increase in production can be shown a m o u n t i n g
i n o n e h u n d r e d yearsr to five b u s h e l s per acre. In 1770, according to
A r t h u r Y o u n g , t h e 3 ield was t w e n t y - t h r e e b u s h e l s ; in 1850, by t h e estim a t e s of Caird, t w e n t y - s i x a n d a half b u s h e l s ; a t t h e p r e s e n t time t w e n t y e i g h t b u s h e l s is considered t h e real average, t h o u g h t h e crop of l a s t y e a r
e x c e e d e d it. T h e average in I r e l a n d for t w e n t y y e a r s p a s t is placed a t
t w e n t y - f o u r b u s h e l s ; for Great B r i t a i n — E n g l a n d ' Scotland, a n d I r e l a n d —
twenty-seven bushels.
V e r y respectfullv,
H o n . W I L L I A M S P B A G U E , United States

Mr. S P R A G U E . Mr, President, prior to 1861 the farming as
well as the manufacturing interest of this whole country was
in a state of general bankruptcy. There is not a member here
from the TV^est who can gainsay the position I assume.
is not a man in 3STew-England that can disprove my proposition,
Mr- WILSON*, W h a t is the proposition?
Mr. S P R A G U E , The proposition is, that if the manufacturing
interest of New-England had been sold prior to this war, it
would not have paid the debts of those engaged in it. If legislators of the past can find satisfaction in the hand they have
h a d in shaping the destinies of this country, I must confess they
are satisfied with very small results. W h y sliould we be behind
t h e nations of Europe? W h y should we be behind Grreat
Britain, with a territory not greater than the State of ISTewY o r k , and with a climate not favorable to the development of
t h e industries in which she is engaged, while this country lias
every variety of climate, a virgin soil, and every thing that the
h a n d of man desires? W e are considered in the estimation of
the world as destructives and disorganizes.
That is the estimate p u t upon the people of this country when they go abroad,
or whenever legislation is directed toward the relations that exist between this and other countries. Is that a picture to rejoice
t h e heart of an American citizen?
Mr. President, I have no other object than to convince you
of the disastrous condition of our situation, and to point out the
remedy. I tell the Senator from Massachusetts that the condition of the industries of his State and of New-England m a y
be compared to a row of bricks; when one goes, your fabric is
gone. If, sirs, you are not standing on a volcano, I am no
j u d g e of the condition of things; and it is all in consequence
of the mighty money power waged against the industries of
the country and the masses of the people.
Here come to me letters from the S o u t h : " Extricate us from
t h e terrible extortions made upon us by the moneyed men ;


twenty-five per cent per annum to carry on our business, and
money difficult to get at that." AVhy, sir, it is in m y remembrance that a shaver of paper beyond the legal rate was detested
and despised by the whole community wherein he lived, b u t today he commands all branches of your industry and property,
and is as surely enslaving the people of this country as the
slave master who commanded his negro household. I have
felt anxioxis about the situation, because I have seen this tendency for three years; and I have studied it deeply, night and
day, for three years, and I believe I comprehend the situation.
Docs the Senator from Massachusetts understand the forces
by which business is regulated? Can he create a business and
carry it on profitably? Can he, when that business is in dan*
ger of being brought to a stand, suggest measures that will
carry it on successfully? Yes, sir, he can, in the issue of more
money power to the masters liere and elsewhere, for that in substance is the character of the proposition he presents to this
body. I have no doubt that lie is informed by those around him
that the condition of the people of the country is peaceful and
prosperous; but the information he receives is from men who
derive advantage from his great position and great influence*
Can he tell, of his own knowledge, that the statements ho makes
can bo relied upon ? Can he tell that his informants know correctly as to the information which they give h i m ? Certainly
not. "What does he know about society ? IIow much of it
docs he mingle with? H e mingles with those that he comprehends. A r e they such men as can give a comprehensive view
of our present situation? l$o man shall stand here, either
through inattention or ignorance, or from any other cause, and
mistake the situation, if I can help it.
He tells the people of the country that their material interests
arc prosperous, and that every body is getting rich. H e may influence this Senate, but the people will ask him if he intends to
make them believe that white is not white, but that it is black.
As the farmer who was rich laughed at one that made the statement that he was poor, so will the masses of the people of this
country laugh at the 'statement made by the Senator from
Massac 1i usetts.
The Senator understands parties, the creation of parties, and
the carrying of them on successfully. iSTo man is more familiar with that subject; but lie mistakes his calling when he
gives utterance to opinions touching the interests of the masses
of the people of the United States. Cities are indeed prosperous, and the whole capital of this country is collected in those
cities, and the power of that capital is controlled and exercised
in increasing the value of the property there; but the people


