View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

The Monthly

Business Review
Covering financial, industrial, and agricultural conditions
in the Fourth Federal Reserve District
VOL. 6

CLEVELAND, OHIO, APRIL I, 1924

“ T O GET AN UNCLOUDED VIEW OF THE
BUSINESS SITU ATIO N THESE D AYS IT IS
NECESSARY TO DISTIN GUISH BETWEEN
FACT AND F A N C Y ; OTHERW ISE ONE IS
L IK E L Y TO LET IM AG INATIO N G E T TH E
BETTER OF COM M ON SENSE. ” —ED ITORIAL

FEDERAL RESERVE BANK of CLEVELAND



D. C. W ills, C hairm an of th e Board
(COMPILED MARCH 22, 1924)

NO. 4

THE M O N T H L Y BUS I NES S R E V I E W

2

An Editorial

T

O get an unclouded view of the business situation these days it
is necessary to distinguish between fact and fancy; otherwise
one is likely to let imagination get the better of common sense.

Considered from a sentimental angle there is probably less confi­
dence in the forward movement o f industry than there was a month
ago. Viewed from a rational standpoint, however, and a cce p tin g as
trustworthy guides those factors which are not susceptible to ex­
ternal disturbances, the indexes o f dependable business such as record
car loadings, capacity production o f iron and steel, plenty of work at
good wages, the high consuming power of the country, an almost
complete absence o f speculative tendencies, and sound financial
conditions, justify confidence in the future.
Careful observation of both sides of the situation has led to the
general adoption of a middle-of-the-road course, which, in addition to
being safe, makes it easier to steer clear of the rough places.
So far we can see no sufficient reason to revise the statement we
have frequently made in the past; namely that the business structure
continues sound. Desiring to repeat this and at the same time not
wishing to depend upon our judgment alone in the matter, we made a
careful check of the opinions of representative business men in the
Fourth District in the following manner:
1. We assumed that each business head, judging by the trend o f
his business in 1923, and by the returns shown on the financial state­
ment for the year, formed an estimate several months ago as to where
and how he would stand in March, 1924.
2. We asked each of these men if anything of sufficient importance
to make them change their original estimate had actually happened.
3. The replies we received showed clearly that business now, with
few exceptions, is just about the place its leaders thought it would be.




Frankly, we can think of no fairer test.

THE

MONTHLY

BUSINESS

REVIEW

3

Agricultural Loans Slightly Higher than a Month Ago; No Outstanding Feature in
City Bank Borrowings; Reserve Ratio Steady
Since our last report, loans to member banks in
agricultural districts have shown a slight increase. On
February 20 they were $14,108,000, while on March
20 they had advanced to $15,560,000. This is a cus­
tomary occurrence for this season of the year arid
may be attributed to various causes. The three which
follow, however, are outstanding:
L Quite a number of notes which are coming in are
based upon the carrying of livestock.
2. A considerable volume of tobacco has not been
marketed.
3. Preparations are now being made for spring
work on the farms.
Loans to city banks indicate no particular feature of
importance at this time. Accommodations of this na­
ture totaled $22,440,000 on February 20 as compared
with $20,827,000 on March 20, a decrease during this
period o f $1,613,000.

The reserve ratio of this bank on February 20 was
80.7 per cent while on March 20 the same percentage
was shown. The reserve ratio o f the System on Feb­
ruary 20 was 81.4 per cent as compared with 81.8 per
cent on March 20.
The combined reports of 18 selected banks in the
Fourth District on savings deposits for the month of
February of this year show an increase of 1 per
cent over the preceding month. When comparison is
made with February, 1923, an increase o f 12.2 per
cent is shown.
A recent report compiled by R. G. Dun & Company
shows that 135 commercial failures occurred in this
District in the month of February as again 175 dur­
ing January, a drop of 40, or 22.9 per cent. Liabilities
for February totaled $2,824,143 as compared with $6,160,933 for the preceding month, a decline o f $3,336,790, or 54.2 per cent.

Restrained Buying and High Production Feature Iron and Steel Industry; Heavy
Railroad Buying One Striking Exception to Cautious Attitude;
Buoyancy of Prices Lacking
Marked conservatism as to obligating themselves
against expected requirements very far in the future
has appeared in recent weeks so broadly among iron
and steel buyers that it has become the conspicuous
feature o f market conditions. At the same time ship­
ments by the mills are running at a high rate and
this is requiring a pitch o f production that today
is closely approximating the record peak of all time.
These two seemingly opposing factors, restrained buy­
ing and high production, apparently signify very clearly
the tremendous scale of present consumption, since all
indications point to a condition o f relatively small
stocks in the hands of consumers.
It may be said that the gap between producer and
consumer has been abnormally narrowed under present
conditions and in this situation the efficiency of the rail­
roads by their dispatch of delivery furnishes a major
factor. It is pointed out that present operating and
delivery conditions in iron ami steel are free of any
of the retarding factors which so often have been
present in the past, such as car shortages or con­
gestion, labor shortages or disturbances, the latter
either within the industry or in closely related fields
such as coal, etc. Under present conditions, therefore,
production and shipments of steel, it is indicated,
register very sensitively the underlying position of gen­
eral consumption.
As an index to the rather extraordinary relation­
ship of present orders and production, the unfilled ton­
nage of the United States Steel Corporation at the
end of February was only 18 per cent above the
low point of the extreme depression year o f 1921
when output for the steel industry was at the lowest
relative stage in history. Today, the Steel Corporation
is operating around 96 per cent of capacity which vir­
tually approximates the maximum possible rate.




Railroad and building demands continue to provide
large new requirements for steel and are the two chief
factors in the visible demand. Railroad orders espe­
cially offer a striking exception to the cautious spirit
displayed by steel buyers. Awards o f cars and locomo­
tives have been maintained at a high rate.
During the year to date the railroads have placed
orders for approximately 75,000 cars which compares
with 63,000 cars for the entire first quarter of 1923
when the equipment market was very active. Febru­
ary car orders totaled 41,346, the largest of any single
month excepting March, 1923, since 1918 when the
wholesale purchases by the government were made un­
der federal control. The March, 1923, total was 42,500.
During March to date car and locomotive orders have
shown no signs of diminution from the recent marked
expansion and a number of important new inquiries
have been appearing.
Building work, as measured by contracts for struc­
tural steel, is sustained on a large scale. February
awards for the country are reported as approximately
189,800 tons or 73 per cent of shop capacity, compared
with 184,600 tons or 71 per cent o f capacity in
January.
Automobile production is beginning to taper off
as various builders are nearing the completion of
their stocking schedules in anticipation of the spring
market. Future conditions in this industry depend
upon the magnitude of the spring market which is
yet to develop. Export demand for iron and steel
has been running in good volume. With the leading
producer it has been averaging 8,000 tons daily or
about 15 per cent of total capacity.
Iron and steel production has been rapidly approach­
ing the historical high point. The daily average of
steel ingot output in February represented 96 per cent

