View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

M O N T H L Y R E V IE W
of Credit and Business Conditions
______________________________S e c o n d

Federal Reserve Agent

M on ey

F e d e r a l

D i s t r i c t _____________________________

R e s e r v e

Federal Reserve Bank, New York

M a r k e t in O c t o b e r

November 1 , 1929

Keserve Bank. In a period of one week from October 23
to 30 the reserve requirements of these banks were in­

The past few weeks have witnessed an abrupt reversal
of credit trends which had continued for about two years.
Stock prices have turned downward. Bond prices have
made some recovery. Loans to brokers and dealers have
decreased sharply and there has been a sudden shift be­
tween lenders. Interest rates have declined rapidly and
foreign exchange rates have strengthened to points where
gold exports have been made.
Of these developments the decline in stock prices has
been the most spectacular and in large measure the con­
trolling event.

The decline has carried representative

creased more than $200,000,000.
These movements illustrate once more the fact, which
has previously been commented upon in this Review, that
loans to brokers and dealers by lenders other than banks
constitute a potential drain upon bank resources, which
is most likely to become an actual drain in periods of
emergency.

The New York City banks were able to

handle the huge burden which was shifted to them with­
out any disturbance to the money market by reason of
an increase of over 150 million in the security holdings
of the Reserve Banks and a like increase in rediscounts.

price averages below the lowest points heretofore reached

After the first week of October the prevailing call

this year, though not to points which are low relative to

loan renewal rate was 6 per cent compared with 8 and 9

the levels of prices of 1928 or any previous year.
Whereas the gradual recession in stock prices which

per cent in September.

had taken place in September had not been accompanied
by any substantial liquidation in loans to brokers and
dealers, partly because of the continued large volume
of new stock issues calling for additional amounts of
credit, the drastic declines of the past two weeks have
released a considerable amount of funds. For the two
weeks from October 16 to October 30 the figures for loans
to brokers and dealers reported by the New York City
banks for their account and the account of their bank
and other customers show a decrease of $1,263,000,000.

Accompanying ease in call loan

rates, time loan rates declined from 9-91/4 per cent at the
beginning of October to 6 per cent at the end of the
month. Open market commercial paper rates showed a
slight decline from 6% per cent to 6-61?4 per cent.
Bill rates dropped from 5 % to 4 % per cent and the
yield rate on Treasury certificates declined over threequarters of a point. On October 31 the rediscount rate
of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York was reduced
from 6 to 5 per cent, effective November 1.
These
changes are summarized in the table on the following
page.
_______________ ________________

BILLIONS OF DOLLARS

The distribution of this decrease between lenders is of
particular interest.

Loans made for account of others
O'fHER AC:counts

than the New York City banks and their out-of-town cor­
respondents decreased $1,432,000,000, and loans made by
the New York banks for their out-of-town correspondents
decreased $805,000,000.

On the other hand loans to

/

brokers and dealers made by New York City banks for
their own account increased $974,000,000, and these
banks also increased their loans directly to customers by

//.

y 'v '-v -

•

j
/

FOF* ACCOUNT OF

_ ro RRESPOf^JDENT—

N -

V"*

\

A

an additional $260,000,000.

\Kf*

From the point of view of the general credit situation

ba n k :

V w

V——------J V
v

^r

i

OWN ACXOUNT

the net result of these movements was to bring about an
increase of $1,374,000,000 in the loans, and a similar in­
crease in the deposits of the New York City banks, wTith
a consequent increase in the amount of reserve balances
they are required to maintain on deposit at the Federal




_ --------- L
. 1I1-------. ---------11
t____I____
t i ____ I--------1-----------------------1
-------- 1
1------1928
1 92 9
Loans to Brokers and Dealers in Securities Placed by New Y ork
City Banks for Own A ccount, for out-of-tow n Corre­
spondent Banks, and for Other Lenders
(as o f weekly reporting dates)

i..i

■

82

MONTHLY REVIEW, NOVEMBER 1, 1929
Money Rates at New York
Oct. 31, 1928 Sept. 30,1929 Oct. 31, 1929

Stock Exchange call loans......................
Stock Exchange 90 day loans.................
Prime commercial paper.........................
Bills— 90 day unindorsed........................
Customers’ rates on commercial loans.
Treasury certificates and notes
Maturing December 15.......................
Maturing March 15..............................
Federal Reserve Bank of New York
rediscount rate.......................................
Federal Reserve Bank of New York
buying rate for 90 day bills...............

