View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
Covering financial, industrial, and agricultural conditions
in the
F ourth Federal Reserve D istrict
Federal Reserve Bank o f Cleveland

No. 7

Cleveland, Ohio, July 1, 1928

Vol. 10

Business in the Fourth District remains spotty, but on
the whole is fair to good. Out of 26 of the largest man­
ufacturers in the District, 15 report that business is bet­
ter than a year ago, 10 state that it is not so good, and
in one case there has been no change. As compared with
the first quarter, the second quarter was reported to
have shown an uptrend in 13 cases, a downtrend in 9,
and no change in 4.
The general trend in the first part o f June showed
little change from that o f May outside o f seasonal de­
velopments.
Toward the latter part of the month a
rather pronounced falling-off in steel operations oc­
curred which appeared to be somewhat greater than sea­
sonal. Tire sales have improved lately, following the cut
in tire prices. Motor accessory manufacturers continue
their heavy production schedules. A fter a poor Spring,
a slight recovery is noted in clothing manufacturing.
Building as a whole compared unfavorably in May with
last year, although residential construction made a new
peak. The lumber industry is quiet. Retail trade was a
little better in May than last year, and wholesale trade
showed a distinct improvement. Winter wheat is still in

Solid line— weekly index o f car loadings,
F.
RB.
of
Cleveland
(1923-1925 = 100),
Latest figure: W eek ending June 9— 101.7.
Broken line— m onthly indei of industrial pro­
duction. Federal Reserve Board <1923-1925=:
100).
Latest figure: M ay— 109,
Both curves
adjusted for seasonal variation.




bad shape, but the prospects for other crops are brighter
than a month ago.
General business in the United States in May was about
the same as in April, after allowing fo r seasonal fa c­
tors. The Federal Reserve Board’s index of industrial
production stood at 109 in May— the same as in March
and April, but two points under a year ago. The Annal­
ist’s index of general business activity was 96.4 in May,
as compared with 96.5 in March and 96.6 in April. This
bank's weekly index of distribution, based on car load­
ings, fluctuated between 103.8 and 105.7 in May, a slight
improvement over April. A decline, however, in this
curve is noted in early June. For the week ending May
26 the index stood at 104.5; the next week it fell to 104.3,
and the next to 101.7, but rose to 102.3 for the week
ending June 16.
FIN AN CIAL
The month of June was marked by heavy Treasury
financing, firm money rates, a sharp decline in security
prices accompanied by a decrease in brokers' loans, and fu r­
ther large gold exports. Total credit extended by reporting
member banks declined slightly in the first half of the
month, and Federal Reserve bank credit extended fell off
sharply during the week ending June 20 after an almost
uninterrupted rise commencing late in January.
Money Rates. New York money rates were conspicu­
ously firm in June, with an advancing tendency. Time
money on the stock exchange rose from 5*6-5% per
cent at the beginning o f the month to 5% -5% on the
22nd, and call money rose from 6 to 6 M> per cent during
the same period and went to 7 per cent on June 27.
The latter rate was the highest for several years,
but was partly due to the approach o f heavy mid­
year settlements.
Commercial paper held firm at 4 V24% per cent, with the tendency toward a flat 4%
per cent quotation. Bankers' acceptances crossed the 4
per cent line late in May.
Treasury Financing. On June 15 the Treasury Depart­
ment retired $400,000,000 o f certificates of indebteness
and put out two short-time issues whose allotments aggre­
gated $428,000,000, one fo r six months at 4 per cent and
the other fo r nine months at
per cent. Income tax
payments were close to $500,000,000 and debt payments
made by foreign countries were nearly $100,000,000. The
total turnover o f funds was about $1,500,000,000.
Security Prices. On June 2 the Dow-Jones average of

3%

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
20 industrial stocks reached 220.96, a new high record for
all time. During the next ten days a severe drop took
place which brought the average down to 202.65 on June
12. After a two-day recovery the average again worked
lower, reaching 201.96 on the 18th. During the fol­
lowing week prices were irregular and volume was greatly
curtailed. Bond prices in the first half of June con­
tinued the decline which started about the middle of
May, but steadied in mid-June.
Gold Movements. Gold exports in May were $83,689.000, while imports only amounted to $1,068,000. The
net loss through exports of $81,721,000 was the third
largest in the past four years, being exceeded by March
and April of this year. Earmarkings brought the total
net loss to this country’s gold stock in May to $104,743.000, stocks amounting to $4,161,114,000 (preliminary
figure) on May 31.
Prance continued to take very large amounts of gold
in both May and June, and about $30,000,000 was also
shipped to England in May. For the three weeks end­
ing June 20, total gold exports from New York were ap­
proximately $70,000,000, while imports were less than a
million dollars.
Member Bank Credit. The principal development here
was the drop in loans to brokers and security dealers made
by or through New York reporting member banks. These
loans reached a record high of $4,563,240,000 on June
6, but two weeks later they had fallen nearly $300,000,000 to $4,269,590,000. This drop accompanied the fall in
stock prices. Loans secured by stocks and bonds for
all banks in the United States decreased somewhat in
the first part of June, while “all other” loans increased
slightly. Investments
remained
virtually
unchanged.
Total loans, discounts and investments were slightly
lower, owing to the decline in collateral loans.
Reserve Bank Credit. Bills discounted continued their
marked advance up to June 13, when they amounted to
$1,043,000,000— a gain of over $600,000,000 since the
end of January. The following week, however, brought
a drop to $991,000,000. Government security holdings
on June 20 were $223,000,000, representing a small in­
crease from June 6 as compared with the long decline
of the preceding five months. Acceptance holdings have
now been falling steadily since May 9, but this is partly
seasonal. On June 20 they were down to $224,000,000.
Total bills and securities on the same date were $1,438.000.000, a drop of $70,000,000 for the week but still
high as compared with the level prevailing from Feb­
ruary through May.
Fourth District. Bills discounted by the Cleveland
bank, as in the System, rose to a peak on June 13 and
then dropped sharply the following week, standing at
$79,000,000 on June ?0 as against $90,000,000 the week
before. Acceptance holdings declined in June while Gov­
ernment securities held remained about the same. Total
bills and securities were $136,000,000 on June 20, a de­
crease from the week before but an increase from
May 23.
Loans of reporting member banks secured by stocks
and bonds reached their high point of $690,000,000 for
the year late in May and then fell to about $675,000,000



on June 13.

