View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

The attached set of minutes of the
meeting of the Board of Governors of the Federal
Reserve System with the Federal Advisory Committee
on September 17, 1957) which you have previously
initialed, has been amended to make a change in
paragraph 1 on page 16.
If you approve these minutes as amended,
please init1P1 below.




Governor Szymczak

Governor Robertson

To:

Members of the Board

From: Office of the Secretary

Attached is a copy of the minutes of the meeting of
the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System with the
Federal Advisory Council held on September 17, 19570
It is not proposed to include a statement with respect
to any of the entries in this set of minutes in the record of
P°11cY actions required to be maintained pursuant to section 10
Of the Federal Reserve Act.
Should you have any question with regard to the minutes,
it will be appreciated if you will advise the Secretary's Office.
Otherwise,
if you were present at the meeting, please initial in
_ c)lumn. A, below to indicate that you approve the minutes. If you
were not present, please initial in column B below to indicate
that you have seen the minutes.

Chm. Martin
Gov. Szymczak
Gov. Vardaman
Gov. Mills
Gov. Robertson
Gov. Balderston
Gov. Shepardson




x

d„,1/1

A meeting of the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve
SYstem with the Federal Advisory Council was held in the offices of
the Board on Tuesday, September 172 1957, at 10:30 a.m.
PRESENT

Mr.
Mr.
Mr.
Mr.
Mr.
Mr.

Martin, Chairman
Balderston, Vice Chairman
Szymczak
Vardaman
Mills
Robertson
Mr. Carpenter, Secretary
Mr. Sherman, Assistant Secretary

Messrs. Brace, Massie, Mitchell, Denton,
Fleming, Kimball, Livingston, Miller,
Murray, Kemper, Jacobs, and King,
members of the Federal Advisory Council
from the First, Second, Third, Fourth,
Fifth, Sixth, Seventh, Eighth, Ninth,
Tenth, Eleventh, and Twelfth Districts,
respectively
Mr. Prochnow and Mr. Korsvik„ Secretary and
Assistant Secretary of the Federal
Advisory Council, respectively
President Fleming noted that Mr. Gordon Murray, President of
the

First National Bank of Minneapolis, was attending his first meetof the Federal Advisory Council, having been selected by the

Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis to succeed Mr. Baird who had
res.;
1gned as a member of the Council from the Ninth District to accept
4Ppointment as Under Secretary of the Treasury.
Before this meeting the Council submitted to the Board of
Gover
nors a memorandum setting forth the Council's views on the
81).bjects
to be discussed with the Board at this joint meeting. The
8tatern

-ent of the topics, the Council's views, and the discussion with




(‘

9/17/57
respect to each of the subjects were as follows
1.

What are the views of the members of the Council as to the existing economic situation,
particularly with respect to its trend during
the rest of the current year? What are the
prospects with respect to construction (industrial, commercials, and residential), and
the demand for funds for this purpose? What
effects are the recently announced terms on
FHA and VA mortgages having on the residential
mortgage market?

All members of the Council believe that business will coninue strong for the balance of the current year. Although there
18 some spottiness in the economy, a major supporting factor is
the present large volume of retail sales.
The prospects are that industrial, commercial, and residential construction and the consequent demand for funds will
continue about at present levels for the balance of the year.
The recently announced terms on FHA and VA mortgages have had
very little effect on the residential mortgage market up to the
present time. VA loans have ceased to be a significant factor
in the mortgage market because of the continuing unrealistic
rates.
Mr. Brace said there was considerable variation in activities in
the D
virst District, with some decidedly good and some fairly weak.

The

e3cPectati0n was for about a level total for the rest of this year.

Not

Much Change in total industrial output was expected in the next few months.
Retail trade recently bad been good, and the average business was continuin
g at about the same satisfactory level as six to nine months ago. This
was expected to continue for the next several months with no new weak spots
and
With the strong spots having enough momentum to carry on for some time.
Mr. Massie stated that aggregate business in the Second District
lias at a high level.
Potty3

Employment was at the top but it had been somewhat

with some layoffs in defense industries and strikes in the light

Metal-working and cement industries.



