View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

186
A meeting of the Federal Reserve Board was held in the office of
the Federal Reserve Board on Tuesday, September 27, 1927 at 11:30 a.m.
PRESENT:

The Chairman
Vice Governor Platt
Mr. Hamlin
Mr. Miller
Mr. James
Mr. Eddy, Secretary
Mr. McClelland, Asst. Secretary

An informal discussion was had of a proposed amendment to the Bylaws of the Board.

No action was taken as it was the consensus of opinion

that the proposed amendment should be considered at a meeting of the Board
following the qualification as a member of the Board of Mr. H. A. Young.
Bond of Mr. V. A. Burgess, Assistant Federal Reserve Agent at the
Federal Reserve Bank of New York, executed under date of September 21,
1927, in the amount of 450,000.
Approved.
Memorandum dated September 24th from the Director of the Division
Of Research and Statistics, recommending the appointment of Miss Bess
Brougher as stenographer in the Division at a salary of 41560 per annum,
effective October 1, 1927.
Approved.
Report of Executive Committee on letter dated September 23rd from
the Acting Comptroller of the Currency, recommending approval of a salary
of :,1i2400 nr annum for National Bank Examiner Carvel C. Linden, assigned
to the Twelfth Federal Reserve District; the Committee recommending approval.




Approved.

9/27/27

MOB

Report of Executive Committee on letter dated September 23rd from the
Acting Comptroller of the Currency, recommending approval of an increase
from „i;5200 to 45600 per annum in the salary of National Bank Examiner Earl
W. Moon; the Committee recommending approval.
Approved.
Report of Committee on Salaries and Expenditures on letter dated
d,
September 22nd from the Secretary of the Federal Reserve Bank of Clevelan
advising of the action of the Executive Committee of that bank in voting
to grant an extension of two months from September 22nd, with full pay,
in leave of absence on account of illness previously granted Miss Margaret
Osten, stenographer in the Discount Department; the Board's Committee
recommending approval of the salary payment involved.
Approved.
Report of Committee on Salaries and Expenditures on letter dated
September 21st from the Federal Reserve Agent at St. Louis, advising of
the action of the Executive Committee of that bank in voting to extend
for a period of thirty days from September 27th, with full pay, leave
Of absence on account of illness previously grantea Mr. R. B. Niese,
14anager of the Custody Deoartment of the Memphis Branch; the Board's
Committee recommen-ing approval of the salary payment involved.
Approved.
Letter dated September 24th from the Assistant Federal Reserve
Agent at Cleveland, advising that the Guardian Trust Company of Clevewhich
land will be unable to establish before .3eptember 29th, the date on
the souththe permit wiil expire, the branch approved by the Board for




I8
-3-

9/27/27

west corner of Pearl and Broadview Roads, and that as there seems to be
no immediate prospect for the opening of the branch the bank does not
desire an extension of time for its establishment.
Noted.
Letter dated September 19th from the Assistant Federal Reserve Agent
at San Francisco, advising that the Security Trust and Savings Bank of
Los Angeles on September 17th moved to a permanent location at the southwest corner of West Adams and Victoria Avenue (4450 West Adams Street)
the branch which has been operated in temporary quarters at 4349 West
Adams Street.
Noted.
Letter dated September 20th from the Assistant Federal Reserve
Agent at. San Francisco, with reference to the Board's action of February
19th, 1927 in approving an application of the American Trust Company
at San Francisco, to move a branch located at 3850 San Pablo Avenue,
Emeryville, to a new location at 18th Street and San Pablo Avenue, Oakland, and to transfer its business to the branch being operated at 3900
San Pablo Avenue; the Assistant Agent stating that because of the in-

adequacy of the quarters at 3900 San Pablc Avenue that branch has been
closed instead Of the 3850 San Pablo Avenue Branch, and will be moved
to a new location at 2053 San Pablo Avenue.
Noted, without objection.
Letter dated September 20th from the Federal Reserve Agent at
Atlanta, advising that the office of Assistant Federal Reserve Agent
at the Jacksonville Branch will be discontinued as of September 30, 1927




