View original document

The full text on this page is automatically extracted from the file linked above and may contain errors and inconsistencies.

M O N TH L Y REVIEW
O f Credit and Business Conditions
F E D E R A L

R E S E R V E

V ol. 26

B A N K

JULY

M O N E Y

1,

N E W

Y O R K

1944

M A R K E T

The Fifth War Loan was the dominant influence in the

O F

IN

No. 7

JU N E

and the Federal Reserve System that subscriptions be placed

As usual, there were large with­

where funds are deposited, and that the subscribers apply, if

drawals of funds from New York after the beginning of the

they so desire, for the allocation of parts of their subscription

money market during June.

drive on June 12, and the New York City banks found it

to other communities instead of transferring funds.

necessary, for a time, to draw rather heavily upon the Federal
Reserve Bank for funds with which to maintain their reserves

tions to other districts of subscriptions received in this District
have been much more numerous than in any previous War

at the required levels.

Loan; nevertheless, withdrawals of funds from New York dur­

Selling of outstanding Government

Alloca­

securities appeared to be smaller before the opening of the

ing the two weeks ended June 28 appear to have been fully as

drive and during its early stages than in the corresponding

large as in the corresponding weeks of either the Third or the

period of any of the four preceding War Loans. The compari­

Fourth War Loan drive. The total outflow of funds from New

son was reversed, however, by large increases in bank holdings

York City for business accounts amounted to nearly 900 million

of Government securities and in loans to security dealers on

dollars in the two weeks.

June 26 which suggested that sales were arranged in unusually

related to quarterly income tax payments, especially by cor­

Part of this outflow may have been

heavy volume for clearance on the issue date for the marketable
War Loan securities. The market for outstanding Government

porations, and part reflected payments for securities sold in the

securities in general was firm during the whole period, although
temporary unbalance between supply and demand developed

a substantial part, however, appears to have represented with­
drawals of funds from New York to pay for subscriptions

occasionally in particular types of securities.

placed elsewhere.

New York market by institutions in other parts of the country;

The invasion of France had little effect on the Government

In addition to meeting this drain on their reserves, the New

security market, but gave some impetus to the sale of new

York City banks were called upon to purchase large amounts

securities during the initial phase of the War Loan drive, and

of Government securities offered for sale by other investing

had an inhibiting effect on redemptions of War Savings bonds.
Purchases of War Savings bonds by small subscribers especially

institutions to increase the funds at their disposal for the pur­
chase of securities offered in the Fifth War Loan. In the four

were unusually numerous.

(Large subscribers in many cases

weeks ended June 28, New York City banks purchased a total

had subscribed during the Fourth War Loan to all the War
Savings bonds they are permitted to buy this year, and conse­

other than Treasury bills, and in addition made loans totaling

of more than 900 million dollars of Government securities

quently were limited to purchases of other securities in the

500 million dollars to Government security dealers, chiefly to

Fifth Loan.) Redemptions of Series E bonds in this District
were less in June than in May, contrary to the usual tendency

enable the dealers to take up some of the securities sold by

of redemptions to increase in quarterly income tax periods.

other institutions.
Although business transfers of funds to other parts of the

One of the less satisfactory aspects of the situation during

country were partly offset by an increase in the New York

the opening weeks of the War Loan drive was a repetition

balances of out-of-town banks and by net Government disburse­

of the large scale shifting of funds which has been characteris­

ments in New York during the first two weeks of the War

tic of other War Loan drives, despite the urging by the Treasury

Loan drive, the New York City banks sustained a net loss of

“S
*

a c k
D

t&
U




R

e r ft t a
I

N

G

z A

-

B uy M O R E Than B e fc ? e

F I F T H

W A R

L

O A N

D R I V E

*

50

MONTHLY REVIEW, JULY 1, 1944

Principal Factors Affecting Member Bank Reserves in the
Second Federal Reserve District, Exclusive of
Federal Reserve Credit*

T r e a s u r y O p e r a t io n s

i n t h is

D is t r ic t

Treasury operations during June were conducted in such a
manner as to minimize effects on the reserve positions of com­
mercial banks of the large quarterly income tax payments as
well as cash payments for securities sold during the drive.

As

the tax date approached, the Treasury suspended withdrawals
of funds from War Loan deposit accounts and, pending the
receipt of funds in large volume from tax collections, drew
down its balances with the Federal Reserve Banks in meeting
current disbursements.

During the latter half of the month

Government expenditures were more than covered by cash
receipts from tax collections and from sales of securities, so
that no further withdrawals from War Loan deposits were
required.
The proportion of income taxes paid by the surrender of
Treasury Savings notes, rather than cash, is higher in the
Second District than in the rest of the country, and the great
bulk of securities sold during the War Loan drives are paid
for initially with credits to War Loan deposit accounts on the
books of the banks, rather than in cash. Consequently, Govern­
ment disbursements in the Second District ran well in excess
of cash receipts during the latter half of June.

