View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

The meeting of the Federal Open Market Committee was recon
vened in

the offices of the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve

System in

Washington on Tuesday, March 1, 1938,
PRESENT:

Mr.
Mr.
Mr.
Mr.
Mr.

at 11:00 a.m.

Eccles, Chairman
Harrison, Vice Chairman
Szymczak
McKee
Ransom

Mr. Davis
Mr.
Mr.
Mr.
Mr.

Sinclair
Newton
Schaller
Peyton
Morrill, Secretary
Wyatt, General Counsel
Goldenweiser, Economist
Williams, Associate Economist
Burgess, Manager of the System Open
Market Account
Mr. Carpenter, Assistant Secretary of
the Board of Governors of the Federal
Reserve System
Mr. Thurston, Special Assistant to the
Chairman of the Board of Governors
of the Federal Reserve System
Mr.
Mr.
Mr.
Mr.
Mr.

The Secretary reported that records of the elections for the
period of one year commencing March 1,

1938, of members and alter

nates representing the Federal reserve banks,

or certified copies

thereof, had been received by the Secretary of the Committee; that
each newly elected member and alternate had filed the required oath
of office; and that it

was the opinion of the Committee's counsel on

the basis of these documents that the newly elected members and alter
nates present were legally qualified to participate in

as follows:

the meeting,

3/1/38

-2George L. Harrison, President of the Federal Reserve
Bank of New York, with Roy A. Young, President of the
Federal Reserve Bank of Boston, as alternate member;
John S. Sinclair, President of the Federal Reserve
Bank of Philadelphia, with M. J. Fleming, President
of the Federal Reserve bank of Cleveland, as alternate
member;
Oscar Newton, President of the Federal Reserve Bank
of Atlanta, with Hugh Leach, President of the Federal
Reserve Bank of Richmond, as alternate member;
George J. Schaller, President of the Federal Reserve
Bank of Chicago, with Wm. McC.Martin, President of
the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, as alternate
member; and
John N. Peyton, President of the Federal Reserve

Bank of Minneapolis, with George H. Hamilton, Presi
dent of the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City, as
alternate member.
Upon motion duly made and seconded, the
following officers of the Committee were re
elected by unanimous votes to serve until the
election of their successors at the first meet
ing after March 1, 1939:
Marriner S. Eccles, Chairman
George L. Harrison, Vice Chairman
E. A. Goldenweiser, Economist
John H. Williams, Associate Economist
Walter Wyatt, General Counsel
J. P. Dreibelbis, Assistant General Counsel
Upon motion duly made and seconded, and by
unanimous vote, the Committee selected the Fed
eral Reserve Bank of New York to execute trans
actions for the System open market account until
meeting of the Com
the adjournment of the first
mittee after March 1, 1939.
Mr. Harrison stated that it

was his intention to recommend

to the board of directors of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York the
selection of Mr. Burgess as Manager of the System Open Market Account.
Upon motion duly made and seconded, and by
unanimous vote, the Committee approved the selec
tion of Mr. Burgess as Manager of the System

-3account in the event of his reappointment by
the board of directors of the Federal Reserve
Bank of New York to act in that capacity.
Upon motion duly made and seconded, and by

unanimous vote, the following were selected to
serve with the Chairman of the Federal Open Market
Committee, who under the provisions of the by-laws
is also chairman of the executive committee, as
members and alternate members of the executive
committee until the first meeting of the Federal
Open Market Committee after March 1, 1939:
Members

Alternate Members

M. S. Szymczak
Chester C. Davis
George L. Harrison
John S. Sinclair

John K. McKee
Ronald Ransom
(to serve in the order
named as alternates for
Messrs. Eccles, Szymczak

and Davis)
George J. Schaller
John N. Peyton
(to serve in the order
named as alternates for
Messrs. Harrison and
Sinclair)
There were then presented by Mr. Ransom certain suggested amend
ments to the by-laws of the Federal Open Market Committee and the regu
lation adopted by it

with respect to open market operations of Federal

reserve banks.
After discussion of the proposed changes,
upon motion duly made and seconded, the follow
ing amendments were approved unanimously:
Section 1 of Article I of the by-laws of the Committee
was amended to read as follows:

