View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
Covering financial, industrial, and agricultural conditions
in the
Fourth Federal Reserve District
Federal Reserve Bank o f Cleveland
Vol. 13

Changes in trade and industrial conditions in the Fourth
District in the past month have been limited. Some im­
provement of a seasonal nature was reported in most lines,
but in the more important ones changes were smaller than
for similar periods of preceding years, so adjusted indexes
touched new low levels for the current depression.
A waiting attitude is displayed in most industries, and
though sentiment improved follow ing the announcement
of the new credit plan, and inquiries received by manu­
facturers indicate that stocks are low, as yet they have
not been transformed into actual orders in any volume.
Unit inventories at the end o f the third quarter were re­
ported 20 per cent lower than a year ago and the dollar
value down 25 per cent.
W holesale sales in all reporting lines in this District
showed greater-than-seasonal improvement in September,
and stocks at department stores advanced after allowing
for seasonal changes. The upturn raised the stock index
from 71.7 in August to 74.7 per cent o f the 1923-1925
monthly average, the first sizeable increase in many months.
Building activity, though in very limited volume, in­
creased more than seasonally in September, but fell off
sharply in the first half of October. Life insurance sales
in Ohio and Pennsylvania were ten per cent smaller in
September than a year ago.
Shoe production declined by less than the usual sea­
sonal amount and output in September in this District
exceeded the same month last year by ten per cent and
in the first nine months was slightly larger than in the
corresponding period of 1930.
In the manufacturing industries iron and steel produc­
tion changed but little, instead of increasing seasonally.
Expanding inquiries were reported in several fields in late
October, but actual orders are still limited. Automobile
production has reached a very low level, partly, it is under­
stood, in preparation for new model introduction. Opera­
tions at parts and accessory, hardware, and machine tool
plants remain at low levels, chiefly because o f the slump
in the automobile industry.
During the past few weeks there have been a number
o f bank suspensions in this District and the demand for
currency has increased further, although recently the rate
o f increase has diminished somewhat. This added demand
for currency, together with the reduction in the country’s
stock o f monetary gold follow ing Great Britain’s suspen­
sion o f gold payments, has resulted in an exceptionally
rapid increase in demand for Reserve bank credit, both for




No. 11

Cleveland, Ohio, November 1, 1931

this District and for the country as a whole. A t member
banks loans and deposits have been reduced sharply in
the past few weeks.
The month proved very favorable for the maturing and
harvesting o f agricultural crops. Prices on these comm odi­
ties declined in September, but increased in the first three
weeks of October. Other wholesale prices also advanced
slightly in the latter period.
FINANCIAL.
During the past month there was a sharp increase in
the amount of Reserve bank credit outstanding as demand
for currency expanded. Deposits at member banks de­
clined and loans and investments were reduced quite
sharply. There were numerous bank suspensions recent­
ly in several sections o f the District.
Follow ing the suspension of the gold standard by the
Bank o f England and the conversion into gold (earmarked
or exported) of short time funds o f other nations held in
New York in an amount exceeding $600,000,000, money
rates throughout the country were increased from the ab­
normally low levels to which they had declined in the
early months o f this year.
The discount rate of the
Federal Reserve Bank o f Cleveland was advanced from
2 y2 to 3 per cent on October 10, and to 3% per cent on
October 24. Rates reported by large commercial banks in
mid-October showed a slight upward tendency.
Savings deposits at 55 selected banks on September 30
amounted to $1,022,090,000, a reduction in the month of
two per cent and from the same date last year of 6.3 per
cent. The declines were quite well distributed.
Bank
debits, though showing some seasonal improvement in the
four weeks ended October 21, were 21.5 per cent below
the same period o f last year and for the year to date down
20 per cent.
Commercial failures in this section increased slightly
from August and were 11.5 per cent more numerous than
in September, 1930. In the first nine months there were
12 per cent more failures than in the same period o f 1930.
Liabilities o f the defaulting concerns were smaller than
in other recent months, but were still much larger than a.
year ago.
Reserve Bank Credit. Changes in assets and liabilities
o f the Federal Reserve Bank o f Cleveland in the past few
weeks have been more rapid than in any similar period
o f the bank’s history. In other years at this season gold
reserves o f this bank have declined, but the falling-off has

2

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

not been as sharp as in the period just passed. Since
September 9 gold reserves have declined $73,386,000, or
21 per cent, and at $272,190,000 on October 21, were lower
than since February, 1930. One year ago they were $302,6 6 6 ,0 0 0 .

Total credit extended, as shown on the accompanying
chart, has increased very rapidly. At $22 3,052,0 00 on
October 21, it was higher than since 1921, when this bank
was still rediscounting for other Federal reserve banks.
In ten weeks total bills and securities rose about $125,000,000, an unprecedented expansion.
Holdings of Government securities increased slightly
in the past month, but the change was insignificant com­
pared with the expansion in discounts and acceptances.
Bills discounted for members banks in this District,
representing credit extended directly to banks in this sec­
tion, increased from $31,890,000 on September 16, to
$92,465,000 on October 21. On the latest date they were
higher than since December, 192 9, and compared with
$27,049,000, on the corresponding date last year.
Though holdings of bankers’ acceptances usually in­
crease at this season of the year, the expansion in the four
weeks ended October 21 was much greater than seasonal.
Purchases of acceptances are made chiefly through the
Open Market Committee at New York, where demand for
credit, arising from unprecedented gold movements and
expansion in currency circulation, was greater than usual
for this season. Acceptances held by this bank on October
21 were valued at $57,566,000, compared with $17,672,000
on September 23, and $2 0,102,000 one year ago. They
were higher than since December, 1922.
As in the entire country, demand for currency continued
to increase, though judged by note circulation of the
Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland, the rate o f expansion
in the second and third weeks o f October was at a lower
rate than in the three preceding weeks. Note circulation
on October 21 was $295,914,000, as against $250,159,000
a month earlier and $182,493,000, a year ago. It was
higher than since March, 1921, and was 62 per cent above
one year ago, despite the fact that the volume of busi­
ness done and prices have fallen materially in th® past
twelve months.
As deposits at member banks declined, reserve deposits
dropped accordingly, and at $157,275,000 on October 21,