Disbursements

in this period were augmented by large interest payments on
the public debt, and by cash redemptions of the unexchanged
portion of a Treasury note issue that matured on June 15, a
reserves which necessitated substantial sales of Treasury bills
to the Federal Reserve Bank, and intermittent borrowing, to
maintain their reserves at the required levels.

large part of which was held in this District. As the accom­
panying chart shows, member banks in this District, after a
steady and substantial loss of funds through Treasury opera­

The situation of member banks in the country as a whole

tions since the early part of April, had some net gain through

did not indicate a need for additional Federal Reserve credit

such transactions after the first two weeks of June. The funds

in this period, but the heavy shifting of funds caused an uneven
distribution of reserves among individual banks and communi­

gained in this manner helped to meet the loss of funds through
business transfers, referred to previously.

ties. Some banks— chiefly in other districts— accumulated
excess reserves, while other banks, including the New York
City banks, required additional Federal Reserve credit to main­

the Treasury have been considerably less rapid thus far in 1944

On the whole, withdrawals of funds from this District by

As a result, excess reserves of all member

than in the corresponding period of 1943. In the first five
months of this year, the Treasury transferred approximately

banks increased considerably in the first three weeks of June,

1,250 million dollars out of this District to other parts of the

rising from about 700 million dollars on May 31, to nearly

country, compared with 1,900 million in the first five months

tain their reserves.

double that amount on June 21.

In the following week, which

of 1943.

Revenue collections in the District were about 2,600

included the issue date, June 26, for War Loan securities other

million dollars greater than in the first five months of 1943, but

than Savings bonds and Savings notes, excess reserves of all

Government disbursements were nearly 2 billion dollars more,

member banks increased further to 1,500 million dollars despite

and Treasury receipts from public debt operations ( including

the retirement of a moderate amount of Federal Reserve

withdrawals from War Loan deposit accounts as well as cash

credit through the repurchase by member banks of Treasury

receipts from security sales) were almost 1,300 million less.

bills previously sold to the Reserve Banks under repurchase

Income tax collections in the first five months of 1944 were

options and through repayments of loans from the Reserve

nearly double those of a year previous, and miscellaneous re­

Banks.

ceipts, including excise taxes, proceeds of war contract rene­

This further rise was caused by a large reduction in

private deposits on June 26, reflecting payments for War Loan

gotiation, and other items, also increased considerably.

securities, and a corresponding increase in Government War

other hand, Government checks deposited in the banks of the

On the

Loan deposits against which the banks are not required to

District, representing largely war expenditures, increased

maintain reserves.

substantially.

Estimated reserve requirements for all

member banks were reduced by about 800 million dollars dur­

Most of the reduction in receipts from public debt operations

ing the week as a result of this shift of deposits from private

was due to the smaller net increase in Treasury bills outstand­

to Government accounts.

ing in the early months of 1944 as compared with 1943. From




51

FEDERAL RESERVE BANK OF NEW YORK

January through May of 1943 the increase in Treasury bills
outstanding amounted to more than 4,200 million dollars,
whereas in the corresponding months this year the increase

being offset by the virtual elimination of direct offerings of

was less than 700 million dollars. Net sales of bills in this
District in the first five months of the year, consequently, pro­

trends in the major classes of Government receipts and dis­
bursements, there is a tendency toward closer balance between

duced about 1,200 million less cash for the Treasury this year

total receipts and disbursements in the Second Federal Reserve

than last.

District, and a consequent reduction in the net drain of funds

Net sales of other securities in the District showed

no material change, increases in sales to nonbank investors

IN D U S T R IA L

LO ANS

O F T H E

from the District to other parts of the country.

FE D E R A L

Under an amendment to the Federal Reserve Act dated
June 19, 1934, the Federal Reserve Banks were authorized to
make working capital loans, or to enter into commitments to
make such loans.

securities to the banks.
On the whole it appears that, underlying these divergent

R ESER VE

B A N K

O F

N E W

Y O R K

have been a factor in the reduction in demand for Federal
Reserve industrial loans.
In the ten years since the inception of the industrial loan

These loans must be for periods not ex­

program, over 5,000 inquiries for loans have been reviewed

ceeding five years, and may be made either directly to es­

by the Credit Department of this bank. Many of the inquirers

tablished business enterprises, or indirectly through advances

sought types of loans clearly ineligible under the law; in

on, or discount or purchases of, up to 80 per cent of the value

numerous cases applicants for funds were found to be in need

of loans extended by other financial institutions.

In view of

the fact that ten years have now elapsed since the Reserve

of fixed capital rather than working capital.

The financial

position of still others was such as to present no sound basis

Banks received authority to make such loans, and that little of

for the extension of credit.

the business now remains on the books of the Federal Reserve

applications filed was reduced to 1,380, and many of these

As a result, the number of formal

Bank of New York, this is a convenient time to review the

applicants failed to qualify for working capital loans; a few

experience and to draw some conclusions concerning it.

withdrew their applications before final action was taken. The

Furthermore, such a review seems appropriate at this time in

total number of loans approved was 538, but in 162 cases the

view of current public interest in the availability of credit,

applications were withdrawn after approval.

especially to small businesses, in the postwar period.

drawn upon numbered 376, involving 285 individual bor­

Applications at this bank for working capital loans have
largely disappeared during the war period.

There have been

Credits actually

rowers and a total amount of close to $32,000,000.

