View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
Covering financial* industrial, and agricultural conditions
in the
Fourth Federal Reserve District
Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland
Vol. 10

Cleveland, Ohio, October 1, 1928

September closed with industrial activity in the Fourth
District at a high point Iron and steel plants during
September were able to expand operations on a rising
price scale. Heavy automotive demand has been a strong
factor in the situation, reacting as it has on the District's
steel, accessory, rubber, paint, and glass industries. Vari­
ous other lines, such as electrical supply and machinery,
axe likewise doing more business than a year ago. Money
rates are firm, but no shortage of credit for commercial
usage is reported from the District’s leading financial
centers. An increase in speculative activity on the part
of the public is reported by several localities.

Solid lint—.weekly Index of ear loadings P.
J. B. of Cleveland (1923-1925 = 190). Latest
!PELS W*tk “ »din* September 8—19S.4. Brok•» Iwa—montlily Index of industrial prodncHK* P«d*ral Reserve Board (1923-1925 =
199). Latest Scare: Aurust—113. Bath carves
adjnstsd for seasonal variation.

FINANCIAL
Tlie five weeks ending September 22 have witnessed
jtorther tightening in call and time money rates, increas­
ing speculative activity on the New York stock exchange,
ana larger borrowings from the Federal Reserve System
r^ Ji •^anks. Gold imports and exports have been
negligible in comparison with earlier months, the counif sto°k of
8howinS a slight gain during August.
Money Rates. The spread between rates in New York



No. 10

on call and time money, used for stock exchange loans,
and commercial paper and bankers’ acceptances, used
largely for commercial purposes, has become more marked
in recent weeks. Since August 20, when call money re­
newed at 6 per cent, the renewal rate has been either 7
or 7% per cent except on September 21, when it rose to
8 per cent. The average renewal rate for the first 22
days of September was 7.42, as compared with 6.81 in
August, 6.12 in July, and 3.74 for the first 22 days of
September, 1927. Time money has also strengthened, the
90-day rate advancing from 6*6 to 7 per cent on Septem­
ber 10, 1*4 on the 18th, and 7%-% per cent on the 21st.
Commercial paper rates, on the other hand, have held
steady for some time at 5% per cent (90-day, prime),
while 90-day bankers’ acceptances (asked) declined from
4% to 4tVz per cent on August 31, remaining at the lat­
ter figure since that date. There is thus a spread of 3
per cent between acceptances and call money, and of 2
per cent between prime commercial paper and call money.
These differences are considerably larger than in the past.
Money rates in Cleveland are firmer than in the early
summer, but show little change as compared with a
month ago. Prime commercial paper ranges between 5%
and 6 per cent, and collateral loans are 5%-6. In Cin­
cinnati, these rates are 5%-6 and 5%-7 per cent respec­
tively, and in Pittsburgh the quotation on both is 5-6 per
cent.
It should be remembered in discussing the present
money situation that this is the season of normal
strengthening of rates in connection with crop-moving.
Reserve Bank Credit. Bills discounted by the Reserve
System declined irregularly for several weeks following
the year’s peak on July 10, but since August 15 have
again moved upward, standing at $1,094,000,000 on Sep­
tember 19, as compared with $1,037,000,000 on August 22
and $415,000,000 a year ago. Acceptance holdings have
increased seasonally, standing at $237,000,000 on Septem­
ber 19 as compared with $184,000,000 a month ago, and
$219,000,000 a year ago. Government security holdings
have changed but little, the figure of $225,000,000 on Sep­
tember 19 being $18,000,000 larger than a month earlier.
As compared with a year ago, however, there is a drop
of $259,000,000.
For the Cleveland bank, discounts on September 19 were
$70,000,000, a sharp drop for the week and a drop of
nearly $50,000,000 from the year’s high on July 3. Ac­
ceptance holdings at $21,800,000 are up seasonally, while

2

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

Government securities at $35,200,000 were slightly higher
than a month ago.
Member Bank Credit* Collateral loans of reporting
member banks have shown a declining tendency for two
months, reflecting in part the growing practice of large
corporations of lending direct to brokers and security
dealers. Commercial loans have shown but little change
lately. Investment holdings have been noticeably re­
duced, and time deposits show a corresponding loss,
though not so large. Demand deposits have exhibited a
very marked downtrend since Spring, another reflection
of the withdrawal o f corporation deposits for direct lend­
ing.
Loans to brokers and security dealers made by report­
ing member banks in New York City have turned sharply
upward since mid-August, amounting to $4,470,476,000 on
September 19. This is less than $100,000,000 below the
high for all time reached on June 6 of this year. The
feature of the situation in brokers' loans continues to
be the growth in loans made by the banks as agents for
corporations and individuals. These now stand at $1,911,104,000 as compared with $910,000,000 a year ago.
In the Fourth District, collateral loans have declined
somewhat during the past month, "all other” loans have
increased, and investments are noticeably lower. Demand
deposits have not changed a great deal recently, although
lower than in the late Spring. Time deposits have de­
creased gradually since July 3.
Security Prices. The bond market has been stronger
recently, after declining for about three months. The New
York Times average of 40 bonds was 90.80 on September
19, a gain of about a point for the month. The stock
market as a whole marked time during the first three
weeks of September, although violent fluctuations in in­
dividual issues and lines took place. Speculative activity
increased as evidenced by heavier trading and larger
brokers’ loans. The Dow-Jones industrial average rose
from 214.08 on August 14 to 240.38 on September 1—an
exceptionally rapid advance—but fluctuated in a narrow
range thereafter, standing at 239.40 on September 26.
Debits, Failures, Savings. Debits to individual account
at 13 leading centers in the Fourth District amounted to
$2,553,261,000 in August, as against $2,700,414,000 in July
and $2,468,506,000 a year ago.
Commercial failures in this District numbered 156 in
August, as compared with 132 in July and 174 in August
of 1927. Liabilities were $4,231,357 in August, $3,248,216
in July, and $4,276,479 a year ago. In the United States
there were 1852 failures in August, 1723 in July and 1708
in August, 1927.
Savings deposits in 67 banks in the Fourth District
amounted to $1,033,966,343 on September 1, a loss of 1.4
per cent for the month but a gain of 7.8 per cent for the
year.
The following table gives the changes in the main items
o f the balance sheets of Federal Reserve and reporting
member banks:
Federal Reserve