they were 21 per cent below one year ago, and lower
than for any week since the middle of 1924.
Member Bank Credit. At reporting member banks in
leading cities sharp reductions in both demand and time
deposits in the past month were accompanied by a fallingoff in loans, chiefly those secured by collateral, and in­
vestments. In the four weeks ended October 21, total
deposits declined eight per cent, and on the latest date
were lower than since early 1927. In the same period total
credit extended was reduced by about five per cent, loans
falling three per cent and investments eight per cent.
The follow ing table shows changes in the past year in
loans and investments at all member banks in the Fourth
District, based on the September 29, 19 31, reports of con­
dition.
A L L M EM BER B A N K S — FO U R T H D ISTRIC T
(In M illions o f D ollars)
Reserve City Banks
C ountry Banks
Per cent
P er cent
change fro m
change from
Sept.
June
Sept.
Sept.
June
Sept.
30,
29,
24,
29,
30,
24,
1931
1931
1930
1931
1931
1930
T otal Loans & Inv. 2,004
— 6.1
— 7.5
1,200
— 11.9
— 2.9
Loans & Discounts 1,222
— 5.0
— 11.6
791
— 13.9
— 4.3
Investments.
440
127
U. S. Govt. Sec.
— 7.6
+ 9.8
-f-13.3
+ 1 0 .8
342
A ll other inv....
— 7.8
— 11.1
282
— 5.1
— 14,3
Num ber o f banks
35
— 5,4
— 2.6
— 16.7
664
— 8.4

The decline in the number of banks has been propor­
tionately greater in the past year in the Reserve cities
than in the smaller centers of the District, but the con­
traction in credit extended has been greater at country
banks.
Compared with June, the reduction has been
more drastic at Reserve city banks.
Despite the decline in number, investments in Govern­
ment securities at country banks were larger in Septem­
ber than in June or a year ago, but holdings o f other
securities were down. At the Reserve city banks, Gov­
ernment securities owned were lower than in June, but
ten per cent higher than a year ago.
MANUFACTURING, MINING
Iron and
Steel

Steel production, for both the country
as a whole and the Fourth District, in
the month ended October 15 broke
through previous lows of this depression. F or the entire
country the steel rate sagged from 33 per cent to 28;

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
Youngstown declined from 41 to 30 per cent, Pittsburgh
from 29 to 25; Cleveland stepped up from 29 to 35 per
cent— inadequate to neutralize the losses at Pittsburgh
and Youngstown.
This easing production reflected quite accurately the
consuming situation. Not only has the expected postLabor Day pick-up failed to materialize, but the markets
experienced a distinct dip. This further curtailment cut
across all products, and, despite current low operating
rates, unfilled orders declined in September.
For the Fourth District, the failure o f the automobile
industry to swing into substantial production in October
was particularly disappointing.
As one after another
manufacturer postponed production schedules on new
models the late fall buying o f automotive steel was putoff, precipitating the post-Labor Day slump. Nevertheless,
in mid-October there were signs that the necessity of pro­
ducing new models for dealers* stocks and January shows
would provide the industry with the equivalent of four
fair production weeks, and sentiment in the Mahoning
Valley was measurably better.
Statistics on pig iron production in September were
mildly encouraging in that for the first time since April
there was an actual gain in the number o f steelworks
stacks in blast, and the net decline in total active stacks
— which was one— was the smallest since April. Likewise,
the fall in the daily rate was the smallest since May.
September’s daily rate was 38,321 gross tons, compared
with 41,264 tons in August and 75,893 tons in September,
1930. In nine months, total output was 15,004,243 tons,
against 25,745,000 tons in the same period o f 1930.
Seventy-four stacks were in blast at the end o f September.
Steel ingot output, on a daily basis, like pig iron, was
the smallest since September, 1921.
At 59,523 gross
tons daily, open-hearth and bessemer output was at 28.02
per cent o f capacity. The nine-month total for steel out­
put stands at 20,411,736 tons; a year ago it was 39,286,287 tons.
Reflecting more weakness in pig iron than in finished
steel, the iron and steel composite of Steel declined
from $31.04 in mid-September to $30.78 by mid-October.
Coal

Buying o f coal for household use has
been retarded by the unusually warm
weather, and dealers reported that sales
in September and the first half o f October did not show
a seasonal upturn comparable with other years. The low
level o f industrial operations also has made it difficult to
market fine steam coals. Prices were slightly higher in
September than in the preceding month, but were below
last year.
Production of bituminous coal in this District in Septem­
ber was 12,300,000 tons, an increase of 2.4 per cent from
August, about the average seasonal expansion of the past
six years. Compared with a year ago, output was down
21 per cent and in the first nine months 18 per cent less
coal was mined than in the same period o f 1930.
Part o f the reduced output o f local mines was a result
o f smaller demand for coal to be shipped to the upper
lake ports. Loadings of coal at Lake Erie ports in the
season to October 1 were only 23,429,000 tons, a drop
of 21.6 per cent from the same period o f last year.