A small

portion of these credits was not used, however.

many instances in which war contractors have needed credit in

The total liability of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York

amounts substantially greater than they could reasonably expect

for loans actually made over the whole period amounted to

to obtain from their usual banking connections on the basis

$22,000,000, of which $6,000,000 consisted of direct advances

of their current position, but these needs have been largely met

to business enterprise and $16,000,000 consisted of commit­

by advance payments by Federal procurement agencies or by

ments to participate with other financing institutions. Inasmuch

loans made by commercial banks, with guarantees obtained
through this bank from the War Department, the Navy De­

as this bank was called upon to take up only $6,000,000 of
these commitments, the total of Federal Reserve funds actually

partment, or the Maritime Commission under the provisions

advanced was $12,000,000.

of Regulation V of the Board of Governors of the Federal

participating commercial banks and other financial institutions

Reserve System.

had limited their liability to $9,000,000, they actually retained

Aside from the effects of the war on business activity and
on business financing, however, there has been a downward
trend in applications received by this bank for direct loans to

On the other hand, although the

Industrial Loans and Commitments Approved in the
Second Federal Reserve District*
(June 1934-May 1944; values in thousands)

industry, or for commitments to participate with other lenders,

Loans and commitments

since the initial period following the enactment of the legisla­
tion in June 1934. The total of outstanding loans and commit­

Size of loan

ments of this bank, as of any one date, fell from a peak of
approximately 8 million dollars in December 1935 to a low
of 120 thousand dollars at the end of May 1944 (exclusive of
loans in default).

In general, applications to this bank for

direct loans have been most numerous in periods of depression
and have diminished as business conditions improved.

The

growing tendency of commercial banks to extend credit for
longer periods (term loans) and to adopt other new methods
of financing business during the period under review may also




$ 10,000 and under.. . .
10,001—
25,0 0 0 ...
25,001—
5 0,000...
50,001— 100,000...
100,001— 250,000...
250,001— 500,000...
500,001— 1,000,000...
Over 1,000,000............

Direct

Indirect**

Number

Amount

Number

64
41
34
24
12
6
0
0

$ 308
657
1,128
1,477
1,840
1,650
0
0

42
45
35
29
24
13
5
2

181

$7,060

195

Amount
$

Total
Number

Amount

274
785
1,202
2,052
3,844
5,160
4,982
6,400

106
86
69
53
36
19
5
2

$

$24,699

376

$31,759

581
1,442
2,330
3,530
5,684
6,810
4,982
6,400

* Exclusive of applications approved but subsequently withdrawn.
** Includes liability of both Federal Reserve Bank of New York (approximately
$15,500,000) and other financial institutions (approximately $9,000,000).

52

MONTHLY REVIEW, JULY 1, 1944

full liability on loans totaling $18,000,000. About $1,000,000
of commitments was not used by the borrowers.
Individual loans have varied in original amount from $300
to more than $4,000,000, with an average of about $85,000.
As may be seen from the accompanying table, the smaller loans
of $25,000 or less came to more than 50 per cent in number
but only 6 per cent in value of all loans. Loans of over
$250,000 constituted 7 per cent in number and more than 55
per cent in value. Two thirds of the borrowers were engaged
in manufacturing, largely in the durable goods industries. The
remaining borrowers were mainly in wholesale and retail dis­
tribution, construction and contracting, and in the service
trades. More than 40 per cent of the dollar amount of the
loans was secured by first mortgages on real estate. A wide
variety of other security devices was used including liens on
commodities and inventories and on machinery and equip­
ment, and assignments of accounts receivable, contracts, and
cash surrender value of life insurance policies. About 15 per
cent in amount were unsecured loans.
Gross earnings from industrial advances and commitments
of this bank in the almost ten years ended May 31, 1944 came
to approximately $1,816,000, compared with expenses of
$867,000, leaving a balance of about $949,000 available for
absorption of losses. Expenses have been relatively high (even
though no overhead charges have been allocated to the in­
dustrial loan operations), because the financial position of
most borrowers necessitated extensive credit investigation, and
close supervision over loans once granted. In addition, this
bank has absorbed costs of handling loans ordinarily borne by
borrowers (accounts receivable loans are a case in point).
Finally, expenses have been swollen, especially during the first
year, by the cost of interviewing the large number of inquirers
and instructing those who decided to file applications.
Net reali2ed losses to date have amounted to $646,000, and
it is now estimated that further losses on loans in default and
still unsettled will amount to approximately $332,000 addi­
tional, for which reserves have been provided. Thus it now
appears that expenses and losses on loans made to date will
exceed earnings by a small margin. The loss experience on
CO NSUM ERS’ GOODS

IN D U S T R IE S

The real strength and nation-wide importance of New York
City’s manufacturing industries lies in the field of consumers’
nondurable goods, as pointed out in the June 1 issue of this
Review. The extent to which these industries depend on mar­
kets in the rest of the country varies tremendously. Some in­
dustries, such as bread baking, by the very nature of their
product rely essentially on the local market, whereas other in­
dustries, such as furs and apparel, supply consumers from coast
to coast.
Three groups of consumer industries produce substantially
more than the City’s population purchases: the apparel indus­
tries, printing and allied industries, and those light industries
that are lumped together as ’miscellaneous.” The output of




