View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
Covering financial, industrial, and agricultural conditions
in the
Fourth Federal Reserve District
Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland
Vol. 15

Cleveland, Ohio, October 1, 1933

An increase in consumer buying, but a contraction in
most lines of industrial operation was apparent in this
district and other parts of the country in the latter part
of August; a falling-off in both was evident in early Sep­
tember. The Federal Reserve Board’s index of industrial
production, after correcting for seasonal fluctuations,
dropped from 100 in July to 92 per cent of the 1923-25
average in August, while the adjusted. retail trade index
for the entire country rose from 68 to 71 per cent of this
same average.
Of the important industries, the most pronounced de­
cline occurred in steel ingot production as buying was
sharply curtailed. Although the drop in fourth district
steel centers was substantial, the fact that the automobile
industry continued to specify for materials in fairly satis­
factory volume maintained local plant operations at a level
somewhat above the average for the entire country. In
fact, slight increases in steel operations were shown for
Cleveland and Youngstown in late September as specifica­
tions against contracts which expire October 31 were in­
creased.
In view of the drop in industrial activity, the increase
in employment and pay rolls in August was somewhat of
a paradox. In the fourth district, employment gains av­
eraging ten per cent in industrial centers and of over five
per cent in the entire section were reported between July
15 and mid-August. Pay roll figures are not available,
but the sharp increase in retail buying in the period sug­
gested considerable improvement in this field.
Department store sales in leading cities of the fourth
district had a 40 per cent larger dollar volume in August,
than a year ago, and, while part of the gain was due to
higher prices, these advances were insignificant in com­
parison with the sharp upturn in sales. Although usually
there is an increase in sales from July to August, the ex
pansion in the past month was much more than seasonal
and the adjusted index rose from 64 to 72.6 per cent of the
192 3-1925 monthly average. Value of stocks also in­
creased more than seasonally, but the gain was largely
due to higher prices.
Coal production increased more than seasonally in Au­
gust, the improvement from the same month last year
being 77 per cent at mines in this district. Although a
moderate slackening occurred in early September, the
later weeks of the month showed that output was still




No. 10

much higher than in the preceding year. Tire production
in August and early September was down somewhat from
the high levels reported earlier this year, but production
and sales were still materially above last year at this time.
Automobile assemblying in August exceeded July and held
up quite well in the first part of September, which was of
particular benefit to local parts and accessory companies.
A moderate improvement in the construction industry and
its allied lines was reported in August, due entirely, how­
ever, to increased public works and utility building.
Crop prospects improved in many localities as a result
of more normal weather conditions, but yields of principal
crops are still reported much below the ten-year average.
Prices of goods farmers buy have advanced recently at a
faster rate than agricultural prices and the improvement
in farm purchasing power reported earlier this year has
been partially cancelled.
FINANCIAL/

Changes in reserve and reporting member bank credit
in the fourth district in the four weeks ended September
20 were relatively unimportant. Borrowings from tho
reserve bank continue at very low levels and loans made
by reporting member banks in leading cities still showed
a downward trend, though holdings of Government securi­
ties by both the reserve and member banks increased
slightly in the period. Total deposits at member banka
were unchanged in the four latest weeks.
In September, eight banks were licensed in this dis­
trict and of the 1,402 banks in operation on March fourth,
licenses have been granted to 1,122, unlicensed banka
number 243, and 37 are in process of liquidation, have
been merged with other institutions, etc. Although no ac­
curate recent figures of 'deposits in the unlicensed banks
are available, the proportion of total deposits still tied
up is known to be relatively small.
Savings deposits at representative banks in this dis­
trict increased 0.7 per cent in August, but on Septembei
1 they were 5.2 per cent smaller than a year ago. Debito
to individual accounts at banks in 24 cities in this district
were 3.2 per cent larger in the four weeks ended Septem­
ber 20 than in the same period of 1932, but for the year
to date a decline of 13.4 per cent was shown in bank
debits.
Life insurance sales in Ohio and Pennsylvania in Au
gust were 7.7 per cent larger than a year ago. This was

2

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

the first increase shown for many months. For the year
to date a decline of 12.7 per cent was reported. A slight
increase in the number of commercial failures reported
occurred in August, according to R. O. Dun, although the
number was still 57 per cent below the same month of
1932. Liabilities of the defaulting concerns were down
41 per cent from August last year.
Reserve Bank Credit. Total credit extended by the Fed­
eral Reserve Bank of Cleveland increased about $8,000,000 between August 23 and September 20. The gain was
due entirely to increased holdings of Government securi­
ties, which, on the latest date, totaled $199,085,000. This
expansion again represented participation in the System’s
open market operations. Borrowings of member banks
were down about $1,000,000 in the four most recent
weeks, and on the latest date, at $11,439,000, they were
close to the low level reported in mid-July.
Circulation of Federal reserve notes and bank notes
declined in the four latest weeks at a time when in sev­
eral past years an increase in note circulation was re­
ported. This reduction was all the more significant in
view of the fact that prices, particularly retail, increased
quite sharply in August and September. Total note circu­
lation, however, at $308,000,000, was still about $25,000,000 higher than a year ago. Total deposits dropped
about $8,000,000 between August 23, and September 20,
and the ratio of reserves to deposits and note liability com­
bined dropped from 64.5 to 62.8. On the latest date, how­
ever, it was still about three points higher than a year ago.
Member Bank Credit. Total credit extended by report­
ing member banks in the fourth district showed practi­
cally no change in the four latest weeks, although there
was a decline in total loans in the period. This was offset
by increased holdings of Government securities amounting
to $5,000,000. Loans on securities were reduced $6,000,000 between August 2 3 and September 6, but increased
$3,000,000 in the following week. “ All other” loans still
continue to decline. Total deposits were practically un­
changed in the period, the $4,000,000 drop in demand de­
posits being offset by a corresponding increase in time de­
posits. The accompanying chart shows the week-to-week
change in total credit extended and total deposits by re­
porting member banks in leading cities from March 1 to
the present time. The gain in deposits in the period has




