View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

The attached set of minutes of the
Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve
System on December 11, 1958, has been amended
at the request of Governor Robertson to mAkt.
certain changes on pages 7 and 10.
If you approve these minutes as
amended

please initial below.

Governor Szymczak
Governor Mills

Minutes for

To:

Members of the Board

From:

Office of the Secretary

December 11, 1958

Attached is a copy of the minutes of the
of the Federal Reserve System on
Governors
Board of
the above date.
It is not proposed to include a statement
with respect to any of the entries in this set of
minutes in the record of policy actions required to
be maintained pursuant to section 10 of the Federal
Reserve Act.
Should you have any question with regard
to the minutes, it will be appreciated if you will
advise the Secretary's Office. Otherwise, if you
were present at the meeting, please initial in column A below to indicate that you approve the minutes.
If you were not present, please initial in column B
below to indicate that you have seen the minutes.
A
Chm. Martin
Gov. Szymezak
Gov. Mills
Gov. Robertson
Gov. Balderston
Gov. Shepardson x




x

3660
on
Minutes of the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System
Thursday, December 11, 1958.
PRESENT:

Mr.
Mr.
Mr.
Mr.

The Board met in the Board Room at 10:00 a.m.

Szymczak, Acting Chairman
Mills
Robertson
Shepardson
Sherman, Secretary
Kenyon, Assistant Secretary
Hackley, General Counsel
Masters, Director, Division of Examinations
Molony, Special Assistant to the Board
Solomon, Assistant General Counsel
Hexter, Assistant General Counsel
Hostrup, Assistant Director, Division of
Examinations
Mr. Nelson, Assistant Director, Division of
Examinations
Mr. Davis, Assistant Counsel

Mr.
Mr.
Mr.
Mr.
Mr.
Mr.
Mr.
Mr.

Request of Mrs. Hoffman.

Mr. Hackley reported that late yesterday

he received a telephone call from Mr. O'Kane, General Counsel for the
Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco, who had discussed with President
Matigels the request of Mrs. Claire Giannini Hoffman, referred to at
Yesterday's meeting of the Board, for an opportunity to appear before

the Board in connection with the pending application of Firstamerica
C°rPoration under the Bank Holding Company Act.

Mr. O'Kane had not yet

8c/tten in touch with Mrs. Hoffman because he thought it would be highly
irregular for her to appear before the Board, even if not in private,
114lees she first submitted a statement of the reasons for which she
14Etrxted to appear.

Mr. O'Kane suggested that, having acted as Associate

13°4rd Counsel at the hearing on the Firstamerica Corporation matter, he
Illight call upon Mrs. Hoffman and obtain from her a statement for the
130ard's use.

He also stated that President Mangels would call Governor

SzYmezak on the telephone at 11 a.m. today, EST.




12/11/58

-2-

Mr. Hackley said it appeared that what Mr. O'Kane had suggested
Would accomplish about the same purpose as the procedure the Board agreed
UPon yesterday except that Mrs. Hoffman would be asked to include in her
request an indication of why she wanted to appear or the substance of
what she wanted to say.
Discount rates.

Unanimous approval was given to a telegram to

the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco approving the establishment
Without change by that Bank on December 10, 1958, of the rates on
discounts and advances in its existing schedule.
Application of Union Trust Company of Maryland.

The Union

Trust Company of Maryland, Baltimore, Maryland, had applied through
the Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond for permission to establish a
branch at York and Timonium Roads in Baltimore County.

In January 1958

the Board had approved a branch for Union Trust Company at a location
about two miles north of the site now proposed but the bank had been
114able to obtain a zoning regulation which would permit the
establishment of the branch.

The proposed new site had been protested

by The Towson National Bank, principally on the grounds that its existing
branch in a nearby location had not yet had time enollEh to become firmly
established and that there was not sufficient banking business in the
area for two bpnking facilities.

While the Federal Reserve Bank of

Richmond recommended approval of the application of Union Trust Company,
4

representative of the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency

claPPorted the position of The Towson National Bank.

The file on the

matter had been circulated to the members of the Board.




3662
12/11/58

-3-

view
Governor Robertson said he saw considerable merit in the
expressed by the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency.

