View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
Covering financial, industrial, and agricultural conditions
in the

Fourth Federal Reserve District
Federal Reserve Bank o f Cleveland
Vol. 16

Cleveland, Ohio, April 30, 1934

General business in the fourth district increased in
March at a greater than seasonal rate and the upward
movement continued in April, despite the fact that in
the latter half of the month the strike situation was dis­
turbing to operations in some fields. The recent increase
in the number of interruptions, however, is merely a
substantiation o f the fact that general business has im­
proved considerably, for employees seldom strike so long
as operations are contracting and people are being laid
off from lack o f orders. But as business improves and
men go back to work, labor disturbances usually increase
in number as they have recently in an attempt to better
working conditions and raise pay rolls.
The accompanying chart shows the improvement that
has occurred in employment in about 800 Ohio con­
cerns which report regularly to the Ohio State Uni­
versity Bureau o f Business Research.
In March this
index was 87.4 per cent of the 1926 monthly average,
higher than at any time in the past three years. From
the low point o f 59 in March last year, an improvement
of about 48 per cent has been recorded at these companies,
part o f which are engaged in construction work. In
Pittsburgh the number o f man-hours worked in March
(reflecting not only increased employment, but also the
number of hours w orked) was 21 per cent ahead o f Feb­
ruary, 47 per cent greater than in March 1933, and
higher than since March 1931. As a result of the nu­
merous wage advances granted, pay rolls have shown an
even larger increase.
This has been reflected in retail trade channels. De­
partment store dollar sales were 72 per cent larger in
March in cities of the fourth district than at the time of
the bank holiday a year ago when trade for a time was
almost at a standstill. Several elements made the gain
unusually large, among them being the fact that all preEaster buying was in March this year, whereas much was
in April last year, but even allowing for this and seasonal
changes, the index o f sales was 76.4 per cent of the 19231925 monthly average, as against 68.8 in February.
Compared with 1932, when Easter was in March, sales
showed an increase o f 17 per cent, a larger gain than
is accounted for by changes in price level. Other lines
of wholesale and retail trade also increased.
There were only 75 commercial failures reported in
this district in March, compared with 182 a year ago,
and liabilities of the defaulting concerns were down even



No. 4

more sharply. In the first quarter there were 73 per cent
fewer failures than in the same period o f 1933.
Life insurance sales in Ohio and Pennsylvania in March
were larger than in any month since March 1932, and
they were nearly equal to the monthly average o f 19231925.
In the industrial field the iron and steel and automo­
bile industries which, so far as this district is concerned,
are very interdependent, were responsible fo r the m ajor
share of the improvement experienced in March and April.
Automobile production in March was 337,000 cars and
trucks, according to the Department o f Commerce, the
highest since April 1931, and April weekly schedules were
such that output was estimated at 400,000 units. A l­
though retail demand has advanced sharply, the indus­
try was turning out cars somewhat in excess o f actual
sales, partly in anticipation o f interruptions. Parts and
accessory, glass and tire factories were operating at high
rates in March to build up stocks as well as supply the
assembly plants, and releases continued large generally in
April. Sales o f machinery and small tools declined in
April, the drop being attributed partly to the uncertainty
in the general situation.
The steel industry, after announcing higher prices for
most grades o f steel, was almost deluged with orders
placed before the increases became effective.
Operat­
ing rates increased sharply in most centers, a sizable
expansion occurring at Pittsburgh where activity in the
first quarter was considerably below the average rate
for the entire country. Buying was partly in anticipation

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

2

o f future needs, but it was quite well distributed among
the m ajor users o f steel.
Clothing production declined seasonally in early April
and demand for ceramic products fell off. Operations
o f electrical apparatus and supply plants increased and
paint sales expanded seasonally.
Building contracts awarded in March in this section
were up more than seasonally from the preceding month,
but in the first half o f April a falling-off was evident,
particularly in the residential field.
Bituminous coal production at fourth district mines
increased sharply in March to the highest point since
October 1930, and output was larger than in any corre­
sponding month since 1927. Compared with a year ago,
an increase o f 75 per cent was reported and the first
quarter gain was 38 per cent. Unusually cold weather,
increased industrial activity, and an anticipated price ad­
vance, were factors contributing to the improvement.
FINANCIAL
Of particular significance was the increase in loans on
other than security collateral at the reporting member
banks in this district in the fou r weeks ended April 18.
Although the gain was slight it was the first indication of
a reversal o f the downward trend in these loans evident
for many months. Deposits o f member banks also in­
creased. There was a further contraction in bills discount­
ed by the reserve banks in the four latest weeks as dis­
bursements o f Federal funds through many channels
continued at a high rate. Payments to farmers through
the Agricultural Adjustment Administration, refinancing
o f mortgages through the Home Owners’ Loan Corpora­
tion and Farm Credit agencies which releases frozen
funds, opening of Federal Savings and Loan companies to
relieve the building and loan situation, the starting of
work on Public W orks’ Administration projects, funds for
which were allocated some time ago, the distribution of
relief through the Federal Emergency R elief Corporation,
which superseded the Civil W ork s’ Administration and con­
tinued activity of the Reconstruction Finance Corporation
have caused funds to flow into the fourth district and
other sections of the country at an unprecedented rate.
This, coupled with the improvement in general business,
which has resulted in increased employment and larger
wage payments, has caused a steady growth in de­
posits at member banks. Though demand deposits have
fluctuated somewhat, time deposits have shown an almost
uninterrupted increase since the beginning o f 1934.




