View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

M
Busin
Covering financial, industrial
and agricultural conditions

eview
Fourth Federal Reserve District
Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland

,

Vol. 26

________ Cleveland/ Ohio/ January 31 1944_____________________ No. 1
FINANCIAL

War
For more than three years, the volume of
Expenditures business activity and financial developments

in the fourth district, as well as in the en­
tire country, have been determined almost exclusively
by the needs and requirements of the armed forces of
the nation. Unfilled orders, current rates of production,
labor supply, and innumerable other aspects of economic
conditions have been subject to this predominant influ­
ence. There has been no choice as to the general eco­
nomic conditions under which all businesses— trade, finan­
cial, or manufacturing— have had to operate. Few calcu­
lations for the future can be made without first appraising
the probable trend of this dominant factor in the busi­
ness picture.
There are several ways by which this powerful economic
influence is, or can be, measured. One is the munitions
production index published at intervals by the War Pro­
duction Board, which now stands at some six or seven
times the Pearl Harbor level. Another method might be
that of tabulating contracts awarded (after adjusting for
cancelations and cutbacks) by the procurement services,
month by month. So much of the fourth district’s ac­
tivity, however, is of the subcontract type (the supply­
ing of parts and semi-finished articles) that the prime con­
tracts awarded figure consistently understates the effect
of war demand.
Perhaps the most practical single yardstick available
is that of “War Activities Expenditures” as reported in
the Daily Statement of the U. S. Treasury. This statistic
includes all disbursements for war purposes, with the ex­
ception of transactions by the RFC and its subsidiaries.
Because of the varying lengths of months, and for other
reasons, monthly changes since 1939 have been some­
what irregular. Such short-term fluctuations have been
smoothed on the accompanying chart by means of a threemonth moving average, which in turn was converted into
terms of an annual rate.
By June 1941 (actually May-June-July) war activities
expenditures had risen to a rate equal to $10 billions per
year. Orders being placed by the Army, Navy, etc., had
already become the most powerful single influence in
shaping the business outlook. Since that time it has mere­




ly been a case of accentuating the degree of dominance.
Immediately before Pearl Harbor, the war effort had
attained a $20 billions-per-year rate, which broke the rec­
ord for any fiscal year during 1917 to 1919. By the
end of 1942, Treasury expenditures for war purposes had
crossed the $70 billions-per-year rate, with a correspond­
ing change in the extent to which war work was exclud­
ing all other considerations.
Although there was some further expansion during the
early months of 1943, the movement has been sidewise
since the April-May-June 1943 peak of $86 billions per
year. This leveling-off has been interpreted in some quar­
ters as representing the maximum war effort attainable.
Moreover, an impression seems to have been created that
changes or reductions in military requirements will cause
a decline in the expenditure curve within the near future.
In that connection, it should be remembered that the
fiscal 1945 budget submitted on January 13 estimated war
activities expenditures at $90 billions for the year be­
ginning next July 1. If that schedule is to be fulfilled a
further rise, rather than a drop, in the annual rate of Treas­
ury expenditures is to be anticipated.
In any event,, it is almost axiomatic that as long as the
curve of war expenditures remains at the $85 billions-peryear level, not to mention a possible increase beyond
that, no great quantities of raw materials, labor services,
or shipping facilities can be made available for non-war

2

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

purposes. Post-war planning is highly desirable and de­
serves encouragement; but post-war plans themselves can
hardly be effected along a broad front until Treasury war
expenditures decline from present levels and peacetime
economic forces are allowed to become more influential.
A few materials, once critical, are now becoming avail­
able in varying quantities, but labor, and especially cer­
tain more or less standard component parts used for war
production as well as peacetime products, are extremely
short, resulting in a very unbalanced situation. Also, the
problem as to how some concerns might be allowed to
revert to peacetime production without penalizing com­
petitors who are required to continue turning out needed
military supplies has not been solved.
Decline in
The protracted decline in total deposits
Bank Deposits which has persisted from October 20 to
date and has been evident at weekly
reporting banks throughout the country as well as in
the fourth district is an outstanding feature of recent
banking trends. In terms of dollars the contraction has
been moderate, amounting to only four to five percent,
or $210,000,000, for the weekly reporting member banks
of this district. But the decline has been more prolonged
than any other in a number of years, with the result that
on January 12, the last reporting date prior to the Fourth
War Loan Drive, total deposits showed a net gain of only
2V2 percent for the preceding seven months. This is a
much slower rate of increase than had prevailed prior
to mid-1943.
An examination of the causes, visible and implied, may
shed some light on the permanence of this most recent
trend.
The $210,000,000 decrease in total deposits of fourth
district weekly reporting banks was the net result of these
four movements:
Changes in Deposits—October 20, 1943 to January 12, 1944
Type of Deposit
Increase
U. S. Government ................................
Domestic Banks .....................................
Time Deposits ........................................ $ 4 3 ,0 0 0 ,0 0 0
Demand Deposits ...................................
1 95,000,000
Net

....................................................

Decrease
$4 4 5 ,0 0 0 ,0 0 0
3 ,0 0 0 ,0 0 0

$210,000,000

The decline in Government deposits (over 50 percent)
was anticipated. The proceeds of the Third War Loan
were being disbursed. That some of those funds should
find their way into time deposits of individuals, etc., was
likewise a logical expectation. The significant develop­
ment is that the gain in demand deposits failed by some
$210,000,000 of making up the difference.
A partial explanation can be found in the behavior of
loans during this interval:
Changes in Loans—October 20, 1943 to Jannary 12, 1944
Type of Loan
Increase
Decrease
To Brokers ......................................................... ...................... $ 5 6 ,0 0 0 ,0 0 0
“All Other”
5 2 ,0 0 0 ,0 0 0
Commercial, Industrial, and Agricultural
9 ,0 0 0 ,0 0 0
To Banks ..................................................................................... 8,0 0 0 ,0 0 0
On Beal E s t a t e ...........................................................................2 ,000,000
Other Secured ..................................................
$9,000,000
Net

..............................................................

