Full text of Federal Reserve Bulletin : June 1915
The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.
FEDERAL RESERVE BULLETIN ISSUED BY THE FEDERAL RESERVE BOARD AT WASHINGTON JU N E , 1915 WASHINGTON GOVERNM ENT PRIN TING OFFICE 1915 SUBSCRIPTION PRICE OF BULLETIN, May and June issues of the Federal Reserve Bulletin have been distributed without charge. This distribution will be con tinued to member banks of the system and to the officers and directors of Federal Reserve Banks. In sending the Bulletin to others the Federal Reserve Board feels that a subscription price should be required. at $2 per annum. It has accordingly fixed this^price Single copies will be sold at 20 cents. Remittances should be made to the Federal Reserve Board. T A B L E O F CONTENTS. Page. Work of the Federal Reserve Board........... .................................................................................................................. 65 Address by Hon. W. P. G. Harding............................................................................................................................... 66 Informal rulings of the Federal Reserve Board............................................................................................................ 72 Imports and exports of gold................................................................ ........................................................................... 76 Circulars and regulations................................................................................................................................................. 78 Distribution of Aldrich-Vreeland currency.................................................................................................................. 80 Gold settlement fund........................ 82 Acceptances..................................................................................................................................................................... 71, 84 Redistricting decision..................................................................................................................................................... 85 Law department......................................................................................................................................................... 91 General business conditions..................................................................................................................... Resources and liabilities of Federal reserve banks........................................................................................................ 112 106 FEDERAL RESERVE BULLETIN V ol. 1 JUNE 1, 1915 WORK OF THE BOARD. During the month of May the work of the Federal Reserve Board has included four important elements: (1) The development and perfecting of the system of clearance between Federal Reserve Banks through the establishment of a gold settlement fund at Washington. (2) The working out and perfecting of a circular relating to the conditions of admission of State banks into the Federal reserve system, shortly to be issued. (3) Visits to several of the reserve banks by members of the Board, followed by con ferences with the officers of these institutions while the visiting members of the Board were on the ground. (4) Participation in the Pan American Finan cial Conference which convened at Washington on May 24. In addition to these principal lines of activity, the Board has, of course, been carry ing on the usual routine work of administration, and has been granting applications for the right to exercise the functions of trustee, executor, etc., as well as requests for authority to accept drafts and bills of exchange running not more than six months, up to an amount not to exceed 100 per cent of the capital and surplus of the applying bank. An especially interesting feature of the month’s work has been the announcement of the decision of the Board in the redistricting cases which had been appealed to it from the Reserve Bank Organization Committee. The work of preparing the decisions in these cases had been accomplished before the beginning of May, but the publication of them occurred on May 4. In the course of carrying to completion the work of drafting provisions for the gold settle ment fund, there occurred at Washington on No. 2 May 6-7 a conference with governors of Federal Reserve Banks constituting a committee on clearance, who had been interested in the preparation of the plan of settlement and its going into operation on a satisfactory basis. During this conference further discussion of the technical details of the settlement plan occurred between members of the Federal Reserve Board and representatives of the several banks. The success of the plan was therefore assured, in advance, by reason of the hearty cooperation of the governors of the Fed eral Reserve Banks who had been interested in it. On May 27 the Board, in further develop ment of the plans for the gold settlement fund, adopted a resolution providing as follows: Whereas Under the provisions of Regula tion L, series of 1915, adopted by the Federal Reserve Board, it is necessary, in order to transfer title to the gold order certificates deosited in the Gold Settlement Fund, that they e indorsed by the Federal Reserve Board; Now therefore be it resolved, That this in dorsement by the Federal Reserve Board, to be valid and binding, must have the signatures of two members of said Board, and Be it further resolved, That the Governor and Vice Governor, or in the absence of either or both of them, Mr. Warburg, Mr. Harding, or Mr. Miller, in their place or stead, be and they are hereby authorized to indorse such gold order certificates, for and in behalf of the Federal Reserve Board. The Pan American Conference began on May 24 and proceeded during the succeeding week. An analysis of the results of this con ference will be made in a later number of the Bulletin. During the month the printing of the additional supply of Federal reserve notes, authorized some time ago, proceeded rapidly, and the stock of such notes in the hands of the Board is rapidly approaching the prescribed figure. OPERATION OP FEDERAL RESERVE SYSTEM. Hon. W. P. G. Harding, a member of the Federal Reserve Board, delivered the following address before the Texas Bankers’ Association Convention, at Waco, Tex., on May 18, 1915: I shall not attempt any discussion of the Federal reserve act from its broadest view points, but shall confine myself to certain phases of its operation that are of paiticular mterest to member banks, and in endeavoring to stress some of the benefits of the system, I shall not seek to evade a discussion of certain features to which objection has been made, particularly*by the smaller banks. The profits arising from exchange charges have always been dear to the hearts of bankers, for the reason that transactions against which these charges are made are quickly closed up and involve no long tying up of funds. Profits from this source, however, are constantly be coming smaller, so that in the case of many banks, in the larger towns especially, they have so diminished that the exchange account shows a loss instead of a gain. I can remember the time when banks in Alabama charged a pre mium of one-half of 1 per cent for their checks upon financial centers, while they would buy at the same time sight drafts upon the same cities at the same rate of discount, thus netting a clear 1 per cent. I presume that there was a time when rates equally as high prevailed in Texas. Some of these same banks are, now glad to make a net profit of one-tenth of 1 per cent, and in many cases this profit is derived only from the purchase of bills drawn against cotton when that commodity is moving ac tively, or from the collection of and remittance for bills-of-lading drafts drawn against ship ments of goods. Theoretically, exchange may be defined as the rate at which the documentary transfer of funds is made, so that if the debits reciprocally due by two places be equal, the exchange will be at par, but when greater in one than in the other, the exchange will be against that place which has the larger remittances to make and in favor of the other. It is customary for the seller of goods to forward them at the expense of the purchaser, who is supposed 'to pay for them in funds current at the place of residence of the seller. Thirty years ago it was the prac tice for settlements to be made between parties living in different towns, by draft on New York or some other financial center, by post office money order, or by shipments of currency by express. In those days the rate of exchange was governed to a great extent by express rates, especially when the amount involved was large, for the remitter would not pay a bank a higher rate for its check than it would cost him to forward the actual funds by express. Merchants would go to their local bank and purchase drafts in favor of their creditors, paying the bank the agreed premium. Al the S business of the country developed, the local merchant gradually acquired the habit of send ing his own check, drawn upon his local bank, to his creditor in New York, Chicago, or St. Louis, who would deposit the check in his own bank, which would, in turn, forward it for pay ment. The local merchant found that by do ing this he could avoid paying a premium for a bank draft drawn upon the city where his debt was due. The city dealer found that he could in most cases, prevail upon his own bank to accept his country checks on deposit without making any deduction, so he soon became ac customed to this method of settlement. In the course of time, when many remittances were being- made in this way, the burden upon the banks in the financial centers became very reat, and to protect themselves, the crediting ank would impose a charge on country checks deposited with it, so that the cost of remitting funds for settlement of goods purchased had been shifted from the local merchant to the dealer or jobber in the cities. In many cases, however, this cost is borne by neither of the arties to the transaction, but is Still absorbed y the city bank which has the dealer’s account, although there seems hardly more reason for it to be taxed with the cost of transfer of funds from the buyer to the seller, than for it to pay freight upon the goods purchased. The banker in the smaller towns naturally looks with favor upon this method of settle ment, as he exacts his exchange charge from the bank from which he receives the check, and his bank has enjoyed an increased deposit during the time the check has been outstand ing. Many abuses have crept in, however, and it frequently happens, particularly where the drawer knows that his check will be out standing four or five days, that he will forward it before he actually has funds in bank to meet it, relying upon his ability to make the account good by the time the check is returned for payment. The merchant in the small town, therefore, prefers to continue this method of settlement, as it frequently saves him an interest charge. It often happens also that S E in cases where the bank in the larger city makes a charge against its depositor more than ample to cover actual cost of collecting a country check, that it seeks to retain all or a part of this as a net profit, and is frequently enabled to do so by taking advantage of competitive conditions in an intermediate town where it has a reciprocal account, so that the expense is in many cases borne by a bank in some local center which is willing to take business at a loss to prevent a com petitor from getting it. The ideal arrange ment which the bank in the small town, or the real country bank, likes to make, and one which it is frequently able to make, is to charge its correspondent bank located in a financial center of its own State, exchange at the rate of 25 cents per hundred on all checks received for collection, at the same time clearing through the same correspondent all checks payable outside of is own town without any expense whatever. I believe, however, that arrangements of this kind are becoming harder to make, and that the greater part of exchange charges now being made in this country are borne by the sellers of goods. It may be that their profits are sufficient to admit of their bearing this expense, and I have always been impressed with the logic of a contention made by a country merchant when I was a bank clerk in Alabama more than 30 years ago. It seems that on one occasion he sent his own check on the local bank to a New Orleans merchant in payment of some sugar, instead of following what was then the prevailing custom of going to the bank and buying its draft on New Orleans. This check was deposited in a New Orleans bank, who sent it for collection to the rival bank so that the bank on which the check was drawn made no profit out of the transaction. The cashier asked this merchant what he meant by sending his local check as far away as New Orleans, and sug gested that he come in as usual and buy a bank draft. The merchant replied that whenever the New Orleans merchants would pay the freight on their goods shipped to him that he would be willing to pay the freight on their money. Sellers of goods all over the country have for several yeai's past been paying freight on the money paid them for their goods, and the volume of local checks that are transmitted in the mails every day now reaches enormous proportions; certainly $200,000,000 would not be a high estimate. When the Federal reserve act was being debated in Congress, representa tives of those who have been paying exchange charges on checks sent them in payment of goods sold exerted their influence in favor of free check collections, and shortly afterwards representatives of more than 2,000 country banks went to Washington and appeared before the committee having the bill in charge and entered a vigorous protest against being deprived of what they regarded as a legitimate profit. The result was that this paragraph was included in section 16 of the bill as enacted, and is now part of the law: u Every Federal Reserve Bank shall receive on deposit at par from member banks or from Federal Reserve Banks checks and drafts drawn upon any of its depositors, and when remitted by a Federal Reserve Bank checks and drafts drawn by any depositor in any other Federal Reserve Bank or member bank upon funds to the credit of said depositor in said Reserve Bank or member bank. Nothing here in contained shall be construed as prohibiting a member bank from charging its actual ex pense incurred in collecting and remitting funds or for exchange sold to its patrons. The Federal Reserve Board shall, by rule, fix the charges to be collected by the member banks from its patrons whose checks are cleared through the Federal Reserve Bank, and the charge which may be imposed for the service of clearing or collection rendered by the Fed eral Reserve Bank.” It seems to have been the idea in Congress that country banks would be appeased by the provision that they might make a charge against those of their patrons whose checks were cleared through the Federal Reserve Bank. In other words, if Mr. Brown, of Abilene, should draw his check upon the Citizens National Bank of Abilene, in favor of Smith & Co., of Chicago, for $100, and that check should Ipe returned to the Abilene bank for payment through the Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas, it was thought that the Abilene bank could charge Mr. Brown 15 cents for having paid his check in Chicago funds. The fact, however, was evidently overlooked that Mr. Brown would not look with favor upon this charge, which, if persisted in, would result in the loss by the Citizens National Bank of Mr. Brown’s account. Neither is the permission given u to charge for exchange sold to patrons” any more satisfactory to the small bank, for the reason that their patrons have long since gotten out of the habit of buying bank drafts and make a practice of remitting their own checks. It seems, therefore, in actual practice that the only charge allowed is for “ the actual expense ittcufred m collecting and remitting funds,” wliich must seem a mere pittance to banks that have been charging 25 cents per hundred. Yet the Federal Reserve Banks are required to Receive on deposit at par from member banks or "from Federal Reserve Banks checks and drafts draWn upon any of its depositors,” and the Federal Reserve Board is charged with the duty of carrying out the law. It has been the earnest desire of the Board to cause as little hardship as possible in making these changes, and after a careful study of the whole subject, and after many conferences with representatives of ail Federal Reserve Banks and officers of member banks, a plan has been agreed upon which will, be* gradual in its operation, and which will, it is thought, in the course of time prove effective. Each Federal Reserve Bank, in accordance with this plan, has notified its member banks that a cneck clearing system will be establishd, but that for the present the system will be a voluntary one, and no bank will be required to be a party to it except of its own free will and accord. In order best to describe the workings of this plan, I will assume that the member banks in Dallas, Fort Wortn, Waco, Austin, Houston, San Antonio, Paris, Galveston, Sherman, and El Paso assent, and agree to permit the Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas to charge against their respective accounts as soon as received checks upon each bank which may come into the hands of the reserve bank. Such checks will be immediately forwarded to banks upon which drawn, for credit, and any checks not good are to be returned to the Federal Reserve Bank and recredited by it. Each of the banks agreeing to the plan must carry with the Federal Reserve Bank, in addition to its re quired reserve, an amount sufficient to provide for the debiting against its account of these checks. We wifi assume that there are 40 banks which agree to this plan at the start. Any one of these 40 banks having checks upon the other 39 banks will forward them all to the Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas, and receive immediate credit. It will, of course, have to stand an immediate debit on tiie books of the Federal Reserve Bank of all checks drawn upon itself received by the Reserve Bank from the other 39 banks, so that the net result to any one bank is merely a balance, and it will at the same time have been convenienced by having to write only one remittance letter instead of a great many, and by receiving only one incoming letter from the Federal Reserve Bank, instead of perhaps 39. Parties receiving checks upon any of these 40 banks will soon appreciate the fact that they are collectible at once, without change, ana, therefore, are as desirable as checks on New York, Chicago, or St. Louis have been hitherto. There will thus be established a preference for checks drawn on these banks, and parties remitting in payment of bills checks on banks not connected with this clear ing plan will soon be brought to realize that checks drawn on banks in the clearing system are preferred. If a merchant in Sherman finds that by reason of his bank being a member of the clearing system that his checks are received without question, he will appreciate the facil ity given him, but if a merchant in Texar kana, for instance, finds that by reason of his bank not being a member of the clearing sys tem, he is charged exchange upon the checks that he sends out, while his competitor in Sherman or Waco is exempt from such charge, he will soon, no doubt, exert enough pressure upon his own bank to induce it to become a member of the clearing system. If Galveston, Austin, and Fort Wortn, as well as Dallas, should all be members of the clearing system, merchants in all these towns would enjoy the same advantage, and in the course of time the banks in Amarillo; for instance, would find that they would lose business by remaining out, and would, I think, as a matter of busi ness necessity, finally become members of the clearing system. The Federal reserve act does not, of course, become entirely effective as far as its reserve requirements are concerned until three years from November 16, 1914, or until November 16, 1917, after which time the entire reserve of a member bank must be partly in its own vaults and partly with the Federal reserve bank of its district. It is thought that during this time there will be a gradual accession to the number of banks assenting to the new clearing plan, and after the fall of 1917 it is not believed that many banks who have customers sending their checks to distant points will fail to become members of the clearing section. As balances with other member banks will then no longer count as reserve, surplus funds will be loaned, rather than kept with other banks to control collections. We ought to look this matter squarely in the face, and should realize that we must give and take, that we could not in any event have ex pected permanently to be able to make a charge of from 15 to 25 cents per hundred on checks sent us for collection, at the same time collecting all of our out-of-town checks without any cost whatever. The banks in the smaller towns will learn, as the city banks have already learned, to make up losses in exchange by add ing to their volume of business, and while at first thought many of you may feel that there is little chance of increasing the volume of business in your own towns, I am sure that as the workings of the Federal Reserve System become better known, and the safeguards it offers are more fully appreciated, that any money now being hoarded in your communities will come into sight and be deposited with you, and with the development of your section your business will expand in a healthy way. You have been given facilities, whether you borrow your money from the Federal Reserve Bank or not, of getting all the rediscounts to which you are entitled at lower rates than ever before. You will soon realize that there is no longer occasion for you to hoard money by carrying abnormally large reserves, and before the new reserve requirements under the act are fully effective I am sure that you will all have found that you can more than recoup your losses in the way of exchange profits by the gains derived through a greater volume of business. What I have just said relates to the clearing of checks between banks in the same Federal reserve district, but the broader question of exchanges between the respective Federal Reserve Banks has also been considered by the Federal Reserve Board. It is proposed to obvi ate as far as possible the necessity for an actual transfer of currency from one Federal reserve district to another, and I think we have seen for the last time the stringency which has been recurring every fall during the active cropmoving period. Member banks will no longer be obliged to undergo the expense of nor to suffer the inconvenience due to delays attached to shipping in currency from the old reserve cities, but their currency requirements will instead be abundantly and quickly supplied at a minimum cost by their Federal Reserve Bank. The money that you will use in handling the crop next fall will consist largely of Federal reserve notes, which will stay in circulation as long as needed, and when the crop movement is over and the notes become redundant they will find their way back to the Federal Reserve Bank, where they will be retired., The abnor mally high rates to which we have become accustomed during the closing months of the 64995— 15------ 2 year will no longer obtain, nor will there be the usual demoralization of rates in the early spring due to the heavy flow of redundant currency into the great financial centers. Your cotton drafts can, if you wish, still continue to take their usual course, and I presume that you will prefer to send them direct in order to avoid delays in transit. You can, however, instruct your correspondent bank to make deposit with the nearest Federal Reserve Bank for the credit of your Federal Reserve Bank for your use, and you can order Federal reserve notes from your own Federal Reserve Bank against such depos its as made. Many years will doubtless elapse before uniform interest rates prevail throughout the country. Under present conditions money will continue to command higher rates in Hous ton, Dallas, and Waco than it will in New York, Chicago, or Boston, but the rates will certainly be stabilized and extreme fluctuations will cease. Section 16 of the Federal reserve act pro vides that— “ The Federal Reserve Board shall make and promulgate from time to time regulations gov erning the transfer of funds and charges there for among Federal Reserve Banks and their branches, and may, at its discretion, exercise the functions of a clearing house for such Fed eral Reserve Banks, or may designate a Federal Reserve Bank to exercise such functions, and may also require each such bank to exercise the functions of a clearing house for its member banks.” The Board has accordingly, after conferences with the Federal reserve agents and the gov ernors of the several Federal Reserve Banks, decided to establish a gold settlement fund, to be carried in the Treasury at Washington, and to which each Federal Reserve Bank shall contribute $1,000,000 in gold, gold certificates, or gold order certificates, in addition to an amount at least equal to the net indebtedness due to all Federal Reserve Banks as of May 24. Each Federal Reserve Bank will be required to keep at all times in this fund a balance of not less than $1,000,000, and this balance will count as a part of its lawful reserve. At the close of business each Wednesday night (or when Wednesday is a holiday, Tuesday night) each Federal Reserve Bank will telegraph to the Federal Reserve Board the amounts, in'even thousands, due to the other Federal Reserve Banks as of that date, and on each Thursday the settling agent of the Federal Reserve Board will make the proper debits and credits in the accounts of each Federal Reserve Bank with the fund, telegraphing each bank the amounts, in even thousands, of credits to its settlement account, giving the names of each bank from whom received, and also giving the net debit or credit balance in the weekly settlement. Proper debits and credits