View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

The Monthly

Business Review
Covering financial, industrial, and agricultural conditions
in the Fourth Federal Reserve District
VOL. 6

CLEVELAND, OHIO, SEPTEMBER 1, 1924

FEDERAL RESERVE BANK of CLEVELAND



D. C. Wills, Chairman of the Board
(COMPILED AUGUST 22, 1924)

NO. 9

2

THE M O N T H L Y B U S I N E S S R E V I E W

Editorial
URING the past month there has been a gradual improve­
ment in the important iron and steel trade, and numerous
other industries have shown increased activity. A spirit of
confidence has largely replaced the pessimism and apprehension that
existed three months ago. Credit remains cheap and abundant,
and the progress made with regard to the Dawes plan gives promise
of a more stabilized Europe.

D

In analyzing this betterment of conditions, it must be remem­
bered that business in many lines usually begins to pick up at this
time of year, so that some improvement would naturally be expected.
Another factor, however, must be taken into consideration at this
time, and that is the materially higher prices being received for farm
products. The question then arises as to how much of the increase
in orders noted in various lines is due to seasonal factors and how
much to the anticipation of subsequent buying on the part of the
farmer. There is a further question as to whether such buying,
when it does come, will exceed or fall short of anticipations. It is
as yet too early to answer these questions, but in comparing business
conditions with a month or two ago, it may be repeated that there
has been an improvement, and that business at the present time is
on the upgrade.




t h e

m o n t h l y

b u s i n e s s

r e v i e w

3

Commercial Failures Increase; Cleveland Reserve Bank Reduces Rediscount Rate
Earning assets of the Federal Reserve Bank of
Cleveland increased from $65,915,000 on July 9 to
$79,588,000 on August 13. Practically all the in­
crease was due to additions to the holdings of
United States securities, which amounted to $56,026,000 on August 13. Bills discounted on the same
date stood at $22,594,000, an increase of slightly
less than $2,000,000. Total gold reserves stood at
$319,800,000, a decrease of $6,116,000, while Federal
Reserve notes in actual circulation declined from
$217,086,000 to $206,883,000. Member bank de­
posits showed an increase of about $15,000,000,
amounting to $175,397,000 on August 13.
Loans of reporting member banks in the Fourth
District on August 13 were $1,146,388,000, an in­
crease of $3,442,000 over July 9. Investments
amounted to $622,000,000, an increase of $40,000,000. Demand deposits increased from $936,103,000
to $975,277,000 during the same period, while time
deposits also increased from $676,759,000 to $695,795,000.
The reserve ratio for the Federal Reserve Bank
of Cleveland was 84.4 per cent on August 13, as
compared with 87.1 per cent on July 9. For the
System, the figure was 82.5 per cent on both dates.

On August 15, the Federal Reserve Bank of
Cleveland reduced its rediscount rate on all classes
of paper from 4 per cent to 3l/2 per cent. On Au­
gust 8, the New York bank’s rate was reduced
from Syi to 3 per cent. On August 25 the San
Francisco bank's rate was reduced from 4 to 3J4
per cent. The rates of the other banks remain un­
changed.
Savings deposits of 66 banks in the Fourth Dis­
trict on July 31 amounted to $791,722,000, as com­
pared with $772,633,000 on June 30, and $711,231,000 on July 31, 1923.
Commercial failures increased during July both in
number and liabilities, according to Dun's review.
There were 1615 failures in the United States with
liabilities of $36,813,238, an increase of 8 in num­
ber and of about $2,700,000 in liabilities. Failures
in the Fourth District during July numbered 155
with liabilities of $5,947,876, an increase of 6 in
number and $2,262,000 in liabilities. As compared
with July of last year, failures in the United States
showed an increase of 384 in number and $1,092,058 in liabilities, and in the Fourth District
the increase in number was 64 and in liabilities,
$183,895.

Improvement Noted in Iron and Steel Trade
Further progress has been made in the come­
back of the iron and steel industry after its three
months or more of falling business, but the rate of
expansion still is modest and indications are that
complete recovery is not to be a rapid one. En­
largement of buying, which came in July and has
been continuing in August, has had to do largely
with the replenishment by consumers of stocks
which had fallen to so low a point as to demand
some immediate attention. The automobile indus­
try is one of the cases in point. Orders for steel
from this direction are better, due to various re­
leases against suspended contracts, but it is ap­
parent that the revival of motor manufacturing
is coming slowly. A greater tonnage also has been
provided through some reinvigoration of new en­
terprises such as building work, railroad better­
ments, etc. Various steel companies estimate the
gain in new tonnage in July over June, April or
May, from 10 to 70 per cent, depending upon the
individual product. The relatively large increase in
some lines is attributable more to the extremely
low stage to which buying previously had fallen,
than to the new tonnage itself.
Steel works operations are beginning to reflect
the enlargement of in c o m in g orders. The Steel
Corporation at present has raised its production to
55 per cent of ingot capacity after having been



down to 40 to 42 per cent two or three weeks pre­
viously. Independent companies also are getting
into a better stride, notably in the Pittsburgh,
Youngstown and Eastern districts. At Chicago,
however, the situation shows little change, although
prospects have materially improved with respect
to agricultural implement requirements, railroad
buying, building work, and in general, manufactur­
ing demands. One western road has placed orders
for 3000 cars, which is the largest single order since
April. Ordering of rails for last half delivery
amounting to probably 100,000 tons has appeared.
Agricultural implement manufacturers, because of
the improving conditions as to the farming com­
munities, are preparing to enlarge their produc­
tion schedules for the fall and winter term.
Pig iron production in July as compiled by IRON
T R A D E R E V IE W showed a further tapering off of
14.6 per cent, but this is a comparatively better
showing than in June and May when the reduc­
tions were 20 and 21 per cent respectively. Fur­
thermore, more new furnaces were put back in
blast in July than in any other preceding month.
Whether August production will turn upward,
however, still is a question, and it is generally be­
lieved that the turn probably will come in Sep­
tember. Pig iron production in July had fallen
to the rate of 21,000,000 tons annually, compared

THE

4

MONTHLY

BUSINESS

with 40,800,000 tons in March, the high point of
the present year. This represents a loss of 48.5
per cent. Total output in July was 1,783,778 tons
compared with 2,022,836 tons in June. Active fur­
naces at the end of July were 146, a loss of 12
from June.
Steel prices still are shifting with the general
tendency downward and this may explain the re­
luctance of many consumers to obligate themselves
for future requirements. Most sales of steel for
manufacturing purposes at least are to cover im­
mediate and pressing needs and are not large indi­
vidually, although they are increasing.
IRON
TR A D E R E V IE W 'S composite of 14 leading iron
and steel products as of August 6 stood at $39.29.
One month previously it was $39.91.
The pig iron market apparently has been sta­
bilized as a result of heavy buying in June which

