The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.
PROGRESS UNDER THE JOINT PROORAM TO IMPROVE ACCOUNTING IN THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT INTRODUCTORY STATEMENT This report was prepared jointly by staffs of the General AoooW1t..ing Office, Treasury Deparbnent, and Bureau of the Budget for the heads of the three agencies e It is the second report on progres·s bein.g made, under the leadership of these agencies, in bringing about imp;i:ovements in the Government• s accounting and financial reporting.. IJ.'ha first report on progress was.released under date of January 12, l9SO, This report is arranged in two parts and an api)endi.x. The first is a general .statement of progress in broad perspective. The second part describes developments in significant areas; for example: new fiscal legislation,, improvements and simplification in central a.ooounting and related requirements, cooperative work with individual agencies, more eff~otive.~ethods of a~c)j_ting, etc. The appendix illustrates ~e oooperativ~ work which has been and is being done with individual agencies of the Government in finding solutions to their special problems and improving their particular accounting syst~s. Thi~ report undertakes to sununarize progress from the beginning of the program in order that it may be a more complete and useful cfooumenti. Distinction is made, however, between new developments and those earlier in the program. January 12, 1951 PROGRESS IDIDER THE JODJT PROGR.Al.1 TO HIPROVE ACCOUNTING IN HIE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT I. GENERAL STATEMENT OF PROGRESS The joint program faced a formidable problem in the light of the historical background and traditions of the Government 8 s accoWlting, the size, complexity, and diversity of it.s operations, the legal requirements and restrict.ions involved, and the conflicting philosophies which existed respecting the function of accounting and auditing. In spite of this, noteworthy progress has been made in the relativelJt· short time that the program has been under way since December 19470 More than a year of spade work, starting with the activation of a new Accounting Systems Division in the General Accotmting Office, was necessary.. Irollowing this, in January 1949, the Comptroller General of the United States, Secretary of the Treasury, and Director of the Bureau of the Budget jointly issued a comprehensive statement concerning the program to improve the Government•s accounting and financial reporting., The pattern was thus firm)y set with regard to poJicies, objectives, worldng arrangements, and a broad but sufficiently specific· outline of work to be done in various areas This was essential in order that the program might be systematically pursued along sound lines so that all work, either in particular situations or from a Government,....wide stand-. point, could be carried out in the right direction and proper:ty interrelated with ultimate goals in view. 0 ·A great deal of cooperative work has been done,, since the program. was launched, with practically all agencies of the Government on their particular.. accounting systemsQ The work ·with individual agencies has been spearheaded by the Accounting Systems Division (GAO), with appropriate consultation and participation on the part of the staffs of the Treasury Department and Bureau of the Budget. This groundwork at the operating points in the Goverrurient is the only sure way that accounting can be made· responsive to management and eventua.lly be brought in line with the f ollowi.ng goals of the program: ( 1) , The use by all of correct gu:i.cl:ing principles and terminolosy,; (2) Making accolU1ting not only a protective device but also an aid in spending wisely and not more than is needed; (3) Providing the strongest possible internal control as a current operating matter; (4) Achievj.ng the greatest degree of simplification in accounting and related procedures in the interest of economy and more productive efforts; GAO wash., o.c. - 2 -, (5) Obtaining accounting results which are necessary as substance for the Government's central reports; (6) Acquiring the necessary accounting talent, properly placed organizationally, to make accounting a vital factor in manag anent o Important 3 however, as this cooperative work on the systems of individual agencies was, and will continue to be, there are three additional goals in the :wider field of the Government• s financial operations. These are r (l) Obtaining the most realistic financial planning (budgeting) with proper accounting support,; (2) Having a system of reliable and useful central reporting together with a strong systf;'ffi of accounting over the fiscal operations of the Goverrunent which focus in the Treasury Department J and (3) Realizing the full benefits of independent audit performed within the Government in ~ccordance with generally accepted ,principles and standards of audit... , 'The pr.ogram is ent¢ng the phase in which certain far-reaching results .are 1being realized on the basis of the original planning done and experience ,gained in the earlier years of the programo The fallowing developments have been .selected as illustrative of the major progress being made. Highlights of Progress One of the prime objectives of work under the joint program is to provide be:tter financial information for the use of the Congressa Effective worldng arrangements have been established with the legislative committees on apP.ropriations and expendituresa In the field of legislation, interest of the Congress in the improvement and strengthening of the fiscal system of the Government along with the work being done under the joint program has oulminat,ed in the ,Budget and Accounting Procedures Act of 19500 Treasury Secretary John We Snyder, Comptroller General Lindsay Co Warren.? and Budget Director Frederick Jo Lawton appeared before the Congressional Connnittees on Expenditures in the Executive Departments and expressed united support of the legislationo In approving it.ll the' President called it "the' most important legislation enacted by the Congress in the budget and accounting field since Uie Budget and Accounting Act., 1921, was passed almost thirty years ago" u 'ltds Act provides a permanent basis for the most fundamental kind of changes fen· improvement in the Govermnent 1 s budgeting, accounting, financial reporting, and auditing" The Post Office Department Financial Control Act of 1950 and Title IV of the National Security Act Amendments of 1949 a.re major pieces of legislation for fiscal reorganization_, including accounting,, of two of the largest executive departments. Legislation obtained for the Bureau of ..~ J Engraving and Printing, and for the National Bureau of Standards, is typical of the kind of financing and accounting requirema1ts which are desirable for certain types of operations. The program has played an active part in these legislative developments as well as in connection with other important legislation mentioned in the second part of this report. In the area of Government-wide requirements, controls and procedures., fundamental changes facili.tated by the new legislation are taking place as the result of intensive review and analysis of the central operations of the General Accounting Office and Treasury Department. The Accounting and Bookkeeping Division of the General Accounting Office has been abolished, elirainating the maintenance of appropriation, expenditure, limi tution, receipt and personal ledger accounts which parallelled certain classes of these accounts kept in the Treasury Department. Thia has resulted in a direct saving of nearly $1 million. The Postal Accounts Division of the General Accounting Office also has been abolished and its. functions of maintaining the .administrative accounts for the Post Office Department transferred to that Department. A tremendous amount of paper work and considerable duplication was cut out by discont.inuing the submission to the General Accounting Office of advance copies of schedules of collections prepared by admini.stra ti ve agencies. Similar results were derived from discontinuance of the submission of monthly reports of disbursements by appropriation limitations and monthly reports on the status of approprla,..o. tions. The General Accounting Office is collaborating with the Treasury Department in intensive work to provide the Department .with the strongest· and most efficient system of accounting and internal contro.l possible and early means of producinB central financial reports that will truly serve the needs .of the Government. Other outstanding accomplishments are set out below: first joint regulation, under authority of the Budget and AcProcedures Act of 195o, has been issued by the Secretary of the and Comptroller General. It simplies procedures involving the and countersignature of warrants with respect to the deposit and accounting for repayments to appropriations. This elirrdnates paper work and delay in ma~ing the repayments available for disbursement. ·All other phases of the warrant system with respect to the receipt., retention, and disbursement of the Government• s funds are under examination with the view to effecting simplification and improvements. The , counting Treasury issuance General Regulations No. 84 of the General AcCOl,mting Officu luJ::> Leon completely revised. It prov:ides an improved basis for the cla&:~ifi.ci-ition of receipt., appropriation, and related fund accoW1ts and establishes the principles under which the 'll:'easury Department will assign account symbols a.nd titles for general use. - 4Budget-Treasury Regulation No. 1, dealing with apportionments and reports on the status of. appropriations, has been completely revised. It provides an improved and practical set of requirements for all agencies. Revision of this regulation and of related General Accounting Office requirements has eliminated certain duplication in reporting which previously existed. A joint review was made of the budgeting and accoWlting practices of the executive agencies at the request of the House Appropriations Committee. The reports furnished to the Committee will also be useful in establishing priorities for further cooperative work 1Nith agencies under the program~ · The General Accounting Office and Treasury Department are participating with the Bureau of the Budget in review of the regulations of all executive agencies to ~st~blish systems of administrative control over appropriations and other spending authority. Such regulations are required by Section 1211 of the General Appropriation Act, 19.51, to avoid the necessity for defic:lency or supplemental appropriations and fix responsibilities for violations of law in that respect11 The General Accounting Office and Treasury Department are con-tinuing to' explore the introduction of a better integrated and more economical system for reconciling the checking accounts oi,' disbursing officers, which is a large and costly operation. A pilot installation with the Department, of the Army is under way which has considerable potentialities. Meanwhile some improvements have been made in existing procedures which have been brought to light as a result of the larger undertaking, All these and other developments in the Government-wide cussed at more length in the second part of this report. ~rea are dis-· Cooperative work done with practically all agencies of the Governmen-t, since inception of the program, is too extensive to enumerate in detail but is summarized, to the extent practicable, in the appendix to this report relating to work with forty agencies or major subdivisions.. This day-to-day work ranges from full-time technical assistance on major conversions of' accounting systems or installations of new systems to innumerable formal 'and inf'ormal consultations and telephone contacts,, and much oorre~pondence, in the solution of large and small problems, coordinated with all else being done under the joint program. The truly remarkable progress made in three years demonstrates that this ldnd of cooperative approach is the only ef, fective way of mastering the problem of improving accounting systems and performance at the many points where operations take place. The Budget ru1d Accounting Procedures Act of 1950, for the first time in law,, places squarezy on each agency the responsi bill ty of establishing and maintaining adequate systems of accounting and internal control with respect to its own operations"' In this continuing work wi.th individual agencies,, and the application and further development of accounting principles, standards, and :related requirements for their guidance, emphasis has been given to: - 5{l) Obtaining a well-conceived fund structure with related account classifications for the Government as a whole; (2) Decentralizing accounting to the i.ndividual agenci.es 1 and within such agencies to the points of delegated operating and management responsibilities Wlder centralized control; (3) Integrating the Government•s accounting through clear-cut and simplified accounting relationships between the Treasury Department and other a.gencies.; (4) Applying, in appropriate circumstances, the accrual method of accounting, with corresponding simplification of budgetary accounting performed in confa.. 9lling obligations and commitments under appropriations; (5) Establishing accounting entities for certain types of operations in which financial results need to be disclosed by segregating and grouping assets, liabilities, costs and expenses; ( 6) Establishing accounting control over and disclosure with respect to inventories and other property; (7.) Employing cost-accounting methods, where necessary,, integrated with appropriation accounting; (8) Synchronizing budgetary and accounting classifications and data. Proper organization and staffing in each agency for the efficient performance of the accounting function is of paramount lmportance. There has been real progress and encouraging deyelopments in certain agencies. A great deal, however, still needs to be done in many agencies to improve organization and the quality of staffing for accounting. An important step was taken by the Civil Service Commission toward the establishment of new classification standards for, a general series of accounting positions. In order that such standards will be most bene!icial from the standpoint of the joint program, the General Accounting Office, Treasury Department, and Bureau of the Budget, together with certain major executive agencies, are in an advisory capacity assisting the Commission in the perfection of the classification standards before it officially promulgates them. In the field of auditing, the extension of comprehensive and other type audits at the site of operations, with more effective coverage_, less paper work, and reduced flow of documents into Washington, is progressing as rapidly as practicable in the light of the size of the task and the rate. at which qualified staff can be obtained. - 6Sixteen comprehensive, on-the-site type audits have been tnsti tuted for the following agencies not subject to the Government Corporation Control Acts Farmers Home Administration, Soil Conservation Service, Rural Electrification Administration, and Farm Credit Admi.nistration (Agriculture) f Bureau of Reclamation and Bureau of Land Management (Interior); Atomic Energy Commission; General Services Administration; Veterans Administration (insurance activities).; United States Coast Guard and Bureau of Engraving and Printing (Treasury); Maritime Administration and National Bureau of Standards (Co:mmeroe)J Housing and Home ~'"'inance Agency (Administrator•s Office)l Natural Fibers Revolving Fund (Army); and Post Office Department. A new Postal Audit Division has been set up in the General Accounting Office to perform the comprehensive audit of the Post O.f'fi°oe Department. These are in addition to the hundreds of site audits of vouchers and other fiscal documents being made by the General Accounting Office. Moreover, the central receipt and appropriation accounts of the Government are now being audited where the accounts are maint.ained in the Treasury Departmente PROGRESS UNDER THE JOINT PROGRAM TO IMPROVE ACCOUNTING IN THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT !Io DEVELOPMENTS IN SIGNIFICANT AREAS The following summary is indicative of the kind of progress being made in various areasg ~egislative Developments Since the joint program started~ a number of important pieces of legislation have been enactedo Participation from the standpoint of the program has played an important part in these legislative developmentso Of fundamental and far=reaching importance is the recent Budget and Accounting Procedures Act of 1950 9 which the President cited as the most important legislation in the budgeting and accounting field since the Budget and Accounting Act~ 1921~ was passed almost thirty years agoo The new Act lays a solid foundation in law for carrying out the policies and objectives of the joint program and provides the needed flexibi.li ty for putting into effect more economical and effi .... cient procedures for obtaining maximum benefits from work going forward under the programo 'I1he declaration of policy in the new law provides a permanent legal basis for the joint programo During the past yearJJ other noteworthy legislative were the enactment of g ~ 0 .. relopments 'rhe Post Office Department Financial Control Act of 19.50.