View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
industrial

Fourth Federal Reserve District

and a g ric u ltu ra l c o n d itio n s

Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland

Covering financial,

Vol. 20

Cleveland, Ohio, November 30, 1938

Many fourth district industries have advanced opera­
tions further in recent weeks, largely because of pressure
for delivery of parts and materials to automobile as­
sembly plants. That industry expanded operations in
November to the highest rate in more than a year in an
effort to stock dealers, following an apparent underesti­
mation of public interest in and demand for new cars.
Other local industries have shown improvement, but they
have been more moderate, and the total gain, while causing
a substantial rise in employment, has not been sufficient
to restore it to levels prevailing a year ago. This present
sharp upward movement, however, is in decided contrast
to the contraction which was well under way last year at
this time.
Steel mill operations in local producing areas rose quite
sharply between the third weeks of October and Novem­
ber, and were somewhat above the national average. It
is reported that sheet and strip steel rollings, against large
commitments made in mid-October when price conces­
sions were available, are the most important factors in cur­
rent ingot output. Production facilities for these types
are large in this district, which accounts for the fact local
plant operations, excluding Pittsburgh, have been above the
national rate since early in October. Pittsburgh is a large
producer of heavy steels, and while gains have occurred
there in recent weeks, demand for this product has lagged.
In the week ended November 26, steel operations in Cleve­
land, Pittsburgh, and southwestern Ohio receded slightly,
but such a fluctuation after so long a period of increasing
operations is not unusual. Reports, however, indi­
cate that steel has been stocked in recent weeks, the rate
of ingot operations being in excess of actual finished steel
consumption. Nevertheless, scrap steel prices have ad­
vanced, and the largest number of blast furnaces was
placed in operation in October since April 1936.
Automobile assemblies rose sharply to 96,700 in the
week ended November 19, but declined in the following
period because of the holiday. This was well in excess
of 1937 production which turned down in mid-October,
whereas this year gains have been recorded each week
since mid-September. Reports from the industry regard­
ing sales, unfilled orders, and limited inventories, have
been favorable, but at the current rate of assemblies a large
supply of cars can be built up rapidly. Companies sup­



No. 11

plying the assembly plants have been pressed for parts de­
liveries recently. Toledo employment in the third week
of November was seven percent under last year, whereas
in October the decrease was over 30 percent. Plate glass
production was stepped up, but the larger shipments re­
ported were partly from stock. Tire plant operations,
which had been showing improvement since early summer
as a result of a better replacement tire situation, increased
further in October because of greater demand from the
auto industry. Tire production in the latest month was
seven percent in excess of last year at this time.
New machine tool orders received in October were about
the same as in the preceding month. In the recent recov­
ery period, however, new domestic machine tool and foundry
equipment purchases have lagged, and those plants not doing
a foreign business continue to operate at rather low levels.
Shoe production in October, though down seasonally, was
23 percent greater than last year, and only exceeded in
one October since 1929.
Retail trade in this area was irregular. Department and
wearing apparel store sales increased less than seasonally
in October, though improvement was indicated by weekly
reports in November. Other lines of trade showed mod­
erate gains. Conservative inventory policies are still being
followed, for despite the less-than-seasonal rise in sales,
stocks on hand were little changed in the latest month,
after allowing for seasonal variations.
The construction industry has presented a favorable
picture this fall. With one special exception, total con­
tracts awarded in the three latest months were larger than
in any similar period since 1931. However, except in the
residential field the bulk of the increase in awards has been
for contracts under the Public Works’ program. In the first
ten months of this year, total contracts awarded in the
fourth district were 16 percent under the same period
of 1937, but in the three latest months a gain of 34 per­
cent was recorded.
FINANCIAL
Total loans and investments of weekly reporting mem­
ber banks in leading cities of the fourth district, after
experiencing a steady rise from May through October, de­
clined slightly in the first three weeks of November. In­
vestments in securities other than United States Govern­

2

THE MONTHLY
ment obligations have been kept at a constant level for
over two months following continued moderate expansion
in this type of asset during the summer. The decline
in total credit extended this month is traceable to the first
substantial drop in Government securities since last April,
and to a continuation of the slow liquidation of commer­
cial and miscellaneous loans. Deposits showed little change.
The recent drop in total loans and investments has not
been large enough, nor has it extended over a sufficient
period, to demonstrate reversal of the upward trend. Ex­
cess reserves of member banks are still rising, thus adding to
the banks’ incentive to expand investment portfolios as long
as demand for loans remains at a low level. In the mid­
dle of November, reserves held by all member banks in the
fourth district were estimated to be 53 percent in excess
of requirements, a gain of two points over the figure report­
ed last month. In amount, they were approximately $170,000, 000.

The results of a recent special study of interest rates
charged on new commercial loans made by banks in Cleve­
land, Cincinnati, and Pittsburgh during a 15-day period,
are shown on the accompanying chart. The study reveals
that the plethora of bank funds seeking investment has
resulted in very low rates being charged large borrowers.
During this two-week period, the banks included in the
survey made 1,624 new commercial loans aggregating $11,949,000, an average of $7,400 per loan. This excludes
renewals of loans. Interest rates charged covered a rather
wide range, one bank reporting some loans at less than
one percent and another bank charging several borrowers
seven percent. The largest number of loans was made at
relatively high rates, 26.5 percent of the total number car­
rying five percent and 51 percent being made at six percent.
Dollar volume of these loans was small, for the five percent
loans averaged only $2,500, and the six percent loans only
$1,500. Together they accounted for 20 percent of the
money loaned during the period. Only nine percent of the
total number of loans was made at three .percent or less,
but they accounted for over 66 percent of the total funds
loaned. Fourteen loans were made at rates below two
percent, but higher than one percent; they accounted for
30.8 percent of the total funds loaned in the period by
these large banks.
Developments at the Federal reserve bank during the
past month were again of minor significance. Holdings
of Government securities are being kept at a constant level,
and rediscounting is in small volume. Industrial advances
continue to decline. Interdistrict transfers during the past
three months have resulted in little net change in gold
certificate holdings or total reserves. Although total money
in circulation in the entire country on November 16 was
$200,000,000 in excess of the amount outstanding a year
earlier, Federal reserve notes issued by the Cleveland bank
were nearly $14,000,000 under a year ago.
MANUFACTURING, MINING
Iron and
Steel mill operations for the entire counSteel
try rose at a faster rate in the first three
weeks of November than in October. The
national rate, which crossed 50 percent of capacity in midOctober, continued upward to 63 percent in the week ended
November 19, the best in over a year. Since that date
the rate has declined slightly, partly on account of the




