View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
Covering financial, industrial, and agricultural conditions
in the
F ou rth F ederal Reserve D istrict
Federal Reserve Bank o f C leveland

Cleveland, Ohio, April 1, 1929

^$8 ^
of business in the Fourth District in March
aUov* *eaS^ equa^
if not greater than February, after
^
for seasonal differences. Employment generally
aW
a
Point and operations in most industries were
level of a year ago. Steel mills in mid-March
evGlf J*av*ng some difficulty in keeping up with orders,
l&er
. 2k their output was at practical capacity in nu^stances. The marked recovery in the rail equip^ttstry continued, with orders for locomotives and
j c^rs much larger than for months. Tire output
**£©» and motor accessory concerns were very busy,
sales of new passenger cars were about 50 per
4 ljtJarger t^lan a year ago. Coal prices in March were
buvi
^rmer! domestic demand was good and industrial
We
continued steady. Orders for electrical supplies
gi ^eavy, being well above last year at this time. Plate
0
Manufacturers have been receiving large automotive
de r*8’ ^aint and varnish manufacturers are confident,
lei*’ stocks are low, and spring business is developing

J ^ to r ily .

tiTaVOrable sPots are few» the most important being
the building industry. This trade has continued to run
^
last year, building permits in February showing a
®c*ease of 16 per cent. Business in March was slow in
j. 6 ®h°e trade; wholesale trade was less than last year
^ February, and retail clothing sales were irregular as
spared with last year.
AN INDEX OF F O U R TH

120

D IS TR IC T

BUSINESS
INDEX
120

110
too

110

s\Ji -y w --\r

90

1925

1926

fit*

A / \y
1927

1926

100
90

1929

FINANCIAL
month ending with March 23 has been charactert 6 kjr a further rise in money rates, a slight decline in
^Serve bank credit, an increase in total loans and investof member banks in leading cities, and a large inea®e in loans to brokers.




No. 4

Gold Movements. Gold imports in February amounted
to $2 6 ,9 1 3 ,0 0 0 , including a shipment of $22,000,000 from
England. Exports were only $1,425,000, the net gain to
our gold stock (including changes in earmarked gold) be­
ing $26,426,000. In the first three weeks of March, im­
ports at the port of New York amounted to $10,460,000,
mostly from Germany, while exports were $200,000.
Money Rates. Money rates in New York are higher
than a month ago.
On March 23, prime commer­
cial paper was quoted at 5 %-6 per cent as compared with
5%-5% per cent a month earlier. During the same period,
90-day bankers' acceptances (asked) advanced from 5%
to 5% per cent, and time money on the stock exchange
rose from 7% per cent to 8 per cent flat, the highest in
years. Call money between March 1 and March 23 ranged
between 7 and 10 per cent (renewal rate), averaging 8.25
per cent as against 7.09 in February, 7.35 in January,
and 4.50 in March of 1928. Customers' rates in the
Fourth District are slightly firmer than a month ago. In
Cleveland, collateral loans are mostly at 6 per cent flat,
as compared with 5%-6 per cent last month.
Reserve Bank Credit- Total credit extended by the Re­
serve System on March 20 amounted to $1,372,000,000, a
drop of $31,000,000 from a month previous. An increase
of $77,000,000 in discounts brought this item up to $942,000,000, but acceptances fell from $356,000,000 to $237,000,000. Government securities increased slightly, stand­
ing at $185,000,000 on March 20.
Discounts are
practically double what they were a year ago, but both
acceptances and Government securities are materially
lower. Total bills and securities are $176,304,000 larger
than last year.
In the Cleveland reserve bank, discounts dropped from
81 million dollars on February 20 to 77 millions on March
20; acceptances fell from 34 to 25 millions, and Govern­
ment security holdings from 30 to 29 millions. Total
credit extended on March 20 was $131,000,000, a decline
of $15,000,000 for the month and of $3,000,000 for the
year.
Member Bank Credit. Collateral loans made by all re­
porting member banks stood at $7,642,000,000 on March 20
as compared with $7,448,000,000 a month earlier. For the
same dates, “all other” loans were $8,910,000,000 as com­
pared with $8,740,000,000; investments, $6,028,000,000

2

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

and $5,991,000,000; demand deposits, $13,281,000,000 and
$13,259,000,000; and time deposits, $6,805,000,000 and
$6,867,000,000.
Brokers' loans made by or through New York report­
ing member banks advanced rapidly to a new high dur­
ing the month. The previous high was $5,669,000,000,
reached on February 6, from which there was a reaction
to $5,477,000,000 on the 20th. In the next four weeks
these loans increased 6 per cent to $5,792,582,000 on
March 20. Most of this gain occurred in the item “for
the account of others”, although loans made direct by
the New York banks also increased.
In the Fourth District, loans on securities rose from 696
millions on February 20 to 714 millions on March 20, “all
other” loans increased from 804 to 816 millions, while in­
vestments were off slightly, aggregating 691 millions on
the later date. No great changes took place in demand
and time deposits, the former standing at 1027 millions
on March 20 and the latter at 977 millions.
Security Prices. Stock prices have been very irregular
during the month, with a weakening tendency toward the
close. The Dow-Jones industrial average made a new
high of 322.06 on February 5, declined to 295.85 on the
16th, advanced to a second top of 321.18 on March 1, fell
to 305.20 on the 6th, and again rose to a third peak of
320 on the 16th. Since then another reaction has taken
place, the average standing at 303.22 on March 27. Bond
prices in general have been weak.