~ which transferred tc the Department certain administ:rati ve accounting func .... tions performed by the General Accounting Office for that Department~ provided for reorganLrntion of all accounting of the Post Office De= partmentj and laid the basis for improved audit by the General .Account·ing Officeo An act which enables the Bureau of Engraving and Printing to have a business~·type budget and revolving fund method of financing under which all expenses and costs of production will be reimbursedJJ and pro<= vides for an annual audit of the financial transactions~ records~ and reports by the General Accounting Officeo Provisions in the Deficiency Appropriation Act.\! 1950.? which enable the National Bureau of Standards to establish a working capital fund as a basis for an improved system of financing and cost accounting for the BureauYs activitieso Sections 1210 and 1211 of the General Appropriation Act.? 1951, whieh;;i reBpec ti vely.1, provide for simpl;i.fyi.ng the method of making t:cansfers between appropriation accounts and strengthening the Jystem for administrative control over expenditures to av9id the necessity for deficiency or supplemental appropriationsa An act which authorizes agencies to pay the beneficiaries of deceased employees the amount due at time of deatho Previously, agencies were required to send documents supporting the amount due to the General Accounting Office for· settlement as claims by that Office. This act speeds up payments, eliminates unnecessary paper work, and simplifies related accountingo In addition.9 a number of improvements and simplifications have been accomplished in the appropriation structure for individual agencies. These are from the standpoint both of reduction in m1mber of appropri.ations and providing the basis for better budgeting and accounting results o Earlier developments were the property accounting and auditing provisions of the Federal Property and Administrative Services Act of 1949; the Travel Expense Act of 1949, providing certain simplifications of ac1'Tlinistration 3 accounting, and audit in connection with official travel; and Title IV of the National Security Act Amendments of 1949, establishing the controller function and organization for budgeting, accounting, and auditing.9 along business lines, in the Department of Defense. Accounting Principles and Terminologl Early in the joint program comprehensive material was prepared on a wide range of subjects dealing with accounting principles and practices and providing a basis for the adoption of common terminology. This material has been used as a guide in the cooperative work with various agencies and many of the principles have been embodied in their accounting systemso With a view to setting up appropriate guides which will have general use throughout the Government for years to come, the extensive material initially prepared has been under review and revision in the light of actual experienceo In this work the services of' a number of accountants with broad experience, presently in the Government, are being utilized to make certain that the principles give adequate and balanced recognition to the proper degree of urliformity for the Government on the one'hand and the diversity of operations and management needs on the othero '11 he development of a sound body of principles and practices for general use is proceeding as rapidly as possible in accordance with this approach~ This is consistent with the policy of the program and the intent of the related legislation that principles, standards, and related requirements be prescr1.bed only after considering the needs of all concernedo = 3 = Because of their Government=wide significance~ the following matters have been given special attention in the application and further development of guiding principles and standards. Fund Structure and Account Classificationso A well conceived fund structure and related account classifications is an essential element of a sound budgeting.9 accounting and reporting system for the Govermnent as a whole. The revision by the General Accounting Office of General Regulations Noo 84.11 mentioned elsewhere in this report~ is a major step in establishing principles for achieving ~his objecti veo Of equal importance is the incorporation in accounting systems of individual agencies of accounting entities which will segregate and group assets 3 liabilities 9 cos:ts, and expenses when appropriate for certain types of operationso There has been much emphasis and progress in the development and application of thi.s principleo Integration~ the Governmente s Accountin&!. A major objective is the achievement of integrated, but decentralized, accounting for the Government6 This is being accomplished on the principle that accounting will be performed where operations take place and by the agencies re= sponsible for the operations~ and that there will be clear~cut and simpli~ fied accounting relationships with the Treasury Department's accounting for cash receipts~ disbursements~ and appropriations pertaining to the Government as a wholeo Progress in applying this principle is evidenced by: elimination and simplification of certain warrant procedures; elimina= tion of the duplication of accounti.ng for appropriations and receipts between the General Accounting Office and the Treasury Department, and discontinuance by individual agencies of submission to the General Ac= counting Office of monthly transcripts of appropriation accounts for reconcd:Ji:ilati.onp ~ internal improvements made by the Treasury D'epartment in procedure for maintaining central receipt and appropriation accounts3 and development o.f improved procedures for effecting reconciliation between the appropriation accounts of certain agencies and those of the Treasuryo These developments are discussed elsewhere in this reporto Decentralization of Accounting =in Agencie~.! To make accounting of ma:x:imllni usefu1ness for management~ emphasis is' being given to appropriately decentralizing the maintenance of accounting records to the points of delegated. operating and management responsibilities., Of __ particular im~ portance in the application of this principle are organizational arrange~ ments for exercising)) through a controller or similar official, central technical control over accounting operations and procedureso In 'the case of field operations.9 use is being made of methods and techniques customary in business for decentralizing detailed accounting to branch offices under central controls and interlocking accounting relationstiipso I Basis of Accountin~ Emphasis has been given to the practical applica tion 9 in appropriate circumstances~ of' the accrual ~ual - 4basis of accounting, common to businesso Such method of accounting re• sults in having .the accounts and reports of agencies reflect, classifyj and analyze expenditures of appropriated money in terms of amounts of goods and services received--not simply contracted for or ordered. Expenditures under the accrual concept represent disbursements in combination with unpaid liabilitieso Inventories acquired are taken up as assets and recorded as costs when they are applied to specific purposes. Accounts receivable and other controls over money due the Government are also factors. Accounting on the accrual basis should make possible better disclosure of the costs of the work and services the Government performs, its liabilities, and resources available for financing its operations@ Progress in the application of' accrual accounting has included the establishment of revolving funds and busciness-type budgets for certain activities as well as limited use of such accounting under conventional budgeting and appropriation controlo Expenditures forinterest on the public debt are now accounted for on the.basis of interest due and payable rather than interest pai4 by the UoSo Treasurero Continuing emphasis on accrual accounting is of vital imp~rtance to the 11 performanceti budget concept o Property A'ccountingo .As a phase of accrual accounting, attention has been given and progress made in establishing accounting control over and disclosure of inventories and other propertyo The work done has recog~ nized the need for integration between accounting procedures and the operating procedures needed for property management o A report on property management and accounting was made as a result of an extensive joint survey throughout the Government by staffs of the Treasury Department, General Accounting Office 9 and Bureau of the Budget, and was approved by the heads of these agencies and concurred in by the Administrator of the Genera~ Services Administration in 19490 The report was sent to all agencies for their guidanceo Specific working arrangements were subsequently agreed upon by the Comptroller General a~d the Administrator of the General Services Administration to provide for appropriate coordination between accounting and management phases of the property problemo · Cost and Appropriation Accountingo Employment of cost accounting methods, where·· necessary:-; and their integration with the appropriation accounting.of agencies, are important objectives to which attention has been given o Through· accrual accolintin·g 3 ·including adequate property and inventory accounting9 improved bases have been developed for unifying detailed cost accounting systems with appropriation accounting o This produces more accurate and useful cost results for management purposes, including better control over and support of appropriationso It also leads to simplification arid elimination of overlapping where cost accounting systems have previously been maintained separately from other accountingo Control of Obligationso Accounting procedures for control of commitments and obligations should be kept in their proper sphere, and not expanded, as in the past~ out of all proportion to the purposes which they can effectively serveo Improvements in this connection have been closely linked to the application of accrual accounting.. The availability of classified cost information on the accrual basis reduces the need for developing detailed and extensive classifications of allotments.9 encum= brances.11 obligations.'J and disbursements~ and repetitive~ cumbersome.9 and inaccurate accounting which this involves., Progress made in this connec= tion is directly linked to the application of improved and modernized management concepts involving clear=cut delegations of responsibility for control of commitment action and corresponding decentralization and sim.., plification of formal.accounting procedureso It is expected that· joint review.9 now taking placeJ of administrative regulations for controlling obligations in relation to apportionments.9 submitted by agencies for ap~, proval of the Director of the Bureau of' the Budget (pursuant to section 1211 of the Gene1--al Appropriation Act~ 1951) ~ will provide a basis for making further improvements on a wider scale in connection with this entire mattero Synchronization of Accounting and Budget Classificationso An area in which improvement is urgently needed concerns the synchronization of expenditure classifications and data under each appropriation with classi-~ fications and data used for budget purposeso The principle involved is that all classifications of expenditures or costs under each appropriation siho.uil.d be sound and practical from an accounting standpoint while at the same time being inf orma ti ve and useful in preparing and carrying out the financial program of the agency concerned" In addition to improvements along these lines in certain agencies.9 there has been practically com~ pleted 3 as explained elsewhere in this report, a Government=wide survey of agency accounting and budgetary practices and related expenditure classifications~ which will be used as a basis for effecting improvements on a wider scaleo Reporting and Budgetary DeYelopments The Budget and Accounting Procedures Act of 1950 affords considerable latitude for the President to determine the form in which the budget shall be presentedo It gives specific recognition to budget presentation in ·terms of functions and activities o This provides the legal means for taking full advantage of past developmental. work which has been directed at achieving meanill:gf'ul financial planning along the lines of work to be done by functions and activities 9 the synchronization of budget and ac~,, counting classifications 9 and the use to an appropriate degree of the ac.,., crual method of accounting to reflect the real cost of performance and for controlling resources and liabilities o A concentrated joint review was made of the budgeting and accounting practices of the executhre agencies o 'rhis was done at the request of the Chairman of the House Appropriations Commi tteeo In its report on the General Appropriation Bill.:1 1951 51 the Committee indicated the need for accelerated action in synchronizing budgeting and accounting classifica= tions and procedures in order to realize the advantages of performance 0 - 6 budgetingo Reports of practically all the reviews of agencies have been furnished to the Comrni ttee. The results of these reviews are being used as a basis for establishing priorities for further work to be done with the agencies under the joint program" They should also be beneficial by stimulating action in the various agencies for improving their systems and methods o The revision of Budget-Treasury Regulation No@ 1, dealing with apportionments and reports on the status of appropriations, was completed and put into effect November 1, 1950. The revised regulation represents an improved and practical set of requirements for all executive agencies to follow from the standpoint of budgetary reporting and better integration of accounting with such reporting.. Dupli,cation in reporting, which previously existed under separate reg-µlations of the General Accounting Office and the Treasury Department and: Bureau of the Budget, has been eliminated@ Section 1211 of the General Approprtation Act, 1951, requires the head of each agency to establish, by regulation, a system