BUSINESS REVIEW

holiday, but also because production of some grades of
steel recently, as a result of the heavy ordering in October,
has been reported in excess of actual consumption. Steel
producers stipulated that lower quotations prevailed only
on steel delivered prior to the year end. With much of
this lower-priced sheet and strip steel ordered being pro­
duced on continuous mills in the fourth district, operating
rates at local centers advanced quite sharply prior to
November 19. In the four weeks preceding that date the
rate at Cleveland-Lorain mills rose over 15 points to 79.5
percent of capacity, the best rate since August 1937. In
the following week it dropped back two points. At Youngs­
town the rate rose to 66 percent from 57 in the third week
of October, but receded six points toward the month end.
Southwestern Ohio mills advanced their rate five points to
75 percent, remained at that level for three weeks in Novem­
ber, but dropped five points toward the month end. Pitts­
burgh mills, which are more dependent on heavy steel
requirements than other local areas, stepped up production
from 39 to 52 percent of capacity prior to November 19,
but dropped back two points in the succeeding week, while
Wheeling plants advanced production .to 66 percent in the
period under review. Most local centers were operating
at better than the national rate in recent weeks.
Steel prices appear to have steadied after the flurry in
mid-October and are subject to only occasional minor shad­
ing of negligible proportions. Announcement was made of
a reduction of $7 per ton on tin plate, from $5.35 to $5.00
per base box. Buying of this product had been held back
pending announcement of prices for the first quarter, but has
been slow appearing since the reduction. Scrap steel prices
have shown strength recently, heavy melting steel at Pitts­
burgh being marked up to $15.50 a ton, the highest in over a
year.
Automobile production is one of the chief supports of the
steel industry, but this is being augmented by demand from
other sources, Government work, and construction projects
furthered by Federal aid. Railroads are taking slightly
more steel than recently, though they still are held back by
lack of funds. Routine purchases of rails for maintenance
work are being delayed; they usually are large at this
season. Some necessary car buying has added to current
demand. Freight car awards in October totaled 2,537, com­
pared with 1,355 a year ago. For ten months they were
NEW COMMERCIAL LOANS AND RATES CHARGED
Fifteen banks in Cleveland-Pittsburgli-Cineinnati
15-day period
............ i

7
6.1 -6 .9
BE WB5SBKK&BHBHI H U S H
6
I 5.1-5.9
5
u n
1
4.1-4.9
4
i 3.1 -3.9
3
i 2.1-2.9
■ 2
i I.I-I.9
a

i

|

NUMBER OF LOANS

1000

750

5 00

250

J

.
0 -9

HI
1

r H
r j
S i

■

B H
|

I NTEREST RATE.
PER CENT

HHHDBS9BBB

MI LLI ONS OF DOLLARS
1

2

3

1
4

THE MONTHLY
only 12,520, contrasted with 51,061 in the same period
of 1937.
Steel ingot production in October amounted to 3,117,934 gross tons, 17.3 percent more than in September. This
was the first month in a year that output exceeded 3,000,000 tons, but it was still eight percent under last year.
The ten months' total this year was 21,123,872 tons, 54
percent less than 45,875,521 tons produced in the same
period of 1937.
October pig iron production totaled 2,067,499 gross tons,
a gain of 22.8 percent over September, and the largest
since October 1937, with 2,891,026 tons. Pig iron output
for the first ten months this year totaled 14,390,284 tons,
against 33,198,634 tons in the 1937 period, a decrease of
56.7 percent, and well below the 24,601,570 tons for 1936.
Seventeen blast furnaces resumed production last month,
the largest addition in any month since April 1936, when
the same increase was reported. Active furnaces at the
end of October totaled 114, the largest number since
November 1937.
Iron ore consumption in October totaled 2,780,585 tons,
an increase of 466,720 tons over September. Stocks on
hand at lower lake docks and furnaces November 1 were
38,593,569 tons, approximately 4,700,000 tons less than on
the same date last year, but sufficient for nearly 14 months
at the current rate of consumption. Total ore shipments
so far this season have been 71 percent smaller than in 1937.
Coal
Bituminous coal production has been
approximately 8,000,000 tons a week re­
cently, compared with approximately
9,000,000 tons a year ago, but then a decline was under
way whereas this fall up to mid-November the gains
made from the summer’s low point have been maintained.
Some of the increased output has gone into inventories
which usually are built up at this season of the year,
although on October 1 total coal above ground was 20
percent less than a year ago. The rise in the third quar­
ter was ten percent, but because of the increase in coal
consumption, these larger actual inventories, in terms of
days’ supply, were 12 percent smaller than in mid-year,
and only one percent above last year at this time. Prac­
tically all of the contraction in coal stocks was in indus­
trial supplies, but total coal on upper lake docks on Octo­
ber 1 was 13 percent less than a year ago. Shipments of
coal from Lake Erie ports in October were within eight
percent of last year, although for the season to November
1 they were off 27.5 percent.




