View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
Covering financial, industrial, and agricultural conditions
in the

Fourth Federal Reserve District
Federal Reserve Bank o f Cleveland
Vol. 18

Cleveland, Ohio, December 1, 1932

Trade and industry in the fourth district continued
to expand in October at a greater-than-seasonal rate, but
in the first three weeks of November some irregularity
was reported in several lines. The increase from Sep­
tember to October was slightly more than the usual sea­
sonal amount, whereas in the entire country just about
a seasonal change was recorded, for the Board’s adjusted
index was 66 per cent of the 1923-1925 monthly aver­
age in October, the same as in the preceding month.
In this district, although the expansion in operations in
September was somewhat slower than in the entire coun­
try, the advance was continued in October at a betterthan-average rate, largely because of the volume o f au­
tomobile parts and material orders that was placed in
the period. Some slackening in a few' lines was apparent
in mid-November; in most cases, however, the changes
were seasonal in character, but in a few instances slightly
more than that in amount.
There was a greater-than-seasonal increase in em ploy­
ment in October and, compared with the low of August,
a gain of about four per cent has been experienced. Im­
provement in all m ajor lines o f activity was reported in
the latest month.
The steel industry increased output in October, con­
trary to the seasonal movement of past years, and opera­
tions were maintained in the first three weeks of No­
vember at a level slightly under the average for October,
almost entirely by automobile material orders. Cleveland
mills were producing at 38 per cent of capacity in the
third week of November, the highest level for any m ajor
producing center. Lack of rail and structural steel buy­
ing depressed operations in other sections, particularly
Pittsburgh.
Automobile production in October touched a new low
for any month since the war, but operations expanded
in the first half o f November as production o f new mod­
els was begun.
Production of bituminous coal by mines in this dis­
trict in October, was only 7.5 per cent below the same
month o f 1931, whereas output in the ten-month period
was down 28.5 per cent. Greater household demand and
a slight increase in industrial takings coincided with
the heavy shipments of coal from lake ports. As the
lake shipping season drew to a close in November, how­
ever, a recession in coal production occurred.
Tire production was down seasonally in October and
the first part o f November and schedules in the latter




No. 12

month pointed to a smaller output in that period than
for ten years.
Shoe production was seven per cent above a year ago
in October, but the reduction from September was slightly
more than seasonal. Clothing demand and production
have been fairly well maintained, though irregularities
are reported in some cases.
In the miscellaneous industries, glass production was
up sharply in October and cement production improved,
being above a year ago. The brick and tile industry is
very much depressed and activity at china and pottery
plants w^as little changed from September to October.
Activity at machine tool, electrical equipment, engineer­
ing, etc., plants improved slightly and orders for indus­
trial paints were larger than in September.
The dollar volume o f retail trade increased by more
than the usual seasonal amount in October and some
lines o f wholesale trade also improved. The weakness
in wholesale prices, however, was somewhat of a dis­
turbing factor; in the past few weeks comm odity price
indexes have fallen to approximately the levels of mid­
summer, due chiefly to weakness in prices o f farm prod­
ucts and foods.
Building activity declined less than seasonally in Oc­
tober, but the volume was much below the average of
past years.
In the first half o f November, contracts
awarded were only slightly below the same period of
1931 and higher than in the first two weeks of October.
Contracts for public w^orks and utilities were respon­
sible for the improvement.
Commercial failures were eight per cent less numerous

%

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

in October than a year ago and liabilities o f the default­
ing concerns were down 40 per cent. So far this year,
however, there have been 30 per cent more failures in this
district than in the same period o f 1931, though the av­
erage liability per failure was down materially.
FINANCIAL
A further reduction in the volume of member bank
borrowing at the Reserve bank was evident in this dis­
trict in the five weeks ended November 23 and such di­
rect loans were at about the same level as two years ago.
Member bank balances were reduced rather sharply and
demand for currency showed a slight increase, approxi­
mately seasonal. The volume o f credit extended by mem­
ber banks declined in the period and there was a slight
contraction in deposits, largely time deposits.
There were three bank suspensions in the district
in the first 28 days o f November, the same number as
occurred in October. Last year there were nine suspen­
sions in November and 49 in October. One sizeable bank
reopened in November in this district.
The decline in bank debits in October and the first
three weeks of November from a year ago in principal
cities o f the fourth district was somewhat smaller than
in earlier months o f the year; check payments in the
latest five-week period were about 29 per cent below the
same interval o f 1931.
The very moderate contraction in savings deposits in
recent months in contrast with the heavy withdrawals
which occurred in the last half of 1931 have tended to
reduce the percentage decline in the comparison of sav­
ings deposits with a year ago. On ^November 1 savings
deposits at selected banks were ten per cent lower than
on the same date last year; the reduction in October
was only 0.1 per cent, or approximately $1,000,000. Ohio
banks showed a slight increase, which was offset by de­
clines at banks in western Pennsylvania.
Reserve Bank Credit. During the five weeks ended No­
vember 23, gold reserves o f the Federal Reserve Bank of
Cleveland increased about $11,000,000, a movement con­
trary to the trend o f past years at this season. Compared
with a year ago, however, gold reserves are down about
$65,000,000.
In the period under discussion, member banks reduced
their borrowings about $4,000,000 to the lowest level
since mid-summer o f 1931. As shown on the chart on




