The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.
https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Secretary's OVERNORS C ¢ October 1 0 =12, 1922 Washir g t o n , D , C . C205S REFERENCE INDEX TO SECRETARY'S MINUTES AND STENOCRAPHIC FICORD OCTOBER 10 = 12, 1922 CONFERENCE OF COVERNORS Paragraphs in} P a g e s i n Secretary's |Stenographic Minutes R e p o r t A’sorption o f costs o f shipments o f coin to and from member banks . . . . . . . - | G 1 2 , 1 5 9 8 b - 1 1 2 128-132 Acceptances = Report o f General Committee ON <ce S s m s I 3 2 0 - ACCOUNTING A N D AUDITING Report o f Committee o n Standardization m Accounting Torme o>. s s 5 6 ws : Proper nethod o f distributing commissions earned o n investments for 2 oreign “banks < 4 2 42. 2 ‘ L 1 i 2 2 - 1 Accumulation o f used but fit currency 1 Action t a k e n 2 7 2 6 9 8 = 9 8 b i ‘ Advice o f opening o f banks previously oe e e e a e e e e e 7 Advice t o direct sending banks o f other districts o f non-payment o f cash items . 1 8 6 - 1 9 1 7 1 5 Advisability o f further reduction i n total investment sacegunt: < < 2.04 b s S e S e o n subscriptions t o n e w issues of Government ‘secu ities <4. 4% s s s s American Acceptance Council = sustaining m e m o e r sih i a 6 2 4 s s a e a ee Bond Investments b y Member banks . o s .... "Borrower" ~ - Interpretation o f i n Sec. 3 P a Se B O a aes e e a e e e Cancelled bonds/notes = Risk assumed by F. R, B s i n shipping t o Washington . . Closed banks =< Advice o f reopening . . . . https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis - 1 a t Governors C o n f e r e n c e s Varying interpretations o f . . . . . Allotments 7 2 Gov.II-8. - 4 7 + 1 8 5 8 Secretary's Pages i n Stenographic Minutes Report Paragraphs i n COIN, CURRENCY A N D CIRCULATION Vault reserves o f F, R. B s and percentage o f gold coin and cer~ Sifictatom (et 0tet o e e e s e Til .As Standard of fitness o f currency . T1i.8. Reconsideration o f action o f last conf erence relative t o absorption o f costs o f ail shipments of coin t o and from member banks in view of possible attitude o f Treasury because o f discrinina- 98b-112; 128-132 tion against nonmember banks . . Coin s h i p m e n t s t o and from member banks ~- absorption o f costs i n view of Treasury attitude because o f dis= crimination against nonmember banks . 98b-112; 128-132 Collection o f items payable .in foreign countries . . . . + 18-82. COLLECTIONS AND CLEARINGS Report o f Standing Committee o n Collections + «++. + «+s -e-+e-s Extent t o which non-cash collection department has been developed in e a c h b a n k * a a 7 - . ¢ = s e 2 * s Raising limit o f no-protest items ga. o 0 S O e e e e e eee Liability o f Res. Bks. i n making unqualified indorsement o n checks received for collection . . 16; 398-399 Advice of opening of banks’ pre7778 viously closed : Should F. R. B s handle collection items payable i n foreign e e e e a a ea o f foreign Commissions o n Investmentsr ' banks - distribution of https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis 217-226 Secretary's Pages i n Stenographic Mirutes Report Paragraphs i n Committees < « Covnittee o n Centralized Execution o f Purchases a n d Sales o f Govt, securities pee S S y e e 2 a Cove s h e Gov. Fancher added t o personnel o f asa0 250 14; 3 0 s o fe meeting t uO c t . n 2,i 5h MBeate 30 Committee o n Open 3i11 Market Condition aiid O p e lt na— 6.6. 6 6. o eg S e 39 Committee o n Standardization o f Account ite Pere 6 S s e ww e e e General Comaittee o n Acceptances Gov. V I . A . 25 Gove I » D e 38 General Committee o f Twelve o n Economy ani Efficiency Insurance Committee . , .., Leased Wire Committee Pensiun Counittea:. | Gov. IV.H. 191+212 Gov. I V . A . 132-140 Gov. -IV.6d. 140-150 S 358-367 Standing Committee o n Collections Stone Of. i 6 « 638 6 w a S e Gov. I I .As. Condition - Weekly report o f = change i n 6=56 956-357 Costs o f shipments o f coin t o a n d from member banks = absorption o f i n view of Treasury's attitude because o f discrimination against nonmember banks . . Gov.III.Cc. 98b-112 128#132 CREDIT TRANSACTIONS A N D POLICIES Investment Policy o f Reserve Banks Gove I . A s Report o f Committee o n Centralized Execution o f Purchases and Sales of Govt. Sonds b y F. Rk. 8s . Gov.l .A.l Advisability o f further reduction in total investment account . . Investments for Earnings . . . . . Gov.J A . 2 Govel.A.3 291-293 Gov.[sA.4 293<297 Policy i n relation t o Gold Imports and Money market . https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis . Program |Paragrajhs in} P a g e s i n and S e c r e t a r y ' s |Stenographic Topic M i n u t e s R e p o r t Purchase of Exchange... . +. +s + « G o v . I.A.5. 3 5 9 7 - 3 0 0 Interoretation o f "Borrower" Sec. 13 F.R.A. limiting amount which F.R.Bs may rediscount for any one tnuocsiD Toit ete e r y eee o s ‘Rates Report o f General Committee o n Acceptances. . . e« « Currency accumulation = u Currency fitness - standard o f 9 0 - 9 8 Direct sending banks <+ advice o f non mers of Sher (tens S S 8 se : pemount Nites 4 5 ) 6 1 1 5 4 - 1 5 8 o e Se e si : 3 2 5 Distribution o f commissions earned o n in- vestments for foreign banks ....4.-+ | Gov Duplex telegraph wire N. Y. - Chicago - 2 - 1 1 7 - 5 2 0 - 2 1 5 6 4 ij Earnings ~ Investments for i G o v . I.A.3. 3 3 2 9 1 - 2 9 3 | Beonomy a n d Efficiency - Progress o f work } of General Committee o f Twelve o n . . . ! Gov. I V . H . : 1 9 1 - 2 1 2 | | Examination o f National Banks - { Payment for reports o f . . i o e . fa. --ts a h 1 1 2 - 1 1 4 ; {115-127; 270 ~291; 368-371 | i Use o f Revorts o f b y Branch Managers . 3 6 Exchange = Purchase o f . . . . + . + . + . + - . - |Gov. I-A.5. Extent o f development o f non-cash collection department i n each bank . . . G o v . 11.8. 8 2 9 3 7 7 = 3 1 0 0 Fancher, E . R . - Member Committee o n Centralized Execution o f Purchases and Sales of Government Securities . . . [ 1 1 4 - 1 1 5 ; 1247-270 Farm Land Banks - reimbursement a s fiscal Mee O e e s e o a ee w e e s | Federal Reserve Pension P l a n https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis { } = z y a a . s e Paragraphs in, P a g e s i n Secretary's ;€tenograpkic Minutes R e p o r t FISCAL AGENCY OPERATIONS Payment o f Savings Stamps due January 1 , 1923 Allotments. o n subscriptions t o n e w issues o f Govt. securities t o banks a n d o t h e r s Permanent r e c o r d s . . a g a g e eee a e o f source Government securities o f all . . . . . ‘SES (391-296; | 422-425 Payment o n presentation o f 211 matured Victory coupons regardless o f whether the notes f r o m which detached h a v e been p a i d o r not - « . . . 396+398;siv 425428 § Fit but used currency - accumulation of & 98-98 Fitness o f currency ~ standard o f ..,.. Gov -III.B. 90-98 Foreign Collection items + » . . . ao Sa Gov. II.F. 78-82 GovelII.A. 83-90 Gov.1.A.4 293-297 Gov. V.B. 279#390 e e G o l d coin and ctfs. i n vaults o f Federal reserve Banks - percentage o f Gold imports and money market = policy in POlutioi-t6 4 . g g s e e e + 2 4 6 e s Government Securities « Allotment o n subscriptions t o new issues to banks a n d others , Permanent r e c o r d s $ e o f source a e e e e of . . , a e Gov. V.C. | 422-425 Purchases a n d Seales - Report o f Committee Govel.A.l Interpretations o f action taken a t Governors Conferences ~ variations i n e e e e oe e r e 1-6;247-270; 432-439 O 186-191 Interpretation o f "Borrower" Sec. 1 3 F R.A. limiting amount which F .R.Bs may rediscount. eer tny tue Sank s e e e e Gov. 1.8, Investment Account < advisability c f further reduction i n total investment account : a e a e e e C e Investments for foreign banks - distribution of commissions earned o n . . https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis o s ! o r4 ~ % V e 2sV C L G «4 > 300+320 n 291 291-293 217-226 ~Propram jpParagraphs e r a j 5 in) P a g e s i n & and S e c r e t a r y ' s ; Stenographic Topte.*} M i n u t é s Investments i n bonds b y member banks . . . . & 1 Liability o f Res. Bks. i n making unqualified indersement M N S GR o n checks received f o r col- e e e ea ee a o e ees e e e Mail = pouching o f through establishment o f M a p e t e t s Gn. po0n.- 0:7 L o s a 6 Wee 2 Matured Victory coupons - sayment Sel S o a e a eSoa o e eee e e e . = ee = Member banks' b o n d investments G S O s u p Membership i n American Acceptance Council Vals . IV. S u r . Like National B a n k Examiners Reports i ? Porn O F a o o S e G o v . 