Savings deposits at 41 selected banks throughout the
district increased $6,000,000 in March, or nearly one per
cent, and at the month end were 2.1 per cent larger than
a year ago. The gain in Ohio banks was somewhat
greater than at those in Pennsylvania, both compared with
the previous month and a year ago.
Bank debits to individual accounts at 25 cities in the
fourth district were 32 per cent larger in dollar volume
in the fou r weeks ended April 18 than in the corresponding
period of 1933. For the year to date the increase was
15 per cent.
RESERVE BANK CREDIT. There was only a slight
increase in total reserves o f this bank in the four weeks
ended April 18, although reserves o f the entire System
increased considerably. Shifting o f funds between dis­
tricts was partly responsible for the less-than-average in­
crease locally.
Although the volume o f bills discounted for member
banks and of acceptances held declined in the fou r latest
weeks, holdings o f these have been so small recently that
the drop was relatively unimportant. Investments in Gov­
ernment securities remained at $213,025,000, there hav­
ing been no change in this item since November o f last
year.
Despite the improvement in business activity in March
and early April, accompanied by larger pay rolls which
might be expected to necessitate an increase in money
in circulation, the volume of Federal reserve notes and
bank notes o f this bank in circulation was approximately
the same on April 18 as four weeks earlier and somewhat
lower than at the beginning of the year.
Member bank reserve deposits, after declining in late
March and early April from the record high o f $244,000,000 to $219,000,000, recovered most o f the loss, and on
April 18 amounted to $238,000,000. Daily average ex­
cess reserves o f member banks in this district in March
were $108,000,000, compared with $93,000,000 in Feb­
ruary and $8,900,000 in April last year.
(The March
1933, figures are not available.)
MEMBER BANK CREDIT. Loans on securities, made by
reporting member banks in leading cities, declined slight­
ly in the four weeks ended April 18 and on the latest
date they were 15 per cent lower than in the correspond­
ing week o f 1933. “ A ll other” loans, changes in which
usually are regarded as reflecting fluctuations in loans
to trade and industry, rose from $219,000,000 on March
14 to $228,000,000 on April 4, but dropped back to $226,000,000 on April 18. In the first three weeks o f April
these loans were higher than since December, 1933.
Investments of reporting member banks increasd to new
high levels in the four latest weeks, but the gain repre­
sented larger holding o f Government securities. Invest­
ments in other than Government securities declined in
April after increasing slightly in the first three weeks of
March.
Since the increase in investments in Government securi­
ties was greater than the decline in other investments and
total loans, credit extended by reporting banks rose to
$1,162,000,000 on April 18, a gain o f $80,000,000 in the
past year. This increase resulted from an expansion
o f $159,000,000 in Government securities owned in the
period offset by a decline o f $79,000,000 in loans, and
investments in other than Government securities.
The

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
funds invested by local banks in Government securities in
the past year resulted in no loss o f funds to the district,
for the amount o f money already expended or allocated
to this section through the extension o f credit by new
Federal agencies has exceeded this figure.
This accounts in part for the fact that deposits at mem­
ber banks, as shown on the accompanying chart, have
increased at a faster rate than credit extended. On April
18 total deposits of reporting member banks were $1,100,000,000, whereas a year ago they were $941,000,000.
In the four latest weeks demand deposits increased quite
sharply and the gain since the first o f the year was ten
per cent. Time deposits in the same period increased
nearly six per cent.
MANUFACTURING, MINING
Iron and
Steel

Steelworks operations stepped up from
a 9 to above 50 per cent as a national
average in the month ended April 21
and an increase o f about fou r points to 55 per cent oc­
curred in the latter part o f the month. In the Youngs­
town district the rate in the same period advanced from
44 to 60; at Pittsburgh from 21 to 54, while in the Cleveland-Lorain district it moved down from 74 to 69, due
to the accumulation o f large stocks of raw steel, but
rose to 74 per cent again later in the month. Finishing
mill operations in the latter district were not reduced,
with sheet, strip and bar mills continuing close to capaci­
ty.
Price advances ranging from $2 to $8 a ton on prac­
tically all semifinished and finished steels, and $1 a ton on
pig iron for the second quarter were the most important
developments o f the month and the rise resulted in un­
usually heavy contracting in the period immediately pre­
ceding the effective dates, April 12 to 16. Tonnage o f
finished steel thus covered is estimated by leading pro­
ducers as 25 per cent ahead o f that actually booked in
the first quarter. The advances in finished steel have
raised Steel's finished steel composite $3.80 to $54.93,
practically level with March 1930, while increases in
hourly wages April 1, with those previously made under
the NRA, lifted iron and steel wages to the 1929 level.
Steelmakers have been buying scrap actively in anticipa­
tion of heavier operations and Steel’s scrap composite
reversed its recent trend, rising four cents to $12.21.
Judging by the heavy covering o f miscellaneous re­
quirements as well as the increased amount of steel con­
tracted for by the automobile industry, and releases of
steel for railroad equipment recently placed, steelmakers
believe second quarter steel consumption will show consid­
erable improvement over the first quarter.
Structural
requirements have improved recently, but they continue
in limited volume.
Steel ingot output in March averaged 103,600 gross
tons a day, up 12.3 per cent, and total output for the
month, 2,797,194 tons, compares with 2,213,569 tons for
February. The first quarter's output, 7,007,660 tons, is
somewhat more than double the 2,961,735 tons last year.
Daily average pig iron production last month was up
15.5 per cent to 52,438 gross tons; while total output,
1,625,588 tons, was 27.8 per cent above February. For
the first quarter, production o f 4,122,023 tons represents
a gain of 147 per cent over last year. Ninety-seven stacks