$ 1 18,000,000

A maximum of $118,000,000 of deposits was obliterated
by the liquidation of bank loans. The $52,000,000 con­
traction in so-called “all other” loans erased all of the
remarkable rise which characterized the period of the Sep­
tember
War Loan. The $56,000,000 contraction in brok­



ers’ loans retraced only about half of the Third War Loan
credit expansion. It would have been desirable from the
point of view of sound public finance if all or nearly all
such war-bond-purchase loans had been retired before the
advent of the Fourth Loan. If the current Drive is ac­
companied by borrowing on a scale comparable to that
of September-October, total deposits will increase accord­
ingly.
It is impossible to determine how much of the total
deposit shrinkage was caused by loan liquidation as tabu­
lated above, since in some cases the borrower probably
sold his collateral to the lending bank, with no effect what­
soever upon total deposits.
Another important part of the $210,000,000 decrease can
be attributed to the continued public demand for handto-hand currency. During the twelve-week period under
review, money in circulation increased nationally by near­
ly $1,400,000,000. It is estimated that from $75,000,000
to $100,000,000 was provided through the medium of the
weekly reporting banks of this district. Depositors’ bal­
ances shrank correspondingly. Currency demands have
always produced this result, but in recent years the in­
crease in banks’ investments generated deposits more rap­
idly than currency was being paid out. Thus the de­
flationary aspects of hoarding— or currency accumulation
—were obscured by credit expansion elsewhere.

Changes in Investments—October 20, 1943 to January 12, 1944
Type of Investment
Increase
Treasury Bills .............................................
Government-Guaranteed and Other
Investments .......................................
Treasury Notes ..........................................
Treasury Certificates ................................ $ 34,000,000
Treasury Bonds ........................................
3 8 ,000,000
Net

.........................................................

Decrease
$127,000,000
24,000,0 00
2,000,000

$ 8 1 .000.000

During this most recent interval, the reporting banks
actually disposed of $81,000,000 of investments on bal­
ance. However, these banks’ cash resources increased
only $1,000,000 (net) from October 20 to January 12.
Hence, it is a reasonable supposition that the disposal of a
certain quantity of Treasury bills and other investments
was necessary merely to maintain cash reserves at the Oc­
tober 20 level. Because of that liquidation, weekly re­
porting banks’ holdings of Treasury 91-day bills have
dropped below the aggregate of "other securities”, such
as corporate, municipal, and other securities, for the first
time since early 1943.
In summary, the decline of deposits, as typified bv the
weekly reporting banks, can be ascribed to the follow­
ing influences:
a. Considerable liquidation of Third War Loan credit.
b. Continued outflow of currency into circulation.
c. Disposal of investments— a deviation from the trend
of recent years.
Any conjecture as to the future trend of deposits must
take into consideration the probability of permanence of
these influences.
MANUFACTURING, MINING
Manpower The cutbacks and cancelations of war orders
reported currently have had little effect on
the local manpower situation. Labor conditions in in­
dustrial centers indicate that to date most workers so re­
leased have been re-employed promptly on other war
work. In December the number of areas of acute labor
shortage in the entire country was reduced from 69 to

8

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

67, according to the WMC. The number of areas antici­
pating a labor shortage within six months declined from
124 to 119. In general, the labor problem has eased
slightly, but with continued demand from the armed serv­
ices, need for workers in areas where an acute shortage
still exists, and the requirements of agriculture in the
spring, the relief would seem to be spotty and temporary.
Iron and ^ or t^ie ^our^1 consecutive year the American
Steel
steel industry has established a new record out­

put of steel ingots and castings. December pro­
duction fell to 7,266,000 tons (94.3 percent of capacity) as
a result of the Christmas layoff and work stoppage late in
the month, but the total output for 1943, 88,873,000 net
tons, was still nearly 3,000,000 tons greater than in 1942.
By mid-January, steel production recovered to 99 percent
of capacity, the approximate level of operation for the lat­
ter part of 1943.
December output of pig iron totaled 5,139,000 net tons,
making a total annual production for the year of 61,000,000 net tons. This represents an increase in production
over 1942 of more than 1,000,000 tons.
Due to the difficulties encountered during the Great
Lakes shipping season, stocks of Lake Superior iron ore
on hand at furnaces and on Lake Erie docks January 1,
1944, totaled 43,429,000 tons compared with 47,424,000 a
year earlier. Despite the reduction, this supply is con­
sidered adequate for all needs until the 1944 navigation
season opens.
Recent developments in contract cancelations and cut­
backs and recommendations to hold up work on new steel
plants indicate that wartime requirements in steel are
equaled if not exceeded by our expanded production facili­
ties. The backlog of orders, except for plates, has been re­
duced and deliveries shortened on many items. Alloca­
tions of steel are now being made for the most pressing
civilian needs and although at present the tonnage so al­
lotted is small, observers in the field feel that there are
definite indications that the program may become more
flexible as the pressure of war demand permits.
Demand for steel plates for the landing craft program
continues. December’s production was the highest ever
recorded, 1,169,096 tons. For the year just ended, steel
plate shipments totaled 13,382,000 tons, exceeding the
1942 output by 2,500,000 tons. It is expected that pro­
duction will increase slightly before leveling off as ca­
pacity is fully utilized early in 1944.