will tnen be made upon the books of each Federal Reserve Bank. In case the debit settlement balance of any Federal Reserve Bank should be in excess of the amount to its credit in the gold settlement fund, such deficiency must be immediately covered either by the deposit of gold, gold certificates, or gold order certificates in the Treasury or any subtreasury, or by credit operations, which term includes rediscounts with other Federal Reserve Banks which have an excess balance in the gold settlement fund. Excess balances may remain in the fund to the credit of the banks to whom they are due, or they may, if desired, be refunded by the return to the reserve bank of gold order certifi cates, properly indorsed, or of gold certifi cates payable to bearer, and, whenever practi cable, payments will be made by the nearest subtreasury. I am violating no confidence when I say that the Federal Reserve Board dosires earnestly to have the State banks become members of the Federal Reserve System. The Board feels that the membership of the State institutions is es sential to the coordinated banking system that it wishes to establish, and realizes that there can be but one credit system of nation-wide extent. It fully appreciates that the strength of the Federal Reserve System must be gauged by the q u a l i t y of its members, rather than by number, and it will use all the broad discre tionary powers vested in it by the Federal re serve act to bring about this coordination. It seeks to establish only such reasonable stand ards of admission as will be generally recog nized as necessary to protect the Federal Re serve System against the admission of banks which would be a source of weakness rather than of strength, and it intends to prescribe only such regulations governing their conduct as members as will insure a reasonable con formity to the fundamental principles deemed essential to the success of the new banking sys tem. The banks of this country are beginning to realize that membership in the Federal Re serve System carries with it privileges and guaranties of great value, not only to them selves but to their customers as well. It is believed that membership in the system will come to be regarded as a test of banking solid ity, and that membership, giving as it does full access to the facilities and resources of the sys tem, will add to the prestige of even the strong est institutions, so that in the course of time the public will, instead of drawing a distinction as heretofore between national banks and State hanks, will distinguish rather between banks which belong to the Federal Reserve System and the banks which do. not belong, so that ulti mately little importance will attach to the terms “ National banks” and “ State banks,” and banks will be classified as “ member banks” or “ nonmember banks.” Section 9 of the Federal reserve act requires that State banks becoming members of the Federal Reserve System must comply with cer tain general requirements which now apply to national banks. The minimum capital per mitted is $25,000, and this requirement as to capital-is raised according to the population of the town in which the bank is located, so that in cities of more than 50,000 inhabitants the minimum capital allowed will be $200,000. State banks becoming members must also con form to the provisions of law governing na tional banks regarding the limitation of liabil ity which may be incurred by any person, firm, or corporation to such banks, the prohi bition of purchases of or loans upon their own stock, the withdrawal or impairment of cap ital, and the payment of unearned dividends. The Board is not disposed to make any hard and fast rules respecting loans upon real estate or mortgages by State banks who wish to be come members. It will seek rather to provide reasonable limitations, so that loans or invest ments of this character will not be so excessive in amount as to endanger the bank’s liquid condition. The important question of examinations has been fully considered by the Board. As ad mission to the system will be regarded as evi dence of a bank’s strength, the Board must necessarily have accurate and reliable informa tion regarding the condition of an applying bank and the character of its management. Examinations must, therefore, be under the direction of the Board, but it will as far as possible avoid imposing additional expense upon a bank by adopting a method of joint or supplementary examination in cooperation with State banking authorities. It will use ex aminers and auditors in the employ of the respective Federal Reserve Banks in supple menting the examinations conducted by the banking departments of the several States, and in .passing upon applications for member ship the Board will appreciate the cooperation of the State banking authorities. The membership of State banking institu tions in the Federal Reserve System differs from that of national banks in being optional, and the Board has felt from the start that the directors of State banks should be given the right to terminate their banks’ membership in case they should deem it advantageous to do so. The Board does not believe that State banks after becoming members will wish to withdraw from the system which offers so many advantages, but at the same time it recognizes the responsibilities attached to the management of the State banks, and having received ample assurances from high legal authorities as to its powers it will, I think, reach the conclusion that the State bank mem bers may, with reasonable limitations as to the maximum withdrawal of capital and reserves during any one year, surrender their member ship should they elect to do so. I am sure that the Board will define its position in this matter clearly within a very short time. Permit me, in closing, to impress upon you all the fact that we are living in a critical period of the world’s history. The sun never sets upon the lands that are sending troops to en gage in the most stupendous conflict of all the ages, and the toll in human lives and in destruc tion of property is enormous. The money cost of this war and the indebtedness of the nations party to it are beyond the comprehension of the average mind. No one can predict the duration of this titanic struggle nor its ultimate out come, nor can we foretell what readjustments of capital must be made between the nations after the restoration of peace. We were able last summer to withstand the shock occasioned by the outbreak of war by putting into circula tion over $300,000,000 of emergency currency, now practically all retired or in process of retire ment. After June 30, however, the law will no longer permit such issues, and such currency expansion as may be necessary in future will be in the form of Federal reserve notes. The Federal Reserve Banks can ultimately provide, even without the State banks as members, an emergency issue more than three times as large as the maximum outstanding last year, but it can extend direct aid to member banks only. Those of you who control the destinies of State banks are earnestly invited to bring your insti tutions under the protecting aegis of the Federal Reserve System, and I confidently believe that in doing so not only will you promote your own interests but you will perform at the same time a patriotic act by adding to the power of the world’s strongest banking system. Form for Discount Rates. That the recommendations in connection with discount rates from the 12 Federal Reserve Banks may be uniform, the Federal Reserve Board has prepared the following form for such recommendations. It is to be forwarded to reach the Board not later than Thursday morn ing of each week: D a te --------- , 1915. Federal R eserve B oard, Washington, D . C. Sir : I have the honor to forward the recommendation that no change be made in the existing discount rates for the Federal Reserve Bank o f --------- for the week ending Thursday--------- , 1915. Respectfully, Federal Reserve Agent. I have the honor to request that the following rates be approved by the Federal Reserve Board for the Federal Reserve Bank o f --------- to become effective Friday morn ing, --------- , 1915: RECOMMENDED RATES. Maturities, in days. 30. 31 to 60. 61 to 90. Agricultural and live-stock paper over 90. Acceptances. PRESENT RATES. Respectfully, Federal Reserve Agent. Acceptances to 100 per cent. Below is given a list of member banks authorized to accept up to 100 per cent of their capital and surplus under circular 12, regulation K : First National Bank, Boston, Mass. National Shawmut Bank, Boston, Mass. American Exchange National Bank, New York City. Merchants Exchange National Bank, New York City. Bank of New York, N. B. A., New York City. Merchants National Bank, Richmond, Va. Commercial National Bank, New Orleans, La. First National Bank, Chicago, 111. Anglo and London Paris National Bank, San Francisco, Cal. Bank of California, N. A., San Francisco, Cal. Crocker National Bank, San Francisco, Cal. First National Bank, San Francisco, Cal. Wells-Fargo Nevada National Bank, San Francisco, Cal. INFORMAL RULINGS OF THE BOARD. • Below are reproduced letters sent out from time to time over the signatures of the offi cers of the Federal Reserve Board, which con tain information believed to be of general interest to Federal Reserve Banks and member banks of the system: Paper o f Financing Companies. In answer to your letter of November 17 and subsequent communication of November 20, you are advised that the question, how to deal with paper issued by finance companies, has been carefully considered and that the Board is of opinion that collateral trust notes of the kind you describe ought not to be ac cepted by Federal Reserve Banks as a basis for discounts. The Board feels that paper of the kind referred to does not afford sufficient evidence of the nature of the transaction which gave rise to it, while the obligation itself presented by one of these finance companies is cer tainly not inherently a commercial one. You are therefore informed that it is not considered desirable to encourage the offering of such paper by member banks. D ecember 18, 1914. Loans for Agricultural Purposes. You are right in supposing that the 25 per cent limit applies only to the proceeds of loans used for agricultural purposes or based on live stock, provided the maturities of these notes ex ceed three months. In other words, the limi tation applies only to paper having maturity in excess of 90 days. As to the question whether notes bearing the indorsement of nonmember banks are eligible for rediscount, you are advised that the matter is one that is now under very careful considera tion for the purpose of establishing general reg ulations regarding the relation of State banks to the new system in various connections. The question you raise as to whether the direct note of a member bank can be redis counted has already been fully covered in other connections, as I believe that we have sent you copies of replies to other Federal reserve agents dealing with this point— the answer being in the negative, i. e., that such direct notes can not be rediscounted. Live stock, the Board thinks, should include not only beef cattle, but horses and mules. January 2, 1915. Agricultural Loan M ortgages. You are advised that in the opinion of the Board the Federal reserve act certainly does not require the taking of chattel mortgages as security for loans based on agricultural opera tions. In the dealings of the Federal Reserve Banks with member banks, the statement of the member bank that the loan is desired for agricultural operations must, under ordinary circumstances at least, necessarily be accepted as to the purpose for which the funds are acquired. So, also, from the standpoint of the member bank itself, it would seem clear that if the act is to be of any real service to the agri cultural community, it would not seem prac ticable to enter into an exhaustive inquiry as to whether any minute part of the loan has been or may be used directly or indirectly for the support of the farmer while preparing the soil for cultivation or for feeding his cattle. It would, on the contrary, seem to be sufficient if the direct primary purpose of the loan is for the purpose of carrying on the ordinary opera tions of agriculture. You further ask wdiether in section 13 of the Federal reserve act, in dealing with six-months’ agricultural paper, the words “ based on ” should be considered synonymous with “ se cured by.” The language of the act is— “ provided that notes, drafts, and bills drawn or issued for agricultural purposes or based on live stock,” etc. The Board does not understand that such agricultural paper must be directly secured by agricultural products. It would seem to be sufficient if they are genuinely based upon transactions entered into for the purposes of agricultural operations. In conclusion, I would state that these questions must be handled with general bank ing prudence, using all the knowledge of local conditions which the directors of the bank must possess. January 9, 1915. Cotton-mill Paper. At a meeting of the Board yesterday Mr. ----------brought up the matter of discounts by your bank, upon the indorsement of member banks, of notes made by cotton mills whose statements do not show an excess of quick as sets over current liabilities. I am authorized and directed by the Board to say that, the new discount regulations were not intended to reverse the ruling previously made by the Board in the matter of discounts of cotton-mill paper by your bank, and your directors are authorized to discount such paper as heretofore where general conditions are sat isfactory, and where the statement of the cot ton mill shows that the plant is not mortgaged, and that the deficiency between capital and plant account does not amount to more than $5 per spindle. F ebruary 11, 1915. which were accepted by the depositor at the time the account was opened under which the depositor may be required by the bank to give notice of intended withdrawal not less than 30 days before the withdrawal is made. The pass book which you inclosed refers to accounts which may be classed as savings accounts, provided that such deposits are not subject to check. If, however, the depositor has the privilege of drawing checks on the account in your interest department, under regulation E issued by the board, your bank will be required to carry full 12 per cent reserve against such accounts. If withdrawals can only be made upon the presentation of pass books, such accounts may be classed as “ time savings accounts” upon which it will be necessary to carry but 5 per cent reserve. F ebruary 4, 1915. Stock Notice to Banks. Tim e Deposits and Savings Accounts. Receipt is acknowledged of your letter of February 2, referring to the interpretation of the term “ Time deposits.” In your letter you quote from Circular No. 6,’ series 1915. In this connection your atten tion is called to regulation E, which was attached to the circular above referred to, and in which the distinction between time deposits, time certificates of deposit, and savings accounts is made clear. All deposits are subject to full reserve except the following: 1. “ Time deposits— open accounts.” This refers to accounts which are subject to check but that under written agreement “ neither the whole or any part of such deposit” may be withdrawn except on a given date on written notice given in advance, in no case less than 30 days. In this connection it will be noted that the date of payment must be fixed before such accounts may be classed as time deposits. 2. “ Time certificates of deposits” refers to those deposits which are evidenced by cer tificates (a) which have a fixed maturity; (6) which are payable after lapse of specified num ber of days; (c) or upon written notice given at least 30 days before the date of repayment. 3. “ Savings accounts.” This item refers to accounts which are evidenced by (a) pass book, certificate of deposit, or similar form of receipt, which must be presented to the bank whenever a deposit or withdrawal is made; and (i ) which accounts are subject to printed regulations It is believed that a system of notifying mem ber banks of the approval of applications for stock which will be more satisfactory to the Federal Reserve Banks can be adopted. It has heretofore been the practice of the Federal Re serve Board to send a notice of call for the pay ment of the first installment of subscription directly to the member bank, and at the same time advising the Federal reserve agent of the district of this action. This system will be more satisfactory to all if the member banks receive notice of the approval of their applica tions for stock directly from the Federal Re serve Banks, and to accomplish this the follow ing procedure will in the future be observed: Under the law new banks can be required to pay one-half of their subscription at the time of taking out stock. Upon the receipt of notice from the Board of the allotment of stock to such banks the Federal reserve agents can notify the banks and require the necessary payments to place them on the same footing as those which originally entered the system, until May 2, 1915, when the third installment is payable, and then require payment in full of the required 3 per cent. The Board has been advised that in the issu ance of additional stock member banks very frequently prefer to pay one-half of their sub scription at the time the stock is issued, thereby avoiding the inconvenience of three small pay ments. Under the law this can not be re quired, but the option should, it would seem, be given. Therefore, upon receipt of notice from the Board of allotment of additional stock, the Federal reserve agents should advise the ap plicant banks and extend to them the option of paying the installment necessary to place it on the same footing as other stock held by them. It is believed if tne foregoing procedure is fol lowed, so *that all stock will be upon the same footing as regards payments, the work of keep ing accounts will be greatly simplified both for the Federal Reserve Banks and tor the Federal Reserve Board. M arch 10, 1915. Adjustment of Stock Ledgers. In order to obviate the necessity for daily adjustment of the stock ledger accounts ana the consequent confusion which results from continuous changes in the stock holdings of member banks occasioned by the increase or decrease of their capital or surplus, you will please request all member banks to file their applications quarterly— that is, on the 1st day of January, Apnl, July, and October of each year— in all cases where additional stock is to be applied for, or where member banks desire to surrender and cancel a part of the stock held. In making applications for additional stock or for surrender of stock, banks should exercise care to see that the blanks are properly filled in, using as a basis the total capital and surplus at the time of their last previous stock allot ment, and stating the total of all increases and decreases in capital or surplus, separately, so that the total at the date o f the prior allotment plus the increases and less the decreases, will equal the total capital and surplus as of date oi application. Those national banks which have increased or decreased their surplus since the last report of condition to the Comptroller of the Currency, should send a certificate to that effect to the Comptroller contemporaneously with filingtheir applications with the Federal Reserve Bank, in order that the records of the Comptroller’s office may be in accord with those of the Federal Reserve Board. In the case of changes in capital, this addi tional certificate will be unnecessary, in view of the fact that the Comptroller’s approval must be obtained prior to any such change, and the records of his office must necessarily conform in such case. M arch 13, 1915. Mortgages Secured by Live Stock. The Federal Reserve Board has received a letter under date of March 9 from Mr. R. L. Van Zandt, in which he asks whether paragraph 3 of Circular No. 3 covers a bill specifically secured by a chattel mortgage on cattle. The Board is of the opmion that there is nothing to require a mortgage on cattle, and that the question whether such paper is selfliquidating when so secured is a matter that can be settled very much better at your bank than here, inasmuch as it is a matter of local usage and custom as to which we have no reliable information. The requirement in the case is merely that the general principles of the regulation referred to Be observed according to the best judgment of the officers in charge. M arch 17,1915. Discount of Renewal Notes. Your letter of March 15 raises a very inter esting question of principle in the operation of a Reserve Bank, to wit, the question whether it is proper for a Reserve Bank to discount a note which is obviously a renewal. Broadly stated, the question can not be answered by an invariable “ yes” or “ no.” A renewal as such is neither “ eligible” nor “ ineligible.” There are good renewals and bad renewals; and it is a matter for banking judgment to determine the merits of each particular case by a knowledge of the circumstances in which both the original loan and the renewal have been made. It is clear that paper successively jm nftw p.d for the, purpose of pjxmding-~a^permanenlL addition to^ wxukiag capital^M^ior-the purpose.of financing jixgd investments is not eligible for rediscount by a Federal Reserve Bank; on the other hand, paper that is_j2Hr questionably, self-liquidating, even though the 'transaction which gives rise to it does not liquidate itself within the limits of a 90-day maturity, might be discounted by a Federal Reserve Bank even though it appeared that it was renewal paper. There are many proc esses of production which take a longer time than 90 days; and while no Federal Reserve Bank should ever enter into an agreement for the renewal of discounted paper, nevertheless in cases where the “ process oi production and distribution ” covers a period longer than 90 days there is no reason why a borrower should not renew his 90-day borrowing; and, in such case, there is no reason why a member bank should not purchase the paper and a Federal Reserve Bank discount it if it is otherwise sat isfactory and at the then prevailing rate. It would be a mistake for a Federal Reserve Bank as a matter of principle to refuse to buy paper based on transactions of this kind. At the same time they must be counseled to exercise great care in scrutinizing the paper and trans actions that have given rise to it, in order to determine whether it is of the character above described as legitimate and notjusefLaa^a.scre^u for financing fixed.invesfm pn ts or for the pur pose of providing additional working capital. As the circulars and regulations of the Federal Reserve Board have undertaken to state the fundamental principle, it is the liquidity of the paper that must be looked to to determine its eligibility, and liquidity should not be tested by standards that are too narrow, arbitrary, or inflexible. Such mechanical rules must not be allowed to take the place of a discriminating banking judgment. A p r i l 27, 1915. reserve agent. It is, however, permitted under the terms of the Federal reserve act to carry part of its required reserve with approved re serve agents; but this is optional with a bank and not mandatory upon it. I quote the fol lowing from an opinion of counsel of the Federal Reserve Board: “ If the laws of South Carolina permit or re quire State banks to carry a part of their re serve with national banks, reserve so carried in accordance with the State law may be counted as reserve under the Federal reserve act, and it is unnecessary for the State bank to have such national bank approved as its reserve agent unless the laws o f South Carolina so re quire. If the laws of South Carolina do not permit or require State banks to carry a part of their reserve with national banks a State bank might, under the previous paragraphs of section 19, have a national bank in a reserve or central reserve city approved as its reserve agent and balances carried with such approved reserve agent might be counted as reserve under the Federal reserve act, but might not be treated as reserve by the State authorities. “ It, therefore, seems unnecessary for a State Undivided Interests as Security. bank to have a national bank approved as its In answer to your letter of May 3, relative to reserve agent unless the laws of the State in a loan secured by a mortgage upon one share which it is incorporated make this requirement.” May 15, 1915. of an undivided interest in a piece of farm property, you are advised that the Board agrees with the views you have expressed. — j The mortgage on such share of an undivided N otes for Commercial Fertilizer. interest would be very hard to reduce to One of the Georgia member banks has made possession in case it should become necessary to the Federal Reserve Board the following to sell out the collateral, and moreover, the suggestion: question would have to be investigated pretty I learn that the Reserve Board has under carefully whether the remaining nine-tenths consideration the question of admitting to of the holders could not mortgage the property, rediscount notes given by farmers for com provided that as we take it, it is now un mercial fertilizer, and having more than three encumbered. but less than six months to run. These cases must, of course, be judged on I want to suggest that unless a note given their own merits, but looking at the question by a farmer for commercial fertilizer, to be used merely as a matter of principle, as it is brought under his growing crop, constitutes an agri before the Board, to lend on this type of paper cultural paper under the terms of the reserve does not appear to be advisable. bank act, I can not understand what character May 7, 1915. of paper would come under such description. Below is the decision of the Board in the matter: Approved Reserve Agents. I inclose you a copy of a letter with the sug Replying to your letter of April 20 as to gestion that you transmit to the writer a reply whether or not it is necessary for State banks indicating that the Board’s feeling is that a which are members of a Federal reserve bank farmer’s six-months’ note of the kind herein to have approved reserve agents, I beg to ad referred to, discounted and indorsed by a vise you that there is nothing in the Federal member bank, is to be regarded as agricultural reserve act which requires a member bank to paper eligible for rediscount by Federal Re carry any part of its reserves with an approved serve Banks. j IMPORTS AND EXPORTS OF GOLD. The Federal Reserve Board since January 1 of the present year has been in receipt of weekly telegraphic reports from collectors of customs showing the imports and exports of gold ore, bullion, and coin. The tables below show the totals, for the 17 weeks from January 1 to April 30 (brought into accord with the figures of the Bureau of Foreign and Domestic Commerce), and in addition for each of the three weeks during the month of May, for which telegraphic advices have been received. Of the total of about 79.5 million dollars of gold imported into this country during the first 20 weeks of the present year, 39.5 millions are shown to have come by way of Ogdensburg (St. Lawrence district), 18.7 millions via New York, and 14.5 millions by way of San Francisco, the imports through these three gateways consti tuting almost 92 per cent of the total gold imports into this country. Comparisons with previous years are possible only for the first four months of the year. The Bureau of Foreign and Domestic Com merce gives the total gold imports during January-April, 1915, as 61.4 million dollars, compared with 25.0 million dollars during the same period in 1914 and 19.9 million dollars in 1913. Over 60 per cent (37.7 million dollars) of the imported gold came from Canada, about 5.6 millions from European countries, 5.5 millions from Japan, 5.1 millions from China, and 3.3 millions from Mexico. The exports of gold during the first 20 weeks of the present year are shown to have been less than 4.5 million dollars in value, almost 95 per cent leaving the country via New York. Gold exports for the first 4 months of the present year totaled less than 3.5 million dollars, com pared with 19.0 million dollars exported during the corresponding period in 1914 and 50.7 million dollars in 1913. Practically all the 1gold exported was consigned to Central |America, the West Indies, and South American ! countries, over two-thirds of the total gold ] exports going to Cuba. Imports o f gold, by customs districts, Jan. 1 to May 21,1915. 