View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
Covering financial, industrial, and agricultural conditions
in the

Fourth Federal Reserve District
Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland
Vol. 15

Cleveland, Ohio, January 1, 1933

Little change in the general level of business was visible
in this district from October to November, though it ap­
peared as if the upward movement recorded in the early
fall months had about terminated. Preliminary data for
the first three weeks of December show that a slightly
more-than-seasonal contraction was felt in that period by
some of the more important lines of trade and industry,
though several unusual factors were present which might
account for the declines. Unfavorable weather no doubt
retarded retail trade, building, etc.
Bank debits in this district in November expanded by
considerably more than the usual seasonal amount and
the reduction from last year, 26 per cent, was much
smaller than the falling-off recorded in the first ten
months of the year when they were down 36 per cent.
Commercial failures were less numerous in November
than in October and liabilities of the defaulting concerns
were down sharply, both from the preceding month and
November, 1931. There was an increase of one in the
number of banks in December, there being three openings
during the month and only two suspensions.
Production of steel ingots at plants in this district was
maintained in November by orders from the automobile
industry which expanded output considerably, largely
through the introduction of new models. In December,
a contraction in steel operations occurred, though pro­
duction of fourth district factories in the third week of
the month was still somewhat above the level for the en­
tire country.
Building operations in November expanded, contrary to

End of month figures at 27 selected banks in Ohio and Western Penn­
sylvania




No. 1

the seasonal movement of past years, chiefly as a result
of the awarding of government contracts. In the first
half of December a sharp reduction was recorded.
Coal production of fourth district mines was greater
in November than a year ago and, though output for the
entire year was down sharply from 1931, considerable im­
provement in this industry developed in the last half of
the year.
Though the general level of business in 1932, in this
district as well as in the entire country, as reflected
by employment, payrolls, bank credit, retail trade, and in­
dustrial production, was at the lowest point in many years,
possibly lower than for any twelve-month period in the
present century, as the new year begins it is quite certain
that, despite the recession in late November and Decem­
ber, a large part of the improvement from the low point
touched some time last summer has not been surrendered.
FINANCIAL
There was some improvement in the financial situation
during the year 1932. This was reflected in the almost
constant decline in Federal reserve note circulation dur­
ing the year, after excluding seasonal movements, and by
the fact that the sharp rate of decline in savings deposits
at selected banks, evident in the last half of 1931 and the
early months of 1932, slowed down in the summer months.
Deposits actually increased in October and November as is
shown on the accompanying chart. Savings deposits at
these banks, which were selected so that mergers, etc.,
would not affect the figures, are lower than since early
1926.
Although there were 58 bank suspensions in 1932 in
the fourth district, 22 member banks and 36 non-member,
there were 20 banks reopened in the period. The greater
proportion of the suspensions occurred in the early months
of the year, there being only two in December, four in
November and three in October. Reopenings numbered
three in December, two in November and three in Oc­
tober. In 1931 there were 182 bank failures in this dis­
trict and only four banks were reopened.
Reserve Bank Credit. Changes in the total volume and
the various types of credit extended by the Federal Re­
serve Bank of Cleveland in 1932 reflected in a large part
operations of the Reconstruction Finance Corporation and
the policy of purchasing Government securities adopted
by the System as a whole early in the year.
The total volume of credit extended as the year ended

2

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

was only slightly in excess of the amount outstanding
at the close of 1931, but bills discounted for member
banks, at approximately $28,000,000 on December 21,
were down almost $100,000,000 from the corresponding
date a year earlier. As customer loans by member banks
were reduced faster than deposits during the year and
banks obtained loans from the Reconstruction Finance
Corporation after it was organized in this district in Feb­
ruary, the member banks were able to reduce sharply
their borrowings from the reserve bank.
The decline in discounts was more than offset by the
increase in the holdings of Government securities during
the year when purchases of the System amounted to
$1,090,000,000 from March to August. The Federal Re­
serve Bank of Cleveland purchased $110,000,000 of Gov­
ernment securities in the period. Holdings of these se­
curities as the year ended, at $178,282,000, were the
highest on record, and were more than double the previ­
ous high point in 1922.
Member bank reserve deposits on December 21 were
$139,177,000, practically the same as a month earlier,
but down about $6,000,000 from the corresponding date
last year. This reflected the drop in deposits at mem­
ber banks, though excess reserves in the closing months
of 1932 were somewhkt larger than a year ago.
Circulation of Federal reserve notes on the latest date
was $41,000,000 lower than a year earlier and the sea­
sonal expansion prior to Christmas was less marked than
in other years.
Member Bank Credit. A moderation in the rate of de­
cline in deposits at reporting member banks in leading
cities, evident in the last half of 1931, occurred in the
first quarter of the past year, and though a slight down­
ward movement was discernible in the last three quar­
ters of the year, the recession was interrupted by an in­
crease in August and September.
The total volume of loans and investments of these
banks also was reduced at a moderate rate during most
of the year, but the rate of decline was not so pro­
nounced as the downward movement in deposits because
the increase in investments (entirely in Government se­
curities) which amouted to almost $100,000,000, or 25
per cent from January to December, offset almost half
the decline in total loans. As shown on the accompany­
ing chart, however, the contraction in deposits from the

MEMBER BANK CREDIT AND DEPOSITS
FOURTH DISTRICT
MILLIONS OF DOLLARS
1
1
1
2400
— — TOTAl. LOANS. DISC INVESTMEIMTS
— -----DEMAND& TIME DEI30 SITS

2000

'

V-'-'H
/

V /v

J

51
t

J

\\
\

1600

1927




1928

1929.