3

were in blast at the close o f March, a net gain o f seven
in the month.
February iron and steel exports amounted to 151,184
tons; imports, 25,407 tons. F or the two months this
year exports are 173 per cent higher than last year; im­
ports, 16 per cent.
Coal

Output o f bituminous coal by fourth
district mines increased sharply in
March to the highest level since Octo­
ber 1930, and at 15,934,000 tons, was greater than in any
corresponding March since 1927. Compared with a year
ago a gain of 75 per cent was recorded in this section,
whereas in the entire country output was up 62 per cent.
In the first quarter of this year 40,399,000 tons o f coal
were produced in this territory, a gain of 38 per cent from
the corresponding period o f 1933.
Production rose sharply in March as a result of the in­
creased industrial activity in many lines and because of
the unusually cold weather. Higher prices on coal con­
tracts fo r the year beginning April 1 stimulated buying,
partly for stock piles, prior to that time. In early April,
follow ing the announcement o f higher prices, production
dropped sharply and although a slight improvement oc­
curred in the second week o f the month, daily average
production was much lower than in earlier weeks of this
year.
Stocks o f coal were sharply reduced in February and
March and though the total supply above ground showed
a slight increase from a year ago, in terms of current
consumption it represented a decline.
Opening o f the
lake shipping season, upon which local producers are
quite dependent for maintaining production during the
summer months, was delayed by the unseasonably cold
weather, but movement o f coal to upper lake ports this
season is expected to exceed last year's shipments, for
stocks o f coal at upper lake ports are practically de­
pleted.
Although the recent increase in coal prices was mod­
erate, compared with a year ago a marked improvement
is apparent. Miners' wages, partly as a result o f the
code, also have increased sharply.
Automobiles

There were 100,000 more cars and
trucks produced in March o f this year
than in February and total output, at
335,993 units, according to the Department o f Commerce,
was the highest fo r any month since April 1931, when
336,939 cars were produced. Barring this month, pro-

4

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS R EVIEW

duction was higher than since early 1930. The 42.7 per
cent gain from February was considerably more than
seasonal and the adjusted index o f the Federal Reserve
Board rose from 73 to 80 per cent of the 1923-1925
monthly average. One year ago this index was 27.
Not only was the increase in March quite pronounced,
but it occurred despite the fact that the industry in the
period was confronted by several uncertainties, chiefly
in regard to the labor situation. The upward movement
apparently was continued in April and factory schedules
indicated that output would approximate, if not exceed,
400,000 cars.
Compared with March a year ago (when the industry
was operating at unusually low levels fo r the spring
season) a gain o f 182 per cent was shown in total produc­
tion. Passenger car output was up 170 per cent and
truck production showed an increase o f 219 per cent; the
number o f trucks manufactured in the latest month was
higher than since May 1930. Increased truck production
is one indication o f the improvement in general business,
for buying o f such equipment is generally deferred in
times of reduced activity.
W age increases were quite general in the industry in
March and total manufacturing costs, because o f this
and increased prices o f raw materials, were raised. As
a result, some manufacturers advanced the selling price
of cars and while this was temporarily retarding to re­
tail sales, it was felt in the trade that ultimately it would
have little effect on general buying. Dealers’ stocks are
much lower than they have been for several years.
The effect o f the improvement in the automobile industry
has been very noticeable in the fourth district; the in­
creased buying o f steel and other parts and accessories
has been translated into larger pay rolls and greater pur­
chasing power, which was reflected in a sharp gain in
retail trade in most centers. The unemployment situa­
tion has become less acute. One indication o f the im­
provement is found in new passenger car registrations in
this section. In March they numbered 13,486 units com ­
pared with 8,354 cars in February and 4,741 in January.
In the first quarter of the year there were 2 6,581 cars reg­
istered in principal counties o f Ohio and Pennsylvania
compared with 15,597 in the same period of 1933.
Rubber,
Tires

The rubber and tire industry was generally active in the first quarter, but
operations fell off slightly in ear­
ly
April.
C o n s u m p t i o n of
crude rubber
in
the
period
was
128,636
tons,
an
increase
of
110 per cent from
the
62,591 tons consumed in
the first three months of 1933, when the industry was
abnormally depressed. The current figure, however, has
not been equaled since 1930. Takings of domestic fac­
tories were in excess o f imports by over 7,000 tons in
the quarter with a consequent decline in stocks, which,
nevertheless, are still large.
Official monthly production figures for the tire indus­
try have not been released this year, but some indication
of activity within the industry can be gained by the fore­
going rubber consumption figures and the employment
and pay roll indexes of the Federal Reserve Board. The
form er in March was 83.3 per cent o f the 1923-1925
monthly average, after allowing for seasonal variations,
compared with 80.6 per cent in February and 56.6 per




cent a year ago. Pay rolls in this same period were 74.0
per cent o f this same average against 68.4 in February
and 31.1 last year in March.
The much sharper increase in pay rolls was due to an
advance in wage rates and also to the greater number
of hours worked.
Most factories have been operating
at capacity levels in recent weeks for a number of reasons.
The industry normally is active at this season in anticipa­
tion o f increased demand for replacement tires and also
because o f the larger shipments to the auto industry for
original equipment. Increases in raw material costs and
wages indicated that higher tire prices were forthcom ing
if the industry was to operate at a profit, so considerable
dealer buying was in anticipation of that. Under the
temporary retail tire code now in effect current prices were
about eight per cent higher than the average o f 1933, but
they were below last year at this time.
Manufacturers increased stocks sharply early this year
as a precaution against any possible labor interruptions.
Since none developed and the peak o f the season has
passed, operations were reduced slightly in early April.
Raw material prices increased further in March and
April, crude rubber being about 12 cents in the third
week of the month, compared with three cents a year ago.
Cotton prices doubled in the past year, the current quota­
tion being 12 cents a pound. Rubber prices in the past
few weeks have fluctuated with the progress being made
in production restriction plans; recently reports were more
hopeful, but no definite program has been announced.

