View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
Covering financial, industrial, and agricultural conditions
in the
Fourth Federal Reserve District
Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland

VoL 9

Cleveland, Ohio, September 1, 1927

No. 9

General business activity receded further in July, the
Annalist index declining from 105 in June to 101 (pre­
liminary) in July. Both employment and payrolls also
exhibited a downtrend in the past month, the Federal
Beserve Board’s index of employment falling from 92,3
in Jane to 90.7 in July, and that of payrolls falling from
105.7 to 101.1.
Wholesale prices, on the other
hand, strengthened slightly for the first time in months,
due to the rise in agricultural prices.
The record of second quarter earnings also indicates a
moderate recession during the last three months. Earn­
ings of 153 industrial corporatons, excluding General
Motors and United States Steel, showed a loss of over
12 per cent from last year.
Including these two
companies, earnings were just about equal to last
year; but it is apparent that profits in general were not
up to the 1926 level. An increase in profits was re­
ported by 73 corporations, and a decrease by 80.
In this District, a slight revival of demand for iron
and steel took place in August, but operations were still
at a low point. Coal prices rose noticeably in response
to increased demand. The tire industry is doing well,
and shoe manufacturing has experienced an improvement.
Building contracts awarded in July were 25 per cent under
a year ago. Crops in general are poor; corn is late,
wheat is only fair, tobacco is uneven, and fruit is very
poor. Hay, oats, and potatoes, however, are doing well.

of the Board of Directors on August 5.
Bills dis­
counted on August 17 totaled $28,000,000, the same as a
month previously but $12,000,000 less than a year ago.
Acceptance holdings fell from 19 to 11 millions during
the month, while holdings of Government securities
advanced from 46 to 50 millions. Member bank borrow­
ings during the last few weeks have been at their lowest
level since the summer of 1924, owing at least in part to
the moderate business recession which was under way
during May, June, and July.
Loans of reporting member banks in this District se­
cured by stock and bonds fell slightly between July 20
and August 17, but on the latter date were still 34 millions
ahead of the figure of $558,000,000 on August 18, 1926.
"A ll other” loans, largely commercial, increased from
$785,000,000 on July 20 to $804,000,000 on August 17, the
latter figure being 10 millions higher than a year ago.
Investments during the same period rose from 672 to 681
millions, as compared with 642 millions a year ago;
demand deposits were almost the same on all three dates,
while time deposits on August 17 were $906,000,000, a
gain of 84 millions over last year and 18 millions over
last month.
Debits to individual accounts at 13 large cities in the
Fourth District aggregated $2,775,779,000 in July, as
compared with $2,671,960,000 a year ago and with
$2,984,591,000 in June.

Financial

Commercial failures in this District numbered 140 in
July of 1927 and 137 in 1926. Liabilities in July took a
big jump, amounting to $7,269,891 as compared with
$3,202,436 last year and $3,572,903 in June.
In the
United States, there were 1756 failures in July, 1833 in
June, and 1605 in July of last year.

The past month from a financial view­
point has been characterized by a
general lowering of the Federal Reserve
banks9 discount rate from 4 to 3% per cent, and a
further sagging of money rates in the New York market.
The commercial paper rate touched 4 per cent during
the second week in August, the lowest since early
in March, and acceptances, which held at the 3% per
cent mark for several months, finally declined to 3% per
cent late in July and to 3% per cent in August. In the
Fourth District, interest rates have shown practically
no change, remaining at 4% -6 per cent for prime com­
mercial paper and 5-6 on collateral loans. The banks
report that funds are plentiful for the coming crop-moving
season*
In accordance with the lowering of rates by other
Federal Reserve banks, the discount rate of the Cleve­
land bank was reduced from 4 to 3% per cent by action



The following table gives the monthly and yearly
comparison of the main items in the balance sheets of
the Federal Reserve and reporting member banks:
Federal Reserve
Bank of Cleveland
Federal Reserve System
(In Millions)
(In Millions)
Aug. 17. Aug. 18, July 20, Aug. 17, Aug. 18. July 20.
1927
1926
1927
1927
1926
1927
325
Gold Reserves ..............
297
809 3,003
2,884 3,012
Discount .........................
28
40
28
390
536
403
11
25
19
171
254
185
U. S. Securities ............
50
88
46
442
860
886
Total bills and securities
89
108
93
1,003
1,152
976
Federal Reserve notes in
circulation ...................... 212
195
211
1.665
1,686 1,676
Total deposits .................... 194
196
187 2,347 2,272 2,346

2

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

REPORTING MEMBER BANKS
Fourth District
United States
(In Millions)
(In Millions)
Aug. 17, Aug. 18, July 20, Aug. 17, Aug. 18, July 20,
1927
1926
1927
1927
1926
1927
Loans secured by stocks
and bonds ......................
592
558
604
5,847
5,459
5,787
All Other ........................
804
794
785
8,656
8,462
8,597
Total loans ........................ 1,414
1,373
1,407 14,621 14,065 14,492
Investments
......................
681
642
672
5,913
5,620
5,986
Demand deposits ............ 1,068
1,064
1,064 13,281 12,845 13,240
Time deposits ..................
906
822
88S
6,251
5,738
6,188