Personal income was up to a new

_3_

9/17/57

high, although there had been some drop-off in overtime.

Industrial and

commercial construction activity was good, particularly construction of
office buildings in New York.

Residential building had declined about

31 per cent this year and showed no signs of picking up.

Retail trade had

not been good
in the early months of 1957, but beginning in May sales had
risen rapidly and in recent months had been good, with the year to date
total about

S.5

per cent above last year.

a fair
volume but not much profit.

The textile industry reported

The apparel business was fair and

looking for a large pickup this fall, although such a rise had not yet
shavn U. Bank deposits were down, particularly demand deposits, savings
cleP°sits having shown some rise with the increase in the interest rate
Paid. Loan demand was at a top, with requests coming in in large pieces,
arid

this was expected to continue to the end of the year.

Taking the

District as a whole, Mr. Massie said that operations were at a high level
a-/Id he could see no reason why aggregate business should not stay good
until the end of this yearn even though there were some soft spots.
Mr. Mitchell reported that the Third District was showing about
the —
oame pattern as for the last five or six months.
were the
same as earlier--steeln

The strong spots

shipbuilding, rubber, and chemicals;

arid the
weak spots also were the same--anthracite coal, residential
building, and disappointing sales of automobiles.

Residential building

4/lards were 13 per cent under last yearn while nonresidential awards
118I
'
e up 7 per cent.

Recently there had been some indication that in-

dustri
-al programs were being reduced or postponed, Mr. Mitchell said,
but
on the other hand State and local government construction was



9/17/57

increasing and was expected to continue to rise. Agriculture had been hard
hit by the drought this year, particularly in vegetable growing areas;
dairymen had not been hurt by the drought except that costs had risen
because of the need for heavier feed.

Personal income was up and

employment was about the same as a year ago. Factory pay rolls were up.
There was a substantial labor surplus in the Altoona-Scranton area, as
had been the
case for some time.

Money was tight, deposits were dawn,

and loans were the same as a year ago, with banks lending about 57 per
cent of their
deposits.
sanie as a year ago.

Borrowings from the Reserve Bank were about the

Mr. Mitchell felt that until the end of this year

business should continue at the present high level without much increase
Or

decline and with loans rising seasonally.
Mr. Denton described conditions in the Fourth District as having

the same pattern as that expressed for other Districts.

He expected a

high level of business for the rest of this year, although he would
clual fY that statement with the comment that industrial concerns he was
in touch with were more pessimistic than comments at this meeting.
ness of many concerns was down a little
g°0c1 as formerly.
current

year.

Busi-

and the atmosphere was not as

Forecasts for the coming year were lower than for the

This was true in basic steel,, alloy steelD and firms

euPPlYing trim
for the automobile trade.

Orders for heavy electrical

eluiPment were far below anticipations earlier this year. The chemical
tr
ade was burdened by oversupplies of materials with which it made
131'°duct8; and the storage problem was becoming acute.

The oil industry

w48 in long supply,, but if the coming winter turned out to be cold it




9/17/57
would help
the fuel oil situation.
about the same as last year.

Coal production was expected to be

Orders for railroad equipment were slack.

On the other hand, Mr. Denton reported that consumer buying was strong
and retail
trade high, with demand for consumer credit in the automobile
field substantial.

Loan demand showed no slackening.

Next year would

see the beginning of payoffs on loans to expand facilities and there
Should be
some relief.

Some companies were feeling that they had moved

ahead in expanding facilities before they were needed.

Demand for money

ccrntinued steady and strong; deposits were running higher than last year
hut were not as much above as earlier in

1957.

Despite the qualifica-

ti°ns he had given, Mr. Denton said that business was good even though
the atmosphere
was not as optimistic as it had been.
Chairman Martin noted that there had been marked swings in
PsYchology in
the business community in relatively short periods of time
and Lte
inquired as to the reasons for these sharp changes in feelings.
Mr. Denton said that the recent shift in feelings of the businessllen to whom he
had referred probably reflected the fact that they had
reallY anticipated earlier this year a bulging fourth quarter.
f°11rth

While the

quarter had not yet arrived, business had not approached their

eXIDectations.

