View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

MONTHLY

S E P T E M B E R 1951
CONTENTS
Credit Restraint— Its Necessity and Impact

1

The Defense Bond Drive— an Editorial

2

.

Portland C e m e n t............................... 6
Statistical T a b le s ............................... 11
Ultrasonics— A New Tool for Industry

K

e

v

i

e

. 12

w

FINANCE • INDUSTRY • A G R IC U L T U R E • TRADE
FO URTH

Vol. 33— No. 9

FEDERAL

RESERVE

D IS T R IC T

Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland

Cleveland 1, Ohio

Credit Restraint— Its Necessity and Impact
HE abatement of inflationary pressures in recent
months has focused attention on the whole
mechanism of economic controls in a m anner almost
completely opposite to that which was in vogue at
this time last year. Concern is frequently expressed
that the controls imposed since the outbreak of the
Korean w ar may prove either unnecessary or too
stringent, or both. Of the various measures adopted
to restrain the expansion of credit, the more recent
selective controls have aroused the greatest volume
of discussion. However, the effects of these controls
can seldom be completely segregated from the reper­
cussions of traditional policies aimed at insuring
monetary stability. It may be appropriate, there­
fore, to review briefly the developments leading up
to the current phase of credit management, and to
examine the joint impact of the restraining measures,
both general and selective, adopted by the banking
system in the past twelve months.

T

Leaving aside the ques­
tion of what the pri­
mary causes of infla­
tion were in 1950, it is apparent that monetary and
credit developments contributed to the ascending
wage-price spiral in the latter half of the year. Along
with the sharp rise in the volume of consumer, busi­
ness and government stockpiling, the accelerated
turnover of bank deposits, and increased withdrawals

Expansion of Loans
and Money Su p p ly — 1950

An ed ito ria l discussing th e cu rren t
Defense B ond Drive appears on page 2



of savings at savings institutions and in the form of
savings bonds, banks throughout the United States
expanded their loans and their investments in state
and local government and corporate securities by
an unprecedented $13 billion (2 1 % ). This record
extension of credit to the private sector of the
economy and to state and local authorities far ex­
ceeded the increase in such credit in any previous
postwar year, including the war-peace transition
period of 1946 and 1947 (see C hart I ) . The 1950
expansion of bank credit to private borrowers and
to states and political subdivisions was five times as
great as in the rearmam ent year of 1941. In addi­
tion to the record volume of bank lending, funds for
expenditures on current output and on capital assets
of the economy were also made available in near­
record volume out of current and past savings by
such financial organizations as life insurance com­
panies, and savings and loan associations.
As a result of the expansion of bank credit, the
supply of money available for the cash balances
of individuals, partnerships, corporations and state
and local governments increased over $7 billion dur­
ing 1950, exceeding slightly the expansion in the
prewar years 1940 and 1941, and substantially that
of any postwar year except 1946 (see Chart I I ) .
W ithout the increase in loans and in the money
supply, it is certain that at least part of the demand
for goods by all sectors of the economy would have
failed to become effective and therefore would not
have been translated into sharply higher prices. Not
so many consumers would have been able to try to
buy houses or automobiles at advanced prices, for
example, if they had been unable to borrow on rela­
tively easy terms both as regards their initial down(C O N T IN U E O O N P A G E 3)

Page 2

Monthly Business Review

September 1, 1951

THE DEFENSE BOND DRIVE—Editorial
On Ju ly 12, 1951, th e H on. John W. Snyder, Secre­
ta ry of th e T reasury, announced plans for a Defense
Bond D rive to s ta rt on L abor D ay, Septem ber 3. The
D rive will run through October 27. In order to cover
th e tim e lag in th e transm ission of reports, all Defense
Bond sales reported b y N ovem ber 13 will be counted
in th e D rive. T he D rive has tw o objectives: (1) to sell
as m any bonds to individuals as possible during the
period and (2) to get as m any people as possible signed
up for continuing regular weekly, m onthly or periodi­
cal purchases th ereafter. Com m ittees have been set
up in every state and in nearly every county to further
the D rive. Efforts are being m ade to increase th e use
of th e payroll savings plan in business establishm ents,
to foster savings in th e schools and to encourage others
to arrange for m onthly or periodic purchases of bonds.
B onds are being sold for th e T reasury b y v irtu ally all
financial institutions. T his includes m ost commercial
banks, savings banks, tru s t companies, savings and
loan associations and credit unions.
S upport of th e D rive b y th e people of th e nation
will serve 4 purposes:
(1) I t will provide th e T reasury w ith funds needed

for financing th e n a tio n ’s defense program .
(2) I t will reduce th e need of the T reasury for
going to th e banking system for m oney, and
th u s will reduce inflationary pressures and
help to pro tect th e buying power of every
m an, wom an and child in th e land.
(3) I t will provide individuals and families w ith
increased savings as protection against th e
uncertainties of th e future.
( 4) I t will fu rth er dem onstrate public support
■
of th e defense effort.
T he T reasury needs m oney to pay for th e defense
program . Federal expenditures for defense are ex­
pected to increase su b stantially over th e next several
years. T o tal governm ent expenses are expected to be
higher th a n revenues. T he T reasury will have to
borrow th e difference.
T o th e ex tent th a t th e T reasury borrows from the
banking system , deposits are increased, to ta l govern­
m ent and p riv ate spending tends to rise and infla­



tionary pressures m ount. T he T reasury gets new d e­
posits to spend while individuals and businesses are
left w ith th e funds or m oney to spend th a t th ey had
previously. However, when th e T reasury borrows from
individuals (by selling bonds), th a t m oney, which in ­
dividuals m ight have spent, is transferred to th e
T reasury and th e T reasury spends it. In this case the
T reasu ry ’s spending is in place of ra th e r th a n in
addition to individuals’ spending; it helps to keep
to tal spending from increasing more rapidly th a n the
supply of goods, and thus serves as a check on infla­
tion. W hen people try to increase th eir buying of
goods and services m ore rapidly th a n supplies increase,
the result is th a t prices advance, th e cost of living rises,
and salaries and wages buy less.
T he volum e of savings increased substantially d u r­
ing W orld W ar I I and th e people of our nation came
out of the w ar w ith th e largest volum e of liquid savings
in our history. These savings, furtherm ore, were more
widely distributed th a n ever before. As a consequence,
when goods becam e more plentiful during peacetim e,
people were able more easily to buy th e homes, a u to ­
mobiles, refrigerators and other household goods n o t
available to them during th e war. Now again, resources
are being diverted to defense. If people will d iv ert in ­
creased proportions of th eir present record-breaking
incomes into savings, th ey will have more funds w ith
which to buy m ajor durable goods when m aterials b e­
come m ore plentiful and perm it increased o u tp u t of
these item s. E ven b etter, increased savings will provide
people w ith more funds to m eet emergencies which
m ight arise later in this uncertain and uneasy world.
T hey will also help to cushion th e shock of unem ploy­
m ent or of changes in em ploym ent incidental to future
changes in our economy growing o u t of ad justm en ts
to war and peace.
W idespread response to th e Defense B ond D rive in
th e form of o u trig h t purchases or of subscriptions to
buy bonds regularly in th e future will provide con­
vincing evidence th a t th e people of this nation are
united in support of th e defense program . O ur recent
grow th in pro d u ctiv ity has dem onstrated our will to
produce th e goods needed. T he purchase of Defense
Bonds and an increase in savings generally will dem on­
stra te our ability to exercise self-restraint and th u s to
help keep our internal economy strong and healthy
while we are building our external defenses.