BUSINESS REVIEW
3
Local dealers and producers reported a slightly better
demand and higher prices for industrial grades of coal
in recent weeks, but lagging sales of domestic grades
because of the extended period of mild weather. Fourth
district mines produced 13,197,000 tons of soft coal in
October, a reduction of 14.5 percent from last year. This
compares with a decrease of 31 percent reported for the
first ten months.
Automobiles
October automobile assemblies, as re­
ported by the Department of Commerce,
failed to come up to preliminary trade
production estimates, output for the month being given at
209,522 cars and trucks. This was a sharp, considerably
more than seasonal, gain over the low level of September,
but was still 37 percent below October 1937, despite the
fact that new models were introduced four to six weeks
earlier this year than last.
Reports emanating from the auto industry regarding
both sales and production have been quite optimistic in
recent weeks, a characteristic of this season of the year,
and yet it would appear that the industry so far has not
been able to step up production schedules fast enough
to keep up with the recent demand for new cars. Evi­
dence that new car sales are much improved was found
in the fact that sales to consumers of one large company
in October were the best, on a seasonally adjusted basis,
since October 1937, despite the fact that volume production
of one of that company’s principal models did not occur until
mid-month. New passenger car registrations in leading
counties of this district in October were up somewhat more
than seasonally, despite the fact that new models of several
producers were not available for volume delivery. The de­
cline from last year was smaller than in earlier months of
this year, although about half as many new cars were
registered as in October 1937.
As the new model sales year gets into full swing there
are several factors favorable to the industry that were not
present a year ago. As of October 1, inventory of new
passenger cars was estimated at 107,000. This compared
with 249,000 last year at that time, and a high total of
over 400,000 early in 1937. Used car inventories are also
down quite sharply from last year, though not so drastically
as new car stocks. Moderate price reductions have been
announced. A preliminary survey places them at less than
five percent, but this does not take into consideration
certain accessories included as regular equipment for the
first time. In addition, the new models, at least outwardly,
reveal more changes from the preceding year than was
true of the 1937 models. Other important factors are that
business has been improving for several months, more
persons are being employed, and sentiment is better gen­
erally.
As a result of the favorable acceptance of new models,
dealer reports of larger sales, and reputedly increasing
backlog of orders, the auto industry has stepped up weekly
assembly schedules quite sharply recently with consequent
gains in employment, increased hours (with the greater
part of the industry now operating five days a week for the
first time this year) and larger orders for parts and mate­
rials. This latter is particularly important to the fourtli
district. Employment at Ohio auto parts plants in Octo­
ber was 29 percent greater than in September, but it was
still under a year ago. Recent reports indicate that this

4
THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
discrepancy was materially lessened in November, for in be shipped from control countries in the first quarter of
the second week of the month estimated auto production 1939.
rose above the corresponding period of 1937, and still all
The immediate effect of announcing the larger rubber
models were not yet in full production. Local parts com­ quota for the first quarter was a reduction in domestic
panies reported considerable improvement in new inquiries, prices to slightly below 16 cents a pound for ribbed smoke
orders, and actual shipments in the last half of October, sheets in New York, compared with a recent high of 17.08
with further gains in November. Large steel orders were cents early in November.
placed in October when price concessions prevailed, but Clothing,
While conditions in the clothing and texreleases on other materials and parts in like amounts have Textiles
tile field of this district continue to show
not appeared, according to reports, although it is indicated
improvement basically, both wholesale
that more advance releases have been made recently than for and retail branches of the industry were adversely affected
many months.
by the unusually fine weather this fall. In some cases
Rubber,
The rise in rubber consumption which this represents merely a temporary postponement of pur­
Tires
set in last May was further extended in chases, but in the case of strictly seasonal merchandise
October, and a gain of four percent it is lost so far as this season is concerned. In the local
over last year was recorded. This was the first increase retail field, October sales of men’s wear, women’s clothing,
over the corresponding month of the previous year since particularly coats and suits, and furs were from 25 to 40
May 1937, and the first month in more than a year when percent smaller than a year ago. Sales of dresses and
consumption exceeded 40,000 tons. The improvement in men’s furnishings were down less than 15 percent, and the
the rubber industry developed first as a result of greater re­ decrease in total department store sales was 16.6 percent
placement tire demand. September sales were reported up 30 in this district. Comparison of department store clothing
percent more than seasonal over August. Continuation of stocks with last year revealed little change at the month
good weather in October and the first three weeks of No­ end from September; inventories of men’s clothing being
vember was also reflected in retail sales. This was fur­ down 24 percent, and women’s wear 15 percent from last
ther augmented by greater-than-expected increases in auto year. Clothing buyers were conservative regarding ad­
assembly schedules for November. As a result, the tire vance purchases of fall and winter clothing, and the effect
industry stepped up operations to nearer capacity levels of the retarded retail buying was reflected largely in lessthan for some time. October production, according to the than-usual repeat orders from manufacturers. They in
Rubber Manufacturers' Association, was 4,276,000 cas­ turn had prepared for only a fair winter season, buying
quantities from textile mills last spring so that, de­
ings. This was a gain of eight percent over September limited
spite
the
season, manufacturers’ inventories are small­
and seven percent over 1937. Shipments in the month er than a slow
ago.
again were slightly in excess of output, and manufacturers’ Textile year
firms
buying of spring goods in satisfac­
inventories were 27 percent smaller on October 31 than tory volume withreport
sufficient
orders booked to keep plants
a year previous.
in
operation
well
into
next
year.
Prices have also improved
In addition to gains in employment at rubber factories, and employment has increased. In
men’s clothing in­
evidence of the improvement was to be found in the restora­ dustry, advance orders for spring the
delivery are reported
tion of pay reductions ranging from 10 to 20 percent substantially ahead of last year. Plants
just starting
among salaried rubber workers effective November 16. production on these orders and should be are
at capacity levels
As a result of increased crude rubber consumption in early in December.
the face of curtailed shipments from producing centers, raw Other
Barring seasonal movements, most of the
rubber inventories in this country have been reduced by
industries of the district reported
more than 30,000 tons since April. They are now at the Manufacturing smaller
improvement
In some in­
level of the beginning of the year, although still 35 per­ stances the gains were sufficient into October.
the level of oper­
cent above last year at this time when they were accumu­ ations above last year when declinesraise
were becoming pro­
lating rapidly. At the current rate of consumption there nounced.
is sufficient rubber on hand to last nearly seven months,
Shoe production at fourth district factories declined less
compared with a six-month supply which is considered than
in October from September, despite com­
normal by the industry. With imports showing the full plaintsseasonally
about
the
retarding effect the fine fall weather had
effect of the 55 percent curtailment in exports from pro­ on shoe sales. Output
month was reported to have
ducing centers, tire production expanding, and other uses been 23 percent in excessin ofthelast
year and, excluding 1936,
of rubber increasing, the International Rubber Regulation it was the best October since 1929.
shoe sales at
Committee in mid-November fixed the export quota for department stores were from 11 to 13Retail
percent smaller in
the first quarter of 1939 at 50 percent of the basic quota October than a year ago, but some improvement was re­
instead of 45 percent as at present. This rise in permis­ ported in November as more seasonable weather developed.
sible exports from cartel countries is slight, but at the Shipments from manufacturers showed up similarly. Soli­
same time the basic tonnages of export areas, against which citation of orders for spring delivery is now under way,
quotas are computed, go up on January 1 by about 13 and it is reported that the industry has passed its seasonal
percent. The combination of these two factors will permit low point, for advance orders are encouraging. Raw mate­
a rise in rubber exports for the first quarter of about 25 rial prices were firm until mid-November when weakness
percent over the prevailing level. These figures do not appeared, although they remained higher than at mid-year.
include rubber to be exported from areas not covered Some raw material accumulation in excess of current re­
by the restriction plan, constituting about 10,000 tons a quirements has occurred recently, but inventories are still
month, or about one-sixth of the larger amount which will much smaller than a year ago.