He urged

careful consideration of the matter and noted the desirability of
relating
Preserving good interagency relations in the area of problems
to branch bank applications.
primarily
Governor Mills suggested that the case should be decided
in the light of the facts of the application, including competitive
conditions in the area where the branch was proposed to be established.
It was difficult for him to believe that the question of competition
between branches of two existing banks was important enough a consideration
to deny the application, especially where the application had the approval
of the State banking authorities and the favorable recommendation of the
Richmond Reserve Bank.

Therefore, he would favor approval of the

aPplication.
After some further discussion of procedure, Governor Robertson
suPPlemented his earlier comments by saying that he regarded this as a
Close case, one that it might be well to explore further.

He would not

Ifant to go against the recommendation of the Reserve Bank and the action
Or the
State authorities if it could be avoided.

It might be found that

the development of the national bank's branch and the development in
size of the community would warrant allowing the competition that would
be afforded by the branch of the Union Trust Company, but he would like
view.
to have the Federal Reserve Bank explore the case from that point of




12/11/58

-4-

Governor Shepardson noted from the file a statement of the
Federal Reserve Bank to the effect that there was a growth potential
of the area which would seem to warrant another banking facility in
the near future.

On that basis, he said, he would be willing to act

favorably on the application.
However, in view of the desire of Governor Robertson that
further information be obtained from the Richmond Reserve Bank, it
Iges agreed to defer action on the application until such information
was available.
Items circulated or distributed to the Board.

The following

iteMs, which had been circulated or distributed to the members of the
I)°ara and copies of which are attached under the respective item
ratibers indicated, were approved unanimously:
Item No.
Idetter to The Peoples-Liberty Bank and Trust Company,
,
1 °vIngt0n, Kentucky, approving the establishment of a
y,"'I'anch at 407 Dixie Highway, Elsmere, Kenton County,
ientucir—
(For transmittal through the Federal Reserve
4.11k of Cleveland)

1

Ir ter to The First National Bank of Barrington, Barrington,
approving its application for fiduciary powers.
kror transmittal through the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago)

2

tatter to the First Bank and Trust Company of Utica, Utica,
1/ York, approving the establishment of branches in Rome,
1 13 1, Herkimer, and Middleville, New York, incident to a
;Z°Posed merger of The Farmers National Bank of Rome and
First National Bank and Trust Company of Herkimer with
!
rid into First Bank and Trust Company of Utica under the
IfiTi title of Marine Midland Trust Company of Mohawk Valley.
\ror transmittal through the Federal Reserve Bank of New York)

3

7:




12/11/58

_5_

In connection with the foregoing Item No. 3, Governor Robertson
said his favorable vote reflected the fact that all of the banks involved
were already subsidiary banks of Marine Midland Corporation and that the
merger therefore would represent simply a realignment of the holding
c°mPany's internal organization and structure.
Application of The Northern New York Trust Company.

The Northern

4ew York Trust Company, Watertown, New York, had submitted through the
Federal Reserve Bank of New York an application for approval of the
establishment of a branch in Saranac Lake, New York, incident to a
Proposed merger with the Adirondack Nationnl Bank and Trust Company
Saranac Lake.

A memorandum from the Division of Examinations,

aistributed to the Board under date of November 24, 1958, indicated
that both the Division and the New York Reserve Bank recommended
favorable action on the branch and that the merger had been approved
by the New York State Banking Board.
Mr. Molony reported having received telephone calls within the
Past few days from Mr. Roger Tubby, the editor of a newspaper in
Saranac Lake, who reported that local parties were interested in
I'etaining the bank in Saranac Lake under local control if possible,
eIld inquired whether there would be time for those parties to explore

the matter further. On the basis of the comments made by Mr. Tubby,
14r. Molony, who at the time was not familiar with the application of

The Northern New York Trust Company, assumed that this might be a
Matter coming before the Board under the Bank Holding Company Act




rItZ
iZ
ji

12/11/58

-6-

and advised Mr. Tubby of the usual procedures followed in bank holding
ccmPany cases.

Mr. Tubby had indicated that he would forward a letter

Presenting further information about the situation but no such letter
had been received by Mr. Molony up to the time of this meeting.

Mr.