1930

1931

1932

peaks in 1930 and 1931 has been sharper than in credit
extended by the reporting banks.
Loans to customers were reduced about 16 per cent in
the past year, the decline being equally divided between
loans on securities and “ all other” or so-called commercial
loans. Total investments were increased 6.4 per cent, but
investments in “ other” securities declined, for holdings
of Government securities were 16 per cent higher in the
third week of December than a year earlier. In the clos­
ing weeks of the year reporting member bank holdings
of Government securities were at the highest level ever
reported and amounted to over 25 per cent of the total
volume of credit extended.
MANUFACTURING, MINING
Iron and
Steel

The past year in the iron and steel industry was one in which the downward
movement of 1930 and 1931 was con­
tinued and intensified. So far as consumption, prices, prof­
its, and employment were concerned, the industry sank to
new low levels for what might be called modern times. All
major consumers of steel took materially less tonnage in
1932 than in preceding years. No large pipe lines were
laid; most shipyard ways were empty; manufacture of
farm equipment, freight cars and steel rails was negligible;
structural awards in 1932 were about half as large as
in the preceding year; and automobile production was
only about 58 per cent of 1931 and 40 per cent of 1930.
The net result is that output of pig iron (with December
partly estimated) was 8,710,000 gross tons in 1932, less
than half the 18,263,011 tons produced in 1031, and
only slightly more than one-fourth the 31,441,488 tons
of 1930. Since 1896 yearly production has not been so
small. Steel produced in the year totaled 13,109,000 tons,
lower than since 1900, little more than one-half the out­
put of 1931, and less than one-third the 40,084,631 tons
of 1930.
Steel ingot production in the entire country in 1932
averaged about 19 per cent of estimated capacity. This
rate was bettered by producers in this district because of
the large proportion of tin plate and automobile ma­
terials which is made by local mills. Pittsburgh opera­
tions were depressed by lack of structural and rail buy­
ing, but Cleveland mills produced at an average rate of
28 per cent during the entire year. Mills in the south­
ern part of the district also were operating at better

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
levels, tin plate production being at about 40 per cent of
capacity as the year closed. Operations in the Mahoning
Valley were about the same as the average for the en­
tire country.
The decline, however, was quite general throughout the
industry. Great Lake shipments of iron ore, at 3,667,985
tons, were the lowest in 46 years and only about one-sixth
the 23,468,000 tons moved in 1931. This limited move­
ment of ore reduced lower lake stocks to 32,100,000 tons
on December 1, a drop of 8,100,000 tons in the year.
Price reductions, measured by the composite of Steel,
were less pronounced in the year than the drop in output.
At the end of the year this average was $28.91, compared
with $30.32 at the end of 1931, a reduction of about five
per cent. In the past two years iron and steel prices have
dropped about 12 per cent.
Notwithstanding the very unfavorable elements, the
year was not without some encouragement. The rate of
decline visible in 1930 and 1931 slackened in the first
half of the past year and a notable rally occurred in Sep­
tember, October and November. Some weakness devel­
oped in the closing weeks of the latter month and in De­
cember, as specifications for the automobile industry,
which was engaged in new model production, were part­
ly fulfilled. In the week preceding Christmas, operations
were at about 13 per cent of capacity.
Coal

Though total volume of bituminous
coal produced by mines in this district
in the first 11 months of 1932 was 26
per cent below the amount mined in the same period of
1931, marked improvement occurred in the rate of pro­
duction in the last half of the year, despite the fact that
normally output increases seasonally in the summer and
fall months. The upward movement, shown on the ac­
companying chart, continued through October, but a slight
reduction occurred in November, which was less than the
seasonal trend of past years and output in the latest peri­
od exceeded the same month of 1931 by 1.8 per cent.
The reduction from October was partly a reflection of
the closing of the lake shipping season, but this was less
marked than in past years because household demand ex­
panded somewhat and industrial takings were up slightly
in November as operations of railroads and factories im­
proved.
Retail demand in early December was slightly below

expectations in view of the extremely cold weather
throughout the country, partly because of the sustitutes
that are being used and the fact that more than one
family is living in many dwellings.
Production costs have been lowered in the past year,
largely in the form of wage reductions, but prices received
for coal also have declined, though the drop in the past
year has been very slight. Coal prices are lower than
since 1922, but the reduction from 1929 has been only
about 10 per cent.
A reopening of the discussion concerning rail rates on
coal moving to lake ports occurred in 1932, but as yet
the Interstate Commerce Commission has not decided on
the validity of the lower Ohio intrastate rates allowed
early in the year.
Automobiles