Clothing

Because o f the seasonal nature o f the
clothing industry operations slowed
down in the latter part o f March and
manufacturing was proceeding at a low rate in the first
half o f April. W ith Easter somewhat early, demand for
wom en’s spring clothes reached its peak in late March,
but after the holiday orders were sharply reduced and
prices weakened. Operations on fall goods will start in
June and although the actual selling season has not op­
ened, advance orders have shown a definite upward trend.
Employment at 26 wom en’s and miscellaneous clothing
factories in March was up 24 per cent from last year and
in the first quarter averaged 10 per cent better than in the
initial quarter o f 1933. The 2.7 per cent gain from Feb­
ruary was contrary to the seasonal trend. There was an
even greater increase in the average number o f hours
worked.
At fourth district department stores, wom en’s and
misses’ clothing sales in March were 90 per cent larger
than in the same month o f 1933, but the increase in wear­
ing apparel costs in the year, according to Fairchild’s,
was only 27.5 per cent. In March last year little cloth­
ing was bought on account of the bank holiday and much
of the pre-Easter buying was done in early April.
Men’s clothing sales in March showed almost as great
an increase in dollar volume, but men’s apparel prices
advanced less sharply than did prices o f wom en’s wear.
Operations at factories making men’s clothing showed
a greater increase in March, both from the preceding
month and compared with a year ago. Manufacturers’
sales have held up well at reasonably favorable price
levels. Advance showing o f fall materials indicate higher
prices, due partly to higher raw material costs and also

5

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS R EVIEW
to increases in production expenses.
improved.

Collections have

Other
Manufacturing

Although the sharp upward movement
evident in most lines was retarded in
late March, in many instances gains con­
tinued to be shown in the first half o f April, though much
o f the improvement was seasonal.
Comparison with a
year ago reveals some startling increases in operating
rates, the number of employees, and wages paid.

Autom obile Parts, Accessories. Operations at auto parts
and accessory plants in this section in March were more
than double a year ago, despite disturbances which tend­
ed to retard activity temporarily at some factories. At
36 factories in this section employment in March was up
138 per cent from a year ago and in the first quarter
it averaged 73 per cent better than in the comparable
period of 1933.
The gain from February was nearly
12 per cent whereas the average change in the past five
years was a decline of 0.8 per cent. Further increases
were reported in the first half of April. Both costs and
selling prices have increased and wages in many in­
stances have been raised. Despite the sharp im prove­
ment operations and employment still continue much be­
low the level considered as "n orm al” by the industry.
B rick and Tile. Although employment at brick and tile
plants in this section was little changed in March from
the preceding month, a rather sizable gain from a year
ago was shown. Despite the improvement, the industry
was operating at only a small percentage of capacity.
More seasonable weather in April was accompanied by
an increase in brick and tile shipments, and the large
volume o f contracts awarded for public w orks’ construc­
tion and the improvement in other building lines are
favorable factors confronting the industry. Prices have
increased, but are not yet profitable on the present vol­
ume.
China, Pottery. The number o f employes at ten pot­
tery and china plants declined 3.5 per cent in March
from February, a little more than seasonal, but in the
first quarter it averaged 37 per cent above the same
period of 1933. New orders declined in April from the
high level enjoyed in the first quarter of the year. In­
quiries have been numerous, but orders have lagged re­
cently.
Electrical Supplies. The number o f employees at 29
electrical machinery, apparatus and supply companies op­
erating in this district was 73 per cent higher in March
than a year ago and the 7.9 per cent improvement from
February was considerably more than seasonal. Buying
o f industrial and household electrical equipment increased
sharply in March, both from the preceding month and a
year ago and the number and size of unfilled orders were
larger than at this time last year. The increase in pay
rolls was even greater than the number employed, the
gains being accounted for by the greater number o f hours
worked and also increased wage rates. Prices o f raw
materials have advanced and this is thought to have
caused increased buying on the part o f jobbers and re­
tailers.
Glass. Glass factories in this district continued to op­
erate at high levels in March and early April. The num­
ber of employees in March at eleven factories was over
80 per cent above a year ago, although there was a slight