Page 3

Monthly Business Review

September 1, 1951

CREDIT RESTRAINT

Chart II

(C O N T IN U E D F R O M P A G E l )

INCREASES IN BANK LOANS AND SECURITIES,
AND MONEY SUPPLY
Other Than U. S. Government
(Annual 1940-1950)

payment and the subsequent monthly payments.
Retailers, wholesalers and manufacturers would have
been less willing and able to augment their inven­
tories and expand their scale of operations if they
had been less able to secure the cash to finance it.

b I l s '. O F

$ ’ 5.

B l LS p d F

15
14

The main reason why the expansion of bank loans exceeded the
growth in the money supply in
1950 was that the banking system was able to reduce
further its holding of U. S. Government securities,
as has been the case in every year since 1945. (The
reduction in 1949, however, was nominal.) Insofar
as the reduction in bank holdings of Governments
in 1950 was accomplished by net redemptions, the
contractive effect on the money supply which re­
sulted from these redemptions was achieved by an
indirect route. When the Treasury collects revenues,
from income taxes for example, this generally in­
volves the transfer of deposits by check from private
accounts at commercial banks to Treasury accounts
with the banking system. W hen the Treasury spends
these revenues — for armaments, social services, aid
to agriculture, etc. — there is another transfer of
deposits, this time in the reverse direction, out of
Treasury balances and into private accounts. W hen
excess revenues are used by the Treasury to redeem
its securities held by the banking system, this also
causes a reduction in Treasury deposits, but without
any corresponding addition to private accounts.
An additional factor which partially offset the in­
fluence of the record loan expansion on the privately

13

Offsets to
Loan Expansion

Chart I
INCREASES IN BANK LOANS AND SECURITIES
Other T han Obligations of the U. S. Government
(Annual 1940-1950)
IMC IN
B IL S . OF %'•>,

1940

in c

. IN

B IL S . OF $■.
•>

1941

1946

19.47

19 48

1949

1 95 0

. . . loans to private borrowers and to state and munici­
pal authorities by all banks in the U. S. increased a rec­
ord $13 billion during 1950 (chiefly after “Korea”), in
sharp contrast to increases of only $1 Vi billion and $2 Vi
billion, respectively, in the rearmament years of 1940
and 1941.




1
2

-2
-3
19 40

1941

. . . the expansion of bank loans was responsible for the
$7 billion increase in the privately-owned money supply
in 1950, the largest increase since 1946. In 1940 and
1941, on the other hand, bank loans were only a second­
ary factor in the growth of the money supply. In the
period from the end of World War II to the end of
1950, the aggregate increase in bank loans to private
borrowers and to state and local authorities was equal to
the net gain of nearly $40 billion in the privately-owned
money supply in this period.

owned money supply in 1950 was an outflow of
gold totaling nearly $2 billion, chiefly in the second
half of the year.
The significance of these contractive forces and
the implications for past and future monetary policy
cannot be overemphasized. Yet they were not pur­
posely planned. They were among the very small
number of natural anti-inflationary forces operating
in 1950, and resulted more from circumstance than
design. Actual Treasury outlays did not reach the
proportions commonly anticipated, and foreign coun­
tries benefited to an unforeseen degree from the
spectacular rise in world raw material prices while
continuing to receive economic aid.
These circumstances no longer prevail. In the
second quarter of 1951, cash payments by the Treas­
ury exceeded cash receipts, though defense expendi­
tures still lagged behind the pace of contract awards.
By midsummer, the prices of many primary com­
modities imported by the United States had declined
substantially from the peak levels reached earlier in
the year, with the result that this country had to
pay less for a given volume of such imports. In July,
a nominal inflow of gold was reported for the first
time in more than a year. Defense expenditures are
scheduled to increase, and total expenditures by the
Federal Government are likely to exceed revenue.
To the extent that the deficit is not financed by

Page 4

Monthly Business Review

private and public nonbank sources, the banking
system may again be called upon to finance rearm ­
ament by purchasing U. S. Government securities,
as it did from 1940 through 1945, thereby adding to
the money supply and to the now latent inflationary
pressures. In this connection, however, it is worthy
of note that in recent weeks approximately $1 / 2
billion has been raised by the Treasury, largely from
outside the banking system, through the issuance of
new bills in excess of the volume of weekly m aturi­
ties. In the course of the financing operation, the
yield on new bills rose to the highest level in nearly
twenty years.
Partly as a result of restrictive monetary and credit policies and partly as
a result of seasonal factors, the growth
in bank loans has moderated (see
Chart I I I ) . While the slowing down in the rate of
bank loan expansion is not impressive when seasonal
influences are taken into account, nevertheless it may
well have contributed to the lessening of inflationary
pressures this year. T he slowdown was particularly
marked in the second quarter of the year. While re­
ports for recent weeks reveal further expansion in
bank loans, thus far it has been smaller than in most
previous postwar years.
In the Fourth District, member banks also show a
decline in the rate of expansion of their loans from
the record pace of the third quarter of 1950, though
to a less marked extent than at all banks in the United
States. In contrast to the national trend, however,
the expansion of loans by Fourth District member
banks in the second quarter of this year was greater
than in the comparable period of any other year. Pre­
liminary figures indicate that the third-quarter expan­
sion may also be greater than average for this period
of the year. Some of the reasons for the continued
relatively high rate of loan expansion in this District
are noted later in the discussion of the various types
of loans.

September 1, 1951

Chart III
EXPANSION OF BANK LOANS AND SECURITIES
Other Than Obligations of the U. S. Government
(1950-1951 compared with average 1947, ’48, and ’49)
(Quarterly)
INC IN
b ils . o f $ v

IN C

IN
b ils .

or $ .
•»

Rate of Loan
Expansion
Slow s Down

General Before considering developments in speControls cific categories of the loan portfolio, how­

ever, it may be desirable to review the
operation of the traditional weapons of monetary
control, which react on the credit structure as a
whole. Federal Reserve Bank discount rates were
increased from l / 2% to 1^4% and a more flexible
open market policy was inaugurated in August last
year. M ember bank reserve requirements were in­
creased in January and February, making it neces­
sary for banks to hold an additional $2 billion of
reserves. In M arch it was announced that the Treas­
ury and the Federal Reserve had reached agreement
with respect to monetary and debt management
policies with the purpose of minimizing monetization
of the public debt and at the same time assuring the



quarter since the third quarter of 1950. Although this
reflected seasonal influences in part, the loan expansion
in the second quarter of 1951 exceeded the average of the
increases in the second quarter of 1947, 1948 and 1949 by
a relatively small margin.
* Data received since this chart was prepared indicate that the expan­
sion of loans in the second quarter of 1951 was somewhat in excess
of $1 billion.