For examplen the coal industry had anticipated a

5

per

cellt gain but instead sales were at about the same level as a year ago
4" the Price structure was weak.

There was an accumulation of such

feelings and they were being reflected in the stock market, Mr. Denton
4id

or perhaps developments in the stock market were being reflected in

the feelings of these businessmen.




2589
9/17/57
President Fleming commented that he felt the Congressional
,hearings of the past summer had been confusing to the public and thus
affected psychology.
Mr. Livingston expressed the view that the longer a boom ran,
the more sensitive the businessman got and thus the sharper his reaction
to

Psychological factors that came along.
In response to a question from Governor Balderston as to whether

the members of the Council were concerned over the foreign situation and
its future impact on the domestic situation2 President Fleming commented
that this was a factor.

Inflation was a problem in most parts of the

/4°r1d9 he noted, and the situation in countries such as France could
have an unfavorable effect on U. S. export trades particularly if the
aln°unt of foreign aid extended by the United States were cut dawn.
Mr. Livingston said he anticipated a continuing deterioration in
the French situation but he doubted that this would have a major effect
°11 the
economy of the United States.

He would apply substantially the

3e-me comments to the remainder of Western
Europe.
Mr. Massie doubted that the full impact of the French exchange
Millstment would appear for soue time.

He said that in recent months

cc'qlorations exporting to Western Europe had had a sharp decline in their
bus;
'fless and were finding it very difficult to compete with European de

products being produced at lower cost. While the percentage of total

b"insss of United States firms represented by exports to Western Europe
had been smalls it had been very desirable.
President Fleming said that the Fifth District was keeping on an




9/17/57
even keel.

There were some bright spots and some not so good.

had been a cutback of military personnel.
tinued strong demand was expected.

There

Bank loans were up and con-

Deposits had increased slightly

Where banks had increased the rate of interest payable on savings deposits, but demand deposits were down a little.

Construction of

industrial and commercial buildings was strong, particularly of
aPartment and office buildings.

The bituminous coal industry was a

br1
6uu spot, but lumbering and paper products were dawn.

Transporta-

tion equipment was down except for a new large atomic powered airplane
carrier.

Tobacco and cigarette production was up slightly and an in-

crease was expected for the fourth quarter.
°°fltinued to be depressed.
badly hit by the drought.
Were

The textile industry

Farm income was up slightly but had been
Residential construction was down.

practically not being made.

VA loans

The recent increase in rate on FHA

loans ultimately would result in an increase in such mortgages but at
Present there was a lag in getting commitments.

Retail trade was strong,

having shown a sharp increase since the first of September.

This was

"Pected to continue during the fall with a record volume of Christmas
trade.
Mr. Kimball said that the over-all Sixth District picture was
still

generally quite strong but there was a trend toward increasing

diversity by States.

If Florida were taken out of the picture, the

8/1cth District would not look so strong.
light upward tendency.

Over-all employment showed a

The textile, lumbering, wood products, and paper

and allied products industries were tending downward with the textile




259
9/17/57

-8-

industry reporting a work week of 37 hours compared with /10 hours a
Year ago. Food processings transportation, and metals continued to
shall a rise in employment.

Construction was exceptionally vigorous

showing an 11 per cent gain in the first seven months of

1957 compared

With 1956. Retail sales were holding up extremely well, department
store sales having turned strong in July after showing slackness earlier
this Year.

Loans and deposits continue to inch ups Mr. Kimball said,

With the food processing and metals firms largely responsible for the
increased loan demand. Loans to the textile industry have risen more
than seasonally.

Gross cash income of agriculture was about matching

last years but net agricultural income would be smaller than 1956
because of increased costs.