REVIEW

was well maintained in July, prices, however,
are at so low a point that they are discouraging
continued operation by many furnaces, and more
merchant stacks still are being blown out. This
action, furthermore, is influenced by the tremen­
dous stocks of unsold iron in the hands of the
furnaces, the largest in years. Shipments have
been increasing and in some districts n ow are in
excess of production.
Exports of iron and steel products from the
United States for the fiscal year ending June 30
amounted to 2,020,005 gross tons, a gain of 10
per cent over 1923 and 5.5 per cent over 1922, but
a loss of 8 per cent from 1921 and of about 25
per cent from the pre-war year of 1913. A large
part of the increase over 1923 is accounted for
by Japanese requirements, but it is also o f interest
to note that exports to Europe increased materially

Automobile Production Increases
After a decline which lasted three months, and
which was precipitate during May and June, automo­
bile production for the United States in July showed
an increase of nearly 10 per cent over June. As is
shown by the table given below, furnished by the Fed­
eral Reserve Bank of Chicago, the increase was all in
passenger cars, truck production being 8 per cent below
the previous month. Total production is still running
below last year and is far below the 1924 high point,
which was reached in March, but indications are that
stocks of passenger cars in the hands of many dealers
have finally reached the point where the restricted buy­
ing of recent months will have to give way to a more
liberal buying policy. Officials of the Chevrolet Motor
Company recently stated that stocks in dealers’ hands
were normal, and that July sales were almost twice
as great as July production. Truck manufacturers in
the Fourth District report that their business showed
no change for the better in July, and although a

gradual improvement is anticipated, it has not as yet
become apparent.
In connection with the future of the automobile in­
dustry, a survey taken by the National Chamber of
Commerce some months ago shows that, contrary to
the opinion quite prevalent, the farming communities
of the country are undersupplied, there being only 70
cars per thousand persons in rural districts as ^compared
with 127 cars per thousand in towns of 1,000 or more
The significance of this condition becomes apparent in
the probability of increased buying power on the part
of the farmers during the fall and winter months
During the post-war years, the prosperous industrial
centers have bought cars more heavily than the rural
sections which have not been so well off, but a return
to prosperity in the agricultural communities should
tend to increase the percentage of ownership among
the farmers.

Automobile Production 1923-1924
Figures R ep resen t Practically C om plete P roduction and Are Based Upon R ep orts R eceiv ed
by th e Federal R eserve Bank o f Chicago in C ooperation with th e N a tion a l
A u tom ob ile Cham ber o f C om m erce from Id en tica l Firm s Each M on th
1923
1924
Passenger
Total
Passenger
Trucks
Month
Trucks
Total
Cars
Cars
242,566
287,211
18,913
223,653
28,247
January. ..
315,458
280,794
336,284
21,411
259,383
30,399
February..
366,683
353,590
348,287
34,063
33,061
319,527
March. . . .
381,348
336,968
36,786
380,579
343,793
34,977
April........
371,945
279,385
392,446
42,373
350,073
32,326
M ay....... .
311,711
217,845
376,993
39,945
337,048
27,040
June........
244,885
237,431
29,712
326,885
297,173
24,895
Ju ly..........
262,326
29,882
343,854
313,972
August. . .
27,841
326,441
298,600
September.
363,882
29,638
334,244
October.. .
312,132
27,374
284,758
November.
302,562
27,275
275,287
December.
Total



3,637,511

365,213

4,002,724

t h e

m o n t h l y

b u s i n e s s

r e v i e w

5

Rubber Industry More Active
The rubber and tire industry is beginning to emerge
from the dullness of past months. Tire manufacturers
in the Fourth District report a noticeable increase in
orders during July, which has been followed by in­
creased production schedules. The gain in the volume
of business is stated to be greater than might be ex­
pected at this season, arid this is no doubt due princi­
pally to three factors: First, the continued decline in
stocks in the hands of dealers; second the recent in­
crease in the price of crude rubber, which, although
not as yet reflected in increased tire prices, has never­
theless caused some buyers to come into the market
rather than to follow their previous policy of awaiting
possible price declines; and third, the general im­
provement in business. Crude rubber prices 0 11 August
19 stood at about 28 cents a pound, an advance of
almost 9 cents since the beginning of July.
A report of the Rubber Association of Amcrica, cov­

ering 51 companies in the United States, shows that
shipments of inner tubes and of casings during June ex­
ceeded production for the first time since January,
However, for the past several years, production has
exceeded shipments during the spring months and has
fallen behind during the summer months, so that the
excess of shipments during June may be attributed
to seasonal factors. June production of inner tubes
continued the decline which began in April, and
amounted to slightly over 3 million tubes, while June
shipments attained a total of 3,700,000 tubes, the high
point for the year. Production for the first six months
of 1924 amounted to 23 J
/2 millions, as compared with
shipments of 213^ millions. The production figure was
about 4 per cent less than in 1923, while shipments
were slightly ahead of last year; but both figures were
well ahead of 1921 and 1922.

Oil and Gasoline Prices Cut
The brakes which have been applied so far to
check the upward course of domestic oil production, in
the form of proration of runs and price declines, have
not proved sufficient and the past month has seen
a consistent increase in domestic production which has
carried the total to well over 2,050,000 barrels a day.
Since the middle of March, crude output has gone
steadily upward in this country from around 1,900,000
barrels. The degree to which settled production in
practically all fields has held up has upset the cal­
culations of the industry made at the start of the year.
The opening up of deeper sands in certain portions
of the California fields gives promise of stimulated
Gutput there. The Tonkawa and Burbank fields in
Oklahoma have been responsible for production in the
Oklahoma territory generally reaching 518,390 bar­
rels a day within the past two weeks, its highest
mark of the year, and not much under the peak of
532,330 barrels for 1923.
Practically all fields with the exception of California
have met price declines in the past month. Pennsylvania
grade crude stands at $3 and $3.25, the price estab­
lished by reductions on July 7 of 50 and 25 cents, ac­
cording to the grade. Lima, Ohio, grade is $1.83, the
result of a 10 cent reduction on July 17 and 25 cents
on July 29. Indiana grade is $1.63, Wooster $1.65,
Illinois $1.62, Petrolie, Canada, $2.23, and Somerset
light, Kentucky, $1.85, through reductions of the same
amounts on the same dates.
The price for Mid-Continent crudes of various
gravities has been variously adjusted over the past
month, and certain grades have been eliminated in the
effort to bring quotations of the Prairie Oil & Gas
Company and the Sinclair interests, principal pur­



chasers, into line with existing conditions. Their price
for the highest gravity crude is $1.50. One other large
purchaser has a price of $1.25 for this grade. The
Prairie’s price reductions were made on July 17 and
July 28, varying in amounts from 10 to 50 cents a
barrel. The largest reductions have been made in the
higher gravity crudes, with the greatest gasoline con­
tent, and it is quite likely that the principal purchasing
agencies have realized the necessity of having crude
prices follow more closely the relations of supply and
demand for the principal petroleum commodity, now
gasoline. Low gravity crudes, with minimum gasoline,
content from old settled fields have been faced with
only moderate reductions.
During July, gasoline stocks over the country were
reduced by perhaps as much as 125,000,000 gallons,
National Petroleum News believes, as compared with
a reduction of 51,000,000 in June. In spite of heavy
consumption, stocks of this product remain very high,
and this fact is largely responsible for holding the
refinery price of gasoline down.
Reductions have taken place in the retail price of
gasoline pretty well over the country, in line with the
readjustment in the crude market. These reductions
have reached the point at some places that the margin
for the marketing company has been reduced to less
than it can operate on at a profit. In the Fourth Dis­
trict, there has been further sagging of gasoline prices
during the month. On July 31, the Midvale Oil Com­
pany sold gasoline at 18 cents a gallon in Cleveland,
coinciding with a reduction from 19 to 18 cents by the
Standard Oil Company of Indiana. The 18 cent price
is now general in Cleveland and other parts of the Dis­
trict.

