View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
Covering financial, industrial, and agricultural conditions
in the

Fourth Federal Reserve District
Federal Reserve Bank o f Cleveland
Vol. 16

Cleveland, Ohio, January 31, 1934

In the latter part of December and the first three
weeks o f January general business in the fourth district
showed a degree o f improvement. Usually at this season
there is no marked trend discernible in business activity
because o f the irregularities resulting from holiday in­
terruptions, inventory-taking, and year-end adjustments.
In comparison with a year ago, current conditions in
practically all lines show a marked change fo r the bet­
ter. The number o f unemployed has been reduced to
quite an extent, though the situation is still in need of
further improvement. Pay rolls at industrial concerns
were up sharply from a year ago and the combined effect
of the increased distribution of wages to industrial w ork­
ers and o f Government funds through the various federal
channels is reflected in retail and wholesale lines.
Department store sales in this district in December had
a 14.4 per cent greater dollar value than in the closing
month o f 1932. W earing apparel store sales were up 15
per cent and furniture store sales 38 per cent in the
same period. Part o f these gains represented higher
prices, but the expansion from November was greater
than seasonal and in the last two months o f 1933 there
was little change in retail prices reported.
Further
marked improvement in retail trade circles was evident
in January. Sales of Cleveland reporting stores in the
first three weeks were 36.7 per cent higher in dollar vol­
ume than in early 1933 and the number o f transactions
was up 28.7 per cent in the same period.
In late December, operations in the iron and steel in­
dustry were expected to contract rather sharply in Janu­
ary since much of the steel shipped prior to the year
end was thought to be for stock-piles. The falling-off,
however, was slight and o f short duration, fo r in midJanuary operations in most steel centers o f this district
expanded and the industry was turning out steel at double
the rate of January, 1933. The expansion resulted from
increased demand from automobile and allied industries
and miscellaneous steel users. W ork on railroad steel
has encountered delays, but orders fo r structural mate­
rial have improved slightly.
The automobile industry experienced more than the
usual delays resulting from model changes. This adverse­
ly affected operations at parts, accessory and other allied
plants in December, but in recent weeks a marked im­
provement in these lines became apparent as rush orders




No. 1

for materials were received.
Tire production has ex­
panded and glass output has increased.
In the building industry contracts awarded in Decem­
ber were valued at over $30,000,000 in this district. This
was about six times as large as a year ago and was near­
ly double the November total. In the first half of January
a further increase was recorded. By far the greater part
of the contracts awarded was in the public works cate­
gory and represented allotment of federal funds.
The paint industry enjoyed a gain in sales in late De­
cember and the first half of January which was not sea­
sonal.
Production also was increased.
Clothing fac­
tories in mid-January were operating at capacity levels
permitted by the code and the number o f employees was
much greater than a year ago. Advance sales o f spring
goods were reported to be much larger than in early 1933.
Electric power production in the Central Industrial
region in the week ended January 20 was 13 per cent
greater than in the corresponding period o f 1932. Ex­
cluding the R ocky Mountain region, this was the largest
gain reported in the entire country. F or the last four
weeks, gains in this section have exceeded 13 per cent.
The accompanying chart shows the week-by-week com ­
parison of electric power production in this area with the
same period of the preceding year, for the past three
months.
FINANCIAL
Relatively few changes over the year end and in the
first three weeks o f January were evident in the condi-

2

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

tion o f weekly reporting member banks and of the Fed­
eral Reserve Bank o f Cleveland. The temporary Fund
of the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation became op­
erative on January 1. As a result, the surplus fund of
the Federal Reserve Bank o f Cleveland was reduced by
50 per cent, or over $14,000,000, fo r the reserve banks
were required by law to subscribe one half their surplus
in the Corporation’s stock. All licensed banks in this dis­
trict were accepted as members in the Corporation, and
while the period o f operation has been too short to per­
mit any conclusions, reports that considerable old-size
currency and money o f large denominations are being
received at banks might indicate that some hoards are
being returned to circulation.
Savings deposits at selected banks throughout the fourth
district increased 0.5 per cent in December, but at the
year end were still 5.4 per cent smaller than at the close
of 1932. A slight reduction in savings deposits occurred
in Western Pennsylvania banks in the latest month, but
this was offset by gains in Ohio centers.
Bank debits to individual accounts at 24 cities in the
fourth district in December were 1.1 per cent smaller
than in December, 1932. In the four weeks ended Janu­
ary 24 bank debits were down 1.8 per cent in these cen­
ters, while in the entire year 1933 a reduction of nine
per cent in debits was shown.
L ife insurance sales in Ohio and Pennsylvania in De­
cember were less than one per cent smaller than in De­
cember, 1932, whereas the entire year showed a drop of
nine per cent in the value o f new life insurance policies
written.
There were only 90 commercial failures reported in
the fourth district in December, according to R. G. Dun
and Company, a reduction of 54 per cent from December,
1932. Liabilities of the defaulting concerns were down
81 per cent in the same period, while in the year 1933
the number o f failures and their liabilities were down
approximately 42 per cent in this district from 1932.