* 6 ^ -8
7
5K
4K
f 5 .47

*8-10
9-9 M
6M
5H
t6 .0 7

*6
6
6-6 M

4 .48
4 .6 3

4.62
4.6 3

3 .94
3 .9 7

5

6

6

4H

5H

5

f 6 .07

* Range for preceding week
t Average rate of leading banks at middle of month

The decline in interest rates in the early part of Octo­
ber was a consequence in part of a lessened demand for
funds in the security markets, but more largely a cumu­
lative effect of purchases of bankers acceptances by the
Federal Eeserve Banks for a number of weeks in amounts
larger than the increasing requirement for funds of the
autumn season. Autumn currency requirements were
also somewhat less than usual. Under these circum­
stances the New York City banks had been able largely
to liquidate their indebtedness at the Eeserve Bank, a
condition which is normally accompanied by easy money
conditions.
The liquidation of the stock market in the last two
weeks of the month and the accompanying movement of
brokers loans was not a factor making directly for easier
money, for, as has been indicated above, the net result
of the changes in brokers loans was to increase rather
than to diminish the call upon bank funds, and the banks
were able to meet the huge additional demand for credit
only by reason of large security purchases by the Fed­
eral Eeserve Banks and an increase in their rediscounts.
So that at the end of the month the borrowings of the
New York City banks were $170,000,000 compared with
$63,000,000 in the early part of the month, and the dis­
counts of the Federal Eeserve System were $990,000,000
compared with $930,000,000 earlier in the month.
Two accompaniments of the easing tendency in inter­
est rates have been the recovery in bond prices which
has raised representative averages about one point,
and a vigorous recovery in foreign exchange rates. The
recovery in exchange rates has been comparable with
that which occurred in the late summer of 1927. On both
occasions the principal European exchanges rose rapidly
from quotations which were close to the points at which
gold tended to move into the United States to quotations
close to, if not actually above, the gold export points. In
fact, in the case of the French exchange the quotations
have recently been such as to show a slight profit in gold
exports and a small amount of gold has moved from
New York to Paris. Both in 1927 and during the past
month this vigorous recovery in the exchanges has ap­
peared to reflect a movement of funds from New York
to the principal European centers, largely in response
to a differential in money rates between New York and
those centers, though in the recent instance it has also
accompanied a liquidation in the stock market.
B

il l

M

arket

During the first part of October, seasonal drawings of
bills increased the supply in dealers’ hands very sub­




stantially, and although the investment demand also rose
materially, dealers’ aggregate purchases exceeded their
sales. As open market portfolios of bills already were
large, the excess of supply over the demand was offered
to the Eeserve System. The development of easier money
conditions, however, allowed the dealers to carry an in­
creasing proportion of their portfolios outside the Ee­
serve Bank.
The continuance of relatively easy money conditions
throughout the balance of the month was accompanied
by a large increase in the investment demand, both local
and foreign, and as dealers’ purchases of new bills were
materially reduced, supplies of bills on hand declined to
a total between one-third and one-half the volume at the
opening of the month. In an effort to replenish their
portfolios, the dealers made four successive reductions
in their rates, a total decrease of % per cent between
October 22 and 29, bringing the offering level for 30 to
90 day unindorsed bills to 4 % per cent, the lowest level
since January 3 of this year. Offering rates for four
months bills also showed a decline of % per cent to 4 %
per cent, and 5 and 6 months bills a reduction of % per
cent to 4 % per cent.
A further increase of $72,000,000 in the volume of
bankers acceptances outstanding occurred during Sep­
tember. The total of $1,272,000,000 on September 30 was
within $12,000,000 of the peak of outstanding dollar ac­
ceptance credits, reached at the end of December 1928,
and was $268,000,000 larger than the total for September
of last year and $408,000,000 above the outstandings of
September 1927. Acceptances based on goods stored in or
shipped between foreign countries again showed a larger
increase than any other class, and it is this type of ac­
ceptance financing that accounts for the larger part of
the increase in total outstandings over a year ago.
C

o m m e r c ia l

P

aper

M

arket

Accompanying the lower rates prevailing on stock ex­
change security loans, some revival of the bank invest­
ment demand for open market commercial paper oc­
curred after the first week of October. Better buying
was reported as coming from banks in the Middle West,
Southwest, and in New England; and in the New York
market there were larger orders reported for the account
of out-of-town correspondents than in some months. The
rate for prime names declined slightly during the latter
part of the month to a range of 6-61/4 per cent, as against
the 6 % per cent rate prevailing when bank investment
demand was least active. Even at the slightly lower
rate level, the amount of new paper being created by
commercial and industrial concerns remained of rather
small proportions, and dealers indicated that they were
more desirous of acquiring additional paper than they
had been in some time.
During September, the amount of commercial paper
outstanding through 23 firms declined 1 per cent to
$265,000,000 on the 30th. This amount is 38 per cent
less than the outstandings at the end of September of
last year.