of administrative control over the expending of appropriations to avoid the necessity for deficiency or supplemental appropriations and to fix responsibility for violations of law in that respect"' The regulations of executive agencies must be approved by the Director of the Bureau of the Budgeto The regulations have the most important implications since, if properly developed, they will be a force in strengthening control over expenditures~ The General Accounting Office and Treasury Department are participating with the Bureau of the Budget in the reView of the regulations from the st{µldpoint of the joint program(/ Disbursement and Collection Procedures Substantial progress has been made and further valuable experience gained in continuing the intensive work that was undertaken in the early stages of the program in order to simplify basic procedures, in various agencies and from a Government-wide standpoint, for the collection, · deposit and disbursement of funds, and related audit and control. Much work has been done toward simplifying procedures for the control of collections and disbursements in relation to individual appropriations a A procedure was previously developed, for trial installation in the United States Coast Guard, to eliminate overlapping between cash controls maintained by disbursing officers and those of the administrative agencyo The application of this procedure to the Coast Guard has been deferred, however, pending installation of the revised accounting system of that agency in its district officese Meanwhile, the approach to simplified procedures has broadened to a Government-wide basis as the result of the new legislative develoPments previously discussedo Sectlon 1210 of the General Appropriation Act, 1951.si and the Budget and Accounting Procedures Act of 1950, are - 7 important factors in the lU1dertaking to simplify the entire system of control over collections and disbursementso Under section 1210 of the General Appropriation Act, 1951, Governmentwide procedures were developed and installed in order that all transfer,s, between appropriation accolll1ts may be accomplished by the issuance oft checks rather than by warrants issued by the Secretary of the Treasury and countersigned by the Comptroller Generalo These procedures have expedited transfers and resulted in improved reporting of expendituresfor work done with funds so transferredj by charging such expenditures against the appropriations provided for that purpose rather than against the appropriations to which funds are transferred as a means of. f!i1nancing the work to be doneo SectJ.on 115 of the Budget and Accounting Procedures Act of 1950 gives the Secretary of the Treasury and the Comptroller Genera1 the power jointly to modify procedures which under existing law involve the issuance and colllltersignature of warrants for the receipt and disbursement of the public fundso Shortly after the Act became law, the first joint regulation was issued under which all collections representing repayments to appropriations are deposited directly into the accounts of disbursing officers:> wi thoU"~ issuing warrants to cover the repayments into the ~'reasury and then requisitioning them for advance to dispursing officerso This eliminates paper work and delay in making repayments available for disbursement without impairment of accounting control or essential i.nformationo All other phases of the warrant system are under examination and revised procedures are being developed for recommended adoptiona Separate appropriation control and receipt accounts in the General Accounting Office have been eliminateda Coordinate with this and other developments, both in the General Accounting Office and the indi TI.dual agencies 9 fundamental proposals are being perfected for revision of the Treasury 0 s system of cash controls and accountingo All of this is in the direction of the basic objective of the program ·to effect primary fOntrol through the accounts and related procedures of the operating agencies of the Government and eliminate unnecessary duplication and overlapping in central controls o 'l1here were other accomplishments, in the earlier stages of the program.$) which now form important elements in the transition to simplified accounting and control for disbursements and co1lectionso Regulations of the General Accounting Office were amended to discontinue the submission to that Office of advance copies of schedules of collection prepared by the adnrinistrati ve agencieso Voucher payment, examination 1 and audit processes for certain agencies were simplified by the adoption of a schedule type of voucher on which a number of authorized payments to different payees are 1.istedo Use of a schedule type voucher makes it unnecessary to send indi vi.dual vouchers to a disbursing officer, the - 8 - underlying documentation being retained instead in the administrative agencies for either on-the-site audit or direct transmission to the General Accounting Offfoeo The test O'f this procedure for all administrative agencies served by the Treasury Department's regional disbursing office in St. Louis was completed on a satisfactory basis during the yearo Obtaining benefits of this procedure by its wider application will depend to some extent, however, on the progress which can be made, as a practical matter, in the extension of on.... thesite auditso Another procedure which has a close relationship to the wider adoption of a schedule type of voucher is the use of the transfer posting method of check writing by which the name and address inscriptions on vouchers are mechanically transferred to checks» thereby eliminating repetitive typing and proof readingo This method, originally used by the Treasury Department to some extent in connec'"li tion with income tax refunds, was also used to advantage in the issuance of checks in connection with the first insurance dividend payment of the Veterans Administrationo In order to develop the further potentialities of thi.s method of check writing, in conjunction with the use of a schedule type of voucher, arrangements have been made to test the procedure in its application to the disbursements of a typical Government agency (Farmers Home Administration, Agriculture) o As a consequence of the application of on=the=site comprehensive audit to the United States Maritime Commission and the U;n.ited States Coast Guard, collection procedures in those agencies were simplified by the elimination nf the preparation of the schedules of collections for submission with the collections to disbursing officerso Instead,, collections of those agencies are being deposited directly with designated Government depositarieso Improved and strengthened controls and simpli:fied p~cocedures for collections, accounts receivable and billings were installed in the Bureau of Land Management (Interior):; and integrated with on-thesite audito The General Accounting Office and Treasury Department are con= tinuing to explore the matter of introducing an improved and more economical system for :reconciling the checking accounts of disbursing officers of the Governmento This is a large and important undertaking since all related operations are. involved-=from the issuance of checks to their final payment by the Uo S., Treasurer,.along with the necessary processes of accounting and audito As a result of continuing consideration of the alternative proposals and procedures previously developed, a nurnber of interim improvements have been made in the existing systemo These include, cross~verification between the General Accounting Office and disbursing officers of the issuance of substitute checks, more effici.ent_development and use of outstanding check lists in connection with the payment of checks~ establishment of a destruction schedule for paid check statements at Federal Reserve Banks, the use of prenumbered certificates of deposit to avoid duplication of serial numbers, and similar modifications of procedure which contribute to strengthening or simplifying the present systemo An important step taken from the standpoint of more far-reaching. revision of the existing system is a trial installation which has been made with respect to the checking account of the Army Finance Officer at Sto Louiso Under this trial procedure, the check issuing operations of the A.rnr.f Fina.nee Of fie er are integrated with the paying operations at the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, with the view to reconciling on a decentralized basis the checking account of the Finance Officer maintained w1-th the Uo S. Treasurero This is being accomplished through the fac:ilities of the field accounting office of the Army 3 together with appropriate sifa=:i to be made by the General Accoµnting Officeo Q_~tral _Accounting and Reporting The Budget and Accounting Procedures Act of 19.50 assigns important responsibilities and dU'ties to the 'rreasury Department in the field of central reporting and accountingo Section 114 of the Act places on the Secretary of the Treasury t,wo responsibilities& (1) to furnish reports showing the results of the financial operations of the Government; (2) to org(3.nize the Treasury Department us own accotmting and reporting in such a manner that there will be an efficient operating center for this purposeo These responsibilities a.re in addition to the responsibility which secti.on 113 of the Aet requires each achninistrati ve agency to assume in establishing and maintaining systems of accounting and internal control which will fulfill c.ertaii1 .specified needs consistent with principlesj standards 9 and related requirements preseribed by the Comptroller Generalo The policy and objectives of the joint program as subsequently embodied in the new accounting and auditing law involve a different approach to the performance of the central control and accounting functions of ·the Goverillilent o In line with this, the Comptroller General has been making an intensive review· of the organization an.d operations of the G~neral Accounting Office coordinated with a review and analysis of the accounting organization and procedures of the Treasury Department o While this work has not been concluded:> it has resulted recently in the abolishment of the Accounting and Bookkeeping Division of the General Accounting Office with a di:cect saving of nearly $1 million and additional savings on the part of' ·all agencies because of the simplification or elimination of certain requirements a By this actionj the maintenance in the General Accounting Office of' appropriation, expenditure~ limitation, receipt, and personal ledger accounts for the Government as a ·whole has been discontinuedo In addition~ under authority of the Post Of'fi.ce Department Financial .... 10 Control Act of 1950, the Postal. Accounts Division of the General Accounting Office was abolished and its functions of maintaining the administrative accounts for the Post Office Department transferred to that Department. A Postal Audit Division was created in the General Accounting Office. General Regulations No o 84 has been completely revised to provide an improved basis for the classification of receipt, appropriation, and related fund accounts and to establish the principles under which the Treasury Department will designate the account symbols and titles to be used by all concerned 0 The revised regulations afford a basis for accomplishing simplification in accounting procedures for various classes of funds and a better disclosure of the results of the Government 1 s operations in the Budgete The Comptroller General's responsibilities in connection with these matters will hereafter be mor~ effectively served by audit ·of the accatmts maintained in the Treasury Department and the other agencies, together with establishing appropriate requirements with respect to the maintenance of accounting systems in agencies and reviews of the reconciliations made be·tween such agencies of their fund account balances with those maintained by the Treasury Department o With the advent of the new legislation, the Secretary of the, Treasury took two important steps regarding its implementation" He estab1ished: for the guidance of the responsible operating officials of the Treasury Department a framework of policy concerning the manner in which the law wp.s to tie carried out as it affects the Department" He also made formal arrangements with the Comptroller General for the full collaboration of the General Accounting Office in providing the Treasury Department with the strongest and most efficient system of accounting and internal control possible and the means of producing central reports which will be of real value to the Governmento This collaboration is based on an extension of the work being done in connection with the review of the organization and operations of the General Accounting Officeo On the ba1:Jis of this cooperative arrangement, intensive work has been going on, for some months, with the objectives of (1) appraising the accounting and financial reporting of the Department, both Departmentally and from the standpoint of its component uni ts; ( 2) developing comprehensive proposals for the reorganization of accounting and reporting; and (3) putting systematically into effect reorganization which is necessary or desirableo This fundamental work in the Department is necessary as a preliminary to the reaching of conclusive determinations by the Treasury Department, Bureau of the Budget, General Accounting Office, and others concerned, as to the complete pattern of financial reports which should be centrally produced on a reliable and useful basis without wasteful effort Meanwhile, emphasis will be given t.o certain central reports for which there may be a special needo For example, because of the urgent need of the Bureau of the Budget, proce.dure and regulations are now being developed to provide essential and reliable information concerning the collection, custody, and disbursement of foreign currency by various agencies of the Federal Government both on an actual and projected basiso 0 - l l '""' A great deal of the work mentioned elsewhere in this progress report has special significance for the central systemo The full development of performance budgeting and the application of accrual accounting have an important bearing on central reportingo In addition, certain changes which were made earlier in the joint program with respect to the principles underlying the preparation of the daily Treasury statement have important implications; namely, the new basis of accounting for expenditures for public debt interest as it becomes due and payable 9 the treatment of refunds as deductions from receipts, and the more current classification of expenditures on the basis of checks issued rather than checks paido Also of importance is the work which was earlier started and is continuing in developing practical means of working out the necessary process for the reconciliation or integration of the accountiing of the various agencies with the central appropriation and cash accounting of the 'l'reasury Department . . Cooperative Work Y'ith Individual Agencies The key to lasting achievement µnder the joint program is the cooperative work being done with individual agencies in improving their accounting systems from the standpoint of day ....to=<lay operating and management needs., The Budget and Accounting Procedures Act of 19.50 requires the head of each agency to establish and maintain systems of accounting and internal control which will fulfill certain needs specified in the Acto This re~ponsibility~ for the first time in law, is placed squarely on each agency with respect to its own operationso Uqder the joint program~ initiative by the individual agencies is encouraged and they are being urged to assume to the fullest extent their responsibility for making accounting a vital factor in management in the light of their particular operating needs., This approach brings direct and immediate benefits to the agencies concerned and identifies procedures and techniques for Government~wide application which have met the test of experienceo Technical advice and assistance to individual agencies, and review of their systems from the standpoint of conformance with principles:; standards;) and related requirements is provided by the Accounting Systems Division of the General Accounting Office, with participation by the Treasury Department~ Bureau of the Budget, and others concerned in the light of their respective needs and requirements. The cooperative work in this area, relating to forty agencies or major subdivisions of agencies, is summarized in the appendix to this report. At· least sixteen of the projects enumerated have involved the development and installation of new accounting systemso Considerable work has also been done on special phases such as hospital accounting and motor vehicle accounting!j which present problems common to several or most agencieso ... 