All other loans rose slightly in early June.

Savings deposits of 68 banks amounted to $1,028*
028,000 on June 1, a gain of 1 per cent for the month
and of 7.8 per cent for the year.
Commercial failures in the Fourth District, according
to Dun’s, numbered 157 in May as compared with 125
in April and 148 a year ago. Liabilities were $2,377,533
in May, $7,055,083 in April, and $3,225,890 a year a go .
In the United States there were 2008 failures in May*
1818 in April, and 1852 a year ago.
*
Debits to individual account at 13 large centers in th is
District were $2,705,272,000 in May, $2,741,802,000 in
April, and $2,589,809,000 in May of 1927.
The following table gives the changes in the m ain
items of the balance sheets of Federal reserve and re­
porting member banks:
Federal Reserve
Bank o f Cleveland
f In Millions)
June 13, June 15. May 16.
1928
1927
1928
248
292
260
Gold reserves .............
Discounts .....................
91
59
59
Acceptances ....— ....—
24
18
34
U. S. Securities............ 336
46
37
Total bills and securities 149
123
130
Federal Reserve notes
in circulation ------195
212
192
Total deposits ----------- 191
200
190

Federal Reserve
(In Millions)
m
June 19, June 15.
««
1928
1927
2,580
3,017
o JZl
1,043
361
*252
240
183
223
547
1.508
1,092
1 55?
1,605
1,698
1
2,436
2,474

Reporting Member Banks
Fourth District
United States
(In Millions)
(In Millions)
June 13, June 15, May 16, June 13, June 15, M a » 1 .
1928
1927
1928
1928
1927
Loans secured by stocks
and bonds ................ 672
641
676
6,908
5,999
7
All other ..................... 784
780
781
8,970
8,649
8*251
Total loans ................. 1,456
1,422
1,456
15,878
14,648
115 215
Investments .................
746
678
747
6,658
6,176
Si 2 fT
Demand deposits ....... 1,060
1.110
1,080
13,717
18,727
lS*S51
Time deposits ............. 959
868
985
7,002
6,172

Iron and
Steel

Production of both pig iron and steel
ingots declined in May, the form er
inappreciably and the latter rather
sharply, yet operating rates generally continued on a
higher plane than a year ago and a record first half year
in ingot output appeared in the making. Within th e
industry the let-down in May was more noteworthy f or
its mildness than its appearance, and fostered a situa­
tion spotty both as to products and districts.
Despite support from the automotive industry, the
Pittsburgh and northern Ohio districts gave more ground
than the Chicago and eastern Pennsylvania district
Car builders, tank makers and pipe mills were unable
May to equal last May’s rates, but tin plate mills and
sheet producers, especially of the full-finished grad
were pressed frequently to make deliveries.
Outstanding in pig iron was the break in basic ir
late in the month. Following a transaction involving011
small tonnage at $17.00 per ton, delivered Alliance
a
contrasted with a price of $17.00, valley, that had pe**
sisted for a number of months, a Pennsylvania consum ^
closed on 46,000 tons, part of which came from a steel*
maker quoting $15.35, valley. Bessemer and fo u n d ,l
iron proved sympathetic immediately. As May closed
efforts were under way to stiffen the basic market *
$16.00.
to
Steel prices continued predominantly weak. In hot and
cold rolled strip, prices slumped to the first quarter i0^

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
points. In sheets substantially all of the price gains of
the first quarter also were surrendered. Heavy steel
continued at $1.85 per 100 pounds (Pittsburgh) with
an announced $1.90 price for the third quarter, which
was not tested. Some semi-finished steel users suc­
ceeded in their contention that semi-finished prices be
marked down $ 1.00 per ton to reflect the weakness in
basic iron. Consumption, however, remained unimpaired
by this soft situation in prices, as evidenced by the mar­
gin over last May in production.
The daily rate of pig iron production in May was 105,962 tons, barely under the 106,066 tons of April, and
at the close of May, 197 blast furnaces were in opera­
tion, or three more than at the close of April. Early
in June, however, the blowing out of stacks both at
Chicago and Pittsburgh neutralized this gain. May’s
total pig iron output was 3,284,811 tons, bringing the
five-month total up to 15,420,144 tons, against 16,339,501
tons in the like period of 1927.
Though steel ingot output fell from 172,103 tons a day
in April to 155,674 tons in May, the 155,663 tons of last
May was just topped. May production, in fact, was the
second best for that month in steel history. The total
of 4,203,190 tons in May made possible a five-month total
of 21,049,919 tons, against only 20,311,778 tons in the
corresponding period of last year. Thus far in 1928
steel making capacity has been engaged 85.89 per cent.
The soft price situation is reflected in the Iron Trade
Review’s composite of fourteen leading iron and steel
products. This index averaged $35.54 for May, con­
trasted with $35.67 for April, $35.81 for March and
$36.76 last May.

