The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.
Labour rid MateroaD Requirements s U.S. Department of Labor Bureau of Labor Statistics January 1983 Bulletin 2146 Labor and Material Requirem ent fer Federal Hylldlsig ©®©gtry©to@m U.S. Department of Labor Raymond J. Donovan, Secretary Bureau of Labor Statistics Janet L. Norwood, Commissioner January 1983 Bulletin 2146 For sale by the Superintendent of Documents, U.S. Government Printing Office Washington. D.C. 20402 - Price $4.75 Ptrsfe©® This bulletin presents the results of a survey of Fed eral building construction. It is one of a series of con struction studies conducted by the Bureau of Labor Statistics which provide detailed data on employment requirements by occupation and type of contractor and information on contract costs and material requirements. A summary of this study was published in the Decem ber 1981 issue of the Monthly Labor Review. Other published studies in the series include high ways, public housing, commercial office buildings, ele mentary and secondary schools, college housing, civil works, sewer works, private multifamily housing, pri vate single-family housing, and general hospitals. The Bureau gratefully acknowledges the cooperation of the Office of Construction Management, Public Buildings Service, General Services Administration in helping to develop the initial universe of projects. The Bureau also wishes to thank the almost 1,100 general and special trade contactors who provided information for the survey. The study was prepared in the Bureau’s Office of Productivity and Technology by John G. Olsen under the supervision of Robert Ball in the Office of Produc tivity and Technology, Jerome A. Mark, Assistant Com missioner. Karen I. Horowitz of the Office of Economic Growth assisted in the development of offsite employee hour estimates. Material in this publication is in the public domain and may, with appropriate credit, be reproduced with out permission. 0©nt®nts Page Chapter 1. Introduction............................................................................................................... Scope of survey.......................................................................................................................... Survey methods.......................................................................................................................... Nature of the industry................................................................................................................ 1 1 2 2 Chapter 2. Highlights of findings................................................................................................. General findings............................................................................................, .......................... Requirements by occupation and type of contractor................................................................. Distribution of costs.................................................................................................................. Regional differences.................................................................................................................. 4 Chapter 3. Labor requirements ................................................................................................... O nsite....................................................... Offsite......................................................................................................................................... 7 7 8 4 5 5 6 Chapter 4. Distribution of costs and wages and other characteristics.......................................... 11 Construction costs by selected characteristics..............................................................................11 Relative cost shares....................................................... 11 Contractor c o s ts ........................................................................................................................... 11 Wages and earnings by region...................................................................................................... 12 Wages by occupation....................................................................................................................12 Materials, supplies, and equipment...............................................................................................12 Construction tim e......................................................................................................................... 17 Contractors...................................................................................................................................17 Chapter 5. Comparison with other surveys..................................................................................... 18 Text tables: 1. Employee hours per $1,000 of Federal building construction by industry, 1959, 1973, 1976, and estimated 1981..................................... 5 2. Federal building construction project characteristics, 1959, 1973, and 1976 ..................... 5 3. Onsite employee hours required per $1,000 of Federal building construction cost by occupation, 1959 and 1976 ......................................................................................... 8 4. Percent distribution of apprentices employed on Federal building construction projects by occupation and region, 1976 ........................................................................ 8 5. Onsite employee hour requirements in Federal building construction by type of contractor, 1959, 1973, and 1976...................... 9 6. Onsite employee hour requirements for Federal building construction by selected characteristics, 1959, 1973, and 1976............................................ 9 7. Indirect employee hour requirements per $1,000 of contract construction cost for Federal building construction, 1959 and 1976 ................................................................................. 10 8. Construction costs of Federal buildings by selected characteristics, 1959, 1973, and 1976 .. 12 9. Percent distribution of contract costs for Federal building construction, 1959, 1973, and 1976............................................................................................................13 10. Percent distribution of contract cost on Federal building construction projects by type of contractor and region, 1973 and 1976............................................................... 13 v Contents—Continued Page 11. Average onsite earnings and wages as a percent of contract cost on Federal building construction projects by region, 1959 and 1976................................................................. 13 12. Average hourly earnings for selected onsite construction workers on Federal building projects by region, 1976 ...................................................................................................... 13 13. Materials, equipment, and supplies used in Federal building construction, 1959 and 1976.. 14 14. Average number of weeks of construction time for Federal building projects by selected characteristics, 1959, 1973, and 1976 ................................................................................. 17 15. Percent distribution of onsite employee hours by decile of construction time, 1959 and 1976 ..................................................................................................................... 17 16. Average number of contractors for Federal building projects by type of contractor and region, 1976 ........................................................................................... 17 17. Employee hours per 1,000 current dollars of contract cost by industry, all construction studies, 1958-76................................................................................................................... 19 18. Percent distribution of onsite employee hours per 1,000 current dollars of contract cost by occupation, all construction studies, 1958-76 ....................................................... 20 19. Percent distribution of construction contract costs, all construction studies, 1958-76 ........21 20. Percent distribution of cost of materials, supplies, and equipment by product group, all construction studies, 1958-76 .........................................................................................22 Appendixes: A. Detailed labor and cost data by region.................................................................................. 23 Tables: A-l. Onsite employee hour requirements per $1,000 of contract cost for Federal building construction by occupation and region, 1976 ...................................................... 24 A-2. Percent distribution of onsite employee hour requirements per $1,000 for Federal building construction by type of contractor and region, 1976 ..........................................25 A-3. Onsite employee hour requirements in Federal building construction by selected characteristics and region, 1976...........................................................................................26 A-4. Construction costs of Federal buildings by selected characteristics and region, 1976. .27 A-5. Average onsite earnings and wag© as a percent of contract costs on Federal building construction projects by selected characteristics and region, 1976.....................28 B. Survey scope and m ethods...................................................................................................... 29 C. Forms used for data collection ...............................................................................................31 D. Bibliography........................................................................................................................... 51 vi ©(hapfer l Introduction to market research analysts and companies manufactur ing equipment and supplies are lists of material require ments per $1,000 of construction contract. The construction industry is an important component of the U. S. economy. It is a major source of employ ment and a major consumer of the materials and serv ices furnished by many manufacturing, trade, transpor tation, and service industries. Because of this extensive employment impact, the creation of new construction projects often is regarded as a means of counteracting cyclical unemployment. Information on the number and composition of jobs generated by construction activity is necessary in order to determine training needs and to develop priorities for construction expenditures. To assist in evaluating the impact of construction expenditures on employment, Congress established a program of construction labor requirements studies in 1959. Since then, the Bureau of Labor Statistics has conducted periodic surveys of la bor and material requirements for various segments of the construction industry. These studies provide data which are important in determining skill shortages or bottlenecks for various types of construction. Resurveys of a given type of construction indicate cost changes and productivity trends for onsite construction labor. Of special interest This study, the third BLS study of Federal office building construction,1 is based on a survey of all Fed eral building construction completed in the continental United States in 1976 and 1977 under the auspices of the Public Buildings Service, General Services Admin istration.2 The survey was designed primarily to deter mine the number of employee hours per $1,000 of con tract cost. Employee hours included both onsite and offsite construction and the indirect employment re quired to produce and deliver the materials used in the construction activity.3 The study originally comprised 33 projects, but was reduced to 24 due to lack of cooperation by contrac tors and because some projects were judged to be out of the scope of this survey. Lack of cooperation was particularly acute in the West. As a result, data from the West were not sufficiently reliable to permit publi cation of separate figures for that region.4 However, 1 John G. Olsen, “ Decline Noted in Hours Required To Erect Federal Office Buildings,” Monthly Labor Review, October 1976, pp. 18-22; Roland V. Murray, “ Labor Requirements for Federal Office Building Construction,” Monthly Labor Review, August 1962, pp. 889-93; and Labor Requirements fo r Federal Office Building Con struction, Bulletin 1331 (Bureau of Labor Statistics, 1962). The 1973 survey of Federal building construction was one of a group of abbreviated studies of construction labor requirements. To allow more frequent measurement of the labor requirements of dif ferent types of construction as well as to reduce survey costs, the abbreviated studies omitted the collection of onsite occupational and material data. Material and equipment cost information is used to generate indirect employment estimates for the industries which mine, manufacture, and transport construction materials. As a result, de tailed data on occupational requirements, material usage, and indirect employment impact are not available for the 1973 survey. 2 Although the study was based on project completions, most of the value put in place occurred between 1973 and 1977, with peak ac tivity in 1976. The length of time between the data year and the year of publica tion results from several factors. A considerable amount of time is needed to define and refine the universe and collect, compile, and verify the data. Actual data collection does not begin until at least a year after construction is completed, and surveyed projects require many personal visits to contractors and subcontractors. Additional time is required for preparation and publication of the results. Never theless, the data presented indicate trends in labor and material re- quirements and are useful in analyzing changes in these factors over periods of time. The data also serve as benchmarks for developing current estimates of employment generating effects on construction expenditures. 3No attempt was made to measure the labor required for planning, design work, and public utilities installation. The employment gen erated from the spending and respending of wages and profits—the multiplier effect—also fell outside the scope of the survey. 4Data from the study were provided for the continental United States and four broad geographic regions. The States included in each region were: Northeast—Connecticut, Maine, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, Pennsylvania, Rhode Is land, and Vermont; North Central—Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Michigan, Minnesota, Missouri, Nebraska, North Dakota, Ohio, South Dakota, and Wisconsin; South—Alabama, Arkansas, Delaware, Dis trict of Columbia, Florida, Georgia, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maryland, Mississippi, North Carolina, Oklahoma, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, Virginia, and West Virginia; and West—Arizona, California, Colorado, Idaho, Montana, Nevada, New Mexico, Oregon, Utah, Washington, and Wyoming. No separate data are presented for the West, but those for the other regions and for the Nation as a whole are believed to be accurate. The detailed data, however, have a wider margin of sampling error and may be subject to other limitations. Except for the data estimated by the contractors, there are no known sources of probable nonsam pling error. Sampling variances are being developed by the Bureau of Labor Statistics. S<g@p® ©f survey 1 declining level of Federal building construction activity is primarily a result of delayed replacement of old struc tures. Technological changes in the construction industry during recent years have primarily consisted of modi fications and improvements in existing methods, equip ment, and materials. The technology of building con struction continues to advance slowly through the adop tion of new design concepts, stronger and more dur able materials, laborsaving computer processes, and more efficient management techniques. Advances in design concepts are allowing increas ingly complex buildings to be erected economically. The development of new and better structural design techniques, such as plastic design, tubular design, the staggered truss frame method, and the shear friction principle, have helped reduce the weight and construc tion costs of high rise buildings. Tubular design, which uses exterior columns to carry wind loads, eliminating the need for any interior bracing, decreased the struc tural steel requirements for one multistory office build ing by 30 percent, significantly lowering framing costs.6 The growing interest in energy conservation is re sulting in the development of energy saving designs for office buildings. The installation of a solar energy sys tem in a new Federal building project, while increas ing labor requirements and construction costs, signifi cantly reduced water and space heating costs, suggest ing the possibility of more efficient energy systems for future office building structures. Continuing advances in computer technology are speeding production, improving output quality, and re ducing unit labor costs on a variety of construction jobs. The development of smaller, less expensive, and easier to use computers has made it easier for construc tion contractors to use computers for many offsite func tions. Most major design firms employ computer sys tems for design and cost analysis because of their greater sophistication, accuracy, and operating speed. Com puter models have been devised to analyze an entire structure for stresses, enabling complex geometric de signs to be built more efficiently. Electronic account ing sysems are used by most large contractors for regu lar billing, payroll, and inventory functions, reducing the amount of clerical work required. Computer graphic systems, which provide visual representations of various design components, are used by surveyors because of their map-making ability to aid in the analysis of con struction surveys. Architects are employing these pro gramming methods to accelerate the production of de tailed drafting plans. Development of construction management methods in which the individual components of a project are data for the West were adjusted for nonresponse and included in national totals. Projects in this study included regular and Social Se curity Administration office buildings, border stations, and other buildings included in the 1959 and 1973 BLS studies on Federal building construction. Federal and Social Security Administration office buildings ac counted for about 80 percent of all Federal projects in 1973 and 1976. Although all three of these surveys are essentially studies of office buildings, several factors make comparisons among them difficult except in the broadest terms. The average building size, for example, varies con siderably among the studies. In 1959, the average size was about 94,000 square feet. In 1973, this dropped to 67.000 and then rose to 266,000 in 1976. A further com plication resulted from the abolition of the Post Office Department, whose physical plant was formerly under the control of the General Services Administration. After the establishment of the U.S. Postal Service, control of the buildings reverted to the new agency. Thus, Postal Service buildings were excluded from the 1973 and 1976 studies. In addition, a larger proportion of small Social Security Administration office buildings, those with 10.000 square feet of floor space or less, were included in the 1973 study and made up about 40 percent of all projects. (See appendix B for further details on the scope of the survey.) Survey methods Onsite employee hour requirements in the construc tion industry were developed from payroll data sup plied by contractors. Indirect labor requirements in other industries were derived from the materials and equipment cost information collected for the sample projects. Estimates of indirect employment were devel oped by classifying and aggregating individual material values, deflating them by an appropriate producer price index to match the base year of the input-output tables to generate estimates of final demand. Sector produc tivity factors then were applied to derive employee hours by industry group. (Further details on survey methods are presented in appendix B.) M u r e of fth@ industry According to the Bureau of the Census, expenditures for the category “other Federal building construction” amounted to about $711 million in 1981.5Federal build ing projects constructed under the auspices of the Pub lic Buildings Service accounted for a substantial portion of this total. In 1981, other Federal building construc tion was about 26 percent lower in constant dollars than in 1976. This decline represents a continuation of a long-term trend that began in the late 1960’s. The 5See table 2 of Construction Report C30-81-5, Bureau of the Census. 6 “ Hexagonal Tube with Rigid Frames Reduces High Rise’s Steel by 30 Percent,” Engineering News-Record, October 4, 1973, p. 36. 2 examined according to their contribution to the whole building process is helping to control construction timelags and costs. Techniques such as value engineering, fast-tracking or phased construction, design building, the Program Evaluation and Review Technique (PERT), and the Critical Path Method (CPM) are en hancing contractors’ ability to coordinate the various aspects of large, complex construction projects. Value engineering, which is used in several Federal construc tion programs, is a systematic study of a design that evaluates the functions of its various components. A cost reduction incentive in the Federal value engineer ing programs offers to share cost savings arising from contractor-initiated changes in plans, specifications, or other contract requirements. Fast-tracking, in which the design and construction schedules are overlapped, has the potential to shorten construction duration and to provide a defense against rising construction costs, ma terial shortages, and early obsolescence in the design process. 