12 .,,. Organization and Staffing It has been recognized from the outset of the joint program that regardless of the progress made in the technical improvement of accounting systems the matter of proper organization and staffing for the efficient performance of the accounting function in each agen.cy is of paramount importance o An important step has been taken by the Civil Service Commission toward the establishment of new classification standards for a general series of accounting positions in the Government. · In order that the new standards for classification will ·be most beneficial from the standpoint of the policies and objectives of the joint program, the General Accounting Office, Treasury Department, and Bureau of the Budget,, together with certain major executive agencies are, in· an advisory capacity.9 assisting the Civil Service Corrunission in perfecting such standards before the Commission officially promulgates them for general useo Of major significance was the action taken by the Secretary of Defense, on September 27j 1950, in defining and clarifying the controller function and organization under 'l'i'.tle IV of the National Security Act Amendments, 1949, as the basis for implementing the program to strengthen, simplify~ and effect economies in accounting and fiscal operations of the Department of Defenseo In connection with the installation of 'a new financial system for the Bureau of Engraving and Printing to meet the requirements of Public Law 656, approved August 4, 1950!1 the controller type of function and organization is being established coincident with the installation of the new accounting syst.emo To improve fiscal operations of the Bureau of Internal Revenue, the Commissioner recently established an Office of Budget and Finance~ bringing under the control of that office all activities relating to budgeting and accounting for the administrative expenses of the Bureauo Ground work is being laid in the new Economic Stabilization Agency for a sound organizational structure for the fiscal and accounting work of the Agencyo Progress was made in the application of improved organizational and staffing concepts for accounting performance in a number of other agencies, such as the Atomic Energy Commission, Economic Cooperation Administration 9 General Services Administration, Bureau of Reclamation and Bureau of Land Manaeement (Interior), and the United States Coast Guard (Treasury) Entire department such as Agriculture, Commerce, and Interior are taking important steps in organizing departmentwide programs for improvement in accounting operations under modernized concepts of decentralization with central technical guidance and coordination. o While these developments are progressive and encouragint:s, the fact remains that a great deal still needs to be done all along the line to improve organization and the quality of staffing for the accounting - 13 functiono Attention to this factor takes on added importance in view of the responsibilities imposed by the Budget and Accounting Procedures Act of 1950 on each executive agency to establish and maintain systems of accounting and internal control which will meet certain standards of quality and usefulness. Audit Comprehensive audit at the site of operations, as it is being put into effect by the Comptroller General, extends not only to the appropriate review of the legality and propriety of financial transactions but also to the reliability of accounting results, fairness of presentation and disclosure in financial reports, and constructive recorrnnendations regarding the improvement of accounting, internal control, and related matters which are of concern to management. · Sixteen comprehensive on-the-site audits have been instituted for ·the following 'agencies not subject to the Government Corporation Control Act: F'armers Home Administration, Soil Conservation Servl.ce, Rural Electrification Ad.Iainistration, and Farm Credit Administration (Agriculture); United States Coast Guard and Bureau of Engraving and Printing (Treasury); Maritime Administration and National Bureau of Standards (Commerce); Housing and Home Finance Agency (Administrator• s Office); Natural Fibers Revolving Fund (Army); General Services Administration; Veterans Administration (insurance activities); Bureau of Reclamation and Bureau of Land Management (Interior); JA.tornic Energy Comnrl.ssion; and Post Office Departmento A new Postal Audit Division has been set up to perform the comprehensive audit of the Post Office Department. These are in addition to the hundreds of site audits of vouchers, and other fiscal documents.? which have been made by the General Accounting Office for a number of years, for various classes of activities and transactions (eogo, payrolls)o The central receipt and appropriation accounts of the Government are now being audited where the accounts are maintained in the Treasury Departmento One of the important features of the comprehensive type audit is that it provides· a sound basis for limiting the examination of individual transactions and related documents to the extent deemed necessary in the light of the effectiveness of the sy·stems of accounting and internal control and related administrative practices of an agency. Under this method of auditing, as authorized by the Budget and ·Accounting Procedures Act of 1950 and the Post Office Department Financial Control Act of 1950, test checks can suffice as opposed to the detailed examination of all transactions and supporting documents. Moreover, the documents can be retained in the files of an agency instead of being transported to Washington as was previously necessary under law. - 14 This action is in addition to the elimination of previous Governmentwide requirements for the submission to the General Accounting Office of monthly reports of disbursements classified by appropriation limitations, and other monthly reports relating to the status of appropriations, apportionr.ients, and related. account balances v The expansion of comprehensive and other site audits, with increased auditing coverage, less paper work, and reduced flow of documents into Washington, will proceed as rapidly as practicable. Jn. this connection, an important consideration is the rate at which a sufficient audit staff, of qualified accountants, can be obtained. Benefits to the President and to Congress The improvements in accounting in individual agencies and in the Government as a whole being achieved under the joint progrrun are basic to the President•s program for the improvement of management in the executive branch9 Likewise, progress under the program is providing a basis for improvement in service to the Congress by establishing a generally more reliable foundation of financial information for legislative action and an improved structure for control of the public funds. This is being accomplished by cooperative impro~ent of agency accounting systems and related internal control procedures combined with more effective audits by the General Accounting Office. Also, in many specialized areas of interest to the Congress, work done under the joint program provides a basis for helpful assistance to interested Congressional committeeso Continuing working relationships are maintained with the staffs of the appropriations, expenditures, and other committees of the Congress and provide an effective means of coordinating progress under ·eke pro~ram with the functions and objectives of such committees. January 12, 1951 PROGRESS UNDER THE JOINT PROGRAM TO IMPROVEAOOOUNTINQ IN ·rHE~ FEDERAL dO'VERNMENT ~ :at{ APPENDIX ~AOCOUNTING DEVELOPMENTS · INDIVIDUAL AGENOD?a January 12, l9Sl J:W PROGRESS UNDER THE.JQINT'PROGRA'M TO IMPROVE ACCOUNTING ITu !HE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT Accounting Developments in Individual Agencies CONTENTS Page Pref ace . •' 0 0 0 6 ~ 0 0 0 • • l ' ' • • Departments Agriculture . Depart.mental ~ • "' .. • • • • • • .o • • C! • • • • · • • t Agricultural Research Administraticm. • • • " ., · • " .. • · ,, •. Farm Credi·t .Admin:l.stration •.- • • • ,. e • ~ · • • • • • , • • • Soil c'onservi1.tion Service •• •. - • ~ • • , • ~ • ~ • •. • . • • , , . • . Farmers }Jome Administration ., • Gp • • • • • • • • .., • o • e .~ o Office of Foreign Agricultural Re~ations , ,• Rural E,lect1~if'ication Administra.tion· •••. , , • , .••. , • • • II) • • ·2 • fl • • .. •. • • , • ·. • 3 3· 3 3 41 i! Oonmerce: Departmental 11 o · .,.,· • • •. . • • • • Office of the Secretary • • • • • • • Coast .and Geodet.ic Survey • ·• ·• • • ·• • Civil Aeronautics· .t~dministration • • •. :Patent Office. o , Iii o o ~ .•. ~-" • National BU.reau of Standards • , ••• Maritime Adminis~ratto;n , • • • • • • • 111 ·• • 111 111 Defense • 0 0. f) • fl> • • • • • • • • • • • , • • • • , •· • • •. '• •. " • •· • • • • •• o • 3 . :# 5· S ~. , • • • , ·• ., • • • , • • • . , ·., .• • . • •. • • • • • •. , ! • • , • 111 •• • , ~ •••. • • • • , ·" • , , · fl . . . . .. . ' . • • Interior:. ·])epartmental o o • • , • • • • • • • • " ·:Bureau of' Reclamatiqn Bureau of Land Management • • , , Iii , .,. o Bureau of Mines o • o ·, • • • • ,. • • " Bureau 'of Indian A.ffairs · • • • • • " • • •• •• • ' , • • ~ • , • .. S· ., • 1 ~. ~ • 6. ., . • 6 • • • 12 • , , ·• , · • • • , , • .• ~ • , , •• ~ • • ~ , • , • • • , • ., • • e • , II\' • .• , ... , • • •. • . 12 13 , \It • .. • et . • • • ' a :ll. Justice: Departmental Immigration and Naturalization Service • . •. • , ~·. • ,. • • • • • Office of United States Marshals • . • ~ • • , . , • • • , - • • • • 11' 14 14 111 ei · Post Office State o • o 0 Q • o II Iii " , • • • • • • • • • • • • . • • • · • . , • • • fl , . • ,. • • • • • .,, • , 7 .. • • l~ Page Departments (Continued) Treasury: Departmental. ~ • , • , , , , , 18 18 18 0 • • , , , • • 19 United States Coast Guard • • • • •. , • • • • • • • , • • • , Public debt interest • Withheld tax deposits • • • • • • • • • e .. • 111 • • ' • ill I • • • Bureau of Accounts o t: o • • • • • (i') • • • • "' • • • • " " • • .• • "' • • • o • • • • , • • ., • • " .. • • Bureau of Cus·toms • • • • • • • • ,, Bure~u of Engraving and Printing • • • • • • • , • • • , • • • Bureau of Internal Revenue • ~ • • • • • • • 11 111 • • • , • • • • • • • • • , • , • , • • • ~ • • • • , ~ • • • • ., • ,, ·• 19 • • 19 20 20 Ill •. 21 !ndef>2ndent Agencies Atomic Energy Commission • • • .Civil Commission District of Columbia , 22 o • Econoudo Cooperation Administrat.ion • • • • • • • , • , Economic Stabiliza.tio:q Administraticm Federal Security Agency 23 ii • 24 • • 24 • • , • • • • • • • , • 24 General S·ervices Administration Veterans Administrations Office of Insurance o o ~ , ••• , •• •. • • • • , • , ~ e • e • ., • ., ~ •• 24 • • • • . • • • • • • • • • ·• • • 25 Interstate Commerce Oomm:Lssiori • • • o • • • • • • •.• • • , , Housing and Home Finance Agency Offi.ce of Finance 22 • • • • • • • • • ••• • 4? Ill • , • , • • • • • • , • • • • • • • • • 26 a • o , o. • • • o • • • • • • • • • • • 27 Office of Construction, Supp)¥ and Real Estat~ • • • • • • • • Cooperative Improvement of Acc~untin§ Forms ••• , • • • • • • • • • . ,,· '1 28 29 -1- ACCOUNTING DEVELOPMENTS IN INDIVIDUAL AGENCIES This appendix summarizes various accounting developments in individual agencies of ~e Government,, on the basis of cooperative done -within the framework of the· joint program~ The material does not purport to deal with the extensive work which still needs to be done in this widespread areai nor does it attempt to explain the extent.of deficiencies in the accounting systems of agencies mentioned in this report and others ·not mentioned. It would be completely misleading to attempt to describe in a general summary» such as this 9 the many hundreds of dif.f'erent. improvements whie.h are cooperatively worked out on a da;y-to-dq basis and· which of.ten lead to more .far..·reaching accomplishments in other areas of the joint progra.rr11r Many of these improvements in p:rooedure have been developed as an internal matt~r by agencies simply on the b_asis of informal discussions with the Accounting Systems Division of the General Account.ing Office. Moreover, some places progressive a.cti.on is taken» without direct cooperative discussions or asaistanoe,, in whioh the stimulus and basic of the program.(j and i tts concepts of agency r·esponsibili ty.si are important .faotorso · The material included in this appendix is intended to illustrate the kind· of progress made and which continuing as a·result of cooperative work on the accounting problems various agencieso Such progress results in the main from the efforts of the individual agencies concerned with cooperativ.e assistance, consultation, and guidance provided in varying degrees by the Accounting · Systems Division of' the General Accounting Offi_ce., and with participation by Qj,her divisions 0£ the General Accounting 0£fice 1 the Treasury Depa:rtment, and the Bureau of the Budge·t when appropriate. · Progress in some agencies ha.a been remarkable and steps taken in others are encouragingo It wouldJ> however» be a. fatal mistake to continued progress· to underestimate the size and di££icUlty of the task which still lies ahead in making accounting in all agencies meet the req~iremente of Section 113 of the Budget and Accounting Procedures Act of 1950·,o Enough has been done a .however 9 to provide a .prac,tioa.l demonstration of what oan~be accomplished through real initiative on the part of individual agencies and through the cooperative ap-! proach under the joi.nt program of the Gene.ral Accounting Office in ·the discharge of its .functions in prescribing accounting requirementso ********** 2 ..., . Department of AgrJ:cul t ure Departmentalt The Departmental Office of Budget and Finance in cooperation with the component agencies of the Department and the Accounting Systems Divisio~ of the General Accounting Office has spearheaded the accounting improvement work in furtherance.of the objectives of the joint program in the Department of Agricultureo A number of improvements have been made of the departmental accounting operationso On June JO, 1950,, most of the detail records which were maintained qn a centralized basis at the Departmental level were eliminated throUgh making the following major changes: lQ Discontinuance of all department ledger accounts other than cash and appropriation availability accounts for unallottad departmental appropriations (those allotted to two or more agencies) and for such special and trust fund receipt accolmts as are to be ·appropriated or allotted to more than one operating agencyo 2o Delegation to the agencies of the responsibility and authority to approve req~isitions upon the Secretary of the Treasury for disbursing fundso: Jo Delegation to the agencies of the responsibility and authority tQ .administratively .approve disbursing officers 1. accounts current;. 