THE

4

MONTHLY

BUSINESS

of the high record rate of last April and a gain of
33 per cent since December. On the February basis,
the country was making steel ingots at the annual
rate of 47,030,000 tons compared with a rate of 41,460,000 tons in January and 35,370,000 tons in De­
cember.
Pig iron production in February, as compiled by
Iron Trade Review, did not make quite as good a show­
ing as steel ingots which is normally the case. The
average daily production of pig iron in February rep­
resented 85 per cent of the record rate last May. In
February the country was making pig iron at the
rate of over 38,500,000 tons annually. Furnaces in

REVIEW

blast at the end o f February had risen to 262, a gain
of 14 over January and 31 over December.
'
Buoyancy of prices is lacking in both finished steel
and pig iron reflecting both the check on buyine
and the general ease with which wants are beinl
supplied by the rnills and furnaces. Within a limited
range, prices are irregular although there is no marked
softening tendency. These facts are well displayed bv
Iron Trade Review composite of fourteen leading iron
and steel products. For the week ending March 19
this average stood at $43.25 compared with $43.53 one
month previously and $43.35 on the corresponding date
in January.

Oil Market Checked Somewhat by Cold Weather; Crude Oil Market Strong;
Producers Enlarging Drilling Operations
Persistent cold weather throughout the past month
has acted to check somewhat the improved sentiment
that was apparent in the oil market a month ago.
Motoring has been at a comparatively low level dur­
ing the month and the retail sales of gasoline have
suffered accordingly. For this reason, jobbers whose
tanks were well filled a month ago have not had oc­
casion to come into the market, with the result that the
refiners have found a slow market for their motor fuel.
Heavy buying of gasoline for export, however, has
had a sufficient influence to prevent a real slump.
While retail sales of gasoline have lagged somewhat,
they have not fallen sufficiently to bring about any
general reduction in the tank wagon or service station
prices.
The crude oil market has remained strong, being
marked by increases in the posted prices of mid­
continent and most of the other crudes. National
Petroleum News investigations, however, show that
there is probably less premium paying for crude by
the independent refiners than was the case a month
ago.
The principal reason for the strong crude market
is found in the fact that January production of crude
oil in the United States, for the first time in many
months, fell below consumptive demand. The total daily
average indicated consumption in January, including
domestic and export demand, was 2,071,419 barrels.
The total daily domestic production averaged 1,817,871
barrels a day. The total new supply of crude (do­
mestic production and imported crude) averaged 2 ,021,193 barrels a day, causing a draft on stocks of
some 50,000 barrels a day to make up the deficit.
Drilling operations are increasing somewhat and in­
dications are for further expansion with the opening
of spring. Many pipe line construction projects in­
dicate activity during the spring and summer in the
producing fields.
In spite o f the slowness of the present market, the
refiners are looking forward to a prosperous sum­
mer, believing that heavy buying will start with the
coming of favorable motoring weather.
Export demand has held up fairly well during the
month, although unfavorable foreign exchange has been
a discouragement to heavy buying.




A report by the petroleum economist of the Bureau
of Mines states that gasoline production during Tann
ary attained a new high record of 695,322,500 <«,i
Ions, a daily average of 22,429,758 gallons, which
shows an increase in the daily average over that f
the preceding month amounting to 1,165,997 g a llo p
or 5.5 per cent, and an increase of H .5 per cent " f ’
the rate a year ago. Imports during January were 19
309,197 gallons, a decrease of appoximately 6,000 OOrt
gallons from the December imports. The new
ply (production plus imports) was 714,631697 ~ T
Ions, a daily average o f 23,052,635 gallons, and an ini
crease of 12.1 per cent over last year’ s figures.
Gasoline stocks on January 31 were 1 202 547
gallons, an increase of 127,647,740 gallons during th i
month which represents the excess o f supply over d
mand during this period. This increase in stocks com
pares with the increase of about 119,000,000 eall
during January, 1923.
’
’
° ns
The output of kerosene in January was 217 7 6 7 q ? i
gallons, a decrease of about 17,000,000 gallons fWT
the December production. Exports decreased about *
500,000 gallons, amounting to 64,762,389 gallons Th~
domestic demand increased slightly to 122 (Mn ^
gallons and about 31,000,000 gallons were addeH
stocks which amounted to 314,181,465 gallons th°
end of January.
tne
The production of gas and fuel oils was 1,062 892 IQ'
gallons, a slight decrease from the December’ out^ *
Imports declined over 7,000,000 gallons amount^
to 36,471,249 gallons. Exports were 109,908 000 **Ti*
Ions, a decrease of 40,000,000 gallons from the Dece '
ber figures. The domestic demand was 9 7 7 143 7* ?.'
gallons, an increase of about 25,000,000 gallons over’
December demand. About 12,000,000 gallons w*
added to stocks which were 1,527,346,622 gallon*
the end of the month.
on
Lubricants showed a slight decrease in productm
in January, the output amounting to 94,534 650 1^1
Ions. Exports were 25,175,405 gallons, a decrease r
8,000,000 gallons from December exports. DomeE£
demand was 67,391,215 gallons, an increase o f Ia
000,000 gallons or 26.9 per cent over figures for th
preceding month. Stocks of lubricants were 244 755

THE

MONTHLY

BUSINESS

997 gallons, an increase of 2,000,000 gallons during
the month.
There were 247 refineries reported to the Bureau of
Mines as operating during January at 77.2 per cent
of their aggregate daily crude oil capacity oi 2,142,-

REVIEW

5

222 barrels, running to stills a daily average of 1,653,025 barrels of both foreign and domestic crude oils.
This was almost exactly the same rate of operation as
in December but an increase of 9.4 per cent as compared with operations a year ago.