6

m

_______ T H E

MONTHLY

BUSINESS

R E V I E W _______

Coal Industry Quiet; Outlook Slightly Improved
No change of importance has taken place in the
bituminous coal industry during the last month,
but reports indicate that the outlook is slightly
better than it was a month ago. There has been
some increase in production, and mines in some
sections of the country are operating at a greater
per cent of capacity. In addition, the usual sea­
sonal increase in demand is anticipated, although
the hot weather during August has so far held
back buying by householders in many localities.
The level of bituminous coal production through­
out July was higher than at any time since the
latter part of March, which marked the end of
the abrupt decline in production. The daily av­
erage production for the five weeks ending August
9 was 1,250,000 net tons, as compared with about
1,200,000 net tons for the preceding five weeks,
according to figures furnished by the Geological
Survey. During the week of August 9, produc­
tion reached the highest point since March.
In the western sections of the country, mines
generally were operating on August 2 at from 4
to 15 per cent greater capacity than during the
latter part of June. Average mine operations
ranged from 60 per cent of capacity in New Mex­
ico to 22 per cent in Arkansas. In the Fourth
District, however, no such general increase was
noticeable. The Pittsburgh rail mines increased
from 12 per cent to 29 per cent of capacity in the
period under review, and the mines in Southern
Ohio and Central Pennsylvania operated at slightly
greater capacity; on the other hand, mines in
the Panhandle District of West Virginia showed
a decline from 69 per cent to 53 per cent, and sub­

stantial declines were also shown by the W est­
moreland and Cumberland mines and the com bi­
nation rail and river mines in the Pittsburgh dis­
trict.
A report issued by the National Association of
Purchasing Agents, covering coal consumed for
industrial purposes, shows that industrial stocks
on h^nd of both bituminous and anthracite coal
stood at about 46 million tons at the beginning of
1923, rose to 78 million in August of that year,
declined slightly to 72 million at the end o f March,
1924, and then fell rapidly to 54 million at the
end of June. The second quarter of the year was
therefore devoted by dealers to working off sur­
plus stocks, and indications are that some dealers
are reaching the point of replenishment.
The anthracite industry has been quiet. Shut­
downs in Pennsylvania mines have occurred since
the last Review, due to the sluggishness of the
market, and this has resulted in a decline in pro­
duction since the first part of July. A ccording to
the Geological Survey, production o f anthracite in
the United States during the week ending August
29 amounted to 1,683,000 net tons, as com pared
with 1,720,000 net tons for the previous week, 1 871,000 for the week ending July 12, and 1,735,000
for the week ending August 7, 1923.
The Ore and Coal Exchange states that during
July, 1924, a total of 3,621,665 net tons were loaded
into vessels at Great Lake ports, as compared with
4,910,479 net tons in July, 1923. For the first
seven months of 1924, the figure was 10,113 512
net tons, as compared with 15,009,872 net tons*for
the corresponding period in 1923.

Grain Car Loadings Increasing
An increase in car loadings was manifested
during the latter part of July, which is usual at
this time. According to the report of the Ameri­
can Railway Association, more cars were loaded
during the week ending August 2 than for any
week since February, although considerably under
the same week last year. The general level through­
out July was higher than in June, and showed an
upward trend during the month. Total cars loaded
during 1924 up to August 2 numbered approxi­
mately 27,600,<X)0, which was about 1,000,000 cars
less than in 1923, but was ahead of the three pre­
ceding years.
Some interesting facts come to light in a com­

parison of the loadings of various kinds of freight
during the last few weeks. The total increase in
the number of cars loaded during the week ending
August 2, as compared with the week ending June
28, amounted to 37,000 cars. Grain loadings in­
creased 18,000 cars and miscellaneous merchandise
increased 26,000 cars, while other classes of load­
ings showed declines with the exception of coal
which increased very slightly. These figures show
that farm products have already begun to move to
market in good volume. During the same period
ore loadings declined by 5,000 cars, reaching their
lowest point for several months and being only
about half the total attained early in May.

Tobacco Crop in Kentucky Less Than Last Year
A recent Government crop report estimates the
1924 Kentucky tobacco crop at 396 million pounds,




as compared with 494 million last year. Inasmuch
as the crop is reported to be doing well, the decline

THE

MONTHLY

BUSINESS

in the total yield may be attributed largely to de­
creased acreage, which is particularly noticeable in
Central Kentucky. Many members of the Burley
Tobacco Growers’ Co-operative Association report
reductions in acreage from 5 to 25 per cent, and
there have been instances of even greater reduc­
tions. It is estimated that the Association held
on August 1 about 250 million pounds of unsold
stock, for which there was but little demand at
that time.
In last m o n th ’ s R e v ie w , it w a s n o te d th at a c o m ­

REVIEW

7

mission of the Burley Tobacco Growers’ Co-oper­
ative Association had recently gone abroad for
the purpose of establishing foreign oulets for to­
bacco. This visit has already resulted in an or­
der for Burley tobacco placed by the Italian g ov ­
ernment monopoly, the first order to be received
from that source. It is the hope of the Burley
Association that a considerable export trade with
Europe will be built up, as reports indicate that
there is an increasing demand in Europe for Ameri­
can cigarettes, the chief constituent of which is
Burley tobacco.

Agricultural Conditions
Forecasts issued by the United States Department
o f Agriculture indicate that in the country as a whole
the leading crops show substantial improvement over the
prospects of a month ago. The decrease in certain
sections appears to be largely balanced by an in­
creased yield in others, and it is very generally con­
ceded that there is no occasion to fear a general
shortage. The corn crop,— and to a lesser degree,
the potato crop,— is an exception of this rule, the
corn crop suffering in every section of the country,
while indications are that the potato crop will fall
short of the average in all but a few sections. The
latest estimates at hand from the Department of
Agriculture indicate a decrease of approximately
15 per cent in the corn yield, and about 3.3 per
cent in potatoes.
The outlook in the Fourth District is somewhat less
encouraging than throughout the country at large.
Both corn and wheat show a serious shortage, and
fruits appear to be below the average. On the other
hand, hay and oats show an increase, and the potato
crop is reported to be about up to the average, if
not slightly ahead of it.
OHIO
CORN— The prospects for corn declined during the
past month, and the latest available estimate from the
Ohio Department of Agriculture is that the crop will
not be more than 60 per cent of that of last year.
The dry, hot weather during the early part of Au­
gust brought about a premature tasselling that will
seriously reduce the yield. By far the better fields
are to be found in Southwestern Ohio, while
throughout the northern part of the State there are
practically no good prospects.
W HEA T— In the northern section of the State,
there was a somewhat better yield than had been pre­
dicted earlier in the year. The average yield through­
out the States is estimated at 16.8 bushels per acre, as
against a yield of 17.1 last year. The total crop
is now estimated at 37,000,000 bushels, as compared
with 43,000,000 bushels in 1923.
H A Y —The yield of hay is estimated at 25 per
cent more than last year’s crop, and as weather con­