been 11.6 per cent, whereas the increase in credit extended
has been only 2.3 per cent and all the expansion in the lat­
ter has been in holdings of Government securities. Member
banks are maintaining considerably more than the required
amount of reserves with the Federal Reserve Bank of
Cleveland; the excess over legal requirements in August
averaged $30,000,000. In August, 1932, excess reserves at
member banks were $4,000,000 and in 1931 they were
$2,800,000.
MANUFACTURING, MINING
Iron and
Steel

Steelworks operations in the United
States dropped from 51 to 41 per cent
from the middle of August to the third
week of September. In the Cleveland-Lorain district the
rate declined from 77 per cent to 56 per cent, but rallied
in the week ended September 16 to 60 per cent; Youngs­
town operations dropped from 53 to 45 per cent, then ad­
vanced slightly; Pittsburgh fell from 43 to 35 per cent,
and Wheeling mills in the latest week were operating at
75 per cent of capacity.
This pick-up in the Cleveland and Youngstown districts
after several weeks of successive reductions reflected the
need for additional steel to fill third quarter contract
specifications for finished products, mainly sheets, strip,
bars and wire, which under the steel code had to be
shipped before October 1.
As most of these contracts were placed at lower prices
than now prevail, consumers were anxious to obtain the
material. New bookings, however, were off sharply from
the levels of a few weeks ago.
With September automobile assemblies close to the Au­
gust output, automotive steel requirements were the main
support of the local markets. Public and private construc­
tion improved slightly though many local and state gov­
ernments are still waiting to determine what financial
aid they can obtain from the R. F. C. before proceeding
with various projects.
Railroad purchases remained
light.
Under the iron and steel code, producers filed new price
schedules August 29, to apply for the remainder of the
quarter. Pig iron was advanced $1 a ton in practically all
districts. In steel, the principal advances were made in
sheets and strip. The new set-up of basing points, differ­
entials, extras and code regulations created considerable
confusion which was a further cause of slow buying. As
late as September 16 leading iron and steel producers were
uncertain as to their prices on heavy finished steel and
many of the lighter finished products for fourth quarter,
and they reported few inquiries on which to quote.
Pig iron production in August averaged 59,137 'gross
tons a day, compared with 58,108 tons in July. Total
production was 1,833,265 tons, a gain of 1.7 per cent. At
the close of the month 98 blast furnaces were in operation,
a reduction of seven from July 31.
Daily average production of steel ingots in August was
107,430 gross tons, compared with 128,152 tons in July.
Total calculated production for the eight months this year
was 15,093,613 tons, in contrast with 9,350,662 tons in
the corresponding period last year.

THE3 MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

Iron ore receipts at Lake Erie ports continued to in­
crease in August and in that month, at 3,930,000 tons,
they were over six times larger than a year ago and ex­
ceeded any month since October, 1930. Ore consumed was
less than receipts and stocks at furnaces and on Lake Erie
docks increased to 30,155,875 tons on September 1, but
this was 2,000,000 tons less than was on hand a year ago.
Coal

Coal production in the fourth district
increased from July to August despite
the fact that conditions within the in­
dustry caused disturbances and uncertainty in many sec­
tions. Output in August was 14,230,000 tons in this sec­
tion, the highest for any month since January, 1931, and
represented a gain of 76.5 per cent from last year. The
gain in output of fourth district mines in the first eight
months of this year was 25 per cent.
The increase m iocal mine production, both from July
ail’d a year ago, was much greater than the average shown
for the entire country, partly because of the improvement
in lake coal shipments so far this season. In August coal
loaded at Lake Erie ports for shipment to Canadian and
upper lake cities amounted to 5,225,000 tons, a gain of
48 per cent from last year, and in the first eight months of
19 33 these shipments were up 52.6 per cent. The increase
in industrial operations, particularly in steel plants, also
partly accounted for the gain in coal production this year,
since industrial stocks have been limited in size for some
time and buying is largely for current consumption. Un­
certainty as to the provisions of the coal code regarding
wages to be paid and prices established for the various
grades of coal and the falling-off in industrial production
were partly responsible for the irregularities apparent
within the industry in September. Little stocking by
industrial concerns is reported.
Automobiles

The mainstay of industrial production
for the past several weeks, so far as
this district is concerned, was the au­
tomobile industry, which, prior to late September, has
been assemblying cars at a rate only slightly lower than
the peak touched in late July. Total production in Au­
gust, according to the Department of Commerce, was 236,480 cars and trucks, a gain of 15 per cent from July and
162 per cent from August a year ago, when only 90,325
units were turned out. The increase from July was small,