Reserve Bank
Credit

In the five weeks ended January 24
there was an increase of about $14,000,000 in gold reserves o f this bank
and in the past year these reserves have advanced over
$60,000,000, partly a result of transfers o f funds from
other districts following the discontinuance of interest pay­
ments on demand deposits.

millions
OF DOLLARS

200

MEMBER FOURTH
BANKDISTRICT
RESERVES

____

RESERVE CITY
I

COUNTRY BANKS

BANKS

□ R E Q U IR E D

I REQUIRED RESERVES

®EXCESS

■

RESERVES

excess

re s e rv e s

Member Bank
Credit

re s e rv e s

150

100

On January 24 the total volume o f bills and securities
held by the Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland was prac­
tically unchanged from the third week o f December, but
at $232,000,000, they compared with $198,474,000 on
January 25, 1933.
In the four latest weeks there was little change in the
volume o f bills discounted, acceptances held, or Govern­
ment securities owned. In contrast with early 1933, however,
there was a reduction of about $20,000,000 in bills dis­
counted. In recent weeks discounts for member banks
have fluctuated around $7,000,000, the lowest level since
the early days of the Federal Reserve System. Acceptances
held, at $12,357,000, were about $10,000,000 higher than
in early 1933. Holdings o f these acceptances have been
higher recently than since 1931.
There has been no
change in the volume of Government securities owned
by this bank since early November, but in contrast with
January, 1933, an increase o f approximately $45,000,000
was apparent.
In the five latest weeks there was a decline of about
$10,000,000 in note circulation o f this bank; this was
entirely seasonal and was slightly smaller than in cor­
responding periods o f recent years. This less-than-seasonal post-holiday decline may be partly explained by the
increased distribution o f funds through Civil W orks A d­
ministration channels. In the first 24 days o f January
there were approximately 1,500,000 o f these checks
handled by this bank and its branches. Averaging slight­
ly more than $15 apiece, somewhat more than $20,000,000 has gone into circulation locally in this manner. Com­
pared with a year ago, note and bank note circulation was
up about $30,000,000 in the latter part o f January, but in
view o f the total volume o f business being done, and the
higher prices now prevailing, the increase is not without
reason.
Member bank reserve deposits increased about $23,000,000 in the five latest weeks to the highest point, as shown
by the weekly figures, since 1927. The gain in recent
weeks represented in part an increase in the number of
member banks, but excess reserves were up sharply in
the period. As shown on the accompanying chart daily
average required reserves o f both reserve city and country
banks increased slightly in December, from November, but
actual reserves, and therefore excess reserves, were up
sharply in the period. Excess reserves o f reserve city
banks increased from about $20,000,000 in November
to $39,000,000 in December.
Country bank excess re­
serves increased only slightly in the latest month, but
were 50 per cent more than were required.

■nHlin.1
DEFICIENCY
OF RESERVES

50

JUN

AUG

OCT

nhnnn

DEC APR

JUN

AUG

OCT

DEC

____________ 1933 ____________________________________________ 1933 _______________________




There was a decline in the total volume
o f credit extended by weekly reporting
member banks in the fourth district in
the five weeks ended January 24. The reduction of $33,000,000, or three per cent, in the period was due to a
drop o f $12,000,000 in loans and discounts and of $21,000,000 in total investments. Holdings o f Government
securities were reduced from $465,000,000 on December
20 to $448,000,000 on January 24, while investments in
other securities were reduced about $4,000,000 in the
period.
In the same five-week interval demand deposits increased

TfeEE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
from $530,000,000 to $552,000,000, and on the latest date
they were higher than since July, 1933. Time deposits in
the same period showed only a minor increase.
Year-end condition figures o f all member banks in the
fourth district were received recently and a tabulation of
principal items is shown below, compared with figures
for October 25 and December 31, 1932.
All Member Banks— Fourth District
(000 omitted)

% change
1933 from
Dec. 31,
1932
1932
$1,538,174
— 32.9

Dec. 30,
1933*$
Loans and Discounts ........... $1,032,617
Investments—
672,998
U. S. Gov't. Securities...... .
392,229
All Other Securities...........

Oct. 25,
1933$
$1,050,177
658,826
388,721

591,260
513,836

+13.8
—23.7

$2,097,844

$2,097,724

$2,643,270

—20.6

773,270
896,017
137,634
104,951

857,716
968,704
57,071

993,030
1,243,425
32,525

—22.1
—27.9
+ 323.2

,.$2,101,918

$2,047,937

$2,538,952

— 17.2

549

509

630

— 12.9

Total Loans and Investments

Government Deposits ...........

Number o f Banks ................
♦Preliminary.
^Licensed banks only.

In the year 1933, as shown above, there was a reduction of
about 13 per cent in the number of operating banks in the
fourth district which were members of the Federal Reserve
System. Numerous member banks are still in process of
reorganization, but at the year end they were conducting
business only on a very restricted basis. The same pe­
riod showed a reduction o f 17 per cent in total deposits of
member banks.
(Demand and time deposits on the two
dates were not strictly comparable because of the new
deposit classification; in condition reports prior to Decem­
ber 31, 1933, public funds were included either in demand
or time deposits). Total loans and investments were down
20 per cent in the year, the 33 per cent decline in loans
being offset in part by the 14 per cent increase in hold­
ings of Government securities.