page 1, bills discounted are $66,000,000 below the level
o f last year, when demand for currency was very active,
and are at approximately the level of two years ago.
This bank’s holdings o f other bills and securities
showed practically no change in the five weeks, holdings
of Government securities remaining at record levels,
while acceptance holdings dropped slightly.
Circulation o f Federal reserve notes increased about
$3,000,000 in the five latest weeks, the first sizeable ad­
vance since July. Normally, note circulation expands at
this season, but the upturn so far has been smaller than
in preceding years. A t $278,000,000 on November 23,
however, circulation was $33,000,000 below a year ago
when the volume was unusually high as a result o f the
disturbed banking situation, which caused individuals
as well as banks to accumulate larger holdings o f cash.
Reserve deposits declined rather sharply in the sec­
ond and third weeks of November as deposits at mem­
ber banks were reduced. On the latest date reserve de­
posits were lower than since June and about eight per
cent below one year ago. A reduction in the number of
member banks was partly responsible for the drop in re­
serve balances, both from a year ago and in the past
month.
Member Bank Credit. Loans and investments of week­
ly reporting member banks in leading cities of the fourth
district declined from the middle o f October to the third
week of November, reflecting largely a reduction in loans
to customers; investment holdings, however, which in­
creased to a record high level in the week of November 9,
were reduced in the two ensuing periods.
Comparison o f current figures for weekly reporting
member banks with those of last month are affected by
the suspension of two Pittsburgh banks with loans and
investments o f $19,000,000, both of which were included
in the weekly reporting group.
Time deposits have declined slightly in recent weeks,
but demand deposits, after allowing for the reduction in
the number of banks, remained at the highest level since
January.
As shown on the accompanying chart the ratio of loans
to total deposits has declined quite sharply since Janu­
ary. In October it was at approximately the same level
as in the middle o f 1931, and about the lowest in the past
ten years. The recent reduction is a result o f a sharper
contraction in loans than in total deposits. Deposits are
up substantially from the low point touched in July,
whereas loans are at the lowest level in many years.
MANUFACTURING, MINING
Employment

Industrial employment in the principal
states o f this district as well as in the
entire country increased from Septem­
ber to October and payrolls expanded generally to a
greater degree.
In Ohio, employment advanced two
per cent in October in contrast with an average decline
o f that amount in the past five years. In Pennsylvania,
as a whole, an increase was reported, but at Pittsburgh
a slight reduction in the number o f man hours worked
was recorded as a result o f declines in operations at
structural and miscellaneous plants. Foundries and ma­

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
chine shops increased operations somewhat. In western
Pennsylvania, outside Pittsburgh, industrial activity
showed strength generally. Part of the increase in em­
ployment resulted from the wider distribution of avail­
able work among employees in an endeavor to share the
work as much as possible, instead o f increasing the num­
ber of hours worked by each individual.
In Ohio, of the 761 firms reporting to the Ohio State
Bureau of Business Research, 375 reported increases and
105 no change from September. A ll important lines of
activity showed increases or less-than-seasonal decreases
except the miscellaneous manufacturing group which
showed a reduction o f two per cent in contrast with a
five-year average decline o f one per cent. All principal
manufacturing centers in the state except Columbus and
Youngstown reported an increase in employment from
September to October.
Iron and
Steel

Support from automobile manufacturers, getting into production on new
models, imparted a vigor to iron and
steel production in the fourth district in late October
and the first three weeks of November that was lacking
in other producing districts largely dependent upon rail­
road, building and miscellaneous requirements.
Releases, principally from low-priced car manufacturers,
enabled mills at Cleveland to advance their operating
rate from 23 per cent to 38 during the period. Pittsburgh
producers expanded from 17 per cent to 20, then fell
back to 18 in mid-November. Youngstown mills gained
fractionally from 19 per cent to 1 9 % , then eased off to
16. Meanwhile, steel production for the country as a
whole expanded during this month from 20 per cent to
21, then declined to 19.
By the middle of November, however, it was apparent
that automotive releases had reached their peak, although
it was thought they would maintain a fair volume into
December. Failure of railroad equipment repair, building
and other emergency projects, financed by government
loans, to mature rapidly was a retarding factor, but a re­
duction in operations from mid-November to the year-end
is not unseasonal. It was hoped in the trade that, because
of the low rate o f operations which have prevailed this
fall, this downward movement would not develop to the
extent it had in other years, but releases for automobile
steel requirements have been insufficient to offset the
decline in demand for other types of steel.
This slightly easier market situation was accompanied
by more irregularities in prices. Tin plate, quoted at
$4.75 per 100-pound box for the past year, was reduced
50 cents November 17. Completing the cycle, inaugurated
when rails were reduced $3 a ton, angle bars and spikes
have been lowered $4 per ton and tie plates $2. Sheets
for automotive purposes eased off an average o f $2. In
the absence of further demand from consumers, scrap
surrendered 50 to 75 cents of the recent advance and
fo th foundry and beehive coke went to slightly lower
levels. These price changes are reflected in a decline
in the iron and steel composite o f the magazine Steel
from $29.32 on October 22 to $28.92 on November 19.
Over the same period the scrap composite of this publica­
tion went from $6.96 to $6.81.
Final statistics on production in October disclose sub­