FOURTH DISTRICT EARNINGS
The chart below presents the net earnings by quarters,
1925-1928, of 25 leading industrial corporations in the
Fourth District. The group includes only concerns which
operate wholly or largely in this District, so that it may
be considered fairly representative of business in the Dis­
trict. Numerous large corporations doing considerable
business in this area, but possessing plants in other parts
of the country as well, have been excluded.
It will be noted that the fourth quarter of 1928 marked
a new peak for quarterly earnings during the four-year
period, the figure being $19,418,000. This is particularly
noteworthy in view of the fact that fourth quarter earn*
ings in the past have ordinarily declined somewhat from
the level of the second and third quarters. The last qnar*
ter of 1928, therefore, was the most prosperous period in
the Fourth District throughout the four years.
The figures shown on the chart are as follows (in
thousands of dollars):
1928
1927
1926
1926
First quarter ............... $12,392 $13,698 $16,128 $13,142
Second quarter ............ 18,537 15,667 18,568
16,666
Third quarter ............. 18,264 11,682
16,729
14,464
Fourth quarter ............. 19,418 10,329
13,877 15,319
Year .............................. 68,611

51,376

65,302

59,591

Debits, Savings, Failures. Debits to individual account
of 13 large cities in the Fourth District were $2,740,000,000 in February, as compared with $3,028,000,000 in Jan­
uary and $2,375,000,000 a year ago.
Savings deposits of 66 banks in this District totaled
$1,057,141,289 on March 1, a gain of 0.3 per cent for the
month and of 3.7 per cent for the year.
Commercial failures in the Fourth District numbered
166 in February, as compared with 196 in January and
186 a year ago. Liabilities were $2,891,340 in February,
$4,636,425 in January, and $4,727,509 in February of 1928.
In the United States there were 1965 failures in February,
2535 in January, and 2176 a year ago.
MANUFACTURING, MINING

Debits to Individual Accounts

A k r o n .......................
B utler, P a ...............
C a n to n .....................
C in c in n a ti...............
C le v e la n d ................
C o lu m b u s...............
C onnellsville, P a . .
D a y t o n ....................
Erie, P a ...................
Franklin, P a ..........
G reensburg, P a . ..
H om estead , P a . . .
L exin gton , K y . . . .
L im a .........................
L o r a in ......................
M id d le t o w n ...........
Oil C ity, P a ...........
P ittsbu rgh , P a ___
S p rin gfield..............
S teu b en v ille ...........
T o l e d o ......................
W a r r e n .....................
W h eelin g, W . V a ..
Y o u n g s to w n ..........
Z a n esv ille......... ..

Total................

(In thousands o f dollars)
5 weeks
1929 to
%
ending
change
date (D e c.
M ar. 20,
from
2 6-M ar.
1929
1928
20)
140,822
+ 2 2 .6
362,600
13,349
+ 1 8 .1
35,907
62,895
+ 1 8 .1
170,998
525,740
+ 1 0 .9
1,458,801
1,097,764
+ 2 6 .5
2,864,935
218,158
+ 1 5 .1
588,446
4,371
— 6 .6
11,242
137,459
+ 2 5 .4
343,687
i4 4 ,5 2 4
+ 1 8 .4
114,225
6,482
+ 1 7 .0
16,166
22,691
+ 5 .0
60,400
5,576
+ 1 8 .8
14,004
35,082
+ 3 0 .8
112,704
18,553
+ 7 .7
53,428
+ 1 1 .2
6,744
17,433
15,616
+ 9 .6
38,891
19,744
+ 1 7 .9
53,039
+ 2 6 .1
1,282,354
3,354,591
29,932
+ 2 3 .3
81,463
13,323
— 3 .3
35,791
— 9 .9
265,144
760,890
+ 1 7 .6
16,565
43,720
+ 1 7 .6
62,470
164,253
+ 2 6 .5
90,407
245,724
+ 1 1 .1
14,674
39,701
4.150,439




+ 1 9 .4

11,043.039

1928 to
date (D e c.
2 8-M ar.
21)
310,590
*31,153
144,140
1,394,450
2,522,499
510,565
11,806
291,032
99,413
15,570
62,487
11,865
92,902
46,961
16,634
39,585
44,749
2,856,401
66,518
33,564
796,377
39,429
143,213
203,714
37,073
9 ,822.690

Iron and
Steel
change
from
1928
+ 1 6 .7
+ 1 5 .3
+ 1 8 .6
+ 4 .6
+ 1 3 .6
+ 1 5 .3
— 4 .8
+ 1 8 .1
+ 1 4 .9
+ 3 .8
— 3 .3
+ 1 8 .0
+ 2 1 .3
+ 1 3 .8
+ 4 .8
—

1.8

+ 1 8 .5
+ 1 7 .4
+ 2 2 .5

+ 6.6

— 4 .5
+ 1 0 .9
+ 1 4 .7

+20.6

+

7 .1

+ 1 2 .4

Though steel production in February
surpassed all previous efforts when it
attained a daily rate of 180,198 gross
tons, additional capacity was put on in the first half of
March. Specifications which have impelled steelmaking
to these record heights have been predicated, apparently,
upon immediate requirements, principally for the manu­
facture of automobiles, freight cars, rails, farm imple­
ments and line pipe. Small metalworking plants have
rounded out tonnage demand.
A concomitant of record steel production is a shortage
of semifinished steel. Virtually for the first time since
the war, there is talk of premiums for spot material. Some
finishing capacity has been idle on account of a lack o f
billets and sheet bars. Mahoning valley mills in partic­
ular have been held back on this account. Chicago, as
usual at the season, is carried along by railroad require­
ments, but Pittsburgh and northern Ohio have benefited
chiefly from record automobile steel demand. Sheets, bars
and strip are the most wanted classifications. On

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS BEVIEW
high finishes of sheets mill capacity is engaged into June.
With deliveries on many sizes of bars and grades of
sheets and strip four to eight weeks deferred, secondquarter contracting has been subordinated. As a result,
advances on bars, plates, shapes, sheets and strip—the
latter taking the form of a revision of extras—have not
been tested. In mid-March, pig iron prices in the Ma­
honing and Shenango valleys tended to strengthen. Iron
and steel scrap prices were subsiding slowly, forecasting
the usual spring easiness in consumption.
February’s steel ingot rate of 180,198 tons readily ex­
ceeded the 166,274 tons of January and the 161,812 tons
of February, 1928. The previous all-time record daily
rate was 172,144 tons, in October, 1928.
Pig iron production in February, at a daily rate of
114,833 tons, was a record for that month and closely
approached the all-time pig iron record of 115,207 tons, in
March, 1925. Two hundred and eight blast furnaces, six
more than the month previous, were active at the close
of February.
Further price advances for iron and steel are shown
by the Iron Trade Review composite of fourteen leading
iron and steel products. In February this index averaged
(36.28, compared with $36.24 in January, and $35.62 last
February. In the first two weeks of March this index was
stationary at $36.37.

