View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

FEDERAL RESERVE BANK
OF NEW YORK
Circular No. 10437 "I
March 4, 1991

[
AUTOMATED CLEARING HOUSE FEES
Modification to the ACH Participation Fee

To All Depository Institutions in the Second
Federal Reserve District, and Others Concerned:

The Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System has issued the following statement de­
ferring to July 1, 1991, the implementation of a new ACH participation fee that had previously been
scheduled to take effect on April 1, 1991:
The Federal Reserve Board has postponed the implementation of a new $10 monthly automated
clearing house (ACH) participation fee that had previously been scheduled to take effect on April 1,
1991.
The Board also has modified the manner in which the fee will be applied during 1991.
The new participation fee will become effective on July 1, 1991, and during the remainder of 1991
will apply only with respect to participant records that have commercial ACH volume in a given month.
These actions are being taken to address concerns raised by some institutions that they would not
be able to act on a sufficiently timely basis to avoid paying multiple participation fees beginning in April
1991.
Enclosed is a copy of the First Supplement to Appendix 2 to Operating Circular No. 10, which
reflects the revised implementation date for the new monthly ACH participation fee, and which su­
persedes the ACH fee schedules that were issued with our Circular No. 10417, dated December 21,
1990. (Items other than the $10.00 ACH participant fee, included therein, have not been revised).
Also, printed on the reverse side hereof is the text o f the Board’s notice in this matter, which
has been reprinted from the Federal Register o f February 20, 1991. Questions regarding this matter
and other provisions of Operating Circular No. 10 may be directed to Andrew Heikaus, Manager,
Funds Transfer Department (Tel. No. 212-720-5561).




E. G e r a l d C o r r i g a n ,

President.
(O V E R )

FED ER A L RESERVE SYSTEM

[Docket No. R—0710]
Federal R eserve Fees fo r A u to m ated
Clearing House Service; M o difications
to th e ACH P articipation Fee

Board of Governors of the
Federal Reserve System.
ACTION: Modification to the ACH fee
schedule.
AGENCY:

The Board is delaying the
implementation of a new $10 monthly
ACH participation fee that had
previously been scheduled to take effect
on April 1,1991 and is modifying the
manner in which the fee will be applied
during 1991. These actions are being
taken to address concerns raised by
some institutions that they would not be
able to act on a sufficiently timely basis
to avoid paying multiple participation
fees beginning in April 1991. The new
participation fee will become effective
on July 1,1991, and during the remainder
of 1991 will apply only with respect to
participant records that have
commercial ACH volume in a given
month.
EFFECTIVE d a t e : The ACH participation
fee becomes effective July 1,1991.
summary:

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:

Louise L. Roseman, Assistant Director
(202/452-3874), Gayle Brett, Manager
(202/452-2934), or Scott Knudson, Senior
Financial Services Analyst (202/4523959), Division of Reserve Bank
Operations and Payment Systems; for
the hearing impaired only:
Telecommunications Device for the
Deaf, Dorothea Thompson (202/4523544).
On
October 31,1930, the Board approved
the introduction of a.monthly
participation fee for the automated
clearing house (ACH) service. (55 FR
46720, November 6,1990) Under the new
fee structure, the Reserve Banks would
assess a monthly fee of $10 for each
commercial ACH participant
(represented by a routing number on the
ACH Customer Information File (CIF)),
beginning on April 1,1991.1 This fixed
monthly fee is designed to recover costs
that are influenced by the number of
participants rather than by volume.
These costs include accounting—related
costs, such as billing and settlement, the
costs of providing statistical reports, and
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

1 Also effective April 1. the Board approved a
decrease in the interdistrict per item transaction fee
and an increase in the fees for processing return
items.




the costs of maintaining routing numbers
on the CIF.
Since the announcement of the new
fee, several depository institutions and
ACH associations have raised concens
about the ability of many institutions to
reduce the number of routing numbers
before the April 1 effective date in order
to avoid paying multiple participation
fees. These difficulties are related to the
apparent time it takes for the
commercial ACH notification of change
(NOC) process to reroute ACH
payments to a different routing number
and the need to monitor routing numbers
for payment activity for a number of
months to ensure that they are indeed
dormant. A number of depository
institutions have a large number of
routing numbers on the ACH CIF; many
of these numbers are inactive or support
only minimal volume.
The Reserve Banks have made
information available to depository
institutions on the routing numbers
included on the CIF together with the
recent volume associated with each
routing number. Even though some
institutions have begun efforts to reduce
the number of routing numbers by
sending NOCs to originators of
payments, these institutions have
indicated that payments may continue
to be sent to these routing numbers for
some time. Some depository institutions
have indicated reluctance to eliminate
these routing numbers even after taking
action to reroute payments because they
cannot be assured that the originator
has complied with NOC instructions
u n til th e n e x t p a y m e n t c y c l e has b e e n
completed. Due to the infrequent nature
of some payments, this process may be
quite lengthy.
In order to address these concerns,
the Board is delaying the
implementation of the participation fee
until July 1,1991. The July 1,
implementation date will provide
depository institutions that have
multiple routing numbers on the CIF
additional time to migrate commercial
ACH transactions to a fewer number of
routing numbers, if they so choose. The
Board is also modifying the manner in
which the fee will be applied during
1991. The Reserve Banks will assess the
participation fee only for those routing
numbers that have commercial ACH
volume in a given month. This policy
will be effective until January 1,1992, at
which time the Federal Reserve Banks
will begin assessing the monthly fee for
all routing numbers maintained on the
CIF that are eligible to receive
commercial ACH items, regardless of
volume levels. These actions will allow