S

stantial gains in both pig iron and steel ingots. The Oc­
tober daily rate o f coke pig iron output, at 20,795 gross
tons, compares with 19,788 tons in September and was
the highest since June. The October total o f 644,648
tons brought ten-month production o f pig iron up to 7,~
501,135 tons, compared with 16,180,814 tons in the com ­
parable period o f 1931. A net gain o f four furnaces in
blast increased the number of active stacks on October
31 to 50 of a potential 292.
October's daily steel ingot rate of 41,098 tons com ­
pares with 37,502 in September and was the best since
May. October production was at 19 per cent o f capacity,
contrasted with 17.3 in September and 14.2 in August.
The October total o f 1,068,550 tons put production for
ten months at 11,236,315 tons, compared with 22,299,860 tons a year ago.
Coal

W hile coal production has shown the
usual seasonal recession from the midOctober high point, the decline has
been about the same as last year’s, despite the sharp rise
from the summer low.
Output o f bituminous coal in October, both in the fourth
district and the entire country, was up sharply from the
preceding month and, in the case of some mines, exceeded
production in October, 1931.
There were 12,380,000
tons of coal produced by mines in this section in October,
an increase o f 22 per cent from September and repre­
sented a reduction o f only 7.5 per cent from October,
1931. In the first ten months output was 28.5 per cent
below the same period of last year. In the entire country
production in October was five per cent below a year ago
and the decline in the ten-month period was 32.2 per
cent.
Shipments o f coal from Lake Erie ports have stopped,
but the amount o f coal thus shipped in October was only
6.7 per cent less than the volume moved by water in
October, 1931, whereas lake shipments for the season
were down 26 per cent. More than the usual percentage
of coal was shipped from Lake Erie ports this year be­
cause of irregularities in rail rates.
The basic factor of strength in the coal industry at
the present time is the low level o f stocks above ground.
Unlike many other raw materials, stocks are at tha
lowest level for this season in the past ten years, accord­
ing to the Bureau o f Mines. Compared with a year ago,
stocks above ground are down 20.3 per cent and even
allowing for the current low rate o f consumption, stocks
in terms o f days* supply were 2.6 per cent smaller than a
year ago. There was 20.5 per cent less coal on upper
lake docks on October 1 than a year earlier. Stocks in
retail yards showed the largest discrepancy from a year
ago, representing only 40 days' supply on October 1 as
against 45 days’ supply on the same date last year.
As a result o f the colder weather there has been an in­
creased demand for domestic sizes and grades, with a
consequent advance in price. The supply o f slack and
steam coal is still large.
Automobiles

The automobile industry came nearer
being entirely inactive in October than
at any time for which figures are avail­
able. The Federal Reserve Board’s adjusted index dropped

4

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

to 17 per cent of the 1923-1925 monthly average, com­
pared with 21 in September and 28 in October last year.
Passenger car production was only 14 per cent of the
1923-1925 average, while truck production was 36 per
cent of this same base.
There were only 48,934 cars and trucks made in the
month, according to the Department o f Commerce, a re­
duction of 39 per cent from the same period last year.
Truck production was off 37 per cent and passenger car
39.5 per cent. In the first ten months the reduction in
automobile production from the same interval of 1931
was 45 per cent.
As retail sales o f automobiles contracted in recent
months, production was curtailed and most factories
started to work on 1933 models in October. This was re­
flected in the parts and steel orders placed at factories in
this district which caused their operations to expand in
that month. The weekly automobile production index of
the Annalist also turned up in the closing week of Octo­
ber and advanced more than ten points in the first two
weeks of November as output o f new models began at
several plants. This weekly adjusted index for the lat­
est period was 30 per cent o f the 1927-1929 average com ­
pared with a low o f 14 per cent in late October and 17.8
per cent for the corresponding week last year. Actual
output in the latest week, according to Cram's reports,
was 13,282 cars and trucks as against 8,709 units in the
same period of 1931. Many o f these new cars are needed
to provide dealers with samples prior to the annual shows.
Tires,
Rubber

The tire industry usually experiences its
lowest production in November and,
from indications, output in the past
month was lower than in any preceding period of 1932.
In addition, it was the smallest for any month in the
past ten years, being unusually low, partly because of the
over-ordering by dealers in July and September when
price increases were anticipated.
Tire production in the first nine months of 1932 was
down 18.2 per cent from the same period of 1931. Part
of this reduction is a result o f the smaller number of
cars in use, registrations in 1932 being only 23,500,000
against 25,814,000 in 1931. This, however, is a loss of
only nine per cent. The drop in gasoline consumption in
1932, on the basis o f figures now available, is estimated
at 8.4 per cent, indicating that cars are being driven
about as much this year as in 1931, after allowing for
the drop in registrations. W hile the loss in original equip­
ment sales for new automobiles has been large on a per­
centage basis, actually it has been o f only moderate im ­
portance so far as total tire production is concerned be­
cause original equipment tires represent only about 25
per cent of total tire sales.
The chief reason for the decline, therefore, in the num­
ber of tires produced is the increased mileage which is
being built in the individual tire. A reliable authority
estimates the average life of a balloon tire conservatively
at more than 18,000 miles, whereas two years ago it was
only 15,900 miles. As the quality o f the tire has im­
proved, the demand has declined, and incidentally for
other reasons the price has been reduced sharply.




