View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

ivivn
nL
nY
M ON Ti H

IN

FEDERAL RESERVE BANK Of CLEVELAND

THIS

IS S U I

Expansion in the Cement Industry. . . . . . .
Farmers M echanize on C red it...........

/ W ?<?57

Board o f G overnors' Statement on
Instalment C re d it.....................
The 1 9 5 7 Survey of Ownership of

CEMENT MILLS IN THE FOURTH DISTRICT

A rising demand for portland cement has boosted
production to near ca­
pacity levels at Fourth
District mills during the
past several years, An
expansion of mill facili­
ties is now under way to
meet a n t i c i p a t e d in­
creases in demand over
the next few years.

14 mills in the Fourth District.)




2

Expansion in the Cement Industry

to keep pace with the steady
rise of construction activity to new record
rates year after year, the portland cement
industry has increased its manufacturing
capacity by about one-third in the last ten
years. At the same time, the industry has
made more efficient use of its facilities, rais­
ing the operating rate from around twothirds of capacity in 1946 to virtually full
capacity during the past two years. Conse­
quently, portland cement production in the
United States increased more than 90 percent
between 1946 and 1956.
The near-term outlook for cement suggests
further increases in demand during the next
few years. An enlarged highway construction
program, coupled with the probable continua­
tion of high levels of activity in many other
types of construction, points in this direction.
The cement industry has programmed an ex­
pansion of its manufacturing facilities to
meet the expected rise in demand. The ca­
pacity of the nation’s cement mills, rated at
over 320 million barrels annually in 1956,
will be one-fifth larger by the end of 1958
when all of the planned improvements and
additions are completed.(1)
n an e ffo r t

I

The cement industry, unlike many other
industries, is not identified primarily with
any particular area of the country. Plant
( l ) Based upon a survey conducted in December 1955 by the
U. S. Bureau of Mines. Preliminaiy capacity figures for 1956
■how that capital additions fell slightly short of original ex­
pectations, but there is no reason to believe that the 1958
target has been lowered.




location is governed by the availability of
raw materials and fuels, plus the nearness of
markets. Since transportation costs bulk large
in total costs to the consumer, cement mills
tend to be scattered over the United States in
general conformance with the population,
each mill serving markets in its own immedi­
ate area.

Expansion Slower at Fourth District Mills
The cement industry in the Fourth Fed­
eral Reserve District is similar to that of the
rest of the country in most respects, but it
has not expanded as rapidly. Production at
Fourth District cement mills, for example,
has fluctuated in about the same pattern and
increased at about the same rate as the na­
tional totals during the past decade. How­
ever, the rate of expansion by mills of the Dis­
trict was less than half that of the entire
industry during the 1946-56 period and Dis­
trict mills plan to continue this relatively
slower rate of expansion during the next few
years.
Eleven companies operate 14 cement mills
in Ohio and western Pennsylvania having a
combined annual capacity of 28.6 million
barrels of portland cement in early 1957.
Expansion now under way will boost the
cement capacity of the District to 31.2 million
barrels annually by the end of 1958, or about
28 percent greater than the 1946 total. In
contrast, the industry as a whole will have

enlarged its production facilities by 62 per­
cent during the same 12-year span, according
to known expansion schedules. Consequently,
the District will have only about 8 percent of
the nation’s portland cement manufacturing
capacity at the beginning of 1959 as com­
pared with slightly over a 10 percent share in
1946.(2)
One of the more obvious reasons for the
slower rate of expansion at Fourth District
cement mills is the much faster population
growth of such areas as the West Coast and
the Southwestern states. The resulting boom
in the construction of highways, factories,
homes and related facilities needed more
cement than ever before. Existing mills in
these areas were enlarged and new mills were
built to meet the rising demand. Still, the
population of the Fourth District—paced by
above-average gains in Ohio—has grown at
about the same rate as the United States total
during the postwar period.
The not so obvious reasons for the Dis­
trict’s smaller relative expansion of cement
capacity seem to relate to the retirement of
some of the older District facilities and to
the after-effects of an apparent over-exten­
sion of capacity in the late 1920’s that seems
to have plagued the local industry for about
two decades.