3

ably between the middle of February and March 9, and
on the latter date was below the preceding four years.
Ohio production, however, has recovered to a marked ex­
tent in recent months after the extremely depressed con­
dition in Ohio union fields in 1927 and 1928.
Rubber
and Tires

Akron tire factories have been at practical capacity.
Dealer buying has
been somewhat disappointing, but bad
weather has held back the demand and up to the middle
of March, spring buying by the public had not been felt
to any great extent.
Demand for tires as original
equipment remains exceptionally heavy as motor com­
panies attain new high production records. Tire manu­
facturers are carrying rather heavy inventories, partly in
anticipation of large orders when spring weather arrives.
Employment in tire factories in February was slightly
higher than January and nearly 10 per cent greater than
a year ago.
As shown in the chart below, crude rubber prices re­
covered materially in the first two months of 1929 after
averaging about 18 cents a pound during most of 1928.
The January average was 20 cents, and that for February
was 23% cents. By the middle of March a further ad­
vance to around 25 cents had been scored, but by the 20th
the price had reacted slightly. Price advances have re­
cently taken place in some mechanical rubber goods and
rubber footwear.
Crude rubber imports into the United States in Feb­
ruary amounted to 64,538 tons, as compared with only
29,445 tons last year. For the first two months, the fig­
ures are 116,843 and 75,688 tons respectively.
Tire production (including solids) in the United States
aggregated 5,074,000 units in January, as compared with
4,155,000 a year ago—an increase of 22 per cent.

The soft coal markets displayed a
slightly firmer tone in February and
the first part of March. Domestic de­
mand was strong, owing to the cold weather in February,
while steam coal was taken steadily in response to high
industrial activity. Industrial consumers were estimated
to have about 41,000,000 tons of soft coal on hand in the
middle of March, a drop of nearly 10,000,000 tons from
a year ago. The “ Coal Age” weighted average price for
bituminous (spot, mine) was $1.87 in February as against
$1.85 in January.
Fourth District dealers report a good volume of sales
uring the past few weeks. Profit margins are still nar­
row, however, owing to the low scale of prices now ex­

isting.

Production of soft coal in the country declined notice­



Automobiles

Automobile production in the United
States made a new high for all time
in February, the figure of 466,084 ex­
ceeding that of last August by nearly 5,000 cars. The
record is particularly noteworthy in view of the short
month. The February figure, of course, was far beyond
any previous February, the next highest total for that

4

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

month being 370,569 in 1924. Last year, February out­
put was 323,796 cars and trucks. For the first two months
of 1929, production totaled 866,799 units, as compared with
555,524 last year, 543,643 in 1927, and 672,850 in 1926.
In 1924, the total for the first two months was 689,158
units, a new mark up to that time, but a marked slump
in output occurred later in that year.
The pace of production has not slackened in the first
half of March; in fact, some of the largest manufacturers
increased their output during the month, so that the av­
erage daily rate showed a gain even over February’s high
figure. Sales are reported to be fairly satisfactory, al­
though somewhat spotty, the bad weather having had a
retarding effect.
In the Fourth District, sales have been well in excess
of a year ago. February registrations of new passenger
cars in 59 Ohio counties, representing over 80 per cent of
the state's population, increased 51 per cent over the same
month in 1928, according to the Ohio State University
Bureau of Business Research, and also gained 16 per
cent over January. Truck registration was 89 per cent
greater than last year. Employment in motor and motor
accessory plants in the District is nearly 50 per cent
larger than a year ago.
NEW

PASSENGER CAR
F eb .
1929

A k ron
(S u m m it )
..................
C a n to n (S t a r k ) ......................
C in c in n a t i (H a m ilto n ) ......
C le v e la n d (C u y a h o g a ) ........
C olu m b u s ( F r a n k lin ) ........
D a y t o n (M o n tg o m e r y ) ......
T o le d o (L u c a s ) ......................
Y ou n g stow n
(M a h o n in g )....
T o t a l .........................................

Clothing

904
619
1,230
3,537
948
787
1,028
533
9,586

R E G IS T R A T IO N

Jan% c h a n g e J a n .-F e b . F e b .
f r o m 1928
1929
1928
+ 7 5 .9
1,922
1,077
4-67.8
1,123
632
+ 19.9
2,114
2,472
+ 5 3 .6
3,739
6,250
+ 3 3 .7
1,935
1,343
+ 37.8
1,090
1,646
+ 65.8
1,168
1,811
+ 51.4
1,008
666
+ 4 8 .3
11,829
18,167

% ch ange
f r o m 1928
+ 7 8 .5
+ 7 7 .7
+ 16.9
+ 67.2
+ 4 4 .1
+ 5 1 .0
+ 55.1
+ 51.4
+ 5 3 .6

Business in most clothing lines was
quiet in February, but March brought
the stimulation of Easter purchasing.
Orders for knitted wear exceed those of a year ago. Busi­
ness in women’s wear is more active than last month.
In men’s underwear a reduction in rayon prices has
brought some readjustment in prices of finished goods,
which has hampered manufacturers who hold stocks pur­
chased at higher levels. The woolen goods trade has been
quiet. Men’s clothing concerns are employing more help
than a year ago, and February employment also exceeded
January.
Sales of 12 wholesale dry goods houses in the Fourth
District in February declined 5.4 per cent from last year,
but increased seasonally over January. For the first two
months of 1929, sales were 4 per cent less than a year
ago. Collections in February were slightly greater than
last year.
Retail clothing sales in 45 department stores in this
District made an indifferent showing in February as com­
pared with the same month in 1928. Increases of 1.6
per cent in juniors' wear, 31.3 in sports’ wear, 6.7 in
aprons and house dresses, 1.0 in hosiery, 2.5 in knit under­
wear, 5.5 in negligees, and 0.4 per cent in infants’ wear
were offset by decreases of 10.3 per cent in men’s cloth­
ing, 5.3 in men’s furnishings, 3.7 in women’s coats, 4.6
in women’s dresses, 0.5 in misses’ ready-to-wear, 6.7 in
boys’ wear, and 19.5 per cent in furs.