The higher prices, inaugurated in September,
the increased cost of raw materials, the Federal
were not long maintained, a general reduction
mating 2 Vz per cent being reported in dealers’
early November.

to cover
tax, etc.,
approxi­
prices in

Employment at 22 Ohio rubber factories showed a
slight increase in October in contrast with a five-year
average decline o f three per cent fo r the period, but the
number employed continues ten per cent below a year ago
and only 59 per cent of the 1926 monthly average. A
decline, largely seasonal, was reported for November.
Crude rubber consumption in October by manufac­
turers in the United States amounted to 21,018 long tons,
compared with 22,491 long tons in September and 22,271
long tons in October, 1931, according to the Rubber
Manufacturers’ Association. Imports in October, at 35,473 long tons, exceeded consumption by over 60 per cent,
being up 20 per cent from September. They were 14 per
cent below the same month last year, and down 13.6 per
cent in the first ten months. Domestic stocks are still 37
per cent larger than a year ago.
Some recession developed in crude rubber prices coin­
cident with the recent drop in com m odity prices, but they
still remain about 75 per cent above the June low point.
Clothing

Although irregularities are apparent in
the clothing industry, the general trend
o f operations in October was upward in
this district and some companies report the best volume
in September and October that has been experienced in
over a year. Employment at 42 plants reporting to the
Bureau o f Business Research was up ten per cent in Oc­
tober from the preceding month and the index was 88 per
cent o f the 1926 monthly average. This is two points
above last year at this time.
The number employed
at men’s clothing factories was 101 per cent o f the base
period, about the same as last year, but plants making
wom en’s and miscellaneous clothing had eight per cent
more employees than a year ago.
Throughout the country generally, demand for cloth­
ing has been increasing for several months and consump­
tion of raw materials has advanced sharply. Takings of
raw wool in September, the latest available, were 95.5
per cent of estimated normal, according to the Annalist's
index. This was an increase of 142 per cent from the
low point in May, after allowing for seasonal changes.
Cotton, silk and rayon consumption also have increased
sharply in recent weeks, the forem ost being 83 per cent
of estimated normal in October, an advance o f more than
25 points from the low in May. Textile plants, both in
this district and the entire country, are operating at the
highest level and employing more people than any time
in the past year.
So far as clothing sales are concerned, orders for winter
garments have fluctuated with the weather. They fell off
somewhat in late October, but sales in November, boiH
wholesale and retail, improved.
A few companies introduced
ly and advance orders on these
were most gratifying. Prices
due to the lower material costs

their spring lines recent­
items in the first ten days
in general are quite low,
and wage rates prevailing

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
now than a year ago.
Some dissatisfaction regarding
collections was reported.
Demand for knitted outerwear has declined in the past
month, largely seasonally, but activity in other knitted
lines has increased sharply. In the trade, however, this
is interpreted as being little more than orders which usu­
ally are placed early in the year.
Other
Manufacturing

Irregularities were quite evident in the
trend of operations in the smaller in­
dustries of this district in October and
the first part of November. Some rather sizeable in­
creases were reported in a few specific lines, but they
were offset by declines in other branches.

The most important expansion occurred in the various
lines connected with the automobile industry. Produc­
tion o f metal products, parts and accessories increased
in October and the first part o f November and demand
for machine tools expanded as plants retooled in prepara­
tion for the new models which will make their appear­
ance from now until the time of the annual shows. Em­
ployment at machine tool factories increased four per
cent from September to October in contrast with a fiveyear average decline o f one per cent, and special pur­
pose machinery plants increased the number of their
employees three per cent. Engineering appliances and
specialties were also in greater demand.
Orders for electrical equipment, which improved in
September, continued to expand in October and in the
latter period were materially above the low point o f m id­
summer. This was partly seasonal and therefore only
slightly affected operations, the larger sales acting as
sort of a backlog. There has been no appreciable change
in prices of raw materials, wages or finished goods re­
cently.
Employment in the ceramic industry was up five per
cent in October, but was only 56 per cent of the 1926 av­
erage. The brick and tile branch was very depressed,
the number of employees declining 11 per cent in Octo­
ber to only 34 per cent of the monthly average o f 192 6.
Glass production increased sharply, employment being
up 30 per cent to 111 per cent o f the base period, tne
advance coming at a time when there usually is little
change in the number of workers. Plate glass demand
increased because o f the larger orders from the automo­
bile industry, but demand from jobbers and mirror manu­
facturers has fallen off slightly. Sales of glass containers
dropped off recently, largely a seasonal development,
but sales of flat glass have shown little change. Stocks
of window glass in jobbers’ hands are the lowest on rec­
ord, and in October consumption exceeded production.
Conditions in the pottery industry have been irregular
recently, and operations are around 40 per cent of ca­
pacity. There has been no recent change in wages or
prices. Collections have improved slightly.
Although this is the dull period so far as consumer
paint demand is concerned, there has been a slight in­
crease in orders for industrial paint. Paint sales for the
novelty business are fairly good and very slight increases
in demand for paints and lacquers for furniture have
been observed. Sales of paints for building maintenance