A mill originally erected in 1909 at Uni­
versal, Pennsylvania, for example, was re­
placed by an entirely new plant in 1956. By
the end of 1957, the oldest plant in the Fourth
District—at Wampum, Pennsylvania—will
be succeeded by a brand new mill costing
around $12,000,000. The latter is designed
around two dry process kilns that are as large
as any in the country.
The retirement of older, less efficient facili­
ties offsets to some extent the addition of new
capacity, and this occurs to a greater degree
in this District than in many other sections
of the country. The net increase in capacity,
therefore, considerably understates the actual
amount of mill construction and moderniza­
tion already completed in the postwar period,
or currently planned and under way.
From 1946 to 1958, for example, capacity
at Fourth District portland cement mills is
scheduled to rise from 24.4 million to 31.2
million barrels annually, showing a net gain
of 6.8 million barrels. However, actual
changes, mill by mill, show a gross increase
of 14.0 million barrels in capacity between
1946 and 1958 being offset by retirements of
7.2 million barrels of over-age or obsolete
capacity. Thus, while capacity will be only

Old Mills Being Retired
Some of the portland cement mills in the
Fourth District are among the oldest in the
United States, dating back almost 50 years.
Modifications and additions have been made
to these older plants over the years, but they
are relatively inefficient in comparison with
modem plants. It has been profitable to
operate the older plants in the District be­
cause they were located near abundant sup­
plies of the necessary raw materials and fuels
and close to major consuming markets. But,
the companies have realized that the older
facilities would need to be replaced in time
and they have started to do so.
(2) Based upon a survey of the 14 cement mills operating in
the Fourth District; the surrey was conducted in March 1957
by this hank.




3

28 percent greater in 1958 than in 1946,
roughly one-half of the 1958 production
facilities will have been built in the last
decade—most of them since 1951.

Plant Efficiency Boosted
Until recent years, the cement industry
has not utilized its facilities to the fullest
extent possible. For the nation as a whole,
the operating rate did not exceed 80 percent
until 1948, and it has been above 90 percent
only for the last four years. In part, this was
due to the practice of producing for immedi­
ate consumption, so that low production rates
characterized the winter months when con­
struction activity was at its seasonal low. The
drop in construction activity during the
colder months has not been as severe in re­
cent years as it was prior to World War II.
Although construction activity still exhibits
a marked seasonal swing, demand for cement
has been evened out somewhat over the year.
Also, mills have added storage facilities so
that higher production rates could be main­
tained during the winter when spot demand
slackened seasonally.
The operating rate was even lower at
Fourth District mills than it was nationally
from the late 1920’s to the early 1950’s.
There appears to have been over-expansion
of cement capacity in the District during the
1920’s which was reflected in the operating
rate. But, the older plants in the District,
with their less efficient machinery, also con­
tributed to the lower operating rate. Produc­
tivity at District mills, for example, ran con­
siderably below the national average all
through the 1930’s and 1940’s. Although
figures are not available for the 1950’s, it
would seem fair to assume that output per
man-hour at District mills has risen sharply
as the older, less efficient facilities have been
replaced by modem new plants and that pro­
ductivity is currently close to the industry
average.
Since 1953, District cement mills have
operated at a rate several points above the
national rate. In addition to the factors al­
4



ready mentioned, it appears that local de­
mand exceeds the supply available from
District mills and that this has kept the mills
operating at near-capacity levels in recent
years.