ditions were favorable at the time of harvesting, the
quality is reported as above the average.
FRUITS—The present conditions indicate somewhat
less than half a crop of apples, while pear and grape
prospects have also declined during the past month.
Earlier forecasts of an abundant crop of blackberries
have been fully verified.
PEN N SYLVAN IA
CORN— No change is reported in the conditions of
the corn crop, the estimates still being 73 per cent of a
normal yield. Present conditions indicate a yield of
35.8 bushels per acre, or a total production of 52,948,000 bushels as compared with 61,640,000 bushels in
1923, and a ten-year average of 64.928,000 bushels.
W H E A T — Preliminary estimates of the winter wheat
yield per acre place the figure at 16.5 bushels, with a
total production of 19,850,000 bushels as against 24,168.000 last year, and a ten-year average of 24,356,000
bushels. The quality is also judged to be 3 per cent
less than last year, and 4 per cent below the tenyear average.
Spring wheat shows a decrease in total production
of 25 per cent from the average, conditions presaging
a yield of some 164,000 bushels as against an av­
erage crop of 220,000 bushels.
OATS— Steady improvement has been noted in this
crop, and present indications point to an acreage yield
of 33.6 bushels. Latest official forecasts of the State
Department of Agriculture are for a total production
of 34,205,000 as against 33,930,000 in 1923.
POTATOES—While forecasts of production indicate
a slight falling off from last year, it is believed that the
crop will exceed the ten-year average. The estimated
total production for this year is 24,595,000 bushels as
compared with a ten-year average total of 24,573,000
bushels.
Sweet potatoes are reported as below normal, indica­
tions pointing to a total production of 249,000 bushels
as against an average total of 266,000 bushels.
H A Y — The conditions of all hay crops is decidedly
better than for many years, and the total production
is estimated at 4,344,000 tons as compared with 3,066.000 tons last year. The acreage of grain cut green

8

THE

MONTHLY

for hay shows an increase of 5 per cent over last year.
FRUITS— The outlook for the fruit crop is rather
discouraging; apples, peaches, and pears all show a
very marked decrease from last year. The grape
crop is estimated as somewhat in excess of last
year, the latest estimates placing total production
at about 19,700 tons as against 17,000 tons in 1923.
KENTUCKY
CORN—Total production in the State is now esti­
mated at 78,336,000 bushels, a decrease of almost 11 per
cent from last year. This is a slightly better showing
than is made by the country at large as the decrease in
the United States is estimated at about 15.4 per cent.
W H E A T — The wheat crop in this State is but little
more than half last year’s total, the estimated
production this year being 4,340,000 bushels as against
a total yield of 7,688,000 bushels in 1923. However,
this is much better than was predicted earlier in the
season, due to a favorable turn in the weather during
the month or so immediately preceding the maturing of
the grain.
OTHER CROPS— The showing of other crops
throughout the State appears to keep pace generally
with the country at large, oats, hay and potatoes making

BUSINESS

REVIEW

a much better showing than last year. One of the
bright spots in the situation in this State is the splendid
fruit crop. While in certain sections there is less
than an average crop, the State as a whole will show
a total yield of more than twice that of 1923 in both
peaches and apples.
OUTLOOK FOR CANNERIES
Indications point to a shortage in practically all
crops entering into the canning industry in the Fourth
District. Unfavorable weather has been the principal
factor contributing to this situation, continued early
rains interfering with proper cultivation, and a subse­
quent dry, hot spell materially decreasing the produc­
tion.
Canners report an increasing number o f inquiries as
to canned goods of all descriptions, and the demand
has improved. Peas are reported as having failed to
come in in the customary volume and the grade in
some instances has fallen short of the usual standard.
Corn, which should at this writing be in the height of
the season, is reported as scarcely more than half the
average crop, and an actual shortage is anticipated as
many packers are not planning to handle corn this
season, and supplies with the wholesale grocery trade
are practically exhausted.

Agricultural Implement Industry Shows Little Change
There has been but little change in the farm implement industry in the Fourth District during
July. Production remains the same, and but few
price changes are reported. There has been littie, if any, increase in sales over recent months.
Some manufacturers, however, report an increase in

orders for spring delivery,
As noted in last month’s Review, many farmers
are using old and worn-out machinery, and this
fact, coupled with the higher prices being received
by farmers for their products, is expected to provide the impetus for increased buying in the Spring

Livestock Movement During July
Livestock shipments in the Fourth Federal Reserve District were less during July than in July
of last year, but were greater than in June, with
the exception of hogs.
The following table shows the combined movement for the principal centers of the District:

July, 1924
July, 1923
June, 1924

Cars
UnCattle Hogs
Sheep Calves loaded
76,369 417,941 206,263 70,363 8,176
78,110 423,274 228,108 73,606 8^238
62,544 457,130 165,676 63,106 7^269

Boot and Shoe Outlook Is Better
There has recently been a more optimistic feel­
ing manifested by the boot and shoe industry as
a whole than for some time past. Some increases
in orders are reported. In the Fourth District,
there has been a turn for the better. Several man­
ufacturers report a noticeable increase in orders
within the last 60 days, although customers still
seem inclined to buy mostly for immediate needs.
Preliminary production figures for the Fourth Dis­
trict for July indicate a 10 per cent increase over
June, and there appears to be a much more opti­
mistic spirit among shoe dealers than was in evi­




dence a month ago. In addition to the usual sea­
sonal factors, the improved condition in the agricul­
tural communities is expected to play a part in
the recovery of the shoe industry.
Final production figures for June, compiled by
the Census Bureau, show a further sagging, both
in the United States and in the Fourth District.
In fact, June production for the country as a whole
was the lowest at any time during 1923 and 1924
and in this District only April of this year showed*
a lower figure. As stated above, preliminary fig­
ures for this District indicated an improvement

THE

MONTHLY

BUSINESS

in July; for the United States, however, a slight
decrease is indicated. Actual production for the
country during June amounted to 22,403,547 pairs,
as compared with 25,240,153 pairs in May and a

REVIEW

9

1923 monthly average of about 28,500,000 pairs,
In the Fourth District, June production decreased
over 5 per cent from May and was about 24 per
cent under the 1923 monthly average.

Textile Trade Shows Gradual Improvement; Manufacturers and Jobbers Optimistic
There have been but slight changes in the tex­
tile market during the past month, but there ap­
pears to prevail a m on g both manufacturers and job­
bers an increasing optimism in regard to the fu­
ture. A gradual improvement in the demand for
cotton goods is apparent, due in a measure to the
downward trend in prices of raw cotton. On the
part of manufacturers, there has been a consider­
able tendency toward curtailment of production,
with the staple at such a level as to eliminate
profits, and many factories have declined to ac­

cept orders at the current prices.
Garment and clothing manufacturers are be­
ing forced to replenish their stocks to some extent
as they have carefully guarded against overstock­
ing, and have at the same time been cautious about
accumulating stocks of made-up goods. Orders
were small but numerous, indicating a desire to
guard against any sudden fluctuation.
Trade in broad silks showed a gradual improve­
ment, while woolen and worsted dress goods con­
tinued in fair demand.

