View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
Covering financial, industrial, and agricultural conditions
in the
Fourth Federal Reserve District
Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland

Vol. 9

Cleveland, Ohio, May 1, 1927

The improvement in the general business situation
which became noticeable in February, continued in March.
April, however, was accompanied by recessionary ten­
dencies in important industries, such as iron and steel,
and conditions at present are irregular. It is not clear
as yet whether or not the slackening in April is more
than the seasonal decline which has appeared in that
month during the past few years.
With regard to the first quarter, business started com­
paratively slowly in January following a brief but sizable
slump in the last two months of 1926. But February and
March both improved more than seasonally, with the re­
sult that industrial profits for the quarter appear to be
slightly larger than in 1926, according to the information
now available. Net earnings of 50 industrial corporations
in the United States, whose quarterly figures have been
published up to April 25, amounted to $55,246,000 in the
first quarter of 1927, as compared with $53,608,000 last
year, a gain of 3.1 per cent. Increases were reported by
32 companies, and decreases by 18.
In the Fourth District, reports with regard to first
quarter earnings have been received by this bank from
35 large manufacturing establishments, representing 19
types of business. Of the total, an increase in net
earnings for the first quarter as compared with last year
is reported by 14 concerns; a decline by 12; and "no
change” by 9. In the District, therefore, first quarter
business on the whole was equal to or a little better than
in 1926, but with wide variations as between different
industries.
Financial
Conditions

Bills discounted by the Federal Reserve
Bank of Cleveland rose from 38 millions
on March 16th to 52 millions on April
13th, the latter figure being 12 millions lower than a
year ago. Government securities held declined, while
acceptance holdings were practically unchanged. Federal
reserve note circulation increased from 202 to 214 mil­
lion^ while deposits fell off slightly.
A further rise in commercial loans made by reporting
member banks in this District took place between March
16th and April 13th. Loans secured by stocks and bonds
were lower, as were investments. Both demand and time
deposits declined.
The prevailing interest rate in Cleveland, Pittsburgh,




No. 5

and Cincinnati on prime commercial paper is 6 per cent.
On stock exchange collateral loans, the range is from
5 to 6 per cent.
Debits to individual accounts at 13 large centers in
this District amounted to $2,659,473,000 in March, as com­
pared with $2,472,654,000 in March, 1926, and $2,440,874,000 in February, 1927.
Commercial failures in the Fourth District numbered
193 in March, as against 162 in February and 214 a year
ago. Liabilities aggregated $4,724,804 in March, $3,494,055 in February, and $3,738,723 a year ago. In the
United States, there were 2143 failures in March, 2035
in February, and 1984 a year ago.
Federal Reserve
Bank o f Cleveland Federal Reserve System
(In Millions)
(In Millions)
Apr.13, Apr.14, Mar. 16, Apr.13, Apr.14, Mar.16,
1927
1926
1927
1927
1926
1927
Gold reserves .......................
295
279
303
3,031
2,782 3,024
Discounts ...............................
52
64
38
426
677
331
20
21
22
257
274
219
Acceptances ...........................
U. S. Securities.....................
37
36
44
355
377
475
Total bills and securities..
108
122
104
1,040
1,242 1,027
Federal Reserve notes in cir­
culation ...............................
214
202
203
1,744
1,681 1,706
Total deposits .......................
177
185
200
2,307
2,347 2,323
Reporting Member Banks
Fourth District
United States
(In Millions)
(In Millions)
Apr.13, Apr.14, Mar.16, Apr.13, Apr.14, Mar.16,
1927
1926
1927
1927
1926
1927
Loans secured by stocks and
bonds ................................... 581
All other ............................... 804
Total loans ........................... 1,385
Investments ...........................
653
Demand deposits ................. 1,050
Time deposits .......................
841

Iron and Steel

531
793
1,324
635
1,003
786

588
794
1,382
679
1,086
845

5.502 5,256 5,561
8,843 8,641 8,824
14.345 13,897 14,385
5,855 5,600 6,959
13,059 12,898 13,236
6,032 5,505 6,000

April was a month of reaction in steel
and of inaction in pig iron. The mo­
mentum of a record March in the pro­
duction of steel sustained the first half of April, but
in the last half a gradual downturn was apparent. Prices
became more irregular as the month wore on, this being
evident more in a broader application of preferred prices
than in a definite breaking of published levels. Pig iron
reflected a between-quarters stagnation. In point of
production and new business, however, April was a shade
better than April, 1926, but from a price situation, it was
much less satisfactory.
In many steel lines a large portion of the quieter