3

and 1927, but somewhat less than in 1926. Ohio pro­
duction has been slowly picking up until it is materially
greater than a year ago, following the calling of the
strike on April 1, 1927. Ohio’s output, however, is still
only one-fourth of the level which prevailed in the state
several years ago. Production in Pennsylvania and east­
ern Kentucky in May was slightly less than a year ago.
Reduced freight rates on lake cargo coal originating
in the Pittsburgh area, effective June 18, has provided a
stimulus to shipments from that area.
Rubber and
Tires

The most important development of
the month in this industry was the
cut in tire prices by leading manufac­
turers about the middle of June. The average reduction
was 10 per cent. Such a reduction was not unexpected
in view of the sharp slump in crude rubber prices, and
dealers had been keeping their purchases to a minimum in
anticipation of the cut.
Business of Akron manufacturers was relatively slow
in May and the first part of June, due to the cool weather,
which retarded public buying, and to the disinclination of
dealers to stock up, already mentioned. An improvement
has recently taken place and prospects are brighter.
Crude rubber prices have strengthened slightly in re­
cent weeks but are still at an exceedingly low point.
On June 18, first latex (spot) was quoted at 20 cents
a pound, as compared with 19 cents a month ago, 17%
cents late in April, and 39 cents a year ago.
Production of pneumatic casings in the United States,
according to the Rubber Association of America, was 4,633,308 in April, a decrease of 92,000 for the year and
481.000 for the month. Shipments numbered 4,358,831, as
compared with 4,276,464 a year ago and 4,298,551 for
March. Inventories were seasonably high and were
also somewhat larger than last year and the year before.
World rubber production (net exports), according to
the Department of Commerce, was approximately 175,000
long tons for the first four months of 1928. Of this
amount, 55,000 tons were produced in British Malaya and
25.000 tons in other British possessions, making a total of
80.000 tons for British-owned plantations. Dutch colonies
produced almost the same amount, Brazilian output was
7,649 tons, and Mexican Guayule rubber amounted to
2,008 tons.
Automobiles

in view of the size of stockpiles in
consumers’ hands, and as a result prices
showed further weakness. The Coal Age average for
May (spot, mine) was $1,728, as compared with $1,743
in April and $1.86 a year ago. The present price is
about 8 per cent under the 1926 average.
Production of bituminous coal in the United States
during May was approximately 36,542,000 net tons. The
daily average rate showed a slightly advancing tendency
during the month and was about equal to that of 1925



The rapid gain in automobile produc­
tion since the first of the year cul­
minated in a figure of 425,990 for
May, the highest in two years. In May of 1927, car and
truck production amounted to 404,115. The greater
part of the increase during recent months may be as­
cribed to seasonal factors, but after eliminating such
factors it is found that a recovery has been staged from
the low level of the industry existing in the last quarter
of 1927.
For the first five months of 1928 production was 1,805,060 cars and trucks as compared with 1,747,007 last
year, a gain of 3.3 per cent. Passenger car output was
1,609,223 as against 1.523,891 last year, while truck output
declined from 223,116 a year ago to 195,837 in 1928.
Some concerns were experiencing a slowing-down i

4

THE

MONTHLY

June owing to preparation o f new models, while Ford
and one or two others were swinging into heavier pro­
duction. Reports indicate a good buying demand in
this District.
Registration of new passenger car bills of sale in May
in 59 Ohio counties was 12 per cent greater than a
year ago and 6 per cent greater than in April, accord­
ing to the Ohio State University Bureau o f Business Re­
search. Cuyahoga County (Cleveland) showed a gain o f
7 per cent over last year; Hamilton (Cincinnati) a gain o f
20 per cent; Lucas (Toledo) a gain of 35 per cent; and
Franklin (Columbus) a gain o f 11 per cent.
The chart below shows that automobile production in
May almost reached the high points o f 1925 and 1926.

BUSINESS

REVIEW

hosiery, 10.4; and men’s furnishings, 1.8 per cent.
On
the other hand, men’s clothing sales decreased 10.5
per cent, women’s dresses 1.9, knit underwear, 1.0, an d
silk and muslin underwear 5.1 per cent.
Shoes

This line has been subject to ra th e r
pronounced ups and downs d u rin g
recent months. Operations of m an­
ufacturers in the Fourth District in January and F eb ­
ruary were heavy. A slowing-down took place in M a rch
which was other than seasonal, although activity w a s
still high. A further slackening appeared in A p r il
when production dropped abruptly from March and w a s
also considerably lower than a year ago. May b ro u g h t
a revival in retail and wholesale shoe sales, but p r o _
duction was still low. Preliminary production fig u re s
indicate a loss o f 20.9 per cent from a year ago. i n
June, manufacturers reported that their salesmen o n
the road were booking an excellent volume of b u sin ess
and that prospects for the summer are correspon din gly
bright. Unseasonably cool weather, a retarding fa c t o r
in the Easter selling season o f March and April, had
given way in mid-June to more normal early-sum rner
temperatures.
May likewise brought an improvement to the w hole
sale end o f the shoe trade. For the first time this year*
sales o f Fourth District reporting wholesale shoe fir m s
were larger than in the same month o f 1927. The i n
crease was 1.9 per cent, and May also recorded a g a in
of 6.4 per cent over April. For the first five months o f
1928, sales were 11.8 per cent less than in the corr^
sponding period o f 1927.

Clothing

Unseasonable weather proved a handi­
cap to clothing manufacturers in April
and May. Demand from retailers was
slow, and buying was largely restricted to immediate
needs. As a result, business compared unfavorably both
with the first quarter and with last year. Some better­
ment has been noted recently, but it is a question as to
whether this is developing sufficiently to make up for
the loss of business caused by the cold weather.
Business in knit goods is now running a little ahead
o f last year. Manufacturers o f men's clothing report
sales as being less than a year ago, and the same is
true o f men’s underwear. Business in woolens is quiet.
Demand for women's ready-to-wear is showing signs of
picking up, after a good month in May from the re­
tail standpoint.
Both wholesale and retail clothing sales in May showed
sizable increases over last year. In the case o f whole­
sale dry goods, the majority of reporting firms suffered
a loss in sales as compared with May, 1927, but this
was more than made up by the rest, the 13 firms com­
bined showing a gain o f about 10 per cent.
A fter a very poor April, sales o f most lines o f re­
tail clothing in 46 department stores in this District in
May were well ahead of last year. Women's coats gained
15.6 per cent; misses’ coats and suits, 25 per cent; misses’
dresses, 3.1; girls’ wear, 22.0; sports’ wear, 6.9; aprons
and house dresses, 18.9; furs, 26.8; infants’ wear, 7.8;



