View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
Covering financial, industrial, and agricultural conditions
in the
Fourth Federal Reserve District
Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland
Vol. 15

Cleveland, Ohio, March 1, 1933

No. 3

Little change in the volume of fourth district business
from the level of recent months was manifest in the clos­
ing week o f January or the first three weeks of Febru­
a r y and a waiting attitude seems to be displayed gen­
erally. Increases in a few o f the less important indus­
tries of the district were reported, but these were partly
seasonal and were offset by reductions in other lines
so that the general level o f activity in the latter part of
February was about the same as a month earlier.

by department store sales, though, compared with a year
ago, a falling-off o f 22 per cent was shown in the dollar
value.
The general movement o f both retail and wholesale
comm odity prices was downward in January. The latter
improved temporarily coincident with the extremely cold
weather.

Employment throughout the district declined from De­
cember to January at a more-than-seasonal rate, with
each of the m ajor industries reporting reductions ex­
cept the textile, shoe, and automobile parts accessory
groups. Some weakness in the latter was reported in
the first half o f February.
Commercial failures did not Increase the usual sea­
sonal amount in January and were down 22 per cent
from the first month of 1932. Liabilities o f the default­
ing concerns were 38 per cent smaller in January than
a year ago.
The extremely cold weather in early February caused
a sharp increase in coal production at mines throughout
the country as retailers found it necessary to replenish
their depleted stocks. Coal production o f local mines
was nine per cent greater in January than a year a g o .
Manufacture o f shoes and clothing increased in Jan­
uary; the form er expanded at a much-greater-than-seasonal rate, and in the opening month o f the year was
7.4 per cent ahead of the same period o f 1932. Several
pottery plants resumed or increased operations in early
February follow ing the annual exhibit o f products.
Iron and steel production fluctuated at a rate between
19 and 20 per cent o f capacity in the first three weeks
of February though some weakness was visible near the
end of the period. The contraction in automobile pro­
duction was largely responsible for the decline in steel
output, there being very little demand from the railroad
or construction industries. A little more activity in resi­
dential construction in this district was reported in Jan­
uary compared with December, but the general building
situation is still very unfavorable.
Tire price reductions caused an increase in retail sales,
but this was not reflected in production schedules, which,
however, were up slightly in anticipation o f spring buy­
ing.
Retail trade throughout the district declined slightly
less than the usu?il seasonal amount in January, judging

The effect of the Michigan bank moratorium and the
subsequent limitations on banking operations within that
state was quite pronounced on industrial and credit con­
ditions in the fourth district in the month ending Febru­
ary 25. A goodly proportion of this district's business is
carried on with firms whose banking connections were
affected by the restrictions. Several o f the large manu­
facturers have now made arrangements for usual pay­
ments, but the flow o f goods and funds was temporarily
hampered by recent developments.




FINANCIAL

Not knowing what the effect o f the moratorium might
be, banks in this district fortified themselves against any
unusual demands by increasing their cash on hand. Re­
porting member banks increased their holdings of cash
from $21,000,000 to $36,000,000 between February 1 and
15, but in the follow ing week the amount o f cash in
vault declined somewhat. Borrowings from the reserve
bank increased quite sharply in the first three weeks of
February and the downward trend o f deposits at re­
porting member banks continued in the four latest weeks.
Savings deposits at 44 reporting banks throughout the
district declined 1.2 per cent in January, being down 0.8
per cent in western Pennsylvania and 1.4 per cent in
Ohio. Compared with a year ago savings deposits were
off 5.6 per cent on February 1.
The dollar volume o f check transactions in 24 cities of
the district in the five weeks ended February 21 was
16.8 per cent below the same interval o f 1932. This
was an improvement from the preceding period wheri
the reduction was 29 per cent.
In the month o f February there was one small bank
suspension in this district, compared with eight in Janu­
ary; two previously closed banks reopened and a new
National bank was form ed during the month.
Reserve Bank Credit. Total volume o f credit extended
by the Federal Reserve Bank o f Cleveland on February
21 was $230,545,000, an increase o f nearly $33,000,000

