View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

519
A meeting of
the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve
SYstem.

was held in Washington on Saturday, March 21, 1942, at 11:30

a•Pa.
PRESENT:

Mr.
Mr.
Mr.
Mr.

Eccles, Chairman
McKee
Draper
Evans

Mr.
Mr.
Mr.
Mr.

Morrill, Secretary
Bethea, Assistant Secretary
Carpenter, Assistant Secretary
Clayton, Assistant to the Chairman

The action
stated with respect to each of the matters herein—
after
referred to was taken by the Board:
The minutes of
the meeting of the Board of Governors of the
Peder
ad
'Reserve System held on March 20, 1942, were approved unani—
Mously.
Memorandum
dated March 16, 1942, from Mr. Goldenweiser, Di—
of the
Division of Research and Statistics, recomnending that,
-"all8e of approaching
confinement, Mrs. Kathryn S. Faulkner, a clerk
ill that Division, be granted leave of absence without pay from May 6
(when her
accumulated and current accrued annual and sick leave will
have been
exhausted) through the middle of October 1942. The memorandum
stated that,
in accordance with the Board's policy on confinement
ea.8e8
adopted November
10, 1941, Mrs. Faulkner informed Mr. Golden—
Ilei8er more
than five months before her expected confinement, that
The
clise'ntinued work at the close of business on March 15, 1942,
f°11r
months prior
to the expected confinement, and that the three—month




520
3/21/42

-2-

Pellod of
absence following confinement should end about the middle
of
October 1942. The
memorandum further stated that Mrs. Faulkner's
case would be
reviewed at the end of the period of leave of absence
and an appropriate recommendation made to the Board, and recommended
that the Board
continue its contributions to the retirement system
0/Ibehalf of Mrs.
Faulkner during the period of leave of absence without Pa7 Provided
she continues her own contributions during the same
Period.

Approved unanimously.
Memorandum dated March 16, 1942, from Mr. Goldenweiser, Director 0.r.
1. the
Division of Research and Statistics, recommending that
1418' Ca
therine M. Counts, a clerk in that Division, who has been on
lea:" of absence since
September 16, 1941, because of confinement,
be ellanted an

additional leave without pay from March 16, 1942, through

413111 15
'1942, and that during the additional leave the Board conto make its contributions on her behalf to the retirement sys41 with the

understanding that she will continue her own contributione during
the period.
Approved unanimously.
Or

Letter to Mr.
Leach, President of the Federal Reserve Bank
chmond
, reading as follows:
lett "In accordance with the request contained in your
of March 16,
1942, the Board approves the appointMent-er
- of Robert L. Miller as an assistant examiner for




521
3/21/42

—3—

"the Federal
Reserve Bank of Richmond.
us of the
effective date."

Please advise

Approved unanimously.
Letter to Mr. Davis, President of the Federal Reserve Bank of
St. Louis,

thee

reading as follows:

"The Board of Governors approves the changes in
Personnel classification plan of your Bank as rein your letter of March 14, 1942."
Approved unanimously.

Memorandum dated March 20, 1942, from the Division of Security
14ans) reading

as follows:

. "There is
attached a list of the automobile ap,71841 guides which it is recommended that the Board
cp.gnate for purposes of Regulation IV, showing in dethe exact
territory for which it is recommended
each guide or each edition be designated.
Fed "There are
also attached a proposed letter to the
n,eral Reserve Banks, a proposed press release, and prosed letters
notifying the guide book publishers as to
boe
d 8°ard i s decision. The letters to the publishersemth Y the
requests that it is proposed to make regarding
dee.nlanner in which the publishers may announce their
saslgnations,
and some other requests that seem necesr7 regarding
details,
ge4.'These
recommendations follow substantially the sugsmi;3v:°fls made in the memorandum dated March 6, from Mr.
and Mr. Dembitz to Governor Ransom, with the exc?pha -,8
noted beim:. The substance of these recommendations
pr
:
sbeen discussed with Mr. Cravens, and he has not exwith any of them.
tO b It will be observed that the proposed press release
det,:,18sued by the Board is relatively brief, with full
It -Le to be
obtainable from the Federal Reserve Banks.
11414:i
lls Proposed that the matter of public announcement be
deta d in this way because a press release giving full
be '
1 8 of all designations throughout the country would
unduly long.