o u t s i d e of the cities suffer, and tliejwojrfe in the cities suffer too.
]S*ot three weeks ago, information came to me of a gentleman
a d v e r t i s i n g for labor to go to tho South, and the first day he
h a d three hundred applicants, and the next three thousand.
D o e s that indicate a state of industrious contenfinent among the
p e o p l e in the rich city of New-York? The manufacturers of
N e w - E n gland ? induced by my example, are manufacturing tod a y at a loss, and accumulating stocks, and they have made no
m o n e y for the past two or three years. Money is made by
manufacturers only by the application of the power I have indicated, which crushes out those who are engaged in the same
business with itself
T h e tendency of this collection of capital in few hands, as I
h a v e repeated time and time again, is to crush out all small
industries and to build up mammoth ones, and they are being
b u i l t up on the poverty of the people of the United States, and
to t h e sacrifice of their property, unchecked. They are runn i n g riot over this la net WhV, sir, in the exercise of this
p o w e r a man connected with the'Eric Railroad who, two years
ago, was without a dollar in his pocket, exercises five hundred
times more control now over the business and social affairs of
this covmtry than Rothschild with his $400,000,000 can exercise
in t h e affairs of Great Britain. Rothschild to-day, exercising all
vthe power of his $400,000,000, can not change the value of cons o l s one eighth of one per cent Rothschild's capital is a part
..of t h e great working capital of the country, and he can not
j a v a i l himself of it. Fisk, with the hoarded capital of banks,
bankers, and others, which is at his command, is able any day
to launch it upon any property or condition of the market
favoring his designs.
I have spoken of society in this country. The Senator frem
' Massachusetts has told us that the moral condition of the people
of this country may bo imitated with profit. My comparison
of the people of our own country with people abroad has been
criticised by-anonymous letters, the writers of which say to me
" Y o u must be familiar with the disturbing element' in and
among American society/' Certainly, if I was not familiar
with American society, I should not have hazarded the statement I made. I make no statement in this Senate or elsewhere
that I can not substantiate by the clearest proof and the best
evidence. Anonymous writers criticise the comparison. Tho
corruptions, the dregs of society abroad, appear at places growing out of the purifying of the stream of general society, and
Americans who travel abroad mix and mingle in that filth, and
come homo here to inoculate the immoralities they have
seen into their own society. The comparison can not, in any



form or in any manner, eease to be exactly as I have indicated
it. I might point to the condition of things, and the reeking
corruptions attending the collection of your internal revenue,
Jt is clear to any man Avith half an eye that the statement I
made is true, and it is responded to perhaps more t h a n . a n y re-/
mark I have made since it was my duty to take my stand
upon this floor.
The great power that I have referred to, corrupt and vicious,
now controlling the affairs of this country, the people can never
touch except by the application of a power of a like character,
and equal to it. In a monarchical government it is resisted and
subdued, as Charles I, subdued it, when he stole the deposits of the
goldsmiths and put them in the tower, and then took them from
the tower for his own use. We have no such controlling influence over this most despotic, this most tyraunical power upon
our whole society.
Mr. President, I said on a former occasion, touching the ability of this body to originate wise legislation, that, owing to the
pressure from without, it was impossible for its members to give
time and close attention to the consideration of important public
matters. I pointed to the President and to the various heads of
Departments, the objective points of the office-seekers from
ovcry section of the country, and I told you that no man or set
of men could stand before the pressure thus exercised upon
them. The people of the country may as well understand that
the men engaged in legislation, and in performing the executive
functions pertaining to the administration of the Government,
are muzzled, and the Government itself is breaking down under
the force of the weight thus placed upon it.
Jt is said that the people of a republic will receive unwholesome truths carelessly, and that they will derive no advantage
from such truths when placed before them; that they will not
act upon them; that it is only under monarchical institutions
that virtue can prevail. This statement comes from }ncn who
are familiar with both, and have watched both for years. I
deny the assertion. If the people of a republic can be made to
comprehend the principle on which monarchs give prost>erity
to their people, and apply it to their own institutions, why will
they not succeed as well? A monarch, having his throne to
sustain, is more watchful and guarded than any irresponsible
representative, body is likely to be. Hence he applies the
principle and the means that will best promote his security.
This people need never intrust superior control in any man's
hands, as they have in the remedy I have proposed a sure one,
more faithful, more honest, more reliable than any man can
possibly be. The people of the United States have been pointed