Substantial increases over last year in retail shoe
sales also took place in May. Reports from the shoe de
partments o f 46 department and apparel stores in thi~
District showed a gain of 30 per cent in children’s shoes3
6 per cent in men’s, and 3.9 per cent in women’s shoes*
Hide prices in May and June failed to maintain
previous advance and on June 15 were some three
a pound lower than in April, standing at 22%
Leather prices have held firm at 69 cents a pound
leather).

the* *
ce n t*
cent *
(s o f*
le

In various manufacturing lines in th
Fourth District, operations in the sec6
ond quarter compared favorably both
with the first quarter and a year ago. Considerabl
spottiness exists at present, with the general trend u 6
changed or slightly downward since the first o f Jun*"
Boxboard. Competition remains exceedingly keen a
second quarter earnings have been considerably less th
both last year and the year before.
n
oth er
Manufacturing

Can. Sales in the first half year ran ahead o f l
year. June sales were good.
Cigar. Manufacturers are doing a smaller volume
business than a year ago.
Cork. The second quarter was slightly better th
the first, and also exceeded the same period in iq o **
and 1926. June business was about the same as in M
Electrical. Unevenness is apparent in this line.
prevailing state o f business in the second quarter
peared to be below the first quarter (partly season &l)~

THE

MONTHLY

BUSINESS

but above a year ago. June business has been either
unchanged or slightly lower as compared with May.
Glass. Improvement continues in window glass. Pro­
duction and manufacturers' stocks are low, while demand
is strong. Business in plate glass has not held up so
well; automotive demand has recently slackened, and
profit margins are small.
Machinery, Machine Tools. Sales of machine tools are
fair to good. Motor demand was high in April and May,
but has been slightly lower in June in some instances.
Good business is reported by agricultural implement
makers. Sales of woodworking machinery and engineer­
ing specialties in the second quarter were less than last
year.
Paint. Business is materially better than a year ago.
The present trend is upward after allowing for seasonal
factors.
Paper. April and May brought an improvement over
the first quarter, but some hesitation appeared in June.
The second quarter as a whole showed up better than
the same period last year.
AGRICULTURE
Field crops in the District, retarded in growth by the
unseasonably cool, dry weather of Spring, are rapidly
making up for lost time. The weather in May was
quite favorable for farm work and all that was needed
was the general rains of early June to improve the
condition of the crops planted.
Wheat
About one-quarter of the entire winter wheat acreage
in the United States was abandoned. The June 1st con­
dition of 73.6 per cent for the country indicates a pro­
duction of 512,252,000 bushels, compared with 552,000,000
bushels harvested in 1927.
Ohio winter wheat prospects on June 1 were for a crop
of 8,501,000 bushels, indicated by a condition o f 46 per
cent, as compared with 28,980,000 bushels harvested in
1927. The average June 1 condition for the past ten
years was 80 per cent.
West Virginia reports a condition o f 66 per cent of
normal on June 1, the lowest at that time since 1866.
This points to a production of 1,390,000 bushels as com­
pared with 2,101,000, the average harvest of the past
ten years.
Kentucky’s June 1st wheat condition o f 48 per cent o f
normal indicates a crop o f only 26 per cent of the one
harvested in 1927. The 1927 crop was 3,059,000 bushels
and the crop for 1928 is expected to be about 801,000
bushels on the basis of present estimates.
The condition of winter wheat in Pennsylvania on June
1 was 71 per cent as compared with the ten-year av­
erage of 87 per cent. Using this estimate as a basis
for comparison, the 1928 crop is expected to be 17,651,000
bushels as against a ten-year average of 21,795,000
bushels.
Oats
The heavy rains in June have materially changed the
condition of the oat crop in the District. The latest re­
port for Ohio (June 1) shows a condition o f 74 per cent
of normal as compared with 82 per cent a year ago; fo r



5

REVIEW

Kentucky, 77 per cent as compared with 75 per cent a
year ago; and for W est Virginia 78.3 per cent, the lowest
by a small margin ever reported on that date.
Hay and Pasture
Unfavorable growing weather this Spring, together
with considerable winter-injury to alfalfa and clover, is
now reflected in the low conditions for Ohio pastures
and hay crops. On June 1st pastures had an average
condition of 66 against 94 a year ago; all tame hay, 61
against 89 last year; clover and timothy 61 against 89;
and alfalfa, 63 as compared with 86 per cent one year
ago.
West Virginia reports poor stands among the hay
crops. A condition of 72 per cent is shown fo r this
June as compared with 90 per cent last year and a tenyear average of 83 per cent.
The condition o f all tame hay in Kentucky averaged
69 per cent, timothy and clover hay 67, alfalfa 71, and
pasture 73 per cent o f normal.
Fruits
The condition of the apple crop in Ohio on June 1
was 61 per cent o f normal compared with 56 per cent
last year. Some frost damage occurred this Spring
and the dry weather up to June 1 was rather unfa­
vorable to a good crop. Many reports state that apples
are showing a heavy drop.
The peach crop for Ohio as indicated by the June 1
condition points to a crop of 1,386,000 bushels this year
as compared with the 1927 crop of 1,326,000 bushels.
The forecast fo r the Ohio pear crop was 341,000 bushels
on June 1, against 250,000 bushels produced last year.
The fruit situation in W est Virginia is quite favorable
as compared with the poor crop harvested in 1927. The
June 1st condition o f apples is 64 per cent as com­
pared with 31 last year and indicates a much larger
crop than in 1927. Peaches show a condition at pres­
ent o f 61 against 19 per cent in 1927 and points to a
crop of 762,000 bushels as compared with the crop of
202,000 bushels a year ago.
Potatoes
The heavy rains of early June have caused consider­
able alarm with regard to the condition o f the 1928 po­
tato crop. Many seed potatoes are rotting in the ground
and although it is not too late to replant, good seed p o­
tatoes are scarce and high priced in this District.
Farm Prices
The index of wholesale prices of farm products in May
as compiled by the Bureau o f Labor advanced 2.2 points
above the April level to 109.8. This is well above the figure
of 96.3 one year ago. The rise was due mainly to price in­
creases in corn, oats, rye, wheat, hogs, cotton, eggs, alfalfa,
timothy hay, and citrus fruits. Prices o f sheep, lambs,
poultry and potatoes were lower in May than in April.
Tobacco