T




522

3/21/42

-4-

"It is recommended (with Mr. Cravens' concurrence)
that the
their de Board request the publishers not to announce
signations except in the manner specified in the
ttached proposed letters, but that the Board refrain
Irom prescribing the exact -wording of the publishers'
ouncements. The measure of flexibility obtained in
hle way seems essential, especially in view of the differences in
the publishers' set-ups, and it seems unlikely
at
anY publisher -- knowing that his designation is
la.uuject to termination at any time -- will abuse this
llebility. In case the Board wishes, however, to prescribe the exact
wording of the publishers' announcements,
a have prepared a draft of a form for this purpose which
we
e can submit if desired.
"It is proposed that the Board's designations of all
aPPraisal guides be limited to their quotations for used
?ars of
1935 and later models. This is proposed in order
that the
maximum credit value of a car of 1934 or earlier
will be 66-2/3 per cent of the cash purchase price -'Without
requiring that the 'appraisal guide value' limita,;:°n be applied to such old cars. Reasons for this proused
exception include the fact that average price quotathoseor older models are necessarily less accurate than
flo
on the later cars, the fact that application of the
rule to very old cars would result in down payment rebetterof 50 per cent and more on an old car in much
than average condition, and certain other technical
as°ns as set forth on page 23 of the March 6 memorandum.
dif "Each respect in which the designations now proposed
in fer from those recommended in the March 6 memorandum
dev?Ives a proposal that the Board refrain from giving a
slCnation in a case
where further information has reied that a particular guide has little or no circulaa°11 to automobile dealers in the territory involved. The
mesee Involving significant differences from the March 6
morrldum are as follows:
'1. It is not recommended that the 'Official Autamobile
co
e Guide,
published by the Recording and Statistical
rPoration be
given any designation at this time. Further
a sis since March 6 has indicated that the general
lel
anarj
than of quotations in this publication is somewhat higher
ar'n had been
indicated in the March 6 memorandum, and we
p114!"°1d by the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago that this
has -cation, compiled primarily for the insurance business,
arid * negligible' circulation among automobile dealers
th instalment
lenders. As to circulation figures by states,
e co
rporation wrote:

n

T




523
3/21/42

-5-

"'Our list of subscribers is limited to 500600 subscribers, who may take anywhere from
one to three thousand annual subscriptions.
All of the large . . . Insurance Companies operate in more than one State, . . . so that we
do not know just
where they send the books,
since we send them all of their books in one
shipment for distribution.'
"2. The memorandum of March 6 suggested that the
Board •
might refrain from designating the 'Blue Book-ExelItivs
l
Edition' for the State of Texas, on the ground
veat the
circulation of this edition was believed to be
4r:T
the prices quoted by it tended to be congher than those quoted by other publications
higher
l'
s°1
'which
designation in Texas was proposed. For the
frae reason it is now recommended that the Board also refrom designating this publication for the State of
asnrsota. On 15 out of the 29 models which we analyzed
nes:,selple, this edition quoted higher prices for MinerO
than the extreme western portion of the
'
alIgLe) than
either the Market Record or the N.A.D.A. guide,
thl °lir inquiries as to circulation details revealed that
st;s
t edition
has a circulation of only 9 copies in the
Other
editions of the same publisher are recomMende.
e for designation for Texas and Minnesota.
and N '
3 For the states of Montana, Wyoming, Colorado,
in
ew
CO, analysis indicated that the prices quoted
in Zue 'Blue Book-Executive Edition' were higher than those
he N.A.D.A.
the
guide and the Market Record on 26 out of
cule. ? models
used as a sample. Study of the detailed cirthei,1,211 figures given us by the publishers indicates that
a
'led Book and Blue Book-Editions A and B (which quote
higinewhat lower level
of prices) have a considerably
4lit?I
'circulation in those states than the Executive
and .1
t,°n- It is therefore recommended that the Red Book
sta
, he Blue Book-Editions A and B be designated for those
state
a
and that the
Executive Edition not be given such
esi
gnation."

il

The list of automobile appraisal
guides referred to in the memorandum
was as follows:
'




524
3/21/42

-6-

Name of
Guide and
b
MARKET ANALYSIS
REPORT,
published by Used Car
Statistical Bureau, Inc.