success of the Federal Government’s financing opera­
tions.
The adoption of a more flexible open market
policy by the Federal Reserve injected a long-absent
element of risk and uncertainty into the market.
The slow decline in prices of Treasury bonds which
had been evident throughout 1950 was sharply ac­
centuated, and the yield on the Victory 2 ^ ’s, for
example, rose from 2.45% at the end of February
to 2.67% at the end of April, and remained at about
that level for the next three months. T he Treasury
offered holders of $20 billion of long-term restricted
marketable Treasury bonds bearing a 2 ] ^ % coupon
the privilege of exchanging these issues into market­
able bonds at 2^4% , and most investors accepted
the offer. In all, nearly $14 billion, (or 70% ) of the
bonds were converted. T he rates offered by the
Treasury in refunding m aturing or called issues were
increased, in keeping with the upward movement of
yields in the market. In the August 1, 1951, refund­
ing, for example, an 11-month certificate at 1% %
was offered, in contrast to a 5-year note at 1^4%
issued on January 1, and a 13-month note bearing
l l 4 % issued on July 1, 1950. T he traditional
monetary restraints imposed by the Federal Reserve
System— discount rates, open market operations and
reserve requirements— have succeeded, with the co­
operation of the Treasury, in increasing the cost,
reducing the volume and restricting the availability
of credit.
Some moderation was apparent in August, and

September 1, 1951

Monthly Business Review

prices of Governments rose, with the result that the
yield on the Victory 2 / 2,s, for example, declined
I
from 2.67% to 2.59% in the first two weeks of the
month. The more buoyant tone in the market re­
flects progress by various institutions in reducing
heavy backlogs of loan commitments, and this has
released a greater proportion of current savings for
investment in other outlets, such as U. S. Govern­
ment securities. In addition, there are indications
that the total volume of current savings has risen
substantially in recent months. Since the end of
June, Federal Reserve holdings of U. S. Government
securities have remained relatively stable at approxi­
mately $23 billion.
Trends by Type of Loan

Commercial and industrial loans have
been the most im portant single factor in
the post-Korean expansion of bank credit,
rising $ 6^2 billion at member banks throughout the
country between the end of June 1950 and the end
of June 1951. The bulk of the expansion occurred
in the second half of 1950 and presumably was
caused in large measure by inventory and working
capital borrowing growing out of the desire of busi­
nesses to build up their stocks, rises in commodity
prices and other production costs and out of increased
business. The increase in the first half of 1951 was
concentrated largely in the early months of the year,
probably u n d e r the impetus of similar forces.
Although there was virtually no net change in the
total of these loans in the second quarter of 1951,
the stability contrasts with a normal seasonal decline
in this period of the year, and in recent weeks signs
of a resumption in the expansion of business loans
have been apparent.
While the principal increase in business loans in
the nation as a whole occurred during the second
half of 1950, the sharpest increase in this District
was in 1951. (See Chart IV ). Fourth District weekly
reporting member banks show an expansion in busi­
ness loans of 2 0 % in the first half of the year com­
pared with a gain of 8 % for the country as a whole.
This difference in trend reflects differences in the
character of loans made and of businesses financed.
Products such as steel, machinery, metal compo­
nents for engines and bodies, rubber, etc., which bulk
large in the defense program, form an important
part of the Fourth District economy, and pressure on
these industries generally is increasing. In addition,
the seasonal pattern for business loans in this District
is somewhat different from that of banks throughout
the country, due partly to the greater importance of
commodity loans in other areas. The contrast is illus­
trated by the fact that business loans declined during
the first half of 1951 at reporting banks in the
Atlanta, St. Louis and Dallas districts, where com­
modity loans are more important.
Business
Loans




Page 5

Classification o f I*1 recent months, a large numSusiness Loans
ker of the weekly reporting mem­

ber banks have provided a detailed
breakdown of new commercial and industrial loans
made and of repayments on such loans, showing
both the purpose for which the loans were made and
the business of the borrower. This information was
compiled by the banks at the request of the National
Committee for Voluntary Credit Restraint, which
exercises general direction of the Voluntary Credit
Restraint Program. This program was established
by the financial institutions of the nation for the
purpose of screening loans made by commercial
banks, investment bankers, insurance companies,
savings banks and savings and loan associations with
a view to eliminating or restricting borrowing which
would not contribute directly or indirectly to the
defense effort or to the increased productivity of the
nation. The program injected an element of selec­
tive restraint into those fields of business and state
and local government borrowing not otherwise sub­
ject to mandatory selective controls. (A description
of the scope, purpose and mechanism of the Program
can be found in the June issue of the Business
Review).
According to the data reported by the banks, com­
mercial and industrial loans would have declined
somewhat between early May and early August had
it not been for'an increase of more than $500 million
in loans to finance defense and defense-supporting
activities (see table below). Outstanding debt for
Chart IV
COMMERCIAL, IN D USTR IA L AND
AGRICULTURAL LOANS
Cumulative Changes during 1948, 1949, 1950 and 1951
Weekly Reporting Member Banks, Fourth District

that of the second half of last year, occurred in the early
months and was followed by a sporadic upward move­
ment in the spring and early summer. In August, how­
ever, seasonal influences contributed to a sharp accelera­
tion of the rate of expansion.
(C O N T IN U E D O N P A G E 8)

Page 6

September 1, 1951

Monthly Business Review

Portland Cement
RESPONSE
continued
I Ndemand, Districttocement millsand unprecedented
are well on their
way toward topping the 1950 record output of 20
million barrels. Cement production in the first six
months was 20 percent higher than in the same
1950 period. Each year since 1947, when the old
1927 mark of 17.4 million barrels was first exceeded,
the mills have set successively higher records.
Despite the rising tide of production, District mills
have been unable to rebuild finished stocks to pre­
war levels when output averaged about half that of
recent years. Nevertheless, mill operators foresee no
general shortage of cement in this area in the second
half of the year. It is expected that supply will just
about balance with anticipated construction activity.
This takes into account the expected drop in resi­
dential and commercial building activity, and as­
sumes that there will be no unusual interruptions in
production and supply lines.
Rate of
O perations

The cement industry, unlike other
heavy industries such as steel, has
never been able to push operations to
100 percent of theoretical capacity even in periods
of sustained demand. In June, for example, District
mills turned out a near monthly record of 2 million
barrels of cement but this was only 87 percent of
capacity as figured by the Bureau of Mines. The
industry in 1950 achieved the highest annual utili­
zation factor in more than a decade with output of
about 72 percent of theoretical capacity. Neverthe­
less, this was substantially below the national aver­
age of 87 percent as shown by the accompanying
chart.
PORTLAND CEM ENT PRO D UC TIO N
4TM.Q
m il.

U.S.
M IL.
OF $

or $

The percent of District mill utilization has been
below the United States average every year since
1931. This is the result, in part, of the marked ex­
pansion of capacity that took place in this area in
the 1920’s. It may also be due to the age of certain
mills and the failure of their local markets to m ain­
tain or equal anticipated rates of demand envisioned
when the mills were originally constructed. Steadily
advancing freight charges have also reduced the areas
which given mills can serve on a competitive basis.
An industry that has been slowly increasing its
rate of operations in recent years might be expected
to be, at the very least, eliminating marginal pro­
duction facilities. This has happened—some facilities
have been taken out of service. However, these have
been more than offset by expansion at other loca­
tions with the net result that District total capacity,
which amounted to 25.8 million barrels in 1945,
rose 8 percent to 27.9 million barrels by the end of
1950.
over-all rise in capacity has masked
some interesting changes at individual
mills which were disclosed in a recent survey made
by the Research Departm ent of this bank. O f the
14 cement mills located in the District, only four have
the same capacity as in 1945, five have expanded
operations, and five others have contracted their
production facilities.
The five mills that have dropped capacity in the
last five years averaged a 15 percent decline with
the range between 7 and 23 percent. O n the
other hand, the mills which expanded facilities had
an average increase of 48 percent. The increases

C ap a city

CAPACITY U TIL IZA TIO N
1935-1950

/ /
ft

#/

P

h

/

/T
r
✓

\\
\\
\V
t \
y

J /

_J

1913

1 1 1 - — 1 ..J.. 1 1 — J— 1 1
— —
__ __I— — L - L . l - t .