Total coal output of all types in 1943 exceeded
output for 1942 by approximately 0.5 percent.
Bituminous coal output in the fourth district for 1943
fell short of the 1942 production of 222,000,000 tons by
approximately 3,200,000 tons. Coal shipments on the
Great Lakes for 1943 totaled 52,007,690 tons; shipments
for 1942 totaled 52,533,797 tons. The curtailed coal out­
put in the fourth district can be accounted for by the labor
difficulties of 1943, the effects of which were only par­
tially offset by the increase in hours of the work week ef­
fective throughout the year.
Coal

Other
Total shipments during the past year for
Manufacturing t^ie mac^ine tool industry have shown a

steady decline from a high in March of
$125,445,000 to a low of $61,000,000 in December. The
output for 1943 totaled $1,179,638,000. The volume of
business estimated for 1944 is one-fourth of present ca­
pacity or about $325,000,000 worth of machine tools.
Some machine tool manufacturers have already accom­
plished one reconversion and are at present manufacturing
subassemblies and parts for airplane and Diesel engines
on subcontracts. Ultimate reconversion after the war is
viewed with considerable anxiety, further complicated by
renegotiation and Government ownership of compara­
tively new machine tools costing some $500,000,000.
Government regulations continue to limit shoe manu­
facturers to 1942 production totals, but lack of skilled
workmen has made it impossible for the industry even
to equal that volume. Shoe production in the fourth
district for 1943 fell approximately twelve percent under
the total output for the previous year.
The ceramic industry, hampered by lack of manpower
estimated at 25 percent under total working force needed,
finds production further restricted through frequent cur­
tailment of gas supply. Incoming orders continue to ex­
ceed shipments and production is estimated at 80 percent
of capacity.
Construction Total construction awards as reported by

the F . W. Dodge Corporation for the fourth
district dropped sharply in December to $24,121,000. This
was $5,000,000 less than the total for November and
brings the total construction awards for the year to
$270,079,000, approximately 37 percent of the total for
1942.
AGRICULTURE

As 1943 crops grew and matured,
there circulated many gloomy forebodings
about the imminence of devastating drouth.
Reasoning behind these presentiments ran
all the way from hunches to analyses of meteorological
cycles. Individuals skilled in the science of weather dis­
counted the value of cyclical changes for forecasting pur­
poses but indicated, nevertheless, that weather does tend
to average out and that we have had seven years of rela­
tively favorable rainfall.
With such prophecies as a background, the extremely
low precipitation of the last five months of 1943 naturally
raises the question of whether seven lean years may con­
sume the seven fat years. Although rainfall in Ohio was
13.5 percent above normal during the first seven months
of 1943, rainfall during the last five months was 38.7 per­
Rainfall
and the
Water Table

Rainfall:

4

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

cent below normal. The accompanying chart shows that
in addition to being below normal the trend during the
last five months of the year was toward a consistently
greater rainfall deficiency. These Ohio data depict the
entire fourth district rainfall situation fairly accurately.
In Kentucky the fall was extremely dry; in Pennsylvania
and West Virginia the moisture deficiency was less marked
than in Ohio. In the Blue Grass area of Kentucky the
drouth was said to be the most severe in 75 years and
meadows and pastures suffered considerable damage.
Some observers have pointed out that the rainfall pat­
tern of 1943 was very similar to 1933 conditions— condi­
tions which presaged, according to some, the drouth of
1934. Others place little reliance in what they call
“chance occurrences” and emphasize that our weather
history is not yet of sufficient length to shed much light
on cyclical variations.
Water Table: In recent years changes in the Ohio
water table have drawn a great deal of interest from
many quarters. Much has been said, correctly and in­
correctly, regarding the causes of changes, their effects,
and what may be done about them. Usually the prob­
lem has been pointed to as “the declining water table,”
with implications that the decline may be permanent.
When wells go dry and farmers haul water for human
and livestock consumption, they frequently blame “the
declining water table.” Industrialists often voice the
same lament when their wells prove inadequate. In seek­
ing causes for the decline, many persons have attributed
the lowering of the water table to the cutting of forests,
to intensive farming, and to land drainage. Naturally,
those who view these developments as causes find their
remedies in the same factors.
Early in 1942 the Ohio Water Supply Board was cre­
ated with the understanding that one of its principal func­
tions would be the study and detailed observation of
the water table. Since that time the Board has gathered
a large body of information and is attempting to sub­
stitute fact for conjecture on many aspects of the water
table controversy.
Most of the information assembled by the Ohio Water
Supply Board on water table changes comes from vol­
untary reporters. These reporters, now submitting in­
formation from 60 counties, periodically measure the dis­
tance from some fixed point to the surface of the water in
their wells. This procedure does not, of course, give
any indication of the depth of the water table below the
earth s surface, but it does provide accurate information
on the amount of rise or fall from preceding observations.
County agricultural extension agents coordinate the work
in the cooperating counties.
Although the Board has been active only a short time
in terms of weather cycles, it has issued two general re­
ports on the water table and one specialized report dealing
with water for Ohio industry. With regard to the water
table, the Board recognizes no long-time trend toward a
permanently lower level. The water table, according to
Board spokesmen, is tied closely to rainfall, and the gen­
eral water table problems of recent years are believed
to be mostly repercussions of the “dry thirties.” It is ex­
pected that a recurrence of “wet years” will recharge the
ground water and general water table difficulties will
vanish until “dry years” come again.
The Board points out, however, that there are local



water table problems which have little or no relation to
hydrological factors but are, in the main, results of ex­
cessive pumpage in industrial areas such as Canton and
the Mill Creek Valley. It is reported that overpumping
can completely obscure the natural effects of rainfall and
its attendant phenomena. City and industrial require­
ments in Canton amount to about 60 million gallons of
water per day. The Youngstown-Warren area provides
an even more striking example of the heavy use of water
by industry. It is estimated that the total flow of the
Mahoning River is recirculated six times daily to meet the
Youngstown-Warren demand. This recirculation during
summer months has raised the temperature of the river
to as high as 130 degrees Fahrenheit.
Reforestation and proper cultural practices on the part
of farmers do have definite beneficial effects on the water
table, according to the Board. However, it is maintained
that though these practices may be very desirable, they
still do not solve the water table problem by themselves,
for rainfall is held to be the dominant factor. In its De­
cember 1943 report, the Board contended that the water
table recession in the 1930’s cannot be interpreted as a
result of modern intensive farming, forest removal, and
kindred practices because there were many similar ex­
tended periods of drouth during the 1880’s, when Ohio
was still largely in forest. According to the records of
Ohio canal commissioners, the ground water was so low
in 1824 and 1825 that it was impossible to operate the
canal system.
Some intimation of the relationship of the Ohio water
COUNTY WATER TABLE CHANGES
Movement in Feet During Nine Months
Ending December 1943

