View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

A meeting of the Federal Reserve Board was held in the office of the
Federal Reserve Board on -lednesday, Mirch 5, 1924, at 11:05 a.m.
P3=: Governor 2rissin,;.er
Mr. Platt
Mr. Hamlin
Mr. Miller
Mr. Cunningham
Mr. 3ddy, Secretary
file minutes of the meeting of the ...ledert...1 Reserve Board held on
March 4th wore read and approved as amended.
The Governor then presented v letter dated March 4th from Mr. 7;alter
Stewart tendering his resignation as Director of the Division of Research
and Statistics, to
become effective not later ',Jinn May 1,
lkoon motion by Mr. Hamlin this ma-,ter was laid
on the table.
1.1r. Cunningham then stated that he had studied the ';alley proofs
of the
Annual Report and that he has no serious objection to any part of
it although he
felt that the fo1lowin7 sentences in the chapter on Federal
aesorve Discount Policy were a rarotition of preceding statements and might

wal

be eliminated:
" It is its responsibility to regulate the flaw of now and
additional credit from its reservoirs in accordance with solid
indications of the economic needs of trade and industry."
" It seems clear that if business is undergoing a rapid
expansion and is in danger of dcveloping an unhealthy or speculative
boom, it should not be assisted by too easy credit conditions. In
such circumstances the creation of additional credit by rediscountiflr at Federal reserve banks should be discouraged by increasing the
cost of that credit - that is, by raising the discount rate. It seems
efually obvious that if industry and trade are in process of recovery
after a period of reaction, they should be given the support and encoura3
,oment of cheaper credit by the prompt establishment at the Federal reserve banks of rates that will invite the use of Fedei-al reserve
credit to facilitate business ro3overy."




1,70 action taken.

3/5/24

The Governor then announced that the special order of business for
this morning's meet in

would be the nutter chi' inclusion in the Annual Re-

port of articles re-;ardine; branch bankin; and the separate statin: of reserve reties on note and deposit liabilities.
2he Governor reiterated the statement nr..de l

him at the reeetin; on

Llarch 4th that he had talked with the Secretary regarding the suggested
explanation in the 2,nnual Report of the proposal to state ce:•arately the
note and deposit reserve ratios in the weekly consolidated statement, and

that vthile the 3ecretary worroved of the plan in principle, he did not
believe that it would be expedient to make any announcement regarding it
at the present
time.
The Board then discussed the action which should be taken, in the
:ht of the
position of the Secretary of the Treasury as nude lmown to it
1),. the lovernor.
Hamlin moved that the chapter on "Statement of Reserve Position"
be amended by
striking out the following:
"In view of important differences between the affects of changes
in note circulation and in deposits on the reserve ratio, and in view
Of the nranner already discussed in which a demeni for currency arises
out.of and follows upon an antecedent growth of credit, the board has
decided to publish separate reserve ratios for Federal reserve notes
and for deposits. Beginning with the year 1924 the consolidated statement of condition or the 12 'Federal reserve banks will show each 7.-eek
the position of the note reserve and of the deposit reserve in the
iorm Of two reserve ratios, namely, a note reserve ratio and a deposit
reserve ratio. In the computation of these ratios the note reserve
is arrived at by adding the gold held with the Federal reserve agents
coll:teral against Federal reserve notes outstanding and the gold
in the redemption fund with the Treasury which constitutes, in accord, nee with
the law, the reserve against 2edereel reserve notes. The
dePesit reserve consists of ;old in the gold settlement :Auld with
the Pederal Reserve Board and gold and lawful money in the vaults of




3/5/24 ,

"the Federal reserve banks. The law provides that the '
gold in vault and in the gold settlement fund may be counted,
at the option of the banks, either as reserve against deposits
or against Federal reserve notes. The deposit reserve ratio
is computed on the assumption that the barks, on the date of
the statement, have elected to count this gold as deposit reserve.
The items entering into the composition of the note reserve and
;he deposit reserve have been shown in the statement of condition
of the reserve banks from the beginning, but totals of the separate
reserves have rot been carried in the statement. The new form of
statement will dhow 'total reserves against Federal reserve notes'
and 'total reserves against deposits'. The Board is of the opinion
that the publication of these totals and of the separate note and
deposit reserve ratios is in accordance with the spirit of the
Federal reserve act, which prescribes different reserve requirements
against notes and against deposits. The act provides that 'every
Federal reserve bank shall maintain reserves in .;old or lavreal money
of not less than 35 per centum against its deposits and reserves in
cold of not less than 40 per centum against its Federal reserve notes
in actual circulation'. The statement of the reserve position of the
Federal reserve banks in the form of separate note and deposit reserve
ratios is no innovation, but a return to the method adopted by the
board Immediately following the important amendments to the Federal
reserve act of June 21, 1917, and continued during that year. It is
the belief of the board that those two separate ratios will give the
public a clearer picture of chances in the reserve position of the
Federal reserve system and of the factors responsible for those changed.
Ur. Miller suggested that this mould leave this section of the report
With an unsatisfactory ending
and asked Mr. Hamlin if he would be willing to
accept the
fAlowin; to be added to the concluding sentence of the paragr4h
Preceding the one he wished to have omitted:
"and does not give a clear picture of changes in the reserve
position of the Federal Reserve System and of the factors
responsible for those dhanges."
ar..Hamlin stated that he would.
Thereupon




after discussion, the motion being put by the chair was

3/5/24

-.4..

voted upon is follows:
Mr, Hamlin, "aye"
.Mr. Mill or, "aye"
Mr. Cunningham, "aye"
Governor Crissim;er, "no"
Platt, "no'
IMPORTS OF STArDING 001 MITLS;
Recommending action on application for fiduciary powers as
set forth in the Auxiliary Minute Book of this date.
Approved.
Dated, March 4th, Recommending approval of the application of Mr. Sealy
Hutchings to serve at the same time as Member of the firm of
Hutchings, Sealy & Company and as director of the South
Texas National Bank, both of Galveston, Texas.
Approved.
Dated, March 4th, ilecommending approval of the application of Mr. N. 0. Stein
to serve at the same time as director of the South Texas
National Bank and as Member of the), private banking firm of
Hutchings, Sealy & Company, both of Galveston, Texas.
Approved.
Dated, March 4th, ,lecommending approval of the application of Mr. John Sealy
to serve at the same time as Member of the firm of Hutchings,
Sealy & Company and as a director of the South Texas rational
Bank of Galveston, Texas,
Approved.
D
Dated, March 4th, Recommending approval of the application of Er. eorge Sealy
to serve at the same time as director of the South Texas
National Bank and as a member of the firm Of Hutchings, Sealy &
Company, both of Galveston, Texas.
Approvea,
Dated, barch 4th, R
- ecommending approval of the application of Mr. Julian H.
Schermerhorn to serve at the same time as director of the
First National Bank of JerseyCity, N.J., as director of
the New Jersey Title Guarantee & Trust Corm ny, also of
Jersey City, N.J.
Approved,

Dated, March 5th,

A

stin

A
pproved:

jie
JA




Gaverno

adj

ed at 1:05 p.m.