View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
Covering financial, industrial, and agricultural conditions
in the

Fourth Federal Reserve District
Federal Reserve Bank o f Cleveland
Vol. 15

Cleveland, Ohio, June 1, 1932

The statistical records of business in this district in
April and the first part of May continued drab and irregu­
lar generally, though a slight contrary-to-seasonal in­
crease was reported in some of the most important indus­
tries in this district. Further progress was made in the
banking situation and member bank indebtedness to the
reserve bank declined sharply. Member bank credit ex­
tended continued to recede, but deposits have moved al­
most horizontally for several weeks.
Steel operations, which touched an extremely low level
in April, worked upward in the first three weeks of May
and in the latest period averaged 25.5 per cent of capacity.
Operations at Cleveland in the latest week were at 38 per
cent, but Youngstown and Pittsburgh mill activity lagged
somewhat. This recent expansion is contrary to the usual
trend. It was due primarily to increased demands from
automobile manufacturers, chiefly those engaged in the
production of small cars, but there have also been slight
increases in orders for pipe, structural steel and tin plates.
The coal industry failed to reflect the expansion in stedl
operations and bituminous output sank to the lowest level
in many years. This was partly a result of shutdowns
caused by disputes over wages and working conditions.
In the first month of the lake shipping season coal load­
ings at Lake Erie ports were seven per cent below a year
ago. Coal stocks generally are low.
Department store sales increased at a more than sea­
sonal rate in April, but were still 29 per cent below the
same period a year ago, when some Easter buying fell
in that month. The cool weather has retarded seasonable
sales and demand for clothing and textiles has been par­
ticularly dull. A sharp curtailment occurred in opera­
tions at clothing manufacturing plants in April and the fall
selling season was over a month late getting under way.
Wholesale trade generally declined in April, part of
which was seasonal. . Drug sales have held up better than
other lines. Collections are reported slow in many in­
stances.
Sales of replacement tires increased in early May as
gasoline consumption expanded seasonally; still demand
continues below last year. Dealers’ tire stocks on April
1 were lower than since 1926, but manufacturers are car­
rying a larger supply of tires than a year ago.
General manufacturing industries in the district re­
ported little change in April from the low level of the




No. 6

past few months. Employment was off about two per
cent from March, a greater-than-seasonal decline.
Agricultural conditions in this section are above the
average for the entire country with winter wheat pros­
pects much better than the average of the preceding five
years. Fruit prospects are fair with little frost damage
reported. Crop growth was somewhat retarded by the
cool weather in May, but the rains overcame the effects
moisture shortage earlier this spring.
FINANCIAL
Changes in condition of reporting member banks and
this reserve bank in the month ended May 18 show in part
the effects of the aggressive open market policy of the
reserve system which has continued now for over six
weeks. There was only one bank suspension in the fourth
district up to May 27, and one large bank was reopened, part­
ly with the aid of the Reconstruction Finance Corporation.
Borrowings of member banks declined sharply and their
position on the whole has changed in the past three months
from one of heavy indebtedness to the reserve bank to a
position where borrowings are much nearer the average
of preceding years. Withdrawals from deposit accounts
continue at a slow rate, but the size of the debits indi­
cate that they are more a result of actual need than of un­
certainty regarding banking conditions.
Savings deposits at 45 selected banks in this district
were reduced 0.6 per cent in April, and were 16 per cent
below one year ago on May 1.
Member Bank Credit. The contraction in total member
bank credit in this district continued, up to the 18 th of
May, at approximately the rate apparent since the be­
ginning of the year. As in earlier weeks of the period,
the reduction was chiefly due to a falling-off in collateral
and “all other” loans; investments have worked up­
ward at a moderate rate recently.
The reserve system’s purchases of Government securities
have tended to make money conditions easy, resulting in
lower short-term interest rates, an accumulation of excess
reserves at New York, etc. Some of the latter found their
way to interior centers, the movement being aided by the
transfer of funds for operation of the Reconstruction
Finance Corporation. Although loans of reporting mem­
ber banks in this district continued downward in the
face of very little change in either demand or time de­

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

posits, investments of these banks increased slightly in
recent weeks, chiefly through the purchase of Government
securities. The fact that the decline in loans has b'&en
at a more rapid rate than the falling-off in deposits en­
abled member banks to reduce their indebtedness to the
Federal Reserve bank of Cleveland quite sharply in the
past four weeks.
The contraction in reporting member bank credit in the
past year has amounted to about 13 per cent and in de­
posits to 21 per cent; nevertheless, the distribution of prin­
cipal types of assets and liabilities, on a percentage basis,
has changed but little, as is shown in the following table.
Reporting Member Banks in Leading Cities

Collateral Loans ..............................
All Other Loans ................................
Investments— Governments ...............
— All Other .....................
Total Loans & Investments .............
Demand Deposits ............................. .
Time Deposits ....................................
Government Deposits ....................... .
Total

Deposits

..................................

Percentage of Total
May 18,
May 20,
1932
1931
28.0
29.1
33.3
32.9
20.9
20.7
17.8
17.3
100.0
100.0
50.0
49.0
1.0

52.3
47.4
0.3

100.0

100.0

Per cent decline in actual figures
— 16.6
— 11.9
— 12.3
—10.6
— 13.1
— 24.8
— 18.8
-f260.0
—21.3

Reserve Bank Credit. The volume of credit extended by
this bank fluctuated somewhat in the four weeks ended
May 18, and on the latest date was about $9,000,000
higher than in mid-April. The increase resulted entirely
from participation in the System’s open market purchases.
In the past four weeks this bank’s holdings of Govern­
ment securities increased nearly $34,000,000 to an alltime high record of $126,768,000. Since the first week
of March these holdings have expanded 85 per cent, the
sharp upward movement being shown on the accompany­
ing chart. Although the funds released by these purchases
were immediately available, chiefly in New York, balances
were gradually transferred to banks in this district (and
elsewhere) and they in turn were able to reduce their in­
debtedness to the Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland, a
drop of over 50 per cent occurring in this item in about
two months. The decline in the latter part of April and
the first three weeks of May was at a sharper rate than
in the preceding four weeks. As in other periods of largescale buying of Government securities, it takes several
weeks before the effects of such purchases are widely felt.