Iron and
Steel

Demand fo r the finished steel lines
improved perceptibly in the early part
of August, but the remainder o f the
month did little more than hold this gain. Expansion in
automotive schedules did not materialize. Railroads, as
usual in August, bought sparingly.
Tractor manufac­
turers stepped up their operations, but the output o f
tillage and harvesting equipment fell back.
Tubular
goods experienced a slight revival but still continued
under the cloud o f over-production in August. Bookings
o f structural steel were at an unusually high rate for
August.
Pig iron production enjoyed a good month considering
mid-quarter factors, but at the expense o f price. While
finished steel prices were holding in all districts, pig
iron was losing an average of 50 cents a ton.
The
Pittsburgh market was not active on the surface, but
quiet closings are numerous. A t Cleveland sales aver­
aged nearly 50,000 tons weekly and northern Ohio pro­
ducers were a shade more firm in their price attitude at
the close o f the month.
A Mahoning valley furnace was
quoting $17 on basic, with a general market at $17.25
to $17.50, while No. 2 foundry was sold at the equivalent
of $17.50 (V alley).
The rise in beehive coke at Pittsburgh, which put the
market to $3 to $3.35, was checked when production and
demand struck a balance.
Spot offerings o f beehive
furnace fuel was a stiffening factor.
Heavy finished lines of steel held throughout the
month at $1.80 to $1.85 (Pittsburgh), fo r general con­
sumers.
Sheet prices, while subject to some pressure
at Detroit, showed no major break. Cold finished steel
was weak at Detroit, but firm elsewhere. Alloy steel
continued highly competitive, especially fo r the auto­
motive trade. Strips, like sheets, continued firm. Scrap
was strong sentimentally, and in dealer trading some
grades advanced, but consumer buying was light and
the market lacked real support.
The production o f pig iron in July was 2,944,251 gross
tons compared with 3,489,726 tons in June and 3,224,663
tons last July. For seven months, production has totaled
22,373,478 tons against 23,075,576 tons in the same period
of 1926 and 21,647,145 tons in 1925. A t the end o f July,
190 blast furnaces or 52.5 per cent o f the country’s
serviceable furnaces were in blast. This was a reduction
of eight from the end o f June.
Steel ingot production also declined in July, being
3,178,342 tons as compared with 3,468,055 tons in June
and 3,634,993 tons last July.
Seven-month figures for
1927 are 26,796,783 tons and fo r 1926, 27,788,802 tons.
The Iron Trade Review composite o f fourteen leading
iron and steel products continued to decline in August,
due largely to weakness in pig iron, and this barometer
averaged $36.23 or a loss o f approximately 20 cents from
July.



Coal

The coal markets have finally shown
signs of activity, after an exceedingly
dull spring and early summer. Prices
continued to slump up to mid-July, but since then have
undergone a sharp rise. On July 15, the Coal A ge aver­
age price of bituminous coal stood at $1.80 a ton, a
decline o f 27 cents during the four months’ existence o f
the strike, but by August 5 it had advanced to $2.12,
slightly higher than before the strike. Railroads have
been buying more heavily.
Production has varied but
little since April, fluctuating about the 1,400,000 daily
average mark, but showed a slight advancing tendency
during July. The output is now running behind both
1926 and 1925, but owing to heavy production early in the
year, the total up to August 6 was practically the same
as in 1926. Stocks in the hands of industrial consumers
have declined slightly. This indicates that the present
rate o f production is not quite sufficient to take care
o f the demand, although no figures are available on
householders1 stocks.
Non-union coal mines in the Fourth District have
naturally benefited from the recent price rise, some
eastern coal going westward to the market form erly
supplied by Illinois and Indiana mines.
W holesalers
report no great change in the situation since last month,
although inquiries are more numerous, and the general
feeling among coal men is better.
Conditions in the Ohio fields are very unsatisfactory.
The miners and operators have been unable to come to
any agreement, and the state’s level of production has
dropped to one-third o f that of last year and one-sixth o f
1923. In Pennsylvania, on the other hand, a considerable
number o f mines have re-opened on a non-union basis,
and the output is running at about 80 per cent of last
year and 56 per cent o f 1923. Kentucky’s production
continues high, being well ahead of previous years, and
W est Virginia still ranks first in soft coal producing
states, being slightly ahead o f Pennsylvania.
Rubber and
Tires

The tire industry in this District is in
good shape at present. First half-year
profits were considerably in excess o f
last year in a number of cases, net earnings during
this period fo r six large companies amounting to $17,600,000, as against $12,400,000 in 1926, a gain o f more than
40 per cent. Last year, of course, was a poor one for
rubber manufacturers, and although 1927 to date has
shown a marked improvement, it has not equaled the
unusually prosperous first half year o f 1925, when net
earnings for the same six corporations amounted to
$24,200,000.
July and August business has compared favorably with
the first half-year. Stocks in manufacturers’ hands are
still very large, but this is made necessary by the great
number o f sizes o f tires now in use and by the gradual
change from cord to balloon tires. Sales continue in good
volume in mechanical rubber products as well as in tires
although a small seasonal let-up is reported.
Demand
fo r footwear is increasing.
One reason for the better showing made by rubber
concerns in 1927 has been the stability in the price of
crude rubber. This has fluctuated around the 40-cent level
since the first o f the year, and early in August stood at

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
35% cents a pound, the same as a month earlier but 3
cents under last year.
Aotofliobiles

Automobile production in every month
of 1927 to date has been less than in
the corresponding month of 1926. The
July total, for the United States only, was 263,406 cars
md trucks, as compared with 354,394 last year, a de­
crease of about 26 per cent. Truck production slumped
noticeably in July, but the first seven months* total
is still slightly ahead of last year. Passenger car output
lor the seven months, however, is considerably below that
of 1926.
Demand at present appears to be rather dull, due
possibly to the desire of many people to await the
appearance of the new Ford car. For example, new
registrations in July in Wayne County (including Detroit)
show a tremendous falling-otf in Ford cars registered,
while other makes were holding their own as compared
with a year ago. In Cuyahoga County (including Cleve­
land) both new and used cars sold in July numbered less
than in July, 1926, the percentage decreases being 11.7
and 7-6 respectively.
The number of used cars sold
was more than three times as great as that of new cars.
Half-year earnings statements of 15 automobile and
track manufacturers (excluding General Motors) illustrate
the irregularity which has characterized conditions within
the industry. Only three concerns showed a gain over
the first half of 1926, the group as a whole showing a
loss of 22.8 per cent. General Motors, on the other hand,
gained 27.1 per cent.

