View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
Covering financial, industrial, and agricultural conditions
in the
Fourth Federal Reserve District
D. C. WILLS, Chairman of the Board and Federal Reserve Agent
Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland

Vol* 7

General

Cleveland, Ohio, April 1, 1925

On the whole, business conditions have
shown no material change during the
month of February. Some disappoint­
ment is expressed with the situation,
but this largely is due to the fact that
people expected too much, rather than to any unfavorable
turn in the trend of business. Looking at the situation
from the viewpoint of what has actually taken place, rather
than from the viewpoint of those who expected a “boom,”
it is evident that a real improvement has occurred during
the past months. Business in many lines is considerably
better than it was last summer, and also compares favor­
ably with a year ago. The improvement above noted, how­
ever, has been conservative and orderly, rather than spec­
tacular.
In an effort to find out as definitely as possible just
how conditions in the Fourth District have compared with
last year, this bank recently asked a large number of man­
ufacturers in the District to state whether their business,
particularly orders ahd sales, during the first two months
of 1925, was better or worse than during the same period
in 1924. Of the replies received, slightly more than onebalf reported conditions as being better in 1925 than in
1924; about one-third stated that business was not so good
as last year; while the remaining one-sixth reported prac­
tically no change. The following gives the comparison of
the two-months' period by industries, wherever the data
was sufficient to indicate the trend:
Iron and Steel: Pig iron and steel ingot production
greater by about 8 and
per cent, respectively.
Coal: Depression both in 1924 and 1925; indications
that 1925 has been somewhat below 1924.
Tires; Considerably better this year.
Building: Value of permits 36 per cent ahead of last
year.
Lumber: Reports conflicting. General feeling is that
1925 compares unfavorably with 1924.
Building Brick: Orders and shipments less in 1925.
Textiles: In general, about the same or a little better
than last year.
Agricultural Implements: Somewhat better in 1925.
Paint: Markedly better this year.
Paper: Better this year.




No* 4

Electrical: Not much change.
Stoves: Business less than last year.
Glass: Better in 1925.
Miscellaneous: Striking a rough average, 1925 on the
whole has been slightly better than last year.
Retail Trade: Department store sales 4 per cent under
last year.
Wholesale Trade: Hardware sales slightly ahead of
1924; other lines less, particularly dry goods with a 20
per cent decrease.
Financial
Conditions

The four weeks ending March 11 were
marked by an increase in the total earn­
ing assets of the Federal Reserve Bank
of Cleveland, which totaled 125 millions
on March 11 as compared with 117 mil­
lions on February 11 . This gain was entirely due to an
increase in bills discounted, which rose from 33 mil­
lions to 51 millions. The latter amount is the highest
for 1925 to date, and was 23 per cent above a year ago.
Holdings of acceptances and government securities both
declined during the period under review, the former from
37 to 31 millions and the latter from 45 to 43 millions.
For the Federal Reserve System, bills discounted rose
from 332 millions on February 11 to 410 millions on
March 11. The latter figure is considerably under a year
ago, when discounts totaled 483 millions. Both acceptances
and government securities held continued to show a de­
clining tendency. On March 11, acceptances stood at
301 millions and government securities at 388 millions.
Gold reserves also showed a further decline, amounting
to 2,875 millions on March 11 as against 2,896 millions on
February 11.
On February 27 the Federal Reserve Bank of New
York raised its rediscount rate on all classes of paper
from 3 per cent to 3J4 per cent The Boston, New York,
Philadelphia, Cleveland, and San Francisco banks now
have a Zl/2 per cent rate, while the other seven banks
maintain a 4 per cent rate.
Loans and discounts of reporting member banks in
the Fourth District stood at 1,192 millions on March 4,
a gain of 22 millions for the month. Between Feb­
ruary 4 and March 4 demand deposits declined from
1,022 millions to 1,000 millions, while time deposits rose

THE MO N T H L Y B U S I N E S S REVIEW

2

from 707 millions to 717 millions. For all reporting
member banks in the country, loans and discounts amounted
to 13,243 millions on March 4 as compared with 13,113
millions on February 4 and 11,935 millions on March 5,
1924. Demand deposits on March 4 were 12,924 millions,
a loss of 115 millions for the month but a gain of 1,750
millions for the year. Time deposits rose from 4,900
millions on February 4 to 4,945 millions on March 4,
the latter figure being 751 millions greater than a year ago.
Savings deposits of 67 banks in the Fourth Federal
Reserve District amounted to $821,087,853 on February
28, 1925, a gain of 0.5 per cent over the preceding month
and of 7.6 per cent over a year ago.
Commercial failures in the Fourth District numbered
120 in February as compared with 135 a year ago, ac­
cording to R. G. Dun & Company. Liabilities were
$2,057,013 as against $2,824,143. For the United States,
February failures numbered 1,793 in 1925 and 1,730 in
1924. Liabilities were $40,123,017 in February, 1925, and
$35,924,037 in 1924.
Iron
and Steel