Gold Reserves .....................
Discounts ................... .......
Acceptances -------------- -—
U. S. Securities ..............

S S T

T < £ r ^ nitrz::::::::::::::



Bank of Cleveland
Federal Reserve System
„ (InMilUons)
(In Millions)
AusrSept* 12, Sept. 14, Au*. 15
1928
1927
1928
1928
1927
1928
265
309
262
2,629
2,984
2,618
87
40
79
1,069
375
1 002
20
16
20
211
227
lao
35
53
83
221
500
206

142

S?

108

m

182

1*504 w#2

yg

f

»;«»

REPOSTING MEMBER BANKS
Fourth District
(In Millions)
Loans secured by stocks
and bonds .......................
670
616
670
6,721
All other ............................. 800
799
795
9,093
Total loans ....................... 1,470
1,415
1,465 15,814
676
742
6,390
Investments ....................... 722
Demand deposits ........... . 1,044
1,053
1,033 13,197
Time deposits ................... 962
926
980
6,890

United States
(In Millions)
6.140
8,707
14,847
5,930
18,544
6,287

6,690
9,040
15,780
6,445
12,952
6,904

MANUFACTURING, MINING
Iron and Steel
August’s performance in setting a new
high steel ingot record was the more
impressive because it was apparently
the direct reaction to consumptive demand. Consumers
of steel experienced unusual and unexpected call for their
own products and in turn looked to the steel industry for
additional raw material. Although producers in August
were announcing higher prices and reduced discounts for
cash payments, effective with the fourth quarter, little of
the tonnage that made August a record month is be­
lieved to have been driven in.
This condition of strong production and prices con­
tinued into September and promised to make that month
also a record one. Some of early September’s tonnage
came under suspicion of being artificial to the extent that
consumers were mildly anticipating their requirements,
especially in view of advancing prices, but stocking in
the pre-war sense did not appear general. Substantially
all of the material ordered out in August and September
apparently was for a definite consumptive purpose.
All sources of outlet for steel, excepting possibly rail­
road equipment builders, were taking steel beyond their
usual requirements. With Ford gradually stepping up
his production and other important makers behind orders
on new models, automotive consumption was practically
record breaking. Farm implement manufacturers were
near capacity on their Fall runs. Supplementary orders
for track material were up to normal. Indicating the
wide distribution of steel rather than tonnage, jobbers
in the Middle West were reporting the heaviest demand
in many months from country hardware stores.
August and early September also saw a heavy buying
movement in pig iron, which culminated in a series o f
price advances late in August and a secondary one in
mid-September, after most users had covered for the last
quarter. August shipments, a record for some producers,
depleted furnace stocks and such important users as some
automotive foundries in Michigan were down to five days’
stocks. By mid-September pig iron prices in the Cleve­
land and Mahoning Valley were 50 cents to $1.00 per ton
higher than 60 days previous.
The character of demand benefited northern Ohio
Youngstown and Pittsburgh particularly. Pipe mills in
August and early September rounded out their rolling
schedules so as to leave little unfilled capacity over the
remainder of the year. Tin plate mills operated at 90
per cent, winding up their season of 1928 commitments.
Sheet mills, especially on the higher finishes, became three
and four weeks behind on deliveries to the automotive
industry. Strip mills also were pressed to make deliv­
eries. Scrap iron and steel entered a sharply rising market as consumers bought railroad offerings direct and
compelled dealers, many of them “ short” on the market
to buy in other districts and at higher prices.
’
August’s record ingot tonnage was 4,187,481, compared

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
with 3,811,573 tons in July, and 3,498,549 tons in August,
1927. The eight-month total stands at 32,782,937 tons,
against 80,510,071 tons in the like period of 1927. The
August pig iron total was 3,136,008 tons, compared with
3,072,711 tons in July, and 2,950,674 tons in August, 1927.
The eight-month total for pig iron is 24,719,182 tons, and
in 1927 it was 25,334,626 tons. The disparity between
steel ingot and pig iron production is accounted for by
the higher percentage of scrap used this year in the
open hearth furnaces.
In the first week of August, the Iron Trade Review
composite of fourteen leading iron and steel products ap­
parently touched the bottom of the summer dip, at $34.93,
and rose to $35.10 by the last week. The August average
was $34.96, compared with $34.91 for July, and $36.25
for August, 1927.

8

increase in orders by customers, both for present and
near future delivery, but the general feeling is that this
increase is largely seasonal.