2

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

market can be attributed to failure of the automobile
industry to parallel last year's rate. The sheet industry
in particular has suffered from the extreme competition
created by the smaller requirements o f the industry and a
precarious situation for many independent makers has
arisen. Despite a reduction in sheet bars, present levels
o f sheets are frequently below mill costs. The automo­
bile industry made a substantial gain in March, pro­
ducing in the United States, 386,721 units compared with
298,750 in February, but the comparison with last March
shows a heavy reduction from the 422,728 of that month.
Semifinished material at Pittsburgh and Youngstown
receded 50 cents to $1.00 in April, sheet bars now being
held at $33.50 to $34.00, slabs and billets at $33.00, and
wire rods at $42.00. Users bought even more closely in
April and specifications received by producers underwent
a severe check.
Coke weakened progressively during April despite the
bituminous coal strike and distress lots at the close
o f April were selling for 25 cents and more per ton under
the market at the close o f March. Coke producers have
been willing to contract at $3.50, whereas they asked $4.00
when the strike broke. No furnace or foundry has ex­
perienced any difficulty in obtaining plentiful supplies of
fuel.
Pig iron remained largely unchanged, both as to pro­
duction and price, in April. This was largely because
most melters had contracted liberally for their second
quarter needs, the third quarter was too distant to con­
sider, and the melt was not such as to compel the pur­
chase of rounding-out supplies. Although $1.90 (Pitts­
burgh) has been the open market for steel bars, plates
and shapes for the general run of business, this level has
been shaded for attractive orders. Hot rolled strip prices
at $2.10 (Pittsburgh) for the wide and $2.30 (Pitts­
burgh) fo r the narrow widths have held fairly well.
Tin plate demand revived late in April when some July
specifications were submitted and the 85 per cent gait
held through the month.
A new high in steel ingot production was set in March
with 4,559,400 tons which compared with 3,831,397 tons in
February and 4,488,362 tons in March, 1926, the previous
high. The daily average rate in March was 168,867 tons.
March pig iron production totaled 3,482,223 tons against
2,940,604 tons in February and 3,458,171 tons in March,
1926. The month's total was the third highest for any
March in history.

o f going through the usual seasonal decline.
Prices
continued to sag up to the close of March; since then
they have recovered, but on April 13th were only
slightly higher than a month previously.
Consumers1
demand as yet has not increased to any extent, and the
sluggishness o f the market is doubtless caused by the
very large stocks of storage coal in the hands o f the big
industrial users.
Dealers and operators in the Fourth District state that
storage stocks have been very little affected so fa r by
the strike, and that both industrial and public demand
remains apathetic. The union mines in Ohio and Penn­
sylvania, o f course, are shut down, with occasional ex­
ceptions where mines have reopened under the nonunion
wage scale. Activity in the nonunion fields in Kentucky
and W est Virginia continues at a high rate.
Rubber and
Tires

Conditions in this industry are much
better than a year ago. Good weather
has brought an early opening to the
driving season, and both production and shipments have
been very heavy in March and April. In spite o f low
tire prices, the high rate of activity, together with the
stability o f crude rubber prices, have enabled tire man­
ufacturers to show first quarter earnings considerably
in excess of the corresponding period o f 1926.
Dealers' stocks of casings on April 1 averaged 68.8 per
dealer, according to the Department of Commerce, this
being somewhat higher than the two preceding years
(63.9 in 1926 and 62.2 in 1925). Inner tubes per dealer
were 114.7, lower than 1926 but higher than 1925.
The price o f crude rubber has changed but little during
the past several weeks. On February 18 it was 39 cents
a pound; on March 18 it had advanced to 42.3 cents*
but by April 8 a decline to 41.6 cents had taken place.
Cotton likewise has remained virtually unchanged.
Sales of mechanical rubber goods in the first quarter
are reported to have been somewhat disappointing. Both
volume o f goods sold and profits are stated to be matel’ially lower than last year.
Automobiles

Automobile production in the United
States made the usual seasonal gain
in March over February, but was still
materially below last year.
The output of cars and
trucks in March was 386,721 as compared with 422 728
a year ago. For the first quarter of 1927, production
amounted to 919,687 cars and trucks; in 1926 to 1 077,771 cars and trucks.

A fter holding at $36.81 for the first half o f April,
the Iron Trade Review composite of fourteen leading iron
and steel products slumped off to below $36.65 in the last
half of the month. A year ago this barometer stood at
$38.48.

Competition is still very keen as is evidenced by the
various price cuts of recent months. Accessory manu­
facturers in general are reported to be doing well. Fourth
District truck and parts manufacturers report business
as being spotty.