AMRICAN AUTO APPRAISAL,
Published by Automobile Reference and Appraisal Bureau
OFFICIAL laSCONSIN AUTOMOBILE
VALUATION GUIDE,
Published by National Used Car
Market Report, Inc., for Wisconsin Automotive Trades Ass
ociation
NEBRASKA OFFICIAL USED CAR
SURVEY,
Published by State of Nebraska
Motor Vehicle
Dealers Administration
KELLEY BLUE
Published BOOK,
by Kelley Kar Company

OFFICIAL
Published GUIDE,
by Pacific Auto Guide,
Inc.

NOR

TEST USED CAR
VALUES,
11311blished by Northwest PublishIng Company




Territory for which
publication is
designated
Connecticut
Maine
Massachusetts
New Hampshire
Rhode Island
Vermont
Michigan - Southern
Peninsula
Ohio

Wisconsin

Nebraska

Arizona
California
Idaho
Nevada
Oregon
Utah
Washington
Arizona
California
Idaho
Nevada
Oregon
Utah
Washington
Idaho
Oregon
Washington

525
3121/42

-7,-

Name of
Guide and
OFFICIAL BLUE BOOK NEW AND
USED CAR
GUIDE,
Published by National Used
Car Market
Report, Inc. -A EDITION

B EDITION

BLUE BOOK
NATIONAL USED
CAR MARKET
REPORT -EXECUTIVE EDITION,
Published by National
Used Car
Market Report,
Inc. -"Retail sales values"
for Zone No. 1




Territory for which
publication is
designated

entire United States
except the states of
Arizona, California,
Idaho, Nevada, Oregon,
Utah, Washington
entire United States
except the states of
Arizona, California,
Idaho, Nevada, Oregon,
Utah and Washington and
the following ten counties of Michigan:
Genesee, Jackson, Lapeer,
Livingston, Macomb,
Monroe, Oakland, St.
Clair, Washtenaw, Wayne

Connecticut
Delaware
District of Columbia
Maine
Maryland
Massachusetts
New Hampshire
New Jersey
New York
Pennsylvania
Rhode Island
Vermont
Virginia

526
3/21/42
-8Name of
Guide and
b ishe
BLUE BOOK
NATIONAL USED
CAR MARKET
REPORT -EXECUTIVE EDITION (Continued)
"Retail sales values"
for Zone No. 2

"Retail sales values"
for Zone No. 3

"Retail sales values"
for Zone No.
4

"Retail sales values"
for Zone No.
5




Territory for which
publication is
dsiiated

Alabama
Arkansas
Georgia
Louisiana
Mississippi
North Carolina
South Carolina
Tennessee
Illinois
Indiana
Kentucky
Michigan (Southern
Peninsula, except
the following ten
counties: Genesee,
Jackson, Lapeer,
Livingston, Macomb,
Monroe, Oakland, St.
Clair, Washtenaw,
Wayne.)
Ohio
West Virginia
Florida
Iowa
Kansas
Michigan - Northern
Peninsula
Missouri
Nebraska
Oklahoma
Lisconsin
North Dakota
South Dakota

527
3/21/42
Name of
Guide and
blishe
BL
BOOK NATIONAL USED
CAR MARKET
REPORT -EDITION
(Cont
inued)
"Retail sales values"
for Zone No. 6

RED BOOK
NATIONAL USED CAR
MARKET REPORT,
published by National
Used Car
Market Report,
Inc.

