View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

MINUTES OF MEETING
of the

FEDERAL ADVISORY COUNCIL
February 18, 19, 1924

O lT T l h k S A N D M E M B E R S O F T H E F E D E R A L A D V IS O R Y COUNCIL
For the Year 1924

O F F IC E R S :

E X E C U T IV E CO M M ITTE E

President, P. M. W arburg

P. M. Warburg

Vice President, A . L. Aiken

A. L. Aiken
L. L. Rue
J. M. Miller, Jr.
J. J. Mitchell
E. F. Swinney

M EM BERS:
A. L. Aiken

Federal Reserve District No.

1

P. M. W arburg

Federal Reserve District No.

2

L. L. Rue

Federal Reserve District No.

3

C. E. Sullivan

Federal Reserve District No.

4

J. M. Miller, Jr.

Federal Reserve District No.

5

0 . Wells

Federal Reserve District No.

6

J. J. Mitchell

Federal Reserve District No.

7

F. J. Wade

Federal Reserve District No.

8

G. H. Prince

Federal Reserve District No.

9

E. F. Swinney

Federal Reserve District No. 10

W. M. M cGregor

Federal Reserve District No. 11

D. W . Tw ohv

Federal Reserve District No. 12




BY-LAW S

OF

THE

F E D E R A L A D V IS O R Y

COUNCIL

ARTICLE J. OFFICERS

Officers of this Council shall be a President, Vice President and Secretary.
ARTICLE II. P R E S I D E N T A N D VICE P R E S I D E N T

The duties of the President shall be such as usually pertain to the office; and in
his absence the Vice President shall serve.
ARTICLE III. S E C R E T A R Y

The Secretary shall be a salaried officer o f the Council and his duties and com­
pensation shall be fixed by the Executive Committee.
ARTICLE IV. E X E C U T I V E C O M M I T T E E

There shall be an Executive Committee o f six ( 6 ) members o f the Council, of
which the President and Vice President o f the Council shall be ex-officio members.
ARTICLE V. DUTIES OF E X E C U T I V E C O M M I T T E E

It shall be the duty o f the Executive Committee to keep in close touch with the
Federal Reserve Board and with their regulations and promulgations, and communi­
cate the same to the members of the Council, and to suggest to the Council from
time to time special matters for consideration.
The Executive Committee shall have power to fix the time and place of holding
their regular and special meetings and methods o f giving notice thereof.
Minutes of all meetings of the Executive Committee shall be kept and such min­
utes or digest thereof shall be immediately forwarded to each member of the Council.
A majority of the Executive Committee shall constitute a quorum and action of
the Committee shall be by a majority o f those present at any meeting.
ARTICLE VI. M E E T I N G S

Regular meetings of the Federal Advisory Council shall be held in the City of
Washington on the third Monday of the months o f February, May, September and
November of each year, unless otherwise directed by the Executive Committee.
Special meetings may be called at any time and place by the President or the
Executive Committee, and shall be called by the President upon written request of
any three members of the Council.
ARTICLE VII. A M E N D M E N T S

These By-laws may be changed or amended at any regular or special meeting h>
a vote of a majority of the members o f the Federal Advisory Council.

February 18, 1924.




M IN U TE S OE M E E T IN G O F T H E F E D E R A L A D V IS O R Y COUNCIL

February 18, 1924.
The organization meeting o f the Federal Advisory Council for the year 1924
was held in the Federal Reserve Board room, Treasury Building, Washington, D. C.,
at 10.30 A. M., Monday, February 18, 1924.
Present:
Mr.
Mr.
Mr.
Mr.
Mr.
Mr.
Mr.
Mr.
Mr.
Mr.
Mr.
Mr.