loans has been more favorable than might have been the case
under ordinary circumstances. The high level of industrial
activity induced by the war appreciably facilitated disposal
of buildings and other collateral pledged as security for de­
faulted loans. And a continuation of these favorable condi­
tions for the disposal of remaining collateral is assumed in the
estimate of future losses.
All but 15 advances and one commitment out of the total
of 376 have been repaid in full, although in about one third
of the cases extensions or renewals of loans or other relaxation
of terms have been made. Losses were heaviest among the
larger loans, those with original amounts of over $250,000.
Concentration of losses among the larger loans has occurred
chiefly because in several cases such loans were made, with full
recognition of the high degree of risk involved, primarily to
continue in operation businesses that were large factors in the
maintenance of employment in their respective communities.
On the other hand, the relative absence of losses among the
small loans has been offset by a lack of profitability for other
reasons. Income from such advances has often been exceeded
by the high cost of handling them. Whereas losses have been
relatively high among large loans, the latter have provided
the bulk of the revenue.
A general conclusion that may be drawn from this bank’s
experience over the last ten years is that the type of business
financing which the bank was called upon to undertake was
definitely a marginal one, not to be expected to result in profits
but not necessarily committed to losses. Some of the borrowers
failed in spite of the financial assistance they received, but
others have been enabled to reestablish themselves on a firm
basis, and meanwhile have helped to provide employment in
their communities. The volume of loans made has been a
small factor in the over-all total of business financing in the
District, of course, and the effects have been of importance in
individual communities rather than in the District generally.
The whole episode represents an experiment, in a field where
further experimentation is probably desirable, to determine
the extent to which the credit requirements of marginal
borrowers can reasonably be met and the best means of supply­
ing them.
IN

N E W

Y O R K

C IT Y

these three groups is largely for national markets and is ex­
changed for goods and services of other regions. The impor­
tance of these industries in the manufacturing activities of the
City is indicated by the fact -that these industries together
employ nearly 58 per cent of the City’s manufacturing wage
earners.
In three other industries—food and kindred products (which
is the second largest industry group in the City), leather and
leather products, and paper and allied products—output is on
the whole not much greater than the City can absorb. Of course,
high grade shoes and certain leather goods find national mar­
kets, and less expensive goods are imported from other pro­
duction centers. The same is true to a lesser extent for certain

FEDERAL RESERVE BANK OF NEW YORK

New York City’s Share in Total Employment of Wage
Earners in Various Manufacturing Industries, 1939
Major Groups
Consumers’ Nondurable Goods
Producers’ & Consumers’ Durable Goods
Primary Products
Durable Goods
Nonferrous Metal Products
Transportation Equip. Excl. Autos
Furniture
Iron & Steel Products
Electrical Machinery
Chemicals
Machinery Excl. Electrical
Rubber Products
Automobiles & Equipment
Apparel
Miscellaneous Light Industries
Chemical Preparations
Printing &. Allied Industries
Food & Kindred Products
Paper & Allied Products
Leather & Leather Products
Textiles
Tobacco Products

Based on data from U . S. Bureau of the Census, Census of the United
States, 1940, M anufactures.

products of the food industry, but the bulk of the food indus­
tries located in the City supply the local and transient popula­
tion. The paper industry also produces about the number of
containers, bags, and similar products required by the City’s
production and trade.
In only two groups of consumers’ nondurable goods indus­
tries does New York City’s output fall short of the require­
ments of the metropolis. The cigar and cigarette industry,
once important in the City, has nearly disappeared; and many
of the major industries in the textile group are barely repre­
sented here. The City’s many apparel industries are supplied
with textile products from various parts of the country, and
only a few finishing industries of the textile group are located
in New York.
Principal Industries

Apparel industries

The apparel industries are paramount among New York
City’s manufacturing industries. In 1939, this group of in­
dustries alone employed 208,000 of the City’s manufacturing
wage earners, a number greater than the total employed by the
automobile industry in the entire Detroit industrial area or by
the steel industry in the Pittsburgh area. Because of the pre­
dominance of distributive and service industries in New York,
however, the economic life of the City does not depend on the
apparel industries to the same extent that the welfare of
either Pittsburgh or Detroit depends on its leading manufac­
turing industry.
The apparel group consists of a large number of more or
less connected industries. Nearly all degrees of mechaniza­
tion, standardization, and integration can be encountered, and
all of the industries are highly specialized and closely related
to the wholesale trade. According to the 1940 Census of
Manufactures, no less than 56 different apparel industries were




53

represented in New York City; they provided employment
for 27.6 per cent of all the wage earners in the country engaged
in the various apparel industries. Some of these industries
in New York were exceedingly small; others employed thou­
sands of wage earners each.
The women’s clothing industry (including childrens and
infants’ wear), which is the most important component of
the apparel group, employed 115,000 wage earners in 1939.
During the past two or three decades, however, New York
City has not fully retained its dominant position in this in­
dustry; in 1939 its share in the national total of all wage
earners in the womens clothing industry was only 41 per cent,
compared with the peak figure of 62 per cent for 1914. The
decline between the two years was continuous. Manufacturers
of the lower priced lines tended to seek factory locations
where operations could be carried on at lower costs. Since
the machinery investment in the dress industry is relatively
small, removal (or entry of out-of-town competitors into the
field) is relatively easy. Many firms maintain only designing
rooms and sales offices in New York; their manufacturing
plants are located in neighboring areas outside the City.
Nevertheless, the number of people employed by the industry
in the City has not shown an actual decline over the years; the
reduction in the City’s share of the national total has been only
relative, and is attributable to more rapid growth in some other
areas. During recent years, efforts have been made to make
New York City the world fashion center for womens dresses.
It is premature to judge whether after the war New York City
will be able to supersede Paris as the world’s style center, but
thus far it has maintained its leading position as a fashion
center in this country.
New York City never dominated in the men’s clothing in­
dustry to the same extent as in the production of women’s
clothing. The City’s share in the total number of wage earners
in the men’s clothing industry, after reaching a peak of 28 per
cent in 1909, declined continuously to 10.0 per cent in 1933;
it was 11.5 per cent in 1939. The actual number of workers
employed in this industry also declined, in contrast to the
women’s clothing industry.