5

have declined seasonally. One company reported an in­
crease in export sales.
The paper and boxboard industry showed a greaterthan-seasonal increase in September and October, but in
recent weeks a rather sharp contraction in orders and
operations has developed.
Production o f shoes in this district in October declined
rather sharply from September, but the reduction, 19
per cent, was smaller than a year ago, though somewhat
greater than seasonal. Part of the falling-off was the r e ­
action from the relatively high level of September, but
despite the decline, output in October was 17.7 per cent
above the same month last year. In the first ten months
there were 2.9 per cent fewer shoes made at the 29 fourth
district establishments than in the same period of 1931.
Irregularities still are quite noticeable, producers of
the low and medium-priced footwear, particularly wom­
en’s enjoying a much larger volume of orders than makers
o f high grade shoes. The seasonally adjusted daily aver­
age index of shoe production in this district was 68 per
cent o f the 1923-1925 monthly average in October, com ­
pared with 78 in September and 55 a year ago.
TRADE
Retail trade in the fourth district, judging by reports
from 55 large department stores in principal cities, im­
proved slightly more than the estimated seasonal amount
in October, the adjusted index rising five-tenths of a point.
Compared with the record low point o f August, October
sales were up 13 per cent after allowing for usual seasonal
changes. This increase in dollar sales occurred despite
the fact that the trend o f prices during the three-month
period was downward, judging by Fairchild's index. On
November 1 this index was 15 per cent lower t h a n a year
ago and 38 per cent below November, 1929. Dollar sales
in October at reporting stores were 25 per cent below
the corresponding month o f 1931, and sales in the first,
ten-months were 27 per cent smaller than in the same
period of the preceding year.
In individual departments sales of furs in October were
2.7 per cent larger than in the same month o f 1931. Sales
o f neckwear and scarfs were down 3.6 per cent from last
year and silverware and yard goods sales were off 15 per
cent from a year ago. Sales of notions were down 17 per
cent and art needlework and art goods sales were ten
per cent below one year ago. Most other departments
showed reductions approximating the decline in total
sales.
The dollar value o f stocks increased 4.6 per cent in
October, which was slightly less than the estimated sea­
sonal amount and the adjusted index dropped to 57 per
cent of the 1923-1925 average, a new low level for this
depression. Compared with a year ago the dollar value
o f stocks was down 24.1 per cent.
Charge sales in October amounted to 57.5 per cent of
total sales, approximately the same as a year ago, but
slightly under September.
Some improvement in collections was reported in Octo­
ber, when 29.3 per cent o f accounts receivable on Sep­
tember 30 were paid during the month. This was partly
seasonal, but the collection ratio was seven per cent below

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

6

a year ago.
Collections on installment accounts were
down ten per cent from last year.
Sales of reporting wearing apparel stores, largely wom­
en’s shops, were off 28 per cent in October and 30 per
cent in the first ten months from similar periods of 1931.
The dollar value o f stocks was off 30 per cent from a
year ago.
Chain drug and grocery store dollar sales showed
larger discrepancies in October from a year ago than in
earlier months o f 1932, the form er being off 14.5 per
cent and the latter 13.3 per cent.
W holesale
Trade

A contrary-to-seasonal reduction in the
dollar volume of wholesale sales in four
reporting lines occurred in October, the
composite index being only 51 per cent of the 1923-1925
monthly average compared with 70 per cent a year ago
and 56 in September. The largest decline was in grocery
sales which were down 14 per cent from September and
26 per cent from a year ago. In the ten-month period
the decline in sales was 22 per cent.
Wholesale drug sales dropped three per cent in Octo­
ber and were off 16 per cent from last year. The loss
in the January-to-October period from 1931 was 14 per
cent.
Dry goods sales improved slightly, but less than in
form er years, and were still down 32 per cent in October
and 37 per cent in the ten-month period.
Hardware
sales increased about the usual seasonal amount, but were
only 45 per cent o f the 1923-1925 average and 25 per
cent below last year in October and down 26 per cent
in the ten-month period.
Collections as a per cent of accounts receivable were
down quite sharply in all reporting lines except dry goods
where the reduction was slight from last year.
BUILDING
Contracts awarded for new construction in this dis­
trict in October were valued at $9,830,000, according to
the F. W . Dodge Corporation. This represented a lessthan-seasonal decline from September, the falling-off o f
6.8 per cent comparing with reductions of four to 32 per
cent in seven of the past ten years, increases of 15 to 25
per cent being shown in the other three periods. Com­
pared with preceding years, however, building activity
is very depressed. The drop from October, 1931 was 25
per cent, and compared with the average of the past ten
years, awards were down almost 80 per cent.
Increases in non-residential building in October over
the preceding month, a result of the awarding of six con­
tracts for post offices in Ohio and a slight increase in
public utility contracts awarded, were insufficient to o ff­
set the reduction in residential and public utility con­
tracts awarded. The latter, however, were above a year
ago, the increase being due to contracts awarded for sew­
erage systems and waterfront developments. Building ac­
tivity in this section is thus being maintained to some ex­
tent by projects financed by public funds, but the total
is still much below a year ago because of the drastic cur­
tailment of residential and commercial building.
Total awards in Ohio, eastern Kentucky and West Vir­
ginia were larger in October than a year ago, but some




