View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

700
A meeting of the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve
SYStenl

was held in Washington on Thursday, May 16, 1940, at 11:30

Et. ra.

PRESENT:

Mr.
Mr.
Mr.
Mr.
Mr.

Eccles, Chairman
Szymczak
McKee
Davis
Draper

Mr.
Mr.
Mr.
Mr.

Morrill, Secretary
Bethea, Assistant Secretary
Carpenter, Assistant Secretary
Clayton, Assistant to the Chairnan

The action stated with respect to each of the matters herein4tter
referred to
was taken by the Board:
The
ederta).

minutes of the meeting of the Board of Governors of the

Reserve Q
LTstem held on May 15, 1940, were approved unanimously.
Letter to Mr. Martin, President of the Federal Reserve Bank
"St.
Louis,
reading as follows:
"In accordance with the request contained in your
lett
Geo
,
7
r Of May 9, the Board approves the appointment of
geniTe 1. Baggott as an examiner for the Federal Reserve
sist2! 8t. Louis, and that of Earl H. Chapin as an aspoinZt examiner. Please advise us of the dates the apents became effective, and, as requested in letter
appoi4e
8!:e fkl..rnish us with recent photographs of the

V

Approved unanimously.
Letter

to the board of directors of the "Newtown Title and
Net c m
Q-PEtnr, Newtown, Pennsylvania, stating that, subject to con4104
°r membe
rshipnumbered 1 to 6 contained in the Board's




901
2-

-

Regtilation H and
the following special condition, the Board approves
the bank's aPPlication for membership in the Federal Reserve System

d

the appropriate amount of stock in the Federal Reserve Bank

ot
Philadelphia:
"7.

S'ach bank shall make adequate provision for dePreciation in its banking house and furniture and
fixtures."
The letter also contained the following special comments:

It appears that the bank possesses
certain powers
Which
eal1 are not being
exercised and which are not necesbILY required
in the conduct of a banking and trust
ci:'1188s, such as the power to act as surety in certain
it:ceuzastances. Attention is invited to the fact that
ex,
,
th, bank
desires to exercise any powers not actually
be —clisad at the time of admission to membership, it will
88rY under condition of membership numbered 1 to
obtilee"
ex 8i11 the
pernission of the Board of Governors before
etni
!
ising them. In this connection, the Board underco-"us that
there has been no change in the scope of the
orlTrate Powers exercised by the bank since the date
'
48 application for
membership."
Approved unanimously, together with
a letter to Mr. Sinclair, President of
the Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia,
reading as follows:
:Me Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve Sys-P
the application of the 'Newtown Title and
tilqest Proves
company?,
Newtown, Pennsylvania, for membership in
Pre P
ee.clieral Reserve System, subject to the conditions
in the enclosed letter which you are requested
Two -rward to the
Board of Directors of the institution.
is fr,
e°Pies of such letter are also enclosed, one of which
to r-r Your files
and the other of which you are requested
or p°rWard to
the Secretary of Banking for the Commonwealth
elliasylvania for his information.




702
5/16/40
-3-"In submitting the application Mr. Hill recommended
hat
'no Special conditions of membership be prescribed in
view of the
fact that the managing officer of the bank had
assured the Reserv
e Bank that upon admission to membership
Pj°vision would be made for the estimated losses shown in
p4e report
of examination as of March 30, 1940, and that a
lirr n as to provision for depreciation in banking house
ar
rniture and fixtures had been agreed upon. Accordthe usual condition regarding elimination of losses
yos not been prescribed. It is assumed, however, that
,2"
011
.1ill satisfy yourself that provision has been made for
vrinating losses
in accordance with the assurances given.
, 1-1
.1-1-e the usual
condition regarding provision for depreciai
rliblzking house and furniture and fixtures has been
you will note that the condition is general
ts terms
and is not inconsistent with the program
greed Upon.
th
It is assumed that you will follow the matter of
ore 1,11ank's revising its certificate of deposit form and
ti 111-Lso bringing into conformity with the Board's regula,,,°ns the savings
accounts listed on page 16 of the report
ex
amination.
tir..:
On Page 17 of the report the examiner states that
is
c)r Sidney F. Tyler is a partner in a concern which
rio,ctonsidered to be primarily engaged in the issuance,
icoa underwriting and sale of stocks and bonds,
Which
co
rel
ationship, in the examiner's opinion, will be
ActrarY to the
provisions of Section 32 of the Banking
thatc), 1933 upon the bank's admission to membership, and
;
ords
rs Tyler is to resign as a director of the bank in
thai. to
correct the situation. It is assumed, of course,
-v You will
11 follow the matter to a conclusion. Please
48e the
ad
'
co
Board of the steps which are taken in this
4rlection.”