Enough Capacity?
At the national level, the supply of cement
will apparently be adequate over the near
term if all expansion plans are completed.
It is estimated that about one-half of the
71-million barrel addition to capacity by the
beginning of 1959 will be needed for the
expanded highway construction program.
But, other types of construction activity are
not expected to rise nearly as rapidly as high­
way work during the next few years, so that
the anticipated supply of cement should be
sufficient to meet the expected demand.
Despite the satisfactory supply-demand
outlook for the next few years on a nation­
wide scale, it looks as if the demand for
cement in the Fourth District might still
exceed the local supply in 1959. The expected
expansion in manufacturing capacity is just
about sufficient to fill the current gap between
apparent supply and demand in Ohio alone.
Since 1951, apparent consumption of portSHIPMENTS OF PORTLAND CEMENT FROM
OH IO MILLS COMPARED WITH RECEIPTS OF
MILL SHIPMENTS IN THE STATE
(Figures in thousands o f barrels)
Average
or total

Shipments
from mills

Estimated
Consumption

Apparent
Deficiency

1946-50
1951
1952
1953
1954
1955
1956

9,635
11,872
11,378
12,532
13,077
13,982
15,150

9,865
12,968
13,095
14,292
16,033
17,475
17,555

230
1,098
1,718
2,240
3,044
3,493
2,405

Data from U. S. Bureau of Mines

land cement in Ohio has substantially ex­
ceeded shipments from the nine mills in the
(Continued, on Page 11)

Farmers Mechanize on Credit
f a r m e r s borrow from banks, it
Loans for Machinery
has traditionally been for the purpose
of acquiring real estate or meeting currentMore credit is used for machinery than for
any other type of intermediate capital goods.
expenses. At one time, in fact, such types of
This category of credit use, which includes
borrowing almost completely accounted for
tractors
and trucks as well as equipment,
the farmer’s financial needs. Nowadays, how­
accounts
for 50 percent of the number of in­
ever, the advance of mechanization is re­
termediate
capital loans which farmers have
flected in the farmer’s borrowing. Purchases
at
banks
and
for 43 percent of the outstand­
of tractors, or of large milk-cooling tanks, for
ing
dollar
volume.
(See chart.)
example, are increasingly important forms
A
typical
loan
for
machinery would be for
of farm finance. Likewise, the renovation of
$500 to $1,000, secured by a chattel mortgage,
buildings or the purchase of high-quality
“ producer” livestock fit into the framework
of “ intermediate capital” borrowing, which
has now acquired major status in the farmer’s
PURPOSES OF BANK LOANS
balance sheet.

W

hen

Unlike fertilizer or other current expenses,
intermediate capital goods have a life which
extends beyond one year; yet such items do
wear out eventually, distinguishing them
from the relatively fixed nature of real estate
capital. The cost of intermediate capital
goods is likewise greater than that of items
commonly considered as current expenses,
but it is generally less than the investment re­
quired in farm real estate.
As a part of a detailed study of bank lend­
ing to farmers, information was obtained as
of June 30, 1956, pertaining to the manner
in which commercial banks finance farmers’
purchases of intermediate capital goods. Data
were assembled specifically on loans for ma­
chinery, for improvement of land and build­
ings, for producer livestock (as distinguished
from feeder livestock) and for purchase of
durable consumer goods. The following dis­
cussion and illustrations relate to this type
of farm financing as carried on by banks in
the Fourth Federal Reserve District.




TO FARMERS

(Fourth District, June 30, 1956)
INTERMEDIATE
CAPITAL USES

Loant tor Intermediate capital uses, inch as the
purchase of m achinery and the Improvement of
land and buildings, account for nearly one-third of
the credit In use b y farmers.

5

MATURITY OF BANK LOANS TO FARMERS, ACCORDING TO PURPOSES
(Intermediate C apital Type, Fourth District)

Percent Distribution by Maturity

M A T U RIT Y

IOO —

Notes
year

written
or

less

for

-* O V E R 3 YEARS

one

represent
— 15 MONTHS THRU
^
3 YEARS

over one-halt of the loan
volume

outstanding

for

m achinery and producer
livestock, and over onethird of the outstanding
loans

to

improve

— 1 Y EA R OR L E S S

land

and buildings or to buy
consumer durables.
—
TO BUY
TO IMPROVE
TO BUY
MACHINERY LAND AND PRODUCER
BUILDINGS LIVESTOCK