Coal

Clothing

The soft coal strike appears to have
had very little effect upon general busi­
ness. Production fell off sharply after
April 1st, but for the week ending April 9th it was
still ahead o f any of the four preceding years except
1926, owing to the fact that during the entire first
quarter the output held up at record high levels instead



As has been the case for some time,
irregular conditions prevail in the cloth­
ing industry. Makers o f woolens are
still experiencing great difficulty in showing profits, as
prices are so close to the level of production costs.
Easter sales o f women’s dresses have been good and'
this branch o f the industry appears to be on a ’satis­

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
factory basis. Men’s underwear manufacturers are do­
ing a little better than a year ago.
The wholesale branch of the industry continues in a
state of depression. Monthly sales of reporting firms in
the Fourth District during the past two years have been
steadily less than in the same month in the preceding
year; in fact, only six out of the past 27 months have
shown gains over the previous year. Part of the slump
in sales is due to falling prices; but even after removing
the price element, sales have shown a sagging tendency.
For the first quarter of 1927, sales were 9.8 per cent less
than in 1926; for March, they decreased 7.3 per cent.
In retail clothing, department store sales in March
gained 3 per cent over a year ago in women's dresses,
8.8 in misses’ ready-to-wear, 42.2 in sweaters, 12.5 in
silk underwear, 6.2 in house dresses, 20.7 in negligees,
6.7 in petticoats, 3.8 in hosiery, and 1.6 per cent in in­
fants’ wear. On the other hand, men’s clothing decreased
11.8 per cent, men’s furnishings 4.9, and women’s coats
1.9, and losses also took place in boys’ wear, 22.4;
juniors’ ready-to-wear, 3.2; corsets, 3.3; and muslin
underwear, 0.8 per cent.
Shoes

Cincinnati shoe manufacturers report
business as the same or better than a
year ago, and a slight improvement
in first quarter net earnings is indicated. Preliminary
Fourth District production figures for March show a
gain of nearly 6 per cent over February, output in the
latter month being about 15 per cent greater than last
year*
Sales of reporting wholesale shoe houses in this Dis­
trict in March were 0.3 per cent under 1926, and in the
first quarter were 3.4 per cent less. March gained 50
per cent over February.
In retail stores, sales of both men’s and women’s shoes
in March were under last year’s figures—7 per cent in
the case of men’s and 5 per cent in women’s shoes.
General
Manufacturing

After a generally poor start in 1927,
most lines of manufacture in this Dis­
trict have expanded their operations to
the point where activity in April has been about up to
last year. A slackening tendency here and there has
recently appeared, but this was also true in various
lines about the same time in 1926 and 1925. Keen com­
petition has had a tendency to reduce profit margins,
particularly among the smaller concerns. In one or two
cases, first quarter production actually exceeded that of
last year while net earnings were less. Employment is
about normal for the most part; a few establishments re­
port “below normal.”
Better weather than a year ago has favored the paint
trade. Improvement has recently taken place, and the
outlook is satisfactory. Operations in the electrical sup­
ply industry are easing off, with a reduction in orders,
and the same is true of the paper trade. A recovery
in the demand for window glass is reported. The boxboard mills are operating at high levels, and conditions in
this line have improved. Business of agricultural im­
plement manufacturers is about the same as a year ago.




3

The stove business is dull; demand for hotel and restaur­
ant equipment has fallen off considerably, and prices
have weakened. Other lines show no great changes.
Agriculture

Spring weather has been generally fav­
orable for farm operations and the
season is much farther advanced than
it was at this time last year. Interest in the Fourth
District, at this time, centers largely on fruit prospects,
but the season is not yet sufficiently advanced to obtain
any accurate idea of the size of this year’s fruit crops.
While the warm weather in mid-March started the buds
prematurely, the cold weather which followed was not of
sufficient intensity to cause more than slight damage.
Conditions of wheat, rye and pasture are somewhat
above average, being 84.5, 86.4, and 91 per cent of nor­
mal for April, as compared with 79.8, 85.9, and 77 per
cent of the ten year average, respectively.
Reports indicate a large and excellent crop of spring
lambs. There was an early and abundant pasture, the
lambing season was favorable, the mortality of lambs
was low, and they are unusually thrifty and in good
condition. Marketings are earlier and of a better quality
than last year.
Reports to the Department of Agriculture of inten­
tions to plant, in the entire United States, indicate in­
creased acreage in the following crops: corn, 2 per cent;
oats, 8 per cent; barley, 14 per cent; and potatoes, 15
per cent. The average condition of winter wheat for
the United States on April 1, 1927, was 84.5 per cent
of normal, compared with 84.1 per cent for 1926, 68.7
for 1925, and 79.8, the average condition for the past
ten years on April 1st.
Tobacco

The Department of Agriculture’s “ In­
tention to plant” report as of March 1
indicates a decrease of 21.5 per cent in
the 1927 burley tobacco crop as compared with 1926.
This is not a forecast of actual acreage to be planted,
but is merely the expression of the farmers’ intentions
at the time of making their reports. The very low prices
received for burley during the past season have without
doubt been the main factor in the farmers’ intention to
reduce the acreage this year.
About 39 million pounds of burley were sold in March,
according to the Kentucky Commissioner of Agriculture’s
report, the price averaging 12% cents a pound. This
represents a still further weakening of prices, although
slight, from February. The 1926 selling season is now
over. On April 6, it was announced by the Burley To­
bacco Growers’ Association that a seven-year contract
would be submitted to the tobacco growers in the burley
growing regions, the old membership contracts having
expired. In case 75 per cent of the 1926 production is
not signed up by November 1st, 1927, the 1927 crop will
be sold at auction without pooling of either tobacco or
proceeds. The Association also announced that its hold­
ings of old crops now amount to 90 million pounds, but
that the entire 1926 crop has been sold and delivered, the
balance of the money due to growers in this crop to be
distributed soon.
Total production of tobacco in the United States in