Iron and steel production is holding up
surprisingly near to a high record basis
and a material step-down which it was
thought might develop by this time has
not yet put in its appearance. Gen­
eral operations probably are off 5 per cent on the aver­
age from the peak point reached late in February, but
still are maintaining an activity of around 85 to 90 per
cent of capacity. The mills have continued to profit from
the heavy bookings taken in November and December
against estimated first quarter requirements. Monthly
quotas under these contracts have been taken out al­
most to the limit and shipments from producers into
distributing channels have been very heavy. These speci­
fications, plus a considerable amount of new business,
have kept plants operating in high gear. New buying at
present cannot be described as generally vigorous, and
April promises to tell the story as to whether actual
consumption has kept pace with production; for by that
time first quarter tonnage will have been worked off by
the mills. At this time buyers are showing conservatism
in making future obligations, due apparently to the fact
that prices are considerably higher than in the first quar­
ter, and there is a disposition to await the definite de­
velopment of the business situation.
The automobile industry has been one of the conserva­
tive factors, but more liberal releases of tonnage are now
coming from that source as production schedules are
swinging out. Building requirements have remained large.
Railroad buying has been fair and is again expanding,
particularly in equipment contracts which are running
well ahead of February. Miscellaneous industry which
generates the big call for iron and steel appears to be
enjoying a fair enlargement.
The peak of steel production apparently was reached in
February, which showed a gain of only .06 per cent as
pom/pared with increases of 13.3 and 9.9 per cent in Jan­




uary and December, respectively. The annual rate of
steel ingot output in February was 48,400,000 tons com ­
pared with a rate of 48,150,000 tons in January. February
production represented 96.7 per cent of the high water m ark
in steel ingot output for all time attained last March. The
February pig iron output as compiled by IRON T R A D E
REVIEW was the highest for that month in history both
in gross total and in daily average. It ran at the an­
nual rate of 40,650,000 tons compared with an annual rate
of 39,700,000 tons in January. The daily average w as
114,645 tons compared with 108,781 tons in January, a gain
of 5.4 per cent. At the close of February the furnaces
in blast totaled 256, a gain of five in the month. T he
active list represents 62.3 per cent of the total num ber
of furnaces in the country.
Iron and steel prices have shown some tendency to
give ground. Advances of $2 per ton in finished steel
products to apply to second quarter which were posted in
January on the strength of heavy first quarter bookings
have not held. Most of the business being done in the
heavier lines is on the basis of $2 per ton lower than
the maximum quotations. There is no real weakness to
the market, however, except in sheets where, because of
the large productive capacity and the delayed automo­
tive buying, competition has been unusually keen. T he
range in going prices on this product has been from $ 4 to
$6 per ton. Conservatism in asking price advances has
become more marked among steel producers, who count
themselves satisfied if they can maintain an even keel cm
the present basis.
n

The pig iron market has eased up, with reductions o?
50 cents to $1 per ton quoted in various centers. H eavier
foreign importations have been a factor in softenin* tZ
market m the East. Consumers of pig iron are s W
ing the same attitude of picking their way in c o n t r ^ /
mg for the second quarter that prevails in finished steel
IRON TRADE REVIEW composite of fourteen 1
ing iron and steel products definitely reflects the tr*„H
and range of recent changes. This index as of M arch lft
stood at $40.63. On the corresponding date one m onth
previously it was $41.06. The recent high point was $ 4 1 ™
m the first and second weeks in February.

Iron and Steel Production

PIG IRON
STEEL IN G O T S
(Iron Trade Review) (American Iro n 6?
Mcel Institute)
Un thous. of tons) (In thous.
of tons)
1925
1924
1925
1924
^372

January...............
February............. 3,210
March..................
April....................
........
May.....................
........
une.....................
uiy ........ ..................
August.................
........
September...........
........
October................ ........
November............ ...!!
December....................... .
Total...............................