MolonY inquired whether the Board would be willing to defer action on
the

application until he had had an opportunity to get in touch with

11r. Tubby and advise him correctly concerning the circumstances under
Which the
branch application was being made to the Board.
After Messrs. Masters and Nelson summarized the actions
already taken by the parties concerned with respect to the proposed
merger, Governor Mills expressed agreement with them that the case
should be decided on its merits without delay, although Mr. Molony
should of course explain to Mr. Tubby that a branch application
incident to a merger was involved rather than an application under
the Bank Holding Company Act.

Governor Mills pointed out that there

had been
rumors of the impending transaction for a long time and one
might expect that people in the local community would have had ample
°PPortunity to act.

He said that it would be his judgment to accept

the recommendation of the Division of Examinations and approve the
branch application.
Governor Robertson expressed a somewhat different view as to
the Procedure that should be followed.

He said that although nothing

r4iEht come of the efforts reported by Mr. Tubby, nevertheless Mr.




„1,1--Tr )4, •

12/11/58
Tabby, as a citizen of the community, had attempted to contact the
Board about a week ago, had inadvertently been furnished certain
misleading information, and appeared to be attempting to get money
together with which to maintain an independent bank in the community.
After noting that Saranac Lake was a fairly sizable community-for a
one-bank town, Governor Robertson said that if citizens of the town
desired to retain an independent bank, they should have the right to
take the effort within a reasonable length of time.

In all the

circumstances, he would not wish to act today, but rather to hold
the matter over until next Monday.
Governors Szymczak and Mills expressed concern that information
e°11veyed by

Mology to Mr. Tabby might give the latter the impression

that if there was any possibility of attracting capital to retain control
Of the local bank, the Board would be likely to make its decision
accordingly.

Governor Mills said that the question whether action on

the application was deferred until Monday was inconsequential, but
that he would have great doubt about indicating to Er. Tubby that the
Board might be so influenced in its decision by the possibility of
maintaining an independent bank as to interfere with developments that
had really reached the decisive stage.

Governor Shepardson concurred

14 these views.
Mr. Hexter then suggested that a possible way of handling the
Matter would be for Mr. Molopy to call Mr. Tubby to straighten out a




366
12/11/58

-8-

misunderstanding, without saying anything about the Board having
considered the branch application. Mr. Molony could simply say that
from his knowledge of the Board's affairs, the branch application
wee likely to come before the Board for decision early next week.
That would give Mr. Tubby time to do something about the matter if
he so desired.
Following further discussion, it was agreed that the matter
would be handled on the basis suggested by Mr. Hexter, with the
understanding that the branch application would be put on the agenda
for the meeting of the Board on Monday, December 15.
Mr. Molony then withdrew from the meeting.
Application of Northwest Bancorporation.

Northwest

Bancorporation, Minneapolis, Minnesota, had applied pursuant to
section
3(a)(2) of the Bank Holding Company Act for the Board's prior
approval of the acquisition of 1,085 of the 1,200 outstanding shares
°I
'capital stock of The First National Bank at Eveleth, Eveleth,
llinmesota.

Two memoranda from the Division of Examinations had been

distributed to the Board, both under date of December 8, 1958, along
With a memorandum from the Legal Division dated December 9, 1958.
Like the Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis and the Comptroller of
the Currency.
, the Division of Examinations recommended that the
application be granted. While the proposed acquisition would give
Northwest Bancorporation a large proportion of deposits of individuals,




12/11/58

-9-

partnerships, and corporations in Eveleth and in the cities of Eveleth,
Gilbert, and Virginia combined, it was the Division's opinion that
co nsummation of the transaction would not be inconsistent with adequate
and sound banking, the public interest, or the preservation of
competition.

It was the opinion of the Legal Division that, while

there appeared to be no compelling reason either for approval or
disapproval, approval of the application would be sustained by the
courts as a
proper exercise of the Board's discretion.

At the same

tlme it was regarded as unlikely that disapproval would be considered
bY the courts as an abuse of the Board's discretion.
Using as a basis the information compiled in the memoranda
from the Division of Examinations, Mr. Hostrup commented on the facts
Of the application, with particular reference to the statutory factors
l'equired to be considered pursuant to section 3(c) of the Bank Holding
C°mpany Act.

Mr. Hackley then reviewed the information and opinions

c°ntained in the memorandum from the Legal Division.
Governor Mills stated that he concurred in the recommendation
clf the Division of Examinations although in his opinion this
was one
of the closest cases yet to come before the Board under the Bank
R°1ding Company Act.