Holdings of acceptances were practically unchanged in
the four latest weeks, but the volume, in comparison with
total earning assets, is insignificant. They amounted to
only $3,104,000 on the latest date as against $17,000,000
in 1931.
Gold reserves of this bank increased in late April, but
declined in early May, and on the latest date, at $269,000,000, were about $8,000,000 lower than on April 20 and
more than $40,000,000 below a year ago.
Circulation of this bank’s Federal reserve notes con­
tinued to recede in the latter part of April at the rate ap­
parent in the first three months of the year, although in the
first three weeks of May a slight upward movement was
evident. In normal years note circulation tends to increase
in spring and early summer; but, partly because of the very
high level to which circulation advanced in late 1931 co­
incident with the anxiety over the banking situation and
partly because there has been practically no spring ex­
pansion in business, the general trend of note circulation
has been downward so far this year. At $292,000,000 on
May 18, note circulation was still over $100,000,000
higher than a year ago.
Collateral pledged to secure Federal reserve notes in
circulation included Government securities on May 11 for
the first time. This was in accordance with one of the
provisions of the Glass-Steagall Bill. The law requires
that Federal reserve notes in circulation be secured by 40
per cent gold, the rest, to 100 per cent, being made up of
eligible paper or gold. The decline in the amount of
eligible paper at the reserve banks, as a consequence of
the falling-off in discounts and acceptances and recently in
gold holdings, in the face of the large volume of note cir­
culation made it necessary (in order that the operating
margin of gold be maintained at a level which would in­
sure efficient functioning of the banks) to permit the re­
serve banks to substitute some of their increased holdings
of Government securities as collateral to secure note cir­
culation.
MANUFACTURING, MINING
Steel
Steel production staged a very moderate
rally in the first three weeks of May,
rising from the slump of the preceding
month and regaining the rate of activity of early March.
For the country as a whole, steelmaking operations ad­

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

vanced from 22 per cent on April 15 to 25% per cent in
the third week of May. Meanwhile, Pittsburgh mills
were holding at about 21 per cent, but Youngstown pro­
ducers increased from 20 per cent to 26, and Cleveland
from 20 to 38 per cent.
This advance resulted chiefly from the limited improve­
ment in the automobile industry, which has been con­
fined almost entirely to cars in the lower-priced class.
Schedules of most manufacturers in the medium and highpriced lines were somewhat smaller than a month ago,
but the low-priced cars were being produced at the high­
est rate since September, 1931.
A more stable price situation has been apparent re­
cently, except for pig iron, but the steel price structure
was approaching a test period with wages and salaries
generally reduced 15 per cent beginning May 16. An
advance of $2 per ton in sheet bars for the third quarter
was expected to discourage sheet mills from making con­
cessions.
During the month bessemer iron at Pittsburgh and
malleable iron at Youngstown declined 50 cents a ton.
Scrap prices grew progressively weaker at Pittsburgh,
Youngstown and Cleveland. Reflecting this softer pr;ce
situation in raw materials, Steel’s iron and steel composite
receded from $29.74 in mid-April to $29.58 by May 21.
Daily production of both pig iron and steel ingots in
April declined to the lowest point since July, 1921. Nor­
mally in April production is at or near peak levels, but
so far in 1932 output has been very disappointing. In
most past years there has been a seasonal decline in May,
but up to the present time in this abnormal year the
trend of iron and steel production has been contrary to
seasonal movements and operating figures covering the
first three weeks of May indicate a slight increase for
that month.
For pig iron, the April daily rate was 28,524 gross tons,
compared with 31,194 tons in March and 66,986 tons in
April, 1931. For ingots, the April daily rate of 47,685
tons contrasted with 52,253 tons in March and 104,711
tons last April. In both pig iron and ingots, the gains
over previous low marks of this depression were sur­
rendered. In the first four months of 1932 total output
of steel ingots was 5,571,478 tons, against 10,677,124
tons in the same period of 1931. For pig iron the fourmonth total was 3,754,736 tons; a year ago it was 7,465,023 tons. On April 30, active blast furnaces numbered
5 9, a net loss of one from March 31.
Coal

Production of bituminous coal in April,
both in this district and the entire coun­
try, declined sharply from the preceding
month. The reduction was 25 per cent in the fourth dis­
trict and 37 per cent in the entire country. The average
March-to-April change of past years has been a con­
traction of about ten per cent.
Compared with a year ago output of local mines was
down 25 per cent in April and was 20 per cent below the
average April production of the preceding ten years. In
the first four months, coal production in this district was
26 per cent below the same period of last year.
Industrial demand is very limited and with the advent
of warmer weather household orders have declined. The




3

lake shipping season began in a rather moderate way, load­
ings in April at Lake Erie ports amounting to 1,197,000
tons, a reduction of seven per cent from the same month
of 1931. Stocks of bituminous coal at upper lake ports
are quite large and, with movement of iron ore sharply
curtailed, lake coal shipments are expected to be light
this summer. Coal prices continue weak.
Automobiles