1918

1923

1928

FOURTH
D IS T R IC T
SCALE

ft
i

__1 — 1 4 __1 —

1933

n \ ji
r
\
riV /

1938

J J

1943

. . . there has been no postwar let-down in cement mill
activity. New production records have been established
each year since 1947, in the Fourth District as well as the
country as a whole.

. . . utilization of capacity has crept up in recent years
in this District, but has failed to match the national gain.

Source: Bureau of Mines

Source: Bureau of Mines




September 1, 1951

Monthly Business Review

ranged from 25 to a maximum of 78 percent. In
addition, one of these operators was closed down
completely in 1945 because of a lack of sufficient
orders to operate, but is now back in full production
with new additional facilities.
At least five District mills are currently in the
process of further raising productive ability through
a wide variety of programs. One company is in­
creasing its storage area so that it can continue oper-

Page 7

CEMENT PR O D UC TIO N PER MAN H O U R

CHANGES A T F O U R TH DISTR IC T CEMENT
MILLS *
1945-1950
Rotary Kilns
Number
Average Less than
Length
100'
100'-125' 126'-149' 150'-199'

1945
1950

141'
142'

—0—
—0—

45
41

—0—
—0—

200'
and up TOTAL

7
7

19
19

71
67

Rotary Kilns
Distribution
Less than
100'
100'-125'

1945
1950

0
—0—

126'-149'

150'-199'

200'
and up

27%
29%

10%
10%

0
—0—

63%
61%

TOTAL

100.0%
100.0%

Capacity
BY PROCESSES
000’s bbls.
Distribution
Wet
Dry
Wet
Dry

TOTAL
000’s of bbls

1945
1950

22,604
24,673

12,733
14,883

9,871
9,790

+ 9%

+ 17%

44%
40%

-1 %

% Change

56%
60%

NUM BER OF PORTLAND CEMENT PLANTS *
by size groups
Estimated annual
capacity, bbls.:

United States 1949** Fourth District 1950
No. of
Percent
No. of
Percent
plants
of total
plants
of total

Less than 1,000,000 .. .
1,000,000 to 2,000,000
2,000,000 to 3,000,000
3,000,000 to 10,000,000
T O T A L ..................

26
87
28
11
152

1
10
2
1
14

17%
57
19
7
100%

7%
72
14
7
100%

CAPACITY OF PORTLAND CEMENT PLA N TS*
by processes
Process

W et................
D ry ................
T O T A L ..

Capacity (000’s of barrels)
U. S. 1949** District 1950

139,169
119,779
258,948

14,883
9,790
24,673

Percent of total
U. S.
District

54%
46%
100%

60%
40%
100%

* Fourth District data in these tables were obtained from 14 mills
located in the Fourth Federal Reserve District. Production data
used in the text material were obtained from reports published by
the Bureau of Mines for their territories of Ohio, Western Penn­
sylvania and West Virginia. This includes all of the Fourth Dis­
trict plus production from West Virginia mills outside of the
District with an additional rated capacity of 3,241,000 barrels.
** U. S. Bureau of Mines.




provements and nearer-to-capacity operations have been
the major factors.
Source: Bureau of Mines
Years 1947, 1948, 1949, and 1950 are estimated.

ating its kilns and grinding machines steadily through
the normally dull winter demand period and store
the excess production. Another company will step
up output by converting from the wet to the dry
process. Another is renovating its kilns to increase
efficiency and adding to its grinding capacity. The
fourth company has dismantled an old kiln and will
replace it with a more efficient and somewhat larger
unit.
These various construction plans will raise Dis­
trict rated capacity by at least 600,000 barrels in
1951 and another 250,000 barrels in 1952. An im­
portant producer has a 2,000,000-barrel expansion
program in the talking stage but as yet has not made
any definite commitments.
Output
Cement mills have gradually been
Per M an hour improving their efficiency to meet

ever-rising costs. One measure of
this trend is cement production per m an hour and is
shown on an accompanying chart.
Perhaps the most im portant factor influencing
man-hour productivity is the rate at which a mill
is being operated. Operations have become so mech­
anized that as operations move up toward 100 per­
cent of capacity the increases are achieved with a
less than proportional in-put of m an hours. This
tendency is clearly shown by the chart. The sharp
dips in productivity occurred during periods of re­
stricted output but rose markedly as total production
increased.
There has also been, of course, a gradual increase
in output per man hour over the years due to the
development of more efficient methods and machin­
ery and improved materials handling devices. These
have been applied all the way from the quarry or
slag pile to the clinker grinding machines and load­

Page 8

Monthly Business Review

ing docks. The construction of new and more effi­
cient plants, modernization of existing properties,
and abandonment of obsolete mills have all played
a part in raising the industry’s average m an-hour
output. But the sharp year-to-year fluctuations
shown by the chart are due to changes in the gen­
eral rate of production.
Considering the close relationship between rates
of operation and output per m an hour, it is not
surprising to find that output per man hour at Dis­
trict mills has been below the United States average.
This corresponds to the fact that District operations

September 1, 1951

as a percent of theoretical capacity have also ranged
consistently below the United States average. Per­
haps another contributing factor is that all of the
District mills except two operate their kilns entirely
with powdered coal. One company supplements its
coal with by-product furnace gas and the other uses
some oil. Coal makes for larger labor requirements
as preparing it for burning takes more m an hours.
The national trend, especially in the Southwest and
Far West, has been toward higher and higher utili­
zation of natural gas and fuel oil which can be
handled with a minimum of labor.

CREDIT RESTRAINT
(C O N T IN U E D F R O M P A G E 5)

nondefense purposes was reported to have declined
some $350 million in the same period. In the Fourth
District also, defense and defense-supporting loans
were reported to have increased substantially during
a similar period of time, but nondefense loans de­
clined only slightly.
In interpreting these figures, however, certain con­
siderations should be borne in mind which tend to
modify the extent to which the defense program
appears to have been the direct cause of a continua­
tion of the loan expansion. Under the present sys­
tem of classification, a loan to a steel firm, for
example, is considered to be “defense-supporting”
because of the basic dependence of the rearmament
program on an adequate supply of steel, regardless
of whether the plans of the firm were made prior
to the outbreak of hostilities in Korea. Such a loan,
although defense-supporting, is not directly attri­
butable to the defense program itself. Furthermore,
the reports tend to understate the volume of repay­
ments, since transactions involving less than $50,000
are excluded. Since repayments are frequently made
in smaller units than loans, it is probable that part
of the repayments on a loan of, say, $200,000 might
be in units of less than $50,000, and such repay­
ments consequently would not be included in the
reported figures. As a result, the net increases in
loans which have been reported chiefly in the de­
fense or defense-supporting categories are probably
overstated, and the net decreases (chiefly in non­
defense categories) are probably understated.
The most recent data show net increases in
the amount of outstanding business loans incurred
for nondefense inventory and working capital pur­
poses. Prior to August, loans for this purpose were
the m ajor contracting factor both for the national
and Fourth District sample of banks.
An accompanying table indicates the net changes
reported in business loans by industry or business
groups. As might be expected in view of the increase