4

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

1926 was 1,323,388,000 pounds, as compared with 1,376,628.000 in 1925, The Kentucky burley crop in 1926 was
223.121.000 pounds, an increase of 16,400,000 pounds over
1925. The average price secured on the Kentucky burley
crop for 1926 was 14% cents a pound, as compared with
19 cents in 1925, and with 18% cents for all types in
the country in 1926.
Cigarette output in the United States in 1926 totaled
89.460.000.000, a gain of 7,000,000,000 during the year*
The people of this country consumed 80 billion cigarettes
during the year, or approximately 700 per capita.
Building

According to Bradstreet’s, building per­
mits issued during March in 178 cities
in the United States aggregated $335,623.000, or a loss of 9.1 per cent from last year. The
first quarter showed a decrease of 5.4 per cent. A
different picture for March is presented by the Dodge
report on contracts awarded, which includes various
forms of construction not covered by building permits.
Contracts awarded in March in 37 eastern states were
$620,738,000, a gain of 3.8 per cent over a year ago,
and furthermore, building projects contemplated at the
end of March amounted to $1,198,090,000, a gain of
about 17 per cent over a year ago. For the first quarter
of 1927, awards aggregated $1,398,776,000, as compared
with $1,462,938,000 in the same period of 1926, a loss of
4.4 per cent.
In the Fourth District, March contracts awarded were
about 25 per cent under last year, and were slightly
lower for the quarter. Projects contemplated at the

Building Operations

Cleveland Heights, and Lakewood, while large gains were
made in Barberton, Parma, Rocky River, Columbus, Day­
ton, Hamilton, Lima, Newark, Toledo, and Youngstown.
Most of the cities showed gains, and in fact the entire
District loss is accounted for by a $9,000,000 drop in
Cleveland, which in turn was due to the issuance of one
very large permit in March, 1926.
Building
Materials

On the whole, April has brought some
improvement to the lumber trade in this
District after a mediocre first quarter.
Good weather in April has been a favorable factor. Sev­
eral manufacturers state that business is now about
equal to that of a year ago, although the general feel­
ing is still one of caution and conservatism. Buyers are
still adhering closely to the “ hand-to-mouth” method of
purchasing, and competition in the industry is very keen.
Some curtailment of production is reported. Prices of
soft woods continued to improve slightly during the
month, but hardwoods have weakened.
Cement production for Ohio, Western Pennsylvania
and West Virginia totaled 1,265,000 barrels in March, over
twice as great as a year ago. Shipments were 925,000
barrels, a gain of 36 per cent, while stocks at the end
of the month were 3,283,000 barrels, a material increase
both over February and over March 31, 1926. In the
United States, stocks continued at record high levels at
the end of March, the seasonal peak usually being reached
about this time.
The Aberthaw index of industrial building costs con­
tinued at 193 on April 1st.
Retail Trade

March, 1927
(Valuation of Permits)
& change
w
.
% change
March
from
Jan.-Mar. Jan.-Mar.
from
1927
1926
1927
1926
1926
1,540,328
— 27.5
5,328,366
3,547,541
+50.2
45,630
— H).8
135,825
+8.8
124,890
89,395 +198.6
132,015
95,163
+ 38.7
297,341
— 58.1
765,729
1,263,250
— 39.4
2,053,935
— 20.8
5,074,480
4,890,820
+ 3 .8
3,142,800
— 75.1
7,262,900 18,339,925
— 60.4

Sales of 64 department stores in the
Fourth District in March were 1.4 per
cent under the same month a year ago
and first quarter sales were 0.7 per cent less. For
March, Columbus made a gain of 8 per cent, and in­
creases also took place in Toledo and Youngstown. These
same cities together with Cincinnati showed gains for
the first quarter.

Akron......................
Ashtabula...............
Barberton...............
Canton....................
Cincinnati..............
Cleveland...............
^ **
suburbs:
Cleve. Heights...
East Cleveland..
Euclid.................
Garfield Heights.
Lakewood...........
Parma.................
Rocky River___
Shaker Heights..
Columbus...............
Covington, Ky.......
Dayton...................
Erie, Pa..................
Hamilton................
Lexington, Ky........
Lima.......................
Newark...................
Pittsburgh, Pa.......
Springfield..............
Toledo.....................
Wheeling, W. V a...
Youngstown...........