MANUFACTURING, MINING
Iron and
Steel

Increased support from automotive and
general steel consumers in mid-January
caused steel production to advance from
30 to 35 per cent of capacity, although a slight reaction de­
veloped in the closing week o f the month.
A con­
siderable part of the raw steel output in some sections
was for stock piles— in preparation fo r an expansion in
finished steel demand which makers feel is about to de­
velop—but operations also have been increased because of
an inflow of orders from manufacturing industries.
Steelworks operations in the third week o f January in
the Cleveland-Lorain district advanced five points to 59
per cent of capacity; this compared with 57 in the third
week of December and represented a sizeable increase
from the early January level. At Pittsburgh production
was at 24 per cent, up three points in the latest week,
but slightly below the late December level. Youngstown
mills were working at 37 per cent, up 11 points in the
latest week, and at approximately the same level as in the
closing weeks of 1933.
In the last half o f December the steel industry was
rushing shipments to complete fourth quarter contracts




at a rate somewhat in excess of manufacturing require­
ments at that time because prices on first quarter de­
liveries were somewhat higher than on fourth quarter
shipments. It was generally expected in December that
a sizeable reduction in steel orders would develop in early
January to permit stock assimilation. Actually, however,
this was less pronounced than expected. Autom otive as­
sembly schedules were stepped up follow ing favorable
reception of the new models and the overcom ing of me­
chanical difficulties incident to the model changeovers.
As a result steel requirements have expanded and finish­
ing mill operations have increased. Steel salesmen in
the Cleveland district report that new orders so far this
month are larger than in the corresponding period of
December.
W ork on railroad materials has encountered delays,
but the continued authorization o f loans by the Public
W orks Administration fo r purchase o f railroad supplies
indicates that fabrication o f a considerable volum e of
this material is expected shortly by the trade.
In building construction, total weekly steel awards have
mounted, and recently have included some substantial in­
dustrial building projects, long held in abeyance. The
requirements o f these three consumers— railroads, build­
ing construction and automotive, appear to be heading
toward a combined large-scale demand in early spring.
Prices are firm, and the trend is upward. Scrap, some­
times barometrical, has advanced for six consecutive
weeks, Steel’s scrap price composite rising in this period
$1.75 to $11.08.
Daily average steel ingot production for December, re­
ported at 72,786 gross tons, was 22.6 per cent higher
than in November. The m onth’s total of 1,819,648 tons
brought the output for last year to 22,878,571 tons, com­
pared with 13,322,833 tons in 1932, and 25,192,715 tons
in 1931.
Daily average pig iron production in December was
38,456 gross tons, 6.4 per cent higher than November.
The total for the month, 1,192,136 tons, brought the out­
put for the year to 13,221,707 tons, 52.3 per cent over
1932. A t the year’s close 74 stacks were active, three less
than on November 30.

Coal

Production of bituminus coal at fourth
district mines in December was at a
slightly lower rate than in November
or in the closing month of 1932. The decline from No­
vember, amounting to 6.4 per cent, was a little more than
seasonal, but compared with December, 1932, output was
down only 0.7 per cent. In the entire year, however, pro­
duction of local mines was up 13.4 per cent from the
preceding period, the first year-to-year gain since 1929.
This was considerably larger than the increase o f 5.9
per cent in coal production in the entire country in the
same period.
Shipments o f coal from Lake Erie ports, amounting
to 32,333,000 tons in the past season, a gain of 28 per
cent from 1932, were one of the reasons for the propor­
tionately larger output of coal in the fourth district than
in the entire country. Another factor was the increased
activity at steel plants which was evident in the consump­
tion of gas and steam coal and also in the substantial

4

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

increase in consumption of coking coal by both by-product
and beehive ovens.
In early January, weekly production exceeded 1933 by
about ten per cent and early 1932 slightly. Producers
in this district reported conditions much improved from
a year ago. Stocks of coal, in terms of days supply at
the current rate o f consumption, were smaller than a
year ago. Prices have increased, and wages are higher,
but many companies are only operating a few days a week
despite the improvement.
Automobiles

In the last half o f January a sharp in­
crease occurred in automobile assem­
blies, the weekly index of production
advancing to a level slightly above a year ago and to the
highest point since late October, after allowing for sea­
sonal changes.
Gains in production were reported by
most companies, but two of the m ajor low-priced car manu­
facturers were responsible for most of the increased out­
put.
Gradually the difficulties encountered coincident with
model changes have been overcome, but some makers have
turned out very few cars, the models displayed at the vari­
ous shows being partly hand-made. Attendance at the
recent exhibitions was unusually large and reports of or­
ders received were very gratifying, both to dealers and
manufacturers. Judging by the weekly figures, however,
January output will not reach the height it was expected
to at the turn o f the year, but parts makers in this dis­
trict are operating at rates indicating a further expansion
at assembly plants in the near future.
Autom obile production in December totaled 84,045 cars
and trucks. This was a decline of 21.7 per cent from the
closing month o f 1932, but represented a gain o f 31.2
per cent from the low level of November. The rise was
greater than seasonal; the Federal Reserve Board’s ad­
justed index rose six points to 38 per cent of the 1923-25
monthly average. A year ago this index was 60.
It is interesting to note that the contraction in recent
months was confined chiefly to the passenger car field.
In December there were 53,900 passenger cars turned out.
This compared with 86,149 units in December, 1932, a
drop o f 37.4 per cent, but represented a gain from the
unusually low level of 44,429 units produced in November.
For the entire year, 1,606,703 passenger cars and taxicabs
were made in the United States, a gain o f 41,5 per cent
from 1932.
Truck production in December reached 30,145 units,
a gain o f 42 per cent from the preceding year and of over
50 per cent from November. In the entire year 352,498
trucks were assembled, a gain o f 50 per cent from 1932.
Although 1,959,201 cars and trucks were made in the
entire year, a gain o f 42.9 per cent cent from 1932, there
was a reduction in the number o f cars in operation in
the entire country in 1933, as evidenced by motor vehicle
registrations which totaled 23,720,000 units. The drop was
1.7 per cent compared with 6.6 per cent in 1932. In the
peak year, 1929, there were 26,545,281 cars registered.
R ubber
Tires