A. L. Aiken
P. M. W arburg
L. L. Rue
C. E. Sullivan
C. E. Rieman
(Alternate for Mr. John M. Miller, Jr.)
O. Wells
E. A. Hamill
(Alternate for Mr. J. J. Mitchell)
G. H. Prince
E. F. Swinney
W . M. M cGregor
D. W . T w ohy
H. L. Hilyard

District
District
District
District
District

No.
No.
No.
No.
No.

1
2
3
4
5

District No.
District No.

6
7

District No. 9
District No. 10
District No. 11
District No. 12
Secretary

Absent :
Mr. F. J. W ade

District No.

8

Mr. Rue, acting as temporary Chairman, called the meeting to order and called
for the Secretary’s report o f accredited members for the year 1924.
The Secretary reported that he had received communications from
eral Reserve Banks, certifying to the election o f their representatives
listed above. Communications were also presented from the Federal
of Richmond and Chicago, appointing Messrs. C. E. Rieman and
respectively, as alternates in place o f Messrs. Miller and Mitchell.

all o f the Fed­
for the year as
Reserve Banks
E. A. Hamill,

On motion, duly seconded, the Council held its election o f officers for the year
1924. Mr. Rue, who had served as President for the past three years, declined to
stand for re-election to this office and nominated Mr. P. M. Warburg for President.
On motion, duly seconded, the nominations were closed and the Secretary was in­
structed to cast one ballot for Mr. W arburg, who was thereupon declared elected
President o f the Council for the year 1924.
At the suggestion o f Mr. W arburg, Council, upon motion, duly seconded, ex­
pressed its thanks to Mr. Rue for his administra tion o f the office o f President for
the past three years, and adopted the following resolution:




i

W H EREAS, Levi L. Rue has been a member o f the Federal
Advisory Council since its organization, serving the first seven years as
its Vice President, and the last three years as its President,
And, W H EREA S, Mr. Rue has stated to the Council that it is his
determination not to accept a re-election as President o f the Council for
the current year,
Now, therefore, be it R E S O L V E D : that it is with profound
regret that the Council sees itself obliged to defer to Mr. Rue's desire,
and that in doing so it records its genuine and deep appreciation of the
faithful and invaluable services rendered by him, and o f the tact and
courtesy with which he has performed his duties,
And, furthermore, be it R E S O L V E D : that while the Council will
miss Mr. Rue as a presiding officer, whose fairness, courage and tact
have won him the admiration o f every member, it rejoices in the
thought that his association with the Council will continue, and expresses
the hope and wish that, as in the past, so in the future, it may have
the benefit of his wise counsel and genial companionship.
The President, Mr. Warburg, took the Chair and called for nominations for Vice
President. Mr. Sullivan nominated Mr. A. L. Aiken and on motion, duly seconded,
the nominations were closed. The Secretary was instructed to cast one ballot for
Mr. Aiken, who was thereupon declared elected Vice President o f the Council for the
year 1924.
The President, Mr. Warburg, called for nominations for the four appointive
members of the Executive Committee and Messrs. L. L. Rue, J. M. Miller, Jr.,
J. J. Mitchell and E. F. Swinney were nominated. On motion, duly seconded, the
Secretary was instructed to cast one ballot for Messrs. Rue, Miller, Mitchell and
Swinney, who, together with the President and Vice President, ex officio, were there­
upon declared elected members o f the Executive Committee for the year 1924.
On motion, duly seconded, the President, Mr. Warburg, was authorized to
appoint the Secretary for the Council at a salary o f $1,500. per annum.
On motion, duly seconded, Mr. H. L. Hilyard was requested to act as Secretary
pro tem. until the permanent appointment has been made.
On motion, duly seconded, the Council readopted for the year 1924 the existing
By-laws, copy of which is attached hereto and made part o f these minutes.
On motion, duly seconded, the minutes o f the Council meeting o f November 19,
1923, copies of which had previously been sent to the members, were approved.
The Secretary presented his financial report for the year 1923, which had been
audited by the Auditor of The Philadelphia National Bank, and which report was, on
motion, duly seconded, approved. The report is attached hereto and made part of
these minutes.
On motion, duly seconded, the following resolution was unanimously adopted:

“ Resolved, that the President be and he is hereby authorized to
ask each Federal Reserve Bank to contribute $200. toward the sec­
retarial and incidental expenses of the Federal Advisory Council for
the year 1924 and to draw on them for that purpose.”
The Council discussed informally the provisions o f the McFadden Bill. H.
6855, amending the National Bank Act and the Federal Reserve Act.