429,290
187,209
171,365
271,600
109,959
199,030
80 325
511,975
4,362,200
181,300
1,022,141
777,977
399,266
146,670
51,460
83,818
3,114,634
198,179
2,184,163
215,413
1,020,705

— 49.1
+ 2 0 .5
+ 36.1
+ 32.2
— 83.1
+152.0
+ 52.3
— 11.5
+111.9
+ 3 5 .0
+ 6 0 .0
+36.1
+ 102.9
— 10.0
+ 149.6
+ 5 3 .9
— 23.8
— 15.5
+ 53.8
+ 3 6 .0
+ 75.2

1,013,922
302,845
322,690
421.500
254,442
560,346
354,330
1,586,575
7,160,200
316,700
2,186,429
1,192,861
532.500
468,415
93,241
115,918
8,515,034
315,469
3,407,774
639,360
1,703,405

1,922,525
310,427
349,865
459,700
1,050,675
213,915
100,450
1,212,130
4,256,400
305,200
1,386,601
828,210
453,398
602,591
505,560
69,775
10,015,398
340,785
2,557,654
288,741
1,901.985

— 47.3
— 2.4
— 7.8
— 8.3
— 75.8
+161.9
+252.7
+ 30.9

Totals..................

22,888,108

26.5

50,163,271

57,393,397

— 12.6

Stocks on hand at the end of March were 0 8 nei
cent less than a year ago, but 9.2 per cent above February. The stock turnover rate for March was .255 oi
8.31 times a year. For the quarter, it was .727’ oi
2.91 times a year. For 47 stores reporting their credit
sales, the percentage of such sales in March to the total
was 58.8, and for 19 firms reporting instalment sales
the percentage of instalment sales to the total was 6 8*
and of 30-day charge sales to the total was 51.2 Col
lections in March were 38.8 per cent of accounts receiv
able on February 28; for the 19 firms showing collection^
on both 30-day and instalment accounts, the percental
of collections on the former was 45.2, and on the i«**
was 17.9 per cent.
tel

end of March were roughly about 30 per cent less than a
year ago. Residential and public utility buildings ac­
counted for two-thirds of the awards in March.
Turning to individual cities, 27 centers in this District
reported building permits in March of $22,888,108, a
decline of 26.5 per cent from last March. Substantial
decreases took place in Ashtabula, Canton, Cleveland,

Twenty-five out of 52 separate departments showed
gains in March sales over last year. Increases of mors
than ten per cent took place in jewelry, 14.2; umbrellas
35.5; women’s skirts, 72.4; sweaters, 42.2; silk unde ’
wear, 12.5; negligees, 20.7; draperies, 12.5; an<j bo k
14.6. Decreases of more than 10 per cent occurred hi
woolen dress goods, 16.5; cotton dress goods 15 8* n v
wear, 16.3; ribbons, 29.0; handkerchiefs, 10.2* silvern*0




+68.2

+ 3 .8
+ 57.7
+ 44.0
+ 17.4
— 22.3
— 81.6

+66.1

— 15.0
— 7.4
+ 3 3 .2
+121.4
— 10.4

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
23.0; men’s clothing, 11.8; boys’ wear, 22.4; gloves,
14.5; millinery, 10.4; toys, 14.7; luggage, 12.1; and musical
instruments, 20.9.
Percentage changes in the main departments were as
follows:
% Gain or Loss
over March, 1926
Silks and Velvets ....................................................
— 9.1
Men's Clothing ......................................................
— 11.8
Men's Furnishings ..................................................
— 4.9
— 1.9
Women’s Coats ........................................................
Women’s Dresses ..................................................
-j-3.0
Millinery .................................................................. — 10.4
Shoes ..........................................................................
— 6.3
Furniture ..................................................................
f3.6
Floor Coverings .................... .................................
+0.2
Draperies, Lamps, Shades .................................... +11.8

This bank’s index o f sales of 101 wholesale firms
(1919-1923—100) stood at 88 in March, this being the
lowest in seven years with the exception of 1922. The
dry goods index was 75, as compared with an average
o f 81 for March o f 1923-1926; groceries— 78, as compared
with an average o f 82 fo r 1923-1926; hardware— 113,
against an average of 114; drugs— 127, against an aver­
age o f 119; shoes— 94, against an average of 90.
Collections in March were larger than a year ago
in drugs, hardware, and shoes, but smaller in dry goods
and groceries.
Stocks on hand at the beginning of
April were quite generally smaller than last year. The
stock turnover rate fo r dry goods in March was .368, or
4.42 times a year, and for groceries was .53, or 6.36
times a year.
City Conditions

Wholesale Trade

Four of the five reporting wholesale
lines registered decreases in March as
compared with a year ago, hardware
being the only line to show a gain. For the first quarter
sales in all lines except drugs declined.

The chart below illustrates, for nine
leading cities in the Fourth District,
the changes during the last five years
in three important business barometers— bank debits,
department store sales, and building permits (valuation).
The base (100) fo r each chart is the 1923-1925 average.

