View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

MONTHLY

QcuiimM et/ieuJ
IN

THIS

ISSUE

F E D E R A L RE S E R V E BANK of C LE V E LA N I
Regional Expansion in Steel Capacity

flc c n e

Current Trends in Farm Prices

J 9 5 4

. . . .

Better Jets Through Ceramic Materials

S TEEL INGOT CAPACITY
OTHEi
U.S.

..... \

GO

Fourth District steel capacity has
been expanded in recent years, but
not as rapidly as capacity outside
the District. Consequently the Dis­
trict's share of the steel market is

20

declining.
I See page 21

I
1948




1951

1952

1953

1954

DISTRICT SHARE OF TOTAL CAPACITY

.

2
5
12

Regional Expansion in Steel Capacity
he
n a t i o n ’s
steel
in d u s t r y
has ex­
in the Fourth District from 1948 through
panded its ingot-making capacity 32 per­
1953 is due to the small percentage gains in
cent since the end of 1947, with the bulk ofcapacity made in the Pittsburgh and Youngs­
the new or improved facilities coming into
town producing areas, where nearly twoproduction during the last three years. Steel
thirds of the Fourth District’s steel capacity
mills located in the Fourth Federal Reserve
is concentrated. During the last six years,
District participated in the industry’s expan­
the capacity of these two areas was increased
sion, but not to the same extent as mills out­
from 33.5 to 36.9 million net tons or only 10
per cent, while the industry elsewhere boosted
side the District. Fourth District steel areas,
as defined by Iron Age, include Pittsburgh,
its production potential 44 percent. With
the sole exception of the small Eastern dis­
Youngstown, Cleveland, the South Ohio
trict (New England and eastern New York)
River area, and Wheeling.
every other steel district increased capacity
The proportion of the country’s basic
by more than 30 percent.
steel-producing facilities located in this Dis­
trict, in the aggregate, has shrunk from 45.0
The Pittsburgh-Youngstown area is re­
percent to 40.6 percent during the past six
garded by some authorities as a single pro­
years. Such a shrinkage highlights a trend
ducing center. Taken together, the two areas
towards greater geographic dispersion of
contain nearly 30 percent of the nation’s steel
steel furnaces that may continue for the next
capacity and comprise the largest concentra­
few years.
tion of steel furnaces in the country. If
The relatively low rate of steel expansion
Pittsburgh and Youngstown are considered
as separate steel-producing areas, they rank
second and fourth, respectively, among the
LOCATION OF STEEL-MAKING FURNACES
IN THE FOURTH DISTRICT
country’s thirteen steel districts as delineated
by Iron Age. Pittsburgh, traditionally the
nation’s top producing center, yielded first
place to Chicago in 1953, while Youngstown
lost the third-ranking spot to Philadelphia
during 1952.
:v e i a n o
Changes at plants in other Fourth District
•F A R R E LL
LORAIN
WARREN*
steel areas during the six years 1948 through
YOUNGSTOWN *®S
.b u t le r
. VCANTON • a l i q u i p p a
1953 ranged from the abandonment of some
MANSFIE*LD MASSILLON
r
PITTSI
W E IR T O N -jl
facilities
to the threefold expansion of others.
S TEU B EN V ILLE */
DONORA
The biggest percentage increases were made
in the South Ohio River steel district where
•M ID D LETO W N
capacity was expanded nearly two-thirds
since 1948. Capacity additions exceeded 70
[WPORT
PORTSMOUTH,
percent at mills in Portsmouth, Middletown
and Newport. Two new mills were built in
ASMLAND*i*HUNTtNGTON
the same general steel area — one at Owens­
boro, Kentucky, and one at Huntington,
West Virginia; both of the latter happen to
fall outside the Fourth District.
In the Cleveland producing district (which
includes Lorain) individual mill gains ranged
from 26 percent to 72 percent, averaging 48

T

2



REGIONAL CHANGES IN STEEL CAPACITY: 1948-1953
(Capacity figures in thousands of net tons as of January 1st)

Ir o n A g e

STEEL CAPACITY

NET INCREASE
1 9 4 8 -1 9 5 3

PERCENTAGE
OF TOTAL

RANK

District
1954

1948

Tons

Pet

1954

1948

1954

1948

1
6
12

2
10
12

C H IC A G O ........................
DETROIT............................
ST. LOUIS........................

