View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
Covering financial, industrial, and agricultural conditions
in the
Fourth Federal Reserve District
Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland
Cleveland, Ohio, July 1, 1930

Vol. 12

Trade and industrial activity in the Fourth District de­
clined slightly in May and the early part of June. This
recession reflects in part a slackening that is customary
in a number of industries during the summer months,
although it has occurred somewhat earlier than in some
recent years. There have been further marked declines
in commodity prices.
The iron and steel industry has followed an irregular
course. Pipe mills at Youngstown and Pittsburgh are
producing at good rates, several being booked fo r the
rest of the year.
Other mills, particularly those at
Cleveland, have been curtailing operations chiefly because
of the slightly greater than seasonal drop in automobile
orders. Cleveland mills are only producing at 50 per
cent of capacity.
Employment and payrolls declined in May more than
the usual seasonal amount. May bank debits, however,
were off only six per cent in contrast with the ten per
cent shown in the first five months o f this year. Savings
deposits increased from April, but were still 1.7 per
cent smaller than last year.
Postal receipts and life
insurance sales were both smaller than one year ago.
Electric power production was lower than the same
month last year for the first time in over two years.
Building activity increased from April to May and also
showed a very favorable improvement in June, but the
total so far this year is still the lowest since 1924.
Coal production increased slightly, chiefly because o f the
larger loadings at Lake ports which established an alltime record in May.
Iron ore receipts have been 50
per cent smaller than last year, although they exceeded
the same period o f 1928.
Smaller payrolls and declining commodity prices con­
tinued to affect retail, and in turn, wholesale buying, but
some improvement has been reported. Department store
sales in May were three per cent smaller than one year
ago, the drop being about half as great as the six per cent
decline shown for the first five months. Crop conditions
in the District have suffered somewhat from unfavorable
weather.
FIN AN CIAL
In recent weeks the few changes in condition o f re­
porting member banks and this Reserve bank reflected
the further easing of credit conditions.
Rates charged
by commercial banks in this District declined slightly



No. 7

and the rediscount rate o f the Federal Reserve Bank of
Cleveland was reduced from four to three and one-half
per cent on June 7. This was as low a rate as has
ever been established by this bank and was the lowest
since early 1928. Boston and Chicago were discounting
at the same rate, but the New York rate was reduced
on June 20 from three to 2% per cent, the lowest ever
shown by any Reserve bank. Acceptance rates (90-day
asked) were reduced to 17s per cent on June 24, the lowest
quotation on record, and call money has renewed at 2 ^
per cent or lower since the 13th o f June.
Member Bank Credit. Total credit extended by Fourth
District reporting member banks increased $34,000,000
in the four weeks ended June 18 and was $39,000,000
larger than one year ago.
This was more than ac­
counted fo r by an increase in investments o f $38,000,000
in the past month. Amounting to $693,000,000 on June
18, they were $30,000,000 higher than at this time last
year.
With little commercial demand developing, col­
lateral loans showing little change and deposits increas­
ing, banks have turned to investments as a means of
keeping funds employed. Loans secured by stocks and
bonds were at comparatively the same level as a month
ago. “ All other” loans continued to sag and were $37,000,000 below last year and at the same level as this
time in 1928. No seasonal expansion has occurred in
these commercial loans as yet this year, neither has the
decrease since the first of the year been so sharp as
in some other Reserve districts.
Demand deposits reached a new high record on June 11,
declined slightly the follow ing week, but increased $28,000,000 from May. Amounting to $1,098,000 on June 18,
they were $96,000,000 higher than in 1929 at this time.
Reserve Bank Credit. Increased holdings o f govern­
ment securities more than offset the declines shown in
acceptances, and with bills discounted fo r member banks
at substantially the low level o f last month, credit ex ­
tended by this bank was only $85,000,000, about the same
as in May. The drop in acceptance holdings has been
seasonal, but total bills and securities o f this bank for
more than a month have been lower than at any time
since 1924.
Reflecting the increase in deposits at member banks,
reserve deposits since the first of the year have increased
quite rapidly and on June 18 were the highest in over
two years. Federal reserve note circulation of this bank

2

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

has increased slightly since January in
the declines shown in the entire system.

contrast with

BANKING OPERATIONS
Federal Reserve Banks
Federal Reserve Bank o f Cleveland
Federal R eserve System
(In M illions)
(In M illions)
June 18, June 19, M ay 21, June 18, June 19, M ay 21,
1930
1929
1930
1930
1929
1930
316
282
314
3,067
2,880
3,076
Gold Reserves ..............
Discounts ........................
20
82
18
207
959
210
A cceptances ..................
10
7
13
133
87
187
U. S. Securities ............
55
28
50
598
139
528
Total bills and securi­
ties ...............................
85
117
81
943
1,199
932
Federal reserve notes
in circulation ............
182
199
179
1,419
1,649
1,453
Total deposits ................
201
188
199
2,465
2,369
2,439

REVISED CORPORATION EARNINGS
(Quarterly net earnings of 162 identical industrials in the United States)
All scales in millions of dollars.

500

162

INDUSTRIAL

CORPORATIONS

375
TOTAL

250
125
GM & USS

Reporting Member Banks
Fourth D istrict
United States
(In M illions)
(In M illions)
Jane 18, June 19, May 21, June 18, June 19, May 21,
1930
1929
1930
1930
1929
1930
Loans on securities .....
742
696
744
8,615
7,382
8,322
A ll other ........................
783
820
786
8,513
9,161
8,484
Total loans .................... 1,525
1,516
1,529
17,128
16,543
16,806
Investm ents ....................
693
663
655
5,989
5,755
5,855
Demand deposits ......... 1,098
1,002
1,070
13,638
12,938
13,382
Tim e deposits ................
969
954
968
7,228
6,727
7,132