FEDERAL RESERVE AGENT AT NEW YORK

83

1

S to c k

M ark et

A fter a series of rather wide fluctuations during the
first three weeks of the month, in the course of which
the tendency of stock prices was toward lower levels,
one of the most drastic declines in the history of the
security markets in this country occurred from the 23rd
to the 29th of October. During this period, trading
gained in momentum, except for a temporary pause on
the 25th and 26th, and exceeded all previous records for
volume, totaling from 9,100,000 to over 16,400,000 shares
on the three days of heaviest liquidation. The decline
carried stock prices at the close on the 29th to levels
averaging about 36 per cent below the highest prices
reached early in September, and canceled the rise in
prices since August 1928. In the last two days of the
month, there was a substantial recovery, which averaged
more than one-third of the recent decline.
The accompanying diagram indicates the extent of the
October decline in comparison with the long rise of the
preceding six years and with the swings in stock prices
at other periods during the past thirty years. The last
figure shown is the average at the close of business Octo­
ber 29. This indicates that the almost uninterrupted
rise in stock prices from the autumn of 1923 to Septem­
ber 1929 was the largest in at least 30 years. A s the
diagram also indicates, the volume of trading has shown
a similar increase. The October break was the most
severe on record for so brief a period, measured by the
average price declines, and one of the most severe in
the percentage decrease in prices. But even at the low­
est levels reached on October 29, prices averaged more
than twice as high as the average levels of 1923 and
1924.




The extent of the decline varied greatly between the
different groups of stocks, and even more between indi­
vidual issues. Public utility stocks in general showed
large price reductions but at their lowest points re­
mained far above the levels that prevailed during most
of 1928. Industrials in a number of cases reached the
lowest levels since 1927, although some issues re­
mained above the highest levels reached prior to 1928.
Railroad stocks, which in general have shown the small­
est advances in recent years, likewise had the smallest
declines in October and remained higher than at any
previous time except from May to September of this
year.
B ond

M ark et

The bond market in October showed the first material
advance in a considerable number of months. The aver­
age price of the eight United States Government bond
issues now outstanding rose 2y$ points up to October 28,
and reached a level 3 points above the March low of the
year, and less than % point below the high for the
year reached the first of January. Domestic corpora­
tion bonds toward the close of the month showed an
average net advance of around 1 % points to a level
about the same as that of last M a y ; advances were gen­
eral except in convertible bonds. Foreign bonds ad­
vanced somewhat, and near the end of October were
quoted at approximately the same levels as in last
August.
During the last few days of the month, however, there
was a reaction in bond prices accompanying the unset­
tlement in stocks; U. S. Government issues lost about
one-quarter of the gain registered earlier in the month,

84

MONTHLY REVIEW, NOVEMBER 1, 1929

domestic corporation bonds lost nearly three-quarters of
the previous advance, and foreign issues had material
declines.
The daily average turnover of bonds on the Stock E x ­
change increased from $9,500,000 during the last week
of September to $16,900,000 in the week ended October
26, the largest volume of trading in many months, and
during the last few days of the month averaged about
$25,000,000. Although some part of this unusual trad­
ing may be attributed to transactions in convertible
bonds, in keeping with the activity of stocks, the increas­
ing weekly totals as the month progressed gave evidence
of a more active demand for bonds than in some time.
N ew

F in a n c in g

Total new security offerings of domestic corporations
in September, amounting to $1,200,000,000, were 60 per
cent larger than in August and were almost four times
as large as in September 1928. The huge increase over
a year ago reflected chiefly the continued large volume
of investment trust and financial trading and holding
company securities floated during the month, and all of
the increase was in stock issues; corporate bond issues,
in fact, were slightly smaller than a year ago. Domestic
municipal and State financing was in somewhat larger
amount than in either the previous month or a year ago,
while foreign new security flotations in this market fell
short of either the August total or that of September of
last year.
During October, the principal feature of the new
financing appears to have been an increase in the volume
of bond issues, together with some decline in the amount
of financing through stock offerings. Important bond
flotations during the month included $100,000,000 of
Texas Corporation bonds yielding 5 % per cent, $50,000,000 of short term New York City notes yielding 5 % per
cent, $32,000,000 of Southern Bell Telephone and Tele­
graph bonds priced to yield 5 per cent, $30,000,000 of
Port of New York Authority bonds on a 4.86-5.15 per
cent yield basis, and two railroad equipment trust issues
yielding from 5 % to 6 per cent. Foreign bond offerings
also increased, with the placing in this market of the
major part of a $30,000,000 Canadian National Railway
Co. issue at a price to yield slightly over 5 per cent.
A fter the first week of the month, there was a marked
curtailment in the amount of stock issues of investment
trusts and financial trading and holding companies, fol­
lowing the unprecedented total of the preceding months.
In addition, a large public utility holding company,
which earlier in the month had offered additional shares
to stockholders for the purpose of raising over $100,000,000 of new capital, withdrew the offer, in view of
the heavy declines in stock prices. Other new financing,
including the sale of $60,000,000 of New York City cor­
porate stock and bonds, was also reported to have been
deferred at this time.
G o ld

M ovem en t

Arrivals of $6,575,000 from Argentina, $2,500,000
from Colombia, and $1,000,000 from England accounted
for practically all of the gold imported at New York dur­
ing October. Exports amounted to $3,700,000, of which