The progress of the new burley to­
bacco crop in Kentucky up to June 20
was distinctly favorable. Practically all
the plants have now been set, and in spite of early fears
over their condition, reports indicate that the stands
generally are excellent. Some of the plants are small,

THE

6

MONTHLY

but the great majority are vigorous and give promise of
good quality leaf. But little damage from insects was
reported up to the middle of June.
All estimates indicate a considerable increase in acreage
over last year, those from private sources pointing to a
40 or 50 per cent gain. In this connection, however,
it must be remembered that last year’s crop in Kentucky
was short, being nearly 50 per cent under the 1922-1926
average.
BUILDING
Residential contracts awarded in May in this District
made a new high record fo r that month. Total awards
of all types fell below last year's figure, although larger
than in any May before 1927. Total contracts awarded
were $63,813,000, as compared with $70,938,000 a year
ago and $56,810,000 in May of 1926. Residential contracts
amounted to $27,845,000, as compared with $22,189,000
and $18,159,000 in the two preceding years.
For the first five months o f 1928, total contracts were
$265,062,000 as compared with $300,471,000 in 1927, a
decline o f 11.8 per cent.
Residential awards were
$101,625,000 as against $106,140,000, a decrease o f 4.3
per cent.
The valuation of building permits in 27 cities in May
was 2.6 per cent less than a year ago, but the first five
months o f 1928 registered a gain o f 4 per cent. For
the month, the largest gains took place in Ashtabula,
Euclid, Dayton, Hamilton, Newark, and Springfield, while
the greatest decreases were in Cleveland Heights, Garfield
Heights, Parma, Rocky River, Lexington, Lima and
Pittsburgh. For the first five months, large gains occurred
in Euclid, Lakewood, Dayton, and Newark, while the
greatest losses were shown by Columbus, Erie, Lima,
and Springfield.
The Aberthaw index o f industrial building costs re­
mained unchanged at 191 on June 1.

Building Operations
May,
1928
Akron.................
1,811,727
Ashtabula.........
59,489
Barberton.........
183,201
C anton...............
390.159
Cincinnati. . . .
4,458,060
Cleveland.........
4,424,325
Cleveland suburbs
Cleve. Heights
449,495
East Cleveland
80,956
Kuclid..............
326,045
Garfield H ts..
200,100
Lakewood. . . .
329,531
Parma..............
332.698
Rocky R iv er.,
83,535
Shaker H g ts. .
672,725
Columbus.........
2,042,800
Covington. K y.
175.400
D ayton ..............
2.759,009
Erie, Pa..............
399.442
H am ilton..........
279,143
Lexington, K y.
123,775
Lim a................ ..
47.400
Newark..............
313,815
Pittsburgh, P a. 2.559,717
Springfield . . . .
129,560
Toledo................
1.337,676
Wheeling. W . Va
255,841
Youngstown. . .
919,869

(Valuation of Permits)
%
change Jan.-M ay
from 1927
1928
4 -1 2 .1
7,441,605
+ 4 0 .8
180,662
+ 3 3 .1
457,626
+ 2 8 .2
1,958,458
+ 1 4.9
14,061,810
19,321,075
— 1 .6

Jan.-M ay
1927
9,096,859
224,180
487,166
1.491,683
12,217.888
16.413,800

%
change
from 1927
— 18.2
— 1 9 .4
— 6 .1
+ 3 1 .3
+ 15.1
+ 17.7

2,222,775
540,329
1,231,086
951,650
1,837,743
1,186,908
485,863
3.448,140
7,862,000
708,850
6,214,442
1,506,407
758,353
665,700
212,074
4 8 6 .4 8 0
17,630,409
479,112
8,590,647
858,640
3,525,334

2,314,437
454,783
727,783
1,056,600
1,126,732
1,583,922
612,663
3,601,925
11,926,600
779,000
4,174,032
2,350,567
941,037
840,618
414,986
183,108
15,658,622
689,411
6,145,003
1,170,356
4,139,520

- 4 .0
+ 18.8
+ 6 9 .2
— 9 .9
+ 6 3 .1
— 25.1
— 2 0 .7
— 4 .3
— 34.1
— 9 .0
+ 4 8 .9
— 35 .9
— 19.4
— 2 0 .8
— 4 8 .9
+ 165.7
+ 12.6
— 30.5
+ 3 9.8
— 2 6 .6
— 14.8

104,824,178

100,823.281

— 4 6 .4
+ 17.5
+ 6 1 .8
— 5 1 .3
— 3 8 .2
— 5 4 .0
— -42.6
— 1 5.0
— 14.5
— 3 8 .4
+ 2 5 6 .2
— 4 .8
+ 4 4 .7
— 5 0 .9
— 7 5 .7
+ 8 7 2 .5
— 4 5 .4
+ 4 2 .2
— 1.4
— 4 .8
+ 3 4 .4

T o ta l..................... 25.145,493

Retail Trade

seasonably

cold

—

2 .6

+ 4 .0

TRADE
Sales o f 62 department stores in May
were 1.6 per cent larger than in the
same month last year, despite the un­
weather.
All reporting cities except