At 11.15 A. M., the Council adjourned to convene in joint session with the Fed­
eral Reserve Board.
'
■
H. L. H ILY A R D ,

Sccrctary pro tcm.

M IN U TE S O F JO IN T C O N FEREN CE OF TFIE F E D E R A L A D V ISO R Y
C O U N C IL A N D T H E F E D E R A L R E SE R V E BOARD
February 18, 1924.
At 11.15 A. M., a joint conference o f the F'ederal Advisory Council and the Fed­
eral Reserve Board was held as arranged.
Present:

Members o f the Federal Reserve Board:

Vice Governor Edmund Platt, Messrs. A. C. Miller, C. S. Hamlin, G. R. James,
also Mr. Winston, Undersecretary o f the Treasury.
Present:

Members o f the Federal Advisory Council:

Mr. P. M. Warburg, President, Mr. A. L. Aiken, Vice President, Messrs. L. L.
Rue, C. E Sullivan, C. E. Rieman, O. Wells, E. A. Flamill, G. H. Prince, E. F. Swin­
ney, W . M. McGregor, D. W . Twohy, and H. L. Hilyard, Secretary.
The President o f the Council, Mr. Warburg, called the meeting to order and invited
Vice Governor Platt to address the conference. Mr. Platt discussed particularly the
banking situation in the Northwest, and there followed a general discussion among the
members o f the Board and o f the Council regarding methods o f aiding the situation.
The members o f the Board and o f the Council also discussed informally the topics
which had been presented by the Board for Council’s consideration.
(Topics Nos. 1,
2, 3, attached.)
Mr. Hamlin spoke o f the Board's recent resolution to publish in the future, in
connection with weekly statements o f the Federal Reserve Banks, a separate percentage o f gold held against Federal Reserve notes and o f gold held against deposits, in
addition to a combined reserve ratio, and the Council was invited to give its attention
to this topic. (T op ic No. 4 attached.)
The members o f the Board and o f the Council also discussed the provisions of the
McFadden Bill, H. R. 6855, in connection with which members o f the Board requested
Council to make a recommendation concerning branch banking particularly. (Topic
No. 6 attached.)
At 12.45 P. M., the joint conference adjourned.




H. L. H IL Y A R D .

Sccrctary pro tcm.

3

MINUTES OF M EETING OF T H E F E D E R A L A D V IS O R Y COUNCIL
February 18, 1924.
At 3.15 P. M., the Council reconvened in the Federal Reserve Board room.
Present: Mr. P. M. Warburg, President, Mr. A. L. Aiken, Vice President,
Messrs. C. E. Sullivan, C. E. Rieman, O. Wells, E. A. Hamill, G. H. Prince, E. F.
Swinney, W. M. McGregor, D. W . Twohy, and H. L. Hilyard, Secretary.
The President, Mr. Warburg, called the meeting to order and invited Hon. H. M.
Dawes, Comptroller of the Currency, to discuss with the members of the Council the
provisions of the McFadden Bill, H. R. 6855.
Mr. Dawes explained the provisions o f the Bill particularly as they relate to the
question of branch banking.
At 4.30 P. M., Mr. Dawes retired from the meeting.
The Council thereupon took up consideration of Topics submitted by the Board
and those referred to in the morning session. The Executive Committee was requested
to draft formal recommendations to be approved by the entire Council on the follow­
ing day before presentation to the Federal Reserve Board on the following topics:
Topic
Topic
Topic
Topic
Topic

No.
No.
No.
No.
No.