»

Three m o n t h s e n d i n g D e c e m b e r 1 9 4 3 only.

Source:

O h i o W a t e r S u p p l y B o ard

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

table to rainfall can be obtained by comparing the map of
water table changes with the chart of 1943 rainfall and
normal rainfall. If a relationship exists between the two,
the rainfall deficiency of the last five months of 1943
would logically exert an influence on the water table, as­
suming that the lag between cause and effect is no longer
than the period involved. As a matter of fact, 40 of the
42 reporting counties showed lowered water tables as
compared to previous readings (see map).
Eventually, as its information grows in coverage and
accuracy, the Ohio Water Supply Board hopes to correlate
water table and rainfall changes within a small margin of
error. By using rainfall statistics it may be possible at
some future time to predict accurately changes in the
water table and, by this means, effect planned use of
water resources.
Dairy Subsidy As of December 31, subsidy payments to
Payments
fourth district dairy farmers for their GcFor October
tober production amounted to $1,085,441.
Although payments on October production
were still being made during the last week in January,
the number and amount of daily disbursals of the Com­
modity Credit Corporation had dropped rapidly from the
peak period during the first week of December. For this
reason it is felt that the December 31 data represent a
large share of the total which will ultimately be paid out,
and thus comprise representative and adequate informa­
tion on the October disbursements.
Of the total amount $762,676 was paid to Ohio dairy­
men; $59,938, $251,164, and $11,663, respectively, were
paid to dairymen in Kentucky, Pennsylvania and West Vir­
ginia areas of the district. Subsidy claimants within the
AVERAGE SIZE OF OCTORER DAIRY FEED PAYMENTS
(Calculated From Payments Authorized Through December 31)




5

district numbered 97,035, of which 71,916 were in Ohio,
8,791 in Kentucky, 14,986 in Pennsylvania, and 1,342 in
the Panhandle of West Virginia.
The size of individual payments varied widely, ranging
from a low of $1 to more than $100. The average size
of individual payments for the district was $11.19. On
a county average basis Cuyahoga County, Ohio, was high­
est ($36.65 per payment), whereas there were several
counties in Kentucky where no payments were made at
all (see map).
In analyzing individual and county payment data, it
should be remembered that the basis of payment varied
among the areas of the district. In 16 counties in north­
western Ohio milk producers received 30 cents per one
hundred pounds, whereas producers in other Ohio coun­
ties and in Kentucky received 35 cents, and Pennsylvania
and West Virginia producers received 40 cents. Cream
producers received four cents per pound of butterfat in
Ohio and Kentucky and five cents in Pennsylvania and
West Virginia. This lack of uniformity limits somewhat
the interpretations which may be given the data shown
by the map. For example, owing to area differences in
payment per unit of production, the map does not present
an accurate picture of size of dairy units in the various
counties, although it would serve this purpose admirably,
if the basis of payment were uniform throughout the dis­
trict.
Some speculation has developed regarding the propor­
tion of dairy farmers eligible for subsidies who have actu­
ally submitted claims for their October payment. To be
eligible an applicant must be a bona fide dairyman who
has produced for sale during the month a quantity of
milk or cream sufficient to establish a subsidy payment of
$1 or more.
An estimate of the number of eligible dairymen can be
obtained from the Sixteenth Agricultural Census, 1939.
For this purpose the number of farms reporting three or
more cows milked probably provides the best available
estimate of the number of dairymen eligible for sub­
sidies. However, because these data are five years old
and several assumptions underlie their use, they should
be handled with extreme caution and only for areas in­
volving several counties. For such value as they may
have, these data together with actual number of October
subsidy claimants are listed below for areas of the fourth
district.
Number of Farms
Reporting Three
or More Cows
Milked— Census
State of Ohio ............................................. 123,009
Kentucky portion of d is tric t.................
20,012
Pennsylvania portion of district ..........
26,914
West Virginia portion of district..........
2,442
District

.........................................................

Farm Wage
Rates

V/A
$10 - 14.99
$ 1? - 19.99

$20 - 24.99
$ 2 5 and mors
No payments

172,377

Number of Dairymen Who Have
Submitted October
Subsidy Claims
71,916
8,791
14,986
1,342
97,035

Farm wages in the United States averaged
$76 per month last year, an all-time high.
This record, which is on the “without
board” basis, was 30 percent higher than the 1942 aver­
age and 11 percent above the 1920 peak following World
W7ar I. Similar conditions prevailed in the four states
comprising the Fourth Federal Reserve District. As of
January 1944, Ohio and Pennsylvania farm wage rates
“without board” were about 20 percent higher than a year
earlier. Kentucky and West Virginia average rates in­
creased 14 and 9 percent, respectively.
A recognition of the effects of these increasing farm