Tire manufacturers in this district reported an increase in production in
January which would put it about 30
per cent above the level o f the last two months in 1933




and considerably ahead of January, 1933. Output for the
past few months has been somewhat in excess of shipments,
but this is partly seasonal and sales have been larger than
a year ago in every one of the last six months.
Inventories in hands o f manufacturers on December 1,
however, were larger than since early 1932 and, at the
rate of present consumption, represented 4.2 m onths’ sup­
ply. The increase in stocks in recent months accompanied
the sharp reduction in automobile production prior to
the introduction of new m odels; this apparently was a
contributing factor to the rise in stocks, but replacement
tire demand also receded in the closing part o f 1933. On
December 1, 1933, tire stocks were 24 per cent higher
than a year earlier, according to the report o f the
Rubber Manufacturers’ Association.
This same report, covering November, indicates that
output in that period was 31.9 per cent greater than in
the corresponding month o f 1932 and shipments were up
28 per cent.
Rubber consumed in the United States in December,
1933, amounted to 29,087 long tons, approximately the
same as in November, but was 61.2 per cent greater than
in the closing month o f 1932. In the entire year 405,689
tons of rubber were used in the United States, compared
with 332,000 tons in 1932.
Rubber imports in December totaled 42,099 tons, some­
what in excess of consumption in the period, but this
situation did not prevail in the earlier months o f 1933,
for stocks o f rubber on hand at the year end were esti­
mated at 364,541 tons, compared with 388,229 tons at
the close o f 1932. Inventories had a much higher value,
however, for crude rubber in early January was quoted
at 9.8 cents a pound, compared with less than four cents
in early 1932.
Employment at Ohio rubber factories in December av­
eraged 1.6 per cent less than in November, a slightly
greater than seasonal decline.
Compared with a year
ago, however, the number employed was up 34 per cent
and for the entire year 1933 averaged 13.7 per cent above
the year 1932.
Clothing

In mid-January most clothing manufac­
turers, according to reports, were oper­
ating full time, i.e., 35 hours a week,
and in many plants the number o f employees was much
larger than a year ago. Production on spring goods is
well under way and, on the basis o f orders received, should
continue for some time. Salesmen have booked a con­
siderably larger volume o f orders, both in units and on
a dollar basis, than in the corresponding period o f last
year. Dollar sales are reported to be up anywhere from
40 to 100 per cent, but the gain in units is somewhat
less than this, because o f the increase in prices from
last year at this time.
According to the Ohio State University Bureau o f Busi­
ness Research, employment at 41 textile and clothing con­
cerns in Ohio declined 5.4 per cent in December from the
preceding month, somwhat more than seasonal.
Com­
pared with a year ago, however, the number o f employees
was up 6.3 per cent and fo r the entire year averaged 15.8
per cent higher than in 1932.
Retail sales o f clothing in December improved materially
and stocks of clothing were considerably reduced. Sales

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
of women’s ready-to-wear were 17.2 per cent larger in
December than a year ago, and men’s clothing sales were
up 22 per cent in the same period at fourth district re­
porting stores, but in both cases part o f the gains repre­
sented price increases.
Other
Manufacturing

Most of the smaller manufacturing lines
in the fourth district reported a gain
in operations in the first part of Janu­
ary which either exceeded or was contrary to the seasonal
change of past years. The general situation was much
improved from a year ago, employment, pay rolls and
sales all showing sizeable gains.
Autom obile Parts and Accessories. Conditions in the au­
tom obile parts and accessory industry in early January
were much improved from a year earlier. Sales in Janu­
ary were estimated by various firms to be from 30 to 65
per cent ahead of January, 1933, with a corresponding in­
crease in employment and a somewhat larger gain in pay
rolls. Orders for materials were placed later than usual
and the demands for early shipments caused operations at
local plants to be increased sharply. In December the
number employed at 35 plants was 46 per cent above De­
cember, 1932, and the five per cent increase from Novem­
ber was greater than seasonal.
Clay Products. Employment at brick and tile plants in
this district was little changed in December from Novem­
ber, though there was an average decline of nearly ten
per cent at this time in the past five years. Increased
demand for supplies used in connection with the Civil
and Public W orks Administrations were partly responsible
for the maintenance o f operations, but, compared with a
year ago, employment was off 11 per cent and output
was down sharply.
Considerable improvement was reported in the pottery
and china industries in recent weeks. Both the number
and size of orders received at the annual show at Pitts­
burgh in early January were much larger than a year ago.
It was stated that orders and shipments in the first half
of January were at least 50 per cent above early 1933.
In December, employment was 18.5 per cent above a year
previous, but the number of hours worked per week was
limited. The slight decline from November was less than
seasonal.
Electrical Supplies. There was a slight decline in the
number employed at plants manufacturing electrical ap­
paratus in December, but in the closing month of the year
there were 47.5 per cent more workers at local plants than
at the close of 1932. The number o f inquiries received
recently has increased and actual sales also have im­
proved.
Glass. Substantial orders for plate and laminated glass
were received by the industry from automobile manufac­
turers and operations have expanded. Employment at 12
concerns was up 17 per cent from November to Decem­
ber in contrast with a five-year average decline of two
per cent in the period. Compared with a year previous,
an increase of 65 per cent in employment was evident
in December. Operations at molded glass and bottle fac­
tories continue at much higher levels than a year ago.
Machine Tools, Hardware. The number employed at
19 machine tool plants in Ohio in December was 47.5 per
cent greater than a year previous, but there was a slight