3

Shoes

The price of leather has moved up
rather sharply during the last two
months. On June 17, sole leather was
selling at 49 cents a pound, but by August 13 it had
advanced to 55 cents. The latter quotation is 9 cents
higher than a year ago. In spite of this upward move­
ment, Cincinnati manufacturers report that orders are
still coming in plentifully. July was a good month for
most of the factories in the District, and shoe manufac­
turing here, as in the country as a whole, appears to
have taken a slight turn for the better after a long period
of very mediocre business, amounting to actual depres­
sion in some cases. One evidence of this is found in the
half-year earnings of five shoe and leather concerns,
which were 14.4 per cent greater than in the first half
of 1926. This contrasts favorably with the loss of 6.7
per cent shown by 221 firms of all types.
Sales of reporting wholesale shoe houses in the Fourth
District in July fell 13.5 per cent behind last year’s figure
but were ahead of 1925. Retail shoe sales also failed to
equal the 1926 total by 6.6 per cent.
Fourth District shoe production in June showed a very
large gain of 31.2 per cent over the same month a
year ago. Preliminary figures for July indicate a fallingoff of about 20 per cent from June, and also a decline
from a year ago. In the United States, 27,302,372 shoes
were produced in June and 25,625,840 in May. The pre­
liminary figure for July indicates a slight increase over
June.

Clothing

Earnings for the first six months of
General
Reports from manufacturers in various
1927
of ten representative
clothing and lines in the Fourth District are rather
Manufacturing
more optimistic than a month ago.
textile concerns in the United States
showed a gain of 59 per cent over the first half of
Several instances of a real improvement are recorded,
1926. This was the largest gain reported by any major
in spite of the fact that the usual dull season is not over.
industrial line, and speaks well for the condition of the
In general, business is a little better than a month ago,
clothing industry.
and compares fairly well with last year.
The sales season for the Spring of 1928 has formally
Conditions are quiet in the paint and varnish trade.
opened and clothing concerns in this District are showing
Business is average or better, and is about equal to 1926.
Spring models at prices almost identical with a year ago
Orders are coming in well for the season. Makers of
Retailers at large, particularly the city stores, are
white lead report a very active demand, taxing operating
following a very hesitant buying policy and have not
capacity, and the price of raw materials, particularly
entered to any extent into forward buying as in former
pig lead, has strengthened. A slight improvement has
years.
The prevailing cooler weather, however, has
taken place in the glass industry, which has been forced
stimulated an earlier demand for Fall wearables, so that
to meet keen foreign competition in recent months. The
repeat orders are beginning to come to the manufacturer
usual seasonal lull prevails in the paper trade, but one
in larger quantities than is usual at this time of year.
or two concerns are experiencing an unusually active
So far this year manufacturers in this District report
sales which compare quite favorably with those of last
year. One cause of this is found in the strike of the
New York clothing industry of a year ago, which re­
sulted in many orders being diverted to other markets,
including those of the District.
Wholesale dry goods sales were somewhat less during
July than either in June or a year ago. Sales by the
manufacturer of dry goods to the wholesaler for the
Spring of 1928 have increased, which is in keeping with
the recent rise in the price of cotton. The increase
in price of the raw' material has not been reflected in the
price of the manufactured article as yet.



demand. Conditions in the electrical supply trade are
practically unchanged from last month. An improved
tone is noted in the demand for boxboard, and that in­
dustry has been on the upgrade during the past month.
Agricultural implement makers report business as satis­
factory, one firm having a gain in business of 20 per
cent over a year ago.
Shipments in the watch and
jewelry trade are holding up to last year. A decided
improvement in business has been experienced by manu­
facturers of woodworking machinery. In the stove trade,
makers of ranges for public institutions report an active
demand, but business in household ranges is stated to be
rather quiet.

4
Agriculture,
Livestock

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

The growing season has made up some
time during the past month and the
principal crops in this District are
somewhat nearer normal development.
Improvement in the corn crop was general during the
last month, but much of the crop is still from two to five
weeks late. Early planted com has been in tassel for some
time, but later planted varieties have made slow growth,
and the net result is a very spotted corn outlook. The
latest estimate of probable production fo r the District,
August 1st, is 138,073,000 bushels against a yield last
year o f 197,337,000 bushels. The conditon o f the crop
is reported as 68 per cent in contrast with the ten year
average of 84 per cent fo r the District. The poor stands
so noticeable throughout the District point to a much
larger abandonment o f fields this year than fo r several
years past.
The condition of corn fo r the entire United States
on August 1 was 71.2 per cent o f normal as compared
with 80.3, the five-year average, and 72.5 on August
1, 1926. The condition of 71.2 per cent indicates a crop
of 2,385,226,000 bushels, which would be the smallest
crop in 26 years with the exception o f 1924.
The estimated wheat yield fo r the District is 138,073,000
bushels against a yield last year of 197,337,000 bushels,
a probable decrease o f 30 per cent. The quality of the
Ohio wheat is generally good with little damage to grain
in shocks from rain reported. The yield is estimated at
18 bushels per acre, slightly above the average but con­
siderably lower than the bumper crop o f last year which
was 22.5 bushels per acre.
Pennsylvania reports a wheat crop below expectations,
both in quality and yield. Smut, fly, rust, and hail appear to
have done considerable damage to the crop in that part
of the District. The harvest was late, and in some cases
rushed, so that a number o f farmers cut the crop too
green and as a result early deliveries to the mills contain
excessive moisture. The average yield for the country
is reported to be 14.5 bushels per acre, one bushel less
than the five-year average and 2.5 bushels less than last
year. The preliminary estimate o f total production is
551 million bushels as compared with 579 million pre­
dicted at this time a year ago and 627 million actually
harvested.
The condition of the oat crop has improved considerably
in the past month and the yield for the District is pre­
dicted to be only slightly less than last year.
The District shares in the increase in potato prospects
over last year. The United States crop is estimated at
411,000,000 bushels as compared with 356,000,000 bushels
in 1926; the estimated production fo r the District is
20,408,000 as compared with actual production last year
o f 18,183,000 bushels.
The fruit outlook both fo r the District and for the
country is anything but favorable. The Ohio apple crop
is estimated at 70 per cent o f average and the total
orchard crop is about 60 per cent o f the average o f recent
years. In West Virginia, the condition o f the apple crop
is 25 per cent o f normal as compared with 63 per cent
last year and a ten-year average o f 46 per cent. The
estimated production o f apples fo r the United States, as
indicated by their August 1st condition, is 128 million
bushels, against 246 million bushels harvested in 1926.