50 10,582 1 50 28 3 2 !........ 1 524 1,591 1,343 524 65 162 65 50 192 26 350 358 22 2,282 50 192 26 3,012 55 149 54 80 184 1,952 31,210 495 3 33,657 3 56 640 498 538 === == 56 1 640 !......... 2,246 20 2,430 •••. I 5 ! 3 .... 1 81 4 81 ___ 55 7 42 146 56 . . . 1 311 1,099 490 ! 6,256 . . . . 21 ....j 8,224 1,484 368 6 1,744 457 1,155 490 1,858 1,753 14,543 7 153 ___ 80 9 80 54 660 1 660 39.520 | 251 984 2,501 504 4,240 10,835 5,223 2,592 36,433 495 61,446 272 251 10,257 55 5,223 1 8 ...J 3,566 13,896 34,333 9,651 1,297 | 1,338 80 288 5 6 , i............ 82 80 40 30 . 3 ;= — -= ■ 73 1 6 20 1 14 93 Total. | Vermont. 1 St. Lawrence. Michigan. Dakota. i ----------- 1 7 Buffalo. 11,494 Alaska. 7 Washington. ! 1 El Paso. 42 5,951 21 5,480 1 Southern Cali fornia. 1 1 141 ! 45 I 42 ' 289 .1,082 490 1 7 , 10 .......i......... 1 ......... 24 141 j 334 1,124 490 Ore and base bullion............. 2 15 3 Bullion, refined......................,......... 219 United States coin.................!......... 2,501 Foreign coin_______________!_____ 6 1 Total............................. 1 3 15 2,728 = For week ending Mag 14 . Ore and base bullion............. 3 Bullion, refined......................I......... 140 United States coin........................... 22 Foreign coin........................... .......... 36 Total............................. | 3 198 For week ending May 2 t Ore and base bullion............. 9 Bullion, refined...................... 167 United States coin................. 5,030 Foreign coin........................... i 50 i Total............................. 50 5,211 ja n . 1 to May %i. 1 1 60 1 Ore and base bullion............. 159 Bullion, refined...................... ........ |4,363 10 ____ 110.633 "*i"! United States coin................. A! Foreign coin........................... 100 i 3,663 — j 10 1 Total............................. 1 100 |18,719 27 159 1 Arizona. 1 j j 49 3,837 3,080 3,616 San Francisco. Jan. 1 to Apr. SO . 1 Ore and base bullion............. Bullion, refined____________ United States coin........................... Foreign coin_______________1 _____ Total............................. I 1 F/m C lwfnrfi/nn \rn*i /• 1 jr Vi W C C illy J M 7 T ivil jfJ y 1 1 Porto Rico. i l l !a* 1 Florida. | New York. I f Maryland. ■ I§ New Orleans. j i i j [In thousands of dollars.] 3 4,439 15,489 47,112 12,439 3I 79,533 Exports of gold, by customs districts, Jan. 1 to May 21, 1915. [In thousands of dollars.! Maine and San New Hawaii. New Alaska. Fran Hamp York. cisco. shire. Du luth and Su perior. Michi Wash ington. Buffalo. gan. St. Law rence. Ver mont. 4 2 4 6 119 7 32 2,385 940 10 6 3,483 Total. Jan . 1 to A p r . SO. 1 118 2 2 31 3 17 3 5 1 151 28 1 U nited States mint, nr assav office bars...................... 2 2,328 935 Total ............................................. 2 14 3,263 14 646 United States coin......................................... .................... ........................ 1 1 1 2 4 Foreign coin 3 4 1 F or week ending M ay 7. United States coin......................................... 648 F or week ending M ay 14 . 175 2 132 10 132 United States coin.......................................... 10 177 F or week ending M ay 21. 1 United States mint or assay office bars....... United States coin......................................... Total ............................................. 1 142 1 143 ' Jan . 1 to M a y 21. Ore and base bullion..................................... United States mint or assay office bars........ "Bullion refined .......................................... U nited States coin _ Foreign coin Total 1 3,281 935 .................................. ......................... ................................................ 2 16 2 16 4,216 118 2 2 3 17 1 16 3 31 3 5 151 28 1 119 8 6 4 1 16 5 2 1 11 32 3,352 940 6 4,451 Standing Committees, Federal Reserve Board. (1) Committee on Federal Reserve Board Organization and Expenditures. Mr. D elano, Chairman; Mr. H arding, Mr. Miller. (a) Subcommittee, Organization and Staff: Mr. Delano, Mr. Harding. (b) Subcommittee, Budget and Expenditures: Mr. Delano, Mr. Miller. (2) Committee on Audit and Examination. Mr. W illiams, Chairman; Mr. D elano, Mr. W arburg. (3) Committee on Operation o f Federal Reserve Banks. Mr. H amlin, Chairman; Mr. W arburg, Mr. H arding, Mr. Delano, Mr. Miller. (a) Subcommittee on Operation: Mr. Hamlin, Mr. Warburg, Mr. Harding, Mr. Miller,Mr. Delano. (b) Subcommittee on Discount Operations: Mr. Warburg, Mr. Delano, Mr. Harding, Mr. Miller. (4) Committee on Reports and Statistics. Mr. Miller, Chairman; Mr. D elano, Mr. W illiams. (5) Committee on Legal Matters. Mr. H amlin, Chairman; Mr. W arburg, Mr. H arding. (6) Committee on Admission o f State Banks. Mr. H arding, Chairman; Mr. W illiams, Mr. W ar burg. 94995— 15------3 * (7) Committee on Issue and Redemption. Mr. D elano, Chairman; Mr. W illiams, Mr. Miller. (8) Executive Committee. The Governor, the V ice Governor, Mr. W arburg. Government Rate for Official Telegrams. Both the Postal Telegraph Cable Co. and the Western Union Telegraph Co. will accept telegrams from Federal reserve agents when they relate to the official business of the Fed eral Reserve Board. Such telegrams should be indorsed “ Official business, Government rate, charge Federal Reserve Board.” Messages from Federal Reserve Banks will be accepted by the telegraph companies at Government rates when indorsed “ Official business, Government rate, collect.” Such messages will be billed to the Federal Reserve Board at Washington, D. C. CIRCULARS AND REGULATIONS. The circular and regulation given below were issued by the Board on May 8. CIRCULAR N O . 13, SERIES OF 1915. W a s h in g t o n , May 8,1915, CLEARINGS BETWEEN FEDERAL RESERVE BANES. Section 16 of the Federal reserve act authorizes the Federal Reserve Board, at its discretion, to exercise the functions of a clearing house for the Federal Reserve Banks. Pursuant to the authority of this section the Federal Reserve Board has dev'sed a plan for the establishment of a gold fund for the weekly settlement of balances arising out of transactions among the 12 Federal Reserve Banks, to be operated under the direction of the Federal Reserve Board with the cooperation of the Treasury Department. The regulation governing the establishment and opera tion of this fund is issued herewith. REGULATION L, SERIES OF 1915. W a s h in g t o n , May 8, 1915. CLEARINGS BETWEEN FEDERAL RESERVE BANKS. I. Statutory provisions under section 16. “ The Federal Reserve Board shall make and promul gate from time to time regulations governing the transfer of funds and charges therefor among Federal Reserve Banks and their branches, and may at its discretion exer cise the functions of a clearing house for such Federal Reserve Banks, or may designate a Federal Reserve Bank to exercise such functions, and may also require each such bank to exercise the functions of a clearing house for its member banks.” II. General provisions. In the exercise of the functions of the clearing house authorized under the provisions of section 16, quoted above, the Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Re serve Banks will be governed by and subject to the fol lowing regulations and the Federal Reserve Board will be the custodian of the funds hereinafter termed the “ gold settlement fund.’ ’ The Board will appoint a settling agent, who shall keep the necessary records and accounts. certificates, and, in addition, an amount at least equal to its net indebtedness due to all Federal Reserve Banks. (h) The Treasurer of the United States or Assistant Treasurer will, in accordance with arrangements made with the Treasury Department, advise the Federal Reserve Board, by mail or telegraph, of the receipt of all funds deposited on account of the gold settlement fund, and the Treasurer will issue and deliver to the Federal Reserve Board gold order certificates made “ payable to the order of the Federal Reserve Board” covering the sum so deposited. (c) Each Federal Reserve Bank shall maintain a balance in the gold settlement fund of not less than $1,000,000. (d) Excess balances may, at the convenience of each Federal Reserve Bank, remain deposited with the gold settlement fund. IV. Custody o f funds. (a) A safe in the Treasury vault will be set apart for the exclusive use of the Federal Reserve Board. (b) To open the Treasury vault, the presence of two per sons designated by the Secretary of the Treasury is required. The combination of the safe-set apart for the use of the Board will be controlled by two persons desig nated by the Board. (c) A vault record shall be kept, giving a memorandum of all entrances to the safe, by whom made, for what pur pose, and the certificates deposited or withdrawn. Each entry on the vault record book shall be signed by the persons having access to the safe. V. Accounts. In its relations with other Federal Reserve Banks each Federal Reserve Bank shall keep an account showing balances “ due t o ” other Federal Reserve Banks repre senting the proceeds of items which it has actually col lected, and payments and transfers which have been made to it for the account of such other Federal Reserve Banks; and an account showing balances “ due from ” other Fed eral Reserve Banks representing the proceeds of items which it has sent to such other Federal Reserve Banks, and payments and transfers which have been made to such other Federal Reserve Banks for it account. V I. Procedure. (a) At the close of business each Wednesday night, each Federal Reserve Bank shall telegraph to the Federal Reserve Board, confirming such telegram by mail, the amounts in even thousands due to each other Federal III. Deposits in the gold settlement fund. Reserve Bank as of that date, as indicated by its “ due to ” (a) Each Federal Reser\e Bank shall, not later than account provided for in Rule V. If Wednesday is a May 24, 1915, forward to the Treasury or the nearest sub- holiday in the State in which a Federal Reserve Bank is treasury, for credit to the account of the gold settlement located, then such bank shall telegraph as herein provided fund, $1,000,000 in gold, gold certificates, or gold order on Tuesday, at the close of business. (6) The settling agent shall, on each Thursday, make to ship from one point to another in order to have the gold the proper debits and credits in the accounts of each or gold certificates available at the sub treasury to which Federal Reserve Bank with the gold settlement fund, such gold order certificates are presented, the Federal and shall telegraph to each bank the amounts, in even Reserve Board will, for the account of the gold settlement thousands, of credits to its settlement account, giving the fund, refund any expense incurred by the Treasury in name of each Federal Reserve Bank from which each of making such shipments. its credits was received and also its net debit or credit IX . Reserve. balance in the weekly settlement. (c) Each Federal Reserve Bank shall, on receipt of the Each Federal Reserve Bank shall count as a part of its telegram from the settling agent, debit the “ due to ” legal reserve the funds standing to the credit of its account Federal Reserve Banks’ accounts, and shall credit the on the books of the gold settlement fund. gold settlement fund; and shall credit the “ due from ” Federal Reserve Banks’ accounts and charge the gold X . Expenses. settlement fund. The difference between the total debits and credits shall equal the net debit or credit to the gold Cost of operation of and shipment of currency by the settlement fund, as advised in the telegram from the gold settlement fund shall be apportioned b y a semiannual settling agent. accounting among the 12 Federal Reserve Banks on a basis V II. Deficits. to be hereafter determined b y the Board after consultation with the Federal Reserve Banks. (a) Should the debit settlement balance of any Federal Reserve Bank be in excess of the amount of its credit in X I . Audit. the gold settlement fund, such deficit must be immediately A t least once in each three months an audit shall be made covered either b y the deposit of gold, gold certificates, or gold order certificates in the Treasury or nearest sub of the gold settlement fund b y a representative of the ' treasury, or by credit operations with other Federal Federal Reserve Board and a representative appointed Reserve Banks which have an excess balance with the b y the Federal Reserve Banks. gold settlement fund. Any delay in covering such deficit shall be subject to such charge as the Federal Reserve Board may impose. (b) As required in III (c) of this regulation, each Federal Reserve Bank shall maintain a balance in the gold settle ment fund of not less than $1,000,000. Should the credit balance of any Federal Reserve Bank in such fund fall below $1,000,000, such bank shall restore its balance to that amount in either manner indicated under V II (a) of this regulation on or before Tuesday of the following week. V III. Excess balances. Any excess balance shall, on request, either by telegraph or letter, of the Federal Reserve Bank to which it is due, be refunded by the return to the Reserve Bank of the gold order certificates held by the gold settlement fund, properly indorsed, or b y the indorsement and delivery to the Treasurer of a like amount of such certificates, for which he will give in exchange bearer gold certificates, which the Federal Reserve Board may send by registered mail, insured, to the banks, if they want funds other than gold order certificates, or in lieu of such payment, the Treasurer may by wire or mail direct payment to be made by a subtreasury office through the medium of the general account, provided funds are held in such office available for the purpose. Gold order certificates will, when pre sented at the office of the Treasurer of the United States or any sub treasury, bearing the signatures of duly author ized officers of the Federal Reserve Bank, be payable in gold or gold certificates. If the Treasury finds it necessary X II. The Federal Reserve Board reserves the right to add to, alter, or amend these regulations. Aldrich-Vreeland Currency Outstanding. There was on May 20 Aldrich-Vreeland cur rency outstanding to the amount of $3,539,600.78. States in which the currency is held, with the amounts, are as follows: Alabama.......... California........ Florida............ Iowa................. Kentucky....... Louisiana........ Missouri........... New Jersey___ New M exico... North Carolina, Pennsylvania.. South Carolina Tennessee....... Texas............... Wisconsin........ Total $214, 250.00 361.140.00 264, 000.00 433.150.00 25, 000.00 245, 450.00 30, 000.00 35, 000.00 85, 950.00 72, 500. 00 413, 872. 98 308, 787.80 150, 000.00 875, 500.00 25, 000.00 3, 539, 600. 78 DISTRIBUTION OF ALDRICH-VREELAND CURRENCY. (Compiled by the Comptroller of the Currency.) Aldrich- Vreeland Act circulation approved, classified as to kind o f security— Original applications. Portions secured b y - States. Maine................... New Hampshire.. Vermont.............. Massachusetts.... Rhode Island...... Connecticut......... Total New England States. New Y e tk ......... . New York City., New Jersey............... Pennsylvania. Delaware....................... Maryland....................... District of Columbia___ Total Eastern States.. Virginia............ West Virginia . . North Carolina. South Carolina. Georgia............. Florida.............. Alabama........... Mississippi........ Louisiana.......... Texas................ Arkansas........... Kentucky......... Tennessee......... Total Southern States. Ohio......... Indiana___ Illinois. . . . Michigan... Wisconsin. Minnesota. Iowa......... Missouri... Total Middle States. North Dakota. South Dakota. Nebraska......... Kansas............ Montana......... Wyoming........ Colorado......... New Mexico... Oklahoma....... Total Western States. Washington. Oregon......... California___ Idaho........... Utah............ Nevada........ Arizona........ Alaska......... Circulation approved. State and Per Per Miscellaneous Per cent. county bonds. cent. securities. cent. 9352,000 986,500 9175,500 990,000 *3,’ 338,*266' i2,324,050 *i3‘ 6i2,*256 Warehouse receipts. Per cent. 27 ’ 28,’ 674’ 506' 4 6 49 **” 645*666' ” * 606,’ 666' 30,277,500 3,424,700 13,144,550 12,708,250 11,564,000 144,975,960 1,980,000 24,451,730 1,408,230 24,458,176 854,000 944,845 5,088,050 55,294,153 810,000 13,351,905 5,067,720 65,223,631 316.000 10,155,000 *’i* 4 * 6 ' 4 67 6 **5,*i6i,'i6o' ” i*25i'666' ” *M 6i,oo6' 637,000 268,000 364.000 191,777,710 29,297,451 15 76,252,808 40 86,227,451 45 6.458.100 323.000 4,037,450 3,285,380 6,289,625 1,368,500 4.662.400 1.572.000 4.155.000 18,136,300 624.000 5.150.400 4.968.100 937,950 14 708,100 12 2 732,600 410,750 41,625 69,350 6,200 10,500 181,000 129,000 414,750 346,0.50 43,750 1,214,200 607,200 72 100 57 79 87 58 75 37 69 91 74 63 80 $105,000 1,166,565 111,900 355.000 296.000 892,650 838,125 518,765 1,068,950 4,707,050 323,000 2,315,535 2,596,230 5.478.650 778.875 3,486,150 580.875 2,830,485 16,477,200 464,250 3,203,600 3.943.650 513,725 507,900 449,775 283,125 102,600 24,000 391,000 244,100 116,000 13 16 8 21 2 2 9 1 19 61,030,255 7,329,255 3,771,725 47,185,550 80 2,743,725 16.984.500 719,500 27.825.000 2.414.000 4.864.000 12.416.500 3,018,400 13.173.000 3.669.000 121,334 5,114,500 1.310.000 720,100 737.500 143.500 448,000 1,965,600 225.000 3,996,500 11,349,900 373,166 18.714.000 1.098.000 2.948.000 5.874.000 2,829,900 12.163.000 81,414,900 12,263,934 13,801,000 6,000 1,195,900 5,805,000 45,000 562.000 16 150,000 6,500 55,349,966 150,000 2,083,000 842,000 54.000 63.000 1,395,000 297,500 1,313,700 *ii9 6 ' ,’6 6 6,081,200 561,875 772,900 530,000 2,053,000 13,110,250 245.000 895,904 212.000 23 746,700 12 92 322,425 297,500 1,146,500 10,000 100 2,029,000 769,000 ” i 6*206' 325,875 23 100 88 32,000 4,714,425 80 32,000 285,000 1,157,096 11,711,500 1,186,750 127,500 127,500 ” 4i*906' 41,900 Total Pacific States.. 15,862,650 1,352,904 Total United States. 386,444,215 54,230,119 Commercial Per cent. paper. 13,281,096 1,228,650 14 109,386,633 100 100 28 220,466,678 5* 7 2,360,785 Aldrich- Vreeland Act circulation approved., by States and reserve cities. States. Total Banks num receiv ing ber of circu banks. lation. By States. Connecticut.. .................... 69 56 48 172 19 76 Total Northeastern States..................... 440 63 30,277,500 New York City................... New York........................... New Jersey......................... Pennsylvania...................... Delaware..... ....................... Maryland............................. District of Columbia.......... 38 441 202 837 25 101 13 32 39 7 54 144,975,960 11,564,000 1,980,000 24,451,750 18 12 8,169,000 637,000 Total Eastern States..................... 1,657 162 191,777,710 Virginia............................... West Virginia..................... North Carolina................... South Carolina.................... Georgia................................ Florida................................ Alabama............................. Mississippi........................... Louisiana............................ Texas................................... Arkansas............................. Kentucky........................... Tennessee............................ 135 118 75 55 114 53 90 38 32 519 58 142 116 40 3 48 52 79 13 65 18 19 353 8 41 40 6,458,100 323,000 4,037,450 3,285,380 6,289,625 1,368,500 4,662,400 1.572.000 4.155.000 18,136,300 624,000 5,150,400 4,968,100 Total S o u t h e r n States..................... 1,545 779 61,030,255 Maine.................................. Vermont _ ............ Massachusetts..................... 6 $352,000 47 28,674,500 10 1,251,000 By reserve cities. States. Ohio.................................... Indiana............................... Illinois................................. $24,944,500 , Michigan............................. Wisconsin........................... Minnesota........................... Iowa.................................... Missouri.............................. 24,944,500 Total Middle States.. 144,975,960 3,045,000 North Dakota..................... South Dakota ................... 21,957,750 Nebraska............................ Kansas...................... .......... 7,888,000 Montana.............................. 637,000 Wyoming............................ Colorado.............................. New M exico....................... 178,503,710 Oklahoma........................... 3,271,000 3,150,000 2.370.000 6.349.000 2,947,000 Total Banks num receiv ing ber of circu banks. lation. By reserve cities. 377 254 465 100 131 274 343 130 57 9 20 7 16 18 56 24 $16,984,500 719,500 27,825,000 2.414.000 4.864.000 12,416,500 3,018,400 13,173,000 $11,834,000 2,074 207 81,414,900 71,037,000 149 106 220 213 61 32 125 38 346 1 150,000 12 13 2,083,000 842,000 1,994,000 469,500 5 7 52 i, 395,000 297,500 1,313,700 1,395,000 90 6,081,200 4,041,000 530,000 2,053,000 13,110,250 490,000 1,770,000 10,435,000 27.070.000 1.926.000 3.960.000 11.861.000 1.410.000 12,976,000 182,500 Total Western States. . . 1,290 Washington........................ Oregon................................ California............................ Idaho................................... Utah................................... Nevada................................ Arizona............................... Alaska................................. 78 84 262 55 23 10 13 2 2 9 48; 2 1 41,900 62 15,862,650 12,695,000 1,363 386,444,215 309,308,210 Total Pacific States.. 527 Hawaii............................... 18,087,000 By States. 5 Total United States.. 