3

but in all years since 1929, a rather sharp falling-off in
automobile assemblying has occurred. Barring June this
year, output was higher than for any month since early
1931.
Passenger car production was practically unchanged
from July to August, but was up 157 per cent from a
year ago and output in the first eight months, at 1,239,401
units, was 37 per cent above the same period of last year.
More cars have been manufactured since the first of the
year than in the entire twelve months of 1932. Truck
production in August numbered 41,336 units, a gain of
187 per cent from the corresponding period of 1932. Com­
pared with July, output was up almost 3,300 units, partly
reflecting the better industrial conditions prevailing. In
the first eight months of 1933, truck production was 40
per cent ahead of the same period of 1932.
Although operations declined in late August and the
holiday week of September, assemblies were increased in
the second week of the month and, according to Cram's
reports, over 48,000 units were made in the week ended
September 16. This was more than double output in the
same period of 1932.
Several uncertainties have complicated the general sit­
uation in recent weeks, but retail buying of automobiles,
according to reports, has held up very well and in midSeptember it was understood to be close to the August
level which was very much above last year.
The relatively high rate of operations in this industry
in late August and the first part of September was par­
ticularly helpful to steel, parts and accessory, tire, glass,
etc., companies located in this district which depend upon
the automobile industry for a large part of their orders.
While the time of year for model changes is rapidly ap­
proaching, which usually affects output considerably,
changeovers apparently are being spread over a wider
period of time, and as yet have had little effect on output.
Makers of cars in the low-priced field continue to operate
at fairly satisfactory levels and prior to the third week
of September no significant recession in demand for these
cars had appeared.
Rubber,
Tires

The manufacturing end of the rubber
industry experienced a falling-off in
sales and production in August and the
first part of September, although both were materially
above the levels reported a year ago at this time. These
declines were seasonal to a degree, but in addition, were a
reaction from the high rate of production and buying in
May, June and early July. Improvement from early 1933
is still substantial and output in July, according to the
Rubber Manufacturers Association figures, which repre­
sent about 80 per cent of the industry, was up 58 per cent
from a year ago, but was down slightly from June. Ex­
cluding June of this year, production was larger in July
than in any month since May, 1930. The sharp gain from
last year is partly accounted for by the fact that output
a year ago was unusually small following the heavy pro­
duction of June, prior to the enactment of the Federal
tax on tire sales. Shipments in July and August, accord­
ing to reports, have held up quite well, and inventories

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

are lower now than at the beginning of the year.
Employment at 22 rubber factories in this district in­
creased almost eight per cent in August from July, a con­
tra-seasonal gain brought about largely through opera­
tions of the N. R. A. and the adoption of a four-shift sys­
tem of six hours each. Compared with a year ago, em­
ployment in this industry was up 38 per cent and the
first eight months averaged about three per cent better
than the same period of 1932.
Consumption of crude rubber by manufacturers in
United States was down about 12 per cent in August from
July, but, at 44,939 long tons, it was 89.4 per cent above
August, 1932.
Consumption was only slightly larger
than crude rubber imports in the latest month and do­
mestic stocks of crude rubber on August 31 were esti­
mated at 325,418 long tons. This was slightly lower than
a year ago, but rubber stocks continue unusually large.
In the mechanical goods division of the industry, sales
have been increasing for several months and recently they
have been running close to 50 per cent above the same pe­
riod of 1932. Footwear sales lagged somewhat in the first
six months of the year, but current orders for fall deliv­
ery have been running heavier.
The trend of finished goods prices has been distinctly
upward for some time, due to the increasing cost of crude
rubber and other materials entering into the manufacture
of these products. The recent increases in selling prices
have raised tire prices to the levels prevailing about six
months ago. Costs of raw materials entering into the
manufacture of this product have increased from 75 to
100 per cent in recent months and are very much above
last year. In the third week of September crude rubber
was quoted at 7 % cents a pound and cotton was a little
better than ten cents. One year ago these prices were
about 4 and 6.6 cents a pound, respectively.
Clothing

Consumer buying of clothing increased
quite sharply in August, partly because
it was felt generally that prices were to
advance. This did occur in many lines in early Septem­
ber and the mark-up was necessary because of sharp in­
creases in raw material prices, higher operating costs,
processing taxes, etc. Raw Ohio wool was quoted at 43
cents a pound in September compared with 23 cents a year
ago. Following the advance in retail prices in September,
buying declined quite sharply and factory operations were
curtailed. Cold weather is anxiously awaited to test con­
sumers’ reaction to the increase so as to provide a gauge
for operations in the next few weeks.
In August, clothing and textile companies in this dis­
trict were employing 51 per cent more help than in the
same month of 19 32, and the four per cent gain from July
was contra-seasonal. At the 40 plants reporting to the
Ohio State University Bureau of Business Research the
number employed was 8.2 per cent above the 1926 month­
ly average. Men’s clothing companies showed a greater
improvement from July than did others, but the latter
companies experienced a much larger gain from last year.
Production of women’s clothing dropped in August from
the July level, but output still exceeded a year ago.
Manufacturers’ stocks of finished goods are almost nil,
according to reports, but dollar value of clothing stocks




at department stores in this section was somewhat higher
than a year ago at this time. Retail prices of men’s cloth­
ing, according to F a i r c h i l d index, are up 7.5 per cent
from last year and women’s apparel prices have advanced
14 per cent in the period.
Other
Manufacturing;