5

decline from November, contrary to the trend of past years.
An increase in sales was reported in early January, or­
ders coming chiefly from the automobile industry. Spe­
cialty goods and foundry products were in good demand.
Paints. Sales o f paint in December were very much
in excess of a year earlier and, though much o f the work
was in connection with the Civil W orks Administration,
retail outlets also reported an increased demand for
paints and supplies. Plants in this section were operat­
ing at capacity levels and the falling-off in production,
which many times occurs in late December and early
January, did not develop this year.
Paper, Boxboard. A greater-than-seasonal falling-off in
paper and boxboard production developed in December,
but some improvement was reported in January.
As
the year started, operations were about 40 per cent
above early 1933.
Shoes. Output of footwear at fourth district factories
increased slightly in December from the preceding month,
but was only 0.3 per cent ahead of the last month of 1932.
For the entire year the gain in shoe production was 23.5
per cent. Shoe sales in December at fourth district de­
partment stores were about five per cent ahead of the
same period of 1932.
TRADE
Retail

The dollar value of December depart­
ment store sales swelled the year’s total
so that a gain of 0.03 per cent was
shown in the entire period from 1932 at reporting units
in the fourth district. Although the higher price o f many
items was a factor contributing to the expansion, the year
made a relatively good showing in view o f the large de­
clines reported in early 1933.
Compared with December. 1932, a gain of 14.4 per
cent in dollar sales was reported in the closing month
o f 1933, and the increase from November was greater
than seasonal. The daily average adjusted index in the
latest month was 64.4 per cent of the 1923-1925 month*
ly average, as against 63.9 per cent in November and
53.8 per cent a year ago. Increased pre-holiday sales,
as shown on page seven, were reported in all principal
cities, the gains ranging from ten to nearly 40 per cent
from the corresponding month of 1932.
In the individual departments for which figures are
available, gains from a year ago were shown in every in­
stance except in sales of domestics. Sales of electrical
household appliances, housefurnishings, misses’ dresses,
woolen dress goods, and silverware were over 30 per
cent above a year ago.

The proportion of total sales bought on credit was ap­
proximately the same in December as a year ago, but
there was relatively more installment buying and less
purchasing on a 30-day credit basis than in December,
1932. There was comparatively less buying on credit in
December than in November.
The dollar value of stocks at department stores on De­
cember 31 was 21.6 per cent smaller than on November
30, the reduction being slightly more than seasonal. The
adjusted index o f stocks was 62.3 per cent o f the 192325 monthly average, compared with 63.4 in November and
54 in December, 1932.

6

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

Collections in December, as a per cent of accounts re­
ceivable at the beginning o f the month, were a trifle
better than in November, and were up about 6.5 per cent
from December, 1932.
A t 44 reporting furniture stores in this district sales
in December were 37.9 per cent larger than a year ago
and in the entire year a gain of 14.9 per cent was shown
from 1932. The increase in December compared with a
19.9 per cent gain in sales in furniture departments of
department stores.
Chain grocery sales in December were up 7.6 per cent
from the same month of 1932, and chain drug store sales
increased 8.7 per cent in the same period.
W holesale

The four reporting lines of wholesale
trade in the fourth district showed an
increase in dollar sales in December
from a year earlier, and, compared with November, a
contrary-to-seasonal expansion was reported.

In contrast with December. 1932, the largest gain in
dollar sales occurred in the hardware trade, the increase
being 49.8 per cent. F or the entire year, dollar hardware
sales were up 10.8 per cent from 1932.
Drug sales were 34 per cent larger in December than
in November, and 22 per cent above December, 1932.
The gain, according to reports, was due to the sharp in­
crease in liquor sales, both wholesale and retail, in the
latest month. In the entire year sales were down 7.3
per cent.
Dry goods sales were only slightly larger in December
than a year earlier, and were down somewhat more than
seasonally from November, but in the entire year a gain
in sales o f 11.5 per cent was reported from 1932.
W holesale grocery sales in the last month of 1933
were 7.4 per cent above the preceding year, but for the
twelve-month period sales were down 1.8 per cent from
1932.
BUILDING
Building contracts awarded in the fourth district in
December were larger than in any month since May, 1931,
and exceeded those awarded in every December since
1928. Being valued at $30,130,000, awards were nearly
six times as large as in December, 1932, and were nearly
twice as large as in November, 1933. The rapid expan­
sion in the building industry in the closing months of