Traffic Grows as Year Progresses; Car Surplus Represents Considerable
Margin of Safety
An outstanding feature of the business situation
at this time is the marked increase in traffic together
with the quick and efficient deliveries which the roads
are making. During the week ending March 1, 945,049 cars o f revenue freight were loaded, the highest
point ever reached at this season of the year. For
the previous week loadings dropped to 845,898 cars
as compared with 935,109 cars for the week ending
February 16, due to the observance of Washington’s
birthday on February 22.
Loadings from January 1 through March 1 totaled
7,924,617 cars as against 7,654,218 cars for the same
period last year and 6,616,628 cars for the correspond­
ing period in 1922.
The car supply continues to be good. The average
daily surplus for the week ending February 29 was
134,273 cars as compared with 125,177 cars in the
preceding week. The figure for February represents

a reduction in the total surplus since January o f
about 100,000 cars but still shows a considerable
margin o f safety.
Domestic shipments of locomotives during February
total 92 as compared with 147 for the previous
month and 305 for December, 1923. For the month
of February last year domestic shipments totaled
196. Unfilled orders at the end of February totaled
466 (domestic) and 33 (foreign) as against 344 (do­
mestic) and 32 (foreign) at the end of January.
Reports given out at the last meeting o f the Great
Lakes Shippers Regional Advisory Board, held in
Grand Rapids February 19, indicate a probably heavier
traffic movement during the next sixty days than
was the case a year ago, and this same condition
seems to exist in other parts of the eastern section o f
the country, for the Advisory Board for the Middle
Atlantic States predicts an increase this year as com­
pared with last of about 10 per cent.

Automobile Makers Push Production; Inquiries for Trucks Numerous But Orders
Difficult to Close; Exports Make Auspicious Start in 1924
The automobile industry, under the stimulus of ad­
vancing sales and the efforts of manufacturers to pro­
vide for the anticipated spring and summer demand,
is moving at a rapid pace. Plant schedules have
been enlarged with the result that February output
showed a decided increase over that of January,
and was far in advance of February a year ago. Prac­
tically all the plants in this District have increased their
working forces since the first of the year.
Truck manufacturers tell us that orders during Feb­
ruary were very good but that so far this month
they are hardly living up to expectations. They are
at a loss to account for this, for general conditions
are good and their branches throughout the country
without exception report that there never was a time
when the inquiry for trucks was greater. The dif­
ficulty is to get the orders closed. However, it is be­
lieved that at least a part of this hesitancy may be
accounted for by the fact that there are more trucks
on hand for immediate delivery than there were a year
ago and consequently the customers are slower in
anticipating their requirements. February output, as
shown by the Department of Commerce figures, was
considerably above that of the preceding month.
Shipments o f automotive products to foreign coun­
tries in 1920 broke all records, but recent figures com­
piled by the Department of Commerce show that the
present year is making an even more auspicious be­
ginning. In January the total value of automotive




exports from the United States was $18,465,202 as
against $16,892,651 in January, 1920, an increase of 9.3
per cent. As compared with $10,787,344 in January,
Every class of cars showed a large increase but
leadership was taken by those valued tip to $500,
which advanced from 2,099 in January, 1923, to 4,734
in January, 1924.
Exports of trucks were larger with heavy and high
priced machines showing the principal advances, TruAs
up to one ton increased from 1,095 in January, 1923,
to 1,191 in January, 1924, while those ranging in
size from^ one to two and one-half increased from
205 to 355. Trucks over two tons increased from 52
to 145.
Australia is the chief market, taking three times as
many in January, 1924, as in January, 1923. Argentine
took second place in January. Japan stood first in
the ^purchase of trucks, her imports increasing from
10 in January, 1923, to 1,245 in January, 1924. This
increase which is due to the demand resulting from
the destruction o f vehicles in the earthquake, and which
has continued since September of last year, is the most
noteworthy item in January export statistics. Al­
though the truck shipments to Japan in December
dropped to 841 from the high mark of 1,859 in No­
vember, the January shipments brought them up
a^ain to a high point.

THE

6

MONTHLY

BUSINESS

REVIEW

Automobile Production
The Department of Commerce announces February
production of automobiles, based on figures received
from 186 manufacturers, 96 making passenger cars
and 119 making trucks (29 making both passenger
cars and trucks). Data for earlier months include

12 additional manufacturers, now out of business, while
February data fo r 9 small firms were not received in
time for inclusion in this report.
Figures on truck
production also include fire apparatus and street
sweepers.

NUMBER OF MACHINES
1922
81,696
109,171
152,962
197,224
232,462
263,053
225,086
249,492
187,694
217,566
215,352
208,010
Total ........
* Revised

2,339,768

Passenger Cars
1923
1924
223,819
*287,302
254773
336.363
319,770
344,639
350,410
337,362
297,330
314,373
298,911
335,023
284,923
*275,439
3,636,772

22,640
24,097
26,298
22,046
24,692
19,462
21,795
21,949
20,354

Trucks
1923
19,720
22,161
35,260
38,056
43,678
41,145
30,663
30,829
28,638
30,166
28,070
*27,743

246,281

376,129

1922
9,576
13,350
20,022

1924
* 28,846

31,072

Men’s Clothing Industry Awaits Opening of Spring Retail Season;
Consumers9 Objections to High Prices Unchanged
With the advent of warm weather there is likely to be
a rapid change for the better in the condition of the
clothing industries. A leading manufacturer of men’s
clothing in this District reports that retail dealers had
a rather dull fall season resulting in an accumulation
of stocks, but that these were substantially reduced
during the January and February sales. At present the
men's clothing industry is marking time while awaiting
the opening of the spring retail season and the showing
of new fall lines by manufacturers during March.
Consumers’ resistance to high prices remains un­
changed in the women's clothing trade. Because of
the excessive costs of retail distribution, some manu­
facturers of women's garments are entering the re­
tail field and actively competing for the consumers’
business at the sacrifice of their wholesale trade. One
large local manufacturer says that, on the basis of their
own experience, the women’s clothing industry as a
whole is now operating on a sound basis and at a
profit, relying more on quantity production than on
high prices for gainful results.
A manufacturer of textile fabrics in this District
notes a slight falling off in production recently, but

reports that business in his line is on a more substantial
footing than it was six months ago. Clothing man»
facturers are, as a rule, ordering fabrics in sm' n
quantities as needed. A recent survey of 2 000 ma
facturers of clothing showed an average o f 30
cent less stock on hand this year than last.
^>er
There appears to be no consensus among maniifa^
turers o f knit underwear in this District regardin '
the outlook for business this spring. One p r o d u c t
reports that retailers are carrying over large stock*
due to the mild winter, and that there is no incen«
for buying today. It is possible, however that
spring re-order season may improve conditions som
what because spring purchases have been very r
servative and both the jobber and the retailer
need goods when warm weather comes. Another ma
facturer, whose business is not seriously affected
the wide fluctuations that have occurred in the
cotton market, anticipates a good year. There has
a steady decline in the cotton market and the tende °
of buyers of knit goods is to hold off purcha*?™
until there is a rising market. That time has
yet come.
not