in defense and defense-supporting loans, net borrow­
ing by producers of metals and metal products was
the m ajor expansionary factor both nationally and
in the Fourth District. Prior to mid-August, such
loans had risen sharply in every week for which data
are available for Fourth District banks, but since then
the rate of expansion appears to have slowed down.
An increase of about $90 million was also reported
for the textiles, apparel and leather category for the
banks throughout the nation, but in this District new
borrowing by such firms has comprised only a small
part of the total with virtually no net change in the
volume of such loans outstanding. Public utility
borrowing is reported to have contributed substan­
tially to the increase in loans both nationally and in
the Fourth District.
A m ajor contracting factor in the period under
review has been loans to commodity dealers, down
more than $200 million at all reporting banks. Such
loans declined in this District also until late July
when a sharply expanded volume of new borrowing
offset the earlier reductions. Loans to food, liquor
and tobacco manufacturers declined $224 million
(net) in May, June and July, but in recent weeks
net increases have been reported in these loans also.
Both locally and nationally, bank debt of wholesalers
and retailers combined shows a net decline for the
three months as a whole, but in the latest weeks for
which figures are available, substantial net new
borrowing has been reported. T he largest volume of
repayments to Fourth District banks for any single
business classification was reported for sales finance
companies, resulting in a net decline of $21 million
in their indebtedness, whereas nationally, new bor­
rowing and repayments by such firms were virtually
in balance.
Securities O ther
Than Federal

T he other m ajor component of
bank credit for which the Volun­
tary Credit Restraint program is

September 1, 1951

Monthly Business Review

the only selective instrument of restriction is that
credit extended through bank purchases of corporate
and state and local government securities. Bank
holdings of these securities have expanded much more
slowly in 1951 than they did last year. By late
August, investments in such securities by weekly
reporting banks throughout the country showed a
net increase of approximately $100 million, in con­
trast to a $1 billion expansion in the same period
of 1950. Moreover, the small gain this year occurred
in the early months, and since mid-April no net
change has been registered. The curtailment of bank
activity in this field took place in the face of a sub­
stantially higher volume of new capital flotations in
M arch, April and M ay of this year than in the cor­
responding months of 1950. Although holdings of
non-U. S. Government securities by reporting banks
in this District registered a net gain during the first
half of the year similar to that of 1950, by Sep­
tember this expansion was wiped out and the port­
folio stood at virtually the same figure as at the end
of last year.
Expansion in
Of great prominence in the
Real Estate
1950 inflation was the recordLoans Slow s Down breaking growth in mortgage

loans. In addition to the more
than $3j/2 billion increase in real estate loans at banks
throughout the country, savings and loan associations
reported a gain of more than $2 billion and life
insurance companies an increase of $3 billion in
their mortgage holdings during the year. In this
District also, record increases in mortgage loans
were reported by banks and savings and loan associChart V
INCREASES IN REAL ESTATE LOANS
First half of year, 1946 — 1951
Weekly Reporting Member Banks, U. S.

. . . the expansion of real estate loans at reporting banks
throughout the country in the first half of 1951 was less
than in the comparable period of any other postwar year
except 1949.
• Partially estimated.




Page 9

ations. Regulation X was imposed in October last
year and subsequently broadened in scope with a view
to imposing restraints on the growth of credit, to
moderating the boom in real estate and to reducing
the volume of building.
The full effects of Regulation X and the compan­
ion regulations of the Federal Housing Administra­
tion and the Veterans Administration were not felt
immediately. M any lenders had large volumes of
commitments outstanding at the time the regulations
were imposed and these loans were, of course, exempt
from the restraints of the regulations. As a conse­
quence, the restrictions have become effective only
gradually as new commitments or loans have been
made. While the regulations have undoubtedly had
some restraining effect on the growth of credit, it is
pretty clear that the most im portant factors have
been the decline in prices of U. S. Government securi­
ties and the increases in money rates which accom­
panied the changes in the monetary and debt
management policies of the Federal Reserve System
and the Treasury last M arch. The sale of govern­
ment securities at lower prices in order to lend the
proceeds on mortgage loans involves an initial loss
which makes the transaction much less attractive to
the lender. The rise in money rates has made U. S.
Government securities and other alternate forms of
investment more attractive. As a consequence, lend­
ers have become much less interested in lending on
mortgages at 4% or 4 l4 % — the rates for VA and
FH A mortgages— and rates on so-called conventional
mortgages have tended to rise.
The tightening of money and the slowing down
of expansion in the real estate mortgage field are
undoubtedly due in part to the regulations, but for
the most part reflect the interrelationships existing
in the money market and illustrate the m anner in
which changes in Treasury debt management and
in Federal Reserve open market policies are trans­
lated into restraints on inflationary forces.
All types of lenders reveal a slowing down in the
growth of their mortgage loan portfolios, particularly
in VA and FH A mortgages. At banks, the expan­
sion in real estate loans in the first half of 1951 not
only was substantially less than in the second half
of 1950, but (as indicated in Chart V ) was smaller
than in any other first half year of the postwar
period except 1949.
O n September 1, legislation was enacted modify­
ing the terms of Regulation X for the extension of
credit on homes of $12,000 or less. The law extends
the maximum maturity of a loan on a new home
selling for more than $7,000 but less than $12,000
to 25 years and liberalizes the down-payment re­
quirements for houses in this price range. M inimum
down-payments specified in the law compared with
those prescribed in the then prevailing regulations
are shown in the following table:

Page 10

M inim um Down-Payment Permitted
Value of Family Unit

September 1, 1951

Monthly Business Review

By Old Regulation

By New Act

VA Loans
$250
Up to 7.1%
7.1%-13.0%
13.0%-15.8%

$7,000 or less*........
$7,000-$10,000.......
$10,000412,000....

FHA and Conventional Loans
10.0%-17.1%
10%
17.1%-23.0%
15%
20%
23.0%-25.8%

|

M inimum
Down-payment
Reg. W Def. Prod
Act

Type of
Instalment Credit

$5,000 or less..........
$5,000-$7,000.........
$7,000-$10,000.......
$10,000412,000....

* Where the value of the family unit is
lation does not apply.

Effect of Revised Defense Production Act
on Regulation W

4%
6%
8%

2,500 or less, the Regu-

To maintain conformity with the revised schedules
of minimum down-payments on family units costing
$12,000 or less prescribed by law, the Board of
Governors modified slightly the down-payment re­
quirements on family units costing up to $24,500.
In addition, the law suspends restrictions on credit
in “critical defense areas” on housing costing up to
$12,000 or renting under $84 a month, and provides
that the President may order relaxation of the credit
restraints on higher priced housing in such areas.

Automobiles.................
Household Appliances
(incl. TV and radio)
Furniture and floor
coverings...................
Home repairs and
improvements...........