The motor car industry provided one of
the encouraging elements in the indus­
trial situation in November and it con­
tinued to show distinct improvement in December. This
expansion, however, came after a prolonged period of
stagnation when output averaged lower than since 1918.
The extreme low point was touched in October when only
48,702 cars and trucks were produced, and the adjusted
index of the Federal Reserve Board dropped to 16 per
cent of the 1923-25 monthly average.
Although in past years the trend of production from
October to November was downward, in 1932 a gradual
expansion in factory operations occurred in the first part
of November as one company after another started pro­
ducing their 1933 models. Output for the month was
about 69,500 cars and trucks, an increase from October of
22.3 per cent and only 13.5 per cent below production in
November, 1931. The Board’s adjusted index rose 31 in
the month, the highest since July.
Preliminary reports for the first three weeks of De­
cember indicated a very sharp rise in production and the
Annalist's adjusted index, which on December 17 was 72,
was the highest for any time since May, 1931, and more
than twice as high as it was a year ago. Oram's reports
show that 32,976 cars and trucks were produced in the
third week, compared with 13,629 units in the same period
of 1931. Indications point to an output of about 100,000
cars and trucks in December, a considerable increase from
November, but still under the 121,541 cars manufactured
in December, 1931.

AUTOMOBILE

1928




1929

1930

1931

1932

1933

PRODUCTION

4

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

With December partly estimated, output for the en­
tire year should be close to 1,400,000 units, the lowest
for any period since 1915, excluding 1918 when manu­
facture of war supplies engaged a considerable part of
the industry’s production capacity. Compared with 1931,
the past year’s production was down approximately 42
per cent and the number of cars made was only slightly
more than one-fourth the number produced in the peak
year of 1929.
The increased activity in November and December was
almost entirely in preparation for 1933 sales campaigns,
cars being manufactured for dealers’ stocks and in antici­
pation of the annual shows in January. Retail sales con­
tinue in limited volume, and in November they touched
a new low record on the basis of reports from 30 states.
The decline from October was 30 per cent compared with
a seasonal drop in past years of 24 per cent. The in­
dustry, however, is in quite a favorable position so far
as stocks of both new and used cars in hands of dis­
tributors are concerned. During the year both have been
markedly reduced and a potential demand for replace­
ment cars has gradually been built up, for it is estimated
by Standard Statistics that close to 2,000,000 fewer cars
are now registered than a year ago.
The greater-than-seasonal increase in November and
December production was responsible for the advance in
operations at steel, parts and accessory, tire and glass
factories in this district and for the fact that local steel
companies were operating at higher-than-average levels
in the third week of December.
Tires
Rubber

According to reports, November replacement tire sales were considerably
below a year ago, but the reduction in
original equipment sales was somewhat smaller because
the automobile industry began producing 1933 models in
that month and continued to expand in December.
Rubber consumption in November, at 21,910 tons, was
about 900 tons greater than in October, but still about
500 tons below a year ago. Imports of crude rubber in
November were 27,080 long tons, a decrease of 24 and 38
per cent, respectively, from October, 1932, and November
last year, but they exceeded consumption. Crude rub­
ber stocks on the latest date were about 30 per cent above
a year ago.
The report from the Rubber Manufacturers' Association,
which covers about 80 per cent of the industry, shows that
tire production in the first ten months of 1932 was 18
per cent below the same period of 1931. The accompany­
ing chart shows the Board’s seasonally adjusted index of
tire and tube production in the United States.
The tire industry began to feel seriously the effects of
the depression this year when gasoline production turned
downward and registrations of automobiles showed a de­
clining tendency. Normally, at this season, tire manufac­
turers are expanding operations as a result of orders placed
in the fall months, but this year the dealer who ordinarily
placed a fair-sized spring-dated order is buying on a strict­
ly hand-to-mouth basis, a thing which no doubt will affect
the monthly volume for some time to come. Dealers’ in­
ventories are being held at low levels now, in keeping




with sales, after having increased in June and September
when price changes were announced.
The price situation is still unfavorable and disturbing.
The price of crude rubber has declined from more than a
dollar a pound in 1926 to little more than three cents a
pound at the end of 1932, the drop in the past year be­
ing over 25 per cent. Cotton prices also declined sharp­
ly in 1932. This has caused manufacturers to lose on their
inventories and dealers to lose on stocks as their mer­
chandise declined in value.
In other branches of the rubber industry, the boot and
shoe producers enjoyed quite a successful year, the first
in four, but foreign competition has been a disturbing
factor in this line. The mechanical goods division held up
fairly well in the past year, but the reduction in rubber
consumed by manufacturers of these articles in the first
nine months of 1932 from the same period of 1931 was
only slightly less than the 11 per cent decline in con­
sumption by the tire industry.
Clothing