Printingindustries

While the number of wage earners employed in the printing
industries is considerably smaller than that in the apparel in­
dustries, the activities of the printing industries contribute
substantially to the manufacturing life of New York City.
The City retains a large share of the nation’s printing business,
although a significant decline has occurred since the first
World War. Newspaper printing has been an exception to
the general trend, particularly since the advent of the tabloid.
The printing of periodicals has suffered the greatest losses.
Beginning in the early twenties, national magazines, one after
another, transferred the manufacture of their publications
from New York City to more central locations which offered
economies in mailing charges, although many of the magazines
retained publication offices in the City.

54

MONTHLY REVIEW, JULY 1, 1944

The largest group of wage earners in the printing industry
in 1939 was employed in the general commercial job printing
branch. Despite the fact that New York’s losses in this trade
were heavy after the early twenties, the printing which has
remained in New York City is in many cases so closely asso­
ciated with the immediate needs of the City (newspapers,
printing of reports, circulars, forms, pamphlets required in
large quantities by corporate offices, banks, insurance com­
panies, trade associations, etc.) that a continuation of the de­
cline can hardly be anticipated.
Miscellaneous light industries

The group of miscellaneous industries—which includes a
wide range of unrelated industries, such as hair work, optical
instruments, plastic products, and umbrellas—covers more than
2,100 establishments and employs almost as many wage earners
as printing. Most of these industries require neither heavy
plant equipment nor bulky raw materials. No statistical data
can adequately describe the amount of ingenuity, initiative, and
adaptability required by these industries to meet the changing
tastes of the public, and to create constantly new fashions, new
needs, and new demand. Because of the rapid style changes,
a location near the New York wholesale markets is favored by
many concerns within this group. This influence, among
others, is reflected in the large and increasing share of New
York City in the country’s total output of a substantial number
of the 'miscellaneous” industries.
ADEQUACY OF LABOR SUPPLY IN THE
SECOND FEDERAL RESERVE DISTRICT
The labor supply in relation to war labor requirements is
considerably more adequate in the Second District than in
the country as a whole, according to ratings given the various
areas of the country by the War Manpower Commission. All
labor market areas in which there is a central city with a popu­
lation of 25,000 or more, or which have special labor supply
problems, have been classified by the Commission into four
groups: Group I — Areas of current acute labor shortage;
Group 11 — Areas of labor stringency and those anticipating a
labor shortage within six months; Group 111 — Areas in which
a slight labor reserve will remain after six months; and
Group IV— Areas in which a substantial labor reserve will
remain after six months. Classification is based on estimates
of anticipated labor requirements and Selective Service with­
drawals, and of the presently available and potential labor
supply.
During June, 24 labor market areas in the Second District
were classified in the four groups. The favorable position of
the District, in so far as the adequacy of the labor supply is
concerned, is indicated by the fact that only about 6 per cent
of the total population of the District was included in Group I,
whereas the comparable figure for the entire country was about
20 per cent. (See accompanying table.) Furthermore, the
ratings indicate that the labor market in this District has not,
on the whole, become materially tighter since the beginning




Population o f L abor M ark et
A rea s as Percentages o f T o ta l Population

Second District

United States

Labor market areas

January
1943

June
1944

January
1943

June
1944

Classified areas.................................

Unclassified areas............................

91.0
7 .4
2 6.0
7.1
5 0.5
9 .0

91.8
6 .4
28.1
6 .8
50.5
8 .2

60.5
7 .8
19.4
16.5
16.8
39.5

66.5
2 0.4
2 1 .7
12.8
11.6
33.5

T otal..........................................

100.0

100.0

100.0

100.0

Group I I I ......................................

of last year, contrary to the situation in the country as a whole.
Because of the predominantly urban character of the District,
the population included in the classified labor market areas
represents about 90 per cent of the District’s total population,
while the comparable figure for the nation is considerably
lower. Areas of labor shortage (Groups I and II), which
include about 35 per cent of the population of all classified
areas in the District, have received roughly two thirds of the
total war supply and facility contracts let in the classified areas.
This concentration of contracts has been the chief cause of the
labor shortages.
The position of labor market areas in the W.M.C. classifica­
tion is of considerable significance, since the War Production
Board places adequacy of labor supply second among the factors
to be considered by procurement agencies in awarding war
contracts, and prime contractors are requested to pursue the
same policy in letting subcontracts. Also, limitations have
recently been placed by the War Production Board on the
resumption of civilian production in Group I and Group II
areas.
Apparently in response to such factors as changes in the
volume of war contracts, recruitment drives, etc., which influ­
ence the adequacy of labor supply, many Second District areas
have shifted from one group to another at different times.1
Bridgeport, Connecticut was classified as an area of current
acute labor shortage (Group I) during all of 1943, but moved
into Group II in 1944; Massena, N. Y. was classified in Group
I between October 1943 and February 1944, but at other
times it was included in Group II; Plainfield-Somerville, N. J.
has been a Group I area except from October 1943 to March
1944; and Buffalo-Niagara Falls, N. Y. has been placed in
Group I continuously since January 1943.
As of July 1 the War Manpower Commission has extended
the application of several of its special programs designed to
relieve labor shortages. Manpower Priorities Committees,
which fix manpower allocations in accordance with the need
for war products, were established in all Group I and Group II
areas. These Committees, therefore, are now in operation in
15 labor market areas of the Second District, whereas formerly
they were confined to 9 areas. Employment ceilings, limiting
the number of workers which can be hired by major firms,
were established in all Group I and Group II areas; formerly
they were utilized in the Second District only in the Bridge1The W.M.C. classification is available beginning January 1943.