I

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

In the four latest weeks to a point only $2,000,000 be­
low the recent high figure reported in July, 1932, which
was the highest level for any time since 1920. The in*
crease in the four latest weeks was due to larger hold*
ings of all types o f paper.
Bills discounted for member banks rose $20,000,000
in the four weeks ended February 21 as demand for Fed­
eral reserve notes increased in the period and member
bank reserve deposits were reduced. At $46,041,000 on
the latest date, discounts were very much below a year
ago when they amounted to $121,217,000.
Holdings of bankers* acceptances, which remained at
unusually low levels for over six months, increased $5,000,000 in the latest week, coincident with sharp increase
in the System’s holdings follow ing the reduction in the
buying rate at New York.
Moderate increases occurred in the System's holdings of
U. S. Government securities in the three latest weeks and
on February 21 investments in Government securities, of
both this bank and other reserve banks, were close to
the high level maintained in the latter part of 1932.
Member bank reserve deposits were reduced $6,000,000
in the four latest weeks, but, at $137,000,000, they were
about the same as a year ago, though down considerably
from preceding years.
Circulation o f this bank’s Federal reserve notes in­
creased $30,000,000 in the first three weeks of February,
most of the expansion occurring between February 8
and 15, the period in which the Michigan bank holiday
was announced. Note circulation, at $305,863,000, is still
$5,000,000 below the same date a year ago, but the vol­
ume of notes outstanding is unusually large in view o f
the low level o f business and prices, compared with pre­
vious periods when a much smaller volume o f money
sufficed for the greater activity.
Member Bank Credit. Between January 25 and Feb­
ruary 21, loans and discounts o f reporting member banks
in leading cities of the fourth district were reduced $22,000,000, most o f the contraction occurring in the latest
week. Compared with a year ago, total loans, at $1,039,000,000, are down 17 per cent. Investments of member
banks increased in the first half o f February, but hold­
ings o f Government securities were reduced in the latest
week, so that total investments on February 21 were
$6,000,000 lower than on the last report date in Janu­
ary. Holdings o f other than Government securities were
reduced slightly in the four latest weeks.
On the latest date, member bank total investments
were up about nine per cent from a year ago, entirely
through larger holdings of Government securities, for
holdings of other securities were down $38,000,000, or
10.8 per cent. The increase in investments in the past
year offset part o f the contraction in loans in that pe­
riod and on the latest date total credit extended by mem­
ber banks was 7.2 per cent below the corresponding
date o f 1932.
Net demand deposits o f reporting member banks in
leading cities were reduced $41,000,000, or 5.4 per cent
between January 25 and February 21. Time deposits
declined $14,000,000, or 1.7 per cent in the same period.
Most of the reduction in both time and demand deposits
occurred in the latest week. Compared with a year ago,




demand deposits are down about five per cent and time
deposits about six per cent.
The follow ing table shown the principal assets and
liabilities of Federal reserve banks and reporting mem­
ber banks, for this district and the entire country, on
designated dates.
MANUFACTURING, MINING
Iron and
Steel

Steel production, which opened the new
year at about 12 per cent, had advanced
to 18 per cent by the third week o f
January, but a further rise to 19 per cent in the last
week of January apparently about exhausted the in­
dustry's momentum and operations held rather close to
this rate through the third week o f February. In the
last week o f the month considerable weakness in fourth
district steel centers was reported.
To a large extent, the early January rebound was caused
by a substantial flow of small miscellaneous requirements,
reinforced by moderately good automotive releases. By
late January, automotive orders receded slightly, no
further support from miscellaneous users materialized,
and the railroads and the building industries were or­
dering very little steel.
Benefiting from the dominant flow of automotive re­
quirements, fourth district mills through late January
and early February were operating on a more substantial
basis than other districts. Youngstown mills advanced
from 15 per cent in the last week o f January to 21 per
cent in the third week o f February, but receded four
points in the last week of the month; Pittsburgh ex­
panded from 16 per cent to 21 but dropped back to 18
per cent; Cleveland, evidencing the easier situation in
the automotive industry, retreated from 41 to 31 per
cent.
January steel ingot production, for the country as a
whole, developed a substantial gain over December when
it turned in a daily rate of 38,704 gross tons and a total
o f 1,006,297 tons, this representing 17.78 per cent o f ca­
pacity. In December, the daily rate was 32,485 tons, the
month’s total 844,618 tons and the per cent o f capacity

Banking Statistics
Federal Reserve Banks
Federal Reserve Bank
of Cleveland
(In Millions)
Feb. 21. Feb. 24. Jan. 25,
1933
1932
11933
273
243
241
Gold Reserve*..........
27
46
121
7
3
8
69
169
177
U. S. Securities.........
Total
Bills . and
197
199
231
Securities...............
Federal reserve notes
277
306
311
in circulation........
149
146
145
Total Deposits.........

Federal Reserve System
(In Millions)
Feb. 21. Feb. 24, Jan. 25,
1933
1933
1932
2,938
3,259
3,118
835
265
327
133
31
174
1,763
1,834
741
2,340

1,724

2,064

3,000
2,399

2,643
1,973

2,706
2,587

Weekly Reporting Member Banks

Loans on securities.
A ll other loans.........
T otal Loans..............
Investm ents..............
Demand D ep osits...
Tim e Deposits..........

Fourth District
(In Millions)
Feb. 21, Feb. 24. Jan. 25.
1932
1933
1933
479
558
474
689
582
565
1,247
:1,061
1,039
810
804
739
836
791
835
m
841
789

United S u t:e»
(I n Millions)
Feb. 21, Feb. 24, Jan. 25,
1933
1933
1932
4,173
4,199
5,438
7,171
5,867
5,666
10,040
9.865
12,609
6,997
8,579
8,392
11,936
11,001
11.286
5,685
5,656
5,499

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
15.02.
In January, 1932, the industry was engaged
25.96 per cent.
The recovery in pig iron in January was less marked,
the daily rate being 18,348 gross tons, the m onth’s
total 568,785 tons and the per cent of capacity engaged
12.6. In December the rate was 17,650 tons, the month’s
total 547,179 tons and the rate o f activity 12.5. A net
gain of three, all o f the steelworks classification, put
active blast furnace stacks up to 45 out o f 291 as of
January 31.
From the week ended January 21 to that ended Feb­
ruary 28 the reduction in the iron and steel composite
of the magazine Steel was from $28.55 to $28.31. The low
point in this period was $28.27, with a recovery of four
cents in the third week o f February as a price stabiliza­
tion movement got under way, prompted partly by
publication o f the huge losses experienced by the indus­
try in 1932. Total deficit for the entire steel industry
was estimated at $160,000,000, or over $12 for every
ton of steel produced in the period.
In mid-February, therefore, many wire products, which
had suffered reductions in January, were advanced $1
per ton; sheets were being reclassified to produce a more
impregnable price structure and semifinished steel pro*
ducers accounted it an achievement to hold their levels
against the pressure which demoralized sheets and wire.