F20
-4-

9/27/27

and that the necessary supply of Federal Reserve notes at that branch
will be carried as bank cash; the Agent recommending, however, that Mr.
W. E. Miller and Mr. James R. Stevens be redesignated as Assistant Federal Reserve Agent and Alternate Assistant Federal Reserve Agent, respectively, at the New Orleans Branch, for terms of three months beginning October 1, 1927.
Upon motion, it was voted to redesignate Messrs.
Miller and Stevens as recommended.
Letter dated September 22nd from the Chairman of the Federal Reserve
Bank of St. Louis, transmitting By-laws of that bank as amended at the
meeting of the board of directors held on September 21st.

The Secretary

reported that the important changes are a provision for the annual election of officers, in accordance with the request recently made by the
Board, and amendments discontinuing the Governor of the bank as Chairman
of the Executive Committee and providing instead that the Chairman of the
Committee shall be appointed by the board of directors of the bank.
Upon motion, the By-laws, as amended, were noted
with approval.
The Vice Governor then presented a telegram from the Chairman of
the Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis, dated September 26th, advising
that the board of directors oi the bank on that day appointed Yr.

B.

Geery, now Deputy Governor, as Governor of the Bank to succeed Mr. A.
A. Young, effective when Mr. Young takes oath of office as a member of
the Federal Reserve Board.
After discussion, the Vice Governor was requested to
acknowledge the above telegram and call attention to the
fact that it does not mention the salary proposed for Mr.
Geery, on which the Board's approval is desired.



190
-5-

9/27/27

The Vice Governor then presented a proposed telegram to the Chairmen
and Governors of all Federal iieserve banks, advising of the postponement
for one week of the dates of the forthcoming Conferences of Governors
and Federal Reserve Agents; the Agents to meet October 31, November 1
and 2, the Governors November 2, 3 and 4, with a joint Conference on
Saturday, November 5th.
Upon motion, the proposed telegram was approved.
The Vice Governor then submitted favorable report of Committee on
District 45 on letter dated September 16th from the Chairman of the
Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond (1) Submitting contract approved by
the directors of the bank covering vault equipment for the Charlotte
Branch, in an amount of 0.7,954.00; (2) Requesting approval of increases
from

255O to ,2760 in the salary of Mr. H. L. Cherry, and from

2520

to 42700 in the salary of Mr. H. L. Whitemore, being transferred from
the head office to the Charlotte Branch as Managers of the Transit and
iloney Departments, respectively, and (3) Submitting final draft of bylaws for the Branch, providing among other things a definite territory
for the Charlotte Branch embracing the following counties in North
and South Carolina:
North Carolina
Alexander
Allegheny
Ashe
Avery
Buncombe
Burke
Cabarrus
Caldwell
Catawba
Cherokee
Clay



South Carolina
Abbeville
Aiken
Anderson
Cherokee
Chester
Edgefield
Fairfield
Greenville
Greenwood
Lancaster
Laurens

191
-6-

9/27/27
North Carolina

South Carolina

Cleveland
Gaston
Graham
Haywood
Henderson
irelell
Jackson
Lincoln
Macon
Madison
McDowell
Mecklenburg
Mitchell
Polk
:Iowan
Rutherford
Stanly
Swain
Transylvania
Union
Watauga
Wilkes
Yancey

Lexington
McCormick
Newberry
Oconee
Pickens
Richland
Saluda
Spartanburg
Union
York

Upon recommendation of the Committee on District
#5, it was voted to approve the three matters covered
in the Chairman's letter.
Letter dated September 24th from the Chairman of the Federal Reserve
Bank of St. Louis, with reference to the eligibility for service as a
director of the Louisville Branch of Mr. John T. Reynolds, who was elected
by the 3t. Louis directors for the unexpired term of Kr. Attilla Cox; the
Chairman stating that Yr. Reynolds is County Treasurer of Luhlenberg County
Kentucky, under appointment of a Fiscal Court, and inquiring whether this
position should be classed as a political office under the terms of the
Board's resolution of December 23, 1915.