2 4 ,5 8 7
6,551
2 ,785

18,856
3,473
1,674

5,731
3,078
1,111

30.4
88.6
66.4

19.8
5.3
2.2

20.0
3.7
1.8

Subtotal.......................

33,923

24 ,0 0 3

9 ,9 2 0

41.3

27.3

25.5

PITTSBURGH....................
Y O U N G S T O W N .............
CLEVELAND......................
SOUTH O H IO RIVER.. .
WHEELING.......................

2 3 ,0 1 6
13,896
6,241
4,875
4,8 6 6

2 0 ,8 2 9
12,644
4,2 2 4
2,933
3,4 9 5

2 ,1 8 7
1,252
2 ,0 1 7
1,942
1,371

10.5
9.9
47.8
66.2
39.2

18.5
11.2
5.0
3.9
3.9

22.1
13.4
4.5
3.1
3.7

2
4
8
10
11

1
3
7
11
9

5 2 ,8 9 4

4 4 ,1 2 5

8,7 6 9

19.9

42 .5

4 6.8

••

..

PHILADELPHIA.................
BUFFALO..........................
EASTERN...........................

16,386
6,452
733

11,505
4 ,423
6 34

4,881
2 ,0 2 9
99

4 2.4
4 5 .9
15.6

13.2
5.2
0.6

12.2
4 .7
0.7

3
7
13

4
6
13

Subtotal........................

23,571

16,562

7 ,0 0 9

42.3

19.0

17.6

Total N. E. States............

110,388

8 4 ,6 9 0

2 5 ,6 9 8

30.3

88.8

89.9

WESTERN.........................
SOUTHERN.......................

8,883
5 ,0 6 0

5 ,7 0 6

3 ,8 3 7

3 ,1 1 7
1,223

5 5 .7
3 1.9

7.1
4.1

6.1
4.1

5
9

5
8

TOTAL U. S.....................

124,330

9 4 ,2 3 3

3 0 ,0 9 7

31.9

100.0

100.0

FOURTH DISTRICT..

50 ,5 3 8

4 2 ,4 3 5

8,103

19.1

40.6

4 5.0

••

♦•

OTHER U. S.....................

7 3 ,7 9 2

5 1 ,7 9 9

2 1 ,9 9 4

4 2.5

59.4

5 5.0

Subtotal............ ..

American Iron and Steel Institute data. Compilations by Iron Age and Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland. Details may not add to
totals because of rounding. The subtotal for the Iron Age districts of Pittsburgh, Youngstown, Cleveland, South Ohio River and Wheel­
ing differs from the Fourth District total because: (1) several plants included in the Pittsburgh and South Ohio River districts are not
in the Fourth District; and (2) several Erie, Pa. plants, which are located in the Fourth District, are included with the Buffalo district.




3

percent for the three companies in the area.
Percentage gains in capacity in both the
South Ohio River and Cleveland districts thus
exceeded the 44 percent average increase
posted by all U. S. mills outside the Pitts­
burgh-Youngstown area.
The increase in the Wheeling area aver­
aged 36 percent, with a Steubenville mill
nearly doubling its capacity. Other plants in
the area are located at Weirton and Toronto.
Geographic changes in the location of steel
capacity that have occurred in the last six
years are given in an adjoining table. The
regional compilations were made by Iron
Age from the comprehensive reports of
American Iron and Steel Institute. As the
table suggests, the Iron Age districts of Pitts­
burgh, Youngstown, Cleveland, South Ohio
River and Wheeling are almost identical
with the Fourth District.
As might be expected, most of the new or
expanded steel facilities added since 1947
have been located in the nation’s “ industrial
belt,” which may be defined roughly as the
states east of the Mississippi River and north
of the Ohio River and Mason-Dixon line.
The geographic relocation of steel furnaces
in recent years has been largely a shift to
the east and west of the Fourth District
within the limits of this “ industrial belt.”
The Fourth District “ lost” capacity mainly
to the Chicago, Detroit and St. Louis steel
districts on the west and to the Philadelphia
and Buffalo steel districts on the east. The
Western district increased its share of the
U. S. total from 6 to 7 percent during this
interval, while that of the Southern district
remained unchanged at 4 percent.