Ooal

Output o f coal in January, both in the
country and the fourth district, de­
clined more than seasonally from December as moderate weather affected domestic consump­
tion and industrial activity and transportation of goods
fell off. Production of local mines in the opening month
o f the year exceeded the same period o f 1932 by 9.4 per
cent, while in the entire country output was slightly un­
der last year. Compared with the average of the past
ten years, however, mines of this district extracted 47
per cent less coal in January, there being 10,033,000 tons
produced in the month.
The extreme cold weather in early February caused
daily average production to increase about 28 per cent
and in the second week of the month it exceeded daily
average output in the corresponding week of 1932 by 13
per cent. Retail distribution facilities were taxed to ca­
pacity furnishing household coal and were compelled
immediately to replenish depleted stocks.
Practically
no change in industrial demand was reported. Larger




3

sales o f domestic-size coal have resulted in an increase ta
slack coal stocks which are difficult to dispose o f be­
cause o f the depressed industrial situation.
Total stocks o f bituminous coal at the beginning o f the
year were lower than at any corresponding time since
1920, follow ing the great strike o f 1919. The supply of
coal on hand at industrial and retail yards was 35,500,000 tons, or 16.4 per cent less than a year ago. Re­
tailers had 9.5 per cent less coal on hand than a year
ago, while industrial stocks were down 18.4 per
cent in the same period. Prompt railroad deliveries and
the fact that the rate of production at mines is much
less than capacity make it unnecessary for users to keep
large stocks on hand.
Automobiles

January output of automobiles in the
United States was about 12.8 per cent
ahead o f December and exceeded pro­
duction in the opening month o f 1932 by 1.5 per cent.
The January increase from the preceding month followed
an expansion o f 80 per cent in December compared with
November, and activity in the latest month was up about
200 per cent from the low point in October.
The December-January increase was less than has oc­
curred in preceding years at that season, however, and
the adjusted index o f the Federal Reserve Board dropped
from 60 to 43 per cent o f the 1923-25 monthly average.
Recent month-to-month changes in the automobile in­
dustry lose much o f their significance because of the
changed seasonal pattern which appears to be developing
in the industry.
A rather sharp falling-off in February was indicated
by the weekly production estimates. In the third week of
the month the Annalist adjusted weekly index was only
slightly above the low point of October. Operations at
several plants were affected by labor disturbances,
and the fact that production declined at a time when in
past years it was increasing caused the index to drop
sharply. These difficulties appeared to be about overcome
in the third week of the month as schedules at nine plants
were higher than in the preceding period. The increases
were comparatively small so far as total output was con­
cerned and reductions at five other plants, including one
m ajor small-car factory, more than offset the gains. Now
that dealers are supplied with models, production is be­
ing held down pending developments in the retail sales
field.
Retail demand for passenger cars improved in Decem­
ber and, on the basis o f preliminary returns for January,
was slightly ahead o f the first month o f 1932 and almost
double the December total. Truck sales also increased in
December, and in January were only slightly below the
corresponding month of the preceding year, according to
reports.
Tires,
Rubber

The rubber tire industry has just passed
through another price war, the effects
o f which were more widely felt than
some o f the previous ones. An almost chaotic situation
prevailed for a few days and a huge volume o f tires was
sold at less than half the prevailing list price. Dealers’
stocks were sharply reduced as a result o f the increased
selling, and though there has been some restocking, oper­

4

THIS MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

ations at Akron factories have not expanded to any extent.
The net result Is that prices appear to have stabilized at
lower levels with the same relative relationship existing
prior to the price-cutting.
A ccording to reliable reports, the number o f employees
engaged in tire production in January was ten per cent
below the same period o f 1932, and in addition the num­
ber o f hours worked has been lowered from 20 to 25 per
cent in the past year. There was little change, either in
the number o f employees or hours worked, in January and
the first half o f February from that prevailing in Decem­
ber, though usually there is an expansion at that time o f
year in preparation for the greater activity in the spring
months.
Tire shipments in December and January to the auto­
mobile industry were up slightly, as a result o f the increase
in car assemblies, but replacement sales, prior to the pricecutting, were very limited. December, 1932, shipments,
according to the Rubber Manufacturers’ Association, were
35 per cent below the same month of 1931 and were 8.3
per cent below production in the closing month o f 1932.
Output in December was 25 per cent smaller than in the
corresponding period of the preceding year. W ith the ex­
ception o f one month, production o f tires in the last half
o f 1932 exceeded manufacturers’ sales by a considerable
margin; stocks in producers’ hands increased over 50 per
cent in the half-year and on December 31 were only 1.7
per cent smaller than at the end o f 1931. The increase
in the six-month period was partly a rebound from the
low level to which inventories receded prior to the date
the Federal tax became effective.
Crude rubber imports in January were only slightly
smaller than in the same month o f 1932, but the supply
o f crude rubber in this country continues to be close to
25 per cent larger than a year ago. W orld production o f
crude rubber has been curtailed until it is aboTit in line
with demand, but any change in takings would almost
certainly be follow ed by increased production. Crude rub­
ber prices recently have been slightly under three cents a
pound.
Clothing