4o Delegation to the agencies of the responsibility for currently reconciling the balarwes of their appropriation and fund accounts with balances reported by the Treasury Department o In this connection a pilot study leading to the establishm~nt throughout the Government for simpli... t'ied and more adequate reconcill.ation procedures was· conducted in the Department and an agreement ·has been reached with the 'rreasury ])apartment as to the reports to be furnished by the Treasury for use in the direct· reconciliation of agency cash accountso 5o Elimination of the departmental review of adjustment documents prepared by the agencies for submission to the General Accounting Officeo 60 More effective utilization of information reflected in the agencies 1 records in the compilation of financial data for budgetary and reporting purposes~ In addition.t a new accounting system was developed and installed in the Office of the Secretary for the working capital fund for certain central admirdstrative services which embodies commercial accounting·principles and permits the ready preparation of balance sheets, income and expense statements, and other financial statements and :reports o indicated,, the Office of Budget and Finance has cooperated with the representatives of the joint program in bringing about improvements in the accounting methods and procedures in other agencies of the Department of Agricultureo The .Projects undertaken are briefly described in the paragraphs that follow. Agricultural Research Administration: A completely new acc.xrnnt.ing system was developed and installed for both the recently established working capital and the appropr.i. ated funds applicable to operations of the Agricultural Research Center o The ·system embodies connnercial accounting principles including the accrual basis and provides for the preparation of balance sheets 9 income and expense statements~ and other essential financial statements and reports" Some accounting complexities are involved in financing the Center from both an aPpropriation and the working capital fund and further refinements may be necessary or desirableo Farm Credit Administration: Plans have been completed and procedures have been develop'f:)d for implementing the on-the-site comprehensive audit by the General Accounting of the Farm Credit Ad.mini.strati.on,, Janua~J 1 19510 Soil Conservation The on-the-site comprehensive audit has been . provided by the General Accounting Office for the Soil Conservation Servi.ca,. In antictpation of approach to improved au,di t, t.he use of a voucher schedule has been apprcnred and adoptedo This has resulted in a cons:tderable decrease in documentati.on by the agency as well as effecting additional economies in the disbursing functionso Also, plans and procedures have been developed for decentralizing maintenance of the general ledger the Regional· Offices to eliminate repetitive record keepingo Farmers Home Administration: On-the-site comprehensive type audit has been instituted for t.he Farmers Home Administrationo In addition; significant improvement and savings have been made possible through the . use of voucher schedules, eliminating extra copies of docurnents, and by reducing the work involved in handling funds borrowed from the Treasury and in computing interest paymentso Procedures for preparation of voucher schedules have been adapted to punched card processes and have been tied in with the use of tran~fer posting processes for check preparation in the Treasury 1 s Division of Disbursement. This work is of significance in developing potentialities of this method of check writing for other agencieso Office of' Foreign Agricultural Relations: A survey has been made of the accounting practices· and activities of the Office of Foreign Agricultural Relations and specific areas in improvements can be made in the accounting system have been determined6 Revised procedures are being developed to improve the accounting practices and methods and to provide management with timely and essential datao Rural Electrification Administration: ·The accounting system of the Rural -Electrification Administration is being redesigned to embody the latest developments in Government accounting@ Although the work on this proj~ct not. yet completed there have been some developments A new organi~ation plan with respect to the accounting function has been developed and will be placed in effect shortly to merge the present program and administrative accounting organizations into a single organizational unit responsible for . <J all accounting within the Administration 0 In 9-ddition, an internal au<;}.it staff has been established independent of the accounting organizationn Extension of the comprehensive program to the agency has permitted the simplification of disbursement P!'.Ocedures. thl."ough use of a combined voucher and schedule form., This in t~ has m.~e possible the ·elimination of pU,blic voii c;her forms for advances to · ·and for payments to vem:lor-s when certified invoi.ces 1 are recei yedo Simplified procedures for of .collections t.hrough the use of collection , been an~, are under study9 A :review of loan accounting procedures has been undertaken to deter·mine the .fe~sibility of adopti.ng punched card.methods as well as to develop any eimplifications tiona~ calculations and and ~~-·--~~····~· 5- Departmental: The Office of Budget and Management is coordinating a. planned program of accounting improvements in the several organization units in the Department under close working arrangements w:i.th the component agencies and. the Accounting Systems Division of the General Accounting Of'ficeo The most significant progress to date is described generally in the paragraphs that follow <ii The Office of the Secretary is the accounting and Domestic Commerce, Office of Inter~ Production Administration:) and Office of the new system of accounting was developed and insta1le4 the Department, 8 s working capital fund utilizing such as the accrual basis to provide accounting data reflect the business type operations of this on the accounting services rendered to the with a view to improving the quality of the furnished to such units in the light of operating accounting for the Office of Foreign and is performed by the Office of the Secretary fl transactions relative to the sale of publications are handled at the field of fices of the Office of F·oreign Domestic Commerceo Procedures were developed for simpli..fying the techniques a.nd the processing of collec·tionso Coast and Geodetic Survey: A major modification of pay roll proce~ .dures applicable to individual ships .wws developed resulting in considerable simplification this fvnctiono Revised procedures for disbursing by Treasury disb1~rsing agents were released to the fieldo Arrangements were completed for audit of pay rolls at the agency office a. Civil Aeronautics Administration: A comprehensive survey of th~ accoun'"tingpractices ... and procedures ·and of the operating needs for· financial data is currently in progresso It is anticipated that this survey will serv~ to determine the areas in which further accounting improvements should be made and.will serve as the basis for making such improvements a Previously .11 internal i.mprovements were developed and installed for more adequate.documentation and control of accounts receivable and more simplified obligation control., Modifications also were made in the chart of accounts to provide more inforrnati ve data and to permit using the accounts as media for fixing responsibility for various phases of accounting and billing operationso and applicationsw Improvements have been made in accounting for fees connection with processing of patent and trade-mark This has resulted in these operations being brought Q:rt - 6 a current basis as opposed to prcY11rL:1us delays of at least two days and saving of administrative expensesa A complete survey of the accounting practices and procedures is scheduled for early commencemento A completely revised system of aoBureau of Stande.rds which provides for the development of project costs on an applied cos·t bash in a manner consistent with principles a.pp,lica.b to industrial opera.tionsc Conourrently 9 procedures have been developed to implement tP,e legisl,ation for f the operations of the Bureau throueh a wholly sable working c (revolving) fundo Provisions have been made f rrr on=the-s comprehensive audits by the General Ao counting Office with re s from ·the elimination of duplicati\Jro doou• men-ta through the :retention by the agency of origina.l documents.and utilization o voucher and scheduleo Emphasis is being placed on th in the system as needs therefo:r become througlJt. d.ay ..·to'"''qay operations~ particularly the tn"eas of more accounting JI more equitable overhead di stributionj) reporting., an.d formalization of prooedure~Ja Various changes were made within the decentralization of acoountin~ work to under the supervision of diat:d.ct oomptrollers,p a oomplete r of the Division of Audits 9 and the establishment of an and Pr~cedur,es Branch~ A sta.ff provided under the joint cooperation with personnel o.f the Comptroller' G , developed and issued a manual of accounts and proceP.ural s cover !.ng detail most of. the .accounting operations 11 and has much a stance in the Washington and district offioes in implementing the prp and ·training the personnel o Comprehe~ eive reports for budgetary ation of operating costs have been introduced on a decentralized basis o All .assets have been plaoed under accounting'coritrolo The personnel of the bivision of-Accounts was reduced by more than 27% 9 but through the, introduction of simpli~ · fied accounting cedurea it been possible t,0 accomplish the and current work and further progress in reducing the·a~co~ting logs o The installation of the tmproved a,ccounting methods and th'tt training of f a.oili tated. by close coordination of' systems work site audit worko 7 of Def'ense Developments within the Defense Department under the National Security Act Amendments of 1949 have provided essential internal. leader- · ship and enabled the Treasury Depa:rtment ~ Bureau of the Budget~ and General Accounting Office to work with the Defense establishment ·largely on the basis of providing assistance and advice and coordinating improve"' menta initiated by the depa.rtrnen t with the. overall acoountine; improvement; program.o·. These developments include: establishment of Comptroller type organizations,p flexibility in rearrm1ging appropriation and .f'unotional ~ccount structure in terms of performance. type budgets, establishment of working capital funds~ establishment of' staffing patterns of fully qualified personnel at the policy making level 9 and full reoognition Qf. the primary a.ccounti11g responsibili.ty of th~ depa.rtmentl' Th.a following of progressive steps 9 which :l.n the main be:1en ini·tiated by the departments and al'.'e being develop~d with the day"" to-day cooperation the three central fiscal ageno iea of the Go·vernm.ent 4 'are illustrative ·of actual accomplishments rmd of the gemar~l objeotive:l:J toward which progress is being ~adeo L L Ba.sic regulations governing the establishment and operation of working cap!t.al funds have been promulgated to cover in.dustrial9 stook .~n·d m.an.agem-ent funds. Three pilot combined .def.ense printing s.ervi.ce inst.allations have been made~ one in each military depa:r·tmento There has· been established an Air Force Clothing Fund and plans are well alotlig for setting up a olothi.ng and equipage stock fund in the Q~artermaster Corps of the Army" The Military Sea Transport Service has taken over the operations of the Army Transport Service» the Navy Transport Servioe 9 and the Navy Tanker Serviceo Substantially all preliminary work has been completed for converting three major industrial activities (an Army Ordnance arsenal p a Naval Shipyard,, and a Naval Ordnance Plant) to the fund type of operationo Experience gained in these pilot installations will be used as a basis fo:r the rapid expansion of this conversion. program to all shipyards.I) arsenals an.d other industrial activitieso The advantages of these developments» which will become more and more apparent as fund type operation's expand 9 include ~""' ao Elimination of the chaotic financing arrangements fdlich were inherent under appropriation and allotment procedures with their inescapable burden of paper work and splitting and intermingling of opeqd:;ing and accounting re spOIJ.S ib i 1 ities o bo The ascertainment of real costs in terms of both, the workii'1g fund operations and the distribution of such received by costs on the b a.sis of ~ctivities financed from appropriationso Co Adequate control of inventories and other assets including appropriate segregati.on of capital and operating outlays o d~ Savings due to the gre;ate:r restraint upon 0 and attention to, operating costs by agencies which must pay from .their own funds .for work or services ordf!:redo · cation of billing and payment procedures for ell> services r f o A basi Er for the extenSion of the oomprehensiv'e type audit(' processes are beint( developed in connection wi.th 21$ the asaigmnent single service" procurement responsibilities under which the compl:j.cated !'unQ.ing iind reporting mechan:i.sms of ad\fe.nce payments.I! cross· senio~· allotments 8 etc-n. will be siimplU"ied through direot fun.ds ohargeableo Accounting procedures have been 'developed· in connection with "cross disbursing" (under 'Which vouchers for all three military departments be paid by the most conveniently located dis..., · bu:rBing officer) o 4o The central accounting operations of the Army have been decentralized on a ba.sis 11 with emphasis being placed on sim- plified procedures and improved service to the operating components. Separation of the Air Force finance and accounting operation from that of the Army is w:ider wa.yo military ·pay ·systerrxs 5'° o.r ·'t?ll,~ uniformo They are bei~g ~crutinized E,md of Defense for the purpose .or devel9ping and improved internal c-0ntrolso departnier+ts have· b$en made> ~ested fu~ther in the Department simplifications 60 have been and coordinated with sim.1 .. le.r developments on a Government-wide basis for simplifying warrant and accordance with the Budget &nd Accou.nting A ' type budget under which substantial improve .. ·terms of functional alignment of operations est ab li-shed in the Navy Department o pe:rrc:>r110.a.rH~e and a pi installation is now as an ad_junct of the payment - 9 procedures in the Federal Reserve banks provide a basis for -- o These procedures will ao Improved and integrated internal controls and ultimately for the application of internal and external comprehensive audit techniques in connection with all phases of. disbursing accountsa bo Determining the extent to which central check :re .... conciliation processes may be eliminated or modifiedo co Exparndon of the use of cheaper punched card checks and related processeso There is being developed a sinr;le document 11 a.ll purpOl!H~1 1 i1 billin~ and payment procedure in the form of a combination vouM cher and schedule which it is anticipated will greatly simplify accounting for inter-departmental and inter-bureau transactions by ....... 9o ao Eliminating the need for the use of sav0ral separ· ate documents (invoices» disbursement voucher 9 disbursement schedule 9 collection voucher. and collection schedule) for each transeu~tl.ono bo Reduoine the number of' steps in each transaotlono co Reducing the numb er of copies of' the new "all purpose'' docwnent below those now required for the dh.