View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

63

A meeting of the Execut lye Committee of the Federal Reserve *Board
was held, in the office of the Federal Reserve Board on Wednesday, Augtzst
49 1926, at 11:00 a.m.
PRESMIT:

PliESENT ALSO:

Governor Cris singer
Lir. James
Mr. Hamlin
Mr. Eddy, Secretary
Mr. McIntosh

Telegram dated August '.3rd from the Federal Reserve Agent at Atlanta,
recommending the appoint:neat of L:r. Claude Gilbert as Assistant Federal
Reserve Agent at the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta to conduct a constructive survey of member banks for the purpose of strengthening their
Position, with salary at the rate of ,;;10,000 per annum.
On motion by Mr. Hamlin, Mr. Gilbert was appointed
Assistant Federal Reserve Agent at Atlanta for a
temporary period, with salary at the rate of ;„;10,000
per amum.
Memorandum dated July 29th from Counsel, with regard to the application of Mr. L. H. dindholz to serve at the same time as Director of the
Virginia National Bank of Norfolk, Va., as Director of the National Marine
Bank or Baltimore, Md., and as Director of the Maryland. Trust Company of
Baltimore, Lid.; Counsel stating that it is not believed that the iiorfolk
bezik is in competition with the Baltimore banks, and that the question of
competition between the Baltimore banks is a close one in which the Board
IllaY well, in view of the position taken in previous cases, conclude that
the competition is not substantial.
On motion, the amlication of Mr. ,iindholz
to serve the three banks in question was approved.
Memorandum dated July 26th from Counsel, recommanding temporary




64
8/4/26

-2-

refusal of the applications of Messrs. C. Walter Lotte, Wilmer A. Cadmus,
George d. Renkel, and Albert H. Slater to serve upon the directorates oi the
Broadway National Bank and the National Bank of America, both of Paterson,
Nay Jersey; Counsel stating that the Federal Reserve Agent at New York
recommends that these applications be refused because, in his opinion, the
banks must be considered to be in substantial competition, and suggests if
the applications are refused that the applicants be permitted to continue
to serve on the boards of both banks until the end of the year in order
to avoid any abrupt termination of the existing relationship.

Counsel in

his memorandum suggests that, in accordance with the usual practice, if the
Board is not not

on or before August 23rd that the applicants desire to

present additional facts, the applications be considered to be definitely
refused.

Counsel in his memorandum also calls attention to letter dated

LIarch 26th from the Federal Reserve Agent at New York in connection with
these applications, suggesting the advisability of reviewing the situation
concerning interlocking directorates between banks in Paterson with the idea
cf revoking permits previously granted because of existing competition between
the banks.
On motion, it was voted to temporarily refuse
the applications referred to, such refusal to become definite on August 23rd if the Board is not
previously advised that the applicants desire to
present additional facts, and to postpone action
on that part of Counsel's memorandum suggesting
the advisability of revoking certain permits previously granted to serve banks located in Paterson,
New Jersey.
The Secretary then presented a memorandum dated August 3, 1926, from
the Board's Chief Telegraph Operator, advising that Raymond Burrows, messenger




65
8/4/26

in his office, was offered. and accepted a position outside of Washington, and
recommending that he be dropped from the rolls of the Board as at the close
Of business July 31, 1926; the Secretary requesting authority to employ a
messenger to fill the vacancy, with salary at the rate of 00 il)r month.
On motion, the recommendation contained in the
memorandum was approved, and the Secretary was
authorized to employ a messenger to fill the vacancy
with salary at the rate of c,350 per month.
Governor Crissinger stated that while ta conversation over the telephone
With Deputy Governor Harrison of the Federal Besexve Bank of New York on
another matter, he had discussed with him the present money maiket and. the
relation thereto of the present New York rediscount rate. The Governor
Stated that he had advised. Mr. Harrison that in his opinion the New York
rate should be raised at this time, vhich action might put the bank in a
better position to consider a lover rate later on when the crops began moving.
He stated that he had called hr. Harrison's attention to the falling off in
the amount of brokers' loans as reported to the Board weekly and. expressed
the view that the stock market was being financed by commercial banks, not
through the brokers, but by direct loans made to the brokers' customers.
The Governor stated that he felt that there was a manifestation of a spirit
Of optimism thrcughout the country which might develop a condition difficult

to control, and that in his opinion the raising of the New York rate at this
time would. do no harm to the business or commercial interests, but would have
a beneficial psychological effect on the speculative interests.

The Governor

stated that he had later been advised. by Deputy Governor Harrison that at an
info =al meetirg of the New York directors yesterday, there was some discussion
Of the advisability of raisix




the New York rate and it developed that the

66
8/4/26 ,

-4-.

directors were divided on the question.

He stated that Deputy Governor

Harrison advised him that another meeting would be held tamorrow at which
the matter would. be discussed.

The Governor also stated that he received

another telephone call from Deputy Governor Harrison yesterday afternoon
and was advised that the question had been discussed by the officers of
the bank who felt that it would be beneficial to them and to the directors
at their meeting tomorrow to have before than an expression of the views
Of the Board on the question of the advisability of raising the New York
rate at this time.
At this point, Dr. Goldenweiser, Acting Director of the Board's
Division of Research and Statistics, entered the meting and stated to the
Board that he was of the impression that the money rate situation as it
exists in New York now is not in itself indicative of a necessity for a
Change in the New York bank rate. He stated that the acceptance rate is
sliEbtly below the discount rate arid that the commercial raper rate is a
full half of one per cent above.