The clothing and textile branch of in­
dustry in this district is unique in that
the number employed by the 37 firms
reporting to the Ohio State Bureau of Business Research
was five per cent higher in January than a year ago, and,
at 88 per cent o f the 1926 monthly average, the index
was unchanged from December. In the separate branches,
however, some variations were shown. The number en­
gaged in the manufacture of men’s clothing was down
three per cent in January from the preceding month,
though the index was 96 per cent o f the base period, one
point lower than a year ago. In the wom en’s and miscel­
laneous branches, the number of employees increased
three per cent from December to January and in the latest
month was 13 per cent above a year ago.
Correspondents reported an increase in sales as well as
in operations in January and the first part o f February,
but this is largely a seasonal change. Production o f spring
models caused many plants to operate at capacity levels
for the past several weeks, and the lateness of the Easter
date this year is expected to prolong the spring season
somewhat.
Buying by retailers has not been in particularly large




volume, but the number o f orders already placed was
quite encouraging to producers, considering the general
state o f affairs. Demand is confined largely to low-priced
merchandise and the decline in prices from a year ago
makes the dollar comparison an unfavorable one.
Stocks o f raw and manufactured goods in hands of
producers are low and retail stocks also are down. On
Jani&ary 31 stocks o f women's clothing at fourth district
department stores were valued at 34 per cent less than a
year earlier and men’s clothing stocks were down about
29 per cent in the same period. The decline in the retail
price o f clothing at department stores, which amounted to
about 12 per cent in the past year according to Fairchild
index, was partly responsible for the drop in the value of
clothing stocks at local stores.
Other
Manufacturing

Irregularities were reflected in operations o f the smaller manufacturing in­
dustries o f the district in the latter
part of January and the first half o f February. Disturb­
ances in automobile centers from several causes affected
production schedules at many factories o f the district and
the general waiting attitude displayed in many fields was
also disturbing.

Auto Parts and Accessories. Employment at plants en­
gaged in the manufacture o f automobile parts increased
12 per cent from December to January, but in the latest
month the index of the Ohio Bureau o f Business Research
was only 64 per cent of the 1926 average, a reduction o f
nine per cent from a year ago. A slackening occurred in
the first part o f February as releases on orders were held
up due to disturbances at Detroit and elsewhere, and to
the slowing down in retail automobile sales. Inventories
are satisfactory generally, and less raw and finished goods
are on hand than a year ago.
Clay Products. A resumption or an increase in opera­
tions at several clay products plants occurred in early Feb­
ruary, the rebound offsetting, in part at least, the decline
in January which resulted in a 15 per cent drop from De­
cember in employment at local plants. Increased orders
follow ed the annual show^ at Pittsburgh, but plants are
operating at only slightly more than half capacity. Con­
ditions at brick and tile plants are very depressed.
Glass. Conditions in the glass industry showed prac­
tically no change in the past four weeks. Employment in
January was up one per cent from December and was
three per cent above one year ago. Plate glass shipments
were interrupted by developments in the automobile in­
dustry. Container sales and shipments also declined, both
of which affected employment somewhat.
Hardware, Machinery. Employment in the machinery
industry dropped three per cent from December to Janu­
ary and one per cent in the metal products industry in the
same period. In both cases the change was greater than
seasonal. Machine tools were in slightly better demand
in early February and electrical supply sales were larger
in that period than in January.
Engineering special­
ty sales dropped in January. Stocks o f raw and finished
goods are materially below last year.
Paints. Sales o f paints in the first part o f February im ­
proved and inquiries from dealers, whose stocks are low
generally, have been more numerous.
The number o f

I

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
hours worked by local plants is somewhat under last year
and the number o f employees also is down. Stocks of
finished goods are being increased in anticipation o f great­
er spring demand.
Shoes. Production of footwear at 31 establishments in
the fourth district in January was up considerably more
than seasonally from December, the 42 per cent increase
in the two months being the largest for any similar period
on record. The expansion was larger than was reported
for the entire country and output o f local plants in Janu­
ary was 7.4 per cent ahead o f the initial month of 1932.
TRADE
Retail

The dollar value o f sales in January
at reporting department stores through­
out the district was 22.4 per cent be­
low the corresponding period of 1932, the falling-off
ranging between 18 per cent at Akron and 26 per cent
at Pittsburgh. F or the fiscal year ending January 31,
sales were off 26 per cent.