Recent developments have brought
about an unusual situation in most lines
of industry in the past few weeks. The
general employment situation, so far as reducing the num­
ber of unemployed is concerned, has been improved. This
was accomplished by a spread in the volume of work, to
a large degree, as a result of the N. R. A. codes, which
in the case of most industries, have required a reduction
in the number of hours worked.
Auto Accessories. August shipments from automobile
parts and accessory plants held up very well for this sea­
son of the year and, though a slight decline was reported
for the first part of September, operations in general at
these factories far exceeded those of a year ago. Em­
ployment in August, the latest available, at 37 companies
was 56 per cent above last year at that time and a gain
of 5.4 per cent was recorded from July, whereas the av­
erage July-August change in the past five years was a
reduction of 6.6 per cent.
Brick and Tile. A slight increase in building activity
and possibility of further expansion of public works as a
result of the allocation of Federal funds to construction
projects caused a contra-seasonal increase in operations
at brick and tile plants in this section in August. Em­
ployment, however, continues under a year ago and only
a very small part of the potential capacity of this industry
is being utilized at the present time.
China, Pottery. August was a very good month for
most companies in this industry, according to reports, a
decided improvement being shown over July and a year
ago. Part of the increased buying is attributed to the
fact that prices are expected to increase when the indus­
trial code is approved. Employment was up six per cent
in August from July, at eight concerns, and was 87 per
cent better than in August, 1932. Prices of raw materials
used by this industry have advanced 10-15 per cent in re­
cent weeks.
Electrical Supplies. There has been a steady increase
in orders received by electrical apparatus and supply
companies in this district in the past few months and Au­
gust was no exception in this respect. Compared with a
year ago gains in both the number and size of incoming
orders ranged from 30 to over 100 per cent. Much of
the activity has been in the lighter machinery lines, though
some large projects are pending. Compared with a year
ago employment at 27 concerns was up 32 per cent in
August.
Glass. Production and sales of flat glass and molded
glass products in August continued at very high levels
compared with a year ago, and the employment index of
this industry was up 131 per cent. A slight falling-off
in orders was observed in the first part of September
which was reported as being partly seasonal, particularly
in the container and molded glass industry. Raw mate­
rial prices have increased and a compensating advance

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

in the finished product has occurred in many instances.
Machinery, Machine Tools. Though retooling of auto­
mobile factories has begun in some cases in preparation
for production on new models, operations of most machin­
ery and machine tool factories in this district continue at
low levels. Compared with a year ago, however, decided
improvement was evident. There is some demand for
used machinery and replacement parts, but with little ex­
pansion or new industrial construction, orders for capital
equipment continue in a limited volume.
Paint. Conflicting reports have been received from
paint manufacturers; some tell of a falling-off in orders
in late August and early September, whereas others state
that buying has held up quite well, particularly in view
of the fact that August sales usually are down quite
sharply from the peak normally occurring in the spring
and early summer months. Raw material price changes
in recent weeks have been nominal although a shortage
of some materials is reported.
Paper. Demand for boxboard in mid-September was not
as great as in August, but operations of producing plants
continue at very satisfactory levels compared with a year
ago. The accumulated boxboard orders reported in Au­
gust were worked off in September as the supply of waste
paper increased. Paper production in August was up from
July and employment was 12 per cent above a year ago.
Raw material inventories have increased in recent months.
Shoes. Production of shoes at fourth district factories
increased 23.4 per cent from July to August, a muchgreater-than-seasonal gain, and in the latest month out­
put was higher than since August, 1928, being 56 per cent
ahead of the corresponding month of 1932. In the first
eight months of this year local plants produced 28 per
cent more shoes than in the corresponding period of last
year.
Increasing raw material and labor costs have
prompted buying generally and retailers have shown a
tendency to replenish their depleted stocks.
A slight drop in hide prices occurred in September, but,
at 13c a pound, heavy native steer hides compared with
8M*c a year ago. Dollar value of women’s and children’s
shoe sales in August was 19 per cent greater than a year
ago at department stores in this district and men’s and
boys’ shoe sales were up 25 per cent in the same period.
Part of the gain represented higher prices, but better re­
tail demand for footwear was reported in the past month.
TRADE
Retail

Increased consumer buying in August
was reflected in the reports on retail
trade for this district, and indications
that purchasing held up fairly well in early September
have been received.
Dollar value of sales at re­
porting department stores in August was 40 per cent
higher than a year ago, the increase from July being
considerably more than seasonal. The adjusted index
of sales advanced from 61 per cent in July to 72.6 per
cent of the 1923-1925 monthly average in August and was
higher than since December, 1931. Despite the fact that