J

3,015
3,072
3,465
3,226
2,620
2,022
1,783
1,883
2,054
2,462
2,515
2,956
31,077

;U80
•'.‘40

—

11

3,634
31809
4,188
3,334
2,628
-*056
1,869
2,542
2,815
3,1U
3,107

3*SS2

36.64S

THE M O N T HL Y B U S I N E S S REVIEW

Coal
and Coke

There appears to have been practically
no improvement in the coal situation
in this District during the past month.
The depression caused by the exccss of
operating capacity over demand still con­
tinues, and even in the face of a marked decline in pro­
duction during the past few weeks, demand has been
slow and prices unsatisfactory. Some idea of the general
condition of the bituminous industry throughout the
country may be gained from the fact that of 1,837 mines
reporting to the Geological Survey on January 24, 1925,
only 396, or 21.6 per cent, were working full time, while
480, or 26.0 per cent, wTcre entirely idle. Efforts are be­
ing made by operators to improve the situation, an ex­
ample of which is the pending consolidation of 80 West
Virginia mines which was noted in last month’s Review.
According to the Geological Survey, production of bi­
tuminous coal in the United States declined sharply dur­
ing the seven weeks ending February 28, amounting to
1.5 million tons per day for the week ending February
28 as compared with slightly over 2 million tons for the
week ending January 10. There was a similar decline last
year, which, although less marked during its earlier stages,
continued through the week ending April 12. This year
the week ending March 7 showed a slight gain, produc­
tion amounting to 1,566,000 tons per dav as compared to
1,501,000 tons the preceding week.
On February 21, the percentage of full-time output in
mines in this District ranged from 36.6 per cent in Northern
and Central Ohio to 68.4 per cent in the Westmoreland
region of Pennsylvania. As compared with a year ago,
the percentage of full-time output was considerably less
in the case of mines in Northern and Central Ohio, Cen­
tral Kentucky, and the Pittsburgh district, while the West­
moreland and Central fields were operating at greater
capacity than a year ago.
The price of bituminous coal per net ton (Coal Age
average) was $2.04 in February as compared with $2.10
in January and $2.25 in February a year ago. Coke stood
at $3.62 per net ton in February as compared with $3.94
last month and $4.08 last year.
Exports of bituminous coal from this country amounted
to 15,240.000 net tons in 1924, a decrease of 3,912,000 from
1923. With the exception of 1922, exports in 1^24 were
the smallest for any year since 1914.
Estimated production of anthracite for the four weeks
ending March 7 amounted to 6,^22,000 net tons as com­
pared with 7,303,000 net tons during the corresponding
period last year.
The total estimated world production of all coal in 1924
was 1,350,000,000 metric tons, of which the United States
produced 520,420,000 metric tons, or 38 per cent.
Production of beehive coke declined steadily between
February 7 and March 7, the principal loss occurring in
Pennsylvania and Ohio. The output for 1925 to March
7 amounted to 2,469,000 net tons as against 2,665,000 last
year. Pennsylvania and Ohio together produced 1,944.000
tons in 1925 to March 7 as compared with 2.143,000 tons
in 1924.




3

Oil

The markets for both crude oil and re­
fined products have been easier the past
month, and recent price declines in gaso­
line raise the question of whether the
oil industry is to experience this year a
repetition of conditions in the past three years, when price
declines were entered into at the time of year when it
would naturally be expected that oil markets would be
strongest.
While crude production has declined consistently this
year in practically all fields and is now down to about
1,925,000 barrels a day, as compared with 2,000,000 bar­
rels in January, according to figures reported to Na­
tional Petroleum News, gasoline and motor oil is in its
period of lowest consumption for the year, and it is very
possible that total stocks, both of crude oil and refined
products, for the country are being added to rather than
drawn upon.
Automobiles

Production of both passenger cars and
trucks during February increased season­
ally over January, Truck production
was also ahead of February, 1924, but
passenger car output continued to run
far below last year’s figure. For the first two months
of 1925, total production amounted to 508,090 cars and
trucks, according to figures furnished by the Federal
Reserve Bank of Chicago. This total is 25 per cent
below 1924 and 3 per cent below 1923.
Automobile manufacturers appear to have become more
optimistic recently, it being stated that a conservative pro­
duction program has been followed by most companies
for several months, with the result that the overproduc­
tion which took place in the first quarter of 1924 is not
being duplicated this year. Indications are that dealers
generally are not overstocked. In the Fourth District,
reports from truck manufacturers, though somewhat con­
flicting. indicate that the 1925 volume of business in gen­
eral has been satisfactory so far, and automobile parts are
also being sold in good volume.

Automobile Production 1924-1925

Figures Represent Practically Complete Production and Are
Based upon Reports Received by theFederal Reserve Bank of
Chicago in Co-operation with the National Automobile Chamber
of Commerce from Identical Firms Each Month.
1925
1924
Passenger
Passenger
Cars
Trucks
Cars Trucks
January................ 203,757 25,650
287,211 28,247
February.............. 246,669 32,014
336,284 30,399
March.........................................................
348,287 33,061
April............................................................
336,968 34,977
May............................................................
279,385 32,326
June............................................................
217,845 27,040
July.............................................................
237,431 24,895
August........................................................
251,553 26,781
September............ .............................
260,091 30,154
October.......................................................
257,839 30,597
November...................................................
201,652 26,246
December...................................................
178,570 25,333
Total.
3,193,116 350,056

4

Tires

T H E M O N T H L Y B U S I N E S S RJEVI EW

Tire manufacturers in this District re­
port that the first two months of this
year brought a considerably greater vol­
ume of business than January and Feb­
ruary of 1924. Production is running
at higher levels than last year, and demand is said to be
very satisfactory, particularly for balloon tires. Stocks
of inner tubes in manufacturers’ hands on February 1,
however, were rather high for that time of year. As
stated in previous Reviews, the price of crude rubber
has been the adverse factor in the tire industry for some
time. This declined early in February, but rose again
toward the end of the month, and on March 6 stood at
39 cents per pound as compared with 25 cents a year
ago. The possibility of higher tire prices has been men­
tioned from time to time, but as yet nothing has oc­
curred along this line. Earnings of tire companies have
improved, however, even under the depressing price sit­
uation.
The latest report of the Rubber Association of America,
giving information as of February 1, shows that stocks
of inner tubes in manufacturers’ hands continued to climb
during January. Although production declined slightly
from December, it was still 15 per cent greater than
shipments, which also declined. Stocks have been rising
since September, and on February 1 were over 15 per
cent higher than a year ago. The seasonal rise in stocks
began earlier than usual last fall, and on February 1 in­
ventory was not much below the peak of last year, w h ich
was not reached until May 1.
Balloon tube shipments took another sharp jump in
January, amounting to 538,533 tubes as compared to
427,111 in D ecem b er, a gain of 26 per cent for the month.
Production rose from 444,794 tubes in December to 585,243 in January, and inventory rose from 870,383 tubes in
December to 920,728 in January.