The reduction in sales from December was about the
usual seasonal amount, and the adjusted index was 54
per cent o f the monthly average o f the three years
1923-25.
This was still slightly above the low point
touched in the summer o f 1932, though sales in the
entire country declined to a new low level in January.
Retail department store prices declined one per cent
in January, according to Fairchild's index, and on the
latest date were 12.5 per cent below the same date a
year ago.
The proportion o f basement sales to total store sales
was somewhat greater in January than a year ago and,
on the basis of figures received from 29 stores, the d e ­
cline in basement sales, compared with last year, was
17.7 per cent as against a falling-off in total store sales
o f 22.4 per cen t
In the individual departments smaller declines than
the drop in total sales were shown in the cotton and
woolen dress goods;, linens, domestics, art goods, hand­
kerchiefs, underwear, sports’ wear, furs, men’s clothing
and furnishings, draperies, glassware and sporting goods
departments.
The dollar value o f stocks on January 31 was 23 per
cent below the same date a year ago and the reduction
from December was slightly more than seasonal, the ad­
justed index declining from 54.3 to 53.9 per cent of the
monthly average of the three years 1923-25.
As for several past months, the ratio o f credit to to­
tal sales in January was below a year ago, the reduction
being 4.2 per cent. The 4.6 per cent rati© o f installment
to total sales was the same as in January, 1932, but buy­
ing on regular 30-day accounts has been curtailed.
Collections continue to hold up fairly well, payments
during January on accounts receivable on December 31
being only 2.7 per cent below a year ago. The dollar
volume o f collections is down because o f the reduction
in sales.
Chain grocery and drug sales were down quite sharply
in January, the reduction in the form er from the same
month last year being 9.5 per cent, while sales o f the
latter were down 15 per cent.




W holesale

All lines of wholesale trade declined sea­
sonally in January in this district, but
the reduction was smaller than in 1932
and about the same as occurred in early 1931. Compared
with a year ago, sales were down approximately 16 per
cent and were only 43 per cent of the monthly average
of the three years 1923-25. In the four lines reporting
sales, wholesale grocery business was down 16 per cent
from a year ago and 7.5 per cent from December; dry
goods sales were off 16 per cent from January, 1932,
and 27 per cent from December o f that year; hardware
sales in January were 18.5 per cent under last year and
20 per cent below Decem ber; and drug sales, which have
been holding up relatively better than most lines, were
down 10.5 per cent from January, 1932, and 8.5 per
cent from the closing month o f last year.
In view of the sharp reduction in sales, collections
have held up quite well. Dollar value o f stocks in all
reporting lines has been materially reduced.
BUILDING

Construction activity in the fourth district in January
was valued at $4,074,000, a reduction o f 20 per cent from
December and o f 41 per cent from January, 1932. In
past years the value o f building contracts awarded showed
rather wide fluctuations from December to January, being
partly affected by weather conditions, etc.
Variations
ranging from an increase o f 72 per cent to a reduction of
51 per cent have been shown in the past ten years, an
expansion being reported in four years and a contraction
in six years.
Total awards in the latest month were less than oneseventh as large as the average value o f contracts let in
January in the preceding ten years and the report cover­
ing the first half o f February indicated a further fallingoff in that period.
Residential building in this locality showed important
gains over December, chiefly in the construction of small
houses, though there were only 200 projects started in
January throughout the district. In the non-residential
class, increases over December were reported for comm er­
cial, educational, hospital, and religious and memorial
buildings; losses were shown for factories, and public and
recreational structures. Substantial reduction, both from
December and January, 1932, were evident in public util­
ity contracts awarded in January and new public work
projects also compared unfavorably with these periods.
The situation in the building supply industry, naturally,
is very unfavorable. Stocks o f manufactured materials
are almost nil and raw material stocks are down sharply
from a year ago. Orders received by lumber producers
were considerably smaller than in early 1933. Cement
production at mills in this district dropped sharply in Jan­
uary, partly seasonal, and was 13 per cent below output
in the same month o f 1932.
AGRICULTURE
The Department o f
farms as o f January
number o f cattle and
tire country from a

Agriculture’s report o f livestock
1, 1933, showed an increase in
hogs on farms throughout the
year earlier, but the number

on
the
en­
of

6

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

horses, mules, and sheep declined in the period.
The
farm value o f all livestock on the latest date was esti­
mated at $2,661,985,000, a drop o f 16.7 per cent in the
past year and 40 per cent from January 1, 1931. The
farm value per head o f horses increased slightly in the
past year, but the value o f all other animals declined
sharply. The number o f cattle on farms increased 3.9
per cent in 1932 and was 15 per cent above 1928, the
recent low. The number o f swine on farms was 2.8 per
cent larger than on January 1, 1932, but the number of
sheep was 3.2 per cent smaller than at the beginning o f
last year, the first reduction since 1923.
In the states included in the fourth district, the num­
ber o f horses and colts on farms as of January 1 was
about three per cent smaller than a year earlier. There
was, however, a greater number of meat animals on farms
as 1933 began than at the time of the survey in 1932. The
increase in the number of cattle on farms (including those
on feed and those kept for m ilk) ranged from one per
cent in Pennsylvania to three per cent in Kentucky and
West Virginia and five per cent in Ohio.
The number of sheep and lambs on farms in this section
was practically unchanged in the past year which was in
contrast with the decline o f 3.2 per cent in the entire coun­
try. Ohio ranks seventh in sheep-raising, having 2,129,000
o f these animals on farms on January 1.
Swine on farms increased from eight to 20 per cent in
the four states of the district, compared with an increase
of 2.8 per cent in all states. In 1932 there were over
4,000,000 pigs raised on Ohio farms, the number remaining
on farms on January 1 being 2,486,000.
Tobacco