Factors in Location
There are several reasons for the location
of most of the new and improved furnaces
outside the Pittsburgh and Youngstown areas.
First, these two districts have traditionally
been surplus production areas. Rising freight
rates have made the proximity to metal
fabricating markets an important factor in
determining the location of expansion pro­

4



grams. Economies in transport costs dictated
locations in, or nearer to, areas of production
deficits. This helps account for the large
additions to capacity in the Chicago and
Detroit districts, since both areas have long
been ones of production deficits.
A second factor is the age of furnaces in
the Pittsburgh and Youngstown areas. The
steel industry, as we know it today, traces
its beginnings to this area as the historic
meeting place of iron ore and coal. It would
be only natural to find that the area has a
higher proportion of older furnaces than
newer steel-making centers. Since 1948, the
retirement of tired facilities has served to
offset, somewhat, improvements and addi­
tions. In the Pittsburgh area, for example,
one major steel company has retired 1.8
million tons of old capacity since the end
of World War II, while adding 3.7 million
tons of new capacity. During 1953, the
scrapping of old furnaces in the Pittsburgh
district more than offset expansion in the
area, reducing the area’s annual capacity by
more than 2 percent. Some of the abandoned
furnaces were first fired in 1900. Further
reductions will take place this fall, when
other marginal high-cost facilities in the area
are scheduled for retirement. Scrapping older
furnaces results in operating economies and
improves the area’s competitive position.
A third factor that bears on the differen­
tial growth rates exhibited among the vari­
ous producing areas is the development of
new sources of iron ore, notably in Venezuela
and Canada. Two steel companies have
developed properties in Venezuela. One com­
pany began shipments in 1951 after several
years of development work and imported
more than 2,000,000 tons of iron ore last
year. First shipments from the other Vene­
zuelan mine were received at an Eastern
port this January, with shipments for the
current year expected to exceed 2,000,000
tons and to increase gradually for several
years. An entirely new steel works was con­
structed on the Delaware River to use the
output of the newest Venezuelan property.
(Continued on Page 9)

Current Trends In Farm Prices
this year are estimated as about on a par
a g r i c u l t u r e is a big enough
with 1953 in tonnage. Contrasting situations,
factor in today’s industrialized econ­
such as shortages of hogs and surpluses of
omy to “ make or break prosperity” is still
dairy products, again illustrate a wide vari­
debatable. The economic well-being of count­
ation among specific products.
less towns and villages throughout the nation
in 1954, however, will rest directly and un­
questionably upon the level of farm income.
Milk
To these may be added the large industries
Milk prices in April (Ohio prices) were
such as farm machinery, feed processing and
the lowest at wholesale in four years and the
fertilizer manufacture, as well as a host of
lowest for any April since the end of World
other nonfarm enterprises, whose sales are a
War II. Despite evidence of a prolonged
direct function of farmers’ ability to buy.
cost-price squeeze, however, milk production
It is reassuring in this respect both to farm
throughout the nation during the first quar­
and to many nonfarm groups that farm
ter of 1954 continued to expand, reaching a
prices have held within a fairly narrow range
record level about 5 percent above the yearof fluctuation since last spring. Such sta­
ago output. Even after allowance for popu­
bility has followed a precipitous price decline
lation growth, milk production is the largest
which extended over two years. Many prob­
since early in the postwar period.
lems and an element of uncertainty still
Continued high milk production without
prevail, however, as farm production plans
corresponding demand has brought the gov­
for 1954 are being pushed into action.
ernment into prominence as a buyer of dairy
products. Continued failure to adjust out­
put to market needs has forced a lowering of
Farm Income
support rates on dairy products from 90 per­
During the first four months of 1954, sales
cent to 75 percent of parity as of April 1 of
of farm products, nationally, totaled some­
this year. These support prices are indicated
what short of $8i/2 billion—moderately below
in a later table.
a year ago. The net contribution to national
Adjustment to the milk-price dilemma
income continues short of $12y2 billion at an
seems particularly difficult for dairymen.
annual rate, as compared with an approxi­
mate $16 billion rate in early 1951 and a still
Compared with recent years, prices are lower,
higher rate in the early postwar years.
marketings are steady to larger, Income has eased.
Farm-product prices in the aggregate have
IN DEX
O NITEO STATES
I9 3 5 - 3 9 ‘ <Q0
shown a strong tendency so far this year to
level out very near to the year-ago position,
although they have been decidedly lower
than in the corresponding periods of 1951
CASH RECEIPTS
and 1952. Prices received by farmers in
April, for example, were less than one per­
cent below the comparable date of 1953. As
3 0 0 -'
usual, any such aggregate measure fails to
^ -P R IC E S RECEIVED
reveal the contrasts among individual com­
A > PHYSICAL
— / “X volume OF”
modity lines.
jJ
\m a r k e tin g s
/
I V- .
Similar comments apply to the physical
------ 1 9 3 5 -3 9 A ve ra g e -----------volume of farm marketings. Farm products
hauled to market during the first quarter of

W

h e th e r




Milk prices and egg prices have dropped sharply
this spring.