pectations for the first two months of the year. The price
of hides has softened, being l2>l/ 2 cents a pound on M arch
13 as compared with 15 cents a month ago, but is still 3 ^
cents a pound higher than a year ago. Leather prices
have undergone no change of importance during the past
month.
Sales of reporting wholesale shoe firms in this D istrict
showed an increase of 13.4 per cent in February as com ­
pared to January, but a decrease of 9.6 per cent from
February, 1924.
Final figures furnished by the Bureau of the Census
place the production of boots and shoes of about 1,200
factories in the United States in January at 26,067,930
pairs as compared with 24,602,393 pairs in December. P ro ­
duction in the Fourth District gained 20 per cent from
December.

Various lines of manufacture in the
Fourth District report improvement in
business during the past month. T his
is particularly true of the paint indus­
try, in which the unusually good busi­
ness of recent months still continues, with heavy ord ers
and capacity production. The demand for glass has im ­
proved, due in part to a drop in receipts of imported glass
and to increased requirements by the automobile indus
try. Lead manufacturers report capacity business and
a very encouraging outlook. Orders for electrical products
have recently increased somewhat. Conditions are al<^
better in the paper trade and in certain lines of m ach in ed
manufacture. Several lines such as pottery and cork „
port that there has been little change during the m onth'
There are but few spots of depression; perhaps the m ™
noticeable are the stove manufacturing industry, which h ,I
been characterized by dullness for some months, and in
the boxboard industry, which slumped during the
month as a result of overproduction during the w inter
Textiles
Reports indicate that conditions in the
Prices on the whole have shown but little change d „r
textile industry in this District are about
the same as last month. As compared •ng the month. Employment is somewhat greater in
few lines. Buying on the part of customers is still con*
with last year, the volume of business servative.
to n *
being done by some lines, such as
worsted goods, is greater; by others, such as knit goods,
less. Prices show no great change from a month ago, Tobacco
The selling season for burley tobacco
but in some cases are considerably under last year. Raw
is drawing to a close, and no im portant
cotton, for example, stood at 24.70 cents per pound in
sales have been announced recently
February as compared with 31.88 a year ago. Similarly,
Sales at some of the independent w arecotton yarn fell from 49.20 to 42.60 cents per pound;
houses have already closed for the sea
cotton goods, from 17.15 to 15.66 cents per yard; and son. On March 13 the Burley Tobacco Growers’ A sso
silk, from 7.64 to 6.86 dollars per pound. Raw wool, c.ation mailed out checks to members aggregating ^ I
on the other hand, has receded only slightly from the
,Q Vburley
^ Se,U'ng
final ofPa™
t on
crop. tHe
This.f°Urth
makesand
a total
$49,389,270
high level attained in December, and in February stood the 1922
paid to members on that crop. According to the
at 68.8 cents per pound as against 56.5 cents last year.
port of the Commissioner of Agriculture, independent
Shoes
The approach of spring has brought re­ warehouses during February sold over 14 million pound,
burley tobacco for growers, at an average price o.#
newed activity to the boot and shoe of
trade, the usual pre-Easter demand about $i).55 per hundred pounds.
keeping many factories well supplied
Planting in the burley regions of Kentucky Was
with orders. In the Fourth District, delayed early m March by cold weather, but farmers w **
the situation appears spotted. Although business in some preparing to burn their tobacco beds and begin planting
cases is good, on the whole it has hardly come up to ex­ upon the arrival of warmer weather. It is as yet too




General ^
Manufacturing

THE MONTHLY BUSINESS REVIEW
early to obtain a clear idea as to what, if any, reductions
in acreage will take place.
The membership of the Burley Association is now put
at 107,875, an increase of 1,310 since the opening of the
tobacco delivery season.
It is of interest to note that during the years 1913 to
1924, inclusive, estimated production in the United States
of burley tobacco increased 76 per cent, while that of all
types increased only 30 per cent. During the same
period, estimated stocks of burley in the hands of man­
ufacturers and dealers increased 90 per cent, while stocks
of all types rose 48 per cent. Stocks of burley increased
rapidly during 1923 and 1924, and on October 1, 1924,
stood at 428 million pounds, a point much higher than
for any preceding year.
The following taUle gives detailed figures:
• S t o c k s of
•P r o d u c ti o n * P ro d u c tio n ‘ S t o c k s a ll ty p es * • A c r e a g e of
of b u r l e y
o f all t y p e s o f b u r l e y ( q u a r t e r l y
burley
(estim ated)
(estim ated) (estim ated ) ( O c to b e r) a v e ra g e )
a v e r a g e 2 3 2 ,7S6
2 77,650
315,259
2 20 ,849
275,601
326 ,116
310 ,7 40