Selling o f this district’s 1932 tobacco
crop has been about completed, only a
small amount of tag-end tobacco remain­
ing to be disposed o f at the present time. This type of
leaf usually brings a low price, but there has been a de­
cided drop in tobacco prices in recent weeks, so that, grade
for grade, the prevailing price now is materially less than
it was when the markets reopened in January after the
holiday.
The average price received for burley tobacco sold on
auction floors this season was quite satisfactory on the
whole, according to reports, though final figures are not

yet available. The selling season opened with an average
price in the first week o f $13.43 a hundred pounds, com ­
pared with $11.77 in the same period o f 1931. As the
season progressed, prices advanced until a range o f 15-16
cents a pound was reached in early January. This was
almost 50 per cent better than the average price for all
burley tobacco sold in the 1931-32 season.
The returns this season were well distributed, for more
o f the crop was o f average quality, with leaf thin in
character and of more desirable color, than in 1931. In
that year a small part of the crop was of high quality,
some o f it was o f average quality, but the bulk o f the
crop was o f low grade. Because o f the condition of the
1932 crop, prices for low and medium grades o f tobacco
have been considerably higher than a year ago, while top
grades are cheaper.
Farmers in this district are quite ©nthused over the
favorable price they have received for their crop, which,
however, has been largely a direct result of the very poor
tobacco yield in other sections o f the country and to the
25 per cent reduction in the size o f the 1932 burley
tobacco crop from the preceding year. Higher prices have
resulted in talk o f larger acreages in the com ing season.
CHECK CliEARINGS
That the Federal check tax o f two cents on every item
drawn has had an inhibiting effect on the number of
checks used in this district is clearly brought out by
the accompanying chart. This shows an index o f the
daily average number o f checks handled by the Federal
Reserve Bank o f Cleveland and its branches in Cincin­
nati and Pittsburgh with the daily average o f the three
years 1923-25 representing 100 per cent. The i n d e x was
adjusted for seasonal variations so that irregularities
resulting from this source do not influence the movement
o f the curve.
The increase in the volume of business done and the
increased popularity o f the check as a means o f set­
tling financial obligations is shown by the sharp ad­
vance in the index during the years 1919 to 1929. The
depression o f 1921 had little effect on the upward m ove­
ment, but the 1924 period of depressed business caused
the index to level off in that year and early 1925 and

CHECKS CLEARED BY FR.B.OF C LEVELA N D AND BRANCHES

1

[................

!
1
DAILY <
A VERAGE NUMBER 1923-192*i-100
SEASONA LLY A O Jl JSTED

\

j

--- ----- ----- ----- ----- ----- ----- ----- --- ------------ ----- --- — ,
— lo
1919




1920

1921

1922

1923

1924

1925

1926

1927

1926

1929

1930

1931

1932

.

1933

7

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
from then until 1929 the advance was at a slower rate.
The peak in the number o f checks handled was reached
in late 1929, though the daily average number handled
in the entire year 1930 was slightly higher than in 1929.
Every business day o f 1930 this bank and its branches
cleared on an average 286,609 checks. This does not
include checks handled in "packages,” each package be­
ing counted and handled as one check, although the
package might have contained many individual checks.
However, so far as the movement of the index is con­
cerned, this in all probability would cause the index
to show an even sharper decline, for package checks arise
only in clearings against banks in reserve bank or branch
cities. Payment o f local bills by cash instead of check
is much more feasible, and has been resorted to, to a
greater extent, than in payment o f out-of-town bills.
The daily average number o f checks handled by this
bank and its branches in 1932 was 15.8 per cent under
1930 and 12.0 per cent below 1931, the decline in general
business being responsible for part of the downward move­
ment in the past three years.
The sharp drop in the adjusted index in July, 1932,
however, clearly shows that the levying o f the check tax
was directly or indirectly responsible for a large part of
the falling-off. F or the past seven months, the number
of checks passing through these offices has been close to
the level o f 1924, and was 17 per cent below the same
period of 1931.
Increased postage rates, which occurred at the same
time the check tax w'as levied, and the wider use o f a
metered service charge, are also factors affecting the use
o f c h e c k s , for the writing and mailing of each check now
costs not less than five cents and may cost as much as
ten cents. The decline in the number of checks used is
partly responsible for the increased amount o f money
in circulation.

(1933 compared with 1932)




Percentage
increase or decrease
COLLEC­
SALES
STOCKS
TION S
Jan.
Jan.
Jan.
— 17.8
— 23.8
— 9.3
— 22.5
— 26.9
— 27.4
— 18.0
— 31.6
— 23.7
— 23.0
— 20.4
— 20.2
— 25.5
— 21.9
— 28.2
— 21.6
— 28.1
— 22.2
— 20.4
— 21.0
— 23.2
— 26.5
— 17.2
— 32.8
— 27.3
— 22.9
— 22.4
— 33.1
— 26.9
— 29.3

— 18.9
— 21.5
— 20.5

— 32.4
— 28.7
— 5 .5
— 23.5
— 41.8
— 26.6
— 26.2

— 31.1
— 23.2
— 25.3
— 29.5
— 36.9
— 17.0
— 25.6
— 45.3
— 34.5
— 33.6

— 15.3
— 9 .5
— 31.0
— 18.8
— 8.3
— 14.4
— 22.8
— 9 .8
— 16.0
— 16.2
— 10.5
— 18.5