t o t h i s m a n a n d to that man on whom they were to rely. T h e
m o m e n t t h e y made the application, commenced the temptation
b y w h i c h t h a t favorite hoped to arrive at superior power over
t h e m . T h e people of this country should repudiate every man
w h o is n o t competent to take care of the situation and give good
a n d -wholesome advice, no matter what m a y have been his
r e v i o u s history or his previous services. If any man foists
imself uf>on the people of this country because of past services,
u n l e s s h e is successful in continuing those services in the intere s t of t h e people, h e is a worthless instrument, and should be
a b a n d o n e d at once.
Sir, t h e Senate controls to-day the executive, the legislative,,
a n d thejmaterial interests of this country. The Senate of the
U n i t e d States is responsible for the present condition of the
political, social, and material affairs of the people, and it is bec a u s e I believe that responsibility rests here that I have taken
t h e time of the Senate as I have, to give to them the benefit of
m y experience and my research. I shall close now with a
h a s t y consideration of the idea—which has blinded this body,
t h e people, and the executive department—that our present dist u r b e d condition is in consequence of the non-payment of specie*
"We are told that specie payments will effect a cure for our
financial difficulties. T h e aim, then, is to force such a condition. I t is not to come as a natural consequence of the increaseof t h e industries of the people, but it must be forced through
b y legislative enactment. Y o u r commerce is destroyed ; y o u r
manufacturing interests jeopardized ; your agriculture paying
n o profit; trade stagnant and dull, and without profit; and yet
specie payments are to be forced upon the people, and every
t i m e t h e screw is turned labor ceases to be employed, and tho
people are more anxious as to their living for t h e future, "When
specie payments are thus forced, the holders of national b a n k
currency will apply for redemption. L*et them do it, and see
w h e r e t h e y "will come out. The bonds of the banks will be
forced on the market. M y friends will say, let them be forced.
T h e b a n k s of New-England, under m y o w n observation,
w e r e unable, prior to the war, to keep out more than ten per
cent of their circulation, and the time that that circulation was
k e p t out would not average more than fifteen days, and it
w o u l d then be rediscounted. AVhat value is there in a circulation w h e n it must be constantly distributed in that way ? Is
it a capital on which business can be done, and is it that upon
which you can rely, m y friends from the South, to do your
p l a n t i n g and farming and general business ? Our bills were
held at as high a credit as the national currency is now, or ever
will be. Let the bills be redeemed before the sale of the bonds,




and the securities that were received when the currency was
discounted must be sold. Then, what are the customers to do
who have their obligations to meet, and who must pay the
wages to those they employ? There will come m\ the market
$350,000,000 of your currency to be p a i l for by the capital of
the banks, .and your business will cease to be carried on. Besides, about the same time your market is to receive an additional amount of $400,000,000 of your bonds. That, it must
be easily observed, depreciates the value of both the bonds and
the securities ; but it does not lessen the indebtedness of the
banks. You can never, so long as ea:h of you live, arrive at a
condition of specie payments on the road you have commenced
and followed, with such terrific disasters to the interests of the
This measure is in the interest of speculators. My friends
from the South will get no possible advantage from this act*
They think they will. I vote against it because it adds to the
power centralized in New-York, which holds despotic sway
from the centre to the circumference of the country. If it were
to rest in the hands of those engaged in the productive interests
of the South, it might be confined to those interests ; but I have
never yet seen men engaged in any business, who would not
apply their means where they would obtain the highest profit.
Those who have money to loan will be exceedingly cautious
bow they invest this year to be paid in the next, dependent
upon the price of the" products of the farmer. The men who
obtain this currency by depositing the bonds of the United
States in the Treasury, will take it from the South and use it in
the lotteries going on in every city of the United States. If its
tendency was in any other direction, why is there not a flow of
the $700,000,000 of currency that no\v~eyLi$t< to the Southern
States, where money commands twenty-live per cent? It will
go to New-York. Our currency from Khodo Island goes to
New-York ; and when it is required to pay our people, we buy
it. W e send to New-York for it. It does not come to us,
But, sir, I do not oppose this proposition on that ground.
This change is one of the most dangerous experiments that has
ever been suggested by the Finance Committee and advocated
by the Senate. I told you the other day that it would disturb
the relations of sixty or ninety million dollars, if the proposition
of the Senator from Indiana prevails* W h a t will be the result
of taking from the monev-market. even for three or four days,
any portion of this $20^000.000? It will all be taken with
great rapidity ; for the sharks, who now observe with keen eye
all opportunities to absorb lands, or money, or securities, will


