View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

FINANCIAL STABILITY OVERSIGHT BOARD

Page 1

Minutes of the Financial Stability Oversight Board Meeting
April 30, 2012
A meeting of the Financial
Stability Oversight Board (“Board”) was
held at 2:00 p.m. (EDT) on Monday,
April 30, via teleconference.
MEMBERS PARTICIPATING:
Mr. Bernanke, Chairperson
Mr. Geithner
Mr. Donovan
Ms. Shapiro
Mr. DeMarco

Mr. Ryan, Chief Risk Officer,
Department of Housing
and Urban Development
Mr. Delfin, Special Counsel to the
Chairman, Securities and Exchange
Commission
Mr. Lawler, Chief Economist,
Federal Housing Finance Agency
Mr. Naylor, Deputy Associate Director,
Federal Reserve Board

STAFF PARTICIPATING:
Mr. Treacy, Executive Director
Mr. Gonzalez, General Counsel and
Secretary
AGENCY OFFICIALS
PARTICIPATING:
Mrs. Miller, Under Secretary for
Domestic Finance, Department of
the Treasury
Mr. Massad, Assistant Secretary for
Financial Stability, Department of
the Treasury
Mr. Pendo, Chief Investment Officer,
Office of Financial Stability,
Department of the Treasury
Mr. Kingsley, Chief, Homeownership
Preservation Office, Office of
Financial Stability, Department of
the Treasury
Mr. Grom, Acting Senior Advisor to the
Assistant Secretary for Financial
Stability, Department of the Treasury

Mr. Leahy, Deputy Director, Division of
International Finance, Federal
Reserve Board
Ms. Rice, Chief, Global Financial
Institutions Section, Division of
International Finance, Federal
Reserve Board
Chairperson Bernanke called the
meeting to order at approximately
2:05 p.m. (EDT).
The Board first considered draft
minutes for the meeting of the Board on
March 26, 2012, which had been
circulated in advance of the meeting.
Upon a motion duly made and seconded,
the Members voted to approve the
minutes of the meeting, subject to such
technical revisions as may be received
from the Members.
Officials from the Department of
the Treasury (“Treasury”) then provided
an update on the programs established by
Treasury under the Troubled Asset Relief
Program (“TARP”). Discussion during
the meeting focused on the Capital

FINANCIAL STABILITY OVERSIGHT BOARD

Page 2

Purchase Program (“CPP”); the PublicPrivate Investment Program (“PPIP”); the
American International Group, Inc.
(“AIG”); the Automotive Industry
Financing Program (“AIFP”); and the
Making Home Affordable (“MHA”)
program and related initiatives. Among
the materials distributed in advance of the
meeting was the monthly report issued by
Treasury under Section 105(a) of the
Emergency Economic Stabilization Act
(“105(a) report”), which contains
information concerning the programs
established by Treasury under TARP and
aggregate information regarding the
allocated and disbursed amounts under
TARP. Throughout the meeting,
Members raised and discussed various
matters with respect to the effects of the
policies and programs established under
TARP.

through a modified Dutch auction
registered under the Securities Act of
1933 and resulted in proceeds of
approximately $362 million. While this
was less than the original par value of
these investments, Treasury officials
indicated that the proceeds were in line
with the valuation of these investments
provided by the Office of Financial
Stability’s Office of the Chief Financial
Officer. In addition, the cumulative
dividend payments received on the shares
exceeded the difference between the
proceeds and the original investment
amounts. On March 30, Treasury sold its
remaining shares of common stock in
Central Pacific Financial Corporation,
which resulted in approximate proceeds
of $36 million for a total of
approximately $71.9 million in proceeds
from all sales of Central Pacific Financial
Corporation. Officials also reported that,
on April 4, Regions Financial
Corporation repurchased all of its
outstanding preferred shares from
Treasury for $3.5 billion, including
accrued dividends. Officials further
reported that, in March, Treasury
exercised its right to elect members to the
board of directors of three additional CPP
institutions (First Security Group;
PremierWest Bancorp; and Intervest
Bancshares Corporation) bringing the
total number of Treasury-elected board of
directors members to sixteen at nine CPP
institutions. As part of this discussion,
Members and officials discussed
Treasury’s progress in and plans for
disposing of its remaining CPP
investments.

Treasury officials first discussed
the latest cost estimates for TARP. As
part of this discussion, Treasury officials
discussed with Members Treasury’s daily
TARP update report as of April 2, 2012,
which showed for each TARP program
the amount of funds obligated, the
amount actually disbursed, repayments
and income received, and any gains or
losses with regard to individual TARP
investments.
Using prepared materials, Treasury
officials then updated Members on CPP
developments that occurred during the
month of March. Officials noted that
Treasury completed secondary public
offerings of the preferred stock it held in
six institutions (Banner Corporation; First
Financial Holdings Inc.; MainSource
Financial Group, Inc.; Seacoast Banking
Corporation of Florida; Wilshire
Bancorp, Inc.; and WSFS Financial
Corporation). The offerings were priced

Treasury officials then provided
Members with an update on the PPIP.
Officials noted that, in March, Invesco
Legacy Securities Master Fund
(“Invesco”) became the first of eight

FINANCIAL STABILITY OVERSIGHT BOARD

Page 3

remaining Public-Private Investment
Funds established under PPIP to sell its
investments and return substantially all of
the proceeds to Treasury and its private
investors.

discussed Treasury’s progress in
implementing certain enhancements to
MHA that Treasury had announced on
January 27, 2012. Treasury recently
completed community events for
homeowners in Illinois, Indiana and
California as part of a nationwide
outreach initiative to provide free help for
struggling homeowners by connecting
them directly with their mortgage
servicers or a HUD-approved housing
counselor to discuss alternatives to
foreclosure. Treasury officials then
provided an update on the HHF. As part
of this discussion, officials discussed
recent disbursements to HFAs and the
different approaches by HFAs to improve
the take-up and performance of their
respective HHF-sponsored programs.

Treasury officials then provided
Members with an update on the U.S.
government’s investment in AIG.
Members and officials discussed the
recent sale by the Federal Reserve Bank
of New York of the MAX CDO holdings
from its Maiden Lane III portfolio to a
consortium consisting of Barclays
Capital, Inc. and Deutsche Bank
Securities, Inc. following a competitive
bid process. Officials noted that the
transaction substantially reduced the
Maiden Lane III portfolio and loan.
Using prepared materials, Treasury
officials then provided an update on the
AIFP. During this discussion, Treasury
officials reviewed the status of Treasury’s
investment in Ally Financial, Inc.
(“Ally”), including its 73.8 percent
common equity ownership stake in Ally,
and $5.9 billion of Ally mandatorily
convertible preferred stock. As part of
this discussion, officials discussed the
recent financial performance of Ally and
its non-bank affiliate, Residential Capital
LLC, which earlier in April had not made
a scheduled bond interest payment.
Using prepared materials, Treasury
officials then provided an update on the
MHA and other related housing
initiatives, including the Home
Affordable Modification Program
(“HAMP”) and the Housing Finance
Agency (“HFA”) Hardest-Hit Fund
(“HHF”). During this discussion,
officials discussed the numbers of
temporary and permanent modifications
made under HAMP. Officials also

Oversight Board staff then
provided an update on the expected
timing of the Oversight Board’s quarterly
report to Congress for the quarter ending
March 31, 2012, that will be issued by the
Oversight Board pursuant to section
104(g) of the EESA.
The meeting was adjourned at
approximately 2:55 p.m. (EDT).
[Signed Electronically]
______________________________
Jason A. Gonzalez,
General Counsel and Secretary