Consumption of all types of raw mate­
rials used in the production of clothing
improved markedly in the second and
third quarters, but slackened somewhat in the closing
months of the past year as retail and wholesale sales de­
clined. Output of woolen and cotton cloth in November
was above the same period of 1931 by a good margin. One
large woolen company in this district states that produc­
tion in December was more than twice what it was a year
ago, but material prices have not improved.
The spurt in clothing sales in September and October
experienced by most manufacturers slackened in Novem­
ber, though a fairly satisfactory volume of orders for
spring goods was indicated in some instances. On the
whole, conditions in the industry were better as the year
closed than they were in midsummer, but there has
been some recession in the past two months.
Retail prices of clothing declined about 15 per cent
in 1932, and are down over 25 per cent from two years
ago.
Manufacturers of knit wear generally had a fairly sat­
isfactory year due to the popularity of knitted outer wear,
particularly for women. Operations as the year closed
were down seasonally, but arrangements for the produc­
tion of spring goods were being made.

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
Other
Manufactnring

Operations in the miscellaneous industries of the district were slightly lower
in the first part of December than in
November and were down sharply from a year ago in most
cases. In November, activity increased in those lines al­
lied in some way with the automobile industry which
in that month and December was engaged in new model
production. The falling-off in the closing month of the
year was largely seasonal, and the fact that business in
general was at extremely low levels during the entire
year had little effect on the seasonal movement of em­
ployment or production, though the share-the-work move­
ment has cushioned the drop in the former in recent
months.
Conditions in the clay products and glass Industries
were quite varied and irregular throughout the year. Pro­
duction of tableware at the close of the year was esti­
mated to be about 25 per cent below a year ago, but con­
siderably above the level of late summer, as a result of
the improvement in September and October. Payrolls
are down, but the number of employees is only slightly
under last year. The price situation is none too favor­
able. In the glass industry, demand from automobile
plants increased in November, but household glass, win­
dow glass, etc., has been moving at a very slow rate.
Moulded glass sales were down seasonally as the year
closed. Brick and tile plants are producing at the low­
est level, figured as a per cent of capacity, of any branch
of the industry and prices on common brick, at $9.25 a
thousand, are the lowest on record.
Paint sales at the close of 1932 were running from 20
to 30 per cent below the preceding year in dollar volume,
but considerable variation in the separate branches of
the industry was apparent. Sales of certain industrial
paints were larger in November and December than a
year ago, but sales to dealers were down quite sharply.
Prices in the period were down about 11 per cent.
Paper production in 1932 was about five per cent be­
low the preceding year and boxboard production showed a
greater reduction. Prices declined about ten per cent in
the year and show a tendency to seek lower levels, though
there is a better feeling in the trade at present than a
year ago.
Production of footwear in the fourth district and the
United States declined from October to November, the re­
duction being slightly more than the average falling-off




5

in the past nine years. At 29 establishments in this dis­
trict, most of which are in the vicinity of Cincinnati, No­
vember production was 6.2 per cent greater than in the
same month of 1931, and output in the 11-month period
was only 2.3 per cent below the corresponding interval
of the preceding year. Irregularities were apparent dur­
ing the year in the various branches of the trade, output
of lower-priced footwear being at a higher rate than that
of medium or high-priced shoes.
In the miscellaneous metal trades’ industries of the
district an increase in employment occurred generally in
November as production of materials required by the au­
tomobile industry expanded. Some weakness was visible
in the first three weeks of December pending the intro­
duction of the new automobiles. Rehabilitation projects
are helping the machine tool industry slightly. Employ­
ment generally has declined about 25 per cent in the past
year and over 50 per cent in the past three years. Pay­
rolls have been reduced by a greater amount due to parttime employment. In the electrical lines, sales declined
sharply in 1932. Prices in general have been reduced,
but the declines have been more moderate than in some
other lines.
TRADE
Retail

Though there usually is a slight reduc­
tion in department store sales from Oc­
tober to November, the falling-off in the
latest month was somewhat greater than seasonal, and
the adjusted index of daily average sales was 56.2 per
cent of the 1923-25 monthly average, compared with 57.6
in October. As shown on the chart, however, it was still
above the low point touched in August. Compared with
a year ago, November dollar sales were down 22 per cent
and the contraction continued in December, judging from
preliminary reports. In the first three weeks of Christ­
mas buying, sales were about 30 per cent below the same
period of 1931, whereas the decline in dollar sales in the
first eleven months was 26.5 per cent. Store executives
report that the number of sales have held up fairly well,
but that people are buying in lower price classes than in
former years and the general reduction in prices in the
past year, which, according to Fairchild’s index, was ap­
proximately 15 per cent, is the cause of a large part of the
discrepancy in the dollar value of retail sales from 1931.
In the various cities the smallest declines, about 18 per
cent, were shown at Akron, Cincinnati, Columbus and
Wheeling in November; Pittsburgh experienced a greater
than average reduction.
Although normally there is a slight increase in the
dollar value of stocks from October to November, the ex­
pansion in the latest month was a little more than sea­
sonal and the adjusted index rose to 57.6 per cent of
the 1923-25 monthly average. The value of stocks was
23 per cent below a year ago. The ratio of November
sales to average stocks was the same as in November
last year.
As in earlier months this year, proportionately more
sales were for cash than in 1931 and there was a reduc­
tion in installment buying. An improvement in collec­
tions was evident in November, the ratio of collections
during the month to accounts receivable on October 31
being greater than in October or in November, 1931.