Mr. James reported that this matter had been taken
up with him personally by Mr. J. C. Utterback, one of
the Class C Directors of the Federal Reserve Bank of
St. Louis, to wham he had expressed the opinion that
Mr. Reynolds would not be eligible to serve as a director

192
9/27/27

-7-

of the Louisville Branch while holding the office referred
to.
After discussion, it was voted that the Chairman of
the St. Louis Bank be officially advised that service by
Mr. Reynolds as County Treasurer makes him ineligible to
serve as a director of a Branch Federal Reserve Bank.
Memorandum from the Secretary dated September 26th, recommending that
the Board fix November 15th as the date for the opening of the polls in
the forthcoming elections of Class A and B Directors of the Federal Reserve
banks.
Approved.
The Vice Governor then submitted draft of telegraphic reply, prepared
by Counsel, to letter dated September 20th from the Assistant Federal Reserve
Agent at Chicago, with reference to a change in the bank's circular setting
forth a list of those authorized to vote in the forthcoming elections of
Class A and B directors, so as to list officers of banks authorized to cast
votes rather than the names of the individuals occupying said office; the
proposed telegraphic reply advising that the Board will have no objection
to the change proposed, but that in all cases the list should follow strictly the terms of the member bank's resolution of authorization, to wit: if
the resolution authorizes certain officers, naming official positions only,
the list may correspondingly show official positions only, but in any case
where the resolution has authorized a certain officer individually by
personal name, the voting list should contain the same designation.




Upon motion, the proposed telegraphic reply
was approved.
In this connection, the Secretary was authorized
to take up with all Federal Reserve Agents, through
their Committee on Elections, the matter of uniformity
in this regard.

193
9/27/27

-8_

The Vice Governor then presented draft of a letter, approved by the
Executive Committee, addressed to the Chairman of the Federal deserve
Bank of Dallas, replying to certain questions raised by the Chairman in
a letter dated April 17, 1927 regarding the new procedure to be followed
at all Federal

eserve banks in the forthcoming elections of Class A and

B directors.
Upon motion, the proposed letter was approved.
Memorandum dated September 26th from the Secretary, approved by the
Executive Committee, with reference to letter dated May 14, 1927 from the
Chairman of the Federal Aeserve Bank of San Francisco, with reference to
the procedure to be followed in connection with the forthcoming elections
of Class A and 3 directors; the memorandum suggesting that the Chairman
be adviseu, in reply to a specific inquiry, that he has editorial powers
in handling biographical sketches of candidates for election, and recommending that the Board lift the requirement of the new procedure that after
the elections each Chairman should inform member banks whose ballots were
invalidated of the reason for such rejection and in lieu thereof require
the Agents to send out a general letter listing all banks whose ballots
were invalidated because election instructions were not followed.
Upon motion, the recommendations contained in the
Secretary's memorandum .;ere approved.
Memorandum from Counsel dated September 20th, submitting drafts of replies to letters from the Treasurer of the First Federal Foreign Investment
Trust and Messrs. Kaye, McDavitt and Scholer, counsel for the trustee under

a recent bond issue of the corporation, both inquiring whether under the
law and the regulations of the Board it is necessary for an Edge corpora-