last year was almost sufficient to counteract the large
losses reported in the early months o f that year, for 1933
as a whole showed a loss of only 3.6 per cent in the
value of contracts awarded from the preceding year.
Gains over November in this district were shown in
each of the m ajor types o f building except residential
construction, and, compared with December, 1932, in­
creases were reported in all classes except public utilities.
As has previously been pointed out, however, most of
the contracts awarded represented public works projects
financed partly though the Public W orks Administration.
According to the F. W. Dodge report covering the
Pittsburgh territory, which includes W estern Kentucky
and all o f W est Virginia in addition to the area included
in the fourth district, contracts awarded for this type
of work were valued at nearly $25,000,000, compared
with $14,000,000 in November and $1,558,000 in Decem­
ber, 1932. The m ajor part o f this work contracted for
in December will occur in Ohio, for public works and
utilities contracts awarded in this state in December
were valued at $15,613,000. By far the greatest part
of this total represented highway construction, awards
for this type o f work in this section amounting to over
$19,000,000. Sewerage systems and water front develop­
ments accounted for the major part of the remaining
public utility contracts.
Residential building in December was down sharply
from November, but this was largely seasonal and awards
in the latest month were 18 per cent ahead of December,
1932. F or the year as a whole residential building con­
tracts awarded were about 11 per cent less than in 1932.
In the case of non-residential building, other than public
works and utilities, the year 1933 showed gains over 1932
in factory, educational, social and recreational building
construction. Losses were shown fo r comm ercial, hos­
pital, public and religious buildings.
The value of contemplated work reported in December
in this section was in excess o f $50,000,000, but this was
about one half as large as reported in November, 1933,
although it was over three times as large as a year ago.
So far as demand for building supplies is concerned,
aside from the materials needed in connection with the
Civil W orks Administration projects, chiefly limited to
supplies for renovating and repairing buildings, there has
been very little demand for building materials. Gener­
ally speaking, the year 1933 as a whole, was a better
year for the lumber and supply industry than the one
immediately preceding it, but with new construction in
the residential and non-residential fields, other than public
utilities, extremely limited, demand for building supplies
has made it necessary for manufacturers o f these mate­
rials to operate at low levels.
COST OF LIVING
Living costs of wage earners and lower-salaried w ork­
ers in Cleveland, Cincinnati and Pittsburgh increased five
per cent in the last half o f 193 3, according to figures com ­
piled semiannually by the United States Bureau of Labor
Statistics. This gain was slightly less than the average
increase in the period in 32 cities throughout the country.
In June of last year, the index of the cost of living, as
shown on the chart, was lower than for seventeen years,

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
but increased prices in the latter part of the year caused
the index to advance, the first since 1929. Compared with
a year ago, however, living costs were up only slightly,
the gain being 0.9 per cent in the three principal cities of
the fourth district. In contrast with the post-war peak
touched in December, 1926, cost o f living is still down
about 24 per cent. Higher wages paid in the latter part o f
1933 and the increase in employment in many fields in the
period made up in part for the advance in living costs.
Not all items included in this index of living costs were
higher in December, 1933, than a year ago. There was a
sizeable reduction in rents, amounting to 14 per cent in
the period, in the three cities and rents generally were
lower than since 1917. The decline in Pittsburgh and
Cleveland was somewhat greater in 1933 than in Cincin­
nati.
Miscellaneous living costs dropped 0.8 per cent in the
twelve latest months, but were still relatively high com­
pared with other components o f the index.
The most pronounced increase in costs occurred in the
housefurnishings group, which was 12.3 per cent higher
in December, 1933, than a year earlier. Housefurnishings
are still about 30 per cent below the 1926 level.
Food costs, the largest item in an average fam ily’s ex­
pense, were 8.8 per cent higher in these three cities
at the close o f 1933 than a year earlier, but the gain was
less than the average increase in the entire country. They
are still about 35 per cent below the recent peak in 1929.
Clothing costs in the past year increased 6.3 per cent,
and fuel and light expense was up 2.2 per cent in 1933.
The latter group was relatively higher in December than
any other entering into a fam ily's living expense. Com­
pared with 1917, fuel and light costs are up 83.5 per cent
and the decline from 1929 was only 2.4 per cent and from
1926 only 6.5 per cent; reductions of 22 and 24 per cent,
respectively, occurred in total living costs in the same
periods in Cleveland, Cincinnati and Pittsburgh.

Wholesale and Retail Trade
(1933 compared with 1932)
Percentage
Increase or Decrease

DEPARTM ENT STORES (49)
Cincinnati.
Cleveland..
Columbus.,
Pittsburgh.
Wheeling..................................
Other Cities............................
District....................................
WEARING APPAREL (11)

FURNITURE (44)
Cincinnati................

CHAIN STORES*
Groceries— District (5 )....................
WHOLESALE GROCERIES (33)
Cleveland.
Erie..........

♦Per individual unit operatea.