1 l V.F vse oy Managers o f Branches . . . . . . New Issues o f Government securities - allotments o n subscriptions t o banks a n d Serer e t 5 e t e p e s e t S e e a Non-cash collection department - development R o e S S a . Se e S e e e e e e e Non-member clearing banks - telegraphic transfer for 1 Non-payment o f c a s h items - 7 1 No=protest itens - raising limit o f Opening o f banks previously closed - advice SS a a e e e e OPERATION Report 2 f Insurance Committee Report o f Leased Wire Committee Method o f advising direct sending banks o f other districts o f https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis 1 8 2 method o f advice todirect sending banks of other districts. non-payment. - o f c a s h items 1 5 4 - 1 5 8 and Secretary's Pages i n St enographic Topic Linutes Report Gov.IV.D. 20 Program Telegraphic transfers - + + + + = » Paragraphs Use o f test words b y Treasury Dept. telepraphic transfers . ..- +--+ - in 159-171 182-185 Gov.1V.E. Payment ofor use o f N- B. Examiners' reports P Gov.1V.F. e eo 5a. (46 112-114; 115-127 270-291; 368-371 Varying interpretations o f action taken a t Governors C o n f e r e n c e s . Gov.IV.G. 186-191 Progress o f work o f Gen'l Comm. o f Twelve o n Economy and Efficiency Gov.iIV.H. 191-212 Par Collection System e k o e 401-402 n s Payment f o r u s e o f National B a n k Examiners Meporus- = , 4. 6-e S o o e e o S e e Gov.1V-F. 112-114; 115-127 270-291; 368-371 Payment o f Matured Victory Coupons Gov. V.D. 396-398; 425-428 Gov. V.A. 271-279; 407-422 ... - Payment o f Savings Stamps and Certificates dug Sander yha Loss e c i e n t o e e S POnsiSn Pian 5 6 Permanent r e c o r d s S O G EtPT 168-3 s e a See o f Source 358-367 eee o f a l l Govt. 6 6 h eee a a we Gov. V.C. 391-396 422-425 Policy i n relation t o Gold Imports and Gov.1-A.4 293-297 for pouching of mail . . + + + + + + + s s ene B e 227-231 Pouching o f mail ~ establishment o f substatjon post offices « « + « + + 2 «e+ « » Sup. I. 227-231 Purchases a n d Sales o f Government Securities Report o f C o m m i t t e e . . « «.& 2 2 0 « o s Gov.J.A.1 1-6; 247-270; 433-439 114-115; 247-270 Gov.1.A.5 297~300 Money Market . 2. 1 6 6 © = © © © + 2 + = Post Office sub-stations - establishment o f Gov. Fancher appointed member o f Comm. . .- Purchase o f Exchange . « https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Ralsing limit o f no-protest items Rates o f discount . . . . Reimbursement o f Federal R as fiscal agents F a r m Land banks =: e s W a r Finance Corp, c s ft o rn oun e o bank - i d e R 4 inter vretation of"borrower" Sec. 1 3 F. R. A. limiting Pe 0 8 oe i a e e 3 =}C o v e . Be Reduction i n total weality o f = > . ;G Reports o f Examination o f Nation=1 Ranks 1 S e e e e e e e e e o vwheni Gov.1V.F. 1412-114 | 115-127 > , 270-291; | 368-371 Use by Managers o f Branches . 368=371 Reports o f Committees Committee o n Centralized Execution o f purchases a n d sales o f Government Securities b y Federal reserve banks . Gov. -AelL Gov. Fancher a d d e d t o personnel o f t t B e e e e r o 248~252 1 114-115 | 247~270 Minutes o f meeting o f Oct. A , 1922 Committee o n Open Bill Market Condition Mean O O P S i o e S s e e s s se E S , : Committee o n Standardization o f Account o e S S S S e e e e e = Gov.VL.A General Committee o n Acceptances Gov. I.D. General Committee o f Twelve o n Economy and Efficiency . . . . . Insurance Committee . Gov.IV.H. < 2 Leased Wire Committee . . , ecw Standing Committee o n Collections Gov.1V.A. 135-138 Gov.1V.3. aighios Gov.ii <Ax 18-56; Reserves - Gold a n d Gold ctfs. https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis ji9l-<le | i n vaults o f F, R. Bs. Gov,ill.A 400 Pages i n Paragraphs i n | | Secretary's Minutes a e Risk a s s u m e d by t s { S t enographic Report B a c i n shipping cancelled bonds/notes t o Washington. . Savings Stamps and Certificatas d u e Jam. 1, 1923, payment o f 2 s s s i a e s 28;55 aa 1-242; 42 8-433 45;52 271 se Shipments o f cancelled pice an eateigese to Washington Risk assumed b y F. Source o f a l l Government Securities Hermationt rererds o f o o S e e e Subscriptions t o new issues o f Govt. Securities allotments o n t o banks a n d DUMOT G 6 a s we S e a a a e e 27 9-390 Sub-station post offices - establishment of for pouching o f mail . . . . . - . Sustaining membership i n American AcCO t i t e C o u n c ) — 2 o s ew e e e 24 3-245 Treasury savings certificates a n d stamps due Jan. 1, 1923 - payment o f . . . . Supe VeAe Standard o f Currency Fitness . . . . G o tvrass s Telegraphic Transfers For non-member clearing banks . . Limitation over orivate wires . . Use o f test words o n by Treas. Dept. 17 1-132 15 9-171 18 2~185 Test words o n telegraphic transiers - use of b y Treasury Department . . . . . . 18 2-185 Transfers For non-member clearing banks . . . . . Limitation o f over private wire . . - Use o f test words b y Treasury i n wikine < C G U .V e 1 171-182 is 9-171 18 2-185 Gov.II.D. 76 3398-399 Gov.1V.D. Unqualified indorsement o n checks received f o r collection ~ Liability of reserve banks i n making . . . + . + . . Used but fit currency - accumulation o f Vault reserve o f Federal reserve banks Victory Coupons - Cov 1litahe payment o n presenta- So00- Of a1) emiured 4 ° . 6 hss Jar Finanee Corp'n. - reimbursement o f F, R, Bs. as fiscal agents of . . . Weekly Report o f Condition https://fraser.stlouisfed.org form o f report o f . Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis - chanre i n Gov. V . D . PROGRAM F O R GOVERNORS' CONFERENCE October 10, 1922 Washington Ee C R E D I T TRANSACTIONS AND POLICIES A.Investment Policy o f Reserve sanks ( d i s c u s s i o n ) 1. R e p o r t o f Committee o n Centralized Control o f Purchases a n d Sales o f Government Securities f o r o Federal Reserve Banks, agcount f Governor Strong, Chairman, Advisability o f further reduction i n total i n v e s t ( d i s c u s s i o n ) ment account, Investments for Earnings, ( d i s c u s s i o n ) New York San Francisco Policy i n relation t o Gold imports a n d Money Market. ( d i Purchase o f Exchange s c u s s i o n ) ( d i s c u s s i o n ) New York San Francisco Interpretation of "Borrower" Section 13 F, R, Act limiting amount which Federal Reserve Banks may rediscount f o r any one bank, ( d i s c u s s i o n ) Richmond Discount Rates (see Federal Reserve Board letter X-3518 of September 9, 1222 - Joint Conference Program) (discussion) San Francisco Report o f General Committee o n Acceptances Mr, Kenzel, N e w York Chairman, COLLECTIONS A N D CLEARINGS A,Report o f Standing Committee o n Collections Mr, Strater, Cleveland Chairman, 8, Extent t o which non-cash collection department has been developed i n each bank, number o f banks using facilities, classification o f banks a s to reserve cities and otherwise, and expense involved, ( discussion) Chicago €.Raising limit of no-protest items from 1 0 to 920 (discussion) D, Liability o f Reserve Banks i n making unqualified https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis indorsement o n checks received f o r collection, Recommended: Theat uniform indorsement b e adopted, Richmond egZg-« COLLECTIONS AND CLEARINGS (continued) E. A d v i c e o f opening o f banks previously closed. Recommended: That e a c h Federal Reserve B a n k advise e a c h other Federal Reserve Bank, b y wire o r letter, w h e n a member o r nonmember b a n k in its district, previously advised a s S closed, i s reopened, n Francisco a F. S h o u l d Federal Reserve Banks handle collection i t e m s payable i n foreign countries. S t a n d i n g Committee o n Collections. COIN, CURRENCY AND CIRCULATION A. V a u l t reserve o f Federal Reserve Banks a n d percent-~- age of gold coin and certificates t o total. (discussion ) B o s t o n B. Standard of fitness of currency ( d i s c u s s i o n ) R i c h m o n d C. R e c o n s i d e r a t i o n o f action o f last conference rela- tive t o absorption o f costs o f all shipments o f coin to and from member banks. i n view of possible attitude o f Treasury because o f discrimination against nonmember banks. ( d i s c u s s i o n ) S a n Francisco OPER ATION A. Report o f Insurance Committee Mr. Cramer ,Chicago Chairman. B. Report o f Leased Wire Committee https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Governor .McDougal, Chicago Chairman. Method of advising direct-sending banks of other districts o f non-payment o f cash items. Present practice i s t o send s u c h advice prepaid over commercial wires. Recommended: That private wire b e used for such advices t o S banks located i n Federal Reserve cities. n Francisco a Telegraphic transfers. W h e t h e r transfers over private wires s h o u l d b e limited t o transfers of bank balances s o that transfers f o r account of individuals, firms, corporations, etc., should