and written either on demand or to mature
within one year. The probability would be
about even as to whether the note would be
repaid in instalments or as a single payment.
The borrower would most likely be over 35
years of age, his net worth would be any­
where from $2,000 to $25,000, and the note
would probably be paid off without being
renewed. In this respect, the machinery loan
most commonly encountered by bankers is
treated much the same as a current expense
loan.
There are many deviations, however, from
the “ typical” machinery loan just described.
The various loan-size intervals above the
$500-$l,000 range account in total for twofifths of the number of machinery loans and
for three-fourths of the dollar volume of
outstandings. Banks have twice as much ma­
chinery credit outstanding on loans of $2,000
to $5,000 in size than on loans in the $500$1,000 interval. Thus, what is a typical size
from the standpoint of numbers of loans is
not reflected in a similar concentration of
dollar volume.
Loans of over $1,000 for machinery also
give rise to variations from the “ typical”
6



TO BUY
CONSUMER
DURABLES

D EM A N D

ALL
PURPOSES

pattern of terms of the note. Of the ma­
chinery notes that are less than $1,000 in
size, about 30 percent are written to mature
in one year or longer; of the notes $1,000 and
larger, 43 percent are written for the longer
maturity. Also a greater proportion of the
loans of $1,000 and larger are represented by
demand notes—14 percent as contrasted with
8 percent for the smaller loans.
Relatively more of the larger loans are
written with the understanding that they
will be renewed to stretch out payments. Of
those notes specifically written for one year
or less, about 40 percent of the notes $1,000
and over in size are renewed according to
such a plan, compared with 25 percent for
the notes under $1,000 in size. Security re­
quirements also tend to be considerably
greater in some instances for the larger
loans; real estate was taken as security for 6
percent of the loans of $1,000 and larger,
compared with only about 1 percent of the
loans under $1,000.
A closer look at repayment methods on
machinery loans shows nearly half to be in­
stalment loans. Of the single payment loans,
accounting for the remainder, three of every

ten had been renewed according to pre­
arranged plan (as of June 30, 1956), one of
every ten had been renewed, although not
originally planned, and one of every ten
represented a demand note. Most of the re­
maining single-payment notes were written
to fall due in full within one year.
Repayment methods on many of the ma­
chinery loans were originally established by
dealers from which banks purchased farm
notes. Presumably such financing arrange­
ments as made by dealers, however, were also
satisfactory to the lender. Nearly one-third
of the machinery loans had been purchased.
Due to the substantially smaller average size
of purchased notes, they accounted for less
than one-fourth of the volume of machinery
loans outstanding.

Loons to Improve Land and Buildings
Greater productivity in agriculture has not
been due solely to machinery. Improved
drainage, conservation projects, building re­
novation to improve labor efficiency, and
other similar capital investments have both
supplemented and complemented mechaniza­
tion. The volume of credit in use to improve

land and buildings ranks second only to ma­
chinery among the various intermediate
capital uses by farmers.
Loans for land and building improvement
tend to run larger in size than loans for ma­
chinery. The average size of loan, in fact, is
nearly double the average size of machinery
loans. Over one-fifth of the loans are between
$1,000 and $2,000; loans larger than $2,000
account for an additional one-third of the
number and over three-fourths of the out­
standings.
In conformity with the generally larger
sizes of loans for land and building improve­
ment, maturities of such loans also tend to
be substantially longer. About one-third of
the loans, representing half of the dollar
outstandings, were written to mature in two
years or longer. About 45 percent of the out­
standings were represented by loans with
maturities of over three years. (See chart.)
Longer maturities and larger loans for pur­
poses which are essentially real-estate im­
provement point to farm real estate as a
common security for the loans. About 40 per­
cent of such loans, representing nearly twothirds of the outstandings, are secured by

SECURITY OF BANK LOANS TO FARMERS, ACCORDING TO PURPOSES
(Intermediate C a p ital Type, Fourth District)
Percent Distribution by Security

Chattel

m ortgages

SEC U R ITY

are

the mast common securi­
ty

for

consumer

m achinery

and

durables,

real

estate security is usually
taken far real estate improvement,

producer

livestock loans are com ­
monly unsecured.