Considerable damage has been done by aphids, scabs, and
caterpillars, and apples now on the market are small and
o f poor quality.
Hay has made an excellent crop both in quality and
quantity, and though rain interfered with harvest in some
sections, by fa r the greater part o f the crop has been
stored away in good condition. A lfalfa was affected b y the
dry weather during the month o f July and the second
cutting is short.
A favorable outlook for producers of lambs is indi­
cated by an increase o f 22 per cent in lamb production
over last year. The increase in the number o f lam bs
is due both to an increase in the number o f breeding ewes
and the increase in the number o f lambs saved p er 100
head of ewes. W ool prices have shown some strength
during the past months. Domestic mills have follow ed a
hand-to-mouth policy. Imports have shown a considerable
decline and stocks have been depleted.
Dom estic p ro­
duction of fleece wool was 4.4 per cent greater than
fo r 1926.
Tobacco

Recent rains have helped the grow th of
burley tobacco in Kentucky. The crop
continues uneven, however, and m uch of
it is only fa ir in quality. The Department o f A gricu ltu re
on August 1 reported a slight increase in the estimated
yield for the country as a whole, the outlook on that
date being for 1138 million pounds as compared with 1099
million pounds on July 1. The Kentucky crop is sm all
owing to reduced acreage and late planting.
The Burley Co-operative Growers’ A ssociation has
sold an additional 3,625,000 pounds o f redried tobacco
leaving only 2,000,000 o f the old crop on hand; but stocks*
in general are still high, dealers and m anufacturers
reporting 518 million pounds o f burley leaf on hand on
July 1.
The rapid growth in the demand fo r cigarettes has re­
sulted in some wide variations in acreage figures o f the
various different types of tobacco as compared with last
year. Bright flue-cured tobacco, the chief cigarette type__
grown mostly in the Carolinas and Georgia— has an acre­
age 15 per cent greater than in 1926. Dark fire-cured
tobacco, on the other hand, has suffered from the drift
to cigarettes and the increase in the production o f dark
tobacco abroad; as a result, acreage o f the various types
coming under this heading has declined from 25 to 40
per cent as compared with last year. Burley tobacco
acreage is 25 per cent less than a year ago, and the aircured types also show heavy declines, ranging from 16 to
45 per cent.

Building

Contracts awarded in 37 Eastern states
in July, according to the Dodge Com­
pany, ran slightly ahead o f last year”
the figures being 534 and 518 millions respectively. The
gain was chiefly in public works and utilities, including
road building. Bradstreet’s record o f building permits
confined to residences, factories, office buildings and
stores, showed a big decline o f 19.5 per cent from Ju ly
1926, the figures being 240 millions for this year and
299 fo r last year.
In the states o f the Fourth District, July contracts
awarded totaled $66,736,000, as compared with $76,224 800

6

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
a year ago, a loss of nearly 25 per cent.
Permits
in 27 cities aggregated $24,300,508 in July, a loss of 3.8
per cent from last year, and for the first seven months
of 1927 they were $148,142,826, a loss of 6.3 per cent.
For July, Wheeling led with an increase of 225.4 per cent,
followed by Lexington with 177.6 per cent, Dayton with
135.1, and Ashtabula with 80 per cent. Several of Cleve­
land^ suburbs also recorded very large gains.
The
greatest decline took place in Newark, with 82.6 per cent.
Heavy declines were also shown by Canton, Columbus,
Covington, Erie, Lima, and Springfield. For the first
seven months of 1927, the largest increase— 144.3 per cent
— occurred in Parma, while gains of more than 50 per
cent also appeared in Barberton, Rocky River, Dayton,
and Wheeling.
The largest declines were in Canton,
Ashtabula, Lima, and Cleveland.

Building Operations

Akron......................
Ashtabula................
Barberton................
Canton....................
Cincinnati...............
Cleveland................
Cleveland suburbs:
Cleveland Heights
East Cleveland...
Kuclid..................
Garfield Heights..
Lakewood............
Parma..................
Rocky River........
Shaker Heights...
Columbus.................
Covington, K y........
Dayton....................
Krie, Pa...................
Hamilton.................
Lexington, Ky.........
Lima........................
Newark...................
Pittsburgh, Pa.........
Springfield...............
Toledo.....................
Wheeling, W. Va....
Youngstown............
Total...................

(Valuation of Permits)
% change
Jan.-July,
1927
12,728,845
397,290
760,470
2,303,058
18,148,425
26,905,225

July
from
1927
1926
1,544,470 — 3.1
100,150 +80.0
111,517 +12.6
256,880 —38.9
3,314,167 + 9.2
7,077,400
+5.3

from
1926
+26.3
—50.2
+53.2
—33.4
+ 3 .8
—35.5

4,307,487
757,103
1,028,791
1,446*750
2,768,204
958,633
527,589
3,896,255
14,711,100
1,068,600
4,646,827
3,183,700
1,688,267
1,291,558
990,506
278,455
23,600,396
920,229
8,467,672
1,056,415
6,522,552

—23.5
+ 8.2
+ 6 .8
+27.0
— 13.9
+144.3
+55.3
+37.5
—0.01
+ 5.4
+55.1
—4.5
—26.3
—0.5
—50.4
—20.4
— 12.0
+37.5
+19.3
+80.2
—14.4

— 3 8 148,142,826 158,154,421

—6.3

400,535 —45.1
233,505 +209.1
173,980 —6.7
439,300 +124.6
394,242 +65.7
454,320 +154.5
108,000 —55.6
811,450 —5.5
1,518,800 — 50.1
135,800 — 39.1
1,315,050 +135.1
278,238 —50.6
142,793 — 10.9
265,465 +177.6
23,365 —68.5
11,400 —82.6
2,813,964 —20.3
71,720 —52.6
1,346,566 —6.8
406,326 +225.4
551,105 — 5.8
24,300,508