be effected b y member banks a t own expense over commercial wires, ( d i s c u s s i o n ) S a n Francisco OPERATIONS (continued) Use o f test words b y Treasury Department on discussion) telegraphic transfers. { S a n Francisco Payment for use o f National Bank Examiners’ reports. ( S u g g e s t e d f o r discussion a t con- ference, also with Comptroller o f Currency. C h i c a g o , San See also Joint Conference Program) F r a n c i s c o & Recommended; ( S a n Francisco) B o s t o n ‘That t h e matter b e taken u p with t h e Comp- troller again with view to eliminate the cost o f these reports o r t o reduce t h e amount o f the charge t o cover o n l y t h e actual c o s t o f copying. Varying interpretations o f action t a k e n a t Governors’ Conf erences, ( discussion) S t . avis N e w York Propress o f work o f General Committee o f Twelve o n Economy and Efficiency. ( d i s c u s s i o n ) FISCAL ACENCY OPERATIONS A. Payment o f Savings Stamps and certificates due January 1 , 1923 (Suggested that Mr. Gilbert discuss w i t h Governors. B o s t o h B. A l l o t m e n t s o n subscriptions t o n e w issues o f Government securities t o banks a n d others. Recommended: That the Treasury b e requested not t o make allotments t o Reserve Banks until t h e subscriptions a r e closed a n d the total- amount known, a n d then t o make allotments o n the basis o f t h e total subscriptions received b y each Reserve B a n k o n a n exact percentage basis, i n order t h a t t h e Federal Reserve Banks m a y i n turn make allotments o n a sliding scale, allotting t h e smaller subscriptions i n full. N e w York G. P e r m a n e n t records o f source o f all Government securities. Recommended: That the Treasury b e requested to reconsider its instructions with regard t o Reserve Banks keeping a permanent record o f the source from which a l l G o v e r n m e n t s e c u r i t i e s and t o waive t h i s requirement. a r e received, N e De P a y m e n t o n presentation o f a l l matured Victory coupons regardless o f whether t h e notes f r o m which detached https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis have been paid o r not. Recommended: That t h e Treasury b e r e jested t o reconsider i t s w York FISUAL AGENCY OPERATIONS (continued) instructions with regard t o the handling o f coupons f r o m called Victory notes a n d t o authorize Federal Reserve B a n k s t o p a y all New Y o r k matured coupons o n presentation, ACCOUNTING AND AUDITING A. Report o f Committee o n Standardization o f Accounting Forms, M r . Vogt, Chicago Chairman, B, Proper method o f distributing commissions earned on investments for foreign banks, . ( discussion) San F r a n c i s c o TOPICS FOR DISCUSSION A T JOINT CONFERENCE OF GOVERNORS AND AGENTS O F FEDERAL RESERVE BANKS CREDIT POLICY Federal Reserve Board letter +3518 o f September 9, 1922 {Topic I C Governors’ Program) Federal R e serve s o a r d PAYMENT F O R USE O F NATIONAL BANK EXAMINERS' R E P O R T S (Topic I V F Governors’ Program) https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Chicago, S a n Francisco & Boston SUPPLEMENTAL LIST OF TOPICS RECEIVED TOO LATE FOR PROGRAM OCTOBER 1922 CONFERENCE OF GOVERNORS Pouching o f Mail + Establishment o f sub-station Post Offices ( d i s c u s s i o n ) Philadelphia Risk Assumed b y Federal Reserve B a n k s i n shipping canceled bonds/notes to’ Washington : (discussion) Sustaining Membership i n American Acceptance Council ( d i s c u s s i o n ) Chicago New York Bond Investments b y Member Banks ; (discussion) (Governors Norris and Seay requested toprepare a memorandum). https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Atlanta - Richmond Philadelphia Boston Group Conf, 1 F E D E R A L RESERVE BOARD PROGRAM Joint Conference of Federal Reserve Agents and.Gove rors With! Federal Reserve ‘Board, October 1922, Federal Reserve Credit Policy (See X-3518 - Sept. 9, 1922) L.__What object should Federal Reserve credit policy seek to accomplish and by what test may we know that it is sound? _Discussion t o b e led b y Messrs. Norris and Wills. What relative importance should b e given t o the following factors i n d e t e r m i n i n gh c u s policy? a, F e d e r a l Reserve reserves, b.Interest rates in the open market. Intere st charged b y member banks. Interést rates paid on time deposits, Balance o f trade a n d inward o r outward movement o f gold. Credit conditions in, and exchanges with, leading foreign countries, Volume of bank loans and deposits, e e Business and industrial activity, present o r prospective, Commodity price levels, j. Condition o f security markets, ee D i s c u s s i o n to be led by Messrs, Jay and Seay. 3, What light does the experience of the Federal Reserve Banks throw o n the value of different methods of making their credit and discount policy effective!- “ Discount rates, Open market operations,. Discretion i n rediscounting, Credit examination o f member banks. Credit ratings o f commercial borrowers. Discussion t o b e led b y Messrs, Strong and Perrin, What _is the most practicable method o f bringing about timely and competent consideration o f matters o f credit p o l i c y b y all of the Federal Reserve Banks and effective action t o ebtain the results aimed at? Discussion to be led by Messrs, McDougal and Curtiss, SSIS R I E Following the afternoon session devoted t o the above program, proposed t o devote a n evening session t o the question - https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis What does the present business and credit situation indicate with reference t o the prospective demand for credit and the need or advisability of any action at the present time by Federal Reserve Banks with respect t o matters o f credit and discount policy? General discussion, {7.- f s M E A Oe e e October 1 0 - e e 12, 1 9 2 2 First Day's Session, Tuesday, O c t o b e r 1 0 Joint C o n f e r e n c e w i t h F e d e r a l R e s e r v e B o a r d and Federal Reserve Agents Morning i The meeting was called t o order a t 10:30 o'clock a. m. Present: Honorables Platt, Miller, Crissinger, Mitchell and Hamlin, M e m b e r s o f t h e Federal Reserve Board; Messrs. Curtiss, Jay, Austin, Wills, Hardy, McCord, Heath, Martin, Rich, A s a E. Ramsay, Wm. F. Rameey, and Perrin, Federal Reserve Agents; a n d “Governore Morss, Strong, Norris, Fancher, Seay, Wellborn, y licDougal, Biggs, i Young, Bailey f and Calkins. Vice Governor Platt adiressed the joint conference, calling attention ( 1 ) to the importance ‘ o f many o f the topics o n the program for discussion, a n d staiing that one o r two additional topics t o b e presented t o the respective conferences should b e considered, At 10:50 o'clock a. m. the joint conference adjourned, separate Governors Session The meeting was called t o order a t 10:55 o'cleck a. m. Present: Governors Morss, Strong, Norris, Fancher, Seay, Wellborn, McDougal, Bigzs, Young, Bailey and Calkins. Mr. Harrison, Secretary. Topic I.A.1 R e p o r t o f Committee o n Centralized Execution o f Purchases a n d Sales o f Government Securities b y Federal R e s e r v e B a n k s . The Chairman presented t o the conference t h e report o f the Committee o n Centralized Execution o f Purchases and Sales o f deaevieent Securities b y Federal Reserve Banks, b u t inasmuch a s some o f the Governors had not had a n opportunity t o read it, t h e whole t o p i c o f “Credit Transactions a n d Policies," a s well a s con- sideration o f the minutes o f the October 2, 1922 meeting o f the Committee o n Cen-tralized Execution o f Purchases a n d Sales o f Government Securities b y Federal R e serve B a n k s w a s h e l d o v e r u n t i l t h e n e x t d a y ' s s e s s i o n , https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis { s e e paragraphs 3 0 : & 56) es Topic II.A. R e p o r t o f Standine Committee o n Collections Upon motion o f Governor Fancher, i t was “VOTED t h a t the report (pages 18-56 stenographic record) o f the Committee o n Collection should b e approved and that i t is the sense o f the Conference thet the Standing Committee o n Collections appointed a t the last conference o f Governors shall have active a n d complete jurisdiction over 211 current collection matters, inelud ing forms, a n d thet a n y such matters arising should b e referred b y the Reserve Banks t o such cenmittee f o r disposition, with the understanding thet i t make a report t o each successive conference o f Governors o f all matters acted u p o n by it. I t is the sense o f the Conference, however, that general questions o f collection policy, a s distinguished