Debits, Department Store Sales, Building Permits in Leading Cities in the
Fourth Federal Reserve District




6

Base=1923-1925

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

«

Fourth District Business Statistics
(All figures are for Fourth District unless otherwise specified)

Bank Debits (23 cities)
Savings Deposits (end of month)
Ohio (41 banks)
Western Pennsylvania (27 banks)
Total (68 banks)
Commercial Failures— Number
44
44 — Liabilities
Postal Receipts-—9 cities
Sates— Life Insurance— Ohio and Pa.
44 — Dept. Stores— (50 firms)
*' — Wholesale Grocery
(51 firms)
44 —
“
Dry Goods — (16 “ >
44 —
44
Hardware
— (16 44 )
“
Drugs
— (15 44 )
Building Permits, Valuation— 27 cities
Production — Pig Iron, U. S.
*•
— Steel Ingots, U. S.
“
— Automobiles, U. S.
Passenger Cars
Trucks
44
— Bituminous Coal, 4th Dist.
»•
— Cement: Ohio, W. Va., Wn. Pa.
44
— Electric Power: Ohio, Pa., Ky.
*4
— Petroleum,: Ohio, Pa., Ky.
44
— Shoes, 4th Dist.
— Tires, U. S.
Bituminous Coal Shipments (from Lake Erie ports)
Iron Ore Receipts (at Lake Erie ports)
1 3 months* average
** Jan.-Feb.
Feb*„ .
4 Figures Confidential

Millions of dollars
Thous. of dollars
Actual Number
Thous. of dollars

Thous. of Tons
Actual Number
Thous. of Tons
44 44 barrels
Millions o f k.w. hours
Thous. of barrels
44 44 pairs
44 44 casings
44 44 tons

Retail and Wholesale Trade

DEPARTM ENT STORES
Akron...........................................
Cincinnati....................................
Cleveland.....................................
Columbus....................................
Dayton........................................
Pittsburgh...................................
Toledo........................................
Wheeling.....................................
Youngstown................................
Other Cities.................................
District........................................

No. of
reports

Percentage Increase or Decrease
SALES
SALES
March, 1927
Jan.-Mar. 1927
compared with
compared with
Jan.-Mar. 1926
March, 1926

5
7
6
7
3
7
4
5
3
17
64

— 2.2
— 1.1
— 1.3
+ 8 .0
— 3.9
— 4.5
+ 3 .1
— 5.3
+ 3 .0
+ 4 .6
— 1.4

—0.2
+ 0 .1
— 1.3
+ 11.4
+ 3 .1
—4.5
+ 5 .9
— 3.5
+ 4 .3
+ 2 .9
—0.7

WEARING APPAREL
Cincinnati...................................
Cleveland.....................................
Other Cities.................................
District........................................

6
3
10
19

+ 0 .1
+ 4 .0
+ 3 .5
+ 2 .6

+ 6 .1
+ 2 .7
+ 4 .9
+ 4 .5

FURNITURE
Canton.........................................
Cincinnati...................................
Cleveland.....................................
Columbus....................................
Dayton........................................
Toledo..........................................
Other Cities.................................
District........................................

3
11
7
15
4
6
7
53

+ 25.9
— 3.1
— 14.7
— 17.1
+ 33.5
— 2.5
+ 5 .4
— 3.7

3
5

— 5.2
— 8.3

—4 .0
— 7.6

3

— 10.0
—0.5
— 0.3
— 7.2
—0.1
— 8.4
— 3.3
— 3.0
— 7.3
— 0.9
+ 0 .7
—0.3

— 11.9
+ 2 .5
— 3.5
— 7.7
—4.5
— 7.1
— 5.0
— 1.7
— 9.8
+ 2 .2
—0.7
— 3.4

CHAIN STORES*
Groceries— District.....................
WHOLESALE GROCERIES

.7

4
4
8

Toledo..........................................
Other Cities.................................
District........................................
WHOLESALE DRY GOODS.
WHOLESALE DRUGS............
WHOLESALE HARDW ARE.
WHOLESALE SHOES............




3
27
52
16
15
16
5

March
1927

March
1926

3,189

%
Change

Jan.-Mar.
1927

Jan.-Mar.
1926

Change

2,969

+ 7 .4

9,480

8,869

+ 6 .9

686,102
262,261
948,363
193
4,725
3,432
117,640
22,882
6,730
3,145
2,286
2,019
22,888
3,483
4,559

638,108
239,299
877,407
214
3,739
3,382
110,036
23,364
6,915
3,394
2,270
2,037
31,159
3,442
4,488

+ 7 .5
+ 9 .6
+ 8 .1
— 9.8
+ 2 6 .4
+ 1 .5
+ 6 .9
— 2.1
— 2.7
— 7.3
+ 0 .7
—0.9
— 26.5
+ 1 .2
+16

678,108*
253,134*
931,242*
575
11,268
9,441
301,398
62,144
18,500
8,304
5,894
5,546
50,163
9,521
12,198

632,251*
236,518*
868,7691
646
13,287
9,125
275,133
63,083
19,497
9,206
5,935
5,426
57,393
9,681
12,440