6

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

wages resulted in a plan of the War Food Administration
to extend government control over farm wage rates where
necessary. According to preliminary reports, the plan,
announced January 22, is to appoint state agricultural
wage boards to hold public hearings and to assist in estab­
lishing specific wage ceilings. They will function sim­
ilarly to the War Labor Boards. Wages and salaries of
agricultural workers earning more than $2,400 a year were
ordered frozen. Regulations were drawn up which pro­
vide that wages cannot be increased without approval of
the WFA. At the same time, the lower limit for any
specific kind of farm labor was set at the highest rate
paid for the labor between January 1 and September 15,
1942.
TRADE
Retail ^S s^own on
accomPanying chart, fourth dis­
trict department store sales increased steadily since
1938, reaching an all-time high last year. Sales at 97 re­
porting stores totaled $482 millions during 1943, and the
annual average index advanced to 166 percent of the
1935-39 base. This was nine percent higher than that
of the previous year and 36 percent over the pre-depression peak of 1929. Twice during 1943 the seasonally
adjusted index rose to over 190 percent of the 1935-39
daily average— in February and November— and dropped
to its lowest level— 151 percent— in April, September, and
again in December, when sales were only three percent
better than those of the same month of 1942. The ad­
justed index declined sharply from November to Decem­
ber, largely as a result of the fact that a substantial por­
tion of gift merchandise was purchased in October and
November.
Year-to-year gains in 1943 showed considerable varia­
tion among leading cities of this district. These increases
ranged from five percent in Cleveland and Pittsburgh to
25 percent for Columbus retailers. Sales in Akron, To­




ledo, and Youngstown were up 14 percent, and in Cin­
cinnati and Canton 11 percent.
Department store business was greater last year than
during 1942 despite the fact that inventories were smaller.
Apparently a large amount of last year’s sales were made
from stocks accumulated the previous year, when the dol­
lar volume of merchandise on hand was the largest on
record. On the average, stocks were 26 percent smaller
during 1943 than 1942, but at year-end were only four
percent less than those of December 31, 1942. The re­
duction in inventories that occurred during December
last year was somewhat less than seasonal. As a result,
the adjusted stocks index for the month advanced five
points to 147 percent of the 1935-39 average. Orders
outstanding at the close of 1943 were over twice as
large as those of the previous year-end.
Women’s apparel and accessories departments sold 24
percent more merchandise last year than in 1942, and
piece goods sales were up 36 percent. In contrast to
these sharp increases, sales of men’s and boys’ clothing
and furnishings were only five percent greater, while the
dollar volume of housefurnishings sold showed a four per­
cent decrease. Retailers reported during the year that
women’s wear and textiles were generally somewhat less
difficult to obtain than articles for the home. Reduced
stocks of many housefurnishings were largely responsible
for the smaller sales of these items last year.
A larger share of merchandise was paid for at the
time of purchase in 1943 than during the previous years;
cash transactions were over one-fourth greater than in
1942. Regular 30-day credit sales were only slightly
larger, while instalment sales were down 19 percent.
During December credit business accounted for 43 per­
cent of total dollar volume at reporting stores, compared
with an average ratio of 53 percent for 1942 and 60
percent for 1941.
Post-holiday buying was slightly smaller this year than
last, when dollar volume was at an unusually high level.
During the first half of the month sales were two per­
cent smaller than those of the corresponding two weeks
of January a year ago.
Wholesale

According to Department o f Commerce re­
ports, sales at 154 wholesale firms in this
district were six percent greater last December than
during the same month of 1942. Sales of metals weye up
47 percent, drugs 26 percent, paper 24 percent, and gro­
ceries four percent. Firms selling paints, dry goods, and
electrical goods reported year-to-year declines in their
business. During 1943 sales at all reporting wholesalers
were up one percent from those of 1942.
During December wholesale inventories were reduced
slightly, but at year-end were 15 percent greater than
those of December 31, 1942.

7

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

Wholesale a n d R etail Trade

Indexes o f D ep a rtm en t Store Sales and Stocks

( 194 1 compa red with 1942)