MACHINERY

LAND AND
BUILDINGS

PRODUCER
LIVESTOCK

CONSUMER
DURABLES

PURPOSES

7

real estate. (See chart.) Unsecured notes
were nearly as common numerically as real
estate security; however, only about onefourth of the dollar outstandings were un­
secured. Security by endorsement is relatively
uncommon. A mortgage on chattels, the most
common security for machinery, is little used
in loans to improve land and buildings.
Further investigation of the nature of the
large block of borrowers that have unsecured
loans for land and building improvement re­
veals a close relationship to net worth. Bor­
rowers with net worths of $25,000 and over
accounted for about half the unsecured notes,
which in turn amounted to nearly threefourths of the dollar volume. The taking of
real estate for security on improvement loans
is rare for borrowers with very high net
worths; conversely the extension of un­
secured notes is not a practice followed with
borrowers having less than $3,000 equity in
their farm business.
Loa n s t® Buy " P r o d u c e r " Livestock

A considerable portion of farm livestock
may be properly classified as intermediate
capital. Feeder livestock would not be so
considered insofar as they represent products
destined to be sold. Dairy cows, beef-breeding
herds, sows and boars, however, are kept
primarily as intermediaries in the production
process rather than for direct sale. About 18
percent of the loans outstanding by banks
for intermediate capital are for such pro­
ducer livestock; loans for machinery and to
improve land and buildings accounted for 43
percent and 28 percent respectively as indi­
cated in an accompanying chart.
Loans for producer livestock tend to be
considerably smaller in size than those for
real-estate improvement, but they average
somewhat larger in size than machinery
loans. Over one-third of the loans are for
less than $500; nearly two-thirds are for less
than $1,000. The remaining one-third of the
loans, however, tend to be quite large in size
and account for the bulk of the dollar out­
standings for this purpose.
For producer livestock, unsecured loans
8



are more common than any specific physical
type of security. (See chart.) Chattel mort­
gages are fairly prevalent. Most of the re­
mainder of loans for producer livestock are
secured by endorsement.
About one loan in seven is specifically
written for more than one year; an additional
one in seven is a demand note. The remainder
of such notes, also reflecting the bulk of out­
standings, are written with maturities of one
year or less. (See chart.) Planned renewals
are used to a considerable extent to stretch
out repayment periods on the notes with
maturities of one year or less; one-third of
the notes, representing nearly three-fourths
of the outstandings, are written with the
agreement that they will be renewed on the
maturity date.

Loans for Consumer Durables
Although loans for home freezers, tele­
vision sets, automobiles and other consumer
durable goods do not loom especially large in
dollar totals, they do constitute a significant
proportion of the number of intermediate
capital loans. Nearly one of every five inter­
mediate capital loans is for consumer durable
goods; such loans account for 11 percent of
the outstandings.
Loans of this type tend to be decidedly
smaller than those in the other major inter­
mediate capital areas. One-third of the notes
are smaller than $250; over half are less than
$500 in size. Loans of more than $1,000, how­
ever, are not unusual.
Nearly all of the borrowers for consumer
durable goods have net worths of over $3,000;
well over half have net worths of $10,000 or
more, indicating that borrowing of this type
is largely a matter of convenience rather than
necessity. Most of the borrowers are over 35
years of age. A chattel mortgage is the most
common form of security for the notes, al­
though a substantial volume is unsecured.
(See chart.)
Maturities on loans for consumer durables
fall largely into four periods—6 months, 12
months, 18 months and 24 months. About 70

percent of the notes are being repaid in regu­
lar instalments. The substantial number of
notes with 18-month and 24-month maturi­
ties, and the prevalence of the instalment
method of repayment, both tend in part to
reflect the volume of farmer notes purchased
from dealers where such financing arrange­
ments are standard. Nearly one-third of the
loans for consumer durables had been pur­
chased from merchants and dealers.