3 Chapter Si. Highlights of Findings Federal building construction generated more than 34 employee hours directly in the construction sector for each $1,000 expended on construction contracts in 1976 (table 1). This compares with estimates from simi lar studies of 48 employee hours in 1973 and 108 hours in 1959. In 1976, about 30 of the construction employee hour requirements were expended at the site, and almost 5 hours were created in offsite construction. In addi tion to the construction hours, almost 47 employee hours were generated in industries which produce, transport, and sell the materials, equipment, and supplies used in Federal building construction. When adjusted for inflation, each $1,000 (in 1959 dol lars) spent on Federal building projects in 1976 gener ated about 79 construction employee hours, compared with 80 employee hours in 1973 and 108 hours in 1959. Assuming a continuation of this trend, an estimated 72 construction employee hours per $1,000 (1959 dollars) would have been generated in 1981.7 In terms of employment, each $1 billion spent on Federal building construction during 1981 would have generated the equivalent of about 24,100 year-long, full time jobs throughout the economy.8 About 10,400 of these w ou ld h ave been in the construction industry, 9,100 onsite and 1,300 offsite.9 In addition, about 13,700 jobs would have been indirectly created in other indus tries. In comparision, during 1981, for each $1 billion expended for commercial office building construction, about 21,100 jobs were generated; about 22,400 jobs were generated per $1 billion spent on elementary and secondary school construction.10 Onsite employee hours per $1,000 (constant dollars) decreased at an average annual rate of 22 percent be tween 1959 and 1976.11 While this is not a measure of onsite labor productivity, the decline indicates some productivity improvement in this construction activity. On average, a Federal building project finished in 1976 and 1977 required 130 weeks to complete, com pared with 64 and 73 weeks, respectively, for projects completed in 1973 and 1959 (table 2). The increased length of time for completion reflects, in part, the larger average size of projects in the current survey. Actual construction of the sample projects took place in 1972 through 1978, but most projects were completed dur ing 1976 and 1977. Construction time varied from 54 weeks for a small border station to 295 for one of the largest office buildings. Federal building projects in 1976 required an aver age of 47 contractors, twice as many as in 1973 and 1959. E ach project contained about 266,100 square feet and cost about $12.7 million per project. The Federal 7The 1981 employment estimates for Federal building construction were developed from 1973 and 1976 survey data adjusted for price and productivity changes. The deflator used to adjust survey data for price change is the Bureau of the Census’ cost index for “nonresidential building” construction. This consists of: An unweighted average of the Bureau of the Census single-family housing price in dex, excluding the value of the lot; the Turner Construction Com pany cost index; and the Federal Highway Administration structures price index. The nonresidential building construction price deflator, derived from an unweighted average of the three indexes on a 1972=100 base, equaled 224.8 in 1981, 136.8 at the midpoint of the 1976 survey, and 109.3 at the midpoint of the 1973 survey. The estimate used to adjust the survey data for productivity change is the inverse of the change in onsite employee hours per $1,000, after adjustment for price variations, between the 1973 and 1976 surveys. The annual rate of change averaged 1.6 percent during this period. 8Estimates of the number of full-time jobs per $1 billion spent in 1981 were derived using 1,800 hours per employee year for onsite construction; 2,000 hours for offsite construction; 2,068 for manufac turing; 1,780 for trade, transportation, and services; and 2,024 for mining and all other. Because of part-time workers, transients, and the seasonal nature of employment in the construction industry, more workers would be employed than indicated by the full-time jobs estimates. 9Offsite construction labor requirements were estimated from the ratio of nonconstruction workers to total workers for the general building and the special trade contractors (SIC 15 and 17) segments of the contract construction industry as shown in Employment and Earnings, March issues of the years covered. 10These 1981 employment estimates were developed from earlier BLS survey data adjusted for price and productivity changes. For reports on the earlier studies, see Barbara Bingham, “Labor and Ma terial Requirements for Commercial Office Building Projects,” Monthly Labor Review, May 1981, pp.41-48; and John G. Olsen, “La bor and Material Requirements for New School Construction,” Monthly Labor Review, April 1979, pp. 38-41. 11Average annual rates of change in the article were calculated be tween the midpoints of the various surveys. The midpoint of a sur vey is based on estimates of the value of surveyed construction put in place by year of construction time. For the 1976 survey, most of the value put in place occurred between 1973 and 1977 with the mid point falling in 1975. For the 1973 survey, most of the value put in place was erected between 1971 and 1973 with the midpoint occur ring in 1972. General findings 4 Table 1. Employee hours per $1,000 of Federal building construction by industry, 1959,1973, 1976, and estimated 1981 CD 00 Constant 1959 dollars' Current dollars Industry 1959 1973 1976 19812 1973 1976 235.7 n.a. 81.4 45.7 n.a. 187.2 172.6 107.9 97.1 10.8 47.7 42.8 4.9 34.4 29.8 4.6 19.0 16.4 2.6 80.2 71.9 8.2 79.1 68.5 10.6 71.8 61.9 9.8 127.8 79.2 35.7 12.9 n.a. n.a. n.a. n.a. 47.0 26.0 16.5 4.5 26.7 14.4 9.7 2.6 n.a. n.a. n.a. n.a. 108.1 59.8 37.9 10.3 100.8 54.4 36.6 9.8 1 The deflator used to adjust for price change is the Bureau of the Census’ cost index for “ nonresidential building” construction. (See text footnote 2.) 2 The 1981 employment estimates were developed from 1976 survey data adjusted for price and productivity changes from the midpoint of the 1976 sur vey. 3 Offsite construction employee hours were estimated from the ratio of non construction workers to total workers for the general building and special trade contractors (SIC 15 and 17) segment of the contract construction industry as shown in Employment and Earnings, March issues of the years covered. 4 Indirect employment data were revised from the original 1959 survey re sults because of the reprocessing of materials data through improved input-out put tables. buildings consisted primarily of steel-framed, multistory office structures. Most projects had a built-in roof with a concrete roof base, an acoustical tile ceiling, dry wall interiors, a concrete floor base with carpet covering, and a basement. A majority of the buildings had forced-air heating, central air-conditioning, and outdoor parking areas. All structures of more than two stories contained elevators. with the two earlier studies, this represents a continu-. ing decline in the proportion of onsite hours worked by general contractors. The major subcontracting groups employed in Federal building construction are: Heating, ventilating, and air-conditioning; electrical; concrete; and structural steel. Along with the general contractors, these groups accounted for more than twothirds of all onsite hours in 1976. Requirements by occupation and type of contractor Distribution of costs n.a. = Data not available. NOTE: Detail may not add to totals because of rounding. General contractors accounted for about 29 percent of all contract costs for Federal building projects in 1976. Among subcontractors, heating, ventilating, and air-conditioning made up the largest cost group, fol lowed by structural steel and electrical work. These three major subcontractors accounted for almost onethird of total construction costs. About 26 percent of the construction costs of Fed eral buildings completed in 1976 and 1977 represented expenditures for onsite wages and salaries. The largest share of the construction costs, around 42 percent, went for materials, built-in equipment, and supplies. Equip- Onsite employee hour requirements contributed by skilled trades workers increased from about 60 percent of total onsite employee hours in 1959 to more than 68 percent in 1976. Employee hours attributable to semi skilled and unskilled workers, more than one-third of onsite employee hours in 1959, declined to less than 24 percent in 1976. Hours of nonproduction employees, such as supervisors, engineers, and clerks, increased slightly to almost 3 percent in 1976. General contractors accounted for 31 percent of on site employee hour requirements in 1976. Compared Tabl© 2. Federal building construction project characteristics, 1959, 1973, and 1976 Characteristic 1959 1973 United States United States 19761 United States Northeast North Central South Average square feet of space per project................................ 93,700 67,300 266,100 281,800 248,500 338,100 Average cost per project............................................................ $1,760,100 $2,780,100 $12,692,400 $18,476,900 $10,412,400 $15,743,200 Average cost per square fo o t.................................................... $18.80 Average hourly earnings of construction w orkers................... $2.98 (2) Average wages as a percent of contract cost......................... 29.0 34.0 $41.28 $47.70 $65.60 $41.90 $46.55 $8.66 $9.54 $9.93 $7.64 25.8 24.7 28.1 24.3 Average number of weeks of construction per project............ 73 64 130 179 107 148 Average number of contractors per project............................. 22 22 47 36 54 50 1 In the 1976 study, data for the West are not sufficiently reliable to permit publication of detailed data for that region. 2 Not available, 5 ment used to construct the projects accounted for an other 3 percent of cost. The remaining almost 29 per cent covered contractors’ overhead costs and profits. This cost distribution suggests that a significant change occurred between 1959 and 1976 in the relative cost shares for Federal building construction. The pro portion of costs represented by materials fell from about 51 percent in 1959 to around 42 percent in 1976. The proportion contributed by onsite wages also declined slightly, while contractors’ equipment showed a slight rise. Overhead and profit costs, which include salaries of offsite workers, supplemental benefits, performance bonds, contractors’ profits, and expenses for interest, office, and miscellaneous items, increased from 18 per cent in 1959 to almost 29 percent in 1976. More than three-fifths of the costs of materials, equip ment, and supplies used in Federal building construc tion during 1976 were expended for materials in three product groups—stone, clay, glass, and concrete prod ucts; primary metal products; and fabricated metal prod ucts, except ordnance, machinery, and transportation equipment. These three groups accounted for about 63 percent of material costs in 1976 compared with around 55 percent in 1959. Between 1959 and 1972, expendi 6 tures for primary metal products as a percent of total materials almost doubled, reflecting, in part, an increase in the size of projects in the current study, requiring more structural steel products. Regional! differences Data reflect differences in construction requirements due to differing regional conditions under which projects are built. For example, the leading roof base and exterior wall material used in projects in the South was concrete. In contrast, projects in the North Cen tral States made extensive use of steel decking for roof bases and of load bearing masonry for exterior walls. These different characteristics lead to differences in costs by region. The Northeast led all regions in aver age cost per project and per square foot, reflecting sev eral factors; including a higher proportion of projects with more than two stories which required elevators. Regional differences also were observed in earnings. Hourly earnings, for example, for all construction av eraged $8.66, ranging from $7.64 in the South to $9.93 in the North Central region. Wages as a percentage of costs varied from about 28 percent in the South to about 24 percent in the North Central. Chapter III. Labor Requirements Onsite cent of the onsite employee hours of all skilled workers in Federal building construction during 1976 (table 3). Other major skills, in descending order, included: Elec tricians, structural iron workers, plumbers, and sheet-metal workers. Together, these five occupations accounted for almost 60 percent of all skilled trades hours. Bricklayers, and semiskilled and unskilled workers, who contributed 2.7 and 23.6 percent, respectively, of all onsite employee hour requirements in 1976, experi enced a substantial decline from the 1959 Federal build ing study. These trends reflect the increasing use of prefabricated components and the mechanization of some material handling operations. The proportion of hours contributed by structural iron workers, elevator constructors, cement finishers, operating engineers, and electricians increased significantly over this period. These trends reflect greater use of structural steel and concrete as building materials as well as a larger mix of multistory office buildings with elevators in the 1976 study. Onsite labor requirements for Federal building projects averaged about 30 onsite employee hours per $1,000 of contract cost in 1976, about 37 percent of all employee hour requirements. Federal and Social Secu rity Administration office building projects generated slightly lower onsite labor requirements than other Fed eral building projects, an average of about 29 hours, compared with 33. In comparison, in 1959, Federal building projects av eraged about 97 onsite employee hours per 1,000 cur rent dollars and, in 1973, 43 onsite hours. The 1959 on site figures constituted about 41 percent of all employee hour requirements in that study. Current estimates based on trends from the three Federal building studies indi cate that about 17 onsite employee hours per $1,000 of Federal building construction cost would have been generated in 1981. On a constant (1959) dollar basis, onsite labor require ments declined from 97 employee hours per $1,000 in 1959 to almost 72 hours in 1973, and more than 68 hours in 1976. The average annual rate of decline was 2.3 percent between 1959 and 1973 and 1.6 percent between 1973 and 1976. Apprentice onsite employee hours. Apprentices made up about 11 percent of all skilled workers in 1976 com pared with approximately 6 percent in 1959. The oc cupations that had the largest relative number of ap prentices were sprinkler fitters, plumbers, pipefitters, and electricians. The distribution of total apprentice hours in 1976 in dicates that about one-quarter of the apprentice hours were contributed by electricians (table 4). Other major occupations included plumbers, carpenters, structural iron workers, sheet-metal workers, and pipefitters. These six trades accounted for almost three-quarters of all apprentice hours in 1976. Onsite employee hours per $1,000 (1959 dollars) 1959 .............................................. 1973 .............................................. 1976 .............................................. 97.1 71.9 68.5 Average annual percent change 1959-76 ...................................................... 1959-73 ...................................................... 1973-76 ...................................................... -2.2 -2.3 -1-6 The change over time in onsite employee hour re quirements per unit of output reflects the introduction of new methods, equipment, and materials, and shifts in the composition and location of construction. Al though changes in onsite employee hour requirements reflect some differences in the type of structures built in the survey years, they provide a rough indication of productivity trends in this type of construction. Employee hours by type of contractor. The distribution of onsite employee hours per $1,000 of Federal build ing construction cost by type of contractor in 1976 re flects a continuing trend toward more subcontracting (table 5). The proportion of onsite hours worked by general contractors has declined between each of the studies. While the proportion of hours worked by struc tural iron work, site preparation, excavation and grad ing, concrete work, electrical, acoustical, and wallboard Employee hours by occupation. Carpenters, the major skilled trades workers, accounted for about 13.9 per 7 subcontractors increased substantially. This trend to ward more subcontracting of onsite work reflects the need for general contractors to concentrate more of their efforts on coordinating, financing, and purchasing functions. Compared with the two earlier studies, the propor tion of hours worked by plastering and lathing and plumbing contractors declined substantially in 1976. These trends reflect, in part, the substitution of wallboard for plastering and lathing methods and the grow ing use of prefabricated materials that require less on site finishing work. Employee hours by selected characteristics. Federal building projects during 1976 required an average of 378,000 onsite employee hours or about 210 employee years of onsite labor, compared with 119,000 onsite hours in 1973 and 171,000 hours in 1959. On a square footage basis, Federal building projects in 1976 gener ated an average of almost 142 onsite employee hours per 100 square feet, a decline from the approximately 177 onsite employee hours generated in 1973, and the 183 hours in 1959 (table 6). Employee hour require ments per 100 square feet during 1976 ranged from about 102 hours in the North Central region to about Table 3. Onsite employee hours required per $1,000 of Federal building construction cost by occupation, 1959 and 1976 Occupation Onsite employee hours Percent distribution 1959 1976 1959 1976 All occupations.............................. 97.1 29.8 100.0 100.0 Skilled trades........................................ Bricklayers........................................ Carpenters........................................ Cement finishers............................... Electricians....................................... Elevator constructors....................... Glaziers.............................................. Insulation workers............................. Iron workers, ornam ental................ Iron workers, reinforcing.................. Iron workers, structural.................... Lathers............................................... Operating engineers........................ Painters.............................................. Plasterers........................................... Plumbers and pipefitters.................. Plumbers....................................... Pipefitters...................................... Roofers.............................................. Sheet metal workers........................ Soft floor layers................................ Terrazzo workers and tile setters.... Other skilled workers....................... 58.2 5.0 12.2 2.0 8.8 .7 .4 2.1 .8 2.1 1.2 1.8 2.3 2.0 2.0 8.5 0 (1) .7 4.9 .2 .5 0 20.4 .8 4.1 1.0 3.4 .4 .1 .4 .3 .4 1.7 .3 1.1 .5 .3 2.4 1.3 1.1 .3 1-3 (2) .2 1.2 59.9 5.2 12.6 2.1 9.1 .8 .4 2.1 .8 2.2 1.2 1.8 2.4 2.1 2.0 8.7 O (1) .7 5.0 .2 .5 0 68.3 2.7 13.9 3.3 11.5 1.4 .5 1.4 .9 1.2 5.8 1.1 3.6 1.6 1.1 7.9 4.5 3.4 1.0 4.5 .1 .6 4.2 Laborers and other............................... Laborers, helpers, and tenders...... T ruckdrivers...................................... O ther.................................................. 33.0 31.5 .9 .6 7.0 6.4 .2 .4 34.0 32.5 .9 .6 23.6 21.4 .8 1.4 2.2 .8 2.3 2.8 3.6 1.6 3.7 5.3 Professional, technical, and clerical w orkers.............................................. Superintendents and blue-collar supervisors....................................... 1 Data not available. Less than 0.05 employee hours. NOTE: Detail may not add to totals because of rounding. Table 4. Percent distribution of apprentices employed on Federal building construction projects by occupation and region, 19761 Percent distribution Occupation United States North east North Central South All skilled trades............... 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 Bricklayers................................ Carpenters................................ Cement finishers..................... Drywall finishers...................... Electricians............................... Elevator constructors.............. Glaziers.................................... Insulation w orkers................... 2.4 13.6 3.9 .1 24.5 1.3 .6 2.4 .2 13.9 .9 (2) 31.0 5.4 (2) 5.1 10.3 4.0 .3 23.3 2.3 .6 .6 1.8 14.9 4.5 23.8 (2) .7 3.8 Iron workers, ornamental....... Iron workers, reinforcing........ Iron workers, structural........... Lathers..................................... M achinists................................ Operating engineers................ Painters.................................... Pipefitters................................. 1.2 .9 7.4 1.0 .1 .5 1.9 6.9 1.1 .2 15.1 1.4 1.1 1.2 6.7 2.0 .6 4.6 .2 1.0 1.8 9.8 1.0 1.1 7.1 1.3 .2 .1 1.9 5.8 Plasterers................................. Plumbers.................................. Roofers..................................... Sheet metal w orkers............... Sprinkler fitte rs........................ Soft floor layers....................... Tile setters................................ Other skilled trades workers ... 1.2 13.9 1.4 7.2 5.0 .2 .6 1.6 .3 12.6 (2) 7.5 .9 .2 .3 1.4 9.6 .7 7.0 14.7 .2 1.3 15.9 1.9 7.2 1.8 .2 1.0 2.6 - .1 - 1 Data for the West are not sufficiently reliable to permit publication of detailed data for that region. 2 Less than 0.05 percent. NOTE: Dash denotes that the survey had no sample projects in this cell. Detail may not add to totals because of rounding. 170 hours in the Northeast. Onsite employee hour re quirements per $1,000 frequently do not parallel re quirements per 100 square feet. Differences in project type, design, materials, geographic location, and rela tive costs will affect the comparisons between these two measures of unit labor requirements. In 1976, Federal and Social Security Administration office buildings generated slightly lower onsite labor requirements per $1,000 than other Federal build ings—an average of about 29 hours compared with 33. Projects costing more than $10 million experienced the lowest unit labor requirements of any cost class, sug gesting that some labor saving may have resulted from economies of scale associated with large buildings. The distribution of onsite employee hours per $1,000 in 1976 also varied by geographic location. Federal building projects in the North Central region experi enced the lowest unit labor requirements of any region. In contrast, projects in the South required the highest number of onsite employee hours per $1,000, reflecting the more frequent use of semiskilled and unskilled workers. Offsite Offsite employee hours represent builders’ adminis trative, estimating, and warehousing activities and the Table 5. Onsite employee hour requirements in Federal building construction by type of contractor, 1959, 1973, and 1976 Employee hours required per$1,000 Type of contractor1 Percent distribution 1959 1973 1976 1959 1973 1976 T o ta l................................................................................................................... 97.1 42.8 29.8 100.0 100.0 100.0 General contractors.................................................................................................. Plumbing, heating, ventilating, and air-conditioning............................................. Heating,ventilating, and air-conditioning............................................................ Plumbing................................................................................................................ Electrical.................................................................................................................... Plastering and lathing.............................................................................................. Structural and ornamental iron w o rk ..................................................................... Structural steel erection....................................................................................... Ornamental iron w ork.......................................................................................... 38.5 19.5 (2) (2) 9.5 4.7 3.4 (2) (2) 16.1 8.5 5.9 2.6 4.2 2.7 1.7 1.4 .2 9.1 . 