After allowing for usual seasonal
changes, automobile production ex­
panded at a moderate rate each week
since the middle of April, the Annalist’s weekly index,
based on Cram’s figures being 40.7 per cent of the 1927*29
average, compared with 32.7 in mid-April, the low point so
far this year. Actual output was 44,587 units in the week
ended May 14, as against 75,720 cars and trucks in the
corresponding period last year. The recent gain was the
result of expanding operations at factories engaged chiefly
in production of small cars, part of which was offset by
reduced schedules at plants making higher-priced ma­
chines.
The upturn has had a very beneficial effect on opera­
tions of steel mills, particularly at Cleveland, and also
has aided some of the auto parts and accessory producers
in this district, though the volume of orders placed so far
is very small in comparison with preceding years.
New car sales in April, based on reports from 37 states,
were 20.2 per cent higher than in March, but 37 per cent
below a year ago. The upward movement was smaller
than has occurred at this season of past years. Normally
more sales are made in April than in any month of the
year.
Because of the increase in production in the latter half
of April, motor car output in the entire month was more
than seasonally higher than in March, the Federal Reserve
Board’s adjusted index advancing from 28 to 32 per cent.
In April a year ago the index was 77 per cent of the 192325 monthly average. According to the Department of
Commerce 148,013 cars and trucks were made in April,
an increase of 24 per cent from March, but a reduc­
tion of 56 per cent from the 336,939 cars and trucks
turned out in April, 1931. April passenger car produc­
tion was 58 per cent below the corresponding month of
1931 and the number of trucks manufactured was down
46 per cent in the same period.
In the first four months of this year automobile pro­
duction was only slightly more than half as large as in
the same period of 1931. Truck production in the fourmonth period was down 46 per cent and passenger car
output was off 50.6 per cent.
Rubber
Tires,

Sentiment in the rubber industry in the
first half of May improved slightly as
demand for replacement tires increased.
Most if not all the upturn, was seasonal, however, and
demand continues below a year ago.
March and April production was somewhat disappoint­
ing from the volume standpoint based on actual output of
tires in March as reported by the Rubber Manufacturers’
Association and rubber consumption and employment in
April.
March production of tires (80 per cent of the industry)

4

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

was 2,947,000 casings, a slight contrary-to-seasonal re­
duction from February, and 21 per cent below March,
1931. Output in the first quarter was 10.7 per cent un­
der the corresponding period of last year. Production so
far this year has exceeded shipments by somewhat more
than the usual amount, the excess for the first quarter
being 25.6 per cent, compared with four per cent in 1931
and 13 per cent in 1930. Stocks in hands of manufac­
turers at the end of March represented 3.3 months’ sup­
ply at the current rate of sales, compared with about 2.3
months’ supply on the same date last year.
Part of this increase, however, represents a transfer of
stocks, usually carried by dealers, to manufacturers. Av­
erage stocks of tires, per dealer, (based on 24,000 reports
to the Department of Commerce) on April 1 totaled 66.2
casings, compared with 78.4 tires a year ago. This was
the lowest average stock since 1926, and inventories of
inner tubes constituted a new low record. Total stocks of
independent dealers were estimated at 4,650,000 casings, a
reduction of 840,000 from a year ago. Inventories of mass
distributors were practically unchanged on April 1 from
the same date in 1931.
Employment at 22 rubber manufacturing concerns in
this district was unchanged in April from the preceding
month, whereas the average change of the past five years
for this period was an increase of one per cent. April
consumption of crude rubber by manufacturers was esti­
mated 6.7 per cent under March and 22.1 per cent below
April, 1931.
Imports of crude rubber in April declined, being 12.7
per cent below March and 20.6 per cent below a year ago.
This is the first sizeable reduction in imports and re­
flects in part a curtailment of tapping on plantations which
followed the recent abandonment of all restriction discus­
sions. Despite the falling-off in imports, they still exceed
current consumption and stocks of crude rubber in the
United States on May 1, at 343,098 long tons, were over
9,000 tons larger than a month earlier and more than 50
per cent above a year ago.
Crude rubber prices advanced sharply in early May co­
incident with the announcement of a proposed tariff on
rubber, but soon declined to new low levels of less than
three cents a pound in the third week of the month.
Clothing

Although this normally is the dull sea­
son for clothing manufacturers, spring
production having ceased and the fall
season not yet having opened, the reduction in April this
year was greater than the average falling-off of preceding
periods. The number of persons employed dropped nine
per cent from March to April and was 11 per cent below
1931, at 47 factories in this district. Employment in the
men’s clothing industry was off eight per cent in April, but
in the first four months of 19 32 averaged about the same
as in the corresponding period of 1931.
Salesmen are now on the road with fall samples, but
the season started at least a month later than usual, chief­
ly because of unsettled conditions, including the down­
ward movement of prices, which as yet seems unabated.
Dealers and retailers continue to operate on very lim­
ited stocks and hesitate about placing orders, either for




immediate or future delivery. The arranging of credit is
disturbing and collections are slow.
Fairchild's retail price index showed rather sharp de­
clines in both men’s and women’s apparel in April. Prices
average from 15 to 25 per cent below a year ago.
Other
Manufacturing

Operations in April were generally lower
than in March, contrary to the seasonal
movements of past years. Total indus­
trial employment declined about two per cent and in Ohio
was 19 per cent lower than a year ago. A slight increase
in automobile production in May caused a moderate ex­
pansion in operations at some parts and accessory com­
panies, but the general level of activity is very much be­
low the average of recent years for this season.
Auto Parts, Accessories. Irregularities were apparent
in the auto accessory industry in April and the first half
of May, some companies reporting an increase in opera­
tions, while others showed declines. April employment
at 61 concerns cooperating with the Ohio State Bureau
of Business Research dropped four per cent from March,
in contrast with a five-year average March-to-April in­
crease of three per cent.