MARKET RECORD,
Pu
blished by Market
Record, Inc. -D
ISTRICT 1 EDITION




-9Territory for which
publication is
designated

Arizona
California
Idaho
Nevada
Oregon
Utah
Washington

Same as territory designated for Official
Blue Book New and Used
Car Guide - B Edition

Connecticut
Delaware
District of Columbia
Illinois
Indiana
Kentucky
Maine
Maryland
Massachusetts
Michigan (except
the 10 counties
for which District
3 Edition is designated)
New Hampshire
New Jersey
New York
Ohio
Pennsylvania
Rhode Island
Vermont
Virginia
Nest Virginia

528
3/21/42

-10-

Name of
Guide and

iggilet-Eliii76:11-1;17ed)
DISTRICT 3 EDITION

Territory for which
publication is
esiiated
...

DISTRICT 5 EDITION

DISTRICT 7 EDITION

D
ISTRICT 9 EDITION

n
OFFICIAL USED CAR
GUIDE,
Published by National Automobile Dealers
Association -DISTRICT
B EDITION .........




Following 10 counties
in Michigan -- Genesee,
Jackson, Lapeer, Livingston, Macomb, Monroe,
Oakland, St. Clair,
Washtenaw, Wayne
Alabama
Arkansas
Florida
Georgia
Kansas
Louisiana
Mississippi
Missouri
North Carolina
Oklahoma
South Carolina
Tennessee
Texas
Colorado
Iowa
Minnesota
Montana
Nebraska
New Mexico
North Dakota
South Dakota
Wisconsin
Wyoming
Arizona
California
Idaho
Nevada
Oregon
Utah
Washington

Connecticut
Delaware

529
3/21/42
-11Name of
Guide and
he
N.A.D.A. OFFICIAL USED
CAR GUIDE
(Continued)
DISTRICT B EDITION (Continued)

D
ISTRICT EF EDITION

D
ISTRICT G EDITION




Territory for which
publication is
designated

District of Columbia
Maine
Maryland
Massachusetts
New Hampshire
New Jersey
New York
Pennsylvania
Rhode Island
Vermont
Virginia
Lest Virginia - following 8 counties:
Berkley, Grant, Hampshire, Hardy, Jefferson, Mineral, Morgan,
Pendleton
Alabama
Arkansas
Florida
Georgia
Louisiana
Mississippi
Tennessee
Following county in
Texas - Bowie.
Illinois (except the
southern section for
which the J Edition
is designated)
Indiana
Following 4 counties
in Iowa -- Clinton,
Dubuque, Jackson,
Scott
Kentucky
Michigan - Southern
Peninsula (except the
10 counties for which
the S. E. Michigan Edition is designated)

530
3/21/42

-12-

Name of
Guide and
P1-422-1-ahar_
N.A.D.A. OFFICIAL USED
CAR GUIDE
(Continued)
DISTRICT G EDITION (Continued)

S. E. MICHIGAN EDITION

DISTRICT
H EDITION

DISTRICT J
EDITION




Territory for which
publication is
desigriated

North Carolina
Ohio
South Carolina
Lest Virginia (except the 8 counties
for which the District B Edition is
designated)
Following 10 counties in
Michigan -- Genesee, Jackson,
Lapeer, Livingston, Macomb,
Monroe, Oakland, St. Clair,
Washtenaw, Layne
Michigan -- Northern
Peninsula
Minnesota (except the
15 counties for which
the District K Edition is designated)
Wisconsin
Illinois -- Section
south of and including following counties:
Adams, Cass, Champaign,
DeWitt, Logan, Menard,
Piatt, Schuyler, Vermilion
Iowa (except the 4
counties for which
the District G Edition is designated)
Kansas
Missouri
Nebraska (except the
12 counties for which
the District K Edition
is designated)

531

3/21/42

-13-

Name of
Guide and
h
R.A.D.A. OFFICIAL USED
CAR GUIDE
(Continued)
DISTRICT J EDITION (Continued)