Summary Observations
Considerable variation is obvious in lend­
ing patterns, depending upon the specific
item of intermediate capital being purchased.
Security and length of maturity, for example,
tend to be adapted to the special nature of
each broad category of use, such as the pur­
chase of machinery. Within any of the broad
uses, loan terms tend to be further adapted
to the size of the loan, the net worth of the
borrower and other factors.
One feature is apparent—loans for inter­
mediate capital uses are not necessarily set
up to be intermediate term in maturity. Rela­
tively small loans may well be liquidated
within a year, despite the nature of their use.
Characteristics of many borrowers may also
make it far more desirable that a periodic
“ new look” be taken at the progress of the
loan before stretching it out further. (See
chart.) Many borrowers with large net

worths do not desire to have loans stretched
out beyond one year; a demand note or a
six-month note may be completely satisfac­
tory in meeting their maturity requirements.
It cannot be clearly ascertained whether these
factors can satisfactorily explain the statisti­
cal observation that only a little over onethird of the loans for intermediate capital
purposes are specifically written for more
than one year. It is of significance in this re­
spect that 48 percent of the loans are $1,000
and larger, but these larger loans are not, in
all instances, the same as those with the
longer maturities.
The matter of the age of borrowers also
brings up an interesting point. Young
farmers, it is sometimes argued, are not get­
ting enough credit for investment capital.
However, a distribution of borrowers accord­
ing to age, as compared with a distribution
of all farm operators by age, shows that
farmers in each of the age classes up to 45
years account for a proportionately larger
share of the credit than their numbers would
indicate. The widest margin exists in the
35-44 year age bracket, however, which ac­
counts for about 22 percent of the farm
operators and 33 percent of the credit in use.
Such comparisons do not resolve the very
real problem of capital accumulation for be­
ginning farmers; they do tend to throw doubt
on the suggestion that operators may be dis­
criminated against solely because of age.

RENEWAL STATUS OF FARM LOANS, ACCORDING TO MATURITY
(Intermediate C ap ital Type, Fourth District)
O ne-half

the

volume

of

loans written to mature
in one year or less are
accompanied
agreement

to

by

an

renew

on

the maturity date; such
planned

renewals

relatively

are

uncommon

with other maturities.




MATURITIES OF
1 YEAR OR L E S S

A LL OTHER
M ATURITIES

ALL
MATURITIES

9

Net worth, and need appear to be over­
riding factors, in most instances, for guiding
the allocation of credit for intermediate
capital uses. The process of tailoring credit
to fit the specific intermediate capital needs
of farmers is still in the development stage,
both among bankers and among farmerowned cooperative credit sources. Many
lenders are far advanced in this field; others
have hardly more than recognized the need
for adapting their services to this growing
area of credit use.

would seem desirable to have adequate
amounts of intermediate capital in the hands
of farm operators to permit an optimum
scale of operation while they are in the
“ prime” producing years of their lives. A
problem arises insofar as, for a considerable
part of this period in the farmer’s life span,
net worths are so low as to require a cautious
policy on the part of lenders in the extension
of credit. There is no easy solution of this
problem.

Some problems will continue unanswered
for some time to come. Economically, it

Note: Interest rates on loans for intermediate capital uses
and. a summary of all loans to farmers were discussed in the
February 1957 and December 1956 issues respectively of the
Monthly Business Review.

REGULATION OF CONSUMER
INSTALMENT CREDIT
A statement of the views of the B o a r d o f G o v e r n o r s o f t h e
which was transmitted to the respective
chairmen of the Senate and House Banking and Currency Com­
mittees. of the Joint Economic Committee, and of the Council of
Economic Advisers.
F e d e r a l R eserve S y stem

Early in 1956 the President, through the Council
of Economic Advisers, requested the Board of Gover­
nors o f the Federal Reserve System to undertake a
broad study of consumer instalment credit. When
this request was made a record-breaking year o f ex­
pansion of this credit had just been completed. The
ability of the Government to discharge its responsi­
bilities under the Employment Act of 1946 was felt
by some to be jeopardized by this development, since
credit expansion in this special sector seemed unre­
sponsive to the general monetary actions that were
then being taken to restrain inflationary pressures.
The Board had been concerned with instalment
credit developments for some time, and had initiated
an inquiry into the effects of general credit policy on
consumer instalment credit as early as 1953. While
neither the Council of Economic Advisers nor the
Board o f Governors felt that conditions prevailing
early in 1956 warranted a request at that time for
authority to regulate consumer instalment credit,
they agreed that a background study o f the part
played by consumer credit in economic instability was
needed and would be timely. The chairmen of the
banking and currency committees o f both houses of
the Congress and the chairman of the Joint Economic
Committee concurred in the desirability o f such a

study.