$3,000,000 was for shipment to France. There was an
increase of $4,500,000 in gold earmarked for foreign
account, which, together with exports, reduced the esti­
mated net gain for the month to $2,000,000, the smallest
gain since February.
The gold import movement from Argentina began in
October 1928, and since that time, with the exception of
December 1928 and February 1929, monthly shipments
have been received here, which now total about $70,000,000. This represents the reversal of a movement of gold
from New York to Buenos Aires which began in Sep­
tember 1927 and ended in June 1928, in the course of
which $130,000,000 was shipped. It may be added that
since April 1929 approximately $10,000,000 has been
received in London from Argentina, and Buenos Aires
has lost gold also to Paris, Berlin, and Rio de Janeiro in
the past year.
Of principal interest abroad was the resumption of
French gold withdrawals from London towards the end
of October. Since the London bank rate was raised on
September 26, France has taken roughly $30,000,000 in
London, of which approximately $12,000,000 was be­
tween October 22 and 30.
C e n tra l B a n k R a te

Changes

Effective October 31, the Bank of England reduced its
rate by one-half per cent to 6 per cent. The last change
in bank rate was an increase of one per cent on Septem­
ber 26. The published statements of the bank do not
indicate any important change in its situation during the
past month, but the easier rates obtaining in the New
York money market, and the reflux of British funds to
London have presumably contributed to a more favorable
position in London.
The only Continental bank rate change reported dur­
ing October was an increase of one-half per cent from
i y 2 to 8 per cent in the rate of the Bank of Estonia on
the 3rd. The lower rate had been in force since January
2, 1928. The Bank of Republic of Colombia raised its
rate from 7 to 8 per cent effective October 10, following
a change from 8 to 7 per cent on August 1. The Reserve
Bank of Peru, which had lowered its rate from 7 to 6
per cent on September 3d last, returned to the 7 per cent
rate, effective October 31. The Imperial Bank of India
rate was increased on October 10, from 5 to 6 per cent.
This is in accordance with the seasonal practice of this
bank, whose rate is ordinarily raised progressively be­
tween autumn and spring and lowered during the sum­
mer months of each year.
F o r e ig n E x c h a n g e

The vigorous upturn of the principal European ex­
changes during the past month, following a period of
general weakness, is shown in the accompanying chart.
The pound sterling began a few days before the in­
crease in bank rate, on September 26, a gradual advance
which has continued during October. On the first day of
October the pound crossed $4.86 for the first time since
August 1928, reached parity ($4.8665) on the 14th, and
on the 24th at $4.88 1 /3 2 was the highest since June
1928. A fter a slight recession, sterling stood at approxi-

FEDERAL RESERVE AGENT AT NEW

YORK

85

DOLLARS

.0396 r
___ GOL p EX POF\T POINT r
.2390

g o l d e ;(PORT

.0394

P DINT

PAR
.2 38 0
...............

J
.4060

Z

GERM;

T g o l d IMPORT p o in t "’

- -<

2370

,2360

PAR.-...

.0392

.0390

.0388

F M A M J

J

A S O

.1400

FRAN*
:e
i .
J F M A M

J J

A

- SO

.9740
-f“—
'“‘ g o l d EX PORI " p o in t

.4040

,1395

.9680
PAR

.4020

.1390

.4000

.1385

.9620
-----------

----

J

ARGEi

J A S O

Course of Foreign Exchanges at New York

mately $4.87% when the month ended, still below the
theoretical gold export point.
W ith minor exceptions other European currencies fol­
lowed much the same course as sterling. French francs
started the month above their parity of $0.0392, and,
advancing steadily to a high of $0.03941/4, have been the
only currency to cross the gold export point in October.
Reichsmarks were somewhat more irregular, though
strong, during the first half of the month, but, after
closing at $0.2385% on the 14th, rose almost without in­
terruption to $0.2393% on the 30th. Belgas registered
steady gains which carried the quotation from $0.1393%
at the beginning of October to $0.1399:V^ near its close,
and Dutch guilders and Swiss francs moved similarly.
The former sold for $0.4016 on October 1 and $0.403514
on the 30th; the latter rose from $0.1931 to $0.1938%
during the same period.
Lire fluctuated between
$0.0523% and $0.0523% from the 2nd to the 21st of
October, then abruptly crossed $0.0524 on the 23rd, and
closed the month at about that price.
Among the Scandinavian currencies, Danish and Nor­
wegian crowns moved upward from about $0.2670 at the
month’s opening to their parity of $0.2680 toward the
end, while Swedish crowns, which were strong at $0.2684
on October 1 dipped to $0.2681% on the 9th, recovered
rather sharply to $0.2688% on the 24th, and sagged
slightly thereafter. The Spanish peseta declined on the
14th to $0.1452 from a high of $0.1486% on the 11th;
subsequent declines carried it to $0.1421 on October 18,
after which it fluctuated irregularly.
The Japanese yen during most of the month fluctuated
between $0.4762 and $0.4795 but crossed $0.4800 on the
28th. Canadian dollars weakened further to a discount
of $0 .0 2 % on the 29th. Argentine pesos, reflecting local
conditions and a decrease in gold shipments, declined to
$0.9259% on the 30th, considerably below the gold im­
port point for New York.