Brick and Tile. A slight upturn in operations at brick
and tile plants was reported in April, but it was below sea­
sonal proportions. At 28 concerns the number employed
was only 40 per cent of the 1926 average and was about
30 per cent lower than a year ago. Decline in large build­
ing and road construction has affected demand for these
materials.
China, Pottery. A sharp drop in demand for china and
pottery in April resulted in a reduction of 12 per cent in
employment, compared with a five-year March-to-April in­
crease of one per cent. Collections are slow, but some­
what improved from a month or two ago.
Electrical Supplies. A further tapering-off in operations
at electrical apparatus and supply houses was reported in
April, employment declining two per cent in contrast with
an average increase of three per cent in other years.
Glass. A slight increase in demand from the automo­
bile industry in April was more than offset by declines in
other fields. Glass production was reduced in April, em­
ployment falling 20 per cent from March. In the pre­
ceding five years an average increase of one per cent
was shown. The ten per cent price increase made in Feb­
ruary has been maintained generally, but orders for plate
and rolled glass have been small. Makers of moulded
glassware reported a hesitancy on the part of buyers to
place orders. The backwardness of the season has affected
demand for glass food containers.
Hardware, Machinery. An increase in machine tool or­
ders was experienced in the entire country in April, the
first upward movement since December. Unfilled orders
on May 1 were about 25 per cent larger than April ship­
ments. The upturn, however, was not general in this dis­
trict, many concerns reporting a contraction, both in or­
ders and operations. Hardware sales improved slightly,
but they are very much below normal.
Paint. Ordinarily at this season paint sales are at or
near peak levels, but production so far this year has

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

been about 25 per cent below the same period of 1931.
The decline in the number of orders received has been
much smaller. Retail purchases of household paints have
been in small quantities, with much less exterior house
paint being sold than in other years. Dealers stocks con­
tinue low and hand-to-mouth buying is evident every­
where. Sales of automobile paints and lacquers for re­
painting machines have increased sharply, but orders from
manufacturers, though having advanced slightly, are
much below other years.
Paper, Printing. Production of fine paper declined in
April and employment in this district dropped two per
cent in contrast with stability in other years at that time.
The number employed averaged eight per cent lower in
the first four months of 1932 than in the same period of
1931.
Sheet Metal. Concerns in this class showed a contraryto-seasonal falling-off in operations as building activity
lagged, and demand for metal containers failed to expand
in usual amounts in preparation for the canning season.
Shoes. Production of footwear in April declined some­
what more than the usual seasonal amount at factories
in this district. The reduction was 25 per cent, as against
13 per cent in the two preceding years. Output was 14
per cent below April, 1931, and a large part of the in­
crease shown in the first quarter was wiped out, produc­
tion being only two per cent higher in the first four months
of the year than in the same period of 1931. Factories en­
gaged in producing the cheaper grade shoes, which en­
joyed a higher level of activity in the first quarter than
makers of higher-priced footwear, reported a falling-off in
April.
TRADE
Retail Trade

The expansion in department stores sales
from March to April was considerably
more than seasonal and the daily aver­
age seasonally adjusted index advanced from 61 to 67 per
cent of the 1923-25 monthly average. March dollar sales
were particularly low on account of the cool weather
which prevented the influence of Easter exerting its full
force on buying of spring goods. This was evidently de­
ferred until April, though sales in this month were 28.8
per cent below the corresponding period of last year.
Easter was in April last year, however, and sales in that
month therefore were increased because of that fact. In
the first four months sales were down 24 per cent from
the same period of 1931.
The falling-off in sales in all the principal cities showed
little variation from the district decline and in the various
departments the smallest reductions from a year ago were,
toilet articles. — 8.6 per cent; neckware and scarfs, — 6.0
and china and glassware, ■
— 14.0 per cent.
Declining prices continue to be an important factor in
the reduction shown in dollar sales, though the falling-off
in Fairchild's index in April was one of the smallest for
any month of the current depression. The decline was
only one per cent from March, but in the past 16 months
this index has dropped 22.5 per cent. The reduction in
prices of women’s wear continues at a faster rate than in
men’s wear.
The dollar value of department store stocks receded in




5

April, contrary to seasonal movements of past years, and
touched a new low level for the period since 1919. A re­
vised index of stocks at department stores in this district
is shown on the accompanying chart. The seasonally ad­
justed index in April was only 64.6 per cent of the 192 325 monthly average, a decline of 16 per cent in the past
year.
Sales so far this year have declined at a more rapid
rate than stocks and the cumulative stock turnover rate
or ratio of sales to average stocks was only .81 in the
first four months of 1932 against .91 in the same period
of 1931.
The ratio of credit to total sales in April was the same
as in March, but was 6.5 per cent below a year ago. Col­
lections in April on accounts outstanding on March 31
were about seven per cent below a year ago, with col­
lections on installment accounts down about ten per cent.
Sales at reporting wearing apparel stores were down
28.6 per cent in April from the same month of 1931 and
stocks were off about 30 per cent in the same period.
Chain grocery sales, per individual unit operated, were
8.5 per cent lower in April than a year ago and off about
eight per cent in the first four months. Chain drug sales
dropped quite sharply in April and were 14 per cent un­
der the same month of 1931. In the four months, sales
were down eleven per cent.
Wholesale
Trade

All reporting lines of wholesale trade
except hardware declined in April from
the preceding month. The reduction
was of a seasonal nature in drugs and dry goods sales, but
contrary to seasonal movements of past years in grocery
sales. The combined index of dollar sales of the four lines
was only 55 per cent of the 1923-1925 monthly average, as
against 75 per cent a year ago.
Wholesale drug sales declined 13 per cent from March
to April and in the latest month were 17.5 per cent lower
than in 1931. Compared with other reporting lines drug
sales have held up very well; in April they were 81 per
cent of the 192 3-25 monthly average. Dry goods sales
in April were only 34 per cent of this same average and
grocery and hardware sales were 58 and 51 per cent re­
spectively of sales in the base period.
Collections generally are slow and the dollar value of
stocks is much below last year at this time.