Daih

Pe r ce nt a ge
Increase or De crease
SALES
SALES
STOCKS
De ce m b e r
Year
D e c em b e r
1943
1941
1943
D E P A R T M E N T S T O R E S (97)
A k r o n ..................................................................................... + 2
+14
C a n t o n ........................................................................... ....... + 2
+11
C i n c i n n a t i .................................................................... ........+ 8
+11
C le v e la n d ..............................................................................-— 3
+ 5
C o l u m b u s ..................................................................... ........+ 1 6
+25
E r i e .................................................................................. ........+ 1
+10
P i t t s b u r g h ............................................................................+ 3
+ 5
S p rin g fie ld ........................................................................... + 5
+24
T o l e d o ............................................................................ ....... + 8
+14
W h e e l i n g .............................................................................. + 1 6
+15
+14
Y o u n g s t o w n ....................................................................... + 1 1
O th e r C i t i e s ............................................................... ....... — 2
+ 1
D i s t r i c t ..................................................................................+ 3
+ 9
W E A R I N G A P P A R E L (16)
C a n t o n ........................................................................... ........+ 1 4
+26
C i n c i n n a t i .................................................................... ........+ 4
+13
C l e v e la n d ..............................................................................+ 7
+20
P i t t s b u r g h ............................................................................+ 3 7
+35
Ot he r C it ie s ........................................................................+ 6
+27
D i s t r i c t .......................................................................... ........+ 1 2
+24
F U R N I T U R E (00)
— 2
C a n t o n ........................................................................... .......— 9
C i n c i n n a t i .................................................................... .......— 16
-0C le v e la n d .............................................................................— 13
-0C o l u m b u s ..................................................................... ....... - 0 + 8
D a y t o n .................................................................................. -— 45
— 21
— 5
P i t t s b u r g h ........................................................................... — 6
T o l e d o ............................................................................ ....... — 2
+ 9
O t h e r C i t i e s .......................................................................— 15
— 2
D i s t r i c t .......................................................................... .......— 11
— 2
C H A IN S T O R E S *
Dr ug s— D i s t ri c t ( 5 ) ............................................... .......+ 7
+13
G roceries — D i s t ri c t ( 4 ) ................................... ....... + 1 3
+15
W HOLESALE T R A D E **
+ 5
A ut o m o t iv e Supplies ( 8 ) .......................................... + 1 6
B e e r ( 4 ) ...................... . . ........................................... ....... + 3 0
+23
a
Clo th in g and Fur nis hi ngs ( 3 ) .......................... .......+ 1 5
Dru gs and D r u g Sundries ( 5 ) .................................+ 2 6
+20
D r y Goods ( 3 ) ........................................................... .......— 13
+11
— 35
E le c tr ic a l Goods ( 1 0 ) ...................................................— 15
F r e s h Fr ui ts and Vege ta bl es ( 6 ) .................... .......+ 2 3
+19
G r o c e r y Gro u p ( 3 6 ) ......................................................+ 4
+10
T o t a l H ard w are G ro u p ( 2 8 ) ....................................— 5
— 7
G en era l H ar dw ar e ( 7 ) ............................................+ 4
— 9
Indu str ia l Supplies ( 1 1 ) ................................. .......— 14
— 7
Plu mb in g & H ea t in g Supplies ( 1 0 ) . . . .
— 7
— 6
Je w e lr y ( 3 ) ................................................................. ....... + 2 4
a
M e a t s and M e a t Pr od uc ts ( 4 ) ............................... + 1 4
— 3
M e t a ls ( 3 ) .................................................................... ....... + 4 7
a
— 6
P a in t s and Varn ish es ( 4 ) .................................... .......— 13
P a p er and its Pr od uc ts ( 6 ) ............................... .......+ 2 4
+ 3
T o b a c c o and its Pr odu ct s ( 1 4 ) ....................... ....... — 8
+ 4
Miscellaneous ( 1 7 ) .........................................................+ 5
-0D is tr ic t— All Who lesa le T r a d e ( 1 5 4 ) .................+ 6
+ 1
* P e r individual unit ope rated.
* * Wh olesale da ta compiled b y U. S. D e p a r t m e n t of Co m m e rc e ,
of the Census.
a N ot av ailable.
Figures in par entheses indica te n um b e r of firms rep or ti ng sales.

— 1
a
-0— 8
+16
— 9
— 9
a
-0+ 8
a
-— 1
— 4
+ 8
— 24
— 4
+ 8
+16
-0— 31
— 32
— 39
— 22
a
— 41
— 21
— 27
— 33
a
a
— 9
— 70
a
+11
a
+ 2
+19
+24
— 3
— 3
— 10
+22
a
+57
a
a
a
+ 1
+18
+15

B a n k De b it s (2 4 c i t i e s ) ............................................
C om m e rc ia l Failu res ( N u m b e r ) ..........................
”
( L i a b i l i t i e s ) ......................
Sales— Life Ins ur a n ce (O. and P a . ) ..................
” — D e p a r t m e n t S to res (9 7 f i r m s ) .............
” — Wh olesale Drugs (5 f ir m s ) ..................
” —
”
D r y Goods (3 f i r m s ) .............
” —
”
G roce ries (3 6 f i r m s ) ............
” -—
”
H ar dw ar e ( 2 8 f i r m s ) ...........
” —
”
All (7 2 f i r m s ) ...........................
” — C ha in Drugs (5 f i r m s ) * ..........................
” — C ha in Groc eri es (4 f i r m s ) .....................
Building C o n t r a c t s ( T o t a l ) ....................................
”
( R e s i d e n t i a l ) .......................
Pro du ct io n— Coal (O., W . P a . , E . K y . ) . . . .
— Cement ( 0 ., W . Pa., E . K y . ) * *
”
— E le c . Po w er (O., P a . , K y . ) * * . .
”
— P e tr o le u m (O., Pa . , K y . ) * * . . .
”
— S h o e s ......................................................
* Pe r individual u ni t ope rated.
* * N ov em be r.




Dec.
1942
215
43
53
89
252
176
129
126
203
147
23 0
155
179
124
137
177
174
95
91

Dec.
1941
194
65
30
157
232
167
128
116
248
147
181
138
140
247
142
165
154
91
104

De c .
1939
128
52
43
90
195
124
99
100
129
98
139
115
122
153
113
133
124
102
79

134

163

307
329
249
253
267
312
229
343
253
217
257
252
139

186
171
151
147
163
166
137
193
155
119
167
151

232
241
179
205
212
245
176
254
203
166
209
193

182
168
139
152
141
164
134
181
144
104
151
146

147

142

153

D ebits to Individual A cco un ts

C o l u m b u s ..........
C ovingto nNewport . . . ,

Dec.
1940
153
64
98
101
2 06
134
106
95
164
113
110
113
118
155
122
151
133
90
87