55

FEDERAL RESERVE BANK OF NEW YORK

port, Newark, Paterson, and Plainfield-Somerville areas. A
nation-wide system of priority referrals was established, pro­
viding for the hiring of all male workers through the U. S.
Employment Service or other approved agencies; in the Second
District, such plans were previously in operation only in the
Buffalo-Niagara Falls, Newark, and Syracuse areas. The new
War Manpower Commission ruling also limits replacements
in nonessential industries to women, and intensifies programs
for transferring workers from areas with surplus labor to areas
with shortages.
Production Urgency Committees, which establish production
urgency ratings for war products to enable Manpower Priorities
Committees to allocate workers in accordance with these needs,
are utilized in the Albany-Schenectady-Troy, Buffalo-Niagara
Falls, New York City, Newark, Paterson, Rochester, and
Syracuse areas. The minimum wartime work week of 48
hours is in force in seven areas of the District: Bridgeport,
Buffalo-Niagara Falls, Massena, Newark, Perth Amboy, Plain­
field-Somerville, Utica-Rome. Every classified labor market
area in the Second District has in operation at least one of the
special programs of the War Manpower Commission designed
to relieve labor shortages.
CLASSIFIED LABOR MARKET AREAS, JUNE 1944
Se c o n d Federal R eserve D istrict

Group I
Buffalo-Niagara Falls, N. Y.
Plainfield-Somerville, N. J.

Group 11
Albany-Schenectady-Troy, N. Y.
Auburn, N. Y.
Bridgeport, Conn.
Geneva, N. Y.
Massena, N. Y.
Morristown, N. J.
Newark, N. J.
Norwalk, Conn.
Paterson, N. J.
Perth Amboy, N. J.
Rochester, N. Y.
Stamford, Conn.
Syracuse, N. Y.

Group 111
Batavia, N. Y.
Binghamton, N. Y.
Dunkirk, N. Y.
Elmira, N. Y.
Jamestown, N. Y.
Long Branch, N. J.

about two and a half times its prewar level, has declined 10
per cent from the November peak; reductions have been
especially large at plants producing aircraft, tanks, munitions,
and electrical and scientific equipment.
Among the various industrial areas of the State, the decreases
in employment between November and May have ranged from
3.6 per cent for Rochester to 14.3 per cent for Utica. In several
areas, such as Albany-Schenectady-Troy, Utica, Buffalo, and
Rochester, the contraction of the last six months is a continua­
tion of the decline that began in the summer of 1943.
The State index of factory payrolls dropped from 286.0 per
cent of the 1935-39 average in April to 284.3 per cent in May;
the May figure was slightly below the level of May 1943 and
Indexes o f B u sin ess

Sidney, N. Y.
Utica-Rome, N. Y.

1943

1944

Index

Group IV
New York Metropolitan
Region, N. Y.

EMPLOYMENT AND PAYROLLS

The number of wage earners employed in manufacturing
industries in the United States declined by 165,000 between
April and May, to 13,007,000, a figure 7 per cent below the
peak reached last November. The decline reflects the con­
tinued withdrawal of men into the armed services, more
efficient use of labor in war industries, completion of many
war contracts, cutbacks in certain industries, and a continued
low level of output of some consumer goods. The downward
tendency of recent months for the country as a whole has also
been apparent in New York State, as indicated on the accom­
panying chart.
In general, those New York State industries which had re­
ported the greatest expansion between 1940 and 1943 have
shown the largest declines in recent months. Employment in
the metals and machinery industries, which had increased to




Indexes of Factory Employment and Payrolls
in New York State*
(1935-39 average=100 per cent)

Industrial production*, 1935-39 = 100.........
(Board of Governors, Federal Reserve

May

Mar.

Apr.

May

239

241

239

237p

117r

113r

114p

198p

System)

Munitions output, 1943 = 100f...................

( War Production Board)

Electric power output*, 1935-39 = 100........

(Federal Reserve Bank of New York)
Ton-miles of railway freight*, 1935-39 = 10C
(Federal Reserve Bank of New York)
Sales of all retail stores*, 1935-39 = 100 .. .

(Department of Commerce)

Factory employment
United States, 1939 = 100..........................

9 5r
190

201

202

236

232

243p

155

178

167p

167

164

161

159 p

159

155

152

149p

314

324

318p

285

299

286

209

230

230p

(Bureau of Labor Statistics)
New York State, 1935-39 = 1 0 0 .................

(New York State Dept, of Labor)
Factory payrolls
United States, 1939 = 100.........................

(Bureau of Labor Statistics)
New York State, 1935-39 = 100 ...............

(New York State Dept, of Labor)
Income payments*, 1935-39 = 100...............

(Department of Commerce)

Wage rates, 1926 = 100 ..................................

152

161

161p

125

124

125

85
80

79
82

73
76

(Federal Reserve Bank of New York)
Cost of living, 1935-39 = 100.........................

(Bureau of Labor Statistics)

284p

125p

Velocity of demand deposits*, 1935-39 = 100

(Federal Reserve Bank of New York

New York City..............................................
Outside New York C ity ..............................