Shoe Manufacturers Report “ Better Business” ; Orders Small But Numerous •
Surplus of Workers
In the past nine weeks the shoe industry in the present a surplus of labor is reported, which enable rt,
_____T~\ ’» i_________! _ 1
_
inormfn/'fiii'ore
fA
fining,
--f V i a i t * n ____
i*
• .
^
lIlC
Fourth
District has been showing a steadyr o improvemanufacturers
to enlarge
their operations
without
cTfR_
liffiment. There has been a very material increase in pro- culty. The industry in general continues to operate1
on
duction and most of the plants now have sufficient busi- small orders. These are sufficiently numerous to
ness to keep them operating at a fair rale of speed. At up a good total volume but at the "same time "they




THE

MONTHLY

BUSINESS

the effect of keeping the factories closely dependent on
the current bookings of their sales forces.
Final figures compiled by the United States Bureau
of the Census on boot and shoe production in the
Fourth Federal Reserve District for the month of
January show that the output of 42 establishments re­
porting was 11.9 per cent more than that of the pre­
ceding month. Production of 1,119 establishments in
the United States was 26,397,808 pairs as compared
with 22,676,436 pairs for December, or an increase
for the month of 16.4 per cent.
According to data compiled by the Department of
Commerce, based upon reports received from 4,668
manufacturers and dealers, the total number o f cattle
hides held in stock on January 31, 1924, by packers and
butchers, tanners, dealers, and importers (or in tran­
sit to them) amounted to 4,938,926, as compared with
5,086,286 on December 31, 1923, and with 6,384,131 on

REVIEW

7

January 31, 1923. The stocks, o f calf and kip skins
amounted to 2,568,605 on January 31, 1924, as com­
pared with 2,935,094 on December 31, 1923, and 4,086,044 on January 31 o f last year. Goat and kid
skins numbered 8.903,835 on January 31, 1924 ; 9,926,128 on December 31, 1923; and 8,952,825 on Janu­
ary 31, 1923. The stocks of sheep and lamb skins on
January 31, 1924, amounted to 6,348,865; on Decem­
ber 31, 1923, to 7,400,296; and on January 31 o f last
year, to 9,188,283.
The total stocks of sole leather (cattle) reported by
tanners, dealers, and manufacturers using the leather as
a material, amounted to 9,642,850 backs, bends, and
sides on January 31, 1924, the corresponding figures
for December 31, 1923, being 10,043,085, and for Janu­
ary 31, 1923, 9,543,580. The production o f sole leather
during January, 1924, amounted to 1,373,255 pieces
(backs, bends, and sides), and the stocks in process at
the end o f the month to 5,216,341 pieces.

Building and Wall Paper Business Advances; Demand in Box Board Industry
Fails to Meet Expectations
According to latest available information the paper in­
dustry has shown little change during the past month.
There has been some improvement in the demand for
fine papers, however. Building and wall papers have
also been moving fairly steadily, although the de­
mand for wall papers has been less active than was
anticipated.
The paper box board industry which is usually quite
active at this season o f the year is not living up to
expectations. This is particularly true o f the Cincinnati

plants where most o f the manufacturers have but a
limited amount o f advance business booked and where
operations are below normal. The lateness o f die
Eastern season is believed to be partly responsible
for this situation.
Cleveland box board makers report more satisfac­
tory conditions and are anticipating even better busi­
ness as die spring season advances. A t present the
principal demand is coming from the food and garment
manufacturers.

Delivery of 1923 Burley Tobacco Progresses Rapidly; Part of 1922 Crop Still on Hand;
Steps Taken to Establish Agricultural Bank
Delivery o f the balance o f the 1923 crop o f Burley
tobacco by the growers progressed rapidly during the
first half of March. The Kentucky Commissioner of A g­
riculture reports that about 17 million pounds o f Burley
were sold over the floors of the independent warehouses
in that state in February at an average price o f ap­
proximately 22 cents a pound. No recent sales have
been announced by the Burley Tobacco Growers Co­
operative Association at the time of this writing.
The Association still has on hand some of the 1922
crop and final payments for that year cannot be made
to the members until all of this tobacco has been sold.
Two payments have been made to the members on
the 1922 crop; one in the nature of an advance at the
time of delivery and the other a second payment made
in the spring o f 1923. The board of directors o f the
Association at the March meeting voted to make a third
payment on the crop this spring.

The Association announced early in March that over
15 million dollars had been paid out as advances to
growers on delivery of the 1923 crop. Since that time
a large amount o f tobacco has been delivered so the
total o f the advances to date is considerably larger
than the above figure.
The board of directors also voted to
steps to
establish an agricultural bank, the purpose of whidi
will be to lend money to members on the basis o f their
participation certificates. These certificates indicate
the amount and grade o f tobacco delivered and are
issued to the growers at the time they deliver their
tobacco.
With reference to the distributing phase, the volume
o f cigar business which, following the rush o f the
holiday season fell off during January, is again some­
what larger. Cigarette business is growing rapidly, but
both jobbers and retailers are being affected by price
cutting which is reported to be quite general.

Construction Again Makes Rapid Strides; Upward Trend in Material Prices;
Demand for Apartment and Dwelling Houses
After a decline last month due largely to unusually

Fourth District is again making rapid strides forward,

cold weather which made outdoor construction work
practically impossible, the building industry in the




start new ones.

THE

8

MONTHLY

BUSINESS

Prices o f building materials are showing an upward
trend while labor rates and conditions remain practically
unchanged. Up to this time there are practically no
indications of the bonus payments which became a
general practice a year ago. Dealers report a steadily
growing demand for materials.
A rather dose race with the opening months of
1923 is being run by the corresponding period this
year in Geveland as indicated by building statistics
compiled by the Builders Exchange. Figures for the
period from January 1 to March 15, 1923, showed a
total valuation o f permits issued o f $11,568,900, while
the corresponding period in 1924 indicates a total of
$11,415,325. In making this comparison it is to be
remembered that 1923 was the greatest building year
thus far in the city's history.
The difference in the figures for the period from
March 1 to 15 in the two years was only $25,000 in
a total o f over two and a half million dollars in val­
uation.
While it may be true, as claimed by certain experts
on building conditions, that Geveland is overbuilt in
certain lines, including theaters, hotels, and office

REVIEW

buildings, there is still a remarkable demand for single
houses and apartments. It is evident that the city is
entering upon an unusual era in the last mentioned
class, the number o f apartment houses for which per­
mits were issued fo r January and February this w a r
being 52 as compared with 33 fo r the first two months
of last year. The ratio 0f increase in percentage o f
dwellings is shown in similar figures the ratin
1923 being well sustained.
°r
February building totals for the entire country were
unusually large. T h e total value of building permitted
for in February at 166 cities is reported to Bradstr***>~
as $270,045,981, as compared with $217,337774 at th*
identical cities in January and $221,753,727 in Feb
ruary a year ago. There is here shown a gain o f 24 ?
per cent over January and of 21.7 per cent over Feb*
ruary of last year.
New York City showed the largest quantitative gain
over February, 19Z3, while increases were also recr
istered by New England, Middle Atlantic, and F ar"
Western cities. In the same comparison, however tho«Z
in the Central Western, Northwestern Sotithwp-_tn.„
and Southern sections show decreases.
tern.