4.9 4.0 .9 3.3 .5 1.8 1.7 .1 39.6 20.1 (2) (2) 9.8 4.8 3.5 (2) (2) 37.6 19.9 13.7 6.1 9.8 6.4 3.9 3.3 .6 30 5 16.6 13.6 3.0 11.2 1.6 6.0 5.8 .2 Elevator and other equipment installation............................................................. Elevators................................................................................................................ Mechanical and equipment installation.............................................................. Masonry and stonework.......................................................................................... Site preparation, excavation, and grading............................................................. 1.5 (2) (2) 7.7 ' 2.0 1.6 .4 1.2 1.2 .9 .8 (2) (2) 1.5 1.4 1.5 (2) (2) 7.9 2.1 3.8 1.0 2.8 2.9 2.2 2.8 (2) (2) 5.2 4.7 Roofing and sheet metal w ork................................................................................ Roofing and gutter w ork...................................................................................... Sheet metal work (except heating).................................................................... 1.2 (2) (2) 1.0 .9 .1 .5 .4 .1 1.2 (2) (2) 2.3 2.1 .2 1.6 1.3 .3 Painting and paperhanging..................................................................................... Ceramic tile, terrazzo, and marble......................................................................... O th e r......................................................................................................................... Concrete w o rk ...................................................................................................... Carpentry............................................................................................................... Acoustical......................................................................... ..................................... Wallboard............................................................................................................... 2.0 1.4 5.7 (2) (2) (2) (2) .5 .5 3.7 .8 .8 .2 (3) .5 .3 3.0 1.8 .3 .5 .9 2.1 1.4 5.9 (2) (2) (2) (2) 1.2 1.2 8.7 1.8 1.8 .5 .1 1.5 1.0 17.1 6.0 1.2 1.8 2.9 1 Because many contractors perform more than one operation, contractors are classified according to the major cost component of their work. 2 Data not available. 3 Less than 0.05 employee hours, NOTE: Detail may not add to totals because of rounding. Table 6. Onsite employee hour requirements for Federal building construction by selected characteristics, 1959, 1973, and 1976 Employee hours per 100 square feet Employee hours per $1,000 Characteristic 1959 1973 1976 1959 1973 1976 97.1 42.8 29.8 182.6 176.8 142.2 Federal office and social security buildings.................... All other buildings............................................................... (1) (1) 44.4 35.3 29.4 32.9 (1) (1) 178.2 168.6 138.5 177.0 Construction cost group: $1,000,000 and u n der................................................... $1,000,001 - $5,000,000.............................................. $5,000,001 - $10,000,000............................................ $10,000,001 and o v e r................................................... (1) 103.7 (2) (2) 44.3 42.1 47.8 (2) (2) 27.7 (2) 30.0 (1) 195.9 (2) (2) 181.0 194.0 182.3 (2) (2) 160.1 (2) 138.8 Region: Northeast........................................................................ North C entral.................................................................. S o u th ............................................................................... W est................................................................................. (2) 100.2 96.0 89.2 35.4 36.1 48.7 37.9 25.9 24.4 36.3 (2) (2) 204.0 180.7 133.6 211.4 119.5 176.3 149.5 169.6 102.3 168.9 (2) All projects................................................................... 1 Not available. 2 Insufficient data. cluding offsite construction) were required to produce these materials, supplies, and services. Expenditures for Federal building construction during 1976 generated an estimated 52 offsite hours for each $1,000 of con struction. labor to produce and distribute the materials, supplies, and equipment used in the construction process. Major categories involved are: (1) Offsite construction; (2) manufacturing; (3) trade, transportation, and services; and (4) mining and all other industries either directly or indirectly involved in the production and distribu tion process. For every hour of work performed at the construc tion site, an additional 1.75 hours of offsite labor (in Builders’ offsite employee hours. Federal building con struction during 1976 required an estimated 4.6 offsite employee hours in the construction industry per $1,000 9 of contract cost. Offsite construction employee hours include builders’ administrative, coordinating, estimat ing, scheduling, engineering (but not design work), maintenance, site protection, and warehousing activi ties. Estimates of builders’ offsite employment require ments indicate that the proportion of total labor re quirements contributed by offsite construction person nel has increased from 4.6 percent in 1959 to 5.8 per cent in 1976. This trend reflects the increasing com plexity of many construction projects, requiring more planning, coordination, and offsite work. Current estimates based on trends from the surveys indicated that 2.6 hours per $1,000 of contract cost would have been required for this segment of the in dustry in 1981. Table 7. Indirect employee hour requirements per $1,000 of contract construction cost for Federal building construction, 1959 and 1976 Manufacturing employee hours. The manufacturing sector accounted for the second largest component of total labor requirements in both the 1959 and 1976 studies of Federal building construction. Labor require ments per $1,000 of Federal building construction in 1976 totaled 26 hours in manufacturing industries. The manufacturing sector declined slightly from almost 34 percent of total labor requirements in 1959 to about 32 percent in 1976. In 1981, an estimated 14 hours per $1,000 would have been generated in the manufacturing sector. 1959 1976 Manufacturing............................................................ 79.2 26.0 Trade, transportation, and services....................... T ra d e ..................................................................... Wholesale trade................................................ Retail trade........................................................ Transportation....................................................... Services................................................................. 35.7 23.0 12.9 10.1 9.0 3.7 16 5 10.4 5.0 54 37 24 Mining and oth e r...................................................... Agriculture.............................................................. M inina.................................................................... Communications................................................... Public utilities......................................................... Finance, insurance, and real estate................... Government enterprises............................... Construction........................................................... 12.9 1.4 4.3 1.1 1.2 2.8 1.1 1.0 45 4 13 .4 .5 10 5 .4 NOTE: Detail may not add to totals because of rounding. increased, rising from about 15 percent in 1959 to ap proximately 20 percent in 1976. About 10 hours per $1,000 of contract cost would have been required for these industries in 1981. Mining and other industries employee hours. This group of industries includes agriculture, mining, communica tions, public utilities, finance, insurance, real estate, gov ernment enterprises, and maintenance construction. More than 4 employee hours per $1,000 of Federal building construction cost were generated in these in dustries during 1976. This employee hour estimate rep resents the same proportion of total labor requirements, 5.5 percent, as was contributed by this sector in the 1959 study. Among individual industries, public utilities and government enterprises showed a slight increase between 1959 and 1976, while agriculture and mining declined over this period. An estimated 3 hours per $1,000 would have been generated in these industries in 1981. Trade, transportation, and services employee hours. Dur ing 1976, more than 16 employee hours per $1,000 of Federal building construction were generated in indus tries which distribute or provide other services for the materials, supplies, and equipment used in the construc tion process, either between processing stages or be tween the last stage of manufacturing and the construc tion site. The trade sector, including both wholesale trade and retail trade, accounted for almost two-thirds of this amount (table 7). Since 1959, the proportion of total labor requirements contributed by this sector has Sector 10 Chapter IV. Distribution of Costs and Wages and Other Characteristics Construction costs by selected characteristics On average, Federal building construction in 1976 cost about $12.7 million per project (table 8). Federal and Social Security Administration office buildings cost more per project than other Federal building projects in both 1973 and 1976, reflecting the larger size of of fice buildings in these studies. In contrast, Federal and Social Security Administration office building projects cost less per square foot of space than other Federal building projects during both 1973 and 1976. These findings indicate that some cost saving on office build ing construction may have resulted from economies of scale associated with large projects. Relative cost shares Materials, supplies, and built-in equipment constituted the largest share of total contract costs in all three stud ies of Federal building construction (between 42 and 51 percent) (table 9). Onsite wages and salaries made up the second largest cost group in the 1959 and 1973 studies (29 and 34 percent, respectively), followed by contractors’ overhead and profit (18 and 16 percent).12 In the 1976 study, however, overhead and profit costs accounted for the second largest cost group, rising from 18 percent in 1959 to almost 29 percent in 1976. Fac tors contributing to this large rise include increases in the proportion of total labor requirements contributed by offsite construction employees; a rise in interest rates for contractor loans; and increases in employer contri butions for supplemental benefits such as paid holidays and vacations, health insurance, and retirement plans. The distribution of construction contract costs within each of the four regions during 1976 was similar to the distribution for all projects, except for the South where onsite wages and salaries comprised the second largest cost group. There were greater differences, however, between the regions. The Northeast region showed the greatest proportion of contract dollars allotted to over head and profit of any region in 1976. The South had the lowest percentage in that cost category. The re verse relationship for these two regions was observed for the materials, supplies, and built-in equipment cost 12For 1973, general contractors’ costs were obtained directly, but some subcontractors’ costs were estimated by general contractors. 11 component. The South generally had the highest per centage in this category, about 44 percent in 1976, while the Northeast showed the lowest proportion, almost 39 percent in 1976. The percentage of total costs contrib uted by onsite wages and salaries was highest in the South region and lowest in the North Central in 1976. These trends may reflect, in part, variations in the level of financial costs and profits among the regions. For example, the cost of supplementary wage benefits received by employees is one of the items included in overhead. These benefits tend to be less costly in the South than in the Northeast. Variations in such factors may help to explain the wide differences in the per centage of total contract cost allotted to overhead and profit in the regions. A definitive explanation of these trends cannot be made without further research, par ticularly with respect to the composition of overhead costs. Contractor costs General contractors accounted for the major portion of total costs for materials, equipment, and supplies as well as onsite labor in all four regions in 1976 (table 10). Costs paid to heating, ventilating, and air-condi tioning; structural steel; electrical; and concrete work contractors were among the largest categories of costs in all regions. Together with the general contractor, these four contractor groups accounted for about twothirds of all contract costs in each region. The distribution of construction contract value by contractor is substantially different for some groups from the employee hour distribution discussed earlier. Masonry, plastering and lathing, and painting contrac tors made up a significantly higher proportion of total onsite employee hours than of total contract value. On the other hand, structural steel, acoustical, and sheet-metal contractors showed a higher proportion of contract value than of employee hours. These discrep ancies may reflect, in part, the higher cost of materials, supplies, and equipment for structural steel and sheet-metal work and the more labor-intensive nature of plastering, painting, and masonry work. Differences in the mix of projects among the regions resulted in a wide range of contract values contributed Table 8. Construction costs of Federal buildings by selected characteristics, 1959, 1973, and 1976 Cost per project Cost per square feet Characteristic All projects............................................................. 1976 1959 1973 1976 1959 1973 $18.80 $41.28 $47.70 $1,760,100 $2,780,100 $12,692,400 Federal office and social security buildings.............. (1) 40.13 47.04 (1) 2,840,800 14,136,200 All other buildings........................................................ (’ ) 47.78 53.87 (1) 2,525,000 6,915,700 Region: Northeast.................................................................. North C entral............................................................ S o u th ........................................................................ W est........................................................................... (2) 20.35 18.83 14.98 59.63 33.08 36.17 39.42 65.56 41.90 46.56 (2) (2) 1,402,600 2,008,600 1,466,000 2,929,700 230,300 4,188,800 4,154,300 18,476,900 10,412,400 15,743,200 (2) 1 Not available. 2 Insufficient data. by some types of contractors. For example, masonry work, which averaged almost 4 percent of all contract costs, ranged from close to 7 percent in the Northeast to around 2 percent in the South. Structural steel erec tion varied from about 5 percent in the South to more than 15 percent in the North Central region. The pro portion of value contributed by general contractors ranged from less than 17 percent in the North Central to more than 41 percent in the South. in the building trades as of July 1, 1975 (table 12).13 Ex ceptions are shown in the following tabulation: Wages and earnings by region Occupation Average. hourly. earnings from study Union wage rate All occupations ..... Bricklayers................ Cement finishers....... Lathers ...................... Marble setters........... Plasterers................... Tile setters ................ $8.66 9.76 8.94 9.45 11.31 9.02 9.00 $8.88 9.35 8.81 9.17 9.01 8.81 8.75 Factors that may account for some of the disparity between these two series are the inclusion of overtime in the study’s data and the exclusion of Alaska from the area covered by the survey. During 1976, onsite wages and salaries paid to con struction employees working on Federal building con struction projects averaged $8.66 per hour (table 11). This figure accounted for about 26 percent of all con struction contract costs compared with 29 percent in 1959. Average hourly earnings varied among the regions. Differences in average onsite hourly earnings were caused by a number of factors, including variations in the degree of unionization and the general level of wages in individual areas. (See the following tabulation.) Con struction workers whose rates are set by labor-manage ment agreement generally receive higher average hourly earnings than nonunion workers. Construction personnel working on Federal building projects com pleted in the South during 1976, for example, were paid substantially lower average hourly earnings than workers in other areas. The proportion of union con tracts as a percent of all contracts was much lower in the South (less than 60 percent) than in the Northeast or North Central regions (more than 84 percent). Materials, supplies, and equipment Wages by occupation Materials, supplies, and equipment costs for Federal building construction amounted to about $454 per $ 1,000 of construction costs in 1976 (table 13). This value rep resents a decline of $79 per $1,000 of costs or about 15 percent from the 1959 survey. Of the total materials, supplies, and equipment costs, more than 93 percent were spent for materials, supplies, and built-in equip ment in both the 1959 and 1976 studies. The balance was allocated to contractor construction equipment re quired during construction. Materials, supplies, and built-in equipment accounted for more than two-fifths of construction costs in 1976. Three major product groups made up more than three-fifths of all materials. Stone, clay, glass, and con crete products constituted the largest material group ing, representing almost $103 per $1,000 of total project costs. Most important within this group were ready-mix concrete and concrete products. Primary metal prod ucts were the next largest group of materials—about $94 per $1,000 of total cost. Structural steel products, which contributed $65 per $1,000, represented the largest cost category in the primary metal group. Fab ricated metal products, except ordnance, machinery, Straight-time average hourly rates in this study gen erally were lower than average union hourly wage rates ,J Union Wages and Hours: Building Trades, July 1, 1975, Bulletin 1907 (Bureau of Labor Statistics, 1976). Union contracts as a Onsite average hourly percent o f total earnings (all contracts) contracts United States Northeast ....... North Central . South .............. 75.4 90.5 84.0 59.4 $8.66 9.54 9.93 7.64 12 Table 11. Average onsite earnings and wages as a percent of contract cost on Federal building construction projects by region, 1959 and 1976 Table 9. Percent distribution of contract costs for Federal building construction, 1959, 1973, and 19761 Type of cost North North South east Central United States 1959 19732 1976 1976 1976 1976 Total expenditures........... 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 34.0 25.8 24.7 24.2 27.7 Onsite wages and salaries..... 29.0 Materials, built-in equipment, and supplies........................ 51.4 Contractors’ equipment........... 1.9 (3) Overhead and profit................ 17.7 16.0 ___________________ 50.0 42.5 38.9 42.8 43.8 2.9 3.0 2.9 2.9 28.8 33.5 30.1 25.6 Characteristic Wages as a percent of contract cost Average hourly earnings 1959 1976 1959 1976 All projects..................................... $2.98 $8.66 29.0 25.8 Region: Northeast........................................... North C entral.................................... South ................................................ W est................................................... (1) 3.15 2.90 3.22 9.54 9.93 7.64 (2) (1) 31.5 27.9 (28.7) 24.7 24.2 27.7 (2) 1 Insufficient data. 2 In the 1976 study, data for the West are not sufficiently reliable to permit publication of detailed data for that region. 1 In the 1976 survey, data for the West are not sufficiently reliable to permit publication of detailed data for that region. 2 Estimated. 3 Equipment included in materials. Table 12. Average hourly earnings for selected onsite construction workers on Federal building projects by region, 19761 NOTE: Detail may not add to totals because of rounding. Table 10. Percent distribution of contract cost on Federal building construction projects by type of contractor and region, 1973 and 19761 1973 Type of contractor2 Subcontractors: Heating, ventilating, and air-conditioning.............................. Structural steel.................................. Electrical............................................ Concrete w o rk .................................. Excavation, footing, foundations, and grading................................... Masonry............................................. Elevators............................................ Plumbing............................................ A coustical.......................................... Wallboard........................................... Carpentry........................................... Roofing, gutter work, flashing, and siding...................................... C arpeting........................................... Glass and glazing............................. Sheet metal w ork.............................. Plastering and lathing...................... Painting and wallpapering............... Insulating........................................... Ceramic tile ........................................ Mechanical equipment installation .. Landscaping..................................... Ornamental iron w ork...................... W aterproofing................................... Concrete reinforcement................... Linoleum, vinyl tile, and vinylasbestos tile .................................. T e rra zo.............................................. Asphalt paving.................................. Other.................................................. Occupation 1976 United United North North South States States east Central All contractors............................... 100.0 General contractors.............................. Average hourly earnings 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 38.6 29.1 24.7 16.5 41.1 8.7 6.4 7.4 2.2 12.6 10.3 9.8 5.9 11.2 13.0 12.0 5.5 13.3 15.3 8.1 11.5 13.0 5.1 10.0 1.7 3.2 2.7 2.1 6.3 4.2 3.8 3.3 2.7 5.5 6.8 38 3.2 5.9 4.2 3.5 2.3 2.4 2.2 29 2.4 .5 .1 1.7 2.6 2.2 1.5 4.6 .7 1.4 2.6 1.3 1.4 1.7 3.6 1.7 2.3 .2 (3) .2 4.3 .7 .4 1.4 1.1 1.1 1.0 .9 .8 .6 1.0 .8 (4) .5 (4) .5 (4) .9 1.5 .9 2.6 1.2 .7 1.6 1.9 .9 1.8 (4) .6 1.0 .1 1.5 4.1 .4 1.4 .8 (3) .5 (3) .4 .4 .4 .2 .2 (3) .1 (4) .3 (4) .8 (3) .4 .7 .4 .1 .4 (3) .4 (4) .6 .3 .3 (3) .2 3.2 .2 .2 .1 2.7 (4) (4) (4) 4.2 .1 (4) .1 2.2 .3 .4 .1 3.3 All occupations........................................... $8.66 Skilled trades workers: Bricklayers...................................................... Carpenters.............................................. !...... Cement finishers............................................ $9.54 $9.93 $7.64 9.65 8.04 7.99 8.91 8.91 8.33 9.07 8.12 8.79 9.76 8.60 8.94 9.07 9.44 9.72 9.61 8.63 9.54 9.18 9.29 9.96 10.04 9.33 9.85 10.75 10.71 9.88 9.69 10.19 8.83 10.73 9.97 9.42 10.90 Iron workers, ornam ental............................. 9.48 Iron workers, reinforcing............................... 8.87 Iron workers, structural................................. 9.25 Lathers............................................................ 9.45 Machinists....................................................... 8.68 Marble setters................................................ 11.31 Millwrights....................................................... 