BUSINESS

REVIEW

Pittsburgh shared in the increase.
For the first five
months of 1928, sales were 1.4 per cent less than in the
corresponding period o f 1927.
Thirty out o f 49 individual departments reported
increases in sales over May, 1927.
The percentage
changes in the principal departments were as follow s:
% change, M ay,
1928, com pared
with May, 1927.
Silks and Velvets ................................................
— 14.0%
Millinery .................................................................
+20.7
Hosiery ...................................................................
+11.7
Women’s Shoes ....................................................
+ 4.7
Women's Coats ......................................................
+16.6
Women’s Dresses ..............................................
— 1.3
Misses’ Ready-to-Wear ......................................
+12.1
Juniors’ and Girls’ Wear ..................................
+15.7
Men’s Clothing ....................................................
— 8.6
Men’s Furnishings ..............................................
+ 6.3
Boys’ Wear ..........................................................
+ 6.5
Furniture ..............................................................
— 17.5
Floor Coverings ..................................................
— 1.5
Draperies, Lamps, Shades ................................
— 1.0
House Furnishings ..............................................
-f 2.0
Wholesale Trade

All reporting wholesale lines in th is
District recorded increases in M ay
sales as compared with a year a g o.
This is the first time that has happened since October,
1923. Drugs led with a gain o f 9.8 per cent; dry g ood s
gained 9.3 per cent; groceries, 7.2; shoes, 1.9; and h ard­
ware, 0.5 per cent.
For the first five months of 1928, groceries, dry good s,
and drugs showed increases over last year of 3.2, 2.6 ,
and 1 per cent respectively, while hardware sales w ere
down 8.2 per cent and shoes, 11.8 per cent.
Turnover Rate

The following table gives the annual
rate of department store turnover f o r
1925, 1926, and 1927 for the 20 indi­
vidual departments doing the largest volume of business.
The turnover rates are compiled from the figures o f 26
department stores in the Fourth Federal Reserve D istrict
for which departmental sales and stocks are available
for each month in the three-year period. The yearly
turnover rate is found by dividing the total sales f o r
the year by the average end-of-month stocks for the 13
months beginning and ending with December.
Rate of Turnover

1927
1926
Millinery ................................................. 8.99
9.34
Women’s Dresses ..................................
7.64
7.75
Women’s Coats ......................................
7.52
7.17
Misses’ Ready-to-Wear .....................
6.54
6.50
Juniors and Girls’ Ready-to-Wear.... 5.71
5.68
Women’s and Children’s Hosiery ...... 4.50
4.18
Infants’ W ear .......................................
3.57
3.39
Boys’ Wear ............................................
3.40
3.41
Toilet Articles ......................................
3.03
3.20
Men’s Clothing ......................................
3.01
3.23
Men’s Furnishings ............................... 2.98
2.99
Silks and Velvets .................................. 2.85
3.13
Domestics ..............................................
2.82
3.14
Toys, Sport Goods ................................ 2.66
2.72
Draperies ..............................................
2.59
2.45
Furs .......................................................... 2.56
2.99
House Furnishings .............................. 2.54
2.73
Women’s Shoes ...................................... 2.48
2.56
Furniture ................................................
2.31
2.30
Floor Coverings ....................................
1.82
1.78

1U25
9.07
6.7g
7.3$
5.92
5.13
3.8*0
3.29
3*40
3.21
3.34
3,06
3.33
2.94
2.68
2*58
2.*88
2^88
2 54
2.43
1*73

7

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

Fourth District Business Conditions
(All figure* are for Fourth District unless otherwise specified)
May
1928
Bank Debits (24 cities)
Millions of dollars .................
Sayings Deposits (end of month)
Ohio (41 banks)
Thou s. of dollars
.................
Western Pennsylvania (27 banks)
“
44
44
....................
Total (68 banks)
“
44
........................
Commercial Failures — Number
Actual Number
.................
4*
“
— Liabilities
Thous. of dollars
.................
Postal Receipts — 9 cities
44 44
4‘
....................
Sales — Life Insurance— Ohio and Pa.
44 44
4*
....................
“ — Dept. Stores — (62 firms)
44 “
4‘
...................
** — Wearing Apparel (17 firms)
“
“
“
....................
— Furniture (49 firms)
44 44
“
....................
M — Wholesale Grocery (45 firms)
..............
** —
44
Dry Goods (13 firms)
*4 44
44
....................
44 —
44
Hardware (16 firms)
44 *4
44
....................
_
.**
Drugs (14 firms)
44 44
44
....................
Building Permits, Valuation— 27 cities
*4 44
44
....................
Building Contracts — Total, 4th District
“
'*
“
....................
“
44
— Residential, 4th District
“
44“
........................
Production— Pig Iron, t ’ . S.
Thous. of tons.
.................
— Steel Ingots, U. S.
..............
44
— Automobiles, U. S.
— Passenger Cars
Actual Number
..................
— Trucks
44
44
..............
44
— Bituminous Coal, 4th DUt.
Thous. of tons
.................
44
— Cement: Ohio, W. Ya., Wn. Pa. 44 44 barrels ....................
44
— Electric Power: Ohio, Pa., Ky.
Millions of k.w. hrs.................
44
— Petroleum: Ohio, Pa., Ky.
Thous. of barrels
..................
44
— Shoes, 4th District
’ * “ pairs
.....................
44,
— Tires, U. S.
•* “ casings .....................
..............
Bituminous Coal Shipments (from Lake Eric ports) 44 44 tons
Iren Ore Receipts (at Lake Erie ports)
..............
*5 months' average.
aApril.
*January-April.
•Figures Confidential.

Index Numbers of Trade in the Fourth Federal
Reserve District
May,
1924
Department Stores (60)*......................... 115
Whofaaal* Drugs (14)**.........................
97
Wholesale Dry Goods (18)*».....................
79
Wholesale Groceries (45)** .....................
95
Wholesale Hardware (16)**................... 102
Wholesale All (98)**|............................
95
Chain Drugs (8 )* t.................................... 101
*Base=Average monthly sales, 1919-1923
* *Base=Average monthly sales. 1928-1925
tlncludes 4 shoe firms
fP er Individual* unit operated.