CORPORATION

EARNINGS

The accompanying chart presents this bank’s revised
index of quarterly net earnings of industrial corporations
in the United States. The number o f concerns used in
the index has been reduced from 170 to 162 as a result
o f mergers and consolidations which have occurred in the
past year.
In some instances, two or more concerns
whose figures were used in the index merged; in others,
a company included joined with one whose earnings were
not included. In case o f such a consolidation, back quar­
terly earnings for the merging firm not included were
obtained or estimated from the yearly earnings, where
available. Because o f these additions the total earnings
o f the 162 concerns are slightly larger than o f the 170
corporations previously published.
The course o f industrial profits during the past year,
has, in a general way, followed the curve o f industrial
production. This is to be expected, but might not neces­
sarily follow, particularly for the various groups or the
individual concerns in the groups. An industry could be
operating at a relatively high level and yet show only
a small profit or even a loss. Earnings and production
do not always parallel each other. Nevertheless in the
first quarter of 1930 the entire group o f concerns showed
3.7 per cent smaller earnings than in the closing period
o f 1929 and the volume o f production in the first quarter
o f this year taken as a whole was in smaller volume than
in the last quarter o f 1929. The drop in profits was
caused by, among other things, declining prices o f fin­
ished goods and raw materials.
As noticed on the chart, corporation earnings reached
their peak in the second quarter o f 1929 when industrial
activity was also at record levels. A slight decline oc­
curred in the third quarter, again paralleling the produc­
tion curve, and although the drop in the fourth quarter
was greatly accelerated, as was the drop in production,
part of it was seasonal. In spite o f the fact that profits
in the first quarter o f past years have been larger than
in the closing period o f the preceding year, net earnings
of the 162 industrial corporations in the opening period
of 1930 were the smallest fo r any quarter since 1927
and the smallest first quarter since 1925. If the figures
of the two largest companies, General Motors and United



5 CIGAR

25
6

26 '27 *28 *29 *30

8 MACHINE TOOLS

4
2
o

30i

12 MINING

'25 *26 *27 *28 *29 *30

I50|t ---

13 MOTOR

)
nOTA

20

A

rV

j: A

fr\
ff\

10

'p.

-K-\ / \ A >Y
\

f:—

OTHC,

15 MOTOR ACCES.

4 RESTAURANT
J

i

12 STEEL
90

<
J
wyj1
9¥
_

-----TOl AL

30

'u s s
OTH

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
States Steel, are excluded, 1930 first quarter earnings
have only been exceeded by corresponding periods o f 1928
and 1929.
The course o f earnings in the individual groups is quite
interesting and throws a little light on the trend of cor­
poration profits in a period o f business recession. Com­
pared with the first quarter o f 1929, only four groups,
coal, leather (a smaller deficit), restaurant and railroad
equipment, reported larger earnings in the opening period
of this year. Chemical, food and amusement concerns
held up very well, showing only small decreases from
1929. The mining, motor, motor accessory, oil and mis­
cellaneous groups all showed large declines, in some cases
more than 50 per cent.
The fourth quarter is usually the period o f smallest
earnings, although this year only two groups, motor and
railroad equipment elicited an improvement in the first
quarter of this year. The largest drop fo r the period
was shown by the chemical group, but this is largely
seasonal. Steel companies reported a decline of 6.5 per
cent from the closing period o f 1929, all o f which was
accounted for by the drop in earnings o f the United
States Steel Corporation; all other steel companies showed
little change.

Corporation Earnings
(162 identical industrials)
(In T h ou san d s o f D ollars)
1930
1929
1929
1928
1st
4th
1st
1st
Q uar.
Q uar.
Q uar. Q uar.
5
7
5
5
5
14
8
12
13
15
17
12
4
40
162
160

Building & Supplv
C h em ica ls............ '
Cigars.
...
.
C oa l. '
....
E q u ip m en t— R .R .
F o o d s .......................
M ach in ery, T ools.
M in in g .....................
M o t o r ......................
M o to r A c c e s s o r y ..
O i l .. .
..............
S teel..........................
R estau rant.............
M iscella n eou s. .
T o t a l ........................
T o t a l.........................

1,713
14,910
1,416
1,763
6,442
28,325
2,139
11,976
54,329
4,519
7,085
57,204
1,750
40,962
234,533
203,747

3,339
21,876
3,260
2,281
6,334
3 0 ,7 0 9
2,431
13,367
38,954
4,622
10,672
61,154
2,128
42,509
243,636
208,933

2,100
2,901
15,638 11,902
2,037
1,709
1,130
1,980
5 ,290
3,953
29,372 26,593
2,807
2,177
19,091 8,692
97,807 97 ,5 6 0
10,964
5,704
16,475 6,804
68,166 33,420
1,305
1,224
54,387 49,474
326,569 254,093
264,692 213,914

1927
1st
Q uar.
3,283
11,112
2,100
1,375
3,983
24,945
1,961
7,308
75.832
5,662
16,530
41,591
1,598
38,142
235,422
196,877

1926
1st
Q uar.
3,681
10,011
1,461
2,00S
4,735
23,522
2,667
7,778
69,577
7,842
21,947
43,113
1,344
39,338
239,024
193,045

(Less H. M. & l.T. S. S.)

COMMODITY PRICES
The general course of wholesale prices continued down­
ward in May and early June and was one o f the most
disconcerting factors in the entire business situation.
The Bureau o f Labor’s index on a 1926 base, standing
at 89 in May was 13 per cent below the same month
last year and the lowest for any month since 1916.

COMMODITY
H

PRICES

’

• : *"
** i

5 *■

A /^

v
—

AL.L COMI dODlTtE! >
kRM PRC)DUCTS

1924
B«rfaa

of

V

1925

1926

1927

1928

1929

1930

Labor Statistics Index. Latest figures, May
prices, 93.0. All commodities, 89.1.




1931
Agricultural

3

Wholesale prices have followed a downward course since
1925 with only a slight temporary reversal in the last
part o f 1927 and the first nine months o f 1928. Although
prices tended only moderately downward in late 1928
and early 1929, beginning with August, 1929, the drop
became quite abrupt, partly because o f overproduction
and partly in sympathy with the fall in security prices
and the lessened consumer demand which followed. This
was caused by, among other things, the decrease in em­
ployment and payrolls and the low level o f general
business.
The declines shown in the past nine months have been
world-wide in scope, being more pronounced in some of
the foreign countries than in the United States and have
not been confined to any particular classes o f goods.
Kaw materials, including grains, cotton, wool, silk, sugar,
copper, silver, coffee and rubber have fallen to the lowest
levels in years, in some cases to the lowest point on
record, but prices of iron and steel products, glass, leather
and many other manufactured goods have also declined.
Retail prices have also fallen slightly, particularly
since the first of the year, but the reduction has not been
in proportion to the drop in wholesale prices.
M ANUFACTURING, MINING
Iron and
Steel