The effect of approval of the application would

be to leave competition in the three-city area represented by three
gr°uPs, including two holding companies.

In his view, however, the

"InP•
etitive picture would continue to be such as to justify not
c)biecting to the proposed transaction.




36I
12/11/58

-10-

Governor Mills noted that Northwest Bancorporation proposed to
Purchase the shares of 25 of the 39 shareholders of the Eveleth bank
and inquired as a matter of information whether the remaining
Shareholders would have an opportunity to dispose of their shares on
the same
basis.
Comments made in reply by Messrs. Hostrup and Hexter indicated
that the offer had been limited to 25 shareholders because certain
rulings of the Securities and Exchange Commission under the Securities
Act of 1933 prevented making the offer to more than that number of
Shareholders under the terms of a "private offering."

It had been

reported by the applicant that at a meeting of the shareholders of
the Eveleth bank no objection was interposed by the iL remaining
Shareholders.

However, it was not known by the Board's staff whether

it would be possible for Northwest to pick up the remaining shareholdings
at later dates.
Governor Robertson said that he too regarded this as a very
Close case because of the control already exercised by Northwest
Bancorporation in the area concerned and the further control it would
obtain by virtue of this transaction.

However, on the basis of the

facts In the memoranda from the Division of Examinations
he did not think
there was sufficient basis for the Board to deny the application.
Thereupon, tentative approval of the application was given
bY unanimous vote, with the understanding that the Legal Division




3670
12/u/58

-11-

Would prepare for the Board's consideration as promptly as possible
a notice of tentative decision and a tentative statement.
Applications of The Michi an Bank (Item No. 4).

On December 8,

1958, the Board decided to reaffirm its decision of August 20, 19.58,
aPProving the establishment of two branches applied for by The Michigan
Bank, Detroit, Michigan, on condition that prior to establishment of
the branches the capital structure of the bank would be increased by
not less than $1 million through the sale of additional common stock.
A letter to The Michigan Bank had been drafted for the purpose of
carrying out the Board's action of December
8, and copies thereof were
diatributed prior to this meeting.
In response to questions raised by members of the Board, Mr.
Solomon said that the staff had two thoughts in mind in preparing the
letter. First, it had in mind that inasmuch as the matter had been
reconsidered twice by the Board, it seemed desirable to go into some
detail in order to indicate the thoroughness of the Board's
"nsideration.

The staff also had in mind that the Board's decision

Probably would result in litigation. While it appeared unlikely that

the matter could be terminated without litigation, one possibility
'
"uld be to impress upon The Michigan Bank that the Board was going to
stand by its position and that it
would insist on having brought into
the record in any litigation the reasons why the bank's stockholders
Ilere averse to the issuance of additional common stock.




4-1

12/11/58

-12-

Governor Robertson then suggested certain changes in the
language of one of the paragraphs of the draft and it was agreed that
those changes would be incorporated in the letter in its final form.
Governor Robertson also suggested that the staff consider
Whether it would be feasible to include in the letter some reference
to the fact that the subject bank had continued to experience growth
°f its deposits since the date the branch applications were first
considered and that even the proposed amount of additional capital

mielt, be insufficient to capitalize the bank adequately at the present
ti". Secretary's Note: After careful consideration of this suggestion,
the staff concluded against the advisability of including statements to
such effect in the letter.
A copy of the letter sent to The Michigan Bank is attached as

Major medical insurance contract.

Governor Shepardson stated

that agreement had now been reached on the detailed provisions of the
18°ard's contract with Prudential Insurance Company of America for
r1°11°°oupational employee and dependents major medical expense insurance,
Which

became effective November 17, 1957, that both the Legal Division

44d the Personnel Division were satisfied with the wording of certain
endorsements that had been attached to the policy relating to premiums,
elceePtions, and limited coverage for certain retired employees and
qUalified dependents, and that the insurer had asked that the Board




12/11/58

-13-

forma1ly indicate its acceptance of the contract and the said
endorsements.

Governor Shepardson went on to say that he had

reviewed the contract and the endorsements, and unless there was
objection on the part of the Board he would send a letter to
PrUdential stating that the Board had authorized the Secretary to
execute the contract on behalf of the Board.
No question being raised, it was understood that Governor
8hePardson would send the proposed letter.
Stock market credit.
the

It was noted that in accordance with

understanding at the meeting on November 20, 1958

further study

Of the operating difficulties that might be encountered through
stricter withdrawal and substitution rules under the Board's margin
regulations was being held in abeyance pending completion of arrangements
tor the study pursuant to discussion of the subject by Chairman Martin
'4th the President of the New York Stock Exchange.