Ii

Letter to the
board of directors of the "Sulphur Springs State
8111Phur Springs,

7

Texas, stating that, subject to conditions of

13 elbsrehiP numbered
1 to 3 contained in the Board's Regulation H and
th_
tollomitig

special condition, the Board approves the bank's appli-

etIti°4 rOh" members
hip in the Federal Reserve System and for the approqttte sr
acillit of
stock in the Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas:




b/16/40
-4ft4
.

Such bank shall make adequate provision for dePreciation in its banking house and furniture and
fixtures."
Approved unanimously, together with
a letter to Mr. Gilbert, President of the
Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas, reading
aS follows:
tea "The Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve Sys13641013Pr°vas the application of the 'Sulphur Springs State
Sulphur Springs, Texas, for membership in the Feder„0
ttaserve
System, subject to the conditions prescribed
in
to ne enclosed letter which you are requested to forward
of "
4
Board of Directors of the institution. Two copies
filsuch letter are also enclosed, one of which is for your
to n and the other of which you are requested to forward
"vs C
ommissioner of Banking for the State of Texas for
-48
information
bank,"It is assmmed that you will follow the matter of the
tio,8 bringing into conformity with the Board's regula0
,'Ls the
time deposits listed on page 16(1) of the report
are
mination."
MaMorandwm dated May 10, 1940, from Mr. Smead, Chief of the
'111810/1 of
Bank
operations, recommending that Form F.R. 105, call reor
e°11diti0n of State member banks, be amended in the manner in°11 the Copy of
the form attached to the memorandum.

The memo-

lb"d11111"ed that all of the proposed changes were of a minor nature
:
4d1'4*e stIggssted merely in
the interest of clarity and that it was
-1/ci rstood th,.L
*1-- c
made by the Comptroller
or the c‘trren_y orresponding changes would be
tozte

c

and the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation in the

,Atite Of e"1 reports required of national banks and insured nonmember
l'esPectively.
The proposed changes were approved
Unanimously.




704
5/16/40
_5Letter to

Mr. Upham, Deputy Comptroller of the Currency, read-

1118 118 fOliows:

"This refers to your letter of May 3, 1940, inquiring whether a
loan made by the Liberty National Bank,
Weatherfo
rd, Oklahoma, to the wife of Mr. C. H. McBurneY,
President of such bank, is in violation of section 22(g)
of the
Federal Reserve Act.
42 "It appears
that Mrs. McBurney has a net worth of
12000 and that she does some business in her own name,
or conve
nience the husband and wife keep most of
their
p
funds in a joint account. It also appears that
l'eeident McBurney, durin the examinatio
g
n of the bank,
Paid one loan
of $1000 made to his wife and that he has
lid the
interest on the :2500 obligation of Mrs. McBurney.
The
Eaeminer concludes that the loan in question was made
meLthe accammodat
ion of her husband, while President
dia"uu
„'
4 rneY states that the loan was not made for his inbenefit. Although it is not so stated, it is
lit;s11111ed that
President McBurney is not legally liable in
nlanner in connection with the loan.
Boa :In view of
the conflicting statement of facts, the
Thar'
4 is reluctant to take a defin
ite position in this case.
10 mere fact thet
the husband paid the interest on the
waas
ail.f,in question is not conclusive evidence that the loan
rect r his accomodation and, on the other hand, the
oint that
the wife has rather substantial assets in her
havenelue does not neces
sarily mean that the loan may not
that been for the accommodation of her husband. We hope
reachY°1-1 will appreciate
our difficulty in attempting to
we d a definite concl
usion in cases of this kind where
it tcli not have ready acces
s to all of the details involved
fiea
,
e transaction and the statement of the executive ofaPPears
inconsistent with the conclusion of the exthet%'
:
1 For Your guidance, however, in view of the fact
in havIle Wife of the executive officer has separate assets
the ar °wn name sufficient to justify the loan and upon
with .rumPtion that
he is not legally liable in connection
that l',
1!.e loan, it
is not clear in the opinion of the Board
goa "ge t
/TN,ransaction was in violation of the law or the
t egIllation O."

t




Approved unanimously.