from routine questions o f operation, should be referred t o the committee f o r recommendation t o the next Conference o f Governors and not for final disposition b y the committee. Governor Calkins, not having hed opportunity t o read the report, voted for its adoption with the understanding that h e might, b y correspondence with the Chairman o f the Committee, discuss possible amendments after h e had had opportunity to study it. (See also paragraph 50) Topic II-B. E x t e n t t o which non-cash collection department hes beeh developed i n each bank. Severel o f the Governors discussed the nature o f the services o f the non-cash collection departments o f their respective banks. C o v e r n o r McDougal said that h e had raised this question for discussion with a view t o considering whether the services o f this department should b e continued i n the light o f the expense t o each Reserve Bank i n carrying o n its operations.» I t seemed t o be the opinion o f individual governors t h a t t h e present services afforded b y this department should b e continued- N o ection was asked for, although i t wes felt by some that c i t y items should n o t b e collected f o r banks i n the same city. Topic II.C. R a i s i n g Limit o f No-protest I t e m s f r o m $ 1 0 t o { 2 0 After general discussion o f whether o r not Federal Reserve Banks Bhould initiate a recommendation o f a uniform limit o n no-protest items, a n d if so whether that limit should b e 910 o r ($20, upon motion o f Governor Fancher, https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis VOTED t h a t i t i s the sense o f the conference that there should b e a unif orm no-pr otest Limit and that the Federal Reserve Banks should agree unif orm= ly to adopt either the 310 o r 320 limit, whichever i s determined b y the majority " of the menber banks t o b e preferable t o them, i t being the sense o f the conference i 4 that the Federal Reserve Banks should adapt their practice i n this regard t o the Wishes and convenience o f the majority of their member banks. Tonic IT.D. L i a b i l i t y o f Reserve Banks i n making unqualified indorsement o n checks received for collection. ( 6 ) Upon motion o f Governor Fancher, i t was VOTED t h a t this tonic b e referred t o the Collection Committee t o dispose of after correspondence with Governor iicKinney, who had proposed the topic f or consideration, b u t who was absent from the conference o n account o f illness, (see also paragraph 49) Topic II.E. Advice of opening of banks previously closed. ( 7 ) Upon motion o f Governor Young, i t was VOTED t h a t e a c h Federal Reserve B a n k advise e a c h other Federal Reserve nae, b y wire o r letter, w h e n a member o r nonmember b a n k i n its district, previous- ly advised as closed, i s reopened. Topic IT.F. Should Federal Reserve Banks handle collection ( 8 ) items payable i n foreign countries. After general discussion o f the advisability of Federal Reserve Banks handling collection items payable i n foreign countries, i t was VOTED (upon motion o f Governor Fancher) that, a s a matter o f general Policy Federal Reserve Banks should not handle collection itens payable i n foreign countries, with such exceptions, however, a s may be necessary i n special cases such as Canadian items. ws Topic ITI.A. V a u l t reserve o f Federal Reserve Banks and ( 9 ) percentage o f gold coin a n d certificates t o total, Governor Morss referred t o the fact that n o w that many o f t h e Federal R e - serve Banks have, o r soon would have, their o w n vaults, i t would b e desirable for https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis ate them t o hold'a considerabie portion o f their gold reserve i n their o m vaulte and a e a basis o f diecuseion r e a d t o t h e conference t w o resolutions passed b y the last Soeton-rhiladelphia-Atlanta a n d Richmond G r o u p Conference w h i c h suggested a serve o f 257, i n coin o r bullion. vault r e - A f t e r discussion, u p o n motion o f Governor Mores, it was VOTED t h a t i n determining t h e amount o f vault reserve n o definite percent-- ase should b e fixed for each reserve bank, but that each bank should build u p its available gold supply held i n its owm vaulte, t a k i n into consideration the amount of ite gold, remoteness from source o f supply o f available circulatins gold, a n d other relevant factors. Governor Strong referred t o the fact that at. the present time the several Federal Reserve Banke had a relatively emall percentage o f their liabilities i n gold coin a n d bearer certificates, t h e aggregate f o r the System being only 11.9%, a n d many o f the banks having less t h a n 5 % , Topic ZII.B. Standard of fitness of currency. ( 1 0 ) Many of the Governors expressed the opinion that the test ofthe etandard of fitness prescribed i n the "Currency Distribution and Payment Policy for Federal Reserve Banke" program adopted a t the May, 1922 Conference o f Governors, w a s too etrict a n d that Federal Reserve Banks should revert t o the sort which prevailed i n the System a s a whole prior t o last I’ay when that test was adopted, T h e discussion brought out the fact that several o f the Treasury officials who had made a careful investigation o f the sort made i n accordance with the test prescribed i n May felt that i t was t o o strict a n d resulted i n the payment b y Federal Reserve Banks o f a er standard o f fit notes t h a n those b e i n g paid o u t b y the Treasury itself. low Upon motion o f Governor Seay, i t waz VOTED t h a t the method o f determining the standard o f f i t n e s s s a prescribed in the Currency Distribution and Payment Policy for Federal Reserve Banks appro ved in May, 1922 b e discontinued a n d that the officials o f the Treasury Department furnish each Federal Reserve B a n k with a sample package o f notes t o represent t h e lowest standard t h a t should b e p u t i n eirculation, a n d that t h e monthly teste b y the Treas. https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis <nue ury b e discontinued; w i t h t h e understanding t h a t t h e Chairman would report these views t o Under Secretary Gilbert withthe request t h a t t h e Treasury Department g i v e formal confirmation o f o r assent t o the action o f the conference. Accumulation o f Used b u t F i t C u r r e n c y . Governor Young discussed the difficulties that h e i s having i n his district in the accumulation o f used b u t f i t currency, a n d sugzested t h e possibility o f each of the Federal Reserve Banks agreeing for a given period not t o pay out any new curs rency, saying that i t was futile for any one Reserve Bank to. attempt such a policy alone, I t seemed t o b e the sense o f the conference t h a t this w a s a ehould b e disposed o f i n eaen district b y a judicious handling matter which o f the amount o f new notes paid out, without a n y agreement b y all Reserve Banks not t o pay o u t any new currency. N o action being asked f o r the topic was passed. Topic LI1.C, Reconsideration o f action o f last conference ( 1 2 ) relative t o absorption o f costs o f all ship-ments o f coin t o a n d f r o m member banks. Governor Calkins referred t o the fact that the action o f the last confer. ence, i n voting to absorb the cost o f outgoing shipments o f subsidiary and minor coin, reculted, i n hie district, i n considerable abuse and unnecessary expenditure of money b y the Reserve Bank, H e moved, therefore, that the conference vote t o dis- continue absorbing t h e c o s t o f such shipments. G o v e r n o r McDougal moved t o continue to absorb t h e expense o f outgoing shipments o f such coin, b u t t o discontinue absorb-- ing the expense o f incoming shipments. A f t e r come diecuesion Governor lHeDougal withdrew his motion a n d asked that t h e subject g o over until t h e next conference. Governor Calkine expreesed the view that thie wae a matter that should b e definitely settled a t this time, a n d that i n a n y event, t h e r e should b e uniformity o f practice throughout t h e System. G o v e r n o r Strong seconded Governor Calkins’ original motion, but, upon vote, t h e motion was lost, Gevernor Calkins voting i n the affirmative. (see paragraph 15). Topic IV.F. P a y m e n t for use of National Bank Examiners’ ( 1 3 Reporte. The Chairman sugzested t h a t a https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis committee o f two Governors b e appointed t o ) Bw meet w i t h a similar committee o f the Agents t o discuss w i t h the Comptroller o f the Currency the question o f making payment for copies o f reports o f examination o f