"Priorto the first meeting of the Committee fol
lowing March 1 each year, each member of the Com
mittee representing the Federal reserve banks

"shall cause a record of his election and of the
election of the alternate to serve in his absence
to be forwarded to the Secretary of the Committee
If any question be raised as to the election or
eligibility of such member or alternate, the Com
mittee shall determine such question before per
mitting such member or alternate to participate
in the meetings."
The clause "and upon receipt of such notice the alter
nate shall advise the Secretary whether he will attend such
meeting", was added to the last sentence of Section 5 of
Article I of the by-laws so that the sentence would read
as follows:
"Whenever any member of the Committee represent
ing Federal Reserve banks shall find that he
will be unable to attend a meeting of the Com
mittee, he shall promptly notify his alternate
and the Secretary of the Committee in writing
or by telegram, and upon receipt of such notice
the alternate shall advise the Secretary whether
he will attend such meeting."
Section 2 of Article II of the by-laws was amended by
substituting for the last sentence the following two sen
tences:
"At its first meeting after March 1 of each year
the Committee shall elect an Assistant Secretary,
to serve until the first meeting after March 1 of
the next year. In the absence of the Secretary
of the Committee, the Assistant Secretary shall
act as Secretary pro tem."
The first paragraph of Section 7 of the regulation of
the Federal Open Market Committee relating to open market
operations of Federal reserve banks was amended to read as
follows:
"No Federal Reserve bank shall purchase or
sell Government securities, for its own account
or for the account of any other Federal Reserve
bank, except pursuant to authority granted by
the Committee or in accordance with an open
market policy adopted by the Committee and in
effect at the time."

Paragraphs (1) and (2) of Section 8 of the regulation
of the Federal Open Market Committee relating to open market
operations of Federal Reserve banks were amended to read as
follows:

"(1) Each Federal Reserve Bank, as may be
required from time to time by the Committee,
shall report all such transactions to the Secre

tary of the Committee.

"(2) Only acceptances and bills of exchange
which are of the kinds made eligible for purchase
under the provisions of Regulation B of the Board
of Governors of the Federal Reserve System may be
purchased and the rates of discount shall be es
tablished in accordance with the provisions of
section 14(d) of the Federal Reserve Act: Pro
vided, further, That no obligations payable in
foreign currency shall be purchased or sold for
the account of the Federal Reserve bank except
in accordance with directions of the Committee."
Upon motion duly made and seconded,
and by unanimous vote, S. R. Carpenter was
elected Assistant Secretary of the Commit
tee to serve until the election of his suc
cessor at the first meeting after March 1,
1939.
It

was stated that at the meeting of the Board of Governors

with the Presidents of Federal reserve banks yesterday, at which all
of the members of the Federal Open Market Committee with the exception
of Mr. Harrison were in attendance, Messrs. Goldenweiser and Williams,
as economists for the Committee,
credit situation.

reviewed the present business and

Copies of the memorandum prepared by Mr. Golden

weiser under date of February 26, 1938, on the subject of recent
business and credit developments,
ment,

which formed the basis of his state

and a summary of Mr. Williams'

statement which reviewed the

3/1/38

-6

possible trends of business activity in the near future, have been
placed in

the files of the Federal Open Market Committee.

There ensued a general discussion of open market policy and
of the resolutions to be adopted by the Committee authorizing the ex
ecutive committee to direct open market operations pending another
meeting of the full Committee.

Chairman Eccles stated that he felt

the present policy should be continued for the reason that the excess
reserves held by member banks are not excessive under existing circum
stances; that, in view of the low volume of business activity, declining
prices, and business uncertainty, no useful purpose would be achieved
by reducing the total amount of securities held in the System open
market account; and that such action might be misinterpreted and thereby
result in a further unfavorable element in the business situation.

He

also expressed the opinion that the present policy of reducing the amount
of holdings of long-term bonds in the System account should be continued
in

order to exercise some restraint upon increases in prices of Govern

ment bonds and to place the System in a better position to make purchases
later if

they should be necessary to maintain an orderly market.

Others

expressed agreement with this statement of principles.
Mr. Harrison stated that, while he did not wish at this time
to vote for a reduction in the total amount of securities held in

the

System account, he felt that careful consideration should be given from

time to time to the reasons that might be advanced for such action in

3/1/38

-7

order that the Committee might be ready to take that action whenever
conditions might make it

possible without undue risk.

During the en

suing discussion of the circumstances under which the Committee might
be justified in reducing the amount of securities held in the System
open market account there was general concurrence in the opinion that
such action should not be taken at this time.
There was also a discussion of ways in which a policy of re
ducing the System open market account might be made effective,

such as

through the sale of securities in the market thereby reducing excess
reserves, or sales simultaneous with purchases by the Treasury to be
paid for from the inactive gold account, which would not affect the
excess reserve position of member banks.

Reference was made to sugges

tions that had been made from time to time in the past that small fluc
tuations in the total amount of securities held in the account be per
mitted in order to prevent the appearance of inflexibility in

the ac

count and to prevent undue importance being attached in the market to
the Committee's action when a decision is made to reduce the amount
held in the account.

Some of the members stated that they felt, however,

that no change should be made in the portfolio until there is

a change

of policy as to the amount to be held, in order that the action of the
Committee at that time might have as great a psychological effect as
possible.

3/1/38

-8
Upon motion duly made and seconded, and by
unanimous vote, the Committee instructed the ex
ecutive committee, until otherwise instructed
by the Committee, to direct the replacement of
maturing securities in the System open market

account with other Government securities and to
make such shifts between maturities in the ac

count as may be necessary in the proper adminis
tration of the account, provided that the amount
of securities maturing within two years be main
tained at not less than $1,000,000,000 and that

the amount of bonds having maturities in excess
of five years be not over 850,000,000 nor less
than $500,000,000.
Upon motion duly made and seconded, the
Committee voted unanimously to authorize the
executive committee, upon written, telephonic,
or telegraphic approval of a majority of the
members of the Committee, and until otherwise
directed by the Committee, to direct the pur
chase in the open market from time to time of
sufficient amounts of Government securities to
meet the requirements of commerce, business, and
agriculture by keeping at member banks an aggregate
volume of excess reserves adequate for the con
tinuance of the System's policy of maintaining
credit conditions conducive to economic recovery;
and to authorize the executive committee, upon
written, telephonic, or telegraphic approval of
a majority of the members of the Committee, and
until otherwise directed by the Committee, to
direct a reduction of the holdings of such se
curities, to the extent that their retention
is found to be unnecessary for the purposes of

this resolution.

It was understood, however,

that the executive committee, under this reso
lution, was not authorized to increase or de
crease by more than $300,000,000 the amount of
securities now held in the System open market
account.
Reference was made to the action taken at the session of the
Federal Open Market Committee yesterday in voting to recomend that

-9

3/1/38
the Committee, at its

meeting today, take action to appoint a special

committee to consider Section 6 of Article I of the by-laws of the
Committee in

the light of the discussion at the meeting yesterday and

to submit a report and recommendation at the next meeting of the Com
mittee as to changes in

the section.

Mr. Harrison moved that the Chairman be
requested to appoint a special committee in
accordance with the recommendation made at
the meeting yesterday.
Having been duly seconded, Mr. Harrison's
motion was put by the chair and carried by
unanimous vote.
In accordance with the Committee's action,
appointed Mr. Davis as chairman,

Chairman Eccles

and Messrs. Ransom and Sinclair as

the other two members, of the special committee.
Thereupon the meeting adjourned.

Secretary.

Approved:
Chairman.