DISTRICT K EDITION




Territory for which
publication is
desimated

Oklahoma
Following 5 counties
in South Dakota: Bon
Homme, Charles
Clay, Union, Yankton
Texas (except Bowie
County and the 6
counties for which
District K Edition
is designated)
Colorado
Following 15 counties
in Minnesota: Big Stone,
Clay, Kittson, Lac qui
Parle, Lincoln, Marshall,
Norman, Pennington, Pipestone, Polk, Red Lake,
Rock Traverse, tilkin,
Yellowmedicine
Montana
Following 11 counties
in Nebraska -- Banner,
Box Butte, Cheyenne,
Dawes, Deuel, Garden,
Kimball, Morrill,
Sheridan, Scotts Bluff,
Sioux
New Mexico
North Dakota
South Dakota (except
the 5 counties for
which the District
J Edition is designated)
Following 6 counties in
Texas -- Brewster, Culberson,
El Paso, Hudspeth, Jeff
Davis, Presidio
Utah
Wyoming

532

3/21A2
-14Name Of
Guide and
blisher
N.A.D.A. OFFICIAL USED
CAR GUIDE
(Continued)
DISTRICT L EDITION

DISTRICT 0 EDITION

Territory for which
publication is
destmated

Arizona
Following 11 counties
in California: Imperial,
Inyo, Kern, Los Angeles,
Orange, Riverside, San
Bernardino, San Diego,
San Luis Obispo, Santa
Barbara, Ventura
California (except
the 11 counties for
which the District
L Edition is designated)
Idaho
Oregon
Washington

.
In accordance with the recommendatlons contained in the memorandum and effective April 1, 1942, the current and
subsequent editions during the remainder
of 1942 of the automobile appraisal guides
as shown in the list were designated by
the Board, as provided in Part 3 of the
Supplement to Regulation W, with the understanding that the designation was subject to revocation as to any guide at any
time. The draft of letters to the Presidents of the Federal Reserve Banks and
the guidebook publishers and the proposed
press statement submitted with the memorandum were approved unanimously, the
letter to the publishers reading substantially as follows:
hed"The
Board has included
, pubautomobile
the
8
bY
among
4PPraisal guides
designated for use for purposes of Regulation W in
the States of




533
3121/42

-15-

"(Thi
-8 Paragraph to be varied as necessary for publishers
""0 publish more than one edition.)
"This
(date)
is to apply to the
edition(s) designation
of
during
the reand,
(name of guide)
Illainder of the year 1942, to subsequent ..r,11onthly)
editions,
Loimonthl )
but is subject to revocation by the Boara
at any ime.
mai "It is assumed that the issues published during the render of the year 1949 will he similar in form to the issue(s) of
p
and that the basis on which the
retail
Prices quoted are determined will be generally
s'"-L-Lar to the basis of the retail prices quoted in the
ate
issue(s). If your organization decides
tO make
any
substantial change in form or basis, or to
ll
,angc your schedule of publication dates, it is suggested
"at You notify the Board in advance.
b_. "The Board's designations of all appraisal guides are
anng limited to their quotations for used cars of 1935
.1,
1 later
models. The maximum credit value of a car of
or earlier
model -- in the absence of designated 'apce:'teal guide values' for such cars -- will be 66-2/3 per
"of the bona fide cash purchase price, and there will
be.
.4.. no objection to
your pointing out these facts in conneculon
zodele '" any values that you quote for 1934 and earlier
publ."It is requested that your organization refrain from
or
elselehing any statement (in
(name of guide)
th Ilhere) to the effect that such publication is among
3(11e designated by the Board for the purposes of Part
oeftattt
ation W unless such statement is accompanied
dL?'
b
of equal prominence to the effect that such
to !eation does not indicate any finding by the Board as
the -e accuracy or correctness of the prices shown or of
sticLmethods of compilation. It is also requested that any
1)110 statement as to this designation appear inside of the
of 4-i-cation rather
than on an outside cover. It is assumed,
eQuree, that you will avoid making any statement (in
'de
or in any advertisement, cirei;tr, letter, or
other material) that would improperly
that your prices or methods of compilation have
tes
o found t0
be correct by the Board or by the United
Government or by any other agency thereof, and that
use your best efforts to prevent any such mis-F4'Tntation by others.
It 13 also suggested that your publication, if it