1.
2.
3.
4.
5.

The banking situation in the Northwest.
Bankers’ acceptances drawn by banks.
Open market operations.
Subdivision o f gold reserves.
Fulmer Bill, H. R. 3206.

A special committee consisting o f Mr. Twohy, Chairman,
Prince and McGregor, was appointed by the President at the
draft formal recommendation relative to the McFadden Bill,
presented to the Council on the following day for adoption and
eral Reserve Board.

and Messrs. Sullivan,
request of Council to
No. H. R. 6855, to be
presentation to the Fed­

The Council considered two topics which had been presented at the November
meeting by Mr. Sullivan (see minutes of meeting o f Council, November 19, 1923) as
follows:
(a)
(b)

Elimination of all limits to the use o f Federal Reserve exchange.
Allow country banks (those banks required to maintain only a 7% reserve i
to deduct the float as between themselves and the Federal Reserve Bank,
and in addition, cash in vault before computing their deposits for reserve
purposes.

The Council, however, decided to make no recommendation on these topics at this
time, but it was resolved that at the next meeting o f the Council, the topic should be
discussed of whether or not a change in reserve requirements should be recommended
by the Council, particularly whether any changes should be made for the benefit ot
member banks not located in Federal Reserve bank cities or Federal Reserve branch
bank cities.
At 6 P. M., the Council adjourned.




H. L. HILYARD.

Sccrctary pro ton.
4

M IN UTES OF M E E T IN G O F T H E E X E C U T IV E CO M M ITTEE OF TH E
F E D E R A L A D V IS O R Y COUNCIL
February 18, 1924.
A S P. M., the Executive Committee o f the Federal Advisory Council met in the
New Willard Hotel as arranged.
Present: Mr. P. M. Warburg, Chairman, Messrs. Aiken and Swinney, also
Messrs. Wells and Hamill, and H. L. Hilyard, Secretary.
The Executive Committee drafted recommendations on the topics submitted to it
to be presented to the Council for its approval on the following day. (Topics Nos.
1, 2, 3, 4 and 5.)
At I I P . M., the Executive Committee adjourned.
H. L. H IL Y A R D ,

Sccrctary pro tern.

M IN U T E S O F M E E T IN G O F T H E F E D E R A L A D V IS O R Y COUNCIL
February 19, 1924.
At 9.30 A. M., the Federal Advisory Council met in the Federal Reserve Board
room, Treasury Building, Washington, D. C.
Present: Mr. P. M. W arburg, President, Mr. A. L. Aiken, Vice President,
Messrs. C. E. Sullivan, C. E. Rieman, O. Wells, E. A. Hamill, G. H. Prince, E. F.
Swinney, W . M. M cGregor, D. W . Twohy, and H. L. Hilyard, Secretary.
The President, Mr. W arburg, called the meeting to order and as Chairman of
the Executive Committee, submitted the Committee’s report for the Council's approval.
On motion, duly seconded, the report was adopted and the recommendations approved
for presentation to the Federal Reserve Board.
(Recommendations Nos. 1, 2, 3, 4
and 5.)
Mr. D. W . Tw ohy, Chairman o f the special committee, appointed the previous
day, submitted its report on the McFadden Bill, FI. R. 6855. On motion, duly sec­
onded, Council approved the report for presentation to the Federal Reserve Board.
(Recommendation No. 6 .)
At 12 o ’clock noon, Council adjourned to convene in joint session with the Fed­
eral Reserve Board.




FI. L. H IL Y A R D ,

Sccrctary pro tern.