Shoes

Business in this line has been slow In
the past several weeks. Both produc­
tion and sales in February made an
unfavorable showing as compared with last year.
Unusually cold weather in that month was a retarding
factor, with retailers reporting poor sales and the Easter
trade lagging. March brought the usual rush of Easter
orders, but business was still rather quiet after allowing
for the seasonal increase. Collections are reported as
“ slow” by Cincinnati manufacturers.
February production in the Fourth District ran 23 per
cent behind last year and also declined about 6 per cent
from January, although in the past February has nearly
always recorded a gain over January. Output for the
first two months of 1929 was 14 per cent less than last
year, but was 0.3 per cent ahead of 1927 and 9 per
cent larger than in 1926.
Wholesale shoe sales in this District in February showed
a large decrease of 42.5 per cent from a year ago. Retail sales in department stores were also lower, the de­
cline being 1 per cent in women’s shoes and 3 per cent in
men’s shoes.
Hide prices continued weak in March after their pro­
nounced slump in January and February, being quoted at
around 14% cents a pound as compared with about 28
cents a year ago and 22 % cents in December.
Other
Manufacturing

General activity is holding up to a
month ago, with most lines doing, a
good business. There are some un­
favorable spots, however. Buying is still hand-to-mouth
in nearly all cases.
Boxboard. Depression continues with profit margins
unsatisfactory, but recently demand has increased slightly
in response to low prices.
Electric Supply. Orders are holding up well, being
heavier than a year ago. Radios and accessories show a
particularly large increase.
Food Products. Stocks of wholesalers are not large,
and buying has been steady with an increase in staple
products.
Glass. Business in general in this line is a little better
than a year ago. Plate glass companies have benefited
considerably from extremely heavy automotive demand*
and plants are operating at near capacity. Orders fo r
window glass up to mid-March were quiet, owing to severe
weather. Buying of household glassware has been light
on the part of both retailers and public. Employment is
running ahead of last year.
Metal Containers. February business was slightly leas
than a year ago.
Motor Accessories. Activity, of course, continues at a
very high rate along with record-breaking automobile pro­
duction.
Motor Trucks. Manufacturers report an encouraging
increase in orders since the first of the year, with the
immediate outlook promising. Collections are better.
Paint. Industrial demand is good. Stocks in dealera*
hands are low, although the motor industry is pretty weU
stocked up. Manufacturers are confident concerning the
spring trade. Orders for raw materials have exceeded

fH E MONfHLT BUSINESS REVIEW
those of a year ago; pig lead has advanced sharply, and
the market is active.
Stoves. Business is quiet. Demand has been sluggish,
and collections are slow. Some price-cutting is reported,
but without any sizable increase.
AGRICULTURE, CANNING
Whatever the growing season may develop hereafter, it
has not made a very early start. The winter has been
severe and farmers have not been able to begin their
spring work as soon as desired. Frost in the ground
made it impossible to plow early and even the balmy
weather of the past two or three weeks has not aided
farmers to any great extent because of the numerous
rains. This long steady winter weather has, however,
benefited the winter grains to the extent of affording
them from four to six weeks of snow protection. As a
result, the condition of the young plants this year is
about 10 per cent higher than at the same time a year
ago. Few complaints of winter-killing have been received
so that abandonment this year for that reason is stated
to be small. The acreage sown last fall was smaller than
for the 1928 crop, but abnormal abandonment of fields
took place last spring.
Wheat stocks on farms are much below average. Last
year’s harvest was the smallest in many years and
stocks on hand on farms in this District are less than
half as large as the average for the past five years. Corn
held on farms, following the large crop of 1928, is con­
siderably greater in Ohio, but slightly smaller in Penn­
sylvania, than a year ago. Stocks of oats and barley
are much heavier than a year ago due to the large pro­
duction of both grains in 1928.
The outlook ii> the canning industry is said to be fair­
ly promising. The pack of peas in 1928 was quite large,
that of corn larger than in 1927, but below the five-year
average, and that of tomatoes only 8,500,000 cases as
compared with a normal pack of about 13,000,000 cases.
This, coupled with an active consumptive demand, has re­
duced stocks of whoesale grocers and packers more than
usual. One large canner reports stocks as being less than
at any time during the past ten years.
Tobacco

Planting in seed-beds has been going
on in the Kentucky burley tobacco re­
gion. Government estimates of the new
crop have not yet appeared, but private estimates, which
are not forecasts, continue to indicate an increase in
acreage this year. Some requests for burley seed have
been received from Western Kentucky, which ordinarily
grows dark-fired tobacco.
Very little selling of the 1928 crop has been done re­
cently, as most of the crop had been disposed of by the
first of March. The Lexington market was still running
in mid-March, but was selling only once a week to take
«are of the last of the crop. The small amount of leaf
still coming in was rather mediocre in quality and was
not bringing as good a price as earlier in the season. The
season’s sales at Lexington alone amounted to about 62,000,000 pounds, at the very good average price of $33.40
per hundred pounds.