7,538 127,500 Gold Settlement Fund. The operation of the gold settlement fund in Washington became an actuality with set tlements between the twelve Federal Reserve Banks made on Thursday, May 27. At this time the gold deposits, as represented by receipts from the Treasurer of the United States for the fund, were $18,450,000. Earlier in the month the Federal Reserve Board had sent out to the twelve banks the following letter: The Board herewith encloses a regulation concerning the operation of the gold settle ment fund, and also instructions containing a list of dates on which the various steps are to be taken leading up to the establishment and the beginning of the operations of this fund. The question of transfers between Federal Reserve Banks has been fully discussed with a committee of governors on “ clearings” and the report of that committee, dated May 6, 1915, isnereto appended. The Board is in accord with the prmciples and recommendations con tained in this report and suggests that each bank proceed promptly to prepare the nec essary schedules and whatever instructions may be thought appropriate for its own member banks. Forms to be used for the transfers are in course of preparation by the above-named committee ana will be transmitted to you in due course. Inclosed, herewith, is a revised time schedule regulating the time allowance to be applied in crediting or debiting accounts in connection with transfers between member banks. The documents referred to in the letter follow :— Instructions to Federal Reserve Banks rela tive to the establishment of the gold settlement fund: (1) At close of business Wednesday, May 19, 1915, each Federal Reserve Bank will telegraph to the Federal Reserve Board the amounts in even thousands due to each other Federal Reserve Bank as of that date. (2) Thursday, May 20, settling agent will telegraph to each bank the amounts of credits to its settlement account, giving the name of each bank from which such credits were re ceived, also net debit or credit balance in settlement. A confirmation will be sent bv mail. (3) Each bank will be expected to forward to the nearest subtreasury not later than Mon day, May 24, 1915, in gold, gold certificates, or fold order certificates properly indorsed, at east $1,000,000, and in addition an amount equal to its net debit balance as telegraphed by the settling agent. Transfers of gold or gold certificates should be credited to the ac count of “ Gold bullion and U. S. coin” and “ U. S.jgold certificates,” and charged to the item “ Gold settlement fund” on the books of the Federal Reserve Banks. (4) As soon as all transfers have been effected each Federal Reserve Bank will be advised by telegraph, at which time the transfer entries should be made on the books of the bank. Each Federal Reserve Bank will then debit the due to Federal Reserve Banks’ accounts and credit the settlement fund, and will credit the due from Federal Reserve Banks’ accounts and charge the settlement fund. (5) The second settlement will be made on May 27 and figures telegraphed as at close of business on May 26, and at weekly intervals thereafter. { May 8, 1915. REPORT OF THE COMMITTEE OF GOVERNORS. W a s h i n g t o n , D . C ., May 6, 1915. To the Federal Reserve Board: The committee of governors, appointed to consider collection matters, believes that, in the interest of sound banking practice, trans fers of funds by member banks through the Federal Reserve Banks should be encouraged, and that it will both induce and facilitate such transfers if standard forms be prepared by all the Federal Reserve Banks and distributed among their members for general use. They recommend that such forms be prepared, and, if desired, suggestions for these forms will be submitted by the committee.1 The committee on clearing further recom mends that no stated charge be fixed for inter district mail transfers to be made by Federal Reserve Banks for their members, but that, inasmuch as conditions vary greatly in the several districts, and will fluctuate with the seasons, each Federal Reserve Bank be allowed to arrange its own schedule of charges to be based upon the cost of the service rendered, and adequate to protect it in its dealings with its members. The cost of such transfers should i A joint committee of the Board and the Federal Reserve Banks has since prepared a set of forms which will be sent out shortly. not exceed the expense of shipping currency to the nearest subtreasury city. It further recommends that a protective charge is advisable upon all telegraphic trans fers for members, and that such charge, when made, shall include cost of telegraphing and the interest on the sum transferred at a minimum rate of 2 per cent, for the time required by a Reserve Bank to make the transfer by mail in accordance with the schedule hereto annexed. Whenever a charge for mail transfers is im posed, the protective charge for telegraphic transfer shall be in addition thereto. (Signed) district n o . First National Bank, Anniston, Ala. LaGrange National Bank, LaGrange, Ga. National City Bank, Mobile, Ala. district n o . Chairman. 7. Rockford National Bank, Rockford, 111. Farmers National Bank, Valparaiso, Ind. district n o . 8. Henderson National Bank, Henderson, K y. Morganfield National Bank, Morganfield, Ky. Citizens National Bank, Tell City, Ind. district n o . J. B. M cD ougal , 6. 10. Colorado National Bank, Denver, Colo. New England National Bank, Kansas City, Mo. Average time (in days) to destination between Federal Re serve Banks. Trustee. ‘ ii* i l •2* ‘ 12 2 *2* 12 1 2 ” 2 12 2 2 2 2 2 12 2 12 2 2 2 13 3 3 2 6 5 6 5 3 2 2 2 2 2 1 1 2 3 3 3 3 3 2 2 2 3 2 12* 4 *4 San Francisco. 2 2 3 2 2 2 2 2 2 i l 12 2 2 2 2 12 12 2 il 1 i*i‘ 2 il ” 2 il il "2 12 12 3 14 14 4 [ Dallas. Kansas City. 3 2 2 2 2 St. Louis. Atlanta. 2 1 1 2 Chicago. 2 2 1 Minneapolis. il U Richmond. Philadelphia. il il ‘i i ’ U 12 12 12 i l 13 12 12 12 12 12 13 12 13 12 13 13 6 16 Cleveland. B oston................ New York.......... Philadelphia....... Cleveland............ Richmond.......... Atlanta............... Chicago............... St. L o u is............ Minneapolis....... Kansas City....... Dallas................. San Francisco... New York. Boston. district n o . 6 6 6 6 6 6 4 4 4 4 4 .... i Indicates that items on the point at the top of the column may, at the option of the Federal Reserve Bank, be taken for immediate credit at par or at the market rate of exchange. Trustee Powers. Applications from the following banks for permission to act under section 11 (k) of the Federal reserve act have been approved since the May issue of this Bulletin, as follows: Trustee, executor, administrator, and registrar o f stocks and bonds. DISTRICT NO. 1. Merchants National Bank, New Haven, Conn. National Tradesmens Bank, New Haven, Conn. Massasoit-Pocasset Bank, Fall River, Mass. Peoples National Bank, Marlborough, Mass. Mechanics National Bank, New Bedford, Mass. Agricultural National Bank, Pittsfield, Mass. Peoples National Bank, Brattleboro, Vt. Citizens National Bank, Poultney, Vt. district n o . 5. Peoples National Bank, Charleston, S. C. National Bank of Charlottesville, Charlottesville, Va. Citizens National Bank, Covington, Va. 1. Old Lowell National Bank, Lowell, Mass. district n o . 6. Colquitt National Bank, Colquitt, Ga. (Trustee for sinking fund of City of Colquitt, Ga.) Trustee, executor, and administrator. DISTRICT NO. 1. Indian Head National Bank, Nashua, N. H. district n o . 6. First National Bank, Quitman, Ga. district n o . 7. First National Bank, Boyne City, Mich. district n o . 8. Nokomis National Bank, Nokomis, 111. Registrar o f stocks and bonds. district n o . 2. First National Bank, Albany, N. Y . Nassau National Bank, Brooklyn, N. Y. Bank of New York, N. B. A., New York City. Chase National Bank, New York City. First National Bank, Saratoga Springs, N. Y. National Newark Banking Co., Newark, N. J. Trustee and registrar o f stocks and bonds. DISTRICT NO. 4. Huntington National Bank, Columbus, Ohio. Trustee and executor. DISTRICT NO. 11. First National Bank, Bonham, Tex. First National Bank, Granger, Tex. Trustee, executor, and registrar o f stocks and bonds. DISTRICT NO. 11. First National Bank, Mexia, Tex. ACCEPTANCES. Acceptances, by classes, held by the Federal reserve banks each week. Member banks' accept ances. Date. 1915. May 3.............................. . ............................................................................................... $5,038,000 May 10................................................................................................ ........................... 5.226.000 May 1 7 . . . . . . . . : . . . . ...................................................................................................... 5.784.000 May 24.............................................................................................................. 5.144.000 Nonmember banks' acceptances. Private bankers. Trust companies. Total. $110,000 110,000 110,000 110,000 $13,347,000 10.713.000 11.485.000 9,286,000 State banks. $10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000 $8,189,000 5.367.000 5.601.000 4.022.000 Acceptances indorsed by member banks: Member bank acceptances, $596,000; trust company acceptances, $52,000; total, 1648,000. Amount. Total. Number of pieces. * Amount. Number of pieces. Amount. Number of pieces. Over $50,000 Over $100,000. to $100,000. Member banks........................... Trust companies.................... '.. State banks................................ Private banks.................... *.___ 45 61 Grand total...................... 106 Per cent of total............... $173,174 ‘ 62 208,135 88 2 $494,054 137 $2,272,041 638,933 119 2,188,451 l 10,046 20,000 6 89,896 381,309| 152 1.152,987 263 4,560,434 3.32;r... 1 10.04 1 Amount. Number of 1 pieces. | Over $25,000 to $50,000. 1 Amount. Amount. Over $10,000 to $2o,000. Number of pieces. Over $5,000 to $10,000. Number of pieces. Amount. Class of acceptors. Number of pieces. To $5,000. 44 $1,619,468 35 1,296,196 11 13 $943,172 962,064 2 2 1 1 V * 79|2,915,664 $272,000 301 $5,773,909 298,130 318 5,591,909 1 10,046 s 109,896 24 1,905,236 4 Per cent of total. Distribution o f acceptances held by Federal reserve banks, as per schedules received by (he Federal Reserve Board, on May 17 , 1915, by classes o f acceptors and sizes. 570,130 628 11,485,760 39.70 ....[ 25.39 . . . J 16.59 4.96 50. 27 48.68 .09 .96 100.00 Amounts o f acceptances held by the several Federal reserve banks at close o f business on the following Fridays: Apr. SO, May 7, May 14, and May 21, 1915. [In thousands of dollars.] THE REDISTRICTING DECISION. Shortly after its organization, the" Federal Reserve Board received petitions from banks located in several of the Federal reserve dis tricts, asking the transfer of designated por tions thereof to other districts. These peti tions were filed under section 1 of the Federal reserve act, which provides for an appeal from the decision of the Organization Committee to the Board, in the following language: As soon as practicable * * * the Re serve Bank Organization Committee shall desig nate not less than eight nor more than twelve cities to be known as Federal reserve cities, and shall divide the continental United States, excluding Alaska, into districts, each district to contain only one of such Federal reserve cities. The determination of said organization committee shall not be subject to review ex cept by the Federal Reserve Board when organized: Provided, That the districts shall be apportioned with due regard to the con venience and customary course of business and shall not necessarily be coterminous with any State or States. The districts thus created may be readjusted and new districts may from time to time be created by the Federal Reserve Board, not to exceed twelve in all. * * * The Board, recognizing the general desire for the establishment of the Federal reserve banks at as early a date as practicable, determined to defer the investigation and hearing of these petitions until a later date, announcing, how ever, that the action taken with reference to the banks would not prejudice the decision to be arrived at later, when the petitions should come up for definite determination. When the first pressure of work attending the organization of the banks was over, dates were set for the hearing of the petitions, and during the months of January and February, 1915, all that had then been filed wire heard by counsel. A detailed list of the dates set for the hearings and a statement of other facts relating to the proceedings were printed in the First Annual Report of the Board (p. 192). Subsequently the petition of certain banks in Tennessee for transfer from district No. 6 to district No. 5 was withdrawn, at least for the 94995— 15------ 4 time being. This left the following cases pending before the Board. (1) The petition of certain banks in northern New Jersey for transfer from district No. 3 to district No. 2. (2) The petition of certain banks in West Virginia for the transfer of the counties of Wetzb\ and Tyler from district No. 5 to No. 4. (3) The petition of certain banks in Okla homa for transfer from district No. 11 to dis trict No. 10. (4) The petition of certain banks in Ne braska and Wyoming for transfer from district No. 10 to No. 7. (5) The petition of the city of Baltimore to be designated as the headquarters of district No. 5 in place of Richmond, Va. (6) The petition of the city of Pittsburgh to be designated as the headquarters of district No. 4 in place of Cleveland, Ohio. Meantime, on March 13, certain banks in southern Wisconsin had filed a petition for transfer from district No. 9 to district No. 7, and still more recently, on May 10, certain banks in Connecticut filed a petition for trans fer from district No. 1 to district No. 2. These last two petitions, however, were received at a time when the Board had either decided or was on the point of deciding the cases already pre sented. They were consequently not included in the action finally taken, but were reserved for later hearing and adjudication. When the arguments and briefs relating to the petitions already enumerated were in hand, they were apportioned to committees of the Board. These committees reviewed the testi mony and filed reports making recommenda tions with regard to the best method of dis posing of the subjects referred to them. Action would then have been taken had it not been for the necessary absence of some mem bers of the Board. This necessitated a post ponement of action during the latter part of March and the whole of April. It was then voted to take definite action respecting the pending cases which had been heard at some time during the week beginning May 3. In accordance with this determination the Board on May 4 passed the following resolution: B e it resolved, That the recommendations of the respective committees be adopted and approved, and that the petitions of the banks in southern Oklahoma, northern New Jersey, Tyler and Wetzel Counties, West Virginia, be granted; and, Be it also resolved, That the petition of tKe banks of Wyoming and Nebraska be denied; and, Be it further resolved, That action on other pending petitions be deferred until further ex perience m the actual operation of the several districts, especially in the light of the new clearing system which is about to go into effect, and of the extent to which State banks take membership in the Federal reserve system, shall have provided the Board with the neces sary data for a conclusion, it being the opinion of the Board that action on petitions relating to changes in cities designated as the location of Federal reserve banks should be deferred until the Board shall have reached a conclu sion from experience as to any further read justments in the boundaries of the several dis tricts, or in the number of districts, which may be desirable in the operation and development of the Federal reserve system. It will be seen that the Board in this decision denied one of the petitions— that of Nebraska and Wyoming— deferred action on two, those of the cities of Baltimore and Pittsburgh, for future consideration, and granted three, those of the banks of New Jersey, West Virginia, and Oklahoma. In order to make plain exactly what changes in the previous districts were made effective by the granting of these three petitions, the accompanying map has been drawn, and is herewith presented for the purpose of showing the boundaries of the twelve districts as they stand to-day. Inasmuch as the map is drawn upon too small a scale to admit of the clear representation of counties, there is hereto appended a list of counties in each of the States affected by the redistricting. The names and capitalization of the banks in these transferred territories are likewise given. N E W JE R S E Y . Counties transferred to district No. 2. Bergen. Essex. Hudson. Hunterdon. Middlesex. Monmouth. Morris. Passaic. Somerset. Sussex. Union. Warren. Counties remaining in district No, Gloucester. Mercer. Ocean. Salem. Atlantic* Burlington. Camden. Cape May. Cumberland. OKLAHOMA. Counties transferred to district No. Beckham. Caddo. Carter. Comanche. Custer. Garvin. Grady. Greer. Harmon. Haskell. Hughes. Jackson. Jefferson. Kiowa. Latimer. Le Flore. Love. McClain. Murray. Pittsburg. Pontotoc. Roger Mills. Stephens. Tillman. Washita. Counties remaining in district No. Johnston. McCurtain. Marshall. Pushmataha. Atoka. Bryan. Choctaw. Coal. W E S T V IR G IN IA . In West Virginia the counties of Wetzel and Tyler were transferred from district No. 5 to district No. 4. N EW JERSEY. List o f banks transferred to district No. 2. Name of bank. Farmers National................. First National...................... Seacoast National................. Atlantic Highlands National First National...................... Do................................... Belvidere National............... Warren County National— Location. Allentown.............. Arlington............... Asbury Park.......... Atlantic Highlands Beleville................. Belmar................... Bellvidere.............. ...... d o ..................... Capital and surplus. $100,000 81,000 175.000 100.000 225.000 75,000 175.000 100.000 n ew jersey —continued. new List o f banks transferred to district No. 2—Continued. Name of bank. Bernardsville National................... First National................................ Peoples National............................ Bloomfield National...................... Citizens National............................ Boonton National........................... Bound Brook National.................. First National................................ D o............................................. D o............................................ D o............................................. Citizens National............................ Caldwell National........................... Califon National............................. Carlstadt National......................... Clinton National............................ First National................................. D o ............................................ Closter National............................. National Union.............................. First National................................. D o............................................. D o............................................. D o............................................. National State................................ Citizens National............................ First National................................. Flemington National...................... Hunterton County National.......... First National................................ Central National............................. First National................................ National Freehold Banking Co___ Union National.............................. First National................................ Do............................................. Hackensack National..................... Peoples National............................ Hackettstown National................. Peoples National............................ Hardyston National....................... First National................................ Do............................................. Second National............................. First National................................ Irvington National......................... First National................................ Do............................................. Hudson County National.............. Merchants National....................... Keansburg National....................... Peoples National........................... Amwell National............................ Lambertville National................... Little Falls National...................... First National................................ Citizens National............................ First National................................ Do............................................. Do............................................. Manasquan National...................... Farmers & Merchants National_ _ Metuchen National......................... First National................................ D o ............................................ Essex National............................... First National................................ National Iron................................. First National................................ Citizens National............................ American National......................... Broad-Market National................. Essex County National................. Manufacturers National................. Merchants National... ................... National Newark Banking Co....... National State Bank...................... North Ward National.................... Union National.............................. National Bank of New Jersey....... Peoples National............................ Merchants National........................ Sussex National.............................. Ocean Grove National.................... Orange National............................. Second National............................. Location. Capital and surplus. Bernardsville.. Blairstown...... .......d o .............. Bloomfield...... Bloomsbury... Boonton.......... Bound Brook.. .......d o .............. Bradley Beach. Branchville_ _ Butler............. Caldwell.......... .......d o.............. Califon............. Carlstadt......... Clinton............ ___ do.............. Cranbury........ Closter............. Dover.............. Dunellen......... East Newark... Eatontown...... Edgewater....... Elizabeth........ Englewood___ Englishtown... Flemington___ ___ d o.............. Fort Lee.......... Freehold.......... ___ d o.............. ___ d o.............. Frenchtown.... Garfield........... Guttenburg.. Hackensack., .do. Hackettstown.. .......do.............. Hamburg........ High Bridge... Hoboken......... .......do.............. Hope............... Irvington........ Jamesburg....... Jersey City___ $50,000 50.000 75.000 150.000 25.000 . .d o................. Keansburg.......... Keyport............. Lambertville...... ..d o ................. Little Falls......... Lodi.................... Long Branch___ Lyndhurst.......... Madison.............. Manasquan......... Matawan............ Metuchen........... Milford............... Milburn.............. Montclair............ ..d o ................. Morristown......... ..d o ................. Netcong.............. Newark............... ..d o ................. .do................. ..d o ................. .d o ................. . .d o ................. ..d o ................. ..d o ................. .d o ................. New Brunswick.. ..do................. Newton............... ..do.................. Ocean Grove....... Orange................ . .do................. 200.000 60.000 125.000 27.500 50.000 110.000 41.000 50.000 31.000 60.000 150.000 70.000 150.000 50.000 375.000 40.000 35.000 33.000 50.000 1 , 000,000 150.000 58.500 200.000 200,000 49.000 100,000 150.000 100.000 160,d o o 64.000 75.000 200,000 300,000 250.000 jersey — continued. List o f banks transferred to district No. 2—Continued. Name of bank. Location. Passaic National............................ First National................................ Paterson National......................... Second National............................. First National................................ Phillipsburg National.................... Second National............................. City National................................. First National................................ Rahway National........................... First National................................ Second National............................. First National................................ D o............. ............................... D o............................................. D o............................................. D o............................................. Rutherford National...................... First National................................ D o............................................. D o............................................. Second National............................. First National................................ D o............................................. D o............................................. D o............................................. Farmers National........................... First National................................. D o............................................. D o............................................. National Bank............................... Peoples National............................ National Bank of North Hudson.. First National................................ D o............................................. D o............................................. D o............................................. Capital and surplus. Passaic....................... Paterson...................... .......do.......................... .......do.......................... Perth Amboy............. Phillipsburg............... .......do.......................... Plainfield.................... .......do.......................... Rahway...................... Ramsey............. ......... Red Bank.................. Ridgefield Park Ridgewood... Rockaway.. Roosevelt.. . Roselle.......... Rutherford............... Sea Bright__ Secaucus____ Somerville__ .......do............ South Amboy. South River.T ._ Spring Lake... Summit.. .. Sussex....................... Tenafly....................... Town of Union. . Washington.. Westfield.................... .......do______ _______ West Hoboken............ West Orange. . . Westwood................. Whitehouse Station... Woodbridge... . $550,000 1, 100,000 600,000 350.000 300.000 500.000 150.000 300.000 300.000 150.000 45.000 225.000 60.000 110.000 30.000 50.000 65.000 150.000 32,500 25.000 250.000 100.000 125.000 125.000 75.000 100.000 200,000 50.000 125.000 250.000 123,948 80.000 115.000 120.000 47.000 47.000 40.000 Total..................................... 32,071,448 100.000 85.000 30.000 660,000 400.000 32.000 145.000 75.000 OKLAHOM A. List o f banks transferred to district No. 10. 1, 200,000 750.000 250.000 27.500 60.000 157.000 200.000 Name of bank. The First National Bank............... Merchants & Planters National_ _ First National.............1.................. Do............................................. Do............................................ City National................................. First National................................ D o ............................................ National Bank of............................ First National..:............................ D o ............................................ Ardmore National......................... First National................................. State National................................ First National................................. D o ............................................ D o ............................................ Calvin National.............................. First National................................. 2 0 ,0 0 The Chickasha National................ ,0 0 0 750.000 Citizens National............................ First National................................. 1, 000,000 2 , 000,000 Oklahoma National....................... 750.000 First National................................ 500.000 Oklahoma State National.............. 3,000,000' First National................................. 500.000 Cordell National........................... 250.000 Farmers National........................... 190.000 State National................................ 400.000 First Natipnal.........; ................... 