Automobiles

Continued weakness was apparent in the
automobile industry in September and
the first three weeks o f October. Cram’s
estimated output in the week o f October 17 was 23,570
units. This was slightly more than half as large as a
month ago and compared with 36,462 units in the cor­
responding week last year. Each week since the middle
o f August declines have been larger than the estimated
seasonal amount and the Annalist adjusted index has
receded from about 65 per cent of computed normal in
the first seven months o f this year to 32 per cent in the
week o f October 17.
The reduction was partly due to a falling-off in retail
sales in September. In that month they were estimated
at 118,000 units, while output in the same period was
140,566 units, according to the Department o f Commerce.
Manufacturers also were curtailing output in an ef­
fort to reduce stocks o f present models before starting
production on cars to be introduced at the January shows.
Compared with a year ago, automobile production was
off 36 per cent and the drop from August was much
greater than seasonal. The adjusted index receded from
52 per cent of the 192 3-1925 average in August to 40 in
September. Passenger car production was 109,087 units in
September and 1,762,206 in the first nine months, a fall­
ing off of 38 and 28 per cent from the corresponding
periods of 1930. Truck production was down 29 per
cent in September and 23 per cent in the first three quar­
ters compared with similar periods o f last year.
Local steel mills and parts and accessory factories have
reduced operations further as specifications on material
needed for new model production have been moved for­
ward by one company after another.

Tires,
Bubber

Activity at rubber plants declined in
September, as revealed by employment
figures o f 24 concerns reporting to the
Ohio State Bureau o f Business Research, and rubber con­
sumption figures. The one per cent decline in the num ­
ber employed from August to September compared with
an average reduction o f two per cent for that period
o f the past five years, but in the latest month there were
16 per cent fewer employed than a year ago. Consump­
tion o f crude rubber dropped 14 per cent from August
to September, as against an average drop o f 11 per cent
for that period o f past years.
The latest available production figures cover August
and show a falling-off o f 21 per cent from July. This
was greater than seasonal, as was the drop from June
to July. A remarkable upturn in tire production was
shown in the first six months o f this year, after allow­
ing for seasonal variations, but since mid-year a greaterthan-seasonal decline has been apparent. In thi* con­
nection inventories did not show as large an increase in
the first half o f 1931 as in other recent years, but they
declined in July and August as shipments exceeded pro­
duction. Compared with a year ago, stocks in August
were down 18 per cent. August tire production was six
per cent below the same month last year and in the first
eight months was off 2.8 per cent.
Prices o f tires have declined 12 per cent in the past
year, according to the United States Department o f Labor.

4

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

Crude rubber has dropped 46 per cent in the same time
and raw cotton has declined about 40 per cent in the
period.
The present low price of crude rubber is due to the
abnormally large supply in relation to consumption. Do­
mestic stocks o f crude rubber on September 30 were
254,324 long tons, an increase of 50 per cent in the past
year and of 5.6 per cent during the month. A t current
consumption rates (23,638 tons in September) this rep­
resented nearly 11 months’ supply, compared with about
seven months’ supply on hand last year and three and
one-half months’ supply in 1929.
The large stocks and very low prices seem to have
little effect on imports, which during September, at 40,505
tons, exceeded the same month last year by 2.6 per cent.
In the first nine months imports were 358,104 tons, a
drop of 5.3 per cent from the same period of 1930.
Clothing

The clothing industry in this District
showed little change in September, and
manufacturers are awaiting the arrival
o f cooler weather with the hope that some increased de­
mand might be experienced. Unusually warm weather
this fall has retarded buying, and reorders of merchan­
dise have been very limited despite the fact that whole­
sale sales were not large when the fall and winter sam­
ples were first displayed.
The showing o f next spring’s goods has just started,
but manufacturers do not anticipate a large volume of
advance orders since little buying o f this type has been
done for some time. Dealers prefer to wait until the
season opens before ordering the bulk o f their goods.
Prompt delivery on such orders has done away with much
advance purchasing.
Demand for knitted dresses and suits this fall has
been very good and knitting mills have been operating
at normal levels, or better. Orders in some cases have
exceeded last year by a good margin.
Textile mills are still feeling the effect o f the late show­
ing on spring goods, and customers are buying in only
limited quantities, it was reported.
Employment at 46 clothing and textile concerns in
this territory was unchanged in September compared with
August, but was five per cent lower than a year ago.
In
the past five years the average August-to-September in­
crease was two per cent. Men's clothing factories have
been operating at relatively better rates than concerns
making wom en’s apparel.
At the former, the number
employed in September was one per cent larger than a
year ago.
W ool consumption in the entire country in the first
eight months o f 1931 (the latest available) was 23 per
cent greater than in the same period o f the preceding
year.
Other
Manufacturing

Many irregularities are still apparent in
general manufacturing lines o f the Dis­
trict, though changes in the past month
have been small, indicating that most concerns are mark­
ing time. Employment at 728 manufacturing plants
dropped one per cent in August, a contrary-to-seasonal
movement. Three groups o f companies, chemical, food
and paper, reported a seasonal improvement. Shoe pro­