Rubber and
Tires

Coal
Coal stocks in the hands of industrial consumers in the
United States and Canada continued to decline during
August and now stand at slightly less than 40 million
tons, or about a 36 days’ supply. There seems to be no
particular incentive to build up these stockpiles to any
extent, inasmuch as the present productive capacity could
amply take care of increased demand due to improving
business and the approach of winter. In most parts of
the country car shortage is a thing of the past, due to
the present efficient operation of the railroads.
The total United States production of soft coal during:
the month of August was 41,108,000 tons, as against 36,276,000 tons in July, and 41,705,000 tons in August, 1927.
The average daily rate in August was 1,523,000 tons,
which was 72,000 tons higher than for the previous
month, an increase of 5 per cent.
The average price of bituminous coal, f.o.b. mines, ad­
vanced from $1.68 per ton on July 27 to $1.90 on August
8 and remained at that figure for the remaining part of
the month.
General conditions in the industry in the Fourth Dis­
trict seem to be a shade better than they were last month
and a year ago, and the outlook for the last quarter of
1928 is slightly encouraging.
Reports coming from dealers and operators in various
parts of this District are agreed that there has been an



Reports indicate that operations in
Fourth District tire factories in Au­
gust were about the same as in July.
The seasonal shrinkage which usually
develops in the industry at this time of year does not
appear to be as noticeable as it was a year ago. Manu­
facturers report a larger volume in the number of tires
produced as compared with 1927, but due to the fact that
selling prices are lower, the dollar volume is about the
same as last year. The automobile industry shows ex­
ceptionally large production for this time o f year, and
the demand for tires as original equipment has conse­
quently been very heavy.
Orders for sundries, rubber boots and shoes are increas­
ing, as is the custom in the fall of the year.
Total shipments of tires during July, the latest figure
available, were 5,924,156 casings, an increase of almost
600,000 from the previous month, and 1,161,557 from
July, 1927. This figure exceeded the actual monthly pro­
duction, 4,873,716, by 1,050,440 units, resulting in a cor­
responding decline in stocks in manufacturers’ hands.
There has been little change in crude rubber prices
lately, first latex (spot) being quoted at 19.4 cents a
pound in New York on September 18, about the same as
a month ago. It is interesting to note that on September
20, 1927, crude rubber was quoted at 33% cents a pound.
The drop is due principally to the decision of the British
Government to abandon the Stevenson Restriction Act.
Automobiles

The August production of passenger
ears and trucks in the United States—
458,429—was the largest for any
month in history, exceeding last year’s figure by 45 per
cent. The second highest month on record was April,
1926, when 441,000 cars and trucks were produced. For
the first eight months of 1928, production totaled 3,051,220, or slightly more than 400,000 in excess of the same
period in 1927. The present year’s output to date, how­
ever, is still about 94,000 short of that of the first eight
months of 1926, the record year so far.
Registrations of new cars in the Fourth District are
keeping pace with the heavy output. In August, registra­
tions in 61 Ohio counties representing over 80 per cent
of the state’s population, increased 37 per cent over Au­
gust of 1927, according to the Ohio State University Bu­
reau of Business Research. In the seven most heavily

4

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

populated counties, registrations as compared with 1927
were 43 per cent greater for the month and 15 per cent
greater for the first eight months.
Clothing

The clothing business was quiet in Au­
gust, as in July. Greater activity has
appeared in September in preparation
for the winter season, and although the present increase
in orders is largely seasonal, there appears to be some
gain not accounted for by seasonal factors. Because of
this, manufacturers are inclined to be more confident of
the winter trade than they were a month ago.
The knit goods branch of the industry is experiencing
a heavy increase in orders for quick shipment, as is nor­
mal at this season. Business in women’s outerwear is
about the same as last year; advance orders are in fairly
good volume and substantial repeat orders are being re­
ceived. Improvement is reported in the men’s wear trade
after a dull summer. But little change has occurred re­
cently in woolens and worsteds.
August sales of reporting wholesale dry goods houses
in the Fourth District were 9.6 per cent less than a year
ago, but increased 44.1 per cent over July. The first
eight months registered a gain in sales of 1.3 per cent
over 1927.
August retail clothing sales were only fair as compared
to last year. In 31 department stores in the Fourth Dis­
trict, gains were shown by misses’ ready-to-wear, 10.5
per cent; juniors’ and girls’ wear, 14.7; aprons and house
dresses, 33.3; hosiery, 4.5; knit underwear, 4.6; and silk
and muslin underwear, 9.8 per cent. On the other hand,
decreases took place in all the men’s wear departments,
and several others of importance, such as women’s coats,
women’s dresses, sports' wear, and furs.
Shoes

The shoe manufacturing industry in
this District is in good condition. Au­
gust production in 32 large factories
exceeded that of July by more than the usual seasonal
gain, and in addition was larger than in any other month
during the past five years except August, 1927, and Feb­
ruary, 1928. Cincinnati manufacturers report business as
being ahead of a year ago, with the outlook for this Fall
quite promising on the basis of orders being received.
The situation in the retail end of the business is also
encouraging. August sales of women’s shoes in 31 de­
partment stores in the Fourth District were 5.5 per cent
larger than a year ago, and children’s shoes also gained
3.6 per cent. These increases are particularly notable in
view of the decreases shown by the great majority of
individual departments. Men’s and boys' shoes showed a
small decline of 1.4 per cent.
Returns from wholesalers are less satisfactory, August
sales of reporting units exhibiting a loss of 14 per cent
from the same month in 1927.
Other
Manufacturing