Lumber Industry Begins to Feel Effects of Spring Building;
Price Trend Upward
According to reports received by the National Lum­
ber Manufacturers’ Association from 389 of the larger
commercial sawmills of the country, lumber produc­
tion during the first ten weeks o f this year exceeded
that of the corresponding period of last year by 135,667,723 feet, or 6.6 per cent. Shipments during the
same period of this year were 197,109,857 feet, or 8
per cent less, and orders were 344,868,234 feet or 13
per cent less than last year. For the week ended
March 8, production was slightly greater (0.9 per
cent) than for the corresponding week of 1923, while
both shipments and orders were subtantially less.
Reports received from selected lumber manufacturers
in this District indicate that their business has held up

fairly well throughout the winter in spite of
building activity. It is believed that there
very large volume of new building this snrinopecially in the industrial field. The trend o f bmidi«S"
material prices is again upward, as shown both bv th f
Aberthaw Company s and the United States T W .
of Labor Statistics’ indexes.
The general fe* 1^ U
among lumber producers in regard to the business o w
look this spnng is decidedly optimistic.
Retail lumber dealers’ stocks are not generally Ure*
They are reported to have plenty of orders o n l h f f r
books for delivery as soon as the weather permits
resumption of outdoor contruction. They are hn
ever, buying cautiously at present.
’

Brick Makers Optimistic; Production Heavier; Ohio Receives Largest Shipments
of Paving Brick
Indications point to good business in the common
brick industry. With the exception of several sec­
tions o f the country where commercial business is
largely dependent upon the agricultural interests and
where the farmers have not yet fully recovered, reirts coming into the office of the Common Brick
anufacturers Association reflect an optimistic feel­
ing on the part o f the manufacturers.
Evidence o f the makers’ confidence in their product
and of their belief in its future was seen at the annual
meeting o f the Association which was held at Los An­
geles, February 11 to 16. Every state in the union
was represented. Out of nearly 400 manufacturers

G




who were in attendance at the business sessions, more
than 2o0 traveled from sis to seven thousand milnc
From the standpoint of the number present the *
terest shown, and results accomplished, the’ m e e ti^
was reported very satisfactory.
With reference to importations, heavy shipments nt
foreign made brick continue. American producers ar
finding that it is practially impossible to meet this com
petition on account of the comparatively low price f
which the imported brick can be sold* however
cording to the Association the artisans and general
building public are showing a preference for the honwl
product.
c

THE

MONTHLY

BUSINESS

The report of the Common Brick Manufacturers As­
sociation as of February 1, 1924, with comparative
figures for the preceding month is as follows:
Feb. 1
Jan. 1
1924
No. of Firms Reporting ..
114
120
Plants Closed D o w n ..........
45
30
Burned Brick on H and... 306,503.000 313.696,000
Unbumed Brick on H and.. 38,349,000 55,646,000
Brick Moved from Yard
During Month .............. 45,762,000 66,199,000
Orders on Books .............. 272,403,000 266,914,000
The following figures showing production, stocks,
unfilled orders, and shipments of face brick for 32
identical plants during February, 1924, as compared
with January 1924, and February, 1923, have been com­
piled by the American Face Brick Association. The
ngures do not include commons or culls.
Feb.
Tan.
Feb.
1924
i924
1923
Production ............ 19,284,000 17,366,000 16,012,000
Stocks ....................67,997,000 61,575,000 70,751,000
Unfilled Orders .. .40,524.000 33,592,000 51,296,000
Shipments ............ 15,363.000 11,231,000 13,660,000

REVIEW

9

That highway departments and municipalities are
awarding contracts for street and highway paving early
in the season is indicated by the sharp increase in un­
filled orders for vitrified paving brick during the month
o f February.1924
The February statistical report submitted to the De­
partment of Commerce by the National Paving Brick
Manufacturers Association, shows an increase in un­
filled orders in the industry for number 1 pavers o f
10 million to a total of 86,691,000. Unfilled orders in
number 2 and off-grade pavers increased 7J4 million
to a total of 19,884,000.
An increase in production during February o f 1,-

200,000 brick is also shown; also that stock on hand
was in excess of the unfilled orders. Shipments during
February showed a falling off o f approximately 3
million to a total of 10,100,000 due to tne unseasonable
weather prevailing over practically all sections of the
country.
The largest shipments were made into the state o f
Ohio during the month. Shipments to the states o f
Texas, Kansas, Oklahoma, and Illinois follow in the
order named.

Cement Shipments Give Evidence of Early Spring Demand;
Stocks Highest on Record
Production of portland cement in February was 8,588.000 barrels, an increase of 378,000 barrels over the
same month last year, according to a recent bulletin
issued by the United States Geological Survey. When
comparison is made with the preceding month, however,
a decline is shown, for January production totaled
8.788.000 barrels.
Shipments for February showed an upward trend as

compared with January, an encouraging evidence of
early spring demand. February shipments were 5,933,000 barrels as against 5,210,000 barrels for Jan­
uary.
Stocks of finished cement at the end o f January,
total 14,155,000 barrels while at the end of February
they had increased to 16,811,000 barrels, the highest ac­
cumulation of cement stocks on record.

Figures on Coal Production indicate Output Much Greater Than Consumption;
Retail Business Slows Down
The output of bituminous coal during the coal year
ended March 8, 1924, exceeded that of the correspond­
ing period of 1923 by 116,742,000 tons, representing
an increase of 29.5 per cent, according to estimates
made by the United States Geological Survey. The
daily average production during the coal year 1923-24
was 30 per cent greater than that for the year 1922-23.
The past year was one of practically uninterrupted
accumulation of reserve stocks in consumers* hands.
A joint estimate made by the Bureau of the Census
and the Ceological Survey showed that commercial
stocks of bituminous coal totaled 62 million tons on
January 1, 1924, as compared with a total of 36 million
tons on January 1, 1923. Consumers’ stocks at the be­
ginning of this year were 72 per cent larger than in
1923, 29 per cent larger than in 1922, and 35 per cent
larger than in 1921. These figures do not include
coal in the bins of householders, nor bunker coal of
steamships, nor the tonnage on the lake docks, which
item is classed as coal in transit. The Retail Coalman
estimates that there are approximately 100,000,000 tons
of coal above ground at the present time. It is evident




therefore, that coal production is now vastly greater
than consumption.
While the three year wage agreement covering union
mines in the central competitive field is viewed by
government officials as a stabilizing influence in the
coal mining industry, it does, nevertheless, place the
operators o f unionized mines at a disadvantage in
their competition with non-union operators. It is re­
ported that business in the Pittsburgh district is very
slow and that there are indications that more mines will
be closing down soon.
Covering the retail coal trade, a large distributor in
this District says, “ Our business is falling off slightly
due to the tendency o f people to buy just enough
coal to tide them over until spring. Our steam business
is still very brisk. We are going to make an attempt
to get our domestic customers to buy their coal during
the summer months when we believe that domestic coal
will reach its lowest price.” This policy appears to
us to be an excellent one for all retail coal dealers to
adopt. It would not only accelerate the flow of coal
from the mines to ultimate consumers, but it would also
have a tendency to keep prices from falling too low.