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

6

Sales at retail furniture stores were down 33 per cent
in November from a year ago and the decline in the 11month period was 39.2 per cent. Wearing apparel store
sales were off 22.5 and 29 per cent in November and the
first 11 months from similar periods of 1931.
Chain grocery and drug sales in November, per unit
operated, were down 3.6 and 13 per cent from last year
and the reductions in the first 11 months were 8.6 and
13.4 per cent respectively.
Wholesale

Although sales of goods at wholesale in
the four reporting lines declined slight­
ly from October to November, the fall­
ing-off was less than was reported in past years at this
season. The dollar volume, however, was about half the
average monthly sales of the three years, 1923-25. In
the individual lines, sales of dry goods and hardware were
most depressed in November and the 11-month period,
compared with a year ago, as well as compared with the
1923-25 base period. Grocery sales were 16 per cent
smaller in November and off 22 per cent in the 11 months
from similar periods of 1931. The best relative showing
in the wholesale field in November, as well as in the en­
tire year, was shown by drug concerns whose sales were
down 10 per cent in the month and 16 per cent in the
eleven months from corresponding periods of the preced­
ing year.
BUILDING
Building activity in this district in November was up
40 per cent from October and the value of contracts
awarded was down only 4.8 per cent from a year ago.
The increase from the preceding month was contrary to
the seasonal movement of past years, the average October-November change in the preceding ten years being a
reduction of 15 per cent.
The volume of awards was buoyed up in the latest
month by governmental expenditures for public works and
buildings, contracts for which exceeded those of both the
preceding month and a year ago. Post offices, bridges,
highways and water front developments all contributed to
the increase.
Residential building contracts were valued slightly
higher in November than in October, but were still 40 per
cent below the same month last year. Commercial build­




ing contracts also were up in November from the preced­
ing month, but were slightly under 1931.
In the first half of December there was a sharp reduc­
tion from November in the volume of all classes of awards,
both in the fourth district and the United States.
The construction industry as a whole, including build­
ing supply and cement production, has been very depressed
for the past two years. Based on awards up to midDecember, construction activity in 1932 was 50 per cent
below 1931, and 72 per cent below 1930. The high point
in building activity so far as this district is concerned was
reached in 1927, a slight decline occurring in the two fol­
lowing years, and construction in 1932 was only aboGt
one-fifth what it was in the peak year.
As revealed by the accompanying chart, the decline in
the past three years has been more pronounced in resi­
dential building than in other kinds of construction. Resi­
dential contracts awarded in 1932 were 66 per cent below
1931, 78 per cent below 1930, and amounted to only onetenth the dollar volume of contracts awarded in the peak
year of 1927.
Although contemplated projects, according to the F. W.
Dodge Corporation, are considerably less than half as
large as were reported a year ago, for nearly two years
the rate of residential planning has exceeded contracts
awarded, indicating a growing demand for housing, which
awaits more favorable conditions before contracts are re­
leased.
AGRICULTURE
Final estimates of 1932 crop production in the United
States and the fourth district show that the harvest of
principal crops raised in this section was substantially Be­
low the average yields of the preceding seven years in all
cases except wheat and potatoes; in these two crops the
reductions were moderate. In the entire country yields
of principal crops were generally better, excluding to­
bacco and wheat, than locally and the revised estimate of
yields of 34 principal crops was only 1.4 per cent below the
ten-year average 1919-1928. The following table shows
the 1932 harvest of principal crops, for which district fig­
ures are available, as a per cent of the average harvest of
the seven years 1925-1931 for the fourth district and the
United States.
Corn
Fourth District .......
91.4
United States ............ 110.9