THE MONTHLY
The foreign situation slowed up purchases of machine
tools in this country in October, according to reports, but
a moderate gain in new domestic orders caused a slight rise
in the combined index over September. The index of the
National Machine Tool Builders' Association has shown
little change for three months, but has been at approxi­
mately the highest level of the year, although well below
1937. Purchases of new machine tools by domestic users
have not turned upward in parallel with the rise in the
steel or automobile industries, although some moderate
gains have developed. Foundry equipment orders expanded
ten percent in October over September, but remained less
than half what they were last year at this time, and ship­
ments in the month exceeded new orders.
Buying of small tools, such as drills, etc., also was up
in October over September, but remained under last year
by about 25 percent. Employment was behind by a slightly
larger amount, and some of the recent gain in production
represented replenishment of finished inventories at a mod­
erate rate. Makers of engineering supplies also experienced
a slight increase in demand in October.
China and pottery producers reported a more-than-seasonal gain in both sales and production in recent weeks,
and October sales were said to be ten percent ahead of last
year. Inventories have been further reduced, for holiday
buying has exceeded expectations. There is little complaint
regarding foreign competition. Plate glass production in­
creased quite sharply, chiefly because of rather unexpected
heavy demand from the auto industry, but it still remained
about half what it was a year ago when, because of special
conditions, production remained at a high rate. Large in­
ventories then on hand have been considerably reduced.
Employment in the glass industry in October was 6 per­
cent greater than in September, but still 8 percent under
last year. Glass container and molded glassware branches
of the industry also have experienced an improvement.
Paper and boxboard industry operations receded in midNovember after attaining a level of 83 percent of capacity,
which was about 11 percent above last year at that time.
The recent contraction was partly seasonal, but the usual
inventory accumulation in preparation for holiday demand
did not materialize this fall, partly, it was felt, because
prices were weak in some grades, but also because of the
slowness in retail trade circles.
Unusually fine weather this fall benefited the paint in­
dustry so far as household demand was concerned, but in­
dustrial maintenance sales have lagged. Better general busi­
ness conditions, however, are also resulting in improved