262
273
215
213
242
262
188
272
221
174
226
212

for
Adi
Seasonal V a riation
Dec.
Nov.
Dec.
1942
1943
1943

( 0 0 0 om it t e d )
Fo u rt h D is tri ct Unless
Dec.
% cha nge
Jan.-D ec.
% change
Otherwise Specified
1943
from 1942
1943
from 1942
B a n k De b it s— 24 c i t i e s ................3 5 , 0 9 9 ,0 0 0
+ 7
52 , 3 1 1 ,0 0 0 + 1 7
Savings Deposits— end of m o nt h:
39 ban ks O. and W . P a ............... 3
943,746
+16
...................
Life Ins. Sales— Ohio and P a . . . 3
92 ,6 43
+23
1, 01 6 ,0 9 7
+13
R e t a il Sales:
De pt. Stores— 97 fi rm s ............. 3
64 , 1 6 5
+ 3
4 8 2, 2 41
+ 9
W ea rin g Apparel— 16 f i r m s . . . 3
2 ,6 8 0
+12
21 , 5 6 2
+24
Fur nit ur e— 78 f irm s.....................3
3 , 22 9
— 11
3 3 ,6 2 2
— 2
Bu ilding C o n t ra c t s — T o t a l . . . . 3
24,1 21
— 45
270,079
— 63
” — Reside nt ia l 3
6,3 03
■
— 34
10 0 ,7 0 9
— 39
C om me rci al Failu res—
Li a b i li t i e s .......................................3
147
— 81
2,9 02
— 49
C om me rci al Failures— N u m b e r .
6
— 79
158
— 67
Pr od uc ti on :
Pig Iro n— U. S ............... N e t tons
5,213
-061 ,7 77
+ 3
Steel In go t— U. S .......... N e t tons
7,266
— 1
88,8 73
+ 3
Bi tum ino us Coal— O., W . P a. ,
E . K y ............................ N e t tons
1 9 ,3 52
+13
21 8, 77 1
— 1
C e m e n t — O., W. Pa ., W. Va.
................................................. .... Bb ls .
753a — 48
1 0, 83 1b
— 26
Ele c.
Po w e r— O.,
Pa .,
K y.
..................................T h o u s. k.w.h.
3 ,0 72 a
+16
3 1 ,3 22 b
+13
Pe tro le u m — O., P a . , K y . . . B b ls .
2, 2 4 4 a
+ 7
24,795b
+ 5
Shoes ......................................... Pa i r s
c
— 2
c
— 12
B i tu m in ou s Coal Sh ip m e n t s:
L. E . P o r t s ....................... N e t tons
1,077
+34
4 7 ,4 5 5
— 4
a November
c Confidential
b January-N ovem ber

A k r o n ................
B u t l e r ................
C a n t o n .............
C in c in na ti

( 1 9 3 5 - 3 9 = 100)

314
335
26<i
245
30 9
316
235
364
273
25 0
284
26 0

inn

F o u rth D istrict B usiness Statistics

Bu re a u

F o u rth D istrict B usin ess In dexes
Dec.
1943
23 0
9
10
110
260
22 2
112
131
192
151
246
166
99
82
154
91
20 2
102
89

SALES:
Akron ( 6 ) .............
C a nt on ( 5 ) ..........
C in c in na ti (9) .
C leveland (10) . .
Col um bu s (5) . .
Er ie ( 3 ) ...................
P i t t s b u rg h ( 8 ) . .
Springfield ( 3 ) . . .
To le do ( 6 ) ..........
W he eli ng ( 6 ) . . .
Yo u ng sto w n ( 3 ) .
D is t r i c t (97)
STO CKS:
D is tr ic t ( 5 1 ) . . . .

Average for 19 35 -1 939 «
W it hou t
Seasonal A djustment
De r.
Nov.
Dec.
1942
1943
1943

De ce m b e r
1943
189,8 21
18,142
82 ,8 42
637,920
1, 3 8 2 ,8 5 6
351 , 9 6 7

24 , 7 1 6
159, 66 4
71 , 4 7 0
6 , 50 7
13 ,057
G re e n sb u r g . . .
22 ,175
5 , 37 0
H om estead.. .
57 ,1 79
Lexingto n.
28,219
8 , 61 0
L o r a i n ...............
20,858
22,328
Middletow n. .
15, 522
Oil C i t y ...........
P i t t s b u r g h . . . . 1 , 5 3 1 ,1 7 0
Portsm outh. .
1 1 ,7 90
1 6, 646
S h a r o n ................
35,04 1
Springfield
14,112
St eu ben vil le . .
285,858
25,076
47,067
86,7 43
Y o u n g s t o w n . ..
13,29 5
T o t a l ............... 5 ,1 8 6 ,0 2 1
a N o t available.

(T ho us a n ds of Dollars)
% cha nge
Jan.-D ec.
fro m 1942
1943
+ 11.3
2 ,1 10, 301
+ 14.3
189,121
+ 12.7
886 ,0 42
6, 99 4 ,0 0 9
— 1.2
14 ,2 3 0 ,0 9 6
+ 7.6
3 .5 1 9 ,0 6 7
+ 8.0

Jan.-D ec.
1942
1,5 69 ,5 86
160,8 22
775,431
6 , 2 8 4 ,2 5 0
11,85 2,10 5
2, 998,035

a
1,694,421
730,873
63 , 6 3 2
129, 582
243,593
57,318
3 98 ,9 88
29 2 , 1 8 0
87 ,9 78
a
2 4 0 ,7 5 4
187,6 54
1 5 ,1 0 4 ,7 4 7
a
1 8 2, 6 84
3 82 ,1 2 2
153,0 59
2 , 8 3 4 ,5 5 7
286,864
4 7 7, 29 1
992,036
15 3 ,9 1 7
5 2 , 6 2 2 ,8 8 6

a
1,382,023
59 2, 11 8
56 ,7 28
125, 038
21 8, 50 2
56,80 8
36 3 , 6 5 6
280, 041
8 1 ,8 5 6
a
224,391
16 2. 179
13 ,1 2 7 ,2 5 7
a
16 8 ,9 1 8
3 09 ,5 97
14 2 ,5 6 7
2 , 4 6 8 ,7 3 4
25 2, 68 1
3 9 1 ,4 9 9
8 8 2 ,4 7 2
137,0 15
4 5 , 0 6 4 ,3 0 9

+ 7.4
+ 10.6
+ 2 0 .3
+ 1 7 .7
+ 1 6 .9
+ 4.7
— 1.2
— 10.2
— 32.8
+ 11.2
+ 1 1 .9
+ 1 4 .6
— 5.9
+ 7.7
+ 7.5
+ 9.8
+ 11.9
+ 2.9
+ 18.4
— 3.6
+ 18.1
+ 6.8
+ 1 4 .4
+ 7.0