10



The circumstances occasioning the study warranted
intensive and comprehensive investigation. Accord­
ingly, the Board of Governors directed its research
staff to plan a survey that would examine the entire
record of instalment financing in this and other
countries. Academic scholars also participated in the
study under the auspices of the National Bureau o f
Economic Research. In addition, the survey employed
the facilities o f the Bureau of the Census and a
private survey organization. The assistance of Fed­
eral Reserve Bank Research staffs was enlisted, as
well as that of foreign central banks. A survey o f
trade and other opinion was conducted under the
direction o f a special consultant to the board.
On March 15 of this year, five of the six volumes
reporting this study were transmitted to the inter­
ested congressional committees and agencies of
government and released to the public. The final
volume was transmitted and released about six
weeks later.
The members o f the Board o f Governors o f the
Federal Reserve System have individually studied the
report and have carefully considered the entire sub­
ject. Based on this study and discussion, the Board
finds that:
(1)
The use o f consumer instalment credit for the
purchase o f costly durable goods and in the manage­

ment o f family finances has penetrated a widening
range of income receivers and social groups. The
pace of penetration, however, has been sporadic.
(2) In the past, the rate at which consumer in­
stalment credit was granted varied considerably.
These variations tended to coincide with general
fluctuations in economic activity.
(3) Though of recognizable importance as a factor
of instability, fluctuations in consumer instalment
credit have been generally within limits that could be
tolerated in a rapidly growing and dynamic economy.
(4) A possible exception to the third finding
occurred during the 1954-56 upswing in economic
activity. The rapid expansion of consumer instalment
credit in 1955, with its accompanying secondary
impacts on capital investment, contributed to the
emergence o f inflationary pressures. This expansion,
however, combined with real estate mortgage and
other types of credit expansion in producing this
sequence of developments.
(5) Since early 1956, expansion in total instal­
ment credit has moderated, in part as a result of
general monetary restraints and in part as a result
o f reduced demand for automobiles and other con­
sumer durable goods commonly financed by instal­
ment credit.
(6) Liberalization of instalment credit terms and
standards from mid-1954 through 1955, which was
particularly marked in connection with the purchase
of new automobiles, contributed to the further widen­
ing o f the practice of instalment buying and borrow­
ing and to the very great expansion in instalment

credit outstanding that occurred. Some o f the forces
making for this rapid widening o f the market for
consumer credit were temporary. Also, this drastic
liberalization o f credit terms and standards exposed
consumer lenders to increased risks. On both counts,
the forces making for credit liberalization in that
period were to an extent transient and self-limiting.
(7) Because o f economic and social factors likely
to affect the future o f instalment credit, its growth
in the years ahead may be at a slower pace than in
the past. The volatility of consumer instalment credit
in the past was to some extent related to its rapid
growth. I f future growth is slower, the potential
instability o f this factor may be contained within
tolerable margins.
(8) Under peacetime conditions, special regula­
tion o f consumer instalment credit would inevitably
present problems o f compliance to the financing and
business concerns subject to it, and of administration
and enforcement to the agency o f government re­
sponsible for the regulation.
On the basis of the foregoing findings, the Board
o f Governors believes that a special peacetime
authority to regulate consumer instalment credit is
not now advisable. The Board feels that the broad
public interest is better served i f potentially unstabilizing credit developments are restrained by the
use of general monetary measures and the applica­
tion of sound public and private fiscal policies.
The Board of Governors and its staff will continue
to follow closely developments in the use of consumer
instalment credit.