Maximum
Maturity
Reg. W Def. Prod.
Act

33 14% 33J^%

15mos. 18mos.

25

% 15

%

15 mos. 18mos.

15

% 15

%

15 mos. 18 mos.

10

% 10

%

30 mos. 36 mos.

In addition, the down-payment for any of the
three categories of consumer durable goods can now
be made completely in the form of a trade-in allow­
ance on such items as used automobiles, appliances
or furniture. As with the liberalization of Regula­
tion X on home purchases, no evidence is as yet avail­
able to indicate the extent to which these relaxations
of credit restraints will add to the demand for bank
credit.
N et Change in Commercial and Industrial Loans
By Purpose of Loan

(Reporting banks: U. S. and Fourth District)
NET CHANGE May 9-Aug. 1
Purpose of Loan

U. S.

Fourth District

(in millions of dollars)

Consumer instalment credit reflected
conspicuously the wave of war-scare
buying last summer. From the end of
June to the end of October (1950) the volume of
these credit balances increased by $1,300,000,000.
The growth was retarded by the imposition of Regu­
lation W in September and the subsequent tighten­
ing of the terms of the Regulation in October.
Leveling off in the last quarter of 1950, consumer
instalment credit outstanding declined moderately
throughout the first four months of this year, partly
as a result of seasonal influences. A subsequent slight
rise since April in instalment loans appears to have
been of less than the usual seasonal proportions.
According to commercial bank figures, the shrinkage
was most pronounced in instalment credit for the
purchase of consumer durable goods other than auto­
mobiles, reflecting the slowdown in sales of such
articles as television sets and major household appli­
ances. Automobile credit and repair and moderniza­
tion loans also declined slightly, but personal instal­
ment cash loans continued to expand. Similar
developments in the various categories of instalment
credit have been apparent at Fourth District banks.
The shrinkage in instalment credit resulted partly
from an increase in the rate of repayments and partly
from a decline in the volume of new credit extended.
The revised Defense Production Act, enacted July
31, 1951, established certain limits on terms which
were easier than those specified in Regulation W.
The principal changes were as follows:

Consum er
Loans




Defense Contracts.................
Defense-Supporting

+$248

+$20

Plant and Equipment.......
All O ther............................

+ 204
+ 52

+ 30
+ 11

— 404
+ 95

— 20
+ 9

+
-

—0—
+ 6

Nondefense

Inventory and Working
Capital............................
Plant and Equipment........
Retirement of Nonbank Debt
and Preferred Stock . . . .
All O ther............................

19
55

Net Change in Commercial and Industrial Loans
By Business of Borrower

(Reporting banks: U. S. and Fourth District)
NET CHANGE May 9-Aug. 1

r,

■

,

Business of Borrower

XI. S.

Fourth District
(in millions of dollars)

Manufacturing and Mining
Food, Liquor and Tobacco
Textiles, Apparel & Leather
Metals & Metal Products..
Petroleum, Coal, Chemicals
and Rubber....................
Other Manufacturing &
Mining............................
Trade—Wholesale and Retail
Commodity Dealers...............
Sales Finance Companies_
_
Public Utilities.......................
All O ther................................

—$224
+ 93
+ 328

—$3
— 1
+60

+

10

— 7

+ 77
— 151
— 206
— 11
+280
+ 39

+16
—10
+ 2
—21
+15
+4

September 1, 1951

Page 11

Monthly Business Review

FIN AN CIAL AND OTHER BUSIN ESS STATISTICS
Time Deposits*
at 54 Banks in 12 Fourth D istrict C itie s

Bank Debits*— July 1951
in 31 Fourth D istrict Cities

(C o m p iled A ugust 7 a n d released for publication A ugust 8)

(C om piled A ugust 10 a n d released for pub licatio n A ugust 11)
____________________________ (In th o u sa n d s of dollars)___________________________
N o. of
% C h an g e
3 M o n th s % C hange
R ep o rtin g
J u ly
from
Ended
fro m
B an k s
1951
Y e a r A go
J u ly 1951
Y e a r Ago
181 A L L 31 C E N T E R S ............. *9,326,179
+ 1 9 .4 %
*28,743,161
+ 22.4%
10 L A R G E S T C E N T E R S :
5 A k ro n ................................ O h io
367,866
+ 3 2 .4 %
1,137,454H + 48.7%
5 C a n to n .............................. O h io
149,318
+ 1 9 .5
447.446H +19.9
14 C in c in n a ti........................ O h io 1,177,810
+ 2 0 .8
3.497.692H +18.8
10 C le v e la n d ........................ O hio 2,503,977
+ 24.4
7,499,130
+25.2
7 C o lu m b u s ........................ O hio
595,813
+ 5.0
1,842,246
+ 4.6
4 D a y to n ..............................O h io
311,196
+ 19.4
909.583H +19.6
6 T o le d o ...............................O h io
437,720
+ 1 4 .7
1,361,376
+21.2
4 Y o u n g sto w n .....................O h io
196,860
+ 1 2 .7
632,159
+21.8
5 E r ie ....................................... P a .
110,850
+ 9.8
353.766H +19.4
44 P itts b u r g h .......................... P a . 2,702,054
+ 21.2
8,658,904
+ 26.0
104
T O T A L .................................. *8,553,464
+ 20.4%
*26,339,756
+ 23.1%
21 O T H E R C E N T E R S :
9 C o v in g to n -N e w p o rt....... K y . * 45,504
+ 1.5%
* 139,278
+ 5.6%
6 L ex in g to n ...........................K y .
62,208
+ 6.3
185,213
+ 4.9
3 E ly r ia ................................O hio
26,465
+ 16.7
82.728H + 26.0
3 H a m ilto n ..........................O hio
51,104
+23.1
153.899H + 21.0
2 L im a ..................................O hio
61,317
+ 16.7
181.785H +23.9
5 L o ra in ................................O hio
22.393H +22.9
65.551H
+19.4
4 M an sfield ......................... O h io
50,829
+ 0.9
166,500
+ 14.6
2 M id d le to w n ..................... O hio
50,647
+ 2 8 .2
153.226H +31.9
3 P o r ts m o u th .....................O h io
23,925
+ 9.1
73,213
+13.9
3 S p rin g field ....................... O h io
51,629
+ 8.7
161,368
+ 14.6
4 S te u b e n v ille .................... O hio
26,611
+ 4.2
83,684
+14.3
2 W a rre n .............................. O h io
48,259
+ 14.4
159,422
+25.1
3 Z a n esv ille.........................O h io
30,223
+ 3.3
97,255
+12.3
3 B u tle r ................................... P a .
35,124
+ 6.7
113,706
+13.9
1 F r a n k lin .............................. P a .
7,211
— 2.8
24,032
+ 7.5
2 G reen sb u rg ......................... P a .
25,558
+ 11.4
78.444H +15.3
11,845
+ 8.1
37,181
+ 20.3
4 K itta n n in g .......................... P a .
3 M e a d v ille ............................P a .
14,728
+ 6.0
46,668
+ 8.0
4 O il C it y ............................... P a .
19,669 — 7.8
61,106
+ 0.4
5 S h a ro n ..................................P a .
33,553 + 12.1
107.114H
+ 22.3
6 W h e elin g .......................W . V a.
73,913 + 5.3
232,032
+ 14.4
77 T O T A L .................................. * 772,715 + 9.7%
* 2,403,405 + 16.0%