9.41 Operating engineers..................................... 9.27 Painters........................................................... 8.22 9.64 8.98 10.08 10.11 (2) (2) (2) 10.41 8.80 10.54 10.95 10.31 10.34 Plasterers........................................................ Plumbers......................................................... R oofers........................................................... Sheet metal workers...................................... Soft floor layers............................................. Sprinkler fitters............................................... Tile setters...................................................... 8.17 9.06 9.54 9.02 8.80 8.78 9.28 10.15 9.69 9.00 (2) 9.28 9.47 9.42 10.54 11.16 (2) 10.03 8.27 Semiskilled and unskilled workers: Laborers, helpers, and tenders................... Truckdrivers................................................... Custodial workers.......................................... 6.54 6.74 3.42 Electricians.................................................... Glaziers........................................................... Insulation workers.......................................... Paperhangers................................................ Pile driver operators..................................... Onsite office and administrative workers: Clerical w orkers.................................. '.......... Professional and technical workers............. Superintendents and blue-collar supervisors................................................. 1 In the 1976 survey, data for the West are not sufficiently reliable to permit publication of detailed data for that region. 2 Since many contractors perform more than one operation, contractors are classified according to the major cost component of their work. 3 Not available. 4 Insufficient data. (2) 9.02 10.18 9.37 8.70 7.88 8.37 8.63 8.23 (2) 7.71 8.30 7.63 (2) (2) 10.64 10.02 10.20 10.33 9.92 12.17 10.00 10.29 7.74 7.60 8.40 8.22 7.98 8.21 8.06 8.59 8.90 8.53 7.72 7.59 7.38 7.52 (2) 5.83 5.94 3.34 4.25 11.56 4.71 7.65 6.03 15.12 3.83 6.21 10.95 11.66 12.70 9.95 1 Data for the West are not sufficiently reliable to permit publication of detailed data for that region. 2 Insufficient data. NOTE: Detail may not add to totals because of rounding. United North North South States east Central NOTE: Dash denotes that the survey had no sample projects in this cell. 13 Table 13. [Materials, equipment, and supplies used in Federal building construction, 1959 and 1976 Percent distribution Value per $1,000 of contract cost Type of material ’ 1959 1976 1959 1976 All materials, equipment, and supplies....................................................................................... 532.50 453.96 100.00 100.00 Materials, built-in equipment, and supplies.................................................................................... 513.40 424.88 96.41 93.59 Agricultural products................................................................................................................................. All horticultural products....................................................................................................................... Agricultural and forestry products, n.e.c.3 .......................................................................................... (2) (2) (2) 1.05 1.04 .01 (2) (2) (2) .23 .23 (4) Mining and quarrying of nonmetallic minerals, except fu e ls ................................................................ Sand and gravel.................................................................................................................................... Mining and quarrying of nonmetallic minerals, n.e.c......................................................................... 2.20 2.20 (2) 2.22 1.74 .47 .41 .41 (2) .49 .38 .10 Textile mill products.................................................................................................................................. Carpeting and pads............................................................................................................................... Textile mill products, n.e.c.................................................................................................................... (2) (2) (2) 7.49 7.28 .21 (2) (2) (2) 1.65 1.60 .05 Apparel and other finished products made from fabrics and similar materials.................................. (2) .30 (2) .07 Lumber and wood products, except furniture........................................................................................ Dressed boards and lumber products................................................................................................. Millwork (wood)....................................................................................................................................... Wood kitchen cabinets and vanities-prebuilt...................................................................................... Hardwood plywood................................................................................................................................ Softwood plyw ood................................................................................................................................. Treated lum ber....................................................................................................................................... Acoustical tile, cork................................................................................................................................ Wood products, n.e.c............................................................................................................................. 17.60 6.70 8.20 (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) 2.70 10.51 2.40 3.56 1.37 .89 .39 .78 .18 .94 3.31 1.26 1.54 (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) .51 2.32 .53 .78 .30 .20 .09 .17 .04 .21 Furniture and fixtures................................................................................................................................ Public buildings furniture and fixtures................................................................................................. Store furniture and fixtures.................................................................................................................... Window blinds and draperies............................................................................................................... Furniture and fixtures, n.e.c................................................................................................................... 1.80 (2) (2) (2) (2) 1.88 .80 .64 .32 .12 .34 (2) (2) (2) (2) .41 .18 .14 .07 .03 Paper and allied products......................................................................................................................... Construction paper and building board products................................................................................ Paper and allied products, n.e.c........................................................................................................... (2) (2) (2) 2.03 1.94 .09 (2) (2) (2) .45 .43 .02 Chemicals and allied products................................................................................................................. Paint and allied products....................................................................................................................... Miscellaneous industrial organic chemicals........................................................................................ Adhesives, sealants, and calking com pounds.................................................................................... Chemicals and allied products, n.e.c................................................................................................... 5.50 2.40 (2) (2) 3.10 4.98 1.67 .16 1.40 1.75 1.03 .45 (2) (2) .58 1.10 .37 .04 .31 .39 Petroleum refining and related industries............................................................................................... Fuels, diesel fuel, gas, oil, and grease............................................................................................... Asphalt paving, asphaltic concrete, bituminous concrete, coal tar paving, and paving b lo ck...... Asphalt felts and coatings..................................................................................................................... 4.70 (2) 3.40 1.30 5.03 1.44 .68 2.91 .88 (2) .64 .24 1.11 .32 .15 .64 Rubber and miscellaneous plastics products......................................................................................... Fabricated rubber products................................................................................................................... Plastic pipe, tubing, fittings, and conduit............................................................................................. Insulation-styrofoam and other cushioning and plastic foam insulation......................................... Rubber and miscellaneous plastics products, n.e.c........................................................................... (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) 3.05 .29 .53 .31 1.93 (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) .67 .06 .12 .07 .43 Stone, clay, glass, and concrete products.............................................................................................. Window glass (manufactured).............................................................................................................. Pressed and blown glass and glassware............................................................................................ Glass products (made from purchased glass).................................................................................... Hydraulic cem ent.................................................................................................................................... Clay brick and structural clay tile ......................................................................................................... Ceramic wall and floor tile ..................................................................................................................... Clay sewer pipe, liner brick, and fittings............................................................................................. Plumbing fixtures and accessories — vitreous china......................................................................... 115.00 3.00 (2) (2) 3.00 14.90 1.50 (2) (2) 102.75 3.05 .78 .47 1.19 1.97 1.92 .12 1.15 21.60 .56 (2) (2) .56 2.80 .28 (2) (2) 22.63 .67 .17 .10 .26 .43 .42 .03 .25 Concrete block, brick, excluding cinder block..................................................................................... Concrete pipe ........................................................................................................................................ Other precast concrete products.......................................................................................................... Precast terrazzo..................................................................................................................................... Ready-mix concrete................................................................................................................................ Lime ..................................................................................................................................................... Gypsum products................................................................................................................................... Marble, granite, slate, and other cut or natural stone........................................................................ 7.60 (2) (2) (2) 43.00 (2) 6.30 9.60 4.20 .45 19.79 .21 33.90 .37 5.76 13.16 1.43 (2) (2) (2) 8.08 (2) 1.18 1.80 .92 .10 4.36 .05 7.47 .08 1.27 2.90 See footnotes at end of table. 14 Table 13. Continued — Materials, equipment, and supplies used in Federal building construction, 1959 and 1976 Value per$1.000 of contract cost Type of material 11959 1976 Percent distribution 1959 1976 Stone, clay, glass, and concrete products — Continued Asbestos cement products................................................................................................................... Crushed rock, slag, and miscellaneous aggregate........................................................................... Insulation — magnesia, perlite, vermiculite, and related products.................................................. Insulation — fiberglass, mineral, or glass w ool.................................................................................. Acoustical tile — fiberglass, mineral w ool.......................................................................................... Stone, clay, glass, and concrete products, n.e.c............................................................................... 2.70 n 1.90 14.80 (2) 6.70 1.22 1.74 1.43 5.40 4.04 .43 0.51 (2) .36 2.78 (2) 1.26 0.27 .38 .31 1.19 .89 .09 Primary metal industries.......................................................................................................................... Structural steel....................................................................................................................................... Blast furnace, steel works, and related products............................................................................... Steel or galvanized raw sheet metal................................................................................................... Steel pipe — galvanized and ferrous noncast iron p ip e ................................................................... Iron nails, spikes, cable, and wire— ferrous....................................................................................... Welded or seamless steel pipe and tubes— from purchased m aterials......................................... Cast iron products................................................................................................................................. Copper pipe and tubing........................................................................................................................ Aluminum sheet, plate, and fo il........................................................................................................... Cable and wire — nonferrous (noniron)............................................................................................. Primary metal products, n.e.c.............................................................................................................. 57.60 24.10 (2) 8.10 (2) (2) (2) 4.80 8.90 3.80 7.90 (2) 94.38 65.28 1.81 2.70 10.67 1.03 .71 4.06 2.10 .24 4.82 .99 10.82 4.53 (2) 1.52 (2) (2) (2) .90 1.67 .71 1.48 (2) 20.79 14.38 .40 .59 2.35 .23 .16 .89 .46 .05 1.06 .22 Fabricated metal products, except machinery and transportation equipm ent................................... Builders’ hardware................................................................................................................................. Plumbing fixtures, and accessories — metal or enameled iron....................................................... Plumbing accessories; fittings and trim — brass............................................................................... Domestic furnaces — steam or hot water.......................................................................................... Fabricated structural steel.................................................................................................................... Fabricated structural alum inum........................................................................................................... Steel doors — all ty p e s .... ................................................................................................................... Aluminum doors — all types................................................................................................................. Metal windows — all metal types........................................................................................................ Prefabricated store fronts — all metal types...................................................................................... 122.70 6.70 7.80 (2) 8.10 (2) (2) (2) 19.80 (2) (2) 87.91 5.30 1.43 .99 2.02 9.36 .62 3.04 .31 5.91 .82 23.04 1.26 1.46 (2) 1.52 (2) (2) (2) 3.72 (2) (2> 19.36 1.17 .32 .22 .45 2.06 .14 .67 .07 1.30 .18 Fabricated metal plate products.......................................................................................................... Fabricated sheet metal products......................................................................................................... Architectural and ornamental metal work........................................................................................... Prefabricated metal buildings and components................................................................................. Metal reinforcing bars and expended metal lath................................................................................ Bolts, nuts, screws, rivets, and related products............................................................................... Other metal stampings .,....................................................................................................................... Plumbing accessories, fittings, and trim — m etal............................................................................. Miscellaneous fabricated wire products — made from purchased w ire ......................................... Fabricated metal products, n.e.c......................................................................................................... 1.80 18.70 6.80 (2) 43.30 (2) (2) 4.20 3.70 1.80 3.21 12.26 8.81 2.04 16.18 1.32 1.26 6.36 5.33 1.34 .34 3.51 1.28 (2) 8.13 (2) (2) .79 .69 .34 .71 2.70 1.94 .45 3.57 .29 .28 1.40 1.18 .30 Machinery, except electrical..................................................................................................................... Elevators and moving stairways........................................................................................................... Pumps, and compressed air, oxygen, and nitrous oxide system s................................................... Compressors.......................................................................................................................................... Blowers and exhaust and ventilation fa n s ......................................................................................... Sprinkler systems — fire prevention..................................................................................................... Electric computing equipm ent.............................................................................................................. Air-conditioning and warm-air heating equipment.............................................................................. Commercial refrigeration equipment................................................................................................... Commercial kitchen equipment other than refrigeration.................................................................... Machinery, except electrical, n.e.c...................................................................................................... 79.10 26.40 2.50 (2) 4.40 (2) (2) 3.50 34.70 (2) 7.60 48.30 18.24 1.73 .93 6.39 2.77 2.45 12.57 .55 1.25 1.40 14.85 4.96 .47 (2) .83 (2) (2) .66 6.52 (2) 1.43 10.64 4.02 .38 .21 1.41 .61 .54 2.77 .12 .28 .31 Electrical machinery, equipment, and supplies..................................................................................... Transformers — power, distribution, and specialty............................................................................ Switchgear and switchboards apparatus...... ........................ ............ ................................................ Electrical motors and generators...........................;............................................................................ Electronic timing systems and electric motor controls....................................................................... Welding supplies.... ............................................................................................................................... Electric housewares and fa n s .............................................................................................................. Household appliances, n.e.c................................................................................................................. Electric lamps and bulbs....................................................................................................................... Current-carrying wiring devices............................................................................................................ Noncurrent-carrying wiring devices....................................... .............................................................. Commercial, industrial, or institutional electric lighting fixtures........................................................ Emergency lighting systems and lighting equipment, n.e.c............................................................... Radio, television, and public address equipment, except communications and transmitting equipment............................................ .......................................................................... Radio and television communication and transmitting devices and parts, except tubes............... Electrical machinery, equipment, and supplies, n.e.c........................................................................ 89.00 2.80 17.30 2.30 (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) 4.20 22.00 30.80 (2) 46.33 1.64 6.57 4.34 1.94 .32 .33 .21 .48 1.74 7.34 13.49 .46 16.71 .53 3.25 .43 (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) .79 4.13 5.78 (2) 10.21 .36 1.45 .96 .43 .07 .07 .05 .11 .38 1.62 2.97 .10 3.50 3.30 2.80 .51 4.34 2.61 .66 .62 .53 .11 .96 .57 See footnotes at end of table. 15 Table 13. Continued — Materials, equipment, and supplies used in Federal building construction, 1959 and 1976 Value per$1,000 of contract cost Type of material '1959 Measuring, analyzing, and controlling instruments....,.................................................... Residential and commercial automatic environmental appliance controls............... Industrial instruments for measurement, display, and control of process variables. Measuring and controlling devices — nonelectrical.................. .............................. Miscellaneous measuring, analyzing, and controlling instruments........................... Percent distribution 1976 1959 1976 15.40 7.90 (1 23 ) (2) 7.50 4.61 3.38 .24 .81 .18 2.89 1.48 (2) (2) 1.41 1.01 .74 .05 .18 .04 Miscellaneous manufacturing industries.............................................................. 2.80 2.04 .53 .45 Total contractors’ construction equipment............................................ 