·bursing voucher aloneo do Reducing the issuance of checks and the making of advance payments or other fund transferso eo Eliminating the basio conflict that has always existed between Defense department billi.ng and payment procedures and those of the civil agencies and the Tr.easu:ry Departmento lOo Basic principles and procedures have been developed and installed with respect to the guaranteed loan program~ authorized by the Defense Production Act of 1950 (Public Law 774, 8lst Congress) and Executive Order No .. 10161 9 dated September 9, 19500 These procedures include proviSions for the full disclosure of the effect of all financial transactions under the pror;ram 9 for effect.... ive internal controls» and for comprehensive type on·tho-aite audits on the basis oi'\ retention of all pnrtinent documents by the responsible program accounting offices~ - 10 - A great deal of work, the significance of which is not.yet apparent in terms of specific accomplishment, also is being done ···in such general areas as -ac Progress that has been·: ma.de in developing improvements in cost accounting philosophy and techniques and in . integrating cost accomrt.ing with overall accounting systems. . bo The ~velopment of the overall accounting structure of the departments to provide most effectively for the needs of management, of the Executive Branch of the Government generally, and of the Congress through accrual accounting and aligning the accounting functions with operational responf3ibility consistently with commar1d channels o Co . The development of overall plans with respect to comprehensive type internal audits in proper· relation to the .development of the comprehensive type of' audit by the General Accounting Office fl including appropriate recognition of statutory or "compliance" featureei as an integral part of the comprehensive type audit<) d. The evolution of a sound and consistent property accounting program including its application to the working fund type of operation and the inherent logistical problems ·or the military. establishmento e. 'I1he developm~nt of. effective and fully concerted plans and instructions with r~spect to the 'application of . comprehensive type audit techniques in the audit of contractors• records, including the elimination of requirements for separate documentation for the departmental audit agencies and for the General Accounting Officeo In addition to the foregoing, a number of projects of less importance from the· standpoint of principle, have been developed, which .represent very practical improvements and should result in substantial sa.Vingso The following examples are merely iliustrative of this type of worka · 1. · · A simplified method of scheduling disbursements and collections on electric accounting machines has been.devised$ teated and is now being installed throughout the Defense Department@ To illustrate potential economies from these procedures~ ~t is estimated that more than 100 clerical jobs in the Navy regional accounting offices can be elindnated 1 and - 11 - that similar; al though more widely dispersed, aa.ving:s wi 11 be possible in the field disbursing activities in the Army and Air Force. 2. Improved and simplified procedures have been developed and are being installed for processin~ debt collections and for adjustment transactions. "" 12 Department of Interior Since the early stages of the program cooperative work in certain bureaus of the Department of Interior httS been an important factor in too development and testing of improved accounting methods and procedures aimed at some of the major objectives o.f the progre.ma Tha results aocoCTplished have been useful in wider application in the Government of such fundamental accounting improvements as decentralization of' accounting operations 9 application of the accrual basis of accounting coordinated with simplified obligation control 9 synchronization of programi> budgetary and accounting classifications 9 improved control of receivables and related billing procedures» and simplification and decentralization of disbursement controls and related administrative examination procedurese Departmental: Leadership and direction exercised by the Departmental Office of Budget and Finance has been an important factor in the conduct of the accounting improvement program of the several bureaus of the Department both from the standpoint of coordina.tion with improvement in management from a departmental viewpoint and Government ... wide obj eoti ves"' Of particular importance is the V1JOrk done by this Office with the Bureau of the Budget and the Congressional appropriation committees in the appropriation and allotment structure in the various bureaus of the Departmento This provides a. greatly improved foundation for integrated improvement of accounting and budgetingo Of importance in this connection als.o, a.re the establishment of a working capital fund for the Department in connection with connnon services and various modificntio:ns which were worked out in appropriation language for various bureaus of the Department to provide a basis for simplifying budgeting and accounting procedures4 Bureau of Reclamation~ The work of installing; a completely revamped accounting system on an accrual basis for the Bureau of Reclamation has been completed except for the adaptation of' policies with respect to the accounting for depreciationo Under the new system~ accounting operations have largely been decentralized to projects~ with a resulting reduction of accounting workloads in the Washington and regional officesc The project cost accounts have been integrated with the appropriation accounts and a completely revised system of financial reporting is used to provide management with comprehensive cost and other accounting data essential for operating purposes and for supporting the budget which ia pre.pared on a performance basi.s o Property accountingp procedures» and policies ha:ve been developed and installed e.s a part of the acccunting aystem for all properties of the Bureauo The management uses of accounting results have been emphasized within th'3 Bureauo Internal audi·t by the ControllerYs Office of the Bureau has been developed on a coordinated basis with the installation of the new system .. On.... the-site comprehensive type audit by the General Accounting Office has been initiated" Bureau of Land Manaf.ement: A revised system of aecounting for receivables has been installed with the result that cont:rol is established over revenues at the time such revenues nre earnedQ The 13 ... establishment of appropriate accounts~ receivable controls and billing procedures was coordinated with the installation of on·-the-site audit methods. Installations have been made for rece1vable and revenue accounting on the new basis and decentralization of accounting to the operating locations a.t which such transactions occur has been practically completed. Addi tione.l areas where improvements are needed in the overall accounting system are receiving continuous attention. Forms and procedures developed in the course of improvements have been adopted for use by other Government agencies. Bureau of Mines~ In the Bureau of Mines the work of dece11traUzing the accountir.1.g functions to local field offi cer:i has been aocompli shed through the use of branch office techniques. The allotment accounting procedures were simplified and considerable duplicatiqn in accounting work and recordation of financial. data were eliminated through the development of improved and simplified accounting procedures e.nd fo:rrnao Refinements !3,re 0urrently being made to brinr; about f'urthe:r i.mprove,... ments and simpliffoations,J Bureau o.r Indian Affairs: The oooperati ve work vd th the Bureau of Indian Affairs has been directed principally to the making of a review and analysis of acootmting needs preliminary to the development of an organization and procedures for ea tab lishing and maintaining ~ modern and comprehensive system of accounting consistent with the provisions of the Budget and Accounting Procedures Act of 19500 In view of the widely diversified activities of the Bureau, which engages in the construction, maintenance» and operation of hospitals, power ·plants 9 irrigation systems 9 and public roads and furnishes local government and other services to Indiana, there is much work that will have to be performed in the development and installation of an adequate accounting system.. In cooperation with the General Accounting Offfoe,, the Interior Department and the Bureau have initiated pians for a continued study· and an improvement program with respect to the accounting in the Bureau of Indi~ Affairso 14 - Justice Departmental: On July 1950.9 the combined general ledger maintained in the Administrative Di visi.on of the Department for the Alien Properly Custodian, Legal Division 1 Immigration Naturalization Service, Federal Bureau of Investigation, and Bureau of Prisons was separated according to the respective organization units and; in August, the general ledg(~r the Immigration and Naturalization Service wa.s transferred to tha.t agency o Attention is being given to t,he problem of integrating the appropriate allotment and other subsidiary accounts vd 'th these general ledgers o cedures have been completed for direct reconciliat,ion of agency accounts for appropriated !u.nds with accounts Department & The wor·k of the accomplished work being done to train the ~"'--'-tu"" in the accounts and 'to work . A proposed reorgani~ation .a..r,•- ..... .,,.ation has been charted and uniform pey procedures been (both Washington and field)() Obligat.ions fo:r persone\l the total appropriations) have been brought under Improved collection and reimbursable procedures and these operations are now on a current basiso to the in August keeping of the resulting from activity along review by the adopted for services (about .88% effective accounting have been placed Q Offices of United States Marshals: The completely revised system of accounting, developed-in the previous year, has been installed in 64 of the 93 judicial districts and installation work in the remaining districts is progressing at a of to five districts completed each montho Improved control and informati.on are being achieved$ with substantially less paper work, through implementation of the new systema Arrangements have' been made tor on-the~site audits of pa;y by the General Accounting Officeo 15 Post Office Depa.rtmen~ On November 15, 1950~ the first time since 1836, the Post Office Department assruned the same responsibility for performing its own accounting f llllctions as has been imposed upon other Government agencies o This was made possible by enactment of the Post Office Department Financial Control Act of 1950~ approved August 17~ 19500 This Act provided for the transfer of ad.mini strati ve accounting and reporting functions performed by the Gener~ lccounting Office for the Department to the Postmaster General and imposed upon him the responsibility to establish and maintain adequate and efficient systems of accounting and internal controlo The Comptroller General is responsible for prescribing principles and standards for accounting, cooperating in the development of the accounting system~ and auditing the financial transactions of the Departmento To the fullest extent practicable, as determined by the Comptroller Qenera1 9 this audit is t~ be performed at the place or places where the accom1ts of the Department are normally kept,· and in a;ccordance with generally accepted principles of auditing., The Act also provided for postponement of any or all of the provisions of the Act for a pe:r":iod not to exceed two years o But the Postmaster General and the Comptrol).er General, desirous of achieving improvements contemplated by the Act as promptly as possible, worked out immediate arrangements for assumption of the new responsibilities by the Post Office Departmento The functions,, personnelJl records, equipment, and appropriations of the Postal Accounts Division of the General Accounting Office at Asheville» North Carolina, were transferred to the Department as of November 15, 19.500 For th& time being most of the operations are being carried on in a similar manner as heretofore, but from time to time as new and improved procedures are developed» operations in Washington or Asheville are being appropriately adjusteda A complete revision of the accounting system and procedures has been initiated by tne Post Office Department with the cooperation and assistance of the General Accounting Officeo During this transition period the General Accounting Office is discharging its audit function through a small staff of the newly formed Postal Audit Divisiono As procedures a.re changed, modified audit techniques will be adopted with the eventual goal being a comprehensive on-the-site audit of the Post Office in accordance with generally accepted principle~ of auditingo Work is progressing on the development of a new accounting system which Will give recognit:i.on to the size of the Postal Establishment, the multiplicity of operating units (42,000 post offices)~ the wide-spread dispersal thereof through the 48 states and territories, and the large volume of financial t:rane"" actions, each involving a small amount but agg·regating over 18 billion dollars annuallyo It will provide the information required.by the Postmaster General for control of these farflung operations~ and will disclose the results of those operations and the financial condition of the Post Office to the Congr•ess and to the publico It will be geared to and facilitate the preparation of the performance-type budget. in cot.formance wit.h the recently modified appropriation structureo 16 It is presently planned to -. the accounting internal audit functions now performed at twelve regionaJ. oTfices where the accounts of all post offices in the i.rlll be consolidated o Control of all expenditures will be directed from Washington but the accounting at headquarters will be liniited to integrating 'Lhe accounts maintained at post with those maintained at the Department through combining the twelve consolidated accounts those of the Department In view of the magnitude and widespread nature of postal operations and the complex transitional problems involved, the development of a completely revised effective accounting system, the procedures under which it will operate, and the accomplishment of the detailed phases of successful installation extensive and intensive coope effort for completion, which can be accomplished on an orderly basis over an extended period of time 0 A specialized development vmich even preceded the enactment, of the Post Act of' 1950.9 and which is of great impora modernized Po!St Office Department accounting system done toward the development installation of a completely , plan operations for postal money lated accolmting control and audit. procedures€! The the new elimination of detailed of money order transactions Accounting Office~ were agreed upon by the Postmaster General and the Comptroller General early in 19SOo Intensive .work in the implementation of and procedures for the installation of this new esystem on ,July l, 1951, are being developed in the Post Office Department With the cooperation and participation of the Accounting Office_. 