&
BUILDING

Building contracts awarded in February in the Fourth
District compared unfavorably with a year ago. Kesidential contracts amounted to only $10,200,351, the low­
est February since 1922, and total contracts were $36,360,000, the lowest for the month since 1924. The first two
months of 1929 combined, however, showed a gain in to­
tal contracts over last year of about 40 per cent, owing
to large industrial awards in Western Pennsylvania in
January. Residential contracts awarded for the first two
months were 23 per cent less than a year ago.
Building permits in 24 cities in February were likewise
less than a year ago, the drop being 15.8 per cent. Only
five cities reported gains—Cincinnati, Covington, Erie,
Hamilton, and Newark. For the first two months, the
loss was 9.5 per cent, with 17 out of 24 cities showing
decreases.
Lumber

Lumber manufacturers in this District
are slightly more confident than a
month ago, although competition re­
mains very keen. Orders are showing a seasonal increase,
and hardwood prices have advanced. Retailers’ stocks of
hardwoods have been permitted to decline to a low point,
and this, coupled with smaller production in the south
on account of prolonged wet weather, has revived activity
in the hardwood branch of the trade.
Mill operations in some parts of the south have been
almost at a standstill on account of impassable roads for
hauling, and Pacific Coast mills have also curtailed op­
erations due to cold weather.

Building Operations
(V a lu a tio n

of

P erm its)

%

C lcve. suburb#:
C leve. H e ig h ts..
East C levelan d ,
E u c lid ..................
G arfield H eigh ts'
L a k e w o o d ..........
R o c k y R iv e r ___
Shaker H eigh ts.
C o lu m b u s..............
C ov in g ton , K y . .
Erie, P a ................
L exin gton , K y . . .
L im a .......................
N e w a r k ..................
Pittsburgh, P a . .
Sprin g field............
W heeling, W Va.
Y ou n g stow n . . . .

Febru ary
1929
^920,970
3,650
32,340
132,810
2,798,165
2,871,400

change
from
1928
— 2 6 .0
— 5 4 .4
— 3 6 .8
— 4 1 .1
+ 4 8 .4
— 1 4 .8

J a n .-F e b .
1929
31,794,078
5,704
53,340
254,910
4,458,200
5,304,975

Jan .-F eb .
1928
31.901,563
31,030
75,418
804,662
2,995,545
5,925,725

%
ch a n g e
from
1928
— 5 .7
— 8 1 .6
— 2 9 .3
— 6 8 .3
+ 4 8 .8
— 1 0 .5

101,025
6,100
48,825
60,000
22,765
164,290
61,005
371,900
535,800
211,450
353,425
2,066,216
103,790
52,220
3,520
15,875
2,008,717
33,125
476,345
69,865
235,755

— 7 7 .4
— 9 3 .1
— 6 6 .9
— 6 3 .9
— 9 3 .7
— 1 9 .6
— 2 0 .1
— 2 7 .0
— 5 9 .2
+ 8 6 .6
— 4 7 .9
+ 7 7 8 .8
+ 2 7 .8
— 6 3 .8
— 8 8 .6
+ 3 2 .8
— 1 8 .9
— 3 4 .0
— 7 4 .5
— 4 6 .1
— 4 4 .4

208,825
13,247
155,325
149,000
739,265
237,530
140,005
628,900
1,211,300
238,650
1,055,204
2,699,661
143,131
357,220
39,920
20,975
3,254,097
208,225
1,392,289
151,627
495,905

854,285
220,165
245,131
246,550
557,685
352,295
138,363
922,000
2,299,800
179,700
1,257,875
345,165
149,855
205,940
50,050
28,675
3,701,224
136,735
3,169,248
207,762
1,068,585

— 7 5 .6
— 9 4 .0
— 3 6 .6
— 3 9 .6
+ 3 2 .6
— 3 2 .6
+ 1 .2
— 3 1 .8
— 4 7 .3
+ 3 2 .8
— 1 6 .1
+ 6 8 2 .1
— 4 .5
+ 7 3 .5
— 2 0 .2
— 2 6 .9
— 1 2.1
+ 5 2 ,3
— 5 6 .1
— 2 7 .0
— 5 3 .6

$13,761,348

— 1 5 .8

325,411,508

328,071,031

—

9 .5

TRADE
Retail
Trade

Sales of 63 department stores in the
Fourth District in February were 1
per cent less than last year, but after
allowing for the one extra selling day in February of
1928, sales this year were slightly larger. The greatest
increase took place in Toledo, with 9.9 per cent. For the

frfiE BfONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
first two months, gales this year increased 0.8 per cent
over last year. Stocks on hand on February 28 were 3.7
per cent less than a year ago but 8.9 per cent larger
than a month earlier.
Sales of 16 wearing apparel firms declined 1.4 per cent
from last year, but the first two months gained 1.1 per
cent. Stocks at the end of February were 10.1 per cent
lower than a year earlier, while accounts receivable were
9 per cent larger.
Sales of 48 furniture stores in February decreased 8.7
per cent from a year ago, and furniture sales in 35 de­
partment stores also dropped 12.4 per cent. For the
first two months, sales were 5.1 per cent less than last
year. Accounts receivable at the end of the month in­
creased 2.4 per cent over a year ago. February collec­
tions were 4.8 per cent larger.
February chain grocery sales (per individual unit op­
erated) were 5.6 per cent larger than a year ago, and the
first two months were up 8.2 per cent. For chain drugs,
the figures showed a loss of 5.3 and 3.0 per cent repectively.
Sales of retail hardware firms in Ohio in February de­
creased 6 per cent from last year, according to the Na­
tional Retail Hardware Association, and were 21 per cent
under the 1926-1928 average. For the first two months
of 1928, there was a loss of 3 per cent.
Percentage changes in the principal departments of
retail stores were as follows:
% change
from Feb. '28
Silks and Velvets ....................................... —21.7
Woolen and Cotton Goods ........................ —11.7
Domestics ..................................................... — 2.4
Toilet Articles ............................................ -f- 8.0
Silverware, Jewelry ..................................... + 4.0
Millinery ....................................................... — 6.2
Gloves ........................................................... + 3.3
Hosiery ......................................................... + 3.0
Knit Underwear .......................................... + 2.8
Silk and Muslin Underwear ........................ + 0.7
Infants’ Wear .............................................. + 5.5
Women’s Shoes ............................................ — 0.9
Women’s Coats ............................................ — 5.7
Women’s Dresses ......................................... — 3.4
Misses’ Ready-to-Wear ................................ — 0.8
Girls’ Ready-to-Wear ................................... + 6.3




Furs ................................................................... —
Men’s Clothing ................................................. .... 3.3

Men's Furnishings .......................................