19.10 29.08 3.59 6.41 (4) Apparel and other finished products made from fabrics and similar materials (2) .01 (2) Lumber and wood products, except furniture.................................................... Wood scaffolding — dressed board................................................................ Contractor's office — trailer.............................................................................. Wood products, n.e.c........................................................................................ (2) (2) (2) (2) .80 .12 .58 .10 (2) (2) (2) (2) .18 .03 .13 .02 Rubber and miscellaneous plastics products.................................................... (2) .05 (2) .01 Fabricated metal products, except machinery and transportation equipment Handtools (nonpowered).................................................................................. Metal forms — any m aterial............................................................................. Metal scaffolding................................................................................................ All other fabricated metal products................................................................. (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) 3.98 1.35 .82 1.72 .10 (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) .88 .30 .18 .38 .02 Machinery, except electrical................................................................................. Power cranes..................................................................................................... Tractors, bulldozers, and crawler tractors...................................................... Backhoes and trenchers................................................................................... Motor scrapers and graders............................................................................. Rollers and compactors.................................................................................... Mixers, pavers, and related equipment........................................................... Hoists, monorails, derricks, booms, and winches.......................................... Off-highway trucks................................................................................... ........ Front-end loaders.............................................................................................. Other light construction machinery and equipm ent...................................... (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) 21.86 8.34 1.45 1.48 .12 .25 .40 2.64 .29 .79 .33 (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) 4.82 1.84 .32 .33 .03 .05 .09 .58 .06 .17 .07 All other heavy construction equipment......................................................... Drill rigs............................................................................................................... Industrial trucks, tractors, forklifts, and related equipment........................... Power driven handtools.................................................................................... Welder and cutting apparatus.......................................................................... Pumps................................................................................................................. Compressors..................................................................................................... Power driven service machines...................................................................... Machinery, except electrical, n.e.c................................................................... (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) .14 .25 .30 1.59 .31 .57 .35 .13 2.14 (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) .03 .05 .07 .35 .07 .13 .08 .03 .47 Electrical machinery, equipment, and supplies............................ Electrical welding apparatus....................................................... Miscellaneous electrical machinery, equipment, and supplies (2) (2) (2) .69 .57 .12 (2) (2) (2) .15 .13 .03 Transportation equipm ent............................................................... Motor trucks (highway)................................................................ Miscellaneous transportation equipment................................... (2) (2) (2) 1.60 1.53 .07 (2) (2) (2) .35 .34 .02 Measuring, analyzing, and controlling instruments...................... (2) .03 (2) .01 Miscellaneous manufacturing industries (2) .06 (2) .01 1 Detailed data have been regrouped for the year 1959 and group totals may vary slightly from those presented in earlier publications of the survey data. 2 Not available. 3 The last items in each group labeled n.e.c. (not elsewhere classified) are those which have not appeared in the previous surveys in sufficient amounts to be recorded, but were included in this table to present the complete results of the latest survey. 4 Less than 0.005. NOTE: Detail may not add to totals because of rounding. Materials data for the 1959 Federal buildings study were reaggregrated to match the 1972 Standard Industrial Classification manual to make comparisons with the 1976 materials data easier. Data include sales tax. and transportation equipment, the third largest group, accounted for more than $88 per $1,000 of contract cost. Within this group, the important products were metal reinforcing bars and expended metal lath, and fabricated sheet-metal products. Three items, whose used increased appreciably in the current Federal building survey, were air-conditioning, structural steel, and concrete products. Air-condition ing is becoming widely used in most Federal buildings to help create a more productive working environment. 16 Concrete block and other concrete products have gained wide usage for floor and ceiling bases and exte rior walls. Structural steel is more widely accepted as a replacement for load bearing masonry and other types of framing materials, particularly on high rise struc tures. Continuing development of new and better con struction materials should help to control material costs on Federal building projects in the future. For convenience, construction machinery and equip ment were included in the materials table as a sep arate category. Costs for construction equipment were based on depreciated or rental costs or equivalent value of machinery or equipment at the construction site, exclusive of equipment operators. Expenditures amounted to about $29 per $1,000 during 1976 or more than 6 percent of all materials and equipment costs. The major cost item in this category is machinery, except electrical, which consists primarily of construction equipment such as cranes, hoists, power-driven handtools, backhoes, bulldozers, and similar items. Construction time 1959 1973 1976 All projects....................................................... 73 63.8 129.9 Construction cost group: $1,000,000 and less.......................................... $1,000,001 $5,000,000.................................. $5,000,001— $10,000,000................................ $10,000,001— $25,000,000.............................. $25,000,001 and o v e r....................................... (1) (1) (1) 0 (1) 45.6 70.3 100.7 (2) — (2) 104.0 (2) 121.9 211.5 (1) (1) (1) (1) 63.1 40.7 78.3 75.7 179.4 107.3 148.4 (3) Characteristic Region: N ortheast............................................................ North C entral..................................................... _____ 1 Not available. 2 Insufficient data. 3 In the 1976 study, data for the West are not sufficiently reliable to permit publication of detailed data for that region. NOTE: Dash denotes that the survey had no sample projects in this cell. Table 15. Percent distribution of onsite employee hours by decile of construction time, 1959 and 1976 Projects in the North Central region required the fewest number of weeks to complete of any region in the 1973 and 1976 Federal building surveys, reflecting the smaller average size of projects in this region (table 14). The South and Northeast regions experienced the highest average number of weeks of construction time, in 1973 and 1976, respectively. As expected, the length of time for completion increased as the size and cost of the projects grew. In order to develop a typical employment pattern, the construction time for each project was divided into 10 equal parts or deciles. This distribution or phasing pattern of onsite work shows that the distribution of onsite hours during the construction period has not changed significantly between 1959 and 1976 (table 15). On average, the percentage of total hours required in creased slowly over about two-thirds of the total time period and then declined gradually in both 1959 and 1976. Percent of onsite hours Construction time 1959 1976 T o ta l.................................................................... 100.0 100.0 1st decile................................................................... 2d decile..................................................................... 3d decile..................................................................... 4th decile.................................................................... 5th decile................................................................... 6th decile.................................................................... 7th decile.................................................................... 8th decile................................................................... 9th decile................................................................... 10th decile................................................................. 2.7 6.4 9.7 11.8 13.0 14.4 13.3 13.8 10.5 4.3 3.7 5.7 10.5 12.7 13.5 14.3 15.8 11.9 8.4 3.5 Table 16. Average number of contractors for Federal building projects by type of contractor and region, 19761 Contraetors Federal building projects in 1976 required an aver age of about 47 contractors per project, ranging from about 54 contractors per project in the North Central region to about 36 contractors in the Northeast (table 16). On average, each project had 1 general contractor, 5 prime contractors, 33 subcontractors, and 8 sub-subcontractors. The North Central region required the highest average number of prime contractors and sub contractors per project. The South region experienced the highest number of sub-subcontractors per project. Table 14. Average number of weeks of construction time for Federal building projects by selected characteristics, 1959, 1973, and 1976 __________________ __ Type of contractor United States North east North Central South All contractors.......................... 47.3 35.8 53.9 50.2 General contractors................. 1.2 1.0 .9 1.8 Prime contractors.................... 4.9 .6 8.3 3.6 Subcontractors......................... 32.9 23.6 38.0 34.2 Sub-subcontractors................. 8.3 10.6 6.7 10.7 1 Data for the West are not sufficiently reliable to permit publication of detailed dataforthat region. NOTE: Detail may not add to totals because of rounding. 17 Chapter V. Comparison With Other Surweys Total employee hour requirements for Federal build ing construction were the lowest of any building con struction activity in the BLS studies of construction la bor requirements (table 17).'4 However, it is possible that requirements for commercial office building and school construction might have been the same as for Federal building construction, or slightly lower, if the studies had been conducted in the same year. The occupational requirements for Federal building construction were essentially the same as for commer cial office buildings (table 18). Compared with all nonresidential building construction activity studied by BLS, the occupational requirements for Federal build ing construction were the highest for administrative and supervisory workers and the lowest for skilled trades workers. Among individual occupations, Federal build ing construction employed the highest proportion of electricians and iron workers and the lowest proportion of bricklayers, plasterers and lathers, and laborers, helpers, and tenders. The distribution of contract costs for Federal build ing construction more closely resembled those for com- mercial office buildings than schools or general hospi tals (table 19). The ratio of onsite wages and salaries for Federal buildings, 25.8 percent, was the lowest among these four nonresidential building activities. The cost of overhead and profit, 28.8 percent, was the high est for Federal building construction, reflecting rising interest expenses and the increasing scope and size of most construction projects, necessitating more planning, coordination, and offsite work. The material requirements for Federal building con struction again most closely matched those for com mercial office building construction than for the two other nonresidential building activities (table 20). Al though Federal buildings required a larger proportion of primary metal products and a smaller proportion of stone, clay, glass, and concrete products and machin ery, except electrical, than commercial office buildings, these three groups of materials accounted for almost 60 percent of the cost of materials in both types of con struction. These three major groupings made up almost 63 percent of total materials, equipment, and supplies for Federal buildings and nearly 59 percent for com mercial office buildings. Federal building construction required a larger proportion of primary metal products and construction equipment and a smaller proportion of mining, lumber, furniture, and fabricated metal prod ucts than the three other nonresidential building activities. 14In comparing the Federal building construction survey with other surveys of construction labor requirements, it must be kept in mind that the studies cover different time periods. Furthermore, compari sons cannot reasonably be made with heavy construction (i.e., high ways, sewer works, and civil works) which is entirely different in nature from building construction. IS Table 17. Employee hours per 1,000 current dollars of contract cost by industry, all construction studies, 1958-76 Construction Trade, transportation, and services Mining and all other Total, all industries Onsite Commercial office buildings: 1 9 7 2 -7 3 ............................................................................. 97.5 37.2 4.8 33.0 16.6 5.9 Public housing: I9 6 0 2.................................................................................. 19682.................................................................................. 1975................................................................................... 246.0 175.1 (3) 113.7 79.6 33.2 15.9 11.9 7.1 65.3 47.8 (3) 36.9 26.7 (3) 14.2 8.8 (3) Elementary and secondary schools: 19592.................................................................................. 19652.................................................................................. 1972................................................................................... 231.8 193.2 114.1 86.0 72.3 41.6 11.7 8.8 6.0 78.0 65.8 40.8 41.4 34.4 14.8 12.0 Federally aided highways: 19582.................................................................................. 1976................................................................................... 250.7 80.5 97.3 32.2 9.0 3.3 66.1 22.8 52.5 15.4 25.8 6.9 Federal office buildings: 19592.................................................................................. 1973.................................................................................... 1976.................................................................................... 235.8 (3) 81.4 97.1 42.8 29.8 10.9 4.7 4.6 79.2 (3) 26.0 35.7 (3) 16.5 12.9 (3) 4.5 College housing: 19612.................................................................................. 1972.................................................................................... 236.3 (3) 93.6 48.3 14.1 8.1 77.5 (3) 37.2 (3) 13.8 (3) (3) (3) (3) 47.4 (3) 3.9 (3) (3) (3) (3) (3) (3) 213.4 (3) 84.7 43.2 4.5 2.5 53.2 (3) 46.9 (3) 24.1 (3) 251.4 (3) 133.9 57.0 15.6 7.0 56.8 (3) 31.6 (3) 13.5 (3) 208.8 128.3 85.9 48.0 4.8 3.0 75.9 48.8 27.2 18.8 15.0 9.7 208.1 127.4 82.7 47.0 5.7 4.0 80.0 51.6 27.1 17.6 12.6 7.2 Private multifamily housing: 19712.................................................................................. 137.5 50.0 6.5 46.9 26.1 8.1 Private single-family housing: 19622.................................................................................. 19692.................................................................................. 215.7 145.6 72.1 51.9 11.0 8.2 68.6 47.2 48.7 29.6 16.1 8.7 General hospitals: 1959-602............................................................................ 19662.................................................................................. 226.0 189.0 88.8 76.1 12.3 9.8 78.0 64.0 34.2 29.6 12.7 9.5 Nursing homes: 1965-664............................................................................ 192.7 73.7 8.4 66.6 33.6 10.4 Type of construction and year Civil works, total: 19 60................................................................................... 1972.................................................................................... Land projects: 1960.................................................................................... 1972................................................................................... Dredging projects: I96 02.................................................................................. 1972.................................................................................... Sewer works: Lines: 19632.................................................................................. 1971 ................................................................................... Plants: 19632................... .............................................................. 1971.................................................................................... 1 Revised. Revision based on adjustment to 1979 benchmarks of Employment and Earnings series. Some SIC groupings were not revised for earlier years; thus, data on offsite construction hours are not strictly comparable. Differences, however, would be slight. 2 Indirect data revised from original study results due to reprocessing Offsite1 Manufacturing materials through improved input-output tables. 3 Not available. 4 Estimated except for onsite construction hours. Based on case study. NOTE: Detail may not addto totals due to rounding. labile 18. Percent distribution of onsite employee hours, per 1,000 current dollars of contract cost by occupation, all construction studies, 1958-76 Type of construction and year AdminisAll trativeand occupa super tions visory Brick layers Carpen Electri Iron ters cians workers Operat ing engi neers Painters Plas terers and lathers Other Plumb skilled ers con and strucpipe tion fitters trades Laborers, helpers, and tenders Other occupa tions (includ ing truckdrivers) Commercial office buildings: 1974......................................... 100.0 7.4 3.3 19.2 6.4 6.3 4.0 1.9 2.1 6.2 19.0 22.6 1.6 Elementary and secondary schools: 19 59......................................... 19 65......................................... 1972......................................... 100.0 100.0 100.0 3.9 3.6 4.4 9.3 9.2 6.0 18.7 16.5 16.8 7.1 7.3 11.0 2.8 3.1 4.2 1.9 2.7 2.4 3.3 3.5 2.8 2.7 2.0 2.7 9.4 9.6 9.6 7.9 10.1 16.9 29.1 30.9 22.3 4.0 . 1.5 .9 Federally aided highways: 1958......................................... 1976......................................... 100.0 100.0 10.4 6.3 (1) - (1) 5.7 (1) 1.2 (1) 2.6 (1) 24.3 0 .4 (1) - (1) .2 38.2 5.9 (1) 33.2 251.4 320.3 Federal office buildings: 1959......................................... 1973......................................... 1976......................................... 100.0 (1) 100.0 6.0 0 8.1 5.2 0 2.7 12.6 9.1 4.2 ( 1) 13.9 11.5 7.8 2.4 (1) 3.6 2.1 ( 1) 1.6 3.8 (1) 2.2 8.7 (1) 7.9 11.8 (1) 17.1 32.5 0 21.4 1.5 (1) 2.2 College housing: 1961......................................... 1972......................................... 100.0 (1) 3.4 O 10.0 0 16.9 (1) 6.6 O 3.9 (1) 1.7 (1) 3.6 (1) 3.4 0 9.7 (1) 7.8 0 31.8 (1) 1.1 (1) 100.0 (1) 10.1 (1) 6.4 (1) - 24.1 (1) - 23.0 26.4 (1) (1) (1) 6.9 0 3.1 (1) - 0 ( 1) ( 1) ( 1) 100.0 (1) 4.7 (1) - - - - n 0 (1) 1.1 (1) 1.7 0 1.7 (1) 490.8 (1) 100.0 100.0 11.2 12.9 1.7 1.0 7.7 6.9 1.5 2.9 1.9 1.9 100.0 100.0 11.6 13.5 1.3 .2 2.4 1.2 .1 .4 100.0 100.0 11.0 12.3 2.0 1.9 14.3 14.0 Private multifamily housing: 1971......................................... 100.0 5.8 5.0 Private single-family housing: 1962......................................... 1969......................................... 100.0 100.0 3.0 2.8 100.0 100.0 4.0 3.6 ( 1) ( 1) General hospitals: 1960.......................................... 1966.......................................... 100.0 100.0 3.9 3.2 5.4 5.0 13.2 13.0 8.8 9.9 3.5 3.1 Nursing homes: 1966s........................................ 100.0 4.4 6.4 15.2 7.8 2.2 Civil works: Land projects: 1960......................................... 1972......................................... Dredging projects: 1960......................................... 1972......................................... Sewer works, total: 1963......................................... 1971......................................... Lines: 1963......................................... 1971 ......................................... Plants: 1963......................................... 1971......................................... Public housing: 1960.......................................... 1968.......................................... 1975.......................................... - ( 1) - - - 0 (1) 0 0 17.4 20.4 .7 .8 - 2.5 3.3 2.7 5.4 39.1 30.0 13.4 14.4 .4 .2 19.6 27.3 - - .4 - 1.2 3.0 44.9 33.7 18.1 20.6 3.3 5.7 3.9 4.5 14.6 11.5 1.5 1.9 - 5.1 7.2 4.6 9.8 31.8 25.1 7.9 5.9 25.4 5.9 2.3 2.9 4.0 1.7 7.6 11.3 25.8 2.3 5.5 5.7 34.6 34.9 2.8 3.0 1.4 1.8 9.5 7.3 2.0 1.7 5.2 4.3 12.2 20.0 23.3 27.9 .5 .5 7.6 7.8 19.1 20.3 4.1 5.8 2.7 3.1 4.4 4.9 6.8 3.0 7.8 9.3 6.5 6.6 30.9 30.2 4.0 1.9 ( 1) 0 ( 1) O 1.6 1.8 2.8 2.6 6.2 6.1 14.2 15.6 12.0 13.1 26.7 25.7 1.7 1.8 4.7 5.6 13.7 11.2 26.7 .4 D ( 1) 0 - 2.1 3.5 ( 1) 0 0 ( 1) .7 4 Includes mostly ships’ masters, captains, mates, crew, and support personnel. 5 Based on case study. NOTE: Dash denotes that the survey had no sample projects in this cell. 1 Not available. 2 Includes apprentices and on-the-job trainees and laborers, helpers, and tenders. 3 Includes blue-collar worker supervisors. ( 1) 20 Table 19. Percent distribution of construction contract costs, all construction studies, 1958-76 — Total contract costs Onsite wages and salaries Materials, supplies, and built-in equipment Commercial office buildings: 1974......................................................................... 100.0 26.7 42.2 2.7 28.5 Elementary and secondary schools: 1972......................................................................... 1965......................................................................... 1959......................................................................... 100.0 100.0 100.0 28.2 25.8 26.7 44.4 54.2 54.1 2.1 1.0 1.4 25.3 19.0 17.8 Federally aided highways: 1976......................................................................... 1958......................................................................... 