.....
— 22.’ 7
— 19.1

(000 omitted)
Jan.,
Jan., % change
Fourth District Unless otherwise specified
1933
1932 from 1932
— 29.0
Bank Debits— 24 cities.........................................$ 1,484,000 2,090,000
Savings Deposits— end o f month:
27 selected banks, O. & Pa................................$
629,647
665,739 — 5 .4
—
6.2
Postal Receipts (9 cities).....................................3
2,355
2,510
Life Insurance Sales:
74,801
96,984
— 22.9
Ohio and Pa.......................................................... $
Retail Sales:
Department Stores— 54 firms........................... $
9,328
12,023
— 22.4
— 29.3
Wearing apparel— 12 firms................................513
726
— 26.2
Furniture—-44 firms............................................ $
298
403
Wholesale Sales:
Drugs— 13 firms................................................... $
1,127
1,259
— 10.5
— 16.3
Dry Goods— 11 firms..........................................S
597
713
2,749
3,273
Groceries— 33 firms............................................. $
— 16.0
Hardware— 14 firms...........................................%
584
716
— 18.4
970
1,916
Building Contracts— Residential....................... %
— 49.4
— T otal..................................$
4,074
6,924
— 41.2
Commercial Failures— Liabilities.......................$
5,951
9,628
— 38.2
— N um ber............................
251
3221 — 2 2 .0
Production:
Pig Iron, U. S.............................................. Tons
567
973
— 41.7
Steel Ingots, U. S.......................................... Tons
1,006
1,459
— 31.0
- f 0 .6
Automobiles— Pass. Cars............................U. S.
*
*
Trucks................................U. S.
*
*
+ 5.7
Bituminous C oal...........................................Tons
10,033
9,167
+ 9 .4
Cement— O., W. Pa., W. Va.....................Bbls.
214
246
— 13.0
Electric Power—-O., Pa., K y.................k.w.h.
1,083*
1,1803 — 8 . 2
Petroleum— O., Pa., K y............................. Bbls.
1,792s
2,076*
— 13.7
Shoes ............................................................Pairs
*
*
+ 7 .4
Tires, U. S.............................................. Casings
1,5933
2,125*
— 25.0
factual number
3 December
Confidential

Debits to Individual Accounts
(Thousands of Dollars)
5 weeks
ending
Feb. 21,
1933
43,359
5,962
.,.
19,431
411,233
..,
Greensburg. . .
. .

Wholesale and Retail Trade

D E P A R T M E N T STORES (53)
A kron.............................................................
Cincinnati.....................................................
Cleveland......................................................
Columbus......................................................
Pittsburgh.....................................................
T oled o............................................................
Wheeling.......................................................
Other Citie«.................................................
District..........................................................
W E A R IN G A P P A R E L (12)
Cincinnati.....................................................
Other Cities.................................................
D istrict..........................................................
F U R N IT U R E (44)
C incinnati................................................
Cleveland......................................................
Columbus......................................................
D ayton...........................................................
T o le d o ...........................................................
Other Cities........................ .........................
District............................... ..........................
CH A IN STORES*
Drug*-—District (4 )............ .......................
Groceries— District (6 )..............................
W H OLESALE GRO C E RIE S (33)
A kron...................................... .......................
C levelan d ...........................................
E rie.................................................................
Pittsburgh.....................................................
T oled o............................................................
Other Cities.................................................
D istrict..........................................................
W H OLESALE D R Y GOODS ( 1 0 ) ....
W H OLESALE DRUGS (1 3 ).................
W H OLESALE H A R D W A R E ( 1 4 ) . ...
•Sale* per individual unit operated.

Fourth District Business Statistics

....
....
....
*
— 20.6
— 20.2
— 7.8
— 14.0

43,862
17,892
2,197
5,080
6,176

21,538
7,716
2,622
M iddletow n...
5,059
Oil C ity ..........
8,072
. 518,480
..,
11,025
Steubenville. .
4,852
77,270
4,350
25,755
Youngstown. .
22,570
5,003
T o ta l.............

%
change
from
1932
— 22.5
— 14.2
— 11.4
— 18.0
— 13.6
— 17.7
— 13.7
— 32.8
— 39.5
— 18.5
— 33.5
— 45.9
— 16.6
— 9 .0
— 35.6
— 25.8
— 18.1
— 16.9
— 21.2
— 29.0
— 14.2
— 14.0
— 13.6
— 28.1
— 26.4
— 16.8

Year to date Year to date
Dec. 29,
Dec. 31,
1932 to
1931 to
Feb. 21,
Feb. 24,
1933
1932
84,660
117,857
11,593
13,847
35,071
40,800
467,374
589,949
795,465
1,061,974
175,499
227,712
85,463
100,003
34,951
51,010
4,104
7,409
9,186
13,966
12,354
17,594
3,177
5,492
52,713
43,314
14,737
15,495
5,195
7,498
9,869
12,363
15,631
19,148
992,290
1,306,196
20,701
28,446
8,978
12,870
143,519
175,219
7,884
9,406
51,543
61,981
42,201
67,312
9,662
13,984
3,084,421
4,030,244

%
change
from
1932
— 28.2
— 16.3
— 14.0
— 20.8
— 25.1
— 22.9
— 14.5
— 31.5
— 4 4.6
— 34.2
— 29.8
— 4 2.2
— 17.8
— 4 .9
— 30.7
— 20.2
— 18.4
— 24.0
— 27.2
— 30.2
— 18.1
— 16.2
— 16.8
— 37.3
— 30.9
— 23.5.