national banks, U p o n motion o f Governor McDougal, VOTED t h a t t h e Chairman appoint s u c h a i t was committee; whereupon, w i t h tie approval o f the conference, Governors Norris a n d S e a y were d e signated f o r the purpose. several of the Governors expressed their views a s t o he position the committee should take i n meeting w i t h the Comptroller. ( s e e paragraphs 3 1 and 44) Addition t o Personnel o f Committee o n Centralized Execution of Purchases a n d Sales Reserve Banks, o f Governvent Securities ( 1 4 ) b y Federal Upon.motion o f Governor Seay, i t was VOTED t h a t Governor Fancher b e made a member of: the Committee o n Centralized Execution o f Purchases and Sales o f Government Securities b y Federal Reserve Banke, At 1:30 o'clock t h e conference adjourned t o reconvene a t 2:30 o'clock. First Day's Session, Tuesday, October 1 0 Separate Governors Session Afternoon The meeting was calied t o order a t 2:30 o'clock p. m. Present: Governors Morse, Strong, Norris, Fancher, Seay, Wellborn, McDougal, Biggs, Young, B a i l e y a n d Calkins. Mr. Harrison, Secretary. Topic III.C. (continued - see paragraph 12) Reconsideration o f action o f last conference relative t c a b s o r p t i o n f o costs o f all shipments of coin t o a n d f r o m member banks. Further consideration w a s given t o the question o f whether o r not a commit. tee should b e appointed b y the conference t o study not only this particular topic, but the whole question o f the absorption o f expenses f o r services rendered t o member banks. T h e appointment o f such a committee n o t being sus7ested b y the conference, however, t h e topic w a s passed without further conecideration, b u t w i t h the under- standing that all Reserve Banks will conferm uniformly t o the action taken https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis on this topic a t the last conference. Topic IV.A, R e p o r t o f Insurance Conmittee Upon motion o f Governor Norris, VOTED ( 1 6 ) i t was t o adopt t h e report (pages 135-138 stenographic record) o f t h e Committee a n d t o refer t o the Committee f o r study and:recommendation t h e question of effecting improvements o r economy i n our present method o f insuring shipments o f currency and securities. Topic IV.B, Report of Leased Wire Committee. Upon motion o f Governor McDougal, ( 1 7 ) i t was VOTED t h a t the report (pages 142-149 stenographic record) o f the Committee b e adopted a n d that t h e recommendations contained i n the report b e approved. Duplex Wire between New York and Chicago. ( 1 8 ) Governor McDougal referred t o a supplementary report o f the officers o f the Chicago bank concerning the establishment o f a duplex wire between New York and Chicago and other changes i n the cireuits, agreed upon after conference with the officers o f the Arierican Telephone and Telegraph Company, i n order t o increase the efficiency o f the wire system a s awhole. “ H e reported the volume o f business now transacted over the various circuits. N o action was asked for. Topic IV.C. M e t h o d o f advising direct sending banks o f other districts o f nonpayment o f cash items. ( 1 9 ) The present practice i s to advise direct~sending banks o f other districts of the nonpayment o f c a s h items b y sending messages prepaid over commercial wires. Governor Calkins suggested that such advices to banks located in Federal Reserve Cities should b e sent over the private wire, S e v e r a l o f the Governors expressed opposition t o any change i n the present practice o n the ground that there i s ereater protection i n sending such messages over the: commercial wires than i n effecting telephone advice o f nonpayment b y the Federal Reserve Bank receiving a message over the private wires. without action. https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis I n view of this general sentiment, t h e topic was passed Topic IV.D. Telepraphic ~Transfers, W h e t h e r transfers over ( 2 0 ) private wires should b e linited t o transfers o f bank balances s o that transfers f o r account o f individuals, firms, corporations, etc., s h o u l d be effected b y member banks a t o w n expense o v e r commercial wires. Upon motion o f Governor Calkins, i t was VOTED t h a t this topic b e referred t o a committee t o b e appointed b y the Chair f o r a thorough study o f the whole subject and for recommendation t o the next Governors Conference. The Chair, thereuvon, appointed t h e Leased Wire Committee t o study all phases o f the Situation, including possible Limitations upon the kind of transfers to b e made, a s well a s possible charges for transfers. Telegraphic transfers f o r nonmember clearing banks. ( 2 1 ) After discussion o f t h e above topic, Governor Y o u n g referred t o the special c a s e o f a nonmember s t a t e bank, n o t eligible f o r membership i n the S y stem, which keeps a Glearing account e n d w i s h e s t o make wire transfers t o cover i t s renit- tances. G o v e r n o r Young moved that the previous action o f the Leased Wire Comite tee limiting wire transfers t o member banks b e amended s o as to permit o f the transfer o f funds for nonmember clearing banks which maintain clearing accounts. This motion was objected to, but after general discussion, i t was brought out that the Leased Jire Committee's report (X-3237 - Feb, 21, 1922) provided that " a s some of the Federal Keserve Banks are under obligations t o accept telepraphic transfers from their nonmember clearing banks, t h e y m a y f o r t h e present continue t o make such transfers," a) 4 opic IV-E. U s e o f test words b y Treasury Department on telegraphic transfers. ( 2 2 Upon motion o f Governor Calkins, i t was VOTED t h a t this topic b e referred t o the Leased Wire Committee with instructions t o work. out some suitable test words t o b e recommended for use b y the Treasury Devartment i n transactions involving telegraphic transfers for the Treasurer's a c c o y n t . https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis ) Popic IV.G. V a r y i n g interpretation o f Action taken a t Governors Conferences. ( 2 3 ) This topic, which related t o the method o f making charges for certain wire advices, was disposed o f b y report o f Leased Wire Committee (paragraph 17) so that n o action w a s asked for. Topic IV.H. Progress o f ifork o f General Committee o f Twelve ( 2 4 0 ~ on Economy a n d Efficiency. There w a s considerable general discussion o f the amount o f progress that had been made since t h e Committee o f Twelve w a s appeinted over a questions o f economy a n d efficieney i n the System a s a whole. year a g o t o study I t was mentioned that while the studies that had beer made b y the Committee had been helpful, nevertheless a comparison o f functional expense accounts o f the several Federal Reserve Banks o n the present dissimilar bases could not o f itself accomplish all that was intended b y the establishment o f the Committee o f Twelve, a n d that while these comparative tables have accomplished much i n prompting study and economies in the individual banks, nevertheless i t was felt b y some that the Committee o f Twelve might also undertake the study o f individual departments i n the different banks in order to ascertain which bank has established the best, most efficient, or most economical organization and procedure i n each function, a n d with a view to Prompting its adoption throughout the system a s a whole s o far as that might b e Possible. Upon riotion o f Governor Calkins, i t was VOTED t h a t the Conference recommend a n early meeting o f the Committee o f Twelve with the Board's committee further t o consider t h e reports recently rendered. Topie VI-A. Report o f Committee o n Standardization o f Accounting Forms, ( 2 5 ) Upon motion i t was VOTED t h a t the report (paces 212-216 stenographic record) b e received - a n d that the recommendations contained therein b e adopted. Governor Young voted i n the negative because o f the fact that h e had not had opportunity t o check u p the forms referred to. https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis - 1 0 - ead Topic Vi... P r o p e r method o f distributing commissions earned o n investments f o r foreign banks. There was general discussion o f ths basis o n which investments for foreign banks are being handled b y the Federal Reserve Bank o f New York for account of all Reserve banks, a s well a s the basis o n which the coumissions earned o n thos: transactions are distributed among the several Reserve Sanks. U p o n motion o f Governor Calkins, i t was VOTED + 9 approve the presert