No Improvement in Smaller Industries
A survey of some of the smaller industries in
the Fourth District shows that for the most part
there has been practically no improvement as yet,
although better business in nearly all lines is looked
for in the Fall. Reports indicate that rather
more than the usual seasonal increase is antici­
pated. In a few lines, such as the manufacture of
lead, increased orders have already been expe­
rienced. Prices in most lines remain about the
same, although a slight downward tendency is
reported by electric supply manufacturers and by

stove manufacturers. Stocks of buyers are re­
ported to be low in the boxboard industry, and
there has been some resumption of buying. A
plate glass manufacturer states that business was
unusually good during the first five months of the
year and that since then a perfectly natural
falling off has taken place. The twist drill in­
dustry is expected to benefit by the betterment in
iron and steel. Conditions in various other indus­
tries appear to be unchanged.

Lumber Industry More Active
The summer dullness in the lumber industry has
recently begun to give way to renewed activity.
There was a substantial increase in production,
orders, and shipments during the four weeks end­
ing August 9, the greatest increase being shown
by orders, according to returns from 375 mills
which report weekly to the National Lumber Man­
ufacturers’ Association. Orders for the period were
10 per cent in excess of production, while shipments
were slightly ahead of production. The dullness
of the past three months in the softwood indus­
try, which was due largely to the hand-to-mouth
buying policy of the retailers, resulted in a steady
decline in prices until the middle of July, when in­
creased buying became evident, attracted by the
lower prices. Orders have since been increasing,
and prices have stiffened.
Lumber manufacturers in the Fourth District re­
port that the volume of business is now good, al­

though not exceptional. A seasonal increase is expected
during the fall, but opinion is divided as to whether
this will be any more than seasonal.
In some
quarters it is felt that the generally improved busi­
ness situation will be reflected in the lumber trade,
while others feel that the downward trend in the
building industry is likely to prevent any unusual
increase in the volume of business, at least in soft­
wood lumber.
Lumber production of the 375 mills above noted
amounted to 928 million feet for the four weeks
ending August 9, an increase of 9 per cent over
the preceding four weeks. During the same pe­
riod, shipments amounted to 931 million feet, an
increase of 15 per cent, and orders totaled 1019
million feet, an increase of 24 per cent. The most
noticeable increases were shown in the lumber re­
gions of the West.

Building Operations Slower
There has been a further slackening in building
operations during Tuly, both in the Fourth District and in the United States. This decline has
continued since March, which registered the high



point for all time. Construction costs fell off slightly during the month. There were some declines
in building materials, while wages generally held
firm.

THE

10

MONTHLY

BUSINESS

The value of building permits in July of 324
cities, reported by S. W. Straus & Company,
showed a gain of 2 per cent over July of last
year, but a loss of over 9 per cent from June, 1924.
The increase over last year occurred in the smaller
cities, since the 25 largest cities showed practically
no gain. In the Fourth District, 13 cities showed
decreases of 12 per cent from a year ago and of 4
per cent from June of this year. The largest de­
creases from June were shown by Pittsburgh and
Toledo, while Cincinnati and Canton showed sub­
stantial increases. For the first seven months oi
the year, building permits in the United States
were about 6 per cent greater than for the cor­
responding period in 1923, but in the Fourth Dis­
trict they were 1.4 per cent less than for 1923.
The largest percentage gains in the Fourth Dis­
trict were shown by Youngstown, with 66 per
cent, and Erie, with 36 per cent, while the larg­
est declines were registered by Columbus, with
30 per cent, and Dayton, with 18 per cent. Pitts­

REVIEW

burgh and Cincinnati both showed small declines,
while Cleveland was practically the same as last
year.
The Aberthaw index number of factory building
costs, (1914-100), stood at 196 on August 1, a drop of
two points during July. The high point of the last
ten years was reached in July, 1920, when the
index number was 265, from which there was
a sharp decline to about 150 at the beginning of
1921. An advance then set in which lasted until
June, 1923, when the index stood at 207. Since
that time, there has been a downward trend. The
recent decrease in costs is a result o f a decline in
the cost of materials, as wages have shown little
change. In Pittsburgh, for example, a com pari­
son of the price of 23 building materials shows that
between April 1 and July 1 of this year, there were
eight declines as against one increase, fourteen re­
maining stationary. In Cleveland, there w ere six
declines and four increases, the declines being more
marked.

Conditions Spotted in Building Brick Industry; Paving Brick Showing Activity
In the face of the steady decline in the value of
building permits issued during the last four months,
the building brick industry as a whole held up well
during July, although conditions were spotted. Re­
ports indicate that demand throughout the East
is good, with the exception of the Atlantic sea­
board, and that production has not been curtailed.
In the agricultural West, the condition of the
industry is quiet, but an increase in business is
anticipated owing to the improvement in the ag­
ricultural situation. There has been a bad slump
in the New York City market, due, for the most
part, to the lengthy strike of the structural steel
workers, and this has resulted in a great number
of bricks lying unsold at the wharves. The New
York wholesale price has declined from $20 per
thousand to around $14 per thousand. July prices,
except in New York, have remained practically
unchanged, the range in the South and West be­
ing from $8.25 to $17 per thousand, and in the
Middle West and East from $10 to $20 per thou­
sand. On July 1, orders on the books of 101 firms
reporting to the Common Brick Manufacturers’
Association of America amounted to 366,098,000
bricks. This figure is 7 per cent under both that
of June 1 and of July 1 a year ago, but compares

favorably with the first five months of this year
Bricks moved from yards during the month o f
June amounted to 158,753,000, a slight decrease from
May. Seven plants were closed down on July 1
as compared with 6 on June 1, 45 on February
1, and 6 on July 1 of last year.
The outlook for the paving brick industry is
good. Conditions are favorable for increased ac­
tivity, due partly to the fact that the bad weather
during the Spring and early Summer in many
parts of the country has naturally held up high­
way construction. Aside from seasonal factors
however, the industry has shown a good growth*
Shipments have doubled in the last five years de­
spite keen competition from other paving materials
A recent report of the National Paving Brick Man­
ufacturers’ Association, covering the entire indus­
try, shows that shipments of No. 1 brick have in­
creased steadily since February and have caught
up with production, which exceeded shipments from
October of last year to June of this year. Unfilled
orders during July declined 6 per cent from June
but were at the fourth highest point of the last
seventeen months. Stocks on hand also declined
slightly from June.