Attempts to lower unit production costs usu­
ally yield an end product of higher aggre­
gate production, while basically the problem
is already one of greater production than
the market will take at prices favorable to
the producer. In addition, the introduction
of cost-cutting mechanization into the dairy
operation frequently requires substantial
sums in new capital investment — a difficult
decision to make when net returns have been
whittled away year after year.
That dairymen are attempting to boost
output per cow and per man is illustrated
in the current rate of grain consumption per
cow and the larger average size of herds.
There are numerous indications, however,
that much of this feed is going into “ extra”
cows which are not paying their way, as con­
trasted with use of the feed in other livestock
enterprises. Accurate accounting methods
would probably reveal the slaughter-house as
the most profitable current use for many
dairy cows which would have returned a
profit at the higher prices of a few years ago.

Eggs
Eggs, a popular supplementary enterprise
on dairy farms, have also suffered from
sharper than expected price drops so far
into 1954. What at first appeared to be a
seasonal drop “ just a bit more severe than

6



last year” failed to reverse on schedule in
late winter. This is shown by the Ohio prices
in the accompanying chart. Forecasts of the
U. S. Department of Agriculture anticipate
egg prices below a year ago until mid-year,
although still high enough to provide ‘ ‘ favor­
able returns.”
Large production is apparently responsi­
ble for the price weakness in eggs. Some in­
crease in production and lowering of price
is normally expected during the late winter
and early spring season. This year, however,
impetus has been added to these seasonal
movements by the greater number of layer
hens on farms and a corresponding increase
in the rate of lay per hen.
A current increase in hatchery output is
providing some further apprehension con­
cerning the egg price outlook for late this
year. March hatchings of chicks in com­
mercial hatcheries topped last year by 12
percent and broke a monthly record of ten
years standing. The margin over a year ago
for the first four months of 1954 averaged
about 11 percent. Most of the gain in number
of hatchings has been in chicks for layingflock replacement.

Hogs
Hog price trends provide a sharp contrast
to both milk and eggs as indicated in the
charts. Reduced slaughter supplies of hogs
this year have pushed prices up to and fre­
quently above the 1947 all-time highs for the
comparable months. The spring seasonal price
decline, which is quite pronounced in most
years, was barely discemable in 1954.
The currently light hog receipts are still
a reflection of farmer adjustments to over­
production and a profitless output back in
1952. For the most part, the restricted supply
of hogs has met with strong demand for over
a year. Furthermore, profitable prices still
seem assured for the light marketing months
of the early summer.
Numbers of pigs born this spring and to
be marketed next fall have not as yet been
determined. An official U. S. Department of
Agriculture count of the spring pig crop will

be released in late June. By all indications
available, however, a substantial expansion
has again occurred in the nation’s hog enter­
prises.

Cattle
Beef cattle have also experienced consider­
able recent price improvement. The winter
and spring of this year marked the first pro­
longed price advance since early 1951. In
Ohio, at any rate, April was the fifth con­
secutive month of price increase for the aver­
age of all types and grades of beef, as shown
in the accompanying chart. It will be noted,
however, that as of April, the 19 percent
gain since last November has lifted prices
only to a par with a year ago. Current beef
cattle prices are still decidedly lower than
the unusually prosperous 1947-52 period.
The price series shown in the chart serves
as a guide to the trend for beef cattle; how­
ever, it does not reflect satisfactorily the sell­
ing prices of specific grades. Finished cattle
prices at Fourth District markets, for exam­
ple, are substantially improved from a year
ago at $22 per hundredweight for the goodchoice grades. Conversely, beef cows and
light cattle have shown some improvement
from late last year, but prices of these grades
still appeared weak during the opening
months of 1954 by comparison with a year
ago.
Beef cattle fall gradesI still undersell hogs; both
have shown substantial recent price advances.