The majority of manufacturing lines in
this District are doing from 5 to 25
per cent more business now than a
year ago. Some others report conditions about the same
as last year, while almost no cases are evident of de­
clines from 1927. In most instances, furthermore, condi­




tions improved during August and the first half of Sep­
tember as compared with July.
There appears to be very little disposition on the part
of customers to increase their forward buying, in spite
of the rise in the general price level during the past few
months. Orders, although heavier, continue to be very
largely for quick delivery. It may be said, however, that
what little change has taken place is in the direction of
more advanced purchasing rather than toward an even
more restricted buying policy. The tendency until re­
cently has been in the latter direction.
Agricultural Implements. Conditions in this line are
very satisfactory.
Electrical Supplies. Business is somewhat better than
a year ago.
Machinery, Machine Tools. Sales of engineering special­
ties are well in excess of a year ago. Steady improve­
ment is reported by makers of woodworking machinery.
Sales of twist drills are well above the normal at this
season; collections are better, and prices remain firm.
Demand for various types of machine tools is good.
Metal Containers. Demand is increasing and 1928 to
date shows a gain in business of about 10 per cent over
last year. An even better record was made by August,
in comparison with both August, 1927, and July, 1928.
Motor Accessory. Manufacturers remain extremely
busy. Numerous factories are operating large night
forces in an endeavor to keep up with incoming orders.
The tendency to replace castings with forgings has aided
the drop forging industry.
Paint, Salesmen now on the road are said to be ob­
taining larger orders than heretofore. Most of the larger
paint and varnish concerns in the Cleveland area have
done better in 1928 than in 1927 and are enjoying good
business at present, especially in lines catering to the
motor trade. Pig lead prices have lately advanced $4.00
per ton.
Paper. Conditions in the paper trade leave something
to be desired; profits are smaller despite heavier business,
and recently orders have exhibited a declining tendency
greater than seasonal.
Stoves. The usual seasonal increase in inquiries for
stoves and ranges is now taking place.
AGRICULTURE
As harvesting progresses, several of the principal crops
of the country give evidence of larger production than
was expected earlier in the season, the composite of the
prospective yields of all crops in the country on Septem­
ber 1 being 3.3 per cent higher than their ten-year av­
erage on that date. It will be remembered that most
spring planting was late and that grass and winter wheat
started the season in poor shape, but crop growth was
generally aided by the rains of June and July.
In the Fourth District, crop prospects on September 1
were, for the most part, slightly lower than a month
earlier, due to hot, dry weather in August. The late
summer was favorable for haying and threshing in most
localities, but fall plowing has been retarded in many
places, the ground being too hard to work.
The following table gives the estimated yield of the
principal crops in the Fourth District, based on the con­

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
dition of the crops on September 1, compared with the
actual yield in 1927 and also compared with the United
States.

Com (bu.) ......
Wheat (bu.) ....
Oats (bu.) ......
Hay (tons) ......
Tobacco (lbs.) ..
Potatoes (bu.) ..

United States
Fourth District
(000 omitted)
Yield
Estimate
Estimate Yield
Sept. 1,
1927
Sept. 1,
1927
1928
1928
150,323 2,930,586 2,773,708
872,595
901,072
33,931
78,362 1,453,829 1,184,146
123,794
7,652
87,859
80,647 1,371,782 1,195,880
466,815
406,964
21,501

will begin in the majority of vineyards about October 1.
The Bureau of Labor’s index of agricultural prices in
August stood at 107.0, a slight decline from the July
figure of 107.1.
Tobacco

The warm, dry weather o f the past few
weeks has been exceptionally favorable
for the Kentucky burley tobacco crop.
As a result, the condition of the crop, which was rather
poor a month ago, has undergone a marked improvement
both as to quality and quantity. The Department of
Agriculture’s September 1 forecast indicated a 1928 yield
of 312,602,000 pounds (all types) for Kentucky, as com­
pared with an estimate of 288,249,000 a month earlier.
This shows the improvement in quantity that has taken
place, and in addition, reports from Lexington state that
the quality of the crop as a whole has improved very
materially. The crop is now figured to be 55 per cent
larger than last year’s low production, but 25 per cent
less than the 5-year average, 1922-1926.
The Department of Agriculture’s estimate of the total
1928 production of the various types of tobacco grown
wholly or partly in Kentucky is as follows (in pounds):