C ity an d N u m b e r
of B an k s

A verage W eekly C hange D uring:
J u ly
Ju n e
J u ly
1951
1951
1950

T im e D ep o sits
J u ly 25, 1951

C lev elan d (4)..............$ 880,777,000
P itts b u rg h (9)............ .....495,294,OOOH
C in cin n ati (7)............. .....175,510,000
A kron (3 )..........................100,020,000

+$
+
—
+

721,000
244,000
58,000
50,000

T o led o (4).........................108.176.000H
C olum bus (3 )...................87.233.000H
Y oungstow n (3)......... .....62,715,000
D a y to n (3 ).................. .....46,104,000

+
+
+

81,000
119,000
131,000
128,000

C an to n (5)................... .....42,461,000
E rie (3 )..............................41,618,000H
W h eeling (5)............... .....26,494,000
Lexington (5).............. .....11,136,000H

+*1,520,000
+ 1,673,000
— 164,000
+
46,000
+

242,000

—

2,000

79,000

—
—
—
—

24,000
138,000
38,000
149,000

62,000
42.000

—
+

105,000
25,000
—0 ..
64,000

+ 101,000
+

80,000
104,000
34.000
30.000

T O T A L —12 C itie s ..12,077,538,000H

— 11,637,000
+
254,000
— 313,000
— 468,000

+

+*1,664,000

10.000
58,000

—

+$3,647,000

— $2,657,000

H —D en o tes new a ll-tim e h ig h .
T im e d ep o sits a t rep o rtin g b an k s in 12 F o u rth D is tric t cities increased for th e
fo u rth successive m o n th during J u ly a t an av e ra g e w eekly r a te of *1,664,000 to
e s ta b lis h a new a ll-tim e h ig h . In t h e th r e e p rior y ears, tim e deposits declined
during J u ly , w ith p a rtic u la rly h e a v y n et w ith d ra w a ls a t a r a t e of *2,657,000 per
w eek being re p o rte d in t h is m o n th of s care-buying la s t year.
E v e r y c i t y rep o rte d a gain in tim e d ep o sits except Cincinnati, a n d th e av e ra g e
w eek ly decline of *58,000 th e re w as n o tic e a b ly sm a lle r th a n in t h e sam e m o n th of
th e th r e e previous y ears.
Pittsburgh, Toledo a n d Lexington, w here gains h a v e been rep o rted in alm o s t ev e ry
m o n th th is y ea r, a d v a n ced to new a ll-tim e h ig h s for th e second successive m o n th ,
th o u g h in ea ch c ity th e r a te of in crease w as slow er th a n in June. Columbus an d E rie
also ac h ie v e d new reco rd s, h av in g show n greater-th a n -av erag e s tre n g th th ro u g h o u t
th e p o st-K o rean p eriod.

T h e inflow of savings to Cleveland b an k s a t th e r a t e of *721,000 per w eek w as
in m a rk e d c o n tra s t to th e n e t w ith d ra w a ls w h ich h a v e ty p ifie d J u ly in ea rlier post­
w ar y ea rs. F o r th e firs t tim e th is y e a r, ag g reg a te tim e deposits of th e four reporting
b an k s in C lev elan d w ere h ig h e r th a n a t th e end of 1950, and in excess of th e yearago figure.

Adjusted W eekly Index
of Department Store Soles*
Fourth District
(Weeks ending on dates shown, 1935-39 average3 100)

1951

1950r
7,,
14
21
28

..278
..310
..320
..308

Jan.

F eb .

4
11
18
25 ,

..293
..308
..279
..265

Mar.

4
11
18
25

..258
..279
..264
..263

1
8
15

..285
..279
..262
..283
..334

Jan.

Apr.

n
29

fi

«
13
20
27

425
412
443
398

Feb.

3
10
17
24

..287
359
..354
365

Mar.

3
10
17
24
31

302
293
266
251
293

Apr.

7
14
21
28

1
8
15
22
29

...354
388
418

Aug.

5
12
19
26

374
344
330
323

Sept.

2
9
16
23
30

295
324
345
318
335

July

297
311
323
358

..299
..296
..299
..295

May

13
20
27

June

1951

1950r

5
12
19
26

336
312
313
312

3
10
17
24

..295
..314
..309
..306

June

2
9
16
23
80

309
311
304
312
325

327

m

July

7
14
21
28

...3 1 4
...3 3 0
...3 2 5
...3 1 5

Aug.

4
11
18
25

...3 1 4
...3 0 9
...3 1 0
...3 1 5

Sept.

1
8
15

D ec.

29
6
13
20
27

297
307
287
298

4
11
18
25

280
281
288
221

3
10
17
24

?
,

195
328
334
314
342

1
8
15

9
16
23
30

n

29

* A d ju sted for seasonal v a ria tio n a n d n u m ber of tra d in g d ay s. B ased on sam ple
of w eek ly rep o rtin g s to res w h ich differs slig h tly from sam ple reporting m o n th ly .




Indexes of Department Store Sales and Stocks

n

7
14
21
28
N ov.

* D e b its to all d eposit acco u n ts except in te rb a n k balances.
H — D enotes all-tim e h ig h .
D e b its to d ep o sit acco u n ts (except in te rb a n k ) in 31 F o u rth D is tric t cities during
J u ly d eclined from th e a ll-tim e h ig h reg istered in Ju n e to th e second lo w est m o n th ly
to t a l th is y e a r—*9,326,179,000. I t is n o t unusual, ho w ev er, for J u ly d e b its to fall
s h o rt of th e June figure, a n d la s t m o n th ’s vo lu m e of d e b its w as still la rg e enough
to s e t a new reco rd for th e m o n th , 19.4% a b o v e th e year-ago figure. T h e fact t h a t
th is m a rg in w as th e s m a lle s t in tw e lv e m o n th s reflects th e slow ing dow n in th e
ra te of expansion of in d u s tria l a c tiv ity in recen t m o n th s.
W ith d eposits rising s lig h tly to re g iste r a new all-tim e h ig h for th e fo u rth suc­
cessive m o n th , th e r a te of tu rn o v e r d ipped to 13 tim e s per y e a r from th e reco rd p o st­
w ar r a t e of annual tu rn o v e r of 14 in June.
TE N LA RG EST CENTERS
D e b it vo lu m e a t each of th e la rg e cen ters except Dayton w as low er d uring J u ly
th a n in th e previous m o n th , following th e p a tte rn of recen t y ears.
A kron le d in y ea r-to -y ear com parisons for t h e fifth tim e t h is y e a r w ith a gain of
32.4%, w h ile C leveland, P ittsb u rg h an d Cincinnati also r e g iste re d increases of m o re
th a n 20%. A gg reg ate d e b its for th e p a s t th r e e m o n th s co m b in ed fell slig h tly below
th e reco rd second q u a rte r to ta l, a lth o u g h fiv e citie s p o sted new a ll-tim e h ig h s for
th e th r e e m o n th period.
T W E N T Y -O N E S M A L L E R C E N T E R S
T h e decline in d e b its a t th e sm a lle r ce n ters from Ju n e to J u ly w as s h arp er th a n
in a n y e a rlier p o stw ar y e a r, an d re s u lte d in a y e a r-to -y ear m a rg in of 9.7%, th e sm all­
e s t since before th e K o rean o u tb re a k .
Lorain w as th e only ce n ter to re g iste r a h ig h e r vo lu m e of d e b its in J u ly th a n in
Ju n e, a n d th e gain w as sufficient to e s ta b lis h a new all-tim e h ig h , exceeding th e pre­
vious seasonal reco rd of D ecem b er 1948. T h e y e a r-to -y ear in crem en t for L orain,
22.9%, w as b e tte r e d b y H am ilto n a n d M iddletow n, an d a ll th r e e cities, to g e th e r
w ith E ly ria, L im a, G reensburg a n d Sharon re g iste re d a ll-tim e h ig h s in ag g reg a te
d e b its for th e p a s t th r e e m o n th s co m b in ed .
J u ly w as th e f irs t m o n th since M a y 1950 in w h ich a m a jo rity of th e s m a ll cen ters
p o sted y ea r-to -y ear gains of less th a n 10%.