£

considerable improvement has occurred in recent months,
dollar sales for the first eight months of this year were
still 7.1 per cent under the corresponding interval of 1932.
Not all the gain reported was due to improved buying,
for prices in August, according to the Fairchild retail
price index, showed an unusually sharp increase. The
average gain for the month was 8.4 per cent and this fol­
lowed an increase of 5.2 per cent in July and smaller gains
in preceding months, the total advance from the May 1
low point having been 19 per cent, with a gain of 12 per
cent being shown from September 1, 1932. Prices on many
individual items have advanced more than 25 per cent
from the low; these include cotton goods, furniture, ho­
siery and luggage.
Dollar value of stocks rose about 12 per cent in Au­
gust from July, and a gain of 1.4 per cent from last year
was shown, the first advance from the preceding year since
1928. Here again the price increase was a factor, but
buyers for many departments are adding to their stocks.
A greater proportion of the total sales reported in Au­
gust were credit sales than in July or a year ago, the in­
creases being entirely in installment buying. Deferred
payment sales represented 9.8 per cent of total sales,
whereas last year they amounted to only 7.1 per cent.
Accounts receivable were only 1.3 per cent smaller than
a year ago, a rather insignificant change compared with
the large reductions reported in earlier months of this
year. Collections improved somewhat and the ratio of
collections in August to accounts receivable on July 31
was 30.2 per cent, whereas last year it was 2 6.1 per cent.
Payments on both regular and installment accounts have
increased.
Decided improvement in furniture buying from the un­
usually low levels reported last year and earlier months
of 1933, has been shown recently by reports from cooper­
ating firms. August sales were almost double those re­
ported last year and the recent gains have been sufficient
to cause an increase of 7.2 per cent to be shown in sales
in the first eight months of 1933, from the same period
of 1932. As has been previously pointed out, the im­
provement in retail buying has been most pronounced in
home furnishing goods, etc., although in August some of
the clothing and ready-to-wear departments of department
stores showed very sizeable gains from last year.

Wholesale

A somewhat more-than-seasonal in­
crease in sales of wholesale drugs, gro­
ceries, and hardware occurred in this
district in August, according to reports received. All four
reporting groups, including dry goods, showed larger
dollar sales in August than in the corresponding month
of 1932. Hardware sales were up 46 per cent from last
year, but were still only 57 per cent of the 1923-1925
monthly average; dry goods sales increased 52 per cent
from August, 1932, and amounted to 44 per cent of the
three-year average; wholesale grocery sales were 18 per
cent larger in August than a year ago and they totaled 66

6

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

per cent of the 1923-1925 average and wholesale drug
sales were 2.2 per cent greater than last year, but they
totaled 7 3 per cent of the base period. Price increases
were an important factor in the larger volume, although
in general some retail stocking-up was reported in most
lines.
BUILDING
Increasing to the highest level reported this year, build­
ing activity in this district in August was only seven per
cent below the same month of 1932. At $12,039,000, con­
tracts awarded were almost double the volume reported in
July. Improvement also was shown in other parts of the
country, but the gain locally and elsewhere was due to in­
creased activity in public works and utilities as Federal
funds, allocated to the construction industry as a part of
the effort to stimulate business recovery, began to flow
into actual projects.
In the fourth district residential contracts were valued
at $2,02 6,000 in August, only slightly under the July fig­
ure, but 8.7 per cent below the amount reported in Au­
gust, 1932. In the first eight months of this year resi­
dential building had a contract value of $13,804,000, com­
pared with $16,054,000 in the same period of 1932. Nonresidential building, excluding public works and utilities,
had a higher contract value in August in this section than
in either August, 1932, or July this year. For the eightmonth period the comparison with last year was not a
favorable one.
Contracts for public works had a higher value in Au­
gust than in July, but they were less than one-third of
the amount reported in the corresponding month of 1932.
Public utility contracts showed the largest gain in dollar
value in August, both from July and a year ago, of all
of the major classifications of the construction industry.
The value of contemplated work reported in August
was down somewhat from that shown in July, but was
over 50 per cent higher than in August, 1932.
Most building supply dealers reported a falling-off in
demand for materials in late August and the first part of
September and considerable uncertainty regarding prices,
etc., prevails. The speculative buying apparent in earlier
months of this year has practically disappeared and the
industry generally is marking time at present. Demand

Ratio of prices farmers receive to prices paid for goods bought.
on indexes of the U . S. Department of Agriculture)




(Based

for hardwood lumber used in the construction of furni­
ture, etc., has improved.
Cement production of fourth district mills was up 45
per cent in August from a year ago and a gain of 24
per cent in the eight-month period of this year from the
same interval of 1932 was shown. Anticipated increased
public construction has caused producers to step up op­
erating schedules.
AGRICULTURE
Crop prospects, in this district as well as in other parts
of the country, which were reported as being very un­
favorable a month ago, improved somewhat in most lo­
calities as a result of more normal weather conditions in
August and early September. Despite this improvement,
very low yields are generally reported for the late-ma­
turing grains, fruits and potatoes. In the entire country
aggregate yields are expected to be about seven per cent
below last year and more than eight per cent below those
of the previous ten years.
Although the ultimate effects of these declines on the
gross farm income cannot accurately be determined at this
time, preliminary estimates indicate that a substantial
increase will result from the higher prices and the grants
made by the Agricultural Adjustment Administration for
reductions in certain crops.
Not only have farm prices risen, but the gain from the
low level has been greater so far than the advance in
prices of goods farmers buy. Though real income of the
farmer, as determined by the ratio of prices received to
prices paid for goods bought has improved, the drop in
grain prices in August and the recent sharp increase in
retail prices had quite an unfavorable effect on this ratio.
Potential buying power in mid-September was down quite
sharply from the July peak. Changes in the farmers’ real
income over the past 20 years are shown on the accom­
panying chart.
If prices received were the same as
prices paid for goods in terms of the base period, this
index would be 100. For only a short period during the
war were farm prices higher than other prices and in the
past few years real farm income has declined almost 50
per cent. In the seven months from the low in February
this year to the present, farm prices have improved
nearly 48 per cent, while prices of goods farmers pur­
chase have risen only about 15 per cent, a real gain in
the farmers’ position so far as prices are concerned.
In Ohio, according to the Agricultural Experiment Sta­
tion, gross cash income from six principal agricultural
products was 21 per cent higher in August than a year
ago, but it was only 57 per cent of the five-year average
of 1924-1928.
In comparison with the estimated yields of principal
crops reported a month ago, the greatest improvement
was shown in corn in this district. The gain exceeded
14,000,000 bushels, but, at 139,653,000 bushels, estimated
production was still 20 per cent below the average harv­
est of the eight years 1925-1932. Rain was very beneficial
in many sections, but in some areas it arrived too late
to be of any help to the maturing crop. The crop is
quite irregular this year; some fields are in very good
condition, while others present a very stunted appear­