5
industrial paint demand. Raw material inventories are
down from last year despite a rise in tung oil and other
supplies which come from foreign countries.
As result of increased power production and some talk of
expanding facilities of that industry, as well as better retail
sales of electrical goods, the situation in the electrical ap­
paratus and supply industries has improved somewhat.
Actual incoming orders in October were up more than sea­
sonally, and more buying is for future delivery than has
been noticeable for some time. October employment in this
field was up 8 percent over September in Ohio, but was
still somewhat below last year. Pre-Christmas ordering of
electrical appliances by retailers has been heavy.
CONSTRUCTION
As shown by the chart, the construction industry in the
fourth district continues to present a favorable picture.
I'igures compiled by the F. W . Dodge Corporation reveal
that, except for the period in 1937 when contracts for a
large steel plant were let, projects started during August,
September, and October were larger than in any other
three-month period since 1931. Contracts awarded in Oc­
tober were 93 percent higher than in the same month last
year, but this favorable comparison is due to an unusually
low month in 1937 rather than to any recent large gain.
Data for the first half of November indicate that Novem­
ber totals will be only slightly under October, but con­
templated construction reported during October was much
less than that noted during July, August, or September.
Total residential construction, which showed such
marked gains early in the year, has failed to maintain the
high level reached in August. Some slackening in this field
is to be expected as winter approaches, but the decline
from August is due largely to a drop in Federally-financed
miscellaneous projects included in the residential category.
In August, 26 percent of residential contracts were pub­
licly financed, and in September, 6 percent. In October they
were practically all attributable to private activity. This
seems to indicate continued strength in private home build­
ing in this district. An encouraging factor is that build­
ing of one and two family houses in northern Ohio and
western Pennsylvania increased somewhat in October over
September, thus re-establishing the level of activity ex­
perienced during the summer months.
Building costs have continued to be more favorable to
new construction than they were last year, but there is a
slight tendency toward higher material prices, particularly
lumber. The average value of homes being built in central
Ohio is about nine percent smaller than last year. Since
there appears to be no marked change in the type of build­
ings erected, this decrease approximates the year-to-year
reduction in total costs.
Wholesale lumber dealers in the district report that their
October and early November shipments were slightly
larger than last year, but that dollar volume is less. This is
partly due to movement of lower grade material, but rela­
tively low prices are probably more important. Anticipa­
tion of higher prices due to the Wages and Hours Law
caused some increase in orders during October and the
first half of November, but retailers in general are still
buying on a hand-to-mouth basis. The orders booked were
for future delivery, so they have not yet been reflected in
shipments. In southern producing areas many mills have
shut down until the effect of the new law on prices can be
more accurately determined. Dealers report that prices

BUSINESS REVIEW

THE MONTHLY
6
have not yet been affected much except on some scarce
items, although southern pine has advanced over the levels
maintained this summer. In several instances West Coast
woods appear to be replacing yellow pine.
TRADE
Retail
Retail trade in the fourth district during
October was rather uneven. Department
store sales were only slightly larger than
they had been in September, although there were more shop­
ping days in October, and fall buying customarily results in
sales expansion. Hence, the seasonally adjusted index of
department store sales fell to 81.8 percent of the 1923-25
average, losing nearly half of its eight-point gain from Au­
gust to September. This relatively smaller volume is at­
tributed by retailers to unusually warm weather which pre­
vailed throughout October. Returns from weekly reporting
stores indicate that more seasonable wTeather helped sales
in the first three weeks of November, for in the four latest
weeks they were within 7.5 percent of the corresponding
period in 1937.
A poor showing is also revealed by year-to-year com­
parisons for the wearing apparel trade. September sales for
reporting firms in the district were 14.7 percent below the
corresponding month last year, while in October they were
18.3 percent below October 1937.
The experience of other retailers in the district was quite
different from that of department and apparel stores. Ten
percent more groceries were sold by reporting chain stores
in October than in September, and chain drug companies
made a seven percent gain. To a large extent both of these
changes are seasonal, but spreads between this year and 1937
are being narrowed. Sales by chain grocery stores in Oc­
tober were only 0.9 percent below those of a year ago, while
the ten-month cumulative from January through October is
still 3.7 percent less than last year. Chain drug sales were
6.9 percent above last year, while the ten-month cumulative
is 6.4 percent below 1937. Retail furniture dealers sold 19.6
percent less in October than in the same month last year, al­
though their sales for the year so far were 36.7 percent
smaller than in the same period of 1937.
Available data on inventories reveal that retailers are still
pursuing a conservative policy. Although department store
sales failed to make their usual advance in October, this
development did not result in a piling up of inventories. On
a seasonally adjusted basis, department store stocks at the
end of the month were 66.5 percent of the 1923-25 average,
only a half point above the September level, and 16.4 points
under the same date in 1937.
Regular charge sales accounted for 53.6 percent of Oc­
tober total sales reported by department stores in this district.
This was a seasonal decrease from September, but the gen­
eral trend still appears slightly upward. Conditions vary
widely between cities. In Pittsburgh, 61.4 percent of all
sales were charged to customers’ regular accounts, while in
Columbus only 43.6 percent were so handled. October collec­
tions were better in all cities of the district than in the previ­
ous month. They amounted to 46.4 percent of accounts re­
ceivable at the beginning of the month, while the correspond­
ing figure for September was 41.1 percent. Collections on
installment accounts also improved.
Wholesale
According to the Department of Com­
merce, total sales by reporting wholesale
firms in the fourth Federal reserve dis­