Over alls Mr. Kimball concluded: the

Picture was still brights particularly because of the strong trend in
?lorida.
Mr. Livingston said that business in the Seventh District contin-tied
very good and he expected it to continue good until the end of
the
fourth quarter. Employment was high although there was some
unemployment in Detroit and Flint because of the autoxobile situation.
er°118 have been good in the Se7enth District this year: moisture having
been more
than adequate.

Hog and cattle prices were very good but the

Packing industry, as is usual when prices of hogs are high: was unPro
fitable. Residential construction in the Seventh District was down
sharPly from a year ago.

Commercial construction was dawn less sharply

4nd industrial construction was up. The farm implement business continued

poor.




Mr. Livingston said that the most significant thing in the

592
9/17/57
Seventh District was the remarkable buoyancy in retail sales.

This was

true all over the country but it was particularly evident since the
first of September in the Seventh District.
Mr. Miller stated that the picture in the Eighth District was
similar to that described for the rest of the country:

business would

continue at a fairly high level to the end of this year.
money was strong and a little larger than a year ago.

Demand for

Deposits were down

hut not drastically, most of the decline having come in tax and loan
accounts.

Retail sales in the Eighth District were similar to the

Picture given by Mr. Livingston.

The tobacco crop was good and prices

were good, Mr. Miller said, noting that this was a large cash crop in
Illuch of the Eighth District.

Residential building was down but com-

mercial and industrial construction was being well maintained.

It was

expected that road construction would continue at a high level.

Mr.

Miller said that while there was no wave of optimism in the Eighth
istrict2 he had not heard as much
in the way of pessimism as was
indicated by comments of some others.
Mr. Murray described business in the Ninth District as good,
"ding that he expected this tp continue for the balance of the year.
Being largely agriculturalc, the Ninth District had been more fortunate
than some other parts of the country as a result of the ample moisture
this year.
Crops were good in almost all areas and farm prices were up.
This bright picture balanced the soft -spats that had
appeared.

Residential

c°48tructi0n was down and this had affected the lumber industry unfavorblY.

Commercial and industrial construction was holding at a good level.




9/17/57

-10-

The paper business was weak, and the small amount of textile business
in the Ninth District was feeling the effects reported for the industry
generally.

The tourist trade, which was fairly important in the Ninth

District, had been good during the past summer.

Retail sales were

strong as in other parts of the country, and retailers looked forward
to very satisfactory business in the coming months, particularly during
the Christmas season.
reaching new peaks.

Money was tight, Mr. Murray said, and loans were

Banks generally were not borrowing quite as much as

earlier in the year.
Mr. Kemper reported a good level of business in the Tenth District, better than a year ago.

This reflected good rainfall this year.

Excepting winter wheat!
, all crops were substantially better than in
1956 and, in addition, the soil bank payments had been a factor adding
t° a gricultural income.

Mr. Kemper suggested that taking agricultural

lands out of production had very little effect on the total volume of
Production
because of the added use of fertilizer and more intensive
faraling of the better lands.

Generally, farmers were prosperous and

Mr. Kemper
anticipated that this would be increasingly true.
tanks were getting liquidation of their loans.

Country

Retail sales were much

better than last year, including even the farm implement business.
Automobil
e sales were still poor.

Residential construction was 11 per

cent below
a year ago but this decline was more than offset by increased
c°nstruction of public works!
, office buildings, and highways.
"
If 1 per cent above a year ago.
clePosit s were
off.




Employment

Loans were higher than last year while

Mr. Kemper stated that from now to the end of this

9/17/57

-11-

year he expected excellent business in the Tenth District.
Mr. Jacobs said that Eleventh District department store sales,
Particularly sales of durable goods, were very strong, having reached
a record high for this time of year.

Employment was good and construc-

tion contract awards reached a peak in June.
28 per cent above the 1956 figure.

Nonresidential awards were

Housing awards showed a smaller gain,

but for the seven months period they were above the previous year in all
Parts of the District except New Mexico.

Agricultural production was

greatly improved as compared with last year.
the cotton crop was expected to be about
average.

Rains had been good and

6 per cent above the 10 year

Good grain and hay crops were reported, and soil bank payments

Ilsre running about three times as high as last year.
were uP and some restocking was noted.