% change

Jan.-July,
1926
10,076,242
797,102
496,444
3,459,409
17,488,285
41,719,850

3,295,757
819,324
1,098,248
1,837,500
2,382,999
2,341,707
819,325
5,357,175
14,708,300
1,126,006
7,206,861
3,039,334
1,244,517
1,285,197
491,516
221,738
20,766,120
1,265,191
10,102,960
1,903,513
5,586,225

Building
Materials

The lumber business is dull, with consumers adhering closely to hand-tomouth buying, according to lumber
concerns in the Fourth District. Hardwood prices were
unable to maintain their advance of June, and slackened
from $42.77 on July 8 to $42.40 on August 5 (composite
index). Softwoods have also undergone a rather notice­
able decline following a period of steadiness; on August
5 the composite index stood at $29.40, as compared with
$30.65 a month earlier.
Cement production in Ohio, West Virginia, and Western
Pennsylvania amounted to 1,909,000 barrels in July, as
against 1,851,000 in the same month of 1926. Shipments
were respectively 2,056,000 and 2,053,000 barrels.
The Aberthaw index of industrial building costs re­
mained unchanged at 192 on August 1. This compares
with 198 a year ago and 194 two years ago.
Wholesale
Trade

All reporting wholesale lines in this
District showed a decline in sales
during July as compared with a year
ago. This bank's index of sales of 100 wholesale firms
(1919-1923=100) stood at 77 in July, the lowest of any
year in the past seven except 1922, when it also stood at




77. Beginning with 1923, when the index was 90, each
year has shown a decrease in sales from the preceding
year.
Grocery firms in July underwent a loss of 5.6 per cent
from a year ago, and for the first seven months the
decrease was 4.4 per cent. The grocery index number
in July was 75, the lowest of any of the past seven years.
Dry goods sales showed less than the usual decrease
from last year, the July decline amounting to only 3.6
per cent. For the first seven months the loss was 10 per
cent. The index number of dry goods sales was 53 in
July, the lowest for that month in seven years.
Drug sales were 2.6 per cent under 1926 in July, and
0.6 per cent less for the first seven months. The index
number of drug sales stood at 110 in July, higher than any
of the past seven years except 1926. Sales of wholesale
drug concerns have held up exceptionally well in com­
parison with most of the other wholesale lines.
Hardware sales in July ran 2.1 per cent under last
year, and 1 per cent under for the first seven months.
The hardware index compares fairly well with past years,
the July figure of 102 being only exceeded in 1923 and
equaled in 1925.
Sales of reporting wholesale shoe houses in July were
13.5 per cent less than a year ago, and for the first
seven months of this year were 5.3 per cent less. The
shoe index, 53, was lower than any of the last seven
years except 1922 and 1925.
The monthly stock turnover rate in July for groceries
was .61, or slightly more than seven times a year, and for
dry goods was .25, or four times a year.
Retail
Trade

Sales of 64 department stores in the
Fourth District in July were 0.2 per
cent less than last year, but for the
first seven months of 1927 were 0.9 per cent greater.
Sales of 19 wearing apparel firms decreased 1.8 per cent
in July, but for the seven months ran 2.9 per cent ahead
of last year.
Individual departments showing gains of more than ten
per cent as compared with July, 1926, were: ribbons, 11.4;
jewelry, 20.8; leather goods, 11.6; women's skirts, 15.9;
sweaters, 23.8; gloves, 28.0; petticoats, 27.0; house dresses,
31.7; and radios, 77.7 Departments having decreases of
more than ten per cent were: silks and velvets, 15.2;
woolen dress goods, 12.5; linens, 10.3; laces, 12.1; and
neckwear, 11.0.
Changes in the twelve departments doing the largest
business in July were as follows (in order of sales made):

Women's Dresses
Men’s Furnishings
Women’s and Children’s Hosiery
Men's Clothing
Women's Shoes
Furniture
Silks and Velvets
Floor Coverings
Silk and Muslin Underwear
Millinery
Draperies
Toilet Articles, Drugs

% change
from 1926
+ 1.3
— 3.2
+ 7.7
— 7.9
— 5.2
+ 2.2
— 15.2
— 6.0
+ 2.1
— 2.4
+ 1.0
— 2.4

M t£ MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

6
Corporation
Earnings

Second quarter net earnings o f industrial corporations in the United States
compared less favorably with last year
than did those o f the first quarter. This bank's record
of 100 identical industrials shows that net earnings in
the second quarter amounted to $93,225,000, as compared
with $101,046,000 last year, a decline of 7.7 per cent,
while the first quarter showed a decline o f only 4.8 per
cent. As usual, second quarter earnings were larger than
in the first quarter, but the gain was not as great as that
which took place in 1926 and 1925.
The quarterly record (excluding General Motors and
United States Steel) is as follow s: (A few slight revisions
have been made since the publication of these figures in
the June Review.)
NET

EARNINGS

OP 100 INDUSTRIAL CORPORATIONS
(In thousands of dollars)
% change,
% change,
1927
1926
1927-1926
1925
1927-1925
First Quarter ........ $88,842
$ 93,299
— 4.8
$80,419
+ 1 0 .5
3econd Quarter ........ 93,225
101,046
— 7.7
91,295
+ 2.1
Third Quarter .....................
101,194
........
93,418
Fourth Quarter ......................
98,750
........
87,083