contrary-to-seasonal decline from February. Plate glass
production in March was higher than fo r over two years,
the automobile industry being almost entirely responsi­
ble for the improvement. Production of practically all
types of containers, etc., continued at a high level in
March, but sales in the first part of April declined, not
an unusual development at this season. Prices were ad­
vanced about 15 per cent recently.
Hardware, Machine Tools. Sales o f machine tools fell
off in late March and early April, although considerable
buying for foreign account was reported in some lines.
Small tools were in good demand, but rather sizable in­
ventories were built up in the early part of this year. The
hardware industry continued to show improvement and
the increase in sales from last year was about 50 per cent.
Paint. This is the best season o f the year for the paint
industry and operations and sales recently have increased
in keeping with the trend o f past years. Although prices
o f raw materials entering into paint manufacture have
increased, little advance in retail prices has occurred, ac­
cording to reports.
Paper. Operations at paper and boxboard plants in
March were up only slightly from February, but the gain
in the first quarter from the same period of 1933 was 25
per cent. Demand for some types o f paper has increased
sharply, but sales o f boxboard changed slightly in the
past month. Boxboard inventories have been built up
recently and are a retarding influence to current opera­
tions.
Shoes. The spring season, so far as shoe production is
concerned, is rapidly drawing to a close and current op­
erations are dependent upon reorders o f spring lines.
Samples o f the shoes to be sold next fall are now being
made, but salesmen normally do not start out until midMay. Retail sales of shoes have improved along with other
lines of trade, but shoe production at local factories in Feb­
ruary, the latest available, was 23 per cent below a year
ago, the decline being somewhat greater than seasonal.
In the first two months o f this year the number of shoes
manufactured by local concerns was 20 per cent below the
first two months o f 1933.
TRADE
Retail

Several factors worked together in
March to raise the dollar volume o f
retail department store sales sharply,
and, even after allowing for seasonal variations and
changes in the Easter date, the index o f sales rose to
76.4 per cent o f the 1923-1925 monthly average, the
highest since 1931. In February this index was 69.8.
Compared with March 1933, a gain in dollar sales
o f 71.9 per cent was recorded at department stores in
leading cities o f the fourth district, two cities, Akron
and W heeling, showing gains in excess o f 100 per cent.
The comparison with a year ago is hardly fair, for
retail trade in that month was very much depressed be­
cause of the banking holiday and in addition Easter
occurred in mid-April last year and on April 1 this year
which meant that all pre-Easter buying occurred in March,
1934, whereas last year the greater part o f it was de­
ferred until April. In addition department store prices
are about 29 per cent higher now than a year ago. Com­

6

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS R EVIEW

pared with March 1932, an increase in dollar sales of
about 17 per cent was shown at reporting stores. This
comparison is not distorted by changes in the Easter date
for in both years all pre-Easter buying occurred in
March.
Current retail prices, however, according to
Fairchild's, are up 13 per cent from two years ago.
Sales in all the principal departments showed large
gains from last year; clothing sales of all types were up
about 80 per cent; house furnishings slightly more than
that; shoes about 90 per cent; millinery 130 per cent
and yard goods over 50 per cent, higher prices account­
ing for a large part o f the gains.
Dollar value o f stocks at department stores increased
about the seasonal amount in March and was 21 per
cent above a year ago. Adjusting stock figures by the
increase shown in retail prices it would seem that stocks
are somewhat lower than at the end o f the first quar­
ter o f 1933. The adjusted index was only 62 per cent
o f the 1923-1925 monthly average. There was a slight
reduction in the ratio o f all credit to total sales in March
from February, although installment buying increased.
Collections on both regular and installment accounts im­
proved in March.
Reporting wearing apparel stores showed an increase
of over 100 per cent in March from a year ago and in
the first quarter a gain of 45 per cent was recorded.
Representative furniture stores throughout the dis­
trict showed an increase of 87 per cent in sales in March
and 69 per cent in the first quarter compared with
corresponding periods o f 1933.
Chain drug sales were higher in March than since
1931 and the gain from last year was 36 per cent; in
the first quarter sales were up 21 per cent.
W holesale

Sales o f all reporting wholesale lines
in the fourth district increased sharp­
ly in March from the preceding month
and the gain was considerably more than seasonal. Dollar
sales in that month were larger than since March 1931,
and were 67 per cent o f the 1923-1925 monthly average.
Wholesale drug sales in March were 70 per cent larger
than in March 1933, and in the first quarter a gain o f
47 per cent was reported. Dry goods sales were up 64
and 56 per cent, respectively, in corresponding periods,
and hardware sales increased 62 and 60 per cent. Re­
porting wholesale grocery firms experienced an increase
in sales o f 34 per cent in both March and the first quarter
from corresponding periods o f 1933. A substantial part
o f the gain represented the increase in prices, but condi­
tions generally have improved and collections are better.
BUILDING
F ollow ing a rather sharp reduction in the value o f
building contracts awarded in February, a greater-thanseasonal improvement was recorded in March, both in
the fourth district and the entire country, but a decline
developed in the first two weeks o f April.
Dollar value o f total awards was larger in March than
in any corresponding month since 1931, and the gain
from February was significant in that all m ajor types of
construction, except public works and utilities, showed in­
creases. Residential building was up quite sharply and
had a higher March value than since 1931. The gain