100.0 100.0 23.8 23.9 46.7 50.6 (2) (2) 29.5 25.5 Federal office buildings: 19 76......................................................................... 19733........................................................................ 19 59......................................................................... 100.0 100.0 100.0 25.8 34.0 29.0 42.5 50.0 51.3 2.9 (4) 1.9 28.8 16.0 17.7 College housing: 19723........................................................................ 1961 ......................................................................... 100.0 100.0 36.0 29.3' 51.1 52.6 (4) 1.6 13.0 16.5 100.0 100.0 26.0 29.1 29.0 26.2 22.0 22.1 22.0 22.6 100.0 100.0 25.0 26.0 32.0 35.0 20.0 19.3 24.0 19.7 100.0 100.0 30.0 32.3 24.0 17.3 28.0 24.9 19.0 25.5 100.0 100.0 24.7 25.3 40.7 46.6 11.5 9.9 23.1 18.2 100.0 100.0 24.3 24.3 35.2 44.5 16.7 11.2 23.8 20.0 100.0 100.0 25.2 26.6 47.0 49.2 5.6 8.2 22.2 16.0 Private multifamily housing: 1971......................................................................... 100.0 27.9 44.2 3.0 24.8 Private single-family housing: 1969s........................................................................ 1962s........................................................................ 100.0 100.0 20.4 22.1 43.4 47.2 .9 1.0 35.3 29.7 Public housing: 19753........................................................................ 1968......................................................................... 19 60......................................................................... 100.0 100.0 100.0 32.7 32.4 35.5 48.7 41.9 45.0 4.4 1.5 2.5 14.2 24.2 17.0 General hospitals: 1966......................................................................... 1960......................................................................... 100.0 100.0 29.6 28.2 50.4 53.2 1.3 1.2 18.7 17.4 Nursing homes: 1966®........................................................................ 100.0 28.7 53.7 1.2 16.4 Type of construction and year Civil works, total: 19723........................................................................ 1960......................................................................... Land projects: 1972......................................................................... 1960......................................................................... Dredging projects: 1972......................................................................... 19 60......................................................................... Sewer works, total: 1971......................................................................... 1963......................................................................... Lines: 1971......................................................................... 1963......................................................................... Plants: 1971......................................................................... 1963......................................................................... Overhead and profit1 j 1 Includes offsite wages, fringe benefits, construction financing costs, inventory, and other overhead and administrative expenses as well as profit. 2 Equipment included with overhead and profit. 3 Estimated. 4 Equipment included in materials. Construction equipment 5 Includes selling expenses. 6 Estimated. Based on case study. NOTE: Detail may not add to totals due to rounding. 1 Table 20. Percent distribution of cost of materials, supplies, and equipment by product group, all construction studies, 1958-76 Type of construction and year Mining Total Lumber and Petro Stone, mate Chemi quarrying and wood leum clay, rials, Furniture cal and Primary of non- products, refining glass, and fix supplies, allied metal metallic except and and and tures prod products minerals, furni related concrete equip ucts except ture products products ment fuel Fabri cated metal prod ucts1 Elec Con trical and elec struction Machin tronic equip Material ery, machin ment and except ery, (rental supplies, elec equip value and n.e.c. trical ment, deprecia tion) and supplies Commercial office buildings: 1974......................................... 100.00 0.67 7.55 0.42 0.99 1.98 23.90 12.55 22.21 11.43 7.62 5.99 4.69 Federal office buildings: 1959 ......................................... 1973......................................... 1976......................................... 100.00 (2) 100.00 .41 (2) .49 3.31 (2) 2.31 .34 (2) .41 1.03 (2) 1.10 .88 (2) 1.11 21.60 (2) 22.61 7.32 (2) 20.82 32.81 (2) 19.33 6.91 (2) 10.65 18.20 (2) 10.11 3.59 (2) 6.52 3.61 (2) 4.56 Elementary and secondary schools: 1959......................................... 1965......................................... 1972......................................... 100.00 100.00 100.00 .83 1.62 .85 9.90 9.13 6.09 1.50 2.90 3.67 1.41 .96 1.41 2.02 2.27 1.72 24.99 24.67 20.15 13.07 11.68 11.03 26.78 24.41 24.06 2.47 5.30 7.71 9.27 8.78 12.32 4.04 4.45 4.52 3.74 3.83 6.47 Private multifamily housing: 1971......................................... 100.00 1.34 18.67 3.89 2.21 1.74 22.12 8.85 15.59 3.72 9.36 6.51 6.00 Private single-family housing: 1962......................................... 100.00 1969......................................... 100.00 .79 .89 40.05 37.40 3.28 2.22 1.82 2.30 1.80 23.58 21.33 5.50 5.05 14.60 12.90 .46 1.90 6.49 6.77 2.03 2.00 1.99 4.87 Public housing: 1960......................................... 100.00 1968......................................... 100.00 1975......................................... (2) .80 .80 (2) 14.10 14.40 (2) .30 .30 (2) 1.80 2.00 (2) 1.70 2.20 (2) 27.10 24.70 (2) 8.00 9.20 (2) 28.50 27.20 (2) 2.30 2.50 (2) 8.40 11.30 (2) 5.30 3.50 (2) 1.80 1.80 (2) General hospitals: 1960......................................... 100.00 1966......................................... 100.00 .42 .51 4.16 4.66 .86 .44 .81 .77 .97 .80 18.98 18.40 6.82 8.61 35.05 31.11 8.48 12.11 15.60 15.62 2.06 2.50 5.89 4.47 Nursing homes: 19664....................................... 100.00 .53 9.06 .27 1.24 1.82 20.16 6.23 33.32 11.03 10.78 2.15 3.41 College housing: 1961......................................... 1972......................................... 100.00 (2) .78 (2) 10.67 (2) 1.70 (2) 1.18 (2) 1.05 (2) 25.78 (2) 6.11 (2) 33.90 (2) 2.92 (2) 11.36 (2) 2.94 (2) 1.62 (2) Federally aided highways: 19 58......................................... 100.00 19 76......................................... 100.00 11.34 12.42 1.76 .85 - .80 .97 17.09 17.58 16.77 14.04 17.46 (2) 4.15 (2) — 3.87 (2) 12.65 (2) 9.09 (2) 3.93 (2) 28.07 (2) — - (2) .36 1.14 3.02 4.82 .98 .87 1.85 1.25 Civil works: Land projects: 1960......................................... 100.00 19 72......................................... (2) Dredging projects: 1960............. ........................... 100.00 1972......................................... (2) Sewer works: Lines: 19 63......................................... 100.00 1971......................................... 100.00 Plants: 19 63......................................... 100.00 1971 ......................................... 100.00 - (2) - — — (2) (2) (2) 4.65 3.43 .79 1.53 - 2.27 1.11 1.64 2.46 .22 - 1 Includes vitreous china plumbing fixtures except for Federally aided highways, private office buildings, elementary and secondary schools (1971), and single-family and multifamily housing. 2 Not available. 19.48 21.22 - - 13.20 (2) .59 (2) (2) 1.49 (2) 1.40 (2) 55.87 40.77 8.79 7.38 2.39 2.20 16.78 15.62 14.48 11.22 13.16 13.87 - 1.33 (2) (3) (3) 32.75 32.92 .24 (2) 35.39 (2) 2.05 (2) — (2) 58.98 (2) 6.13 (2) 3.02 4.48 .74 1.03 20.19 32.22 .20 1.00 22.34 33.51 9.51 6.72 14.25 10.59 2.75 2.54 3 Construction equipment estimate included in materials and supplies, n.e.c. 4 Based on case study. NOTE: Detail may not add to totals due to rounding. Dash denotes that the survey had no sample projects in this cell. /^ppoftKofe Detailed Labor asubl ©®sft Data by ^©gi©ini Tables A-l through A-5 show detailed labor and cost data, by region, for Federal building construction dur ing 1976. Detailed data on employment, wage, and cost requirements are presented for 3 of the 4 economic re gions. (Data for the West are not sufficiently reliable to permit publication of detailed data for that region.) !R(ig)i©rDsii cmptoyment data Tables A-l and A-2 show regional detail during 1976 for the onsite employee hour data summarized in the text in tables 3 and 4. Regional onsite employment re quirements by occupation are presented in table A-l. Table A-2 lists the employment share of the general 23 and special trades contractors engaged in Federal build ing construction, by region. Regional data by selected building characteristics Tables A-3, A-4, and A-5 show regional employment, cost, and wage data, by selected building characteris tics during 1976. These data are summarized in text ta bles 5, 9, and 12. Variations in regional employment, cost, and wage requirements reflect differences in de sign and type of structure as well as the regional con ditions under which the Federal building projects were built. Table A-1. Onsite employee hour requirements per $1,000 of contract cost for Federal building construction by occupation and region, 19761 Percent distribution Employee hours per $1,000 Occupation United States North east North Central All occupations..................................................... 29.8 25.9 Skilled trades workers: Bricklayers................................................................ Carpenters................................................................ Cement finishers...................................................... Drywall applicators and finishers............................ Electricians............................................................... Elevator constructors............................................... Glaziers..................................................................... Insulation workers.................................................... .8 4.1 1.0 .1 3.4 ■4 .1 .4 Iron workers, ornam ental....................................... Iron workers, reinforcing......................................... Iron workers, structural............................................ Lathers....................................................................... Marble setters........................................................... Operating engineers................................................ Painters..................................................................... Pile-driver operators................................................ South United States North east North Central South 24.4 36.3 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 .7 3.8 .5 (1 2) 3.5 ■7 .1 .3 1.0 2.8 1.1 .1 3.4 .4 .1 .3 .7 5.4 1.1 .1 3.4 .4 .2 .6 2.7 13.9 3.3 .2 11.5 1.4 .5 1.4 2.8 14.6 2.0 .2 13.6 2.6 .3 1.2 4.3 11.4 4.4 .2 14.0 1.5 .4 1.2 1.8 14.9 3.1 .2 9.4 1.0 .6 1.6 .3 .4 1.7 .3 .2 1.1 .5 .2 •4 .1 2.2 .5 (3) .9 .2 (3) •2 .3 1.0 .2 (3) .9 .4 (3) .3 .5 2.1 .4 (3) 1.2 .7 .2 .9 1.2 5.8 1.1 .8 3.6 1.7 .6 1.4 .5 8.6 1.9 (3) 3.6 .9 (3) .8 1.1 4.3 .7 (3) 3.6 1.5 (3) .7 1.4 5.7 1.0 (3) 3.4 2.0 .6 Pipefitters.................................................................. Plasterers.................................................................. Plumbers................................................................... R oofers..................................................................... Sheet metal workers................................................ Sprinkler fitters.......................................................... Tile setters................................................................ Other skilled trades workers................................... 1.0 .3 1.3 .3 1.3 .4 .2 .4 .7 .2 1.1 .1 1.2 .2 (2) 1.5 1.3 .3 .8 .2 1.2 .6 .1 .4 1.0 .4 1.8 .5 1.5 .2 3.4 1.1 4.5 1.0 4.5 1.2 .6 1.4 2.7 .9 4.4 .5 4.7 .7 .1 5.8 5.3 1.3 3.4 .6 5.1 2.6 .6 1.5 2.7 1.1 5.1 1.4 4.1 .7 .8 2.0 Semiskilled and unskilled workers: Laborers, helpers, and tenders.............................. Truckdrivers.............................................................. Custodial w orkers.................................................... O ther.......................................................................... 6.4 .2 .1 .4 5.2 .1 4.4 8.6 20.2 .3 .3 (3) .9 18.0 1.2 (3) 1.1 23.7 .8 .4 1.4 Onsite office and administrative workers: Clerical w orkers....................................................... Professional and technical workers....................... Superintendents and blue-collar supervisors....... .2 .6 1.6 .8 1.7 2.4 .3 4.1 5.6 1.0 1.1 6.2 .2 .3 .1 .5 21.4 .8 .2 1.2 .2 .4 .6 .1 1.0 1.4 .4 .4 2.2 .8 2.0 5.3 — 1Data for the West are not sufficiently reliable to permit publication of detailed dataforthatregion. 2 Less than 0.05. .3 .7 24 .3 — 3 Insufficient data. NOTE: Dash denotes that the survey had no sample projects in this cell. Detail may not add to totals because of rounding. Table A-2. Percent distribution of onsite employee hour requirements per $1,000 for Federal building construction by type of contractor and region, 19761 United States North east North Central South T o ta l............................................... 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 General contractor............................... Waterproofing....................................... Concrete w ork...................................... Structural ste e l..................................... Carpentry............................................... Masonry................................................. Heating, ventilating, and air-conditioning................................. Sheet metal w o rk ................................. Plumbing............................................... 30.5 .6 6.0 5.8 1.2 5.2 24.6 .4 8.7 9.2 1.1 8.8 15.4 .6 12.5 7.4 .7 6.2 40.4 .7 1.6 3.8 1.5 3.5 13.6 .3 3.0 9.9 .3 3.9 12.5 .8 3.3 15.6 (3) 2.4 Electrical................................................ Elevators............................................... Insulating............................................... W allboard.............................................. Plastering and lathing......................... Painting and wallpapering................... Linoleum, vinyl tile, and vinyl-asbestos tile ...................................................... Carpeting............................................... Roofing, gutterwork, flashing, and siding................................................. 11.2 2.8 .5 2.9 1.7 1.5 12.0 4.5 (3) .8 (3) .9 13.7 2.9 1.5 2.3 2.5 1.2 9.6 2.2 .1 4.0 1.1 1.9 .1 .6 (3) .5 .1 .6 .2 .7 1.3 1.0 .8 1.7 Ornamental iron work.......................... Asphalt- paving...................................... Landscaping......................................... Acoustical.............................................. Excavation, footing, foundations, and grading............................................... Ceramic tile .......................................... Terrazzo................................................ Glass and glazin g................................ Concrete reinforcement....................... O th er..................................................... .2 .1 (3) (3) .1 3.2 .4 .2 2.4 (3) .1 .4 .9 8.6 1.4 (3) .5 .2 1.1 2.5 .4 .7 .9 .5 2.7 Type of contractor2 .3 1.8 4.8 .6 .4 .6 .4 1.9 5.3 .3 (3) (3) (3) 4.6 .3 1 Data for the West are not sufficiently reliable to permit publication of detailed data for that region. 2 Since many contractors perform more than one operation, contractors are classified according to the major cost component of their work. 3 Insufficient data. NOTE: Detail may not add to totals because of rounding. 25 Table A-3. Onsite employee hour requirements in Federal building construction by selected characteristics and region, 19761 Employee hours per $1,000 Employee hours per 100 square feet South United States North east North Central South 24.4 36.3 142.2 169.6 102.3 168.9 (1 2) (2) 26.0 (2) 28.2 (2) 34.0 (2) 36.9 177.9 120.9 140.7 (2) (2) 174.4 (2) 111.2 (2) 179.1 (2) 163.8 30.0 27.8 25.9 - 24.4 (2) 37.1 (2) 140.5 164.7 169.6 - 99.2 (2) 170.3 (2) Basement: Basement.................................................................. No basement............................................................ 29.4 32.3 26.0 (2) 24.2 (2) 36.6 35.2 139.8 158.9 173.3 (2) 101.7 (2) 166.9 177.2 Parking area: In or under the building.......................................... Outdoor..................................................................... In or under the building and outdoor..................... 29.5 29.4 31.7 (2) (2) (2) (2) 25.0 (2) 36.2 34.5 (2) 146.5 136.1 135.3 (2) (2) (2) (2) 99.2 (2) 158.9 187.9 (2) Heat: Forced a ir ................................................................. Hot w a te r.................................................................. Electric radiant......................................................... 29.5 32.2 31.6 26.0 - 36.8 (2) (2) 146.1 118.6 130.7 173.3 - (2) 23.4 (2) (2) (2) 98.3 (2) (2) 177.7 (2) (2) Fuel: E lectricity.................................................................. G a s ............................................................................ 29.3 31.0 (2) (2) 23.9 25.7 35.8 (2) 140.1 127.6 (2) (2) 103.1 92.3 187.4 (2) Framing: Steel.......................................................................... Concrete................................................................... 29.8 31.1 25.9 - 24.5 (2) 37.5 (2) 141.9 150.6 169.6 - 99.3 (2) 178.7 (2) Exteriorwall: Concrete................................................................... Load bearing masonry............................................. Curtain w a ll............................................................... 32.0 28.8 31.7 (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) 37.4 (2) (2) 150.2 124.6 159.1 (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) 165.6 (2) (2) Interior wall: Drywall...................................................................... 34.2 30.7 28.0 36.2 157.0 177.3 102.1 166.8 Floor base: Concrete................................................................... 29.7 25.9 24.1 36.2 140.7 169.6 99.5 166.8 Floor covering: Carpet....................................................................... Vinyl/vinyl-asbestos tile ........................................... 29.0 33.6 26.0 (2) 23.7 - 37.3 34.7 141.6 162.9 173.3 (2) 103.1 - 170.7 165.9 Ceiling: Acoustical tile............................................................ 29.8 25.9 24.4 37.1 141.5 169.6 102.3 170.3 Roof base: Steel decking............................................................ C oncrete................................................................... 32.4 31.0 (2) 26.0 25.3 27.1 39.9 35.3 139.8 153.8 (2) 173.3 89.0 112.5 210.9 158.7 Roof cover: Built up...................................................................... 29.7 25.5 24.4 36.4 140.5 169.3 102.3 167.2 Characteristic United States North east All projects............................................................ 29.8 25.9 Number of stories: Less than 3 ............................................................... 3 or 4 ........................................................................ 5 or m ore.................................................................. 31.2 29.0 29.7 Conveyor systems: Elevators................................................................... No elevators............................................................ North Central 1 Data for the West are not sufficiently reliable to permit publication of detailed data for that region. 2 Insufficient data. NOTE: Dash denotes that the survey had no sample projects in this cell, 26 Table A-4. Construction costs of Federal buildings by selected characteristics and region, 19761 Cost per square foot United States North east All projects..................................... $47.70 Characteristic Number of stories: Less than 3 ....................................... 3 or 4 ................................................ 5 or m ore.......................................... 57.05 41.73 47.37 Conveyor systems: Elevators........................................... No elevators..................................... 46.84 59.25 Basement: Basement.......................................... No basement.................................... Parking area: In or under the building................... Outdoor.............................................. In or underthe building and outdoor............................................ Heat: Hot w a te r.......................................... Electric radiant.................................. Fuel: Electricity.......................................... G a s .................................................... Oil....................................................... 47.49 49.13 Cost per square foot North Central South $65.60 $41.90 $46.5E (2) (2) 67.09 (2) 39.43 f) 65.56 — 66.78 (2) 40.60 (2) 42.01 (2) Characteristic Framing: Steel.................................................. Concrete........................................... Load bearing masonry.................... 52.7( (2) 44.47' Exterior wall : Concrete........................................... Load bearing masonry.................... Curtain w a ll...................................... 45.8< (2) nterior wall: Drywali.............................................. Plaster............................................... 45.6 50.4 Hoorbase: Concrete........................................... North east North Central South 47.65 48.44 (2) 65.56 (2). 40.60 (2) (2) 47.68 (2) (2) 46.96 43.34 50.17 (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) 44.25 (2) (2) 45.95 (2) 57.69 (2) 36.50 (2) 46.07 (2) 47.34 65.56 41.23 46.07 48.80 48.49 66.78 (2) 43.46 45.82 45.82 49.58 46.26 (2) (2) (2) 39.67 43.9 54.4- 42.75 (2) (2) (2) Floor covering: C arpet................................................ Vinyl/vinyl-asbestos tile ................... 4fi X Ceiling: Acoustical tile.................................... 47.49 65.56 41.90 45.89 Roof base: Steel decking.................................... Concrete............................................ 43.14 49.64 (2) 66.78 35.14 41.55 52.92 45.01 52.39 (2) Roof cover: (2) Built up............................................... 47.26 66.40 41.90 45.96 4Q 4c; 36.87 41.40 47.87 41.24 (2) 7R (2) (2) (2) (2) 3? 04 (2) (2) 43.16 35.84 (2) (2) ' (2) 1 Data for the w est are not sufficiently reliable to permit publication of detailed data for that region. United States 27 “ 2 Insufficient data, NOTE: Dash denotes that the survey had no sample projects in this cell. Table A-5. Average onsite earnings and wages as a percent of contract costs on Federal building construction projects by selected characteristics and region, 19761 Average hourly earnings United States North east North Central Number of stories: Less than 3 ............................................................... 3 or 4 ......................................................................... 5 or m ore.................................................................. $8.67 9.27 8.57 (2) (2) 9.56 Conveyor systems: Elevators................................................................... No elevators............................................................. 8.65 8.87 Basement: Basement.................................................................. No basem ent............................................................ Wages as a percent of contract costs South United States North east North Central South (2) 9.40 (2) $8.37 (2) 7.40 27.03 26.86 25.46 (2) (2) 24.85 (2) 26.50 (2) 28.45 (2) 27.29 9.54 - 9.96 (2) 7.56 (2) 25.95 24.65 24.67 - 24.34 (2) 28.05 (2) 8.80 7.86 9.55 (2) 10.05 (2) 7.68 7.47 25.90 25.41 24.80 (2) 24.31 (2) 28.10 26.27 Parking area: In or under the building........................................... Outdoor..................................................................... In or under the building and outdoor..................... 8.68 8.96 8.15 (2) (2) (2) (2) 9.66 (2) 7.53 8.40 (2) 25.64 26.38 25.80 (2) (2) (2) (2) 24.17 (2) 27.25 29.00 (2) Heat: Forced a ir ................................................................. Hot w a te r.................................................................. Electric radiant......................................................... 8.79 8.11 8.10 9.55 (2) 10.24 (2) (2) 7.69 (2) (2) 25.96 26.08 25.56 24.80 (2) 23.95 (2) (2) 28.27 (2) (2) Fuel: Electricity.................................................................. G a s ............................................................................ 8.65 8.47 (2) (2) 10.17 9.46 7.19 (2) 25.31 26.22 (2) (2) 24.31 24.34 25.70 (2) Framing: Steel........................................................................... Concrete................................................................... 8.68 8.63 9.54 - 9.94 (2) 7.50 (2) 25.85 26.84 24.67 - 24.32 (2) 28.12 (2) Exteriorwall: C oncrete................................................................... Load bearing masonry............................................. Curtain w all............................................................... 8.53 8.86 6.15 (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) 7.80 (2) (2) 27.26 25.49 19.51 (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) (2) 29.18 (2) (2) Interiorwall: Drywall...................................................................... 7.93 8.71 9.13 7.61 27.11 26.76 25.52 27.55 Floor base: C oncrete................................................................... 8.63 9.54 9.91 7.61 25.66 24.67 23.90 27.55 Floor covering: C arpet....................................................................... Vinyl/vinyl-asbestos tile .......................................... 8.72 8.30 9.55 (2) 10.04 - 7.33 8.16 25.28 27.87 24.80 (2) 23.81 - 27.30 28.37 Ceiling: Acoustical tile............................................................ 8.68 9.54 9.93 7.56 25.87 24.67 24.23 28.05 Roof base: Steel decking............................................................ C oncrete................................................................... 8.44 8.38 (2) 9.55 9.66 9.26 7.63 7.64 27.34 25.96 (2) 24.80 24.47 25.07 30.41 26.95 Roof cover: Built up...................................................................... 8.68 9.71 9.93 7.60 25.80 24.76 24.23 27.63 Characteristic All projects............................................................. 1 Data for the West are not sufficiently reliable to permit publication of detailed data for that region. 2 Insufficient data. NOTE: Dash denotes that the survey had no sample projects in this cell, 28 Appendix B. Survey Scope and Methods Data collection procedures The study was designed to develop estimates of the employee hour requirements for the construction of all Federal buildings completed between October 1975 and October 1977 in the 48 contiguous United States and the District of Columbia. After receiving their lists of assigned projects, field representatives usually contacted the appropriate regional General Services Administration (GSA) office to secure their cooperation. They then verified that the work contractors performed was within the scope of the survey. At the GSA office, the field representatives also obtained some project information and summarized contractor payrolls filed with GSA. Field representatives often visited the construction site to become as familiar as possible with the structural characteristics of the projects before visiting the gen eral contractor. If a general contractor should refuse to cooperate, the project would have to be dropped which could bias the survey results. Therefore, every effort was made to enlist the cooperation of the general contractor by explaining the nature of the survey and the reasons for conducting it. If the general contractors agreed, they were asked to verify the final contract value, including change or ders, and the list of subcontractors and their current addresses. In addition to payroll data for onsite workers, the field representatives recorded the type of material item, the purchase cost, and the name and fair rental value or equivalent of any equipment used on the job. Each of the subcontractors also was contacted to ob tain similar data. After all the data for a sample project were collected, they were checked for completeness and internal con sistency by the regional offices and forwarded to BLS in Washington for final review, editing, and coding for computer processing. An imputation procedure was used to supply esti mates for missing data within projects. Universe characteristics The survey included Federal office buildings, Social Security Administration office buildings, border sta tions, and other miscellaneous buildings constructed un der the auspices of the Public Buildings Service of the General Services Administration. Out-of-scope activi ties and costs associated with an in-scope project in cluded additions and renovations to existing structures, moveable equipment, customized construction, and re pair work or materials replacement. Preconstruction activities such as land acquisition, demolition, architec tural and engineering services, force account labor, util ity company services, and any work beyond the prop erty line also were excluded from the survey. The initial universe was composed of 33 new Fed eral building projects. Of the original universe, a num ber were found to be out of the scope of the study or could not be studied because the contractors did not cooperate or could not be located. Therefore, the final sample for this survey consisted of 24 Federal building projects. Accuracy of data The aggregate U.S. data and regional data for this study, except for the West region, are believed to be accurate. Sample response for the West was not ade quate to permit publishing data for that region. The de tailed data, in general, have a wider margin of sampling error and may be subject to other limitations. Employee, hour and material requirements are affected by a num ber of factors such as location, size of project, type of structure, architectural design, availability of certain materials or equipment, labor skills, and local building codes and customs. The effects of these separate fac tors cannot be isolated. Except for the nonresponding sample units and the data estimated by the contractors, there are no known sources of nonsampling error. Sampling variances are being developed by the Bureau of Labor Statistics. Development of employee hour estimates Onsite and offsite employee hour estimates were com bined to obtain estimates of total employee hour re quirements for Federal building construction. Onsite (direct) employee hours were obtained from individual contractor payrolls. Offsite (indirect) em ployee hour requirements, representing the hours to produce, transport, and sell the materials, supplies, and equipment used in construction were developed by the BLS Office of Economic Growth using the 1972 Inter 29 industry Study of the Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA) of the U.S. Department of Commerce. Bureau of Labor Statistics field representatives collected the basic data on materials, supplies, and equipment from each prime contractor and his subcontractors (or esti mated in a relatively small number of cases). The ma terials listings thus obtained were categorized accord ing to the 4-digit industry classification of the Standard Industrial Classification Manual (1972 Edition, Office of Management and Budget). For each product group, the average amount required for $1,000 of construction cost was calculated. This bill of materials was deflated to the 1972 price level by application of the appropriate producer price indexes. The resulting deflated value for each group was reduced by the ratio of producers’ value to purchasers’ value. (This ratio was based on data pro vided by BEA.) The differences between purchaser and producer valuation were allocated to trade and trans portation sectors. The deflated values were matched to the sector coefficients in the 1972 interindustry study. For each group of materials, the interindustry study provided information on the amount of products re quired from each industry sector. The product data were converted to employee hours by use of output per employee hour ratios for each industry. While process ing the data, the Economic Growth Division adjusted 30 for price and productivity changes from the base year of the tables (1972) to the study year. The results were the average total (indirect) employee hours per $1,000 of contract cost required to produce, transport, and sell the materials used to construct the projects covered by this survey. These employee hours, plus the builders’ offsite em ployment, were combined with direct or onsite em ployee hours to determine total employee hours within the definition of the study. Offsite employment of each construction contractor was not obtained directly from the contractors since it would be difficult if not impos sible to allocate a portion of total offsite employment to a particular project. Instead, an estimate for the off site employee hours was developed by applying to the onsite employee hours collected for this study the ratio of construction workers to all employees in the general building and special trade contractors (SIC 15 and 17) segments of the contract construction industry for 1975 as reported in Employment and Earnings, United States, 1909-78 (BLS Bulletin 1312-11, 1979). An additional measure of employee hours expended in construction—employee hours per 100 square feet of construction—was developed by applying the cost per 100 square feet of construction to employee hours per $1,000 of construction contract cost. Appendix C„ Forms Used fo r Date Colteetion Bureau o f Labor Statistics Survey o f Labor and M aterial R equirem ents fo r B uild in g C onstruction U.S. D epartm ent o f Labor Fo rm A p proved This re p o rt is a u th o riz e d b y la w 2 9 U.S.C. 2. Y o u r v o lu n ta ry c o o p e ra tio n is needed to m ake the re sults o f th is survey com prehensive, accurate, a n d tim e ly . Th e in fo rm a tio n colle c te d on th is fo rm b y th e Bureau o f La bor S ta tistics w ill be held in c o n fid e n c e and w ill be used fo r s ta tis tic a l purposes o n ly . O .M .B . No. 4 4 R -1381 Survey N am e o f B u ild in g (s ) B u ild in g (s ) L o c a tio n (street address) (c ity , c o u n ty , state) A F® m Survey Id e n tific a tio n (E n te r 2 d ig it code) S chedule N um b er (E n te r 3 d ig it code) I I SMSA (E n te r 3 d ig it code) | j State Census Region (E n te r 2 d ig it code) (E n te r 1 d ig it code) | , 83 B L S 2 6 5 2 .0 5 A (Revised M arch 1978) 31 84 85 2 Section 1: Type of Construction (See the survey Technical Memorandum fo r type o f con structio n codes.) 001 1a_________________________________________________________ _ . 002 1b. 003 004 1d. 005 1e. Section 2: Total Value of Construction Contract Enter the total value o f all general and prim e contracts on this project, adjusted fo r any change orders. Include the value o f equipm ent and materials supplied by the project's sponsor. E xclude, when possible, the value o f out-of-scope activities described in the survey Technical Memorandum. (R ound to whole dollars.) Section 3: Construction Dates (R eport fo r in-scope activities on ly. Enter dates to tw o digits; fo r example, July 4, 1976 w ould be reported M onth 0 i 7 0 i4 7 i6 A l i . ) Year Day 007 I 3a. Beginning date of construction I I 3b. Ending date o f construction 009 3c. T otal number of weeks in construction (include d o w n /tim e ) Section 4: Wks. Square Footage What is the total square footage of all in-scope flo o r space in the building(s)? (E nter to the nearest square fo o t.) (F o r a d e fin itio n o f square footage, see the survey Technical M em orandum .) Remarks 32 010 Sq. ft. 3 Section 5: Building Characteristics 5a. How many stories are there above ground level in the m ajor building? (Ground level is the highest level at w hich the ground intersects the building, the po in t at w hich excavation begins. The m ajor building is the one tha t cost the most.) 011 Stories 5b. A re elevators installed in the m a jo r building? Code 012 1 - Yes 2 - No 5c. A re escalators installed in the m a jo r building? Code 1 - Yes 2 - No 5d. Is there a below ground basement in the major building? (A basement is the area im m ediately below ground level.) Code 1 - Yes 2 - No 5e. Is au tom o bile parking space provided? Code 1 - Yes, in or under the building 2 - Yes, outdoors 015 3 - Yes, both in or under the building and outdoors 4 - No 5f. What is the major typ e o f heating provided? Code 1 - Forced air (duct heating) 2 - H ot water (exclude steam) 3 - Radiant heating (electric) 4 - No heat 9 - O ther type o f heating (specify, e.g. steam, solar, etc.) 5g. What is the major type o f heating fuel used? Code 1 - E le c tric ity 2 - Gas 3 - Oil 4 - Coal 017 5 - No fuel 9 - O ther (specify, e.g., solar, e t c . ) ___________ 5h. Is air-cond itioning provided in the m a jo r building? Code 1 - Yes, central air c on ditionin g 018 2 - Yes, other than central air con ditionin g 3 - No Remarks 33 4 Section 6: Building Materials For each building feature listed below , select the predom inant typ e o f m aterial (in terms o f d o lla r costs fo r the entire project) w hich best describes th a t feature. 6a. Framing Code 1 - Steel 2 - Concrete: pre-cast, poured, etc. 3 - Load bearing masonry: block or brick 019 4 - Wood 9 - O ther (s p e c ify )_______________________ 6b. E xterio r Walls Code 1 - Steel 2 - Concrete: pre-cast, poured, etc. 3 - Load bearing masonry: block or brick 4 - Wood 5 - Stucco 020 6 - Curtain wall (any material) 9 - O ther (s p e c ify )_____________________ 6c. In te rio r Walls Code 1 - D ryw all 2 - Plaster 3 - Masonry: block or brick 4 - Wood 5 - Metal 6 - Plastic 7 - Glass 8 - Movable pa rtitions 9 - Other (s p e c ify )________ 6d. F lo or Base Code 1 - Concrete 2 - W ood/P lyw ood 3 - O ther (specify) _ Remarks 34 5 Section 6: Building Materials—Continued 6e. Floor Covering Code 1 - Wood 2 - Terrazzo 3 - Carpet 4 - V inyl/vinyl-asbestos tile 5 - Linoleum 023 8 - No flo o r covering 9 - Other (s p e c ify )________________________ 6f. Ceiling Code 1 - D ryw all 2 - Plaster 024 3 - A coustical tile (including suspension type) 9 - O ther (s p e c ify )---------------------------------------- 6g. R oof Base Code 1 - Steel decking 2 - Concrete 025 3 - W ood/P lyw ood 9 - O ther (s p e c ify )---------------------------------------- 6 h. R oof Cover Code 1 - Asphalt/asbestos shingles 2 - B u ilt-up 3 - Wood shingles 026 4 -T ile 9 - Other (s p e c ify )________________________ B e s ik s 35 6 Section 7: General Contractor Information (O btain data fo r this section solely fro m the general con tracto r, if possible.) If there is more than one general con tracto r to the project, report fo r the general con tracto r having the largest dollar p o rtio n of the project am ount. (See the survey Technical M em orandum fo r the year and type o f b u ild in g con structio n.) Report all percentages and dollars to the nearest whole num ber 7a. What percentage o f the general con tracto r's _________ total dollar volum e o f business was fo r (year) (type o f building) . build ing construc- tion? (E nter to three digits. F o r example 50% w o u ld be entered 050; one th ird w o u ld be entered 033.) 7b.W hat does the general co n tra cto r estimate to be the percentage of total contract value "p u t in place" during each of the calendar years the p ro je c t was under construction? O Begin w ith the year the project was started (enter in box 028) and w o rk down to the year the project was com pleted. © Enter the fo u r d ig it year in colum n A. © Enter the percentage to three digits in colum n B. For example, 50% w ould be entered 050; one-third w ould be entered 033. © The total percentage must equal 100. C olum n A (Year) C olum n B (%) 028 % January 1 to December 31 029 % January 1 to December 31 030 % January 1 to December 31 031 % January 1 to December 31 032 % January 1 to December 31 033 % January 1 to December 31 034 % January 1 to December 31 Total = Section 8: 100 % N um ber o f C ontracts How many of the fo llo w in g types o f contracts were let fo r this project? (The total must equal the number of B-forms subm itted.) 035 General 036 Prime 037 Subcontract 038 Sub-subcontract 039 TO TAL Remarks 36 7 Section 9: I Prefabrication ndicate the types of prefabricated components used in this project by answering questions 9a, 9b, and 9c. More than one box may be checked ( \ / ) fo r each question. 9a. Which integrated assemblies (prefabricated com ponents whose installation requires more than one trade) were used in this project? (Check as many boxes as necessary.) 040 1 - Bathroom s 041 2 - Kitchens 042 3 - Pre-engineered buildings 043 4 - Solar heating units 044 5 - ______________________ 045 6 - ________________________________________ 046 7 - ______________________ 047 8 - ____________________________________ 048 9 - None 049 1 0 - Other (specify) _______ 9b. Which special prefabricated com ponents (single construction un its—more than one trade may be em ployed) were used in the project? (Check as m any boxes as necessary.) 050 1 - Pre-cast concrete walls 051 2 - Pre-assembled brick panels 052 3 - A ir handling ducts 053 4 - A ir con ditionin g equipm ent 054 5 - Pre-cast concrete structural beams or colum ns 055 6 - Elevators and escalators 056 7 - Plumbing pipe "tre e s " or electrical conduit "tre e s" 057 8 - C om m unication and alarm systems 058 9 - None 059 10 - Other (sp ecify)_______________________________ (Note: Items 1-6 are fabricated o ffs ite ; items 7 and 8 are fabricated onsite fro m stock parts.) Remarks 37 8____________________________________________________________________________ Section 9: Prefabrication—Continued 9c. W hich stock prefab ricated com ponents were used in the project? (Check as m any boxes as necessary.) 060 1 - T o ile t pa rtitions 061 2 - Steel joists 062 3 - W indows 063 4 - Concrete form s 064 5 - Movable or rem ountable wall pa rtitions 065 6 - Hung ceilings 066 7 - Concrete or metal ro o f and flo o r decks 067 8 - U nderfloor duct 068 9 - None 069 10 - Other (s p e c ify )_____________________ (Note: Items T 4 are fabricated offsite; items 5-8 are fabricated onsite fro m stock parts.) Remarks 38 10 Remarks 11 Section 10: Factors Affecting Productivity Office Use Only What factors can the general co n tra cto r id e n tify as having con trib u te d tow a rd raising or lowering employee-hour requirements (p ro d u c tiv ity ) during the con structio n of th is building project, as contrasted to a sim ilar project on w hich the con tracto r p a rti cipated during the past tw o years? List below each factor cited by the general contractor. E xplain w hy the factors identified raised or lowered requirements. Examples o f factors: strikes, weather, floo ding, bu ild ing codes, apprenticeship programs, union practices, supply o f skilled workers, government specifications, prefabricated com ponents, standardized com ponents, unusual build ing conditions (such as adverse and unexpected ground con ditions fo r fou nda tion), o th e r factors. List o f Factors: 41 I Survey I.D. I Schedule N um ber | 12 Remarks—Continued Bureau o f Labor Statistics Survey o f Labor and M aterial Requirem ents fo r Buildings C on stru ction U.S. Department of Labor Contract Information Form Approved O.M.B. No. 44R-1381 This re p o rt is au thorize d b y law 29 U.S.C. 2 Y our volun tary cooperation is needed to make the results o f this survey comprehensive, accurate, and tim ely. The info rm atio n collected on this fo rm by the Bureau o f Labor Statistics w ill be held in confidence and w ill be used fo r statistical purposes only. Name o f C ontractor Survey Name o f Project Location o f Project (street address) (city, cou nty, state) B Form Office Use Only I Major Operations Code (Enter 2 d ig it code) Contract Number (Enter 3 d ig it code) Schedule Number (Enter 3 d ig it code) | I | I I 093 43 Superior C ontract Number (E nter 3 d ig it code) | 094 Status Code (Enter 1 d ig it code) Part I Contract Information C o n tra c t A m o u n t a. b. c. For the id en tified project, w hat was the fina l contract am ount, including all change orders? (R ou nd to whole dollars.) s 095 How much interest expense, if any, did the con tracto r incur on monies borrow ed fo r this contract? ( I f none, enter " 0 ." ) $ 096 Did this con tracto r have form al labor management agreement(s) covering a m a jo rity o f the employees w ho perform ed w o rk on the contract? Code 1 - Yes 2 - No 097 d. Scope o f Operations B riefly describe the w o rk perform ed fo r the contract. Also, id e n tify the im po rtant kinds of heavy equipm ent, materials, and occupations used or supplied under this contract. e. List o f Sub-subcontracts R eport any sub-subcontractors w ho w orked on the identified project. For each sub-subcontractor, assign a con tract number. For the con tract number, refer to the SO-302 form . C ontract Number Value of Sub-subcontract Name of C ontractor $ f. Record o f Persons S upplying Data Date of V isit Field Representative Name and T itle of Person Contacted 44 Part II C o n s tru c tio n E q u ip m e n t a. Enter the total on-site equipm ent costs (sum of all items reported in colum n C, lines 100-1 09 and 110-198 on the con tinuatio n sheets). If none, enter " 0 ." b. Instructions Complete columns A through D as follow s: Colum n A — List all equipm ent used on-site as a too l o f construction. (Exclude equipm ent required solely fo r personal use.) Record each piece of equipm ent separately. Colum n B — Enter the equipm ent code fo r each piece o f equipm ent listed in colum n A . (Refer to the Coding Manual fo r Labor and Materials Requirements Surveys). Colum n C — Enter, in whole dollars, the contractor's depreciation cost or the rental cost fo r each piece o f equipm ent. If this data cannot be obtained, enter the rental cost equivalent; refer to the Technical Memorandum fo r the Rental Cost Equivalent procedure. Colum n D — Code fo r the info rm atio n reported in Colum n C as follow s: Code 1 - con tracto r owned equipm ent 2 - contractor rented equipm ent For additional entries, use con tinuatio n sheet(s) fo r C onstruction E quipm ent BLS 2652B. In the colum n "O ffic e Use," begin the con tinuatio n sheet w ith the appropriate line item number. In the spaces provided at the b o ttom of the page, explain any unusual entries. Colum n A Colum n B Equipm ent Code Description o f C onstruction Equipm ent C olum n C Depreciation or Rental Cost (express in whole dollars) $ C olum n D Enter Code 1 or 2 O ffice Use Line Item Number 100 101 102 103 104 ' 105 106 107 108 109 Enter Line Item Number Remarks or W ork Area 45 Part III Materials, Supplies, and Built-In Equipment Costs Instructions Complete colum ns E through I as fo llo w s: Colum n E — Enter the building materials, supplies, or b u ilt-in equipm ent used in or during construction. R eport dissim ilar items separately (i.e., rivets should be reported separately fro m structural steel bar beam). Colum n F — Enter the materials code fo r the building m aterial, supply, or b u ilt-in equipm ent listed in C olum n E. (Refer to the Coding Manual fo r Labor and Material R equirem ent Surveys). Colum n G — Enter in w hole dollars the cost o f materials reported in Colum n E. (Include all taxes and delivery'fees.) Colum n H -- If the data in Colum n G does n o t include sales tax, enter the sales tax rate (to one decimal) in colum n H. Exam ple: Colum n 5%% — enter as 5 3% | ; 5% — enter as I — Code fo r the m aterial cost reported as follow s: 5 0% Code 3 - material cost is absolute (hard data) 4 - material cost is estimated For additional entries, use con tinuatio n sheet(s) fo r Materials, Supplies, and B u ilt-in E quipm ent BLS 2652B. In the colum n "O ffic e Use," begin the co n tin u a tio n sheet w ith the appropriate line item number. a. In w hole dollars, report the total cost o f all materials and supplies used during construction (sum o f all costs in C olum n G, lines 200-229 and 230-598 on the co n tin u a tio n sheet). Include all taxes and delivery fees. Colum n 1 Enter Code 3 or 4 If none, enter " 0 .” If " 0 " is reported fo r material cost, leave Column I blank. Office Use Line Item Number 599 Column E Column F Material Item Materials Total Cost Including A ll Taxes Code and Delivery Fees Column G Column H Sales Tax Rate if Taxes not Included in Colum n G (report to one decimal) % $ Column 1 Office Use Enter Code 3 or 4 Line Item Number 200 201 202 203 204 205 206 207 208 209 210 211 212 213 214 Enter Line Item Number Remarks or W ork Area 46 Part III Materials and Supplies Costs—Continued Column F Material Code Column E Material Item Column G T otal Cost Including A ll Taxes and Delivery Fees Column H Sales Tax Rate if Taxes no t Included in C olum n G (re p o rt to one decim al) Office Use Column 1 Enter Code 3 or 4 Line Item Number % $ 215 216 217 218 219 220 221 222 223 224 225 226 227 228 229 b. Referring to the list o f materials and supplies reported in line item number 200-229 and 230-598 on the c o n tinuatio n sheets, record the sales tax rate fo r the greatest do lla r am ount of taxable materials purchased. Express a fra ctiona l percentage as fo llo w s: 3% percent as Enter Line Item Number Remarks or W ork Area 47 098 % 3 3 % Part IV Labor Requirements R eport, b y occupation, m o n th ly data fo r whole hours and gross earnings fo r each m o nth th a t w ork was p e rfo rm e d on the pro je c t's con structio n site. a. Enter total gross earnings (sum o f all earnings reported in Colum n M, lines 600-653 and lines 654 to 997 on the con tinuatio n sheet). 