Demand fo r iron and steel in the
P'ourth District declined sharply in
the month ended June 20. Except for
line pipe and tin plate, consumers’ requirements con­
tracted markedly and as a result, production in late June
was off more than seasonally and was approximating the
low point of last December. The summer lull which did
not occur to any extent last year seems to be at hand.
Automotive specifications were curtailed early in June,
due to both a slower retail market and to an overspecifi­
cation o f material in May. Many important automobile
interests planned their June shipments with the inten­
tion of showing a minimum inventory on July 1, just
prior to the usual shut-downs preparatory to model
changes.
Bar, sheet, strip and, to a lesser extent, wire mills
reduced their operations accordingly.
Structural steel
awards continued in only moderate volume, with no out­
standing inquiry. Tin plate shipments in May and early
June equaled the rate of last year, but were made at the
expense o f backlogs.
The one bright spot in the entire industry was caused
by the large orders for pipe to be used in the construc­
tion of pipe lines fo r the transmission of natural gas,
petroleum and gasoline. Awards in early June attained
record proportion and by the middle of the month the
more important makers in the Pittsburgh district were
booked well into the fall, with several interests com ­
mitted fo r the remainder o f the year. As a result, plate
and skelp mills entered the summer with better prospects
than other departments of the industry.
Pig iron, like finished steel, felt keenly the retrench­
ment in the automotive industry and shipments of Pitts­
burgh, Youngstown and Lake furnaces declined materially
in June. Late in the month, however, inquiry for third
quarter iron developed in moderate volume.
In common with commodity prices generally, most fin­
ished steel quotations declined considerably in early June.
Semi-finished steel fell $2 in the month and was quoted

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

4

at $31 a ton at all centers. Producers were quoting at
unchanged prices for the third quarter, but there was an
evident reluctance to commit too fa r into the period.
The Iron Trade Review composite o f 14 leading iron and
steel products declined to $33.52 in mid-June. This com­
pared with an average o f $33.73 fo r May, $36.96 in June,
1929, and was the lowest since 1916 with the exception o f
three months in early 1922. Although the decline has
been less precipitate in the past week or so, no improve­
ment has yet been shown.
Steel ingot production in May continued the decline
which started in March. The daily rate o f output fo r the
month was 149,066 gross tons, against 159,764 tons in
April, 195,790 tons in May, 1929, and 155,700 tons in May,
1928. Total production in the first five months o f this
year amounted to 20,352,960 tons, compared with 24,133,741 tons in the corresponding period o f 1929 and 21,050,000 tons in 1928. Steelmaking operations averaged 78.2
per cent of capacity in the five months ended with May;
one year ago they were 94.6 per cent. By mid-June the
rate fo r the entire industry had declined to 68 per cent
o f capacity. Two years ago it was operating at 73 per
cent. Cleveland mills were only producing at 50 per cent
o f capacity with Youngstown and Pittsburgh at 60 and
70 per cent respectively.
Pig iron production showed an increase in the daily
rate from January to April, inclusive, but reversed itself
seasonally in May. The daily output was 104,509 gross
tons, compared with 106,371 tons in April and 123,753
tons last May. Production in the first five months was
15,368,401 tons, compared with 17,922,433 tons in the
same period o f 1929 and 15,428,123 tons in 1928.
A slight increase in bituminous coal
production occurred in the Fourth Dis­
trict in May mostly because of the ex­
pansion in shipments from Lake Erie ports which totaled
6,102,000 tons in the month. This was the largest ton­
nage ever loaded in a single period and reduced the
discrepancy shown in April, loadings to June 1 being
only 36,000 tons behind the same period o f 1929 which
was a year of record lake shipments.
Coal output fo r the month totaled 15,604,000 tons, com­
pared with 16,850,000 tons in May, 1929, a decline of
seven per cent. The increase from April was less than
seasonal and production so fa r this year has been 5.5
per cent below one year ago. Production in the entire
country was estimated at 35,884,000 tons in May, a drop
o f about 5,000,000 tons from last year.
The reason fo r the decline of course has been the drop
In industrial activity and railroad operations. A few com­
panies reported a slight increase in sales in the first
part of June, however. Buying fo r stock piles in prepara­
tion for fall and winter demand has not been very gen­
eral, notwithstanding the low level to which stocks above
ground have fallen. Collections are poor, unpaid accounts,
according to the Bureau of Coal Statistics, being about
five per cent larger than last year despite the smaller
sales. Prices have declined slightly.

in May, 1928. The decline from April, 5.8 per cent, was
larger than the 2.8 per cent shown last year at that
time and was contrary to the trend of production in the
past several years. On the average there is relatively
little change shown in output in these two months. A c ­
cording to the Department o f Commerce figures, production
in the first five months amounted to 1,883,616 units,
which still exceeded output in the same period o f 1928
by a good margin, but was 30 per cent below last year.
There was a decided slump in truck production, the
May output being only 54,370 units as against 67,560
in April and 88,510 in May, 1929. Manufacturers report
the trend downward, part of which is seasonal.
The decline shown from April to May continued into
June only at a more rapid pace. In past years the sea­
sonal contraction from May to June has been about 14
per cent, but it is too early to state whether the general
curtailment in preparation for the new mid-summer model
introduction has been greater or less than usual.
This falling-off has affected parts and accessory, steel
and rubber plants in this District with a consequent
reduction in employment.
The reason fo r the drop in automobile production is
found in the new passenger car registration figures which
are much below last year. In the ten principal counties
o f this District, May registrations were 24 per cent less
than one year ago. This smaller decline as com pared
with other months o f this year, due chiefly to sales at
Pittsburgh, reduced the five-month discrepancy to 27
per cent.

New Passenger Car Registrations
T e n Principal Counties

Coal

Automobiles

May production o f automobiles in the
United States totaled 417,154 cars (in­
cluding trucks and taxicabs) compared
with 442,835 in April, 604,691 in May, 1929, and 425,783



U%
c"an8e
A k ro n (S u m m it)................
C a n ton (S t a r k )...................
C incinn ati (H a m ilt o n )...
C leve lan d (C u y a h o g a ). . .
C o lu m b u s (F r a n k lin )-----D a y to n (M o n tg o m e r y ). .
P ittsbu rg h , Pa. (A llg h y .j
T o le d o ( L u c a s )...................
Y o u n g s to w n (M a h o n in g)
W h « lin g , W . Va. (Ohio).
T o t a l ..................................