6

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

BUILDING
Building activity in this section in April was only slight­
ly higher than in March, the upturn 0.2 per cent, being
much less than seasonal and less than the increase re­
ported in the 37 eastern states. Compared with a year
ago, contracts awarded were off 70 per cent in this sec­
tion in April and 64 per cent in the first four months.
This latter decline is about the same as was reported for
the entire country in the same period, construction under­
takings of all descriptions amounting to only about onethird of those during the first four months of 1931. Total
contracts awarded in April amounted to $10,927,000 in
the fourth district, while the average value of contracts
awarded in April in the past ten years was $53,342,000.
Each of the four major types of construction, except
public works, showed losses in April from March and de­
clines were reported in all groups from a year ago.
Residential building has been very disappointing,
amounting to only 20 per cent of last year’s volume in
April and 30 per cent in the first four months. Declines
were general in all residential building types.
Non-residential building started in April was down
about 33 per cent from March and showed a loss of about
70 per cent from last year. Public buildings showed a
slight increase from April, 1931, but all other types were
down sharply.
Public works construction in April was off about 30
per cent from a year ago, but a sizeable gain in high­
way construction raised the April figure well above the
March level. Construction of public utilities was prac­
tically at a standstill and in April as well as the first
four months was only a fraction of what it was in similar
periods of preceding years.
Figures for individual cities show a larger volume of
building permits issued in Cleveland in the first four
months of 1932 than in the same period of 1931, and only
moderate declines at Cincinnati and Middletown. Most
other cities reported losses exceeding 50 per cent from
a year ago.
Contemplated construction reported continues to de­
cline, but, as for the past two years, residential planning
is higher than the rate of contract-letting, indicating an
accumulated demand for housing which is being held
up by disturbing conditions in the industrial and finan­
cial fields.
Building supply and lumber dealers have experienced
no change in the demand for materials in the past month
and they report considerable difficulty regarding collec­
tions and financing of what few orders are received. Ce­
ment production increased slightly in April, but was 63
per cent below a year ago. The decline in public works
and utilities construction particularly has affected demand
for cement.
AGRICULTURE
The early growing season was somewhat retarded in
this section by cool weather in April and the first part of
May. Though precipitation was below normal in April,
heavy and frequent rains in early May interfered with
the planting of corn in some sections, but nearly all oats
were sown prior to the inclement weather. Pastures




have improved with recent rains, though cool weather has
retarded growth. Fruit prospects are only fair.
Winter Wheat. Prospects for winter wheat in the states
of the fourth district seem unusually good, based on the
May 1 condition report of the Department of Agriculture.
This is in contrast with the report covering the entire
country, which indicates a very small crop, chiefly because
of the very poor prospects in the western and central
states. A harvest of only 440,781,000 bushels this year is
indicated by the May 1 report. With one exception, this
is the smallest crop raised since the war and is 44 per cent
below the unusually large harvest of 1931. Domestic con­
sumption in 1930-31, the latest crop year for which com­
plete figures are available, was greater than this year’s
indicated crop. Abandonment of acreage because of win­
terkilling, etc., was 16.6 per cent in the entire country
as against a ten-year average of 12.0, and 5.0 per cent
in 1931. Condition on May 1 was only 75.1 per cent of
estimated normal compared with a ten-year average of
8 3.8 per cent and 90.3 per cent one year ago.
In the states included wholly or partly in the fourth
district, abandonment of acreage was below the average
of both preceding years and the entire country.
It
amounted to only one per cent in Ohio and Pennsylvania,
1.5 per cent in West Virginia and six per cent in Ken­
tucky.
Ohio wheat, with a May 1 condition of 92 per cent of
normal, was more promising than in any of the major
producing states. Condition in Pennsylvania and West
Virginia was 90 per cent of normal, and in Kentucky 87
per cent.
Indicated production in Ohio was 31,939,000 bushels,
about 5,000,000 greater than the average harvest in the
five years 1924-1928. Only two other states, Kansas and
Oklahoma, show larger prospective crops, though in these
two states the indicated crops are very much smaller than
in preceding years. In most sections of the district the
wheat crop never looked better. The stand is generally
heavy and blight or Hessian fly damage is reported in
very few fields.
Rye. The rye crop in this section improved in April
and indications on May 1 were for a large crop. The
local crop was in better-than-average condition.
Hay and Pasture. The cool, dry weather in early spring
retarded growth of hay and pastures, though rains in May
alleviated this condition. The May 1 condition was about
three points below normal in Ohio, Pennsylvania and
Kentucky, and down eight points in West Virginia. In­
dications point to a slightly larger crop of hay in this
section than in 1931. Stocks of hay on farms on May 1
were much larger than a year ago and the five-year aver­
age in this district. In the entire country stocks were
below average, but larger than in 1931.
Fruits. Frost damage to fruit crops apparently has been
less than was reported a month ago, though fruit trees are
not expected to bear so heavily this season because many
were over-burdened with fruit last year and trees rarely
bear bumper crops in two succeeding periods.
Tobacco. Preparation of ground for the new tobacco
crop was hampered somewhat by wet weather in April,
but more progress was made in early May. Tobacco plants

7

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

are growing rather slowly on account of the cool weather,
and insect damage has been more pronounced than usual.
No shortage of plants appears likely, however. Although
preliminary estimates pointed to sizeable reductions in
acreage of tobacco to be planted (14 per cent in the burley
type), recent operations in the main burley district indi­
cate a much smaller reduction, according to observations
of one authority.
Canning Crops. Indications point to considerably smaller
acreages of all principal canning crops, except tomatoes.
Stocks of this crop are fairly well depleted, but carryover
of other crops is large.