534
3/21/42

—16—

n.
includes any notice that it is among those designated for
Purposes of Regulation W., include also a statement indicatin
gterritory for which it is designated and the dates
Ithin which the particular issue is in effect.
"It is noted that the
issue of your
(date)
Publicationdes
states that the values shown for the various
may be increased somewhat if the particular car is
equiPPed with a radio or heater. The 'estimated average
retail values' to be used for purposes of Regulation Wpould be values without any such additions for cars havtng a radio or heater, and it is suggested that your statement
regarding such extra equipment be accompanied by the
f°rmation that such additions should not be included in
.termining maximum credit values for purposes of Regulation
Your publication also specifies an amount that may be
a
.s dded for cars with overdrive or automatic transmission
cot; extra
equipment; there is no objection to the inclusion
, such amount in determining maximum credit values for
pur °ses
13
of Regulation W. (This paragraph to go only to
Publishers who recommend adding for radios or heaters.)
"In the event that you desire that any change be made
in the terms
of designation or in the requests outlined
above, the Board will be glad to give consideration to
any s
uggestions or proposals that you may wish to submit.
'There is enclosed for your information a copy of a
ilirress release which the Board is issuing for release on
23.11

P

Telegram
to the Presidents of all Federal Reserve Banks, reading
4 follows:

vi "In order to assist the Board in determining the adG sabllity of regulating open credits under Regulation W,
:
12 17ernor Ransom has formulated the questions set forth
t_ °17. He would like to have your opinions in response
beenthese questions independently of the views that have
si
received from those engaged in the trade. It Is ashowever, that you will wish to discuss the matter
17e hln Your own staff before formulating your opinions.
th aPpreciate the fact that your opinions, as well as any
lilact we may have, are not necessarily final but would
,
e Your judgment at this time. If you will mall or wire
yo
"1" answers so as to reach the Board not later than next




535
3121/42

—17—

"Thursday, it
will be greatly appreciated.
"1. Do you think open credits (including open book
accounts and
similar non instalment credits) should be
regulated to any extent under Regulation W? Answer yes
or no.
"2. If your answer is yes, which of the following
or
guments have influenced your conclusion, indicating
those
which are the most important in your mind.
A. To prevent evasion of regulation;
B. To more nearly equalize the regulation
of consumer credit between those now subject to
Regulation W and those obtaining and extending
Other forms of credit;
C. To round out the regulation of consumer
credit by covering an important field not now
regulated, thus making more effective the ma—
of Regulation V; for future use;
D. To contribute to the fight on inflation
by
reducing the amount of credit extended on pres—
ent and
future listed articles;
E. To lessen the diversion of materials and
skills from war purposes by dampening consumer de—
mand for present and future listed articles;
F. Through determent of unnecessary purchases,
to
build up a backlog of savings to aid the Govern—
'Rent in
financing the war and to accumulate purchas—
ing
power for use when production for war purposes
-Lessens;
G. To support the efforts of other Governmental
agencies to
curb consumer demand through more direct
methods of control such as taxation, priorities,
l'ati°ninE, price control, etc., and thus possibly
Contribute some assistance particularly to the lessen—
rlg of the
difficult problems of rationing and price
control.
(If the foregoing list does not cover the ground
adequately in your opinion, state any other arguments
whoh have influenced your conclusion.)
If your answer is no, which of the following argu—
nients
ar_
ave influenced your conclusion, indicating those which
the more
important in your mind.
A. Administrative difficulties.
B. Trade reaction.
C. Public reaction.
p.cot
r mt dislike of selective or direct
credit