50.000 Peoples State National............,___ 300.000 First National................................ 300.000 Citv National................................. 30.000 35.000 250.000 150.000 55.000 85.000 75.000 150.000 55.000 45.000 87.000 187,500 150.000 250.000 400.000 50.000 375.000 270.000 Location. Ada.............................. .......do........................... Addington.................. Alex............................ Allen..................... Altus.............. .......do.......... Anadarko__ ... .do.......... Apache.. Aranaho.. Ardmore........ .......do............. .......do....................... Berwyn............. Bterir....................... Blanchard................ Calvin...................... .......do....................... Chickasha................ .......do....................... .......do....................... .......do.......................... C l i n t o n ........................ .......do.......................... C om an ch e............ C ordell.................. ....... do.......................... ........ d o .......................... Custer City............... .......do.......................... Davis....................... Duncan....................... Capital and surplus. $60,000 60,000 26,722 45.000 30.000 54.500 67,250 60.000 30.000 30.000 30.000 120,000 200.000 110,000 30.000 29.000 50.000 28.000 30.000 113,500 90.000 260,000 125,000 35.000 27,750 30.000 35.000 28.500 33.500 30.000 30.000 60.000 42,000 llA * ’ MINN. J 'N s I ° INEAPOLIS v \ i^ -W ..L -L wis. MICH- rX*1 z&'j¥ \ 9": IOWA CH lQ A^0 on'° j'r v :P"NW,5.\Vot'-„ / (. A \ f. W . V A y- *■"""" 1 'p S T . L O j lM S ; / MO. \ 8 / ~ ' yv v p .g c ^ o * 10 ' 5 y " N .C tenn X \ s. c. \ M ’ LANTA^ \ %s. I A L A .g \. GA. Ll l a s ______A ; / ---------? AC ______ S FUA. MAP SHOWING FEDERAL R E SER VE D ISTR IC JTH CHANGES B Y FE D E R A L RE SER VE BOARD. ' b o s t 0 '* Oklahoma — continued, Oklahoma — continued. List o f banks transferred to district N o. 10— Continued, Name of bank. Location. Dunaan National............................ First National................................. D o ............................................. D o ............................................ Francis National............................. First National................................. National Bank of Commerce......... First NationrfL.............................. D o ............... ............................. Fanners National........................... First National................................. National Bank of........................... First National................................. State National................................ City National.................................. Fanners & Merchants National.... First National................................. American National............. ..... Fanners National........................... First National................................ City National.........'...................... National Bank of Commerce....... State National................................ Farmers National........................... First National................................ Keota National............................... First National................................ Peoples National............................ City National.................................. First National................................ First National................................ Do............................................. Do............................................. Mangum National.......................... First National........T....................... Marietta National........................... The National Bank of.................... State National................................ Farmers National........................... First National................................ American National......................... City National.................................. First National................................ Do............................................. Do............................................. Do............................................. Do............................................. Do............................................. National Bank of Commerce......... Pauls Valley National................... First National................................ National Bank o f........................... The Chickasaw National............... Union National.............................. First National................................ Do............................................. Farmers & Merchants National.... First National................................. Do............................................. Do............................................. Beckham County National............ First National................................ D o............................................. Do............................................. Do............................................. Duncan. ........... . : . . .do................ Eldorado........... Elk City............ Francis.............. Frederick.......... .......do................ Gotedo............... Grandfield......... Hammon........... Hartshorne........ Hastings............ Heavoner........... .....d o ................ Hobart............... .....d o ................ ----- d o ....*......... Holdenville....... >.-.. .d o .* * ,. . . . . . . . . . d o . . . . . ....... H o llis............. ___ d o................ ___ d o ................ Hydro............... ___d o................ Keota................. Kiowa............... — d o................ Lawton............. — d o................ Lindsay............. Lone W olf......... Mangum............ ___ do................ Marietta............ ___d o................ Marlow.............. — d o................ Maysville.......... ___do................ McAlester.......... ___d o................ ___ d o................ Minco................. Mountain View. New Wilson___ Olustee.............. Pauls Valley___ ___d o................ — do................ Poteau............... — d o................ Percell............... — d o................ Quinton............ Ringing............ First National................................ Do............................................. D o............................................. D o............................................. Park National................................. First National................................. Temple National............................ First National................................. First National................................. National Bank of. First National........ Walters National.. First National........ D o ................... Waurika National. .......do.......................... Stonewall.................... Stratford...................... Stuart.......................... Sulphur....................... Talmina...................... Temple........................ Thomas....................... Verden........................ ___do........... Walters........ ___do........... Washington. Waurika....... ___do........... ___do................ Rush Springs... Ryan................. Sayre................. ___do................ Sentinel............. Snyder............... Spiro................. Capital and surplus. $50,000 60,000 40.000 56.000 30.000 72.000 90.000 27,700 30.000 27,650 75.000 28.500 31.000 I 25.000 33.500 60.000 30.000 30.000 27.500 31 25.000 25,050 27.500 28.500 36.000 27.500 100,000 110,000 50.000 34.000 75.000 80.000 75.000 100,000 29,200 26,750 27.500 32.500 125.000 55.000 135.000 30.000 30.000 25.000 30.000 150.000 60.000 30.000 42.500 60.000 75.000 33.000 30.000 50,400 37.500 36.000 36.000 60.000 27.500 32.500 27.500 27.500 29.000 30.000 60.000 42.000 27.500 29.000 30.000 26,250 27.500 30.000 26.500 30.000 30.000 40.000 26.000 27,650 25.500 List o f banks transferred to district No. 10— Continued. Name of bank. Location. First National................................. German National........................... American National......................... First National................................. Latimer County National.............. First National................................. Southern National:___ *................ Capital and surplus. Weatherford............... ....... do.......................... Wetumka.................... ....... do.......................... Wilburton................... Wvnnewood............... $28,500 60,000 30.000 35,500 29.000 10 0 0 ,0 0 ............... 80.000 Total..................................... 5,994,873 W E S T V IR G IN IA . List o f banks transferred to district No. 4. Name of bank. Location. First National................................ Do............................................. Farmers and Producers National.. First National................................. Peoples National............................ Middleboume............. New Martinsville Sistersville................... .......do.......................... ....... do.......................... Total..................................... Capital and surplus. $39,500 75,000 136.000 165.000 115.000 530,500 The pending cases divide themselves into two broadly distinguishable classes, the one involving extensive revision of the work al ready done and requiring for its elucidation and proper determination knowledge which could come only from experience and observation of the actual working of the several Federal re serve banks; the other involving simpler and less extensive interests and requiring less de tailed information as to the whole problem of districting. The Board's announcement on the whole subject, while going as far as it has been deemed practicable under existing conditions to take action, is not at all to be regarded as final and was not intended to be so. The right to act further on the matter is reserved for future ex ercise as that may be necessary and at any time. Although there has been no express statement to that effect, it is a clear inference from the opinion handed down that future action will depend very much upon the course of events in the districts as they are now made up, and will be determined by the conditions that are disclosed in the operations of the banks. LAW DEPARTMENT. The following opinions of counsel for the out of the context, expressly, or by necessary Federal Reserve Board have been authorized implication. The words are to be taken in for publication by the Board since the last their natural and obvious sense, and not in a edition of the Bulletin. sense unreasonably restricted or enlarged.” In accordance with the decisions in these and Discount o f Acceptances “ Based on the Importation or other cases, unless such a result is absurd or Exportation of G oods.” Federal reserve banks may, under section 13 of the obviously contrary to the intent of Congress, Federal reserve act, discount acceptances based on the as shown by other parts of the act, the natural shipment of goods (a) between the United States and and usual significance must be attached to the any foreign country, (b) between any two or more foreign words “ importation ” and “ exportation.” The countries, and (c) between the continental United States question, therefore, arises, what is their ordi and Porto Rico, the Philippines, or the Canal Zone; but not acceptances based on the shipment of goods between nary and popular meaning ? In discussing this subject the corelative the continental United States and Hawaii or between any two parts.of the continental United States. terms, “ export,” “ exportation,” “ import,” Sir : I have been asked for an opinion on the “ importation,” and the like will be treated as proper interpretation of that part of section 13 synonymous. of the Federal reserve act which reads: “ Any The Century Dictionary and Cyclopedia de Federal reserve bank may discount accept fines “ export” as “ That which is exported, a ances which are based on the importation or commodity carried from one place or country exportation of goods,” with a view to deter to another,” and “ exportation” as, “ The act mining whether the words “ importation or of conveying or sending to a distance, especially exportation of goods” include (1) shipments to another state or country commodities in the between countries other than the United course of commerce.” The same authority de States, and (2) shipments between the con fines “ exporter” as, “ One who ships goods, tinental United States and possessions of the wares, and merchandise of any kind to a for United States. eign country or distant place for sale.” The The first principles of statutory construction New Standard Dictionary defines “ export” as, require that language which is clear and un “ That which is exported; in general, goods or ambiguous be given its ordinary and natural any article of trade or merchandise sent from significance. The legislative meaning is first one country to another; properly, as used in to be sought in the words used and if they are the United States Constitution, goods sent to clear, the letter of the law controls, unless in a foreign country.” If these broad definitions are applied, it is extraordinary cases such a natural construction would result in an obvious or absurd error. manifest that the words “ importation” and United States v. Goldenberg, 168 U. S. 95, 102; “ exportation” will include shipments between United States v. Union Pacific Railroad Co., countries other than the United States. It is 91 U. S. 72, 79; Lake County v. Rollins, 130 necessary, therefore, to determine whether the U. S. 662. “ The legislature must be presumed natural significance of these terms must be re to use words in the known and ordinary signi stricted because of the judicial construction of fication, unless that sense be repelled by the similar words as used in the Federal Constitu context,” Levy v. McCartee, 6 Peters, 102, 110- tion and in various acts of Congress. The word “ import,” as used in tariff stat In Martin v. Hunter, 1 Wheat. 304, 326, it is said that “ where a power is expressly given, utes of the United States, invariably refers to in general terms, it is not to be restrained to imports to the United States from a foreign particular cases unless that construction grow country, and it might be argued that when the words “ exportation” and “ importation” are used in the Federal reserve act they must be given a corresponding significance— that is, they must be held to refer only to exports from and imports into the United States from a for eign country, and not also to shipments be tween countries other than the United States. This argument, however, is not convincing, because of the fact that the word “ import” as used in tariff laws must necessarily refer to shipments into the United States. “ The power of Congress to levy and collect taxes, duties, and excises is co-extensive with the United States,” Loughborough v. Blake, 5 Wheat, 317. To levy a duty or tax of any sort, a soverign must have jurisdiction over the article taxed. This narrower construction of the word “ im port” was, therefore, necessary, in order to give the tariff laws any effective operation. The United States could have no possible juris diction over a transaction between Buenos Aires and London, for instance, and to attempt to tax such an import would be ineffectual. But even in these tariff laws where the mean ing of “ im port” must necessarily be limited to imports into the United States, Congress has almost invariably provided in terms that the imports be from a foreign country into the United States. In the first tariff act, passed by Congress on July 4, 1789, it was enacted, “ That * * * duties * * * be levied on the following goods, wares, and mer chandise imported into the United States from any foreign port or place,” and it is to be noted that practically every tariff law passed by Con gress since that time has contained some simi lar provision. It might be contended that this restriction, limiting dutiable imports to articles brought from a foreign country , to the United States was intended to preclude any consideration of articles imported into one State from another State of the Union. But such intention is re butted by the fact that the Constitution as construed by the Supreme Court of the United States, does not give Congress the power to lay an impost on goods imported from another State. The Constitution gives to Congress the general power “ to levy and collect taxes, du ties, imposts, and exercises,” but “ imposts” has been construed in Woodruff v. Parham, 8 Wall., 123, to mean a duty, custom, or tax levied on articles brought into the United States and the words “ imports” and “ exports” as used in the Constitution, are uniformly held to refer only to goods imported from foreign countries into the United States, and not to ar ticles carried from one State to another. Pitts burgh Coal Co. v.’ Louisiana, 156, U. S. 590, 600; Brown v. Houston, 114 U. S. 622, 628. It seems clear, therefore, that “ import” or “ export” as used in Federal tariff statutes must of necessity refer to transactions to or from the United States. On the other hand, in the Federal reserve act—which is not a tariff measure, but wdiich is, on the contrary, a law in which the words “ importation” and “ exportation” could con sistently refer to transactions between two for eign countries other than the United States— Congress has failed to put any restrictive limi tation, evidently intending that the words used be given their normal and natural significance, the meaning generally *understood when used in ordinary commercial parlance. The lexicons all agree in defining “ export” as an article or commodity carried from one country to an other, and nowhere except in cases construing the Constitution and the tariff laws is there any suggestion that “ import” necessarily means an article shipped from a foreign country to the country or jurisdiction of the person or legislature using the word. When used in the Federal Constitution or in the tariff laws made in pursuance thereof, the words “ import” and “ export” must neces sarily be given the narrower construction, for the reason already stated; that is, the United States has no jurisdiction to impose a tax or impost on any article not within the confines of the United States. But in the case of a Fed eral banking law, where there is nothing in the context nor in the spirit of the act to demand a narrower or limited interpretation, the words should be given their full significance. All the cases previously cited on the laws of statutory construction demand this result. But even if the literal meaning of the phrase “ importation or exportation” be considered doubtful, a liberal construction in accordance with the general intent of Congress would neces sitate this same result. It must be remembered that the Federal reserve act is remedial and constructive legislation by which Congress clearly intended to eliminate certain patent evils in conditions as they existed at the time of enactment, and to establish on a broad, comprehensive, and firm basis a unified system of banking. The language “ to furnish an elas tic currency, to afford means of rediscounting commercial paper, to establish a more effective supervision of banking in the United States, and for other purposes,” contained in the title of the act, shows that it is remedial, and as such should be broadly and liberally construed in order to accomplish the advancement of the remedies contemplated. (24 Am. and Eng. Enel. 887, and cases cited.) It may be reasonably assumed that Congress not only wanted to create a discount market for acceptances, but at the same time intended to establish a system which would facilitate the trade and commerce of the people of the United States, no matter where that trade or com merce originated or what its destination. Acceptances having become a recognized inci dent of trade as between nations the establish ment of a wider market in this country for such paper was apparently one of the objects of the act. Both the Senate bill and the conference agreement permitted the discount of accept ances, based not only on foreign but also on domestic shipments. The latter, however, were struck out on the floor, probably because of the fear that a general domestic acceptance business might be abused by the smaller banks which were unfamiliar with this class of invest ment and that for the present at least, such investments might prove a detriment not only to such banks but to the entire system. The elimination, however, of acceptances based on domestic shipments could not have been in tended to restrict or limit the field of accept ances based on the “ importation or exporta tion of goods,” that phrase remaining precisely the same as it was prior to the elimination of domestic acceptances and just as it read when the intent was to include acceptances based on shipments of any kind. It seems, therefore, that by all the ordinary rules of statutory construction, giving to the words the natural and ordinary import, which is strongly corroborated by the purposes, spirit, and history of the act, this portion of section 13 was intended to, and actually does, permit the discount of acceptances based on the impor tation and exportation of goods, not only to and from the United States, but also between other countries, separate and apart therefrom. SH IPM EN TS B E T W E E N TH E C O N T IN E N T A L U N ITE D STATES A N D ITS P O SS E SS IO N S. The second question raised is whether the clause “ acceptances which are based on the importation or exportation of goods,” should include acceptances based on shipments be tween the continental United States and its possessions, viz, Porto Rico, Hawaii, Canal Zone, and the Philippines. It is, of course, not to be disputed that if, as contended above, imports and exports to and from countries other than the United States are a satisfactory basis for acceptances, then acceptances based on shipments between any of these possessions and another country, other than the United States are eligible, a fortiori. This leaves to be considered the one question just stated. The definitions given in the standard dic tionaries refer to shipments from one country to another country or to a “ distant place,” and such a general understanding of the words in question would certainly seem to be sufficiently comprehensive to include transactions between the United States and any of its island posses sions, though they are not foreign territory in a political sense. To permit the discount of acceptances based on the importation or exportation of goods from and to the possessions of the United States, it must be shown (1) that these words, as generally known and understood and as intended by the Federal reserve act, do not necessarily refer to shipments to and from a foreign country, and (2) that shipments to and from these possessions are not domestic shipments. As already shown, the word “ import” as used in the Constitution and tariff laws, has been construed by the Supreme Court to refer to imports from foreign countries. In the tariff laws this has necessarily been so because these laws specifically require that the imports be from a foreign country. The word as used in the Constitution, however, not being ex pressly limited, has been construed to refer to imports from a foreign country and not to arti cles shipped from one State to another, for various reasons. A study of the discussions in the Constitutional Conventions and of the his tory of the formation of the Constitution showed that there was no intention in the minds of the framers of that instrument to refer to anything but foreign imports and exports, and the Supreme Court has, in various decisions reciting the history and development of the Constitution and the evils to be obviated by it, decided that “ export” and “ import” mean exports and imports to and from foreign countries and not between States. But in all those cases the particular circumstances under which the words were used were stated at length to show why this narrower interpreta tion was necessary in each instance. Wood ruff v. Parham 8 Wall. 123; Brown v. Houston, 114 U. S. 622. In other words, the burden of limiting the natural meaning of the words was clearly recognized by the court. Justice Brown in referring to this well-settled construc tion of the words as used in the Constitution, said, in Dooley v. United States, 183 U. S. 151, 153: While the words “ import” and “ export” are sometimes used to denote goods passing from one State to another, the word “ import,” in connection with the provision of the Con stitution that “ no State shall levy any imports or duties on imports or exports,” was held in Woodruff v. Parham, 8 Wall. 123, to apply only to articles imported from foreign countries into the United States, thus implying that they are used in other than the constitutional sense. As previously explained, there is no necessity for forcing a restricted construction on this phrase as used in the Federal reserve act, and in consequence there would seem to be no justification for reading the word “ foreign” into its definition as applied to this act. It might be contended that to follow out this argument logically would lead to the conclusion that a shipment of goods from one State of the United States to another State of the United States would be an “ importation or exporta tion of goods,” a result clearly not contem plated by Congress. The answer is found in the history and development of the act before its passage. The House bill provided for the discount of acceptances based on the “ exportation or im portation of goods.” The Senate bill amended this provision to read “ importation or expor tation or domestic shipment of goods,” evi dently intending to cover shipments to and from any points wherever located. As the act read when finally passed, “ domestic shipments” were eliminated. It is evident, therefore, that Congress intended to make eligible acceptances based on all except domestic shipment of goods. This raises the second point: Is a shipment from the Continental United States to one of the island possessions of the United States a domestic shipment? The Century Dictionary and Cyclopedia defines “ domestic commerce” as “ commercial transactions within the limits of one nation or State,” and in 14 Cyc. 829, quoting In re Roofing Contractors Association, 9 Pa. Dist. 569, 570, domestic trade is referred to as, “ the exchange or buying or selling of goods within a country.” The difficulty, how ever, is that the term “ United States” has various different meanings dependent upon whether it is used in a geographical, commercial, or governmental sense, or whether it is in- tended to describe the States of the Union as such. The term uUnited States” as used in the uniformity clause of the Constitution has been held in the insular cases not to extend to the unorganized territorial possessions of the United States. On the other hand, in dealing with foreign sovereignties it is generally under stood to have a broader meaning than when used in the Constitution. It then includes all territories subject to the jurisdiction of the Federal Government, whether it is merely ter ritory appurtenant to the United States or whether it is an incorporated part of the United States. This question of the status of our territorial possessions has been the subject of extended discussions before the Supreme Court, and though it is now generally admitted that these possessions are not foreign in an international sense, nevertheless they may be foreign to the United States in a domestic sense. Downes v. Bidwell, 182 U. S. 244. In the case of Dorr v. United States, 195 U. S. 138, 143, the Supreme Court, in speaking of the extent and limitations of the Constitution as applied to our posses sions, said: The limitations which are to be applied in any given case involving territorial government must depend upon the relation of the particular territory to the United States concerning which Congress is exercising the power con ferred by the Constitution. That the United States may have territory which is not incor porated into the United States as a body politic we think was recognized by the framers of the Constitution in enacting the article already considered, giving power over the Territories, and is sanctioned by the opinions of the justices concurring in the judgment in Downes v. Bidwell, supra. In other words, the United States may own territory which is subject to the control of Congress under the territorial clause of the Constitution but which is not an integral part of the United States until Congress sees fit to make it such and to extend to it the operation of the Constitution and laws of the United States. The doctrine that the Constitution does not follow the flag, ipso facto, seems well settled now by numerous cases of the Supreme Court. See Downes v. Bidwell, supra; Hawaii v. Mankichi, 190 U. S. 197. It is, of course, admitted in all these cases that Congress may, if it chooses, incorporate into the Union any Territories belonging to the United States. Until it does so, however, it seems', from the cases cited, that Territories of the United States, though subject to the jurisdiction of Congress, are not domestic in a national sense, and that shipments to and from such Territo ries are not to be considered domestic ship ments within the meaning of the Federal reserve act. It may be well to consider, separately and briefly, the cases of Porto Rico, the Philip pines, Canal Zone, and Hawaii to determine whether Congress has so acted as to make them an integral part of the United States. Porto Rico.