Fourth District Business Indexes
(1923-1925 = 100)

Bank Debits (24 cities)........................................
Commercial Failures (N u m ber)........................
“
• “
(Liabilities)........ ............
Postal Receipts (9 cities).....................................
Sales— Life Insurance (Ohio & P a .)..................
“ — Department Stores (53 firm s)...........
“ -----Wholesale Drugs (13 firm s)....................
“ .—
Dry Goods (10 firms)
“ —
“
Groceries (33 firm s)............
“ —
“
Hardware (14 firm s)...........
" —
"
All (7 0 )............................ ..
“ — Chain Drug (3 firm s)**..........................
Building Contracts ( T o t a l ) ................................
“
“
(Residential).......................
Production— Coal (O., W. Pa,, E. K y .)..........
— Cement (O., W. Pa., W. Va.)
“
— Elec. Power (O., Pa., K y .) * .. . .
— Petroleum (0 ., Pa., K y .)* ...........
“
— Shoes......................... - . . . . . ............
^December.
**Per individual unit operate^.

Jan., Jan., Jan., Jan., Jan.,
1933 1932 1931 1930 1929
55
77
122
127
136
172
174
121
134
221
135
218
271
138
105
91
97
115
126
122
89
109
116
137
130
43
54
70
77
84
73
8 4 ' 101
130
106
23
28
48
62
70
48
57
76
91
92
29
36
49
64
74
43
70
83
52
90
65
86
77
82
81
9
15
38
73
115
6
11
29
46
66
83
101
55
51
103
18
42
20
60
68
129
141
152
161
149
97
106
128
107
112
72
67
61
89
104

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

Summary of National Business Conditions
By the Federal Reserve Board
Volume of industrial production increased in January by less than the
usual seasonal amount and factory employment and payrolls continued to
decline.
Prices o f commodities at wholesale, which declined further in
January, showed relatively little change in the first three weeks o f February.
Production and Employment

Index of industrial production, adjusted for sea­
sonal
variation
(1923-1925 average = 100).
Latest figure, January, 64.

Industrial activity, as measured by the Board's index, which makes
allowance for usual seasonal changes, declined from 66 per cent o f the
1923-1925 average in December to 64 per cent in January, which compares
with a low level o f 58 per cent last July. Output o f coal declined consider­
ably, contrary to the usual seasonal tendency. Increases in activity in the
cotton and silk industries were somewhat less than seasonal in amount, and
there was a slight decline in production at woolen mills. Output o f shoes
increased seasonally. Activity in the steel industry showed a seasonal in­
crease during January, and little change during the first three weeks o f
February. Autom obile production, which had increased substantially in Becember, showed a further slight increase in January.
Factory employment declined between the middle of December and the
middle o f January by considerably more than the seasonal amount. De­
creases were reported in most lines except in the cotton, wool, and silk
industries, where employment increased.
Construction contracts awarded were in about the same volume in
January as in December, according to the F. W . Dodge Corporation; in the
first half o f February the value o f awards showed a decline.
Distribution

Federal Reserve Board’s index of factory em­
ployment with adjustment for seasonal varia­
tion (1923-1925 average =r 100). Latest figure,
Jannary, 59.4.

Volume of freight traffic was somewhat smaller in January than in
December, reflecting a reduction in shipments of coal. Sales by department
stores decreased after Christmas by more than the usual seasonal amount.

W holesale Prices

...

.

The general level o f wholesale comm odity prices, as measured by the
index o f the Bureau of Labor Statistics, declined further from 62.6 per cent
o f the 192 6 average in December to 61.0 per cent in January, reflecting
substantial reductions in the prices of crude petroleum, gasoline, textiles,
and dairy and poultry products. Prevailing prices for wheat, cotton, and
hogs in January and the first three weeks o f February were somewhat above
the low levels reached in December.

WHOLESALE PR ICE s
i|

| --

i

■■■’

P rotects

■'Tooda'"

s

Other
CommotTffjea

\
^

—

*\j

Bank Credit
B2S

Indexes of the United States Bureau of Labor
Statistics <1926 = 100). Latest figures, Jannaiy,
farm products, 42.0; foods, 55.8; other commodi­
ties, 67.3.

Between January 4 and February 21, there was an increase o f $319,000,000 in the demand for currency, accompanying banking disturbances
in different parts o f the country, and a decrease o f $64,000,000 in the
country’s stock of monetary gold. These demands were met by member
banks in part by the use of their balances at the reserve banks, which
declined by $243,000,000 during the period, but continued to be considerably
above legal requirements. Reserve bank holdings o f United States securities
declined by $88,000,000 between January 4 and February 1, but increased by
$70,000,000 during the follow ing three weeks; their holdings o f acceptances
increased by $141,000,000, and discounts for member banks increased by
$76,000,000.
Loans and investments o f reporting member banks in leading cities
declined by about $100,000,000 during the five weeks ending February 15.
The banks’ net demand deposits declined by $390,000,000, reflecting largely
reductions in bankers’ balances, and time deposits showed a decrease of
$93,000,000 for the period.

Monthly averages of weekly figures for report*
ing member hanks in leading cities. Latest
figures are averages of first three weeks in
February.




Money rates in the open market were slightly firmer during the first
half o f February. Open market rates on 90-day bankers* acceptances, which
had been *4 o f 1 per cent, had increased to % o f 1 per cent by Februray 20.
Rates on prime commercial paper and on stock exchange loans remained
unchanged. The minimum buying rate on bills at the Federal reserve banks
o f Boston, New York, and Chicago was reduced from 1 to % o f 1 per cent.