Wheat
99.2
86.7

Oats
69.5
102.6

Hay Tobacco Potatoes
65.5
91.8
97*1
98.7
72.0
101.6

7

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
In view of the drastic reduction in farm prices, and
consequently gross agricultural income, the changes in
1$32 production from past years are of little significance.
The accompanying chart shows the trend of gross farm
income in the United States and Ohio (used to indicate
the change in income of fourth district farms) as a per
cent of the average of the five years 1910-1914. In the
United States the preliminary estimate of 1932 gross in­
come of farms was $5,240,000,000. This was a reduction
of 25 per cent from 1931 and of 56 per cent from 1929,
when gross income was not high, and was only 77.5 per
cent of the 1910-1914 average. In Ohio, gross income,
on the basis of the first 11 months, as estimated by the
Ohio Agricultural Experiment Station, was 27 per cent
under 1931 and 58 per cent below 1929 and only 68 per
cent of the base period.
According to the Department of Agriculture, 1932 farm
production was 5.5 per cent below 1929, but farm
prices dropped 54 per cent in this period and were only
54 per cent of the five-year pre-war average. Wholesale
prices of commodities farmers buy were 106 per cent of
this same average, so that the ratio of prices received to
prices paid was only 51 per cent of the five-year average.
The reduction in prices, and consequently income, in
recent years is largely attributed to national and world­
wide changes in financial and economic conditions which
have brought about lower price levels in general and cur­
tailed demand for farm products in both foreign and
domestic markets. In the past ten years net farm pro­
duction has remained comparatively stable.
As a result of this sharp contraction in gross income,
coupled with the fact that fixed expenses in the form of
taxes, debt payments, etc., have declined only slightly,
purchasing power of this large group of domestic buyers
has been sharply curtailed in the past three years.

Wholesale and Retail Trade
Percentage
Increase or Decrease
SALES
SALES
STOCKS
N ov.,
N ov.,
First 11
months
1932
1932
D E P A R T M E N T STORES (54)
A kron.................................................
Cincinnati.........................................
Cleveland..........................................
Columbus. . . . . . . * * ........................
Pittsburgh.........................................
Toledo................................................
Wheeling...........................................
Other Cities.....................................
District..............................................
W E A R IN G A P P A R E L (12)
Cincinnati.................................„ . . .
Other Cities............................
D istrict..............................................
F U R N IT U R E (46)
Cincinnati.........................................
Cleveland..........................................
Columbus..........................................
D ayton..............................................
T oled o...............................................
Other Cities.....................................
District..............................................
CH AIN STORES*
Groceries— District (5 )............................
W HOLESALE GRO C E RIE S (37)
Akron...........................................................
Cleveland.....................................................
Erie...............................................................
Pittsburgh...................................................
T oledo...........................................................
Other Cities................................................
District.........................................................
W H OLESALE D R Y GOODS (1 1 )...
W HOLESALE DRU GS (1 3 )...............
W H OLESALE H A R D W A R E ( 1 5 ) ...
*Per individual unit operated.

(000 omitted)

%

change

Jan.-Nov.,
1932
Fourth District Unless Otherwise
Specified
31,330,000
— 26.1 17,488,000
Bank Debits— 24 cities.................
Savings Deposits— end of month:
644,0481
— 9.1
27 selected banks, O. & Pa.............3 630,391
— 4 .3
2,326
Postal Receipts (9 cities)..................$
(6)
Life Insurance Sales:
— 14.9
875,295
77,455
Ohio and Pa...................................... $
Retail Sales:
13,607
— 22.1
148,776
Department Stores— 54 firms........$
8,427
— 22.5
749
Wearing Apparel— 12 firms............$
— 33.4
4,925
436
Furniture— 46 firms......................... $
Wholesale Sales:
1,080
— 10.3
12,954
Drugs— 13 firms..................... . . . . . $
— 2 4.9
9,287
912
Dry Goods— 11 firms.......................$
3,043
— 15.7
36,595
Groceries— 37 firms..........................3
9,643
873
— 22.1
Hardware— 15 firms----- :••••.-------$
— 4 0.0
1,796
21,618
Building Contracts — Residential. . $
131,976
13,786
— 4 .8
— T otal. . . . . . . $
— 23.6
77,272
4,909
Commercial Failures— Liabilities.. .3
2,696
196* + 2 .6
”
”
— N u m b er.. . .
Production:
— 42.8
8,132
631
Pig Iron, U. S............ ................ Tons
12,251
— 36.2
1,015
Steel Ingots, U. S....................... Tons
+ 1 .8
102,535
11,536
Bituminous C oal....................... Tons
— 1.6
757
5,961
Cement— O., W. Pa., W. V a..B bls.
9,964*
1,037* — 11.2
Elec. Power— O., Pa., K y ....k .w .h .
—
17.1
19,672*
1,861*
Petroleum— O., Pa., K y...........Bbls.
5
5
+ 6 .2
Shoes ...........................................Pairs
2,060* — 13.8
28,737*
Tires, U. S............................... Casings
Bituminous Coal Shipments:
+ 2 9 .1
4,127
24,919
Lake Erie Ports............... ..
Tons
Iron Ore Receipts:
299
— 34.6
2,707
Lake Erie Ports..........................Tons
1 monthly average
4Jan.-0ct.^
Confidential
2actual number
(6)not available
•October




N ov.,
1932

from
1931

4 weeks
ending
Dec. 21,
1932
38,660

,,

H om estead....

change

M iddletow n...

from
1931
— 35.2

Steubenville...