5

MINUTES OF JOINT CONFERENCE OF T H E F E D E R A L ADVISORY
COUNCIL AND T H E F E D E R A L R E SE R V E BOARD
February 19, 1924.
At 12 o’clock noon, the joint conference was held as arranged.
Present:

Members of the Federal Reserve Board:

Hon. D. R. Crissinger, Governor, Mr. Edmund Platt, Vice Governor, Hon. H.
M. Dawes, Comptroller of the Currency, Messrs. C. S. Hamlin, A. C. Miller, G. R.
James, and Mr. Winston, Undersecretary o f the Treasury.
Present: Members of the Federal Advisory Council:
Mr. P. M. Warburg, President, Mr. A. L. Aiken, Vice President. Messrs. C. E.
Sullivan, C. E. Rieman, O. Wells, E. A. Hamill, G. H. Prince, E. F. Swinney, W. M.
McGregor, D. W. Twohy, and H. L. Hilyard, Secretary.
The President of the Council, Mr. Warburg, called the meeting to order and pre­
sented to the Board Council’s recommendations on the six topics mentioned above.
Copy of the recommendations is attached hereto and made part o f these minutes.
A general informal discussion took place among the members o f the Board and
of the Council.
The members of the Board, and particularly Vice Governor Platt, raised the
question of whether the approval by the Council in broad terms of Bill H. R. 6855
was to be considered as an endorsement by the Council o f all features of that Bill, par­
ticularly of Section 7, relating to state-wide branch banking; and also whether the
Council was opposed to a grant of power to National Banks to operate branches in
counties. Mr. Warburg stated in reply in behalf o f the Council that the opinion
of the Council was divided on these two questions, and that no vote had
been taken on them; that he believed probably a majority o f the Council would have
voted for them; that the Council was mainly interested in that Section of the Bill
which was designed to give equal powers to National Banks with regard to the opera­
tion of branches within States, where State Banks were not prohibited from operating
such branches; that the Bill had been submitted to the Council only at the morning ses­
sion and that it had been impossible in this brief time to give all its features an ex­
haustive study; that after a discussion with Comptroller Dawes, a majority of the
members had reached the conclusion that in order to secure the main advantages to be
derived from the passage of the Bill, concessions would have to be made with regard
to some of its minor features; that the Bill, probably from a political point of view,
presented the best that could be attempted at this time, but that the Council in endors­
ing the Bill would not wish to have it construed that by so doing, it committed itself
as opposing branch banking outside of cities as bad banking: that branch banking, if
kept within proper limits and if developed gradually and carefully, could not be held
in itself as an objectionable method of banking; that with the strong prejudice exist­
ing against it, however, in a majority of the sections o f the country, the Bill, in the
Council’s opinion, had to be considered not purely from the point o f view of what was
good banking, but what in given social and political circumstances wras practicable and
desirable. Members of the Board suggested that it might be desirable for the Coun­
cil to add an expression of these thoughts to the Recommendation.
At 1 P. M., the Board withdrew.




6

The Council remained in session to discuss the question whether or not its Recom­
mendation No. 6 should be amended along the lines suggested by some members of the
Board. On motion, duly seconded, it was decided, however, to leave Recommendation
No. 6 unamended.
At 1.05 P. M., the meeting adjourned, concluding the session of the Council.




H. L. H ILY A R D ,

Sccrctary pro tcm.

7

REPORT OF SECRE TAR Y OF T H E F E D E R A L A D V IS O R Y COUNCIL

For the year ending December 31, 1923.

Balance on hand January 1,
1923
$1,042.04
v
Annual assessment for 1923 on
T w e l v e Federal Reserve
Banks ................................... 3,000.00

Salary ........................................ $1,50000
„ . .
. c,
Printing and Stationery..........
150.61
^
r
t?
^
Traveling E xp en ses................. 359.19
Corporation Trust ...................

25.00

Telegrams ..................................

59.68

Postage ......................................

30.00

Binders; Economic R eview ...

14.39

Balance on hand 12/31/23 . . .