from last year was 74 per cent in this section. In the
first three months o f 1934 residential building in the
fourth district was up 27 per cent from the same period
o f 1933, but was about 30 per cent below the correspond­
ing quarter o f 1932. In the nonresidential field the de­
cided increase in factory building was quite significant.
Total factory construction in the first quarter was valued
at nearly 100 per cent more than in the corresponding
period of 1933.
Total contracts awarded in this section in the first quar­
ter o f the year were nearly four times as large as in the
same period o f 1933, and they were more than double the
corresponding period o f 1932 and only slightly less than
in the first quarter o f 1931. By far the m ajor part of
the $55,000,000 total value was in the public w orks’ field,
almost half o f which represented contracts for highway
construction. Funds for this work were made available
by the Public W orks’ Administration and, although they
have been allotted for the various projects, little actual
work has been started.
Lumber and building supply dealers throughout the
fourth district reported an improvement in the volume of
sales in March, but most o f the pickup was due to small
orders for repair work. Cement production has improved
and output and also shipments o f brick and tile have in­
creased, all*these changes being chiefly seasonal. Prices
on most grades o f building materials have increased and
are somewhat higher than a year ago.
AGRICULTURE
The situation in farm sections o f the fourth district
and the entire country in early April was more difficult
to appraise than in past years because o f the injection
of so many new factors. The various crop-reduction
plans, extension o f Federal credit to farmers for a variety
of uses, etc., have made it difficult to make the usual
crop estimates or comparisons. It is too early to judge
the damage wrought by the severe winter weather, par­
ticularly to the fruit and wheat crop, and spring work
generally has been very much delayed. In the northern
part o f the district practically no spring plowing had
been done prior to April 20 whereas oat seeding nor­
mally should be well under way by that time. *Other
work has been delayed proportionately.
Based on the April l condition report o f the Depart­
ment o f Agriculture, which showed winter wheat as be­
ing 74.3 per cent o f estimated normal, in contrast with
the unusually low figure o f 59.4 per cent a year ago and
a ten-year (1922-31) average condition o f 79.2 per cent,
a 1934 winter wheat crop o f 491,793,000 bushels might
be expected in the United States. In 1933, harvest was
351,030,000 bushels and the five-year 1927-31 average
crop was 632,061,0D0 bushels. The 1934 estimate makes
no allowance for acreage which might be abandoned as a
result o f the reopening o f the wheat acreage reduction
program, but does take into account a 14 per cent aban­
donment o f acreage sown last fell on account o f winterkilling. Last year acreage abandoned was 33 per cent
and the ten-year average was 12.2 per cent.
The April l condition was below average in all but
four states, excluding the Pacific Northwest. Am ong them
was Ohio with an April l condition o f 74 per cent com ­
pared with 76 per cent last year. Indications point to

7

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
a total crop in the state o f 31,247,000 bushels, compared
with 34,732,000 bushels harvested last year. W hile no
estimate o f abandonment has been made it is expected
to be below average, for, despite the cold weather, wheat
fields are in good condition, having had the benefit o f
snow protection much o f the time.
In Pennsylvania, Kentucky and W est Virginia indica­
tions point to larger harvests than last year and in the
two latter states estimates are larger than the five-year
average harvest. In each case this is due to increased
acreage, for the April 1 condition is much below last
year and the ten-year average.
Stocks o f wheat on farms on April 1 were smaller than
a year ago in the entire country and in all states o f the
district except Pennsylvania. They were also under the
average o f the past three years in most sections. Corn
and oat stocks also are somewhat low er than a year or
two years ago.
Growth o f pastures has been retarded this spring and
the April 1 condition was much below the average o f past
years.
Below normal precipitation for many months
has been detrimental to pastures.
W hile it is somewhat early to approximate the extent
of winter damage to the fruit crop, indications now point
to very few peaches or sweet cherries, but little damage
to sour cherries, apples or pears has yet been reported.
About the same number o f tobacco seed beds have
been started as in past years, but there are very definite
indications that acreage to be planted will be materially
reduced; one estimate for the burley crop is 35 per cent
below last year. The season is late, but considerable
progress was made in early April. Selling o f last year’s
crop was completed in late March and prices held up re­
markably well even to the end o f the season.

Wholesale and Retail Trade
(1934 compared with 1933)
Percentage
Increase or Decrease
SALES
SALES
STOCKS
March
First 3
March
1934
months
1934
DEPARTM ENT STORES (49)
A kron................................................
Cincinnati.........................................
Cleveland..........................................
Columbus..........................................
Pittsburgh...............................................
Toledo.....................................................
Wheeling.................................................
Other Cities......................................
District..............................................
WEARING APPAREL (11)
Cincinnati.........................................
FURNITURE (42)
Cincinnati................

Toledo...............................................
Other Cities...........................................
District..............................................
CHAIN STORES*
WHOLESALE GROCERIES (33)
Akron................................................
Cleveland..........................................
Erie....................................................
Pittsburgh...............................................
T o le d o ..................................................
Other Cities............................................
District....................................................
WHOLESALE DRY GOODS (1 0 )....
WHOLESALE DRUGS (13)..............
WHOLESALE HARDWARE (1 4 )...
♦Per individual unit operated.




+176.1
+ 5 2 .6
+ 89.0
+ 67.8
+ 53.4
+ 78.5
+78.5
+105.2
+ 71.4
+ 7 1 .9

+ 9 8 .2
+ 26.9
+ 5 4 .9
+37.3
+ 31.5
+38.1
+58.5
+ 45.8
+ 42.0

+ 69.5
+120.8
+101.1

+31.1
+ 52.4
+ 44.6

+ 91.8
+103.1
+ 36.5
+ 2 8 .4
,+. 8 2„ .0„
+173.5
*+-173.5
+ 8 7 ,4

[-62.6
-84.0
f-42.0
h-19.6
-72.7
+106.6
+ 68.6

+ 35.9
+ 21.8

+ 21.4
+ 20.5

+ 3 2 .8
+ 5 3 .2
+ 1 0 .4
2 3 .9
+ 23.9
+ 3 0 .4
+ 2 5 .8
+ 33.9
+ 64.2
+ 70.0
+ 6 2 .2