* Adjusted for seasonal variation.
p Preliminary,
f Base shifted from November 1941 to year 1943.

r Revised.

66
72

MONTHLY REVIEW, JULY 1, 1944

56

6.6 per cent below the November 1943 peak. The April-May
decrease was due to the lower employment at war plants in
most areas of the State, and to a seasonal decline in the number
of workers in the apparel industries; the latter decrease was
especially sharp in New York City and in the KingstonNewburgh-Poughkeepsie area. Advances in payrolls occurred
in the iron and steel mills in Syracuse and Buffalo, and in
the photographic and optical goods and the metals and ma­
chinery industries in Rochester.
DEPARTM ENT STORE TRADE
Department store sales in this District during June are
estimated to have been about 10 per cent above those in the
corresponding month of 1943. So far this year sales in the
District have shown approximately the same percentage in­
crease since a year ago as sales in the country as a whole. In
the period since 1939, however, the District’s gain has been
considerably less than that for the entire country and the
smallest of any one of the Federal Reserve Districts. Depart­
ment store sales in the United States are now approximately
70 per cent above the 1939 level.1 Increases for the various
districts are: Atlanta and Dallas, 120 per cent; San Francisco,
95 per cent; Richmond and Kansas City, 90 per cent; St. Louis,
75 per cent; Cleveland, 65 per cent; Chicago, Philadelphia,
and Minneapolis, 55 per cent; Boston, 50 per cent; and New
York, 45 per cent. As indicated on the accompanying chart,
the slower rate of growth in this District, compared with that
in the entire country, was most pronounced during 1942
and 1943.
The largest dollar volume of department store sales of any
city in the country is that for New York City. In this City
the annual rate of department store sales is now approximately
400 million dollars; apparel store sales account for an additional
300 million. New York City, therefore, currently accounts for
1Department store sales in 1939 for each district are given in the
article, “Revised Index of Department Store Sales,” in the Federal
Reserve Bulletin for June 1944.

Revised Indexes of Department Store Sales, United States
and Second Federal Reserve District
(1935-39 daily averages 100 per cent; adjusted for seasonal variation)

200

about 8 per cent of all department and apparel store sales in
the United States. Among the ten cities in the country with
the largest volume of sales, New York City has shown one
of the smallest increases since 1939; in fact, only two of these
large cities—Los Angeles and Baltimore—have reported sales
increases greater than the average for the country. Sales in
each of these two centers were up 85 per cent, compared with
70 per cent for the United States. Percentage increases for the
other cities are: Washington, 70; Philadelphia, Detroit, and
Cleveland, 60; Pittsburgh, 55; New York City, 45; Chicago and
Boston, 40. In general the small cities of the country have
shown greater increases in retail sales during the war period
than the large cities.
In all districts, department store sales as a percentage of
income payments have dropped sharply during the war period.
Because of increased taxes and savings, consumer expenditures
have been accounting for a decreasing proportion of total
income payments. For the country as a whole, consumer ex­
penditures declined from 87 per cent of total income payments
to individuals in 1939 to 64 per cent in 1943. Taxes during
the four-year period rose from an estimated 4 per cent to 13
per cent, and savings increased from 9 per cent to 23 per cent.
The situation in the New York District is similar; retail trade
appears to have expanded considerably less than the income
of the District, which in turn has increased less than that of
the country as a whole.
D epartm en t and Apparel Store Sales and S tock s, Second Federal
R eserve D istrict, P ercentage Change from the P receding Y e a r

Net Sales

May 1944
+19
+23
+14
+12
+ 6
+ 1
+16
+19
+ 4
+ 5
+ 5
K19
- 8
1-13 4
0 Vf *8

Department stores, Second District. . . .
New York City......................................
Northern New Jersey...........................
Newark...............................................
Westchester and Fairfield Counties. .
Bridgeport..........................................
Lower Hudson River Valley...............
Poughkeepsie....................................
Upper Hudson River Valley...............
Schenectady........................................
Central New York State.....................
Mohawk River Valley......................

P e r cent

18 0

Northern New York State...................
Southern New York State...................
Binghamton.......................................
Western New York State...........V-v?
Niagara Falls.....................................
Rochester............................................

160

140

120
100
80
Source: Board o f Governors of the Federal Reserve System and Federal
Reserve Bank of New York.




Stocks on
hand
Jan.through May 31, 1944
May 1944

Locality

l-l 2
bl9 \
-15
[-14
<■*' - -10
bl9

Apparel stores (chiefly New York City)

-H r

1
]

+13
+ 8
+ 11
+14
+12
+ 2
- 1
+12
- 2
0
- 7
- 6
+17
+19
+16
+ 1
+ 1
+ 6
- 4
0
+16
+11
+ 3
+ 5
+ 6
+15
+22
__
+ 8
+12
+ 7
■ + .6 .\
—
+ 9
,
+ 6
s
+11
+ 6
/
; , +11
•+ 1 .
/v .^ -i i
* ,. '+ 1 0
+ 7
y + i8

+ 8

Indexes of D epartm en t Store Sales am ^&tocks
Second Federal R eserve D is t r ic t ^

• -/ —...
•' ' sf
1944

1943 .
Item
May

Mar.

Apr.

May

1935-39 average = 100
Sales (average daily), unadjusted.................
Sales (average daily), seasonally adjusted. .