1

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

ance and will not mature a good crop even though no
early frost damage occurs. In the various sections of the
district prospects are poorest in Ohio, particularly the
northern part of the state.
Oats have been threshing out about as expected and
the September 1 estimate was the lowest on record, be­
ing only 44 per cent of the average harvest of past years.
Potatoes improved in condition in August in some sec­
tions, though rains caused rotting in others. Insect dam­
age has been light this year, but the local crop is ex­
pected to be about 28 per cent smaller than the average
of recent years. Potato prices have advanced sharply in
recent weeks following the report of a short crop.
Fruit crops, as a whole, showed little change in the
past month. With condition of most types below average,
crop prospects are about 13 per cent under the level of
past years. Grapes and apples are small and while the
estimated yield of the former was about average in this
section, the latter was much below that level.
Tobacco prospects improved materially in August, and
the September 1 estimate of fourth district production,
not allowing for the acreage to be removed ulider the
Agricultural Adjustment Act, was considerably above last
year’s harvest and only about five per cent below the
eight-year average production. By mid-September it was
estimated that three-fourths of the crop in this section
had been cut and housed under favorable conditions and
though wet weather has caused some houseburn, the dam­
age is not serious and the crop generally is of good qual­
ity. Burley tobacco production is now forecast at 410r
293,000 pounds in contrast with 312rl 82,000 pounds
produced last year. Cigar-leaf tobacco raised in Ohio
is reported at 12,594,000 pounds, against a five-year av­
erage of 20,405,000 pounds, with a further drop expected
as a result of acreage removed under the crop reduction
plan.

Wholesale and Retail Trade
(1933 compared with 1932)
Percentage
Increase or Decrease
SALES
SALES
Aug.,
First 8
D EPARTM EN T STORES (48) I
1933
months
+ 5 9 .6
+ 0 .7
Akron...............................................
Cincinnati.......................................
+ 2 8 .7
— 8.6
Cleveland........................................
+ 5 1 .3
— 0 .4
— 1 3 .0
+ 12 . 6
Columbus.......................................
+ 4 5 .5
P ittsburgh......................................
— 9 .1
— 9 .0
+ 3 6 .2
Toledo.............................................
+ 3 9 .6
— 7 .9
Wheeling.........................................
— 10 .5
Other Cities...................................
+ 2 8 .5
D istrict.............................. . . . . . . .
+ 4 0 .2
— 7 .1
W EARIN G APPAREL (11) ]
+ 6 3 .0
— 1 0. 0
Cincinnati.......................................
+ 4 2 .2
— 22 . 0
Other Cities............... ...................
— 1 8 .1
D istrict........................ |.................
+ 4 8 .5
FURN ITURE (44) J
— 0 .4
+ 4 5 .1
Cincinnati......................................
+ 1 6 .9
Cleveland.......................................
+ 1 2 2 .5
— 0.8
+ 3 4 .6
Columbus.......................................
— 9 .3
+ 5 2 .4
D ayton ............................................
— 1 .9
+ 120.8
Toledo.............................................
+ 1 5 .8
+ 1 7 3 .7
Other Cities..................................
+ 9 8 .5
+ 7 .2
D istrict...........................................
CHAIN STORES* 4
— 5 .4
— 1 3 .9
Drugs— District (4 )........| .........
— 0.1
+ 1 3 .3
Groceries— District (5). M .........
WHOLESALE GROCERIES (33)
— 8 .5
V
5
.1
A kron..............................................
— 3.3
+ 3 4 .4
Cleveland.......................................
— 19 .3
— 6.8
+ 6.6
+ 2 4 .9
— 2 1.3
— 3 .6
Toledo.............................................
— 0.8
+ 1 8 .4
Other Cities...................................
— 5 .5
+ 1 8 .3
D istrict............................................
+ 1 2 .5
WHOLESALE D RY GOODS (10) ! + 5 1 .8
— 15 .0
+ 2.2
WHOLESALE DRUGS ( 1 3 ) ...
WHOLESALE HARDW ARE (14) + 4 6 .0
+ 1 .0
*Per individual unit operated.




