View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

FINANCIAL STABILITY OVERSIGHT BOARD

Page 1

Minutes of the Financial Stability Oversight Board Meeting
December 17, 2012
A meeting of the Financial
Stability Oversight Board (“Board”) was
held at 2:00 p.m. (EST) on Tuesday,
December 17, 2012, at the offices of the
Department of the Treasury (“Treasury”).

Mr. Berman, Senior Advisor to the
Secretary, Department of Housing
and Urban Development
Mr. Lawler, Chief Economist,
Federal Housing Finance Agency

MEMBERS PARTICIPATING:
Mr. Bernanke, Chairperson
Mr. Geithner
Mr. Donovan
Ms. Walter
Mr. DeMarco

Ms. Williams, Deputy Chief of Staff,
Securities and Exchange
Commission
Chairperson Bernanke called the
meeting to order at approximately
2:05 p.m. (EST).

STAFF PARTICIPATING:
Mr. Treacy, Executive Director
Mr. Gonzalez, General Counsel and
Secretary
AGENCY OFFICIALS
PARTICIPATING:
Ms. Miller, Under Secretary for Domestic
Finance, Department of the Treasury
Mr. Massad, Assistant Secretary for
Financial Stability, Department of
the Treasury
Mr. Pendo, Chief Investment Officer,
Office of Financial Stability,
Department of the Treasury
Mr. Kingsley, Chief, Homeownership
Preservation Office, Office of
Financial Stability, Department of
the Treasury
Mr. Grom, Senior Advisor to the
Assistant Secretary for Financial
Stability, Department of the Treasury

The Board then considered draft
minutes for the meeting of the Board on
November 26, 2012, which had been
circulated in advance of the meeting.
Upon a motion duly made and seconded,
the Members voted to approve the
minutes of the meeting, subject to such
technical revisions as may be received
from the Members.
Treasury officials then provided an
update on the programs established by
Treasury under the Troubled Asset Relief
Program (“TARP”). Discussion during
the meeting focused on the Capital
Purchase Program (“CPP”); the
Community Development Capital
Initiative (“CDCI”); the Public-Private
Investment Program (“PPIP”); the
American International Group, Inc.
(“AIG”); the Automotive Industry
Financing Program (“AIFP”); and the
Making Home Affordable (“MHA”)
initiatives. Among the materials
distributed in advance of the meeting was
the monthly report issued by Treasury
under Section 105(a) of the Emergency
Economic Stabilization Act (“105(a)

FINANCIAL STABILITY OVERSIGHT BOARD

Page 2

report”), which contains information
concerning the programs established by
Treasury under TARP and aggregate
information regarding the allocated and
disbursed amounts under TARP.
Throughout the meeting, Members raised
and discussed various matters with
respect to the effects of the policies and
programs established under TARP.

only one PPIF can continue to make new
investments, and its investment period
ends on December 18, 2012. Officials
then reviewed the current status of the
TALF, noting that, as of December 12,
2012, the TALF loan balance was
approximately $899 million and
Treasury’s commitment under the TALF
was $1.4 billion.

Using prepared materials,
Treasury officials reviewed and discussed
with Members the overall reduction in
Treasury’s TARP investments in 2012.
Treasury officials noted that an amount
equal to approximately 90 percent of the
$418 billion disbursed under the TARP
has been collected through repayments,
dividends and other income, as of
December 14, 2012.

Treasury officials then provided
Members with an update on the CPP.
Officials discussed the current aggregate
status of all repayments and sales of CPP
investments along with dividends,
interest, warrant sales, gains from the sale
of common stock, and fee income
Treasury had received thus far. As of
December 14, 2012, Treasury had
outstanding CPP investments in 218
banks totaling approximately $7.5 billion.
As part of this discussion, officials
discussed Treasury’s plans for future
auctions of additional CPP investments.
Officials also updated Members on the
status of missed dividend or interest
payments by institutions participating in
the CPP and Treasury’s progress in
identifying candidates to serve as
directors for institutions that have missed
at least six payments.

Treasury officials then provided
Members with an update on the U.S.
government’s investment in AIG.
Officials noted that on December 14,
2012, Treasury sold all of its remaining
shares of AIG common stock in an
underwritten public offering. The
aggregate proceeds to Treasury from the
common stock offering totaled
approximately $7.6 billion.
Using prepared materials, Treasury
officials then provided the Members with
an update on the credit market programs
established under TARP, including the
TALF and PPIP. Officials discussed the
relative performance of the Public-Private
Investment Funds (“PPIFs”) established
under the PPIP and the progress of certain
PPIFs in completing their investment
strategy. As of December 14, 2012,
Treasury investment under the PPIP totals
approximately $4.65 billion. Officials
noted that five PPIFs had wound down
their funds. Of the remaining four PPIFs,

Treasury officials then provided
the Members with an update on CDCI,
which provided lower-cost capital under
TARP to qualified Community
Development Financial Institutions
(“CDFIs”), including an update on
several repayments of CDCI investments.
As of December 14, 2012, Treasury had
outstanding investments totaling
approximately $540 million in 78 CDFIs.
Treasury officials then provided
Members with an update on the AIFP.
Among the matters discussed were the

FINANCIAL STABILITY OVERSIGHT BOARD
status of Treasury’s investment in
General Motors and Ally, as well as the
bankruptcy proceeding of Ally’s nonbank affiliate, Residential Capital LLC.
Using prepared materials, Treasury
officials then provided an update on the
MHA and other related housing
initiatives, including the Home
Affordable Modification Program
(“HAMP”) and the Housing Finance
Agency (“HFA”) Hardest-Hit Fund
(“HHF”). Officials discussed the results
of Treasury’s MHA Program
Performance Report as of October 2012,
a monthly summary of recent MHArelated activity. During this discussion,
officials noted that Treasury expected to
begin public reporting of HAMP Tier 2
data in January 2013. Officials also
discussed Treasury’s assessment of the
nine largest servicers for the third quarter
of 2012. Officials noted that two
servicers were found to need only minor
improvement on the areas reviewed for
program performance, while seven
servicers were found to need moderate
improvement. As part of this discussion,
Treasury officials also discussed the HHF
and Treasury’s efforts to provide
oversight and assistance to HFAs.
Members and officials then
engaged in a roundtable discussion
regarding the current state of the housing
markets and the effect of the programs
established under TARP in providing
support to the housing market and
assistance to at-risk mortgage borrowers.
As part of this discussion, officials from
the Federal Housing Finance Agency
(“FHFA”) briefed members on
developments in the housing and housing
finance markets. The information
reviewed included data related to
mortgage rates and delinquencies, Federal

Page 3
Home Loan Bank advances, mortgage
originations, as well as information on
housing prices, sales, starts, and supply.
During this discussion, FHFA officials
also presented data related to the
foreclosure prevention actions taken by
the Government Sponsored Enterprises.
Staff of the Oversight Board then
provided Members with an update
regarding the Oversight Board’s quarterly
report to Congress for the quarter ending
September 30, 2012, that will be issued
pursuant to section 104(g) of the EESA.
Staff discussed, among other things, the
timing of the report.
The meeting was adjourned at
approximately 3:00 p.m. (EDT).
[signed electronically]
______________________________
Jason A. Gonzalez,
General Counsel and Secretary