1913-1913
1919
1920
1921
1922
1923
1924

1,4 87 ,12 5
1,4 65 ,48 1
1,S82,225
1 ,069,69 3
1,2 46 ,83 7
1 ,5 15 ,11 0
1,2 42,623

212 ,6 38
229 ,8 91
267,789
324,351
280,856
3 4 2,885
428 ,3 32

1 ,2 5 9 ,3 0 2
1,402,525
1,440,507
1,650,022
1,5 87 ,42 2
1,6 89 ,63 9
1,8 14 ,68 6

258.000
338.000
356.000
2 59 .0 00
321.0 00
369,300
365,500

#I n t h o u s a n d s o f p o u n d s .
#* I n

number

of

a cr e s.

Building

According to Bradstreet’s, building per­
mits in 166 cities in the United States
during February declined 3.6 per cent
in value from February a year ago.
An analysis of the figures shows that
outside of New York city there was a gain, but this was
more than offset by a very large decline in the value of
permits in New York City.
In the Fourth District, a remarkable gain of 62.9 per
cent was made over February, 1924. Every city showed
an increase except Canton and Wheeling, and increases
of more than 100 per cent were shown by Akron, Co­
lumbus, Dayton, Erie, Lexington and Toledo.
For the first two months of 1925, the Fourth District ran
36. 4 per cent ahead of 1924, while the country ran about
7 per cent behind last year.

Building Operations
February, 1925

No,
p er mit*
A k r o n ....................
£ » a t o n . . . ..........
C i n c i n n a ti
...
C l e v e l a n d * .........
C o l u m b u . ............
D a y t o n . ...............
f rie. ........................
L e x i n g t o n . ..........
c •
..........
Sp rin g fie ld .....
Z ? l ed? ..................
" he e lin * .............
Y oungstow n, . .

%
change
fr o m

338
179
413
U 63
5 05
209
169
61
424

+ 77.9
+
7.8
+
7 .8
+ 35.7
+ 4 7.7
+ 56.0
+ 213.0
+ 79.4
+ 0 - 7
4 4 _j_ 2 . 3
298 + 2 6 .8
101 + 3 1 .2
167 + 5 1 . 8

V aluation

%

change
from
1924192 4
*1,0 65,4 65 + 1 5 1 . 6
6 93,3 30 — 1 7 . 0
1 ,354,445 +
3.9
7,455,885 + 3 5 . 9
2,634,300 + 1 6 7 . 9
9 59,9 31 + 2 7 8 . 7
370,290 + 2 5 2 . 4
2 71,195 + 3 5 7 . 9
4 ,0 2 0 .8 0 0 + 8 8 . 4
62,095 + 7 7 .5
1,48 1,68 0 + 1 1 1 . 1
243.178 — 3 3 .6
5 80 ,630 + 8 1 . 2

F i rs t t w o m o n th *
1925-1924
V aluation
%
c ha n ge
fr om
1924
> 2,137,772 + 2 2 1 . 0
1 , 1 9 7 , 9 1 2 4- 1 6 6
2 , 7 0 9 , 4 1 5 + 27 8
12,28 8,893 + 10 6
3 ,6 3 9 ,9 0 0 + 1 2 1 7
1,3 13,732 + 41 3
450,635 + 26 0
334,490 + 1 2 6 . 2
7 ,3 17 ,65 2 + 7 6 . 8
119,9 45 + 3 8 .2
1.854 ,572 + 3 1 . 0
369,0 99 — 5 8 . 7
883,255 +
4 .8

. ,
4,071 + 3 3 .7
* 21.193.224 + 6 2 .9
* 3 4 ^ 6 1 7 ,2 7 2
Include* F a i t C l e v e la n d , L a k e w o o d a nd S h a k e r Height*,