Live stock prices

Bank deposits and loans were

rising and loans were expected to expand for the rest of this year.
Although production of crude oil had been cut back, the adjustment was
n°t aufficient to prevent a substantial building up of stocks.

Mr.

01oa said that business as a whole had been very good in the Eleventh
District, although he found more and more businessmen were becoming
Pu2z1ed at their inability in
m"eY0

he face of increasing sales to make any

A good part of the public was becoming increasingly alarmed at

the high cost of the things they buy, even though they dontt understand
inf
lation and its impact.
Mr. King said the Twelfth District showed the pattern expressed
It°r other
districts.

Weak spots included lumbering in the Northwest,

Which had been weak for some time because of the residential building




9/17/57

-12-

situation.
workers.

Aircraft also was weak with substantial layoffs of

However9 those laid off apparently had been absorbed in

Other industries and unemployment in southern California was less
than in other parts of the country even after the layoffs in the aircraft industry.

Aircraft companies are quite pessimistic for the

foreseeable
future.

Construction was following the national pattern

With residential building dawn and public and utility construction very
strong.

There was considerable slow-down because of lack of demand

for houses at the prices and terms at which they were offered.
Were

Loans

Up, particularly in the commercial field, but real estate mortgages

Were down
for the first time in some period.

Much of the increase in

deposits had come in savings accounts, Mr. King said, and he noted that
banks in California were now generally paying three per cent on such
deposits which had risen 10 per cent during the first six months of this
Year.

The rate of increase in savings deposits had slowed down since

lp Mr. King noted.

He believed that retail sales would be strong

dllring the rest of this year.

Automobile dealers were reasonably

°Ptimistic and believed that new model automobiles were likely to be
well accepted.

Mr. King said he looked for strong business in the

l'welfth District for the rest of this year.
2. What changes in the over-all demand for bank
credit and in the sources of demand can be
expected during the next six months or a year?
The C,
uncil expects that loans will expand in the fourth
quarter, and that there will be no marked change in the sources
Of demand for credit. If business should decline after the
first of the year, inventories may tend to accumulate. In this




2596
9/17/57

-13-

event, the seasonal pattern of loan liquidation may be diminished to some extent.
In response to a question from Governor Balderston as to whether
steel stocks had been increasing during the past two months, Mr. Denton
stated that this had not been the case.

He also reported that persons in

the steel industry believed that inventories were being reduced substantially during the present quarter, that this process would be largely
completed by the end of the current quarter, and that changes in inventories of steel during the
fourth quarter of 1957 would be relatively
small.
3.

What is the public thinking in the various
sections of the country with respect to
inflation; that creeping inflation is inevitable; that it will be stopped? What
effect is this thinking having on the financial plans of business and investors?

.
The public generally is becoming increasingly concerned
With the rise in the price level. There are undoubtedly some
Who believe that creeping inflation is inevitable and that it
Will not be stopped. However, the increasing volume of
individual savings suggests that the great majority of people
believe the growth of the economy will be orderly with
relatively stable prices and that their savings will not be
dissipated by inflation.
There has been some acceleration in business expenditures
for plant and equipment because of an anticipated increase in
construction costs. However, increased consumer expenditures
because of the rise in personal income and its wider distribution to an expanding labor force, as well as efforts by
management to reduce labor costs and increase efficiency, have
been major influences determining business plant and equipment
expenditures.
The rising price level has probably induced some investors
to purchase equities and real estate.




9

9/17/57

-1hPresident Fleming said that his attention had been directed to

a Washington newsletter that commented on the outlook for changes in
the price
level over the next several years.

He felt that such fore-

casts had a danger in that they focused attention on inflationary
Pcssibilities without giving the readers, who were concerned with increasing prices., the slightest idea of what was causing such advances.
Chairman Martin said that the nature of the problem we were
dealing with was becoming more and more apparent to the public but at
the same time the answer was becoming more confusing.

He doubted that

any real progress had been made in persuading people that the hard way
Ilas the necessary way for combating the inflationary price rises.