method o f distributing those earnings a s described i n a letter addressed t o all Reserve 3anks b y Mr. Case, Deputy Governor f the Federal Reserve Bank o f New York o n June 15, 1922. Topic Sup. I . P o u c h i n g Mail post offices. Establishment o f substation Governor Norris referred t o the fact that h e is having difficulty i n negotiating with the Post Office Department for the establishment o f a sub-station post office a t the Philadelphia Reserve Bank, a n d asked for information from the other Governors concerning their present method o f handling incoming and outgoing mail. S o m e o f the Governors reported progress i n their negotiations with the Post Office Department a n d , without formal action, i t was understood that Governor Strong would s e n d t o Governor Norris copies o f the correspondence between t h e Federal Reserve B a n k o f N e w York a n d the Postmaster General relative t o t h e estabe lishment o f the station a t the New York bank. Tovic Sup. Il. R i s k assumed b y Federal Reserve Sanks i n ( 2 8 ) shipping canceled bonds/notes t o Washington. After informal preliminary discussion, i t was agreed, o n motion o f Governor Seay, t h a t this topic should b e held over until Mr. Gilbert appeared before the conference t o discuss fiscal agency matters. T h e discussion indiceted, how- ever, that most o f the Federal Reserve Banks now insure shipments o f canceled securities t o the Treasury Department, w h i l e t h e Federal Reserve Banks o f N e w York, Philadelphia, Richmond and San Francisco, pendirg adjustment with the Treasury Department, a r e holding u p shipments. https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis ( s e e paragraph 5 5 ) eehee Topic Sup, Ill. Sust2zining membership i n American Acceptance ( 2 9 ) Council. Governor Strong read extracts from a memorandum relative t o the worx of the American Acceptance Council and its financial program. I t was brought out in the discussion that the Council now estimates that its expenses for next year will be about 322,000 and that i n order t o meet thie cost i t has planned t o solicit this year certain sustaining memberships, a t 3500 per annum, which, together with the regular member shivs, o f 53100 per annum, will.be sufficient t o permit a continuation of its work for another year. T h e question presented t o the conference was whether the Federal Reserve 3anks would be willing to become sustaining members for this year if, a s is understood, twenty o r more commercial banks will d o so. I t was ine formally agreed that the matter should be referred to Governor Strong to ascertain what i s the present practice o f the Reserve 3anks with regard t o this and similar matters, and, i f necessary, sonal correspondence, t o take i t u p with the Federal Reserve Soard b y per- i t being the general view of the conference that i t is im- portant t o the best interests o f the Federal Reserve System t o continue the work ofthe American Accept ance Couneil, At 5:45 o'cloek DB. m.- the conference adjourned t o meet a t 10:00 o'clock a» m. o n Wednesday, October li. Second Day's Session, Wednesday, October 1 1 Governors Separate Session Morning The meeting w a s called t o order a t 10:15 o'clock a . m . Present: Governors Morss, Strong, Norris, Fancher, Seay, Wellborn, McDougal, 5iggs, Young, Zailey and Calkins. Mr. Harrison, Secretary. Topic TeAsl. (continued - see paragraph 2) Report o f Committee o n Centralized Execution of Purchases a n d Sales o f Government Secur ities by Federal Reserve sanks. The Chairman announced that the Committee o n Centralized Exeeution o f Purchases and Sales o f Government securities h a d slightly revised the minutes o f its meeting o f October 2 , and submitted t o the conference for its consideration anc https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis approval a copy o f the minutes a s revised. T h e Committee, a s recorded i n these minutes, expressed i t s approval o f t h e action taken b y the Federal Advisory Council its last meeting relative t o investments b y Federal Reserve Banks f o r t h e pure pose of making earnings, and recommended to the conference (1) that Governor Fancher o f the Federal Reserve Bank o f Cleveland b e made a member o f the Committee (see paragraph 14) and (2) that the Committee's duties be extended so as to provide for the making of recommendations and suggestions to each Federal Reserve Bank from time t o time concerning the advisability o f making purchases o r sales o f Government securities. Upon motion o f Governor Young, i t was VOTED t h a t t h e report (pages 248-252 Stenographic record) a n d the recom- mendations contained i n the minutes (pages 25€+263 stenopraphic record) of: the Committee b e approved. ( s e e also paragraph 56) Topic IV.F. (continued - see paragraph 13) ( 3 1 ) Payment f o r u s e o f National B a n k Examiners’ Reports. Governor Norris reported t o the Conference the substance o f the meeting which t h e joint committee o f Agents a n d Governors h a d h a d with t h e Comptroller of the Currency concerning payments for the reports of examination of national banks. He stated that the Comptroller h a d estimated that his deficit for the current year would b e $50,000, o r some $90,000 less than the amount which h e is now receiving froh Federal Reserve 3anks i n payment f o r t h e reports o f examination o f national banks. G o v e r n o r Norris a l s o s a i d that t h e Committee t o l d the Comptroller t h a t t h e present arrangement w a s a temporary o n e t o meet a n emergericy a n d that i f payments for reports w e r e t o b e continued t h e y should b e o n some permanent defensible basis and not o n t h e present emergency basis. he would b e willing t o consider a T h e Comptroller t o l d t h e Committee that revision o f the present charges a t a later meet- ing with the Committee. Upon motion o f Governor Bailey, i t was VOTED t h a t the Committee b e authorized t o conclude a n arrangement with the Comptroller o f the Currency for furnishing reports o f examination o f national banks to Federal https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Reserve Banks o n the best terms Possible, effective from the present time, subject, however, t o revision a t the next fall Conference o f Governors and Agents, provided, however, that while the Federal Reserve Banks feel that they might b e justified i n paying the "cost" o f furnishing such reports, they would not be justified i n naking a payment simply for the purpose o f meeting a deficit i n the Operations o f t h e o f fice o f t h e Comptroller o f t h e Currency. { s e e paragraph 44) Topic 1.4.2. Advisability o f further reduction i n total investment account. ( 3 2 ) This topic was passed inasmuch 1 s it was understood t o be covered b y the Report o f the Committee o n Centralized Execution o f Purchases and Sales o f Government Securities. Topic T.A.3. Investments for Earnings ( 3 3 ) This topic was passed inasmuch a s it was understood t o be covered b y the Report o f the Committee o n Centralized Execution o f Purchases and Sales of Government Securities, Topic T.A.4. Policy i n relation t o Gold Imports and ( 3 4 ) Money Market. Governor Strong briefly referred t o the policy o f the Federal Reserve Bank of New York and the reasons therefor i n selling some of its investments and in making small payments o f gold t o Government disbursing officers and New York City banks. N o action o n this topic was asked for. Topic-I.A.5. P u r c h a s e o f Exchance. | Govern tr Calkins e s k e d for a ( 3 5 ) statement o f t h e practice o f t h e séveral Federal Feserve Banks i n regard t o buying and selling domestic exchange. It appeared from the discussion that n o Federal Reserve Banks are now buying domestic exchange, some o f those banks who had been doing s o having discontinued the practice. N o action was asked for, although Governor Calkins stated that the Federal Reserve Bank o f San Francisco will very likely, o n account o f the difference in time between San Francisco and New York, begin t o give immediate credit o n wire transfers which are not i n fact consummated until the next day, making a n appropriate charge therefor. https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Po oe a Topic I.5. I n t e r p r e t a t i o n of "Borrower" S e c t i o n 1 3 Federal R e - ( 3 6 ) serve Act limiting amount which Federal heserve Banks may rediscount f o r a n y o n e bank. o r inGovernor S e a y raised t h e question whether t h e phrase “signature be indorsement o f any one borrower" i n Section 1 3 o f the Federal Reserve Act could