'j'reasl,lfy Department, Reserve banks, and 'commercial bankers~ Office Department ·tance the The new system will use of a punched card instrument which will pe~ mi t mechanization many accounting and related operations involved in the issuance, payment, a.pd auditing of these large scale operations involving about 400 million trQnsactions a yea:r representing over $5 billion in transfers o:r small amounts of money o The money orders, under the new system, will be payable at any post office or through any Federal Reserve bank rather than only at specified post offices as is the case under the present systemo The new system will also consolidate postal notes and money orders into a single systemo The Post Office Department has developed the new money order to better serve the needs of the public as well as to provide a basis for more economical operations the processing and control of money order transactionso The procedural. plans for the new system which are presently being implemented are being synchronized with the basic plans for the entire Post aQcounting system in terms of decentralization operation$ to regional otherwisec Implemsntation tem is progressing the introduction of the new money order sysa definite schedule with deadlines set for each phase of 'the Inasmuch as the date of introduction of the new money order been definitely determined, this program is receiving ~~th - 17 ... State Department The State Department has organized and undertaken a program for improving its fiscal management affairs and the work of revising accounting methods and practices in selected areas is underway. A chart of general ledger accounts has been developed and installed which forms the framework for the control of accounting transactions and classifications that are necessary for management purposes. Procedures have been developed and installed for modifying and simplifying use of the State Account of Advances., A new system has been installed for accounting for the Foreign Serv:l.ce Retirement and Disability Fund. A comprehensive study of the accounting practices, procedures, classifications, and the operating needs for the financial data is currently in progress. It is anticipated that this study will serve to determl.ne the areas in which further accounting improvements should be made, the priori ties to ·be established and the basis for making such improvements. Unlike most· other Governmental departments which have separate appropriations and accmmting systems for bureaus or divisions, the State Department' a system is operated as one accounting entity for all organizations and appro .... priati.onso The rate of progress will, therefore, depend upon the determination of needs for the entire Department and the coordination of the procedures on an overall basis. 18 Developments in reporting system and the , controls the Governments s central accounting and and simplification of Government-wide was sed elsewhere this progress been made in improving the accounting Department~ Improvements of accounting in bureaus of the Department .......... A'""'"''"'""· under a comprehensive program established by the This program has been so organized as to assure and participation from the standpoint of considerations., Important Departmental poli.cy issued by the Secretary participation the accounting of the nv>'l~mt:>'nT' through the of Fiscal Assistant the bureaus; specific for the of the accounting togethor with au.di t; and Departmental designed to serve substantially the same purposes within the Department as Accounting Systems Memo~anda the General Accounting Office serve for the Government a ~holeo have been made the accotinting practices Division of Deposits, Section of Surety Bonds, Specific areas where accounting improvements <md action has been and being taken to make Revlsions have been made in the administrative and cost accounting of the as the initial project, of a comprehensive program of the designed to improve budgeting, accounting~ and reporting in each bureau of the Departmento Under the new plan the administrative accounting system has been from the «9cash" basis to a practical "accrual" basis, The Chief Disbursing is confident that the new system provides J) • on the most practical integration of accounting results and performance Division of and furnishes The useful information for current operating with this be a valuable basis of other revenue acti vi- of a system of internal control on the collection , it has been Customs before pro- "" 19 to give Substantive legislation was obtained :; effective July l~ 1951'1 a busi- ness-type budget, revolving fund method o financing under vmich all expenses and costs of production will be reimbursed» and an industrial system of accounting together with a comprehensive type of audit by the General Accounting Officeo A completely new accounting vrith cost accounting properly integrated with the general accounts was developed and installation was begun 1July lJ> 19500 This system provides for the development of unit costs of p:roduets with complete utilization of accrual accountingo It involves establishment of accounting control over all inventories and property 9 depreciation of fixed assets, and the preparation of meaningful financial, opera.ting., and cost reports for the use of o The Comptroller General ha.s directed that comprehensive be instituted for the Bureau coordinated with the installation qf the new accounting systemo Thus, conversion to the new accolIDting system and comprehensive audit are in process during the fiscal year 1951 in preparation for the new system for financing and budgeting which will take effect for the year 1952 o An appraisal was made,, at the reque of the ;, the methods of budgeting and accounting used by the Bureau to control and manage its administrative expenseso Tne results of the reported to the Commissione.rl' including suggesfor proceeding with improvements in various the Bureau 9 several months ago 9 undertook a trial installation in one field office to coordinate, integrateD and improve its accounting and disbursement activitieso The results were highly satisfactory and provide the basis for s installations in other field offices~ Also» the Commissioner has established an Office of Budget and Finance bringing under the control of that all activities relating to b~dgeting and accounting ve expenses of the Bur13auo This will be a means of making further improvements on a cooperative basis under the joint prograro.o tions of a fm1damental areas" Based on the United States Coast Guard A completely new and decentralized system of accounting,!) on~ an accrual basis, has been developed and progressively installed in eleven districts of the Coast Guard~ leaving installation to be effected in the near future in one distr~ctj four headquarters units~ and tvro supply centerso The new system is geared to operating needs by providing better information and control over the expenditure of funds through comprehensive cost finding and reporting in connection with programs and activitieso The comprehensive type of audit at the site of operations has been instituted by the Gene .Accounting I> Simplified procedures have been established the handling and o.f collections and for controlling and accounting for disbursing funds thereby :reducing paper work and eliminating duplication in acc01mting with commensurate in operating cost(» Simplification and improvement of the appropriation for the Coast Guard was incorporated in the Appropriation , 19510 The Coast Guard 8 s installation ~~s a yaluable ground accounting and related fiscal operations elsewhere in the 20 Public debt interest: Accounting interest on the public debt was re- visedso that the expenditures are now taken up in the aceounts and reported in the daily Treasury statement on the the ruoount which becomes due and payable rather than according to the checks and coupons which are paid by the Treasurer of the United Also ;; the accounting and re po rt- ing provides for of tha interest coupons and checks not yet presented for payment by the Trea.surer¢l' Related changes in operatina procedure the processing and examination of paid coupons money of a.t $1.50 1 000 annually to the non-rei.mbursable expenses on the part of the ... . ,.,. ...,,,.,.., ..... public debt interest accounts, Bookkeeping and Warrants, been eliminated controlling accountQ · developed the the collection the new procedure the respective operating Reserve banks, s Office , Bureau of Internal Revenue 1 and This procedure is being further simplified in "'"'"""d........ ,•..,, of the Federal Ins'l,\:rance Contributions Act 21 Commission The. controllership organi~a.tion for administering accounting and related fiscal activities of this agency has demonstrated the efficiency of this type of organization in carrying out the objectives of the joint accounting improvement programa A system of accounting on an accrual b~sis has been installed, including accounting 9ontrol over the large and diversified property holdings, aJ1d. refinements are continually being made in the light of operating needs and conditions., Synchronized with the application of this basis of accolll1ting has been the development of a cost type budget in which detailed functional classifications of expenditure data on an actual cost basis form a part of a coordinated presentation of budget estimates tying into an Hobl:i.gationtt basis for the appropriation' as a wholeo The accounting of the major cost type contractors dealing with Atomic Energy Commission has been integrated with the Commission• s accounting system, also on an accrual basiso avoids duplication and overlapping and permits simplification of documentation coordinated with ·site a.udito The revised procedure for effecting payments through the use of voucher schedules has been extended to' the Commission and has resulted in more economical handling of disbursementso The accounting practices and procedures used in all field offices have been reviewed in connec.t.ion with the planning and development of all possible improvements in the accounting systemo Emphasis is being placed on the development of basic policies and procedures with respect to depreciation accounting, simplification of allotment procedures, and development of unit costs& The system in effect provides for meaningful financial statements, including balance sheet, operating cost statements, and statements of source and application of funds. Work underway to improve cost accounting for con.. struction activities and budget presentation of all financial datao Comprehensive audit of the agency's activities by the Corporation Audits . Division of the General Accounting Office was initiated in January 19510 On-the-site audit by the General Accounting Office of exvenditure transactions had already been in effect for several yearso 22 ~ Considerable wo~k has been done by the Commission during the past three years in the development of a new of aooounting for reti~I· ment funds and the proposed aystem>. is nearly :ready for submission to the Comptroller General for approvalo Various phasgs of the revi system are presently being tested in actual opera.tion by the OommiaalGQ. as a basis for working out such modifications and adaptations aa may be neceasa.ry or desirable. · Survey;-s of; th aocounttng praotiqea and :n~e.da have been in. the Govern.ment ·of the Distr iot of' Columbia preliminary to th~ devel()p+w ment of an accounting system t.,o me"t the requirements of the Budget and Acc.ounting '.Prooedures Act of 19500 An organization chart has 'been prepared for the Auditor~s Office which, ·when made effective, will achieve more efficient operationa, A combination purchase order and voucher form has been designed and procedure~ developed to streamline the procurement of materials and aerviqes and control dooum~ntation. Prescribed pay roll procedures adapted to punch c~d method$ have be&n instituted for about 50% or the District of Columbia employees,.. New procedures ware developed ~o p:roQf'HllS P4blic Aasi~tanol$ payments on punched card equipmento avings realized on the foregoing ~pproximate $40 9 000 annuallyQ Appro:dmately 30,000 cheoka are being produood monthlyo A system of genefal ledBer aoc·ounts has b4'~n drafted and tentative procedures have been prepared for EJtrengthening the inte:rnd control exercised oy the Auditor and for decentralizing certain accounting activities to the points of operation appropriately int¢!'grated on ~ ~ccrual basis with the ~coounts in the Auditor' a Office~ - 23 Economic Cooperation Administration The controllership type of organization was established at the incepti.on of the Economic Cooperation Ad.ministration following a pattern utilized in progressive business organizations which places jurisdiction over accountin~ and related fiscal activities at the highest level of management under the Administratore This made it possible to closely integrate the development or the accounting system from the inception of this agency to modern coricepts of management in which clear cut delegation of responsibility was an important element., Significant features of the system include appropriate application of the accrual basis to ·accounting for administrative expenses; decentralization of responsibility for control of such expenses to the points where obligating authority is exercised subject to internal audit by the Economic Cooperation Ad.ministration Controller; and the development of special techniques and methods in the direction of simplified and economical account keeping, reporting, and control. Progress in development of improvements, modifications and refinements in the accounting systems and in keeping it adapted to changes in management needs is continuing under the leadership and direction of the Economic Cooperation Administration Controller under appropriate coordination with the General Accounting Office~ The coordinated development of accounting and internal audit is a significant factor in control over these world-wide operationso From its incept1.on, expenditure transactions under Economic Cooperation Administration appropriations have been audited by the General ~ccounting Office from documents in the offices of the Administration. - 24 Economic Stabilization Administration The work of developing and installing a system of accounting for the Economic Stabilization Administration was begun shortly after the Administration was establishedo The accrual basis of accounting w:lll be applled where appropriate with provision for the disclosure of expenses and costs on the basis of resources actually applied to particular programs or purposeso The system will provide for disclosing and controlling all assets and li.abilities with complete integration of budget and accountso Federal Security: Agency Considerable work has been done towards eliminating 'unnecessary paper These changes included substituting a single monthly voucher for payment of rents, awards, stipends and fellowships, in lieu of several thousand individual vouchers, and a revised and simplified procedure for accounting for patients 1 funds at St. Elizabeth~ s Hospitalo Some survey work has been done of the hospital activities of the United States Public Health Service in connection with the Government-wide project for improvement of hospital cost reporting and accountingo The accounting system of the Food and Drug Administration was surveyed at the headquarters office@ Controls were found to be adequate; however, informal recommendations were made concerning reporting procedures which, when put into effect, will result in furnishing more current information on field obligations and expenditures than have been available heretoforea work and revising internal proc.edureso Ho using and Home Finance Agency The principles and framework for a complete revision of the accounting system for the Office q~ A4miniptrator w~re developed by the Accounting Officer of the Bous:tng: ';.:,md Boni~ fina:(lCe Agency ·and approved by the Comptroller Qf?Peralo The sy~teip. ,is .be·ang Jmpl~niented by· tl)e progressive installation of . necessary detailed piQ;oedu,ti~s~. The principles approved include provision for l(lpplication of the acc;ru~l basis of