May,
1925
118
95
78

May,
1926
117
108
81

99
91
102

101
92
108

92

90

May,
1927
114
102
73
89
98
89
97

Debits to Individual Accounts
Mn thousands of dollars)
Akron.................
Butler, Pa...........
Canton................
Cincinnati...........
Cleveland...........
Columbus...........
Connellsville, Pa.
Dayton...............
Erie, Pa..............
Greensbur*, P a ..
Homestead, P a ...
Lexington, K y ...
Urna...................
Lorain.................
Middletown........
Oil City, P a .. . . .
Pittsburgh, P a ...
Springfield.........
Steubenville........
Toledo................
Warren...............
Wheeling, W. Va.
Youngstown........
Zanesville...........

5 weeks
ending
June 20,
1928
123,165
14.010
56,261
518,268
953,536
199,909
4,982
111,802
45,693
24,574
5,436
24,462
16,441
7,092
14,627
23,676
1,180,717
25,330
14.515
321,262
15,006
59,670
85,467
15,750

1928 to
%
change date ( Dec.
from
2 $—June
1927
20)
642,823
+ 1.7
66.011
+ 6.1
300,623
+ 6.2
+ 14.6 2,766.630
+ 3.3 4,999,568
+ 5.6 1.038,890
— 16.2
24,729
— 0.002 562,693
+ 9.5
212.100
— 3.9
123.668
25,936
+ 1.3
158.763
+ 7.2
92.591
+ 11
— 10.9
35,083
77,376
+15.5
+ 2 7 .9
102,215
— 7.3 5,910.524
— 7.3
133.732
68,696
+ 5.3
+ 17.0 1,651.125
80.907
— 3.9
+ 9 .0
296,008
427,401
+ 4.1
+ 7.3
77,456

Total.............

3,861,651

+ 2.2




19,895,548

1927 to
date (Dec.
29-June
22)
578,982
70,375
290,895
2.436.967
4,876,782
1.017,813
31,775
579.547
217,034
134,544
26,358
154,719
90,619
36,186
66,120
93.582
6,445,248
145,034
67,571
1,417,480
84,014
283,755
436,369
77,139

19,658*908

May.
1928
115
112
80
95
98
95
95

%
change
from
1927
+ 1 1 .0
— 6.2
+ 3.3
+13.5
+ 2.5
+ 2.1
— 22.2
+ 0.5
— 2.3
— 8.1
— 1.6
+ 2.6
+ 2.2
— 3.0
+ 17.0
+ 9.2
— 8.3
— 7.8
+ 1.7
+16.5
— 3.7
+ 4.3
— 2.1
+ 0.4
+ 1.2

May
1927

change

3,276

3,118

+ 5.1

748,384
279,644
I,,028,028
157
2,378
3,128
120,240
26,491
2,064
1,303
6,872
2,172
2,101
1,899
25,145
63,813
27,845
3,284
4,203

696,365
256,976
953,342
148
3,225
2,933
104,309
26,083
1,912
1,352
6,413
1,987
2,092
1,730
25,821
70,938
22,189
3,387
4,047

+ 7.5

375,798
50,192
14,788
1,803
1,054*
1,990*
4

4,676*
4,343
2,848

357,148
46,965
14.158
1,558
1,086s
1,986*
♦

4,787*
5,390
4,969

Jan.*May
1928

Jan.-May
1927
16,131

16,223
737,962*
276,511*
1,014,4731
920
28,590
15,764
535,869
118,911
9,233
5,259
31,766
10,736
9,292
9,177
104,824
265,062
101,625
15,406
21.050

684,636*
254,163*
938,800*
874
20,519
15,607
513,688
120,605
9,436
5,375
30,781
10,467
10,124
9,090
100,823
3u0,47l
106,140
16,330
20,312

+ 5.2
+ 6.9
+ 4.4
+ 15.7
— 2.9

1,609,223
195,837
73,703
5,708
4,5133
7,817s

1,523,891
223,116
91,975
5,624
4,448*
7,701*

— 20.9
— 2.3
— 19.4
— 42.7

18,8003
5,257
2,848

17,281*
9,298
5,702

+ 8.8
+ 6.1
+ 7.8

— 26.3

+ 6.6

+ 15.3

+ 1.6

+
—
+
+
+
+
—

7.9
3.6
7.2
9.3
0.5
9.8

2.6

10.0
+ 25.5
— 3.0
+ 3.9

—

+ 0.2

4

4

change

+ 0.6
+ 7.8

+ 8.8

+ 8.1
+ 5.3
+ 39.3

+ 1.0
+ 4.3
1.4

2.2
2.2

+ 3.2
+. 2.6
8.2

—

+ 1.0
+ 4.0

1 1.8

—

— 4.3
— 5.7
+ 3.6
+ 5.6
—

12.2

— 19.9
+ 1.5
+ 1.5
+ 1.5
— 6.7

+ 8.8

— 43.5
— 50.1

Retail and Wholesale Trade
(1928 compared with 1927)
SALES
May*
MayDEPARTM ENT STORES (62)
Akron....................................
+ 1 3 .4
Cincinnati.............................
+4.1
Cleveland..............................
+4.7
Columbus.............................
+ 4 .6
Dayton..................................
+3.7
Pittsburgh............................
— 5.2
Toledo...................................
+ 1 3 .7
+3.1
Wheeling...............................
Youngstown..........................
+7.1
Other Cities..........................
— 5.2
District..................................
+1.6
WEARING APPAREL (17)
Cincinnati.............................
+6.5
Cleveland..............................
+ 14.2
Other Cities
..................
+1.8
District.................................
+7.9
FURNITURE (48)
Cincinnati.............................
— 2.6
Cleveland..............................
+3.6
Columbus..............................
— 8.0
Dayton..................................
— 4.8
Toledo...................................
— 10.1
Other Cities..........................
— 4. 6
District..................................
— 3.7
CHAIN STORE *
Drugs— District (3 )............
— 1.6
Groceries— District ( 5 ) . . . .
+7.5
WHOLESALE GROCERIES (45)
Akron....................................
+ 4.0
Cincinnati.............................
— 1.5
Cleveland..............................
+ 1 0 .4
Erie........................................
— 4.3
Pittsburgh.............................
+ 8.4
T oledo...................................
+ 1 0 .8
Other Cities..........................
+6.5
District..................................
+7.2
WHOLESALE
DRY GOODS (1 3 )........
+9.3
WHOLESALE DRUGS (14)
+9.8
WHOLESALE
HARDW ARE (16)..........
+0.5
WHOLESALE SHOES (6)
+1.9
•Sales per individual unit operated