depository institutions to maintain
inactive routing numbers on the CIF
until January 1,1992 without being
assessed the participation fee v/ith
respect to these inactive numbers, so
that they can ensure that payment
activity has ceased prior to deleting
them.
Other ACH fee changes that were
approved by the Board in October 1990
that decreased the interdistrict per item
transaction fee and increased fees for
processing return items will be
implemented April 1,1991, as planned.
The Federal Reserve continues to
believe that the elimination of inactive
routing numbers will improve overall
ACH processing efficiency by reducing
the cost of maintaining the CIF, by
eliminating many accounting and billing
statements, and by reducing statistical
processing and reporting. By modifying
the manner in which the participation
fee is applied until Jauanry 1,1992, the
Board intends to provide depository
institutions with the ability to manage
the elimination of inactive routing
numbers more effectively and maintain
the incentives for depository institutions
to act promptly in their efforts to
identify and eliminate unnecessary
routing numbers.
These modifications will not
materially affect the cost recovery for
the ACH service. The Board anticipates
that projected revenue from the
participation fee will be reduced by
approximately $430,000 due to the delay
in its implementation and the
m odification to the m anner in w hich it is
applied, which would lower the
projected 1991 ACH cost recovery by 0.8
percent to 98.0 percent. This revenue
reduction may be offset, at least in part,
by unbudgeted revenue generated by a
larger number of NOCs as depository
institutions attempt to eliminate volume
on routing numbers that currently
receive little ACH volume. Also, it
appears that further cost reductions can
be achieved through the anticipated
deferral of some budgeted expenses
related to the development of new ACH
software. Therefore, the Board estimates
that 1991 ACH cost recovery, assuming
the delay in the implementaion of the
participation fee, will be substantially
similar to the 98.8 percent target
previously approved by the Board.
B y o r d e r o f th e B o a r d o f G o v e r n o r s o f th e
F e d e r a l R e s e r v e S y s t e m , F e b r u a r y 1 3 ,1 9 9 1 .

William W. Wiles,
S e c r e ta r y o f th e Board.
[F R D o c . 9 1 — 3 9 1 1 F i le d 2— 1 9 — 91- 8 :4 5 a m ]

BILLING CODE 6210—01—M

P R IN T E D IN N E W Y O R K , F R O M FEDERAL REGISTER, V O L . 5 6 , N O . 3 4

Federal Reserve Bank
of New York

First Supplement to
Appendix 2 to
Operating Circular No. 10
(Effective January 1, 1991)
March 4, 1991

ACH FEE SCHEDULES

To All Depository Institutions in the Second
Federal Reserve District, and Others Concerned:

Appendix 2 to this Bank’s Operating Circular No. 10 sets forth time and
fee schedules for ACH operations. This supplement supersedes the fee sched­
ules on page 4 of that Appendix. The new fee schedules, reflecting a July 1,
1991 effective date for the new ACH participation fee, are printed on the reverse
side hereof.

E.

G e r a l d C o r r ig a n ,

President.

[Enc. Cir. No. 10437]




(OVER)

FEE SCHEDULES

<
T r a n s a c tio n F e e s5

Origination:
Interregional presorted deposits6 .......................

1.20

Interregional addenda re c o rd ..............................

0.20

Nighttime surcharges:
Debits ...........................................................

2.00

Next-day credits

.....................................

1.00

Interregional items ...............................................

1.20

Interregional addenda re c o rd ...............................

0.20

Automated return item processing surcharge
(effective April1, 1 9 9 1 )..................

4.00

Receipt:

F ix e d F e e s

ACH participation fee
(effective July 1, 1 9 9 1 )................... $10.00 per month
File processing ....................................................... . . . $ 1.25 per file
Non-electronic delivery fe e ..........................................

$ 5.25 per delivery

Input tapes ....................................................................

$ 6.00 per tape

5 T h e fo llo w in g A u to m a ted C lea rin g H o u se tran sa ctio n s w ill b e b illed as regu lar item s: C orporate
Trade P aym en ts (C T P ), C orporate Trade E x ch a n g e (C T X ), D e p o sito r y I n stitu tio n A u to m a ted R e ­
tu rn s (R E T ), D e p o sito r y In stitu tio n A u to m a ted N o tifica tio n o f C h a n g e s (C O R ), and P r e n o tifi­
cation s.
6 P resorted d ep o sits c o n s is t o f file s o f in terregio n a l tra n sa ctio n s p reso rted b y r e c e iv in g F ed eral
R e se r v e O ffic e.