presented t o a Federal Reserve t h e “indorser"™ o n a n obligation Egp ’ terpreted t o mean that ; Bank for rediscount might b e the "borrower." U p o n general discussion i t developed that seven o f the Federal Reserve Banks are a t present oursuing the practice covered re~ in the Federal Reserve Board's letter t o t h e Federal Reserve B a n k o f Richmond, ferred t o b y Governor Seay, that is, they consider the maker the borrower i n all cases except. where i t appears from the circumstances surrounding the loan that the h t bormaker i s an accommodation maker, i n which case the indorser i s c o n s i d e r e de rower. F o u r o f the Reserve Banks, however, including the Federal Keserve Bank o f Richmond, expressed the opinion that either the indorser o r maker might b e the bor~ rower dependent u p o n the circumstances o f e a c h case. U p o n motion o f Governor Seay, it was, VOTED t h a t i t i s the sense o f t h e conference t h a t t h e Federal Reserve o withhold any formal ruling o n this subject until the Board should b e r e q u e s t e d t t study the counsel o f the several Federal Reserve Banks may have a n o p p o r t u n i t yo question a n d submit. their views t o the Federal Reserve Board. Topic 1.C. D i s c o u n t Rates. e eon e This topic w a s passed jnasmuch a s i t i s necessarily included i n the topics presented o n the Board's program f o r consideration a t the joint conference. Topic 1.D. R e p o r t o f the General Committee o n Acceptances ( 3 8 ) Upon motion, i t was VOTED that the report (end of stenographic record) of the General Committee o n Acceptances should b e received a n d filed. R e p o r t o f Committee o n Open Bill Market Conditions a n d Operations. ( 3 9 ) Upon motion, i t was VOTED that the report (pages 321-324 of stenographic record) o f the Committee o n Open Bill Market Conditions a n d Operations b e received a n d f i l e d , https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis -15Reimbursement f o r vrork performed 2 s Fiscal Agents o f ( War Finance Corvoration. 40) The Chairmen reported the fact that the Conference o f Federal Reserve Agents had referred t o the Governors f o r consideration and action the question whether o r not certain overhead expenses should b e included with actual expenses in determining the amount o f reimbursement asked for services rendered e s fiscal agents o f the War Finance Corporation. Upon motion o f Governor Seey, i t wes VOTED t h e t every Federal Reserve Bank performing services f o r the Wer Finance Corporation should advise e v e r y other Federel Reserve B a n k performing similar services, just what items are included i n determining the amount for which reimbursement i s now asked. “Ypon motion of Governor Bailey, i t ves VOTED t o incorporate i n this resolution similar instructions con~ cerning Farm Land Banks. Topic Sup. IV. B o n d investments by Member Banks. { 41) This topic, which wes presented t o the conference b y the Atl anta-RichmondPhiladelphia end Boston Group Conference, wes discussed b y Governors Norris and Seay, members o f that Group Conference, the question being whether i t might b e desirable o r advisable f o r the Federal Reserve Banks t o attempt t o place a n y control o r restrictions u p o n t h e investments b y member banks i n promiscuous bonds, other than Government securities. Governor Seay expressed doubt whether i t was possible o r wise t o attempt a n y such control f r o m t h e point o f view o f the Federal Reserve Banks, although h e stated that many country member banks i n particular, some ‘of which are borrowing from the Federal Reserve Bank, are investing much too great a percentage o f their assets i n such bonds. O t h e r members o f the conference e x - pressed the opinion that the regulating o r supervisory authority for such operations of member benks i s now elready well established b y law, a n d that though Federal Reserve Banks i n dealing with their members could not completely ignore the investment account o f such members, nevertheless they should not attempt t o regulate o r https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis wih 6s run t h e details o f their business- N o action w a s asked fore Form of Weekly Report of Condition ( 42) The Chairman stated t h a t t h e conference o f Federal Reserve Agents h a d reierred t o the conference, w i t h their approval, a memorandum suggesting a change in the form of the weekly report s o es t o separate non reserve cash from other items now included i n that caption, such as “uncollected” i t e m s Upon motion o f Governor Young, i t was VOTED t h a t the conference concur i n the suggestion contained i n the memorandum » At 1:00 o'clock noon the conference adjourned t o meet a t 2:30 p- me Second Day's Session, Wednesday, October 1 1 Governors’ Separate Session Afternoon The meeting was called t o order a t 2:30 o'clock p - m. Present: Governors Morss, Strong, Norris, Fancher, Seay, Wellborn, McDougal, Biggs, Young, Bailey and Calkins. Mr. Gilbert, Under Secretary o f the Treasury, during latter part o f session. Mr. Harriscn, Secretary. Federal Reserve Fension Plan. ( 43) Governor Calkins stated that i t was his opinion that one big step i n the present economy and efficiency program o f the Federel Reserve Banks would b e to establish a pension plan, since i t would d o much t o maintain the continuity and efficiency i n the personnel o f the Federal Reserve Banks. A f t e r general discussion, i n which i t was pointed out that i t is probably impossible now to procure the congressional legislation necessary t o establish any sort o f retro-active pension plan, upon motion o f Governor Seay, i t wes VOTED t h a t i t is the sense o f the conference that, i f possible, some sort o f Federal Reserve pension p l a n should b e inaugurated a n d that t h e question should b e referred back t o the Committee o n Pensions t o make a further study and recommendations a s t o whether congressional legislation. https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis o r not s o m e progress might b e m a d e vrith o r w i t h o u t em Topic IV-F'. { c o n t i n u e d = see paragraphs 13 and 31) ( 44) Payment for use o f National Bank Examiners’ Reports. Governor Norris reported the substance o f the second interview o f the committee appointed t o discuss with the Comptroller o f the Currency the expense of procuring reports o f examination o f national banks. H e stated that t h e com- mittee had advised the Comptroller thet both the Governors and Agents, i n separate meetings a n d without consultation, h a d unanimously reached t h e opinion t h a t pay- ment for reports o f examination o f national banks should b e based not upon a n y probable o r estimated deficit i n the operation o f the Comptroller's office, but rather upon the cost o f preparing the reports which the Comptroller was t o furnish t o the Federal Reserve Banks. H e reported further that the committee h a d Suggested t o the Comptroller e payment for ell revorts o f examination a t the rate of ten cents a page, or, for the sake o f convenience, a t the rate o f $3.00 a report, i t being estimated thet all o f the reports together average approximately a h stated that h e thirty pages. G o v e r n o r Norris reported that the C o m p t r o l i e rd feit ten cents a page too little, and had suggested fifteer cents e page, o r a flat rate of $4.50 per report, regardless of the number of pages. T h i s latter rate was agreed t o b y the committee, i t being understood that all past reports would b e paid for at the old rate, the new rate t o become effective a t once, subject t o review a t semi-annual conferences o f Governorss G o v e r n o r Norris a l s o reported that the Comptroller o f the Currency stated that h e had no objection t o the copies o f the reports o f examinetion o f benks located i n branch territory being furnished t o the managers o f the respective branches, provided thet they were handied b y such manegers i n the proper manner, that i s i n the same wey es eat the parent banke (See paragraph 66a Secretary's minutes of May, 1922 Conference of Governors) Upon motion o f Governor Young, i t was VOTED t h a t t h e action o f the committee b e ratified, w i t h t h e understanding t h e t Governor Norris would make a for the recorde https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis formal written report o f the agreement Topic V.A. Payment of Savings Stamps and Certificates due January 1, 1923. There was preliminary discussion o f this topic pending Mr. Gilbert's presence t a the conference. Governor Morss