10

THE

MONTHLY

BUSINESS

REVIEW

Demand for Tires Reported to be Growing; Preference Shown for Standard M akes;
Mechanical Lines Active
In spite of the growing demand for tires, rubber
manufacturers are watching their production programs
carefully. From present indications it would appear
that producers desire to prevent a recurrence of the
overproduction feature which occurred last year. Busi­
ness is good and is showing further improvement with
the approach of pleasant driving weather.
While the industry is not on as profitable basis as
the manufacturers would like to see it, they realize
that if prevailing conditions are to be met successfully
production must be carried on at the lowest possible
cost and at the same time the quality of their product
must be upheld. The increased production per em­
ploye in the Akron plants would indicate that this
policy is being generally followed.
This close gross profit has naturally narrowed the
margin for the manufacturer of the cheaper grades
of tires so that he does not have so large a spread
of discount for the dealer as formerly, and there is,
therefore, less incentive to purchase unknown brands.
It is authoritatively reported that the dealer is rapidly

drifting back to standard makes, which reduces sales
resistance.
Manufacturers report a growing demand for balloon
tires. This rather sudden demand, however, has created
considerable confusion in the dealers* mind, making
them uncertain as to the kind o f stock to order. The
result is that they are buying only in small quantities.
It is pointed out by some rubber men who are in close
touch with prevailing conditions that the higher prices
quoted on balloon tires and the confusion over rim
sizes will counteract the new popularity to some extent
In the mechanical rubber gooas line business is gen­
erally good. There is a steady demand for this kind
of product and the prices obtained are quite satisfactory
In some instances, however, particularly in the hard
rubber battery box line some of the manufacturers
have recently reduced prices.
According to the latest information at hand there is
still sufficient labor in Akron to take care of production
requirements.

Farm Implement Men Hopeful But Report Spotted Conditions Much in Evidence;
Export Trade Grows
Reports from farm implement manufacturers in
this District indicate a continuation of the spotted con­
ditions which have existed for many months past.
Spring operations on the farms, however, are resulting
in some substantial orders and, as is customary at this
season of the year, some of the makers are expanding
operations. Trade prospects as a whole appear to be
much better than they were at this time a year ago
but no one is looking forward to a normal volume.
At present those states which have diversified farm­
ing interests are supplying the most buyers. In the




past 18 months, according to a report printed in Iron
Trade Review, some implement makers have sold more
machines in the state of New York than in the entire
wheat belt.
According to a late report o f the Department o f
Commerce the value of agricultural implements ex
ported from the United States in January increased
$4,369,386, compared with $3,336,188 in Decemhei?
and with $2,844,284 in January, 1923. This is almost
three times that for January, 1922, when exports were
almost at the lowest point reached during the period o f
depression.

THE

MONTHLY

BUSINESS

REVIEW

11

STATEMENT O F CONDITION
FEDERAL RESERVE BANK OF CLEVELAND
March 19
1924

RESOURCES

Gold held exclusively against F. R. N otes..................... ................
Gold settlement fund with F. R. Board.................................. ................
Gold and gold certificates held by bank..................................

208,819,000
75,868,000

................

297,183,000

March 21
1923
$206,889,000
2,938,000
209,827,000
59,848,000
13,159,000
282,834,000
8,086,000

TOTAL RESERVES................................ ................

305,642,000

290,920,000

Non-reserve cash........................................................................
Bills discounted:
Secured by U. S. Government obligations.......................................
................

16,305,000
20,569,000

21,276,000
21,212,000
42,488,000
44,519,000

U. S. Government securities:
Bonds and Treasury Notes............................................... ..................
..................
Total U. S. Government securities........................ ..................

22,444,000
5,548,000
27,992,000

12,355,000
19,271,000
31,626,000

3,839,000

TOTAL EARNING ASSETS..............

118,633,000

Uncollected items.........................................................................................
Bank premises........................................................................... ..................
All other resources....................................................................

65,008,000
9,117,000
303,000

65,079,000
7,866,000
631,000

TOTAL RESOURCES........... ..................

474,624,000

486,968,000

..................

220,755,000

224,874,000

..................
..................
..................

158,436,000
254,000
1,096,000

157,589,000
10,373,000
984,000

TOTAL DEPOSITS................................ ..................

159,786,000

168,946,000

..................
..................
..................
..................

56,821,000
12,482,000
23,691,000
1,089,000

56,573,000
11,974,000
23,495,000
1, 106,000

..................

?4 74,624,000

$486,968,000

LIABILITIES
F. R. notes in actual circulation............................................
Deposits:
Member Banks-Reserve account....................................
Government......................................................................
Other deposits...................................................................

Deferred availability items.....................................................
Capital paid in........................................................................
Surplus.......................................................................................
All other liabilities..........................................
...
TOTAL LIABILITIES

R atio of total reserves to deposit and F. R. note liabilities com bin ed = 80.3% on
M arch 19, 1924, as com pared w ith 73.9% on M arch 21, 1923.




THE

12

MONTHLY

BUSINESS

R E V I E W

Comparative Statement of Selected Member Banks in Fourth District

Loans and Discounts secured by U. S. Govern­
ment obligations..............................................
Loans and Discounts secured by other stocks and
bonds.................................................................
Loans and Discounts, all other.............................
U. S. Pre-War Bonds.............................................
U. S. Liberty Bonds...............................................
U. S. Treasury Bonds.............................................
U. S. Treasury Notes.............................................
U. S. Certificates of Indebtedness........................
Other Bonds, Stocks, and Securities....................
Total Loans, Discounts, and Investments..........
Reserve with Federal Reserve Bank....................
Cash in Vault..........................................................
Net Demand Deposits...........................................
Time Deposits..........................................................
Government Deposits.............................................
Total Resources on date of this report................