Wholesale and Retail Trade
(1932 compared with 1931)
Percentage
Increase or decrease
SALES
SALES
ST O C K S
First four
Apr.,
Apr.,
months
1932
1932
— 2 7 .6
— 2 8 .2
— 2 3 .3
— 2 7 .3
— 3 1 .9
— 3 2 .4
— 3 1 .9
— 3 5 .4
— 2 9 .0
— 2 8 .8

— 2 1 .2
— 2 2 .6
— 2 2 .0
— 1 9 .2
— 2 7 .5
— 2 2 .4
— 2 5 .0
— 2 9 .0
— 2 4 .4
— 2 4 .2

— 2 3 .3
— 3 1 .4
— 2 8 .6

— 1 9.1
— 2 6 .9
— 2 4 .2

— 4 0 .3
— 4 8 .7
— 3 6 .8
— 3 2 .8
— 2 3 .4
— 4 2 .8
— 4 1 .6

— 4 4 .4
— 4 4 .9
— 2 4 .2
— 1 7 .2
— 2 1 .9
— 3 8 .8
— 3 7 .0

— 1 4 .2
— 8 .5

— 1 0 .9
— 7 .9

— 2 8 .0
— 2 7 .6
— 1 9 .4
— 2 1 .9
— 1 7 .4
— 2 2 .9
— 2 3 .5
— 4 0 .6
— 1 7 .5
— 3 0 .2

— 2 5 .0
— 2 4 .7
-1 5 .8
— 16 .2
— 17 .2
— 2 0 .9
— 2 1 .2
— 3 5 .4
— 13.5
— 2 6 .0

—
—
—

3 .6

21.6
11.1

—
—
—
—
—
—
—

1 6 .4
16.5
2 2 .7
1 5 .0
1 8 .4
2 0.3
1 6 .0

—

21.0

Akron...................
Butler..................
Cincinnati..........
Cleveland...........
Columbus...........
D ayton................
Erie.......................
Franklin..............
Greensburg. . . .
Hamilton............
Homestead.........
Lexington...........
Lorain..................
Middletown. . . .
Oil C ity..............
Pittsburgh..........
Springfield..........
Steubenville----Toledo..................
W arren................
Wheeling.............
Youngstown. . .
T o ta l................




%
change
from
1931
— 3 6.3
— 3 0 .4
— 5 3 .9
— 2 9.1
— 3 4.3
— 4 3 .6
— 4 2 .3
— 3 0 .0
— 3 2 .7
— 4 2 .2
— 2 6 .8
— 3 9 .4
— 1 9 .4
— 1 9 .0
— 5 2 .4
— 3 5.1
— 36 .5
— 31.3
— 3 9 .9
— 4 3 .0
— 4 6 .1
— 5 2 .3
— 2 7 .2
— 4 4 .4
— 38 .1
— 3 4 .6

Year-to-date Year-to-date
Dec. 31, 1931
Jan. 1
to
to
M ay 18, 1932 M ay 20, 1931
252,067
377,829
29,183
43,412
88,975
177,309
1,230,933
1,686,371
2,106,305
3,238,471
484,492
815,050
222,455
397,534
108,951
147,978
14,391
18,361
27,109
44,150
38,550
54,054
11,428
18,797
85,955
104,922
37,574
52,850
15,635
23,545
29,114
45,761
42,802
58,273
2,589,832
3,826,039
60,074
89,733
27,297
40,038
370,342
731,924
23,148
45,002
131,958
176,883
137,638
251,899
27,995
43,849
8,194,203
12,509,224

April,
% change Jan.-Apr., % change
Fourth District Unless Otherwise
1932
from 1931
1932
from 1931
Specified
Bank Debits— 24 cities.....................S 1,736,000 — 3 6 .2
7,047,000 — 3 5 .5
Savings Deposits— end of month:
27 selected banks, O., W . P a ... .
650,944 — 15.1
657,9761 — 14.1
Postal Receipts— 9 cities................
2,537 — 1 5 .0
10,128 — 13 .6
Life Insurance Sales:
Ohio and P a.....................................
78,113 — 2 7 .6
359,514 — 11.5
Retail Sales:
16,523 — 2 8 .8
Department Stores— 55 firm s..
57,639 — 2 4 .7
Wearing Apparel— 13 f i r m s .... .3
1,062 — 2 8 .6
2,192 — 2 9 .2
596 — 4 1 .6
2,084 — 3 7 .0
.3
Wholesale Sales:
1,276 — 17.5
Drugs— 13 firms...............................
5,417 — 1 3.5
911 — 4 0 .6
3,537 — 3 5 .4
Dry Goods— 11 firms...................
Groceries— 37 firms........................
3,374 — 2 3 .5
13,507 — 2 1 .2
1,032 — 3 0 .2
Hardware— 15 firms....................... U
3,445 — 2 6 .0
Building Contracts— Residential.
1,921 — 7 9 .9
8,094 — 70 .3
10,927 — 7 0 .4
“
“
— T o ta l............
35,491 — 6 3 .7
Commercial Failures— Liabilities.. S
8,027 + 7 2 . 7
32,494 + 7 .5
“
“
— N u m b e r..
212* + 2 7 . 7
1,028* + 2 0 . 2
Production:
853 — 5 7 .8
3,757 — 4 9 .7
Pig Iron, U. S............................ Tons
1,240 — 5 4 .4
5,572 — 4 7 .8
Steel Ineots, U. S....................... Tons
413,1842 — 5 0 .6
120,872* — 5 7 .9
Automobiles— pass, cars, U. S..
90,5432 — 4 6 . 2
27,1412 — 4 5 .7
“
— trucks, U. S.........
39,395 — 2 5 .7
Bituminous Coal........................Tons
8,841 — 25 .1
1,011 — 5 3 .8
Cement— O., W . Pa., W . V a .. Bbls.
309 — 6 2 .7
Elec. Power— O., Pa., K y .. . . k. vir.h.
1,079* — 1 0.5
3,1934 — 1 1 .6
1,9473 — 3 .0
5,6864 — 18 .3
Petroleum— O., Pa., K y ......... Bbls.
6 — 1 4 .2
5
+ 2 .1
2,947* — 2 1 .2
8,8324 — 1 0 .7
Bituminous Coal Shipments:
1,197 — 7 .2
1,323 — 4 .4
Lake Eire Ports..........................Tons
s March
1 Monthly average
4 Jan.-Mar.
2 Actual number
3 Confidential.