<

£

F M A M

Z.

.95001

,1380

J

GOLD llv PORT P<)INT
....... -

.9560

.94261

F o r e ig n T r a d e

Exports of merchandise, valued at $442,000,000 during
September, showed about the usual seasonal increase over
the previous month, and were 5 per cent above a year
ago. Imports, valued at $353,000,000, showed a consider­
able decrease from the relatively high figure in August,
but were 10 per cent above a year ago, and continued to
be larger than in the corresponding month of any year
since 1920.
Combined shipments abroad of crude products, prin­
cipally raw cotton and grains, although seasonally larger
than in the previous month, were $20,000,000 smaller in
value than in September 1928. The quantity of such
shipments also decreased substantially. On the other
hand, exports of wholly finished and partly finished
manufactures increased $26,000,000 and $7,000,000, re­
spectively, compared with a year ago.
Gains in imports over a year ago were quite general
among the principal groups, with the largest percentage
of increase in finished manufactures. Receipts of raw
silk, crude rubber, and coffee were all smaller in volume
than in August, but receipts of silk and coffee were
larger than a year ago.
E m p lo y m e n t a n d W a g e s

The number of workers employed in representative
New York State factories showed an increase of 1.8
per cent in September, as compared with the usual sea­
sonal increase of 2 per cent. Consequently this bank’s
adjusted index for the month was 102.5 per cent of the
1925-1927 average, but remained only % of one per cent
under the peak of July, which was the highest since early
in 1924. For the country as a whole, the increase in fac­
tory employment amounted to 0.7 of a per cent, or about
half the usual September increase. The State Depart­
ment of Labor report indicates that the September in­
crease was due in part to increased seasonal activity in

86

MONTHLY REVIEW, NOVEMBER 1, 1929

the clothing industries, but that most of the other large
industry groups participated in the gain, with the excep­
tion of the metal industries, which had contributed
largely to the increase in employment during the past
year.
Average weekly earnings of factory workers in New
York State advanced to a new high record not only for
the month of September but for all months, exceeding
slightly the previous peak of last March. Total payrolls
at the same time were the largest for any month in more
than five years, and were the largest for September of
any year with the single exception of 1920.
B u ild in g

Building contracts awarded in the 37 States east of
the Rockies, as reported by the F . W . Dodge Corpora­
tion, declined 9 per cent further in September, following
a 25 per cent drop in August. The total for September
was 24 per cent smaller than a year ago, and was also
below the total for the corresponding month of any other
year since 1924. Non-residential construction, consisting
of commercial and industrial buildings and public works
and utilities, has been maintained in amounts that com­
pare favorably with last year despite some decline in
September, but residential building has been below the
level of the previous year in each of the past 13 months.
Up to the 25th of October, the daily average of con­
tracts awarded showed a decline from last year’s level
slightly larger than that of September.
In the New York and Northern New Jersey district,
contracts in September were reduced 14 per cent below
the previous month and were 48 per cent smaller than
a year ago. Residential contracts were only one-third as
large as those reported for September 1928, public works
and utility projects were 44 per cent smaller, and com­
mercial and educational building contracts were some­
what smaller. Industrial construction was the only prin­
cipal class to show an increase.
A survey of the mortgage money situation indicates
that the current supply of funds available for mortgages
is much smaller than a year ago, due chiefly to a check
in the growth of deposits in savings banks and difficulty
in distributing mortgage bonds in recent months.
P r o d u c tio n

Productive activity declined somewhat further in Sep­
tember, continuing the gradual recession from the very
high levels of late spring, but remained higher than a
year previous. Combined output of passenger auto­
mobiles and motor trucks in September was substantially
under the high levels of last spring, and was practically
the same as in September 1928. Motor vehicle production
was at unprecedentedly high levels from January to
August, and the total output for the first nine months of
this year was larger than for any previous full year. A c ­
cording to trade reports, it appears that output of the
industry declined further in October.
Among the other industries, there was also some tend­
ency to decline. Average daily production of pig iron
was reduced 4.6 per cent, whereas usually there is little
change or perhaps a small increase. The total tonnage
of zinc smelted also declined, while production of steel
ingots showed little change after seasonal allowance, and
there were increases in copper and lead output and in
tin deliveries. In October, there is usually a rather sub­