Department Store Sales Less Than Last Year
Sales of 58 department stores in the Fourth Fed­
eral Reserve District during July were 2.4 per
cent less than those of July, 1923. July sales also
showed the usual seasonal decline from June. In
the face of the decrease in sales from June, stocks
on hand at the end of July were 5.4 per cent less




than at the end of June, and inasmuch as June
stocks showed a decline of 7.2 per cent from those
at the end of May, it is apparent that buying has
recently been light. A reflection of this may be
found in the sales of wholesale dry goods firms
in this District, which were 13 per cent less in

THE

MONTHLY

July than in June.
July sales of 53 department stores in this District were exceeded twice in the last six years, in
1920 and 1923. Taking the five-year monthly av-

BUSINESS

11

REVIEW

erage sales for 1919-1923 as a base, the relative or
index numbers for July for each year are as follows: 1919, 70; 1920, 91; 1921, 70; 1922, 73; 1923,
82; 1924, 81.

Department Store Sales
(1)
_ (2)
Percentage o f Increase or Decrease
C o m p a riso n o f net sales w ith
those o f co rre sp o n d in g p e riod
last year

No. of
Reports
4
3
7
6
5
5
3
7
5
5
3
5*
58

A
July

Akron...............
6.4
Canton.............
— 6.4
Cincinnati........
4.2
Cleveland........
—4.8
Columbus........
0.5
Dayton............
— 6.8
New Castle. . . .
— 4.4
Pittsburgh.......
— 2.0
Toledo..............
— 9.8
Wheeling..........
0.8
Youngstown . . .
— 2.1
Other Cities. . .
— 1.0
District............
— 2.4
U.S. Average. .
1.4
^Includes reports from Erie,
**Includes reports from Erie,

(3)

(4)

Percentage

Stocks at end o f month comp ared w ith

A
B
B
July
June
July 1
1923
to July 31
1924
4.9
6.4
— 3.6
6.6
— 2.6
— 6.4
— 9.2
4.2
— 4.5
4.4
—4.8
— 2.3
— 11.1
0.5
— 13.4
9.5
— 6.8
— 9.4
— 4.4
8.6
— 8.2
— 2.0
5.5
— 7.0
— 9.8
6.7
3 .4
0.8
— 8.5
— 13.4
— 2.1
— 5.9
— 7.5
4 .0
— 1.0
— 8.9
2.6
— 2.4
— 5.4
1.7
1.4
— 3.9
Portsmouth and Springfield.
Portsmouth, Akron, Springfield, and Dayton.

o f Percentage

of

stocks on July o u t s t a n d i n g
orders at end o f
31, 1924, to net
July, 1924, to
sales during July total purchases
during calendar
year 1923

443.7
939.6
477.2
460.4
343.6
470.7
678.1
481.2
606.8
429.3
365.9
615.4
475.1
480.7

1L 6
7.5
6 .6
9.6
5.3
4.3
6.5
8.5**
8.1
7.7

Index Numbers of Sales of 53 Department Stores
Fourth Federal Reserve District
(Average Monthly Sales for the Five-Year Period 1919-1923 Inclusive— 100)
N ote:

1923
F eb.. .
Mar. .
A p r...
May. .
June. .
July. .
Aug.
Sept..
O c t.. .
N ov . .
D e c...
1924
Jan.
Feb.. .
Mar. .
A p r.. .
May. .
June. .
July. .

T h is table is s u b je c t to slig h t r e v is io n , as a few a d d itio n a l firm s m a y be in clu d ed .

Pitts­
burgh
88
116
110
124
121
80
94
99
130
120
168

Cincin­ Cleve- Toledo Colum­ Dayton Youngs- Akron Canton* New Wheel- Other Dis­
nati
town
land
bus
Castle ing Cities** trict
83
95
77
84
77
80
80
79
76
83
67
74
120
115
108
116
114
127
134
133
104
117
127
104
108
108
104
119
106
109
112
107
117
111
111
98
118
112
122
110
117
118
129
118
114
129
113
119
114
115
118
115
115
119
128
116
123
126
112
119
76
79
81
89
81
92
95
92
90
89
79
82
96
90
84
113
104
105
96
97
92
91
80
96
90
94
96
88
110
101
81
106
112
105
87
101
136
126
113
125
128
127
113
149
141
154
128
129
120
120
102
122
120
121
113
134
127
131
105
121
194
156
183
164
187
187
206
199
212
194
219
175

98
90
91
94
102
101
103
90
98
87
94
92
100
105
100
103
114
124
122
124
114
135
117
131
118
116
109
100
121
118
115
117
100
100
109
99
79
95
87
80
78
83
*Based on 3-year average (1921-1922-1923).
**Includes Springfield, Portsmouth, and Erie.




84
120
118
124
117
111
79

78
88
95
112
106
93
84

88
97
115
128
124
107
83

91
81
93
127
109
98
86

102
87
107
128
118
115
89

74
77
91
112
109
104
78

94
96
104
124
114
108
81

THE

12

MONTHLY

BUSINESS

REVIEW

Wholesale Sales Show Increases in Some Lines
Sales of wholesale groceries, hardware, and drugs
in the Fourth District during July increased over
June, but were smaller than July a year ago, with
the exception of drugs. Dry goods showed a de­
crease both from last month and from last year,
and all reporting lines show decreases for 1924 to

July 31, as compared with the corresponding- period in 1923.
A slightly more liberal buying policy is noted
by a number of dry goods firms, but in other w h ole­
sales lines buying is still cautious and fo r im­
mediate needs.

Wholesale Trade Sales
N um ber o f
F irm s R e p o rtin g

P ercen tag e ch a n g e in
net sales during J u ly ,
1924, com p a red w ith
Ju ne, 1924.

P ercen ta g e chan ge in
net sales during J u ly ,
1924, com p a red w ith
J u ly , 1923.

Groceries3
Cincinnati........................
— 0.9
3
Cleveland..........................
5.2
3
Columbus..........................
14.2
4
Erie....................................
1.9
Lexington..........................
3
3.8
7
Pittsburgh.........................
12.9
3
Portsmouth.......................
— 6.4
3
Toledo................................
— 0.2
n
.>
Youngstown...................... .......
— 1.1
16
Other Cities*....................
5.3
48
D IS T R IC T .......................
4.8
14
Dry Goods— District...............
— 13.1
14
Drugs— District.......................
4.4
17
Hardware— District.................
0.9
*Includes Akron, Canton, Dayton, Dover, Ironton, Lima, Mansfield,
Wheeling, and Xenia.

Percentage change in
net sales from Jan. 1
to July 31,
1924,
compared w ith same
period last year.

— 7.9
2.1
4.7
2 .2
4.1
— 4.3
3.0
8.6
— 7.8
— 5.6
— 1.6
— 4.1
— 9.2
— 3 .0
— 4.6
— 3.4
— 8.0
— 2.4
— 6.4
— 4.9
— 2.2
— 1.8
— 24.7
— 15.4
0.8
— 2.3
— 19.3
— 7.3
Massillon, >pringfield, Steubenville,

Summary of Business and Credit Conditions in the United States
By The Federal Reserve Board

PRODUCTION IN BASIC INDUSTRIES
PCR
T.

WCfMT.---------

czn

150

1

Production in basic industries, after a considerable decline in
recent months, was maintained in July at the same level as in
June. Factory employment continued to decline. Wholesale
prices increased for the first time since early in the year re­
flecting chiefly the advance in the prices of farm products.
P R O D U C T IO N

MO

V

v

t x

\

/
\

/ r

50

JQ

;

I
o
1 *1 9

hmmm
In U eX

Oi

192a

0

1921

4. 4.