Com in practically all parts of the District is poorer
than a month ago. In Ohio the heaviest declines occurred
in the northwest and southwest portions of the State. In
Pennsylvania the crop is quite varied. In some sections
many fields have been abandoned, while in others the
crop has never been better. The September 1 condition
was 81 per cent of normal, compared with 84 on August
1, 05 on September 1, 1927, and 84.3, the ten-year av­
Type
1928
1927
erage*
Burley ..................... 272,698,000
180,659,000
Oats prospects declined about 7 per cent in Ohio, 5 per
Green Biver ............ 23,240,000
18,110,000
cent in Pennsylvania, and 1 per cent in West Virginia
Henderson ..............
5,250,000
4,200,000
daring August. Early threshing returns show oats to
One-sucker .............. 21,230,000
13,056,000
be lighter in yield than was expected earlier in the season.
HopkinsvilleThe September forecast for Ohio, in spite of the decline
82,000,000
63,000,000
Clarksville ..........
in condition, is for a crop of 92,378,000 bushels, a pro­
Paducah .................
28,000,000
18,000,000
duction only exceeded once in the past sixty years. This
large crop is a result of the failure of much of the winter
For the United States, the latest estimate indicates a
wheat, which made it necessary for farmers to replant 1928 crop (all types) of 1,371,782,000 pounds, as com­
the ground to some Spring crop.
pared with 1,211,301,000 in 1927, and a five-year average
The condition of potatoes in the District is much above
(1922-1926) of 1,337,561,000 pounds.
the average of the past ten years, but is not uniformly
Total stocks of leaf tobacco held by manufacturers and
good. Blight, rot, weeds and drought have affected the dealers on July 1 were 1,734,378,240 pounds, according to
crop adversely in different localities. The large increase the Department of Agriculture, as against 1,841,078,123
in estimated production is again explained by the in­ a year earlier and 1,998,144,550 on April 1, 1928. Ex­
creased acreage.
ports for the first seven months of 1928 amounted to
Pastures in most parts of the District are good, though
170,153,254 pounds, an increase of 25,000,000 over the
the condition on September 1 was lower than a month
same period in 1927.
earlier. Hay production in Ohio was estimated on September 1 at 3,288,000 tons, as compared with 5,149,000
BUILDING
tons harvested in 1927.
Fruit crops in Ohio show little change from August 1.
Building operations in the Fourth District made an un­
In Pennsylvania, apples and grapes have changed slightly favorable showing in August, doubtless reflecting the
in condition during the last month but peach prospects higher cost of borrowing for construction purposes. Both
have declined 88,000 bushels since August 1. In spite of contracts awarded and building permits were less than a
this falling-off, the September 1 forecast is still 8 per year ago. In the case of the former, both residential and
cent above the average production for the past five years total contracts were the smallest for any August since
and 75 per cent in excess of the 1927 harvest. Apples 1924, the declines from last year being 37 and 20 per
continue to drop and the quality of the crop as a whole cent respectively. In dollars, total contracts awarded in
is inferior. Scab is still bad, and reports of apples burst­ August amounted to $50,408,000, of which $14,353,000
ing are numerous.
were for residential purposes. For the first eight months
The grape crop, both in Ohio and Pennsylvania, is esti­ of 1928, total contracts awarded were $441,178,000, a loss
mated to be much larger than the harvest of 1927, the of 8.9 per cent from last year, and residential contracts
increase being 43 and 40 per cent respectively. In the were $156,187,000, a decrease of 5 per cent.
Erie belt the crop is in good shape. Weather conditions
August building permits in 27 leading cities in this
have been favorable, the temperature being above normal District totaled $23,697,614, a loss of 13.8 per cent from
and moisture adequate. Disease and insect damage ap­ a year ago and also a loss from 1926. For the first
pear to be light and vines are growing well, clusters are eight months, however, the total of $179,867,675 showed a
large, and the fruit is firm and of good size. Harvest gain of 2.7 per cent over the same period o f 1927. For




6

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

August, permits were larger than last year in only seven
of the 27 reporting cities, the greatest gains taking place
in Ashtabula, Cleveland, Newark, and Hamilton* In the
first three, the gains were more than 100 per cent. To
offset these, decreases of more than 40 per cent occurred
in Akron, Canton, five of Cleveland’s suburbs, Columbus,
Dayton, Erie, Lima, Pittsburgh, and Springfield, and sev­
eral other cities reported declines nearly as large. For
the first eight months, nine cities reported gains, of
which the largest were in Newark, Cleveland, Pittsburgh,
Lakewood, and Euclid.
Lumber concerns state that August was a dull month,
but September has brought a slight betterment in some
instances. Most dealers are doing a somewhat smaller
volume of business than they were a year ago, which is
only natural in view of the falling-off in building pre­
viously noted.
The Aberthaw index of industrial building costs remains
unchanged for September at 191.

Building Operations
(Valuation of Permits)
August,
1928
1,292.060
36,515
59,582
219,930
4.194,705
6,825,300

Akrou............
Ashtabula....
Barberton. . .
Canton..........
Cincinnati.. .
Cleveland....
Cieve. suburbs
Cl eve. Hts...
174,425
Kast Cleve..
29.606
F.uctid..........
76,095
Garfield Hts.
122,300
1.a Icewood...
51,601
195.273
Parma..........
Rocky River
146.650
Shaker Hts..
827,225
Columbus....
1,129.700
Covington, Ky.
154,000
Dayton.........
693,198
347.650
Krie^Pa........
Hamilton. . . .
459.628
l.exington. K.y.
256.2S5
19,175
Lima..............
386,700
Newark.........
3.166,673
Pittsburgh, Pa.
92,820
Springfield...
1,902.903
% !edo...........
Wheeling, W. Va. 277.080
560.535
Youngstown..
Total..........

2J.697.6I4

change
from

-3d! 6
+ 3 9 .8
— 33.9

3,315,585
632,350
1,709,956
1,228,550
4,281,597
1,932,439
866,063
5,720,765
12,770,400
1,227,500
8,720,226
2,639,737
1,523,761
1,178,976
318,229
941,480
30,215,414
952,215
13,041.640
1,360,600
6,298,458

3,792,237
1,012,885
1.357.829
2,073,000
2,591,044
2,628,626
1,012,273
6,675,860
16,830,400
1,299,900
8,664,681
3,693,184
1,534,306
1,662,499
574.586
329,488
26,428,863
1,421,085
12,845.302
2,101,775
6.433.830