SALES
Dec.
1933

First 12

months

SALES

STOCKS
Dec.,
1933

1-39.5
[-11.4
-14.2
f-10.4
b io .o
[-14.9
f-17.0
L22.9
f-14.4

+ 1 2 .4
— 2.3
+ 5.4
— 6.3
— 2.1
— 1.7
+ 0.4
— 1.1
+ 0.03

+ 1 6 .0
+ 11.8
+ 12.8
+ 8.2
+ 17.2
— 6.9
+ 13.3
— 7.4
+ 1 1 .4

+ 1 2 .4
+ 1 6 .7
+ 1 5 .4

— 5.9
— 12.7
— 10.5

+ 9.2
— 6.4
— 1.1

- 3.8
+ 4 0 .4
+ 2 8 .7
+ 9.3
+ 110.0
+ 6 6 .4
+ 3 7 .9

— 1.0
+ 24.2
+ 5.5
— 9.6
+17.3
+ 34.0
+ 1 4 .9

+ 8.7
+ 7.6

— 8.5
+ 3.2

+ 2 0 .4
-f- 1.9
- 0.2
+ 13.1
+ 0.7
+ 11.8
+ 7.4
+ 1.2
+22.1
+ 4 9 .8

— 1.3
— 1.0
— 14.7
+ 1 0 .6
— 17.2
+ 3.1
— 1.8
+ 11.5
— 7.3
+ 1 0 .8

....
• •• •

+ i7 l o
+ 17.5

7

Fourth District Business Statistics
(000 omitted)
% change
Dec.,
from
1933
1932

Year,
Fourth District Unless Other­
1933
wise Specified
Bank Debits— 24 cities............ $ 1,555,000 — 1.1
17,346,000
Savings Deposits— end of month:
l
41 Banks, O. and Pa.............. 3
629,485 — 5.4
Life Insurance Sales:
866,238
Ohio and Penna...................... 3
75,726 — 0.9
Retail Sales:
164,574
Department Stores— 49 firms 3
23,756 + 1 4 .4
7,791
Wearing Apparel— 11 firm s...3
1,025 + 15.3
Furniture— 44 firms................3
640 + 3 7 .9
6,301
Wholesale Sales:
Drugs— 13 firms......................3
1,503 +22.1
13,156
831 + 1.2
11,138
Dry Goods— 10 firms............. 3
38,587
Groceries— 33 firms................ 3
3,191 + 7.3
11,487
Hardware— 14 firms............... 3
1,089 + 49.8
Building Contracts—
870 + 18.0
19,917
Residential........................... 3
30,130 +489.9
122,454
iBuilding Contracts— Total.. . . 3
Commercial Failures—
49,143
1,586 — 80.8
Liabilities.............................3
Commercial Failures— Number.
90» — 54.3
1,6853
Production:
1,192 +115.6
13,222
Pig Iron, U. S................... Tons
22,879
1,820 + 111.4
Steel Ingot, U. S ... .^........ Tons
1,606,7033
53,9002 — 37.4
Automobiles-Pass. C a r...U . S.
352,4983
30,1452 + 4 2 .2
”
— Trucks ...U . S.
Bituminous Coal..............Tons
11,213 — 0.7
129,027
5,417
Cement— O., W. Pa., W. Va. Bbls.
67 — 84.8
Elec. Power-O., Pa., Ky. k.w.h.
1,083® + 7.9
11,521*
1,824® + 1.3
19,712“*
Petroleum— O., Pa., K y ... Bbls.
5
5
+ 0.3
2,4323 + 3 2 .0
33,777*
Bituminous Coal Shipments:
Lake Erie Ports................Tons
291 + 14.6
32,333
Iron Ore Receipts:
16,323
Lake Erie Ports..............Tons
20
2actual number
^ o t available
^first 11 months
8November
5 Confidential

% change
from
1932
— 9.0

— 9.0
+ 0.03
— 10.5
+ 14.8
— 7.3
+ 11.5
— 1.8
+ 10.8
— 10.9
— 3.6
— 42.5
— 41.8
+52.3
+ 7 1 .7
+ 41.5
+ 4 9 .9
+ 1 3 .4
— 17.9
+ 5.0
— 8.2
+ 23.5
+ 10.4
+ 28.4
+503.0

Debits to Individual Accounts
(Thousands of Dollars)
4 weeks
ended
Jan. 24,
1934
42,605
7,455
28,113
274,104
405,342
. . 113,268
39,366
19,230
2,754
Greensburg. . . ,
4,823
7,857
1,870
22,258
8,819
2,401
Middletown.. . ,
6,602
6,823
, , 585,173
13,038
Steubenville...,
5,911
82,649
6,049
31,296
Youngstown. . .
27,971
6,356
, 1,752,133

%

change
from
1933
— 16.5
+ 6.8
+47.3
+ 2.0
— 12.0
+ 1 2 .7
— 21.4
— 5.3
+ 19.6
— 2.8
+ 9.4
+ 1.9
— 18.9
+ 6.1
— 22.6
+ 1 3 .0
— 26.5
+ 2.1
+ 3.7
+ 12.2
+ 2.4
+ 39.4
+ 1.0
+ 16.9
+ 12.8
— 1.8

Year to date
Dec. 29, 1932
to
Jan. 3, 1934
398,354
74,497
232,796
2,743,449
4,279,778
1,110,218
451,411
200,129
27,609
47,404
81,441
19,911
180,320
72,285
27,301
70,571
72,594
6,185,692
123,608
57,977
873,278
61,288
323,070
313,276
63,863
18,092,120

Year to date
Dec. 31,1931
to
Jan. 4, 1933
605,425
76,300
220,912
2,992,247
5,097,651
1,179,089
541,603
254,265
33,015
65,023
94,864
27,694
195,778
99,427
36,898
70,321
108,677
6,337,001
143,206
63,354
928,946
55,798
332,396
323,137
70,210
19,953,237

%
change
from
1933
— 34.2
— 2.4
+ 5.4
— 8.3
— 16.0
— 5.8
— 16.7
— 21.3
— 16.4
— 27.1
— 14.1
— 28.1
— 7.9
— 27.3
— 26.0
+ 0.4
— 33.2
— 2.4
— 13.7
— 8.5
— 6.0
+ 9.8
— 2.8
— 3.1
— 9.0
— 9.3