D a ily A v erag e for 1935-1939= 100
A d ju ste d for
W ith o u t
S easonal V ariatio n S easonal A d ju stm e n t
J u ly
Ju n e
J u ly
J u ly
Ju n e
1951
1951
1950
1951
1951
SALES:
A k ro n (6 )............................... 341
C an to n (5)............................. 375
C in cin n ati (8)....................... 326
C le v ela n d (11)..................... 274
C o lu m b u s (5)........................ 358
E rie ( 4 ) .................................. 371
P itts b u r g h (8)...................... 276
Springfield (3)...................... 294
T o led o (6).............................. 307
W heeling (6).......................... 258
Y oungstow n (3)................... 371
D is tric t (98).......................... 309
S TO C K S*
D is tr ic t................................... 349

J u ly
1950

306
400
280
280
315
381
283
279
291
247
366
306

393
449
386
318
409
420
332
321
353
309
413
364

286
315
251
222
286
289
199
238
237
196
282
241

287
384
261
266
302
347
275
271
270
227
344
287

330
377
298
257
327
328
239
260
272
235
314
284

361

252

348

355

251

Page 12

Monthly Business Review

September 1, 1951

Ultrasonics—A New Tool For Industry
by CLYDE WILLIAMS, Director, Battelle Memorial Institute

During World War II, use of
high-frequency s o u n d waves, or
ultrasonics, was a key factor in the
detection of enemy submarines.
Since that time, we have learned
more about how ultrasonics can be
used, not only in attack on sub­
marines, but also in attack on quite
a few of the problems of industry.
As we learn of more industrial
processes that may benefit from the
use of ultrasonic energy, and as
lower-cost equipment for producing
it becomes available, the number and variety of industrial
applications will increase.
“Silent” sound, as ultrasonic energy is often called, refers
to sound waves with frequencies of vibration higher than
the human ear can hear, or above about 16,000 cycles
per second. The term “supersonic”, formerly used inter­
changeably with “ultrasonic”, now refers usually to speed
only — speeds greater than the speed of sound. Super­
sonic airplanes, for example, travel at speeds over 700
miles per hour.
High-frequency sound waves may be directed in narrow
or broad diffuse beams. As the energy passes through a
given material, the effects vary according to the composi­
tion of the material and the frequency and power of
vibrations. Stable mixtures can be produced from nor­
mally non-mixable liquids like oil and water, or mercury
and water. Large solid particles may be reduced to dust.
Small particles of liquids and solids can be removed from
a gas stream by causing them to collect together. Many
chemical reactions are speeded up in the presence of
ultrasonic radiation. High-powered sound waves can be
used to remove gas from most liquids. The production of
heat by ultrasonics has been used in physical therapy,
where effects differ from those obtainable with X-ray,
infrared or diathermy. Ultrasonic vibrations can also kill
bacteria.
It would be difficult to think of an industry that might
not benefit from the use of high-frequency sound waves.
Some present and potential applications include inspec­
tion of materials for internal flaws; removing water dur­
ing soap-making; causing smoke particles to drop out of
exhaust gases before discharge from chimneys; drying
paper during manufacture; high-speed dyeing of fabrics
and plastic materials; recovering fine metallic dust lost
in smelting operations; removing dirt in laundering; age­
ing liquor; sterilizing foods; and processing of leather
and ceramic materials.
Perhaps the most widely accepted use of “silent” sound
in industry has been in testing metals and metal products
for hidden flaws that may lead to failure. A narrow beam
of very high-frequency ultrasonic energy will penetrate
some metallic materials with thicknesses up to 40 feet or
Editor’s Note — W hile the views expressed on this page are not nec­
essarily those of this bank, the Monthly Business Review is pleased to
make this space available for the discussion of significant develop­
ments in industrial research.




more. Any flaws in the beam’s path will be reflected on
the measuring instrument. Items tested may range from
locomotive axles and rails, to submarine hulls, gun bar­
rels, turbine blades, bolts, and sheet and bar stock.
At Battelle, where an extensive laboratory for research
in nondestructive testing is maintained, we find that this
application of ultrasonic energy is playing an important
part in reducing costs. Today, American industry is using
nondestructive testing equipment to test and inspect bil­
lions of dollars worth of materials, parts, and assemblies.
Used in the production process, as well as in preventive
maintenance, nondestructive testing has also brought added
safety to many phases of military and civilian life.
One of the newest applications of high-powered sound
waves is as a tool for drilling and marking hard or brittle
material, like carbides, glass, and ceramics. These are
almost impossible to work in any other way. Another
ultrasonic device, also of recent development, helps paper
mills cope with the problem of polluting streams with
wastes. By shooting a beam of high-intensity sound at
fiber-bearing waste water, tiny bits of fiber too small to
be picked up by screening are easily removed.
The high cost and low output of equipment for pro­
ducing ultrasonic energy have been factors lim iting its
wider use by industry. T his situation is changing, how­
ever, as a result of several outstanding developments of
recent years.
Through greater production by a number of companies,
it has been possible to bring the price of some crystal
transducers down from about $1000 to around $250. This
type of equipment, probably the best known for generat­
ing ultrasonic waves, converts electrical energy into ultra­
sonic energy through the use of such crystals as quartz
and Rochelle salt. These crystals are capable of changing
electrical vibrations into mechanical vibrations and vice
versa.
N o more expensive than natural crystals is a new ce­
ramic material, barium titanate, which is now being used
for generating high-powered sound waves. T his synthetic
material can be formed into a variety of sizes and shapes
that would be costly to make from natural crystals like
quartz. T he new ceramic also provides power substantial
enough for practical use with voltages low enough for
easy handling. Barium titanate equipment has proved
especially useful in the production of ultrasonic waves in
liquids. It may, therefore, find wide usage in the chemi­
cal processing industries.
The “building blocks” are here. It is now possible to
investigate and properly evaluate the application of ultra­
sonic energy to industrial processes on a pilot-plant scale.
On the “test-tube basis” of former years, this was not
possible.
Ultrasonic energy has become recognized as a scientific
tool useful to industry. Tw o important jobs, however,
remain to be done. T he first of these is to extend the
number of industrial processes than can benefit from the
use of ultrasonic energy. T he second is to continue de­
vising improved higher-power generating equipment, at
lower cost, so that a greater range of applications can be
made economically worth while.