View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

Authorized for public release by the FOMC Secretariat on 1/14/2022

BOARD

OF

GOVERNORS

OF THE

FEDERAL RESERVE SYSTEM

Date:

March 4, 2016

To:

Federal Open Market Committee

From:

Thomas Laubach and David W. Wilcox

Subject: Background Memos on the Probabilities of a U.S. Recession in the Next
Year

Board staff have prepared two complementary background memos presenting
analyses pertaining to the probability that the U.S. economy could transition to a
recessionary state in coming months. The first memo, “Probabilities of the U.S.
Economy Entering a Recession in the Coming Year,” prepared by Travis Berge,
Nitish Sinha, and Michael Smolyansky, takes a purely statistical approach to discerning
which macroeconomic and financial market indicators are most useful for predicting
recessions. The memo concludes that nonfinancial indicators of real activity are most
informative at near-term horizons (three and six months ahead) while financial
variables gain the upper hand at a twelve-month horizon. The memo reports that
data through February result in estimated recession probabilities for the near and
medium term that are close to the unconditional average risk of recession.
Nonetheless, the estimated probabilities of recession 12 months hence have drifted
up, on net, in recent months, primarily reflecting a somewhat flatter term structure of
Treasury yields and a material rise in corporate credit spreads.
The second memo, “Probability of Recession Implied by Credit Market
Sentiment,” prepared by Giovanni Favara, Kurt Lewis, and Gustavo Suarez, focuses
on the U.S. corporate bond market, where some prior research and external analysis
has documented that spreads have predictive power for downturns in U.S. economic
Page 1 of 2

Authorized for public release by the FOMC Secretariat on 1/14/2022

activity. Specifically, the authors analyze credit spreads on corporate debt net of
expected defaults—which they refer to as the “excess bond premium”—an indicator
capturing shifts in investor risk appetite or credit market sentiment. They show that
the predictive capability of credit spreads for U.S. recessions is due entirely to the
excess bond premium and not to the component of credit spreads that can empirically
be attributed to expected corporate default risk. According to this measure, credit
market sentiment has deteriorated appreciably since last summer, and the February
level of the excess bond premium indicates the possibility of higher-than-average odds
of a U.S. recession being called at some point in the next year. This memo also
discusses the potential economic mechanism linking swings in credit market sentiment
to fluctuations in real activity.

Page 2 of 2