1930
1,287
797
1,885
4,863
1,235
763
5,003
996
727
240
17,796

1920
2,349
1,294
2,557
6,097
1,883
1,229
4,683
1,891
1,125
’ 3 10
23,418

%
chanee

^ *rom J an-“ M a y J a n .-M a y fr o m
1929
1930
1929
192 9
— 4 5 .2
4,764 8 243 ____ 42 7
— 3 8 .4
3,003
4,917 — 38 9
— 2 6 .3
7.684
9 915
—
c
— 2 0 .2
18,616
25 082 — 25 it
— 3 4 .4
5,052
7 675 — 3 4 * 5
— 3 7 .9
3 679 5*517 ____
+ 6 .8
16',480
17 557
— *1
— 4 7 .3
3 882 7*547 ____
— 3 5 .4
2 632
4 ’ 286
- 22. 6
8S6
to ll
-1 9 9
— 2 4 .0
66,648 91,807 ____ 2 7 . 4

Rubber,
Tires

Output of tires in the Akron district,
which annually produces more than 60
per cent o f all tires manufactured in the
country, in May was about 25 per cent below the peak
reached last year in June. Employment increased one
per cent from April, but was 22 per cent below one year
ago when the rubber industry was operating at record
levels.
Imports o f crude rubber to the United States in May
totaled 40,745 tons as against 49,927 tons in April and
49,180 tons in May, 1929. So fa r this year imports have
totaled 227,192 tons, compared with 274,018 tons in the
first five months o f 1929. Consumption o f crude rubber
in May was estimated to be 39,902 tons, still slightly
under the import figures. This fa ct that imports have
exceeded consumption fo r some time past has been the
chief reason for the decline in crude rubber prices, which
in early June fell below 12 cents a pound, the low est
point on record, compared with 22 cents last year and

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
about 40 cents in 1927. The extent of the success of the
tapping cessation in an endeavor to reduce stocks and
bring production closer to consumption has not definitely
been ascertained, but shipments in early June continued
near the 9,000-ton-per-week level.
Preliminary production o f tires in the United States in
May was estimated at 4,580,000 casings (including solids),
an increase from April, but 25 per cent below May, 1929.
Other
Manufacturing

6

Paint. Second quarter paint sales, in general, increased
seasonally from the first quarter o f this year. Companies
which depend on the automobile and furniture industry
fo r the bulk o f their orders state that sales have declined.
Prices o f raw materials entering into paint and varnish
manufacture, except linseed oil which increased about
35 per cent, have fallen. The reduced volume as com­
pared with last year has increased manufacturing and
selling costs so that no general price reduction has oc­
curred.

Few changes of any consequence have
occurred in the last month, the only de­
Paper. The general trend of the paper business since
velopment being of a seasonal nature.
the first o f June has been downward and second quarter
Continued unsettled prices have had a generally deter­
business has been materially below the first quarter and
ring effect on orders.
Industrial employment declined
the corresponding period o f 1929.
about one per cent in May and was 14 per cent below
Shoes. Footwear manufacturers, located for the most
May, 1929. In past years little change has been shown
part near Cincinnati, curtailed operations again in May,
in the employment figures from April to May.
despite the fa ct that April production was at an unusually
Brick and Ceramics.
Demand fo r clay products in­
low level. Output of 26 factories in May was 38 per cent
creased seasonally in the second quarter of this year,
below May, 1929, and production in the first five months
although operations are still considerably below 1929.
o f this year was 22 per cent under the like period o f last
China and pottery plants reported a greater than sea­
year, according to the census figures. Salesmen report con­
sonal drop in employment.
siderable opposition to fall buying, most dealers prefer­
Clothing. The clothing and textile industry has been
ring to wait until later in the season. Sales o f wholesale
confronted by several adverse factors so fa r this year—
shoe firms in May were 19 per cent below the correspond­
labor troubles, declining prices o f raw materials and a
ing month o f 1929.
reluctance on the part of merchandising concerns to com­
Stoves and Equipment. Second quarter business has not
mit themselves because of the decline in retail sales and
shown the seasonal increase experienced in other years.
the uncertainty of the general situation.
This is the
Employment decreased in May more than usual.
period of low activity fo r the industry as a whole, the
spring season having closed and the fall season not yet
having started.
BUILDING
Prices o f wool, silk and cotton reached the lowest
Construction activity in the Fourth District, as re­
levels in years and while declining were a retarding factor
on sales. Finished goods are available at lower prices
flected in figures o f the F. W. Dodge Corporation, failed
than for some time, much of the raw material price de­
to maintain its seasonal level in May and amounting to
cline having been passed on to the consumer. Advance
$51,214,000 was 21 per cent below the level o f May, 1929.
orders for fall delivery have been very conservative, de­
Building in the first five months o f this year was ten
spite the fact that stocks in most cases are low.
per cent under the same period last year.
Electrical Equipment. Sales have been retarded by the
Local residential construction showed a very slight im­
decline in copper, which reached 11% cents a pound
provement in May, the decline from last year being only
in mid-June. So far this month there has been a down­
nine per cent, compared with the 31 per cent decrease in
ward tendency reported in factory operations. Em ploy­
the first five months. Total building, including industrial,
ment in May was down one per cent in contrast with a
commercial and public works and utility construction, in­
normal increase o f about four per cent from April to
creased from April, but was 21 per cent below May, 1929,
May.
chiefly because awards last May were unusually large.
Glass. Glass companies reported second quarter opera­
So far this season total building has been lower than in
tions about on a par with those o f the opening period
any year since 1924.
o f this year, but the demand in general continues sub­
Figures fo r the first half o f June on a daily average
normal with no prospects o f immediate improvement.
basis show an improvement over both May, 1930, and
Operations in the Pittsburgh district are from 35 to 40
last June.
per cent below last year. Employment in Ohio concerns
Dealers in building materials report little change in de­
showed the usual seasonal increase o f one per cent. Prices
mand except o f a seasonable nature, in fa ct some report
o f raw materials entering into the manufacture o f glass
that second quarter sales were below those of the initial
and glass products have dropped slightly, but finished
quarter o f this year. Prices of lumber are down about
goods have been at relatively lower levels fo r some time
five per cent from last year's level which was also low.
because o f lessened demand and increased competition.
Machinery, Supplies. Demand for agricultural imple­
ments has slowed down, sales during the second quarter
TRA D E
being smaller than in the first quarter of this year.
Sales o f reporting department stores in May increased
General machinery sales since the first of June have
seasonally
and showed a smaller decline, three per cent,
slackened. Automobile parts concerns have reduced oper­
as compared with the corresponding period of one year
ations after only a very temporary improvement shown a
ago, than was reported fo r the first five months o f this
month ago. Hardware and tool demand has been irregu­
year when sales were 5.6 per cent smaller than in 1929.
lar. May employment was less than April.



THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

6

May sales o f 55 identical stores were the smallest for that
month since 1927, however. Stocks continue to fall, part
o f which was accounted fo r by the decline in commodity
prices. Accounts receivable were larger in May than one
year ago, but collections have also improved and the ratio
o f collections to accounts outstanding increased slightly.
Retail furniture sales have been very bad, one city
showing a decline of 40 per cent in the first five months
o f this year, while sales o f all reporting stores were 24
per cent below 1929.
Wholesale trade in general continues in reduced volume,
May sales being the smallest for that month in the past
seven years.
AGRICULTURE
Unseasonably dry weather prevailed in most sections
o f the District during May and early June. This was
decidedly unfavorable to all growing crops and as a
result, the June 1 condition was below average for this
time o f the year in most cases. Rains in the second week
o f the month have been very beneficial and should go fa r
to correct the unfavorable existing condition, however.

Winter Wheat

O h io ............
Pennsylvania.
K e n t u c k y ----W . V irginia . .
U . S.................

C on dition June 1
(P er Cent)
10-year
average
19191929
19J0
1928
76
90
64
86
91
83
78
87
80
81
91
78
7 7 .2
79.6
7 1 .7

P rodu ction (th ous. o f
, .
H arvested, su bject
to revision
1929
33,696
20,016
2,832
1,782
578,336

Av erage
1924-1928
27,219
20,375
2,773
1,826
550,636

bushels)
j 930
forecast
from c o n ­
dition
J un
1
24,302
20,088
3,062
1,833
532,469

The condition of winter wheat declined several points
in this District in May with a corresponding drop in the
estimated production, based on the June 1 condition figure.
The above table shows the June 1 condition of the crop,
together with the estimated production in 1929, the fiveyear average production, 1924-1928, and the probable
wheat crop for 1930 for states wholly or partly within
this District and for the entire country. So fa r winter
wheat has had a much less favorable season than one
year ago. The stand is quite irregular throughout this
territory and is heading short in the straw. It has been
altogether too dry fo r wheat this spring. In all states
except Kentucky the June 1 condition is below the tenyear average figure and estimated output is below last
year's harvest.
Stocks o f wheat carried over from last season are larger
than usual because o f the greater than average produc­
tion in 1929 and the falling-off in exports. Although these
two factors have had considerable effect on the recent
course of wheat prices, attention is now being given to
the present crop variations. Wheat declined in June to
below 90 cents a bushel, a lower figure than was reached
in any year since 1914.
Oat prospects in general are quite poor, being better in
the northern part of the District than elsewhere. Con­
dition in Ohio and Kentucky was considerably below aver­
age. Most of the planting had been completed by the first
o f June and came up well, but was growing slowly be­
cause o f the dry weather. Other grains have also suf­
fered from lack of moisture and were slightly below aver­
age condition.
The season so far has been very unfavorable fo r hay



and pasture growth. In Kentucky the condition is on ly
60 per cent of normal with only slightly better conditions
reported in Ohio and Pennsylvania. Clover has headed
rather short and fields in general are quite weedy. Un­
less a marked improvement is shown as a result o f the
recent rains, the yield o f hay and clover will be much
below average.
The condition o f most fruits, which was already low,
declined still further in May because of damaging frosts!
Production o f peaches in Ohio appeared to be about onetenth o f a fu ll crop. Last year's harvest was likewise
small, being only one-third o f average. The Pennsyl­
vania crop is stated to be about half as large as the
average crop of 1924-28.
About one-half a normal crop of apples is expected in
Pennsylvania and a one-fourth crop in Ohio. Prospects
are somewhat better in the northern localities. Pear crop
prospects are also very poor.
The United States Department o f Agriculture's index
o f farm prices declined three points in May after a rise
o f one point in April. In May, standing at 124 per cent
of the pre-war average 1909-14, it compared with 136
last year and was the lowest fo r any month since 1922.
All groups o f prices, except fruits and vegetables which
have remained at high levels because o f the relative
scarcity, were lower in May than in April and consider­
ably below last year. Further declines occurred in June,
prices of several commodities falling to pre-war levels.
The 1930 tobacco crop has nearly all
been transplanted to the open fields
and although acreage figures are not
yet available, it is estimated that the full intended acre­
age (15 per cent larger than that harvested last year)
has been set. The work, though somewhat later than in
1929, has been completed in ample time.
Tobacco

One fa ct that is very apparent this year is the great
variation in the condition o f the plants. Many fields suf­
fered from the dry weather, while others, those
which
were set earlier, seem to be in splendid condition, having
taken hold before the dry weather began.
The recent
warm weather and rains have been of great benefit to the
crop in general.
Fields are comparatively free from
weeds fo r this time of year, having been cultivated once
or even twice in some cases.
Some trading continues in the old stock, gradually re ­
ducing the limited quantities that are available.
Canning

Early canning crops in this D istrict
suffered severely from the dry weather,
and although the recent rains have co r ­
rected this condition in some instances, the pea crop w as
beyond saving. As a result, despite an acreage increase
of about 20 per cent, the local pack is estimated to be
about 40 per cent below last year. Other sections of the
country have fared much better so that on the whole the
supply is expected to be about the same as in 1929.
The corn crop started poorly and is in much below
normal condition. There has been some shortage in the
supply o f tomato plants and the setting has been late.
Stocks o f all canned goods are not large, but future orders
have not been very heavy.