BUSINESS REVIEW
trict dropped about 2.5 percent in October from the previous
month. Although sales of retail drug and grocery chains
picked up during October, wholesalers handling these articles
suffered the largest declines. Dealers in automotive sup­
plies, hardware, and lumber, reported substantial gains. The
dip in total sales was a little less than in the same month last
year, so the spread between the two years continued to nar­
row. October sales were 17 per cent behind last year, in­
stead of 19 percent recorded in September. On a city basis,
firms located in Pittsburgh and Cleveland continue to report
the least favorable comparison with last year. In Pittsburgh,
sales were 26 percent under 1937, and in Cleveland 21.6 per­
cent. Lexington, Kentucky, was only 0.8 percent below a year
ago.
Wholesaled inventories increased a very small amount
during October. Collections were a little better than in the
preceding month.
AGRICULTURE
Although price movements are still generally unfavorable
to farmers in this district, the Department of Agriculture re­
ports that cash farm income from both marketings and
Government payments will probably be higher in 1939 than
in 1938. Increased income from marketings is expected to
follow improved consumer demand resulting from better
industrial activity, although business recovery thus far ex­
perienced this fall has merely served to maintain the general
level of agricultural prices at a fairly constant average. Total
cash farm income for 1938 is now estimated at $7,500,000,000,
a decline of 13 percent from 1937 and 6 percent from 1936,
but larger than in any other year since 1929. In this district,
heavier feeding operations and a good price outlook for to­
bacco are expected to increase local farm income this fall
and winter.
Tobacco Burley tobacco harvested in the fourth district this
year appears to be light in weight, but of exceptionally fine
quality. In spite of this lightness, production of all types
of tobacco in the district was estimated by the Department
of Agriculture on November 1 at 122,727,000 pounds, less
than seven percent under last year, and only five percent
below the ten-year average. This amount is much in excess
of this year’s marketing quotas set by the Government. In
Kentucky alone, the burley crop is variously estimated at
from 30,000,000 to 35,000,000 pounds in excess of the Gov­
ernment’s quota. Total burley acreage planted in 1938 was
slightly greater than that planted in 1937 in spite of the
Federal crop-reduction program. Just what effect the mar­
keting quotas announced this spring will have on the selling
of this year’s crop is not yet known, but in areas producing
flue-cured varieties it appears that most of the tobacco has
moved to market in spite of the penalties imposed. These
penalties amount to 50 percent of the selling price of tobacco
marketed in excess of each producer’s quota. In spite of
the large crop and a heavy carry-over from last year,
tobacco men expect prices to hold at about last year’s levels.
Preparation of the crop for market was hampered by
weather conditions in October and the first half of Novem­
ber. Dryness retarded stripping, but some growers brought
their tobacco into condition artificially. In the third week
of November, rainfall was sufficient to bring the tobacco
into shape, and since that time stripping has proceeded
rapidly. There is no indication that weather conditions
have retarded market openings, which are announced for
December 5.

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
7
Wheat Wheat prices during October and the first three
Fourth District Business Statistics
(000 omitted)
weeks of November continued to fluctuate in a very narrow Fourth District Unless
October % change Jan.-Oct. % change
range. Since there has been no marked increase in prices, Otherwise Specified
1938 from 1937
1938
from 1937
$2,170,000
Bank
Debits—
(24
cities)................
— 17.8 $19,981,000
— 22.1
farmers in this district are reported to be feeding a con­ Savings Deposits— end of month
l
siderable amount of their wheat to livestock and poultry.
40 banks, O. and W. P a ...............$ 773,241 + 0.3
Insurance Sales:
For the coming crop year, weather conditions have been Life
Ohio and P a ......................................$ 65,934 — 19.4
— 31.3
663,938
Sales:
quite unfavorable to production. Successive periods of Retail
— 15.8
Dept. Stores— 54 firm s..................$ 21,484 — 16.6
184,322
Wearing Apparel— 12 firms. . . .$
947 — 18.3
7,569
— 16.5
drought and too much moisture prevented seedings from Furniture—
40 firms........................$
787 — 19.6
6,817
— 36.7
being as large as last year even though individual restric­ Building Contracts—
T o ta l............$ 33,089 + 9 3 .1
241,049
— 16.1
“
—
R
esidential.$
7,891
75,855
—
14.5
+
4.5
tive allotments under the Government’s program are yet Commercial Failures— Liabilities.$ 948 — 39.1
10,076
+ 27.3
8022 + 50 .8
“
“ — Number. . .
832 + 2 5 .8
to be announced. Acreage reduction from last year is esti­ Production:
mated to be 11 percent in Ohio and 8 percent in Pennsyl­ Pig Iron— U. S..........................tons 2,067 — 28.5
— 56.7
14,390
Steel Ingot— U. S..................... tons
3,118 — 8.1
21,124
— 54.0
vania. In addition to keeping planting down, the weather Auto—
1,354,6352 — 59.9
Passenger Car— U. S......... 187,4942 — 37.2
374,2162 — 4 9 .9
Trucks— U. S......................... 22,0282 — 29.4
prevented normal development during the fall growing sea­ Auto—
Bituminous Coal, O., W. Pa., E.
son. Lack of moisture in October and early November re­ Cement—
13,197 — 14.5
100,312
— 31.4
— 11.0
O., W. Pa., W. Va. bbls. 1,197 + 5.5
8,081
sulted in undersized plants. Rains during the middle of Elec. Power,
O., Pa., K y..............
12,1594
—
16.6
....................................Thous.
k.w.h.
1,5163
—
5
.2
November improved conditions somewhat, but in most Petroleum— O., Pa., K y ....b b ls. 2,2013 — 10.5
20,1034 — 5 .0
areas the crop is entering winter in a less favorable condi­
+ 2 3 .4
— 9.5
32,069
— 34.8
4,276 + 7.7
tion than is desirable for a good harvest next year.
Bituminous Coal Shipments:
5,247 — 8 .0
29,723
— 27.5
Potatoes Estimates of potato production in this district *. not available
4. Jan.-September.
have been changed very little from those made early in the 2. actual number.
5. Confidential
September.
summer. The latest calculation places output at 20,677,000
bushels, 11 percent above last year and three percent higher
than the ten-year average. Yields vary widely, but in
Debits to Individual Accounts
Ohio are still estimated as averaging 110 bushels per acre.
(Thousands of Dollars)
5