1923

J9Z2
iw l

(1 91 9 = 10 0 .)

Latest




aC aau.i.

figure— July,

94.

1924

The Federal Reserve Board’s index of production in basic
industries, which had declined 22 per cent between February
and June, remained practically unchanged during July.
Iron
and steel and woolen industries showed further curtailment,
while production of flour, cement, coal, and copper was larger
than in June. Factory employment decreased 4 per cent in
July owing to further reduction of forces in the textile, metal
and automobile industries. .Building contract awards showed!
more than the usual seasonal decline in July, but were 10
per cent larger than a year ago.
Crop conditions, as reported by the Department of Agri­
culture, were higher on August 1 than a month earlier. Esti-

THE

MONTHLY

BUSINESS

13

REVIEW

mated production o f nearly all of the principal crops except
tobacco was larger than in July and the yields of wheat, oats,
rye, and cotton are expected to be considerably larger than
last year.

TRADE

adopted

by

B u r e a u )-

L a te st

figure— July,

147.

Railroad shipments increased in July, owing to larger load­
ings of miscellaneous merchandise, grain, and coal. Wholesale
trade was 3 per cent larger than in June, owing to increased
sales of meat, dry goods, and drugs, but was 3 per cent sm aller
than a year ago. Retail trade showed the usual seasonal decline
in July, and department store sales were 1 per cent greater and
mail order sales 7 per cent less than a year ago.
Merchandise stocks at department stores continued to decline
during July and were only slightly larger at the end of the
month than a year earlier.

P R IC E S
Wholesale prices, as measured by the index of the Bureau of
Labor Statistics, increased more than 1 per cent in July. Prices
of farm products, foods and clothing increased, while prices of
building materials again declined sharply and prices of metals,
Euel, and house furnishings also decreased. During the first half
of August, quotations on corn, beef, sugar, silk, copper, rubber,
and anthracite advanced, while prices of cotton, flour, and bricks
declined.

B A N K C R E D IT

figure— July,

87.

Commercial loans of member banks in leading cities, owing
partly to seasonal influences, increased considerably early in Au­
gust. Loans secured by stocks and bonds and investments con­
tinued to increase, so that at the middle of August total loans
and investments of those banks were larger than at any previous
time. Further growth of demand deposits carried them also to
the highest level on record.
Between the middle of July and the middle o f August, Fed­
eral Reserve Bank discounts for member banks declined further
and their holdings of acceptances decreased somewhat. United
States security holdings increased, however, and total earning
assets of Federal Reserve Banks remained practically unchanged.

W eekly ngures for m ember banks in 101 leading cities. Latest
figures A ugust 13.




Continued easing in money rates in the New York market
during July and early August is indicated by a decline of %
of one per cent in prevailing rates for commercial paper to
3 - 3 % per cent. After the middle of August, there was some ad­
vance in open market rates for bankers* acceptances and short
term government securities. During August the discount rate
at the Federal Reserve Bank of New Y ork was reduced from
3 % to 3 per cent and at the Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland
and of San Francisco from 4 to 3 % per cent.

THE

14

MONTHLY

BUSINESS

REVIEW

Comparative Statement of Selected Member Banks in the Fourth District
Loans and Discounts secured by U. S. Govern­
ment obligations............................................
Loans and Discounts secured by other stocks and
bonds...............................................................
Loans and Discounts, all other...........................
U. S. Pre-War Bonds............................................
U. S. Liberty Bonds..............................................
U. S. Treasury Bonds...........................................
U. S. Treasury Notes............................................
U. S. Certificates of Indebtedness.......................
Other Bonds, Stocks and Securities....................
Total Loans, Discounts and Investments..........
Reserve with Federal Reserve Bank...................
Cash in Vault........................................... .............
Net Demand Deposits..........................................
Time Deposits...... .................................................
Government Deposits...........................................
Total resources on date of this report................

Aug. 13, 1924
(78 Banks)

July 16, 1924
(78 Banks)

$18,677,000

$18,321,000

417,122,000413,763,000
710,589,000708,834,000
47,095,000
46,989,000
180,337,000161,687,000
1,971,000 3,035,000
54,772,00047,488,000
5,925,000 8,082,000
332,506,000322,002,000
1,768,994,000 1,730,201,000
120,831,000112,915,000
29,714,000
29,487,000
975,277,000939,633,000
695,795,000684,536,000
13,145,000 13,145,000
$2,274,496,000 $2,221,075,000

Increase
$356,000

Decrease
$ ----- -------

3,359,000
...........................
1,755,000
................ ..
106,000
........ ..
18,650,000
................ ...........
........................
1>064,000
7,284,000
.............................
........................
2,157,000
10,504,000
...........................
38,793,000
........ ...........
7,916,000
................ ..
227,000
........ ..
35,644,000
..................
11,259,000
.................. .. . . ;
........................
.......... ..
*
$53,421,000

...........

Building Operations for Month of July, 1924-1923
New
Akron.........
Canton.......
Cincinnati..
Cleveland*..
Columbus. .
Dayton. . . .
Erie............
Lexington. .
Pittsburgh..
Springfield..
Toledo........
Wheeling...
Youngstown

Permits Issued
Construction
Alterations
1924
1923 1924 1923
..........................................
274
282
83
63
193
183
69
72
346
264
385
267
537
556 1,135 1,199
381
499
133
172
245
140
254
132
117
110
50
57
50
56
38
23
459
599
329
156
90
70
29
27
461
406
187
205
76
59
50
39
266
150
46
41

Valuation
New ConstructionAlterations
Increase or Decrease
1924
1923
1924
1923
Amount Per Cent
517,244 $ 724,913$ 56,335 $ 27,750 $— 179,084 — 23 8
1,176,285
366,997
45,815
76,150
778,953 1 7 5 «
1,981,235
1,265,010
420,375
273,150
863,450
56' 1
5,993,200
8,698,638
1,327,237
786,580 — 2,164,781 — 2 2'8
931,900
2,962,125
152,900
232,275 — 2,109,600 — 66 0
700.754
533,396
224,756
121,952
270,162
41'2
416.755
315,700
42,550
54,400
89,205
24’ 1
112,865
184,605
46,295
18,975 — 44,420 — 2 1 ' 8
2,079,458
2,622,318
544,519
241,922 — 240,263 — 8 ’ 4
134,243
52,540
26,835
23,310
85,228 1 1 2 4
901,221
1,449,569
206,445
168,358 — 510,261 — 31 ' 5
212,285
210,316
44,255
42,695
3,529
14
793,775
300,380
43,935
28,550
508,780 154 7

T o t a l . . . . 3,495 3,609 2,553 2,453 $15,951,220 219,686,507 $3,182,252
*Includes figures for East Cleveland, Lakewood and Shaker Heights.