The suggestion was

Inade that it would be helpful to the Board if members of its staff
vOUld review, in the light of recent developments in the market, the
latest information concerning trends in the use of stock market credit.
T418 suggestion contemplated such a report by the staff at a meeting
Of the Board next week.
The meeting then adjourned.




Secretary's Note: Governor Shepardson today
approved on behalf of the Board the following
items:

t".!
t

12/11/58

-14-

Memorandum dated December 9, 1958, from Mr. Young, Director,
Division of Research and Statistics, recommending an increase in
the basic annual salary of Carolyn Beck, Editorial Clerk in that
Division, from $4,135 to VOW, effective December 14, 1958.
Letters to the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago (attached
Items 5 and 6) approving the appointment of Robert C. Burton,
wl ham Seitz, Jr., and Gordon L. Wold as examiners and the
!
IpPointment of Thomas C. Crays, Richard G. Johnson, Mendal C.
mearkle, and David F. Popp as assistant examiners.




c-•?,
-

3674
BOARD OF GOVERNORS
OF THE

FEDERAL RESERVE SYSTEM

Item No. 1
12/11/58

WASHINGTON 25, D. C.
ADDRESS OrFICIAL CORRESPONDENCE
TU 1HE BOARD

December 11, 1958

Board of Directors,
The Peoples-Liberty Bank and Trust Company,
Covington, Kentucky.
Gentlemen:
Pursuant to your request submitted through the
Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland, the Board of Governors
of the Federal Reserve System approves the establishment
bY The Peoples-Liberty Bank and Trust Company of a branch
at 407 Dixie Highway, Elsraere, Kenton County, Kentucky,
Provided the branch is established within six months from
the date of this letter, and approval of the State
authorities is effective as of the date the branch is
established.




Very truly yours,
(Signed) Kenneth A. Kenyon

Kenneth A. Kenyon,
Assistant Secretary.

BOARD OF GOVERNORS
Item NO. 2
12/11/58

OF THE

FEDERAL RESERVE SYSTEM
WASHINGTON 25, O. C.

ADDRESS OFFICIAL CORRESPONDENCE
IL) 1HE BOARD

December 111 1958

Board of Directors,
The First National Bank of Barrington,
Barrington, Illinois.
Gentlemen:
The Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System

has given consideration to your application for fiduciary

Powers and grants you authority to act, when not in contravention of State or local law, as trustee, executor, administrator,
registrar of stocks and bonds, guardian of estates, assignee,
receiver, committee of estates of lunatics, or in any other
f.duciaL-y capacity in which State banks, trust companies, or
otdher corporations which come into competition with national
banks are permitted to act under the laws of the StaLe of
Illinois, the exercise of all such rights to be subject to the
provisions of Section 11(k) of the Federal Reserve Act and
Regulation F of the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve
System.
A formal certificate indicating the fiduciary powers
'which The First National Bank of Barrington is now authorized to
exercise will be forwarded to you in due course.




Very truly yours,
(Signed) Kenneth A. Kenyon
Kenneth A. Kenyon,
Assistant Secretary.

,Pr-1

BOARD OF GOVERNORS
OF THE

Item No. 3
12/11/58

FEDERAL RESERVE SYSTEM
WASHINGTON 25. D. C.

ADDRESS OFF ICIAL CORRESPONDENCE
TO I tiE BOARD

December 111 1958

80ard of
Directors,
1111,..rEit Bank and Trust Company of Utica,
v'ica, New York.
Oentlemen
:
Pursuant to your request submitted through the Federal
t
sIerve Bank of New York, the Board of Governors of the Federal
c erve System approves the establishment by First Bank and Trust
:
12 461.11V of Utica, Utica, New York, of branches at the following
'cations:
133 West Dominick Street, Rome, New York,
853 Black River Boulevard, Rome, New York,
Main Street, Remsen, New York,
160 North Main Street, Herkimer, New York, and
Southeast corner Little Falls and Fairfield Streets,
Niddleville, New York.
This consent is given provided:

(1) The proposed merger of The Farmers National Bank of Rome,
Rome, New York, and The First National Bank and Trust
Company of Herkimer, Herkimer, New York, with and into
First Bank and Trust Company of Utica, Utica, New York,
under the charter of the latter and new title of Marine
Midland Trust Company of the Mohawk Valley, Utica, New
York, is effected substantially in accordance with the
Flan submitted to the Federal Reserve Bank;
(2) Shares of stock acquired from dissenting shareholders are
disposed of within six months from date of acquisition;

(3)

The branches are established within six monthscf the date
of this letter; and

CIO

Formal approval of the State authorities is obtained.




Very truly yours,

(Signed) Merritt Sherman
Merritt Sherman,
Secretary.

BOARD OF GOVERNORS

ouiiti:40*4

OF THE

e
,
591V *44
:
r

FEDERAL RESERVE SYSTEM
go

.4*

Item No.

4

12/11/58

WASHINGTON 25. D. C.
ADDRESS OFFICIAL CORRESPONDENCE
TO THE BOARD

AIR NAIL

December 11, 1958

Mr. John C. Hay, President,
The Michigan Bank,
Detroit,
Michigan.
Dear Mr. Hay:
This is with further reference to the application of The
Michigan Bank for approval of the establishment of a branch at or
Tnear the southwest intersection of Eight Mile Road, East, and Kelly
LIQad, and a branch at the southwest corner of Murray Hill Road and
Eight Mile Road in Detroit, Michigan. This application was the
.
,.lbject of the Board's letters of August 20, October 20, and
lovember 4, 1958, as well as of meetings on September 5 and November 24, 1958 between representatives of the Bank and the Board of.

Governors.
The Board's letter of August 20, 1958 granted approval
for the establishment of the proposed branches, subject to three
.?riditions. One of these conditions was that "prior to the estab-!-1shmerit of
the branches the capital structure of The Michigan Bank
10 lncreased by not less than 1.,000,000 by the sale of additional
common stock."
At the meeting on September 5, 1958 representatives of
Y°11r Bank urged that this condition be changed so that it would profor the sale of $1 million of additional preferred stock. Upon
beeonsideration in the light of all relevant circumstances, the Board
its letter of October 20, 1958 advised your Bank that the Board
21 again reached the conclusion that approval of the branches would
be warranted without the sale of at least 1 million of common
stock.
By further correspondence, and at the meeting on November 24,
1958, your Bank urged a second reconsideration of the condition. Pur8
r allt to that request, the Board has again carefully weighed all the
levant aspects of this matter. It has considered, among other things,
further information, proposals and arguments presented in your letters
'
fld at the meeting on November 24, including your contention that the

j




BOARD

14r. John C. flay

OF GOVERNORS OF THE FEDERAL RESERVE SYSTEM

-2-

Federal Reserve Act and Regulation 11 require the Board, in passing
laP°11 applications for branches, to limit its consideration to the
amoUnt of the applying bank's capital and to disregard the nature
of that capital.
In that connection your counsel referred to the fourth
Paragraph of section 9 of the Federal Reserve Act, 12 U.S.C. 322,
/113.ch comes immediately after the paragraph regarding approval of
branches,
and which states that:
"In acting upon such applications the Board of
Governors of the Federal Reserve System shall consider the financial condition of the applying bank,
the general character of its management, and whether
or not the corporate powers exercised are consistent
With the purposes of this Act."
It will be seen that this states that the Board "shall"
e°nsider these factors. It is also to be noted that one of the
!
UrPoses of the Federal Reserve Act, as set forth in the Act's
Preamble, is: "... to establish a more effective supervision of.
banking in the United States...."
These provisions, particularly the reference to "the financial
e°ndition of the applying bank", require the Board to give consideration
c)'the capital structure of the applying bank. Such consideration, to
r realistic, necessarily must include analysis of both the amount and
e nature of the applying bank's capital in relation to the other
1!}evant circumstances of the particular case. The provisions of Reguion II in conformity with the law, are consistent with this requirement.

r

130.41

As the Board stated in its letter of October 20, 1958 to your
With respect to preferred stock your Bank proposes to issue:
"... it is true that preferred stock issued by
a bank is part of the bank's capital structure, but it
is also recognized that preferred stock is substantially
different in nature from common stock. The differences
include the claim, in fact if not legally, of preferred
stock on bank earnings, problems connected with undue
separation of control from investment in the institution,
and problems preferred stock may create later in connection with necessary flotation of additional stock....




irin
.