+ 7 .3 *
+ 7 .0 *
+ 7 .2 *

341,665
45,056
21,501*
1,265
1.065s
1,830*

381,116
41,612
20,721*
586
1,019*
1,675*

799,270
120,417
44,413*
2,657

973,801
103,970
43,273®
1,848

3,866’

3,708*

— 10.4
+ 8 .3
+ 3 .8 *
+115.9
+ 4.5*
+ 9.3*
+14.8*
+ 4.3*

4

4

2 ,220 *
3,639*
4

7,732 s

2, 101*
3,389*
4

7,206*

—11.0
— 15.2
+ 3 .5
+ 9 .5
— 1.5
— 5.1
— 9 .8
— 0 .7

+2.2

—

12.6

— 1.7
— 1.9
— 17.9
+ 1 5 .8

+ 2.6*

+ 4 3 .8
+ 5 .7 *
+ 7 .4 *
+ 8 .3 *
+ 7 .3 *

Index Numbers of Trade in the Fourth Federal
Reserve District
(Average Monthly Sales for the Five-Year Period 1919-1923 i
Mar.
Mar.
Mar.
Mar.
1923
1924
1925
1926
Department Stores (5 0 )* ....
117
104
107
108
Wholesale Drugs (15)*.........
120
115
112
129
Wholesale Dry Goods (15)*.
110
87
85
81
Wholesale Groceries (511* ..
85
84
80
80
Wholesale Hardware (U ) * ..
123
106
113
113
Wholesale Shoes (5)*............
118
73
79
88
101
Wholesale— All (101)*..........
90
89
90
Chain Drugs (3 )* f................
108
103
100
107
* Number of firms,
t Per individual unit operated.

•

100)

Mar.
1927
106
127
75
78
113
94

88

102

Debits to Individual Accounts

Cincinnati..............
Cleveland................
Connellsville, Pa...
Dayton...................
Erie, Pa...................
Greensburg, Pa.. . .
Homestead, Pa.. . .
Lexington, Ky........
Middletown............
Oil City, Pa............
Pittsburgh, Pa.......
Springfield..............
Steubenville...........
Toledo....................
Wheeling, W. V a...
Youngstown...........
Total...................

(In thousands of dollars)
4 weeks * > change
1927 to
1926 to <
from
date
date
Apr. 13,
1926 (Dec. 30 to (Dec. 31 to
1927
Apr. 13)
Apr. 14)
89,051
— 9.4
315.104
333,259
11.185
— 2 .8
40,137
39,202
48,037
— 6 .1
168,671
174,226
389,151
+ 6 .7
1,408,014
1.380,632
773,783
+ 4 .8
2,854,864
2,611,304
158,007
+ 1 .4
599.173
550,206
4,752
+ 4 .2
18,194
17,243
92.482
+ 17.7
337,491
305,816
32,012
—0.5
122,031
119,549
20,267
+ 1 4 .4
76,519
75,101
3,903
+ 0.05
14,696
14,472
21,003
+ 7 .0
103,652
96,945
15,393
+1.6
53.694
54,975
5,936
— 7.2
19.656
20,205
9,520
— 9.6
37,494
39,591
13,731
+ 2 5 .4
„ 55.851
, 45,216
1,065,385
+ 2 8 .0
3.820,369
3,330.883
22,708
+ 2 .4
85,632
85,662
10,548
— 2.3
38,605
38,367
238,429
+ 21.9
818,064
763,296
14,695
+ 9 .2
49.425
48,158
43,508
160,871
+1.1
65,675
HZ'™
— 1.2
259,149
237,477
11,776
— 5.2
43,300
44,629
3,160,937
+12.3 11,$00,656 10.60J.821

change
from
1926
— 5.4
+ 2 .4
— 3.2

+2.0

+ 9 .3
+ 8 .9
+ 5 .5
+ 1 0 .4
+2.1
+ 1 .9
+ 1 .5
+ 6 .9
— 2.3
— 2.7
— 5.3
+ 2 3 .5
+ 1 4 .7

—0.04

+0.6
+2.6
+ 7 .2

— 9.3
+ 9 .1
— 3.0

~ + sl

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

7

Summary o f National Business Conditions
(By the Federal Reserve Board)

Index number of production of manufactures
and minerals combined, adjusted for sea­
sonal variations (1923-1925 = 100). Latest
figure: March— 112.
nuciwT