— 12.5
Youngstown. . .
— 15.7
— 26.5
— 29.5
— 39.2
— 15.7
— 35.6
— 21.7
— 26.0
— 6 5.9
— 49.5
— 2.5
— 27.8
— 53.0
— 48.7
— 26.1
— 43.4
— 11.7
+ 1 .6
— 2.3
— 17.9
— 20.5
— 81.7

— 24.1
— 23.8
— 25.7
— 21.9
— 29.8
— 23.0
— 29.3
— 27.0
— 26.5

— 8 .3
— 28.9
— 29.9
— 17.0
— 22.6
— 13.7
— 19.0
— 19.8
— 22.9

— 14.1
— 27.4
— 22.5

— 25.5
— 30.8
— 28.9

— 30.6
— 31.0
— 30.8

— 4 .5
— 39.6
— 28.2
+ 7 .6
— 39.8
— 53.8
— 33.4

— 40.8
— 46.5
— 31.5
— 23.1
— 29.2
— 38.2
— 39.2

— 13.1
— 3 .6

— 13.4
— 8 .6

— 24.5
— 16.6
— 9 .4
— 12.4
— 21.6
— 12.5
— 15.7
— 24.9
— 10.3
— 22.1

— 25.3
— 22.1
— 17.9
— 21.2
— 21.8
— 21.2
— 21.7
— 35.6
— 15.7
— 26.0

....
.•*•

—
— 23.9

Debits to Individual Accounts

Greensburg. . .

Fourth District Business Statistics

— 18.7
— 18.8
— 21.6
— 19.9
— 26.6
— 21.1
— 18.5
— 16.4
— 22.1

16,729
192,125
319,560
80,781
36,021
16,450
2,129
4,101
6,039
2,143
16,319
6,718
2,268
4,892
395,764
9,352
3,837
61,476
3,735
23,295
19,787
4,856

(Thousands of Dollars)
Year-to-Date Year-to-Date
%
change Dec. 31, 1931 Jan. 1 to
Dec. 23,
to Dec. 21,
from
1931
1932
1931
925,920
573,131
— 35.5
102,948
71,990
— 31.8
388,319
— 9 .0
209,954
— 30.4
2,818,054
3,874,222
— 31.1
4,777,925
7,515,645
— 29.8
1,116,530
1,758,848
— 24.3
510,408
850,499
241,086
368,813
— 4 0.0
— 37.6
31,497
44,489
61,629
98,303
— 34.2
128,902
— 25.9
89,726
— 20.2
26,374
45,166
227,944
— 17.1
180,958
— 20.6
94,668
121,404
57,155
— 36.0
35,068
— 25.3
66,759
100,852
144,723
— 31.0
103,365
5,861,415
8,861,894
— 4 0 .0
— 28.6
135,667
205,465
59,895
97,680
— 44.1
873,461
1,463,511
— 20.2
— 24.9
53,289
93,526
— 29.3
309,623
430,009
— 16.6
309,448
555,547
— 27.5
66,424
101,512
— 3 3.0
18,678,344
28,563,296

%
change
from
1931
— 38.1
— 30.1
— 4 5.9
— 27.3
— 36.4
— 36.5
— 40.0
— 34.6
— 29.2
— 37.3
— 30.4
— 4 1.6
— 20.6
— 22.0
— 38.6
— 33.8
— 28.6
— 33.9
— 34.0
— 38.7
— 40.3
— 43.0
— 28.0
— 44.3
— 34.6
— 34.6

Fourth District Business Indexes
(1923-1925 = 100)
N ov., N ov., N ov., N ov., N ov.,
1932 1931 1930 1929 1928
133
Bank Debits (24 cities).........................................
49
122
66
96
131
116
82
Commercial Failures (N u m ber)........................
134
92
“
“
(L iabilities).....................
111
92
78
59
146
Postal Receipts (9 cities)....................................
90
94
106
118
122
93
109
109
137
Sales— Life insurance (Ohio & P a .)...............
122
60
“ — Department Stores (55 firm s)...............
79
95
109
112
“ — Wholesale Drugs (13 firm s).................
71
76
92
106
109
67
34
46
88
97
” —
”
Dry Goods (10 firm s).........
” —
**
Groceries (37 firm s)............
52
62
79
100
98
” —
”
Hardware (14 firm s)...........
42
57
75
93
99
50
60
78
98
100
” —
”
All (7 4 )..................................
67
78
84
88
” — Chain Drugs (3 firm s)**........................
83
29
30
79
50
119
Building Contracts (T o ta l)..................................
34
41
78
10
17
”
”
(Residential)........ ..
63
82
64
Production— Coal (O., W. Pa., E. K y .) ...........
96
97
90
128
132
63
64
”
— Cement (O., W. Pa., W . V a .). . . .
150
150
139
164
”
— Elec. Power (0 ., Pa., K y .) * .. . .
124
101
121
117
137
116
”
— Petroleum (O ., Pa., K y .) * ...........
37
88
79
48
45
”
— S h oe..................................................
♦October.
**Per individual unit operated.