Current cattle supplies likewise show sub­
stantial variations by grades. Heavy liqui­
dation of steers last year, and the slightly
reduced numbers in feedlots now, have con­
tributed to the improvement this spring in
finished cattle prices. On the other hand, net
increases in the 1953 cow and calf inventory
are being reflected in the continued weak­
ness of cow and light-cattle prices as out­
lined above.
Western range conditions are a critical
element in the cattle picture this year. De­
spite recent rains, drought again poses a
threat which could force heavy liquidation
and consequent further disruption of markets.
Even with something akin to normal
weather, there are indications that the long
predicted downturn in cattle numbers will
begin to materialize by the year’s end.
“ Heifer slaughter” last year was in excess
of numbers actually reaching this state of
growth, and thus limited the extent to which
discarded beef cows might be replaced.

Crops
So far in 1954, of the crops most promi­
nent in Fourth District agriculture, soybeans
alone have been traded freely at a price
which is well above support levels and which
has been determined independently of gov­
ernment support activity. A shorter than
expected crop last year (due to drought)
coupled with strong domestic and foreign
demand have boosted prices to levels seldom
before enjoyed by farmers. April prices aver­
aged $3.57 per bushel in Ohio — a 26 per­
cent increase from the year before.
Wheat and corn, unlike soybeans, are
heavily indebted to the price-support pro­
gram for their current price position. Both
of these crops showed substantial seasonal
price declines last summer and fall, but have
since recovered nearly all of the losses. April
prices in both instances were within a few
cents of year-ago levels.
Wheat stocks on the July 1 close of the
current marketing year are expected to total
about 875 million bushels — well over a third
above the previous record high inventory of
7

1942. A carryover of this magnitude would
be somewhat in excess of a full year’s export
and domestic consumption needs at 1953
rates of use. Furthermore, it is expected by
the U. S. Department of Agriculture that
almost all of this carryover of wheat will be
held in Commodity Credit Corporation in­
ventories or under reseal programs.
Besides a high rate of production, the
growing wheat glut is complicated during
1953-1954 by the lowest disappearance rate
since the early years of "World War II. This
weakness stems primarily from the loss of
export demand.
Corn inventories on April 1, nearly six
months before a new harvest, were more than
10 percent greater than a year ago. An esti­
mated two-fifths of these stocks were under
price-support loan and purchase agreements;
however, most of the price-support stocks
were inventories of grain acquired prior to
the 1953 crop. Substantial quantities of the
old inventories have recently been offered for
sale at a reduced price.
At the close of the current crop year on
October 1, a corn inventory of 900 million
bushels is considered plausible by the U. S.
Department of Agriculture. These stocks,
about one-sixth larger than last October 1,
would nearly all be under loan or owned by
the Commodity Credit Corporation.
Corn and wheat prices are near early 7953 posi­
tions, bat soybean prices have soared to new
heights.
O H IO PRICES
Do lia r s p e r bushel

8



Among the other crops important to the
Fourth District are oats, the prices of which
have held stable throughout the winter and
spring. Current selling prices are within a
penny or so per bushel of last year’s quo­
tations.
Selling prices of hurley tobacco for the
auction season which ended in February
were at a record high.
Price support levels for major district
crops are indicated in the following table.

U. S. Average Support Prices
Price
1954
1953
. $2.20*
. 1.62*
. 2.22
.46*
. 1.15
.75
Mfg. milk, cw t.......... . 3.14
.56
Butterfat, lb ..............
.32
Cheddar cheese, l b ...
Nonfat dry milk
.15
solids (spray), l b . .

Wheat, b u ..................
Corn, b u .....................
Soybeans, b u .............
Burley tobacco, lb . . .
Barley, b u ..................

$2.21
1.60
2.56
.47
1.24
.80
3.74
.67
.37
.16

% of Parity
1954 1953
90%
90
80
90
85
85
75
75
75

90%
90
90
90
85
85
90
90
90

75

90

^Minimum forward price, may be increased as market­
ing season approaches.
Source of data: Commodity Credit Corporation.

Crop Plantings
In view of decided surpluses of wheat and
corn, the Department of Agriculture has
announced production controls on 1954 crops
as a prerequisite to price-support aid. Also,
marketing quotas were declared for wheat
so as to place a penalty upon excess plant­
ings. The actual cut in seeded wheat acreage
will amount to an estimated 19 percent.
For com, no clear indication was given by
the March 1 planting-intentions report.
Allotments had called for a 17 percent
smaller acreage, but farmer plans at that
time were for practically no change. The
assignment of allotments to individual farms
since March 1 is expected to cause some sig­
nificant acreage reduction in corn. Due to
the limited incentives afforded by the support
program to farmers who feed rather than
sell most of their corn, however, it is doubt­
ful whether corn plantings will be cut as

drastically as the allotment program suggests.
An expansion in acreages of soybeans, oats
and barley was indicated by the March 1
planting intentions report. Much of the in­
crease for these crops has been on acreages
diverted from wheat.