— Porto Rico is not foreign terri tory within the meaning of the Dingley Tariff Act, approved July 24, 1897, taxing articles imported into the United States from “ foreign countries.” De Lima v. Bidwell, 182 U. S. 1, decided May 27, 1901. In another case— Downes v. Bidwell— decided the same day, the Supreme Court held that the Foraker Act of April 12, 1900, which levied certain duties on articles coming into the United States from Porto Rico, and on goods shipped from the United States to Porto Rico, was valid— even though a tax or burden on shipments between different parts of the United States is uncon stitutional—because “ Porto Rico is a terri tory appurtenant and belonging to the United States, but not a part of the United States within the revenue clauses of the Constitution.” The duties in question are no longer levied; they were only a temporary assessment, but the status of Porto Rico remains the same, no act of Congress having been passed since then to make it an integral part of the Union. Inasmuch, therefore, as Porto Rico is not a part of the United States, it does not seem, for the rea sons considered above, that a shipment be tween Porto Rico and the United States is a domestic shipment in the generally accepted meaning of that term^-a shipment from one part of the country to another. Philippine Islands.— In the case of Four teen Diamond Rings v. United States, 183 U. S. 176, it was held that the Philippines are not a “ foreign country” in the meaning of the tariff act of 1897, imposing a duty on imports from foreign countries. The court went on to say that “ In this respect there is no distinc tion between the Philippines and the Islands of Porto Rico. Neither of them is a foreign country within the terms of that act.” In the later case of Dorr v. United States, supra, it was held that the Philippines were not incorporated into the United States by the mere treaty of cession, and, as the court said: . The legislation upon the subject shows that not only has Congress hitherto refrained from incorporating the Philippines into the United States, but m the act of 1902, providing for temporary civil government (32 Stat. 691), there is express provision that section eighteen hundred and ninety-one of the Revised Stat utes of 1878 shall not apply to the Philippine Islands. This is the section giving force and effect to the Constitution and laws of the United States, not locally inapplicable, within all the organized Territories, and every Terri tory thereafter organized, as elsewhere within the United States. The Philippines, like Porto Rico, are there fore not an integral part of the United States, and, as Justice White said in Downes v. Bidwell, supra, “ it is foreign to the United States in a domestic sense because not incorporated into the United States.” Being generally understood to be foreign to the United States in every sense except an international one, there is no justification for the conclusion that shipments to and from the Philippines are domestic. Hawaii.— Though the Hawaiian Islands were not made an integral part of the United States by the mere act of Congress annexing them (30 Stat. 750, Hawaii v. Mankichi, supra), nevertheless, by the act of Congress of June 14, 1900, 31 Stat. 141, they were formally incorporated. B y |this act (the Constitution and Jail Federal laws were given “ the s&me force and effect in Hawaii as;elsewherd in the United States,” and Justice White, in the case cited, said that by this act “ the islands iyere undoubtedly made a part of, the United States in the fullest sense.” This distinction between Hawaii and the Philippines and Porto R ico is recognized by all the branches of the Government. Porto Rico and the Philippines are under the juris diction 4 f:th # Bureau of Insular Affairs in the War Department, but Hawaii is not. Hawaii, like Alaska^ is represented in Congress by a Territorial Delegate, whereas the Philippines and Porto R ico merely send ‘ ‘ Resident Com missioners” to Washington. Under all the facts, therefore, Hawaii must be considered as an integral part of the United States. Consequently any shipment between Hawaii and the continental United States must be considered a domestic shipment, and as such can not form the basis of an acceptance eligible for discount by Federal Reserve Banks. In other words, it does not seem pos sible to differentiate transactions with Hawaii from those with any part of the continental United States. Hawaii’s relation to the United States seems precisely analogous to that of Alaska. Canal Zone.— The status of the Canal Zone is unique. The United States has, in effect, an easement 10 miles wide across the Republic of Panama. It is foreign territory, subject to the control and supervision of this Govern ment. The tariff act of 1913, imposing duties on imports “ into the United States or into any of its possessions (except the Philippine Is lands and the islands of Guam and Tutuila)” does not apply to the Panama Canal, even though it is not expressly excepted from the term “ possessions,” as is the case with the Philippines. By an act dated March 2, 1905, 33 Stat. 843, Congress specifically stated that “ all laws affecting imports of articles, goods, wares, and merchandise, and entry of persons into the United States from foreign countries, shall apply to articles, etc., coming from the Canal Zone and seeking entry into any State or Territory of the United States or the District of Columbia/7 showing that in no way is the Canal Zone considered an integral part of the United States. Indeed it is not even terri tory owned by the United States, but rather territory merely under its jurisdiction and control. Strictly speaking, it is a depend ency. As such it is less a part of the United States than Porto Rico, and shipments to and from it could hardly be considered domestic shipments in the light of the previous discus sion. To summarize, it would seem that the Fed eral Reserve Banks may, under section 13, discount acceptances based on the shipment of goods (a) between the United States and any foreign country, (6) between any two or more foreign countries, and (c) between the continental United States and Porto Rico, the Philippines, or the Canal Zone; but not accept ances based on the shipment of goods between the continental United States and Hawaii or between any two parts of the continental United States. Respectfully, M. C. E lliott, C ou n sel. To Hon. C. S. H amlin, G overn or F ed era l R eserve B o a r d . Forward Discount Rates. Federal Reserve Banks m under the established right ay, to fix discount rates for acceptances o other eligible paper, r fix a forw rate; that is, a rate to apply at a future tim ard e. Such a rate is calculated to accom odate trade and com m m erce as required by the act, and w tend to obviate ill speculation due to fluctuating rates. May 18, 1915. Sir : The question of the right of Federal Reserve Banks to establish forward discount rates to cover acceptances or other eligible paper has been duly considered by this office, as requested. In an opiniona filed with the Board dated November 19, 1914, the question of the right aSee Federal Reserve Bulletin, May 1, 1915. of Federal Reserve Banks to establish discount rates, subject to review by the Federal Reserve Board, was considered at some length. It is not deemed necessary to review in detail the conclusions reached in that opinion, but so far as pertinent to the question now under consideration authorities were cited to show that Congress has the power to delegate the right to fix discount rates to an adminis trative body and that this right has been vested in the Federal Reserve Banks subject to review and determination by the Federal Reserve Board. The provisions of law which it is necessary to consider in determining the question under consideration are as follows : Section 14, subsection (d), in defining o^^ A the powers of Federal Reserve BanU, provides as follows: To establish from time to time, subject to review and determination of the Federal Reserve Board, rates of discount to be charged by the Federal Reserve Bank for each class of paper, which shall be fixed with a view of accommodating commerce and business. Section 4 provides in part as follows: Every Federal Reserve Bank shall be con ducted under the supervision and control of a board of directors. The board of directors shall perform the duties usually appertaining to the office of directors of banking associations and all such duties as are prescribed by law. Said board shall administer the affairs of said bank fairly and impartially and without dis crimination in favor of or against any member bank or banks, and shall, subject to the provi sions of law and the orders oi the Federal Re serve Board, extend to each member bank such discounts, advancements and accommodations as may be safely and reasonably made with due regard for the claims and demands of other member banks. Analyzing these provisions, it appears that the only limitations to which discount rates are subject are as follows: (a) That they shall be fixed by the Federal Reserve Bank with the view of accommodating trade and commerce. (& ) That there shall be no discrimination as between member banks. (c) That they shall be subject to review and determination by the Federal Reserve Board. Considering the question submitted in the light of these restrictions, it appears— (1) That the purpose of fixing a forward rate, that is, a rate to apply at softie future date, is primarily to accommodate trade and commerce and to prevent those dealing in legitimate trans actions from being subject to the speculative influence of fluctuating rates. For example, a commercial transaction may be safely en gaged in if the purchaser, or one who is assisting the purchaser to finance such a transaction, can have the assurance that an acceptance or other eligible paper possessing the necessary qualifications can be discounted or sold at a fu ture date at a fixed rate, whereas if the rate is undetermined the element of speculation necessarily enters into the transaction. (2) If the rate is so fixed as to be equally ap plicable to all member banks, no element of discrimination is involved. (3) If the Federal Reserve Bank fixes a rate at which it will discount or purchase various classes of paper at the present time and in so doing announces that the rate on any particular class of paper will not be increased beyond a fixed maximum for a specified number of days, and if the Board approves such rate, or if the maximum thus fixed by the Federal Reserve Bank is no greater than the maximum rate pre viously approved by the Board, it will have exercised its right of review and the rates will thereupon become definitely established in ac cordance with the provisions of law applicable thereto. Respectfully, M. C . E l l i o t t , Counsel. To Hon. C h a r l e s S. H a m l i n , Governor Federal Reserve Board. D iscou n t o f A cceptances Indorsed by M em ber Banks Located in Another D istrict. Federal Reserve Banks m ay, U nder the provisions of section 13, discount acceptances based on the im portation or exportation of goods, provided they have a m aturity at tim of discount of not m than three m e ore onths, and pro vided further, that they are indorsed by a least one m em ber bank. It is immaterial whether this member bank is located in the district of the Federal Reserve Bank which is making the discount or in any other district, the term “ member bank” being broad enough to include member banks wherever located. Such discounts, being made under the provisions of section 13, are eligible as collateral security for Federal reserve notes issued under the provisions of section 16. A p r i l 30, 1915. Sir : The question has been raised whether a Federal Reserve Bank may, under section 13 of the Federal reserve act, discount acceptances indorsed by a member bank located in a dis trict other than that of such reserve bank; and, if so, is the paper thus discounted eligible to be used as collateral security for Federal reserve notes issued under section 16. The act provides that— Any Federal Reserve Bank may discount acceptances which are based on the importa tion or exportation of goods and which have a maturity at time of discount of not more than three months, and indorsed by at least one member bank. It is to be noted that an acceptance to be eligible for discount under this provision, of the act must (1) be based on the importation or exportation of goods, (2) have a maturity at time of discount of not more than three months, and (3) be indorsed by at least one member bank. The third requirement is the one to be specially considered in this connection. Does “ member bank” mean a member of the par ticular Federal Reserve Bank, or does it import a more general significance and mean a bank which is a member of the Federal reserve system ? If it is the latter, then no doubt any Federal Reserve Bank may discount accept ances for any member bank, irrespective of the district in which it is located. Section 1 of the Federal reserve act states that— The term “ member bank” shall be held to mean any national bank, State bank, or bank or trust company which has become a member of one of the reserve banks created by this act, and, ‘ applying this definition to the .section in question, it would seem clear that in consider ing the eligibility of acceptances for discount by a particular Federal Reserve Bank, it is immaterial in what district the indorsing mem ber bank is located. As long as it is a member of some one Federal Reserve Bank, it is a “ member bank” as defined by the act itself. This conclusion is further supported by the fact that Congress, in defining eligible paper other than acceptances, required specifically that the indorsement must be by “ any of its member banks,” thus expressly referring to the members of a certain Federal Reserve Bank. The fact that this restriction was omitted in fixing the qualities of eligible acceptances indi cates that Congress intended that there should be a broad market for this class of paper and that a Federal Reserve Bank should not be limited to acceptances indorsed by its own member banks. The same construction of the term “ mem ber bank” has been accepted by the Board in relation to the power of a Federal Reserve Bank to receive deposits of “ checks and drafts upon solvent member banks.” Granting, therefore, that a Federal Reserve Bank may, under the provisions of section 13, discount acceptances indorsed by a member bank of another district, may such paper be put up as collateral for Federal reserve notes ? It is clear that paper bought in the open mar ket under the provisions of section 14 is not eligible as collateral security unless it conforms to the provisions of section 16, defining eligi ble collateral. That section provides in part that— The collateral security thus offered shall be notes and bills accepted for rediscount under the provisions of section 13 of this act. that the same paper might have been purchased in the open market, with or without the in dorsement of a member bank, is immaterial if in fact the paper was accepted for discount under section 13. As previously’ indicated, acceptances in dorsed by a member bank of another district may be so discounted, and if so they may be put up as collateral security under the terms of section 16, which define eligible collateral. Respectfully, M. C. E l l i o t t , Counsel. To Hon. C. S. H a m l in , Governor Federal Reserve Board. P urch ase o f U nited States B on ds by F ederal R eserve B a n k s. Federal Reserve Banks have an unlimited right to pur chase United States bonds in the open market. They may also, under the provisions of section 18, be permitted or required, after December 23, 1915, to purchase bonds bearing the circulation privilege, up to an amount not exceeding $25,000,000 a year, from member banks which make proper application to the Treasurer of the United States. In order to determine the amount any one reserve bank shall buy under section 18 in any one year, it is nec essary to allot to each bank its own proportionate share of the entire sum offered for sale through the Treasurer and deduct therefrom the amount of bonds bearing the circu lation privilege bought b y such bank in the open market within that year. A p r il 22, 1915. There are two separate and distinct methods provided in the Federal reserve act for the purchase by Federal Reserve Banks of Government bonds. Under paragraph b of section 14 of the reserve act such banks are authorized to buy and sell bonds and notes of the United States in the open market. There is no restriction placed in that section upon the kind or amount of bonds eligible for purchase in that manner. The authority is absolute and unlimited except in so far as the Federal Reserve Board may make restrictions under its powers to regulate such purchases. Sir : If, therefore, a Federal Reserve Bank receives acceptances for discount under the provisions of section 13 in the manner indicated above, such paper may be used as collateral for Federal reserve notes. The sole requirement is that the collateral shall be notes and bills—terms which are broad enough to include acceptances Under the provisions of section 18 the Board in this connection— accepted for rediscount may, in its discretion, require the Federal under the provisions of section 13. The fact Reserve Banks to purchase United States bonds bearing the circulation privilege up to an amount not to exceed $25,000,000 a year from member banks which have made application for such sale with the Treasurer of the United States. This section becomes effective Decem ber 23, 1915. When bonds are offered for sale in this man ner each Federal Reserve Bank may be re quired or permitted to purchase such propor tion thereof as its capital and surplus bears to the aggregate capital and surplus of all Fed eral Reserve Banks: Provided, however, That if a Federal Reserve Bank has acquired bonds under section 4 within the same year then such bank shall deduct the amount thus acquired from its proportionate share of the allotment in order to determine the actual amount to be purchased by such bank. Should the bonds acquired by a Federal Reserve Bank under the general authority of section 4 to exercise powers prescribed in the act—-or, more specifically, bonds acquired in the open market under section 14—-exceed the amount to which such bank would be entitled under the proportionate allotment, then it can not be required or permitted to purchase any of the bonds offered for sale undfcr section 18. The disqualification of this particular bank however, would have no effect on the rights and obligations of the other Federal Reserve Banks. Each bank is apportioned a certain definite percentage, determined by the propor tion which its capital and surplus bears to the aggregate capital and surplus of all the Federal Reserve Banks, and each individual bank must, if directed by the Board, purchase this, amount, no more and no less, unless it can be shown that it has acquired bonds under sec tion 4 in the manner previously indicated. It is clear that this $25,000,000 limitation imposed by section 18 refers only to those bonds offered for sale by member banks through the Treasurer and has no effect whatever on the continuing power of the Federal Reserve Banks to purchase bonds up to any amount in open market. The only consideration to be given in this connection to bonds bought in the open market is that they are merely one of the elements in determining the amount of bonds which Federal Reserve Banks may be required or permitted to buy under section 18. It might be noted that there is no specific provision in section 4 for the purchase of any Government bonds, but, in enumerating the powers of a Federal Reserve Bank, under para graph 7, it is provided that it has authority— To exercise by its board of directors, or duly authorized officers or agents, all powers spe cifically granted by the provisions of this act and such incidental powers as shall be neces sary to carry on the business of banking within the limitations prescribed by this act, and the reference in section 18 to bonds ac quired under, section 4 evidently contemplated bonds purchased in the open market under this general authority to exercise the powers specif ically conferred by section 14, since there is no other provision in section 4 which can be said to relate to the purchase of bonds. This might raise the question whether 3 per cent bonds, or bonds not bearing the circula tion privilege, bought under section 14, should be included in determining the amount of bonds to be purchased by each bank under section 18. This conclusion does not seem necessary, because it is not believed that bonds not bear ing the circulation privilege were intended to be considered in making the deduction which is to determine this amount. Section 18 is intended only to afford a market for bonds bearing the circulation privilege, and the pur pose there manifested is to provide a means for the absorption of such bonds by Federal Reserve Banks. The fact that a Reserve Bank may have bought 3 per cent bonds not bearing the circulation privilege in the open market has no relation to and could not be intended to be considered in connection with this question of the absorption or concentra tion of bonds having that privilege. To summarize: In order to determine the amount any one reserve bank may be required or permitted to buy under section 18, take the entire sum offered for sale in this manner, allot to each bank its proportionate share, and deduct therefrom the amount of bonds bearing the circulation privilege bought by such bank in the open market within the year. Let X equal the amount to be bought by Reserve Bank A, then r Capital and' surplus of A. [Total = am ount X <Aggr egate capital and [for sale. surplus of all . banks. X { Am ount of bonds bearing circula tion privilege bought in open market by A . within the year. Respectfully, To Hon. C. S. M. C. E lliott, Counsel. H amlin , Governor Federal Reserve Board. Exchange o f two per cent bonds for one-year gold notes and three per cent bonds. That part of section 18 which provides that the Secre tary of the Treasury m upon application of any Federal ay, Reserve Bank approved by the Board, issue, in exchange for 2 per cent bonds, one-year gold notes and 3 per cent bonds, the gold notes not to exceed one-half of the 2 per cent bonds offered for exchange, becom effective at es once and not after tw years fromthe passage of the act, a o s is provided for other paragraphs of section 18. January 4, 1915. Sir : I have your letter of January 2 and have carefully examined that part of section 18 of the Federal reserve act which relates to the exchange of United States bonds with the cir culating privilege for one-year gold notes of the United States and 30-year 3 per cent gold bonds without the circulating privilege. After analyzing this whole section and after considering all the circumstances I am inclined to the view that technically the Federal Re serve Board has the right at this time to author ize this exchange and that the opening sentence of this section making certain provisions