CEMENT INDUSTRY
( Continued from Page 4)

state, as shown by the following table. Last
year, the deficit amounted to about 2y2 mil­
lion barrels, or nearly 15 percent of total
consumption. Comparable figures are not
available for other parts of the Fourth Dis­
trict, but the partial evidence strongly sug­
gests that a good part of the cement consumed
locally has come from mills outside the Dis­
trict.
The apparent need for additional cement
capacity in the Fourth District may be some­
what illusory, however, as long as cement is
available from outside the District. Except
for some general tightness in supply during




1955, which was also felt in many other parts
of the country, actual shortages have not been
a problem in this area. Transport facilities
are excellent throughout most of the District.
In 1955, some users were reportedly obtain­
ing cement from as far away as Kansas City,
but this was the exception rather than the
rule. With the supply expected to be suffici­
ent to meet the rough estimates of demand
in 1959 for the entire country, Fourth Dis­
trict consumers should experience little trou­
ble in getting their share. Nevertheless, it
seems that the District could support some
additional cement capacity over and above
that already under way.
11

The 1957 Survey of Ownership
of Demand Deposits
1943, the Federal Reserve System
has conducted an annual survey designed
to determine the distribution of demand de­
posits of individuals, partnerships, and cor­
porations, at commercial banks by type of
owner. The purpose of the first survey was
to secure guides that would be useful in estab­
lishing quotas for sales of war bonds by
region and by type of investor. Today, the
survey results provide basic data for analysis
of current financial problems and for the
construction of several widely used economic
series.
The Securities and Exchange Commission,
for example, uses the results of the survey of
demand deposit ownership when preparing
its quarterly estimate of liquid savings. The
Bureau of Agriculture Economics considers
demand deposits of farmers, supplied by the
survey, an integral part of its regular esti­
mate of the assets and liabilities of agricul­
ture, more commonly known as the “ balance
in c e

S

PERCENTAGE DISTRIBUTION OF
DEMAND DEPOSITS OF INDIVIDUALS,
PARTNERSHIPS, AND CORPORATIONS
FO U R TH D IST R IC T INSURED COM MERCIAL BANKS
January 30, 1957

Type o f Owner

Deposits

Number
of
Accounts

62%

10%

Nonfinancial.............................
Financial...................................

54
8

10
1

Corporate..................................
Noncorporate...........................

50
12

3
7

Business:

Personal........................................

29

79

Nonprofit Organizations.............

4

6

Trust Funds of Banks and
Deposits of Foreign Residents
and Firms.................................

3

1

Farmers, Noncorporate...............

2

4

100%

100%

T O T A L ........................

12




sheet of agriculture.” The Board of Gover­
nors of the Federal Reserve System used the
survey results to estimate liquid asset hold­
ings of individuals and business, and to esti­
mate the direction and volume of money flows
among the various sections of the economy.
In 1956, the survey was suspended to pro­
vide time for the development of a new re­
porting procedure that would (1) improve
the accuracy of the results, (2) integrate the
final results with the uses that have developed
over the years, and (3) reduce the reporting
task for cooperating banks. This year, the
survey was reinstated in the new form.
In the Fourth Federal Reserve District,
116 insured commercial banks provided
sample data on ownership of demand deposits
of individuals, partnerships, and corpora­
tions, held at 143 of their banking offices. The
figures were as of January 30, 1957. The
estimate of total demand deposits, IPC, held
by all Fourth District insured commercial
banks contained a sampling error of less than
3 percent; however, errors of estimate may
be substantially larger in some ownership
classes.
The accompanying table contains an esti­
mated percentage distribution of the dollar
volume and the number of demand deposit
accounts held at all insured commercial banks
in the Fourth District. A similar distribution
by size of bank can be supplied upon request.
As indicated in the table, business firms
hold the largest share, about three-fifths, of
total privately-held demand deposits in this
District and only one-tenth of the number of
such deposits. Personal accounts, on the other
hand, make up more than three-quarters of
the total number of accounts and only threetenths of the total dollar volume.
By and large, the distribution by owner­
ship group has remained remarkably stable
over recent years. This in itself is noteworthy
in a period of great business expansion and
growing economic prosperity.