stantial increase in iron and steel output, but this Oc­
tober, steel mill operations showed wide variations and
it appears likely that operations were, if anything, a
little lower than in September.
Mining of bituminous coal increased by a larger
amount than the usual seasonal upswing in September,
and anthracite output increased close to the highest
daily average of the year; further increases have been
reported in October. Average daily output of crude
petroleum declined slightly in September, and showed
a further decline near the end of October.
Among the textile industries, mill consumption of
raw cotton showed about the usual seasonal increase,
while activity in both the wool and the silk industries
was lower than in August. There were declines also,
after seasonal allowance, in output of coke, leather,
cement, wheat flour, boots and shoes, and newsprint
paper, and in sugar meltings, while output of tobacco
products was virtually unchanged, and slaughterings of
live stock increased.
The following table shows a majority of declines
among the indexes of production in the various lines,
compared with August, but a majority of increases,
compared with September 1928.
(Adjusted for seasonal variations and usual year-to-year growth)
1928

1929

Sept.

July

Aug.

Sept.

108
125
93
89
111
110
83
101
115
107
98
106
111
127r
99
99

131
137
103
99
115
118
83
123
116
104
102
109
104
120r
106
109

129
134
99
101
109
120
83r
121
112
96r
104
110
109
124r
107
111

121
134
99
96p
102
117p
88
116
114
107
101
121
102
118r

96r
85
97r
106
90
83
105
103
134
120
124

98r
96
85r
102
68
86
105
122r
120
123
154

99r
99
102r
104
79
91
106
123
93
122
llOr

108r
90
71r
103
102
86
107
112p
93 p
112
100

Producers' Goods
Cotton consumption....................................
Woolen mill activity....................................
Silk consumption..........................................
Bituminous coal.............................................
Coke.................................................................
Copper, U. S. mines.....................................
Tin deliveries.................................................
Leather, sole...................................................
Paper, total....................................................
Consumers' Goods
Live stock slaughtered r..............................
Sugar meltings, U. S. ports r .....................
Anthracite coal..............................................
Paper, newsprint...........................................
Tobacco products.........................................
Boots and shoes.............................................
Automobile, passenger.................................
Automobile, truck........................................
p Preliminary r Revised

In d e x e s o f B u s in e s s A c t iv it y

Indexes of various types of business activity com­
puted by this bank show in general no change of direc­
tion in September from the generally high level which
has characterized recent months.
Average daily carloadings both of merchandise and
miscellaneous and of bulk freight increased in about the
usual seasonal proportions in September. Foreign trade
showed some decline, but remained at fairly high levels,
as did also the domestic distribution of goods to con­
sumers. Bank debits in 140 centers outside of New York
City, reduced to a daily basis, were in about the same
volume as in August, and continued well above a year
ago.
This bank’s indexes of business activity are shown
on the next page.

FEDERAL RESERVE AGENT AT NEW Y ORK
(Adjusted for seasonal variations and usual year-to-year growth)

D e p a r tm e n t S to re T r a d e

1929

1928
Sept.

July

Aug.

Sept.

Primary Distribution
Car loadings, merchandise and misc. r . ..
Car loadings, other.......................................
Exports............................................................
Imports...........................................................
Panama Canal traffic...................................
Wholesale trade.............................................

lOOr
97
94
102
85
95

lOOr
99
114
123
88
104

lOlr
97
100
122
92
107

lOOr
96
98p
117p
103

Distribution to Consumer
Department store sales, 2nd Dist.............
Chain grocery sales......................................
Other chain store sales................................
Mail order sales.............................................
Life insurance paid for................................
Advertising.....................................................

106
101
109
119
101
96

99
94
100
136
99
96

99
96
103
139
101
99

104
92
103
134
111
103

111
165

112
181

117
195

116
203

120
190
398
84
107
98
104
142
100
84r

131
208
429
88
111
104
102
130
119
79r

135r
228
404
87
110
104
109
96
113
78r

135
242
426
81

178
224
173

181
226
172

182
227
174

General Business Activity
Bank debits, outside of N. Y . City..........
Bank debits, New York City.....................
Velocity of bank deposits, outside N. Y.
C ity..............................................................
Velocity of bank deposits, New York City
Shares sold on N. Y . Stock Exchange. . .
Postal receipts...............................................
Electric power...............................................
Employment in the United States...........
Business failures............................................
Building contracts, 36 States.....................
New corporations formed in N. Y . State
Real estate transfers r.................................
General price level........................................
Composite index of wages..........................
Cost of living.................................................

87

103
99
99
107

The total September sales of leading department stores
in this district were over 5 per cent larger than a year
previous, but after allowance for the fact that there
was one more selling day than in September 1928 in the
Metropolitan district and a half day more in other cities,
it appears that average daily sales were about 2 per
cent larger than last year. Sales of New York City and
Newark stores showed substantial increases over Sep­
tember 1928, but department store business in other
localities was very irregular. The large apparel stores
reported about the same average increase as the depart­
ment stores.
Stocks of merchandise on hand in department stores
continued somewhat larger than last year, but the aver­
age rate of stock turnover showed little change. The
percentage of collections during September of charge
accounts outstanding at the end of August was notice­
ably larger this year than in 1928.