accounting, accounting control of all ~sets, the developme·nt bf program cost information geared to management -iteeds, and simplified obligation control methods o Comprehensive on-the-site audit has been initiated by the General Accounting Officeo Interstate Commerce Commission Improvements in the systems and procedures have resulted in placing property under accounting control, improving internal control over purchases and property, and eliminating duplications in the internal auditing work.o General Services AdJ1Linistration The functional responsibility for nll phases of financial manaeement of the General Services Administration is coordinated in the Office of the Controllero .An internal accounting improvement program has made considerable progress in combining the original accounting systems of the sf:iveral previous individual. agencies into one integrated systemi:i Accounting and administrative examina.tion accounts has been decentralized to the regional of fices under the jurisdiction of the regional controllerso The regional accounts are integrated with central office accounts through the application of branch office techniques to eliminate dupli·cation and repetitive record keeping o At the same time, the various central, and field accounting offices of the prior agencies have been consolidated into a single central organi2;ation and into the ten regional offices, resulting in a substantial overall reduction of personnel engaged in accounting workv The agency has established a qualified internal audit staff and has developed an internal audit pro gram"' The internal audit will have a direct relationship to the external comprehensive audH by the General Accounting Office which has oeen initiated. of As a part of the agency's accounting improvement program, a. chart of general ledger accounts and illustrative entries have been developed~ and been approved by the Comptroller Generalo The disbursing operations have been simplified through use of a combined voucher and schedule formo The account-· ing system as approved is based on appropriate application of the accrual basis of accountingl) Other work to date includes revision of existing cost systems for repair service shops and working fund opera.tionso Attention will continue to be directed to improvement and refinement of the system as a whole with particular emphasis on simplification of allotment procedures, improvement and simplification of billing procedures and more effective control of propertyo In the broader relationships of accounting and property management as they effect all of the executive agencies, arrangements have been made for a cooperative approach to the discharge of the respective responsibilities of the Comptroller General and the ,Admi.nistratoro Surveys have been initiated in several agencies in which property management and accounting considerations are coordinated in the light of the respective responsibilities of the General Services Administration~ the General Accounting Office, and the individual agencies directly concerned.? the results of which will be useful in evaluating further improvements in the field of property management and accounting o As a further part of the cooperative program, a combination form of purchase order, invoice and voucher has been developed and promulgated by the Administrator, General Services Administration» for use by Government agencies as a basis for simplification of procedures and paper work in making small purchaseso Where this form is applicable, its use should result in substantial economies and should improve the relationship of Government agencies with vendorso Moreover.9 the manner in which the form and related procedures were promulgated is such as to provide a basis for cooperative development in various individual agencies of the most effective procedures in the light of the many types of individual circumstances and conditions involvedo 26 Veterans Administration Cooperative work under the joint program has been tied into internal efforts of the Veterans Administration to develop and install improved accounting procedures for its large and complex operations and for new operations which it is required to undertake in connection with its general functionso The following are illustrations of some of the more significant developments under this approacho Office of Insurance NSL! Dividend: The development of accounting and related procedures for the payment of the first National Service Life Insurance dividend of 208 billion dollars was a major undertaking in which there was close cooperation on the part of all agencies concernedo The procedures developed incorporated many effective adaptations of modern machine methodso Necessary documentation was simplified.(; The close integration of the procedures of the various agencies involved in these operations resulted in economies through direct utilization by one agency of the product of the work of the othero 'Such economies as the following were the result of this coordinated effort in the development and installation of procedures: lo Direct mechanical reproduction of punched card ch~cks by , the Treasury from the same punched cards produced by the 'Veterans Ad.ministration as an integral part of its procedure in developing · dividend payments from the ·basic recordso 2o Direct mechanical transfer by the Treasury of. name and ad.... dress inscriptions from the payment vouchers, prepared by the Veterans Ad.ministration, to the checks issued by the Treasury Departmehto This eliminated the necessity of key punching, typing and proof reading checks in the Treasury•s Division of Disbursemento ~o Provision for payment of checks by first receiving Federal Reserve bank thereby eliminating the usual necessity of transferring paid checks from the first receiving Federal Reserve bank to the Treasurer of the United Stat~.s, or other designated FeQ.ei--al Reserve b~kso Under the procedur~s adopted, paid checks went direct from the first receiving Federal Reserve bank to the General Accounting Office for reconciliation and audito 4~ Simplification and mechanization of General Accounting Office operations for reconciling disbursing officers• accountso These procedures provide for developing outstanding checks by mechanically matching paid checks against the same punched cards which were previously utilized by the Treasury in the mechanical preparation of checksG In addition to the above there were numerous effective adaptations of mechanical methods in the internal procedures of the Veterans Administration and the Treasury's Division of Disbursement~ and certain internal records of the Veterans Administration, for 16.11000,000 veterans, were established or verified as a by-product of adapting mechanical methods .for paying the dividendo Basic Improvements in Insurance Accounting: Joint understandings were reached early in the joint program relating to the areas which needed to be covered in a general program for accounting improvement to be conducted on a cooperative basis for the large scale operations of the veterans 1 insurance activities o These understandings followed determinations made by Veterans Administration officials and surveys of both central and district offices. The need was recognized for attention to the problem of providing coordinated accowting controls over;1 and between, individual insurance records~ accounts and actuarial recordse It was agreed that the undertaking should include careful consideration in the light of operating factors, of various alternative systems and related mechanical methodso It was also agreed that in the circumstances matters of accounting principle and theory had to be carefully weighed in the light of administrative costs and other practical operating considerations involved in these large .scale operationso The urgency of the dividend payment and related work in planning, developing and installing procedures for that operation resulted in deferring action on this comprehensive programo It has recently been reactivated by the Veterans Administration with special attention being given presently to establishing integrated procedures and related accounting controls between the Veterans Administration and the Armed Services for "in-service it insurance accounts o The General Accounting Office has established the comprehensive type audit for the insurance activities of the Veterans Administrationo In addition to more effective audit, it is expected that this will provide a better basis for cooperatively wor·king out necessary improvements in accounting procedureso Office of Finance There has been continuing cooperative effort for the development of accollllting improvements in the Office of Financeo The following are examples of Work done 8 lo Various alternative proposaJ.s for improvement of benefit payment accounting in the Veterans Administration (for compensation, benefits, annuities, etc o) involving approximately 6 million payments each montho The proposals were intended as a basis for cooperative analysis and development of improvements in the procedures of the Veterans Administration and Treasu~J Departmento Presently, the Veterans Administration is now testing certain tentative procedures to improve accounting control over these monthly paymentso - 28 2o Adoption by Veterans Administration pf accounting organizational arrangements for the direct loan program which eliminated potential duplication of accounting work and thus reduced acirlinistrative cost. An accounting system for the direct loan program and simplified documentation requirements for construction loans was cooperatively developed for this program. 3. Major revision in accounting procedures wns made in the arrangement of accounts for trust fund activities. Provision was made for summary accounts in the Office of Finance relating to the insurance program» for which detailed accounting is performed in the Office of Insuranceo General collection documentation procedures have been and special documentation procedures were developed for collection of amounts due the Government by means of deductions 4o si~plified from the ~ecial insurance divid1:md payments. Office of Construction, Supply and Real Estate: Surveys have bean made of the inventory accounting operations of the Veterans Ad.mini strati on and joint agreement reached on areas for accounting improvement.) 'rhis includes r;eneral agreement regarding plans for integrating inventory accounts with the Eeneral accountss and the achievement of this objective in some cases" Cooperative work on the inventory accounting problem in the Veterans Administration is being coordinated with property management surveys by the General Services Administrationo Veterans Administration officials have adopted a progressive program for improved inventory accounting which envisions ultimate integration of hospital cost accounting with the general accounting system, thereby achieving properly coordinated relationship between the budget, the general accounts, the cost accounts and the inventory recorqs Q • 29 Cooperative Improvement Accounting Forms An important phase of the cooperative work with agencies is that of development, review and approval by the General Accounting Office of various classes of accounting forms used in the Governmento This work is fully coordinated with all phases of the joint program and is of special significance in the cooperative work with agencies from the standpoint of: lo Accomplishing uniformity, to a necessary degree, and improvements in forms having Government-wide use~ and economizing in printing costs; 2o Accomplishing improvements of forms peculiar to individual situations or agencies and affording leads for simplifying or improving procedures involving the use of such forms; 3c Bringing to light opportunities for more comprehensive projects .for the cooperative improvement of accounting systems of individual agencies or Government-wide procedureso In line with the policy of the joint program and responsibilities recently imposed on agencies by the Budget and JAccounting Procedures Act of 1950 in developing and maintaining their system of accounting and internal control, work. done in this field is placing more initiative and responsibility with individual agencies in the development of forms which will best fit their particular operations and internal procedural needso At the same time, central review has proved valuable in giving them the benefit of work done in other agencies on similar matters and providing appropriate guidance from the standpoint of Government-wide considerations During the past year, the Accounting Systems Division (GAO) reviewed and approved over 200 different accounting forms relating to a great variety of operationso In addition to improvements in individual forms and related procedures, there has been a continual reduction in the number of forms used, a single new form in many cases being substituted for a number of old forms serving the same purposeo The work in forms control is too extensive~ detailed and interrelated with other acoounting systems work to be described fully in this kind of reporto A few illustrations, however, should serve to convey an understanding of its importance and value both in itself and as a part of the larger scheme of improvemente A small form combination Purchase Order -· Vendor s Invoice - Public Voucher was promulgated by the General Services Administration to simplify procurement procedures, reduce paper work, and improve relationships between vendors and the Government in connection with purchases of small dollar amounts. The form represents the result of cooperative work between the General Services Administration, the General Accounting Office, and various other agencieso w Provision has been made for developing modifications to the form and related procedures in the light of divergent operations of various agencies, and promulgation of the form on this basis is expected to bring about the adoption of more efficient and economical procurement practices throughout the Government, In the case of agencies for which comprehensive or other on-the-site audits are being made by the· General Accounting Office, the certified invoices of vendors are accepted a~ sufficient vouchers without the necessity of preparing, in addition, .the Government's standard form of voucherQ The certification required of. vendors, ih. connection with their invoices or use of the Government 1 s standard form of voucher, has been simplified., 'I'hia simplified cert'ification eliminates a possible source of delay in effecting payments and consequent misunderstanding and irritation on the part of vendors., Forms and procedures have been developed to facilitate the settlement of due certain deceased civilian employees under recent legislation.:i amo~ts A schedule type of voucher for listing many individual payments was developed, and is being used in certain situations, to eliminate the sending of great numbers of separate vouchers and supporting papers to disbursing officersQ Adaptations of the schedule type of voucher, for particular classes of payments, have also been used; for example, by the Railroad Retirement Board and Social Security Board for the monthly payments of rents to various lessors@ Continuing emphasis is being given to the improvement and simplifica- tion· of forms and related procedures which apply to indi victual agencies or have widler use o Every effort is made also to reduce the number of forms in useo . In all this work careful attention is devoted to making adaptations and modifications in individual circrnnstances in the light of the many diverse types of operations performed in the Government., Progress in forms improvement and simplification is accelerated through the constructive suggestions of the operating agencies.