Building Operations
(Value of Permits)

Cincinnati............
Cleveland..............
Cleve. suburbs:
Columbus..............
Covington, K y . .
Ham ilton..............

— 2 3.5

M ansfield..............
M iddletown.........
Pittsburgh, P a .. .
Portsmouth. . . . .
Sandusky..............
Springfield............
Stuebenville.........
Wheeling, W . Va.
Youngstown. . . .
Total..................

Debits to Individual Accounts
4 weeks
ending
M ay 18,
1932
47,110
6,082
15,415
230,868
372,644
94,838
41,697
21,594
2,502
4,693
8,133
2,242
13,120
7,733
2,489
5,779
8,135
523,086
10,443
4,606
75,599
4,018
24,871
26,328
5,273
1,559,298

(000 omitted)

— 3 4 .8
— 3 0.3

r-i
1 1

D E P A R T M E N T STO R E S (55)
Akron...............................................................................
Cincinnati.......................................................................
Cleveland........................................................................
Columbus........................................................................
Pittsburgh......................................................................
Toledo..............................................................................
Wheeling.........................................................................
Youngstown...................................................................
Other Cities...................................................................
District....................................................... ....................
W E A R I N G A P P A R E L (13)
Cincinnati.......................................................................
Other Cities...................................................................
District............................................................................
F U R N IT U R E (48)
Cincinnati......................................................................
Cleveland........................................................................
Columbus........................................................................
D ayton.............................................................................
Toledo............................. ................................................
Other Cities..................................................................
District............................................................................
C H A IN STO R E S*
Drugs— District ( 4 ) ...................................................
Groceries— District (6 )............................................
W H O L E S A L E G R O C E R IE S (37)
Akron...............................................................................
Cleveland........................................................................
Erie...................................................................................
Pittsburgh......................................................................
Toledo..............................................................................
Other Cities...................................................................
District............................................................................
W H O L E S A L E D R Y G OODS (11)..................
W H O L E S A L E D R U G S ( 1 3 ) ...............................
W H O L E S A L E H A R D W A R E (1 5 )...................
♦Sales per individual unit operated.

Fourth District Business Statistics

%
change
from
1931
— 33.3
— 3 2 .8
— 4 9 .8
— 2 7 .0
— 3 5 .0
— 4 0 .6
— 4 4 .0
— 2 6 .4
— 2 1 .6
— 3 8 .6
— 2 8 .7
— 3 9 .2
— 18.1
— 2 8 .9
— 3 3 .6
— 3 6 .4
— 2 6 .5
— 3 2.3
— 33.1
— 3 1 .8
— 4 9 .4
— 4 8 .6
— 2 5 .4
— 4 5 .4
— 36 .2
— 3 4 .5

April,
% change
1932
from 1931
228,080
— 3 8 .7
12,640
— 8 7 .7
574,070
— 6 6 .5
512,850
— 3 5.3
356,429
— 8 8 .2
211,650
— 5 0 .3
7,355
— 6 6 .9
84,512
— 48. .>
— 5 7 .3
79,675
10,230
— 6 4 .2
4,925
— 5 0 .2
14,540
— 81 .3
4,976
— 4 7 .9
221,854
— 8 8 .3
12,000
— 6 3 .6
1,515
— 9 0 .9
— 9 9 .7
2,396
9,590
— 2 0.1
62,056
— 6 9 .7
5,480
— 8 8 .5
— 2 1 .9
44,774
28,900
— 8 3 .4
2,556,057
— 7 5 .0

Jan-April,
1932
448,701
19,165
5,464,640
5,849,625
1,258,182
479,950
43,797
249,829
251,377
38,495
19,970
113.170
33,309
1,035,620
33,000
10,415
35,969
21,370
159.482
15^920
104,864
51,823
15,819,433

J an^-Aj^ril,
740,473
292,291
6,250,365
5,527,100
5,580,487
1,761,750
112,700
546,525
669,472
91,673
35,364
389,575
35,223
4,241,488
148,000
45,210
942,457
43,350
1,039,295
106,940
255,746
560,257
29,453,741

% change
from 1931
— 3 9 .4
— 9 3 .4
— 1 2 .6
+ 5 .8
— 7 7 .5
— 7 2 .8
— 6 1 .1
— 5 4 .3
— 6 2 .5
— 5 8 .0
— 4 3 .5
— 7 1 .0
— 5 .4
— 7 5 .6
— 7 7 .7
— 7 7 .0
— 9 6 .2
— 5 0 .7
—

84.7

—
—
—
—

85 .1
5 9 .0
9 0 .8
4 6 .3

Fourth District Business Indexes
(1923-1925 = 100)