Locality
p Preliminary

Per cent of
accounts
outstanding
August 31
collected in
September

Percentage
change
September 1929
compared with
September 1928

183
230
173

r Revised

W h o le s a le T r a d e

The September sales of wholesale firms in this district
showed a 4 per cent increase over a year ago, the smallest
increase since March. The grocery, drug, stationery,
and paper firms continued to report increases in sales
over last year, and dealers in shoes and diamonds also
reported increases, following decreases in August. Sales
of wholesale jewelry houses showed the largest increase
in many months. The Silk Association also reported a
substantial increase in quantity sales of silk goods over
those of a year ago. According to figures reported by
the National Machine Tool Builders’ Association there
was a 9 per cent decrease in machine tool orders as com­
pared with the very large volume of September 1928,
the first decrease in nearly two years. There were de­
creases also in sales of hardware and cotton goods.

Commodity

Percentage
change
September 1929
compared with
August 1929

Net
sales
Groceries........................
Men’s clothing..............
Cotton goods.................
Silk goods......................
Shoes...............................
Drugs..............................
Hardware.......................
Machine tools**...........
Stationery......................
Paper...............................
Diamonds.......................
Jewelry............................
Weighted Average.. .

Stock
end of
month

Percentage
change
September 1929
compared with
September 1928

Net
sales

Stock
end of
month

+ 3 .7
+ 1 2 .4
— 10.8
+ 1 4 .3
— 0 .2
— 6 .4 * + 1.2*
— 5 .9
— 11.1
+ 1 2 .1
+ 5 .0
+ 4 .1
+ 0 .8
— 19.2
+ 1-7
+ 6 .6
+ 2 4 .9
+ 4 8 .0 } + 0 .7

+ 5 .3
+ 8 .6
+ 1.8
— 7 .9
— io .9
+ 1 3 .2 * + 5 .0 *
+ 5 .4
— 17 5
+ 2 .7
+ 2 2 .9
— 3 .9
— 5 .6
— 9 .2
+ 1 7 .4
+ 1 2 .2
+ 1 2 .4
+ 1 4 .8 J— 8 .6 1

+ 0 .7

+ 3 .9

New York...........................................................
Buffalo............................................ .....................
Rochester............................................................
Syracuse..............................................................
Bridgeport...........................................................
Elsewhere............................................................
Northern New York State.........................
Southern New York State..........................
Hudson River Valley District...................
Capital District.............................................
Westchester District....................................

1929

68 2
35.0

71 4
37.0

43’.9
31.2
42 0
43.3

44'.4
33.0
39 .4
43.2

64’.9
59.8
22.2

64’.9
66.4
1 26.8

47.4

49.3

+
—
+
+
+
+
—

1928

1929

3 .4
2 .0
4 .6
6 .5
1.6
4 .1
2 .7

47.4
53.6
38.1
31.9
40.0

49.6
51.7
36.4
31.2
42.3

3 i ‘.6

33! 5

+ 5 .3

+ 2 .4

4 3.4

45.1

Apparel stores...........................................

+ 5 .0

+ 4.1

4 1.7

43.1

Sales and stocks in major groups of departments are
compared with those of September 1928 in the following
table.

Net sales
percentage change
Sept. 1929
compared with
Sept. 1928
Toys and sporting goods.......................

1928

+ 7 .4
— 0 .7
— 6 .7
— 11.0
+ 6 .8
— 3.1
— 0 .9
— 13.7
— 1.8
— 3 .5
— 1.6
+ 7.1
0

Stock
on hand
end of
month

All department stores..............................

Per cent of
accounts
outstanding
August 31
collected
in September

* Quantity not value. Reported by Silk Association of America
** Reported by the National Machine Tool Builders’ Association




Net
sales

Toilet articles and drugs.......................
Linens and handkerchiefs.....................
Books and stationery.............................
Men’s furnishings...................................
Home furnishings....................................
Cotton goods...........................................
Women’s ready-to-wear accessories.. .
Luggage and other leather goods........
Silverware and jewelry..........................
Musical instruments and radio...........
Women’s and Misses’ ready-to-wear. .
Men’s and Boys’ wear...........................
Silks and velvets.....................................
Woolen goods..........................................
Miscellaneous..........................................