Percentage Increase or Decrease
SALES
STOCKS
First
May5 mos.
May+ 1 0 .0
+0.8
+1.1
+ 1.3
— 0.7
— 6.1
+4.5
— 5. 8
— 1.0
— 7.9
— 1.4
+0.7
— 2.6
— 4.5
— 2.2

+ 24.2
+ 1.3
+ 3.4
— 1.9
+ 4.6
— 7.3
— l.l
—

11.6

— 5.7
— 3.4
—

1.2

+ 7.5

+ 2. 2

— 0.4

+ 2.0

— 2.8
+1.2
— 7.0
— 2.8
+5.2
— 16.3
— 2.1
— 6.7
+5.8
+ 1 0 .9
+5.4
+2.8
— 7.0
+ 9.9
+1.3
+1.9
+3.2
+2.6
+1.0
— 8.2
— 11.8

+ 1.5

+ 2.0
—

6.2

8

THE

MONTHLY

BUSINESS

REVIEW

Summary of National Business Conditions
By the Federal Reserve Board
Industrial production continued during May in about the same volume
as in the three preceding months. Wholesale and retail trade increased
in May and the general level of commodity prices showed a further advance.
Security loans of member banks, which were in record volume in May,
declined considerably during the first three weeks in June.
Conditions
in the money market remained firm.
Production

Index number of production of m anufactures
and minerals combined, adjusted for seasonal
variations
<1923-1925=:100).
Latest
figure
— M ay, 109.

Index of U . S. Bureau of Labor Statistics
(1926 = 100).
Latest figure— M ay, 98.6.
Or
-----------

M LLRM

2

2

DOLLARS

BILLIONS OF DOLLARS
-------------------------------

Production o f manufactures was slightly smaller in May than in
April, when allowance is made fo r usual seasonal variations, while the
output of minerals increased somewhat. Production o f steel declined in
May from the high level attained in April, but was in about the same
volume as a year ago. Since the first of June buying of steel products
has been light and there have been further decreases in production. Daily
average production of automobiles was in about the same volume in May
as in April, and preliminary reports for the first three weeks in June
indicate that factory operations were maintained at practically the same
level. Activity o f textile mills was somewhat larger in May, and there
were also increases in the slaughter of livestock and in the production o f
building materials, non-ferrous metals, and coal, while the production of
petroleum declined. The value of building contracts awarded during May,
as reported by the F. W. Dodge Corporation for 37 states east of
the Rocky Mountains, was larger than in any previous month, and awards
during the first half of June exceeded those for the corresponding period
of last year. Indicated production of winter wheat, as reported by the
Department of Agriculture on the basis o f June 1 condition, amounted to
512,000,000 bushels, 40,000,000 bushels less than the harvested production
of 1927.
Trade
Distribution of merchandise, both at wholesale and at retail, was in
larger volume in May than in April. Making allowances for customary
seasonal influences, sales in all lines of wholesale trade showed increases,
although in most lines they continued in smaller volume than a year ago.
Department store sales were larger than in April and at about the same
level as a year ago, while sales o f chain stores and mail order houses showed
increases both over last month and over last year.
Volume of freight car loadings increased further during May, but
continued smaller than during the corresponding month o f either o f the
two previous years.
Loadings o f miscellaneous commodities, however,
which represent largely manufactured products were larger in May o f
this year than in that month o f any previous year.
Prices

192*

1925

1926

1927

Monthly averages o f daily figures for 12
Federal Reserve Hanks.
Latest figures are
averages of first 22 days in June.

The general level of wholesale commodity prices, as indicated by the
Bureau of Labor Statistics index, increased in May by over one per cent
to 98.6 per cent of the 1926 average, the highest figure recorded fo r any
month since October, 1926. There were increases in most o f the principal
groups o f commodities, but the largest advance in May as in April occurred
in farm products and foods. Contrary to the general trend, prices o f p ig
iron, hides, raw silk, fertilizer materials, and rubber showed declines during
the month. Since the middle of May there have been decreases in prices o f
grains, hogs, sheep, pig iron, and hides, while prices o f raw wool, nonferrous metals, lumber and rubber have advanced.
Bank Credit

1925

1926

1927

1928

Federal Reserve Board’ s indexes o f value of
building contracts awarded as reported by
the F. W . Dodge Corporation <1923-1925 —
100).
Latest figures, M ay, adjusted index__
152;
unadjusted— 163.




Loans and investments of member banks in leading cities on June 20
showed a decline from the high point which was reached on May 16th.
Loans on securities, which had increased by more than $1,000,000,000 since
May, 1927, declined $200,000,000, while all other loans, including loans for
commercial and agricultural purposes, increased somewhat. There was a
small increase in total investments.
During the four weeks ending June 20th there were withdrawals o f
nearly $75,000,000 from the country’s gold stock, and the volume o f reserve
bank credit outstanding increased somewhat, notwithstanding a decline in
member bank reserve requirements. Member bank borrowing at the reserve
banks continued to increase and early in June exceeded $1,000,000,000 fo r the
first time in more than six years.
Acceptance holdings o f the reserve banks declined considerably, while
there was little change in their holdings of United States securities.
After the middle of May, firmer conditions m the money market
were reflected in advances in open market rates to the highest levels since
the early part of 1924.