effect-, ive only after two years from the passage of the act, does not relate to the provision under con sideration. As heretofore advised the power to purchase bonds having the circulation privilege and to issue national currency against such bonds is specifically given to the Federal Reserve Banks by other sections of the act. When section 18 was incorporated in the act it was originally intended, as its title implies, to provide a method for gradually refunding bonds held at the time by the various national banks. This matter was very carefully considered by the committee of the House and the committee of the Senate and a number of plans were sub mitted having for their object the ultimate re tirement of national bank circulation and the substitution of other notes. At the time of the passage of the act there was approximately $750,000,000 in national bank circulation out standing. The bonds securing this circulation mature at the pleasure of the United States Government after 30 years from the date of issue, and it was accordingly estimated that if the Federal Reserve Banks could acquire a minimum of $25,000,000 a year, they would have in their possession at the maturity of these bonds approximately the entire issue, and the Government would have to deal only with the Federal Reserve Banks instead of with the several thousand national banks in refunding such bonds. It was recognized, however, that unless the national banks desired to retire their circu lation the Federal Reserve Banks would be unable to procure the bonds, and this method was provided of having those national banks desiring to retire the whole or any part of their circulation make application through the Treasurer to sell the bonds for their account, and the Federal Reserve Board was empowered to require Federal Reserve Banks to purchase bonds so offered, and, as suggested by you, it was originally contemplated that the Federal Reserve Banks should thereupon be required to issue Federal Reserve Bank notes against such bonds. In view of the arguments presented to the committee that this circulation becomes re dundant at certain times, it was later deter mined to permit the exchange of bonds thus acquired with the circulating privilege for ob ligations of the United States without the cir culating privilege. As stated, this section was originally in tended to deal only with the bonds acquired from national banks desiring to retire in whole or in part their national-bank circulation. The section was amended, however, in con ference, so that it now provider— (a) For the issuance of Federal Reserve Brink notes against bonds acquired under other provisions of the act as well as against bonds acquired under this section; and (i) For the exchange of . any United States 2 per cent gold bonds bearing the circulation privilege, but against which no circulation is outstanding for one-year gold notes of the United States without the circulation privi lege to an amount not to exceed one-half of the 2 per cent bonds so tendered for exchange and the 30-year 3 per cent gold bonds, without the circulating privilege, for the remainder of the bonds so tendered. It is significant that in the first two para graphs of this section in referring to the bonds which the Federal Reserve Banks may be re quired to purchase, Congress uses-the words' “ such bonds,” manifestly referring to bonds which a national bank desires to sell through the Treasurer in order to reduce its circulation. In the fifth paragraph of this section, how ever, it is provided: States bonds with the circulating privilege, against which no circulation is outstanding, would seem to indicate that the Federal Re serve Board may, in its discretion, authorize the exchange of any such bonds bearing this privilege acquired in any manner by the Federal Reserve Banks, provided such bonds are not deposited as security for circulating notes. Respectfully, M . C . E l l i o t t , Counsel. To Hon. S. H a m l i n , .Governor Federal Reserve Board. Ch arles Rights of Member Banks in Northern New Jersey. Member blanks located in that part of New Jersey which is to be transferred from the Philadelphia district to the New York district not later than July 1,1915, remain mem bers of the Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia until the transfer is actually effected, and as such are entitled to all the privileges extended other members of that bank. All rediscounts made for member banks located in the region to be transferred may be held b y the Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia until they mature, even though the date of maturity is subsequent to July 1,1915, or they may be rediscounted with the Federal Reserve Bank of New York. M a y 21, 1915. Upon the deposit with the Treasurer of the Sir : As requested, I have read and consid United States of bonds so purchased or any bonds with the circulating privilege acquired ered the attached letter from the Federal Re under section 4 of this act, any Federal reserve serve Bank of Philadelphia, dated May 5, 1915, bank * * * shall be entitled to re ceive * * * circulating notes * * * equal submitting the following inquiry: In case any banks in northern New Jersey in amount to the par value of the bonds so de posited. apply to us for rediscounts between now and July 1 ,1 would inquire whether, in your judg In this paragraph the section for the first ment, we should accommodate them, and I time refers to bonds other than those acquired would also inquire whether it would be satis from banks desiring to reduce their circulation, factory to let us carry any rediscounts which and in the following paragraph the language of we may have for northern New Jersey banks which mature after July 1 until the notes the act is— run off. Upon application of any Federal reserve While the order has not yet been formally bank, approved by the Federal Reserve Board, entered, it is my understanding that the trans the Secretary of the Treasury may issue in exchange for United States 2 per cent gold fer of membership from Philadelphia to New bonds bearing the circulation privilege, but York of those banks located in the district to against which no circulation is outstanding be assigned to New York is to be made not later one-year gold notes, etc. than July 1. This being true, the banks in The failure, therefore, to restrict this para northern New Jersey will continue to be mem graph by any qualifying clause as to the bonds bers of the Federal Reserve Bank of Philadel which may be exchanged other than the quali phia until that time and will be entitled to any fication that they shall be 2 per cent United privileges extended to other members. As to the rediscounts carried at the time that such banks cease to be members of the Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia, while the act makes no specific provision in regard to this situation, I can see no legal objection to the Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia continuing to hold such rediscounts until they mature. Where a member bank rediscounts with a Federal Reserve Bank eligible paper held by it, the Federal Reserve Bank becomes the owner of such paper and the member bank is contingently liable as indorser. This being true, there would seem to be no justification for assuming that a change in the status of a mem ber bank in its relation to the Federal Reserve Bank should in any way affect the legality of such rediscounts. For example, if a member bank should go into liquidation, the Federal Reserve Bank would have the right to hold and collect any rediscounts held by it and would have a claim against the estate of such liquidating bank for any loss suffered, under the contract of the indorser. I am of the opinion, therefore, that the Fed eral Reserve Bank of Philadelphia will be fully justified under the law in extending the privi lege of rediscount to the banks referred to as long as they remain members of that bank, and that any rediscounts held at the time when they cease to be members may be retained until col lected, or they may be rediscounted by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York for the Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia. This latter course would from many aspects seem to be the more desirable since in this case ad justment at maturity by payment or by sub stitution of other paper could be arranged directly with the Federal Reserve Bank of New York and it would be unnecessary for the Fed eral Reserve Bank of Philadelphia to send on for collection any rediscounts held. Respectfully, M. C. E lliott, Counsel. To Hon. Charles S. H amlin, Governor Federal Reserve Board. by a change in the geographical limits of his district which results in m aking him a resident of another district. May 11, 1915. This office has been requested to give an opinion on the question of whether or not Mr. La Monte, one of the class C directors ap pointed by the Board for the Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia, may continue to serve after that part of New Jersey in which he re sides has been transferred to district No. 2. Section 4 of the Federal reserve act provides in part that— Class C directors shall be appointed by the Federal Reserve Board. They shall have been for at least two years residents of the district for which they are appointed. Mr. La Monte had been for W o years a resi dent of district No. 3 at the time he was ap pointed. The question, therefore, arises whether the fact that after July 1 he will be a resident of district No. 2 renders him ineligible to com plete his term of office which expires January 1, 1915. The term “ residence” is not synonomous with that of “ domicile” or “ citizenship.” It has been defined by the courts as “ the abiding or dwelling in a place for some continuance of time. There must be a settled, fixed abode or intention to remain permanently at least for a time, for business or other purposes, to consti tute a residence.” (See American and English Encyclopedia, vol. 24, p. 693, for collec tion of cases.) It is, however, susceptible of various meanings which depend largely upon circumstances under which the term is used. Its definition has been held to be a mixed ques tion of law and fact. (Munroe v. Williams, 37 S. C. 81.) The term “ to reside” was held in the case of People v. Owens, 29 Colo. 535, to have different meanings as used in different parts of the same instrument. In order, therefore, to determine the sig nificance to be given to that part of the act above quoted, it is necessary to consider the context and the purpose of this requirement. The class C directors are selected by the Federal Reserve Board but as directors have Qualifications o f Federal Reserve Bank Directors. A director possessing necessary qualifications at the time the same powers and duties as directors of of his election is not m ade ineligible to serve out his term classes A and B. The qualification that such Si r : directors “ shall have been for two years resi dents of the district for which they are ap pointed” was manifestly incorporated in order that those selected should be familiar with the local conditions of such district. Mr. La Monte having been qualified in this respect at the time of his election there would seem to be no reason for declaring him ineligible to serve out his term because his residence after July 1 may be technically said to be in district No. 2 instead of district No. 3. The act does not provide in terms nor by necessary implication that a director shall con tinue throughout his term of office to be a resident of the district in which the Federal Reserve Bank is located, and there does not appear to be any reason for,assuming that this technical change in Mr. La Monte’s residence can in any way prove prejudicial to the inter ests of the Federal Reserve Bank of Philadel phia. I am, therefore, of the opinion that he may legally continue to serve as a class C director until January 1, 1916. Respectfully, M. C. E lliott, Counsel. To Hon. Charles S. H amlin , Governor Federal Reserve Board. Federal Reserve Banks as Collecting Agents. Although there is no express provision in the Federal reserve act authorizing a Federal Reserve Bank to act a s agent for another Federal Reserve Bank in the collection of bills, notes, etc., nevertheless section 4, subsection 7, in granting the right to exercise “ incidental powers,” impliedly authorizes this pow the collection of bills, er, notes, etc., being incidental to the pow to receive de er posits, as authorized by section 13. D ecember 30, 1914. Sir : I have your letter of the 30th instant, in which you ask for an opinion on the followinp questions: Whether or not a Federal Reserve Bank is empowered under the provision of the Federal reserve act to act as agent for another Federal Reserve Bank in the collection of maturing notes, drafts, bills of exchange and other evi dences of debt purchased under the provisions of the act by the Federal Reserve Bank, which items are payable within the district of the Federal Reserve Bank to which they are sent. The exercise of this power would require the collecting bank to act as agent for the forwarding bank in the collection of the items mentioned in your letter sinfce, in such case under the uniform decisions of the court, the agency continues until the items are collected. This right is not specifically included in the powers oHihe Federal Reserve Banks enumer ated in the Federal reserve act. Section 13, in dealing with the subject of collections, pro vides: Any Federal Reserve Bank may receive from any of its member banks, and from the United States, deposits of current funds in lawful money, national-bank notes, Federal reserve notes, or checks and drafts upon solvent mem ber banks, payable upon presentation; or, solely for exchange purposes, may receive from other Federal Reserve Banks deposits of current funds in lawful money, national-bank notes, or checks and drafts upon solvent mem ber of other Federal Reserve Banks, payable upon presentation. It will be observed that the language used in the section above qu6ted does not specifically include notes, drafts and bills of exchange but Federal Reserve Banks are authorized to re ceive deposits of current funds in lawful money, national-bank notes, or checks and drafts upon solvent member or other Federal Reserve Banks, payable upon presentation. The question therefore arises, whether or not such notes, drafts, and bills of exchange may be accepted by Federal Reserve Banks in the capacity of agent for other Federal Reserve Banks and the determination of this question is dependent upon whether or not this power may be said to be incidental to those powers which are specifically granted. Section 4, sub section 7, of the Federal reserve act, in defining some of the corporate powers of Federal Re serve Banks, reads as follows: To exercise by its board of directors, or duly authorized officers or agents, all powers spe cifically granted by the provisions of this act, and such incidental powers as shall be neces sary to carry on the business of banking within the limitations prescribed by this act. This language is substantially similar to the language used in section 5136 of the Revised Statutes which deals with the corporate powers of national banks. Section 7 of this section reads as follows: To exercise by its board of directors or duly authorized officers or agents, subject to law, all such incidental powers as shall be necessary to carry on the business of banking; by discount ing and negotiating promissory notes, drafts, bins of exchange, and other evidences of debt; by receiving deposits; by buying and selling exchange, coin, and bullion; by loaning money on personal security; and by obtaining, issuing, and circulating notes according to the pro visions of this title. It will be observed that in defining the powers of national banks, as well as in defining the powers^ of Federal Reserve Banks, Congress has not specifically authorized such banks to act as agent for other banks. The powers enum erated, however, in both instances, are what may be termed contractural powers of a Fed eral Reserve Bank or a national bank; that is to say, the act defines and limits under what conditions such banks may become indebted to others or may permit others to become indebted to such banks. In the matter of collection of items mentioned in your letter, however, the relation of debtor and creditor is not established as between the forwarding bank and the collecting bank until the item sent for collection is actually collected; and where the instructions of the forwarding bank are to collect and remit the bank receiving such items has this single duty to perform and the proceeds are not credited to the forwarding bank after collection but are remitted to such bank. If the instructions accompanying such items are to collect and credit, then the collect ing bank collects from the drawee of the draft or the obligor of the note funds which it may re ceive on deposit, and, consequently, when its agency terminates it exercises a power spe cifically granted to it, namely, the power to re ceive deposits. Accordingly, it seems clear that the collection of items referred to by you may be said to be incidental to the power to re ceive deposits. Banks very generally act as agents for other banks in making collections of this sort and the right of national banks to perform this duty has, so far as I have been able to learn, never been questioned; on the contrary, there are a number of cases holding that in the matter of collection of items banks, as stated, act only as agents until the item has been actually col lected. This is true even in the case of deposit of checks by individuals with national banks. The courts have held that even though credit may be given in the pass book for the check upon its deposit, the bank continues as the agent of the depositor until the check has been collected. It seems to me, therefore, that unless as a matter of policy the Board determines that the Federal Reserve Banks are not ready to act as collecting agents for other Federal Reserve Banks in the collection of the items enumerated by you, there is no reason why this power should not be exercised without exceeding the corporate powers granted jby statute, and those incidental to the specific powers granted. Respectfully, M. C. E lliott, Counsel. To Hon. Charles S. H amlin , Governor Federal Reserve Board. GENERAL BUSINESS CONDITIONS. General business and banking conditions are described in reports made by Federal reserve agents for the 12 Federal reserve districts. Below are given in detail digests of condi tions in the various districts substantially as reported by Federal reserve agents. D IS T R IC T N O . 1— B O S T O N . Since the 1st of the month there has been a slight hardening tendency in the money market, but this is largely due to the hesitation of banks to invest their money too closely rather than to any appreciable decrease in the supply. A comparison, however, of the statements of the Boston Clearing House shows an increase in loans over the previous month and a decrease in due from reserve agents. The country bank situation is much the same, and those banks are still rediscounting to a considerable extent and show very little change in their condition from the previous month. The savings-bank deposits in this district continue showing in creases, which is an evidence of better business conditions. Money rates are as follows: Banks commer cial customers up to six months, 4 to 4J per cent, with some exceptions below 4 per cent; demand loans to brokers, 3 per cent; note brokers’ commercial paper, 3J to 4J per cent, largely 4 per cent; year notes, 4J per cent; savings-bank mortgages, 4£ to 5 per cent; 90day bank acceptances, 2J to per cent; town notes, 3 to 3J per cent; Boston bank rates to country banks, 4 per cent; Federal Reserve Bank of Boston rates, 4 per cent up to 60 days, 4J per cent 60 to 90 days. Exports and imports for the port of Boston for the month of April are as follows: Imports, free, $15,219,245; dutiable, $2,786,559. Ex ports, domestic, $10,577,596; foreign, $12,586. There is a general feeling of optimism in all lines of business in this district, and a slight improvement in most lines, with the possible exception of the shoe and leather trade. Foreign government orders are reported to be coming into this market almost daily and trades directly influenced are doing a good business. The situation in the shoe and leather trade has not improved to any noticeable extent since last month. In all sections, very limited trade is reported from regular domestic sources and while the general outlook is for improve ment, no marked improvement has yet mani fested itself. In this trade war orders are still the principal factor. There has been considerable improvement in the wool and woolen industries over the past month and, in fact, even apart from war orders the general situation seems to be improved somewhat, both from the mill end as well as in goods, and the general situation in this line is ahead of a year ago. This is noticeably so in worsteds, which have been dull for several months. The cotton-mill situation seems to be^lightly but steadily improving. Most of the mills are running on full time and while the volume of business is reported to be satisfactory there is still room for an improvement in profits, although many mills are reporting a satis factory profit, having purchased their raw material at lower rates than the present market. D IS T R IC T N O . 2— N E W Y O R K . Throughout New York State farmers, fruit growers, and dairymen anticipate a good season. Factories producing goods for do mestic use are not busy and new orders come in slowly. The manufacture of war supplies continues above capacity and is extending to plants normally engaged otherwise, thus partly offsetting slack domestic trade. Shipments from the port of New York since January 1 are $112,000,000 ahead of the corre sponding period last year. Builders, realestate and renting agents find business better. Textiles, dry goods, and mercantile lines gener ally are in better demand, but it is evident that domestic markets of nearly all kinds, while improving in tendency, are subject to the ups and downs in sentiment as the European war continues. The number of unemployed is substantially reduced, but many are still out of work. Figures of new incorporations compared with recent years show a considerable falling off. Failures in this district since the first of the year compared with the same period last year havfc increased 50 per cent in number and 56 per cent in amount. There is less activity in the stock market. Excess reserves of the New York Clearing House banks on May 15 were $173,000,000, an increase of $3,000,000 since May 1. During the same period deposits decreased $4,000,000 and loans $2,000,000. Demand for loans is gener ally light. Rates continue at 3 J to 4 per cent for the best commercial paper. D IS T R IC T N O . 3— P H IL A D E L P H IA . War orders and their influence are un doubtedly helping many industries. General trade, however, upon which in the long run we must depend for our prosperity, is still dull and much below normal. Collections are fair. Re tail trade is picking up in some lines, due to less unemployment and to increasing working hours giving increased purchasing power to labor, and also to favorable weather conditions. On the whole, in district No. 3, business is hesitating and concerned over the outlook. Some lines, producing for domestic consumption, are im proving very slowly. Rates for money are easy and loanable funds are plentiful, both call and time money being quoted at from 3J to 4 per cent; the supply of commercial paper is limited, and a moderate amount is being sold at from 3£ to 4J per cent. The outlook is so uncertain there seems to be a disposition on the part of financial institutions not to lock up their funds in long-time invest ments. Short maturities are readily taken, but there is little demand for longer dates. Be cause of trade conditions and depression a large excess of reserves is reported \fy the banks. A general spirit of caution and economy still per sists on the part of producers and consumers of goods and of investors. Evidence of recovery is given by the decrease in the number of idle cars and increasing freight business by the railroads, the placing of fair sized railroad equipment orders) and the ready sale under unfavorable conditions of the Argen tine loan and a large bond issue for the Penn sylvania Railroad. The effect of the war is most conspicuous in the iron and steel industries, and improvement continues. The Delaware River shipyards are running at full capacity. The automobile trade is brisk. The anthracite coal output is slightly under last month’s record production, while the bituminous output is not up to normal. Building operations are increasing, but the lumber business has fallen off. Paints, chem icals, drugs, and wall-paper industries are good and improving. The hardware business and sales of electrical supplies continue to increase. Leather is quiet, with prices high and firm; footwear is very quiet, with small sales. In wearing apparel (in cluding knit goods, underwear, and dress goods) manufacturers are fairly busy, with the excep tion of men’s and boys’ clothing. The dyestuffs situation is still critical with cloth, carpet, and rug mills, and business in these lines is poor. Cotton-trade conditions are unsettled, while cotton spinners report increased business. Wool and woolen yarns are much below normal. Silk mills are running full. Crop conditions are reported good and the outlook satisfactory. D IS T R IC T N O . 