1,903.17

$4,042.04

$4,042.04

Philadelphia, January 9, 1924.
To the Federal Advisory Council:
We have audited the books, vouchers and accounts o f the Secretary of the Fed­
eral Advisory Council for the year ending December 31, 1923, and certify that the above
statement agrees therewith.




Respectfully,
(Signed) J. A. D U FFY, Assistant Cashier,
The Philadelphia National Bank.

RECOMMENDATIONS OF TH E FED ERAL ADVISO RY COUNCIL TO THE
FED ER A L R ESERVE BO ARD

February 19, 1924.
TOPIC NO. 1. The banking situation in the northwest and middle west and in
New Mexico, with special reference to the large number o f small bank failures. The
Board would like to have your opinion as to whether the lack o f confidence in these
small banks is likely to spread far enough to do any serious injury to banks in the
larger cities or to any banks outside o f the territory principally affected by agricultural
depression. The Board would also like to know whether the Council has any sugges­
tions to make with regard to possible amendments to the National Banking Act which
would not be merely palliatives but would prevent any future similar epidemic o f lack
of confidence.
R E C O M M E N D A T IO N : It is the opinion o f the Council that it is unlikely that
the lack o f confidence referred to by the Board will spread enough to do serious injury
to the banks in larger cities or to other territories affected by agricultural depression
at the present time. It is also the opinion o f the Council that the present unfortunate
banking situation arises largely from the fact that the number o f banks in the sections
involved has been much greater than local needs for banking accommodations required.
The organization o f many o f these banks has been stimulated and encouraged by un­
sound systems o f guarantee o f deposits by various states which gave a false sense o f
security to those organizing the banks and encouraged in the public mind a lack o f dis­
crimination between well-managed and badly-managed banks. This, coupled with un­
sound and inexperienced management, resulted in inevitable disaster. The Council
heartily approves o f the attempt that is being made to meet the present emergency but
is confident that no amendment to the National Bank A ct or Federal Reserve Act will
safeguard the business community from the consequences o f unsound banking methods.
It has, therefore, no amendment to recommend. W hile there are no means that can
prevent banks from suffering the consequences o f mismanagement or dishonesty in the
administration o f their affairs, measures may possibly be devised that would serve to
alleviate the hardships o f the depositors o f banks in receivers’ hands, particularly o f
depositors o f small means.
It may be opportune for the Board to take up anew its earlier recommendation,
made several years ago when combatting form er propositions for a guarantee o f de­
posits. The Board’s recommendation envisaged the creation o f a liquidation fund.
Such fund was designed under very careful safeguards and restrictions to pay to
depositors o f banks in receivers’ hands such proportion o f their deposits as could be
safely advanced against the depositors’ claims against the defaulting bank.
The
Council does not wish to make this suggestion with regard to the present emergency,
but solely with a view to stimulating a careful examination o f the problem which is
bound to recur in the future in some form or other.
TO PIC N O. 2. The general policy involved in bankers’ acceptances drawn by
banks to finance export transactions, assuming that banks may lawfully give such
acceptances. The Board has had a number o f propositions involving such acceptances
submitted to it for rulings as to their compliance with the law, but would like the advice
of the Council as to the policy involved.