large contracts let in western Pennsylvania last year made
the comparison with October, 1932 an unfavorable one.
The value o f residential building contracts awarded
in October was 60 per cent smaller than a year ago
and down 67 per cent in the first ten months o f 1932
compared with the same period of 1931.
All contracts awarded were down 54 per cent in the
ten-month period, declines being shown by all the four
m ajor construction classifications, the largest relative
losses being in public utility and residential building.
In regard to the building supply situation, it is any­
thing but favorable. Operations are exceedingly slow and
orders are limited chiefly to scattered repair or renovizing jobs.
Material prices are slightly above the mid­
summer lows, but have weakened some recently. There
is little incentive for lumber dealers to stock up, and on
the few sales that are made collections are very slow.
A decided increase in cement production in this dis­
trict was apparent in October as several plants resumed
operations after being shut down for varying lengths of
time. Output was 16 per cent above a year ago, whereas
in the first nine months of this year cement production
was 53 per cent behind the same period o f 1931. Sales
have not increased to the extent production has, however.
AGRICULTURE
The 1932 crop year is rapidly drawing to a close and,
pending a final check on acreage harvested, production
estimates remain about the same as a month ago— from
about 5 to 15 per cent below the ten-year average in
the states of this district. Rainfall was quite general in
October and copious in some sections so that much of
the moisture deficiency was made up.
Pastures and
winter-sown grains were greatly benefited and wells that
had been dry for many months were filled with water.
Production estimates o f late-maturing crops in this
district were revised upward slightly, but the corn crop is
still much smaller than the 1931 harvest and also about
16,000,000 bushels, or nine per cent, below the ten-year
average harvest. Potato production this past year in
the district was only slightly below output in 1931 and
about the same as the average of the past ten years, con­
siderable improvement in the crop occurring in the late
months.
Estimated fruit yields were little changed in October,
and, with the exception of the grape crop, were much be­
low average in quantity and condition.
Tobacco production in this section is much below last
year’s output and about 25,000,000 pounds, or 16 per
cent, below the average o f the past ten years. In the
entire country a greater discrepancy from the average of
past years was reported, the falling-off being due to a re­
duction of acreage as well as in yield per acre. Esti­
mated burley tobacco production was reduced one per
cent in October and, though the harvest is nearly 30 per
cent below the 1931 yield, burley is the only type to show
a larger crop than the average of preceding years. Com­
pared with the five-year average harvest o f 1926-1930,
the present crop is up 17 per cent.
A ccording to indications a large quantity o f burley
tobacco will be ready for sale when the market opens

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
early in the month. Curing has progressed very s a t e
factorily and much stripping has been done. It now ap­
pears that the tobacco which will be offered for sale is
o f relatively better quality than last year, but there is
a sizeable amount of red tobacco which will be placed on
the market.
An unfavorable development in the past month was
the drop in the general level of farm prices. The Depart­
ment of Agriculture’s index dropped from 59 per cent of
the five-year pre-war average in September to 56 in October
and showed further weakness in early November. The de­
cline in October was the result o f reductions in all prin­
cipal commodities except eggs, dairy products and wool.
Prices of grains, fruits and vegetables dropped to new
low levels for the 22 years covered by the index. Com­
pared with a year ago prices were down 17 per cent.
The estimated gross cash income from six important
sources in Ohio, according to the Ohio Agricultural Experi­
ment Station, (meat animals, dairy products, grains,
poultry and eggs, potatoes, and w ool) was 20 per cent
smaller in October than in the same month o f 1931 and
only 43 per cent o f the five-year average 1924-1928. Com­
pared with a year ago the largest declines were in grains
and meat animals, but they were offset in part by a size­
able increase in income derived from the sale o f wool.
Wages paid farm labor have declined sharply in the
past j^ear and demand for help is much below normal
with the supply 238 per cent o f demand in Ohio, 190
per cent in Pennsylvania, and 218 per cent in Kentucky
in October. The average monthly wage paid with board
was $19 in Ohio, compared with $26 a year ago. W ith­
out board the average wage was $29 as against $37.75
in October, 1931.

Wholesale and Retail Trade
(1932 compared with 1931)
Percentage
Increase or Decrease
SALES
SALES
STOCKS
Oct.,
First 10
Oct..
1932
months
1932

DEPARTMENT STORES (54)
Akron.................................................................. — 11.3
Cincinnati........................................................... — 25.2
Cleveland........................................................... — 29.7
Columbus........................................................... — 20.8
Pittsburgh.......................................................... — 27.7
Toledo................ . .............................................. — 21.2
Wheeling............................................................ — 22.2
Youngstown....................................................... — 13.6
Other Cities....................................................... — 25.1
District............................................................... — 25.3
WEARING APPAREL (12)
Cincinnati........................................................... — 24.6
Other Cities....................................................... — 30.3
District...................... ....................................... — 28.2
FURNITURE (46)
Cincinnati........................................................... — 32.6
Cleveland........................................................... — 44.9
Columbus........................................................... — 30.3
Dayton............................................................... — 5.4
Toledo................................................................ — 28.8
Other Cities....................................................... — 37.5
District.............................................................. — 35.9
CHAIN STORES*
Drugs— District (4 ).......................................... — 14.5
Groceries— District (5)..................................... — 13.3
WHOLESALE GROCERIES (37)
Akron.................................................................. — 32.6
Cleveland........................................................... — 24.8
Erie..................................................................... — 23.2
Pittsburgh................................................ ..
— 28.5
Toledo................................................................ — 25.5
Other Cities....................................................... — 26.6
District............................................................... — 26.2
WHOLESALE DRY GOODS (11)............... — 32.4
WHOLESALE DRUGS (13)......................... — 17.3
WHOLESALE HARDWARE (15)............... — 25.4
*Per individual unit operated.




— 24.6
— 24.3
— 26.1
— 22.1
— 30.1
— 23.2
— 30.2
— 30.7
— 27.4
— 27.0

— 10.5
— 27.7
— 28.6
— 22.3
— 24.6
— 12.7
— 21.7
— 16.4
— 27.4
— 24.1

— 27.2
— 31.7
—30.1

— 30.5
— 30.3
— 30.4

— 43.7
— 47.1
— 31.8
— 25.1
— 28.3
— 39.1
— 40.1

....
....