seize upon i t ; and my Southern brethren invite them to t a k e
this capital, and to carry it to New-York,.
I do not oppose this proposition at all because it will take circulation from Rhode Island. T h e Senate found it h a r d to believe that suggestion. But, sir, I have advised those who
manage the banks in which I am interested to retire a portion
of this circulation, that they may be prepared for that which, in
my judgment, will speedily happen unless the change that I
propose is made—the depreciation of the Government securities
— t o avail themselves of the high price of Government stocks at
this time to save their capital. This bill does not take from the
State of Rhode Island one cent of capital. I t restores to that
State capital. One dollar in every ten that is taken from her is
a restoration. I t is a matter of interest on that currency, a u d i t
is to transfer it from twenty thousand people ffor I will observe
here, that the banks that are dovetailed into the business in
which I am engaged, are owned b y six hundred people. M y
interest, and the interest of those that I represent, would be something like twenty thousand dollars. T a k e all these banks that
are affected by the proposition under discussion, and it is to
take from twenty thousand laboring people, who use these banks
as their depositories, and give it to one hundred speculators.
Sir, it is following exactly in the precedents that have been
established of creating great powers, great monopolies, and telling the people that you are engaged in promoting their material and social interests and their political advancement. U n d e r
the guise of doing something for the South, the business interests of the country will be jarred from its centre to its circumference, and the South will get not one cent of advantage from
the experiment. I t is not going to affect New-England alone,
I predict that those who write me from the South, and complain
of being compelled to pay twenty-five per cent, will, in consequence of this proposition, be forced to pay thirty per cent.
I s this a measure in the interest of the people of the United
States ? Sir, it is a measure in the interest of the establishment
of institutions like the P a r k Bank of New-York, T h e condition
of this country—I can not parallel it in any better way-—is like
t h a t of a mad horse in full run with broken reins, or a steam-engine without a regulator. T h e remedy for it all is in the paragraph that I will read ; and I point to this little book and ask
Senators, when they have time, to examine i t — U a n k e y on
Banking. I n the paragraph that I shall read is the whole secret
of the success of Great Britain. A d o p t her plan, and in six
months your finances will be in as healthy a condition in the
matter of interest as hers is. If you will provide this machinery,
I will give a bond to the extent of my whole property that that


condition of things will exist; that instead of building your
railroads and losing them at the same time, on the capital advanced to you from Tjondon, you will have the capital at your
door thanking you for using it. Speaking of the Bank of England, the writer s a y s :
*• No. 3 in perhaps the most important of all, as it comprises all tho acTountn kept on behalf of Government, for w h o m tho bank receives every
fthiUin# of tho income of the nation, aa well as tho accounts of a large number of public and private mercantile and other establishments ; and here it
IH that the economy of banking can be most fully appreciated. Tho whole
revenue of the Government arising from its daily receipts of customs, cxCIHC, post-office, taxes, stamps, etc., no matter whether received in London,
Cornwall, tho Hebrides or Oalway, finds its w a y almost immediately into
the liank of Knglnnd, and is thereby rendered instantly available for tho
daily demands on the State, In all these transmissions scarcely a sovereign
is used ; the whole is effected by purely banking arrangements. The collector of Government m a y require to transmit ,£50,000 from Liverpool to
Tjondon, b u t some private individual on tho same day wants to remit «£50,000 from I,«ondon to Liverpool through tho Bank of England, or through
Homo other bank ; both transactions are carried out by tho mere entry in
books and the advice or instructions sent by tho post* The revenue is paid
into the Hank of England at tho rate of about one million pounds a week ;
that is, in ordinary times. A considerable portion of t h i s is allowed to accumulate to provide means on each quarter-day for the payment of tho dividends on the Government debt. Suddenly on thoso days, five or six
millions sterling aro paid away b y tho bank to tho public ; but the difference
a* to the abundance or scarcity of money, j u s t before or j u s t after the payment of this largo sum, is scarcely appreciable."

There go into our Sub-Treasury, from day to day and from
week to week, large amounts of taxes, and they are kept there,
while the money in tho market is bare and scarce, and is operated upon to make it still scarcer b y the speculators with know*
ledge of tho circumstance, to create for themselves increased
value on the capital they employ*
I thank the Senate for their attention*