200f----

------ '200

WHOLESALE PRICES
19?3

1925

1326

^

S- Bureau of Labor Statistics
<1913 — 100, base adopted by Bureau). Latest
* n w : March— 145.3.
SIUJOH5 Of OOLLMU

to

Industrial activity increased further in March and was larger than a
year ago, while the general level o f prices continued to decline. Distribu­
tion o f commodities at wholesale and retail was somewhat smaller than
a year ago.
Production
Industrial production, after increasing continuously for three months,
was larger in March when allowance is made for usual seasonal changes,
than in any month since last September. Output o f bituminous coal, crude
petroleum, and steel ingots, and mill consumption of raw cotton in March were
larger than in any previous month. Since A pril 1, however, steel mill opera­
tions have been somewhat curtailed, and bituminous coal output has been re­
duced by about 40 per cent since the beginning o f the miners' strike on
April 1. The consumption of silk and wool, sugar meltings, flour produc­
tion, and the output o f rubber tires increased in March. Production of
automobiles has shown seasonal increases since the first of the year but
has been in smaller volume than a year ago. The value o f building con­
tracts awarded in March was larger than at any previous time, and the
production of building materials has increased considerably in recent
weeks. The largest increases in contracts, as compared with last year,
were in the middle western states, while the largest decreases occurred in the
southeastern states. In the first half of April contracts awarded were in
slightly smaller volume than in the same period o f last year.
Trade
Sales o f department stores increased less than usual in March and were
slightly smaller than last year, owing in part to the lateness o f Easter.
Sales of mail order houses and chain stores, however, were somewhat larger
than a year ago. Inventories of department stores increased slightly more
than is usual in March in anticipation o f the expansion in retail trade before
the Easter holidays, and at the end o f the month they were in about the
same volume as a year ago. Wholesale trade in March continued slightly
smaller than in the corresponding period a year ago. Stocks o f merchandise
carried by wholesale firms were seasonally larger at the end of March than
in February but in most lines continued smaller than last year.
Freight car loadings which showed seasonal Increases in March de­
clined in the first ten days o f April, owing to the smaller shipments of
coal, but continued larger than in the corresponding period o f previous
years. Loadings o f miscellaneous freight and o f merchandise in less than
car load lots were in large volume.

Prices

1925

1926

1927

a™ra* cs. of we*kly figures for banks
m 101 leading cities. Latest fla r e s are av­
erages for first three weekly report dates
in April.

Federal Reserve Board's indexes of value of
bailding contracts awarded as reported by
the F. W. Dod*e Corporation (1923-1925 av100). Latest figures: February—ad­
justed. 131; unadjusted, 151.




The general level of wholesale commodity prices declined further
in March, reflecting decreases in most o f the important groups o f com ­
modities. Prices o f non-agricultural commodities as a group declined to
the lowest level since the war while the average fo r agricultural products
which advanced somewhat from November to February remained prac­
tically unchanged in March. During the first half o f April, prices o f winter
wheat, sugar, cotton, silk, bituminous coal, and hides advanced; while
those of hogs, crude petroleum, gasoline, and non-ferrous metals declined.
Bank Credit
There was some decline in volume in loans fo r commercial purposes
and in loans on securities at member banks in leading cities between the
middle of March and the middle o f April.
Member bank holdings of
United States securities, which had increased considerably in the middle of
March in connection with the operations of the Treasury, have declined
by more than $100,000,000 since that time but are still about $200,000,000
larger than in the early months o f the year.
At the Reserve banks, total bills and securities, which have fluctuated
near the $1,000,000,000 level since the end of January, showed little change
during the six weeks ending April 20th. Discounts fo r member banks were
in about the same volume on that date as on March 9th, while acceptances
showed a decrease and holdings o f United States securities a slight increase.

Index of National Business Conditions
VOLUME OF CHECK PAYMENTS
r

■
------------ -

PER Cl

------------ 2

I------------

------------ I<

S r-v A

y

V ^ A

K

U—---------5

I923

L

I924

*925

WHOLESALE

1031

0

TRADE
------- ES5.

:
o

1
......

!

I

0 --------------

ir= A

y *
o --------------

0

CAR
L O A D IN G S
... ......................
. .

PER CENT

____ PLR CENT

I50

0----

-- --150

IOO

O
i--- -

50

o----

A
**

A A4

▼

1322

192}

1954 '

3.
4.
5.

(S3 1

O

K
V
I&23 ] 1^24 ^»25

PIG IRON PRODUCTION

Member

T4i4

Bank

1325

Credit:

>92* 'WT
Loans,

March— 124.

°'

i& yiT

Time,

i
V

V

'Tars*

I&34.

19 27

LATEST FIGURES
March
6. Wholesale Trade, February—82.
7. Building Permits, March— 203.
March—
8. Car Loadings, March— 123.
Exports of Merchandise, March— 86.
10. Bituminous Coal Production, March— 150.
11. P i* Iron Production, March— 139.
12* Automobile Production, March— 186.

Investments,

Member Bank Deposits: Demand, March— 120.
202.
Check Payments, except New York, March— 137,
Commercial Failures, March— 166.
Retail Trade, March— 114.




A A; \ /

C7 "

^--- 100
---- 50

________ _____________ PER CENT

“/V

2.

‘ PERCENT

150

A

—145.

EXPORTS OF MERCHANDISE

---- 200

COAL PRODUCTION

1923

1925

0----

0

1.

1924

200

50

1922

1923

2©Oi

100

PER CENT

1922

IB7 'O