— 13.4
— 9.1
— 25.3
— 22.6
— 18.6
— 22.0
— 21.9
— 21.9
— 22.2
— 36.5
— 15.7
— 26.4

....
— 11.2
— 27.0
....

7

Fourth District Business Statistics
(000 omitted)
% change
from
1931
— 36.5

Fourth District Unless
Oct.,
Otherwise Specified
1932
Bank Debits— 24 cities................$ 1. 511.000
Savings Deposits—end of month:
27 selected banks, O. & Pa........$ 629,984
Life Insurance Sales:
Ohio and Pa...............................$
70,209
Retail Sales:
Department Stores— 54 firm s...$
14,779
Wearing Apparel— 12 firms.......$
870
Furniture— 46 firms................... $
496
Wholesa’ e Sales:
Drugs— 13 firms......................... $
1,008
Dry Goods— 11 firms................ $
1,008
Groceries— 37 firms.................... $
3,095
934
Hardware— 15 firms...................$
1,556
Building Contracts— Residential.?
9,830
”
”
— T o t a l..... .$
Commercial Failures— Liabilities $
6,387
— Number..
234*
Production:
Pig Iron, U. S.......................Tons
645
1,069
Steel Ingots, U. S................. Tons
Automobiles-Pass. Cars, U. S.. ..
35,3392
13,5953
”
-Trucks, U. S...........
12,380
Bituminous Coal................. Tons
Cement-O., W. Pa., W. Va. Bbls.
1,053
9583
Elec. Power-O., Pa., Ky. k.w.h.
1,9953
Petroleum-O., Pa., Ky........Bbls.

% change
from
1931
— 36.1

—

9.8

645,4141

—

—

17.9

797,840

—

15.7

—

25.3
28.2
35.9

135,196
7,678
4,505

—
—
—

27.0
30.1
40.1

17.3
32.4
26.2
25.4
59.8
25.3
39.5
8.2

11,001
8,376
33,552
8,770
19,822
108,190
72,363
2,5002

15.7
36.5
22.2
— 26.4
— 67.2
— 54.3
— 0.6
+ 30.3

45.0
32.8
39.5
37.4
7.5
16.5

7,501
11,236
1, 002,0422

—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—

202,9212

12.8

—
—
—

—
—
—
—

53.6
49.6
45.4
37.4
28.5
46.7

—

1 1 .8

—
—

2,0393

4.5
+ 1 7 .7
— 20.1

90,999
5,204
8, 927*
17,8114
5
26, 677*

4,390

— 6.7

20,793

—

26.1

2,408

—

83.2

ft

Tires, U. S............. .......... Casings
Bituminous Coal Shipments:
Lake Erie Ports................... Tons
Iron Ore Receipts:
Lake Erie Ports................... Tons
1monthly average
2actual number
8September

Jan.-Oct.
1932
16, 158,000

614

+
—
—

14.1

69.7
4Jan.-Sept.
Confidential
—

+ 4.0
2.9
— 18.2
—

Debits to Individual Accounts
5 weeks
ending
Nov. 23,
1932
46,644
6,009
17,985
Canton.. . . . . . . . .
241,927
Cincinnati
399,564
94,085
40,984
20,491
2,219
5,227
Greensburg. . .
8,433
2,007
Homestead.. . ,
14,263
8,583
2,845
6,334
Middletown. ..
8,378
496,441
11,844
4,948
Steubenville...
80,085
4,600
26,732
26,410
Youngstown. . ,
5,457
1,582,495

%
change
from
1931
— 37.2
— 30.2
— 8.0
— 24.7
— 31.7
— 28.6
— 23.7
— 38.0
— 36.4
— 37.2
— 20.2
— 46.2
— 23.7
— 4.4
— 36.4
— 24.3
— 27.8
— 34.2
— 27.2
— 33.3
— 3.9
— 27.7
— 25.9
+ 7.3
— 35.9
— 29.4

Year-to-date Year-to-date
Dec. 31, 1931
Jan. 1
to
to
Nov. 23, 1932 Nov. 25,1931
534,471
866,004
66,753
95,274
193,225
369,928
2,625,929
3,598,049
4,458,365
7,051,547
1,035,749
1,643,718
474,387
802,924
224,636
341,414
29,368
41,075
57,528
92,068
83,687
120,750
24,231
42,481
164,639
208,264
87,950
112,943
32,800
53,610
61,867
94,302
96,389
134,609
5,465,651
8,202,142
126,315
192,367
56,058
90,820
811,985
1,386,467
49,554
88,552
286,328
397,082
289,661
531,813
61,568
94,813
17,399,094
26,653,016

%
change
from
1931
— 38.3
— 29.9
— 47.8
— 27.0
— 36.8
— 37.0
— 40.9
— 34.2
— 28.5
— 37.5
— 30.7
— 43.0
— 21.0
— 22.1
— 38.8
— 34.4
— 28.4
— 33.4
— 34.3
— 38.3
— 41.4
— 44.0
— 27.9
— 45.5
— 35.1
— 34.7