John 0. ijaY

:t

-3-

Th^ question of whether approval should be granted for a
Particular State member bank to establish particular branches can be
decided only upon consideration of all aspects which the Federal Re."'" Act requires the Board to consider, including the probable conof any preferred stock in the bank's capital structure and
the
adequacy of that structure in relation to surrounding circumstances.
Accordingly careful consideration
has been given not only to the legal
81. 111ents which you have presented, but also to all the relevant circums of your particular Bank and application.
The pertinent facts show that your Bank's business has been
exPanding rapidly, as partly reflected in the A108 million your Bank
(,),14c1
depositors on June 30, 1958, and that its capital structure has
aled to keep pace with that expansion. Your Bank proposes to sell
sJa- million of preferred stock, which it is understood would be of the
.
um
!type as that your Bank already has outstanding, and it argues that
Ar4c." sale would warrant approval of the establishment of the branches.
''sr that sale of preferred stock and the issuance of a 01 million
Stock
dividend in common stock, your Bank would have t2 million of corns,, Stock and
$2 million of preferred stock, besides surplus, undivided
r
Pofits
and certain reserves.

g

The representatives of your Bank have indicated that they
%loll(
'not anticipate a large increase in deposits in the near future
grnm the proposed branches. However, they have also indicated that the
Th;n1,1_ of the Bank to the present time has greatly exceeded expectations.
ar-J "ave indicated further that the stockholders who control the Bank
al
:unwilling to purchase additional common stock of the Bank and are
or ° unwilling to have their control diminished through sale by the Bank
thic°mmon stock to others. The Board is of the opinion, however, that
re s u nwillingness does not justify approval of the establishment of the
quested branches on the basis you propose.
The Board, having carefully reconsidered this matter in the
relevant circumstances, has again reached the conclusion
bem. the expansion of your Bank branchwise would not be warranted on the
of Your Bank's proposal to sell tl million of preferred stock.
,s,
A cerl
ruingly, the Board reaffirms the conditions upon which it approved
you;
aPplication to establish the branches.

light
that of




Very truly yours,
(Signed) Merritt Sherman
Merritt Sherman,
Secretary.

•

3680
BOARD OF GOVERNORS
OF THE

Item No. 5

FEDERAL RESERVE SYSTEM

12/11/58

WASHINGTON 25, 0. C.
ADDRESS OFFICIAL CORRESPONOENCE
TO THE BOARD

December ill 1958

Mr. W. R. Diercks, Vice Presidents
Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago,
Chicago 90, Illinois.
Dear Mr. Diercks:
In accordance with the request contained in
Your letters of December 8, 3_958, the Board approves
the appointment of Robert C. Burton, William Seitz, Jr.,
and Gordon L. Wold as examiners for the Federal Reserve
Bank of Chicago. Please advise as to the dates upon
which the appointments are made effective.




Very truly yours,
(Signed) Kenneth A. Kenyon

Kenneth A. Kenyon,
Assistant Secretary.

BOARD OF GOVERNORS
440111.1*0

(IF

4°0(14'044.
Ot

41%

a
a'

THE

Item no. 6
12/11/58

FEDERAL RESERVE SYSTEM
WASHINGTON 25. D. C.

ADDRESS OFFICIAL CORRESPONDENCE
TO THE BOARD

tr

%,:timst

December 11, 1958

CONFIDENTIAL CEil
X. W. R. Diercks, Vice President,
Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago,
Chicago 90, Illinois.
Dear Ni'. Diercks:
In accordance with the request contained in your
letters of December 2, 1958, the Board approves the appointment of Thomas C. Crays, Richard G. Johnson, Mendal C. Mearkle,
and David F. Popp as assistant examiners for the Federal
Reserve Bank of Chicago. Please advise as to the dates upon
which the appointments are made effective.
It is noted that Mr. Crays is the son of the president
and director of The First National Bank of Rossville, Rossville,
Illinois. Accordingly, the Board's approval is given with the
understanding that he will not participate in any examination
of The First National Bank of Rossville as long as his father
is an officer or director of that bank.




Very truly yours,
(Signed) Kenneth A. Kenyon
Kenneth A. Kenyon,
Assistant Secretary.