Wholesale and Retail Trade

(1938 compared with 1937)
Percentage
Increase or Decrease
SALES
STOCKS
SALES
October
first 10
October
1938
1938
months
D E P A R T M E N T STORES (54)
— 22.1
— 20.7
Akron.............................................................. — 18.0
— 10.2
— 17.3
Cincinnati..................................................... — 13.3
Cleveland....................................................... — 17.6
— 20. 2
— 16.0
— 15.7
— 9.1
Columbus...................................................... — 9 .6
— 18.9
— 16.8
D ayton........................................................... — 16.6
— 18.4
Pittsburgh..................................................... — 17.6
— 16.6
— 17.7
— 18.5
T oledo............................................................. — 18.1
— 14.1
W heeling........................................................ — 14.8
— 15.5
— 18.2
— 17.8
Other C ities................................................. — 20.7
— 18.5
D istrict........................................................... — 16.6
— 15.8
W EARING APPAREL (12)
— 10.2
— 22.2
Cincinnati..................................................... — 25.6
— 12.6
— 16.1
Cleveland...................................................... — 17.2
— 19.9
— 16.5
Pittsburgh..................................................... — 17.0
— 13.4
D istrict........................................................... — 18.3
— 16.5
FU R N IT U R E (40)
— 4 2 .7
Cincinnati..................................................... — 35.4
C leveland...................................................... — 15.9
— 35.4
— 17.2
Columbus...................................................... — 5.3
— 38.0
D ayton. . . . . . . . ........................................ — 14. 2
— 45.3
Toledo............................................................. — 32.9
— 47.1
Other C ities................................................. — 28.5
— 36.7
D istrict........................................................... — 19.6
CHAIN STORES*
— 6 .4
Drugs— District (4 ).................................. + 3.9
— 3 .7
Groceries— District (4 )........................... — 0 .9
WHOLESALE TR A D E**
— 14.0
— 14.0
Automotive Supplies (1 0 ).................... — 17.6
— 12.6
— 10.3
Drugs (6 )....................................................... — 4 .8
— 25 . 9
— 26.9
Dry Goods (8 )............................................. — 15.7
— 30.7
— 43 .7
Electrical Goods (12).............................. — 36.7
l
l
Farm Products (Consumer Goods) (3) — 11.0
— 13.2
— 15.0
Groceries (59).............................................. — 11.4
i
l
Total Hardware Group (36)................. — 24.2
— 23.3
— 27.7
General Hardware (1 3 ).................... — 21 .0
—20.0
— 47 .6
Industrial Supplies (12)................... — 37.5
—
6.6
— 28.6
Plumbing & Heating Supplies (11) — 19.2
— 21.6
— 38.4
Jewelry & Optical Goods (7 )............ — 30 .7
l
Leather & Shoe Findings (3 )............ — 2.5
Lumber & Building Materials (5 ).. — 25.8
+ 5.5
Meats & M eat Products (5 )............. — 17.3
Paints & Varnishes (3 )......................... — 17.4
Paper & Its Products (8 )...................
— 10.1
+ 6.2
+ 3.1
Tobacco & Its Products (25)............ — 4 .7
+ 0 .3
— 37.1
Miscellaneous (15)........... ........................ — 27.1
— 17.9
— 25.1
District— All Lines (208).....................
— 17.2
*Per individual unit operated.
**W holesale data compiled by U. S. Departm ent of Commerce.
1 N ot available.




5 weeks
ended
Nov. 23,
1938
Akron..................... $ 68,831
Butler.....................
9,393
C anton...................
37,111
C incinnati............ 363,261
Cleveland.............. 636,953
Columbus.............. 190,830
D ayton ..................
71,147
Erie..........................
29,853
Franklin................
3,268
Greensburg..........
7,338
H am ilton..............
12,488
Hom estead............
3,286
Lexington..............
23,656
Lim a.......................
14,951
Lorain.....................
5,122
M iddletow n.........
11,247
Oil C ity.................
11,043
Pittsburgh............ 673,557
9,103
Sharon....................
Springfield............
18,542
10,257
Steubenville.........
T oledo.................... 144,457
W arren...................
10,054
W heeling...............
31,572
Y oungstow n____
48,379
Zanesville..............
9,118
T otal...................$2,454,817

%
change
from
1937
— 19.7
— 20.7
— 20.1
— 9 .3
— 6 .2
— 10.4
— 19.3
— 16.5
— 19.0
— 22.0
— . 6 .9
— 19.4
+ 5 .2
— 9 .9
— 21.5
— 14.3
— 17.5
— 20.8
— 18.8
— 19.8
— 22 .4
— 5 .0
— 13.2
— 12.5
— 11.0
— 4 .0
— 13.1

5

Year to Date Year to Date
Dec. 30, 1937 Dec. 31, 1936
to
to
N ov. 23,1938 Nov. 24, 1937
$ 616,117 $ 762,909
89,774
115,594
321,553
437,416
3,244,032
3,888,984
5,401,794
6,841,623
1,744,940
2,030,063
651,534
828,042
268,466
360.369
30,611
39,327
71,936
82,866
111,612
141,290
30,852
37,834
243,999
260,791
157,191
148,188
60,137
49,346
93,980
121,023
124,634
101,501
6,379,300
8,448,980
103,933
79,636
173,546
208,647
91,337
124,532
“11,147
1,173,857
87,047
115.370
290,092
378,910
583,816
422,159
80,011
91,807
$21,997,220 $27,857,235

change
from
1937
— 19.2
— 22.3
— 26.5
— 16.6
— 21.0
— 14.0
— 21.3
— 25.5
—22.2
— 13.2
— 21.0
— 18.5
— 6 .4
— 5 .7
— 17.9
— 22.3
— 18.6
— 24.5
— 23.4
— 16.8
— 26.7
— 22.3
— 24.5
— 23 .4
— 27.7
12.8

—21.0

—

Fourth District Business Indexes
(1923-25=100)

Bank debits (24 cities)...............................................
Commercial Failures (N um ber)...........................
“
“
(Liabilities)........................
Sales— Life Insurance (O. and P a .)...................
“ — Department Stores (48 firm s).................
“ — Wholesale Drugs (6 firm s).......................
“ —
“
Dry Goods (8 firm s)............
“ —
“
Groceries (59 firm s)............
“ —
“
Hardware (13 firm s)............
“ —
“
All (86 firms)..........................
“ — Chain Drugs (4 firm s)**...........................
Building Contracts (T otal)......................................
“
“ (Residential)..........................
Production— Coal (O., W. Pa., E. K y .)............
— Cement (O., W. Pa., E. K y .). . . .
“
— Elec. Power (O., Pa., K y.)*. . . .
‘‘
— Petroleum (O., Pa., K y .)*............
— Shoes.......................................................
*September.
**Per individual unit operated.