Bank Debits (24 cities).............................................
Commercial Failures (N u m ber)..........................
“
“
# (Liabilities).......................
Postal Receipts (9 cities)........................................
Sales— Life Insurance (Ohio and Pa.)..............
“ — Department Stores (55 firms)................
“ — Wholesale Drugs (13 firms)...................
“ —
“
Dry Goods (10 f i r m s ) ....
“ —
“
Groceries (37 firms)............
“ —
“
Hardware (14 firms)..........
“ —
“
All (7 4 )......................................
“ — Chain Drugs (3 firm s)**.........................
Building Contracts ( T o t a l ) . .. ............................
“
“
(Residential).......................
Production— Coal ( 0 ., W . Pa., E. K y .) ............
— Cement (O., W . Pa., W . V a .) . . .
“
— Elec. Power (O., Pa., K y . ) * . . . .
“
— Petroleum (O., Pa., K y .) * ............
“
— Shoes......................................................
♦March.
**Per individual unit operated.

April, April, April, April, April*
1932 1931 1930 1929 1928
64
100
122
139
124
145
114
93
108
86
182
105
58
58
160
98
115
129
123
119
93
155
129
145
127
68
97
89
90
75
81
106
109
99
112
34
59
78
88
78
58
90
76
90
85
51
73
85
103
89
89
95
87
55
75
74
87
86
82
88
23
77
98
108
147
11
56
74
110
142
49
65
85
86
74
90
69
121
117
110
147
143
129
144
135
105
129
112
109
109
64
74
68
91
73

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

Summary of National Business Conditions
By the Federal Reserve Board
Industrial activity and factory employment declined substantially
March to April, although usually little change occurs at this season.
chases of Government securities by the Federal Reserve banks have
tinued during April and the first three weeks of May and there has
a considerable growth in the reserve of member banks.

from
Pur­
con­
been

Production and Employment

Index of industrial production, adjusted for sea­
sonal variation. (1923-1925 average = 10$)
Latest figure, April, 64.

Indexes based on three-month moving: averages
of F. W. Dodge data for 37 eastern states, ad­
justed for seasonal variation (1923-1925 aver­
age = 100) Latest figure, April, Total, 26,
Residential, 14.

Volume of industrial production, as measured by the Board’s season­
ally adjusted index, decreased from 67 per cent of the 1923-1925 average
in March to 64 per cent in April. Reductions in activity were reported for
many leading industries, with sharp declines at cotton and woolen mills
and at bituminous coal mines; in the automobile industry output increased
from the low level of March by more than the usual seasonal percentage and
in the steel industry, where activity had declined from early February to
the middle of April, production increased somewhat between the middle of
April and the third week of May.
The number of wage earners employed at manufacturing establish­
ments declined further between the middle of March and the middle of April
and there was a substantial reduction in factory payrolls. Large decreases
in employment were reported for the iron and steel, machinery and textile
industries, while the volume of employment in the food and leather indus­
tries showed the usual seasonal changes.
Daily average value of building contracts awarded during April
and the first half of May, as reported by the F. W. Dodge Corporation, showed
a seasonal increase over the first quarter. A substantial increase was re­
ported for public works and public utilities, while residential building con­
tinued at the low level of the first quarter, showing none of the usual sea­
sonal expansion.
Distribution
Freight-car loadings of merchandise showed little change in volume
from March to April, continuing at the level prevailing since January, al­
though increases are usual during this period. Sales by department stores
increased considerably in April.
Wholesale Prices
Wholesale prices of commodities declined from 66 per cent of the 1926
average in March to 6 5.5 per cent in April, according to the Bureau of Labor
Statistics, and in the first three weeks of May further decreases in the prices
of many leading commodities were reported. Downward movements in tex­
tiles, nonferrous metals and imported raw materials, as well as in most do­
mestic agricultural products except wheat, were offset in part by increases
in the prices of coffee, petroleum and petroleum products.
Bank Credit

Monthly averages o f weekly figures for report­
ing member banks in leading cities.
Latest
figures are averages of first three weeks in May.

MIUIONS or DOLLARS
2500

REIS E R V E B A N K CR E D IIT

_

2000

K

Total

V A
ky

k

1500

\

Discounts

Y

J

I

J

V

f l

w

U.S. Sea

500
W
—

/
y

0
1927

'

1928

1929

I AcceptancM j ”
1930
1931

Monthly averages of daily figures for 12 Fed­
eral Reserve banks. Latest figures are aver­
ages of first 23 days in May.




Further purchases of United States Government securities by the Fed­
eral reserve banks were made during April and the first three weeks in May,
and on May 18 total holdings were $1,466,000,000. The funds placed in
the market through these purchases between April 6 and May 18 were used
to the extent of $170,000,000 in a further reduction of member bank in­
debtedness to the reserve banks; and to the extent of $122,000,000 in meet­
ing a demand for gold from abroad; at the same time member banks ac­
cumulated reserve balances considerably in excess of legal requirements.
During May the demand for currency, which had declined in April, increased
somewhat, contrary to usual seasonal movement.
Loans and investments of reporting member banks in leading cities,
which had declined continuously until the middle of April, showed little net
change between April 13 and May 18. The banks’ investments increased
by nearly $300,000,000, chiefly in New York City; while loans declined by
about an equal amount. There was also a growth in net demand deposits,
which reflected in part an increase in bankers’ balances deposited in New
York City banks.
Money rates in the open market continued easy. Rates on commercial
paper were reduced about one half per cent to a range of 2 %-3 per cent
for prime names, and the offering rate on 90-day bankers’ acceptances, which
had advanced to 1V8 per cent in the first week of May, declined on May 11
to the previously prevailing rate of % of one per cent.