7

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

Fourth District Business Indexes

Fourth District Business Statistics
(000 om itte d )
Jan .Fourth District Unless
M ay
% change M a y % ch an ge
Otherwise Specified
1930 from 1929
1930 fro m 1929
Bank D ebits— 24 c itie s ..................... » 3,245,000 — 5 . 6 15,910,000 — 1 0 .4
Saving D eposits— end o f m onth:
O hio— 36 b a n k s .............................. $
769,953 — 1 .7
768,8121 — 2 .2
W estern Pa.— 25 b a n k s ................ $
278,843 — 1 .4
275,4 6 1 1 — 0 .5
T o ta l— 61 b a n k s .............................. $
1,048,796 — 1 .7 1,044,2731 — 1 .8
P ostal R eceipts— 9 cities.................. $
3,083
— 4 .1
16,054
4- 1 .4
Life Insurance Sales:
O h i o a n d P a ...................................... $
118,080 — 3 .0
631,057
+ 6 .1
R etail Sales:
D epartm en t stores— 57 firm s. .
26,307 — 3 .4
115,664 — 5 . 6
W earing A pparel stores—
16 firm s..........................................*
1,729
+ 0 .6
7,630 — 6 .0
977 — 2 8 .3
4,178 — 2 3 .9
Furniture— 48 firm s...................... $
W holesale Sales:
D ry G ood s— 11 firm s................... $
1,748 — 1 0 .9
8,341
— 1 2 .8
D rugs— 13 firm s .............................. 1,617 — 8 .0
8,250 — 9 .1
G rocery — 41 firm s.......................... $
6,003 — 4 .7
21,918 — 2 5 .2
H ardw are— 17 F irm s..................... $
2,100 — 4 .3
9,157 — 12.3
Building Perm its— 27 c itie s ............ #
16,042 — 2 3 .0
70,280 — 1 7 .5
B u ilding C on tracts— R esidential.
13,998 — 1 8 .9
51,167 — 3 1 .2
**
“
T o ta l, all classes #
51,214 — 2 0 .9
228,997 — 1 0 .0
C om m ercial Failures— N u m b e r ...
189
+ 2 7 .7
859 — 0 .3
“
“
— L ia b ilities. . $
3,023 — 6 .3
19,983
+ 1 4 .6
P rod u ction :
P ig Iron U. S................................... T o n s
3,233
— 17.1
15,327 — 14.5
Steel Ingots, U. S............................ T o n s
4,025 — 2 3 .7
20,353 — 1 5 .6
A u tom obiles— Pass. Cars, U. S.
362,2702 — 2 9 .6
1,605,3062 — 3 0 .6
— 'T rucks, U. S.............
54.3702 — 3 8 .6
274,2482 — 2 3.5
B itum inous C o a l.............................T o n s
15,604 — 7 .4
79,348 — 5 .5
C em ent— 0 . ,W n . Pa., W . V a . . .B b ls.
2,011
+ 2 6 .1
6,163
+ 1 1 .0
E lectric Pow er— O ., Pa., K y . . . k . w . hrs.
1,179s — 1 .3
5,0284 + 2 .3
P etroleum — O ., Pa., K y ...............Bbls.
2,565s + 2 3 . 2
9 ,5884 + 2 1 . 8
S h oes .................................................... Pairs
8
— 3 7 .8
8
— 2 2 .2
Tires, U. S . . . . .................................Casings
4,580® — 2 5 .5
20,286 — 27 .5
B itum inous Coal Shipm ents—
Lake Erie P o r t s ..............................T o n s
6,102
+ 1 6 .4
8,040 — 0 .4
Iron Ore R eceip ts—
Lake Erie P o r t s .............................. T o n s
3,987 — 4 1 .0
3,997 — 4 9 .7
1 M o n th ly average
* A ctual num ber
* April

4 J an u ary-A p ril
5 C on fiden tial
6 P relim inary

(1930 com pared with 1929)




P ercentage
Increase
or
D ecrease
SA LE S
STOCKS
SA LE S
First
M ay—
M ay—
M ay
5 mos.
M ay
— 2 9 .2
— 1 4 .8
—12.1
— 5 .7
— 2 .3
—
2.0
— 5 .9
— 2 .4
— 7 .1
— 0 .7
—
8.8
+ 6.0
— 12 4
— 6 .3
—
0.1
— 5.2
— 3 .6
— 0 .9
+ 0.6
— 1 2 .9
— 7 .2
— 9 ,3
—
8.2
+ 0 .3
— 5 .7
— 1 0 .5
— 5 .8
— 6 5
— 5 .6
— 3 .4

+ 6.2

— 4 .5

+

2.7

0. 2
+ 0.6

— 4 .8

6. 0

— 8 .3
+ 4.1
— 1.3

—21 .9

— 2 1 .4
— 1 7 .3
— 2 1 :2
— 1 8 .4
— 4 0 .7
— 2 8.1
— 2 3 .9

............
............
............
............
............
............
.............

— 3 .2
—

—
—
—
—

2 2 .4
2 3 .5
1 8 .7
4 9 .6

—31.0
— 2 8 .2

+ 2.6
+

1 .7

—

—

6.2

— 7 .4
— 3 .9
— 3 .2
— 5 .4
+ 0 .4
— 4 .7
— 1 0 .9

— 8.0
— 4 .3
— 1 8 .7

8.8

+ 2.0

.......

— 0 .7

.............

1 4 .7
1-1
4 .3
4 .0
3 .7
2 .3
4 .5
1 .3

.............
.............
.............
.............
.............
.............
.............
— 2 .3

— 9 .1
— 1 2 .3
— 2 4 .5

.............
— 6 .5
— 2 5 .2

— 1 6 .7
+
—
—
—
—
+
—

Bank D ebits (24 c it ie s ) .............................................
C om m ercia l Failures ( N u m b e r ) ..........................
“
“
(L ia b ilit ie s ).......................
Postal R eceip ts (9 c it ie s ) .........................................
Sales— Life Insurance (O h io and P a .)................
“ — D epartm en t Stores (55 fir m s ).............. ..
“ — W holesale D rugs (13 fir m s )....................
“ —
‘‘
D ry G o o d s (11 fir m s )..........
“ —
“
G roceries (41 fir m s )..............
—
“
H ardw are (15 f i r m s ) . .........
—
“
A ll (83 f ir m s ) f ........................
“ — Chain D rugs (3 fir m s )* * ..........................
B uilding C on tracts ( T o t a l ) .....................................
“
“
(R e s id e n t ia l).........................
P ro d u ctio n — C oal (O ., W n . Pa., E. K y .) . . . .
— C em ent (O ., W n. Pa., W . V a . ) .
“
— Petroleum (O ., Pa., K y . ) * ..........
“
— Elec. P ow er (O ., Pa., K y . ) * . . . .
— S h o e s ....................................................
*A p ri 1
**P er in d iv id u al unit operated
fln c lu d e s 3 shoe firms