duction in September exceeded the same month last year.
Inquiries are reported in several industries, but orders,
as yet, are not forthcom ing in any volume.
Clay Products. Conflicting trends were apparent in
the various branches o f this industry in September. Em­
ployment at 73 concerns declined one per cent from Au­
gust to September, in contrast with a five-year average
August-to-September increase o f the same amount. Thirtyfour companies reported increases, however, and six no
change, but this was more than offset by decreases at 33
plants. Makers o f window glass reported a contraryto-seasonal drop in demand in the first part o f October.
Makers o f glass containers experienced a seasonal drop
in orders, but for the year, operations have been in quite
satisfactory volume. Brick and tile production is still
in very limited volume, though some slight improvement
was reported in September by one large manufacturer.
Electrical Supplies. Some seasonal improvement in or­
ders was experienced in the first part o f October, though,
in most cases, they were for limited quantities. One con­
cern showed a 15 per cent increase in the first ten days
o f October, compared with the same period o f the pre­
ceding month.
Employment at 32 reporting plants was
one per cent less in September than a year ago, but was
three per cent below August.
Hardware, Machinery. The number o f inquiries re­
ceived indicate to makers o f machine tools, etc., that man­
ufacturers are in need o f new equipment, but actual or­
ders are still developing very slowly. Failure of the au­
tom obile industry to expand production had a particu­
larly bad effect on this industry. Employment at ma­
chine tool factories dropped nine per cent in September,
while in the past five years a slight im provem ent was
experienced in the period. Makers o f foundry products
and drop forgings showed a five per cent contraction in
employment in September, with the number o f men work­
ing 26 per cent below last year.
Metal Containers, Products. Miscellaneous metal con­
tainers were still reported in good demand, but fruit and
other packing business has been completed. Makers of
stoves and furnaces showed a seasonal increase in opera­
tions in September, but were employing ten per cent fewer
men than a year ago.
Paint. General conditions in the paint industry have
changed but little in the past month. Demand for prod­
ucts is spasmodic and irregular. W orking forces have
not changed for several months. Orders during the next
few months will be chiefly for spring delivery, but cus­
tomers show little desire to anticipate demand.
Paper. Consumption o f boxboard as containers has
been about equal to a year ago, but writing paper de­
mand is rather irregular. This latter branch o f the in­
dustry is operating at about 70 per cent o f capacity. Prices
on medium grade papers have been reduced from ten to 30
per cent. Compared with a year ago the number em­
ployed in September was down seven per cent.
Shoes. W arm weather curtailed shoe sales in Septem­
ber and buying was irregular. Demand for cheap shoes
has been fair, though better grades have been moving
slowly. Output o f 27 establishments in September was
11.2 per cent below August, a seasonal change, but ex­
ceeded production in September, 1930, by ten per cent.

5

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
The increase was sufficient to show a gain in production
in the first nine months, the improvement being 0.2 per
cent. In the entire country September output exceeded
that o f August. Factories have difficulty gauging de­
mand, since most orders are for rush shipments and only
for a few pairs o f certain lines at a time.

cent. W ith the exception o f drugs, the declines in sales
in the other lines in the first nine months closely approxi­
mated the September percentages.
Hardware and grocery stocks expanded slightly in Sep­
tember, but all lines reported stocks much below one year
ago. Collections have been only “ fair.”

TRADE

BUILDING

Retail Trad©

In September the dollar value o f retail
trade, as revealed by reports from 56
large department stores in the Fourth
District, was 17.6 per cent less than in the same month
of 1930. The increase from August, 18.5 per cent, was
just about the usual seasonal amount and the daily av­
erage, seasonally adjusted index stood at 79.4 per cent
of the 1923-1925 monthly average. Sales in the first nine
months were 10.7 per cent smaller in value than in the
same interval o f 1930.
In the individual cities some wide variations in sales
were evident. Akron stores reported an increase in sales
in September, compared with a year ago, o f two per
cent. A ll other cities revealed declines ranging from five
per cent at Cleveland, and 14 per cent at Columbus, to
22 per cent at Cincinnati, 23 per cent at W heeling, 26
per cent at Pittsburgh and Toledo, and 29 per cent at
Youngstown. Proportionately more sales were for cash
in September than a year ago, the ratio o f credit to total
sales being 59 per cent, a reduction o f eight per cent
from the same month o f 1930.
The retail value o f stocks at department stores in­
creased substantially in September for the first time in
many months, after allowing for seasonal variations. The
adjusted index advanced from 71.7 per cent o f the 19231925 monthly average in August to 74.7 in September.
The percentage increase in stock value was 13.4 per cent,
while the average seasonal increase is about nine per
cent.
Collections fell in September, the percentage o f col­
lections on accounts receivable on August 31 being only
27.7 per cent. This was a reduction o f about 11 per
cent from the corresponding month o f last year.
Sales at wearing apparel stores were 26 per cent be­
low one year ago and at furniture stores were off 25
per cent. Chain grocery sales, per individual unit op­
erated, were six per cent smaller in September and down
four per cent in the first nine months. Chain drug sales
were off eight and three per cent in the corresponding
periods.

As in the entire country, construction activity in the
Fourth District in September showed greater-than-seasonal
improvement from August. The gain, 11 per cent, com ­
pared with an average August-to-September increase in
the past eight years of nine per cent. Despite this slight
improvement, building continues in very limited volume,
total Fourth District awards being valued at $19,342,000
in September, a loss o f 44 per cent from the same month
last year. According to the F. W . Dodge Corporation, the
decline in the third quarter and also the first nine months
o f 1931, from corresponding periods o f 1930, was 43 per
cent. This loss in both periods was much more drastic
than that shown for the 37 eastern states, where the third
quarter loss was 26 per cent and for the first nine months
was only 30 per cent.
In the third quarter the decline was well distributed
among the three m ajor groups. Non-residential building
suffered a loss o f 49 per cent from the third quarter of
1930; civil engineering was off 40 per cent and residen­
tial building was low er by 36 per cent.
In the first nine months of this year the follow ing de­
clines from the like period of 1930 were shown in the
value of principal types of building: commercial build­
ings, 60 per cent; factories, 59 per cent; educational
buildings, six per cent; religious and memorial buildings,
46 per cent; social and recreational facilities, 60 per
cent; residential building, 36 per cent; and civil engineer­
ing, 39 per cent.
In the first half of October a decided falling-off was
apparent in this section, total awards amounting to only
$6,356,600, compared with $47,913,500 in the entire
month o f October, 1930. Outlook for the remainder of
this year is not very promising, for, contemplated projects
reported in September were valued at $24,239,500, com ­
pared with $69,171,200 in the same month last year.
Building supplies are being sold at low prices in very
limited volume. The Aberthaw index of building costs
dropped slightly in the third quarter and was lower than
since 1922.
AGRICULTURE