4— C L E V E L A N D Improvement of conditions in district No. 4, as reported in April, is being held, but no addi tional advance is noted. While our advices seem to indicate no recession in business, there is a slight pause, with fewer orders for new business. Pay rolls are approximately the same as a month ago. Steel mills are running about 5 per cent increase of ingot capacity over 30 days ago. Now that the transportation companies, which consume onethird of the total tonnage of finished iron and steel in the United States, have come back into the market, the indications are that a normal degree of activity should continue in that trade for some months. The lake season opened a little later than usual, and now that the accumulation of grain in the Northwest has been brought on, it is found there are more vessels than can be sup plied with grain, ore, and coal tonnage. Some independent lake carriers will be compelled to dock a number of their vessels unless these conditions improve. conditions show material improvement over those of three months ago. The demand for bank credit is very quiet and modest in amount, with the result that local institutions are apparently comfortably able to care for it without recourse to borrow ing. Bank loans as a whole reflect mofe a desire to shift transactions already open than The settlement of the coal strike in eastern a demand for fresh credit. Manufacturers and exporters of goods for Ohio, permitting the return to work of 14,000 miners, is a favorable item in the coal trade, war purposes are, of course, an exception to the general rule. Diplomatic developments, but prices are still unsatisfactory. The marked decrease in idle cars and the in apparently, have had no effect either upon creased volume of railroad traffic, east of Chi credit conditions or the; demand for funds, for cago are items of improvement in the railroad which fact it is possible the presence of the Federal reserve act may in large measure be situation. The business situation in the extreme south responsible. ern part of this district is not participating in the general improvement throughout the dis D IS T R IC T N O . 6— A T L A N T A . trict, except in certain lines having war orders. Conditions in the sixth district are generally Weather conditions still continue to favor a good. The outlook is brighter than at any normal crop of farm products. time since the European war began. Money has a firmer tendency, but there has Collections are good over the district and the been no increase in rates. banks report a considerable decrease in re newal of paper. The city banks have ample D IS T R IC T N O . 5— R IC H M O N D . loanable funds and are seeking loans. In the There has been very little change in general mercantile lines, owing to the fact that jobbers business conditions in the fifth reserve district and wholesalers did a small volume of business during May. Agriculturally, the month was during the past fall and winter, it has had a one of preparation. Hope for the future has marked effect on the decreased demand for been increased in the presence of timely rains loans. However, commercial men report trade and the knowledge that the close of the plant good; that the merchants’ stocks are somewhat ing season shows that there is material diversi depleted, and jobbers and wholesalers are look fication, especially in sections heretofore al ing forward to heavy buying in the summer and most entirely given over to cotton. The recent fall. The clearings in Atlanta show, for the softening in the price of this staple has some first time this year, a slight increase over the what checked liquidation, which however had same time one year ago. proceeded far enough to be of great help not The cotton mills of the district are running only to the debtors themselves but to their full force, and many overtime, with heavy or creditor jobbers and merchants. Economy ders on hand. Reports indicate conditions seems to be the watchword, and its practice, rapidly assuming normal in the Birmingham while ultimately most beneficial to consumers, iron district. has not contributed to the profits of those min The naval-stores line appears rather slow in istering to their wants. regaining former prices, although the move In consequence, most lines, including re ment is very good. Railroad conditions are im tailers, report in comparison with last year this proving, but rather slowly. Pay rolls of the time, a materially diminished volume of busi various industrial and manufacturing concerns ness, although from almost every direction are, generally speaking, normal. Agricultural conditions appear exceedingly bright, but with a decreased cotton acreage and quite a large reduction in the use of ferti lizers. Seasonable weather is now prevailing following an unusually dry spring. D IS T R IC T J N O . 7— C H IC A G O . Trade development in the seventh district in May has been favorable. Moderate im provement is jnoticed in the leading industries, especially iron and steel and the [metal-working branches, and at more satisfactory prices. The continuation jof the serious (labor troubles in the building trades at Chicago is a depressing factor there. Movements of crude materials and finished products of factories]show^steady gain. The outlook for manufacturers, as a whole, is regarded as improved. Distributive operations maintain their re cent advance. The jobbing centers report increasing orders, with dry goods and collateral lines most active at Chicago. Retail trade'Jhas responded to more settled weather conditions at interior points. Winter wheat now promises a record-break ing crop, with widespread rainfall improving soil conditions over a large area of the grain belt. All agricultural products continue in demand at unusually profitable prices to grow ers, despite lessened spot demands (from Europe. A portion of the fruit district in Michigan was injured by a few nights of low temperature, grapes suffering most. Money conditions remain easy. Commer cial paper rates range from to 4 per cent, with offerings readily absorbed. Bank clear ings indicate slight gains. D IS T R IC T N O . 8— S T . L O U IS . General business conditions in this district, especially in the larger cities and manufactur ing centers, while still below normal, indicate a continued though slow improvement. The manufacturing industries, except those affected by war orders, show less improvement than the general jobbing interests. Crop conditions throughout the district con tinue favorable, although the rainfall for April was below the average and added to the de ficiency for the }^ear. There was enough, however, to allow the breaking of ground and the planting of crops, so that, given sufficient rainfall during the next two months, there is every indication that the harvest will be abundant. Wheat acreage has been mate rially increased, especially in the cotton States; in some districts more than 100 per cent. The fruit crop is reported for the most part in excellent shape. There is still little demand for money. This district, particularly the Southern States, has gone through a period of enforced liquidation, and it seems there will be no great demand for funds until after the harvest. Banks as a general rule, hold reserves largely in excess of their legal requirements and are seeking outlets for their surplus funds. There is little com mercial paper of the best names available in St. Louis, but what there is is quoted at 3J to 4 per cent. The bank loan rate in St. Louis is about 5 per cent. Bank loans are quoted out side of St. Louis and Louisville at 6J to 8 per cent. D IS T R IC T N O . 9— M IN N E A P O L IS . Cold and rainy weather, with a snowstorm on May 17, provoked some reports of damage to the Northwestern grain crop. Careful in vestigations in Minnesota and North and South Dakota indicate that the wheat crop has suffered no damage whatever and that injury from frost is confined to winter rye, flax just coming out of the ground, barley, and oats. On the whole the frost and snow is considered beneficial, as it has killed many of the weeds which are common to the grain fields, and it is not believed that the crop as a whole has suffered any appreciable injury. A small amount of seeding remains to be done in oats, barley, and flax. The last half of May will be mainly devoted to corn planting, which has been delayed by the rains and the cold weather. Weather conditions have been unusual, but have had an excellent effect in giving grain crops good root. Moisture conditions of the entire ninth district are excellent. Underlying business conditions of the entire Northwest are sound. Manufacturing is some what below normal, and the lumber business is off as compared with previous years. Mer chandising conditions in the local communities are normal and the distributing houses of the large cities are doing about the same business as in former years. There is no evidence of any real business depression, except in the northern Michigan iron-mining districts and on the iron ranges of northern Minnesota where conditions in the steel business have reflected themselves in a slowing down of mining opera tion^. Northern Minnesota prospects are con siderably better this season than a year ago, and there is some improvement in the outlook due to an increase in development work which results from the action of the steel corporation in resuming construction on the large steel plant which is soon to be opened near Duluth. Banks are in good condition and are meeting the demands upon them without difficulty. Business houses report that collections are fair to good throughout the entire district. There is considerable activity in the stock business of western North and South Dakota and Mon tana, the noticeable feature of which is the heavy buying of horses for export to Europe by English agents and heavy purchases of a somewhat lighter grade of horses by agents of the Italian Government. Quarantine condi tions, due to the hoof-and-mouth disease, have improved, permitting more active ship ments from local points to Omaha and Chicago markets. A healthy spirit of optimism prevails through out the district, and business men generally are looking forward to a period of good business. D ISTR ICT N O . 10—KANSAS CITY. This district probably was never in better condition so far as purely financial matters are concerned than at the present time. Banks throughout the district have an excess of loan able funds, and interest rates, generally speak ing, are below normal; in fact, many banks are resorting to the purchase of outside commercial paper in order to find employment for their surplus funds, whereas in times past they have experienced difficulty in meeting local de mands. "Crop conditions are promising, with an in creased acreage of wheat and other cereals. The recent ravages of the Hessian fly are likely to sharply reduce the yield of wheat, and may make a difference of millions of dollars. This loss, however, may be substantially offset by prices ruling higher than normal. Corn is now being planted, with weather and soil in perfect condition. Horticultural prospects are almost perfect, with every promise of an abundant yield. The live-stock market is active, with prices steady to strong, as is also the hog and sheep market. The lead and zinc mining industry, on ac count of record prices, is enjoying an unprece dented activity, while the coal-mining industry is normal for this season of the year. The retail and wholesale trade is not quite up to normal. Collections are slightly better than normal, except such small bills as are de pendent upon wages. Building operations are not as extensive as a year ago, and, as a conse quence, labor is not so fully employed. The harvest season now approaching will probably give employment to many who are now idle, and the present conditions, insofar as they are dependent upon wage earners, will undoubtedly improve. DISTRICT No. 11—DALLAS. This section of the country appears to have entered upon a period of lighter demand for funds. There is little evidence of the pressure which existed last fall. Wheat and oats will soon be coming into the market and the agri cultural promise is good. Higher prices for cotton and' sales of cattle, horses, and mules have brought large credits. These Jtiave liqui dated outstanding liabilities and in many cases left balances. In the extreme northeastern portion of Texas and lower Oklahoma agriculture is very prom ising. Bank deposits are large and grain crops will be heavy. Abundant rains have kept the pastures and live stock in good condition. Local commercial interests are fully up to nor mal, but industrial plants are more or less af fected by adverse conditions. Eastern Texas, aside from that portion al ready covered, has had some crop damage from too much rain. Crops here are rather back ward and there is demand for money. The lumber conditions are improving. Oil produc ers report a very low price for crude oil. Con ditions are on the whole improving. Bermuda onions are being shipped in large quantities from southern Texas. Oats are being harvested under ideal conditions. Corn promises a large yield, and cotton, while a little late, is growing rapidly. There is a rather active demand for money in western Texas. Alfalfa has just been cut for the first time, yielding a good crop. There is again activity in the mining section. Central Texas has suffered from too much rain, but on the whole agricultural conditions are promising. The wheat outlook is excel lent. Corn and cotton are in a favorable posi tion. shortly. Cattle and sheep interests are pros pering. Wool sales are being contracted for at good prices. The lumber industry shows no improvement, and it is much depressed. The petroleum industry is at least no more depressed than a few months ago. Copper mining is very active, and exports through Pacific coast ports are at record figures. An interesting incident has been the arrival of a 22,000-ton steamship from New York with a first-cabin list of 400 passengers. Credit conditions are easy throughout the district. From March 4 to May 1 deposits of national banks in the seven reserve cities gained $12,000,000. Savings bank deposits, likewise, show important gains. San Francisco hotels report exceptional bookings throughout the summer, indicating continuance of heavy travel. The general feeling seems to be one of mild optimism*. Discount Rates. Discount rate of each Federal reserve hank in effect on May 26, 1915. D ISTRICT N O . 12—SAN FRANCISCO. Federal reserve bank. Date of last change of rate. Maturi ties of 30 days and less. Maturi Maturi Agricul ties of ties of tural and over 30 over 60 live-stock days to days to 60 days, 90 days, paper over inclusive. inclusive. 90 days. Agricultural prospects throughout the twelfth district are exceptionally bright. Unusually late rains in California, while interfering to 4 3 4 4| 5 some extent with early fruits, have been of Boston................. Feb. 18 New Y o rk ........... Feb. 4 4 4 5 4 Philadelphia....... Jan. 28 4 43f 5 great benefit and assure large crops. In gen Cleveland............ Feb. 6 4 4 5 Richm ond........... Feb. 19 4£ 5 4£ eral, a large increase in grain acreage has been Atlanta................ Apr. 30 4 4 5 4£ 4 4 5 4i stimulated by the exceptional prices. A fine Chicago................ Jan. 23 4 St. L ouis............. Apr. 22 4 5 4£ 4 Minneapolis........ May 18 4 5 5 barley crop, estimated at 1,000,000 bags, is Kansas C ity....... Jan. 28 4 4 4* 5i 4 Dallas.................. Feb. 4 4 5 4£ now being harvested in the Imperial Valley. San Francisco___ May 8 4 6 3^ 4£ Early fruits, berries, and vegetables are going Anthorized rate for acceptances 2 to 4 per cent. to market in steadily increasing volume. A On M arch 10 the Federal Reserve Board fixed the fol considerable balance of the navel orange crop low ing rates for rediscounts betw een Federal reserve is being marketed at advancing prices, and the banks: 3£ per cent for m aturities of 30 days and less; 4 per Valencia orange crop will begin to move cent for m aturities of over 30 days to 90 days, inclusive. Resources and liabilities o f each o f the 12 Federal Reserve Banks and o f the Federal Reserve System at close o f business on Fridays, Apr. SO to May 21. [In thousands of dollars.] RESOURCES: Boston. Gold coin and certificates: Apr. 30....................... May 7......................... May 14....................... May 21.......... ............. Legal tender notes, silver certificates, and subsid iary coin: Apr. 30...... ............... May 7......................... May 14....................... May 21.................... Bills discounted, and loans: a Apr. 30.*.................... May 7......................... May 14....................... May 21....................... Investments: & Apr. 30....................... May 7......................... May 14...-.................. May 21....................... Due from other Federal Reserve Banks, net: Apr. 30....................... May 7......................... May 14....................... May 21....................... All other resources: Apr. 30....................... May 7......................... May 14....................... May 21....................... Total resources: Apr. 30....................... May 7......................... May 14....................... May 21....................... New York. $15,935 17,148 16,548 16,025 $91,940 95,804 96,824 98,643 1,269 1,106 1,130 1,238 15,321 21,239 24,726 25,487 Cleve Rich land. mond. Atlanta. Chicago. Phila delphia. $16,865 $16,170 16,904 17,532 16,589 17,303 18,430 17,329 3,944 3,651 3,579 3,247 729 746 742 741 $8,399 8,026 7,708 7,172 $4,745 5,027 4,705 4,485 53 75 79 96 $34,607 $10,382 34,360 10,905 34,567 10,905 35,858 10,912 470 245 197 2,213 2,383 2,536 2,359 6,118 5,501 4,851 4,189 2,104 1,907 1,655 1,443 1,934 1,369 1,116 1,043 6,943 6,775 6,877 7,191 1,899 1,844 2,050 2,195 8,130 9,360 9,408 9,666 2,129 2,354 2,359 2,403 1,980 2.329 2.329 2,424 1 1 1 531 15,792 8,494 4,045 667 852 1,667 459 550 453 781 1,079 3,148 2,006 3,098 2,102 21,866 140,458 142,404 142,952 140,956 211 22,934 23,576 22,896 2,288 4,570 3,712 3,516 $7,535 $10,715 7,608 11,214 7,618 11,043 7,426 11,050 1,214 1,178 1,183 1,215 517 476 477 478 7 8 4 6 1 2,297 2,131 1,845 1,750 730 787 825 1,016 814 860 758 758 981 1,032 1,046 1,292 6,457 6,637 6,766 6,806 4,780 4,661 4,447 4,361 953 998 998 1,012 1,659 1,689 1,689 1,689 199 246 : 409 . 424 25,908 25,914 26,258 26,406 Total for system. $7,885 $13,050 8,372 11,134 8,715 8,538 8,233 7,813 $238,228 244,034 241,063 243,376 5 19 19 26,518 34,021 36,561 36,832 701 708 713 575 22 5,229 5,432 5,963 6,030 2,443 2,602 2,816 3,194 1,041 1,076 1,076 1,076 ! 36,586 35,440 34,735 34,626 i ! j ! 1,211 1,996 2,045 2,070 1,020 1,392 1,465 739 1,386 1,715 1,960 535 3,713 1,613 1,109 1,532 1,855 1,262 443 229 462 371 37 33 49 52 349 281 291 382 2,609 2,595 2,596 2,601 1,423 1,284 1,763 2,505 665 477. 367 294 650 669 647 306 15,433 15,930 16,106 15,977 11,083 11,600 11,355 11,399 48,258 50,828 53,199 52,144 15,811 16,684 17,529 17,922 10,845 11,313 11,183 11,393 13,904 14,467 14,289 14,202 14,387 14,737 15,266 14,922 11,334 9,175 11,971 11,648 17,398 16,428 , 16,151 ■ 16,195 572 225 52 84 9,468 10,139 13,215 6,650 689 j 677 1,456 ! 1,448 ; 165 671 747 1,220 25,469 28,284 28,721 29,342 1,100 1 1,648 | 481 790 976 928 21,737 22,995 22,928 22,836 i San Fran cisco. St. Minne Kansas Dallas. Louis. apolis. City. 347,603 361,093 366,266 362,474 a The amounts of bills discounted for member banks exclusive of acceptances were as follows: [In thousands of dollars.] Boston. New York. Phila- : Cleve delphia. land. . Apr. 30............................. May 7................................ May 14.............................. May 21.............................. $377 421 413 281 $382 408 403 422 Rich mond. Atlanta. Chicago. San Fran cisco. St. Minne Kansas Louis. apolis. City. Dallas. i j i $622 $735 729 642 i 592 ! 696 579 | 705 $6,943 6,775 6,877 7,191 $4,780 4,661 4,447 4,361 Total for system. 1 $760 747 798 865 $605 662 700 673 $419 506 504 536 $665 683 668 623 $1,257 ! 1,416 1,774 2,036 $5,229 5,432 5,963 6,030 $22,774 23,082 23,835 24,302 For amounts of acceptances held by the several Federal Reserve Banks, see p. 84. 6 “ Investments” comprise “ United States 2 per cent and 3 per cent bonds on hand,” also “ Other investments” (municipal warrants and kindred short term securities), as follows: [In thousands of dollars.] Boston. United States 2 per cent bonds............................ United States 3 per cent bonds............................ Total United States bonds on hand1_ _ Other investments (mu nicipal warrants): Apr. 30............................ May 7......................... May 14....................... May 21 ....................... New York. Phila delphia. Cleve- Rich Atlanta. Chicago. land. i mond. 1 j ! San St. . Minne- Kansas Louis, apolis. City. Dallas.; Francisco. i $2,525 $100 Iftft : $8,139 9,360 9,408 9,666 $2,129 2,354 2,359 2,403 1,880 2.229 2.229 1 2,324 j j i 242 ! 1,025 : 2,932 3,112 3,241 3,281 711 756 ; 756 770 | 1,000 $1 1 1 1 1 No change in figures between April 9 and May 21. j Total for system. : $1,025 3,525 i $1,899 1,844 2,050 2,195 $242 i ! 634 664 1 664 664 $930 .............. $991 $5,713 1,100 991 6,813 220 I ll ............ 1,005 146 ............ 146 ............; 1,054 1,079 146 ............ 18,656 21,471 21,908 22,529 930 .............. Resources and liabilities o f each o f the 12 Federal Reserve Banks and o f the Federal Reserve System at close o f business on Fridays, Apr. SO to May 21— Continued. LIABILITIES. i Reserve deposits: Apr. 30...................... May 7......................... May 14....................... May 21....................... Due to other Federal re serve banks—net: Apr. 30.........! ........... May 7....................... . May 14....................... May 21...................... . Federal reserve notes in circulation—net liabil ity: Apr. 30...................... May 7....................... . May 14....................... May 21....................... Capital paid in: Apr. 30...................... May 7....................... . May 14....................... May 21....................... All other liabilities: Apr. 30...................... May 7....................... . May 14....................... May 21....................... Total liabilities: Apr. 30..................... May 7....................... . May 14...................... May 21....................... $16,105 17,801 18,501 16,876 $131,472 129,444 127,864 128,962 $21,410 $17,102 19,726 17,036 20,034 16,958 20,179 16,859 2,312 352 f $7,927 7,755 7,928 8,249 $5,742 5,554 5,584 5,704 6,985 9,944 9,959 9,962 275 300 140,458 142,404 142,952 140,956 25,908 25,914 26,258 26,406 4,635 5,959 5,970 5,977 21,737 22,995 22,928 22,836 2,288 3,252 3,316 3,344 1,673 2,257 2,396 2,410 11,083 11,600 11,355 11,399 . . . 2,385 2,588 2,371 2,169 1 2,277 2,518 3,069 3,099 2,115 2,754 2,782 2,790 2,107 2,780 2,903 2,916 21 26 27 30 15,433 15,930 16,106 15,977 1 3,647 3,763 3,348 3,255 42 48 55 64 2,001 3,016 5,129 2,032 4,498 6,188 6,224 6,227 $7,618 $12,120 6,848 12,219 6,913 12,236 6,722 12,269 185 _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ i 3,449 4,781 4,800 4,804 $9,379 9,786 9,352 9,538 2,373 1,886 j 2,155 1,689 78 : 5,077 4,875 4,807 4,320 22,934 23,576 22,896 $8,951 8,968 8,809 9,010 37 41 99 916 21,866 $43,280 $13,726 44,269 13,910 46,598 14,746 45,536 15,134 4,900 6,559 6,601 6,608 2,085 2,774 2,783 2,788 1,894 2,345 2,374 2,383 2,238 315 . 11,038 11,197 11,224 10,859 3,040 3,894 3,915 3,926 15,811 16,684 17,529 17,922 10,845 11,313 11,183 11,393 13,904 14,467 14,289 14,202 14,387 14,737 15,266 14,922 39,669 53,487 54,023 54,135 2,064 3,093 5,496 2,442 3 10 16 48,258 50,828 53,199 52,144 $294,832 293,316 295,523 295,038 17,398 16,428 16,157 16,195 347,603 361,093 366,266 362,474 IN D E X Acceptances: Page. BankB authorized to acceptup to 100 per cen t. 71 Am ounts held by Federal reserve banks........... 84 Distribution of, b y classes of acceptors and siz e s.............................................................................. 84 Opinions of counsel of Federal Reserve Board— Continued. Exchange of 2 per cent bonds for one-year gold notes and 3 per cent bonds........ ................ R igh t of member banks in Address b y H on. W . P . G . H arding............................... 66-71 tors................................................................................ 103 Federal reserve banks as collecting agents------ 77 104 R edistricting d ecision.......................................... N o. 2 ............................................................................ 86 Banks in New Jersey transferred to district N o. 2 ................................... 1...................................... 86 Counties in Oklahoma transferred to district N o . 10.......................................................................... Banks in Oklahom a transferred 86 to district N o. 10 .............. 87 Counties in W est Virginia transferred to dis trict No. 4 ................................................................. 91 97 86 Banks in W est V irginia transferred to district N o. 4 ............................................................................ 98 85-91 Counties in New Jersey transferred to district I ll In effect A pril 2 6 ........................................................ Em ergency currency: Am ount outstanding.................................. 79 Distribution o f................................ ..............................80-81 Gold im ports and exports ................................................ 76-77 Gold settlem ent fu n d ................... 82-83 77 Governm ent rate for telegram s....................................... Inform al rulings of the board........... ................................ 72-75 Opinions of counsel of FederalReserve B o a rd .. . 91-105 Discount of acceptances based on im portation or exportation of goods......................................... Forward discount rates............................................. Discount of acceptances indorsed b y mem ber banks located in another d istrict...................... * Purchase of U nited States bonds b y Federal reserve banks............................................................. 102 Qualifications of Federal reserve bank direc Circulars and regulations.....................................................78-79 71 101 northern New J ersey .......................................................................... Business conditions, general........................... 106-112 Committees of the Board................................................ Discount rates: Form fo r ......................................................................... Page- 90 Resources and liabilities of Federal reserve banka. 112-113 Trustee powers, applications for, ap p roved .............. 99 83 W ork of the Board............................................................... 65 o