The Director stated that all available

evidence indicates, however, that there will soon be a rise in both of these
rates, because of the approaching seasonal demand for credit and currency.
He stated that such an advance almost always appears at this time of the year
44a is more certain to occur this year than last because of the increase in
the loans of the commercial banks.

He stated that he believed it .to be de-

sirable to increase the New York rate at this time in order to assume leadership.

He stated that the growth of credit has been very large for two years,

and that the volume of credit has maintained its present level since the beginning of the year, without the usual mid-year slump, the growth being in both




_ 67
8/4/26

-5-

security loans, in commercial loans and in investments.
called attention to the increase

Dr. Goldenweiser

fh the total of security loans made by mem-

ber banks and the decrease in the loans made by Neu York banks to brokers,
as reported to the Board. He stated that in view of the activity and volume
Of business on the exchange, this indicated to him that much of the borrowing was being done by the brokers' customers direct from the banks, rather
than through the brokers. He stated that market prices of securities after
the slump in March of this year have recovered practically all they had gone
Off, and a great many stocks are now at their highest point.

He called at-

tention to the volume of actiVity on the exchange, which has been running
very high again. He stated that since this is the second year of high speculative activity the situation, in his opinion, is more serious than it has
been because the present advance in the market came on top of a year of active
Speculation. He stated that business sentiment is very optimistic now and
all misgivings shown in April, 'march and May seem to have disappeared, and
the general tone of business sentiment is OMB that in his opinion comes close
to "boom psychology". He stated that production and trade are in very large
volume, but there are indications, at least in two basic industries, of an
accumulation of surplus stocks - building and automobiles.

He stated that

some
while there was still a large volume of building activity, there was
indication of a decline.

He stated that wholesale and retail trade evidence

stated
a large volume of business with some reduction in prices. He also




68
8/4/26

-6-

that in view of the continued large volume of production and the fact that
the purchasing power of the consumer is likely to be somewhat below last
year's, it is probable that there will be a growth in the accumulation of
stocks, and that a slump in business would result in a more serious situation
now than a year ago.

He called attention to the fact that the general price

level has been declining for some time and that the decline has been for the
most part in non-agricultural commodities, with a slit rise in the general
agricultural list due principally to the upward movement of wheat and livestock.

In the past few weeks, he stated, live-stock prices have declined.

He statea tint in his opinion ;lien the business situation is considered in
connection with the credit situation and the growth of speculative activity,
a move in the direction of higher discount rates appears to be desirable.
He stated that his advices were that prevailing counter rates for borrowers
La New York City were ranging from about 40 to 5 1/2 per cent. He felt
that if the New York bank rate should go to 4 per cent, this would have no
material effect on business genarally, but would have an effect on the
lative movement in the New York narket.

Specu-

He stated that our export trade at

the present time is not as large as it has been in previous years, and that
the decline was chiefly in cotton and in grains.




Following the discussion, Lir. McIntosh suggested
that the Governor advise the New York bank that if
the directors make a recomnendation for a change upward in the rediscount rate of the bank at this time,
a majority of the members of the Board present would
be inclined to approve their recommendation.
r. James and Governor Orissinger stated that they
agreed with Mr. McIntosh's suggestion, and. Mr. Hamlin
stated that he desired to have an opportunity of studying the eituation and having the views of the directors
of the New York bank before taking any action.

41$

69
8/4/26

Dr. Goldenweiser then presented a draft of the pamphlet descriptive of
the operations of the Federal Reserve System which the Federal Reserve Bank
Of Boston proposes to distribute to mernber banks in its district and. to their
customers, which revised draft he had edited and. found a number of points
ina.dequately covered and. which editorial suggestions he recommended be oommunicated to the Boston bank.
Following discussion, 1.1r. Hamlin moved that
Dr. Goldenweiser be directed to proceed to Boston
arid communicate verbally his suggestions to the
proper officials of the Boston bank, and instruct
them to send on to the Board for its approval another
revision of the text of the pamphlet.
Carried..
RaPoRTs0F 5TDINGillcorauTT.E.E :
Dated, August`..ird, .decommeniing changes in stock at Federal Reserve Banks
as set forth in the Auxiliary Minute Book of this date.
Approved.
Dated, July 29th,
Recommsnding action on application for fiduciary powars
as set forth in the Auxiliary Minute Book of this date.
Held.
ecommending approval of the application of Mr. Fred 0.
Dated, July 30th,
Dickson for pe mission to serve at the same time as
Director of the Merchants National Bank of Indianapolis,
Ind., and as Director of the Indiana Yrust Company of
Indianapolis, Ind.
Approved.
Itec ornrn nding approval of the application of Mr. Gustav
Dated, July 30th,
H. Mueller for permission to serve at the same time as
Director and. Vice President of the Fletcher-Amerioan'
National Bank of Indianapolis, Ind., as Director ard,
Chairman of the Board. of the Madison Avenue State Bank,
Indianapolis, Ind., and as Director of the Belmont State
Bank of Indianapolis, Ind.
Approved.
Dated, August 2nd, Recommending approval of the application of Mr. C. H.
Newman for permission to serve at the same time as
Director of the Citizens National Bank, ?Inparia, Kans.,
and. as Director of the Griswold National Bank, Detroit,




Appro ved•

70
8/4/26




-8_.
The meeting adjaarned at 12:30 p.m.

Secretary.