+ 46.7
+ 4 6 .9
+10.1
+ 3 2 .2
+ 2 2 .9
+ 28.8
+ 33.6
+ 56.0
+ 4 6 .7
+60.3

+19.3
+ 13.0
+ 37.8
+ 20.2
+ 20.0
+ 18.4
+ 2 1 .0
+ 1 4 .4
+ 21.4

Fourth District Business Statistics
(000 omitted)
Fourth District Unless
March,
% change Jan.-March % change
Otherwise Specified
1934
from 1933
1934
from 1933
+ 32.6
Bank Debits—24 cities,..... $ 1,622,000
4,600,000
+ 12.9
Savings Deposits— end of month:
1
41 Banks, O. & Penna ..... $
642,398
+ 2.1
Life-Insurance Sales:
Ohio and Penna........ ..... $
83,017
+ 20.6
227,119
+ 6.0
Retail Sales:
16,909
+ 71.9
Dept. Stores—49 firms----- $
28,844
+ 49.4
Wearing Apparel— 11 firms#
972
+101.2
1,465
+ 5 7 .4
656
Furniture—42 firms.. ..... 3
+ 87.4
1,683
+ 6 8 .6
Wholesale Sales:
Drugs— 13 firms........ ..... 3
1,645
+ 70.0
4,509
+ 46.7
Dry Goods— 10 firms. ...... 3
1,179
+ 64.2
3,035
+ 56.0
Groceries— 33 firms. . ...... 3
3,920
+ 33.9
10,900
+ 33.6
+62.3
Hardware— 14 firms.. ...... 3
1,050
2,885
+60.3
Building
Contracts—
Total
.
.
$
14,233
+129.9
55,363
+298.3
>>
n
_ Resi2,282
+74.3
4,020
+26.5
...... 3
Commerical Failures—
Liabilities...............
1,836
— 71.9
5,187
— 70.8
Commercial Failures—
1653
— 53.1
752
— 73.0
Production:
1,626
+200.0
Pig Iron, U. S........... . .tons
4,120
+147.7
Steel Ingot, U. S........
2,797
+207.4
7,018
+131.8
584,7842
Automobiles-Pass. Car U. S.
278,1512 +178.5
+95.1
147,6792 +167.2
Automobiles—Trucks. .U. S.
57,8422 +219.3
+
7
1
.6
Bituminous Coal........ . .tons
40,399
+38.3
15,934
Cement— O., W\ Pa., W. Va.
385
+314.0
+ 38.5
655
. .bbls.
Elec. Power— 0., Pa Ky.
k.w.h. 1,148,000
+ 28.8
2,342,000
+ 20.3
1,563
Petroleum— O., Pa., Ky. bbls.
+ 0.4
3,435
+ 3.2
Shoes ......................... . Pairs
— 23.0
— 19.5
(8) (5)
(*) (5)
2 Actual number
1 Not available
6 Confidential
3 February
4 January-February

Debits to Individual Accounts
(Thousands of Dollars)
4 weeks
ended
April 18,
1934
44,252
5,970
24,762
Cincinnati. . . . 241,310
365,282
95,884
36,969
16,551
2,225
Greensburg. .
4,455
6,943
Homestead...
1,504
12,942
6,941
Lima.............
2,204
Middletown..
6,096
Oil City........
5,645
Pittsburgh... . 502,380
Springfield —
10,784
Steubenville..
5,909
81,538
6,819
26,264
32,162
Youngstown..
4,778
1,550,569

Year to date Year to date
%
%
change Jan. 3, 1934 Jan. 4, 1933
change
from
to
to
from
1933
1933
April 18,1934 April 19,1933
155,228
+127.2
115,676
+ 34.2
+20.8
23,055
20,223
+ 14.0
+ 65.8
94,685
58,577
+ 61.6
887,990
+25.1
799,065
+11.1
+ 3 6 .6
1,343,721
1,231,519
+ 9.1
+22.2
369,245
308,577
+ 1 9 .7
135,761
131,767
+ 3.0
+ 9.3
54,846
+ 1 4 .9
63,000
+ 19.4
+ 3 0 .7
8,898
7,112
+25.1
+50.1
16,307
14,294
+14.1
+ 1 5 .7
+ 2 3 .0
26,512
21,551
5,781
5,322
+ 2 2 .6
+ 8.6
+23.1
79,781
59,051
+35.1
+ 45.8
27,086
21,186
+ 2 7 .8
+ 18.5
8,605
8,242
+ 4.4
22,523
17,700
+ 2 7 .2
+ 31.4
+ 4 1 .0
22,370
21,849
+ 2.4
1,718,020
+ 27.8
1,948,705
+ 13.4
+ 2 1 .8
+ 2 5 .9
42,834
35,170
20,833
14,931
+62.3
+ 39.5
+ 5 9 .6
307,691
237,353
+ 2 9 .6
22,083
+56.1
14,632
+ 50.9
+ 6.9
100,270
85,372
+ 17.5
+ 6 3 .6
107,611
74,049
+ 45.3
+ 4.0
19,127
17,071
+ 1 2 .0
+ 3 2 .2
5,859,702
5,093,155
+15.1

Fourth District Business Indexes
(1923-1925 = 100)

+ 3 1 .7
+ 4 0 .6

Bank Debit6 (24 cities)....................
Commercial Failures (Number)........
”
”
(Liabilities)----Sales— Life Insurance (Ohio & P a.). .
” — Department Stores (47 firms).
” — Wholesale Drugs (12 firm s)...
” •—
”
Dry Goods (10 firms)
” —
”
Groceries (33 firms).
” —
**
Hardware (14 firms)
” — All (69 firms).............................
” — Chain Drugs (4 firm s)**... . . . .
Building Contracts— (Total) . ..............
”
”
(Residential)...........
Production— Coal (O., W. Pa., E. Ky.).
” — Cement (O., W. Pa., W. Va.
”
— Elec. Power (O., Pa., K y.)5
”
— Petroleum (O., Pa., Ky.)'"
”
— Shoes*.............................
♦February.
**Per individual unit operated.