Fourth District Business Indexes
(1923-1925 * 100)
Oct., Oct., Oct., Oct., Oct.,
1932 1931 1930 1929 192$
Bank Debits (24 cities)......................... ...........
56
88
116
148
136
Commercial Failures (Number)......................
160
175
127
90
111
”
”
(Liabilities)...................
239
145
79
82
54
Sales— Life Insurance (Ohio & Pa.)................
84
102
113
134
130
” — Department Stores (55 firms)..............
62
78
100
111
105
87
** — Wholesale Drugs (13 firms)................
71
118
102
114
” —
”
Dry Goods (10 firms)........
57
38
86
109
106
” —
**
Groceries (37 firms)...........
53
72
98
116
110
” —
”
Hardware (14 firms)..........
45
64
107
85
106
All (74)...............................
51
70
94
113
109
” — Chain Drugs (3 firms)**.......................
80
87
68
89
90
Building Contracts (Total).............................
28
21
87
156
120
”
”
(Residential)...................
71
9
23
46
102
Production— Coal (O., W. Pa., E. K y.)..........
68
74
97
J12
106
— Cement (0., W. Pa., W. V a.)...
88
75
138
144
176
’*
— Elec. Power (O., Pa., K y .)* .. . .
133
156
114
139
135
120
”
— Petroleum (O., Pa., K y.)*..........
108
113
112
105
75
64
115
120
74
”
— Shoes............................................
f *September.
**Per individual unit operated.

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

8

Summary of National Business Conditions
By the Federal Reserve Board
Volume of industrial output, after increasing considerably during Au­
gust and September, remained unchanged in October. Factory employment
and payrolls, reported for the middle of the month, showed a further in­
crease. During October, as in the last three weeks of September, whole­
sale comm odity prices declined, and in the first three weeks of November
the general average was at the level of early summer.
Production and Employment

Index of industrial production, adjusted for
seasonal variation, (1923-1925 average — 100)
Latest figure, October, 66.

Federal Reserve Board’s index of factory em­
ployment with adjustment for seasonal varia­
tion (1923-1925 average = 100) Latest figure,
October, 61,3.

Industrial production, as measured by the Board’s seasonally adjusted
index, continued in October at 66 per cent of the 1923-1925 average, as
compared with a low level of 58 per cent in July. In the textile industries,
which had shown a rapid expansion in August and September, there was a
slight decrease in consumption of raw materials while output of finished
products increased somewhat. Shoe production which also had increased
substantially in recent months, showed a seasonal decline. Operations at
steel mills expanded from an average of 17 per cent o f capacity in Septem­
ber to 19 per cent in October, contrary to seasonal tendency, and, accord­
ing to trade reports, continued at about this rate through the first three
weeks of November. Production of automobiles in October declined fur­
ther to a new low level. At coal mines activity continued to increase
rapidly until the middle of October, but since that time a reduction, large­
ly seasonal in character, has been reported.
Employment in most manufacturing industries increased between the
middle of September and the middle of October, and the Board’s seasonally
adjusted index of factory employment showed an advance from 60 per cent
of the 1923-1925 average to 61 per cent. At textile mills working forces
increased by considerably more than the usual seasonal amount, and sub­
stantial increases were also reported at steel mills, lumber mills and car
building shops. In the canning and automobile industries there were de­
creases in employment.
Value of construction contracts awarded, as reported by the F. W.
Dodge Corporation, continued at low levels during October and the first
half of November.
The Department of Agriculture’s estimate of the cotton crop, based on
November 1 conditions, was 11,950,000 bales, about 525,000 bales larger
than the estimate a month earlier.
Distribution
From September to October volume o f freight traffic increased by more
than the usual seasonal amount; after the middle o f October carloadings
declined, reflecting chiefly seasonal developments. Dollar value o f depart­
ment store sales increased by the usual amount in October.
W holesale Prices

fndex of United States Bureau of Labor Statis­
tics (1926 = lOtf) Latest figure, October, 64.4

W holesale commodity prices, as measured by the monthly index of
the Bureau of Labor Statistics, declined from 65 per cent o f the 1926 av­
erage in September to 64 per cent in October. W eekly figures show de­
clines in the general average from early September through th first week
in November, reflecting reductions in the prices o f many domestic agri­
cultural products and their manufactures, as w*ell as in the prices of steel
rails, copper, coffee, rubber and silk. In the second week of November
prices of many leading commodities, including grains, hogs, cotton, silk,
zinc, lead, and tin advanced considerably, but later the prices of these com ­
modities declined.
Bank Credit

Monthly averages of daily figures. Latest fig­
ures are averages of first 20 days in November.

Volume o f reserve bank credit showed little change for the four-week
period ending November 16. Member bank balances at the reserve banks
increased further by $75,000,000 and in the middle o f November were
about $475,000,000 in excess of legal reserve requirements. This growth in
reserve balances reflected an increase of $60,000,000 in the stock of gold
and the issue of additional national bank notes. Demand for currency
showed little change during the four-week period.
Loans and investments of reporting member banks in leading cities,
outside New York City, and Chicago, declined further between the middle
of October and the middle of November, reflecting a further reduction of
loans at these banks. In New York City the investments o f member banks
increased by an amount larger than the decrease in loans, so that total
loans and investments of these banks showed a further increase.
Money rates in the open market continued at low levels during Oc­
tober and the first half of November. Rates on 90-day bankers' acceptances
were unchanged at Vz of 1 per cent, and rates on prime comm ercial paper
declined from a range of l % - 2 to a range of i y 2-l % per cent.