+ 2 4 .2
+ 1 7 .8
+ 1 4 .7
+ 1 4 .4
+ 13.4
+ 1 1 .3
+ 1 0 .8
+ 8 .6
+ 7 .0
+ 6.4
+ 5 .6
+ 4 .9
+ 3 .4
+ 2 .8
+ 2 .7
— 1.0
— 11.9
— 17.2
— 1.1

Stock on hand
percentage change
Sept. 30, 1929
compared with
Sept. 30, 1928
+ 6 .4
+ 1 3 .2
— 2 .4
+ 7 .2
+ 1 3 .6
+ 4 .2
— 5.1
+ 1.1
+ 2 .3
— 14.2
+ 8 .5
+ 8 .7
+ 2 .2
— 9 .9
— 0 .2
+ 6 .4
— 14.2
— 6 .3
— 4 .4

88

MONTHLY REVIEW, NOVEMBER 1, 1929
Business Conditions in the United States
( S u m m a r iz e d b y th e F e d e r a l R e s e rv e B o a r d )

NDUSTRIAL activity increased less in September than is usual at this
season. Production during the month continued above the level of a year
ago, and for the third quarter of the year it was at a rate approximately 10
per cent above 1928. There was a further decline in building contracts
awarded. Bank loans increased between the middle of September and the
middle of October, reflecting chiefly growth in loans on securities.

I

P

Index Numbers of Production of Manufactures
and Minerals, Adjusted for Seasonal Vari­
ations (1923-25 average = 100
per cent)

1927

1928

1929

Monthly Averages o f W eekly Figures for Re­
porting Member Banks in Leading Cities
(Latest figures are averages o f first
three weeks o f October)

r o d u c t io n

Output of iron and steel declined further in September, contrary to the
seasonal tendency; there was a sharp decrease in output of automobiles and
automobile tires, and a smaller-than-seasonal increase in activity in the textile
and shoe industries, which continued to produce at a high rate in comparison
with the preceding year. Meat packing plants were more active than in August.
Factories increased the number of their employees during September and pay­
rolls were also slightly larger.
Output of coal showed a substantial increase from August and the average
daily production of copper mines was somewhat larger. Iron ore shipments
declined seasonally, and petroleum output was reduced for the first time in
several months.
For the first half of October reports indicate a further reduction in steel
plant operations, a continued increase in production of bituminous coal, and
some increase in petroleum output following a moderate decrease during
September.
Building contracts awarded in September declined seasonally from August
and were substantially below the corresponding month in any year since 1924.
For the third quarter the volume of contracts was 6 per cent less than a year
ago. During the first three weeks of October, contracts continued substantially
below the level of last year.
October estimates by the Department of Agriculture indicate a cotton crop
of 14,915,000 bales, 3 per cent larger than last year; a corn crop of 2,528,000,000
bushels, 11 per cent smaller than the crop of a year ago, and 8 per cent below
the five-year average; and a total wheat crop of 792,000,000 bushels, 12 per
cent below last year but only slightly under the five-year average.
D

is t r ib u t io n

Freight-car loadings increased by slightly less than the usual seasonal
amount in September, and continued to be larger than a year ago. In the
first two weeks of October car loadings were smaller than in the corresponding
weeks of 1928.
Department store sales in leading cities increased seasonally during the
month of September and were 2 per cent larger than a year ago. For the third
quarter as a whole sales of the reporting stores exceeded those of the third
quarter of last year by 3 per cent.
P

Reserve Bank Credit (M onthly averages of
daily figures for 12 Federal Reserve Banks;
latest figures are averages of first 19
days in O ctober)
PERCENT

PER CENT
7

7

7

j V rj
l

. ■“ »
. . .

- t

-

M

-

T - - -

U

Comme/c/a/ Paper Pa/<?
Reserve Bank Discount'■Pate
Acceptcrnce Pete i

_______
1925

1
1926

1Q77

1Q O A

Money Rates in the New Y ork Market (O c­
tober rates are averages for first 23 days)




r ic e s

Wholesale prices showed little change from August to September, according
to the index of the Bureau of Labor Statistics. Prices of meats and live
stock declined considerably, while prices of grains advanced. The prices of
raw silk, cotton, and cotton goods were higher in September, and the price of
coal increased, while prices of iron and steel products, tin, gasoline, and cement
were lower. During the first three weeks of October prices declined for a
considerable number of commodities, including wheat, flour, hides, steel, tin,
cotton, silk, and wool.
B

a n k

Cr

e d it

Between the middle of September and the middle of October, there was a
slight increase in the volume of loans and investments of member banks in
leading cities. The banks ’ loans on securities increased rapidly, while all other
loans, including loans for commercial and agricultural purposes, declined some­
what after reaching a seasonal peak on October 2. Security holdings of the
reporting banks continued the decline which has been almost uninterrupted for
more than a year.
At the Reserve Banks there was little change in the volume of credit out­
standing during the four-week period ended October 19. Further increase in
the holdings of acceptances by the Federal Reserve Banks was accompanied
by a decline in discounts for member banks, largely at the Federal Reserve
Bank of New York.
Open market rates on bankers acceptances and on prime commercial paper
were unchanged during the last half of September and the first three weeks
of October. On October 23 rates on bankers acceptances declined by one-eighth
per cent to a 5 per cent level for the principal maturities. Rates on demand
and time loans on securities declined during the first half of October.