% change
from 1942
+ 3 4 .4
+ 1 7 .6
+ 1 4 .3
+ 1 1 .3

+ 20.1
+ 1 7 .4

+22.6
+ 12.2

+ 2 3 .4

+ 3.6
+ 1 1 .5
+ 0.9
+ 9.7
+ 4.3
+ 7.5
a
+ 7.3
+ 15.7
+ 1 5 .1
a

+

8.1

+ 2 3 .4
+ 7.4
+ 1 4 .8
+ 13.5
+ 2 1 .9
+ 1 2 .4
+ 1 2 .3
+ 1 6 .8

8

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

S u m m a ry o f N ational B usiness C onditions
By the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System
IN D U S T R IA L PRODUCTION

Industrial activity declined slightly in Decem ber from the record levels
reached in preceding months. Prices of commodities at retail showed little change
and distribution was maintained in large volume.

Industrial production

Federal reserve indexes. Groups are expressed in
terms of points in the total index. Monthly figures,
latest shown are for December 1943.
DEP A R T M EN T S T O R E S A L E S AND S T O C K S

Federal Reserve indexes. Monthly figures, latest
shown are for December for sales, and November
for stocks.
C O S T OF LIVIN G

The Board’s seasonally adjusted index of industrial production, which had
been at 247 per cent of the 1935-39 average in O ctober and November, declined
to 245 in December, reflecting largely decreases in output of steel and chemicals.
Steel production dropped 6 per cent in Decem ber to the same rate as in
Decem ber 1942. Output for the year, however, totaled 88.9 million tons, which
was 2.8 million tons larger than the year before. Activity in the transportation
equipment and machinery industries was maintained in Decem ber at a high level.
The number of aircraft accepted during the month was slightly larger than in
November and was at approximately the average monthly rate scheduled for 1944.
The average weight of planes to be produced, however, will continue to increase.
Deliveries of merchant vessels in Decem ber were the largest on record, bringing the
total for the year to 19,238,626 deadweight tons, as compared with 8,089,732 tons
in 1942. Lum ber production in the last two months of 1943 was above the level of
a year ago in contrast to the first 10 months of 1943 when output averaged 10 per
cent below the same period in 1942.
Activity in the chemical industry declined 5 per cent in Decem ber, reflecting a
large reduction in output of small arms ammunition in accordance with plans of
the armed forces. Cotton consumption declined further in Decem ber to a level 13
per cent below Decem ber 1942. Newsprint consumption declined seasonally. Fur­
ther restrictions on its use, as well as on the use of printing paper in books and
magazines, were made effective January 1, 1944, owing to inadequate supplies of
pulpwood. Output in the petroleum refining and rubber products industries increased
further.
Crude petroleum production showed little change in Decem ber and output of
coal was restored to a high level. Bituminous coal production for the year exceeded
1942 output by 1.6 per cent. Iron ore production continued to decline seasonally
in Decem ber and output for the year was approximately 4 per cent below 1942.
The value of construction contracts awarded in Decem ber, according to reports
of the F. W . Dodge Corporation, was greater than in recent months, reflecting
mainly increased Federal awards for manufacturing and other nonresidential buildings.

Distribution
Decem ber department store sales were slightly larger than a year ago and
combined with November sales were 11 per cent larger than in the corresponding
months last year. For the year 1943 total value of sales reached a new peak— about
12 per cent larger than 1942 and 55 per cent larger than 1939. Sales during the
first two weeks of January were about the same as last year.
Railway freight traffic in Decem ber and the first part of January was unusually
heavy for this season. For 1943 total freight carloadings were about the same as in
1942. Shipments of grain and livestock averaged about 20 per cent above 1942,
while loadings of ore, forest products, and less-than-carload-lot freight averaged 8
per cent lower.

Commodity prices

Bureau of Labor Statistics’ indexes. Last month
in each calendar quarter through September 1940,
monthly thereafter. Mid-month figures, latest
shown are for December 1943.
M E M B E R SA N K R E S E R V E S A N D R E L A T E D IT E M S

Wednesday figures, latest shown are for January

19, 1944.



W holesale prices of agricultural and industrial commodities showed little change
from the middle of Decem ber to the middle of January and the general index of
the Bureau of Labor Statistics remained at 103 per cent of the 1926 average.
Retail food prices declined slightly from mid-November to m id-December,
while other groups of cost-of-living items increased and the total index advanced .2
to 124.4 per cent of the 1935-39 average.

Bank credit
During the latter part of Decem ber and the first two weeks of January excess
reserves at all member banks were maintained at an average level close to 1.1
billion dollars. Purchases of Government securities by the Federal Reserve Banks
offset the effect on reserves of increases in nonmember deposits at the Reserve Banks
and the increase in currency in circulation. The System portfolio of Government
securities increased by 900 million dollars in the five weeks ending January 19. After
allowance for expected seasonal movements, currency in circulation increased less
in Decem ber than in November but there was little post-Christmas return flow.
Loans and investments of reporting member banks in 101 leading cities, which
had been decreasing steadily since late October, declined by an additional 620
million dollars during the five weeks ended January 19. A large part of the decline
reflected sales of Government securities, principally Treasury bills, to the Federal
Reserve Banks. Holdings of United States Government securities were reduced by
370 million dollars. Total loans declined by 230 million dollars, representing
reductions in loans to banks, in commercial and industrial loans, and in “other” loans,
mainly instalment credit. Adjusted demand deposits, which had increased sharply
from the middle of October to the middle of Decem ber, declined somewhat over
the year-end, but increased again in the first half of January. United States
Government deposits at banks continued to decline.