Mar. 12, 1924
(79 Banks)

Feb. 13,1924
(79 Banks)

$24,174,000

225.126.000

399.590.000
404,437,000
686.798.000
698,474,000
48.274.000
48,302,000
109.078.000
109,860,000
6,160,000
5,217,000
56.072.000
55,066,000
6,049,000
6,160,000
304.173.000
308,604,000
1,660,294,000 1.641.320.000
115.997.000
108,878,000
30.936.000
30,034,000
899.190.000
896,261,000
616.894.000
626,705,000
17,042,000
17.210.000
2,114,660,000 2.126.131.000

Increase

Decrease

$ . . . . ........

3952,000

4,847,000
11,676,000
28,000
782,000
943,000
1,006,000

..
111,000
4,431,000
18,974,000
..

7.119.000
902,000
2.929.000

9,811,000

168'000
11,471,000

..

Building Operations for Month of Februaryf 1924-1923
Permits Issued
New Construction Alterations
1924 1923 1924 1923
96
20
35
155
Akron..........
87
40
27
126
Canton........
152
231
185
185
Cincinnati . .
442
477
517
615
Cleveland*. .
98
72
247
244
Columbus.. .
59
111
37
75
Dayton........
16
20
45
38
Erie..............
24
20
10
13
Lexington...
86
250
94
327
Pittsburgh. .
8
18
10
33
Springfield...
82
100
Toledo.........
153
139
51
53
26
22
Wheeling....
92
50
12
Youngstown.
18

Valuation
New Construction
Alterations
Increase or Decrease
1924
1924
1923
1923
Amount Per Cent
$ 28,560
$ 394,846 $ 561,401
$ 11,285 5 — 149,280 — 26 1
807,790
1,007,493
28,025
22,340
-1 9 4 ,0 1 8 — 18.8
1,671,175
158,625
1,145,145
503,325 — 870,730 — 40.0
5,410,242
5,627,467
638,550
724,550 — 303,225 — 4 .8
1,146,765
890,525
92,875
109,735 — 273,100 — 21 7
49,167
483,064
204,319
95,047 — 324,625 — 56.2
19,828
85,250
68,815
52,895 — 16,632 — 13.7
14,525
18,235
40,985
8,200
36,495 160.6
1,590,524
179,458
1,954,548
207,720
335,762
18.7
31,500
6,650
28,325
11,250 — 7,775 — 18.2
772,700
126,995
574,935
145,715 — 216,485 — 23.6
345,940
154,870
20,084
34,250
176,904
93.5
119,990
301,180
19,200
18,200
182,190 131.8

T ota l... 2,066 1,916 1,082 1,079 $12,184,030 $13,250,289 $1,386,252 $1,944,512$— 1,624,519 — 10~7
‘ Includes figures for East Cleveland, Lakewood, Cleveland Heights, and Shaker Heights.

Department Store Sales
(1)

(3)

(2)

Percentage o f Increase or Decrease
Comparison o f net sales with
those of corresponding period
last year

No. of
Reports
Akron..............
Canton............
Cincinnati.......
Cleveland........
Columbus.......
Pittsburgh. . . .
Toledo.............
Youngstown...
District............
U. S. Average..

4
3
9
5
5
7
4
3
45*

A
February
13.8
21.4
22.9
14.2
15.1
15.7
18.2
26.7
16.9

B
Jan. 1
to Feb. 29
7.6

A
February
1923
17.7

B
January
1924

8.1

6.6

2.5

7.8

12.1

6. 2

5.5
17.3
17.9

12.6

: five reports from other cities.




Stocks at end o f month com­
pared with

16.7
9.4
9.1
12.7
11.0
21.5

4.2
11.3
— 4.2

11.1

8.8

12.1

10.7

12.2

8.4

12.6

9.8

6. 0

8.9

„

(4)

Percentage of Percentage of
average stocks o u t s t a n d i n g
at end o f each orders at end
month from o f F e b r u a r y
January 1 to 1924, to total
February 29
purchase*
to av e r a
dunng calendar
monthly sa
year 1923

over 9 a „
period
431.8
726.6
438.5
396.3
407.8
360.4
408.0
260.7
392.2
412.8

10.6
10.0
7.9
16.0
14.7
6.9
6.4

10.8
7.6

THE

MONTHLY

BUSINESS

REVIEW

13

Debits to Individual Accounts
Increase or Decrease
Week Ending Week Ending Increase or Decrease Week Ending
Amount Per Cent Mar. 14, 1923
Amount Per Cent
Mar. 12, 1924 Feb. 13, 1924
(325 Banks)
(326 Banks)
(325 Banks)
$ 1,500,000
5 13,627,000
$ 16,263,000 $— 1.136.000 - 7.0
11.0
Akron.................... $ 15,127,000
2.124.000
8.8
2.648.000
187.000
2.311.000
Butler, Pa.
337.000 -12.7
8.692.000
2.763.000
12,208,000
31.8
Canton..................
11.455.000
753.000 - 6. 2
61.745.000
76.423.000
3.783.000
6.1
65.528.000
Cincinnati.............
10.895.000 -14.3
1 19.039.000
133.208.000
18,484,000
15.5
137,523,000
Cleveland............
4.315.000
3.2
26.364.000
31.325.000
2.650.000
10.1
29.014.000
Columbus..............
2.311.000 - 7.4
Connellsville.......
1.132.000
1.759.000
39.000
3.4
1.171.000
588.000 -33.4
13.194.000
15.877.000
27.4
3.609.000
Dayton................
16.803.000
926.000
5.8
6 266.000
7.218.000
946.000
15.1
7.212.000
Erie........................
6,000 - 0.1
4.848.000 — 243,000 - 5.0
4.795.000
Greensburg...........
4.605.000
190.000 - 4.0
738,000
704,000
10.6
78.000
Homestead...........
816,000
112.000
15.9
6.859.000
8.643.000
4.4
301.000
7.160.000
Lexington, Ky
1.483.000 -17.2
3.556.000
3.494.000
36.2
1.287.000
Lima......................
4.843.000
38.6
1.349.000
1.082.000
1.216.000
130.000
12.0
Lorain..................
1.212.000
4,000 - 0.3
2.303.000
1.670.000
471.000
28.2
Middletown........
2.141.000
162,000 - 7.0
2.327.000
2.290.000
310.000
13.5
New Brighton . . .
2.600.000
273.000
11.7
2.902.000
2.621.000
20.2
530.000
3.151.000
Oil City...............
8.6
249.000
193.697.000
171.943.000
4.7
8.057.000
Pittsburgh..........
180,000,000
13.697.000 - 7.1
5,497,000
3,781,000
43.6
1.648.000
5.429.000
Springfield..........
68,000 - 1. 2
2.179.000
30.3
660.000
Steubenville*. .. .
2.839.000
42.907.000
36.384.000
16.0
5.822.000
Toledo.................
42.206.000
701.000 — 1.6
4.103.000
3.954.000 —
632,000 -1 6 .0
Warren, O ..........
3.322.000
781.000 — 19.0
11.153.000
9.722.000 — 481,000 - 4.9
9.241.000
Wheeling.............
1.912.000 — 17.1
12.183.000
12.763.000
Youngstown.......
13.6
1.735.000
14.498.000
2.315.000
19.0
3.003.000
2.611.000
26.0
680,000
3.291.000
Zanesville............
288.000
9.6

.