0.9

Boys’ Wear .......................................................

2J2

Men’s Shoes .................................................. ... 2.9
Furniture ..................................................... ... 0.6
Rugs ...................................................................
Draperies, Lamps .............................................
House Furnishings ...........................................
Musical Instruments .......................................

Wholesale
Trade

_
—
....
-|~

43
4.9
1.5
0.6

All reporting wholesale lines in the
Fourth District except drugs reported
smaller sales in February than in the
same month last year.
Dry goods sales were 5.4 per cent lower, but increased
14.5 per cent over January. The first two months com­
bined showed a loss of 19.3 per cent. Stocks were 3.3
per cent larger than last year, receivables were up 0.5 per
cent, and collections 2 per cent. Collections during Feb­
ruary were 39.9 per cent of accounts receivable on Jan­
uary 31. The monthly stock turnover rate in February
was .378, or 4.54 times a year.
Drug sales were 3.3 per cent larger than February,
1928, but were 17.9 per cent less than in January. For
the first two months, sales gained 14.6 per cent over last
year. Accounts receivable were 1.4 per cent larger and
collections were 10.2 per cent larger. The collection per­
centage against January receivables was 78.2.
Every reporting city shared the District’s loss from last
year of 5 per cent in grocery sales. As compared with
January, the loss was greater—11.2 per cent. For the
first two months, however, sales increased 3.3 per cent
over last year. Stocks and receivables declined 2.8 per
cent and 3.7 per cent respectively, while collections were
2 per cent larger. The collection percentage was 56.9
and the stock turnover rate was .516, or 6.19 times a year!
Hardware sales dropped 4.4 per cent from last year but
increased 4.2 per cent over January. Sales for the first
two months were 2.3 per cent lower than a year ago.
Stocks were 2.8 per cent less, receivables 1.2 per cent less,
and collections 3.2 per cent greater. The percentage o f
February collections to January receivables was 34.2,
Shoe sales in February decreased 42.5 per cent from a
year ago but gained 6 per cent over January. The decline
for the first two months combined was 27.8 per cent.

7

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

Fourth District Business Statistics
(A ll figures are fo r F ou rth D istrict unless otherw ise specified)
Feb.
1929
B a n k D ebit* (24 cities)

M illion s

°f 'no■,th,
S S o7«pS 3S ” "u (26b,nk,)

of

dollars

T h ou san ds o £ d o lla rs

C om m erdalF ailures — N u m ber
A ctu al N u m ber
T h ou san ds o f dollars
”
“
— Liabilities
P o «ta l R eceipts— 9 cities
“
“
“
Sales — L ife Insurance— O hio and Pa.
“
“
“
■” £ cpt*. Stores— (63 firms)
“ “ W ea n n g Apparel (1 6 firms)
— Furniture (48 firm s)
“
“
“
** — W holesale G ro ce ry (42 firm s)
“
“
**
„ —
“
D ry G ood s (12 firm s)
“
**
“
„ —
**
H ardw are (1 6 firm s)
**
“
**
» .,,7 “
D rugs (13 firm s)
”
"
“
B u ild in g Perm its, V alu a tion — 27 cities
**
“
“
B u ild in g C on tracts — T o ta l, 4th D istrict
“
“
"
.
‘
“
— R esidential, 4th D istrict
M
**
P rod u ction — P ig I r o n, U. S.
“
“ tons
— Steel In gots, U. S.
“
“
“
— A u tom ob iles, U. S.
Passenger Cars
A ctu a l
N u m ber
T ru ck s
"
— B itum inous CoaL 4th D istrict T h ou san ds
o f tons
— C em en t: O hio, W . V a ., W n . Pa.
“
“ barrels
**
— E lectric P ow er: O hio, Pa., K y . M illion s
o f k.w. hrs.
«
— P etroleu m : O hio, P a., K y .
T h ou san ds
o f barrels
**
— Shoes, 4th D istrict
“
“
pairs
— T ires, U . S.
“
“ casings
B itu m in ou s C oa l Shipm ents (fr o m Lake Erie Ports) T h ou s. o f tons
Iron Ore R eceipts (at L ake Erie Ports)
“
“
‘ M o n th ly A v era ge.
•January.
3Figures C on fidential.

Z

Feb.
1928

3,315

2,921

+ 13.5

781,730
275,411
1,057,141
166
2,891
2,942
110,382
21,031

741,643
278,186
1,019,829
186
4,728
3,120
105,921
21,233
1,229
1,061
5,740

+ 5.4

1,211

969
5,454
1,912
1,671
1,677
13,761
36,360

2,021

1,748
1,622
16,336
37,841
15,179
2,899
4,045

10,200
3,215
4,325
407,589
58,495
17,146
829
1,310*
1,968*

291,151
32,645
14,765
978
1,166*
1,864*

5,037*

4,155*

3

3

J an .-F eb.
1929

change

+ 3.7

—10.8
— 38.9
— 5.7
+ 4.2
—

—
—
—
—
—
+
—
—
—
+
+

%
ch an ge

6,356

+ 1 0 .2

7,003
781,251*
274,4 8 6 1
1,055,737*
362
7,527
6,097
219,555
42,842
2,642
1,709
11,598
3,582
3,274
3,718
25,412
91,040
21,503
6,648
8,814