STOCKS
Aug.,
1933
+ 8 .4
— 1 .4
+ 0.6
+ 1 1 .3
+ 2 .0
+ 0. 1
+ 6. 1
— 10.0
+ 1 .4
+ 0 .3
— 1 1 .7
— 7 .8

— ii! 5

+ 2 8 .1

Fourth District Business Statistics
(000 omitted)

% change
% change
Fourth District Unless
August,
from
Jan.-Aug.,
from
Otherwise Specified
1933
1932
1933
1932
+ 8 . 0 11,409,000
— 13 .9
Bank Debits— 24 cities................$ 1,545,000
Savings Deposits— end of month:
1
41 Banks, O. & Pa..................... $
627,304
— 5 .2
Life Insurance Sales:
Ohio and Pa.................................. $
+ 7 .7
578,420
— 1 2 .7
77,251
Retail Sales:
+ 4 0 .2
95,041
Department Stores— 48 firm s.. .$
— 7 .1
14,191
Wearing Apparel— 11 firms. . . .$
+ 4 8 .5
4,622
— 1 8 .1
729
Furniture— 44 firm s..................... $
733
+ 9 8 .6
3,980
+ 7 .2
Wholesale Sales:
+ 2.2
8,197
— 15 .0
Drugs— 13 firm s............................ $
1,096
D ry Goods— 10 firm s................. $
1,084
+ 5 1 .8
7,052
+ 12 .5
Groceries— 33 firm s......................$
3,821
+ 1 8 .3
25,145
— 5 .5
1,116
+ 4 5 .9
7,066
+ 1 .0
Hardware— 14 firms..................... $
— 14 .0
2,026
— 8 .7
13,804
Building Contracts— Residential.3
— 4 0.3
”
”
— T otal...........$
12,039
— 7 .1
52,421
— 4 1 .1
40,486
— 34 .0
Commercial Failures— Liabilities .$
3,791
1182 — 5 7 .4
1,3 0 12 — 3 6 .4
”
”
. . . . Number
Production:
1,833 + 2 4 5 .2
9,159
+ 4 6 .0
Pig Iron, U. S......................... Tons
2,901 + 2 4 2 .5
15,094
+ 6 1 .4
Steel Ingots, U. S...................Tons
1,239,4012 + 3 7 .4
195,1442 + 1 5 7 .1
Automobiles-Pass. Car. . . .U. S.
237,2772
41,3362
+
1
8
6
.7
+
4 0 .4
”
— T ru c k s .........U. S.
Bituminous C o a l................... Tons
14,230
+ 7 6 .5
85,360
+ 2 4 .6
+ 4 4 .8
+ 2 4 .3
Cement— O., W. Pa., W. Va. Bbls.
941
4,176
7,016^ + 0. 1
Elec. Power— O., Pa., Ky. .k.w.h.
1,146* + 1 9 .1
12,1054 — 1 2. 2
Petroleum— O., Pa., Ky. ...B b ls .
1, 866 s — 4 .4
5
5
+ 3 7 .8
+ 2 9 .6
+ 5 8 .0
21,408
— 1 3 .1
4,571
Tires, U. S.........................Casings
Bituminous Coal Shipments:
19,193
+ 4 7 .5
+ 5 2 .6
5,225
Lake Erie Ports..................... Tons
Iron Ore Receipts:
+ 5 2 3 .0
+
5
3
4
.9
3,930
7,756
Lake Erie P orts................... Tons
2actual number
*not available
4First 7 months
8July
Confidential

Debits to Individual Accounts
4 weeks
ended
Sept. 20,
1933
30,831
5,659
19,806
189,139
316,122
89,191
34,179
13,814
2,259
Greensburg. . . .
3,618
6,964
1,560
Homestead........
10,398
4,156
2,306
5,312
Middletown
5,301
407,733
10,179
5,872
Steubenville. . . .
69,213
5,584
24,369
W heeling...........
27,399
Youngstown. . .
4,899
Total.............. . . 1,295,863

(Thousands
%
change
from
1932
— 2 1.3
+ 7 .1
+ 3 6 .3
— 2 .7
+ 0 .4
+ 1 4 .2
— 2 .2
— 9 .1
+ 0 .9
— 20 .6
+ 12 .2
— 1 1 .4
— 5 .2
— 4 4 .9
— 8 .4
+ 1 7 .4
— 3 5.7
+ 6 .8
— 0 .8
+ 2 4 .5
+ 1 2 .0
+ 5 0 .2
+ 12 .2
+ 2 6 .5
— 8 .2
+ 3 .2

of Dollars)
Year-to-date
Dec. 2 9,19 3 2
to
Sept. 20, 1933
282,358
51,775
161,264
1,967,478
3,037,913
783,946
333,542
139,804
19,348
33,660
57,396
14,242
129,461
48,852
19,838
49.905
52,239
4,415,214
87,613
40.708
618,674
41,643
230,138
217,631
45,201
12,879,843

Year-to-date
Dec. 31, 1931
to
Sept. 2 1,1 9 3 2
458,305
55,565
162,628
2,231,976
3,799,116
884,552
402,985
192,260
25,547
48,815
70,523
21,068
144,338
72,921
27,892
51,823
81,883
4.728,615
108,112
48,411
682,864
40,175
243,453
242,406
52,478
14,878,711

%
change
from
1932
— 38 .4
— 6 .8
— 0 .8
— 1 1 .9
— 2 0 .0
— 1 1 .4
— 17 .2
— 27.3
— 24.3
— 3 1 .0
— 18 .6
— 3 2 .4
— 10 .3
— 3 3 .0
— 28 .9
— 3 .7
— 3 6 .2
— 6 .6
— 1 9 .0
— 15 .9
— 9 .4
+ 3 .7
— 5 .5
— 10 .2
— 1 3 .9
— 1 3 .4