—12.8

— 6.6

Vlay, M a y , M a y , M a y , M a y ,
1930 1929 1928
1927
1926
129
121
115
120
106
108
102
106
130
101
69
73
54
73
101
119
120
113
113
124
144
125
119
145
141
108
106
105
106
105
103
112
113
102
104
82
75
81
85
76
91
94
96
90
90
98
98
101
94
90
96
90
93
89
95
93
91
88
95
106
149
119
107
136
134
129
106
162
100
81
79
87
93
82
86
167
133
150
130
152
107
101
139
113
108
129
122
142
126
140
99
72
92
80
61

Debits to Individual Accounts

A k r o n ..................
B u tle r ..................
C a n t o n .................
C in c in n a ti. . . .
C leveland
C o lu m b u s ........
C o n n e ls v ille . .
D a y t o n .............
F ra n k lin ...........
G re e n sb u r g . . .
H a m ilt o n .........
H o m e s te a d .. . .
L e x in g to n .........
L im a ..................

Retail and Wholesale Trade

D E P A R T M E N T STOR ES (57)
Akron...................................................
Cincinnati.............................................................
Cleveland..............................................................
Colum bus..............................................................
D ayton..................................................................
Pittsburgh.............................................................
Toledo....................................................................
W heeling...............................................................
Other Cities.........................................................
District..................................................................
W E A R IN G AP PA R EL (16)
Cincinnati.............................................................
Cleveland. . .......................................................
Other Cities.........................................................
District..................................................................
F U R N IT U R E (48)
Cincinnati.............................................................
Cleveland..............................................................
Columbus......... ...............................
D ayton........... ....................................................
T oledo....................................................................
Other Cities.........................................................
District..................................................................
C H A IN STO R E *
Drugs— District ( 3 ) .....................................
Groceries— District ( 6 ) .................................
W H O L E S A L E G R O C E R IE S (41)
Akron...................................................................
Cincinnati.........................................................
Cleveland............................................................
Erie.......................................................................
Pittsburgh...........................................................
Toledo..................................................................
Other Cities........................ ..............................
District................................................................
W H O L E SA LE D R Y GOODS ( 1 1 ) .........
W H O L E S A L E D R U G S ( 1 3 ) .....................
W H O L E SA LE H A R D W A R E ( 1 7 ) ____
W H O L E S A LE SH OES ( 5 ) ........................
•Sales per individual unit operated.

(1923-1925 = 100)

M id d le t o w n ..
O il C i t y ...........
P ittsburgh
.
S p rin g fie ld . . . .
S te u b e n v ille . . .
W a r r e n .............
W h e e lin g ..........
Y ou n gstow n . .
Z a n e sv ille .........
Tot al . . . .

4 weeks
ending
June 18,
1930
96,263
11,860
42,676
347,400
753,109
173,141
3,229
85,089
36,369
4,886
17,289
13.035
4,238
18,693
12,596
5,779
9,783
15,489
1,035,442
20,330
10,053
162,542
10,027
41,841
67,837
9,140
3,008,136

(T h ou san d s of D o lla rs)
Y e a r to
%
change
D ate 1930
(D
e c . 31from
June 18)
1929
— 13 .3
579,444
69,091
— 5 .4
279,167
— 1 8 .6
2,193,320
— 1 4 .8
— 8 .7
4,761,967
1,047,694
— 1.3
19,397
— 1 3 .0
— 8 .0
540,701
— 8.1
227,126
— 1 3 .4
30,230
— 13.1
106,425
87,379
— 1 6.3
— 1 5.3
25,257
— 1 1 .8
160,668
— 5 .0
73,636
32,648
— 6 .3
65,573
— 2 4 .7
93,298
— 1 6 .0
5,554,753
+ 7 .5
— 1 .0
133,391
— 1 9 .9
59,651
— 1 8 .8
1,051,219
— 2 8 .7
69,836
— 1 0 .9
254,292
403,407
— 1 0 .2
57,608
— 24.1
17,979,178
— 5 .5

Y ear to
D ate 1929
(Jan. 2June 19)
673,365
68,511
314,666
2,568,968
5,111,701
1,060,850
20,824
600,092
221,443
32,164
113,807
95,950
27,155
178,405
87,857
34,591
73,008
104,413
6,116,851
138,209
70,424
1,307,644
83,570
290,882
436,034
74,059
19,905,443

%
change
from
1929
— 13. 9
+ o. 8
— 11. 3
— 14. 6
— 6. 8
— 1. 2
— 6. 9
— 9. 9
+ 2. 6
— 6. 0
—
6 .5
— 8..9
— 7. 0
—
9. 9
-1 3 . 9
— 5 6
— 10. 2
— 10 6
— 9. 7
— 3!5
- —15 . 3
— 19 .6
-1 6 .4
— 12 . 6
—
7 5
-2 2 2
- 9 .7

.

.

Building Operations
M ay,
1930
A k ro n ...................
A sh ta b u la ..........
B a rb e rto n ..........
C a n t o n .................
C in c in n a ti..........
C le v e la n d ...........
Cleve. S u burbs:
C leve. H g h ts. .
East C le v e . . . .
E u clid ................
G arfield H ghts.
Lakew ood . . . .
Parm a................
R o c k y R iv e r . .
Shaker H g h t s ..
C o lu m b u s...........
C o v in g to n , K y .
D a y t o n ...............
Erie, P a ..............
H a m ilt o n ............
L exington, K y . .
Li m a .....................
N e w a r k ...............
P ittsburgh, P a ..
S p rin g fie ld.........