reported his views, pointing out the necessity of making some arrangements t o meet large payments of savings stamps and certificates due January I, 1923.. Governor Strong referred to the great number o f certificates that will probably b e presented for payment i n New York City alone. The topic w a s passed until Mr. Gilbert s h o u l d join t h e conference. ( s e e paragraph 52) Topic V.3. Allotments o n Subscriptions t o New Issues o f Government Securities t o banks and others, ( 4 6 ) For the purpose o f discussion, Governor Young moved that the Treasury be requested n o t t o make allotments t o Reserve Banks until t h e subscriptions a r e closed and the total amount known, and then to make allotments o n the basis of the total subscriptions received by each Reserve Sank o n an exact percentage basis, i n order that the Federal Reserve Banks may in turn make allotments o n a sliding scale, alletting the smaller subscriptions i n full; o r o n some other determined basis after subscriptions are closed. in discussing this motion, several o f the Governors expressed the opinion that i f adopted i t might induce padding o f subscriptions, been largely overcome i n many o f the districts. a n abuse which now has I t seemed t o be the general opinion that the present plan o f allotment o n some basis o f the percentage o f the bank's rescuntes i s the most satisfactory a n d the least apt t o cause padding o f subscrip- tions. whereupon, Governor Young withdrew his motion, and Governor Strong withdrew the topic from the program. ca Topic V.C. P e r m a n e n t reeords o f source o f a l l Government There w a s informal discussion b y eaeh o f t h e G o v e r n o r s f o the question (1) o f the practice o f the Federal Reserve Banks i n keeping records o f the source of all Government securities, a n d (2) o f the desirability o f keeping those records- All of the banks do at present keep such records, but in varying degrees of detail. https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis =] it was the informal opinion o f the majority o f the Gevernors present that the Federal Reserve Banks should b e relieved o f the responsibility o f keeping such records» I t was understood that the topic would be discussed with Mr. Gilbert. (see paragraph 53) Topie V.De P a y m e n t o n presentation of all matured Victory ( 4 8 ) coupons regardless o f whether t h e notes f r o m which detached have been p a i d o r not. After a very brief discussion, this topic was left over for consideration with Mr- Gilbert. ( s e e paragraph 54) Topic I1-D. (continued - see paragraph 6) ( 49) Liability o f Reserve benks i n making unqualified indorsement o n checks received f o r collection The Secretary read a telegram from Governor McKinney e e the subject o f unqualified indorsementse U p o n the suggestion of the Chairman, the telegram was referred t o the Standing Committee o n Collections, t o which this topic had previously been referred. Topic II-A- (continued =~ see paragraph 3) Report of Standing Committee o n Collections ( 50) Governor S e a y referred t o the importance o f h a ving a l l Federal Reserve Banks conform t o the recommendations made b y the Collection Committee i n its report, stating, however, that, a s agreed b y the conference, each Governor might discuss with the committee the prepriety o f meking slight verbal changes i n the report. Par Collection System ( 5 1 ) There was a n informal discussion o f certain problems incident t o the o p e r a t i o nf o the collection systems Sg veenet Caikine briefly described the results o f the Brookings State Bank ease, stating that the Federal Reserve Bank hed won its case i n all particulars Governor Young asked what would be the practice of the other Federal Reserve Banks i n the case o f a nonmember state bank located i n a city where there is n o other bank which refused t o remit a t pare F i v e o f the Governors present -gtakhed that they thought i t would b e proper t o take such a bank off the par list, https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis OQ = & w h i l e the other five expressed i t t o b e their opinion that they would send out a n > agent o f effect collections o n such a bank unless t h a t might b e contrary t o t h e wishes o f counsel i n pending collection cases. Atthis point Mr. Gilbert joined the meeting. Topic V.A. (continued - see paragraph 45) ( 5 2 ) Payment o f Savings Stamps and Certificates due January 1 , 1923. Mr. Gilbert stated that the Treasury Department i s now working o n a plan for the payment o f savings stamps and certificates due J a n u a r y , 1 1923, and that he would endeavor t o have a preliminary copy of: that plan sent t o each Federal Reserve Bank o n o r about October 1 9 i n order t h a t t h e y might m a k e t h e necessary arrangements for carrying out the suggestions the Treasury might make. H e said further that h e considered i t advisable t o have Federal Reserve Sanks a n d Sranches m a k e payments o f savings stamps a n d certificates i n the same manner t h a t t h e y n o w make payments o f ¢oupons o n matured bonds, notes and certificates, W h e n the question of the cost of establishing branch offices, o r making other arrangements, t o make payments o f these certificates was raised, Mr. Gilbert stated that the Treasury would b e willing to listen t o reasonable claims f o r expenses. Topic V.C. (continued - see paragraph 47) Permanent records o f source o f all Government Securities. After a ( 5 3 ) short discussion o f this subject, M r . Gilbert s a i d that h e would be glad t o have all o f the Federal Reserve Banks look into the question o f the exe pense involved i n maintaining permanent records o f t h e sources o f a l l Government securities, a n d advise him of the results o f their investigations. I t was infor- mally understood that that would be done. Topic V.D. (continued - see paragraph 48) Payment o n presentation o f a l l matured Wisters coupons regardless o f whether t h e notes from which detached have b e e n p a i d o r not. ( 5 4 Mr. Gilbert explained that t h e present instructions o f the Treasury D e - partment regarding the payment o f matured Victory coujsons, regardless o f whether https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis ) - 21or not t h e notes f r o m which detached have been paid, conform t o the long-standing practice o f the Treasury Department a n d that unless i t developed, the srraller operations i n the 2 a s a result o f 3/4 Victory Coupons o n December 1 5 , that t h e plan was not workable, h e would prefer t o continue it. Topic Sun. Il. (continued - see paragraph 28) Risk assumed b y Federal Reserve Banks i n shipping canceled bonds/notes t o Washington. Mr. Gilbert reported that h e had had frequent t a l k s with the Comptroller General with regard t o a ruling concerning the risk involved b y Federal Reserve Banks i n shipping cancelled bonds a n d notes t o Washington, receive a n early n e w ruling f r o m hin. a n d that h e expected t o U n d e r t h e vresent ruling o s Treasurer w i l l i t was pass credit only i f and when the actual securities are received b y him. o f the current ruling sugrested that i t might b e possible t o avoid the difficulties to by cutting i n half bonds a n d notes that h a d been cancelled prior t o shipment Washington, thus minimizing the risk o f loss, M r . Gilbert thought that this might be done i f i t were ultimately found to b e necessary, but suggested that n o action be taken until after the Comptroller General had made his ruling. I t was infor- been mally understood that n o action shall b e taken until after such a ruling has received. ( Topic I.A.I, (continued - see paragraphs 2 and 30) Execution Centralized o n Report o f Committee 5 6 ) of Purchases a n d Sales o f Government Securities by Federal Reserve Banks. o f the ComThe Chairnan briefly outlined t o Mr. Gilbert the policies o f Government Securities b y mittee o n Centralized Execution o f Purchases and Sales taken b y the cormittee a t its Federal Reserve Banks, a n d advised h i m o f t h e action m a d e a t that time. meeting o n October 2 , together w i t h t h e recommendations the conference After further informal discussion, a t 5:40 o'clock p. m12, when they were t o g o into adjourned until 10:00 o'clock a. m. Thursday, October Reserve Agents t o disjoint ecorference with the Federal Reserve Board and Federal Credit Policy. cuss t h e Board's program o n Federal Reserve https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis https://fraser.stlouisfed.org Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis