View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

MwdkLj,
FEDERAL RESERVE

BANK

MARCH

OF

SAN

F R A N C ISC O

1948

TWELFTH DISTRICT MEMBER BANK EARNINGS AN D EXPENSES— 1947
n d er

the impetus of an unparalleled increase in loan

Uearnings, net profits after taxes of Twelfth District
member banks combined reached a new high in 1947,

although they exceeded the previous record figure in 1946
by only a small amount. Major factors which restrained
net profits included a reduction in investment income, a
general increase in expenses, some increase in charge-offs
on loans, and an increase in income tax payments which
made the percent gain over 1946 in profits after taxes
substantially less than the increases in profits before taxes
and in net current earnings. As a percentage of capital
accounts, profits after taxes were lowrer in 1947 than in
1946.
The combined figures for all banks presented in the
accompanying table do not reveal the wide differences
among banks. If a few of the larger banks that carried on
especially profitable operations in 1947 had been excluded
from the figures, total net current earnings would have
been about the same in 1947 as in 1946, and profits, both
before and after taxes, would have been lower.
In contrast to the District, net profits of all member
banks in the United States were 14 percent smaller in
1947 than in 1946. Net current earnings and profits before
taxes also declined. In terms of return on capital, District
member bank operations also were more profitable than
those of all member banks. The primary factor in the more
favorable experience of District banks was the greater
increase in loans in this area than in the country as a
whole.

items increased in 1947, with service charges on deposit
accounts being substantially larger.
Expenses rise relatively more than earnings

To achieve larger earnings, increased expenses were
necessary; in fact, the percentage increase in expenses was
larger than the percentage increase in earnings for the
first time in several years. Both higher salaries and larger
staffs contributed to the increase in total salary and wage
payments. The number of persons employed by District
member banks was 6 percent higher at the end of 1947
than a year earlier. Similarly, the payment of a larger
amount of interest on time deposits reflected both a larger
volume of such deposits and higher rates of interest paid
on a considerable portion of them.
Even though expenses increased more, relatively, than
earnings, the additional dollar expenses did not use up the
added earnings. Net current earnings in 1947, conse­
quently, were more than 10 percent above their previous
high in 1946.
E a r n in g s a n d E x p e n s e s of M e m b e r B a n k s —
T w e l f t h D is t r ic t
(millions <jf dollars)

1940
Earnings on loans ...............

Interest and dividends on

securities ......................
.
Service charges on deposit
accounts .................................
Trust department earnings.
Other earnings ...................... .
Total earnings

Loans again become most important source of earnings

Reflecting the widespread and insistent demand for
bank loans, earnings on loans were half again as large in
1947 as in 1946. Loan earnings provided over half of all
earnings and exceeded investment income for the first
time since 1943.
The pressure of Treasury debt retirement and expand­
ing loans shrank United States Government security
holdings substantially. Interest and dividends on securi­
ties were less than in either 1945 or 1946. The rise in
interest rates that occurred in the latter part of 1947
helped to keep the decline in investment income from
being quite as large as the decline in investments, but the
difference between rates of return on securities for the
years 1946 and 1947 was not marked. All other earnings




1946

1947

Percent
change
1946.47

104.01

99.6

138.6

210*5 '

+ 52

44.5

138.4

153.9

129.3

— 16

14.8
10.2
22.7

17.5
12.3
25.7

22.4
12.9
26.2

+ 28
+ 5
+ 2

8.5
6.8
15.8l

.................... 179.6

Salaries and wages ............ ..
Interest on time deposits. . ,
Other e x p e n s e s ........................

1945

54.5
31.4
*
43.42>3

285.7

348.0

401.3

+ 15

84.4
39.3
56.6

109.3
44.9
65.2

127.1
54.1
77.4

+ 16
+ 20
+ 19

Total expenses ...................

129.32, 3

180.3

219.4

258.6

+ 18

N et current earnings............

50.32>3

105.4

128.6

142.7

+ 11

+ 9 .8
6.4
+ 0 .1

+ 5.1
+ 3 .3
13.5

+ 6.6
7.0
7.6

—

6.83

+ 3.4

5.0

8.0

2
2

108.9
27.9

123.7
32.2

134.7
42.2

N et losses and charge-offs
(recoveries and profits-}-)
On securities ......................+ 11.1
On lo a n s ..................................
8.5
9.43
Total net charge-offs..
Net profits before income
Taxes on net income............

—

—

+ 9
+31

N et profits after taxes..........

43.5

80.9

91.5

92.5

+

Cash dividends ........................
Undistributed profits ..........

24.2
19.3

29.9
51.0

35.1
56.4

37.5
55.0

+ 7
— 2

1

1 Service charges and fees on loans included in “ other earnings.”
2 Taxes on net income included in “ other expenses.”
3 Recurring depreciation on bank building and furniture and fixtures in
eluded in “ other net charge-offs.”

26

March 1948

FEDERAL RESERVE B A N K OF S A N F R A N C ISCO

Recoveries exceeded charge-offs on loans in 1946, but
in 1947 charge-offs exceeded recoveries. Nevertheless,
net charge-offs on all non-current accounts were only
moderately higher in 1947, largely because of a substan­
tial reduction in charge-offs other than those related to
loans and securities. Profits before income taxes also
rose about 10 percent to a new record. The percentage
increase in total tax payments on net income was consid­
erably larger than the gain in profits before taxes, how­
ever, and 1947 profits after taxes just exceeded those of
a year earlier. About 40 cents out of every dollar of profits
was again distributed in dividends, and the dollar addi­
tion to capital accounts through undistributed profits was
about the same in 1947 as in 1946.
Earnings and expenses of banks by size group

ercent

E

C

xp e n se

h a n g e s

Ite

m s

,

of

1946-47,
T

w e lfth

b y

S

iz e

Loan earnings of member banks increased substan­
tially over 1946 in each state, and income from securities
declined except in Idaho banks. Total earnings were up
over 1946, but the increases in Washington and Oregon
ercent

E

C

h an g e s

xpen se

Ite

,

1946-47,

m s

of

S

in

D
G

E

elected

is t r ic t

M

a r n in g s

em ber

B

,

roups

Earnings on loans ....................................
Total earnings .............................................. ..
Salaries and wages ............................................
Total expenses ................................................
N et current earnings .........................................
N et profits before income taxes .................
Income taxes ........................................................
N et profits after t a x e s .......................................
Dividends .................................................................

— 18
55
16
16
18
11
12
37
3
7

4
35
22
20
19
26
8
39
2
16

in

S

Other
banks
— 10
40
14
20
16
10
— 1
13
— 6
13

1 15 largest banks, in terms of total deposits.
2 33 banks with total deposits under $1,000,000 in 1943.

Profits of most large banks below 1946

Individual bank experience has been examined only
among the 15 largest banks, but even here the results of
their 1947 operations varied widely. Loan earnings in­
creased over 1946 by 22 to 67 percent, while investment
income was about the same in 1947 as in 1946 in one
bank and was 4 to 30 percent lower in the others. Four­
teen of the 15 banks increased their total earnings, but
the increases ranged from 3 to 40 percent, writh the typical
increase about 10 percent.
Wages and salaries increased at least 10 percent in each
of these banks, with 30 percent the largest rise, and total
expenses rose over a similar range. Net current earnings

elected

w e lfth

Interest and dividends on securities.
Earnings on loans ..................................
Total earnings ....................................
Salaries and w a g e s ..................................
Total expenses ....................................
N et current e a r n in g s .............................
N et profits before income taxes
Income taxes ...........................................
Net profits after t a x e s ...........................
Dividends .....................................................

D

E

is t r ic t

a r n in g s

M

an d

em ber

Calif.

Oreg. and
Wash.

— 17
54
16
15
18
13
17
44
7
8

— 16
43
8
17
14
— 7
— 17
— 12
— 18
— 5

Ariz.,
Idaho,
Nev. &
Utah
—

8
54
22
25
22
23
7
18
3
15

banks were small, and those were the only two states in
which member banks did not increase their net current
earnings. Losses and charge-offs on loans were substan­
tially larger in 1947 than in 1946 in every state. Net
profits after taxes declined in three states, Washington,
Oregon, and Utah.
S

elected

O

p e r a t in g

R

a t io s

w e lfth

D

of

M

em ber

B

a n k s

—

is t r ic t

a n d

a n k s

Small2
banks

T

iAS

T

Large1
banks




Earnings and expenses of banks by state

P

Considerable differences are found within the District
in the profit experience of various groups of member
banks. These are accounted for largely by differing
changes in earnings items in 1947 as against 1946. In­
creases in expense items were much more uniform than
changes in earnings.
Net current earnings of both large and small banks
were higher than in 1946. The increase in the small bank
group was considerably larger than in all banks or in the
large bank group, since income from securities held by
the small banks did not decline. The large bank group
had both the largest relative decline in securities earnings
and the largest relative increase in loan earnings. Net
profits after taxes of the 15 largest District banks com­
bined and of 33 of the smallest banks were slightly above
1946, but net profits of all other District banks were
down 6 percent.
P

were higher than in 1946 in 8 banks and lower in 7.
Although net current earnings combined rose 11 percent,
13 of the 15 banks had an increase of less than 10 percent
or a decrease. Net profits after taxes behaved similarly.
Combined, net profits increased 3 percent, but individ­
ually, they ranged from an increase of 36 percent to a
decrease of 56 percent, with decreases realized by 12 of
the 15 banks.

Percentages of total capital accounts
N et current earnings before income taxes
Profits before income taxes . . . ....................
N et p r o fit s ............................................................

1940

1945

1946

1947

i
8.3

14.6
15.7
12.3

18:4
18.6
14.4

19.0
18.0
13.4

3.9
0.9

1.9
0.5

2.1
0.6

2.5
0.6

21.5
6 2 .72
5.6

46.8
36.4
6.1

44.4
40.3
5.8

36.7
48.6
6.2

31.6
16.6

30.5
13.8

30.4
12.5

30.9
11.8

34.1

36.9

36.8

13.2
11.8

4.9
4.7

4.8
4.5

5.3
5.0

—

32.5

28.7

23.7

—

Percentages of total assets

Percentages of total earnings
Interest and dividends on securities.. . .
Earnings on lo a n s ..............................................
Service charges on deposit accounts. . . .
Salaries and w a g e s ............................................
Interest on time d e p o s its .............................

i

N et current e a r n in g s .......................................
Capital accounts as percentages of
Total d e p o s its .....................................................
Total a s s e t s ..........................................................
Total assets, less cash and U . S.
Government secu rities...............................
Earnings on loans as percentage of
total l o a n s ...............................................................

6.52

5.4

5.5

5.6

Interest on U . S. Government securities as
percentage of total U . S. Government
securities ...............................................................

3 .13

1.3

1.4

1.5

Interest on time deposits as percentage
of total time d e p o s its .......................................

1.7

0.9

0.9

0.9

1 Figure comparable with those for 1945-47 not available.
2 Excluding service charges and other fees on loans.
3 Interest and dividends on total securities.
N o te : Figures are arithmetic averages of ratios of individual banks, not
ratios of aggregate dollar totals. Thus, the operations of each bank regard­
less of size have equal weight in the determination of the averages. Balance
sheet figures used as a basis for ratios are averages of amounts reported for
December 31, 1946, and June 30 and October 6, 1947.
More complete tabulations of Twelfth District member bank operating
ratios for 1947, including separate tabulations by state, by state or com ­
bination of states and size, by proportion of time to total deposits, and by
proportion of loans to total assets, are available upon request.

March 1948

M O N T H L Y R E V IE W

Operating ratios of Twelfth District banks

The average ratio of net profits to capital accounts of
Twelfth District member banks declined in 1947. Most
banks increased their capital accounts over 1946 through
retention of profits but realized either a smaller relative
increase or a decline in net profits. The return on capital
in 1947 was well above prewar levels however, since it
had risen steadily from 1942 through 1946. Net current
earnings (before income taxes and charge-offs) as a
percentage of capital accounts continued to rise in 1947.
Only among Oregon and Washington banks wras this
ratio, as well as the ratio of net profits to capital, lower
in 1947 than in 1946.
The continued expansion in bank loans, while security
holdings were declining, brought a further substantial
increase both in the importance of loan earnings relative
to total earnings and in total earnings as a percentage of
total assets. The average rates of return realized on loans
and on securities were slightly higher again last year, the
low having been reached in 1945.
Both salaries and wages and total expenses increased

27

by about the same proportion as total earnings, and ex­
pense to earnings ratios showed little change.
Relative to total assets and deposits, capital accounts
had declined sharply over the war years when bank hold­
ings of Government securities were expanding. Last year,
the movement of these capital ratios was reversed, al­
though they remain less than half the 1940 percentages.
An opposite shift has taken place in the ratio of capital
accounts to total assets less cash and Government securi­
ties. In these terms, capital accounts increased during the
war because the increase in bank assets occurred primarily
in Government securities. The postwar loan expansion
reduced this ratio of capital to so-called risk assets in
1946 and again in 1947. (This ratio in the accompanying
table is based upon average capital accounts and assets
for the year as a whole. Since loans rose rapidly in the
latter part of the year, the average ratio of capital ac­
counts to total assets less Governments and cash was sub­
stantially lower at the year-end than for the year 1947
as a whole.) The decline in this particular capital ratio
is one of the factors in the increasing caution expressed
by District banks regarding further loan expansion.

COMMODITY PRICE CHANGES SINCE THE BEGINNING OF FEBRUARY
u r in g
the first half of February a price recession oc­
curred in most agricultural commodity markets in
this country. The break began on February 4, after many
of these commodities had shown signs of weakness during
the second half of January. Since the middle of February
a slow upward movement has been noticeable, but prices
of many commodities have moved extremely irregularly.
The February recession in the commodity markets was
soon felt in spotty lowering of retail prices of various food
items. There was also a decline of security prices on
leading stock exchanges. Price developments, however,
were not uniform. One of the chief exceptions was a rise
in the prices of certain steel products.

D

Background of the present price situation

The extent, causes, and the probable meaning of the
recent price recession can be properly viewed and appre­
ciated only against the background of price developments
in this country since June 1946. Since the end of price
control, prices have been rising almost continuously both
because of strong inflationary pressures generated within
the country and, to some extent, because of export de­
mand affecting special classes of commodities.
The wholesale price index (1926 = 100) rose, with a
short interruption in September 1946, from an average
of 113 in June 1946 to 149 at the end of March 1947.
For the following three and a half months, wholesale
prices remained rather stable at a slightly lower level,
around 147 to 148. This slight price recession, which was
caused essentially by a drop in prices of agricultural com­
modities and foods, was in the beginning interpreted by
many as the starting point of a general economic reces­




sion. Beginning in the middle of July 1947 there was
again an almost steady upward movement of prices, and
in mid-January 1948 the wholesale price index reached
its postwar peak of 165.5. This was 17.5 percent higher
than a year earlier. From June 1946 to the middle of Janu­
ary 1948, the general price index rose by 47 percent, farm
products by 44 percent, foods by 60 percent, metals and
metal products by 37 percent, textiles by 34 percent,
building materials by 47 percent, chemicals by 45 per­
cent, and fuel and lighting materials by 49 percent.
For some time prices have been at a level high enough
to cause serious apprehension. There is a general feeling,
easily understood because of past experience, that the
present price level is not only too high, but also that
longer-term price relationships among various groups of
commodities have been disrupted and that a major adjust­
ment is inevitable sooner or later. High food prices have
caused particular concern because of their contribution to
rising living costs.
Declines in specific agricultural commodities

The accompanying table shows the course of spot prices
of some of the more important commodities participating
in the price break in February. For a better perspective,
the table gives the spot price on June 28, 1946, the last
trading day of wartime price control, and the peak price
reached since then. Prices of barley, corn, steers, and
butter reached their postwar peaks in January 1948,
while those of other commodities shown in the table
attained their peaks in earlier periods. With the excep­
tion of butter and hides, all indicated prices weakened
during the second half of January. The fall in prices from

28

March 1948

FEDERAL RESERVE B A N K OF S A N FR A N C ISCO

S pot P r ic e s o f T e n C o m m o d i t i e s i n P r i m a r y M a r k e t s o n S e le c te d D a y s
Wheat
bu.

Corn
bu.

Barley
bu.

Flaxseed
bu.

Cotton
lb.

Steers
1001b.

Hides
lb.

Hogs
100 lb.

Lard
lb.

Butter
lb.

June 28, 1946 ..............................................

$1,871

$1,448

$1.44

$3.35

$14.85

$.140

$.560

Peak since then,
and d a t e .....................................................
Jan. 16, 1948 .................................................
Feb. 3, 1948 ...................................................
Feb. 13, 1948 ................................................
Feb. 27, 1948 ..............................................
Mar. 19, 1948 ..............................................

3.115
1 1 /2 8 /4 7
3.065
2.872
2.295
2.352
2.312

2.808
1 /1 5 /4 8
2.78
2.565
2.012
2.228
2.252

.400
1 0 /2 5 /4 6
.288
.252
.212
.212
.214

.885
1 /2 /4 8

Percent change to
Mar. 19, 1948 from
June 28, 1946 .................................................
Peak since June 28, 1946 ......................
Tan. 16, 1948 ................................................
Feb. 3, 1948 ...................................................

+
—
—
—

23.6
25.8
24.6
19.5

+
—
—
—

55.5
19.8
19.0
12.2

$ .31

$17.00

$.155

2.755
1 /1 9 /4 8
2.745
2.585
2.275
2.385
2.490

7.10
1 /1 4 /4 8
7.10
6.90
6.00
6.25
6.15

.394
7 /1 6 /4 7
.352
.344
.314
.328
.340

32.25
1 /7 /4 8
31.00
29.75
26.75
27.25
27.50

.372
1 0 /2 9 /4 7
.312
.322
.270
.250
.240

+ 72.9
— 9.6
— 9.3
— 3.7

+ 83.6
— 13.4
— 13.4
— 10.9

+ 9.7
— 13.7
— 3.4
— 1.2

+ 61.8
— 14.7
— 11.3
— 7.6

— 35.5
— 23.1
— 25.5

+ 54.8

30.25
9 /1 1 /4 7
28.125
26.875
23.750
23.375
23.250

+
—
—
—

56.6
23.1
17.3
13.5

+
—
—
—

52.9
46.5
25.7
15.1

.858
.872
.770
.770
.790

+ 4 1 .1
— 10.7
— 7.9
— 9.4

Source : United States Bureau of Labor Statistics.

February 4 until about February 13 reached the maxi­
mum limit allowed by exchange rules on nearly every
trading day, and by the latter date almost all of these
prices reached their lows. During the second half of Feb­
ruary an upward movement was noticeable in all these
commodities except hides and hogs, but by the end of
the month only a small part of the loss had been regained
in most cases. In the first three weeks of March, prices
of agricultural commodities moved irregularly and, after
various ups and downs, on March 19 were close to Feb­
ruary month-end levels.
Although the recent price break affected a wide range
of agricultural commodities, the grains, wheat in particu­
lar, were the leaders. The reasons for the price break in
grains are to be found in a combination of circumstances.
(1 ) Grain prices, as well as prices of livestock and live­
stock products which are sensitive to changes in feed
prices, had reached very high levels by the end of 1947.
A short corn crop in the United States threatened to di­
vert an unusually large share of wheat supplies to feed
purposes and pushed up the prices of all grains. (2 ) As
a result, and despite the record 1947 wheat output, the
export goal of 450 million bushels of wheat to feed West­
ern Europe, which had a poor crop in 1947, exerted a
strong influence on prices of grain, particularly wheat.
In the late fall, serious apprehension concerning the
prospects for the 1948 winter wheat crop in this country
added to the pressure on wTheat prices. (3 ) Since late
December, however, the appraisal of the wheat situation
has been revised materially. United States wheat stocks
of 795 million bushels on January 1 have proved to be
larger than expected, and considerably larger than the
corresponding figure for the previous two years. The ex­
pected yield of the new winter wheat crop in this country
has also been revised upward substantially. Estimates of
wheat exports from Australia and Argentina have been
raised markedly owing to their large crops. Expectations
concerning the 1948 wheat crop in European importing
countries have also improved materially. Finally, it ap­
pears that high prices have dissuaded the domestic live­
stock industry from using the expected amount of wheat
for feeding. Consequently, wheat export goals, even if
increased somewhat, probably will be reached without
great difficulty. All these factors indicated that prices of




wheat and many other agricultural commodities were out
of line with market forces in the first half of January, and
the ensuing break in prices represented an inevitable
adjustment.
Repercussion on wholesale prices

The price drop in the primary markets of agricultural
commodities was reflected in a 2.4 percent net decline
in the general weekly index of wholesale prices. The
wholesale price index of about 900 commodities (1926
= 100) fell from 165.5 during the week ended January
17 to 159.2 during the week ended February 21, to rise
to 161.5 during the week ended March 20. But the be­
havior of the component price groups was far from uni­
form. Prices of fuel and lighting materials, building ma­
terials, house furnishing goods, and metals and metal
products have advanced continuously in recent months
and showed no recession during February.1 On the con­
trary, the group indexes of farm products, foods, hides
and leather, and chemicals have declined markedly since
they reached their peaks, mostly in mid-January. The
more important group indexes of wholesale prices for the
period since mid-January are given in the accompanying
table.
W holesale

P r ic e s — U n it e d

States

Percent
change
from
— Week ended— ---------- -\ Jan. 17 to
Jan. 17 Jan. 31 Feb. 14 Mar. 20 Mar. 20

(1926=100)

Commodity group
A ll commodities

........................ .

165.5

163.7

159.7

161.5

— 2.4

Farm p r o d u c ts ............................. .
.
.
Hides and leather products. . .
Building m a te ria ls......................
.
Fuel and lighting materials. . .
Metals and metal pro ducts.. . .

201.5
181.2
140.8
201.4
191.1
145.7
130.0
153.2

195.1
176.5
139.3
201.2
191.3
145.8
131.2
154.1

180.9
173.3
134.0
196.2
192.0
146.7
131.6
154.8

187.6
176.4
135.8
185.9
192.6
145.6
131.7
156.0

— 6.9
— 2.6
— 3.6
— 7.7
+ 0 .8
0
+ 1.3
+ 1.8

A ll commodities other than
farm products and foods. . .

147.4

148.0

147.5

147.3

0

Source : United States Bureau of Labor Statistics.

These indexes show quite clearly that the net decline
in the general price index of 2.4 percent during the nine
weeks from January 17 to March 20 was caused primarily
by the sizable breaks in prices of agricultural commodi1 According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics’ weekly wholesale price index.
Monthly index shows slight decline in building materials prices in Feb­
ruary.

M arch 1948

M O N T H L Y R E V IE W

ties and foods. During the same time industrial commodity
groups, except chemicals and hides and leather products,
showed a slight rise in prices, but the index of all com­
modities other than farm products and foods was practi­
cally the same at the end of the period as at the beginning.
Conclusion

The February price break in agricultural commodities
and foods perhaps is largely explained by the specific
situation in the markets for these products. Price develop­
ments in subsequent weeks support the view that it repre­
sented a selective market adjustment rather than the be­
ginning of a general downward price spiral. Even farm­
ers’ expenditures may not, at least for some time, be
seriously reduced by these price declines. Farm equip­
ment and machinery is still relatively scarce. Liquid as­

29

set holdings of farmers are still at record levels; profitable
operations in 1948 are anticipated; and, with existing
price support legislation, there is little fear that the
bottom will suddenly drop out of the agricultural price
structure.
To be sure, the future behavior of prices is extremely
uncertain. Much will depend upon the outcome of such
developments as the expanded defense program now
under consideration, and the third round of wage in­
creases now under way. Funds available for consumer
buying will be increased by the reduction in income taxes.
Reports indicate an attitude of increased caution on the
part of business following the price break and such a
sobering effect may be salutary in view of the poten­
tial inflationary pressures that may still raise serious
problems.

REVISION OF DEPARTMENT STORE INDEXES— TWELFTH DISTRICT
epartm ent

store sales indexes for the Twelfth Fed­

D eral Reserve District have recently been revised to

take account of several factors. During the war sales
were affected by seasonal forces in a different manner
than in previous years. An increase in the number of
reporting stores since 1942, the date of the last major
revision, made possible an improved sample for recent
years. During 1947, stores reporting to this bank ac­
counted for almost 80 percent of the estimated total sales
in the District. More precise bench mark data for 1939 be­
came available in the course of comparing this bank’s
records with Census tabulations. The new indexes for
most cities and areas show no marked differences in the
direction of the movements of the unadjusted series from
month to month, but they do indicate more precisely the
sales levels attained in recent years.




Seasonal pattern changed during war period

Changes in the seasonal behavior of department store
sales during the war and immediate postwar period were
due to several conditions. As goods became scarcer dur­
ing the war, the availability of merchandise became more
important at times than the seasons of the year in de­
termining the distribution of sales over the year. The
necessity to shop early in order to meet overseas mailing
deadlines for Christmas gifts to servicemen was another
development which affected the pattern of sales in the
latter part of the year. These circumstances combined to
reduce the sharp seasonal differences or to alter previous
relationships among months. Two examples will serve to
illustrate the effect of wartime conditions. In most cities
the difference between March and April attributable to
Easter business was greatly reduced. Similarly, Novem­

DEPARTMENT STORE SALES AND STOCKS-Twelfth District
Monthly indexes of value o! sales and stocks, adjusted for seasonal variation
(1935-39 average = 100)

30

FEDERAL RESERVE B A N K OF S A N F R A N C ISCO

ber sales gained in importance relative to December as
shoppers made earlier purchases to take advantage of
available goods and to meet the overseas shipping sched­
ules referred to above. Some changes became apparent
very early in the war and continued to be of the same
relative importance through the entire period, but others
became progressively more pronounced. These changes
complicated the problem of eliminating seasonal influ­
ences and required a changing set of adjustment factors.
Other adjustments made in sales indexes

Additional stores started reporting to this bank be­
tween 1942 and 1947. The present revision includes these
stores in the sample. Stores which opened for business
since the last revision and which report to this bank have
also been included in the series.
The sales indexes prepared by this bank had been ad­
justed to Census sales data for 1929 and 1939 and to the
data for 1935 wherever complete enumerations were
made for the latter year. Some further adjustments to
the 1939 Census were found necessary. In a few cities it
appeared that stores which met the Census definition of
a department store had been omitted from the Census
totals for 1939. It also became apparent that leased de­
partment sales were not included in the Census totals of
department store sales. Adjustments for these factors
improved the dollar estimates underlying the indexes.
The department store sales indexes published by this
bank do not purport to reflect sales or excise taxes. Ad­
justments were made, therefore, to the figures reported

A STUDY OF B A N K DEBITS A N D CLEARING STATISTICS
N O W AVAILABLE FOR DISTRIBUTION
The technical study, D ebits and Clearing Statistics, T heir B ack­
ground and Interpretation, prepared by George Garvy of the Fed­
eral Reserve Bank of New York and published by the Board of
Governors, is now available for distribution. The purpose of the
analysis is to determine how effectively bank clearings and bank
debits reflect basic economic processes.
The pamphlet may be purchased for 25 cents, or for 15 cents in
group purchases of ten or more copies for single shipment. Orders
may be addressed to this bank.
INCREASE IN LIMIT O N A N N U A L A C Q U ISIT IO N S OF
SERIES E S A V IN G S BO N DS
On March 18, 1948, Secretary Snyder announced that, effective
for the calendar year 1948, the limitation on the amount of Series
E savings bonds originally issued during any calendar year to any
one person is being raised from $5,000, maturity value, to $10,000,
maturity value.
W ITH H O LD IN G TAX FUNDS M A Y BE PLACED IN
W A R LO AN ACCOUNTS BY BA N K S
Effective March 22, 1948, each bank which is qualified as a De­
positary for Withheld Taxes and for a W ar Loan Deposit ac­
count may elect, in lieu of remitting withheld taxes deposited with




March 1948

to this bank, when correspondence with reporting stores
revealed that their figures included sales taxes. No evi­
dence was found that stores were including excise taxes
without reporting a separate figure showing sales exclud­
ing such taxes.
Stocks indexes also revised

The revision of the sales indexes made it necessary to
revise the stocks indexes because the dollar estimates of
stocks are dependent on the dollar estimates of sales. The
estimated amount of total Twelfth District department
store stocks in any month is obtained by the following
procedure: Stocks are divided by sales for a sample group
of stores reporting both items. The result, a ratio by
which sales must be multiplied to obtain stocks, is ap­
plied to estimated total dollar sales obtained in construct­
ing the sales indexes. The revised dollar estimates ob­
tained from the new sales indexes have been substituted
for those previously used.
The revised sales indexes appeared for the first time
in the Monthly Review for February 1948. The revised
stocks indexes are introduced in the present issue.
N o te : A technical description of the sales indexes covering their construc­
tion and adjustment for various factors is in preparation. This descrip­
tion will be furnished upon request. Tabulations for earlier months
of the sales indexes, by city and area, and of the District stocks index
are also available upon request.

Correction: In the February 1948 Monthly Review,
in the article “Agriculture in 1947,” the figure 23 million
pounds appears in the second line under the sub-heading
Meat on page 20. The correct figure is 23 billion pounds.

it directly to the Federal Reserve Bank, to make such remittances
by transfers from the “Withheld T ax” account to the “W ar Loan
Deposit” account on its books. Previously, a depositary bank had
to remit to the Federal Reserve Bank the entire amount in its
Withheld Tax account whenever the balance in this account
reached $5,000, and also at the close of each calendar month re­
gardless of the size of the balance. Balances in W a r Loan ac­
counts, on the other hand, are subject to withdrawal upon call by
the Treasury. The new method of handling withheld taxes will
permit a more even flow of funds into the Treasurer’s account at
Federal Reserve Banks and consequently there will be less periodic
disturbance of member bank reserves.
SECURITY LO A N DRIVE— APRIL 15 TO JUNE 30, 1948
The Security Loan Drive will start April 15 and continue
through June 30. The United States Savings Bonds Division of
the Treasury will be in charge and will use the services of a large
group of volunteer salesmen, in the same manner that the war­
time bond-selling campaigns were organized. The drive will em­
phasize sales of Series E Savings Bonds, which will be termed
“ Security Bonds” during the campaign. The dual purpose of the
drive is to promote savings for individual security and to fight
inflation. The money received from the public will be withdrawn
from the consumer markets, and the Treasury will use it insofar
as possible to pay off bank-held public debt.

M arch 1948

31

M O N T H L Y REVIEW

BUSINESS INDEXES—TWELFTH DISTRICT
(1935-39 average-1001)
I n d u s tr ia l p r o d u c tio n
( p h y s ic a l v o lu m e )*
Y ear
and
m o n th

P etro l e u m 3
L um ber
Ad­
ju ste d

1929_____________
1930_____ ________________
1931__________________________
1932 _________ __
1933_________ ________
1934 _________ . . .
1935 _________ . . . . . .
1936 _________________
1937 ______________ ________
1938 _______________________
1939 _________ _______ __
1940 .......................... _
1 9 4 1 ......................
1942________________________
1943___________________ ______
1944__________________ __
.
1945 ________ ________ __ .
1946_________________________
1947 ..........................

U nad­
ju s te d

C rude

R e fin e d

U nad­
ju ste d

U nad­
ju ste d

148
112
77
46
62
67
83
106
113
88
110
120
140
140
133
138
108
118
139

121
95
78
74
72
73
86
89
99
104
93
93
96
103
118
129
135
131
138

193
168
140
134
127
123
140
154
163
159
160
158
172
175
194
226
243
219
239

W h eat
flo u r

C em ent
Ad­
ju ste d

U nad­
ju s te d

U nad­
ju ste d

110
96
74
48
54
70
68
117
112
92
114
124
164
194
160
128
131
165
193

106
100
101
89
88
95
94
96
99
96
107
103
103
104
115
119
132
128
133

F a cto ry
p a y r o lls 4

T o ta l
m a n u f a c t u r in g
e m p lo y m e n t4
E le c t r ic p o w e r
Ad­
ju ste d

U nad­
ju ste d

C a lifo r n ia
Ad­
ju ste d

83
84
82
73
73
79
85
96
105
102
112
122
136
167
214
231
219
219
256

U nad­
ju ste d

Ad­
ju ste d

U nad­
ju ste d

111
93
73
54
53
64
78
96
115
101
110
134
224
460
705
694
497
339
401

88
100
112
96
104
118
155
230
306
295
229
175
184

1947
January _______________________
February ______________________
M arch__________________________
A p r il___________________________
M a y ___________________________
J u n e ___________________________
July_______________ ____________
A u g u s t________________________
Septem ber_____________________
October________________________
November______________________
December____________________ _

154
172
142
132
129
131
125
130
130
139
153
178

106
120
123
134
150
150
139
157
153
151
146
133

134
136
137
137
138
139
139
139
139
140
141
140

219
227
231
234
243
240
236
254
254
247
246
241

191
182
207
193
193
186
184
185
193
187
205
215

164
166
190
196
195
202
195
201
207
203
199
200

152
147
141
133
129
138
126
125
123
133
133
116

250
249
252
254
251
251
252
252
259
260
263
275

246
244
248
252
253
257
262
263
259
253
258
271

183r
183
183
184
183
182
181
183
184
187
189
188

183r
182
182
184
183
182
181
183
185
187
188
188

386
387
390
392
392
394
392
408
411
418
419
423

379
384
389
392
394
396
392
410
412
423
420
423

1948
January________________________

174

116

141

248

218

188

114

278

275

186p

186p

420

413

C a r lo a d in g s
(n u m b e r)*

Y ear
and
m o n th

Ad­
ju ste d

1948
January____

U nad­
ju s te d

Ad­
ju ste d

112

192 9
193 0
193 1
—
193 2
193 3
193 4
193 5
1936...........
193 7
193 8
193 9
194 0
194 1
194 2
194 3
194 4
194 5
.
194 6
...
194 7
1947
January
February
M arch _____
A p r il______
M a y ______
J u n e ______
Ju ly_______
A u g u s t ____
September .
October____
N ovem ber..
December _.

M e r c h a n d is e
and
m is c e lla n e o u s

T o ta l

66

72
85
90
79
85
90
105
113
109
115

120
112
115
122

108r
108
109
113r

120

108

121
119
130
131
132
132

112
124
124
125
124
128
114
106
107

122
120
122

124
113
103
108

129
134

123
142
142
145
142
147
129
119

91
107
82
91
92
94
103

148

125

117

146
150
129
130
131
134
133
129

121
122

125

D is tr ic t

U nad­
ju ste d

Ad­
ju ste d

88

U nad­
ju ste d

112

109
84
57
37
43
48
56
70
75
65
72
79
91
103
97
97
83

90
96
99
116

117

109
117

A d­
ju ste d

102

110
111
111

O th e r

114
105
89
74
70
81
85
97

96
75
57
58

136
134
117

U nad­
ju s te d

D e p a r tm e n t s to r e s a le s
(v a lu e )* » 7
U ta h
& So.
Id aho

Ad­
ju ste d

Ad­
ju ste d

Ad­
ju ste d

106

98
105

86

140
123

101
72
68
77
86
100
105
100

R e ta il
fo o d
p r ic e s *

D is tr ic t
Ad­
ju ste d

97
89
83
61
64
77
89

U nad­
ju ste d

134
127

110
86
78
83

88

100

96
108

U nad­
ju ste d

13 2 .0
1 2 4 .8
1 0 4 .0
8 9 .8

86.8

9 3 .2
9 9 .6
1 0 0 .3
1 0 4 .5
9 9 .0
9 6 .9
9 7 .6
10 7 .9
1 3 0 .9
1 43.4
142.1
146.3
16 7 .4
2 0 0 .3

225
307
329

109
118
147
189
219
232
252
312
836

106
99
106
115
135
177
232
250
280
348
351

253
281
300
302
302
299
278
308
336
343
410
554

310
308
316
320
325
332
328
355
338
331
339
357

320
320
325
321
332
333
332
345
340
348
344
353

343

325

286

366
355
340
343
350
361
341
343
360
358

331
307
285
282
270
248
257
287
319
342

308
304
296
287
286
273
290
318
338
280

1 9 5 .7
1 9 3 .5
1 9 6 .6
1 9 7 .8
19 7 .3
19 4 .8
1 9 6 .5
19 7 .9
2 0 6 .6
2 0 4 .8
2 0 9 .4
2 1 3 .0

275

337

350

380

352

310

2 1 5 .4

101

103
95
90

313
311
319
320
325
330
327
348
336
333
339
352

84

340

111
98
101
102
100
101

P a c if ic
N o r th ­
w est

74

66

109
119
139
171
203
223
247
305
330

89
93
96

C a li­
fo r n ia

104
99
91
70
67
73

104
92
69

D e p t, sto r e
s t o c k s ( v a l u e ) 6»7

101
110
120
138
164
196

221

356

101
107
114
137
190
174
178
182
235
295
316

278

1 The terms “ adjusted” and “ unadjusted” refer to adjustment of monthly figures for seasonal variation. Excepting department store statistics, all indexes
are based upon data from outside sources, as follows: Lumber, various lumber trade associations; Petroleum and Cement, U.S. Bureau of Mines; Wheat flour,
U.S. Bureau of the Census; Electric power, Federal Power Commission; Manufacturing employment, Factory payrolls, and Retail food prices, U.S. Bureau of Labor
Statistics and cooperating state agencies; and Carloadings, various railroads and railroad associations.
2 Daily average.
* 1923-25 daily average = 100.
4 Excludes fish, fruit and vegetable canning. Factory payrolls index covers wage earners only.
• A t retail, end of month or end of year.
6 Los Angeles, San Francisco, and Seattle indexes combined.
p — preliminary.
r— revised.
7 Revised Series. D ata for earlier periods, by months, available on request. Explanation of revisions appears in this issue.




32

March 1948

FEDERAL RESERVE B A N K OF S A N F R A N C ISCO

BANKING AND CREDIT STATISTICS—TWELFTH DISTRICT
(amounts in millions of dollars)
C o n d it io n it e m s o f a ll m e m b e r b a n k s 1

Year
and
m onth

L o a n s a n d d is c o u n ts
C o m l., in d .
a g r ie .

&

T o ta l

1929
1930
1931
1932
1933
1934
1935
1936
1937
1938
1939
1940
1941
1942
1943
1944
1945
1946
1947

4,254
4,364
4,479
4,558
4,658
4,755
4,879
4,997
5,158
5,240
5,363

1948
January
February

5,413
5,467

In v e stm e n ts2
A ll o t h e r

R eal esta te

U .S . G o v ’t
s e c u r it ie s

647
721
711
635

2,239
2,218
1,898
1,570
1,486
1,469
1,537
1,682
1,871
1,869
1,967
2,130
2,451
2,170
2,106
2,254
2,663
4,068
5,363

1947
February
March
April
M ay
June
July
August
September
October
November
December

F o r p u r c h .,
c a r r y ’g s e c s .