1.0

—

J a n .-F e b .
1928

1.0

1.4
8.7
5.0
5.4
4.4
3.3
15.8
3.9
32.8
10.9
6.9

+ 40.0
+ 79.2
+ 16.1
— 15.2
+ 12.3
+ 5.6
— 22.9

739,488*
272,302*
1,011,7901
455
10,723
6,122
191,981
42,517
2,614
1,801
11,231
3,733
3,352
3,245
28,071
64 ,2 4 4
27,982
5,755
8,036

756,700
110,099
35,738
1,647

496,797
58,727
30,304
1,733

+ 5 2 .3
+ 8 7 .5
+ 1 7 .9
— 5 .0

3

■

+21.2

+ 5 .6
+ 0 .8
+ 4 .3
— 2 0 .4
— 2 9 .8
— 0 .4
+ 1 4 .4
+ 0 .8
+ 11
— 5 .1
+ 3 .3
— 4 .0
— 2 .3
+ 1 4 .6
— 9 .5
+ 4 1 .7
— 2 3 .2
+ 1 5 .5
+ 9 .7

— 13! 5

Fourth District Business Indexes
(1923-1925 ** 100)

Retail and Wholesale Trade
(1929 C o m p a re d w ith 1928)

DEPARTMENT STORES (63)
Akron.........................................................
Cincinnati..................................................
Cleveland...................................................
Columbus...................................................
Dayton.......................................................
Pittsburgh..................................................
Toledo........................................................
Wheeling....................................................
Youngstown...............................................
Other Cities...............................................
District.......................................................
WEARING APPAREL (16)
Cincinnati..................................................
Cleveland.......................................... !!!!*.
Ocher Cities......................................1*. *
District.................................. !!!!!!!
FURNITURE (48)
Cincinnati...............................................
Cleveland...................................
Columbus......................
Dayton.................................. **................
Toledo.........................
Other Cities...................
District............................... ...................
CHAIN STORE*
Dnsgs-^-District ( 3 ) ........................................
Groceries— District (4)...........
]!!!!!!!
raOLESALE GROCERIES (42)...........
Akron...............................
Cincinnati................... !! ! ! ! ! * . ..................
CUreland................ ................................
Erie................................ ...........................
Pittsburgh................................................
Toledo.;............ ; .............................
Other Cities........... ................................
District......................................................
S S n i 'l a A T '!

GOODS'(12)'.;;

WHOLESALE SJR D w V r E (16).'.:

WHOLESALE SHOES <3)...
*Sal« per individual unit operated.




P ercentage
Increase o r D ecrease
SA LE S
SALES
STOCKS
F e b .First
F ebFeb.
2 M os.
Feb.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.

—
—
+
—
—
+
+
—
—
+
—

.
.
.
.

1 5 .0
3 .1
0 .3
1 .9
1 .8
0 .4
9 .9
3 .4
3 .3
4 .5
1 .0

— 0 .1
+ 2 .1
+ 4 .0
+ 0 .2
— 2 .2
— 2 .9
+ 1 0 .2
— 2 .5
+ 0 .0 3
+ 3 .9
+ 0 .8

+
+
—
—
+
—
—
—
—
—
—

— 7 .9
+ 1 1 .8
— 6 .0
— 1 .4

— 5 .7
+ 1 3 .9
— 2 .4
+ 1 .1

— 1 .0
— 1 0 .6
— 1 3 .6
— 10 .1

.
.
.
.
.
.
.

—
—
—
—
—
—
—

1 1 .5
6 .4
1 4 .0
8 .6
3 .6
1 9 .2
8 .7

—
—
—
—
+
—
—

1 1 .9
2 .8
5 .2
1 1 .0
5 .0
7 .6
5 .1

.
.

—
+

5 .3
5 .6

—
+

3 .0
8 .2

.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.

— 2 .5
— 4 .8
— 1 0 .1
— 12 .3
— 2 .2
— 0 .4
— 2 .5
— 5 .0
— 5 .4
+ 3 .3
— 4 .4
— 4 2 .5

+ 2 .8
+ 2 .9
+ 2 .3
— 4 .4
+ 1 .0
+ 5 .0
+ 4 .8
+ 3 .3
— 4 .0
+ 1 4 .6
— 2 .3
— 2 7 .8

7 .4
5 .8
6 .9
0 .1
1 .3
4 .8
1 2 .7
1 0 .5
12.1
6 .5
3 .7

Bank D ebits (24 c it ie s ).............................................
Com m ercial Failures ( N u m b e r .............................
“
“
( L ia b ilit ie s ).......................
Postal R eceipts (9 citie s ). . ....................................
Sales— Life Insurance (O h io and P a .)................
“ — D ept. Stores (52 f i r m s ) ...............................
“ — W holesale D rugs (13 fir m s )....................
41 —
“
D ry G o o d s (12 fir m s )..........
“ —
“
G roceries (42 fir m s )..............
“ —
**
H ardw are (16 fir m s )............

«

All (88 firms)!..............

“ — Chain D rugs (3 firms) * *............................
B u ilding C on tracts ( T o t a l ) ...................................
“
“
(R e s id e n tia l).......................
P rod u ction — C oal (O ., W n. Pa., E. K y . ) .........
— C em ent (O ., W n . Pa., W . V a .) ..
“
— P etroleum ( 0 ., Pa., K y . ) * ...........
“
— E lectric P ow er (O ., Pa., K y .) * ..
— S h oes......................................................
♦January.
* * P e r in divid u al u nit operated,
fln c lu d e s 4 shoe firms.