1,728,366
33,155
29,720
92,052
4,262,320
2,211,550

816,440
21,400
129,571
72,200
144,790
155,159
277,128
548,925
295,550
36,650
412,343
1,009,322
362,236
73,711
70,485
25,875
2,366,462
121,780
382,065
W heelin g, W . Va.
182,736
Y o u n g s to w n .. .
179,925
T o t a l ............... 16,041,916

(V alue o f Perm its)
J a n .-M a y ,
% change
from 1929
1930
4,270,599
— 3 7 .7
— 7 1 .1
179,526
— 8 0 .7
119,950
9 46,437
— 7 9 .2
+ 4 3 .9
21,891,447
— 2 5 .5
11,916,300
+ 4 2 7 .6
— 9 1 .4
— 3 3 .8
— 5 2 .8
— 3 4 .9
— 3 2 .6
+ 8 8 .0
— 3 2 .0
— 7 6 .5
— 3 9 .5
+ 4 7 .8
+ 1 9 4 .8
+ 1 2 1 .8
— 4 8 .4
— 25.1
— 5 9 .4
— 5 1 .5
— 3 .3
— 6 1 .8
+ 5 5 .7
— 7 4 .8
— 2 3 .0

1,658,660
297,926
788,796
328,800
807,116
701,476
593,133
2,009,150
2,018,350
356,350
3,141,650
2,316,057
817,796
480,604
433,475
106,950
7,574,128
409,820
4,572,773
452,088
1,090,209
70,279,566

J a n .-M a y ,
1929
9,219,867
149,297
423 ,767
1,371,810
13,018,590
14,880,250

% chan,c.*'’
from 1929
— 5 3 .7
+ 2 0 .2
— 71 .7
— 3 1 .0
+ 6 8 .2
— 1 9 .9

972,730
1,483,594
1,058,080
542,100
752,996
919,399
768,415
2,747,325
5,179,400
570,125
2,996,404
4,120,502
796,156
1,030,628
290,065
172,745
13,138,726
577,225
5,039,846
636,570
2,348,260
85,204,902

+ 7 0 .5
— 79 ')
— 2 5 .5
— 3 9 .3
+ 7 .2
— 2 3 .7
— 2 2 .8
— 2 6 .9
— 61 .0
— 3 7 .5
+ 4 .8
— 4 3 .8
+ 2 .7
— 5 3 .4
+ 4 9 .4
— 3 8 .1
— 4 2 .4
— 2 9 .0
— 9 .3
— 2 9 .0
— 5 3 .6
— 17.5

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

8

Summary of National Business Conditions
By the Federal Reserve Board
The volume o f industrial production declined in May by about the same
amount as it increased in April. Factory employment decreased more than is
usual at this season and the downward movement o f prices continued. Money
rates eased further, to the lowest level in more than five years.
Industrial Production and Employment

Index number of production of manufactures
and minerals combined, adjusted for seasonal
variations (1923-25 average — 100). Latest
figure— May, 104.

The Board’s index o f industrial production, adjusted fo r usual seasonal
variations, declined about two per cent in May. In 1930, industrial produc­
tion has fiucuated between fou r and seven per cent above the 1923-1925 aver­
age and the preliminary estimate fo r May is four per cent above the average
fo r those years. Production at steel and automobile plants declined, cotton
mills curtailed output and activity at woolen and silk mills continued at low
levels. Cement production increased sharply, while output o f petroleum and
o f copper showed little change. In the first half of June, output at steel plants
declined further.
The decrease in factory employment in May was larger than usual and
there was also a decline in factory payrolls. The number employed in the
cotton and silk goods industries decreased further, while in the woolen goods
industry there was an increase from the extreme low point o f April. Em­
ployment in the agricultural implement and electrical machinery industries
decreased from April, but remained large relative to earlier years. Employ­
ment in the cement industry increased, but in the lumber industry continued
at an unusually low level.
Building contract awards in May, as reported by the F. W. Dodge C or­
poration, continued to be in substantially smaller volume than in any other
year since 1924.
Distribution

Tndex of Bureau of Labor Statistics (1926=100
base adopted by Bureau). Latest figure—
May, 89.1.

Freight car loadings increased by less than the usual seasonal amount
during May and continued to be in somewhat smaller volume than in the
corresponding period o f 1928 and substantially below the unusually active
period of 1929. Department store sales in May were approximately th »
same as those of a year ago.
Wholesale Prices
A further decline in the wholesale prices of commodities occurred in
May and the first half o f June. The downward movement was interrupted
in the last half o f May by substantial increases in the prices o f grains, meats
and livestock, but became pronounced about the middle o f June when the
prices o f cotton, silk, rubber, copper and silver reached exceptionally low
levels. Wheat, meats, livestock and cotton textiles also declined in price at
that time, while prices o f wool and woolen goods, pig iron and steel showed
little change.
Bank Credit

Monthly averages of weekly figures for report­
ing member banks in leading cities. Latest
figures are averages of first two weeks in June.

Monthly rates in the open market in New
Y ork: commercial paper rate on 4-6 month
paper. Acceptance rate on 90-day bankers’
acceptances. Latest figures are averages of
first 20 days in June.




Loans and investments of reporting member banks increased fu rth er
by $265,000,000 in the fou r weeks ending June 11 to a level considerably
higher than a year ago. The increase was entirely in investments and in
loans on securities, of which a large part represented loans made by N ew
York City banks to brokers and dealers in securities in replacement o f loans
withdrawn by other lenders.
All other ’ loans continued to decline and at
$8,400,000,000 on June 11, were the smallest since 1926.
Expansion o f member bank credit during this period was reflected in
larger demand deposits and an increase o f $30,000,000 in member bank re­
serves at the reserve banks. The volume of money in circulation showed a
net increase o f $13,000,000. Funds fo r these uses were obtained larsrelv
from further additions o f $24,000,000 to the stock o f monetary gold and
from an increase o f $22,000,000 in the volume of reserve bank credit outstand­
ing. Reserve bank holdings of U. S. securities increased by about $50 0 0 0 000 and their holdings o f acceptances declined by about half this amount.
F or the week ending June 18, the total volume o f reserve bank credit de­
clined somewhat and there was a decline in the volume o f money in circula­
tion.
Money rates in the open market continued to decline during the latter
half of May and the first half o f June and at the middle o f the month com ­
mercial paper at 3% -3% per cent and acceptances at 2 1/8 per cent were at
the lowest levels since 1924 and early 1925. Bonds yields moved sliehtlv
lower in June. In the first week of June the rediscount rate at Cleveland
was reduced from 4 to 3% per cent, in the third week the rate at New York
was reduced from 3 to 2 ^ per cent and the rate at Chicago from 4 to
per cent.