*1




+

36.4

5

Lumber,
Cement

Reports indicate that February business
in the lumber trade in this District fell
below that of January. Some disap­
pointment is expressed by the lumber
manufacturers because orders are not
holding up as well as a month or two ago, and because
business in most cases has been below that of last year.
Collections are reported to be slow. Prices have weak­
ened somewhat, the composite price of softwood lumber
being $31.65 on March 6 as compared with $31.68 a
month ago and $32.36 a year ago, and the composite price
of hardwood being $44.04 on March 6 as against $44.12
last month and $45.30 last year.
Production of lumber in the United States for the first
nine weeks of 1925 aggregated 1,939 million feet, as com­
pared with 1,973 million feet in 1924. During the same
period, shipments for 1925 amounted to 1,964 million feet,
and for 1924 were 2,077 million feet. Orders show a 10
per cent decrease from last year, aggregating 1,864 mil­
lion feet in 1925 as against 2,096 million feet in 1924.
The Aberthaw index of the cost of industrial building
remained unchanged on March 1 at 197.
Production of cement in the country declined from 8,916
thousand barrels in January to 8,255 thousand in Feb­
ruary, the latter figure being 333 thousand below last
year. Shipments have been below production for the last
four months, but increased from 5,108 thousand barrels in
January to 6,015 thousand in February, or 82 thousand
more than in February, 1924. Stocks on hand continued
to increase during the past month until they reached a
new high mark of 19,897 thousand barrels on March 1.
This figure compares with 16,815 thousand barrels a year
ago.
As a rule, cement stocks rise early in the year and de­
cline in the summer and fall, so that the increase of the
past few months may be attributed partly to seasonal fac­
tors. At the same time, the stock figures attained in
the past three months have been unusually high, and a
reflection of this is seen in the fact that February showed
a considerable falling off from January in production,
while last year there was only a slight decline and in
1923 there' was an increase.
Ohio, West Virginia and Western Pennsylvania pro­
duced 59o thousand barrels of cement in February, or
about 7 per cent of the total output. Production last
year was 708,000 barrels. Shipments for February, 1925,
were 404 thousand barrels as against 461 thousand last
year, and stocks were 1,977 thousand barrels as compared
with 1,735 thousand last year.
Retail Trade

Department store sales in the Fourth
District in February, as shown by sixtytwo reporting firms, were 5.6 per cent
below sales of a year ago. All of the
reporting cities showed decreases, vary­
ing from 21.7 per cent in Canton to 1.3 per cent in Co­
lumbus and 1.4 per cent in Cincinnati. Akron and Colum­
bus show slight increases over the preceding month, all
other reporting cities showing a decrease. This bank’s
index number of department store sales in the Fourth

6

THE MO NT HL Y BUSINESS REVIEW

D istrict stood at 90 in F eb ru ary , this being the highest
F e b ru a ry in years, w ith the ex cep tio n of one year ago
w hen it w as 96. F o r the past seven years in d ex n u m b ers
for F e b ru a ry were as follow s: (1919-1923, 100); 1919,
61; 1920, 79; 1921, 85; 1922, 69; 1923, 83; 1924, 96; 1925, 90.
S eventeen w ea rin g apparel firms in this D istrict show ed
a decrease of 3 per cent in sales as co m p ared w ith last
year.

Retail Trade Sales

Percentage

Increase

or

Decrease

SALES
SALES
Feb., 1925 Jan.-Feb., 1925
No. of
Com pared wi th Com pared with
Reports
Feb., 1924 Jan.-Feb., 1924
Departm ent Stores
4
— 3.3
A kron ..................
1,1
C an to n ................
3
— 21.9
— 15.1
7
— 1.4
Cincinnati.........
— 1.5
— 7.4
6
— 3 .4
Cleveland..........
6
C olum bus..........
— 1.3
6.1
D a y to n ...............
— 2.8
5
— 3 .7
New C a s tle ....
3
—2.6
— 5.9
P ittsb u rg h .........
8
— 5.0
— 4 .9
T oledo.................
5
— 8. 8
— 13.1
W heeling............
5
— 7.2
— 10.4
Y oungstow n. . .
3
— 8. 0
— 5.9
Other Cities*..
7
0.6
1.9
D istrict...............
62
— 5.6
3.7
*Includes Erie, Portsm outh, Springfield, and Lima.
Wearing Apparel
— 1.4
6
C incinnati.........
— 7.1
3
C leveland..........
8
— 7.3
Other Cities**.
— 3 .0
17
D istrict...............
**Includes Canton, Columbus, D ayton, Pittsburgh, and Toledo.
W h o lesale
T ra d e

Sales of all re p o rtin g wholesale lines,
ex c ep t hard w are, decreased during F e b ­
ru ary , as co m p ared w ith the sam e m o nth
last year. D r y goods, w ith 17.5 per
cent, sho w ed the g re a te st decline. A s
co m p ared w ith Ja n u a ry , 1925, sales of dry goods, h ard-

w are, an d shoes, increased, while those of g ro ceries a n d
d ru g s decreased.

Wholesale Trade and Chain Store Sales

Percentage Increase or Decrease
SALES
SALES
Feb., 1925, Jan.-Feb., 1925
No. of
Compared with C om pared w ith
Reports
Feb., 1924 Jan .-F eb ., 1924
Groceries
A kron .............
—5
0.9
Cincinnati. . .
-14 /
—10.2
C leveland. . .
4
-1 0 9
—7.9
Colum bus. . .
3
-14 8
—1
1 .0
E rie .................
4
— 8.7
8.2
L exington. . .
3
-2 0 .9
—16.8
P ittsb u rg h ...
10.6
0.5
T oled o............
3
-1 6 .2
—11.9
Y oungstow n.
3
-2 7 .8
21.0
Other Cities*
22
11.2
—9.8
D istrict...................
55
12.5
—8.5
Dry Goods—D is..
19
-1 7 .5
—19.8
D rugs-D is............
16
— 4. 4
— 1.7
H ardw are-D is.. .
18
2.6
0.8
Shoes-D is.............
6
— 9.6
—1.7
^Includes Butler, Canton Connellsville, Du aayy to nn,, D o v e rr,
G reensburg Ironton L,ma, Mansfield, Massillon, Portsmouth’
Spnngfield, Steubenville, Umontown, W arren, Pa., Wheeling, and
—

-

—

-

-

Chain Stores**
D rugs-D istrict. .
3
__ 2
Groceries-Dist...
5
7
*Sales per individual unit operated.