It is evident from this table that earnings in 1927
have steadily lost ground as compared with 1926, and
have almost decreased to the 1925 level. The first quar­
ter showed a gain o f 10.5 per cent over 1925, but the
second quarter's gain was only 2.1 per cent. The con­
clusion drawn from these figures is that general business
conditions have been gradually receding during recent
months from their record high level in 1926, and this
is borne out by the various indexes o f business activity.
An analysis o f the net earnings o f 221 corporations, in­
cluding 17 groups, fo r the first half-year shows that
profits in 1927 were $414,254,000, as compared with
$443,802,000 for last year, a loss of 6.7 per cent. If the
earnings of General Motors and United States Steel
be included— these two corporations combined showing
a gain of about 24 per cent— there would be a slight gain
of 0.9 per cent over last year, the figures being $595,969,000 and $590,811,000 respectively.
Of the 221 con­
cerns, 106 reported an increase from last year's profits,
and 115 reported a decrease.
As shown in the table below, half year earnings varied




widely as between different industries. The best showing
was made by the clothing and textile group, whose earn­
ings gained 59.2 per cent over a year ago. The chemical
and tobacco group, whose earnings have grown almost
uninterruptedly in the last several years, also showed
substantial increases. Rubber companies have enjoyed a
“ come-back” , having an increase of 32.3 per cent over
the poor figure of 1926. A fair increase o f 14.4 per cent
is reported by the shoe and leather group, while small
gains appear in the coal, food, mining, office equipment,
and stores groups.
The oil industry, of course, has experienced the hardest
going so far this year. Large overproduction and lower
prices have resulted in a falling-off in earnings o f 49 per
cent, most of it coming in the second quarter. Motot
corporations, except General Motors and a fe w others,
have also been unable to keep net earnings up to last
year's levels, their loss being 22.8 per cent.
M otor
accessories have been similarly affected. Railroad equip­
ment companies have suffered from rather light buying by
railroads, the group showing a decline of 12.9 per cent in
earnings.
Alm ost all the steel companies earned less, but the de­
crease was moderate in many cases.

Corporation Earnings

7
9
10
7
17
9
9
6
20
8
5
17
6
61

N e t E a r n in g s N e t E a r n in g s
F ir s t 6
F irst 6
m on th s o f
m on th s o f
1927
1926
(0 0 0 o m it t e d ) (0 0 0 o m it t e d )
£ 4 ,9 6 4
B u i l d i n g ................ ..
£ 6 ,5 6 4
4 8 ,5 0 8
C h e m i c a l .................
4 2 ,0 6 5
5 ,1 7 8
C lo t h in g , T e x t i le .
3 ,2 5 2
2 ,9 7 9
2 ,8 1 0
E q u ip m e n t ( R . R .)
1 4 ,0 2 6
1 6,1 11
5 3 ,0 7 9
5 0 ,1 8 7
F o o d , P a c k in g . . .
2 0 ,0 2 5
1 9 ,0 1 8
M i n i n g ......................
5 2 ,4 5 2
6 7 ,9 7 2
7 ,3 8 8
M o to r A ccessory.
8 ,7 5 2
7 ,1 7 0
O ffice E q u ip m e n t .
6 ,5 8 5
2 2 ,9 5 2
4 5 ,0 6 1
O i l ................................
17,153
R u b b e r .....................
1 2 ,9 6 4
3 ,0 3 0
S h o e , L e a t h e r .. . .
2 ,6 4 8
4 0 ,4 4 5
S t e e l ...........................
4 4 ,9 4 0
1 7 ,1 9 4
1 6 ,0 5 4
9 ,1 6 8
T o b a c c o ...................
7 ,5 2 2
8 8 ,5 4 3
9 1 ,2 9 7
M is c e lla n e o u s .. . .

No.
No.
firms
firms
showing showing
increase decrease
2
5
8
1
7
3
+6.0
3
4
— 1 2 .9
I
6
+ 5 .8
13
4
+ 5 .3
4
5
—22.8
3
12
— 1 5 .6
3
6
+ 8 .9
5
1
— 4 9 .1
5
15
+ 3 2 .3
4
4
+ 1 4 .4
2
3
— 10.0
4
13
+ 7.1
6
2
+ 2 1 .9
5
1
—3.0
31
30

c%Oam

or
L oss
— 2 4 .4
4 -1 5 .3
+ 5 9 .2

—6.7

221 T o t a l ..........................
1 G e n e ra l M o t o r s . .
1 U n it e d S ta te s S teel

3 4 1 4 ,2 5 4
1 2 9 ,2 5 0
5 2 ,4 6 5

£ 4 4 3 ,8 0 2
9 3 ,2 8 6
5 3 ,7 2 3

+ 3 8 .6
— 2 .3

2 2 3 G r a n d T o t a l ..........

$ 5 9 5 ,9 6 9

£ 5 9 0 ,8 1 1

+ 0 .9

—

-

____

106
1

-----107

115

------i

■

116

n

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

Fourth District Business Statistics
(All

Bank Debits (23 cities)
Savings Deposits (end of month)
Ohio (41 oanks)
Western Pennsylvania (27 banks)

figures

are for Fourth District unless otherwise specified)

3,345

Millions of dollars
Thousands of dollars

Total (68 banks)

Commercial Failures—Number
Actual Number
Thousands of dollars
a
.
*4 —Liabilities
Postal Receipts—9 cities
Sales—Life Insurance—Ohio and Pa.
44
44
“
;* “ -Dept. Stores—(SO firms)
44
44
“
— Wholesale Grocery —(SO firms)
“
44
44
**
44
Dry Goods—(16 firms)
44
44
44
„
44
Hardware —(16 firms)
44
44
44
•
« 44
t>rugs
■—(15 firms)
Building Permits, Valuation—27 cities
44
44
44
Building Contracts Awarded—0., Wn. Pa., Ky., W. Va. 44
44
44
Production — Pig Iron, L. S.
Thousands of tons
”
—Steel Ingots, L\ S.
44
44
44
—Automobiles, U. S.
Actual Number
Passenger Cars
tt
Trucks
Thousands of tons
—Bituminous Coal, 4th Dist.
**
*' barrels
—Cement: Ohio, W. Va., Wn. Pa.
Millions of k. w. hours
M —Klectric Power: Ohio, Pa., Ky.
Thousands of barrels
—Petroleum: Ohio, Pa.t Ky.
**
4* pairs
..
—Shoes, 4th District
“
casings
.
—Tires, U. S.
44 tons
Bituminous Coal Shipments (from Lake Erie ports)
Iron Ore Receipts (at Lake Erie ports)
6 months' average
•June
*Jan.-June