Wholesale
Trade

Estimates o f principal Fourth District crops were re­
vised upward again in September, chiefly a result o f very
favorable growing weather and lack o f frost, and so far
as acreage yields are concerned, the District has expe­
rienced one o f the most favorable seasons on record.
The improvement was quite general throughout the en­
tire country, the month being the warmest September on
record, but conditions in several sections, particularly the
West and Northwest where there has been a dearth of
rainfall, are less favorable than in this locality.
The prevailing low level of prices, however, is very
discouraging, and despite the larger yields than were
reported a year ago, gross income o f farmers no doubt
will be under the average o f past years. The United
States Department o f Agriculture reported farm prices

A ll reporting lines o f wholesale trade
showed an expansion in sales from Au­
gust and in every case the improvement
was greater than the average August-to-September in­
crease o f the preceding seven years. Grocery sales were
up 13.2 per cent compared with a seven-year average in­
crease of 7.6 per cent; hardware firms showed an up­
turn of 9.4 per cent against an average change of 8.4;
dry goods sales advanced 22 per cent, while in the pre­
ceding years the improvement was 16 per cent; and drug
sales were 7.5 per cent larger in September than in Au­
gust, compared with an average change o f 4.5 per cent.
Large reductions from a year ago were reported in
dollar sales. Groceries were down 18 per cent; drugs
13 per cent; hardware 21 per cent and dry goods 28 per




6

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

in Septemer as only 72 per cent of the five-year pre-war
average, compared with 111 a year ago, and 143 in Au­
gust, 1929, the most recent high point.
The decline in the past year has been 35 per cent, the
greater part of which was due to a 50 per cent reduc­
tion in grain prices, a 44 per cent drop in fruits and vege­
tables and a 43 per cent decline in cotton and cotton­
seed prices. Livestock prices were down 33 per cent in
the period and dairy and poultry prices fell 24 per cent.
In contrast to the trend in prices o f most other farm
products, dairy and poultry prices advanced in Septem­
ber, butter prices increasing 11 per cent. Dairy and
poultry prices, at 93 per cent o f the pre-war average, were
at an exceptionally high level when compared with prices
of most grains, which were at 50 per cent of the pre-war
average.
The fall in farm prices has been much more drastic
in the past year than in most other commodities, as is
shown by the accompanying chart. Prices of all comm odi­
ties have declined 18 per cent, foods 18 per cent, and
other commodities 13 per cent in the period. Compared
with two years ago, the reduction in farm prices is even
sharper, for, from the spring of 1927 to 1930, prices o f
farm products were higher than other commodities. Prices
of commodities bought by farmers have declined in the
past year, but the ratio o f prices received for crops to
prices paid for goods dropped from 76 per cent o f the
five-year average in September, 1930, to 57 in Septem­
ber, 1931.
Very low prices, particularly for grains, have had some
effect on the acreage o f winter wheat farmers intended
to sow this fall. F or the entire country farmers reported
that they intended to plant 12 per cent less acreage to
wheat this fall than was actually seeded last year. In
the past eight years actual seedings have been three per
cent below reported intentions. In Ohio, farmers intended
to plant 11 per cent less wheat than was planted in the
fall of 1930, but weather conditions always have some
bearing on the actual sowings.
Corn. The estimate o f corn production was revised
upward in September, output for the District now being
put at 209,087,000 bushels. This was nearly twice as
large as the very small crop of 1930, and was over 12
per cent above the 1925-29 average. W ith no serious
frosts in September, the crop matured well and yield
promises to be close to the highest on record.
Corn
Yield per A cre (B u.)
October 1 Condition (P er cent)
10-year
10-year ave. Indicated
ave.
1931
1930
1920-29 Oct. 1, 1931 1920-29
56
81
45
39
Ohio .............................. ...92
45
SI
51
42
Pennsylvania ...............94
Kentucky .......................92
39
80
33
27
W est V irgin ia ...............90
39
83
86
34
U nited States ...............71.4
58.3
77.0
25.6
28.0

The above table shows that the October 1 condition o f
corn in states o f the District was much better than the
average o f past years and the entire country. Acreage
yields also were higher.
Oats. The October 1 estimate of oat production in
this District was revised upward by nearly 3,000,000
bushels, but at 75,111,000 bushels, it compared with a
five-year average harvest of 89,171,000 bushels, a reduc­
tion o f 16 per cent. A smaller than average oat crop
was reported in many sections o f the country, partly on




account o f unfavorable weather, and partly because o f
a reduction in acreage planted.
A ccording to the Department o f Agriculture, supplies
of feed grains (corn, oats, barley, and grain sorghum s)
for the entire country for the 1931-32 season are slightly
below average, but much in excess o f those available last
year, while the supplies o f hay are less than a year ago
and below average. The deficiency o f feed grains is partly
offset by the increased feeding o f wheat, which, at present
prices, is more profitable than some other grains.
The
supply o f hay in this District is much larger than a year
ago, but is slightly below the five-year average.
Potatoes. The condition o f potatoes in the Fourth Dis­
trict improved perceptibly in September, the October 1
production estimate, 19,689,000 bushels, being about 2,000,000 bushels higher than a month earlier and over
4,000,000 bushels larger than last year’s crop, but slightly
below the five-year average harvest. In Ohio the crop was
above average, but in the other three states smaller-thanaverage crops were reported.
Fruits. Little change in fruit estimates occurred in
September, though grapes were yielding higher than was
at first expected, and much better than last year or av­
erage. The Ohio crop is now estimated at 31,500 tons,
against a five-year average of 21,740 tons. The Pennsyl­
vania crop is reported to be 24,840 tons, compared with
18,004 tons in the five years 1925-29.
The apple estimates remain unchanged from a month
ago, but the drop has been large and the fruit is small
where trees are overloaded. W ith the crop one of the
largest in recent years, prices are low, both for fresh
fruit and cider stock.
Tobacco