5519,184,000
$54,314,000
Total.......... 5573,498,000
‘ Corresponding figures tor 1923 not available.

10.5

5595,856,000 $— 25,197,000 — 4.2

Movement of Livestock at Principal Centers in Fourth Federal
Reserve District for Month of February, 1924-1923

Cincinnati...........
Cleveland............
Columbus............
Dayton................
Fostoria...............
Marion................
Pittsburgh..........
Springfield..........
Toledo.................
Wheeling.............
Cincinnati...........
Cleveland............
Columbus............
Fostoria..............
Marion................
Pittsburgh..........
Springfield..........
Toledo.................
Wheeling.............

1924
1923
15,723 17,255
10,858 9,017
74
98
1,787 1,568
238
226
26
61
31,607 25,662
441
123
889
561
377
197
11,942 11,891
10,337 8,675
29
19
25
40
22
60
5,298 4,647
20
40
688

377

197

1923
1924
1924
1923
2,928
2,319
116,880 105,623
75,417
87,551
15,077 14,406
2,806
258
3,503
11,144
13,207
283
138
6,011
702
8,279
544
2,774
3,892
441
115
283,466 237,644 52,514 54,563
2,992
5,039
3,354
990
11,583
10,216
1,266
635
2,141
2,720
26
1
Purchases for Local Slaughter
79,484
58,407
2,236
1,931
54,268
75,620
12,734 12,502
372
278
18
1,406
200
’ "8
5
2,032
2,462
12
4
63,913
42,668
7,442
5,626
912
651
15
2,180
74
2,720
2,141
26
1

1924
11,526
8,753
67
874
555
151
30,985
242
403
1,280
4,428
8,565
32
30
87
6,561
76
323
1,280

1923
11,165
8,398
93
680
396

Cars
Unloaded
1924
1923
1,636 1,576
1,549 1,413
10
4

102

24,822

4,400

3,844

...’
39

i is
26

112

578
745
4,720
8,345
58
25
84
5,159
34
745

Wholesale Trade
Percentage Increase (or Decrease) in Net Sales During February, 1924,
as Compared with January, 1924, and February, 1923
Dry Goods
Net Sales (selling price) during February, 1924, compared with
January, 1924...................... ....................................................... . . 10.4
Net
Sales (selling price) during February, 1924, compared with

February,
1923........................ .......................................................
0.3


Hardware

Drugs

Groceries

12.2

— 2.2

0.5

1.1

— 2.5

11.8

14

THE

MONTHLY

BUSINESS

REVIEW

Summary of Business and Credit Conditions in the United S t a t e s
By The Federal Reserve Board
Employment at Industrial establishments
in F - k.
ruaiy and the output of basic commodities was sHghtly i»T.
Distribution, both at wholesale and retail
wholesale prices were somewhat higher; and there
further increase in the volume of borrowing ( o r ------- r r rlil
purposes.

p r o d u c t io n

IodexTof 22 Basic Commodities Corrected for Seasonal
Variations (1919 -100). Latest Figure—February, 121.




The Federal Reserve Board’s index of production In
industries, adjusted to allow for length of month and
seasonal variations, increased less than 1 per cent in Februarv
Production of pig iron, steel ingots, and flour incrcased w hn,
mill consumption o f cotton and production of
and In—
ber declined. Factory employment advanced 1 per cent in
February, following successive decreases during the three
ceding months. Increases in working forces were reported bv
most industries and were particularly large at iron and nti 1
plants, automobile factories, and textile finishing
nrn i!/
Fuller employment through reduction of part
work ^ r dicated by an increase of over 5 per coat in average __ rfc1
earnings. Building activity was slightly less than in T—rm T
though contracts awarded were 7 per cent larger than a Z ? 1
ago.
^

TRADE
Railroad shipments in February were in greater daily volum
than in January and car loadings of practically all —rn rtT ?
commodities were larger than a year ago. The daily avera*
volume of wholesale business increased about 5 per c e n t * !
February, but was slightly smaller than a year ago. Sales rrf
meat, dry goods, and hardware were larger than in FebruaiV
1923, while sales of shoes were smaller. Department staT
sales in February averaged about the same daily volume as in
January and about 8 per cent more than a year ago, while mer
chandise stocks at these stores at the end of the month wer"
6 per cent above last year's level. Business of matt orde?
houses and chain stores also showed increased activity in eom
parison with January.

PRICES
Wholesale prices, as measured by the index of the Bureau a»
Labor Statistics, advanced slightly in February. Prices of
fuel, metals and building materials increased, while prices of
farm products, clothing, and chemicals declined. During th
first two weeks in March price declines occurred in wh^**
cotton, silk, hides, and rubber, and price advances in hov
copper, and crude petroleum.
^

BANK CREDIT
The volume of borrowing for commercial purposes at m __
ber banks in leading cities in the early pan of March contfowg

THE

MONTHLY

BUSINESS

REVIEW

IS

the increase which began in the latter part of January, and on
March 12 total loans of the reporting banks were higher than
at any time since the seasonal peak at the turn of the year, and
about $275,000,000 higher than a year ago.
At the Federal Reserve banks during the four-week period
ending March 19 a further decline in the volume of discounts for
member banks and of acceptances was offset by an increase in
the holdings of United States securities, so that total earning
assets were at about the same level as in February. Federal
Reserve note circulation continued to decline, while the total
money in circulation increased.

Weekly Figures for 12 Federal Reserve Banks.
Latest Figures March 19.




Easier money conditions were reflected in a slight decline in
rates for commercial paper to 4V* per cent and also in lower
rates for bankers9 acceptances and reduced yields on treasury
certificates. The March offering of $400,000,000 of one year
treasury certificates bearing interest at 4 per cent as compared
with 4% per cent on a similar issue sold in December, was
oversubscribed.

FOUBTM
FEDERAL RESEBVE
DISTRICT
N 6 Y L V ANI A

K-£
1— — ■— . . J




r*

**---------

n

J
)

r u

BOUNDARY OF D IS T R IC T
BOUNDAMS OF MANCH U W T 0 H H 9
— — BOUNDARIES OF STA TE 5
<§) FEDERAL RESERVE BANK. C I T Y
O
FEDERAL RESERVE BRANCH C IT IE S

—