926
3,179

K%
change
+5 .2

+5.0

694,902
256,459
951,362
140
7,270
2,736
97,328
18,281
6,503
2,227
2,058
1,749
24,301
66,736
2,951
3,178

661,926
231,386
893,312
137
3,202
2,711
97,899
18,346
6,779
2,309
1,796
25,248
76,225
3,223
3,635

2.6
— 3.8
— 12.4
—8.4

233,425
29,981
16,462*
1,909
1,057*
2,053*

317,006
37,388
17,587*
1,851
987*
1,953*

4,720*
4,462
6,136

4,109*
4,642
7,300

—26.4
— 19.8
—6.4*
+3.1
+7.1*
+5.1*
+31.2*
+14.9*
—3.9
—15.9

4

2,102

4

+10.8
+6.5
+2.2

+127.0
+ 0 .9
— 0.6
—0 .4
—4.1
— 3.6

— 2.1
—

—

12.6

J' ni £ f y

J« $ ,y
22,924

20,964

688,138'
254,632*
942,770*
I,178
31,362
21,249
715,844
155,491
44,983
18,278
14,289
12,675
148,143
474,099
22,371
26,795

646,923*
236,899*
883,822*
1,282
27,346
20,745
676,213
154.847
47,021
20,312
14,434
12,748
158,154
469,120
23,070
27,911

2,011,961
278,571
117,077*
9,249
6,618s
II,793*

2,387,424
272.847
114,251®
8,477
6,197*
10,990*

26,680s
19,016
17,849

23,334*
14,617
16,984

change
+ 9.3
+ 6 .4 '
+7.5*
+6.7*

8.1

—

+14.7
+ 2 .4
+ 5 .9
+ 0 .4

—4.3

10.0

—
—
—

1.0

0.6

—6.3
+11
—3.0
—4.0

— 15.7
+2.1
+2.5*
+9.1
+ 6. 8*
+7.3*
+22.4*
+14.3*
+30.1
+5.1

•Figures Confidential

Index Numbers of Trade in the Fourth Federal
Reserve District
(Average Monthly Sales for the Five-Year Period 1919-1923 inc.
Department Stores (501* ..............
Wholesale Drugs (IS)*'................
Wholesale Dry Goods (IS)*.........
Wholesale Groceries (50)*.............
Wholesale Hardware (H>*...........
Wholesale Shoes (5)*....................
Wholesale All (100)*.....................
Chain Drugs (3)*f........................
^Number of firms.
tPer individual unit operated.

Ji*fi

82
103
82
89
104
59
90
104

}m yi

81
104
62
80
99
55
84
100

\#i

84
109
64
84
102
48
83
102

100)

85
114
55
79
104
62
80
108

Ji &

84

110

53
75
102
53
77
101

Debits to Individual Accounts

A

A kron .........................
Butler, Pa.....................
Canto®--:....................
Cincinnati.....................
Cleveland......................
Columbus..................
Connellsville, Pa...........
g a m ? .........................
.......•................
Greensburg, Pa.............
Homestead, Pa..............
Lexington, Ky...............
.............................
i f f f l f v .........................
Middletown.................
Oil City, P a .................
Pittsburah, Pa..............
Springfield....................
Steubenville..................
...........................
Warren....
...........
Wheeling, W. Va...........
Youngstown..................
......................................
T ota l........................

(In thousands of
dollars)
5 weeks
%
1927 to
1926 to
ending
change
date
date
Aug. 17,
from
(Dec. 29 (Dec. 30 to
1927
1926to Aug. 17) August 18}
128,460 +18.9
765,345
720,610
13,103
+ 3 .6
88,844
85,117
55,514
+ 3.3
371,564
374,066
480,771
+17.1 3,138,960 2,852,926 *
907.521
+ 4.0 6,226,079 5,684,328
189,013
— 1.2 1,288,092 1,226,721
5,858 — 14.6
39,618
40,694
105,125
—0.6
739,780 672,564 42,969
+ 3 .4
277,097
267,431
26,181
+11.9
172,358
158,270
5,402
—5.1
34,258
35,364
27,709 +16.0
193,163
187,428
16,188 —19.8
114,005
125,685
,?.234
-0 .8
46,719
46,633
13,066
—5.4
84,805
86,656
17,485
— 18.6
118,567
108,632
1,065,714
- 0 . 2 8,218,150 7,225,840 •
28,850
+ 3 .4
186,166
185,229
12,628
+ 1 .0
86,402
84,692
—5-0 M 00,752 1,693,592
16,675
+ 7 .4
107,771
100,980
52,712
+ 6 .7
359,665
360,894
82,979
—0.9
558,728
528,674
14,174
+ 0 .9
98,015
97,685
3,581,089




+ 3 .6 25,114,903 22,864,055

Retail and Wholesale Trade

+ 9 .8

No. of
reports
DEPARTMENT STORES
Akron.........................................
5
Cincinnati..................................
7
Cleveland...................................
6
Columbus...................................
7
Dayton.......................................
3
Pittsburgh..................................
7
Toledo........................................
4
Wheeling....................................
5
Youngstown...............................
3
Other Cities...............................
17
District......................................
64
WEARING APPAREL
Cincinnati..................................
6
Cleveland...................................
3
Other Cities...............................
10
District.......................................
19
FURNITURE
11
Cincinnati..................................
Cleveland...................................
8
Columbus...................................
16
Dayton.......................................
5
Toledo........................................
6
Other Cities...............................
8
District......................................
54
CHAIN STORES*
Drugs— District.........................
3
Groceries— District....................
5
WHOLESALE GROCERIES
Akron.........................................
3
Cincinnati..................................
3
Cleveland...................................
4
Erie............................................
4
Pittsburgh..................................
8
Toledo.?.................................... .......3
Other Cities...............................
27
District.......................................
52
WHOLESALE DRY GOODS. . . .
16
WHOLESALE DRUGS...............
15
WHOLESALE HARDWARE.. . .
16
WHOLESALE SHOES....................... 5
♦Sales per individual unit operated.