Fourth District Business Indexes
(1923-1925*** 100)
Dec., Dec*, Dec., Dec., Dec.,
1933 1932 1931 1930 1929
Bank Debits— (24 cities)...................................
57
58
83
124
134
Commercial Failures— (Number)....................
62
135
180
143
96
”
”
— (Liabilities)..................
36
187
136
102
185
Sales— Life Insurance (Ohio & P a.)................
91
91
140
126
150
” — Department Stores (47 firms)..............
109
91
123
149
175
” — Wholesale Drugs (12 firms)..................
99
83
83
101
111
” —
”
Dry Goods (10 firms)........
34
33
49
70
88
” —
”
Groceries (33 firms)............
55
51
67
80
92
” —
”
Hardware (14 firms)...........
56
37
49
65
81
” —
”
All (69).................................
57
49
63
78
92
” — Chain Drugs (3 firms)**.......................
86
79
97
90
98
Building Contracts— (Total)............................
63
11
30
35
51
5
17
33
”
** — (Residential)..................
4
29
Production— Coal (O., W. Pa., E. K y.)..........
62
62
96
61
84
8
— Cement (O., W. Pa., W. V a .)...
53
35
78
64
120
134
129
156
”
— Elec. Power (O., Pa., K y .)* .. . .
144
99
97
”
— Petroleum (O., Pa., K y.)*..........
112
102
125
51
51
59
44
82
”
— Shoe*.............................................
♦November. **Per individual unit operated.

8

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS R EVIEW

Summary of National Business Conditions
By the Federal Reserve Board
Industrial activity, as measured by the Federal Reserve Board’s season­
ally adjusted index, showed an increase in December, follow ing upon four
months of decline. Factory employment declined somewhat, while employ­
ment by public agencies showed a considerable increase.

P roduction and Employment

Index number of industrial production, adjusted
for seasonal variation (1923-1925 — 100). Latest
figure, December, preliminary, 74.

Federal Reserve Board's index of factory employ­
ment, with adjustment for seasonal variation
<1923-1925 = 100). Latest figure, December, 71.8.

The Board’s index of industrial production, which is adjusted to allow
for seasonal variation, advanced from 73 per cent of the 1923-1925 average
in November to 74 per cent in December. F or the fourth quarter o f 1933, as
a whole, the volume of industrial output was 13 per cent larger than for
the corresponding period of 1932. Activity in the steel industry, contrary to
seasonal tendency, increased considerably in December and there was also an
increase in the output of automobiles.
Shoe production declined by an
amount smaller than is usual in December. At textile mills activity declined
further by considerably more than the usual seasonal amount to about the
low level of last spring.
The number of employees at factories declined between the middle of
November and the middle of December by somewhat more than the usual
seasonal amount, reflecting chiefly reductions in working forces at cotton,
woolen and silk mills and at clothing factories. At automobile factories there
was a substantial increase in employment.
Value of construction contracts awarded, as reported by the F. W. Dodge
Corporation, increased further in December and the first half of January.
There was a large increase in contracts awarded for public works and private
construction also increased. In the fourth quarter of 1933, as a whole, con ­
struction contracts in 37 States totaled $500,000,000, as compared with
$300,000,000 in the last quarter o f 1932.

Distribution
Freight carloadings, particularly o f miscellaneous freight, declined in
December, as compared with November, by less than the usual seasonal
amount. Dollar value of sales by department stores showed an increase slight­
ly larger than is usual for December.

Dollar Exchange
The foreign exchange value o f the dollar, which had fluctuated around
64 per cent o f parity from the end of November to January 13, declined to
62 per cent on January 17, and subsequently advanced to a range from 62
to 63 per cent.

Prices
Three-month moving averages of F. W. Dodge
data for 37 Eastern States, adjusted for seasonal
variation (1923-1925 = 100).
Latest figures,
based on data for November, December and esti­
mate for January; total 250.0; residential 25.7.

W HOLCSAl.E PRICE!s

V

_

M.

Farm Prodwcts

t929

1930

Bank Credit

'r

Commodities

\

1931

1

-

1932

AT'
V
1933

1934

-

Indexes of United States Bureau of Labor Statis­
tics, by months 1929-1931, by weeks, 1932 to date
(1926 = 100). Latest figures, farm products
59.0; foods 64.6; other commodities 78.6.




W holesale comm odity prices, which had shown a slight decline between
the middle of November and the third week of December, advanced in the
follow ing month, reflecting chiefly increases in the prices o f farm products
and foods. Cotton and grains showed marked increases and livestock prices
also advanced somewhat.

At the reserve banks the seasonal return of currency from circulation
after the holiday demand amounted to about $250,000,000 from the high
point on December 22 to January 17. A large part of the funds arising from
this inflow of currency to the reserve banks was added to the reserve bal­
ances of member banks, with the consequence that these balances increased
by January 17 to $900,000,000 in excess of legal requirements. The return
flow of currency from circulation and the reduction of balances held by com ­
mercial banks for the United States Government were reflected in an increase
of demand deposits at reporting member banks. Loans of the banks de­
clined between December 13 and January 17 while holdings of United States
Government and other securities increased.
Short-term money rates in the open market, which had shown a slight
advance in December, declined in January to the previous level.