705
5/16/40
-6Letter to Mr. Paddock, First Vice President of the Federal Rese e
-.. of Boston, reading as follows:
clo:This refers to your letter of May 2, 1940, with en14_ -"res, regarding the applicability of the Clayton Act to
Frederick
H. Tarr, who is president and director of The
R"kPort National Bank, Rockport, Massachusetts, and a di!!ctor of the
Gloucester National Bank of Gloucester,
uloucester, Massachusetts.
It is
understood that the 'City of Gloucester' con11t
4ilt ee; an incorporated political subdivision of a county;
its Population is approximately 24,000; that its total
ti-;
1 e i8 aPproximately thirty-six square miles; that within
area are several distinct settlements or communities
thout
corporate boundary lines; that among them is a cornknown also as Gloucester, the area of which is about
i:vn-eighths of a square mile and the population of which
1.8 7'000; and that the Gloucester National Bank of Gloucester
"")cated in this
community. It is understood that the
el:11.112r Rockport' constitutes an incorporated political
tat;T".sion of a county; that its population is approxie
3,600; that its total area is approximately four
taerit
;
e miles; that within this area are two distinct settle- or co—__
mmunities without corporate boundary lines; that
111,:a°f them is a
community known also as Rockport, the
the °f which is less than one-fourth of a square mile and
The 113,.°Pul8-tion of which is approximately 2,600; and that
it i'"kPort National
Bank is located in this community.
or tisi s180 understood that, although the corporate limits
'Cit.? incorporated political subdivisions known as the
zul4
t of G
loucester' and 'Town of Rockport' touch, the cornare las known also as Gloucester and Rockport, respectively,
the L
E few miles distant from each other, thus presenting
or tration
whether exception numbered (5) of section 8
With ZI,ClaYton Act is applicable to Mr. Tarr's services
banks named above.
Pears FromI'
the information which you have submitted it apco„ that
the distance between the business centers of the
84Zaities known
as Gloucester and Rockport, where the rekiles;v4a.,benks are located, is slightly in excess of four
ratizati '
41.St the distance between the edges of the two cankiles es °n their nearest sides is slightly more than three
is
that the territory within this three mile section
Pract eAl
1
Y unsettled since, owing to the topography




706
5/16/40
_7
Cape Ann, practically all of the settled areas in the
.region are along the coast; that the principal industry
c)f Gloucester is the canning and preserving of fish,
where:
8 Ro ckport is principally a residential town; that The
,'"kPort National Bank has fifteen depositors who are residents Of the
'City of Gloucester', but that these accounts
;
4 re Of long standing and constitute accounts of people,
r"rlY residents of Rockport, who subsequently moved to
h'c/uc'st er; that the Gloucester National Bank of Gloucester
4%s
'
xtY savings depositors who are residents of the 'Town
:ockport', the majority of wham either reside in the
Pigeonl
Cove canmunity or are employed in the community of
'oucester; and that, although the whole of Cape Ann is a
resort by reason of which both Rockport and Gloucester
07,11,!fit from the simmer tourist trade, it is the opinion
IletAu". Loeffler,
vice president of the Gloucester National
:
e
of Gloucester, that the people (including to a large
„.,0Brat the
summer tourists) residing in the 'City of Gloucester'
its
various communities transact their banking business
Gloucester and the people residing in the communities of
Pi
ee°n Cove and
Rockport transact their banking business in
llockport.

j

kxati "Chi the basis of the foregoing, it appears that the sitrespectPresented in this case is similar, in its essential
s, to that discussed in the Board's letter of February
of (
.24° (S-205) to
President Young regarding the 'Towns'
sai;'"-lford and Dover-Foxcroft, Maine, wherein the Board
sectithat it 'is of the opinion that the word "town" in
such °n 8 of the Clayton Act does not refer to a "Town"
Nniteil
l Guilford, and that the question whether two comadiee'
such as those ... discussed are "contiguous or
Int" is similar to the question which would be presslat
:
stat;
-bin the case of two unincorporated villages in another
case- "aving a different system of subdivisions. In such a
eilvs; unless the two
coullaunities were, geographically, a
cipre community
... it would be necessary to apply the prinINhett8 stated in
footnote 8 of Regulation L for determining
4:r or not
two places are "adjacent".'
the c Acc
ordingly, the Board sees no reason to differ from
1n
reached by your counsel that the communities
Gloucester and Rockport are not 'contiguous or adjaB Of
thin the meaning of exception numbered (5) of section
"a ClaYton Act, and that such exception is applicable




707
5/16/40
-8”to the services
of Mr. Tarr as president and director of
Rockp rt National Bank and as director of the Gloucester
onal Bank of Gloucester."




Approved unanimously.

Thereupon the meeting adjourned.

eta.

Chaitman.