Fourth District Business Indexes
(1923-1925 = 100)
Aug., Aug., Aug., Aug., Aug.*
1933 1932 1931 1930 1929
53
57
131
79
100
Bank Debits (24 cities)........................................
81
190
111
99
80
Commercial Failures (N umber).........................
”
”
(Liabilities)......................
86
146
100
72
46
92
86
101
112
126
Sales— Life Insurance (Ohio & P a .)..................
61
43
64
75
86
” — Department Stores (47 firm s)...............
73
71
83
94
113
” — Wholesale Drugs (12 firm s)..................
” —
”
Dry Goods (10 firm s).........
44
29
45
62
100
66
56
97
70
” —
”
Groceries (33 firm s)............
106
57
73
39
56
94
” —
”
Hardware (14 firm s)...........
61
49
65
86
104
” —
”
All (6 9 )..................................
66
70
81
91
95
” — Chain Drugs (3 firm s)**.........................
27
37
71
25
130
Building Contracts (T otal).................................
”
”
(Residential).......................
12
13
34
47
84
45
66
82
100
79
Production— Coal (O., W. Pa., E. K y .)...........
54
108
167
170
78
— Cement (O., W. Pa., W. Va.). . .
151
130
136
136
115
”
— Elec. Power (O., Pa., K y .)* .........
98
116
130
101
106
”
— Petroleum (O., Pa., K y .)* ...........
99
115
91
101
126
”
— Shoes................................................
*July.
**Per individual unit operated.

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

8

Summary of National Business Conditions
By the Federal Reserve Board

Index of industrial production, adjusted for sea­
sonal variation (1923-1925 = 100). Latest figure,
August, preliminary 92.

Indexes o f factory employment and pay rolls,
without adjustment for seasonal variation (19231925 = 100). Latest figure, August, employment,
73.4; pay rolls, 55.7.

RESERVE BANK CREDIT AND FACTORS IN CHANGES

Monthly averages of daily figures. Latest fig­
ures are averages of the first 20 days in
September.




The general level of industrial production declined in August and the
early part of September, reflecting reductions in activity of industries in
which there had been a rapid rise in previous months. Employment and
wage payments were larger in August than in July.
Production and Employment
The Federal Reserve Board’s seasonally adjusted index of industrial
production, which had been rising rapidly for several months, declined from
100 per cent of the 192 3-1925 average in July to 92 per cent in August.
The principal decreases were in the primary textile industries, in flour mill­
ing, and in output of steel ingots which declined from 59 per cent of capac­
ity in July to 49 per cent in August. Average daily output of automobiles
declined somewhat from the level of July. There were increases during
the month in production of petroleum, nonferrous metals, and cigarettes;
and output of lumber and coal increased seasonally.
During September, reports indicate further reductions in output of steel
and flour; petroleum production slackened under new restrictions, and out­
put of lumber decreased.
Increases in employment between the middle of July and the middle of
August, the latest date for which figures are available, were general in most
lines of industry, and there were numerous increases in wage rates and re­
ductions in working hours. Compared with the low point of last spring
there has been an estimated increase of 2,200,000 in number of industrial
wage workers.
Value of construction contracts awarded, as reported to the F. W. Dodge
Corporation, increased in August owing to awards for public works, particu­
larly highways and bridges; contracts for other types of construction were
in smaller volume than in July. An increase of $1,000,000,000 in gross
income of farmers for the year 1933 is indicated by estimates of the United
States Department of Agriculture, primarily as a result of higher prices for
certain farm products, notwithstanding small crops of grains, hay and po­
tatoes.
Distribution
Sales by department stores increased in August, and the Board’s index,
which is adjusted for seasonal variations, advanced from 71 to 75 per cent
of the 192 3-1925 average, the highest level since the spring of 19 32. The
recent increase in dollar sales reflects to a large extent advancing prices.
The volume of freight shipped by rail declined slightly during August,
on an average daily basis, although an increase is usual at this time of year.
Commodity Prices
The general average of wholesale commodity prices fluctuated within a
narrow range during August and early September at a level of about 17 pei
cent above the low point of last spring. Prices of individual commodities
showed divergent movements, decreases being reported for prices of do­
mestic agricultural products, while prices of many manufactured goods, of
coal, petroleum and other industrial raw materials increased. During the
second and third weeks of September prices of commodities in organized
markets advanced considerably.
Retail prices of food continued to advance.
Foreign Exchange
In the foreign exchange markets the value of the dollar in terms of the
French franc declined from 75 per cent of its gold parity on August 15 to
65 per cent on September 22.
Bank Credit
At member banks in 90 leading cities, there was a growth of $200,000,000 in net demand deposits in the four weeks ending September 13, following
a decline of $800,000,000 between the middle of June and the middle of Au­
gust. More than half of the recent increase reflected a return of bankers’
balances to New York City banks. The banks gradually reduced theii
holdings of United States Government securities following an increase in
the week ending August 16, when a new issue of Treasury bonds was sold,
and on September 13 their holdings were in about the same volume as in
early August. There was some increase in commercial loans both at mem­
ber banks in New York City and in other leading cities.
Member bank balances at the reserve banks continued to increase dur­
ing August and the first three weeks of September, and excess reserves of
member banks reached $700,000,000.
This increase reflected primarily
additional purchases of Government securities by the Federal reserve banks,
which have averaged $35,000,000 a week since August 16. Money in circu­
lation, which usually increases at this season, has shown little change in
the past month, indicating a continued return from hoards.
Money rates in the open market showed a renewed decline during Au
gust and the first half of September.