-9-

9/27/27

tion investing in stock of other corporations to obtain the consent of the
Board prior to each and every such investment; the proposed replies stating that the Board's regulations on this subject require that a corporation
organized under Section 25 (a) of the Federal Reserve Act must obtain the
consent of the Federal Reserve Board in each case before investing in the
stock of other corporations.
Ordered circulated.
Memorandum from Counsel on the matter referred to him at the meeting
of the Executive Committee on September 14th, namely, telegram dated September 8th from the Federal Reserve Agent at San Francisco, with reference to
stock ownership by tnL,Bancitaly Corporation in the consolidation of the
United Bank and Trust Company and the French American Bank of San Francisco
and inquiring whether the corporation has been guilty of a violation of
the agreement regarding ownership of stock of independent banks into which
it entered with the Board and the Comptroller of the Currency, prior to
the recent consolidation of the Bank of Italy.
After discussion, it was voted to defer action on
the above memorandum until the next meeting of the Board.
Memorandum from Assistant Counsel dated September 16th, submitting
draft of reply to letter dated September 7th from the Deputy Comptroller
of the Currency, inquiring whether a reserve should be maintained by
national banks against foreign deposit liabilities which are customarily
paid in the particular kind of currency or coin deposited; the propose,
reply stating that deposits of the kind referred to must be considered
deposit liabilities against which reserves must be maintained in accordance




9/27/27

-10-

with the provisions of Section 19 of the Federal Reserve Act, and that the
required reserve may be computed on the basis of the dollar value of the
foreign deposit liability at the current rate of exchange and maintained
with the Federal Aeserve bank in dollars in the usual manner.
Upon motion, the proposed reply was approved.
The Vice Governor then referred to the action of the Executive Committee at its meeting on September 23rd in voting to interpose no objection
to the Governor of the Federal Reserve Bank of Boston complying with a
request made of htm by the editor of the American Bankers Association
Journal, for an article relating to the reduction made recently in the
rediscount rate of the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago.
The Vice Governor stated that in accordance with the
instructions of the Committee, he advised Governor Harding to
withhold transmission of the article until the Committee's
action could be ratified at a meeting of the Board early this
week.
After discussion, upon motion by Mr. James,
it was voted to ratify the action of the Committee.
Memorandum from Assistant Counsel dated September 21st, with reference
to letters dated September 15th and 17th from the Assistant Federal zteserve
Agent at Dallas, one transmitting opinion of Counsel for that bank with
regard to the cancellation of Federal deserve bank stock held by certain
member banks whose charters have expired by limitation, and the other
transmitting an application for the surrender of stock filed on behalf
of one of the institutions, namely, the First State Bank of Seminole,
Texas; Counsel stating that the opinion referred to was evidently transmitted to the Board merely for its information and requires no action,




ice
9/27/27

-11-

and further that the application filed on behalf of the First State Bank
of Seminole, Texas, is in the form prescribed by the Executive Committee
of the Board at its meeting on August 30th and that there is no legal
reason why it should not be approved.
Upon motion, the application of the First
State Bank of Seminole, Texas, for the surrender
and cancellation of 42 shares of stock in the
Federal Aeserve Bank of Dallas was approved.
Matter ordered circulated at the meeting of the Executive Committee
on September 20th, namely, memorandum from Assistant Counsel dated September 2nd, with regard to the interpretation of Sections 5204, 5205 and 5209
of the Aevised Statutes of the United States, in connection with State
member banks which, through losses or other withdrawals, have suffered
impairmentsin their capital.
Action deferred.
Memorandum from Assistant Counsel dated September 12th, with reference
to an inquiry received from the First Federal Foreign Investment Trust of
New York City, with regard to the filing of the financial statement required by the Board's Regulation "K" on the date following an issue of
debentures by an Edge corporation; the corporation stating that their
recent issue was offered to the public on August 1st, notes were signed
and delivered to the trustee on August 19th and were authenticated by
the trustee and delivered to the corporation on August 22nd, and inquiring as to the date of the required financial statement

and whether state-

ments as of July 31, 1927 and August 31, 1927, would be acceptable to the
Board in view of the fact that the books of the corporation are closed
at the end of each month.




In his memorandum, the Board's Assistant Counsel

197
-12-

9/27/27

stated that under the regulation the statement of the corporation should be
filed as of August 23, 1927, but that the Board may, if it wishes, waive the
requirement.
Lessrs. Platt and Hamlin, members of the Board's
Law Committee recommended that the requirament of the
Board's regulation be waived in this case and that the
First Federal Foreign Investment Trust be advised that
the Board will accept from it statements of its financial
condition as of July 31, 1927, and ,..ugust 31, 1927.
Upon motion, the recommendation of the Committee
was approved.
The Vice Governor presented another memorandum dated September 16th from
Assistant Counsel, with reference to information filed by the First Federal
Foreign Investment Crust of New York City, under the provisions of the
Board's ,:iegulation "K", in connection with the corporation's recent issue
of 5/ Five Year Secured Gold Notes; Counsel stating that in his opinion
the documents submitted by the corporation comply with the requirements of
the 7;oard's regulation on the subject, but that his memorandum is not, of
course, intended to pass upon any questions as to the value of collateral
security or the safety or protection of the note holders.
referred to the Law Committee for recommendation.
Letters dated September 15th and 22nd from the Assistant Secretary of
the Federal

eserve Bank of New York, and telegrams dated September 21st

from the Chairman of the Federal Aeserve Bank of Boston, dated Sentember
21st from the Chairman of the Federal Aeserve Bank of Philadelphia, dated
September 15th from the Chairman of the Federal lieserve Bank of Richmond,
dated September 23rd from the Deputy Chairman of the Federal Reserve Bank
of Chicago, dated September 21st from the Chairman of the Federal Aeserve




198
-13-

)/27/27

Bank of St. Louis, dated September 22nd from the Chairman of the Federal
Reserve Bank of Kansas City, and dated September 15th from the Chairman
of the Federal deserve Bank of San Francisco, advising that the boards
of directors of those banks at their meetings on those dates made no
changes in the banks' existing schedules of rates of discount and purchase.
Noted, with approval.
The Vice Governor then submitted the recommendations made to the
Board by the Federal Advisory Council following the last meeting of the
Council held in Viashington on September 16th.
Upon motion, it was voted that consideration
of these recommendations be deferred until the
next meeting of the Board.
The Board then considered the report of the Committee on District
No. 10, which was endorsed by the Executive Committee at its meeting on
September 20th, recommending the appointment of Mr. Wayland W. Magee,
Bennington, Nebraska, as a director of the Omaha Branch of the Federal
Reserve Bank of Kansas City for the unexpired term of Mr. A. J. Weaver,
resigned, ending December 31, 1927.
Upon motion, Mr. Magee was appointed a director
of the Omaha Branch for the unexpired term of Mr. Weaver.
Ileport of Executive Committee on memorandum dated September 8th
from the Comptroller of the Currency, recommending approval of an application of the First National Bank of Madison, Ga., for permission to reduce
its capital stock from 4150,000 to ,„;100,000 on condition that no dividend
be paid to shareholders in cash, but that assets amounting to not less
than 470,000, including all "other real estate" and certain other undesirable




-14-

9/27/27

assets to be designated by the national bank examiner, are withdrawn and
placed in the hands of a trustee for the benefit of shareholders of record
on the date the reduction becomes effective; the Board's Committee also
recommending approval subject to the condition suggested by the Comptroller.
Approved.
:latter on which action was deferred at the meeting of the Executive
Committee on September 23rd, namely, letter dated September 20th from the
Commercial Attache of the Cuban Embassy, inquiring, at the request of the
Secretary of the Treasury of Cuba, whether it would be possible to arrange
for the exchange, between the Cuban Treasury and the Havana Agency of
the Federal Aeserve Bank of Atlanta, of excess American coins totalling
about 1.2,500,000, for United States currency.
After discussion, durta7 which Mr. James, Chairman
of the Board's Committee on District No. 6, reported
certain preliminary negotiations looking toward the
exchange, the Secretary of the Board was authorized,
in the absence of extraordinary complications, to complete negotiations along the lines reported, Mr. Miller
voting "no".
Letter dated September 23rd from the Chairman of the Federal deserve
Bank of St. Louis, who is Secretary of the Federal Reserve Agents' Conference, submitting a revised tentative program for the forthcoming Conference
of Federal deserve Agents.
Upon motion, the amended program submitted by the
Secretary of the Conference was approved.
The Vice Governor then referred to the action of the Executive Committee at its meeting on September 23rd, in deferring for a meeting of
the Board a proposea letter to the Secretary of the Federal Reserve Agents'
Conference advising of topics which the Board would like to have considered