The estimate o f tobacco production in
this District was increased by over 5,000,000 pounds in September, and on
October 1 was 195,344,000 pounds, nearly 40,000,000
pounds larger than the record harvest o f last year, and
about 50 per cent greater than the average harvest in
the five years 1925-29. The crop was all cut under fa­
vorable weather conditions and curing is progressing
nicely. According to present indications, the quality o f
the crop promises to be exceptionally good, since weather
during the entire season has been ideal. Yields are ex­
pected to be the highest on record, for acreage under
cultivation was only 13 per cent larger than a year ago
in the burley sections which are the most important pro-

7

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
ducing areas o f this District.
There has been a large demand for old-crop smoking
tobacco and cigarette grades, with only very limited quan­
tities appearing now and then. Tobacco now available
is practically all o f poor quality.
Interest now centers on the opening o f the selling sea­
son, which w ill occur next month, and the prices most
likely to be paid. Opening sales in eastern Carolina were
rather large, but o f rather poor quality and the average
price was around 8 % cents a pound.
H om estead....

Fourth District Business Statistics
Fourth District Unless
Otherwise Specified

(000 omitted)
Sept.,
% change Jan-Sept., % change
1931
from 1930
1931
from 1930

Bank Debits— 24 cities................. 3 2,268,000
— 21.3
Savings Deposits— end of month:
28 selected banks, O., W. Pa... .3
— 4.1
719,212
Postal Receipts— 9 cities..............3
— 6.5
2,694
Life Insurance Sales:
Ohio and Pennsylvania
— 10.0
.3
75,200
Retail Sales:
Department Stores— 56 firm s ...?
17,602
— 17.6
Wearing Apparel— 13 firms........3
950
— 26.1
Furniture— 51 firms..................... 3
652
— 24.6
Wholesale Sales:
Drugs— 13 firms............................3
1,402
— 12.9
Dry Goods— 11 firms.................. 3
— 28.4
1,392
Groceries— 40 firms......................$
— 17.9
4,864
Hardware— 17 fir m s ...._.............3
1,271
— 21.1
— 36.6
4,568
Building Contracts— Residential.3
Building Contracts— T otal...........3
19,342
— 43.6
+ 5 7 .6
4,314
Commercial Failures— Liabilities.3
Commercial Failures— Number. ..
1652 + 11.5
Production:
Pig Iron, U. S......................... Tons
— 48 . 8
1,165
Steel Ingots, U. S.................. Tons
1,548
— 45.5
109,0872 — 37.8
Automobiles— Pass. C a r ... .U. S.
31,3382 — 29.1
“
— Trucks.............U. S.
Bituminous C oal....................Tons
— 21.4
12,300
Cement— O., W. Pa., W. Va..Bbls.
1,063
— 44.6
Elec. Power— O., Pa., K y ... k. w.h.
1,0963 — 4.5
Petroleum— O., Pa., K y....... Bbls.
1,7703 — 11.1
5
Shoes........................................Pairs
10.0
Tires, U. S.......................... Casings
3,136s — 6.3
Bituminous Coal Shipments:
4,699
Lake Erie P orts..................... Tons
— 4.5
Iron Ore Receipts:
— 39.1
Lake Erie Ports..................... Tons
2,873
1 M onthly Average
January-August
2 Actual
Confidential
3 August

+

22,829,000
755,1401
24,737

+ 0.1

Steubenville...

— 5.2

W arren............

861,304

— 17.3

Youngstown. . ,

165,651
9,919
7,097

— 10.7
— 11.7
— 20.9

13,201
11,709
41.004
11,372
56,508
223,595
62.271
1,6642

—

15.004
20,412
1,762,2062
354,229*
113,961
8,863
9,0014
15,0294

— 41.7
— 37.0
— 27.8
— 23.3
— 18.2
— 36.6

6.8

—

30,0554

— 19.3
+ 0.2
— 2 .9

23,429

—

12.271

— 53.4

5

21.6

Percentage
Increase or Decrease
SALES
SALES
STOCKS
Sept.First nine
Sept.Sept.
Sept.
months
+ 2.3
— 21.9
— 5 .0
— 14.4
— 25.9
— 26.1
— 22.9
— 28.8
— 18.0
— 17.6

— 5.3
— 8 .4
— 9 .8
— 9.1
— 12.8
— 6.1
— 13.9
— 17.8
— 13.2
— 10.7

— 13.3
— 10.6
— 7.8
— 15.2
— 11.3
— 16.6
— 9 .0
— 16.7
— 15.5
— 11.6

— 30.4
— 23.9
— 26.1

— 10.6
— 12.2
— 11.7

— 3 .2
— 11.8
— 9 .0

— 21.6
— 18.2
— 29.9
— 29.6
— 39.2
— 35.5
— 24.6

— 9.1
— 22.3
— 20.9
— 26.1
— 23.5
— 15.0
— 20.9

— 8 .4
— 6 .0

— 3.3
— 4.1

— 16.3
— 29.3
— 11.6
— 7 .4
— 9 .4
— 14.3
— 17.9
— 28.3
— 12.8
— 21.1

— 27.2
— 21.3
— 18.5
— 7.1
— 14.2
— 16.5
— 17.9
— 26.3
— 8 .2
— 22.5

—

4 weeks
ending
Oct. 21,
1931
81,221
10,354
29,704
308,419
641,767
121,415
61,434
30,876
3,638
10,937
4,370
14,474
8,885
4,600
7,021
13,001
746,477
14,632
7,644
78,413
8,067
35,591
42,719
7,926
2,293,585