The

Calairmen then referred to a memorandum that had been prepared recently
by Mr. Riefler, Assistant to the Chairman, presenting comments on some
°f the nuestions that had been raised by critics of System credit
P°11cY in the hearings before the Senate Finance Committee this past
suillmer9 and President Fleming stated that Mr. Riefler had distributed
e°Pies of this memorandum to the members of the Council yesterday
afternoon.

He was amazed at the virulence of the idea expressed by some

Of these critics that the way to stop inflation was to print more money.
He

also mentioned a meeting that he attended in New York last evening at

Ilhich a number of persons connected with the United Nations organization
exPressed the
conviction that the measures taken in Western Europe had
failed to stop the inflation, and they stated the belief that there
'ar°111d be no problem if we would just increase the money supply.

The

Cha
irman felt it important that the Council and all parts of the Federal




259,.
9/17/57
Reserve System combat the idea that we could "spend ourselves rich by
listening to the siren song of the printing press."
Mr. Denton said that the atmosphere in industry had shifted to
some degree in recent months and that businessmen with whom he had
talked do not now seem to have as sure a feeling that creeping inflation
is inevitable as they had three months ago.

He also felt that the

recent decline in the stock market had had an influence in this direction.
Mr. Mitchell said that there was a difference in the feelings
Of businessmen as between long-term inflation and short-term inflation.
An increasing number of businessmen believed that there would be poorer
business in the next year or two., but almost everybody felt that over a
Period of a generation or a hundred years there would tend to be a rise
in prices.

He added that this tendency probably had been true for the

last thousand years.
Governor Balderston nuestioned the latter comment, noting that
/4bile the price level had advanced sharply during periods of war, there
Ilbsequently had been offsetting declines.
Mr. Mitchell responded that while there had been ups and dawns
between wars, he thought it probable that over a long period of time
there had been a rising tendency in the price level.
Chairman Martin commented on the importance of having the public
urlderstand that purchasing power of the currency, as well as maximum
emP1°Yment and production, was important.

In his judgment, the full

ell1PloYment concept could be the most revolutionary idea of the past few




2599
9/17/57

-16-

decades if it vas misunderstood and misapplied.

In England, s defeat-

ist attitude seemed to have developed to the point 'where many believed
that no readjustment in the economy could be permitted because of the
interpretation the political elements put on the concept.

All of us

Should be studying the problem to determine whether there vas a way of
dealing with an idea as vast and potentially serious as that being
advanced under the full employment concept.

4. At the last meeting of the Council there was
a discussion of the effects of the payment
by banks of higher interest rates on savings
deposits. The Board 'would appreciate any
further comments that the members of the
Council might wish to make on this subject.
Banks which increased the interest rate paid on their savings deposits have attracted additional deposits. Those banks
'which increased the interest rate to 3 per cent experienced the
largest gains.
President Fleming said that the effects of payments of higher interest rates on savings deposits had been tapering down.

At his sugges-

ti0n, Mr. King presented the results of a survey made in the Twelfth
tistrict 'which indicated that in 1957 there had been relatively greater
81.°14th in savings deposits in commercial banks than in funds placed in
8"ing8 and loan associations or in savings bonds.
Mr. Kemper said that while banks in Kansas City 'were still paying
2

Pe

Cent

on savings deposits, there had been discussions of an increase

the rate and if any change 'were made it 'would seem that 3 per cent
/ I'd be the magic rate which would produce a substantial increase in
"
8"ings deposits at commercial banks.




-9/17/57

5.

What are the Councills views with respect to
(a) the credit policies followed by the Federal Reserve System since the last meeting
of the Councils and (b) the policies that
would be appropriate for the balance of this
year?

The credit policies which the Federal Reserve System has
followed since the last meeting of the Council have been
appropriate and constructive. In the opinion of the Council,
the Board should at present continue the same degree of credit
restraint which the System has maintained in recent months.
President Fleming said that the Councils opinion as of today was
that System credit policies were appropriate and constructive. At the
time of
the meeting to be held in November the Council might have a different view

but for the present the unanimous appraisal of the members of

the Federal Advisory Council was that the degree of restraint being
exercised by the Systems credit policy should remain unchanged.