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

8

Summary of National Business Conditions
By the Federal Reserve Board

Index of industrial production, adjusted for
seasonal variation, (1923*1925 average = 100)
Latest figure, November, €5.

Indexes based on three-month moving: aver­
ages of F. W . Dodge data for 37 eastern
states, adjusted for seasonal variation, (19231925 average = 100) Latest figures, Novem­
ber, total 2 8; residential, 11.

50

Index of United States Bureau of Labor Sta­
tistics (1026 = 100)
Latest figure, Novem­
ber, 63.9.

PwfckHJH* Ur w»
6300

RESHWE BANK CREDIT iuffl FACTCS5 Si CMAJ.Sf5
t
I

60C0

1

|

7

I Money « Circuistic*

*

i
j

MS0

35C0

. RssfrJe&flsitW!

2S30

*
i£3Si-----—

--

I—

J

A /

X

“"TS2

11

•r:-cs

"'W S8 "

Monthly averages of daily figure*.
Latest
figures are averages of first 20 days in
December.




Industrial activity declined in November by somewhat more than the
usual seasonal amount. Changes in factory employment and payrolls, re­
ported for the middle of the month, were largely seasonal in character.
Prices in wholesale commodity markets were somewhat lower, on the aver­
age, in November than in October, and declined further during the first three
weeks of December.
Production and Employment
Volume of industrial production, as measured by the Board’s season­
ally adjusted index, declined from 66 per cent of the 1923-25 average in
October to 65 per cent in November, compared with a low level of 58 per
cent in July. Output at woolen mills, silk mills, and shoe factories de­
clined in November from the relatively high levels of the autumn, while
cotton mills continued active. Lumber production declined by considerably
more than the usual seasonal amount. Steel production decreased during
November and the first three weeks of December, while automobile out­
put increased considerably, in connection with the introduction of new
models. The number employed at factories declined somewhat from Oc­
tober to November, reflecting in large part developments of a seasonal
character. Working forces in the woolen, silk, shoe, and canning industries
were reduced, while at car-building shops and at factories producing auto­
mobiles and agricultural implements there were increases in employment.
Construction contracts awarded up to December 15, as reported by
the F. W. Dodge Corporation, indicate for the last three months of the year
a decline from the third quarter of somewhat more than the usual sea­
sonal amount, following a non-seasonal increase from the second to the
third quarter.
Estimates of the Department of Agriculture, based on December
reports, indicate a cotton crop of 12,727,000 bales, about 800,000 bales
larger than the estimate a month earlier, but 4,400,000 bales smaller than
last year’s unusually large crop. Wheat, tobacco, flaxseed and other lead­
ing cash crops are also considerably smaller than a year ago, while feed
crops are substantially larger. Acreage of winter wheat planted this fall
was slightly smaller than a year ago, and condition of the crop on Decem­
ber 1 was unusually poor, according to the Department of Agriculture.
Distribution
Distribution of commodities by rail decreased seasonally from October
to November, while the dollar volume of department store sales, which ordi­
narily expands at this season, showed a decline.
Wholesale Prices
During early November the general level of wholesale commodity prices ad­
vanced somewhat, reflecting chiefly increases in prices of domestic agricul­
tural products; in the latter part of the month, however, prices of livestock,
cotton and grains declined considerably; and, during the first three weeks
of December, further declines in livestock prices were reported. By the
third week of December prices of textiles, copper and silver, as well as of
livestock, were substantially lower than in the middle of November and the
general average of wholesale prices was at a level slightly below that pre­
vailing before the advance that occurred last summer.
Bank Credit
During the four weeks ended December 14 there was an addition of
$85,000,000 to the country’s stock of monetary gold. The funds derived
from this source were utilized in meeting an increase in the demand for
currency, which was smaller than usual at this season, in further reducing
by $23,000,000 the indebtedness of member banks to the reserve banks,
and in increasing by $25,000,000 the volume of member bank reserve bal­
ances. On December 15 there was a further increase of $95,500,000 in the
stock of monetary gold in connection with the current payment by Great
Britain on the war debt. This amount of gold was earmarked in London
for account of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York and an equivalent
credit was given by that bank to the United States Treasury. This trans­
action together with other fiscal operations on December 15 resulted in a
temporary addition of $100,000,000 to the reserves of member banks, which
were subsequently reduced by Christmas currency demands and an increase
in Treasury deposits with the reserve banks.
Loans and investments of reporting member banks declined by more
than $100,000,000 between November 16 and December 14, reflecting re­
ductions in the banks’ holdings of United States Government securities, and
in loans other than security loans. Loans on securities increased, both at
New York City and at other reporting member banks.
Money rates in the open market declined further, rates on 90-day
bankers’ acceptances declining from Vz o i l per cent to % of 1 per cent, and
rates on prime commercial paper from a range of 1%-194 per cent to a range
of 1% -1% per cent.