Oct. Oct. Oct. Oct. Oct.
1938 1937 1936 1935 1934
77
64
97
94
80
53
43
57
31
45
22
35
31
25
15
89
92
69
90
90
79
87 104
72
98
94
114 119 113
85
62
69
61
50
52
71
80
84
82
74
69
80
80 102 106
74
86
89
79
70
94
86
74
98
98
36
47
58
22
69
59
14
46
44
44
77
68
73
85
98
94 109
74
59
100
181 190 180 154 132
119 133 125 110 106
112
90 118
98
74

8

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

Sum m ary of National Business Conditions

By the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System
Industrial production continued to increase sharply in October and
the first three weeks of November, reflecting principally larger output
of steel and automobiles. Wholesale commodity prices showed little
change in this period. Volume of employment and national income in­
creased in October.
Production
In October the Board’s seasonally adjusted index of industrial pro­
duction was at 96 percent of the 1923-1925 average, as compared with 90
percent in September. Steel ingot production increased considerably, aver­
aging 53 percent of capacity in October, and in the first three weeks of
November there was a further substantial advance. In the automobile
industry output was increased rapidly during October and the first three
weeks of November both to stock dealers with new model cars and to meet
the increased volume of retail demand accompanying the introduction of
Index of physical volum e of production,
new models. Production, which in the first nine months of 1938 had been
adjusted for seasonal variation, 1923-25
at a considerably lower level, was at nearly the same rate as in the cor­
average = 100. By months, January 1934
to October 1938. Latest figure October 96.
responding period in other recent years. Output of plate glass also in­
creased sharply further in October. Cement production showed a con­
siderable increase, while lumber production declined slightly.
Activity at textile mills, which had risen sharply during the sum­
mer, continued at about the August and September rate, although usu­
ally there is an increase at this time of the year. Shoe production
declined somewhat further in October, and there was a decrease in out­
put of tobacco products, while in most other industries manufacturing
nondurable goods changes in output were largely seasonal in character.
Mineral production showed a further moderate rise, reflecting in large
part increased output of crude petroleum and nonferrous metals. Lake
shipments of iron ore also were in larger volume, although a decrease
is usual in October. Coal production increased seasonally.
Value of construction contracts awarded in 37 Eastern States in­
creased considerably in October, according to figures of the F. W. Dodge
Corporation, reflecting chiefly a sharp rise in awards for public projects.
Contracts for hospital, educational, and other public buildings included
Revised indexes of number employed and
in the Public Works Administration program were in large volume, and
payrolls, without adjustm ent for seasonal
variation, 1923-25 average = 100. By
there was a further increase in contracts awarded for slum clearance
months, January 1934 to October 1938.
projects
of the United States Housing Authority.
Indexes compiled by the United States
Bureau of Labor Statistics. Latest figure
Employment
Employment 89.5, Payrolls 83.7.
Employment and payrolls increased somewhat further between the
middle of September and the middle of October. At automobile factories
employment continued to rise sharply and there were further moderate
increases in most other durable goods industries. The number employed
at canning establishments declined and in other nondurable goods in­
dustries showed little change. Employment increased somewhat at mines,
on the railroads, and in the construction industry, while in trade the
rise was less than seasonal.
Distribution
Sales at department and variety stores and by mail order houses
showed less than the usual seasonal increase in October, partly because
consumer buying of winter merchandise was retarded by unseasonably
warm weather during most of the month. In the first two weeks of
November department store sales increased moderately.
Freight-car loadings rose considerably further in October, owing
largely to increased shipments of grains, coal, and miscellaneous freight.
In the first half of November loadings showed a seasonal decline.
Indexes compiled by the United States Bu­
Commodity Prices
reau of Labor Statistics, 1926 = 100. By
weeks, 1934 to week ending November 10,
Wholesale commodity prices generally showed little change from the
1938. Latest figure 77.3.
middle of October to the third week of November. Prices of steel scrap
and leather advanced. Tin plate prices, on the other hand, were reduced,
and there were also decreases in zinc, hides, and rubber. Prices of farm
products and foods showed small fluctuations in this period.
Bank Credit
Total loans and investments at reporting member banks in 101 lead­
ing cities declined by about $150,000,000 during the first half of November
following a substantial increase during October. The decline in Novem­
ber was almost entirely at New York City banks and reflected the re­
tirement of State and local government obligations held by these banks.
Adjusted demand deposits, which reached an all-time peak of $16,000,000,000 at reporting banks in the last week in October, also decreased some­
what in the first half of November. Member bank reserves in the mid­
dle of November were at about the high level reached a month earlier.
Money Rates and Bond Yields
The prevailing rate on open-market commercial paper declined slightly
in November to % of 1 percent, a new low level. Other short-term openW ednesday figures of total member bank
reserve balances at Federal reserve banks,
market rates were unchanged. Yields on U. S. Government securities and
with estim ates of required and excess re­
on high-grade corporate bonds showed only small changes during Novem­
serves. January 3, 1934 to November 23,
ber, continuing close to the low levels reached in October.
1938.
IN D U STR IA L PRODUCTION