(Thousands o f Dollars)
Year-to-date Year-to-date
%
change
Jan. 1 to
Jan. 2 to
Oct. 21,
Oct. 22,
from
1931
1930
1930
— 13.7
791,723
969,035
86,663
— 22.8
126,460
— 16.1
350,389
448,675
— 10.3
3,276,829
3,683,792
— 19.9
6,613,598
7,991,485
— 33.0
1,512,038
1,788,936
— 23.4
749,185
899,047
— 14.5
308,381
390,002
— 19.2
37,584
50,395
— 8.3
110,176
142,974
— 4 .5
38,749
45,106
— 24.6
189,575
245,288
— 25.0
103,969
125,367
— 13.2
49,140
56,997
— 26.6
85,935
107,982
— 13.4
123,013
163,521
— 19.4
7,447,121
9,747,243
— 20.5
176,101
223,687
— 8.5
83,401
101,910
— 54.6
1,303,092
1,783,709
— 24.5
82,187
116,073
— 6.5
361,030
431,896
— 38.0
507,194
677,301
— 21.7
86,303
99,057
— 21.5

24,473,376

30,415,938

%
change
from
1930
— 18 .3
— 31 .5
— 21 .9
— 11..0
— 17..2
— 15..5
— 16..7
— 20 .9
— 25..4
— 22..9
— 14. 1
— 22. 7
— 17. 1
— 13..8
— 20. 4
— 24. 8
— 23. 6
— 21. 3
— 18. 2
— 26. 9
— 29. 2
— 16. 4
— 25.,1
— 12..9
— 19. 5

8. 2

— 26.3
— 17.9
— 22.5
— 35.0
— 43.3
+ 9 3 .7
+12.2

(1931 compared with 1930)




M id d letow n ...

— 19.1

Wholesale and Retail Trade

D E P A R T M E N T STORES (56)
A kron......................................................................
Cincinnati..............................................................
Cleveland...............................................................
Colum bus...............................................................
Pittsburgh.............................................................
T oled o....................................................................
W heeling................................................................
Youngstown..........................................................
Other Cities..........................................................
D istrict...................................................................
W E A R IN G A P P A R E L (13)
Cincinnati..............................................................
Other Cities..........................................................
D istrict...................................................................
F U R N IT U R E (49)
Cincinnati..............................................................
Cleveland...............................................................
Columbus..............................................................
D ayton...................................................................
T oled o................. ..................................................
Other C ities.. . . .................................................
District. . ...............................................................
C H AIN STORES*
Drugs— District (4 )............................................
Groceries— District (6 ) ......................................
W HOLESALE GROCERIES (38)
A kron.....................................................................
Cleveland...............................................................
Erie.........................................................................
Pittsburgh.............................................................
T oled o.............................................................. . . .
Other Cities..........................................................
D istrict...................................................................
W H OLESALE D R Y GOODS (11)..............
W H OLESALE DRUGS (1 3 ).........................
W H OLESALE H A R D W A R E (1 7 )..............
*Sales per individual unit operated.

Debits to Individual Accounts

’

4.'8

— 22.7
— 21.0

Building Operations
Sept.,
1931
3 162,904
14,910
C anton.................
12,570
1,548,860
Cleveland............
598,750
Cleveland
Suburbs*.........
480,530
82,400
Covington, K y . .
24,475
138,904
2,140
444,220
17,450
9,275
48,920
Middletown*
3,245
N ewark................
11,900
Pittsburgh, P a .. 1,243,157
Portsm outh.........
20,000
30,645
15,580
Steubenville........
17,600
27,849
Warren................
26,795
34,590
Wheeling, W. Va
93,439
Youngstown.......

(Value of Permits)
% change Jan.-Sept.,
from 1930
1931
— 59.2
31,779,709
— 64.9
169,946
— 82.5
647,115
— 10.2
21,837,755
— 86.0
10,585,750
— 46.8
— 79.4
— 34.3
— 22.4
— 85.8
+ 8 2 .7
— 57.6
— 36.3
— 38.0
— 50.5
+ 6 7 .8
+ 7 5 .9
— 58.3
+ 4 0 .6
— 82.0
— 53.3
— 98.6
— 60.6
— 88.5
— 25.9

10,934,523
3,041,700
493,955
2,335,378
115,697
1,981,920
437,107
97,624
680,507
75,968
98,700
10,299,460
293,400
100,175
1,162,507
188,300
1,844,945
263,432
545,250
1,374,034

Jan.-Sept.,
1930
38,665,664
288,923
1,281,007
32,627,512
22,232,875

% change
from 1930
— 79.5
— 41.2
— 49.5
— 33.1
— 52.4

14,877,849
4,202,150
535,650
4,234,734
232,090
3,480,213
1,057,801
540,318
573,448
558,589
228,035
17,344,754
581,500
249,377
679,980
602,020
6,098,059
595,725
941,047
2,333,539

— 26.5
— 27.6
— 7.8
— 4 4.9
— 50.1
— 43.1
— 58.7
— 81.9
+ 1 8 .7
— 86.4
— 56.7
— 4 0.6
— 49.5
— 59.8
+ 7 1 .0
— 68.7
— 69.7
— 55.8
— 42.1
— 41.1

5,111,108
— 56.7
71,384,857 125,042,859
— 4 2.9
♦Includes Bay Village, Cleveland Heights, East Cleveland, Euclid,
Fairview, Garfield Heights, Lakewood, Maple Heights, Parma, R ocky River,
Shaker Heights, South Euclid, University Heights.