999 $ If none, enter " 0 . " b. Instructions Complete the following for all on-site labor: Colum n J— Enter the m onth and year as follow s: January 1976— 01 76 Colum n K — Enter the three-digit occupational code fo r each type o f w orke r (Refer to C ontract Operations and Occupational Codes Lists). Code journey level w orkers and apprentices separately. Colum n L — Report the total num ber o f hours (including overtim e hours) w orked on-site. Do N O T boost overtim e hours w orked to obtain average ho urly earnings. Do N O T include travel tim e unless pay is received fo r this time. Use the remarks or w o rk area to id e n tify the num ber o f w hole h worked in overtim e status. Colum n M — Report total gross earnings paid to employees. Include in " to ta l gross earnings" the follo w in g : 1. Overtim e pay 2. S h ift d iffe re n tia l 3. Cost-of-living additives 4. Em ployer paid fringe benefits w hich are paid d ire c tly to the employee Do NOT include in "to ta l gross earnings," em ployer fringe benefits payments made d ire c tly to adm inistered be nefit funds. For additional entries, use con tinuatio n sheet(s) fo r Labor Requirements by M onth and Year. In the colum n "O ffic e Use," begin the c o n tinuatio n sheet w ith the appropriate line item number, c. Report the total number o f overtim e hours fo r all occupations listed in colum n K (lines 600-653 and 654-997 on the c on tinuatio n sheets.) —— If none, enter " 0 . " Column K Column L Column J M onth (2-digit) Year (2-digit) Occ. Code (3-digit) Whole Hours Column M Office Use Gross Earnings Related to Hours (express in whole dollars) Line Item Number $ 600 601 602 603 604 605 606 607 608 609 610 611 612 613 614 615 616 48 Remarks or Work Area lo g o Part IV Column J M onth (2-digit) Labor Requirements—Continued Column K Column L Year Occ. (2-digit) Code (3-digit) Whole Hours Column M Off iea Use Gross Earnings Related to Hours (express in whole dollars) Line Item Number $ 617 618 619 620 621 622 623 624 625 626 627 628 629 630 631 632 633 634 635 636 637 638 639 640 641 642 643 644 645 646 647 648 649 650 651 652 653 49 Remarks or Work Area Part V Contract Reconciliation Total value o f subcontracts let by this contractor Total equipm ent cost, (from line 199, page 3) Total material cost, (from line 599, page 4) Total labor cost fro m this " B " fo rm (from line 999, page 6) Total labor cost fro m attached payrolls (approx.) TO T A L ON-SITE COSTS (APPROX.) Total con tract am ount, (from line 095, page 2) Total on-site costs (approx.), see above f,subtract) A P PR O X IM A TE TO T A L P R O FIT A N D O V E R H E A D A p p ro x , to ta l p ro fit and overhead ---------= -----;------------------------- -------- = % p r o fit and overhead T o tal con tract am ount Explain any unusual p ro fit and overhead percentages (over 35% o r under 10%) or any unusual expense requirements. 50 Appendfe 0. Bibliography Construction Labor Requirements Studies by BLS Office of Productivity and Technology Federally aided highways Prier, Robert J. “Labor and Material Requirements for Federally Aided Highways,” Monthly Labor Review, December 1979, pp. 29-34. A study of federally aided highway projects completed in 1976. The article discusses trends in highway labor require ments since 1958, and provides data on minority employment, occupational distribution, and material usage. Estimates of la bor requirements are shown for 1978. Civil works construction Bingham, Barbara J. “U.S. Civil Works Construction Shows Decrease in Required Labor,” Monthly Labor Review, October 1978, pp. 24-29. This study was based on a sample of 45 projects completed in 1971 and 1972 under the supervision of the Corps of En gineers. It provided data on labor hours, material and labor costs, and other project characteristic data for both dredging and land projects. Also, a comparison was made with the data from an earlier civil works survey published in 1964. Finger, Diane S. “Labor Requirements for Federal Highway Construction,” Monthly Labor Review, De cember 1975, pp. 31-36. A study of labor and material requirements for federally aided highway projects completed during 1973. The study examines the trends between 1958 and 1973. Labor and Material Requirements for Civil Works Con struction by the Corps of Engineers (BLS Bulletin 1390), 1964, 28 pp. Ball, Robert. “Labor and Materials Required for Highway Construction,” Monthly Labor Review, June 1973, pp. 40-45. A statistical study of onsite and offsite employee hour and wage requirements for dredging and land projects in the U.S. Corps of Engineers’ civil works program from 1959 to 1960. Discussion of labor and material trends in highway con struction between 1958 and 1970. College housing construction Labor and Material Requirements for Construction of Federally Aided Highways, 1958, 1961, and 1964 (BLS Report 229), 1966, 17 pp. Bingham, Barbara J. “Labor Requirements for Col lege Housing Construction,” Monthly Labor Review, May 1979, pp. 28-34. A study providing measures for 1958, 1961, and 1964 of the labor and material requirements for federally aided high ways, with separate measures of the requirements for onsite and offsite construction. For onsite construction, the study also provides a comparision of annual labor requirements for 1947-64. A 37-project sample was surveyed in this study of college housing projects constructed under the supervision of the D e partment of Housing and Urban Development and completed in 1973. The article summarized the findings on employee hour requirements, project costs, and other college housing characteristics and compared them to an earlier survey pub lished in 1965. Wakefield, Joseph C. “Labor and Material Require ments: Highway Construction, 1958 and 1961,” Monthly Labor Review, April 1963, pp. 394-98. Labor and Material Requirements for College Housing Construction (BLS Bulletin 1441), 1965, pp. 34. A summary comparison of the 1958 and 1961 highway surveys. A survey of 43 college housing projects which were ad ministered by the Community Facilities Administration. The survey was designed primarily to determine the employee hours required per $1,000 of college housing construction. Kutscher, Ronald E., and Waite, Charles A. “Labor Requirements for Highway Construction,” Monthly La bor Review, August 1961, pp. 858-61. Miller, Stanley F. “Labor and Material Required for College Housing,” Monthly Labor Review, September 1965, pp. 1100-04. Summary of findings of the 1958 highway survey. A summary of BLS Bulletin 1441 (1965). Federal office building construction Olsen, John G. “Labor and Material Requirements for Federal Building Construction,” Monthly Labor Re view, December 1981, pp. 47-51. Commercial office building construction Bingham, Barbara J. “Labor and Material Require ments for Commercial Office Building Projects,” Monthly Labor Review, May 1981, pp. 41-48. Discusses the employment impact of the 1976 survey of Federal building construction, including estimates for 1980. In addition to the direct and indirect employment impact, the A summary of BLS Bulletin 2102 (1981). 51 Private muitifamily housing construction summary also presents data on labor requirements by occu pation and type of contractor, cost components, and material requirements. Comparisons are made with two previous simi lar surveys. Labor and Material Requirements for Private Multi family Housing Construction (BLS Bulletin 1892), 1976, 69 pp. Discusses labor and material requirements for the construc tion of private multifamily housing projects. Data were ob tained from a survey based on a probability sample represent ing all privately owned structures of five units or more lo cated in metropolitan areas where building permits were is sued during 1969 for 500 units or more of this type. The sur vey covered 89 projects in 22 Standard Metropolitan Statis tical Areas. Most of the construction took place in 1971. Olsen, John G. “Decline Noted in Hours Required To Erect Federal Office Buildings,” Monthly Labor Re view, October 1976, pp. 18-22. A statistical study of 26 new office building projects com pleted in 1973 under the jurisdiction of the General Services Administration. In addition to data on labor requirements, the study provides information on building characteristics and contract operation. Ball, Robert. “Labor and Material Requirements for Apartment Construction,” Monthly Labor Review, Janu ary 1975, pp. 70-73. Labor Requirements for Federal Office Building Con struction (BLS Bulletin 1331), 1962, 43 pp. A statistical study of onsite and offsite labor requirements for 22 Federal office building projects in various localities of the United States over a 3-year period from the fall of 1957 to 1960. Summarizes the first construction labor requirements study of private multifamily housing construction. Murray, Roland V. “Labor Requirements for Fed eral Office Building Construction,” Monthly Labor Re view, August 1962, pp. 889-93. Labor and Material Requirements for Construction of Private Single-Family Houses {BLS Bulletin 1755), 1972, 30 pp. Private single-family housing construction A study of labor and material requirements for construc tion o f single-family housing in 1969. A summary of BLS Bulletin 1331 (1962). Ball, Robert, and Ludwig, Larry. “Labor Require ments for Construction of Single-Family Houses,” Monthly Labor Review, September 1971, pp. 12-14. Hospiltal construction Dougherty, Dawn E. “Labor and Material Require ments for Hospital Construction,” Monthly Labor Re view, March 1982, pp. 34-37. A summary of BLS Bulletin 1755 (1972). A summary of a survey of 90 hospitals constructed in 1976. The article provides data on labor requirements, material costs, and project characteristics. A comparison is made with data from similar studies of hospital construction in 1960 and 1966. Labor and Material Requirements for Private OneFamily House Construction (BLS Bulletin 1404), 1964, 37 pp. A statistical study o f onsite and offsite labor requirements for constructing single-family houses developed from a sam ple of one-family houses built in 1962 in various localities of the United States. Labor and Material Requirements for Hospital and Nursing Home Construction (BLS Bulletin 1691), 1971, 50 pp. Rothberg, Herman J. “Labor and Material Require ments for One-Family Houses,” Monthly Labor Review, July 1964, pp. 797-800. A study similar to the one done in 1962 but with data shown per square foot as well as per $1,000 of construction contract cost. Covers hospitals and nursing homes constructed in 1965-66. A summary of BLS Bulletin 1404 (1964). Riche, Martha Farnsworth. “Man-hour Requirements Decline in Hospital Construction,” Monthly Labor Re view, November 1970, p. 48. Public housing construction Prier,. Robert J. “Labor Requirements Decline for Public Housing Construction,” Monthly Labor Review, December 1980, pp. 40-44. Summary of BLS Bulletin 1691 (1971). A study of public housing projects completed in 1975. The article compares this study to the ones done in 1960 and 1968. It discusses trends in labor requirements and distribution of costs. Labor Requirements for Hospital Construction (BLS Bulletin 1340), 1962, 46 pp. A statistical study of onsite and offsite labor requirements for construction of selected public and private, profit and nonprofit, general hospitals in various localities of the United States between mid-1958 and mid-1959. Labor and Material Requirements for Public Housing Construction, 1968 (BLS Bulletin 1821), 1974, 20 pp. A study based on findings of a survey of 48 public housing projects sponsored by the Housing Assistance Administration of the Department of Housing and Urban Development. Rothberg, Herman J. “Labor Requirments for Hos pital Construction, 1959-60,” Monthly Labor Review, Oc tober 1962, pp. 1120-24. Finn, Joseph T. “Labor Requirements for Public Housing,” Monthly Labor Review, April 1972, pp. 40-42. A summary of BLS Bulletin 1340 (1962). 52 A summary of a study of labor requirements for public housing construction in 1968. consisted of 145 contracts for sewer works: 82 sewer lines and 63 wastewater treatment plants. Data include onsite la bor requirements per $1,000 of contract cost by occupation at the national and regional levels, a detailed listing of the types and values of the materials and equipment used, and the offsite labor hours required to manufacture and transport the materials. Comparision is made with an earlier 1963 study. Labor and Material Requirements for Public Housing Construction (BLS Bulletin 1402), May 1964, 42 pp. A report based on findings of a survey of 31 public hous ing projects which the Public Housing Administration admin istered. Projects were selected in various States to represent four broad geographic regions of the conterminous United States. Ball, Robert, and Finn, Joseph T. “Labor and Mate rial Requirements for Sewer Works Construction,” Monthly Labor Review, November 1976, pp. 38-41. School construction Summarizes the 1971 study of sewer works construction which updates a study done in 1962-63. Provides data on la bor and material requirements for construction of sewer lines and plants for the United States. Labor and Material Requirements for Elementary and Secondary School Construction (Publication Number BLS/LAB Constr-72/81), 1981, 47 pp. (Available from National Technical Information Service, U.S. Depart ment of Commerce.) Labor and Material Requirements for Sewer Works Construction (BLS Bulletin 1490), 1966, 31 pp. This report presents the results of a survey of 68 elemen tary and secondary school construction projects completed in 1972. The report provides detailed data on employment requirements by occupation and type of contractor and in formation on contract costs and materials requirements. Sur vey results are compared with the findings of two similar studies of school construction in 1959 and 1965. A study designed to measure employee hours required for each $1,000 of new sewer facilities construction contract. The basis for this study was 138 contracts for new sewer works in the years 1962-63. Other reports, articles, and summaries Ball, Robert. “Employment Created by Construction Expenditures,” Monthly Labor Review, December 1981, pp. 38-44. Olsen, John G. “Labor and Material Requirements for New School Construction,” Monthly Labor Review, April 1979, pp. 38-41. A summary Constr-72/81. of Publication Number Discusses the direct and indirect employment impact of 13 different construction activities surveyed by BLS between 1959 and 1976. The article shows estimates of jobs generated by $1 billion dollars of construction expenditures in 1980 as well as summary statistics on cost components, average an nual rates of decline in onsite labor requirements and related data. BLS/LA B Labor and Material Requirements for School Construc tion (BLS Bulletin 1586), June 1968, 23 pp. A survey of selected elementary and secondary public schools constructed primarily during 1964-65. In addition to providing information on labor requirements, the study also includes data on the types and values of materials used, wages paid, occupations, and use of apprentices. Ball, Claiborne M. “Employment Effects of Con struction Expenditures,” Monthly Labor Review, Febru ary 1965, pp. 154-58. A summary of labor requirements for eight types of con struction broken down by offsite and onsite hours, by occu pation, and by region. Finn, Joseph T. “Labor Requirements for School Construction,” Monthly Labor Review, August 1968, pp. 40-43. A summary of BLS Bulletin 1586 (1968). Finn, Joseph T. “Material Requirements for Private Multifamily Housing,” Construction Review, April 1976, pp. 4-10. Labor Requirementsfor School Construction (BLS Bul letin 1299), 1961, 50 pp. This article summarizes the results of the survey of labor and building material requirements for private multifamily housing (BLS Bulletin 1892, 1976) with reference to the value of the materials, supplies, and equipment used in this type of construction. A detailed listing of the cost of these materials, supplies, and equipment per $1,000 of construction contract cost and per 100 square feet is included. In addition, com parisons are made between the results of this study and the public housing (BLS Bulletin 1821, 1974) and private onefamily housing (BLS Bulletin 1755, 1972) studies. A study of primary and secondary employee hours required per $1,000 of new school construction based on contracts awarded for 85 elementary and 43 junior and senior high schools throughout the United States. Epstein, Joseph, and Walker, James F. “Labor Re quirements for School Construction,” Monthly Labor Review, July 1961, pp. 724-30. A summary of BLS Bulletin 1299 (1961). Labor and Material Requirements for Sewer Works Construction (BLS Bulletin 2003), 1979, 55 pp. Ball, Robert. “The Contract Construction Industry,” Technological Trends in Major American Industries (BLS Bulletin 1474), 1966, pp. 32-38. This report gives the results of a study of new sewer works construction in the United States completed by August 31, 1973. Most of the construction was done in 1971. The sample Discusses economic trends in the industry with emphasis on the impact of technological change on employment, oc cupations, job skill, and productivity. Sewer works construction 53 “Construction Labor Requirements,” reprint of chap ter 33 of BLS Handbook of Methods (BLS Bulletin 1910), 1976. Discussion of methods for reducing occupational shortages. Ziegler, Martin. “BLS Construction Labor Require ments Program,” Paper presented before the North American Conference on Labor Statistics. San Juan, Puerto Rico, June 1971. Description of techniques of construction labor require ments studies. Mark, Jerome A., and Ziegler, Martin. “Measuring Labor Requirements for Different Types of Construc tion,” Paper presented before the Conference on the Measurement of Productivity in the Construcion Indus try, sponsored by the National Commission on Produc tivity and the Construction Industry Collective Bar gaining Commission. Washington, D.C., September 14, 1972. Construction labor requirements program and objectives are discussed. Finn, Joseph T. “Material Requirements for Sewer Works Construction,” Construction Review, January 1979, pp. 4-13. This article summarizes the results of the survey of labor and material requirements for sewer works construction dur ing 1971 (BLS Bulletin 2003, 1979) with reference to the value of the materials, supplies, and equipment used in this type of construction. A detailed listing of the cost of these materials, supplies, and equipment per $1,000 o f construction contract cost and per 100 square feet is included. In addition, com parisons are made with the results of an earlier study o f sewer works construction during 1963. Discussion of the BLS program of labor and materials re quirements and analysis of the potential of using data from the program to measure productivity by type of construction. Weinberg, Edgar. “Mechanization and Automation of Building Site Work,” National Response Paper for the Economic Commission for Europe, Committee on Housing, Building, and Planning, Third Seminar on the Building Industry. Moscow, October 1970. Ball, Robert. “Material Requirements for Private Of fice Buildings and Other Selected Types of Construc tion Activities,” Paper presented before the Construc tion Marketing Seminar. Chicago, Illinois, September 28, 1978. Discussion of current technology and labor requirements at the construction site. Weinberg, Edgar. “Reducing Skill Shortgages in Construction,” Monthly Labor Review, February 1969, pp. 3-9. Discusses material and equipment requirements for the con struction of private office buildings and other types of build ing construction studied by BLS. 54 Bureau ©f Labor Statistics Regi©mal Offices Region 1 1603 JFK Federal Building Government Center Boston, Mass. 02203 Phone: (617) 223-6761 Region IV 1371 Peachtree Street, N.E. Atlanta, Ga. 30367 Phone: (404) 881-4418 Region V Region S3 Suite 3400 1515 Broadway New York, N.Y. 10036 Phone: (212) 944-3121 Region SSI 3535 Market Street P.O. Box 13309 Philadelphia, Pa. 19101 Phone: (215) 596-1154 9th Floor Federal Office Building 230 S. Dearborn Street Chicago, III. 60604 Phone: (312) 353-1880 Region VI Second Floor 555 Griffin Square Building Dallas, Tex. 75202 Phone: (214) 767-6971 Regions VIS and VS8S 911 Walnut Street Kansas City, Mo. 64106 Phone: (816) 374-2481 Regions SX and X 450 Golden Gate Avenue Box 36017 San Francisco, Calif. 94102 Phone: (415) 556-4678