-15-

9/27/27

at the forthcoming meeting.
After discussion, Mr. Miller moved, that there be stricken
from the list of the Board's topics a request for an opinion
from the Conference on the question whether uniform rates of
discount throughout the Federal Reserve System are gen,2rally
desirable, and whether such uniform rates are in accordance
with the spirit of the Federal Reserve Act.
Mr. Miller's motion, being nut by the Chair,
was carried.
Mr. Miller then moved that the Federal Reserve Agents be
requested to discuss the effect of changes in Federal Reserve
bank rates upon rates charged by member banks on customers'
loans, including loans to banking correspondents, the individual agents in connection with this discussion to make a particular study of the effect upon customers' rates of the recent reductions in their districts.
Carried.
Upon motion, it was then voted to approve the above mentioned
letter to the Secretary of the Federal Reserve Agents' Conference
with the amendments above provided.
The Vice Governor also called attention to a proposed letter to the
Governors of all Federal Reserve banks, requesting the Governors' Conference to discuss the question of uniform Federal Reserve bank rates, on
which the Executive Committee at its meeting on September 23rd also voted
to defer action.
Upon motion, the proposed letter was disapproved.
REPORTS OF STANDING COMMITTEJ-:S:
Dated, September 24th,
26th,

Dated, September 23rd,
26th,




Recommending changes in stock at Federal Reserve
Banks as set forth in the Auxiliary Minute Book
of this date.
Recommendations approved.
Recommending action on applications for fiduciary
powers as set forth in the Auxiliary Minute Book
of this date.
Recommendations approved.

9/27/27

-16-

REPORTS OF 3TANDING COMMITTEES: (Contld)
Dated, September 26th,

Dated, September 24th,

Dated, September 24th,

Dated, September 24th,

Dated, September 26th,

Recommending action on an application of a state
institution for admission, subject to the conditions
stated in the individual reports attached to the
application, as set forth in the Auxiliary 'Minute
Book of this date.
Recommendation approved.
Recommending approval of the application of Mr.
Charles B. Beury for permission to serve at the
same time as Officer and Director of the National
Bank of North Philadelphia, Philadelphia, Pa., as
officer and director of the Tioga Trust Company,
Philadelphia, Pa., and as officer and director of
the _anheim Trust Company, Philadelphia, Pa.
Recommendation approved.
Recommending approval of the application of Mr.
William G. Friedgen for permission to serve at the
same time as director of the National Bank of North
Philadelphia, Philadelphia, Pa., and as director of
the Tioga Trust Company, Philadelphia, pa.
Recommendation approved.
Recommending approval of the application of Mr.
Harcourt J. Pratt for permission to serve at the
same time as director of the Kingston Trust Company,
Kingston, N. Y., and as director of the First National
Bank, Highland, N. Y.
Recommendation approved.
Recommending approval of the application of Mr.
Robert H. Neville for permission to serve at the
same time as director and Vice President of the First
National Bank, Yonkers, N. Yr., and as director of
the First National Bank, A sley, N. Y.
Recommendation appr ed.
The meeting adjourned a

:30 p.m.

Secretww.
Approved:




Chairman.