668

670
662

686
730
798
864
931

82
76
65
59
51
62
184
343
195

663
664
735
933
870
934
956
1,103
1,882
2,338

327
362
399
460
275

1,000
974
899
885
908
1,431
2,153

121

211
228
309
560
750

2,047

134

1,828

649

2,338

121

2,153

750

A ll o t h e r
s e c u r it ie s

495
467
547
601
720
1,064
1,275
1,334
1,270
1,323
1,450
1,482
1,738
3,630
6,235
8,263
10,450
8,426
7,243

458
561
560
528
510
575
587
614
498
486
524
590
541
538
557
698
795
908
872

8,058
7,909
7,677
7,662
7,370
7,375
7,353
7,364
7.361
7.361
7,243

893
894
876
862
871
874
871

7,264
7,021

D em and
d e p o s it s
a d j u s t e d * ’4

1,234
1,158
984
840
951

1,201

1.389
1,791
1,740
1,781
1,983
2.390
2,893
4,356
5,998
6,950
8,203
8,821
8,928

T im e
d e p o s it s
(e x c e p t U .S .
G o v ’t) 4

1,776
1,915
1,667
1,515
1,453
1,759
2,006
2,078
2,164

2,212

U .S . G o v ’t
d e p o s it s 4

36
49
99
148
233
228
167
96
90
127
118

2,263
2,351
2,417
2,603
3,197
4,127
5,194
5,781
5,988

144
307
842
1,442
2,050
303
148

884
872

8,367
8,327
8,334
8,260
8,297
8,366
8,462
8,600
8,722
8,797
8,928r

5,804
5,820
5,837
5,851
5.908
5,888
5,887
5.909
5,949
5,907
5,988

370
396
286
235
103
148
208
216
192
205
148

848
833

8,854
8,495

6,006
6,048

210

68

159

M e m b e r b a n k r e se r v e s a n d r e la te d it e m s 6
Y ear
and
m o n th

R eserv e
b a n k c r e d it*

C o m m e r c ia l
o p e r a t io n s *

T reasu ry
o p e r a t io n s *

C o in a n d c u r r e n c y
in c ir c u la t io n

1947
February
March
April
M ay
June
July
August
September
October
November
December
1948
January
February

_
—

+
—
—

+
+
—

+
+
+
+
+
+
+

+
—
—

+
—
—
—

+
—
+
+

34
16
21
42
2
7
2
6
1
3
2
2
4
107
214
98
76
9
302

14
62
2
34
21
234
48
87
23
4
25
14
20

0
—
53
—
154
—
175
—
110
—
198
—
163
— * 227
—
90
—
240
—
192
—
148
—
596
- 1 ,9 8 0
- 3 ,7 5 1
- 3 ,5 3 4
- 3 ,7 4 3
- 1 ,6 0 7
443

—

+
_
—
—

+
—
—

+
+

23
+
89
+
+ 154
+ 234
+ 150
+ 257
+ 219
+ 454
+ 157
+ 276
+ 245
+ 420
+ 1 ,0 0 0
+ 2 ,8 2 6
+ 4 ,4 8 6
+ 4 ,4 8 3
+ 4 ,6 8 2
+ 1 ,3 2 9
+ 630

25
3
69
14
41
213
78
85
39
0
5

+
+
+
+
+
+

48
153

~

—

+
+
+

—

133
50
47
49
7
381
124
172
35
33
49
253
244

_
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+

—
—
—

+
—
—
—
—

+

—

R eserves7

F .R . n o t e s o f
F .R .B . o f S .F .

T o ta l

6
16
48
30
18
4
14
38
3
20
31
96
227
643
708
789
545
326
206

189
186
231
227
213
211
280
335
343
361
388
493
700
1,279
1,937
2,699
3,219
2,871
2,639

175
183
147
142
185
242
287
479
549
565
584
754
930
1,232
1,462
1,706
2,033
2,094
2,202

171
180
154
135
142
172
201
351
470
418
459
515
720
1,025
1,343
1,598
1,878
2,051
2,085

4
5
4
8
37
84
100
119
70
142
138
257
245
262
103
104
136
59
70

146
126
97
68
63
72
87
102
111
98
102
110
134
165
211
237
260
298
326

32
30
18
10
13
23
23
10
16
3
18

2,765
2,735
2,716
2,714
2,695
2,669
2,685
2,675
2,656
2,653
2,639

1,981
2,003
1,997
1,993
1,992
1,963
2,078
2,095
2,137
2,130
2,202

1,982
1,940
1,934
1,934
1,944
1,956
1,985
2,028
2,046
2,059
2,085

51
61
63
59
51
60
62
80
77
65
70

325
332
309
297
322
305
322
325
346
344
365

113
2

2,541
2,532

2,113
2,045

2,086
2,037

83
57

352
354

T o ta l*

1929
1930
1931
1932
1933
1934
1935
1936
1937
1938
1939
1940
1941
1942
1943
1944
1945
1946
1947

B a n k d e b it s
in d e x
31 c itie s *

R e q u ir e d

E xcess

U n a d ju sted

1 Annual figures are as of end of year; monthly figures are as of last Wednesday in month or, where applicable, as of call report date.

3 Monthly data for 1947 partly estimated.

* Demand deposits, excluding interbank and U.S. G ov’t deposits, less cash items in process of collection.
4 M onthly data partly estimated.
6 End of year and end of month figures.
8 Changes only.
7 Total reserves are as of end of year or month. Required and excess: monthly figures are daily averages, annual figures are December daily averages.
• Debits to total deposit accounts, excluding interbank deposits. 1935-39 daily average = 1 0 0 .
p— preliminary.
r— revised.