Fourth District Business Indexes
(1923-1925 = 100)
Sept.,
1931
84
Bank Debits (24 cities).......................
113
Commercial Failures (N um ber). . ..
(L ia bilities)...
98
Postal Receipts (9 cities)....................
104
Sales— Life Insurance (Ohio & P a.).
90
“ — Department Store (53)..........
75
89
“ — Wholesale Drugs (1 3 )...........
“ —
«
Dry Goods (1 0 )..
54
u —
“
Groceries ( 3 8 ) . . .
79
" —
“
Hardware (1 5 ) ...
61
“ —
“
All (7 6 ).................
73
“ — Chain Drugs (3 )* * .................
77
41
27
Production— Coal (O., W. Va., E. K y .)........... 68
— Cement (O., W. Pa., W. V a .). . .
88
— Petroleum (O.. Pa., K y .)* ........... 96
“
— Elec. Power (0 ., Pa., K y .)* ........ 131
“
— Shoes................................................
90
♦August.
**Pcr individual unit operated.

Sept.,
1930
106
101
62
111
100
91
103
77
96
76
90
84
72
42
87
160
108
137
82

Sept.,
1929
126
103
79
119
113
102
114
108
103
92
104
89
135
73
97
160
124
158
110

Sept.,
1928
118
109
84
110
96
101
107
106
103
96
103
93
142
94
87
188
115
135
110

Sept.,
1927
113
102
73
117
102
95
112
104
103
101
104
96
137
125
88
150
114
123
122

8

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

Summary of National Business Conditions
(By the Federal Reserve Board)
Industrial production and factory employment, which usually increases
at this season, showed little change from August to September, and, conse­
quently, the Board’s seasonally adjusted indexes declined. The general level
o f wholesale prices also declined. Gold exports and earmarkings, together
with an increase in domestic currency demand between the middle of Septem­
ber and the middle o f October resulted in a large growth o f the reserve bank
credit in use and a rise in money rates.

Production and Employment

Index number of industrial production, adjusted
for seasonal variation, (1923-1925 = 100). Latest
figure, September, 76.

Index of United States Bureau of Labor Sta­
tistics (1926 ~ 100). Latest figure, September,
69.1

Industrial production, as measured by the Board’s seasonally adjusted
index, declined from 79 per cent o f the 1923-1925 average in August to 76
per cent in September. Activity at steel mills decreased from 31 per cent
o f capacity to 28 per cent; output o f automobiles was reduced substantially
and lumber production continued to decline. At cotton mills production in­
creased seasonally, while activity at woolen mills and shoe factories declined
contrary to the usual seasonal tendency. Output o f petroleum was smaller
in September than in August, but the rate o f output prevailing at the end
o f September was higher than at the end of August.
The number employed at factories showed little change from the middle
of August to the middle of September, a period when employment usually
increases. In iron and steel mills, automobile factories and lumber mills,
employment decreased further, contrary to the seasonal tendency; in the
clothing and silk industries there were substantial increases in employment,
partly of a seasonal character; in mills producing cotton goods, employment
increased less than usual, and in woolen mills it declined from recent rela­
tively high levels.
Data on value o f building contracts awarded for the period between the
first of August and the middle o f October, as reported by the F. W . Dodge
Corporation, show a continuation o f the downward movement o f recent
months for residential as well as for other types o f construction.
Estimates by the Department o f Agriculture, based on October 1 condi­
tions, indicated a cotton crop o f 16,284,000 bales, the largest crop reported,
except that of 1926; a total wheat crop somewhat larger than usual, and a
corn crop of 2,700,000,000 bushels, 29 per cent larger than last year, and
two per cent smaller than the five-year average.

Distribution
Freight car loadings of merchandise and sales by department stores in­
creased in September, but less than the usual seasonal amount.

Wholesale Prices
The general level of wholesale prices declined from 70.2 per cent o f the
1926 average in August to 69.1 per cent in September, according to the
Bureau o f Labor Statistics. Decreases in the prices o f livestock, meats, hides,
woolen goods, cotton and cotton goods, were offset in part by increases in prices
of dairy products, petroleum and petroleum products. Further declines in the
price of cotton during the first few days o f October were follow ed by sub­
stantial increases in subsequent days.

Bank Credit
Monthly rates in the open market in New York:
Commercial paper rate on 4 to 6 month paper.
Acceptance rate on 90-day bankers* acceptances.
Latest figures are averages of first 17 days in
October

RESERVE BANK CREDIT AND FACTORS IN CHANGES

1§5a

Monthly averages of daily figures. Latest fig­
ures are averages of first 17 days in October.




During the four weeks follow ing the suspension o f gold payments in
England on September 20, $600,000,000 o f gold was withdrawn from this
country’s monetary stock in the form o f exports and earmarkings. Domestic
demand for currency continued to increase, the growth for the month ending
in the middle o f October being about $400,000,000. The growth in the
amount of currency outstanding, however, slowed down after the first few
days in October. The demand for credit arising from gold movements and
currency growth was met by member banks through the sale o f acceptances
to the reserve banks and by rediscounts. Volume o f reserve bank credit
outstanding, consequently increased between the week ending September 19
and the week ending October 17 by $904,000,000, and on October 17 stood
at $2,169,000,000, the highest level for ten years. Gold and currency with­
drawals resulted in a decrease o f deposits at member banks in leading cities.
Loans and investments o f these banks also declined, reflecting reductions in
loans to security brokers, as well as sale o f acceptances to the reserve banks,
and sales of United States securities.
During this period there was a rise in short time m oney rates in the
open market and in yields on high grade bonds. On October 9 the Federal
Reserve Bank o f New York advanced its discount rate from 1 % to 2 y2 per
cent and on October 16 to 3% per cent. Discount rates were also advanced
at the Boston, Philadelphia, Cleveland, Richm ond, Chicago, St. Louis, Dallas
and San Francisco reserve banks.