A kron ......................
Butler, P a .............
C a n to n ...................
C incinnati.............
C leveland..............
C olum bus..............
Connellsville, Pa.
D a y to n ...................
Erie, P a .................
Greensburg, Pa..
Hom estead, Pa.
Lexington, Ky. .
L im a ........................
L orain .....................
Oil City, P a. . . .
P ittsburgh, P a...
Springfield............
Steubenville.........
T oledo.....................
W a rre n ...................
Wheeling, W. Va.
Y oungstow n .........
Zanesville..............
T o ta l..................



4 weeks
ending
M ar. 11,
1925
67,278
9,561
40,923
295,053
559,046
122,109
4,261
67,608
28,955
18,025
3,862
26,852
17,328
5,389
13,230
790,154
19,078
9,977
171,924
9,256
42,615
58,453
9,978
2,390,915

10.0

Index Numbers of Trade in the Fourth
Federal Reserve District
(Average

M o n t h l y S a l e , for the F i v e - Y e a r P er io d 1 9 1 9 - 1 9 1 3
I n c lu s iv e — 100)
" ’
D e p a r t m e n t W ho le s a l e W h o le s a l e W h o l e s a l e W h o l e s a l e
PK

ts s f e ,

F eb . 1 9 2 5 . . . .
Feb . 1 9 2 4 . . . .
J a n . 1 92 5 . . . .

90
96
92

Debits to Individual Accounts

1

2.1

8
9

■

H ^ r - e $*•«

102
107
110

78
94

68

72
83
80

100

93
96
97

98
93

(In thousands of dollars)
4
5
3
6
7
% inc. or % inc. or 1925 to date 1924 to date
4 weeks
4 weeks
me, or
dec. col.
ending
dec. col.
ending
(Jan. 1 to
(Jan. 3 to 7o
col.
1 over
Feb. 11,
1 over
M ar. 12,
Mar. 1 1 )
Mar. 12) dec.6 over
col. 2
1925
col. 3
1924
col. 7
— 7.1
72,398
8.1
62,214
176,568
162,452
8.7
6.9
8,944
8,670
10.3
23,992
22,706
5.7
— 4.7
42,961
42,415
— 3.5
108,725
105,130
3.4
317,459
— 7.1
280,457
5.2
798,529
720,981
10.8
576,612
— 3.0
576,158
— 3.0
1,498,577
1,419,361
5.6
122,495
— 0.3
119,323
2.3
313,744
299,245
4.
8
4,222
4,390
0.9
— 2.9
10,604
11,059
—4.1
60,285
12.1
65,444
3.3
170,581
162,849
4. 7
— 0.1
28,982
27,756
4.3
73,376
70,896
3.5
20,052
— 10. 1
21,461
— 16.0
47,922
54,480
12.0
3,654
5.7
3,561
8.5
9,434
9,136
3.3
32,795
— 18.1
28,619
— 6.2
75,767
72,424
4.
6
16,371
19,179
5.8
— 9.7
42,548
43,698
2.6
6,205
— 13.2
4,981
8.2
14,919
12,806
16.5
12,910
2.5
13,445
— 1.6
32,386
34,509
—
6.2
— 13.4
911,972
758,368
4.2
2,161,855
1,929,286
12.1
19,548
— 2.4
19,922
— 4 .2
49,977
47,594
5.0
2.2
9,762
10,240
—2.6
25,625
25,514
0.
4
4.3
164 ,808
167,080
2.9
443,197
412,265
7.5
— 25.0
12,346
13,929
— 33.5
28,804
33,909
15.1
38,280
11.3
44,401
— 4.0
105,652
111,842
— 5 s
—0.2
58,587
53,708
8.8
159,993
143,942
11.2
— 9.0
10,967
11,769
— 15.2
26,687
29,142
8.4
2,552,615
— 6.3
2,357,490
1.4
6,399,462 5,935,226
7 .8
2

—

—

—

—

THE MONTHLY B U S IN ES S REVIEW

National Summary of Business Conditions
PRODUCTION IN BASIC INDUSTRIES

Index ofvariation
22 basic(1919—100).
commoditiesLatest
corrected
for
seasonal
figure—
Pebruary, 123.5
WHOLESALE

I

PRICES

Index of U. S. Bureau of Labor Sutistics
(1913—100* base
adopted by Bureau).
Latest
figure—February,
161

Weekly figures for member banks in 101 lead'
ing cities. Latest figures—March 11.
FACTORY