I

RECOM M EN D ATIO N : This question was fully covered in the Council's con­
ference with the Board in which Mr. Warburg stated that he thought to express the
Council's views when holding that the transaction involved was clearly within the
legal powers of the accepting member banks. It was, however, a question of good or
bad banking practice. In the Council’s view acceptances o f this character should only be
considered as eligible by Federal Reserve banks when drawn by banks directly con­
nected with or located in the foreign country from which, or to which, the goods were
moving (so-called foreign or colonial banks or their branches) and furthermore, such
bills should be drawn within a time reasonably near to shipment o f the goods and in
no circumstances after the transportation had been completed. The Council thought
that the decision concerning the eligibility o f such acceptances might well be left to
the discretion of the Federal Reserve banks instead o f trying to deal with it by a rigid
regulation which could hardly cover so complex and so individual a case.
TOPIC NO. 3. Open market operations and the basis upon which they should
be handled during the year 1924.
RECOMMENDATION : The Council is reluctant to give very positive advice con­
cerning the desirability of increasing or decreasing the volume o f open market invest­
ments of the Federal Reserve banks at this time.
Experience has shown that the
volume of bills rediscounted and held by the Federal Reserve System and the total
invested in open market purchases are closely interrelated. Only by actual tests and
careful experiments is it possible to ascertain from time to time whether a substantial
increase or decrease in the aggregate o f investments may safely be brought about and
if so, what effects it will have on the position o f the combined member banks and the
money market. The Council is very glad to notice the growing attention devoted by the
Board to the importance of open market operations; for with gold standards suspended
all the world over and gold moving to our country almost automatically, the gold reserve
percentages of the Federal Reserve System have become barometers of much smaller
significance than the fluctuations in the volume o f the Federal Reserve System's total
investments. The Council is inclined to believe that in view o f present domestic and
foreign conditions, it might be opportune for the Federal Reserve Banks to engage in
some careful experiments in the direction o f increasing open market investments.
These might result in a slight easing of money rates and in a more liberal use of our
credit facilities at home and abroad.
It is the unanimous opinion of the Council that discount rates should not be
changed at this time.
The Council urges the Federal Reserve Banks in their open market operations to
show a greater preference for acceptances than for Government issues.
TOPIC NO. 4.

Subdivision o f gold reserves.

RECOM MENDATION: After considering the form contemplated by the Board
for its weekly condensed statement o f combined gold reserves, viz. statement of per­
centage of gold holdings against outstanding Federal Reserve notes, of percentage of
gold holdings against member bank deposits, and o f percentage of total gold holdings
against Federal Reserve notes and deposits combined, the Council is o f the opinion that
the legal requirement is complied with by publishing the amounts of the several gold
reserves without giving the three individual percentages. The Council feels that fluctu­
ations in the gold strength, as indicated in the discussions o f the previous question, are
of minor significance in present circumstances and that by giving three percentages, too
much emphasis would be laid upon fluctuations, which as a consequence of the pro­
posed grouping, are likely to appear more pronounced. Moreover it is to be feared that




during a period o f economic strain, always recurring from time to time, the Board
may be charged with artificially manipulating the reserve percentages. It is to be
expected that the press and the public will continue to watch the combined reserve
percentage (against notes and deposits combined), as it is the only percentage which
will clearly indicate any increase or decrease in reserve strength from week to week.
It would seem to the Council, therefore, that the greater simplicity of the present
method o f reporting would lead to a better understanding of the problem on the part
of the lay community and for the time being, at least, would seem to be the better
course. As it is, there is grave danger that critics o f the Federal Reserve System will
charge the Board as being possessed o f larger powers in the determination or stabiliza­
tion o f price levels than it actually has. The proposed scheme would be construed by
them as an additional means o f control in the hands o f the Federal Reserve Board
and as such might easily be used as an invitation for further attacks upon the Board.
R E C O M M E N D A T IO N NO. 5 : The Council expressed itself as unanimously
opposed to the provisions o f the bill pending in Congress, H. R. 3206, requiring the pay­
ment by Federal Reserve banks o f two per cent, interest on member bank balances.
R E C O M M E N D A T IO N NO. 6 : McFadden Bill.
The Council has read the Bill H. R. 6855, introduced in the House o f Repre­
sentatives by Congressman McFadden, and agrees in principle with the general trend
o f thought embodied in the said bill. The present uncertainty with reference to branch
banking makes it difficult for those engaged in the banking business to determine their
course o f action, and we consider that the proposed bill, if enacted, would offer very
essential and helpful relief in this regard.
Without venturing an opinion concerning
questions o f detail involved in the bill, we endorse its objects and aims and respectfully
urge its passage.




3