124
130

138
157

136
139

142
149

1923-25 average = 100
Stocks, unadjusted..........................................
Stocks, seasonally adjusted............................

104
102

121
120

112
111

118
116

FEDERAL RESERVE BANK OF NEW YORK
MONTHLY REVIEW, JULY 1, 1944

260
240

General Business and Financial Conditions in the United States
(Summarized by the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System)
activity and employment declined
I NDUSTRIAL
was maintained in May and the first three

slightly further in May. Value of retail trade
weeks of June and commodity prices showed

little change.
In d u s t r i a l Pr o d u c t i o n
1 140

1937

1936

1939

1940

1941

1942

1943

1944

Index of Physical Volume of Industrial Produc­
tion, Adjusted for Seasonal Variation
(1 9 35 -3 9 a v erage= 100 per cent)

Industrial production continued to decline in May and the Board’s seasonally adjusted index
was 237 per cent of the 1935-39 average as compared with 239 in April. Small declines in out­
put of metal products and nondurable goods accounted for most of the decrease in the total index.
Steel production was maintained at a high rate. Supplies of aluminum and magnesium
continued to exceed military requirements after further curtailment of output in May, and relaxa­
tion of restrictions on the use of these metals in civilian products was announced on June 18.
Activity in munitions industries declined slightly in May. Aircraft production was at approxi­
mately the same daily average rate as in the preceding month. Deliveries of merchant ships
declined somewhat from the April rate, reflecting curtailment of Liberty ship construction; the
number of Victory ships delivered rose further in May.
Output of lumber and of stone, clay, and glass products declined further in May. Addi­
tional Federal control was established over lumber consumption, effective in the third quarter, in
order to assure sufficient supplies for essential requirements.
Production of most nondurable goods was likewise somewhat lower in May than in April.
Cotton consumption declined 6 per cent from the rate prevailing earlier this year to a level 16
per cent below May 1943. Output of manufactured dairy products showed a large seasonal rise
in May while manufacture of most other food products declined somewhat, after allowance for
seasonal changes.
Output of crude petroleum and coal continued to rise and iron ore production reached an
exceptionally high level for this season of the year.
D is t r ib u t io n

Income Payments to Individuals, Based on De­
partment of Commerce Estimates. W ages and
Salaries Include Military Pay. Monthly
Figures Raised to Annual Rates

Department store sales in May were maintained at the April level, and the Board’s season­
ally adjusted index, as recently revised, was 183 per cent of the 1935-39 average. During the
first half of June sales continued at about the April-May rate and were 4 per cent larger than
in the corresponding period last year.
Railroad freight traffic was maintained at a high level during May and the early part of June.
C o m m o d i t y Pr ic e s

Wholesale commodity prices continued to show little change in May and the early part of
June. Retail prices showed a further slight increase in May. The wholesale price index and the
cost of living index of the Bureau of Labor Statistics were both at the same level as they were
in May 1943.
A g r ic u l t u r e

Crop prospects on June 1 were better than on the same date in the last 10 years except 1942.
The total wheat crop appeared likely to exceed a billion bushels as compared with a harvest of
836 million bushels in 1943 and 974 million in 1942. Prospects for other grains, however,
were not as favorable and, with grain stocks reduced, it is expected that total supplies available
to meet food, feed, and industrial needs will continue short. In recent months the feed situation
has been eased by generally good condition of the hay crops and pastures.
Ba n k
Member Bank Reserves and Related Items
(Latest figures are for June 14)

Member Banks in Leading Cities. Demand De­
posits (Adjusted) Exclude U . S. Government
and Interbank Deposits and Collection
Items. Government Securities Include
Direct and Guaranteed Issues (Latest
figures are for June 14)




C r e d it

In the five months from the beginning of the Fourth War Loan Drive to the beginning of
the Fifth Drive, Federal Reserve Bank holdings of U. S. Government securities increased by
more than 3 billion dollars. Member bank borrowings at Federal Reserve Banks also increased
somewhat during the period, and at times exceeded 200 million dollars for the first time in more
than a decade. These additions to Reserve Bank credit supplied the market with funds to meet
a growth of nearly 2 billion dollars in money in circulation, an increase of 700 million in mem­
ber bank required reserves, and a loss of gold of 700 million. Excess reserves, which declined
to as low as 600 million dollars during the period, amounted to 1.1 billion on June 14.
During the Drive, purchases of Government securities by businesses and individuals will
shift deposits to reserve-exempt Government war-loan accounts and reduce the amount of reserves
that member banks are required to hold. This will result in some further increase in excess
reserves and some repurchases of Government securities by member banks from the Reserve Banks.
Adjusted demand deposits at member banks in leading cities have risen by about 5 34 billion
dollars since the end of the Fourth Drive and are more than 214 billion dollars above the level
prevailing prior to that Drive. Time deposits also increased steadily.
Government security holdings at reporting banks declined by close to 2 billion dollars
between mid-February and mid-June, following an increase of around 3 billion during the
Fourth Drive. Bill holdings declined substantially, paralleling increases in such holdings at the
Reserve Banks. Loans to brokers and dealers in securities, which by the end of May had declined
well below their early January levels, increased somewhat in the first two weeks of June prepara­
tory to the Drive. Other loans for handling Government securities are close to their pre-Fourth
Drive level. Again in the Fifth Drive, as in the previous one, borrowings for speculative pur­
chases will be discouraged.