EMPLOYMENT

m

%

_

_______ " V i S I

• ”—t*M “ •

Index *or M manufacturing industries (1919—
>00). Latest ficure—February, 9J




7

(By the Federal Reserve Board)
Production in basic industries declined in February from the high rate^ of
output in January* but continued above the level of a year ago* Notwith­
standing a decline in prices of agricultural commodities, the average of whole­
sale prices rose slightly owing to a further advance in prices of certain other
commodities.
Production
The Federal Reserve Board’s index of production in twenty-two basic
industries, which is adjusted to allow for differences in the number of work­
ing days and for seasonal variations, declined 3 per cent in February, but con­
tinued to be higher than at any time since the peak reached in May, 1923.
Average daily output of iron and steel was exceptionally heavy, and copper
production per day was the largest since 1918. There was a slight decline in
activity in the woolen industry, and more considerable reductions in the
output of lumber, cement, bituminous coal and crude petroleum. Production
of automobiles increased 19 per cent in February, the largest monthly in­
crease in nearly two years, but the output was still over 25 per cent smaller
than a year ago. Factory employment increased by about 2 per cent in Feb­
ruary, considerable increases being reported for the automobile, iron and steel,
and clothing industries, while the number of workers in the packing and ce­
ment industries declined. Earnings of industrial workers in February were
larger than in January, reflecting in part the resumption of full-time work
after the inventory period.
Reports to the Department of Agriculture of intentions to plant in 192S
indicate that the acreage of practically all grains and of tobacco will be larger,
and that of white potatoes smaller than in 1924.
Trade
Total railroad freight movements continued at approximately the same
daily rate in February as in January, and shipments of merchandise increased
in recent weeks and were much larger than a year ago. Wholesale and retail
sales were smaller during February than a year ago, owing partly to the fact
that this year February had one less business day. Department store sales
were 1 per cent smaller in February than in the corresponding month of 1924.
Wholesale trade in all lines, except meats and hardware, was less than a
year ago, and showed in February about the usual seasonal changes. Sales of
groceries, meats, and drugs decreased, while sales of dry goods and shoes in­
creased.
Prices
The slight rise in the wholesale price index of the Bureau of Labor Sta­
tistics was due to advances in the fuel and lighting group, largely in petroleum
and in building materials, while prices of all the other commodity groups de­
clined. In the first three weeks of March, prices of hogs, cotton goods, and
rubber increased, while prices of many other commodities decreased, the larg­
est decreases being those for wheat and other grains.
Bank Credit
Loans of member banks in principal cities continued to increase between
the middle of February and the middle of March and on March 11 were larger
than at any time in the past four years. The volume of loans for commercial
purposes has been at a high and almost constant level since last autumn, and
loans on stocks and bonds, which have increased continuously since the sum­
mer of 1924, reached in March the largest amount on record. Increases in
loans were accompanied by further reduction in the holdings of securities, par­
ticularly at banks in the financial centers.
At the reserve banks demand for credit increased between the end of Jan­
uary and the middle of March, chiefly as the result of the export demand for
gold and the growth in domestic currency requirements, with the consequence
that earning assets increased. After March 15, however, temporary abundance
of funds arising out of Treasury operations resulted in a sharp reduction in
member bank borrowings.
Somewhat firmer condition in the money market in the latter part of Feb­
ruary and the early weeks of March were indicated by a rise of the rate on 4-6
months’ prime commercial paper from 3% to 4 per cent

Indexes of National Business Conditions
The base (100) for all the charts except the first is the monthly average for the 5 years 1919-1923 inclusive.
For the first chart, the base is the monthly average for the three years 1921-1923.
^VOLUME OF CHECK PAYMENTS C«M1

R E T A IL T R A D E

PC*
CINT
250

P !«
CCMT

W HOLESALE TRADE

2)0

|

200

200

2 00

i

•50

CtKT]

130

J LL

L / I

yV

n

/1

100

JO
•V

so

I?:?

0

0
192<

1 92 0

1922

1 92 3

192 ♦

1925

EXPORTS OF MERCHANDISES!
1
i
i

w j

k

1
V *

T

vs/

4

\

1920 19j i 1022 *923 l<>?* 151^
PE*
CT.M1

COAL PRODUCTION

r«
cewt

PVR
ccm

tso

150

PIG IRON PRODUCTION

200

~

tSO

TV

—

I

i

t v*\K b

i

100

V

i/

SO

30

IO

0

o

.

1920

1921

1922

023

19 2 +

1923

A AJ

i

*v

V

n

1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.

. i

r

AJ

ft

V

30

o
19 2 0

1924

1922

1923

1924

l a t e s t f ig u r e s

Member Bank Credit. February Loans 114, Investments 133.
Member Bank Deposits. February, Demand 120, Time 166.
Check Payments (except N. Y.) January, 127.
Commercial Failures. February, 139.
Retail Trade. January, 97.
Wholesale Trade, January, 88.




A

PC*
CCHT

1325

7. Building Permit*. February, 160.
8. Car Loadings. February, 99.
9. Exports o! Merchandise. February, 78.
!0* Bituminous Coal Production. February, 97
H. Pig Iron Production. February, 128
12. Automobile Production. February, 132