536
3/21/42

-la-

"E. Unsatisfactory results so far from regu1ating consumer credit.
F. Belief that better results can be produced
in curbing consumer demand by action on the part of
Other Governmental agencies, e.g., taxation, priorities, rationing, price control, etc.
G. Belief that some other agency, not the Federal Reserve System, should regulate consumer credit.
H. Belief that all outstanding consumer credit
18 in process of being reduced regardless of regulation.
I. Belief that the disturbance of normal busiess processes would more than offset any possible
benefits.
(If the foregoing list does not cover the
ground adequately in your opinion, state any other
rguments which have influenced your conclusion.)
4. If your answer to Question Number One is yes,
state in
ci
„A.
substance your idea of the types or kinds of
ts that should be included within the regulation.
Boa '5. Assumi,
ng for the sake of discussion, that the
yo
,
rd should regulate such credits, indicate the order of
t41; preference among the following possible methods of conthat or any combination of them (adding any other methods
YOU may think should be considered):
A. Requiring the same cash down payment on any
or future listed article that is required by
the regulation
when such article is covered by ins6alment sale credit.
B. Requiring some particular percentage down
Yment in cash on any article (whether listed or un_lsted) sold on open credit. If you favor this plan,
°I.Iggest the percentage figure that seems appropriate
at this time.
, C. 'Freezing' an existing account, that is, de:Ling further credit for (a) listed articles or (b) for
t
e1.7
1 article whether listed or unlisted (1) whenever
e:
1 e is a charge in such account for a listed article Which has remained unpaid for a specified period or (2) whenever there is a charge in such account,
?ether for a listed or unlisted article, which has
emained unpaid for a specified period.
This plan might work as follows: If there were
an
Unpaid item in the account for (a) a listed article
or (b) any article, the merchant having such account

r




537
3121/42

-1911

on his books could not extend further credit to
such customer until the account was paid in full.
In this connection please consider the question
Whether the denial of further credit should apply
also whenever there is a default in an instalment
sale credit of the same seller or whether the denial of further credit should include the denial
new instalment sale credits, as well as additions to the existing account. If you favor such
a plan state which of the alternatives you prefer.
Also please consider how the account might be 'unfrozen!, as, for example, by payment in full or
by
converting it into an instalment credit with
an appropriate down payment.
D. If you favor plan C, in some form, indicate what period you would specify before the account is frozen and when that period should begin.
Suggestions as to length of period which have been
received range from 15 to 120 days.
E. Requiring a certain percentage of every
°1371 book credit to be paid monthly. (Suggestions
Which have been received have varied from one fifth
to one half). Mat percentage would you suggest?
P. If you favor some other plan or some variat.
1°11 or combination of the foregoing plans, please
°utline its substance here, and give briefly your
reasons.
"6. Since there are many possible ways of stating argunio_ents pro and con and plans for dealing with the subject
012,en book
credit, we would not wish the foregoing to be
arsidered as representing any preconceived conclusions or
th rePresenting any attempt at perfection of statement and
poi
el'efore we hope that you will feel free to add at this
ttan-Y" comments, suggestions or preferences that you
rtia,,n,
tf", 'ink would be helpful in rounding out the considerasiV of the entire problem. In this connection please conand indicate whether your answers to any of the ques'
a 118 would be materially influenced by the possibility of
04ubstantial
increase in the number of listed articles
those
now
covered by the regulation, to include soft
goo8
ev
°ds and goods with relatively small unit values."
Approved unanimously.
Letter




to the Director of the Mint, Treasury Department, reading

538
3121/42

-20-

"Reference is made to your letter of March 11, 1942,
the cooperation of the Federal Reserve System,
as Part of the war effort, in returning to the coinage
mints empty coin bags as they accumulate from time to time.
"A copy of your letter is being sent to all Federal
Reserve Banks and we are sure that they will continue to
:00perate with your office in this matter to the fullest
c:5tent. Incidentally, a number of Reserve Banks forwarded
circulars to their member banks regarding the return of
pItY coin bags after receiving Mr. Julian's letter of
donee ruary 23,
1942, requesting advice as to what might be
in the matter of recovering coin bags from member
1,_
uanks and
other financial institutions."
re

Approved unanimously, together with
a letter to the Presidents of all Federal
Reserve Banks transmitting copies of the
above letter and the one under reply.




Thereupon the meeting adjourned.

eertat,
Secretary.

Chairman.