$2,096,067— 2,649,102 — 12.2

Building Operations for Seven Months Ended July 31, 1924-1923
Permits Issued
Valuation
New Construction AlterationsNew Construction
Alterations
1924 1923 1924 1923
1924
1923
1924
Akron......... 1,607 1,802
875
436
$3,873,640 $3,700,485$ 506,156 $
Canton....... 1,379 1,341
526
493
4,956,276 4,033,945
361,748
Cincinnati.. 2,376 2,739 1,648 1,770
13,567,120 14,228,510
2,170,700
Cleveland*.. 4,146 4,487 7,673 7,234
42,008,180 42,164,189
7,047,312
Columbus.. 2,683 3,325 1,048
893
9,167,165 13,664,795
1,286,235
Da y t o n . . . . 1,469 1,795
827
913
5,279,049 6,380,124
739,024
Erie............
878
800
381
402
2,564,870 1,902,744
751,464
Lexington..
295
310
227
243
956,108 1,158,713
179,637
Pittsburgh.. 3,321 3,492 1,659
939
17,971,620 19,413,010
2,500,489
Springfield..
563
615
187
190
889,171
954,835
151,850
Toledo........ 3,015 2,487 1,304 1,451
9,756,881 8,199,844
1,404,407
Wheeling...
608
539
337
315
2,607,379 2,149,645
454,955
Youngstown. 1,501 1,113
221
234
5,440,745 3,134,945
189,830

Increase or Decrease
1923
Amount Per Cent
813,595 $— 134,284 — 3 0
563,430
720,649
15 7
2,611,265 — 1,101,955 — 6 5
7,090,422 — 199,119 — o ' 4
1,219,305 —4,430,700 — 29 8
828,366 — 1,190,417 — 16' 5
540,447
873,143
35' 7
197,067 — 220,035 — 16 ' 2
1,519,825 — 460,726 — 2 2
103,260 —
17,074 — 1 6
1,564,650
1,396,794
14' 3
345,876
566,813
22 7
257,595
2,238,035
66.0

Total. .. . 23,841 24,845 16,913 15,513 $119,038,204 $121,085,784 $17,743,807 $17,655,103— $ 1 ,9 5 8 ,8 7 6 -^ 4
*Includes figures for east Cleveland, Lakewood, and Shaker Heights.




THE

MONTHLY

BUSINESS

15

REVIEW

Debits to Individual Accounts

Akron...................
Butler, Pa............
Canton................
Cincinnati............
Cleveland............
Columbus............
Connellsville, Pa.
D ayton................
Erie......................
Greensburg..........
Homestead..........
Lexington, K y . . .
Lim a....................
Lorain..................
Middletown.........
New Brighton
Oil City................
Pittsburgh...........
Springfield...........
Steubenville*. . . .
T oledo..................
Warren, O ...........
Wheeling..............
Youngstown........
Zanesville............

Week Ending
Aug. 13, 1924
(324 Banks)
$ 13,850
2,721
9,324
64,049
139,141
28,106
1,103
13,037
7,048
5,668
897
4,092
3,865
1,513
1,689
2,677
2,790
185,698
4,091
2,248
40,727
2,595
9,208
12,852
2,817

Week Ending
July 16, 1924
(324 Banks)
$ 18,032
2,477
10,189
81,119
152,779
30,054
1,178
16,001
7,399
5,728
1,175
3,534
4,086
1,484
2,256
2,767
2,848
190,058
4,780
2,589
41,678
2,955
10,936
15,047
3,124

561,806
T otal.
'Figures for 1923 not available.

614,273

Increase or Decrease Week Ending
Amount Per Cent Aug 15, 1923
(322 Banks)
— $ 4,182 — 23.2
$ 14,556
244
9.9
2,483
—
8 6 5 — 8.5
8,808
—
17,070 — 21.0
60,508
—
13,638 — 8.9
140,980
—
1,948 — 6.5
34,847
—
75 — 6.4
1,338
—
2,964 — 18.5
13,090
—
351 — 4.7
7,405
—
6 0 — 1.0
3,885
—
278 — 23.7
904
558
15.8
3,921
—
221 — 5.4
3,498
29
2.0
1,415
—
567 — 25.1
2,051
—
90 — 3.3
2,617
—
58 — 2.0
2,466
—
4,360 — 2.3
170,396
—
689 — 14.4
4,161
—
341 — 13.2
—
951 — 2.3
37,970
—
360 — 12.2
3,517
—
1,728 — 15.8
8,915
—
2,195 — 14.6
13,922
—
307 — 9.8
2,707
—

52,467 — 8.5

546,360

Increase or Decrease
Amount Per Cent
— $ 706
238
516
3,541
—
1,839
—
6,741
—
235
—
53
—
357
1,783
—
7
171
367
98
—
362
60
324
15,302
—
70
—
—

- - 4.9
9.6
5.9
5.9
- - 1.3
- -1 9 .3
- -1 7 .6
- - 0 .4
- - 4.8
45.9
- - 0.8
4.4
10.5
6.9
- -17.6
2.3
13.1
9.0
- - 1.7

7.3
2,757
922 - -2 6 .2
3.3
293
1,070 - - 7.7
110
4.1
13,198

2.4

Explanation of Charts on Following Page
All charts are monthly.
1. Member Bank Credit. Figures for the last
week in the month from about 800 banks re­
porting weekly to the Federal Reserve Board.
2. Member Bank Deposits. Same as preceding.
3. Volume of Payments by Check. Debits to
individual accounts at 140 centers reporting to
the Federal Reserve Board (not including New
York).
4. Commercial Failures. The number of com­
mercial failures as reported by R. G. Dun & Com­
pany.
5. Retail Trade. The index number of the Fed­
eral Reserve Board with 1919 equaling 100, is
recomputed with the monthly average, 1919-1923,
as a base. This index covers about 350 depart­
ment stores in the country.
6. Wholesale
Trade. The
Federal
Reserve
Board’s Index Number has been recomputed, as
in the preceding chart. This index covers a large
number of wholesale lines.
7. Building Permits. Reports from about 170
cities as shown by Bradstreet’s.
8. Car Loadings. Figures reported weekly by
the American Railway Association converted into
a monthly basis.



9. Exports of Merchandise. Figures reported
by the Bureau of Foreign and Domestic Commerce,
U. S. Department of Commerce.
10. Bituminous Coal Production. Figures from
the Geological Survey, Department of the In­
terior.
11. Pig Iron Production. From the IRON
AGE.

12. Automobile Production (both passenger cars
and trucks). National Automobile Chamber of
Commerce.
Last figures for each chart:
(1) a. Loans
July, 106
b. Investments
July, 123
(2) a. Demand Deposits
July, 113
b. Time Deposits
July, 151
June, 104
( 3) Check Payments
(4) ComT Failures
July, 125
June, 107
( 5) Retail Trade
( 6 ) Wholesale Traded
June, 84
July, 138
( 7 ) Building Permits
(8) Car Loadings
July, 107
(9) Exports
July, 58
(10) Bituminous Coal Production
July, 81
(11) Pig Iron Production
July, 71
(12) Auto Production
July, 127

Indexes of National Business Conditions
The base (100) for all th e charts excep t th e first is th e m o n th ly average for th e five y ea rs 19J9.J923
inclusive. For th e first ch art th e base is the m o n th ly average for th e th ree yea rs
1921-1923. For fu rth er explanations, see preced in g page.