6. (a) As stated at the meeting on May lh, 1957,
the topic of changes to be suggested in the
Bank Holding Company Act of 1956 is to be
carried on the agenda for each meeting of the
Council until the spring of 1958.
(b) Does the Council have any changes to suggest in existing law other than the Bank
Holding Company Act?
(a) Other than the suggested amendments previously submitted to the Board the Council has no further comments to
make at this time on the Bank Holding Company Act of 1956.
(b) In relation to the Financial Institutions Act of
1957p the Council submitted to the Board a number of recommendations which it believed would improve the proposed legislation.
The Council continues to believe that legislation should
be enacted at the next session of Congress which will permit
(1) tax deduction of more adequate bad debt reserves for banks,
and will provide for (2) a general revision and reduction in
reserve requirements. While the Council recognizes that a




26;
9/17/57

-18-

reduction in reserve requirements would not be appropriate
at presents, it favors the enactment of legislation now.
President Fleming commented that the Council realized that passage of legislation with respect to reserve requirements might take time
and he wondered
whether the Board could report progress in its studies of
reserve requirements.
Chairman Martin responded that he could not say that there had
been

any change in the status of this question at the Board since the

Preceding meeting of the Council.
7. What was the effect of the call this year
for reports of condition as of June 6
rather than June 30?
The Council believes that the call this year for reports
Of condition as of June 6 rather than June 30 was an effective method of helping to eliminate certain undesirable
practices by some banks.
There was no discussion of this topic.

President Fleming then stated that the members of the Council
11°111d be happy to have Chairman Martin comment on the hearings before the
R°11se Banking and Currency Committee and the Senate Finance Committee at
'
Itch the Chairman had appeared this summer.
In his comments, Chairman Martin said that perhaps 20 per cent
f the questions presented to him at the hearings before the House Banking
and Currency Committee had something to do with the Financial Institutions
A +
while 80 per cent were not related to the proposed legislation but
e concerned with the Federal Reserve Acts the Banking Act of 1933, and
the
Banking Act of 1935. The dominant theme, which was not new, related
t° banker domination of the Federal Reserve System and a possible conflict



9/17/57

-19-

of interest.

The Federal Advisory Council had been mentioned on a num-

ber of occasions, he said, adding that the meetings the Board had been
having with the Council had been of benefit.
As far as banker domination of the System was concerned, Chairman Martin felt that this showed up largely as a myth, although this
might be
only his impression.

On the whole, he did not think that the

hearings had been particularly impressive.

There had been an opportunity

in the House Committee hearings to place the history of the Federal Reserve System in perspective, and there had been a fairly good opportunity

in the Senate Committee hearings to clarify monetary and credit policy.
While he had found these hearings to be quite harmless, the Chairman noted

that a great deal of time was required to prepare for and appear at them.
Chairman Martin also referred to the report to the Congress,
issued on June 26,

1957,

by the Subcommittee on Fiscal Policy of the

jcint Economic Committee, of which the Honorable Wilbur D. Mills is
Chairman.

This report was well worth reading, he felt, because of the

*clews it expressed concerning the fiscal policy implications of the
"3nomic outlook and budget developments.
In concluding his comments, Chairman Martin stressed the
1111Portance of looking upon the Federal Reserve as a System.

The System

cliffers from a department of the Government headed by a single individual,
he noted, adding that he had tried to impress this difference on the comInitteea of the Congress before which he had appeared.

There were differ-

ences of opinion in the Federal Reserve System and he had no desire to
Present another point of view, but he felt it important that in the end




r.; --/
,k,t)
2g*

-.20there was a System point of view, even though it was reached through a
cuMbersome process.
President Fleming stated that the next meeting of the Federal
Advisory Council would be held on November 17-190 19570 if convenient
to the Board, and it was understood that the meeting would be set for
that time.
Thereupon the meeting adjourned.