Feb.
1929
122
114
66
113
132
82
107
79
80
78
82
80
76
59
95
69
107
156
97

F eb.
1928
108
127
107
120
127
84
104
83
85
82
86
84
79
88
82
81
101
139
125

F eb .
1927
109
111
79
114
117
82
100
79
79
87
83
90
107
89
111
72
98
138
107

F eb.
1926
96
129
90
110
106
81
97
83
82
90
85
95
90
121
108
61
93
129
93

F eb.
1925
91
82
47
99
111
81
95
89
84
96
87
91
89
94
91
49
95
111
96

Banking Operations
Federal Reserve Banka
Federal Reserve
Bank of Cleveland Federal Reserve System
(In Millions)
(In Millions)
Mar. 20 Mar. 21 Feb. 20 Mar. 20 Mar. 21 Feb. 20
1929
1928
1929 1929
1928
1929
Gold reserves .................... 270
248
258 2,712 2,776 2,681
Discounts ...........................
77
67
81
943
477
866
Acceptances .....................
25
29
84
237
888
856
U. S. Securities ..............
29
48
80
186
885
178
Total bills and securities.. 131
184
146 1,372
1,195
1,401
Federal Reserve notes in
.
circulation .....................
202
189
201 1,642
1,565
1,652
Total deposits .................... 186
188
188 2,370 2.860
2,861

— * 2 !8
— 19.3
— '2 i 8
— 16.1

REPORTING MEMBER BANKS
Fourth District
United Statea
(In Millions)
(In Millions)
Loans on securities ..........
714
657
696 7,642
6,545 7,448
All other .........................
816
777
804 8,910
8.806 8,740
Total loans ..................... 1.530
1.484
1.501 16.552 15,850 16,188
Investments .....................
691
782
698 5*25? is 'fa f iJ ’JJJ
Demand d«porits

............. 1.027

Tima deposits ..................

977

1.026

968

1,017 1M 81

MS

6.805

18.M1

6.712

18.26*

G.&67

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW

8

Summary of National Business Conditions
By The Federal Reserve Board
Industry and trade continued active in February and the first part of
March, and there was a growth in the volume of bank loans. Borrowings
at reserve banks increased during the period, and money rates advanced
further.
Production

Index number of production of manufacturer
and minerals combined, adjusted for seasonal
variations (1923-1925 = 100). Latest figure:
February, 117.

Production continued at a high rate throughout February and the first
half of March, and was substantially above a year ago. Automobile output
was at a record rate in February, and there was also an unusually high daily
average production of copper and iron and steel. Large output in the
iron and steel industry reflected demands from manufacturers of automobiles,
machine tools and agricultural implements, and from railroad companies.
Preliminary reports for the first half of March indicate further expansion
in automobile and iron and steel production. During February the daily
average output of coal and crude petroleum also increased, and production
of cotton and wool textiles continued large, while silk output declined some­
what from the unusually high level of January. There was also some
decline from January in the production of lumber and cement, and in the
output of meat-packing companies.
The high rate of activity in manufacturing during February was
reflected in a larger than seasonal increase in factory employment and
payrolls, both of which were considerably above the level of February, 1928,
Building activity declined further in February, and the value of con­
tracts awarded was over 20 per cent smaller than a year ago. Residential
building contracts showed the largest decline in comparison with February,
1928, while those for public works and utilities were only slightly smaller
in value, and commercial and industrial building awards increased. During
the first half of March, there was some seasonal increase in total building
awards, but they continued to be substantially below a year ago.

BUILDING CONTRACTS AWARDED
----

With Stcsanai Adjustment
Without, Adjoxtmitrt

Federal Reserve Board’s indexes of value of
building contracts awarded as reported by the
P. W. Dodge Corporation (1923-1925 = 100).
Latest figures, February—adjusted for seasonal,
119; unadjusted, 88.

Distribution
In February shipments of commodities by rail increased more than is
usual for the season, reflecting larger loadings of coal and coke and mis­
cellaneous freight, which includes automobiles. During the first two weeks
of March, freight car loadings continued to increase.
Sales of wholesale firms were generally smaller in February than a
year ago. In comparison with January, sales of dry goods, shoes, and
furniture increased seasonally, while sales of groceries and hardware
were smaller. Department stores reported about the same daily volume
of sales in February as in the preceding month, and larger sales than
a year ago.
Prices

Monthly averages of daily figures for 12 Fed­
eral reserve banks. Latest figures are for the
first 23 days in March.

The general level of wholesale prices declined slightly in February,
and was approximately the same as a year ago. The decline from January
reflected primarily decreases in the prices of hides and leather, livestock
and meats, and small declines in the prices of wool, cotton and woolen
goods. The influence of those declines on the general average was partly
offset by increases in the prices of copper, lead, iron and steel, rubber,
and grain.
During the first two weeks of March, prices of wool and petroleum
continued to decline, and rubber prices receded somewhat after a marked
rise in February, while leather prices declined sharply. Prices of copper
rose further and there were small increases in prices of hides, raw cotton
and certain grades of lumber.
Bank Credit

Monthly rates fn the open market in New
York: commercial paper rate on 4-to-6 month
paper and acceptance rate on 90-day bankers*
acceptances. Latest figures are averages of
first 23 d a n in Hardt.




Between the middle of February and the middle of March, there was
a rapid growth of loans at member banks in leading cities. The increase
was in loans chiefly for commercial purposes, which on March 13 were
more than $200,000,000 larger than four weeks earlier. Investments of the
reporting banks declined further during the period.
Total volume of reserve bank credit declined somewhat between February
20 and March 20, reflecting for the most part some further gold imports
from abroad. Member bank borrowing at Federal reserve banks was
nearly $80,000,000 larger on March 20 than four weeks earlier, while
acceptances showed a further decline of about $120,000,000 during the period.
Security holdings showed relatively little change.
Money rates continued to advance. Rates on 4-6 month commercial
paper rose from 5^-5% to 534-6 per cent, and rates on 90-day bankers’
acceptances increased from 5 to 5^4 per cent on February 13 and to
per cent on March 21. Open market rates for collateral loans also
increased.