Percentage Increase or Decrease
SALES
SALES
July, 1927
Jan-July, 1927
compared with
compared with
July, 1926
Jan.-July, 1926
+ 7 .0

h i

till
—4.5
+ 2 .4
—4.3
+ 6.5
—4.2
0.2

—

.0

2.2

0.8

1.8

++ 22.8
.9
+1.2
+ 1 4 .4
— 1.4
—2.7
+ 5 .4
—2.4
+ 7 .0
— 1.3
+ 0 .9
—0.3
+ 5.1
+ 4 .9
+ 2 .9

—9.7
—5.8

2.2

—

—9.S
—6.3
— 7.1
—6.3

— 7.0
+ 0 .5
— 1.5
+ 9 .4
— 1.6
—18.0
—

11.8

—

6.0

—

8 .1

—2.4

+ 4 .6
—3.0
—9.4

—9.3

=3:f

—5.6
—3.6

-t .i

— 6 .8
—

—

2.6
2.1

—13.5

10.0

—
—

0.6

1.0
—5.3
—

8

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

Summary of National Business Conditions
(By the Federal Reserve Board)

Index numbers of production of manufactures
and minerals, adjusted for seasonal variations
(1923-1925 — 100). Latest figures: July, man­
ufactures, 107; minerals, 97.
PER CEMT

200

r

WHO LESAIE PRICES

I
1923

1924

1

. ...J
1925

1926

1927

Index of U. S. Bureau of Labor Statistics
(1913 = 100, base adopted by Bureau). Latest
figure: July— 144.6.

Industrial production declined in July to a level below that of a
year ago, while the Department of Labor's index of wholesale prices
advanced fo r the first time since last autumn. Demand fo r bank credit
showed a seasonal increase, but easy conditions prevailed in the money
market.
Production
Output of manufactures declined in July and was in practically
the same volume as a year ago, and the production of minerals, which
was further reduced during the month, was at the lowest level since'
early in 1926, when the anthracite strike was in progress.
Iron and
steel production in July was in the smallest volume since 1925 and
continued at practically the same level during the first three weeks of
August.
Automobile output fo r July and the early weeks o f August
was considerably below that of the corresponding month o f last yearproduction of rubber tires, non-ferrous metals and food products and
activity of woolen mills were smaller in July than in the preceding
month.
Cotton consumption was smaller than in June, but continued
unusually large for this season of the year.
Production o f leather
shoes, and lumber increased in July as compared with June.
Factory
employment and payrolls showed seasonal decreases in July and were
smaller than in any month since 1924.
Employment in coal mining
has be’en reduced in recent months, and reports indicate some unern^
ployment in certain o f the building trades owing to the decline in the
construction of houses. Building contracts awarded in July and in the
first three weeks o f August continued larger than a year ago the
increase reflecting chiefly a growth in awards for engineering projects.
The August 1 cotton report o f the’ Department o f Agriculture
indicated a production o f 13,492,000 bales or 25 per cent less than "the
record yield of last year.
The indicated production o f corn, though
considerably larger than the expectation in July, was 262,000 000
bushels lower than the harvested crop o f 1926.
The August estimate
of 851,000,000 bushels o f wheat indicated an increase o f 18,000 000
bushels over the 1926 <?rop yield.
’
’

Trade
Distribution o f merchandise at wholesale and retail showed about
the usual seasonal decline in July.
Compared with a year ago sales
o f wholesale firms and department stores were slightly smaller, owing
largely to the fa ct that there was one less business day in J u ly ’ o f this
year than in July, 1926.
Sales of mail order houses and chain stores
were somewhat larger than a year ago.
Inventories of department
stores continued to decline in July and at the end of the month were
slightly smaller than a year ago; and wholesale stocks also continued
smaller than last year. Shipments of commodities by freight decreased
contrary to the usual seasonal trend, and were smaller in July and in
the first two weeks o f August than in the same period of last year

Plf\ CENT
6

MONEYRATES

!

— ™ Gvmrrerctaf P c o trftafc
|
M P w ' r e Ban^ D isc u n f Rrfo
- - - Acccp;‘a n c e fto te

-----

Weekly rates in New York money market,
commercial paper rate on 4 to 6 months’
paper, and acceptance rate on 90-day paper.
PfWCCHT

''iso

Payrolls

/

/ \
A
Employment

FACTC)RY EMPU) YMEHT
ANID PAY ROL LS

1
>923

1 1925

1326

Federal Reserve Board’s indexes of factory
employment and payrolls (1919 = 100). Latest
figures,
July,
employment— 90.7;
payrolls
—

101.1




Prices
The Bureau o f Labor Statistics index of wholesale prices advanced
slightly in July, reflecting chiefly increases in the prices o f corn, live­
stock, cotton, and leather, while prices of wheat, silk, metals', and
building materials declined.
Since the latter part of July, prices o f
com , cotton, and cattle have continued upward and those o f wheat
non-fe'rrous metals, and rubber have also advanced, while hogs, lumber
and hides have declined.
Bank Credit
There was an increase in the volume of commercial loans at mem­
ber banks in leading cities between July 20 and August 17, as is usual
at the beginning o f the crop-moving season.
Loans on securities as
well as commercial loans, increased, while investment holdings declined
and total loans and investments were about $60,000,000 larger than a
month earlier.
Total borrowings o f member banks at the Reserve banks increased
slightly between July 20 and August 24; there was a growth o f dis­
counts at the Federal Reserve bank of New York, partly offset bv
decline's in other Districts.
There was little change in the System’s
holdings o f acceptances and a growth in the portfolio o f United States
securities.
Money rates on all classes o f paper in the open market declined
sharply in August, and were at a lower level than a year ago. Discount
rates at eight Federal Reserve banks were reduced from 4 to 3 ^
per cent.