— 28.5
— 0.7
— 29.1
—44.6
+ 185.7
+ 14 .3
— 33.0
+ 1.5
— 35.3
— 2 .1

— 1J.8

179.867.67S

175.187.369

+ 2.7

— 3.7
— 43.2
+ 1 5 .6
+11 9 .4

. 1.9
— 84.7
— 70.7
— 48.1
— 75.2
— 31.9

+10.1

— 37.3
— 46.8
— 11.4
— 52.4
— 46.8
+ 5 8 .6
— 32.1
— 76.9
+ 258.9

Sales o f 62 department stores in the
Fourth District in August were 7.9 per
cent less than a year ago. Sales were
unusually large in August of last year, however, owing
to early Fall buying brought on by unseasonably cool
weather in the late summer. The volume of sales for
the past month exceeded that for August of 1924 and
1925, and was about the same as in August o f 1926.
For the first eight months of 1928, the District showed
a loss of 1.5 per cent in sales from last year. Akron
and Toledo registered the largest gains, while Pittsburgh
showed the largest decrease.
Most o f the individual departments suffered losses in
sales as compared with August, 1927. Decreases in some
o f the principal departments were as follows: silks and
velvets, 17.6 per cent; women's coats, 10.3; dresses, 4.9;
furs, 25.5; men’s clothing, 11.7; boys9 wear, 1.5; women’s
and children’s shoes, 1.0; furniture, 21.0; floor coverings,
10.0; draperies, lamps, shades, 12.3; house furnishings,
2.8 per cent.

from
1927
— 19.8
— 24.4

Jan.-Aug.
1927
15,007,051
414.585
822,359
2,690,118
21,274,153
30,015,450

+111.1

Retail Tirade

u%
change

Jan.*Aug.
1928
12,035,957
313,426
634,698
2,801,373
24,237,005
38,969,275

1927
— 43.3

TRADE

—22.8
f 41
+ 1 3 .9
+ 2 9 .8
—

12.6

— 37.6
+ 2 5 .9
— 40.7
+ 6 5 .2
— 26.5
— 14.4
— 14.3
— 24.1
— 5.6

+ 0.6

8UILDNG C O N TR A C TS -4 TH DISTRICT

Wholesale Trade

Sales o f reporting grocery and drug
firms in the Fourth District in August
were in larger volume than a year ago,
while those of dry goods, hardware, and shoes were sub­
stantially less. For the first eight months o f 1928,
grocery sales exceeded the same period in 1927 by 2.2
per cent, dry goods by 1.3 per cent, and drugs by 0.8 per
cent. Hardware and shoes decreased 6.1 and 10.0 per
cent respectively.
Grocery stocks on August 31 were 1.2 per cent greater
than a year previously, but stocks o f dry goods and
shoes were 6.3 and 7.8 per cent less respectively.
Accounts receivable on August 31 showed an increase
of 4 per cent over the preceding year for groceries, 10.5
per cent for drugs, and 4.7 per cent for hardware. In
dry goods, receivables fell off 8.1 per cent, and In shoes
9.2 per cent.
Grocery collections in August were 9.5 per cent larger
than a year ago; shoes 2 £; and drugs, 0.4 per cent. Dry
goods collections were 8.2 per cent less, and hardware, 9
per cent lower.
The percentage of August collections to accounts re­
ceivable on July 31 was 85.3 for groceries, 40.4 for dry
goods, 35.7 for hardware, 34.7 for shoes, and 81.8 for
drugs.

I RSSlOdNYlAC

lOL-

-

1025

1926




1927

1928

5029

The stock turnover rate for groceries in July was .72,
or 8.64 times a year, and for dry goods was .37, or 4.44
times a year.

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

7

Fourth District Business Statistics
(All figures are lor Fourth District unless otherwise specified)

Bank Debits <24 cities)
s*vinfS Deposits (end of month)
Ohio (41 banks)
WesternPennayIvania (26 banks)
Total (67 banks)
Commercial Failures Number
_ **, _
."
— Liabilities
Postal Receipts — 9 cities
Sale# — Life Insurance — Ohio and Pa.
“ — DfP1: Stores — (62 firms)
z ~~
Apparel (IS firms)
— Furniture (49 firms)
** — Wholesale Grocery (44 firms)

Millions of dollars
Thousands of dollars
Actual Number
Thousands of dollars

„ —
Hardware (16 firms)
7~ D
0 4 firms)
Building Permits, Valuation— 27 cities
Building Contracts — Total, 4th District
^
— Residential, 4th District
Production — Pig Iron, U. S.
“
— Steel Ingots, U. S.
— Automobiles, U. S.
Passenger Cars
Actual
Number
••
•«
Truck*
—- Bituminous Coal, 4th Dist.
Thousands of tons
“
Cement: Ohio, W. Va., Wn. Pa.
44
" barrels
— Electric Power: Ohio, Pa., K>\
Millions of k.w. hrs.
— Petroleum: Ohio, Pa., K>\
Thousands of barrels
— Shoes, 4th District
44 pairs
M
— Tires, U. S.
44
44 casings
Bituminous Coal Shipments (from Lake Erie port*)
44
44 tons
Iron Ore Receipts (at Lake Erie ports)
1 8 months average.

Aug.
1928

1927

3,064

3,005

757,132
276,834
1,033,966
156
4,231
2,865
95,844
21,246
1.390
1,203
7,012
2,553
1,870
1,887
23,698
50,408
14,353
3,136
4,178

699,403
259,410
958,812
173
4,276
2.876
93,102
23,071
1,640
1,177
6,696
2,823
1,983
1,809
27,487
62,447
19,576
2,947
3,471

400,689
57,740
16,118
2,038
1,031*
2,096-

+ 2.6
8.3
6.7
7.8
9.8
—
1.1
— 0 .4
+ 2.9
—
8.6
— 17.1
+ 2.3
+ 4.7
— 9 .6
— 5.7
+ 4.3
— 13.8
— 19.3
— 26.7
+ 6.4
+ 20 .4

1,010s

2,012*
4

4.9202
5,666
6.390

3,864s
4,166
6,451

Jan.-Aug.
1927

26,198

+
f
+
—

274,381
34,445
15.876
1,967

«

Jan.-Aug.
1928

change

744,826*
279,547*
1,024,373*
I,344
38,916
24,228
847,067
184,410
11,681
8,476
51,085
17,058
15,277
14,561
179,868
441,178
156,187
24,729
32,783

+ 4 6 .0
+ 6 7 .6
+ 1.5
+ 3.5

+ 2.1

+ 0.7

690,356*
255,442*
945,798*
I,351
35,638
24,125
808,946
187,256
12,157
8,545
49,975
16,835
16,273
14,447
175,187
484,394
163,956
25,318
30,268

2,704,514
346,706
118.628
II,291
7,626*
14,091s*

+ 4.2
— 8.7
+ 27 .3
+ 3 6 .0
— 0.9

change

26,011

+
+
+
—
+
+
+
—
—
—

+ 1.3

—

6.1

+
—
—
—
+

2.7
8.9
4.7
2.3
8.3

+ 0.8

4

4

1.0

8.0

+ 2.2

2,313,869
332,416
135,531
II.216
7,628*
13,805*

33,904*
20,824
21,515

7.9
9.4
8.3
0.5
9.2
0.4
4.7
1.5

+16 .9
+ 4.3
— 12.5
+ 0.7
— 0.03

+ 2.1

— 7.9

30,544*
23,182
24,300

+11.0

10.2
— 11.5

—

* I®**

* January*July
4 Figures Conf
ifidential

Index Numbers of Trade in the Fourth Federal
Reserve District
Aug.
1924

Retail and Wholesale Trade
(1928 compared with 1927)
Percentage Increase or Decreas<
SALES
SALES
STOCKS
Aug.Aug.First
Aug.«
Aug.8 mos.

DEPARTMENT STORES (62)
Akron..............................................
Cleveland..
Columbus..
Dayton.. . .
Pittsburgh.
Wheeling.. . .
Youngstown.
Other Cities.
District........
WEARING APPAREL (13;
Cincinnati................................
Other Cities.............................
District.....................................
FURNITURE (48)
Cincinnati.................................
Cleveland.................................
Columbus.................................
Dayton.....................................
Toledo..................................... .
District...............................................
CHAIN STORE*
Drugs-^-District (3).........................
Groceries— District (4).....................
WHOLESALE GROCERIES (44;
Akron..................................................
Cincinnati.........................................
Cleveland......................................
Erie................................. ...................
Toledo...........................
Other Cities..................
District.....................

wholIIalI

:

•Salea per individual unit operated.




-r 2.3
— 10.7
— 7.9
— 3.0
— 1.0
— 13.1
+ 1.2
— 2.0
— 6.8
— 4.3
— 8.6

+
—
+
+
+
—
+
—
—
—
—

8.7
0.1
0.6
0.8
0.2
6.3
5.3
2.8
1.6
5.0
1.5

+ 23.9
+ 2.3
— 0.3
+ 4,6
+ 3.9
— 9.7
— 3.0
— 11.4
— 3.3
— 5.6
— 2.6

— 17.1
— 14.9
— 15.3

— 1.0
— 5.6
— 3.9

— 9.0
— 3.6
— 4.8

+ 0.9
— 5.2
+ 3.6
+13.1
+ 2.9
+ 2.5
+ 2 0

— 2.1
— 2.4
— 2.5
+ 3.7
+ 3.6
— 10.0
— 0.8

— 0.5
+ 7.9

— 6.0
+ 5.1

— 5.9
+ 0.02
+ 9.1
— 1.2
+ 7.9
+ 7.1
+ 2.7
+ t 7
— 9.6
+ 4.3
— 5.7
— 13.9

+ 6.4
+ 3.4
+ 2.4
— 6.0
+ 8.2
+ 0.6
+ 1.0
+ 2.2
+ 13
+ 0.8
— 6.1
— 10.0

+ i.i

— 6.3
— 7.8

87
Department Stores (50)*...............
95
Wholesale Drugs (14)**................
Wholesale Dry Goods (13)**........
100
97
Wholesale Groceries (44)**............
Wholesale Hardware (16)**..........
95
96
Wholesale All (92)***....................
103
Chain Drugs (3)*t.........................
♦Base—Average monthly sales, 1919-1923.
**Base a* Average monthly sales, 1923-1925.
1 Includes 4 shoe firms.
TPcr individual unit operated.

A up.
1925
90
101
97
98
90
9<>
10o

Auy.
192b
93
103
92
95
95
96
io<;

.• w .
1927
101
107
104
95

93

99
97

Aus.
1928
93

111
94

100
87
97
96

Debits to Individual Accounts
(In thousands of dollars)

Akron................
Butler, Pa........
Canton..............
Cincinnati.........
Cleveland.........
Columbus..........
Connellsville, Pa.
Dayton.............
Erie, Pa...........
Greensburg, Pa.
Homestead, Pa.
Lexington, Ky..
Lima..................
Lorain...............
Middletown.. . .
Oil City, Pa___
Pittsburgh, Pa..
Springfield........
Steubenville___
Toledo..............
Warren.............
Wheeling, W. Va.
Youngstown....
Zanesville.........
Total.............

5 weeks
ending
Sept. 19,
1928
117,805
13,410
57,233
437,205
898,837
178,788
4,742
107,950
44,070
21,495
4,944
22,848
19,757
8,416
14,268
21,584
1,070,629
25,686
14,879
296,845
15,957
57,337
80,978
15.298
3,550,961

change
from
1927
+ 5.4
+ 3.9
+ 4.8
— 1.5
+ 7.7
—

0.8

—II. I
+ 6.0
+ 5.2
— 10.4
— 5.6
— 9.0
+18 .5
— 0.9
—

2. 1

+ 26 .4
+ 7.9
— 7.6
+ 1 0 .9
+14 .8
+ 3.7
+ 19 .2
+ 5.4

+ 6.8
+ 6.1

1928 to
date (Dec.
28-Sept.
19)
974,841
100.164
446,184
3,991,973
7,410,460
1.507,817
37,707
873,022
328,108
186,106
38,635
221.344
140,543
57,153
115,763
152,998
8,826.328
203,873
106,138
2,446,593
122,691
443,505
648,348
117,549
29,497,843

1927 to
date (Dec.
29-Sept.

21)

896,647
104,604
436,535

change
from
1927
+ 8.7
— 4.2

+ 2.2

3.665,549
7,240,849
1,501,355
46,358
859,258
326,494
201.531
40,417
224,571
133,491
56,487
101,873
138,570
9,417,387
218,457
102,323
2,101,614
126,051
418,898
650,183
115,302

+ 8.9
+ 2.3
+ 0.4
— 18.7

29,124,804

+ f .j

+ 1.6

+
—
—
—
+

0.5
7.7
4.4
1.4
5.3

+ 1.2

+ 1 3 .6
+ 10 .4
— 6.3

— 6.7
+ 3.7
+1 6 .4
— 2.7
+ 5.9
— 0.3
+ 1.9

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

8

Summary of National Business Conditions
By the Federal Reserve Board
Volume of industrial and trade activity increased in August, and there
was a further advance in wholesale commodity prices. Reserve bank credit
outstanding increased in September, reflecting in part seasonal demands for
currency and credit. Money rates remained firm.
PRODUCTION

Index numbers of production of manufactures
and minerals, adjusted for seasonal variations
(1923-1925 — 100). Latest figures, August,
manufactures— 114; minerals— 105.

Production of both manufactures and minerals increased considerably
in August, the output of manufacturing plants being larger than at this
season of any earlier year. Automobile production was in record volume in
August, and available information indicates that output was maintained by
many producers at a high level during September. Iron and steel produc­
tion continued large in August and September, and output of nonferrous
metals increased between July and August. Textile mill activity, which had
been somewhat reduced in recent months, also showed a substantial in­
crease. Factory employment and payrolls have increased since midsummer
and in August were close to the levels of a year ago. In the building in­
dustry, there was evidence of recession in a sharp decline after the early
summer in contracts awarded, which were in smaller volume during August
than in the corresponding month of any year since 1924. In the first three
weeks of September, however, awards were somewhat larger than last year.
Estimates of the Department of Agriculture for September 1 indicate
that yields of principal crops will be larger than last year and above the
average for the preceding five years.
TRADE

Index of U. S. Bureau o f Labor Statistics
<1926 = 100). Latest figures, August, farm
products— 107.0; non-agricultural, 96.7.

Distribution of commodities showed seasonal increases in August, al­
though sales in most lines of wholesale and retail trade did not equal the
unusually large sales of August, 1927. Department store stocks increased
as is usual in August, but continued smaller than a year ago, while inven­
tories in several lines of wholesale trade were somewhat larger than last
year. Freight car loadings were in about the same volume in August as
a year earlier. Shipments of miscellaneous commodities and grains were
larger, and those of coal, livestock, and forest products smaller than last
year.
PRICES

Monthly averages of daily figures for 12 Fed­
eral Reserve banks. Latest figures are aver­
ages for first 22 days in August
PERCENT

------- 1200

The general level of commodity prices increased in August, and the
Bureau of Labor Statistics index at 98.9 per cent of the 1926 average,
was the highest in nearly two years. Increases in August were chiefly in
the prices of livestock and livestock products, which are now higher than
at any time since 1920. There were also small increases in fuels, metals,
and building materials. Grains and cotton showed sharp declines, and there
were decreases also in hides, skins and wool. Since the 1st of September,
there have been some declines in livestock and meats, and a sharp further
decrease in cotton, while prices of pig iron, copper, and petroleum have
advanced.
BANK CREDIT

f

j

m

b u i ld i n g c o n t r a c t s a w a r d e d
m m

—
1024 -

Wi/fy Season?//U jvstm m t
Without Adjusf/seat
1325

1926

1927

1928

Federal Reserve Board’s indexes o f value of
building contracts awarded as reported by the
F. W. Dodge Corporation (1923-1925 average
— 100.) Latest figures, August, adjusted index
— 111; unadjusted index— 126.




Between the middle of August and the middle of September, there was
a considerable increase in the loans and investments of member banks in
leading cities. Part of the increase was in loans on securities and part
reflected a seasonal increase in other loans. Deposits of the member banks
also increased during the period. Volume of reserve bank credit outstand­
ing increased during the four weeks ending September 19 in response to
seasonal demands for currency and growth in member bank reserve re­
quirements. The increase in total bills and securities was largely in hold­
ings of acceptances and in discounts for member banks. During the same
period there were further increases in open market rates on collateral loans
and on commercial paper, while rates on bankers' acceptances were reduced
from 4% per cent to 4% per cent.