A perplexing problem faced by crop farm­
ers generally is how to divert acres from
crops in surplus without creating new market
gluts for other products. Larger acreages of
grass appear prominent in this respect, as a
widely recommended opportunity.

EXPANSION IN STEEL

should be taken of the strides made in the
processing of lower-grade domestic ores.
On the Upper Lakes, large reduction mills
are under construction to process low-grade
taconite into high-grade concentrates. The
1954 ore shipping season on the Great Lakes
was opened by a boat carrying 18,000 tons
of taconite pellets. It was the first large ship­
ment of concentrates to come down the lakes.
The pellets, processed during the winter at
Babbit, Minnesota, were destined for blast
furnaces in Middletown.
Also on the Upper Lakes, a new mine is
being developed in the Steep Rock area of
Ontario. Thus, it would appear that there
will continue to be an abundant supply of
iron ore available to steel mills in the Lower
Lakes area for many years to come.

(Continued from Page 4)

Canadian Ores
Although eastern mills will be the main
recipients of Venezuelan ores, steel mills on
the Lower Lakes will use most of the high
and medium grade ores from the new Labra­
dor field. Some Labrador ore will begin mov­
ing to East Coast ports later this summer
and shipments to Lake Erie ports will start
in 1955. The iron ore will be moved the first
360 miles over a new railroad built to link
the Labrador field with Seven Islands on
the St. Lawrence River. Large ocean-going
carriers will then take the ore upriver to
Montreal, where it will be transshipped to a
fleet of 40 to 50 small lake freighters that
can navigate the present locks and canal
system. Completion of the St. Lawrence Sea­
way will enable the large ore carriers to
make the complete 1,100-mile trip from
Seven Islands to the Lower Lakes.
Large deposits of medium and lower grade
ores have also been discovered in the Ungava
Bay region of northern Quebec. Although
easily accessible — the deposits have been
described as being located practically on the
shoreline with no overburden to remove —
the nearest markets are in Europe. Opening
the St. Lawrence River to large ocean-going
freighters may make the Quebec ores com­
petitive with Lake Superior and Labrador
ores at Lower Lakes ports.
In addition to the recent and prospective
developments in Canadian ores, account




Types

of Furnaces

Another facet of the steel industry’s recent
expansion program is the changes that have
occurred since 1947 in the three major kinds
of steel-making furnaces — open hearth, Bes­
semer and electric. In the last six years,
electric-furnace capacity was nearly doubled,
open-hearth capacity about equaled the na­
tional rate of increase, but rated Bessemer
capacity was contracted, thus continuing a
trend that has persisted since the turn of
the century. In the Fourth District, per­
centage gains in open-hearth and electricfurnace capacity were about half that of the
rest of the country while, contrary to the
national trend, Bessemer capacity was ex­
panded.
At the beginning of 1948, electric furnaces
9

comprised 5.7 percent of the nation’s steel
capacity, on a tonnage basis, as against 8.4
percent (or 10.4 million net tons) this year.
Although still a relatively small proportion
of the total, electric furnaces have shown
the most rapid growth in the postwar period,
expanding 94 percent in the last six years.
The reasons are not hard to find.
Electric furnaces can produce most known
grades of steel, although they excel in the
production of stainless and special alloy
steels. Not only has the demand for these
special steels skyrocketed, but, assuming
location in a favorable scrap-producing area
with low power rates, the electric furnace
can produce carbon steels at costs comparable
with, or sometimes even below, that of openhearth steel.
With the increased emphasis being placed
upon furnace location nearer to steel-consum­

ing markets, this factor, along with the
electric furnace’s advantages in producing
alloy steels, has stimulated its development.
It is not surprising, then, to find that electricfurnace capacity in the Fourth District in­
creased only about half as rapidly during
the last six years as that of the rest of the
country.
The open hearth remains the dominant
furnace, however, accounting for about 88
percent of all steel ingot capacity in the
United States. Nearly 85 percent of the
capacity added in the country since 1947, or
25.5 million net tons, has been in openhearth furnaces.
The open hearth has several major ad­
vantages over the other two types of fur­
naces. First, the ratio of scrap to pig iron
may be varied over wide limits in charging
the open hearth, whereas electric furnaces

STEEL CAPACITY BY TYPE OF FURNACE
(Capacity figures in thousands of net tons as of January 1st)

CAPACITY

NET INCREASE
1 9 4 8 -1 9 5 3

Area and Furnace

PERCENTAGE
OF TOTAL

1954

1948

Tons

Pet

1954

1948

TOTAL U. S............................

124,330

94 ,2 3 3

3 0 ,0 9 7

31.9

100.0

100.0

Open Hearth.....................
Bessemer.............................
Electric.................................

109,095
4 ,7 8 7
10,449

83,611
5 ,2 2 6
5 ,3 9 7

25 ,4 8 4
— 439
5,052

30.5
— 8.4
93.6

8 7.7
3.9
8.4

88.7
5.5
5.7

FOURTH DISTRICT................

5 0 ,5 3 8

4 2 ,4 3 5

8,103

19.1

100.0

100.0

4 2 ,3 5 3
3,951
4 ,234

3 5 ,8 4 7
3 ,824
2 ,7 6 4

6,5 0 6
127
1,470

18.2
3.3
53.2

83.8
7.8
8.4

84.5
9.0
6.5

OTHER U. S...........................

73 ,7 9 2

5 1 ,7 9 9

2 1 ,9 9 4

42.5

100.0

100.0

Open Hearth.....................
Bessemer.............................
Electric.................................

66,741
836
6,215

47 ,7 6 4
1,402
2,633

18,978
— 566
3,582

39.7
— 4 0.4
136.0

90.4
1.1
8.4

92.2
2.7
5.1

Compiled from reports of American Iron and Steel Institute. Details may not add to totals because of rounding.

10



use practically all scrap and Bessemer con­
verters require about 95 percent pig iron.
Since from 25 to 30 percent of the ingots
produced in a mill are reduced to scrap in
the finishing operations, the ability to use
this scrap is important. Secondly, open
hearths can be built much larger than either
the electric furnaces or Bessemer converters.
The open hearth’s ability to produce large
quantities of steel under easily controlled
conditions and to take advantage of relative
changes in the cost of scrap and pig iron by
varying their ratio in the furnace charge
have made the open hearth the dominant
process in the steel industry.
One major point of difference between
Fourth District and other U. S. mills during
the 1948-1953 period has been the expansion
of Bessemer capacity in the District and its
contraction in the rest of the country, as
previously noted. More than four-fifths of
the nation’s rated Bessemer capacity is lo­
cated in the Fourth District. The figures on
Bessemer capacity (shown in the adjoining
table) are somewhat misleading, however,
since they do not show the country’s po­
tential Bessemer capacity. About a third of
the Bessemer converters in the country (10
out of 33) are used solely to provide blown




metal for open hearth charges and their ton­
nage is not included in total capacity.
The modem Bessemer shop is located near
the open hearth furnaces to take advantage
of the duplex process; e.g., using hot-blown
metal from the converters as part of the pigiron charge for the open hearth. This speeds
up considerably the open-hearth operation by
shortening the time of the heat and lengthen­
ing the life of the open hearth. An open
hearth, which averages 15 heats per week
using scrap-pig or scrap-ore charges will
average 40 heats using the duplex process.
The process does not require much scrap, an
advantage when scrap is scarce and costly.
Bessemer steel is interchangeable with
open hearth steel in many mill operations.
The converter provides a quick, cheap means
of converting pig iron into steel. Its main
drawbacks are that it generates more scrap
than it consumes and that the conversion
occurs so quickly (a blow takes only 10 to
15 minutes) that it is difficult to control the
chemical changes to obtain steels of varied
chemical composition. Today, Bessemer steel
is principally used for butt-welded and seam­
less pipe, wire, free-machining bars, flatrolled products and castings.

11

Better Jets Through Ceramic Materials
By CLYDE WILLIAMS, President and Director, Battelle Memorial Institute
t u r b o j e t e n g i n e , relatively unknown before
World War II, now dominates the field o f highperformance military aviation, and is invading
the field o f commercial transportation. The flight
speeds and altitudes o f which turbojet-powered air­
craft are capable represent substantial advances above
those for conventional reciprocating-engine aircraft.
Jet fighters have reached speeds above 750 miles per
hour, and a jet bomber has flown at an altitude above
63,000 feet. The first U. S. jet transport is scheduled
to begin trial flights this fall.
Jet propulsion has been compared, in principle, to
the behavior o f a toy balloon. When a balloon is filled
with air and the opening sealed, the balloon is inca­
pable o f motion unless it is propelled by some external
force such as a gust o f wind. Open the seal, however,
and the rush o f the compressed air out o f the opening
sends the balloon zooming away in a direction
opposite from that towards which the air is expelled.
This is a homely illustration o f the principle that, for
every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction.
For practical application o f this principle in the
turbojet power plant, it has been found that the air­
craft gas turbine must operate at a temperature o f
about 1550 P. It is also known that turbine perform­
ance increases tremendously with increases in operat­
ing temperature. Therefore, to achieve higher speeds
and better performance, aeronautical engineers are
now seeking materials for the construction o f turbine
parts that will withstand a temperature o f 2500 F.
Their studies show that such materials would permit
design for 60 per cent more thrust or jet power from
an engine o f the same size and air-flow capacity; or,
conversely, that present power output could be
achieved with considerable reduction in aircraft size
and weight.
The search for better heat-resistant materials is
proceeding in three principal directions. First, with­
out changes in engine design, efforts are being made
to increase the safe operating temperature o f severely
stressed turbine parts by 100 F, or up to 1650 F. This
may be done by improving the properties o f presently
used nickel- and cobalt-base alloys. Second, consider­
able research is in progress that may lead to coatings
or other means o f protecting molybdenum against
oxidation at elevated temperatures. When such pro­
tection is achieved, molybdenum may find use at
temperatures up to 2000 F. This range is usually con­
sidered the maximum useful service temperature limit
for known metals in adequate supply to meet massproduction needs. Third, ceramic materials and
ceramic-metal combinations, or “ cermets,” are being

T

he

Editor’s Note— While the views expressed on this page are
not necessarily those of this bank, the Monthly Business Re­
view is pleased to make this space available for the discus­
sion of significant developments in industrial research.

12



extensively investigated for service at temperatures
up to and beyond 1800 F. Although difficulties are
still to be overcome, ceramic materials and cermets
may eventually prove the best solution to realizing
the maximum performance o f the turbojet power
plant.
Ceramic materials offer real promise because they
have excellent corrosion resistance, and a wide variety
o f them far exceed most metals and metal alloys in
their ability to withstand very high temperatures. In
one tabulation, seventy-seven different ceramic mate­
rials are listed with melting points ranging from
3000 F to 7500 F. Also an attractive feature o f many
ceramic materials is their relative lightness, which
minimizes centrifugal stress in parts rotating at high
speed. Furthermore, ceramic materials are generally
in much greater supply than metals and metal alloys
now being used, or being considered for use in turbo­
jet applications. In common with some metals,
although to a more pronounced degree, the main
shortcoming o f ceramic materials is their brittleness.
This may cause “ brittle fracture” under conditions
o f severe stress.
One approach to the use o f ceramic materials under
such conditions is to fit the materials to meet the
engineering requirements o f the present aircraft gas
turbine. This is being done through the development
o f ceramic-metal combinations. These attempt to
combine the high-temperature and corrosion-resistance
properties o f ceramic materials with the greater stress
and shock resistance properties o f metals. Progress
is well advanced on the development o f turbine blades
made from combinations o f titanium carbide and
such metals as nickel and cobalt. Many opportunities
still exist for investigating combinations o f metals
with oxides, carbides, nitrides, silicides, and other
refractory ceramic materials.
Another approach to the use o f ceramic materials
in the turbojet engine is to explore the possibilities
o f redesigning the turbine to reduce the severity o f
stress concentrations and thermal shock to which ce­
ramic parts are subjected. Proper engineering design
has already proven a major factor in the successful use
o f ceramic materials as linings in the combustion
chambers o f rocket motors. This experience, together
with more knowledge about the conditions encountered
in turbines and o f the mechanism o f brittle fracture
o f ceramic materials, could play an important part
in the development o f ceramic parts for use in the
turbojet power plant.
To evaluate and use ceramic materials, close cooper­
ation is required between industrial ceramists and
gas turbine engineers. With this close cooperation
today, ceramic parts might well be developed that
will set the standards o f speed and performance for
tomorrow’s aircraft power plants.