1934
60
51
42
99
72
109
48
68
54
67
83
30
13
88
32
137
85
72

1933
45
110
148
82
42
65
29
51
33
45
61
13
8
51
8
106
84
93

1932
60
163
137
114
58
93
40
61
45
59
79
23
13
65
20
122
98
85

1931
95
160
147
134
84
104
59
75
56
72
89
55
45
74
37
136
98
74

1930
117
116
119
169
86
110
81
88
81
89
88
126
54
81
100
146
123
81

8

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

Summary of National Business Conditions
By the Federal Reserve Board
Volume o f industrial production increased further in March and there
was considerable growth in factory employment and pay rolls. The general
level of commodity prices showed little change between the middle of
March and the middle o f April, but in the third week o f April there was a
sharp decline in grain prices.
Production and Employment

Index number of industrial production, adjusted
for seasonal variation, (1923-1925 = 100). Lat­
est figure, March, preliminary 84.

MILLIONS OF DOltARS

MIUI0N5 OF doilap.*;

Three-month moving: averages of F. W . Dodge
data for 37 Eastern States, adjusted for seasonal
variation. Latest figures based on data for Feb­
ruary, March and estimate for April.

V\i' H O L E S A L . e p r i c e :s

.—

Output of manufactures and minerals, as measured by the Federal
Reserve Board’s seasonally adjusted index o f industrial production, ad­
vanced from 81 per cent o f the 1923-1925 average in February to 84 per
cent in March. This advance reflected chiefly increases o f more than the
usual seasonal amount in the output o f steel, automobiles and lumber and
an increase contrary to seasonal tendency in the output o f coal. Produc­
tion o f textiles showed little change in volume on a daily average basis.
In the early part o f April, activity at steel mills and automobile factories
increased further, according to trade reports, while coal production de­
clined by a more than seasonal amount.
Volume o f employment at factories increased further between the mid­
dle o f February and the middle o f March by about four per cent, an amount
larger than is usual at this season. Employment on the railroads and at
mines also showed an increase. The number on the pay rolls o f the Civil
W orks Administration was reduced from about 3,700,000 in the middle of
February to about 2,400,000 in the middle o f March and 1,900,000 at the
end of the month.
The value o f construction contracts awarded in March, as reported by
the F. W. Dodge Corporation, showed a considerable increase from the
low level o f February, follow ed, in the first half o f April, by a decline. For
the first quarter as a whole, the value o f contracts was somewhat smaller
than in the last quarter o f 1933; publicly-financed projects continued to
make up about three-fourths of the total.
Distribution
Volume o f freight car loadings showed a further increase in March,
reflecting chiefly seasonal increases in shipments o f merchandise and mis­
cellaneous freight and a continued large volume o f coal shipments, which
usually decline in March. In the early part o f April, total car loadings
showed a decline, reflecting a sharp reduction in coal shipments. Dollar
volume o f trade at department stores increased in March by considerably
more than the estimated seasonal amount, after allowance for the early
date of Easter this year.

^

Prices
\

Commodities

\
V
~ \

FarmP roducts

1 /

Indexes of United States Bureau of Labor Sta­
tistics, by months 1929-1931, by weeks, 1932 to
date, (1926 = 100). Latest figures for week
ending April 14.

Wednesday figures for reporting member banks
in 91 leading cities. Latest figures are for
April 11.




The general level o f wholesale comm odity prices, as measured by the
index of the Bureau of Labor Statistics was 73.3 per cent o f the 1926 aver­
age in the week ending April 1 4 as compared with 73.8 per cent in the week
ending March 10. During this period prices o f steel, copper and automo­
biles advanced, while prices o f farm products decreased somewhat. In
the third week of April, wheat prices declined sharply and there were also
declines in the prices of other grains, cotton and silver.
Bank Credit
During the four weeks ending April 18 member bank reserve balances
increased by $220,000,000 raising the volume o f reserves in excess of legal
requirements to $1,600,000,000. This increase reflected a growth of $105,000,000 in the monetary gold stock and further disbursements by the Treas­
ury o f funds from its cash holdings and its deposits with the reserve banks.
A t reporting member banks in leading cities an increase o f $400,000,000 in net demand and time deposits for the four-week period ending
April 11 reflected chiefly the deposit by the public o f funds disbursed by
the Treasury, as well as a growth in bankers’ balances. Government deposits
were reduced by about $200,000,000. Holdings by these banks o f securi­
ties, other than United States Government obligations, increased by $64,000,000 and their loans, both on securities and all other also increased
slightly, with the consequence that total loans and investments showed
a growth of $100,000,000 for the period.
Money rates in the open market declined further in April. Rates
on prime four-six month comm ercial paper were reduced from a range
of 1 to 1*4 per cent to 1 per cent, and rates on ninety-day acceptances were
reduced from % per cent to a range of
per cent. Yields on Government
securities also declined.